úúú$$ JJJ {{{{^^,,YYYY ‚ZZZA~~ 6666,,, t LLLL€¦ ·...
Transcript of úúú$$ JJJ {{{{^^,,YYYY ‚ZZZA~~ 6666,,, t LLLL€¦ ·...
áááá$$$$úúúúJJJJ
LLLLtttt~~~~åååå6666,,,,))))~~~~AAAAZZZZ‚‚‚‚2222»»»»óóóóYYYY^,,,,{{{{Research Review of The Contemporary Authoring
Styles on Khasais e Nabavi(Prophet
Muhammad~~~~VVVV 's Characteristics)
/ eZËð¡a
ABSTRACT
The life of Prophet(~V ) is the complete and comprehensive role
model for human being. He possesses Qura'nic Characteristics. He has
some distinguish attributes those nobody else has in the human history.
To convey the personality of Prophet(~V ) to the offspring, likewise
the old scholars, Many scholars of modern time wrote books on the
different aspect of characteristic of Prophet(~V )with the diversity of
methodologies. Some focused on collecting His(~V )attributes wherever
they found in the books without critical analysis of traditions, while the
others tried to sift the Prophetic Traditions and collect the authentic of them.
Some authors paid attention to present attributes in dialectic method
whereas the others formed them on scientific way. It is noteable here that
orientalists also worte on the topics whethe in positive or in negative form.
The article is an effort to point out the contemporary work done by
the scholars in collecting the characteristics of Holy Prophet(~V ).Moreover,
it draws the attention towards the qualities and problems of the work done
on the topic, as it recomends that the topic should be dealt and presented
with the authentic and basic sources. All it is analyzed briefly.
/ZÁÏZf$6,zWÔуg»Ò',ZñpZ&-Eg;ÔуgÔ0*ÎyX
45
gÎw0*u-ZvmzÅŧ‹Ig�ÔW\åÅfZ‹IguÔW\åÅt]zÆe${m¾w»ŠgzgBbìTÃZq†î0’k,zï~Ñä»�Û9Z!ïGL·tåäp[Z�xŠc*ìXá$ú
JLt~åÃ’k,~Ñä»
0Z|[tì�ZyÆ!*g}~ŒÛWyzgzZc*‹Ä~ÐZ~.™**ÑixìXZk§b�uF,KM0*ñ
Çz{„Z!ïGL·tZzg]ZK+MÆaZk!*[~Ç!-:
÷EXEƒÇXtQ|[ÒyZ(g™ä»ÑZzA
§]gÎw-ZvmzÅÃÇÇWÒ{YVJ-à**ìXŠzuZѧ]gÎw-ZvmzÅÅ|
