© 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers)...

58
© 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross

Transcript of © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers)...

Page 1: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

©2018AlexandriaMarieRoss

Page 2: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

2

DoesSocialMediaPresenceIncrease

ConsumerTrustinCPGCompanies?

Author:AlexandriaMarieRoss

Advisor:JoeGoodman

FisherCollegeofBusiness

TheOhioStateUniversity

Page 3: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

3

ABSTRACT

In2014,92%ofmarketersclaimedthatsocialmediamarketingwasimportantfor

theirbusiness,and80%indicatedthattheireffortsincreasedtraffictotheirwebsites

(DeMers,2014).Moreover,socialnetworksandappsarethehighestareaofinvestmentfor

firmsinthedigitalmarketingsector(Tiago&Verissimo,2014).Theutilizationofsocial

mediabycompaniesisnotonlyimportanttoincreasebrandvisibility,italsocanplaya

hugeroleinhowcustomersperceivethecompany,specifically,consumertrust.Thegoalof

thisresearchistofurtherunderstandtherelationshipbetweenacompany’ssocialmedia

presenceanditsrelationshiptoconsumertrust.Forthispurpose,datawascollectedfor30

consumerpackagedgoodsfirmsoverfourmonthsandincludeddailysocialmedia

information(suchasnumberoflikesandfollowers)fromthefirms’Twitter,Facebook,

Instagram,andYouTubepages.Thisdatawasthenusedtodevelopasocialmediaindexto

baseonlinepresence.Additionally,548AmazonMechanicalTurkparticipantswere

surveyedtomeasureconsumertrustandfamiliarityforthese30companies.Resultsofthis

researchshowthatsocialmediapresence,whenusedinamodelalongwithfamiliarity,is

notareliablepredictorofconsumertrust.However,whensocialmediapresencealoneis

used,itisareliablepredictoroftrustinmediumsizedcompanies,butnotinlargeorsmall

companies.Thus,werecommendproceedingwithcautionandhavingthecompanyitself

validatewhethersocialmediaisaffectingitsownconsumertrustsincesomecompanies

aremoreaffectedbysocialmediathanothers.

Page 4: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

4

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Thisprojectwasnotasoleventure,andwouldnothavebeenpossiblewithoutthe

supportofmanyotherpeople.Thankyoutomyadviser,JosephGoodman,whogaveme

countlessgreatideasandleadmethroughnewconcepts.AlsothankstomyHonors

ContractDirector,RogerBailey,whoofferedcontinuedguidance,advice,andsupport

throughoutthepasttwoyears.ThankstoTheOhioStateUniversityforallowingmetobein

aprogramthatgavemetheopportunitytoexpandmyresearchhorizonsandprovidedme

themeanstocompletethisproject.

Page 5: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

5

TableofContents

I. Introduction

II. LiteratureReview

III. Hypothesis

IV. Methodology

V. Analysis

VI. Results

VII. Conclusion

VIII. Appendix

IX. References

Page 6: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

6

I.Introduction:

Withsocialmediabeingsoprevalentintoday’ssocietyanditspopularitycontinuing

togrow,itisanareathatholdsmanyopportunities.Itisaportalinwhichfirmsare

continuouslytryingtodevelopstrategiestoreachtheirtargetaudience.Socialmedia

marketingprovidesasimplewaytoincreasebrandrecognition,improvebrandloyalty,and

covertpotentialcustomers.In2014,92%ofmarketersclaimedthatsocialmediamarketing

wasimportantfortheirbusiness,and80%indicatedthattheireffortsincreasedtrafficto

theirwebsites(DeMers,2014).Moreover,socialnetworksandappsarethehighestareaof

investmentforcompaniestodayinthedigitalmarketingsector(Tiago&Verissimo,2014).

Theutilizationofsocialmediaforcompaniesisnotonlyimportantinregardsto

profitability,italsocanplayahugeroleinhowcustomersperceivethecompany.Infact,

consumershavebeguntoviewsocialmediaasmoretrustworthythanthetelevision,radio,

orothertraditionalsources(Kauletal.,2015).Additionally,previousresearchsuggests

thatforevery100peoplewhosaytheyarelikelytopostapositivecommentonabrand’s

Facebookpage,69ofthemsaytheyarelikelytopreferthatbrandoveritscompetitors

(Smith,2013).Hence,provingthattrustandbuildingrelationshipsonlinecanhavea

positiveimpactonthecompany,bothintheshortandlongrun.

