0123 456*7%82(9:3
Transcript of 0123 456*7%82(9:3
çè·å ŽâŸ¯ã«ããã確èªäžâŸãåŒãèµ·ãã
èŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš å·Šå©éŠš*1 å µè€å¥œçŸ*1 ✥äžå ±âŒŠ*2 äºçŠæ倫*1
Consideration about recognition of factors causing lack of confirmation in the nursing scene
Zuo Wanxin *1, Yoshimi Hyodo*1 Tomoko Tanaka *2 and Akio Gofuku*1
Abstract - In the work process of nurses with high risk, it is very urgent to take countermeasures against
the âlack of confirmationâ of the main factors. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to clarify the details
of the factors leading to the lack of confirmation, grasp the number of near misses, and to explore what kind
of factors the individual characteristics of the nurse who acts as a stopper. We recruited 500 nurses on the
Web and asked about the frequency of near misses due to lack of confirmation, the awareness of the causes
of lack of confirmation, self-evaluation of stoppers, and the reasons why near misses did not lead to
accidents. As a result, three factors were extracted regarding the recognition of the factors of lack of
confirmation: "lack of consciousness", "inability to concentrate", and "lack of knowledge / experience".
Three factors were extracted for self-evaluation of stopper characteristics: "awareness," "verification," and
"cautiousness". In order to reduce the lack of confirmation, it is necessary to secure and allocate appropriate
personnel and create an environment where treatment can be concentrated. Nurses should also raise
knowledge and the awareness of the importance of confirmation. In addition, it is necessary to improve the
clinical judgment of new nurses in order to prevent near misses. And it is thought that new nurses will
become more confident by accumulating experience and affirming their abilities from their superiors,
seniors and colleagues.
Keywords : lack of confirmation, stoppers, nurse
1.ã¯ããã«
1999幎 暪æµåžâŒ€ç é¢ã®æ£è åãéãäºæ ããã£ããã«ãâœæ¬ã§ãå»çäºæ ã«å¯Ÿããé¢âŒŒã⟌ãŸããå®å šãªå»çãæ±ããããã«ãªã£ããå✣åŽåçã¯ã2001 幎ã«å»çå®å šå¯Ÿçãããã¯ãŒã¯äºæ¥ãéå§ãã2004 幎ã«ã¯âœæ¬å»çæ©èœè©äŸ¡æ©æ§ã«ãããŠãå»çäºæ äºäŸçã®åéãéå§ãããã
2019 幎ã«å»çäºæ ã«é¢ä¿ããåœäºè è·çš®(éè€è§£çå¯)ã®å ±åæ°ã5,673件ã§ãå幎床(4,565件)ããå¢å ããŠãã 1ããã®çŽåæ°ã§ãã 2,673件ã«ãçè·åž«ã®é¢äžãèªãããããå¶æ£®(2004)ã¯çè·åž«ã®âœŽå Žã«ã€ããŠã次ã®ããã«è¿°ã¹ãŠãããçè·åž«ã¯å»åž«ãšäžŠãã§æ£è ã«çŽæ¥å»çãæäŸãã圹å²ãæ ã£ãŠãã 2ããããŠç
è·åž«ã¯æ£è ã®æããã°ã«ããŠãæãå»çäºæ ã®åœäºè ã«ãªããããâœŽå Žã«ãã 2ããã®æå³ã§ãçè·åž«ã¯ãå»çäºæ ã«é¢äžãããªã¹ã¯ãæã⟌ãè·çš®ã§ãããšâŸãããã çè·åž«ã¯ã⟌床ãªå€æãèŠããé è³åŽåãâŸäœåŽåãæ ãããããè€æ°ã®æ¥åãåæã«ããªããªããã°ãªããªããæ²»çã®ãããã段éã«é¢äžããå¯èœæ§ããããæ£è ãšã®æ¥è§Šæéãâ»ãã⌌ççãªè² æ ã⌀ãããããã«è¿å¹Žã¯ãå»çã®âŸŒåºŠåãåšé¢âœæ°ã®ççž®åãå»çã«å¯ŸããããŒãºã®å€æ§åãé²ãã§ãããä»åŸãçè·æ¥åãããè€éåããããšãäºæž¬ãããããããã£ãçè·åž«æ¥åäžã®ç¹æ§ãçè·æ¥çãåãå·»ãç¶æ³ããå»çäºæ ãå»çå ŽâŸ¯ã§ã®ãã€ãªãããã«å°ãªããã圱é¿ããŠãããã®ãšèããããã âœæ¬å»çæ©èœè©äŸ¡æ©æ§ã«ãããå»çäºæ æ å ±åéçäºæ¥ã»å¹³æ 28å¹Žå¹Žå ±ã«ãããšã2016幎 1âœã12âœå»çäºæ ãšããŠå ±å
*1:岡山倧åŠå€§åŠé¢ãã«ã¹ã·ã¹ãã çµ±åç§åŠç 究ç§
*2:岡山倧åŠå€§åŠé¢ç€ŸäŒæåç§åŠç 究ç§*1: Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Science and Engineering in
Health Systems , Okayama University *2: Graduate School of Humanities and Social Sciences, Okayama
University
ãç 究ããŒãã
29ïŒ 29 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
ïŒ 29 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
ããã 3,428件ã®çºâœ£èŠå 件æ°(è€æ°åç)ã®ãã¡ãæãå€ãã®ã¯ã確èªãæ ã£ãã(11.3%)3ã§ãã£ããšããã次ãã§ãæ£è åŽã(11.2%)ãã芳å¯ãæ ã£ãã(10.5%)ã®é 3ãšããããªãè€äºã(2020)ã¯ãç é¢ã«ãããã確èªäžâŸããšããèŠå ããè¬å€ãæ²»çåŠçœ®ãæ€æ»ãçé€äžã®äžè©±ãªã©ãã€ã³ã·ãã³ãåé¡ã®ãã¹ãŠã®é ✬ã§âŸŒãå²åã✰ã 4ããšãææããŠããã
çŸåšãæŠç¥çãã¥ãŒãã³ãšã©ãŒå¯Ÿçã«ãããŠãæãå¹æã⌀ããã®ã¯âŒ¯åŠç察çã§ãããæãæåŸ ã§ããªã察çã¯âŒéã®âŒŒçã«å¯Ÿãã察çã§ãã 5ãšâŸãããŠãããå±éºã®æé€ãšããŠã第âŒã«ç°å¢æŽåãåªå ãã¹ãã§ããããšã«ç°è«ã¯ãªãã ãããããããªããããšã©ãŒãæ〈確çã«çããããã«ã¯ãããšãããªã¹ã¯ã®âŸŒãçè·åž«ã®äœæ¥éçšã«ãããŠããšã©ãŒçºâœ£ã«âŒ€ããªåœ¹å²ãæããã確èªäžâŸããžã®å¯Ÿçãè¬ããããšããå«ç·ã®èª²é¡ãšããããäžæã(2016)ã¯ãå»çäºæ ãã€ã³ã·ãã³ããæªç¶ã«é²ãããã«ã¯ããã®äºäŸã確å®ãã€çŽ æ©ãææ¡ãããã®èæ¯ã«ãããšã©ãŒã✣ããåå ãåæããé©åã«å¯ŸåŠããããšãæå¹ã§ãã 6ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠããã確èªäžâŸã«ããã€ã³ã·ãã³ãã®åå ã«ã€ããŠãè€äºã(2020)ã¯ãå€å€ãªã©ã®äº€æ¿å€åãå®æœããŠããããšãçè·åž«ãšããŠã®çµéšå¹Žæ°ãæ✰ã®èªã¿åããäžç¢ºå®ãªããšã圱é¿ãã 4ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠããããŸããâ»âŒã(2016)ã¯æã蟌ã¿ããééãã§ããã¯ãããªããšâŸåãé²ããããšã確èªäžâŸã«ã€ãªãã 7ãšææããŠãããããã«ãæž¡éšã(2010)ã¯ãæã蟌ã¿ãé¯èŠãããå調ãªåäœã®ç¹°ãè¿ãã«ããæèã®äœäžãããè¿éã»çç¥æ¬èœãããäžéæ¥åãâŒã£ããä»æ¥åãåªå ãããããŠããŸãããšãã£ãâŸåãã確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã§ãã 8ãšå ±åããŠãããããããªãããçè·åž«ãã©ã®ãããªå ŽâŸ¯ã«ãããŠç¢ºèªäžâŸã«é¥ããããã®ããå æ¬çèŠç¹ã«ãããåæã¯âŸåœãããªãã ãã¥ãŒãã³ãšã©ãŒãçç¡ã«ããããšã¯é£ãããããšã©ãŒã®æ©
æçºâŸããšã©ãŒã✣ããããªç¶æ ãæ¹åããããšã¯ã§ãããããŒãºã®âœ³ãæããŠé²âŸããŠãã✮ãâœãããã®ãããªãã¡ã¹ããããŒãšãªãååšãããã°ãäºæ ãžã®é²âŸéçšãâœããããããã®æ©èœãããçºæ®ããçè·åž«ãããã€ã¹ããããŒããŒã¹ãšä»®ç§°ããã ãã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡ã⟌ãè ã¯ã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªãããã¯å°ãªãã®ãã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãšã®é¢ä¿ã¯ããã®ãã確èªäžâŸã«é¥ãèŠå ã«é¢ããŠãäºæ é²âœèœâŒã®âŸŒãâŒã¯ã©ããªèªèãæã£ãŠããã®ããç¥ãããšã¯ãäºæ é²âœã«ãšã£ãŠâŒ€äºãªåŽâŸ¯ã§ãããšèããã ããã§æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ã確èªäžâŸã«âŸãèŠå ã®è©³çŽ°ãæããã«ãããšå ±ã«ãã¹ããããŒãšãªãããŒã¹ã®åâŒç¹æ§ãšã®é¢é£ã«ã€ããŠãæ¢çŽ¢ããããšã✬çãšããã