ÐWÇ{ƒ**Zzg¬%îGZÜkÃZkÐWÇ{™**ìXŠZÑZnqgÎw-ZvmzÅÆZë�Û9»Šgu
qÝ™**ìX
ð®ZÅ+A.ð Eqá÷ºò�gÎw0*u-ZvmzÅÆ�z{Zy]Zñgzç5]~�áï
�X»åZŠgZuözŠZKã=Æa**eìYèZk!*[~¹¼Zñ§ÃzR»Š4ìXZk
¯6,Zk*y6,ZVä~ZôoÑixìX
ŒÛWȈ~Zv¬\äZk!*g}~�Z0+ZiZ(g�Ûâc*ìZjZáÐÎg>Zâ~-V�Ûâc*ì:
)1( — æøÚø^møßû_ôÐöÂøàô]ÖûøçFp o Úø^•øØ$‘ø^uôföÓöÜûæøÚø^ÆøçFp o æø]Öß$rûÜô]ôôƒø]aøçFp ™
tYìÒyZyá÷»ÄZyìXÐ{ÅþLÇägÎwZ™x-ZvmzÅÃé�Ûâc*ìX
Zq-Zzg )2( ™]ôôÞ$«]øÂû_ønûßFÔø]ÖûÓøçû$ø†ø— Švá÷~ÐZq-ZkWe$Ig�~Òy�Ûâc*ŠHì:
æø…øÊøÃûßø^ ™ Zzgt�: )4( — æøìø^iøÜø]Öß$fônùàø ™ 2�Ûâc*: )3( ™ÂøŠF³oœáûm$fû³Ãø%øÔø…øe%ÔøÚøÏø^Ú÷^ÚøvûÛöçû9÷]— £x6,�Ûâc*:
5( )û ÖøÔøƒôÒû†øÕø
gÎwZv-ZvmzÅä�Ûâc*: Q
ZZœÂ³_n³kì³ÛŠ³^Ö³Üm³Ã³_ãàœu‚Îf×oVeÃ%k]Öo]¢uÛ†æ]¢‰ç9(æÞ’†le^Ö†Âg
ÚnŠ³†³éJ`³†æq³Ã³×³kÖ³o]¢…šÚŠr‚]æ›`ç…]æ]u×kÖ±]ÖÇß^ñÜæÖÜivØÖfß±Ò^áÎf×±(
æ]³_n³k]ÖQ³Ë^Âè(æ]ÞäÖn‹Úàeßo]Ÿæ΂‰ªÙJË^ÂjäæZÞo]ì†lJË^Âj±ÊrÃ×jã^ÖÛàÚ^l
! )6( ŸmQ†Õe^Ö×äJnò^XX
Zq-Zzg(�Ûâc*:ZZʳ–³×³k³׳o]¢Þfn³^ðeŠ³kVœÂ³_n³kqç]ÚÄ]ÖÓ×Ü(æÞ’†le^Ö†Âg(æœu×kÖ±
! )7( ]ÖÇß^ñÜ(æqÃ×kÖo]Ÿ…šÚŠr‚]æ›`ç…]朅‰×k]Öo]Öí×ÐÒ^ÊèæìjÜe±]ÖßfnçáXX46
V Zq-Zzgug$ì
ZZœÞ³^œæÙJ³Ën³Äʳo]Ö³r³ßèÖ³Üm’‚ÑÞfoÚà]¢Þfn^ðÚà‘‚Îkæ]áÚà]ŸÞfn^ðÞfn^Ú^
! )8( m’‚ÎäÚàœÚjä]Ÿ…qØæ]u‚XX
èÃg{!*ÑWc*]zZqŠg$~gÎwZv~VÆá÷ºòÒyK²/õY
G�XZϧbŒÛWyˆZzggzZc*]Ä~gÎwZv~VÆá÷�ÒyK‰�ZyÆ_¬Ðظì�tñçq
,t~~VÆ!*g}~¥â]�ÛZë™äÆÒpÐZÌ»qïìXZkZÌÆ7ÃZzZb
ŠzgÆfY™Zxäá÷tt6,�Ã’k,XZy~Z~.gzZe$ÆZßßVÃÌæÃg3XZy~ÐP
ÃÆ**xŠg`fs�:
J†Í]ÖÛ’_ËoF!!!!ÚvÛ‚eà]e†]anÜÞnQ^µç…p{
D| 9ŸñØ]Ößfçéý]eç9]ñç9]ÖŠrŠj^Þo{EÝQSN
)x672|( ]¡Ý]Ößfçéý]eàÎjnfè]Ö‚mßç…p{
)x034|( 9ŸñØ]Ößfçéý]eçÞÃnÜ]‘Ë`^Þo{
)x854|( 9ŸñØ]Ößfçéý]Öfn`Ïo{
)x408|( { Æ^mè]ÖŠçÙÊoì’^ñ“]Ö†‰çÙ"#!!!!]eà]ÖÛ×Ïà
�áï�X )x119|( ì’^ñ“]ÖÓf†pFý]ÖŠnç›o{
ZyÃÆ_¬Æ‚B‚BZZŠzZg~�áùƒäzZàÃÆY,}ÐZZ0+Ziz
Z‚2’k,‚tWD�XX~9zßZ‚2»êZy~gzZc*]Ã�áï™äÆZßßVÅgzÝ~ÌÎc*YYìZzgZsxÆãCŠ~o{g‚ªÃæÃgę̃YìXŠz§].h+~̧]gÎw~V6,
ZylZzgZtg¶K‰�XZy~Ðá÷z7Z]t~å6,Šg`ÃÅîsz„ìXábt~~VÌZkŠzg»{m*yìTÆ�<Lt~ÆZÍØVÃZ#ÖÆ‚tÑc*ŠHìX
].h+Šzg~á÷zZqÐiZ‹gÎw~V6,ãCŠ~îg6,ŠzZ0+Zi~Ã’k,ÅYg„�:
xà 1X
:E+™{ 2X