Thegoalofthisprojectistofurtherresearchdoneinbothareasbyexaminingthe

relationshipbetweenthesocialmediapresenceofcompaniesanditseffectsonconsumer

trust.Thispaperwilldiscusspastresearchregardingthistopic,explainmorethoroughly

thehypothesisandmethodologyoftheproject,andthenprovideananalysisandthe

resultsoftheresearch.

Page 7: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

7

II.LiteratureReview:

Sincethisresearchtopiccoversboththeareasofconsumertrustandsocialmedia

presence,onemustlookatpapersthatregardbothtopicsindividually,aswellasthosethat

includebothmeasures.

Therearemanyaspectsofconsumertrust,sotherearequiteafewwaystomeasure

it.Forexample,Mayerandhiscolleaguesinventedamodelthatfocusedonability,

benevolence,andintegrityofacompanyandmeasuredhowthatimpactsthetrustof

consumers(Mayer,Davis,&Shoorman,1995).Abilitycanbedescribedasthecapabilityof

thecompanytocompleteatask.Thisisanimportantaspectoftrustbecauseitrelatesto

thecompany’sknowledgeandcompetence.Benevolencerelatestothecompany’slevelof

courtesy,willingnesstohelp,andkindness.Thisisimportantintrustbecauseifacompany

meetsthisrequirement,itisusuallyperceivedascaringaboutothers’needs.Integrity

relatestoasetofmoralnormsandcharacteristicsofacompany,whichareusuallyviewed

positively.Ifconsumersperceivethecompanytobemorallysound,theyaremorelikelyto

trustthecompany(Calefato,Lanubile,&Novielli,2015).Later,McKnightandhiscolleagues

extendedthismodelbydoingmoreexperimentsandtheywereabletoaddafourth

dimension:predictability(McKnight,Cummings,&Chervany,1998).Predictabilityisthe

degreetowhichacompanymeetstheexpectationsofacustomer,intermsofboth

reliabilityandconsistency.Themorereliableacompanyisperceivedtobe,themore

consumerswilltrustit.Overall,thesefourdynamicsseemtobefairlyinclusiveoftrustand

willbeusedasabaselineforthesurveytomeasuretrustofthecompaniesforthisproject.

Thequestionsaskedinthesurveyconductedforthisprojectwerealsoderivedfromthese

papers.

Page 8: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

8

Socialmediapresenceisusuallymeasuredbycompaniesintermsofbothits

“success”anditsimpact.Sinceitishardtopreciselyquantifythereturnoninvestmentofa

tweetorpost,companiesoftenlooktoalternativemeasures.Forexample,somecompanies

usemodelsthatlookatdailysocialmediaactivitysuchasFacebookPosts,Tweets,

Retweets,andFacebookFriendsaspredictivevariablestotrytomeasuretheirsuccess

(Kim&Wilcox,2013).Bylookingatcustomerresponsesandinteractions,theytryto

decipherthesocialpresenceofacompany.Whileconsumerresponsesareanimportant

partofdeterminingacompany’ssocialmediapresence,whatacompanydoesinitselfis

alsoanimportantfactortoconsider.Thisprojectwillhaveitsownscalingofsocialmedia

presence.Itwillcombineboththeactionsofthecompanyinitselfandtheactionsofthe

consumers,whileencompassingmorethanonesite.Thecompleteexplanationofthe

scalingwillbediscussedfurtheroninthemethodologysection.