2.ç 究✠æ³
2.1 調æ»âœ æ³ãšå¯Ÿè±¡è ã¯ãã¹ã»ããŒã±ãã£ã³ã°ç€Ÿã®æããããã«ãå©âœ€ããWeb äžã«ãŠèª¿æ»ãžã®åå è ãåããåçãµã³ãã«ãåŸãããµã³ãã«ãåéããããã®åçç»âŸ¯ã®äœæãšåçããŒã¿ã®åéã«ã€ããŠã¯ãã¯ãã¹ã»ããŒã±ãã£ã³ã°ç€Ÿã«å§èšãããåçè ã®èšå®ãšããŠãåçæç¹ã«ãããŠçè·åž«ãšããŠçŸè·ãæããããšãæ¡ä»¶ãšããã
2.2 調æ»æé 調æ»æéã¯2020幎3âœ6âœã3âœ9âœã§ãã£ãã 2.3 調æ»å 容 2.3.1 å±æ§ å±æ§ãšããŠãæ§å¥ã幎霢ãå± äœå°åãå€å幎æ°ãæå±éšçœ²ãè·
äœãå°ããã 2.3.2 確èªäžâŸã«ãããã€ãªãããã®é »åºŠ 察象è ãã2019幎床(â19幎 4âœãâ20幎 2âœ)ã®éã«ç¢ºèªäžâŸã«ãããã€ãªããããèµ·ããããšâŸèŠããèšæ¶ããŠããåæ°ã®å ±åãæ±ããã
2.3.3 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªè 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªèãåã20é ✬ãèšå®ããããããã¯ãå»çæ©èœè©äŸ¡æ©æ§ã®ããŒã ããŒãžã«æ²èŒãããã2010 幎ãã2019幎3âœãŸã§ã®éã«ãçè·åž«ã®ç¢ºèªäžâŸã«ããèµ·ãããšããã 128 件ã®å»çäºæ ã®æ å ±ãåç §ãããã®èæ¯èŠå ãšããããã®ãããšã«äœæãããè©å®æ³ã¯ã ã1:å šãããŠã¯ãŸããªãããã2:ããŸãã«ããŠã¯ãŸããªãããã3:ã©ã¡ããšãâŸããªãããã4:ããåœãŠã¯ãŸãããã5:⌀å€åœãŠã¯ãŸããã® 5 件æ³ãšããã
2.3.4 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«é¢ããâŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡ ã¹ããããŒãšããŠæ©èœããçè·åž«ã®åâŒç¹æ§ã«ã€ããŠãâŸâŒ°è©å®ãæ±ãã 20 é ✬ãèšå®ããããããã¯ã✥äžã(2013)ãå ±åããå»çäºæ ã®ãã€ã¹ããããŒããŒã¹ã«ã¿ãããç¹æ§ 9ãããšã«äœæããã確èªãçè«æ§ãçºä¿¡ãäºæž¬ãææ§ã俯ç°ã®èŠçŽ ãå«ããã1:å šãããŠã¯ãŸããªãããã2:ããŸãã«ããŠã¯ãŸããªãããã3:ã©ã¡ããšãâŸããªãããã4:ããåœãŠã¯ãŸãããã5:⌀å€åœãŠã¯ãŸããã® 5 件æ³ãšããã
2.4 åæâœ æ³ å¯Ÿè±¡è ã®å±æ§ã¯ãèšè¿°ççµ±èšã✀ããŠæŽçãããå±æ§éã«ãããåçã®å·®ã¯ãtæ€å®ãããã¯1èŠå ã®åæ£åæã«ãã£ãŠæ€èšããææâœæºã¯äž¡åŽ 5%ãšããã 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªè 20 é ✬ã«å¯ŸããŠãäž»å ⌊æ³ã»
Promaxå転ã«ããå ⌊åæãâŸã£ãããŸããå±æ§ã«ããåçã®å·®ã¯ tæ€å®ãããã¯1èŠå ã®åæ£åæã«ãã£ãŠæ€èšããã確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªèã®20é ✬ããããã«ãããŠãå¹³åå€ãåºæºãšããè©äŸ¡åŸç¹ãå¹³åå€ä»¥äžã®çè·åž«ã⟌矀ãå¹³åå€ä»¥äžã®çè·åž«ãäœçŸ€ã«åãããã€ãªããã件æ°ã«å·®ããããã©ãããtæ€å®ã✀ããŠæ€èšããã ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«é¢ããâŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡20é ✬ã«å¯ŸããŠã¯ãäž»å ⌊
æ³ã»Promaxå転ã«ããå ⌊åæãâŸã£ãããŸããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å ⌊ããšã«ãé ✬ããšã«ãå€å幎æ°ã«ããå·®ããããã©ããã 1 èŠå ã®åæ£åæã«ãã£ãŠæ€èšãããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡20é ✬ããããã«ãããŠãå¹³åå€ãåºæºãšããè©äŸ¡åŸç¹ãå¹³åå€ä»¥äžã®çè·åž«ã⟌矀ãå¹³åå€ä»¥äžã®çè·åž«ãäœçŸ€ã«åãããã€ãªããã件æ°ã«å·®ããããã©ãããtæ€å®ã✀ããŠæ€èšããã
1èŠå ã®åæ£åæãâŸã£ãå ŽåãLeveneæ€å®ã«ãŠçåæ£ã確èªããåŸåæãâŸããBonferroniæ³ã«ããå€éâœèŒã✀ããã
çµ±èšè§£æã«ã¯ãçµ±èšãœãã SPSS Statistics 25.0ã䜿✀ããã 2.5 å«ççé æ ® æ¬ç 究ã¯å²¡âŒâŒ€åŠâŒ€åŠé¢ä¿å¥åŠç 究ç§çè·åŠåéå«ç審æ»å§
30
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 30 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
å¡äŒã®æ¿èª(T19-04)ãåŸãŠå®æœããã調æ»å®æœã«ããã£ãŠã¯ã調æ»ã¯ç¡èšåã§ããããšãâŸç±ææã«ããç 究åâŒã§ããããšããã©ã€ãã·ãŒã¯ä¿è·ãããããšã Web ç»âŸ¯äžã§èª¬æããåçããã£ãŠåæãããã®ãšã¿ãªããã
3.ç 究çµæ
3.1 察象è ã®å±æ§ åçãã€åæã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããåçè 500 åã®å±æ§ã¯ã以äžã®éãã§ãã£ããæ§å¥ã¯âŒ¥æ§88.4ïŒ ãç·æ§11.6ïŒ ã§ã幎代ã¯20代ãã60代ã«åã¶ãã30代ãš40代ãåæ°ãå ãããå€å幎æ°ã¯0.9幎ãã50.1幎ãŸã§ã ã£ããã20幎以äžã33.8%ãš3å²ãè¶ ããŠãããå¹³å16.0幎(SD±9.5)ã§ãã£ããæå±éšçœ²ã¯26ã®ç§ã«åã¶ããå ç§ç³»ã35.8%ãš3å²ãè¶ ããŠãããè·äœã«ã€ããŠã¯ãçè·åž«87.0ïŒ ã䞻任(å¯çè·åž«â»)7.4ïŒ ãåž«â»1.8%ãå®å šç®¡çè 1.0%ããã®ä»2.8ïŒ ã§ãã£ã(è¡š1)ã
3.2 確èªäžâŸã«ãããã€ãªãããçµéšã®æ° ä»ååçè ãšãªã£ãçè·åž« 500åãã2019幎床ã«èµ·ããããšèªèãããã€ãªãããã§ã確èªäžâŸã«ãããšèããŠãããã®ã®ç·æ°ã¯4,390件ã§ãã£ãããããã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªãããã®âŒâŒãããã®çµéšåæ°ãã¿ããšãåæ察象è 500åã®ãã¡ã3å以äžã®è ã267å(53.4%)ãšæãå€ãã次ãã§1ã2åã®è ã121å(24.2%)ã0 åã®è ã 112 å(22.4%)ã§ãã£ããããªãã¡ 388 å(77.6%)ã¯ç¢ºèªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªããããçµéšããŠãããåçè å šäœã«ãããå¹³åçµéšåæ°ã¯8.8å(SD±14.8)ã§ãã£ã(è¡š2)ã
3.3 å±æ§å èš³ããšã«ã¿ã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªãããçµéšã®æ° å±æ§éã®å·®ã«ã€ããŠæ€èšãããšãããæ§å¥ã幎霢ãå€å幎æ°ã
å€åéšçœ²ã«ããããã€ãªããã件æ°ã«ã¯ãææãªå·®ã¯èªããããªãã£ã(è¡š3)ã
3.4 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããå ⌊åæ 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªè 20 é ✬ã«å¯ŸããŠäž»å ⌊æ³ã»
Promax å転ã«ããå ⌊åæãâŸã£ããåºæå€ã®æžè¡°ç¶æ³(10.670,1.713,1.003,0.819,âŠ)ãšå ⌊ã®è§£éå¯èœæ§ãã3å ⌊ã æœåºãã(è¡š4)ã
第1å ⌊ã¯æ³šææ£æŒ«ã確èªã«é¢ããèªèäžâŸãè¬å€ã®é¡äŒŒæ§ã確èªâœ æ³ã®äžé©åãæã蟌ã¿ãšãã£ã10é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšããããèªèäžâŸãå ⌊ãšåœåããã第2å ⌊ã¯å€å¿ãäžææ¥åãæ £ããšãã£ã7é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšããããéäžäžå¯ãå ⌊ãšåœåããã第3å ⌊ã¯å°âŸšç¥èã»çµéšäžâŸã確èªã«é¢ããã«ãŒã«ãç¥ããªãã£ããšãã£ã 3 é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšããããç¥èçµéšäžâŸãå ⌊ãšåœåããã
ä¿¡é Œæ§ã®æ€èšŒã«ã€ããŠã¯20é âœ¬å šäœã®ãCronbachã®Î±ä¿æ°ã¯0.95ã§ããããŸãã å ⌊ããããã® Cronbachã®Î± ä¿æ°ã«ã€ããŠã¯ããèªèäžâŸãã§Î±=.94ããéäžäžå¯ãã§Î±=.92ããç¥èçµéšäžâŸãα=.83ãšâŒåãªå€ãåŸããã(è¡š4)ã
3 ã€ã®å ⌊ã«çžåœããé ✬ã®å¹³åå€ãç®åºãããèªèäžâŸãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 3.84ãSD 0.84)ããéäžäžå¯ãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 4.31ãSD 0.70)ããç¥èçµéšäžâŸãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 3.87ãSD 0.83)ãšããã
