A Self New Knowledge over Old Certainties Alaska …A Self‐Regulation Exploration: New Knowledge...
Transcript of A Self New Knowledge over Old Certainties Alaska …A Self‐Regulation Exploration: New Knowledge...
A Self‐Regulation Exploration:
New Knowledge over Old Certainties
Alaska Staff Development NetworkJanuary 2017
With: Mike McKay & Sandra‐Lynn Shortall
Today’s SessionPart One Self‐Regulation 101
• Setting the Stage
Part Two The ‘Self’ in Self‐Regulation
Part Three Self‐Regulation in the Complex 21st Century Classroom
Part Four Self‐Regulation Next Steps• Taking What We Know and Changing What We Do
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
SELF‐REGULATION 101Part One:
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Setting the Stage: Self-Regulation 101
CSRI’s Multi-Dimensional Approach to the Self-Regulation Journey
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Each of Us Shares a Sacred Trust “Every Child, Every Chance, Every Day”
• Never doubt the impact of high quality, nurturing school environments (Social, Emotional, Physical & Intellectual)
• Understanding and applying a Self-Regulation framework is a fundamental Difference Maker in establishing that high quality environment
• It profoundly changes children’s life chances, particularly those with the greatest needs
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Early Adversity & Its Deep Impact on Learning and the Learner
• The ACE Study – Adverse Childhood Experiences Study
• Physical, Emotional or Sexual Abuse• Physical or Emotional Neglect• Incarceration• Parental Separation or Divorce• Domestic Violence
Early adversity dramatically impacts health across the lifetime. We now know what it takes to interrupt that progression. The single most important thing we need today is the courage to directly address this
TED Talk http://bit.ly/17fegfY
Our Kids Play the Cards Available to Them
Let’s Not Forget
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Whatever They Might Be
As educators, we help kids add cards to their deck
Educators Create the Conditions That Nourish These Three Human Needs:
• to belong
• to develop
• to contributeand…
Self-Regulation & Positive Social-Emotional Climates are Central to This Work
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Mission Control
Our neuro-physiology determines our outcomes
Self-Regulation: A Working DefinitionHow effectively and efficiently a person deals with a stressor and then recovers from the effort
Our response to stressors:
• Social Engagement
• Fight-or-Flight
• Freeze
Every time we experience a stressor, the brain responds with processes that consume energy
Then, restorative processes kick in to recover from this energy expenditure & restore equilibrium
Without a socially, emotionally and mentally healthy environment, kids’ capacity to learn and to thrive is dramatically decreased or even eliminated.
The capacity to learn shuts down if you are filled with anxiety or fear. All of your energy is spent on survival. Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
CalmFocused
Alert
Self-Reg States
Based on the work of Dr. Stuart Shanker
Biological domain:including sensory
Emotional domain: anger, fear, frustration, sadness,anxiety
Cognitive domain:memory, attention, information processing,problem solving
Social domain:understanding social cues,engaging in sociallyappropriate behaviour
Prosocial domain:empathy, interpersonaldynamics, social engagement & contribution
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
From Five to Seven Essential Self-Regulation Capacities
We all have these capacities:
How do we activate them?
BiologicalBiological
EmotionalEmotional
CognitiveCognitive
PerspectivalPerspectivalRelationalRelational
InspirationalInspirational
AspirationalAspirational
7 Essential Capacities
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation Capacities: Developed Over A Life Time
• Cognitive: I already have strengths & strategies in how I think and understand.AND I can discover & practice new ways to process and interact with information.
• Emotional: I am aware of and can manage diverse situations and how I feel inside
• Relational: I value the contribution others can make to me and I can make to them. I read social cues and know when to step in and when to step back.
• Perspective-taking: I can take a step back and look at/think about several different ways of understanding a situation.
• Inspirational: I feel wonder for the world and all of its potential
• Aspirational: I have the ability and desire to learn, to grow and to make a differencein my world.
• Biological: I recognize my unique gifts and challenges - the things that make me me. I am learning how to influence some of the ways the environment impacts me.
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Biological *
Biological *
Emotional *
Emotional *
Cognitive *
Cognitive *
Perspectival
Perspectival
Relational **
Relational **
Inspirational
Inspirational
Aspirational
Aspirational
7 Essential Self-Reg
Capacities
Three Self-Regulation Snapshots
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
We know these kids. Low capacity for self-regulation has current and/or downstream impacts on their life chances.
We will spend some time with Jason. You
know him.
