2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in...

17
2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records System (SPIDER) Nominated by:

Transcript of 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in...

Page 1: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application

City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records System (SPIDER)

Nominated by:

Page 2: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%1%of%16%%%

Table&of&Contents&A.% System%.........................................................................................................................................................%3%

1.%Name%of%system%&%ESIG%award%category%.....................................................................................................%3%

2.%Letter%from%Executive%Administrator%...........................................................................................................%3%

3.%System%summary%and%why%it%is%exemplary%..................................................................................................%3%

4.%User%testimonials%.........................................................................................................................................%3%

B.%%Jurisdiction%.....................................................................................................................................................%4%

1.%Name%of%jurisdiction%....................................................................................................................................%4%

2.%Population%served%by%the%organization/agency%...........................................................................................%4%

3.%Annual%total%budget%.....................................................................................................................................%4%

4.%Chief%elected%official%....................................................................................................................................%4%

5.%System%contacts%...........................................................................................................................................%4%

C.%System%Design%.................................................................................................................................................%4%

1.%What%motivated%the%system%development?%................................................................................................%4%

2.%What%specific%service%or%services%was%the%system%intended%to%improve?%...................................................%5%

3.%What,%if%any,%unexpected%benefits%did%you%achieve?%..................................................................................%5%

4.%What%system%design%problems%were%encountered?%....................................................................................%6%

5.%What%differentiates%this%system%from%other%similar%systems?%....................................................................%6%

D.%Implementation%..............................................................................................................................................%6%

1.%What%phases%did%you%go%through%in%developing%the%system?%.....................................................................%6%

2.%Were%there%any%modifications%to%the%original%system%design?%Why?%What?%..............................................%7%

E.%Organizational%Impact%.....................................................................................................................................%7%

1.%What%user%community%does%the%system%serve%and%how?%...........................................................................%7%

2.%What%are%the%ultimate%decisions/operations/services%being%affected?%......................................................%7%

3.%What%were%the%quantitative%and%qualitative%impacts%of%the%system?%.........................................................%9%

4.%What%effect%has%the%system%had%on%productivity?%......................................................................................%9%

5.%What,%if%any,%other%impacts%have%the%system%had?%.....................................................................................%9%

6.%How%did%the%system%change%the%way%business%is%conducted%with%and/or%service%delivered%to%clients?%...%10%

F.%System%Resources%..........................................................................................................................................%10%

1.%What%are%the%system’s%primary%hardware%components?.%.........................................................................%10%

2.%What%are%the%system’s%primary%software%components?%...........................................................................%11%

3.%What%data%does%the%system%work%with?%....................................................................................................%11%

Page 3: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%2%of%16%%%

4.%What%staff%resources%were%required%to%implement%the%system?%..............................................................%11%

5.%Comment%on%anything%unusual%about%the%resources%used%to%develop%your%system,%such%as%data,%

software,%personnel%and%financing.%...............................................................................................................%11%

G.%Appendices%...................................................................................................................................................%11%

1.%Letter%from%Executive%Administrator%.........................................................................................................%12%

2.%User%Testimonials%......................................................................................................................................%13%

3.%System%Architecture%..................................................................................................................................%16%

%

% &

Page 4: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%3%of%16%%%

A.! System&&1.&Name&of&system&&&ESIG&award&category&&City%of%Hamilton’s%Spatially%Indexed%Engineering%Records%System%(SPIDER)%–%Single%Process%System%%

2.&Letter&from&Executive&Administrator&&&&&See%Appendix%1:%Letter%from%Gary%Moore,%P.Eng.,%Director,%Engineering%Services%Division,%Public%Works%

Department,%City%of%Hamilton%

3.&System&summary&and&why&it&is&exemplary&&The%City%of%Hamilton’s%new%online%engineering%records%system%delivers%significant%efficiencies%in%locating%

information%about%the%City’s%public%infrastructure.%Called%SPIDER%(for%Spatially%Indexed%Engineering%Records),%

the%system%features%an%interactive%web%map%through%which%staff%and%partners%can%quickly%search%more%than%