è¡š2 2019幎ã®ç¢ºèªäžâŸã«ãããšèãããããã€ãªãããçµéšåæ°å¥ã«ã¿ãçµéšè ã®æ° n=500
åæ°/人 人æ°(%)
0 å 112(22.4)
1ã2 å 121(24.2)
3 åä»¥äž 267(53.4)
åèš 500(100.0)
(延ã¹4,390 件äž)
è¡š1 åçãã€åæ察象è ã®å±æ§ n=500 å±æ§ âŒæ° ïŒ
æ§å¥ ç·æ§ 58 11.6
âŒ¥æ§ 442 88.4
20 代 76 15.2
30 代 179 35.8
40 代 154 30.8
50 ä»£ä»¥äž 91 18.2
å°å
åæµ·é 41 8.2
æ±å 35 7.0
é¢æ± 133 26.6
äžéš 69 13.8
è¿ç¿ 75 15.0
äžåœã»ååœ 60 12.0
ä¹å· 87 17.4
å€å幎æ°
0ã5 幎æªæº 56 11.2
5ã10 幎æªæº 103 20.6
10ã15 幎æªæº 99 19.8
15ã20 幎æªæº 73 14.6
20 å¹Žä»¥äž 169 33.8
æå±éšçœ²
å ç§ç³» 179 35.8
å€ç§ç³» 67 13.4
å€æ¥ 48 9.6
⌿è¡å®€ 21 4.2
éäžæ²»ç宀 22 4.4
ãã®ä» 163 32.6
è·äœ
çè·åž« 435 87.0
䞻任(å¯åž«â») 37 7.4
åž«â» 9 1.8
å»çå®å šç®¡çè 5 1.0
ãã®ä» 14 2.8
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
31ïŒ 31 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
è¡š4 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããå ⌊åæ (Promaxå転åŸã®å ⌊ãã¿ãŒã³) é ✬çªå·ã»å 容 Mean(SD) I â ¡ â ¢
13.圢ãâŸã䌌ãŠããæ 3.73(1.11) 0.91 -0.09 -0.05
14.ééããããé åã ã£ãæ 3.79(1.06) 0.88 -0.03 -0.06
15.å調ãªåäœã®ç¹°ãè¿ãã§ãæèãäœäžããæ 3.83(1.08) 0.82 0.03 -0.08
17.ä»ã®ããšã«æ³šæãåããŠãããä»ã®ããšãèããŠããæ 3.99(1.00) 0.74 0.20 -0.1
12.èšæ¶ã ãã«é Œã£ãæ 3.79(1.03) 0.73 0.01 0.08
16.éèŠæ§ã«é¢ããèªèãäžâŸããŠããæ 3.80(1.07) 0.71 -0.04 0.18
19.ä»ã®âŒããã£ãŠãããã®ã§ã確èªããªããŠã⌀äžå€«ã ãšæã£ãæ
3.87(1.11) 0.70 0.07 0.01
11.äœèª¿äžè¯ã§æ³šææ£æŒ«ã ã£ãæ 3.69(1.08) 0.67 -0.04 0.12
18.確èªãããŸã§ããªã確ãã ãšæã蟌ãã æ 4.02(1.01) 0.65 0.19 -0.02
8.声ã ããæå·®ã確èªãããªãã£ãæ 3.89(1.02) 0.42 0.22 0.08
2.æéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæ 4.39(0.87) -0.15 0.93 0.04
1.æ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæ 4.45(0.87) -0.07 0.88 -0.05
9.çŠã£ãŠããæ 4.35(0.88) 0.13 0.76 -0.05
10.æã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæ 4.44(0.77) 0.04 0.75 0.00
6.äžéæ¥åãâŒã£ãæ 4.20(0.90) 0.17 0.64 -0.03
5.ãã€ããã£ãŠãããããšããæ £ãããã£ãæ 4.23(0.89) 0.09 0.55 0.14
7.泚æãæããã«ã✬ãéããæ 4.11(0.94) 0.26 0.43 0.16
4.å°âŸšç¥èãäžâŸããŠããæ 3.70(1.12) -0.14 0.07 0.97
3.ç é¢ã®ç¢ºèªã«é¢ããã«ãŒã«ãç¥ããªãã£ãæ 3.47(1.18) 0.19 -0.06 0.60
20.å°âŸšçãªçµéšãäžâŸããŠããæ 3.74(1.05) 0.44 -0.07 0.49
å ⌊çžé¢âŸå I â ¡ â ¢
I â 0.69 0.69
â ¡ â 0.55
â ¢ â
è¡š3 å±æ§å èš³ããšã«ã¿ã確èªäžâŸãã€ãªãããçµéšã®æ° n=500
å±æ§ ãã€ãªããã ä»¶æ° Mean(SD)
æ§å¥ ç·æ§ 700 12.07(16.49)
âŒ¥æ§ 3690 8.35(14.50)
幎霢 20 代 639 8.41(12.02)
30 代 1520 8.49(14.90)
40 代 1299 8.44(13.06)
50 ä»£ä»¥äž 932 10.24(18.94)
å€åå¹Žæ° 0ã5 幎æªæº 573 10.23(15.46)
5ã10 幎æªæº 1014 9.84(15.22)
10ã15 幎æªæº 519 5.24(8.11)
15ã20 幎æªæº 679 9.30(15.17)
20 å¹Žä»¥äž 1605 9.50(16.84)
æå±éšçœ² å ç§ç³» 1636 9.14(14.93)
å€ç§ç³» 578 8.63(13.04)
å€æ¥ 230 4.79(13.37)
⌿è¡å®€ 165 7.86(12.02)
éäžæ²»ç宀 262 11.91(10.70)
ãã®ä» 1519 9.32(16.35)
32
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 32 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
è¡š5確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã«ã¿ãããå€åéšçœ²ã®å·®
(é ✬ããš
)
é ✬
çªå·
ã»å
容
éšçœ²
çå
æ£
Få€
df (5,
494)
å
ç§ç³»
å€
ç§ç³»
å€
æ¥
⌿è¡
宀
éäž
æ²»ç
宀
(n=1
79)
(n=6
7)
(n=4
8)
(n=2
1)
(n=2
2)
Mea
n(SD
) M
ean(
SD)
Mea
n(SD
) M
ean(
SD)
Mea
n(SD
)
1.æ¥å
ãé
ãªã
ãå€
å¿ã
ã£ã
æ
4.46(
0.84)
4.3
3(1.0
5)
4.33(
1.04)
4.2
4(1.0
9)
4.36(
1.05)
0.4
3 0.4
8
2.æé
åè¿«
ã§ã
æ¥ã
ãã
ãæ
4.4
0(0.8
5)
4.21(
1.05)
4.2
1(1.0
5)
4.24(
1.00)
4.3
6(1.0
0)
0.41
0.80
3.ç é¢
ã®ç¢º
èªã«
é¢ã
ãã«
ãŒã«
ãç¥
ããª
ãã£
ãæ
3.5
0(1.1
3)
3.37(
1.25)
3.3
8(1.2
7)
3.48(
1.17)
3.6
4(1.2
6)
0.71
0.32
4.å°âŸš
ç¥è
ãäž
âŸã
ãŠã
ãæ
3.6
6(1.1
2)
3.55(
1.20)
3.8
5(1.1
9)
3.62(
1.20)
3.5
5(1.1
4)
0.85
0.55
5.ãã€
ãã
ã£ãŠ
ãã
ãã
ãšã
ãæ £
ãã
ãã£
ãæ
4.2
6(0.8
6)
3.91(
1.03)
4.2
9(0.9
2)
3.95(
0.92)
3.7
7(1.0
7)
0.73
3.19*
6.äžé
æ¥å
ãâŒ
ã£ã
æ
4.16(
0.95)
4.1
8(0.8
5)
4.10(
0.95)
3.8
6(1.1
1)
4.23(
0.81)
0.7
4 0.6
0
7.泚æ
ãæ
ãã
ã«ã
✬ã
éã
ãæ
4.1
1(0.9
7)
4.03(
0.95)
4.0
2(1.0
0)
4.00(
0.84)
3.9
1(0.9
2)
0.74
0.30
8.声ã
ãã
æå·®
ã確
èªã
ããª
ãã£
ãæ
3.8
5(1.0
4)
3.91(
1.00)
3.9
2(1.0
1)
3.67(
1.20)
3.8
6(0.9
9)
0.50
0.26
9.çŠã£
ãŠã
ãæ
4.3
1(0.9
3)
4.15(
0.93)
4.3
5(0.8
4)
4.33(
1.02)
4.3
2(1.0
0)
0.80
0.49
10.æ
ã蟌
ã¿ã
ããŠ
ããŸ
ã£ã
æ
4.39(
0.83)
4.2
8(0.8
1)
4.52(
0.83)
4.4
3(0.8
7)
4.45(
0.80)
0.9
3 0.6
3
11.äœ
調äž
è¯ã§
泚æ
æ£æŒ«
ã ã£
ãæ
3.7
3(1.0
8)
3.46(
1.01)
3.6
5(1.2
3)
3.43(
1.12)
3.3
6(1.1
4)
0.61
1.28
12.èš
æ¶ã
ãã«
é Œã£
ãæ
3.8
5(1.0
0)
3.46(
1.01)
3.7
7(1.1
0)
3.57(
1.17)
3.5
5(1.0
6)
0.59
2.05
13.圢
ãâŸ
ã䌌
ãŠã
ãæ
3.7
6(1.0
9)
3.66(
1.04)
3.7
3(1.2
0)
3.57(
0.98)
3.4
5(1.1
4)
0.87
0.52
14.é
éã
ãã
ãé
åã
ã£ã
æ
3.81(
1.05)
3.6
1(1.0
1)
3.90(
1.06)
3.7
6(1.0
0)
3.59(
0.96)
0.9
2 0.8
0
15.å
調ãª
åäœ
ã®ç¹°
ãè¿
ãã§
ãæ
èã
äœäž
ãã
æ
3.86(
1.13)
3.6
4(1.0
3)
3.79(
1.13)
3.8
6(0.6
6)
3.32(
1.36)
0.0
2 1.4
9
16.é
èŠæ§
ã«é¢
ãã
èªè
ãäž
âŸã
ãŠã
ãæ
3.7
7(1.0
8)
3.64(
1.06)
3.7
9(1.2
0)
3.95(
0.81)
3.3
6(1.2
9)
0.08
1.03
17.ä»
ã®ã
ãšã«
泚æ
ãå
ããŠ
ãã
ãä»
ã®ã
ãšã
èã
ãŠã
ãæ
3.9
9(1.0
4)
3.85(
0.93)
3.8
1(1.2
0)
3.95(
0.70)
3.8
2(1.1
4)
0.04
0.46
18.確
èªã
ããŸ
ã§ã
ãªã
確ã
ã ãš
æã
蟌ã
ã æ
4.0
4(1.0
1)
3.93(
0.98)
3.9
2(1.0
7)
3.71(
1.01)
3.6
4(1.2
9)
0.12
1.18
19.ä»
ã®âŒ
ãã
ã£ãŠ
ãã
ãã®
ã§ã確
èªã
ãªã
ãŠã
⌀äž
倫ã
ãšæ
ã£ã
æ
3.92(
1.08)
3.7
9(1.1
4)
3.58(
1.30)
3.9
5(1.0
2)
3.68(
1.29)
0.0
5 1.0
3
20.å°
⟚ç
ãªçµ
éšã
äžâŸ
ããŠ
ãã
æ
3.75(
1.02)
3.6
9(1.0
5)
3.63(
1.32)
3.8
6(1.0
6)
3.41(
1.22)
0.0
9 0.6
5
* ïŒp<
.05; *
*:p<.