xÃ~W8g-ZvmzÅŧ]0*uÆZyUîVÃZÌŠ~ˆì�¿Æ‚B47
ºm�X
¯òZ0+Zi].h+ŠzgÆdgD**]ä¬@p=VÔ(ϲz`zizZwZzgçÙÎaÆiZz-Vл°u
J-ZW,JwHìXtZW,§]Å’k,~Ì0*c*Y@*ìX›âVÆizZwÆ‚BZk~I¾ÔYgq:6Ô”‹’k,ZzgòZ0+Zi�áHX´)(òãÅ"§>Z#åTÅ¢Îx¦Ñy0+z~òä’k,
ŶZkÅZq-VwìXtÂ[TŠzg~’k,ňz{°Z"',R0*uzy~›âVÆizZw»ŠzgåXZkÂ[~dz¯òZ0+ZiÐá÷t~å6,ZÖgìwHŠHìXtŠzg‚³F,¹ÆW¸i»ŠzgåX
].h+Ex~=ÃZâx¯c*Y[åXZka=Åú»‚ây7{Å|Ôt]zg‚ªÅ›+MZzg
X )9( gÎw0*u~VÅfZ]Ig�Ð{mZqÐiZ]ÆÒy~ÌHŠH§>Z¼Ô·ZŠgö»0+z~òÅ@*;ìXZkÂ[~7Z]zá÷t~~V6,gzÝeZàˆ
ìXZk»Z0+ZiÜ:ìT~ÑŠ–Ð%ú[f‚Ã#¥HŠHìX].h+Z‚2§]~Ðt
Q|[úc*VìXZÏQ|[ÃZ(g™äzZßV»ÑZšrÆ‚B‚BŠÃqÌìX·ZŠgö»0+z~
Zq-£x6,&À.5ÿG
GLŠ+Æ*yÆÒy~-Vg¶§Zi�:
LLZzgª#ÖJ-ÆaŠ*ÃZq-Z(»ïZzgåŠ2g)ªÑ<(Š}‰�ZyÆŠ+ZzgŠ*ÅZ&bz#b»ÓìZzgZkÆ›ëzŠ‡ëZzgZuZg
z¬ÃŠN™Š*ªZyìÔª#ÖJ-7WäzZázZu]»¬Ñ<·tå
Ð¥xƒYìXfY·Šz»gòÆ0*kÃðÑ<„7TÂtgÄ™fYZ#ÖZzg�YIŧb:òŠ}ÃXZkz‰Ü»gòÆ0*k
Ñ<»ÃðD7TÅgzÐz{:òŠ}Ã;V»gòÆ0*kÅz
wÄZzg»g~¤/~ÆExz.y�XxZãZzg˜V!*ãZzg°w/ZãÆ0
ZyÆ0*kÃðW�ã‡ây7�TÅgzÐz{Š*~°wzZ»sÆ‚BÓ#Ö™ÃXf!ZZxÆ0*k�Š2gìz{PZI„ÆZ°g
ZzgìÑ]»³ìXÑ$šï GGLZsðŧbW�yÐ**iw”{Ãð‡âyZy
X )01( Æ0*k7óó48
ìXZk~½7gZ0+Zi óóóóóóóó åååå ]]]]ÖÖÖÖ³³³³ççççuuuu³³³³oooo]]]]ÖÖÖÖ³³³³ÛÛÛÛ³³³³vvvvÛÛÛÛ‚‚‚‚pppp LL èÃg{Q|[ÅZq-ZzgVw·gægŸÅ"ЊæzòQ|[Z(gHŠHìX
ÆÄZyÆ�Â[Æ™936,Z,V XX ]Ö³ÃÏØæ]ÖÃ×Ü]ÖfQ†pŸmÇßn^áÂàâ‚]mè]Ö†‰Ø ZZ
ä–ì:
ZZÞ³ÃÜÖÓ؃ÖÔœ‘Øm%fjä]Öj^…mî]ÖÛ^•o(æmQã‚å]ÖÃ’†]Öv^•†!
æÖ³Ó³àenàâ‚]mè]¢Þfn^ðæuÓÛè]ÖvÓÛ^ðæÂ×çÚãÜʆæÎ^ÊoÚ’‚…
Ò³ØÚ³ßã³Û³^(æʳo]Ö%³Ïèe³’vjä(æÊo]¦ƒÂ^áÖvÏnÏäæÊoiª$n†åÊo
œÞË‹qÛnÄ›fÏ^l]ÖÛí^›fnàÊvÓÛè]ÖvÓÛ^ðæÂ×çÚãÜu…]ðeQ†mè
X )11( Þ^Î’èýÊ¡mÓçáÖã^iª$n†]¦mÛ^áæZ‰¡Ý]¦ƒÂ^áæ]ÖjÃf‚!XX
ábt~»Òyá&ÿ
JLt~åÆÒyÆjZáÐZq-Æ»xeZË·†Zt»ìXT»ÄZyLLZÎÒgÎwZ™x
-ZvmzÅþþóóìXZk"~\B{3ïIE
GGLgÎw-ZvmzÅÆiÍØVÃZôoЊg`HŠHìX¬x
ûZ0+Zi~¬%îGZÁÆaá÷t~åÆZkUÃT»mZnqÆ‚B{mìÔ%A$HŠHXtZzgZkZ0+Zi6,’k,™Š{Ãz‰ÜÅ¢zg]�XZ+ÃCÙi!*y~’k,ÅYãeÂ@*�x )21( ì
gÎw-ZvmzÅÅZÌZkŠzg~CkÅYnX
ZZÚ³à‘Ë^l]Ö†‰çÙ‘×o ²!£?~ÐZkZ0+Zi6,’k,™Š{Zq-Â[©†ZvZÅš©3§ö
EGEÅ
X )31( ì ]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×Ü]Öíô×Ïnèæ]Öíö×ÏnèXX
].h+ŠzgZܹi1Vq໊zgìXZܪ]Ã**LÆeäYqÐx/ƒ`�X
ÑŠ–ÆZܹ¦gä„qÝ™1ìT»³].h+±"C{)bÅßg]~ŠÙƒñi0+{