A Field Trip to the Louvre: Not a Self‐Regulation Moment
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Some Kids Lament & Others Wonder…We Can Help Them Expand Their Options
Why is all of this stuff always happening to me?
Good Kid/Bad KidGrowth Mindset/Fixed MindsetI Have My …/My …Have Me
Activating Potential/Overwhelmedby Challenges
Virtuous Cycle/Vicious Cycle
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
As the teacher/adult in the situation, remember to be the thermostat not the temperature (or the furnace)
• Can’t sit still
Jason
• Is easily distracted• Has meltdowns when he’s frustrated
• Is a loner on the playground
• Has a reputation as a bully
The outside view
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
• I have that ‘sinking feeling.” Everyone else knows what’s going on ... but I don’t.
Jason
• I just get so mad!
• The other kids hate me.
• I don’t care what they think ... they’re just dumb!
The inside view
• I’ll never catch up.
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Old School
• We run a tight ship here; bad behaviour is punished.
• Feeling worried? ... don’t be so sensitive; Feeling sad? ... soldier on.
• Life’s a struggle, you have to be a ‘winner’ to do well.
• Don’t worry about Freddy ... you’re responsible for yourself.
• Some kids are born smart; others will never catch up.
Old School
•Sit quietly in your seat.• Nothing on your desk but your pencil & notebook
• Lose marks for bad behaviour
• Solo projects; ‘winner‐takes‐ all’ games
• Mind your own business; keep your hands to yourself
We have invested a lot in “old school.” Classroom design, the learning dynamic, policies, a culture of rewards and sanctions…
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
New School
• It’s never too late – all kids can learn; we can promote a growth mindset.
• Challenging behaviour is linked to lagging skills.
• Emotional competencies are just as important as math competencies.
• Capacity for empathy is an important developmental milestone.
• Learning can happen when you’re having fun with others.
New School
• Classroom designed for movement & engagement
• Kids can opt to use sensory tools to help them focus
• Mindfulness, emotional & resilience capacities taught
• Team learning; cooperative andcompetitive games
• Acts of kindness and contribution are acknowledged
It’s time to hit the refresh button. What we know about kids and learning has to impact what we do.
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
• Feels calm more often than not ...
In his new school, Jason ...
• Knows that there are many things he already knows, and that he will continue to learn.
• Is proud that his teacher noticed how he was feeling a big emotion, but didn’t act on the impulse to kick his chair.
• Is aware that he feels happier during the day when he’s played hard at recess.
• Can see that other people have thoughts, feelings, & preferences that are different than his, and wants them to feel good too.
The inside view
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
• Knows he can take a ‘stretch break’ when needed, or climb on a spin bike.
In his new school, Jason ...
• Is working on a project that draws on his passionate interest in astronomy.
• Is learning about emotions, and uses the Hoberman ball in the classroom to practice mindful breathing.
• Asks if he can join the game at recess; helps other players sort out the rules.
• Comforted a classmate who was feeling sad and left out; invited her to join him in a game.
The outside view
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
A Teacher’s Voice: How a Self-Reg Approach Impacts Learning
…”I am starting to look at the reasons behind problem behaviors, rather thanjust giving consequences for students’ poor choices. It is less about what Ineed them to do and more about what they need from me”…
…”I see more clearly what my students bring to the classroom with them (bothgifts and challenges) and have an understanding of how these issues impacttheir learning time with me. I have also had to take a hard look at myself andmy teaching. The piles of paper , the stacks of books here and there, thechaos is adding to the visual clutter. The disorganization of the “stuff” isunsettling for some of my kids”…
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Your Turn: Questions, Connections and Challenges
What are some “system norms” embedded in our school routines even though they interfere with conditions where kids can learn and teachers can teach?
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
THE ‘SELF’ IN SELF‐REGULATIONPart Two:
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
What are we growing?• Mindfulness skills
• Self-calming skills
• Growth mindset (focus on potential)
• Resilience (bouncing back)
• Focus and attention skills
• Social and emotional skills
• Perspective-taking skills
• Executive function skills
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Growing Self-Regulation
Family
Community
School
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
And every community has its own unique culture …
• worldviews• shared meaning• collective norms, ethics• shared attitudes, values, beliefs• shared vision & goals• stories, myths• shared history, customs, language• culture of participation & contribution
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Community & Culture
•Respond to stressors, and
•Return to a calm and alert state, ready to deal with new circumstances
Meet Life’s Challenges
•Respond to our innate drive to thrive ...