Exploringboththetopicsofsocialmediaandconsumertrusttogether,therehave

beensomeinterestingfindingsinresearchthusfar.Onesuchprojectfocusedonbrand

communitiesestablishedthroughsocialmediasitesandhowtheycanturntrustinto

loyalty.Overall,theconclusionofthisresearchwasthatsocialmediabasedbrand

communitieshavepositiveaffectsonthecustomer/productrelationship,thecustomer/

brandrelationship,thecustomer/companyrelationship,andthecustomer/other

customersrelationship.Thus,thesecommunitiesenhancebrandtrustandbrandloyalty

(Laroche,Habibi,&Richard,2013).Anotherprojectfocusedonhowsocialmediafacilitates

thesocialinteractionofconsumers.Theauthorsusetrusttotrytodetermineintentionto

buy,specificallywithe-commerce.Italsoemphasizedcustomerreviewsonsocialmedia

andhowwordofmouthpublicityaffectsacompany.Overall,theyfoundthatbetterreviews

Page 9: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

9

leadtobetterperceptionofthecompanyforthosereadingthereviewsandinturnpeople

aremorelikelytobuyproductsfromthem(Hajli,2014).Thisshowssocialmediais

importantbecauseitcanleadtoincreasedsalesasaresultoftrustingtheopinionsof

othersonline.Lookingatasinglesocialmediasite,thearticle“ThumbsUp,SalesUp?The

ContingentEffectofFacebookLikesonSalesPerformanceinSocialCommerce”looksat

howFacebooklikescanrelatetopurchasesforacompany.Specifically,theywerelooking

atifFacebooklikescanincreasesocialcommercesales.Itwasmainlyreferral-focused

becauseitlookedtoseewholikedtheproductandthecommentsrelatingtoit.Notonlyis

thistransparentbecauseyoucanseewhodidthis,butyoucanalsoseeifyourfriendsliked

it.Ifsomeoneyoulikeenjoyedtheproduct,thereisagoodchanceyouwilltoo.Italso

discussedhowithasbeenproventhatFacebooklikesareoneofthemosttrustedand

reliablesocialreferencesystemsthatrepresentstheopinionsofcustomers(Lee,Lee,&Oh,

2015).Regardingindustryspecificcompanies,onearticlefocusedonsocialmedia“buzz”

withrelationtoCPGbrands.Theirresearchsoughttotrytopredictbuyingintentions

throughconsumer-generatedmedia.Todothis,theymeasuredandcomparedthingslike

blogbuzz,thecompany’smarketingspending,pre-marketpurchaseintentions,andin-

marketsales.Asaresult,theydiscoveredthatasmallnumberofnewCPGbrandsgenerate

themajorityofbuzzandthatnewproductbuzzusuallyoccursincompanieswithastrong

traditionalmediapresence(Niederhoffer,Mooth,Wiesenfeld,&Gordon,2007).

Consequently,havingastrongsocialmediapresencecreatesthemostawarenessand

interestwithinaconsumer.

Asawhole,therehasbeenagooddealofresearchdoneonthetopicofconsumer

trust,andonthetopicofsocialmediamarketing.However,theideaofcombiningthetwo

Page 10: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

10

areasisfairlynew.Whenconductingthisliteraturereview,therewereafewgeneraltrends

throughoutallofthepapers.First,ifsocialmediapresencewasmeasured,itwasmainly

measuredononesite.Thisresearchwilllookatascalingofsocialmediapresenceacross

fourdifferentsites.Second,themajorityofthepapersregardingsocialmediaandtrust

wereinrelationtoe-commerceandtheeffectoftrustandlikelihoodtopurchase.Inthis

project,trustwillbemeasuredingeneral—notinregardstoitsspecificrelationto

purchasing.Lastly,therewasverylittleresearchconcerningsocialmediapresenceandits

relationtoconsumertrustlookingatconsumerpackagedgoodscompaniesspecifically,

whichissomethingthisresearchwillfocuson.CPGcompanieswerespecificallychosen

becauseitisanindustryinwhichconsumertrustisconsideredvital.

III.Hypothesis:

Thisresearchprojectisgoingtolookintotheeffectsofsocialmediapresenceon

consumertrustinCPGcompanies.Thus,thetwomainvariablesthatwillbeusedaresocial

mediapresenceandconsumertrust.Athirdvariableoffamiliaritywillalsobeconsidered,

butitwillnotbethemainfocusoftheproject.Overall,thehypothesisisthatcompanies

withahighersocialmediapresencewillalsorankhigherinregardstoconsumertrust.

IV.Methodology:

Tomeasureconsumertrust,asurveywasconductedandadministeredtopeople

ages18andolderonAmazon’sMechanicalTurk.Thesurvey,whichcanbeseeninFigure1

oftheappendix,wasdistributedattheendofOctober2017.Eachparticipantwas

randomlyassigned10companiesandwasalsoaskedtoranktheirfamiliaritywiththe

companyandusageofsocialmediaasawhole.Thespecificcompanyquestionsaskedwere

gatheredfromthoseconsideredtobebestpracticewhenconductingtheliteraturereview

Page 11: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

11

andfocusedonfourdynamicsoftrust:integrity,benevolence,ability,andpredictability.