ìX].h+Zܹ)b»iGZÜtzZÎÒ·~åÃZCä~ìXZk|Æ7Ã].h+§]ógzV
äá&ÿJ
Lt~å6,Ã’k,Å�XZyûZ0+ZidZzg¦:ìXeZËaZ£œjÅ"LL“‹
g‚ªóóZkÅZq-VwìXZkÂ[~yZÜtÔ;Š~»ï-ZvmzÅÆZz[W�Û,xÅi^ÃZY¤/HŠHìXW\åÅfZ]0*uкmÚW\å»Óx˜âVÆaу**ìXZkbÅ
zŸs#Ç].h+ÆÚø~eZËaZ£œj-V™D�:49
LL—gZ™x-ZvmzÅaèLLr=2+k,Zóó¬@Ñ�XZkaW\å»xÌZg�áŠ}.Zz0+~
Æ_.¬@ìZzg7g~âqZKãÆaÔaèZKãi0+ϹЇV6,”ìZzgW\~V»x
ZKãi0+ÏÆCÙZzgñh6,gÉZßw7™@*ìZkai0+ÏÅzŒVÆjZáÐW\~VÆx
X )41( ÅzŒVÃ@e7óó
ZϧbZq-»ŠÂ[LL9Zsx~VZzgZÜtõóóìT~§]©ÆÒy~R
jZßVÐæŠàˆìXqƒfZ@ZäZkÂ[Ã~ÂzÆ‚BF,KMŠc*ìXZkÂ[ÅZq-S¤
X )51( tÌì�Zk~§]©ÆZUzV6,dWÌ�áïÅì
o]ÆZÖg»Z|[YìÌ]z¾Ñ]ÔÈg”z@Ze$Ô9ZWzWy~VÅZ#ÖÅplÁìW\~V»ZkŠzg
~¬_ƒ**XW\~VÅZ#ÖW\~VÅ»Š,ÐG»ÑizZw_./gBbìXOçá÷z
ZqÐiZ]t~å6,’k,HYäzZÑic*Š{F,ZŠ[!{3¨4èEE
GEÆfZC_.!*]ÆZÖgÐ{à7ìXtQ|[’k,
&+Z‹pŠ’k,»Zq-�á‚gìXúŠ]Í-öIEÅ’k,ŒV�§%:Šg`ÅYCì:
ZZJí’nè…‰çÙ]Ö×ä‘×o]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×ÜÚ^ƒ]œÂßoe„ÖÔ]ÖÛŠÛo[
œÂ³ßoeä]ÖçÎçÍÊoìQçÅœÚ^ݜ¿ÜÚàÚQoÂ×o¾`†â^æÖÜœJÆ
ʳoun^ioe^ÖíçÍmÛ£Êoæ]Ö†Âgmvj^qßoÚ%ØJÃç…pæœÞ^œu^æÙ
i³×Ô]Ö³Û³v³^æÖè]ŸÞjv^…mèƒÖÔœáJªá…‰çÙ]Ö×ä‘×o]Ö×äÂ×nä
扳׳ÜÖn³‹]Ú†‰ã¡æŸâçe^ÖÛnŠç…]Ö‚ìçÙZÖoœÞç]…åÊ^á]Öí×Ð
q³Ûn³Ã³^ÚŠj³çm^le×ÇèÂ’†Þ^œæÚÏ^Ú^le×ÇèœâØ]Öç‘^Ùæ]Öç‘çÙ
æγ‚œæi³o…‰³çÙ]ֳ׳䑳×o]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×ÜœÂ×o]ÖÛŠjçm^l朅ÊÄ
]ֳ۳ϳ^Ú³^le³ß³“γçÙ]ֳ׳³äi³Ã^Öo™ÂøŠFoœáûm$fûÃø%øÔø…øe%ÔøÚøÏø^Ú÷^
X )61( óó Ú$vûÛöçû9]÷—ÚÏ^Ú^mvÛ‚ÕÊnä]¢æÖçáæ]¤ì†æá
)ZoZ|[’k,\B{0îIE
GGZ°Îw~VÆÒy~äI¾»Z0+ZiÌZCc*ìXTÅ@*G~Ü™Š{gzZc*]zZZw
ÆY,}Ð!{3¨4èEE
GEÅ"6,zZðZzg°xZôoŶKyŠ„̃CìXÒ]Ð’k,™Š{ÃX~50
7Z]zá÷t~å»ÒyìZy~ZkgDyÅj,(ËÀ˜Á„ňìTÆË~úZxäZ#
e;Zzg‰e;Zk**iuZzg"ñçq6,Ò]ЖT6,',¦/h+{fYzpZmÆÌZOŠ7gnpX
ZZì³’³^ñ³“]Ö³Û³’_ËoF‘×o]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×Üenà Zk)ZoQ|[’k,ÆgŠ~Zq-Â[
X )71( @*;Åì�™Št0·0Z',Z Åïì XX ]ÖÇ×çæ]ÖrË^ð
Zk~Šg`fsï]ŶKyŠ„ÅìXÆ!*g}~!{3¨4èEE
GEZ�ÛZozy»Dgƒ‰�X
á÷t~åÆ!*g}~� 1X
Z"mt~åÆ!*g}~‘:x 2X
ZqÐiZ]t~åÆK~Ã:Q|[ 3X
Æ"ìGGLgÎw-ZvmzÅÆ00c*:Z°g 4X
®zñçqgzZc*]6,Z®gZzg9gzZc*]ÐÑdX 5X
èÃg{ï]z{�X~!{3¨4èEE