• Supported by optimal conditions for learning, mental health & wellbeing, positive, productive social engagement & relationships, and healthy human development
Rise to Life’s
Potential
Self‐RegulationCanadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation Described:
1. Matching energy level to the demands of a task or situation.
2. Monitoring and managing emotions.
3. Focusing attention and ignoring distractions.
4. Understanding and engaging in social interactions.
5. Connecting with and caring about others.
Baumeister & Vohs, 1994
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation Five Domains• Biological domain: including sensory
• Emotional domain: anger, fear, frustration, sadness, anxiety
• Social domain: understands social cues, engages in socially appropriate behaviour
• Prosocial domain: empathy, interpersonal dynamics,social engagement & contribution
Shanker, Stuart (2013)Calm, Alert and Learning: Classroom Strategies for Self-Regulationwww.self-reg.ca
• Cognitive domain: memory, attention, information processing, problem solving
Integrative Approach
to S-R
Integrative Approach
to S-R
BiologicalBiological
EmotionalEmotional
CognitiveCognitiveSocialSocial
Pro-SocialPro-
Social
POSITIVE CONTAGION
Positive Contagion?
The amygdala is a trigger point for emotional distress, anger, impulse, fear, and so on.
When this circuitry takes over, it acts as the ‘bad boss’, leading us to take actions we might regret later…
The key neural area for self regulation is the prefrontal cortex, the brain’s ‘good boss’, guiding us when we are at our best.
The dorsolateral zone of the prefrontal area is the seat of cognitive control, regulating attention, decision-making, voluntary action,
reasoning, and flexibility in response.
Dan Goleman, The Brain and Emotional Intelligence: New Insights, 2011
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Awareness & Contagious Feelings
• Notion of ‘Emotional Contagion’
• Whenever people interact, our brains and bodies react to the feelings of those around us
• Mirror neuron system
• Automatic, instant, unconscious and sometimes out of our intentional control system
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Co-Regulation is:
a form of coordinated action between participants that involves a continuous mutual adjustment of actions and intentions.
Fogel & Garvey, 2007
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Starting with the ‘SELF’ in Self-Regulation
1. How am I reacting to this situation and why?
2. What is my adult perspective?
3. How is the environment influencing the situation?
4. What is the child’s need?
5. How can we strengthen our relationship?
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation is not
Self Control
IS IS NOT
A framework for understanding children’s needs and potentials
A program
Differentiated One–size fits all
Integrative – addressing all of the factors that promote self‐regulation
Expecting changes in the child without making changes in the system & the culture.
Self‐awareness & self‐agency Self‐control
Universal Only for learners with Special Needs designation
Part of the equation The panacea
Self- Regulation Savvy
SELF‐REGULATION IN THE COMPLEX 21ST CENTURY CLASSROOM
Part Three:
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Human DevelopmentDevelopmentally children need structure and need direct instruction to co-regulate and self-regulate.
The adults in the child’s world need to create these structures and invest time in creating environments where children can thrive.
Investing time here is important and necessary.
Investing time here is worthwhile and will allow for deeper more complex cognitive processes to take root.
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Student cognition & motivation connects directly with use of Self-Regulation/Executive Function strategies.
Focused Effort
Effective Strategy Use
Efficient Performance
Academic Success
Positive Self-Concept
Academic Success Cycle, Meltzer, Reddy, Pollica & Roditi, 2004
True or False?1. We can lead students’ brains to reasoning.
2. We can act as the frontal lobe and be our students’ executive functioning.
3. We can exercise the frontal lobe in our classrooms.
4. Environmental situations can change brain development.
5. We can teach students how to self-regulate in a way that increases individuals desire to self-regulate.
Our Opportunity1. Plan for transitions
2. Hope in advance
3. Second chances
4. Limit justifications and explanations
5. Graceful exits
6. Set and maintain boundariesV. Lapointe, 2016
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Our Opportunity
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
PROBLEM
POTENTIAL
Looking for the Toolbox?
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
CalmFocused
Alert
- Decrease power/authority relationships
- Give children choice
- Increase activity time
- Change/De-clutter the classroom design
- Recognize “dysregulating” variables
- Introduce classroom tools
- Teach self-regulation
- Up-regulate/down-regulate as needed
School Strategies to Support Children’s Return to Calm
Based on the work of Dr. Stuart ShankerCanadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation is about building emotional literacy.
Children should ‘ have their emotions work with
them, not against them’.C. Blair, NYU, 2010
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Potentials Problems
How would you fill in the blanks?Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Potentials Problems
What’s getting more of our attention? Potentials? Or problems?