250,000%engineering%records%with%six%distinct%themes%(design%drawings,%inspectors’%reports,%private%drain%

sketches,%easements,%geoctechnical%reports%and%utility%activity)%maintained%by%the%City’s%public%works%

department.%The%selfcserve%system%saves%the%City%approximately%2,100%staff%hours%per%year,%resulting%in%annual%

cost%savings%of%$130,000.%%

SPIDER%replaces%the%City’s%homegrown%Plan%and%Record%Index%System%(PRISM).%It%has%moved%users%from%a%card%

index%system%to%a%web%app%accessible%24/7%via%desktop%and%mobile%devices,%improving%support%for%project%and%

operational%uses.%The%new%system%provides%secure,%rolecbased%access%to%internal%departments%and%external%

partners,%such%as%utilities%and%engineering%consultants%and%contractors,%who%can%now%conduct%the%following%

types%of%searches%in%addition%to%keyword%or%topic%searches:%

•! Spatial%searches%c%users%can%draw%a%box%on%the%interactive%map%to%specify%their%area%of%interest.%The%GIS%

then%pulls%all%engineering%data%including%permits,%inspectors’%reports%and%easement%(rightcofcway)%

records%for%that%specific%area.%

•! Thumbnail%searches%c%users%can%scan%small%images%of%engineering%drawings%(e.g.,%bridges,%water%and%

sewer%networks)%to%quickly%find%what%they%need%without%opening%each%file.%

•! Combined%searches%–%users%can%search%various%public%works%data%repositories%with%one%query%and%view%

the%results%in%tabbed%form.%With%the%legacy%system,%users%had%to%submit%separate%queries%to%search%

each%type%of%dataset.%

SPIDER%is%exemplary%because%it%makes%it%significantly%easier%for%the%City’s%staff%and%partners%to%find%the%

information%they%need%to%perform%their%jobs.%It%is%currently%accessed%by%1,500%users%per%month%and%70%unique%

users%per%day.%The%system%receives%90,000%page%views%per%month%and%60%page%views%per%visit.%

Built%on%Esri’s%industrycleading%geographic%information%system%(GIS)%architecture,%SPIDER%is%scalable%and%can%be%

deployed%on%an%intranet%and%the%Internet.%The%GIScbased%system%provides%far%more%functionality%for%integrating,%

mapping%and%analyzing%data%than%the%City’s%previous%system.%This%helps%the%City%gain%further%efficiencies%as%it%

applies%GIS%to%other%projects%and%collects%more%data%about%its%infrastructure.%%

4.&User&testimonials&&See%Appendix%2:%Emails%from%Horizon%Utilities,%Union%Gas%&%Rogers%Communications%

Page 5: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%4%of%16%%%

B.&&Jurisdiction&&1.&Name&of&jurisdiction&City%of%Hamilton,%Ontario,%Canada&

2.&Population&served&by&the&organization/agency&&519,950%(2011)%

3.&Annual&total&budget&&$1,997,900,000%(2015%–%includes%operating%and%capital%budgets)%

4.&Chief&elected&official&&Fred%Eisenberger,%Mayor,%City%of%Hamilton%

[email protected]%

Phone:%905c546c4200%

Fax:%905c546c2340%

Hamilton%City%Hall%

2nd%floor%c%71%Main%Street%West%

Hamilton,%Ontario%L8P%4Y5%Canada%

5.&System&contacts&&Gord%McGuire,%Manager%of%Geomatics%&%Corridor%Management%

Public%Works,%City%of%Hamilton%

[email protected]%

Phone:%905c546c2424%x%2439%%

Fax:%905c546c2463%%

%

Charlie%Lauricella,%Senior%Project%Manager,%Technical%Services%

Public%Works,%City%of%Hamilton%

[email protected]%

Phone:%905c546c2424%x%2440%%

Fax:%905c546c2463%%

%

320c77%James%St%North,%Suite%320%

Hamilton,%Ontario%L8R%2K3%Canada%

C.&System&Design&&1.&What&motivated&the&system&development?&&The%City%of%Hamilton%is%one%of%Canada’s%topcranked%investment%cities.%Over%the%past%five%years,%the%City%has%

averaged%over%$1%billion%in%building%permit%values,%making%it%the%fastest%growing%economy%in%Ontario.%To%

support%this%growth,%the%City%continuously%looks%for%ways%to%facilitate%more%efficient%data%and%service%delivery%

by%leveraging%technology.%

In%2013,%the%City%of%Hamilton’s%public%works%department%evaluated%Esri’s%ArcGIS%Online%solution%to%see%how%the%

cloudcbased%GIS%platform%could%be%used%in%their%operations.%The%team%attended%the%Esri%International%User%