Respectively,thequestionsaskedforeachcompanywere:

1. Promisesmadeby______arelikelytobereliable

2. Iexpectthat______putscustomers’interestsbeforetheirown

3. _______understandsthemarketitworksin

4. Iamquitecertainwhattoexpectfrom________

Tomeasuresocialmediapresence,anoriginalscalingwasproducedusingaweb

crawlerthatcollecteddatadaily.Ittrackedthepresenceofthe30companiesoverfour

monthsonfoursocialmediasites:Twitter,Facebook,Instagram,andYouTube.Overthe

period,numberofposts,numberoffollowers,andnumberoflikesdatawascollected.The

30companieschosenweresplitinto3sectionsaccordingtotheirmarketcap:large

companies(highmarketcap),mediumcompanies(mediummarketcap),andsmall

companies(lowmarketcap)forfaircomparisonofsocialmediapresence.Specificlarge

andmediumcompanieschosenwererandomlypickedbasedoffalistofthetop100CPG

companiesin2016(consumergoods.com),whichwererankedbasedontotalrevenuesand

marketcapitalizationfortheyear,andthesmallcompanieswerecompiledbasedon

startups.Hereisalistofthecompaniesthatwereused:

LARGECOMPANIES• Procter&Gamble• Unilever• PepsiCo• Nestle• CocaCola• Nike• 3M• MondelezInternational• GeneralMills• L’Oreal

Page 12: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

12

MEDIUMCOMPANIES• McCormickSpice• TheCloroxcompany• Hanesbrands• Smuckers• TheHersheyCompany• Mattel• RalphLauren• Avon• Electricarts• Snapple

SMALLCOMPANIES• TriaBeauty• Chubbies• HelloProducts• Thehonestcompany• Harrys• MethodHomeProducts• Walkerandcompany• UnrealCandy• Hamptoncreek• NavitasOrganics

V.Analysis:

Aftercompletingboththesurveyandthesocialmediapresencescaling,abasic

analysiswasconducted.Thislookedatthecompanieswiththehighestsocialmediaindex

andleveloftrustasdeterminedbythesurvey.Thesocialmediaindexformulacombined

thedatafromthe4socialmediasites.Thecalculationusedwas:SMI=(TwitterFollowers*

TwitterPosts)+(FacebookFollowers+FacebookLikes)+(InstagramFollowers*Instagram

Posts)+(YoutubeFollowers*YoutubePosts).Facebookdidnotprovidethenumberofposts

foreachpage,sothatiswhyitsmeasureisslightlydifferentfromtherest.Additionally,an

alternateSMIscalingexcludingfollowerswastestedtobefairertothesmallercompanies.

However,theregressionresultsturnedoutthesame,sowestuckwiththeoriginalscaling

Page 13: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

13

andthesplittingupofcompaniesbysize(sincelargercompaniesalsotendedtohavethe

mostfollowers).

Foramoreadvancedanalysis,tworegressionmodelswererun.Thefirstwasa

multipleregressionmodelthatusedtrustasanaggregateofresponsesfromthesurvey

usingthe4dimensions,familiarityusinganswersgiveninsurvey,andasocialmediaindex

(SMI)thatwascreatedusingthewebcrawlerdata.Thesecondmodelsolelylookedat

socialmediapresenceandconsumertrust.SMIwasscaleddowninbothscenariosby

dividingtheSMIofeachcompany/averageSMIofallcompanies.Thisdidnotchangethep-

values,butitallowedthecoefficienttobemuchlargerforeasiercomparison.

Asmentionedinthehypothesis,itisexpectedthatsocialmediapresenceand

consumertrustwillbehighlypositivelycorrelated.Ifthisturnsouttobethecaseafterthe

analysis,thenitispossibletosaythehypothesiswascorrect.Iftheoppositeistrue,the

originalhypothesiswillhavetoberejected.

Overall,thisresearchwillgiveinsightintoifacompanybeingmoreinvolvedonline

relatestohigherperceptionsoftrustfromconsumers.Theresultscouldhelpcompanies

decideifputtingalltheirmarketingeffortintosocialmediasitesisworthitwhenitcomes

toearningtrustfromitsconsumers.

VI.Results

BASICANALYSIS/RANKINGS

First,Iwillbeginwiththeresultsfromthesurvey.Somebasicdemographic

informationcanbefoundintheappendix(Figure2).Alsointheappendixistherankingof

trustforallparticipants,1beingthehighest,andinparenthesisisthecompany’ssocial

mediapresencerankingfromthewebcrawlerdata(Figure3).Asonecanseefromsolely

Page 14: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

14

lookingatthisranking,socialmediapresenceandtrustarenotexactlyliningup.Itisalso

interestingtonotethatforeachdimensionoftrust,therankingisnotexactlythesame.The

varianceisnotextreme,butitisdistinctiveenoughtocommenton.Forexample,ascanbe

seeninFigure4,Smucker’srankedfirstintermsofintegrityandbenevolence.However,

Nikecameinfirstintermsofability(Smucker’swasnotevenlistedinthetopten),and

Procter&Gamblerankedfirstintermsofpredictability.Thisprovidesaninterestinglook

intohowtheresultscouldhavebeenvastlydifferentifonlyonedimensionoftrustwas

measured.