GEäá÷zZqÐiZ]t~åÆÒy~»l3ðìZk»iŒÛWyÔ<LZzgx™GÆûzZŠgZuÆZnq~ì�Šg„ìX
Zk¿ÒyƈZyx£?»f™HY@*ì�á÷z7Z]t~å6,Ç].h+~�{Ô&bZ−+úŠZ‚ÅLL7Z] )81( óó ZŸ†�XZy~£~Z−%ZlÅÂ[LL7Z]Z°Îw~V
Ô†Z+m,ZÅ3›éIwÅ" )02( óó Ô!{‹§ö
EW%ZŠÅÂ[LLZÄ>.ç
EEZÅ3¨4è GGGE°7Z]Z#ZÑ}~V )91( óó Z°Îw~V
Ô™Ô0Z£gŸÅ )22( óó Zzg†Z>úŠÅ"LLŠÑbZÉ43ð EE>z7Z]Z°Îw~V )12( óó LL7·gÎwZv~V
z){�áï�X )42( óó ·;gzyçztÅ"LLS:]!{‹§öE
W~V )32( óó LLZÑÚiZÅ›Ð+ö°ZwZÉ43ð EEt~V
x£?Æ’k,~gD**]~ÐZq-»mQ#ÖƤ/z„ÃtÐÌìXZkÆ�!{3¨4è
EEGEäZL7gzîVÆZ°gÅ@*G~Ã’k,Å�XÁûZ¾mZkjZáлl»Dg̃D�ZzgfZCgZñ»"ÑvZÖgÌ™D�XZq-Šzu}öKUW̯D�ZzgŠ´½Ã:1
ÌeZs�XZ,gDyÅZ&bÅ¢zg]6,ÌÂz%Ãi™ZðYCìX
æÜZ0+Zi’k,:Ã~á÷t~å6,ŒWc*]ÅzŸs#~÷§ÔÑz—ug$Zzg§>Z#å6,
£?~ñ�ŠZ1Z[�áï�X°Z"tz"uŠgz7»qïìYè·§ÔÑz—ug$51
Zzgµ3ïGEL§]’k,™**fYzpZm»»xìXZyÆZ0+Zi’k,~0*ðYäzZàÏÐZ.Š{"uƃ@*
ìXâèŒÛd$Ƭ¦Z£Œòö_ŠŠ~ÅZq-’k,�g%:ŒVÜÅYCìT~ZrVä£x
úŠÅzŸs#-VÅì:LLx еZâxZ£òZzgF,è~ò~Z1CÙk,{gèZvÅÐgzZe$ì�ô/
gèZveäWÀ]~VÐ7Y�£xúŠÐH%ZŠìXW\~Vä
�Ûâc*�tz{£xì�}.ZŧsÐ'+£éG
g}Ñ~VÃË®)ÅŠ¬™ä
X )52( Æa5ìóó
¬+z�ág±»Z0+Zi%¥ÆÒpЗƒ@*ìXZyÅY+$ÐI¾Wö’k,Á„©¬x6,
WCìXá÷zZqÐiZ]»*y{md*yìXZkÅ™Æaì+z�ág±ÐZ.Š{
ÆìX
‡ZÑjf~ÑbZnè~~†Z°ÝòIgu7g~äug$:
ZZÚ%×oæÚ%Ø]¢Þfn^ðÒ†qØeßo9]…]ʪÒÛ×ã^ýXX
ÅzŸs#t�Ûâðì: ZZÖfßèXX ~ÂZZÎn³Ø]ÖÛQfäeäæ]u‚æ]ÖÛQfäqÛ^ÂèÊÓnÌ‘x]ÖjQfnä[æqç]eäœÞä
q³Ã³Ø]¢Þfn³^ðÒ†qØæ]u‚¢ÞäŸmjÜÚ^œ…]9]ÖjQfnäZŸe^Âjf^…]ÖÓØ(
X )62( æÒ„ÖÔ]Ö‚]…ŸijÜZŸe^qjÛ^Å]Öfßn^á!XX
à:»Z0+ZiÒyZÒŠZzg‚³F,¹ÆŠzg~à:Zzg].h+e$Ð%ú[!{3¨4è
EEGEä,t~å»Y,{fe
ƒñ=Æ£gZ]»–gZ1ìX].h+ÑŠ=è<ØÆ7ZCUÐZïg™CìXz{ïÆ].h+ Z0+Zi”gs™ZCìZzgZLZ0+ZiÐZUîVЧ]»Y,{gìX].h+ŠzgÅàt
Å£?ZkÅVw�X~gÎw0*u~VÊ*z~Òpлx[=Æ Karen Armstrong
X )72( îg6,ÒyHì
§]ÆizZܹUîVÆá÷Ãà:äp[uZ;ì1‰|Z]äWÌÅìX›y§]ógzVäZyÅWZzgZyŧsÐKYäzZáZ‹ZŸ]»�Z[Šc*ìt�Z[
52
].h+‚³Z0+Ziïŧi6,ÌŠc*ŠHì�ZqÐi~Z0+Zig‚rìXZkK~Zq-Â[‚w·ç0ÅìT~Z,Vä].h+à:ÆZ‚26,-cÅìX "Jabal Muhammad Buaben"
Z,Vä°xƒÔ°x_.!*LMZzgÑe$Ãè<ØSîZsxZzggÎwZv-ZvmzÅÆ_¬ÅãCŠÃZëŒÛZgŠïƒñ–ì:
"In the study of Islam and certainly of the Prophet
(PBUH) this observation should be taken seriously,
otherwise the real Muhammad might be missed )82( .