Page 6: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%5%of%16%%%

Conference%in%San%Diego,%California%and%were%struck%by%the%overwhelming%number%of%apps%that%could%be%

developed%with%the%technology.%Inspired%by%what%they%had%seen,%they%worked%with%Esri%Canada’s%Professional%

Services%team%to%revamp%Hamilton’s%online%engineering%records%system.%%

The%department%wanted%to%increase%efficiency%by%consolidating%all%the%City’s%engineering%records%into%one%

system%and%providing%staff%and%partners%with%better%access%to%the%records.%The%City’s%previous%homegrown%Plan%

and%Record%Index%System%(PRISM)%was%neither%scalable%nor%intuitive.%As%well,%it%lacked%many%features%and%

functionality.%Although%the%system%allowed%both%internal%and%external%users%to%conduct%spatial%searches,%PRISM%

did%not%filter%the%data%results,%requiring%users%to%comb%through%thousands%of%plans%to%find%what%they%were%

looking%for.%%

In%2014,%the%City%retired%PRISM%and%launched%SPIDER,%which%allows%staff%and%partners%to%access%more%than%

250,000%engineering%records%through%an%interactive%Web%map.%Some%of%the%maintenance%tools%from%the%

previous%system%are%still%leveraged;%however,%the%user%interface%has%changed%significantly%and%has%been%made%

more%usercfriendly.%%%

Within%its%first%month%of%release,%SPIDER%received%more%than%1,500%visits%and%has%provided%the%City%with%an%

efficient%datacsharing%framework.%%

2.! What&specific&service&or&services&was&the&system&intended&to&improve?&&SPIDER%was%intended%to%provide%Hamilton’s%staff%and%partners%with%enhanced%online%access%to%the%vast%number%

of%engineering%records%(e.g.,%bridges,%sewer,%water%network,%road%construction,%parks%and%contract%records)%

that%exist%in%the%City’s%digital%vault%and%other%record%libraries.%This%helps%accelerate%and%inform%municipal%

processes%including:%

•! development%application%approvals%

•! urban%planning%and%design%

•! public%works%construction%projects%

•! utility%installation%projects%

•! drainage%studies%and%projects%

•! transportation/multicmodal%master%plans%

•! LRT%support%

%

More%importantly,%the%system%expands%the%use%of%valuable%information%across%the%entire%Corporation.%%

3.&What,&if&any,&unexpected&benefits&did&you&achieve?&&In%addition%to%accelerated%record%access,%costceffective%searching%and%delivery%of%accurate%records%to%staff%for%

better%decisions,%SPIDER%provides%the%following%benefits:%

•! ability%to%add%more%data%layers%(e.g.,%easements,%utility%permitting)%to%the%system%without%

customization,%which%the%previous%system%did%not%allow%

•! ability%to%query%and%display%multiple%datasets%simultaneously%in%one%interface,%providing%a%more%

comprehensive%view%and%richer%context%for%engineering%records.%Previously,%users%had%to%log%into%

several%systems%to%access%different%types%of%records.%

Page 7: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%6%of%16%%%

•! a%large,%open%platform%that%provides%opportunities%for%further%system%integration—delivering%greater%

efficiency%and%cost%savings%

4.&What&system&design&problems&were&encountered?&&There%were%no%significant%system%design%problems%encountered%because%the%scope%of%the%project%was%wellc

defined.%While%there%was%a%minor%issue%encountered%opening%the%web%map%services%externally,%the%issue%was%

quickly%resolved%by%adjusting%the%system’s%configuration.%

5.&What&differentiates&this&system&from&other&similar&systems?&&Record%indexing%has%taken%many%forms%over%the%years.%There%are%card%indexes,%plancbased%indexes,%databases%

and%now%SPIDER.%A%common%recurring%issue%in%research%is%finding%the%right%record.%While%many%records%are%

indexed%by%street%name%or%some%other%indicator,%that%particular%indicator%may%change.%This%leads%to%“orphaned”%

records,%which%have%lost%their%connection%with%other%data%(the%parent%record),%and%are%not%easily%found%in%

regular%searches.%

Unlike%other%systems,%SPIDER%provides%rapid,%accurate%searches%by%spatially%locating%records.%Finding%records%by%

geographic%location%decreases%the%dependence%on%other%indicators%or%features%to%be%able%to%locate%the%image%of%

the%file.%%

%

Users%simply%select%their%area%of%interest%on%the%interactive%web%map%(SPIDER’s%main%search%tool)%and%the%

system%automatically%drills%through%the%City’s%database%and%returns%the%results.%