Next,istherankingofsocialmediapresencefromthewebcrawleroverall(Figure

5).Additionally,Ilookedatsitespecificsocialmediapresenceforeachcompanyaswell,

butdidnotincludeitinthispaperforlengthpurposes.Itisinterestingtonotethoughthat

certainsitesaremorepopularwithdifferentsizedcompanies.Facebookseemstobemore

utilizedbylargercompanies,andInstagramseemstobeapopularplatformforsmaller,

newercompanies.

ADVANCEDANALYSIS/REGRESSIONS

Afterlookingatabasicanalysisofthecompanies,Ithenrantworegressionmodels.

Thefirstlookedatthethreevariablesoffamiliarity,socialmediapresence,andtrust.Iran

thisregressionseparatelyforeachofthethreegroupsofcompaniesandhaveincludedthe

chartsinFigures6-8intheappendix.Asonecanseefromtheregressionoutputs,

specificallythep-values,familiarityisareliablepredictoroftrust,butsocialmedia

presenceisnotinallthreescenarios.

Forthesecondmodel,Ijustusedsocialmediapresencetopredicttrust.Onceagain,

IranthreeseparateregressionsandhaveincludedthechartsinFigures9-11.Inthis

Page 15: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

15

instance,socialmediapresenceisareliablepredictoroftrustinmediumcompanies,but

notforlargeorsmallcompanies.Thisdidnotshowintheregressionabovewithfamiliarity

becausefamiliarityhadmediatedtheeffect.Additionally,thecoefficientofmedium

companiesisalsonegative,whichmeansthatsocialmediapresenceactuallymoves

oppositeoftrustinthisinstance.ThisrelationshipcanbebestseenintheplotinFigure12.

Therecouldbeavarietyofexplanationsforthisresult,butonemaybebecausecompanies

whoranklowintrustmaybetryingtoincreasetheirsocialmediapresenceinordertogain

thistrustfromconsumers.Ontheotherhand,companieswhoalreadyhavethishighlevel

oftrustmaynotfeeltheneedtospendasmuchonsocialmediamarketingandincrease

theirpresencesincetheyarealreadyingoodstandingswiththeircustomers.Additionally,

lookingatthecoefficientforsmallcompanies,somethingmayseemoffsinceitissolarge.

However,thisisbecauseofaconsiderablylowsocialmediapresence.WhenIranthe

regressionswithoutfollowers,justpostsandlikes,thecoefficientwasstilllargeat6.2

comparedto.1and-.6forlargeandmediumcompanies.

Alsoasatermofreferenceforthedataprovided,thecorrelationsbetweenthethree

variablesare:

• SMI&FAM:.28

• SMI&TRUST:.25

• TRUST&FAM:.97

Thehighcorrelationbetweentrustandfamiliarityistobeexpectedbasedongeneral

theory,butthecorrelationbetweensocialmediapresenceandfamiliarityisinteresting.

Thecorrelationissomewhatlow,hintingthatotherareasofmarketingorexposuremaybe

greatercausesoffamiliarityforacompany.Totestthis,aregressionwasalsorunusing

Page 16: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

16

socialmediapresencetopredictfamiliarity.Onceagainitwasonlyareliablepredictorin

mediumcompanies.Thus,possiblyprovidingfurtherevidencethatsizeofacompanymay

beanimportantfactorwhenitcomestosocialmediapresenceeffectingconsumertrust.

VII.Conclusion:

Ascanbeseenfromtheresults,whenfamiliarityisincludedinthemodel,social

mediapresenceisshowntonotbeareliablepredictorofconsumertrust.

However,whensocialmediapresencealoneisusedtopredicttrust,itisareliable

predictorformediumcompanies,butnotforlargeorsmallcompanies.Onepossible

explanationmaybethatsocialmediapresencehasagreatereffectforcertainsized

companies.Forexample,largecompaniesmayalreadybeestablishedwiththeconsumer

andsmallcompaniesmaynotbewell-knownenoughtogainconsumers’attentiononsocial

media.However,therearequiteafewotherfactorstoconsiderbesidescompanysizesuch

asthetypeofcontentpostedonsocialmedia(intermsofrelevance,quality,intrigue,etc.)

andtheinteractionofthecompanywithitsfollowers(numberofresponsestoTwitter

mentions,Facebookposts)whichcouldhavealsoeffectedthisoutcome.