ZkQ|[ÒyÐ_“g‚rƒZQ|[eZˆZØŠgŒãÆ8ZÝe~Æó£á»ìXT~Z,Väà:ŧsÐ\B{0î
IEGGZ°Îw~V6,K‰.V»Y,{7HìXz{˜�:
LLŒÛWyäWÀ]-ZvmzÅÅfZ]ÃñëVÆaZÎÒõŒÛZgŠc*
YèZyÅfZ]¤/ZòïZÜtŒÛWã¶Xpaèf[äDÙZg‚wÐ
ic*Š{˜[ÒãŶZkat[Zk§bZyÆgvzg8~'ŠHå�Z#ZsxÅ|ZyÆ‚tWðÂZÐÌPäÑXZ,Vä
˜VZk!*]ÃtH�ïf!ÔZsxŦk,~ßg8-Zzg¼}
Ýl�UZEw™D�z�tÌìÐ!*i:Wñ�tVà™ŠZg§]Zzg
èi~ÅæŠÐF,KMŠc*ŠHìXZkV~ZqŠg$»;BìXÆfg)
™ŠZgÆZëUúc*VK‰�Xf!e°iäS¤Æ‚BZqŠg$»W~_·HXZ,VäZk~@*g+B3ï GE
GGňlÅZzgQt¬ÎŠc*�9ZqŠg$**‡.ÞZ±g�X�áh+Zka�f!¦gÅ@*G7™‰X
gÎwZv~VÆ!*g}~z{Z#ÃðzZ§7,_�ÂyÆ.Þ6,Ãð:X )92( ÃðZ‹ZnaZ™fe�óó
ZkK~Zq-Zzg¤/ZVŠg»x;ZŒÛ7»ì2Väf!WógzVÆŠúîV»æÜ�Z[
Å« " Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and his Western Cristics" ’k,HìXZKÂ[
¢~z{›~zZ^Æ@*g+
÷GE
L§]6,.V»�Z[ZkZ0+ZiЊï�:53
" Watt has made it out as if it was all a question of some
economic or political considerations which weighed
with both sides. This is a gross distortion of history by
givinig simple matters of facts of history a wrong
and standing twist just to 'float' his fantastic
hypotheses and foist 'motives' on the head of the
Prophet where there was no soon for such worldly
aggrandiscment" )03( .
‚³§iï»ZEw‚³§iï6,’k,™Š{;ZŒÛ7Åt"ì�Zk!*]6,ŠÑª™Cì�›yf‚�
].h+Z0+ZizExÅcÄqÝ™@*ìz{›ë+B{}éGE]ttå6,iãZk§i6,™@*ì�Zg»ðp=V»Zq©
™}XZk»Šgu8©3©ïG
GGGL+B{}éGE‹ttå6,'×h+ZƒY@*ìXZk»6,ZOŠƒ™ÄŒÛ¤k6,gzZVƒ@*ìX
Z(»x§]ógzV~»Š£xg‚rìXZkÅZq-VwŠZgZ?xÅ�áù™Š{"ìTÆ!í³¢Z°ÝIgu7g~�ZzgZk»Zôm,~F,À+ "When the Moon Split"
uZ`Ôâ¡gleÍZzg$+gZWW!*Š~äHìXtÂ[YO&VÔæïÔ£zk,ZzgjZ!Y]Ð6,
X( 13 )ì
Š*z].h+Z‚Å3ïGEL’k,»Zz6,%:7HŠHìXŒV!*Ñ"gŠ*z].h+Z‚2Æœuz»Š
ZzgúŠZÅhÍ-öIEÅ ZZ9Ÿñ³³³Ø]Ö³³³ßf³³³ç³³éXX UîV»E+™{HY@*ìX÷}7ÃZÉ
4-A§ö EGXG)x854|(Å@*;ìZk¿Y,}Ð¥xƒ@*ì�Š*z].h+§]óg9 ZZJí’nè]Ö†‰çÙ‘×o]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×ÜXX
ZW~VÆá÷ÆÒy~ZŠ[zZ�ZxÔŠHcZ›ÒyÔZ"gÔ}ŠguZzgZôoлxfe
�XËîgòçV~7Zj½:„mg]pZ;:Z0+ZiZ(g™D�XŠ*z].h+Ã~ZÐZŠ~U
»m].h+§]ógzVÆZ(g~Zˆ‚]ÐìXŠÚ~Wc*ì�].h+§]ógzV~PgD**]