01
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
33ïŒ 33 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
è¡š6 確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã«ã¿ããã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªããã件æ°âŸŒäœçŸ€éã®å·®
é ✬çªå·ã»å 容 ãã€ãªããã件æ°
Mean(SD) tå€ df(498)
èªèäžâŸ
13.圢ãâŸã䌌ãŠããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 10.87(16.48)
2.14* åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 7.71(13.73)
14.ééããããé åã ã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 9.11(15.53)
0.34 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.63(14.45)
15.å調ãªåäœã®ç¹°ãè¿ãã§ãæèãäœäžããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 9.34(15.68)
0.56 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.54(14.39)
17.ä»ã®ããšã«æ³šæãåããŠãããä»ã®ããšãèããŠããæ
åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.46(14.88) 0.27
åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.88(14.77)
12.èšæ¶ã ãã«é Œã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 9.88(15.65)
1.11 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.26(14.34)
16.éèŠæ§ã«é¢ããèªèãäžâŸããŠããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 9.16(14.23)
0.40 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.60(15.04)
19.ä»ã®âŒããã£ãŠãããã®ã§ã確èªããªããŠã⌀äžå€«ã ãšæã£ãæ
åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.78(15,45) 0.01
åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.78(14.52)
11.äœèª¿äžè¯ã§æ³šææ£æŒ«ã ã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 9.51(15.11)
0.82 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.38(14.60)
18.確èªãããŸã§ããªã確ãã ãšæã蟌ãã æ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.07(13.88)
1.42 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.03(16.21)
8.声ã ããæå·®ã確èªãããªãã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.25(12.79)
0.50 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.99(15.50)
éäžäžå¯
2.æéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 6.85(11.05)
2.70** åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.25(16.95)
1.æ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 7.09(12.44)
2.06* åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 9.86(16.02)
9.çŠã£ãŠããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 6.72(11.42)
2.99** åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.55(16.97)
10.æã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 6.99(12.55)
2.44* åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.11(16.13)
6.äžéæ¥åãâŒã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 7.72(13.09)
1.81 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.21(16.71)
5.ãã€ããã£ãŠãããããšããæ £ãããã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 7.65(12.36)
1.88 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.26(17.36)
7.泚æãæããã«ã✬ãéããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.01(13.69)
1.43 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 10.03(16.34)
ç¥èçµéšäžâŸ
4.å°âŸšç¥èãäžâŸããŠããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 7.91(12.40)
0.93 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 9.21(15.83)
3.ç é¢ã®ç¢ºèªã«é¢ããã«ãŒã«ãç¥ããªãã£ãæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 8.55(13.94)
0.31 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 8.96(15.44)
20.å°âŸšçãªçµéšãäžâŸããŠããæ åŸç¹äœçŸ€ 7.79(13.07)
1.11 åŸç¹âŸŒçŸ€ 9.32(15.62)
*: p<.05; **: p<.01
34
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 34 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
è¡š7 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«é¢ããå ⌊åæ(Promaxå転åŸã®å ⌊ãã¿ãŒã³) é ✬çªå·ã»å 容 Mean(SD) I â ¡ â ¢
18.äœæ°ãªãäŒè©±ãããããæ å ±ããæŸãããšãåŸæãªâœ ã§ãã 3.30(0.96) 0.89 -0.07 -0.12
17.äœãå€ããã€ããšéããªã©ã现ãããããšã«æ°ã¥ã✠ã§ãã 3.35(0.91) 0.83 0.03 -0.05
19.èŠçãåºãæã¡ããŸãå šäœãããâŒéãç¹æ€ãããããã«ããŠãã
3.30(0.94) 0.75 0.07 -0.01
15.ãã€ã³ããæŒããããéãå€æããåŸæãªâœ ã§ãã 3.06(1.02) 0.7 0.05 -0.17
20.ããã¯ãã ã£ãã¯ãããªã©èšæ¶ãšã®éãã«æ°ã¥ã✠ã§ãã 3.35(0.87) 0.62 0.15 -0.04
16.ãç°å¢ããæŽã£ãŠããªããšå«ã§ãæ°ã«ãªã 3.39(0.95) 0.34 0.16 0.24
7.ä»âŒãâŸã£ãããšãã信✀ããªãã✠ã§ãã 3.14(0.98) 0.31 0.07 0.25
12.âŸåã®çåãç¶æ ãããç¥ããããããã«ããŠãã 3.52(0.88) -0.05 0.86 -0.14
10.ããããªãããšã¯ãâŸåãç解ã§ãããŸã§ãå°ããã 3.57(0.89) -0.08 0.81 0.04
11.ä»äºã§çåã«æã£ãããšã¯ããææãããããã«ããŠãã 3.43(0.91) 0.07 0.76 -0.17
9.åžžã«ããªããããšè«ççã«èããããã«ããŠãã 3.44(0.93) 0.19 0.57 0.09
8.äºæ³ãšéãããšãããã°ããã®ãçç±ããæ¢ããŠçŽåŸãã 3.43(0.88) 0.11 0.56 0.14
13.æç§æžã®ç¥èãçµéšãããã¿ãŒã³ãããå€åãäºæž¬ããããã«ããŠãã
3.33(0.89) 0.28 0.48 0.05
14.é ã®äžã§ãå±éºã®çºâœ£ããã·ãã¥ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãããããã«ããŠãã
3.44(0.95) 0.32 0.39 0.07
5.ã⌌é ãçã§ãã 3.44(1.07) 0.06 -0.06 0.8
3.ãç¥çµè³ªãã§ãã 3.15(1.08) 0.2 -0.12 0.76
2.ãæ°ã〈ããã✠ã§ãã 3.32(1.10) -0.26 0.01 0.75
6.äœäºã«ãããŠããâŸä¿¡ããªãã 3.18(1.07) -0.34 0.07 0.73
4.äºçŽ°ãªããšããæ°ã«ãªãã✠ã§ãã 3.33(1.03) 0.17 -0.03 0.71
1.ãâŸåã§ããäœåºŠãããçŽåŸããããŸã§ã念âŒãã«ç¢ºèªããªããšæ°ãæžãŸãªã
3.48(0.92) 0.3 0.17 0.35
å ⌊çžé¢âŸå I â ¡ â ¢
I â 0.75 0.36
â ¡ â 0.34
â ¢ â
è¡š8 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡ã«ã¿ãããå€å幎æ°ã®å·®(äžäœå°ºåºŠå¥)
äžäœå°ºåºŠ å€å幎æ°
çåæ£ Få€ df(4,495)
å€éâœèŒ 0ã5幎 (n=56)
5ã10幎 (n=103)
10ã15幎 (n=99)
15ã20幎 (n=73)
20å¹Žä»¥äž (n=169)
æ°ã¥ã 3.06(0.77) 3.13(0.73) 3.29(0.54) 3.34(0.78) 3.39(0.66) 0.01 4.00 ** 0ã5幎,5ã10幎<20å¹Žä»¥äž æ€èšŒ 3.23(0.64) 3.33(0.67) 3.40(0.58) 3.58(0.61) 3.49(0.66) 0.81 3.54** 0ã5幎<15ã20幎 ✀⌌深ã 3.36(0.75) 3.32(0.77) 3.33(0.75) 3.40(0.75) 3.28(0.75) 1.00 0.41
*: p<.05; **: p<.01
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
35ïŒ 35 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
è¡š9 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®èªå·±è©äŸ¡ã«ã¿ãããå€å幎æ°ã®å·®(é
ç®ããš)
é ✬
çªå·
ã»å
容
å€å
幎æ°
çå
æ£
Få€
df(4
,495)
å€
éâœ
èŒ
0ã5幎
5ã
10幎
10
ã15
幎
15ã
20幎
20
幎以
äž
(n=5
6)
(n=1
03)
(n=9
9)
(n=7
3)
(n=1
69)
Mea
n(SD
) M
ean(
SD)
Mea
n(SD
) M
ean(
SD)
Mea
n(SD
)
1.ãâŸ
åã§
ããäœ
床ã
ããçŽ
åŸã
ãã
ãŸã§
ã念
âŒã
ã«ç¢º
èªã
ãªã
ãšæ°
ãæž
ãŸãª
ã
3.36(
0.94)
3.3
1(0.9
6)
3.42(
0.88)
3.6
5(0.8
9)
3.59(
0.89)
0.9
3 2.6
0*
2.ãæ°
ã〈
ãã
ãâœ
ã§ã
ã
3.36(
1.05)
3.3
8(1.0
6)
3.42(
1.12)
3.3
7(1.1
5)
3.18(
1.11)
0.7
3 1.0
3
3.ãç¥
çµè³ª
ãã§
ãã
3.0
0(1.1
6)
3.08(
1.09)
3.1
8(1.0
3)
3.25(
1.12)
3.1
8(1.0
5)
0.74
0.6
4.äºçŽ°
ãªã
ãšã
ãæ°
ã«ãª
ãã
✠ã§
ãã
3.3
4(1.0
1)
3.21(
1.04)
3.2
9(0.9
9)
3.45(
1.03)
3.3
6(1.0
5)
0.96
0.72
5.ã⌌
é ã
çã§
ãã
3.4
2(1.1
2)
3.50(
1.07)
3.5
1(1.0
6)
3.52(
1.07)
3.3
2(1.0
6)
0.98
0.81
6.äœäº
ã«ã
ããŠ
ãã
âŸä¿¡
ããª
ãã
3.3
9(1.1
1)
3.38(