Theresultsofthisresearchmayprovidefurtherinsighttocompaniesdeciding

whetherputtingtheirmarketingeffortsintosocialmediasitesisworthitwhenitcomesto

earningtrustfromconsumers.Inthisinstance,theresultsoftheresearchshowthatsocial

mediapresencewasnotareliablepredictorofconsumertrustinlargeandsmall

companies,butitwasinmediumsizedcompanies.Thus,werecommendproceedingwith

cautionandhavingthecompanyitselfvalidatewhethersocialmediaisaffectingitsown

consumertrust.

Page 17: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

17

Thisresearchisjustthebeginningofunderstandingtherelationshipbetweensocial

mediapresenceandconsumertrust.Somelimitationsofthisresearchwerethatitfocused

ononly30CPGcompanies,therewasashorttimeframe(socialmediapresencemayhavea

delayedeffectontrust),andthatsocialmediapresencemayhaveotherpositiveeffectson

brandequitybesidestrust.Consideringthese,furtherresearchshould:focusonconsumers

usingsocialmediaregularly(especiallythosewhovisitcompanysocialmediasites),

considerhowconsumerdemographicscouldplayaroleinsteadofcompanysize,explore

non-CPGcompanies,andpossiblyinvestigatewhetherdifferenttypesofpostsmatter.

Page 18: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

18

VIII.APPENDIX

Figure1

Survey:TrustinCPGBrands

Q0Thankyouforyourparticipationinthisresearch.Thisstudyisbeingconductedforacademicreasons.Itisnotbeingsponsoredbyanyfor-profitcompany,product,orbrand.Wearesimplytryingtounderstandhowconsumersfeelandinteractwithbrandstobetterunderstandconsumerbehavior.Yourparticipationisvoluntary.Youwillreceive$0.20

throughMTurkforparticipatinginthisresearch.Youcanstopatanytimewithoutpenaltyorlossofbenefits.Youmayskipanyquestionsyoudonotwishtoanswer.

Thisresearchprojectfocusesonlearningmoreabouttherelationshipbetweena

company'ssocialmediapresenceandconsumertrust,specificallythroughlookingat10consumerpackagedgoodsbrands.Youarebeingaskedtoparticipateinthisresearchstudybecauseweareinterestedinhearingyouropinionsaboutthesebrands.Therearenorightorwronganswers—wearejustinterestedinyouropinions.Thissurveyshouldonlytakeabout2-3minutes,andyourresponsesarecompletelyanonymous.Thereisnowaytolinkyourresponsestoyouridentity.Wewillnotbecollectinganyidentifyinginformationand

thissurveywillnotaskyouanyidentifyingquestions.

ForquestionsaboutthisprojectyoumaycontactJosephGoodmanat

[email protected].

Forquestionsaboutyourrightsasaparticipantinthisstudyortodiscussotherstudy-relatedconcernsorcomplaintswithsomeonewhoisnotpartoftheresearchteam,you

maycontactMs.SandraMeadowsintheOfficeofResponsibleResearchPracticesat1-800-678-6251.

*Note:byclickingthenextbuttonyouconsenttoparticipatinginthissurvey.

Click>>>tocontinuetothestudyandacceptingtheseterms.

Q39Inthisstudyweareinterestedinyouropinionsabout10differentbrands.Ifyouarenotfamiliarwiththebrand,that'sOK,justmakeyourbestguessbasedonwhatyouthink.

Page 19: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

19

Q1PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutP&G.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithP&G

(1)o o o o o o o

PromisesmadebyP&Garelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatP&Gputscustomers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

P&Gunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromP&G(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 20: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

20

Q2PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutCoca-Cola.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithCoca-Cola(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyCoca-Colaarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatCoca-Colaputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Coca-Colaunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromCoca-Cola

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 21: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

21

Q3PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutHanesBrands.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

HanesBrands(1)

o o o o o o o Promisesmadeby

HanesBrandsarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatHanesBrands

putscustomers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

HanesBrandsunderstandsthemarketitworksin(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhattoexpectfrom

HanesBrands(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 22: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

22

Q4PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutSmuckers.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

Smuckers(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebySmuckersarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatSmuckersputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Smuckersunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromSmuckers

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 23: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

23

Q5PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutTheHonestCompany.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithTheHones

Company(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyTheHonestCompanyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatTheHonestCompanyputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

TheHonestCompany

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromTheHonestCompany

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 24: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

24

Q6PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutChubbies.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

Chubbies(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyChubbiesarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatChubbiesputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Chubbiesunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromChubbies

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 25: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

25

Q7PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutUnilever.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