�Z¤/p67�Zg»ðîg6,”h+ƒ‰�X~WZzgîs¯òçVÃ�áïHYYìX
6,ñ�Š’k,~uât‡.ÞŠgìXT~6,g å ð®ZÅ+A.ð Eq].h+§]óg~~á÷·t
54
ï]6,Âz%Ãi™ZðˆìX',R~§]óg~»�ŠzgZÞ,œ~ÐÑzqƒZZk~Ñ�Z[dzX )23( ó»z/‚tWð���,œ~J-"Vw²z`J-¬ˆ�
].h+Z»ŠZ‚2zgD**]~ÐZkQ|[»ÌZ^wÃð7ì&Z',Z lO7g~
ZzgŠvZssäZ(gHìXT~ŒÛWȈQZqŠg$ÄÃÜHŠHìZzgQZyÆZëï]ÅJ³Û³^ñ³Ø]Ö³Û³’_ËoF ÌZ(gHŠHìXz™0îEGZ²85ÐöGÅÂ[LL zŸs#ÅìXtQ|[].h+Šzg~
X )33( ZkÅ].h+ì XX ‘×o]Ö×äÂ×näæ‰×Ü
²Zq-Â[LL&Î7Z]óóÆÄZyÐZ£Gä%A$ÅìXZk~ŒÛWyZzgug$Ð
X )43( Z+Ñw™DƒñZq-z„‚’k,~Ñðˆì
ŒÛZyˆ~û§]Æe~�@Ze$QìZkÆ_.ZkK~¡=Ãgɯ**ŠZøq~7ìXZka�ñg2VäZKi0+Ï~=ÃÄgZ{¯c*ZyÆ!*g}~ZkK~Zv¬\ä�Ûâc*ì:
]øÝûmø³Ïö³çûÖöçûáøJø^Âô†ºÞ$jø†øe$“öeôä…ømûgø o Êø³„øÒôù³†ûÊø³Ûø³«]øÞûkøeôßôÃûÛøkô…øeôùÔøeôÓø^aôàõæ$ŸøÚørûßöçûẠ™
]øÝûiø³³ûÚö³†öaö³Üû]øuû¡øÚöö³ÜûeôF„øu]øÝûaöÜûÎøçûݺ o Îö³Øûiø³†øe$³’ö³çû]Êø³³ôôÞôù³oûÚø³Ãø³Óö³ÜûÚôù³àø]ÖûÛöjø†øeôù’ônûàø o ]Öû³Ûø³ßöçûáôX )53( — ›ø^Æöçûáø
:Ã�ÛâDgcYèW\ZL6,zgŠÇgÆaÐ:»‚�Zzg: )
7yXHt)ñg(ë��t�á²�ZzgëZyÆ0¤/Š¶iâ:Ƴ�X)Z}gÎw(W\�ÛâŠØ�?ZOg™zZzg~Ì'+£é
Gg}‚BZOg™@*
ƒVXHZyÅ“¨Ó4èG
GZyø)·!*'(2C�c*tÑk,ßv�(X
×zïÔZ.Š{zZõ[ZzgÜz‹tÆaÌZ¤/p=лx¢8**¦/k,ƒ@*ì1ŒVZ�ág{
Zk=ÆZEw»ì�zkÅgÉðÐWiZŠƒXz¤/:ÅgzW’TÅ].h+§]óg~~¢zg]ì
ZkÃZ¤/ZsxÆãCŠ~ZßßVÆ@*,:g3ŠHÂZkyZy~{§pZ{»x!7ƒ$ËXŠzgq¢»[DzŠZøÆjZáЗF,ƒ[ìz{].h+ŠzgÆ»çVÆÒpÐZK,Åyâ™**eLìXZk
K~ZàzZáÎZÑ]»iÌÔ™@*ìXZka¢zg~ì�¥Z0+ZiZzgŠ!*CQ|[~§]
t~åÃ7HYñYèZkßg]~fZ]zÌ‹t~åZzg¾Ñ]zZõ!*]|‹ZŠkÃZyÆ9Úøz55
Zsò:©~7HYYìXZÏÆfg=gÎwZ™x~VÅfZ]zZÑÌ]»dŠÃqZzgZsxzŠ+»X )63( èIDÌeì
1Š´ñç¬]ÆçA~=ÆYgq:6ÃWiZŠ~ŠbŠ+Æo°Zñg~ÐìX
ÆÒy~gZÉðÅŠ¬ìX å Zv¬\Ч]·t
56
jjjjZZZZÙÙÙÙzzzzjjjjZZZZ!!!!YYYY]]]]1XÎg>ZâÔ35:1D3X
2XÎg>ZÈW,Ô801:1X
3XÎg>µZuZLÔ71:97X
4XÎg>ZÑxZ[Ô33:04X
! (PUVP 5XÎg>ZÑíZb
6Xgg~Ô·0Z�³ÔZÎìZÅ|B-
÷ GÔÂ[ZÉ4-+ê
GGÔñΔîGZ^ZÅk0îGGÔŠZgZÉ4lçEIzZpi#Ô0002YÔm:92X
7X›ÔZâxÔs`0£~ÔZÅ|B-
÷ GÔÂ[ZR].Ôm:957Ôg¶Z�g$:325ÔñΔîGX
8XZÅ|B-
÷ GÅ.hÐêÔÂ[ZÆJZyÔ!*[Z**ZzwZÜk$i©ü GIE°ZÄB0î EEGÔm:517Ôg¶Z�g$:2133ÔñΔîGX
9X§>Z#åÔ38Ô**ÑZyŒÛWyÔуgÔ5931|Ô3B46X