1.01)
3.2
1(1.0
3)
3.13(
1.14)
2.9
8(1.0
6)
0.72
3.10*
20
幎以
äžïŒ
5ã10
幎
7.ä»âŒ
ãâŸ
ã£ã
ããš
ãã
信✀
ããª
ãã
✠ã§
ãã
3.0
3(1.1
3)
3.03(
1.01)
3.0
8(0.9
0)
3.28(
0.95)
3.2
3(0.9
5)
0.32
1.31
8.äºæ³
ãšé
ãã
ãšã
ãã
ã°ã
ãã®
ãç
ç±ã
ãæ¢
ããŠ
çŽåŸ
ãã
3.3
4(0.9
6)
3.34(
0.93)
3.3
8(0.7
9)
3.63(
0.85)
3.4
6(0.8
9)
0.42
1.52
9.åžžã«
ããª
ãã
ããš
è«ç
çã«
èã
ãã
ãã«
ããŠ
ãã
3.2
2(1.0
7)
3.38(
0.87)
3.3
4(0.7
9)
3.60(
0.96)
3.5
5(0.9
7)
0.04
2.32
10.ã
ãã
ãªã
ããš
ã¯ã
âŸå
ãç
解ã§
ãã
ãŸã§
ãå°
ãã
ã
3.46(
0.84)
3.4
5(0.8
7)
3.51(
0.87)
3.7
2(0.8
0)
3.66(
0.95)
0.5
3 1.7
4
11.ä»
äºã§
çå
ã«æ
ã£ã
ããš
ã¯ã
ãæ
æã
ãã
ãã
ã«ã
ãŠã
ã
3.10(
1.03)
3.3
3(0.9
3)
3.36(
0.80)
3.6
1(0.8
4)
3.58(
0.91)
0.3
6 4.3
6**
0ã5幎
ïŒ15
ã20
幎,20
幎以
äž
12.âŸ
åã®
çå
ãç¶
æ ã
ãã
ç¥ã
ãã
ãã
ãã«
ããŠ
ãã
3.3
1(1.0
0)
3.42(
0.89)
3.4
9(0.7
8)
3.67(
0.82)
3.6
3(0.8
8)
0.31
2.40*
13.æ
ç§æž
ã®ç¥
èã
çµéš
ãã
ãã¿
ãŒã³
ãã
ãå€
åã
äºæž¬
ãã
ãã
ã«ã
ãŠã
ã
3.00(
0.93)
3.1
6(0.9
0)
3.32(
0.75)
3.5
1(0.8
6)
3.50(
0.93)
0.3
1 5.3
1**
0ã5幎
ïŒ15
ã20
幎,20
幎以
äžïŒ
5ã10
幎ïŒ
20幎
以äž
14.é
ã®äž
ã§ã
å±éº
ã®çº
✣ã
ãã·
ãã¥
ã¬ãŒ
ã·ã§
ã³ã
ãã
ãã
ã«ã
ãŠã
ã
3.19(
0.99)
3.2
6(0.9
5)
3.47(
0.81)
3.6
9(0.9
2)
3.51(
0.99)
0.4
3 3.6
5**
0ã5幎
,5ã10
幎ïŒ
15ã
20幎
15.ã
ã€ã³
ãã
æŒã
ãã
ãé
ãå€
æã
ãåŸ
æãª
✠ã§
ãã
2.9
5(1.1
8)
3.01(
0.99)
3.0
4(0.8
8)
3.11(
1.15)
3.1
1(0.9
8)
0.00
0.4
16.ã
ç°å¢
ãã
æŽã£
ãŠã
ãªã
ãšå«
ã§ã
æ°ã«
ãªã
3.2
5(0.9
4)
3.44(
0.94)
3.4
2(0.8
2)
3.40(
1.09)
3.4
0(0.9
7)
0.04
0.39
17.äœ
ãå€
ãã
ã€ã
ãšé
ããª
ã©ã
现ã
ãã
ããš
ã«æ°
ã¥ã
✠ã§
ãã
2.9
8(1.0
4)
3.09(
0.91)
3.3
5(0.7
5)
3.47(
0.95)
3.5
9(0.8
5)
0.08
8.22*
* 0ã
5幎
,5ã10
幎ïŒ
15ã
20幎
,20幎
以äž
18.äœ
æ°ãª
ãäŒ
話ã
ãã
ãã
æ å ±
ãã
æŸã
ããš
ãåŸ
æãª
✠ã§
ãã
3.0
5(1.0
2)
3.07(
0.97)
3.4
2(0.8
4)
3.36(
1.04)
3.4
4(0.9
2)
0.21
3.96*
* 5ã
10幎
ïŒ20
幎以
äž
19.èŠ
çã
åºã
æã¡
ããŸ
ãå š
äœã
ãã
âŒé
ãç¹
æ€ã
ãã
ãã
ã«ã
ãŠã
ã
3.00(
1.03)
3.1
1(0.9
5)
3.31(
0.77)
3.4
4(1.0
0)
3.48(
0.92)
0.1
2 4.6
7**
0ã5幎
,5ã10
幎ïŒ
20幎
以äž
20.ã
ãã¯
ãã
ã£ã
ã¯ã
ããª
ã©èš
æ¶ãš
ã®é
ãã«
æ°ã¥
ãâœ
ã§ã
ã
3.14(
1.04)
3.1
8(0.9
0)
3.44(
0.69)
3.3
1(0.8
5)
3.50(
0.87)
0.0
8 3.4
9**
5ã10
幎ïŒ
20幎
以äž
*: p<
.05; *
*: p<
.01
36
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 36 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
3.5 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªèã«ã¿ãããå±æ§ã®å·® å±æ§ã«ãã確èªäžâŸã®èŠå èªèã®å ⌊ãæ€èšãããšããã幎霢ãå€å幎æ°ãéšçœ²ã«é¢ããŠã¯ã1èŠå ã®åæ£åæã«ãããŠææãªå·®ãâŸãããªãã£ãã å€åéšçœ²ã«ããå·®ç°ã詳ããåæããæå³ããã確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã®é ✬ããšã« 1èŠå ã®åæ£åæãâŸãªã£ãããã®çµæãã5.ãã€ããã£ãŠãããããšããæ £ãããã£ãæãã«ãããŠãææãªå·®ãâŸãããããå€éâœèŒã§ã¯ææå·®ã¯èªããããªãã£ã(è¡š5)ã
3.6 確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã®âŸŒäœçŸ€éã«ããã 確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®å·®
確èªäžâŸã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªèã®20é ✬ããããã«ãããŠãè©äŸ¡åŸç¹ã⟌äœçŸ€ã«åãããã€ãªããã件æ°ã«å·®ããããã©ãããtæ€å®ã✀ããŠæ€èšããããã®çµæãã1.æ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæã(t(498) =2.06, p<.05)ãã2.æéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæã(t(498)=2.7, p<.01)ãã9.çŠã£ãŠããæã(t(498) =2.99, p<.01)ãã10.æã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæã(t(498) =2.44, p<.05)ã§âŸŒçŸ€ã®ã»ããäœçŸ€ãããææã«ãã€ãªããã件æ°ãå€ãã£ããããããã13.圢ãâŸã䌌ãŠããæã(t(498) =2.14, p<.05)ã®ã¿ã¯ãäœçŸ€ã®ã»ããææã«âŸŒãã£ã(è¡š6)ã
3.7 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«é¢ããå ⌊åæ ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«é¢ããâŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡20é ✬ã«å¯ŸããŠäž»å ⌊æ³ã»
Promax å転ã«ããå ⌊åæãâŸã£ããåºæå€ã®æžè¡°ç¶æ³(7.989,2.961,1.128,0.947,âŠ)ãšå ⌊ã®è§£éå¯èœæ§ãã3å ⌊ãæœåºããã 第 1 å ⌊ã¯éãããšã«æ°ãã€ããæ å ±ãæŸãããšãåŸæã§ãããšãã£ã7é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšããããæ°ã¥ããå ⌊ãšåœåããã第2å ⌊ã¯çåã«å¯Ÿããæ 床ãäºåäºæž¬ãã·ãã¥ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãšãã£ã7é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšããããæ€èšŒãå ⌊ãšåœåããã第3å ⌊ã¯ãç¥çµè³ªããã⌌é çããâŸä¿¡ããªãã现ããç¹ã«ãŸã§æ°ãé ãã念âŒãã«ç¢ºèªããªããšæžãŸãªããšãã£ã6é ✬ã§æ§æãããŠããããšãããã✀⌌深ããå ⌊ãšåœåããã ä¿¡é Œæ§ã®æ€èšŒã«ã€ããŠã¯ã20é âœ¬å šäœã®Cronbachã®Î±ä¿æ°ã¯
0.91ã§ãã£ããåå ⌊ã«ã€ããŠã¯ããæ°ã¥ããα=.86ããæ€èšŒãα=.89ãã✀⌌深ããα=.84ãšâŒåãªå€ãåŸããã(è¡š7)ã
3 ã€ã®å ⌊ã«çžåœããé ✬ã®å¹³åå€ãç®åºãããèªèäžâŸãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 3.84ãSD 0.84)ããéäžäžå¯ãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 3.45ãSD 0.70)ããç¥èçµéšäžâŸãå ⌊åŸç¹(å¹³å 3.31ãSD 0.78)ãšããã
3.8 å€å幎æ°ã«ããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å·® ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å ⌊ããšã«ãå€å幎æ°ã«ããå·®ããããã©ããã1èŠå ã®åæ£åæã«ãã£ãŠæ€èšããããã®çµæããæ°ã¥ããå ⌊ã«ãããŠ0~5幎æªæºã5~10幎æªæºãã20幎以äžã®ã»ããé¡èã«âŸŒãã£ã(F(4, 495) =4.00, p<0.01)ããæ€èšŒãå ⌊ã«ãããŠã¯0~5幎æªæºãšâœããŠã15~20幎æªæºã®ã»ããé¡èã«âŸŒãã£ã(F(4, 495) =4.56, p<0.01)ããŸããã✀⌌深ããå ⌊ã§ã¯ãå€å幎æ°ã®åŸç¹å·®ã¯ææã§ã¯ãªãã£ã(F(4, 495) =0.22, n.s.)(è¡š8)ã ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§é ✬ããšã«ãå€å幎æ°ã«é¢ãã 1 èŠå ã®åæ£åæãâŸãªã£ãããã®çµæãè¡š9ã«âœ°ããã
3.9 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®âŸŒäœçŸ€éã«ããã確èªäžâŸã® ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®å·®
ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡20é ✬ããããã«ãããŠãè©äŸ¡åŸç¹ã⟌äœçŸ€ã«åãã確èªäžâŸã«ãããšæ¬âŒãèãããã€ãªãããã®ä»¶æ°ã«å·®ãã¿ããããããtæ€å®ã✀ããŠæ€èšããããã®çµæãã5.ã⌌é ãçã§ãããã§ã⟌矀ã®âœ ãäœçŸ€ãã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªããã件æ°ãææã«å€ãã£ã(t(498) =2.25, p<.05)ã
3.10 確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ããã³ ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®é¢é£
確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ããã³ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®é¢é£ã«ã€ããŠçžé¢åæãâŸã£ãããã®çµæã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã®äžäœå°ºåºŠïŒæèäžâŸãéäžäžå¯ãç¥èçµéšäžâŸïŒãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§èŠå ã®äžäœå°ºåºŠïŒæ°ã¥ããæ€èšŒã✀⌌深ãïŒéã«ã¯ãææãªåŒ±ãæ£ã®çžé¢ãâŸãããïŒè¡š10ïŒãããããªããã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®ããããããã€ãªããã件æ°ãšã®éã«ææãªçžé¢ã¯èªããããªãã£ãã
4.èå¯
4.1 確èªäžâŸã«âŸãèŠå ã®èªèã«ãããå ⌊æ§é çè·å ŽâŸ¯ã«ãããŠç¢ºèªäžâŸãããããèŠå ã«ãªãããããšå¯Ÿè±¡è ãèªèãã床åããè©å®ããŠããã£ã 20 é ✬ããã¯ããèªèäžâŸãããéäžäžå¯ãããç¥èçµéšäžâŸããšãã3å ⌊ãæœåºãããããŸããèªèäžâŸãã«ã€ããŠã¯ã以äžã®ããã«èããããã ååŽã(2012)ã¯ãçè·åŠâœ£ãäœéšãããã€ãªããããåæããçµæãèŠå ã®å€ãã¯æ³šæâŒã®âœèœããåŠâœ£ã ãã§âŸããæè¡ç¯å²ã®èªèäžâŸã§ãã£ã 10ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠããããéä¿¡ãšã¯é⌀ãªä¿¡é Œãæ±ãããšã§ãããé©æ£ãªèŠæ⌌ãæã£ãŠäºè±¡ãç¶æ³ãâŸå®ããåªâŒãæ ãããšã11ãšããããããªãã¡å®å šã ãšéä¿¡ããŠããå Žåã¯ãå±éºãååšããããšãèããŠããããå®å šç¢ºèªã®èªèãèãããšãã確èªäžâŸã«âŸãããã€ãªãããã«ã€ãªãããšããæµããèããããã ãã®å¯ŸçãšããŠãçè·åž«ã«ããã確èªã®éèŠæ§ã«é¢ããèªèã⟌ããããšãå¿ èŠã«ãªãããããã§ã確èªäžâŸãã«é¢ããæå¹ãªå¯Ÿçã®âŒã€ãšããŠãééãèªç©ºã補é ã建èšæ¥ãªã©ã®ç£æ¥ã«ãããŠâŸã£ãŠããæå·®åŒç§°ã«ãã確èªãèããããã(財)ééç·å