Unilever(1)o o o o o o o

Promisesmadeby

Unileverarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatUnileverputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Unileverunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromUnilever(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 26: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

26

Q8PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutPepsiCo.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

PepsiCo(1)o o o o o o o

Promisesmadeby

PepsiCoarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatPepsiCoputs

customers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

PepsiCounderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromPepsiCo(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 27: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

27

Q9PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutNestle.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withNestle(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyNestlearelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatNestleputscustomers’interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Nestleunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromNestle(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 28: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

28

Q10PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutMcCormickSpices.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

McCormickSpices(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyMcCormick&Companyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatMcCormick&Company

putscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

McCormick&Companyunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromMcCormick&Company

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 29: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

29

Q11PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutTheCloroxCompany.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithTheCloroxCompany

(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyTheCloroxCompanyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatTheCloroxCompanyputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

TheCloroxCompany

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromTheCloroxCompany

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 30: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

30

Q12PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutTheHersheyCompany.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithTheHersheyCompany

(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyThe

HersheyCompanyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatThe

HersheyCompanyputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

TheHersheyCompany

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromThe

HersheyCompany

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 31: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

31

Q13PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutTriaBeauty

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithTriaBeauty(1)

o o o o o o o Promisesmadeby

TriaBeautyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatTriaBeauty

putscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

TriaBeautyunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromTriaBeauty

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 32: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

32

Q14PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutHelloProducts.

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithHelloProducts(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyHello

Productsarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatHello

Productsputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

HelloProducts

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromHello

Products(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 33: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

33

Q15PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutHarry's

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withHarry's(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyHarry'sarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatHarry'sputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Harry'sunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromHarry's(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 34: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

34

Q16PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutNike

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithNike

(1)o o o o o o o

PromisesmadebyNikearelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatNikeputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Nikeunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromNike(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 35: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

35

Q17Pleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsabout3M

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

with3M(1) o o o o o o o Promisesmadeby3Marelikelytobereliable

(2)o o o o o o o

Iexpectthat3Mputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

3Munderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfrom3M(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 36: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

36

Q18PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutMondelezInternational

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

MondelezInternational

(1)o o o o o o o

PromisesmadebyMondelez

Internationalarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatMondelez

Internationalputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

MondelezInternationalunderstandsthemarketitworksin(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhattoexpectfrom

MondelezInternational

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 37: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

37

Q19PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutGeneralMills

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

GeneralMills(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyGeneralMillsarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatGeneralMillsputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

GeneralMills

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromGeneralMills(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 38: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

38

Q20PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutL'Oreal

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withL'Oreal(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyL'Orealarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatL'Orealputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

L'Orealunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromL'Oreal(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 39: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

39

Q21PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutMattel

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withMattel(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyMattelarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatMattelputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Mattelunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromMattel(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 40: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

40

Q22PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutRalphLauren

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withRalphLauren(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyRalph

Laurenarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatRalph

Laurenputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

RalphLauren

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromRalph

Lauren(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 41: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

41

Q23PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutAvon

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

IamfamiliarwithAvon

(1)o o o o o o o

PromisesmadebyAvonarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatAvonputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Avonunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromAvon(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 42: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

42

Q24PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutElectronicArts

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

ElectronicArts(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyElectronicArtsarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatElectronicArtsputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

ElectronicArts

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromElectronicArts(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 43: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

43

Q25PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutSnapple

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

Snapple(1)o o o o o o o

Promisesmadeby

Snapplearelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatSnappleputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Snappleunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromSnapple(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 44: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

44

Q26PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutMethodHome

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

MethodHome(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyMethodarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o IexpectthatMethodputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

Methodunderstandsthemarketitworksin

(4)o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromMethod(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 45: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

45

Q27PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutWalkerandCompany

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withWalkerand

Company(1)

o o o o o o o Promisesmadeby

WalkerandCompanyarelikelytobereliable

(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatWalkerandCompanyputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

WalkerandCompany

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromWalkerandCompany

(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 46: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

46

Q28PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutUnrealSnacks

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withUnrealSnacks(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyUnreal

Snacksarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatUnreal

Snacksputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

UnrealSnacks

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o

Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromUnreal

Snacks(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 47: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

47

Q29PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutHamptonCreek

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliarwith

HamptonCreek(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyHamptonCreekarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatHamptonCreekputscustomers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

HamptonCreek

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromHamptonCreek(5)

o o o o o o o

Page 48: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

48

Q30PleaseanswerthefollowingquestionsaboutNavitasOrganics

Stronglydisagree1(1)

Disagree2(2)

Somewhatdisagree3(3)