D.&Implementation&&1.&What&phases&did&you&go&through&in&developing&the&system?&&The%system%was%created%using%established%project%management%methodologies%and%completed%in%six%phases:%

1)! Project%Initiation%–%This%initial%phase%involved%key%Esri%Canada%project%team%leads%and%the%City%project%

champion.%

%

Page 8: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%7%of%16%%%

2)! Project%Requirements/Business%Analysis%c%Focus%groups%were%conducted%involving%internal%IT%staff%at%the%

data%centre%and%the%spatial%solutions%groups.%%%

3)! Design%–%The%system’s%design%was%created%by%staff%within%the%public%works%department,%specifically%

within%geomatics,%along%with%the%Esri%Canada%development%team%and%City%IT%support.%

4)! Development%–%The%system’s%development%was%mostly%driven%by%the%geomatics%team%and%the%user%

groups%within%public%works%as%they%were%closest%to%the%project.%

5)! Testing%&%Deployment%c%The%testing%phase%was%completed%by%the%Esri%Canada%development%team%and%

public%works%geomatics%senior%and%technical%staff.%

6)! Training%&%Closure%–%The%Esri%Canada%development%team%provided%handoff%training%to%senior%and%

technical%geomatics%staff%within%the%public%works%department,%who%then%conducted%a%series%of%training%

workshops%for%City%staff%and%external%clients.%%

2.&Were&there&any&modifications&to&the&original&system&design?&Why?&What?&&Yes,%the%department%initially%envisioned%developing%one%application%that%served%both%internal%and%external%

clients.%However,%after%many%considerations%and%system%security%concerns,%they%decided%that%two%SPIDER%

interfaces%were%necessary%to%facilitate%their%stakeholders’%needs:%one%application%for%City%of%Hamilton%staff%and%

the%other%for%municipal%partners.%%%

E.&Organizational&Impact&&1.&What&user&community&does&the&system&serve&and&how?&&SPIDER%provides%online%record%access%to%the%following%groups:%

•! Internal%public%works%(engineering,%surveying%and%construction)%teams%%

•! Internal%business%users%–%operations%and%planning%teams%

•! External%partners%–%utilities,%design%contractors%and%consultants%

Through%efficient%searches,%these%users%are%able%to%more%rapidly%find%the%records%they%need%to%make%better%

decisions.%

2.&What&are&the&ultimate&decisions/operations/services&being&affected?&If&appropriate,&provide&a&few&examples&including,&but&not&limited&to:&screen&input/output&forms,&paper&products,&or&other&descriptive&graphics.&&SPIDER%enables%several%types%of%searches%aside%from%basic%keyword/topic%searches.%%

•! Spatial%searches%c%users%can%draw%a%box%on%the%interactive%map%to%specify%their%area%of%interest.%The%GIS%

then%pulls%all%engineering%data%including%permits,%inspectors’%reports%and%easement%(rightcofcway)%

records%for%that%specific%area.%

Page 9: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%8%of%16%%%

%

•! Thumbnail%searches%c%users%can%scan%small%images%of%engineering%drawings%(e.g.,%bridges,%water%and%

sewer%networks)%to%quickly%find%what%they%need%without%opening%each%file.%

%

•! Combined%searches%–%users%can%search%various%public%works%data%repositories%with%one%query%and%view%

the%results%in%tabbed%form.%With%the%legacy%system,%users%had%to%submit%separate%queries%to%search%

each%type%of%dataset.%

Page 10: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%9%of%16%%%

%

3.&What&were&the&quantitative&and&qualitative&impacts&of&the&system?&&SPIDER%delivers%significant%quantitative%benefits:%