An integrative approach to self-regulation also means responding to challenges and building capacities. Respond to
ChallengesBuild
Capacities
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self‐Regulation & Integration
Your Turn: Individual or Team Reflections & Questions
How can you see the strategies being shared here combine with the concept of growth mindset for kids and for teachers?
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
SELF‐REGULATION NEXT STEPSPart Four:
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
• less natural food/more fast food packed with sugars/salts/fats
• disconnection from nature because of crowded urban living, environmental pollution and “stranger danger”
• lack of sleep – time and quality
• screen time (the video screen is NOT a good teacher or child care provider). ** How many 2 year‐olds have TV in their bedroom or i‐Pad under the covers
• exposure to violence and other anti‐social behaviour
• family stressors: parents working two jobs, intergenerational poverty, family violence, lack of community supports and connections
What We Know
Our Kids (and We) Are Dealing With…
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
“The greatest weapon against stress is our ability to choose one thought over another.” William James, the father of American psychology.
Social Belonging
Affluenza
Cyber
Global issues
Urgency to Succeed
Our capacity to thrive is determined by how effectively we deal with stressors
Fear of FailureMedia frenzy
Family Economic Pressures
Current or
Trauma
Current or Intergenerational
Trauma
Healthy/Unhealthy Healthy/Unhealthy Routines: Nutrition
& Sleep
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
A Few Words from Dr. John Medina
• If you want to create a business or education environment that was directly opposed to what the brain was good at doing, you probably would design something like a cubicle or a classroom. And if you wanted to change things, you might have to tear down both and start over.
Faculty, Department of Bioengineering, University of Washington, School of Medicine
Director, Brain Center for Applied Learning Research, Seattle Pacific University
Understanding and applying a self-regulation framework allows for a less dramatic path forward than a total system rebuild.
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Deficits/challenges Assets/strengths
Nurturing/growth mindset
Limiting/prohibitiveCanadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Self-Regulation and Trauma
Working on self-regulation is especially important for children that have been traumatized, are victims of intergenerational trauma, or are being raised by caregivers who have been traumatized.
These children:
• Quickly shift from Learning Brain to Survival Brain
• Are in a chronic state of fight-or-flight, freeze, or even dissociation
• Have no energy left because fight-or-flight is extremely energy draining, reducing the person’s capacity to pay attention, inhibit impulses, regulate mood, co-regulate
Canadian Self‐Regulation InitiativeBased on the work of Dr. Stuart Shanker
Educators
Human Services
Professionals
Kids & Teens
Parents & Other Family Members
Community Groups & Alliances
Who do we work with & what do we bring to capacity building?
Practical tools and support for taking self‐regulation deeper, generating shared understanding & commitment among…
Together, we can be “The Village Raising the Child.”
Together, We Build Human Capacity
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
It’s Never Too Late
Your Turn: Individual or Team Reflections & Questions
What “take aways” will help you, your students and their families effectively cope with stressors so they don’t escalate to anxiety and more serious
mental health concerns?
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative
Thank you!Mike McKayDirector, Canadian Self-Regulation [email protected]
Sandra-Lynn ShortallDistrict Principal, West Vancouver Schools, British [email protected]
For more information, please visitwww.self-regulation.ca
Reference ListBaumeister, R. F. (1998). The Self.
Blair. C. (2010). An Optimal Balance: Emotion-cognition interaction in context.
Butler, D.L, Schnellert L., Perry, N. (2016). Developing Self-Regulating Learners.
Carney. P. (2015). Well Aware: Developing Resilient, active and Flourishing Students.
Goleman D. (2011). The Brain and Emotional Intelligence: New Insights,
Hart, B. & Risley, T. (1995). Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of Young American Children.
Lapointe, V. (2015). Discipline Without Damage.
Mraz, K. & Hertz. C. (2015). A Mindset for Learning: Teaching the Traits of Joyful, Independent Growth.
Shanker, S. (2013). Calm, Alert, and Learning.
Siegel, D. (2013). Brainstorm.
Thayer, R.E. (1996). The Origin of Everyday Moods. Fogel, A. & Garvey, A. (2007). Alive Communication.
Thompson, H. (2012). Calm, Focus, Joy.
White, M.C. & DiBenedetto, M.K. (2015). Self-Regulation and the Common Core: Application to the ELA Standards.
www.self-regulation.cawww.drdansiegel.cawww.self-reg.cawww.sensorystreet.comwww.ei.yale.edu
Canadian Self‐Regulation Initiative