2 Establish Requirements
description
Transcript of 2 Establish Requirements
1
Essential Nutrients
•Necessary for normal function
•Must obtain from an exogenous source
•Inadequate intake leads to deficiency*
There are 6 classes of Nutrients
Water
Lipids (fat)
Proteins
Carbohydrates
Minerals
Vitamins
The Nutrients
Whitney & Rolfes. Understanding Nutrition. 2011
2
The Science of Nutrition
Foundation in several other sciences
Biology, biochemistry, physiology
Tremendous growth
Sequencing of human genome
Nutritional genomics
Conducting Research
• Use of scientific method
– Systematic process for conducting research
• Research studies
– Controls
• Randomization
– Sample size
– Placebos
– Double-blind experiments
3
The Scientific Method
Conducting Research
• Epidemiological studies
– Cross-sectional studies
– Case-control studies
– Cohort studies
• Experimental studies
– Laboratory-based animal studies
– Laboratory-base in vitro studies
– Clinical trials
4
The Scientific Process
• Identification
• Establish need
• Understand mechanisms of actions
• Identify role in health & disease
• Toxicity
How much of each nutrient do we need?
Needs (requirements) are determined scientifically
using evidence-base approach
5
Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI) A set of standards that define the amounts of energy, nutrients,
other dietary components and physical activity that best support health.
DRI consists of
Estimated Average Requirements (EAR)
Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA)
Adequate Intakes (AI)
Tolerable Upper Intake Levels (UL)
(Reading: Understanding Nutrition)
Danger of
toxicity
Marginal
Tolerable
Upper Intake
Level Safety
Safety
Inta
ke
RDA or AI
RDA Estimated
Average
Requirement
Marginal
Danger Danger
of
deficiency
Inaccurate
view
Accurate
view Understanding Nutrition, 2011
(UL)
(EAR)
6
If a person’s usual intake falls above the RDA,
the intake is probably adequate because the
RDA covers the needs of almost all people.
High Intake
probably
adequate
RDA
A usual intake that falls between the
RDA and the EAR is more difficult to
assess; the intake may be adequate, but
the chances are greater or equal that it
is inadequate.
Intake possibly
inadequate
EAR
Usu
al in
tak
e o
f n
utr
ien
t X
(u
nit
s/d
ay)
Intake
probably
inadequate
If the usual intake falls below the
EAR, it is probably inadequate.
Low Understanding Nutrition, 2011
7
Methods to determine requirements
2 Approaches
- Epidemiological
- Experimental
a) Depletion / repletion
b) Balance study (e.g. nitrogen)
c) Factorial approach (e.g. energy)
d) Isotopic study
Epidemiological data provides
approximate (ball-park) values
on requirements
8
Important concepts on nutrient requirements
When intake is established by epidemiological or experimental approaches, a
scatter plot is obtained.
Usually, this is normally distributed. 50% of the population takes in more than
the mean while the remaining 50% of the population takes in less than the mean.
The range of intake is described as BIOLOGICAL VARIATION – generally
estimated to be 15% (i.e. one standard deviation)
Assuming the intake is the physiological need, then 50% of the population will
have needs above the mean intake.
To ensure the majority of the population is free from
deficiency, a level of intake higher than the mean should be
recommended.
Mean + 2SD will statistically cover the needs of
97.5% of the population.
There may be 2.5% of the population whose requirements
are higher than mean+2SD. If these individuals just
consume that particular nutrient at the level of RDA – they
may run into a risk of not having enough.
9
Understanding Nutrition, 2011
Does subject C meet his need for nutrient X ?
10
Energy requirement versus nutrient requirement
Energy requirement is set at the mean of the
population
Requirements for other essential nutrients are set
using statistical approaches and therefore include
a margin of safety.
Characteristics of
Recommended Daily Allowance (RDA)
•For healthy individuals
•Include a generous margin of safety
•Apply to average daily intakes
•Does not cover therapeutic needs
•Does not allow for losses of nutrients due to cooking,
storage or processing