•! The%selfcserve%system%saves%the%City%approximately%2,100%staff%hours%per%year,%resulting%in%annual%cost%

savings%of%$130,000.%

•! Available%24/7,%it%saves%users%considerable%time%by%eliminating%the%need%to%wait%for%City%staff%to%fulfill%

their%information%requests.%

It%also%provides%the%following%qualitative%benefits:%

•! better%access%to%more%comprehensive%data%for%informed%decisioncmaking%

•! richer%context%to%data%with%the%addition%of%graphical%layers%to%existing%infrastructure%(e.g.,%sewer,%

electrical%layers%for%better%context%to%what’s%actually%out%there)%

•! increased%accuracy%of%record%results%from%spatial%searches%

•! enhanced%user%experience%through%an%intuitive,%usercfriendly%app%interface%

4.&What&effect&has&the&system&had&on&productivity?&&The%system%has%significantly%increased%the%productivity%of%City%staff%and%partners%because%they%can%now%quickly%

access%Hamilton’s%engineering%records%on%a%web%browser%via%their%desktop%or%mobile%device%24/7.%With%the%

previous%system,%conducting%research%was%a%long%process—it%took%several%minutes%to%refresh%the%web%map%that%

served%as%the%main%search%tool.%The%new%ArcGIScbased%system%delivers%high%performance%and%agility.%Through%

selfcservices,%SPIDER%has%freed%up%staff%members’%time%to%focus%on%other%projects%and%has%enabled%external%

partners%to%spend%more%time%on%data%analysis%and%project%planning.%

5.&What,&if&any,&other&impacts&have&the&system&had?&&SPIDER%maximizes%the%value%of%the%City’s%data%by%making%it%more%accessible%to%stakeholders.%It%also%presents%

opportunities%for%further%extending%the%system%to%other%municipal%clients%for%better%decision%support.%%%

Page 11: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%10%of%16%%

6.&How&did&the&system&change&the&way&business&is&conducted&with&and/or&service&delivered&to&clients?&Give&specific&examples&comparing&the&old&way&with&the&new.&&With%PRISM,%searching%for%engineering%and%survey%records%was%a%long%process%because%the%system%did%not%allow%

simultaneous%searches%of%multiple%data%repositories.%There%was%no%integration%between%the%various%databases%

so%users%needed%to%look%up%several%databases%to%access%the%datasets%they%needed.%As%well,%search%results%could%

not%be%filtered%so%users%needed%to%comb%through%all%of%the%documents%to%find%the%information%they%needed.%%

SPIDER%provides%a%simpler,%more%efficient%way%of%finding%records%and%provides%several%options%to%conduct%

searches%(by%keyword,%spatial,%database%or%thumbnail).%It%leverages%more%powerful%and%robust%ArcGIS%

technology%that%enables%consistently%rapid%searches%in%a%secure%online%environment.%The%technology%is%highly%

scalable%and%can%support%virtually%an%unlimited%number%of%data%layers%as%well%as%handle%any%spikes%or%surges%in%

usage.%As%well,%ArcGIS%provides%the%City%with%a%platform%to%organize%its%various%mapping%systems%and%apps.%

Below%is%the%City’s%gallery%of%web%apps%in%ArcGIS%Online%through%which%users%can%access%SPIDER.%%

%

F.&System&Resources&&1.&What&are&the&system’s&primary&hardware&components?&Give&a&brief&list&or&description&of&the&hardware&configuration&supporting&the&system.&&SPIDER’s%hardware%configuration%consists%of%the%following:%

•! one%database%server%(Oracle)%

•! two%file%servers%

•! one%ArcGIS%Server%(virtual)%%

•! one%DMZ%Server%(virtual)%

See%Appendix%3:%System%Architecture%

Page 12: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%11%of%16%%

2.&What&are&the&system’s&primary&software&components?&Describe&the&primary&software&and,&if&a&commercial&package,&any&customizations&required&for&the&system.&&New%geometry%and%data%are%entered%into%the%system%using%PRISM,%which%writes%directly%to%the%Oracle%tables%on%

the%database%server.%%Safe%Software’s%FME%Server%is%used%(with%created%scripts)%to%extract%the%Oracle%tables%into%

the%ArcGIS%file%geodatabase.%%The%ArcGIS%file%geodatabase%is%used%as%the%primary%database%and%ArcMap%is%

leveraged%to%facilitate%the%creation%of%the%web%mapping%services%for%SPIDER.%%These%services%are%stored%on%the%

ArcGIS%Server,%which%also%houses%the%SPIDER%API%for%internal%use.%%The%other%SPIDER%API%is%stored%on%the%DMZ%

server%to%give%access%to%external%clients.%

3.&What&data&does&the&system&work&with?&List&and&briefly&describe&the&database(s).&There%are%two%main%databases%used%for%SPIDER:%