01X·ZŠgö»0+z~Ô§>Z¼)å(Ô„¢6ÔуgÔ2991YÔm:006X
11X·gægŸÔZßkZÅ+A)å~ÔŠZgZÅišï IEÔZØCÙ{Ô0002YÔm:93X
ÂK1XeZˆZÄAöÔZŠZg>ZšgsÔ™ZcÔ0002YX
31X©†ZvZÅš©3§ö
EGE
ÔðÌ]Z°Îw-ZvmzÅZÄCÒ©0îELG
GGzZÄCÒ©0îENG
GGÔŠZgZÅ.¸ç!îGGZÉÓ45é EE"0î EGGÔ5991YX
41XaZ£œjÔeZËÔ“]g‚ªÔ„iZztÔуgÔ9991YÔm:871X
51XqƒiZ@ZÔá÷Z#-ZvmzÅÔgZs#DiÔуgÔ3002YX
61X\B{0îIE
GGZ°ÎwZv-ZvmzÅÔ1B7Ô8)l)(ÔŠZgZÄB5ÿ EGÔÛz]Ô3991YX
71X™Št0·0Z',Z Ôá÷Z¼-ZvmzÅÎZÅ›ÒðEzZÄB¨é EEYÔm:123Ô223Ô$»40î GEGZ°æÔgc*nÔ0002YX
81X£~Z−%ŠZlÔ7Z]Z°ÎwåÔ„4,Zg½Z]iÔZÅ+)ÓÂîGZÅišðŠ!îGGÔ5002YX
91X&bZ−+úŠZ‚Ô7Z]Z°Îw-ZvmzÅÔZÅ)½3ïG
EZÅ3¨éIG°Ô‡CÙ{Ô4002YX
02X½%ZŠÔŠÆgÔ7Z]Z°Îw-ZvmzÅÔŠZgZ—ÉÔ.çGZ_Ô‡CÙ{Ô2002YX
12X†Z+m,ZÅ3›éIwÔ7·gÎwZv-ZvmzÅÔŠZgZº[ZÑsòÔ…3œî EGZ{Å0îIGÔ6891YX
22X†Z>úŠÔŠÆgÔŠÑbZÉ43ð EE>z7Z]Z°Îw-ZvmzÅÔŠZgZšgsÔ‡CÙ{Ô8991YX
32X™Ô0Z£gŸÔZÑÚiZÅ›Ð+ö°ZwZÉ43ð EE!îGGÔ$»40î GEGZÅ›41¹é EGyÔgc*nÔ1002YX
57
42X·;gzyçztÔS:]½-ZvmzÅÔŠZgZÑ�á®)Ô™ZcÔ7002YX
52X¦Z£ŒÔZŒZZ§)‚Îg>µZuZLÔ61:97(ÔZÅ)»40î GEGZ:ÔуgÔ3791YÔ4B95X
62X†Z°ÝIgÁg~Ô‡ZÑjf~Ô!*[âYYéZ#ÔŠZgZ^ZÅ›Ð.0îGÔayÔkXyÔ8B821Ôg¶Z�g$:2203X
72 . Karen Armstrong, Muhammad: A Biography of the Prophet,Phoenixpress 19
82 . Jabal Muhammad Buaben, Image of the Prophet Muhammad in the West, P.328,
Islamic Foundation, Leicester, United Kingdom, 1996
92X†ZØŠgŒãÔeZËÔ9Zsx-ZvmzÅZzgà:f[»Z0+Zi„Ôm362ÔÂ[uZñÔуgÔ5002YX
03 . Zafar Ali Qureshi, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and his western Critics, P 489, Idara
Maarif Islami, Lahore, 1992.
13 . Saif ur Rehman Mubarakpuri, When The Moon Split, (Edited and Translated by:
Tabassum Siraj, Michael Richardson, Badr Azimabadi), Darussalam, Riyadh, 1415A.H.
†Z(g�á™Ô',R~§]óg~ÔŠg,·âx)Šú>ÔŠú>ZOòZÚDZsò-Eg;ÔZsxW!*ŠÔ¢61Ô 23X
Ñg{7D01ÔX
zSZ85ÐöGZ−ÆgÔÑbZ¼~VÔŠZgZËXŠwÔ6002YX 33X
Z£GÔ&Î7Z]ÔŠZgZÑ�á®)Ô™ZcÔ1891YX 43X
Îg>Z´gÔ25:92D23X 53X
†Z°îs;)%A$(Ô£Ñ]§]t~åÔ)£!>Zy§]óg~»9!-:
÷EXEÔeZË·$h4è GGE1œj0+z~(Ô : %A$ 63X
1B17§]çZsð-Eg;Ô·zjgÔ5002YX
58