å°ºã床
äžäœå°ºåºŠ æèäžè¶³ éäžäžå¯ç¥èçµéšäžè¶³ æ°ã¥ã æ€èšŒ çšå¿æ·±ã
æèäžè¶³ â .724**
.738**
.189**
.255**
.304** 0.035
éäžäžå¯ â .738**
.137*
.237**
.270** 0.070
ç¥èçµéšäžè¶³ â .145**
.225**
.232** 0.020
æ°ã¥ã â .764**
.369** -0.051
æ€èšŒ â .582** 0.009
çšå¿æ·±ã â 0.021
ãã€ãªãããæ° â
è¡š10ãã確èªäžè¶³ã®èŠå èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãšã®é¢é£ïŒçžé¢ïŒ
ãã€ãªãããæ°
** p<.01 , * p<.05
ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®èªå·±è©äŸ¡ç¢ºèªäžè¶³ã®èŠå ã«é¢ããèªè
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
37ïŒ 37 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
æè¡ç 究æ(1996)ãå ¬è¡šããæå·®ãåŒç§°ã®å¹æã®æ€èšŒå®éšã«ãããšããæå·®ãåŒç§°ãããå Žåã¯ãäœãããªããå Žåã«âœã¹ã誀ãã®çºâœ£çã 6åã® 1以äžã«ãªã£ã 12ãã¹ã¿ããéã®ããã«ãã§ãã¯ã§æ³šæãåèµ·ãããä»çµã¿ãæã€ããšããæå¹ã ããã ãéäžäžå¯ãã«é¢ããŠã¯ã以äžã®ããã«èãããããå è³âŒã
(2016)ã¯ãâŸâŸã§ã³ã³ãããŒã«ããŠããäœæ¥âŒ¯çšã®äžã«ãä»è ããã®èŠå ã§äœæ¥äžæãæ¥åã«éäžã§ããªãç¶æ ã✣ããå Žåããã€ã³ã·ãã³ããçºâœ£ããããããšâŸèŠããããšãéèŠã§ãã 13
ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠãããããªãã¡ãçè·åž«ãæ²»çã«éäžã§ããç°å¢ãæŽããããšã®éèŠæ§ãã✰ããŠãããšããããã ãç¥èçµéšäžâŸãã«é¢ããŠã¯ã以äžã®ããã«èããããã仲äžã(2016)ã¯ãçè·åŠâœ£ã®ã€ã³ã·ãã³ãã®çºâœ£åå ã«ã¯ãå€æ誀ãããæãå€ãã次ãã§ãæå°è ãžã®å ±åã»é£çµ¡ã»çžè«ã®äžâŸãããç¥èäžâŸããã芳å¯äžâŸãããæè¡ã®æªçããªã©ãé¢ãã£ããšå ±åããŠãã 14ãâŒéäžâŸãå±éºã§ããããšã¯åŠâœ£ãçŸè·ãåæ§ã§ãããçè·åž«âŸâŸãç¥èãèœâŒã⟌ããããšã¯åºæ¬çã«éèŠãšããããç ä¿®ãåè¬ããã°ç¥èã®ç²åŸãä¿ãããšãæåŸ ã§ãããšããæå³ã§ã¯ãé¢å ã®ç ä¿®äŒãå®æã«éå¬ããããšãªã©ãæšå¥šãããã
4.2 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå èªèã«ããã⟌äœçŸ€ã«ãã ãã€ãªãããçµéšã®å·®ç°
確èªäžâŸãããããããèŠå ãšããŠåé ✬ãã©ã®çšåºŠèªèããŠãããããã®èªèã®âŸŒäœçŸ€éã§ã確èªäžâŸã«ãããšæ¬âŒãèãããã€ãªãããã®çµéšåæ°ã®å·®ãèªãããããã®ãããããæ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæãããæéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæãããçŠã£ãŠããæãããæã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæãã®4é ✬ã«ãããŠã⟌矀ã®ã»ããäœçŸ€ã«âœã¹ãŠææã«âŸŒãå€ã✰ããã ãã®çµæãâœæããç 究ãšããŠã以äžããããæ©âŒâŒ¥ã(2011)ã¯ãå¿ããå ŽâŸ¯ãçŠã£ãŠããå ŽâŸ¯ã§ã¯ãåæ°ä»¥äžã®çè·åž«ãæå·®åŒç§°ãçç¥ããŠãããšå ±åããŠãã 15ãå®éã(2014)ã¯ãçè·åž«ã¯âœåžžçã«å€é課é¡ãæ±ããããããšãå€ãããšãæéçåè¿«ãäœæ¥ééå€ãªã©ã®æéçå§âŒãããããšãåšå²ããã®ãã¬ãã·ã£ãŒãšãã瀟äŒçå§âŒãããããšãææãããããã®ç°å¢èŠå ãéåã✣起ããããšããŠæ³šæãä¿ããŠãã 16ãâ»âŒã(2016)ã¯ãæã蟌ã¿ãæ°æã¡ã®çŠãã確èªäžâŸã®èæ¯ã«ããããšããå ±åããŠãã 7ã ããã§å®éã«ãã€ãªãããã«ã€ãªãã£ãâŸåãšããŠã®å€å¿ãæéåè¿«ã«èµ·å ãã確èªäžâŸã«ããäºæ ãèµ·ããã«ããç°å¢ãäœãã«ã¯ããã®ã¢ãããŒããšããŠãŸãå€å¿ãªå€åç¶æ³ã®æ¹åã«åããŠãé©æ£ãªâŒå¡ã®ç¢ºä¿ãšé 眮ã®âŒ¯å€«ãããããšãèãããããå ããŠæéåè¿«ã®ç·©åçã«ã¯ãæ¥åéã®åæžããä»ã®çè·åž«ã«å¿æŽãäŸé Œã§ããç°å¢ã®æŽåãæ±ããããã åâŒç¹æ§ãšããŠã®æã蟌ã¿ã«ã€ããŠãå¶æ£®(2004)ã¯ãâŸåãã¢ãã¿ãŒããããšã«ãããæã蟌ã¿ã«ãããšã©ãŒã®é²âœã«ã€ãªãã 17ãšææããâŸåã®âŸåãåžžã«ãã§ãã¯ããä¿®æ£ãâŸã£ãŠäºæ ãé²âœããŠãããšèããããã å€å¿ããçŠãããã€ãªãããããããããšèªèããŠããâŒã«ãå®éã«ãã€ãªãããã®ä»¶æ°ãå€ãã£ãããšã¯ãçµéšããåŸãç解ãåæ ãããã®ãšæããããâŒâœ ã§ãâŸã圢ã®é¡äŒŒããã€ãªãããã«ç¹ãããšã®èªèãäœãè ã«ãå®éã®ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã
å€ãã£ããšããçµæã¯ã詳现ã«ããã泚æãäžâŸããŠããå Žåããã€ãªãããã«ç¹ãã⟯ãããããšã✰åããã
4.3 確èªäžâŸã®èŠå èªèã«åæ ãããå€åéšçœ²ã®ç¹æ§ ã5.ãã€ããã£ãŠãããããšããæ £ãããã£ãæããšãã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããé ✬ã«ãããŠãææå·®ãâŸããããéšçœ²ã«ãã£ãŠãã®é ✬ã«é¢ããæèãéã£ãã
4.4 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å ⌊æ§é ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡20é ✬ã«é¢ããå ⌊åæã§ã¯ããæ°ã¥ããããæ€èšŒããã✀⌌深ãããšãã3å ⌊ãæœåºããããäºæ ã®èµ·ããæãã®ç 究ã«çµå§ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããžãã£ã⌌çåŠã®çæ³ãå¿âœ€ããŠãäºæ ãžã®æµããâœããããšã«åªããçè·åž«ããããšæ³å®ããã®ããã¹ããããŒããŒã¹ã®çºæ³ã§ãã£ãããã®âŒéã¯ãããã®ç¹æ§ãçºæ®ããŠãããã°äœæã䞊ãã ã¹ã€ã¹ããŒãºã®âœ³ããå£ã®ééã«é®ææ¿ãæ¿âŒããããã«ããŠã✮ãéãæããŠããã®ãâœãããæ°ã¥ããæ€èšŒã✀⌌深ãããäºæ ãžã®æµãã劚ããâŸçºãšãªã£ãŠãã¹ããããŒæ©èœãçºæ®ããŠããã å®è€ã(2007)ã¯ãå»çå®å šã«ã¯ããªã¹ã¯ã«æ°ã¥ãè¡šçŸããããšããã®æ°ã¥ããæŽå©ã«âœ£ããèœâŒãè²ãããšãéèŠã§ãã 18ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠããããããŠãã€ãªãããå ±åãææãšããŠæŽ»âœ€ããããšãçè·åž«ã®ãªã¹ã¯ã«å¯Ÿããææ§ãè²ãŠãçè·æè¡æè²ã«ããªã18ãšããŠãããããã¯ãæ°ã¥ããã®éèŠæ§ãææããŠããç¹ã§ãä»åã®çµæãâœæããç¥âŸãšãããã ✀⌌深ãç¹æ€ãã姿å¢ãäºæ ãé²ããšããç ç©¶å ±å 19ããä»åã®çµæãâœæãããä»åã®âŸâœ ãé✠åããâœæããç¥âŸãšããŠã¯ã迫✥ã(2007)ããçåã«æã£ãŠããŠãé»ã£ãŠæ✰ã«åŸã£ãŠããŸãæ 床ã匷ãçè·åž«ã¯ããã€ãªãããã®å ±åãå€ã 20ããšãå ±åããŠãããã€ãŸãæ°ã«ãªãããšãæŸçœ®ããã°ãã€ãªããããæãããšã«ãªãããä»åã®å ⌊ã«âŸããããçåãæã€ãæ€èšŒããäœåºŠã確èªããã✀⌌深ãããæå³ããâŸçºãå®âŸãããã°ãã€ã³ã·ãã³ãã®æâœãæåŸ ã§ããããšã«ãªããçè·åž«ã✬ã®åã®çŸè±¡ã«ã€ããŠäœæ ãªã®ããåžžã«èããç¥ç奜å¥âŒŒãæã¡ãåãããªããã°èãåæ°ãæã€ãã⌌ãããããšã§ãæ€èšŒã✀⌌深ãã®çºæ®ã«çµã³ã€ãããšãæåŸ ãããã
4.5 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãšç¢ºèªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªãããçµéš ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®é ✬ããšã«âŸâŒ°è©å®ã®å€ã®âŸŒäœçŸ€ãèšå®ãã確èªäžâŸã®ãã€ãªãããã®çµéšä»¶æ°ã®å·®ãã¿ããã5.ã⌌é ãçã§ããããšããç¹æ§ã®âŸâŒ°è©äŸ¡åŸç¹ã⟌ãã»ãããçµéšæ°ã¯ææã«âŸŒãã£ããã⌌é ãçãâŸèªããâŒã¯ãäœåºŠã確èªãããªããšèœã¡çããªããšãã⌌çããããã®ãšæšæž¬ãããããæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ãã®ãããªâŒã¯ããå€ãã®ç¢ºèªäžâŸã«ãããã€ãªããããäœéšããŠãããå€ãã®ãã€ãªãããäºæ ãåŒãèµ·ãããŠããŸããšããæå³ãªã®ããå€ãæ°ã¥ãããšãã§ãããšããæå³ãªã®ãã¯ããããªãæ€èšãèŠããã
4.6 ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãšå±æ§ ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®ãæ°ã¥ããå ⌊ãšãæ€èšŒãå ⌊ã«ã¯ãå€å幎æ°ã«ããææå·®ãã¿ããããçµéšå¹Žæ°ãæµ ãçè·åž«ãããå€å幎æ°ãâ»ãçè·åž«ã®ã»ãããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã⟌ãå€ã✰ãããããªãã¡ã¹ããããŒãšãªãèœâŒãçµéšã«ãã£ãŠâŸŒãŸãèœâŒã§ããå¯èœæ§ããŸãã¯ãããã®èœâŒã«åªããè ãå€åãâ»å¹Žç¶ç¶ãã
38
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 38 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
å¯èœæ§ãèãããããã èšåºå€æèœâŒãšã¯ããŸããŸãªããŒã¿ã®åæãšçµ±åã«ãã£ãŠæ£è æ å ±ãçè·å ŽâŸ¯ã解éããçŸåšã®ç¶æ ãèµ·ããããå±éºæ§ã蚺æããçè·æŽ»åã決å®ããå€æããããã®æ¥µããŠéèŠãªèœâŒã§ãã 21ãã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®é ✬ã«ãããŠããæç§æžã®ç¥èãçµéšãããã¿ãŒã³ãããå€åãäºæž¬ããããã«ããŠããããé ã®äžã§ãå±éºã®çºâœ£ããã·ãã¥ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãããããã«ããŠãããããèŠçãåºãæã¡ããŸãå šäœãããâŒéãç¹æ€ãããããã«ããŠãããããã®èœâŒãè¡šçŸã§ããã次ã®ç 究ã«ã¯ãçµéšãèšåºå€æã磚ããšã®âŸâœ ã✰ãããŠããã