•! Oracle%spatial%corporate%database%–%this%serves%as%the%maintenance%database%where%all%new%data%

entered%via%PRISM%is%maintained.%

•! ArcGIS%file%geodatabase%–%this%is%the%primary%publication%database%that%is%created%each%evening%using%

FME%scripts.%

4.&What&staff&resources&were&required&to&implement&the&system?&(i.e.,&report&approximate&staff&and&consultant&time&as&FTEs)&&The%system%required%a%small%team%of%internal%staff%and%consultants%including:%

•! 3%internal%staff%members:%geomatics%manager,%senior%project%manager%and%an%IT%staff%member%who%

provided%hardware,%network%services%and%database%administration%support.%Twenty%percent%of%their%

time%was%spent%on%the%project%across%an%8cmonth%window,%which%translates%into%approximately%4%

months%of%staff%time.%

•! 6%Esri%Canada%Professional%Services%consultants%spent%approximately%.5%FTE%(combined)%of%effort%over%

the%course%of%the%8cmonth%project.%

5.&Comment&on&anything&unusual&about&the&resources&used&to&develop&your&system,&such&as&data,&software,&personnel&and&financing.&&SPIDER%is%unique%in%that%it%is%the%City’s%largest%and%most%robust%system%deployed%in%the%cloud.%It%also%uses%a%

purely%Esri%development%environment.%The%API%for%external%clients%leverages%ArcGIS%Online,%Esri’s%cloudcbased%

GIS%solution,%which%is%proven%technology.%The%platform%is%highly%scalable,%providing%the%City%with%opportunities%

to%add%more%data%layers%and%functionality%to%SPIDER%and%branch%out%to%other%audiences.%For%example,%raster%

survey%plans%are%currently%only%available%as%Excel%files,%flat%files%and%databases.%With%ArcGIS,%the%City%is%looking%

to%provide%access%to%more%relevant%record%systems%such%as%encroachments,%easements%and%legal%surveys%to%a%

broader%audience.%This%will%support%groups%beyond%the%engineering%realm,%such%as%those%in%administration,%real%

estate%and%land%surveying.%%

Page 13: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%12%of%16%%

G.&Appendices&1.&Letter&from&Executive&Administrator&

%

Page 14: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%13%of%16%%

2.&User&Testimonials&a)! Horizon)Utilities)

From:)Newitt,)Andrew)[mailto:[email protected]]))Sent:)June>06>16)9:52)AM)To:)Howard,)Bob)Subject:)SPIDER)testimonial)

Hi!Bob,!

I’m!a!Supervisor!at!Horizon!Utilities!with!four!technicians!reporting!to!me.!!Within!my!department!are!a!total!of!twelve!technologists/technicians!and!currently!two!coBop!students.!!All!staff!within!this!department!regularly!access!the!SPIDER!software!for!all!municipal!consent!drawings.!!The!software!is!quick!and!easy!to!use,!giving!indication!of!all!existing!plans!of!underground!and!aboveground!infrastructure!and!their!offsets,!within!the!area!in!question.!!Through!the!use!of!SPIDER,!we!are!able!to!quickly!provide!composite!utility!designs!that!allows!the!City!of!Hamilton!to!process!our!Municipal!Consent!permits!quickly!and!efficiently.!

Should!any!party!have!any!questions!or!concerns!in!regards!to!this!testimonial!they!can!feel!free!to!contact!me!per!my!details!below.!

Thank!you,!

Andrew!Newitt,!C.E.T.,!MMP%Supervisor,!Engineering!Design%Horizon!Utilities!Corporation%55!John!Street!North%Hamilton,!ON!!L8R!3M8%Phone:!905B522B6611!Ext.!2338%Cell:!905B807B1077%Email:[email protected]%www.horizonutilities.com%!%

%

) )

Page 15: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%14%of%16%%

b)! Union)Gas)

From:)Greco,)Enzo)[mailto:[email protected]]))Sent:)June>07>16)1:06)PM)To:)Howard,)Bob)Subject:)RE:)SPIDER)testimonial)