飯å¡ã(2011)ã¯ãèšåºå€æã«ã¯ããããããã«âŸãã®ããšããçè·åž«ã®æãšããããåŽâŸ¯ãå«ãŸããŠãããçè·åž«ã®æ¥åéâŸã«ãããŠã¯ãã®ç¹ãéèŠã ãšææããããã§ããã®ãããªç¥èã¯çè·åž«åâŒã®çµéšã«ãããšããã⌀ãã 22ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠãããæ°âŒçè·åž«ã¯å€å幎æ°ãçãããŸã çµéšç¥ãæµ ããâŒå±€ã®ç éœãæ±ããããŠã¯ããããçŸå®ã«ã¯åâŒã®åªâŒä»»ãã«ããã ãã§ã¯çŒåã®å±éºãåé¿ã§ããªããããå 茩ãè·å Žããã®âœæŽãäžå¯âœãšèããããã ã6.äœäºã«ãããŠããâŸä¿¡ããªããããšããè©å®é ✬ã§ã¯ãå€ç¶å¹Žæ°ã0ã5幎ã®çè·åž«ã®åŸç¹ã20幎以äžããææã«âŸŒãã£ããæ°âŒçè·åž«ã¯çè·âŒã®æªçãã®ããå»çäºæ ãåŒãèµ·ãããªã¹ã¯ã⟌ããšããæããçµéšäžâŸã®èªèã§âŸä¿¡ããªããšèãããããâŒåŽã(2008)ã¯ãâœã ã®çè·å®è·µã®ç©ã¿éãããçè·åž«ãšããŠã®å®è·µèœâŒãžã®âŸä¿¡ããããããè·æ¥ç¶ç¶ãâœããŠãããšè¿°ã¹ãŠãã 23ãæ°âŒçè·åž«ã¯âŸåã®çµéšãå¢ãããäžåžãå 茩ãååããèœâŒãèªããããçµéšãå ããããšã§ãâŸåã«âŸä¿¡ãåäžããããšèãããããããã«ãã£ãŠãçåãæ±ããå Žåã«ææããããã«ãªã£ãããâŸåã§å±éºäºæž¬ã§ãããããªã£ãããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãçºæ®ã§ããããã«ãªãã
å âŸç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ãäžå çè·åž«ãæâ»ãžã®æåŸ ããã€âŒâœ ã§âŸä¿¡ãäœãã⌌ççã«äžå®å®ãªç¶æ ã«ãããããäžå çè·åž«ã«å¯ŸããŠããã®åªâŒãèªããŠããããšãäŒããããã«ãåŽããå±ãŸããšãã£ã声ãããããããšãéèŠã§ããããšã®ææããªãããŠãã 24ã
4.7 確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ããã³ ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®é¢é£
確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®é¢é£ã«é¢ããåæã«ãããŠã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®äžäœå°ºåºŠãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®äžäœå°ºåºŠã®éã«ã¯ãææãªåŒ±ãæ£ã®çžé¢ãâŸãããããšãããäºãã®èŠå éã«ã¯äœããã®é¢é£ããããšæšå¯ãããã ãã ã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã®âŸŒãâŒéã¯ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å€ã⟌ãã®ããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®å€ã⟌ãâŒéã¯ç¢ºèªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã⟌ãã®ããçŸæç¹ã§ã¯ããã®âœ åæ§ããªãã¡å æé¢ä¿ãŸã§ç¹å®ããããšã¯ã§ããªããä»åŸããã«åæãé²ãããã®ç¹ãæããã«ããå¿ èŠãããã ãŸãã確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã«ããŠãã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«ããŠãããã€ãªããã件æ°ãšã®éã«ææãªçžé¢ãâŸåºãããŠãããããã®ïŒã€ã®èŠå ã¯ãã€ãªããã件æ°ã®å¢æžã«ããŸãé¢é£ãæããªãå¯èœæ§ãèããããããã®çç±ãã©ãã«ããã®ããããã«æ¢ç©¶
ãå¿ èŠãšæãããã
5.ãŸãšã
確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®èªèã«ã€ããŠãæèäžâŸãããéäžäžå¯ãããç¥èã»çµéšäžâŸããšãã 3 å ⌊ãã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã«ã€ããŠãæ°ã¥ããããæ€èšŒããã✀⌌深ãããšãã3å ⌊ãæœåºãããã 確èªäžâŸãããããããèŠå ãšããŠããæ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæãããæéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæãããçŠã£ãŠããæãããæã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæãã® 4 é ✬ã«ãããŠãè©äŸ¡åŸç¹é«çŸ€ã®æ¹ãããã€ãªããã件æ°ã«é¢ãææã«é«ãå€ã瀺ããã確èªäžâŸãæžããããã«ã¯ãå€å¿ãªå€åç¶æ³ã®æ¹åãé©æ£ãªâŒå¡ã®ç¢ºä¿ãšé 眮ãããã³æ²»çã«éäžã§ããç°å¢ã¥ãããæ±ããããŠãããšãããã ã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ã®ãæ°ã¥ããå ⌊ãšãæ€èšŒãå ⌊ã«ãããŠã¯ãçµéšå¹Žæ°ãæµ ãçè·åž«ãããå€å幎æ°ãâ»ãçè·åž«ã®ã»ãããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãææã«âŸŒãã£ããæ°âŒçè·åž«ã¯åâŒã®åªâŒããã³å 茩ãè·å Žããã®âœæŽã§âŸåã®èœâŒã䌞ã°ããã¹ããããŒç¹æ§ãæã€çè·åž«ã«è²ã£ãŠããããšã✰åãããã 確èªäžâŸèŠå ã®äžäœå°ºåºŠãšã¹ããããŒç¹æ§èŠå ã®äžäœå°ºåºŠã®éã«ã¯ãææãªåŒ±ãæ£ã®çžé¢ãâŸãããããšãããäºãã®èŠå éã«ã¯äœããã®é¢é£ããããšã¿ãŠããããªãæ¢æ±ã課é¡ã§ããã
6.ä»åŸã®èª²é¡
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ã確èªäžâŸã®èŠå èªèã®å°ºåºŠãšããŠã®åŠ¥åœæ§ã¯ãŸã âŒåãšã¯âŸããæ¹åã®äœå°ããããä»åŸã¯è³ªåé ✬ãâŒå±€æŽç·Žããã確èªäžâŸã«ã€ããŠã®æ✀ãªæž¬å®ããŒã«éçºãé²ããŠããããã
åèâœç®
[1] å ¬ç財å£æ³âŒ âœæ¬å»çæ©èœè©äŸ¡æ©æ§,å»çäºæ é²âœäºæ¥éš,å»çäº æ æ å ± å é ç äº æ¥ 2019 幎 幎 å ± http://www.med-safe.jp/pdf/year_report_2019.pdfïŒ(åç §2020-11-22)
[2] å¶æ£®å¥œâŒŠ. æ£è å®å šã®ããã«çè·æ¥å ã®äœæžåãå³ã. 第 127 åâœæ¬å»åŠäŒã·ã³ããžãŠã (4)å»çå®å šãšã·ã¹ãã , å»åŠã»å»çå®å šã®ç§åŠ. 2004. 100-111.
[3] å ¬ç財å£æ³âŒ âœæ¬å»çæ©èœè©äŸ¡æ©æ§,å»çäºæ é²âœäºæ¥éš. å»çäº æ æ å ± å é ç äº æ¥ å¹³ æ 28 幎 幎 å ± ,http://www.med-safe.jp/pdf/year_report_2016.pdf. (åç §2020-11-22)
[4] è€äºçç ⌊, ç§éè£ä¿¡, æ¡åå®çŸ, 寺åŽå代, åæµçŽçŸâŒŠ. 確èªäžâŸã«ããã€ã³ã·ãã³ããšãªã¹ã¯ãã€ãã³ã°âŸåãšã®é¢ä¿. å»çã®è³ªã»å®å šåŠäŒèª. 2020, vol. 15, no. 2, p. 103-114.
[5] æ²³éâ¿å€ªé.å»çã«ããããã¥ãŒãã³ãšã©ãŒïŒãªãééããã©ãé²ã(第2ç). å»åŠæžé¢. 2014, p.52.
[6] äžæ〈å€âŒŠ, ✩✯è£âŒŠ. çè·åž«ã®åâŒç¹æ§ãšã¹ãã¬ã¹ç¶æ³å¯ŸåŠâŸå,泚æã»ç¢ºèªâŸåã«ã€ããŠã®æ€èš. åä¹å·çè·ç 究èª. 2016, vol. 14, no. 1, p. 1-10.
[7] â»âŒä¿¡âŒŠ, æž¡éå Œä¹ , æ劻æ. ã€ã³ã·ãã³ãã»ã¢ã¯ã·ãã³ãå ±åè ã察象ãšãã確èªäžâŸã«é¥ãèæ¯èŠå ã®åæ,åæµ·éçè·ç 究åŠäŒéé². 2016, p. 83-85.
[8] æž¡éšããã, æåªå§«, éåã¿ãã, ⌀å¡äœä»£, ⻫è€äŒéœâŒŠ. ãã€ãªãããå ±åã«ãããçè·åž«ã®ç¢ºèªäžâŸãšãªãèŠå èª¿æ» çè·
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
39ïŒ 39 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
åž«ã¢ã³ã±ãŒã調æ»ãâŸã£ãŠ. âœæ¬çè·åŠäŒè«âœé: çè·ç®¡ç. 2010, vol. 40, p. 126-128.
[9] ✥äžå ±âŒŠ, å µè€å¥œçŸ, âŒäžå¯æµ. å»çäºæ ã®ãã€ã¹ããããŒããŒã¹ã«ã¿ãããç¹æ§ïŒã¹ããããŒã®æ§æèŠçŽ ã«é¢ããæ¢çŽ¢. å»çã®è³ªã»å®å šåŠäŒèª. 2013, vol. 8, p. 311.
[10] ååŽããã¿ ïŒå°ŸåŽéæ±. ç é¢å®ç¿ã«ãããçè·åŠâœ£ã®ãã€ãªãããã®å®æ ãšãã®èŠå . âœæ¬çè·åŠäŒè«âœé çè·ç·å. 2012. vol. 42, p. 346-349.
[11] çš²å£æä¹. ãªã¹ã¯èªç¥ãšæå¿æ±ºå®. âœæ¬ç¥èœæ å ±åŠäŒèª. 2003, vol. 15, no. 1, p. 20-28.
[12] è³è³ç¹, âŸå¡è, ✩⌟å®æïŒãæå·®åŒç§°ãã®ãšã©ãŒé²âœå¹æã®å®€å å®éšã«ããæ€èšŒïŒç£æ¥ã»çµç¹âŒŒçåŠç 究ïŒ1996, vol.9, no.2, p. 107 -114.
[13] å è³âŒææ, è éæµæª, å®è³ç¥åä¹ , 家æ³æ¡âŒ, æâœç §æ¬¡. ã€ã³ã·ãã³ãçºâœ£ã«ä¿ããâŸåç¹æ§ã«ã€ããŠã®è§£æ. å»åŠæ€æ». 2016, vol. 65, no. 5, p. 576-581.
[14] 仲äžç¥çŸâŒŠ, æ²³éççŸ. èšå°å®ç¿ã«ãããçè·åŠâœ£ã®ã€ã³ã·ãã³ãã¬ããŒãåæ. å⟥⟊è⌀åŠçŽèŠ. 2017, vol. 13, p. 77-84.
[15] æ©âŒâŒ¥æ⌊, 森æ¬ä¹ çŸâŒŠ, ✮éè¥è, ä»åŸ³æçŸ, å®â»å žâŒŠ, ⌀海䜳⌊:æå·®ãåŒç§°ã®å®æœã«å¯Ÿãã〈å ç æ£ã§å€åããçè·åž«ã®æè, 第41 åâœæ¬çè·åŠäŒè«âœé 〈å çè·, 68-71, 2011.
[16] å®éæ ⌊, âŒâŒ(äžäž)æŠâŒŠ, æŸæ¬åâŒé, ⟠äºäŒžä¹ä». çè·æåã«ãããéåã®âŒŒçç✣起èŠå -çè·åŠâœ£ïŒãªã¹ã¯ãããŒãžã£ãŒã察象ã«-. å¿âœ€âŒŒçåŠç 究. 2014, vol. 40, no. 1, p. 23-35.
[17] å¶æ£®å¥œâŒŠ. çè·æ¥åããâŸãå»çäºæ ã®é²âœå¯Ÿç. âœæ¬å»åŠéèª. 2000, vol. 124, p. 878-822.
[18] å®è€æŠâŒŠ, é¡åžçæµâŒŠ, 岡✥çŽä¹, å·æ³¢å ¬âŸ¹, 浊✥ç§âŒŠ, 寺åŽæ çŸ. æâŒçè·åŠå®ç¿ã«ããããã€ãªã»ãããäœéšã«é¢ããå®æ 調æ». ä¿å¥åŠç 究. 2007, vol. 19, no. 2, p. 65-74.
[19] ✥âŒæµ©âŒŠ, æž âœçç±âŒŠ, æµ âœ¥æ©çŽ, ç©éçæµ, ç¬ åå ⌊, å¯æé ⌊, ç¥âœ¥âŒ€èŒ, åæ°žèŒå€«, â»âœ¥ä¿âŒ. 茞液ã«ãããæã蟌ã¿ãã¹ãç¡ããããã®åãçµã¿. å»çã®è³ªã»å®å šåŠäŒèª. 2007, vol. 2, no. 1, p. 101-105.
[20] 迫✥è£âŒŠ,å µè€å¥œçŸ,✥äžå ±âŒŠ. å»ççŸå Žã§åãçè·åž«ã®ãã€ãªãããã«åœ±é¿ãäžããèŠå (3). âœæ¬âŒŒçåŠäŒç¬¬ 71 å⌀äŒ. 2007, 3EV006,doi:10.4992/pacjpa.71.0_3EV006.https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/pacjpa/71/0/71_3EV006/_article/-char/ja/(åç §2020-11-29)
[21] 岩✥幞æ, åæž æ⌊, åææ¿å¥œ, æéæŠâŒŠ, 鶎✥æŽçŸ, èäºççŽâŒŠ,éœè€ããã. ç°åžžãå€æãã ICU çè·åž«ã®æèãã¿ãŒã³ã®åæ. 矀⟺⌀åŠå»åŠéšä¿å¥åŠç§çŸ€âŸºä¿å¥åŠçŽèŠ. 2005, vol.26, p.11-18.
[22] 飯å¡â¿çŽ, 鎚✥ç²âŒŠ, 枡蟺éœâŒŠ, éœè€,ä¹ çŸâŒŠ. åšâŒ¿è¡ææ£è ã«å¯Ÿããç æ£çè·åž«ã®èšåºå€æ. çŠå³¶ç✎å»ç§âŒ€åŠçè·åŠéšçŽèŠ. 2011, vol. 13, p. 1-10.