Hello%Bob,%

As%a%manager%within%the%Union%Gas%cConstruction%and%Growth%Department,%I’ve%understood%the%ongoing%need%

for%mapping%information%in%order%for%us%to%plan%and%install%our%new%and%replacement%infrastructure%within%your%

road%allowances.%Our%staff%of%planners/coordinators,%project%managers%and%drafters%have%become%dependent%

on%your%online%engineering%records%system%as%a%required%step%in%our%process%to%submit%Municipal%Consent%

applications.%We%spend%the%time%ahead%of%MC%application%to%ensure%that%all%known%information%is%reflected%on%

our%drawing%submission.%We%have%found%that%Spider%much%like%your%former%PRISM%software%is%very%easy%to%use%

since%we%can%spatially%locate%the%records%geographically%which%is%ideal%in%our%GIS%setting.%Once%in%the%specific%

location,%we%can%pull%all%of%the%most%current%engineering%drawings%and%construction%records%to%serve%our%

purpose.%

This%access%to%Spider%coupled%with%our%design%locate%process%for%our%complex%work%delivers%significant%

efficiencies%in%locating%information%within%the%City%of%Hamilton.%It%will%inevitably%reduce%construction%down%time%

and%added%costs%to%both%the%Union%Gas%and%the%City.%More%importantly%is%the%safety%aspect%of%having%accurate%

information%that%is%vital%in%ensuring%safety%in%our%communities%during%times%of%construction.%

Although%there%has%been%a%significant%investment%by%the%City%with%this%program,%it%does%deliver%with%the%most%

accurate%information%possible%for%the%City%and%all%of%its%external%partners.%Since%we%feel%strongly%about%the%

partnership%between%Union%Gas%and%the%City%of%Hamilton%and%your%investment,%we%feel%obligated%to%ensure%that%

we%use%your%product%and%help%you%to%benefit%from%any%efficiencies%within%your%MC%review%process.%%

Union%Gas%works%within%numerous%communities%within%Ontario%and%this%engineering%records%system%is%second%

to%none%from%what%I’ve%encountered%over%the%years.%Keep%up%the%effort%to%update%the%product,%the%end%result%

can%only%be%positive%for%all%involved.%

Sincerely,!

Enzo!Greco!!Construction!Project!Manager,!Hamilton!District!!Union!Gas!Limited!|!A!Spectra!Energy!Company!918!South!Service!Road,!Stoney!Creek,!ON!L8E!5M4!Phone:!(289)!649B2061!|!Cell:!(905)!741B8395!Email:[email protected]!|!www.uniongas.com!

%

Page 16: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%15%of%16%%

c)! Rogers%Communications%

From:/Richard)Bolliger)<[email protected]>)Sent:/Wednesday,)June)8,)2016)8:02)AM)To:/Howard,)Bob)Subject:/City)of)Hamilton)>)SPIDER)testimonial)

Hi%Bob,%%

Rogers%Communications%system%planners%and%design%consultants%prepare%MC%drawings%for%the%various%projects.%

Having%access%to%the%City%online%selfcserve%information%provides%excellent%benefits%when%developing%accurate%

permit%drawings.%%Once%the%field%survey%has%been%obtained,%working%with%existing%records%using%tools%such%as%

the%“Spider%application”%certainly%helps%the%consent%process%determine%approval.%%

I%agree%this%is%a%very%beneficial%product.%It%allows%full%access%to%many%important%GIS%features%when%developing%a%

utility%drawing.%The%easier%and%faster%access%to%existing%City%and%utility%information%simplifies%the%permit%drawing%

process%with%fewer%errors%or%conflicts.%Overall,%the%accuracy%of%a%plan%is%key%to%understanding%the%existing%City%%

rcocw%for%both%U/G%or%above/Ground%facilities.%%

The%permit%approval%digital%process%is%most%efficient,%saves%paper,%time%and%money%and%makes%it%easy%to%review%

existing%infrastructure,%offsets%and%property%information.%

Regards,%

Richard!Bolliger!Municipal!&!Utility!Relations!!South!Western!Ontario!Region!Rogers!Communications!|!Wireline!Access!Networks!85!Grand!Crest!Place!Kitchener!ON,[email protected]%o!519B894B8142!!m!519B572B9981%

% %

%%

% %

Page 17: 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application · 2016 URISA Exemplary Systems in Government Award Application City of Hamilton’s Spatially Indexed Engineering Records

City%of%Hamilton%% % %%%%%%2016%URISA%ESIG%Award%Application%

%

Page%16%of%16%%

3.!System&Architecture&%

%

%

%