[23] âŒåŽæµâŒŠ, å ✥å®çŸ, â»âœ¥äº¬âŒŠ. äžâŸŒå¹Žçè·åž«ã®è·æ¥ç¶ç¶ã®ããã»ã¹ãšãã®æã. âœæ¬çè·ç®¡çåŠäŒå¹Žæ¬¡âŒ€äŒè¬æŒæé²é. 2008, vol. 12, p. 64.
[24] é¿éšã±ãšâŒŠ. äžå çè·å©Šã®âŸâŒ°æè²âŒãšç®¡çè ããã®âœæŽãšã®é¢ä¿. ç¥å¥å·ç✎çè·æè²âŒ€åŠæ ¡çè·æè²ç 究éé². 2001, vol. 27, p. 244-251.
40
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 40 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
Supplement
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ã«é¢ãã調æ»
1ããããŸã§äœéšãã確èªäžè¶³ã«ãããã€ãªãããã®äºäŸãšããŠãæãå°è±¡ã«æ®ããã®ãäžã€ãæãåºããŠãã ã
ãã
1) ç°¡æœãªé¡ããé¡ãããŸãã
2) ãã®äºäŸã«ã€ããŠããã€ãã©ãã§ãªã©ã®è©³çŽ°ããäžèšã«å ·äœçã«ãæžããã ããã
ãã€(æé垯)ïŒ
äŸ:18:00é
ã©ãã§ïŒ
äŸ:ç 宀ã§
誰ãïŒ
äŸ:çè·åž«ã®èªåã
äœãïŒ
äŸ:æ£è ã®è¬ã
ã©ã®ããã«ãã©ãããïŒ
äŸ:æ®æ®µèªå® ã§é£²ãã§ããè¬ã®ååçµæã確èªãããç é¢ãåŠæ¹ããéå§è¬ãäžè¬ããã
ã©ããªã£ãïŒ
äŸ:çµæçã«éå°äžè¬ãšãªãããã£ãšãæ°åäžè¯ãšãªã£ããããŸããªãå埩ããã
3) äžèšã®äºäŸã§ã確èªäžè¶³ã«è³ã£ãèŠå ãšããŠãäœãèããããã§ããããã
äœã圱é¿ããŠããããã©ãããããšãèªå ã«ãªã£ãããåºãèããŠãã ãããèªåãä»ã®äººã®ããšãè·å Žç°
å¢ãªã©ãçŽæ¥çãªåå ãèæ¯ã®ç¶æ³ãå«ããŠããªãã¹ãå€ãæããŠã¿ãŠãã ããã
4) äžèšã®äºäŸã§ã倧ããªäºæ ã«ã€ãªãããã«ããã çç±ãšããŠãäœãèããããã§ããããã
äºæ ãžã®æµããæ¢ãããã®ã¯äœããäœãééãã®çºèŠãå埩çããæãããŠããã®ãã圹ã«ç«ã£ããšæãã
ãšãããªãã¹ãå€ãæããŠã¿ãŠãã ããã
5) ã»ãã«ã確èªäžè¶³ã«é¥ãããããšãããšããŠæãã€ãããšãããã°ãèªç±ã«ãæžããã ããã
2. ãèªåã®çµéšãããã©ããªæã«ç¢ºèªäžè¶³ã«é¥ãããããšæãããŸããã以äžã®å 容ã«é¢ãã
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
41ïŒ 41 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
åœãŠã¯ãŸããšæãçšåºŠããçããã ããããå šãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªããããã倧å€åœãŠã¯ãŸããã®
ãã¡ã該åœãããã®ãäžã€ã ãéžãã§ãã ããã(ããããã²ãšã€ãã€)
â æ¥åãéãªããå€å¿ã ã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
â¡ æéåè¿«ã§ãæ¥ããããæ 1 2 3 4 5
⢠ç é¢ã®ç¢ºèªã«é¢ããã«ãŒã«ãç¥ããªãã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
⣠å°éç¥èãäžè¶³ããŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
†ãã€ããã£ãŠãããããšããæ £ãããã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
⥠äžéæ¥åãå ¥ã£ãŠããŸã£ã 1 2 3 4 5
⊠泚æãæããã«ãç®ãéããæ 1 2 3 4 5
⧠声ã ããæå·®ã確èªãããªãã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
âš çŠã£ãŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
â© æã蟌ã¿ãããŠããŸã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
⪠äœèª¿äžè¯ã§æ³šææ£æŒ«ã ã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
â« èšæ¶ã ãã«é Œã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
⬠圢ãè²ã䌌ãŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
â ééããããé åã ã£ãæ 1 2 3 4 5
â® å調ãªåäœã®ç¹°ãè¿ãã§ãæèãäœäžããæ 1 2 3 4 5
⯠éèŠæ§ã«é¢ããèªèãäžè¶³ããŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
â° ä»ã®ããšã«æ³šæãåããŠãããä»ã®ããšãèããŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
Ⱡ確èªãããŸã§ããªã確ãã ãšæã蟌ãã æ 1 2 3 4 5
â² ä»ã®äººããã£ãŠãããã®ã§ã確èªããªããŠã倧äžå€« 1 2 3 4 5
ã ãšæã£ãæ
â³ å°éçãªçµéšãäžè¶³ããŠããæ 1 2 3 4 5
倧å€ããŠã¯ãŸã
ããåœãŠã¯ãŸã
ã©ã¡ããšããããªã
ããŸãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
å šãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
42
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 42 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
3. ä»äºãããŠãããšãã®ãèªåã«ã€ããŠã以äžã®ããšã¯ã©ã®ãããåœãŠã¯ãŸãã§ããããããå šãåœãŠã¯ãŸããª
ããããã倧å€åœãŠã¯ãŸããã®ãã¡ãäžã€ã ãéžãã§ãã ããã(ããããã²ãšã€ãã€)
â ãèªåã§ããäœåºŠãããçŽåŸããããŸã§ãå¿µå ¥ãã« 1 2 3 4 5
確èªããªããšæ°ãæžãŸãªã
â¡ ãæ°ãå°ãããæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⢠ãç¥çµè³ªãã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⣠äºçŽ°ãªããšããæ°ã«ãªããæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
†ãå¿é ãçã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⥠äœäºã«ãããŠããèªä¿¡ããªãã 1 2 3 4 5
⊠ä»äººãè¡ã£ãããšããä¿¡çšããªããæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⧠äºæ³ãšéãããšãããã°ããã®ãçç±ããæ¢ããŠçŽåŸãã 1 2 3 4 5
âš åžžã«ããªããããšè«ççã«èããããã«ããŠãã 1 2 3 4 5
â© ããããªãããšã¯ãèªåãç解ã§ãããŸã§ãå°ããã 1 2 3 4 5
⪠ä»äºã§çåã«æã£ãããšã¯ããææãããããã«ããŠãã 1 2 3 4 5
â« èªåã®çåãç¶æ ãããç¥ããããããã«ããŠãã 1 2 3 4 5
⬠æç§æžã®ç¥èãçµéšãããã¿ãŒã³ãããå€åãäºæž¬ãã 1 2 3 4 5
ããã«ããŠãã
â é ã®äžã§ãå±éºã®çºçããã·ãã¥ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãããŠãã 1 2 3 4 5
â® ãã€ã³ããæŒããããéãå€æããåŸæãªæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⯠ãç°å¢ããæŽã£ãŠããªããšå«ã§ãæ°ã«ãªã 1 2 3 4 5
â° ä»ã®ããšãèããŠããæäœãå€ããã€ããšéããªã© 1 2 3 4 5
ã现ãããããšã«æ°ã¥ãæ¹ã§ãã
â± äœæ°ãªãäŒè©±ãããããæ å ±ããæŸãããšãåŸæãªæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
â² èŠçãåºãæã¡ããŸãå šäœãããäžéãç¹æ€ããã 1 2 3 4 5
ããã«ããŠãã
â³ ããã¯ïœã ã£ãã¯ãããªã©èšæ¶ãšã®éãã«æ°ã¥ãæ¹ã§ãã 1 2 3 4 5
倧å€ããŠã¯ãŸã
ããåœãŠã¯ãŸã
ã©ã¡ããšããããªã
ããŸãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
å šãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
43ïŒ 43 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
4. ããªããèªèº«ã®æ¥é ã®æ¥åã«ãããŠãäžèšã®è¡åãããããšã§ééããé²ããããšããçµéšã¯ã©ã®ãããã
ããŸããããå šããªããããããããããã®ãã¡ã該åœãããã®ãäžã€ã ãéžãã§ãã ããããªããâ¡â¢â£ã§
ãããããããããããããšãçãã«ãªã£ãæ¹ã¯ããªãããããŠããã®ããäž»ãªçç±ãšããŠæãã€ãããšãç
ç±ã®æ¬ã«ãæžããã ããã (äŸ:æ°ã«ãªã£ããæå°ããã£ããäºæ äŸããã£ãããªã©)
â çŽãèªåã§æ°ã¥ãã 1 2 3 4 5
⡠念ã®ãã確èªããŠåãã£ã 1 2 3 4 5
çç±:
⢠ããåãããªãããšã調ã¹çŽãã 1 2 3 4 5
çç±:
⣠ããããããªãããšã人ã«èãã 1 2 3 4 5
çç±:
†ååãææããŠããã 1 2 3 4 5
⥠äžåžãææããŠããã 1 2 3 4 5
⊠æ©åšã®ã¢ã©ãŒã ããšã©ãŒèŠåã鳎ã£ã 1 2 3 4 5
⧠æ£è ãæ°ã¥ãããçŽããããã 1 2 3 4 5
âš ãã®ä»ïŒ 1 2 3 4 5
5. ããªããèªèº«ã«ã€ããŠãå°ãããŸãã
1)ããªãã®æ§å¥ããç¥ãããã ããã
â ç·æ§ â¡å¥³æ§ â¢ãã®ä»
2)ããªãã®å¹Žéœ¢ããç¥ãããã ããã
â 20代 â¡30代 â¢40代 â£50代 â€60代以äž
3)çè·åž«ã»åçè·åž«ãšããŠå€åããŠãã环èšã®å¹Žæ°ããç¥ãããã ããã
幎 ã¶æ
4)çŸåšã®ç é¢ã§ã®å€å幎æ°ããç¥ãããã ããã
倧å€ããŠã¯ãŸã
ããåœãŠã¯ãŸã
ã©ã¡ããšããããªã
ããŸãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
å šãåœãŠã¯ãŸããªã
44
çµ±åç§åŠãåµåå·ïŒ2021ïŒ
ïŒ 44 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789
幎 ã¶æ
5)çŸåšã®éšçœ²ã§ã®å€å幎æ°ããç¥ãããã ããã
幎 ã¶æ
6)ããªãã®ãå€ãã®éšçœ²ããç¥ãããã ããã
â å ç§ç³» â¡å€ç§ç³» â¢å€æ¥
â£æè¡å®€ â€éäžæ²»ç宀 â¥ãã®ä»( )
7)ããªãã®çŸåšã®è·äœããç¥ãããã ããã
â çè·åž« â¡äž»ä»»(å¯åž«é·) â¢åž«é·
â£å»çå®å šç®¡çè â€ãã®ä»( )
8)ããªãã®è·å Žã«ãããŠã確èªäžè¶³ã«ãããã€ãªãããã®äœéšã¯ãããŸãããã
2019幎床(â19幎4æïœâ20幎2æ)ã®éã§ã©ãããããã£ãããç¥ãããã ããã
ãªãã£ãå Žåã¯0件ãšãçããã ããã
çè·å Žé¢ã«ããã確èªäžè¶³ãåŒãèµ·ããèŠå ã®èªèã«é¢ããæ€èš
45ïŒ 45 ïŒ
ïŒ ïŒ0123456789