Neitheragreenordisagree4(4)

Somewhatagree5(5)

Agree6(6)

Stronglyagree7(7)

Iamfamiliar

withNavitasOrganics(1)

o o o o o o o PromisesmadebyNavitas

Organicsarelikelytobereliable(2)

o o o o o o o

IexpectthatNavitasOrganicsputs

customers'interests

beforetheirown(3)

o o o o o o o

NavitasOrganics

understandsthemarketitworksin

(4)

o o o o o o o Iamquitecertainwhatto

expectfromNavitas

Organics(5)

o o o o o o o Q32Onaverage,howmanyHOURSperdaydoyouusesocialmedia?(makeyourbestguess)

________________________________________________________________

Page 49: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

49

Q33Onaverage,howmanytimesadaydoyouvisitthefollowingwebsites?Pleasewriteanumber.

TimesADay(1)

Facebook(1)

Twitter(2)

Instagram(3)

Youtube(4)

Q34Almostfinished!Whatisyourage?

________________________________________________________________

Q35Gender?

o Male(1)o Female(2)o Other(3)o Prefernottoanswer(4)

Page 50: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

50

Q36Anyfinalcommentsfortheresearcher?

________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

Figure2

Demographicsfromthesurvey: MAX MINAverageage 35.51 75 18#Females 266 #Males 235 #DailyvisitsonYoutube 4.13 100 0#DailyvisitsonInstagram 2.33 50 0#DailyvisitsonFacebook 5.64 120 0#DailyvisitsonTwitter 2.22 60 0Hours/dayspentonsocialmedia

2.60 44 0

Figure3

TRUSTRANKING(SMIRanking):

1.SMUCKERS(#27)

2.NIKE(#2)

3.HERSHEY(#8)

4.MCCORMICK(#23)

5.GENERALMILLS(#16)

6.COCACOLA(#1)

Page 51: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

51

7.HANES(#26)

8.CLOROX(#18)

9.SNAPPLE(#11)

10.NESTLE(#12)

11.MATTEL(#20)

12.3M(#5)

13.PEPSICO(#6)

14.L’OREAL(#13)

15.RALPHLAUREN(#4)

16.AVON(#9)

17.P&G(#15)

18.UNILEVER(#14)

19.ELECTRONICARTS(#3)

20.HONESTCOMPANY(#7)

21.METHODHOME(#21)

22.NAVITASORGANICS(#24)

23.TRIABEAUTY(#29)

24.HAMPTONCREEK(#19)

25.HARRYS(#17)

26.UNREALSNACKS(#22)

27.WALKER&CO(#30)

28.MONDELEZ(#25)

Page 52: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

52

29.HELLOPRODUCTS(#28)

30.CHUBBIES(#10)

LARGEMEDIUMSMALL

Figure4

INTEGRITY

1.Smuckers2.Hershey3.Hanes4.Nike5.Mccormick6.Cocacola7.Snapple8.Clorox9.3m10.GeneralMills11.Mattel12.Nestle13.RalphLauren14.Pepsico15.L'oreal16.Avon17.P&G18.Unilever19.ElectricArts20.HonestCompany21.Method22.HamptonCreek23.TriaBeauty24.WalkerandCompany25.NavitasOrganics26.Mondelez27.Harrys28.Hello29.UnrealSnacks30.Chubbies

BENEVOLENCE

1.Smuckers2.Nike3.Hershey4.Snapple5.Hanes6.Generalmills7.Cocacola8.Mccormick9.Mattel10.Clorox11.3m12.L'oreal13.P&G14.Nestle15.RalphLauren16.Unilever17.Avon18.ElectricArts19.Pepsico20.Method21.HonestCompany22.HamptonCreek23.NavitasOrganics24.TriaBeauty25.WalkerandCompany26.Harrys27.Hello28.UnrealSnacks29.Mondelez30.Chubbies

ABILITY

1.Nike2.GeneralMills3.Hershey4.Mccormick5.Pepsico6.Clorox7.L'oreal8.Nestle9.3m10.Mattel11.RalphLauren12.Smuckers13.Snapple14.Cocacola15.Hanes16.Avon17.Electricarts18.Unilever19.P&G20.Method21.HonestCompany22.Triabeauty23.Harrys24.Navitasorganics25.Unrealsnacks26.Mondelez27.WalkerandCompany28.Hello29.HamptonCreek30.Chubbies

PREDICTABILITY

1.P&G2.Cocacola3.Hanes4.Smuckers5.HonestCompany6.Chubbies7.Unilever8.Pepsico9.Nestle10.Mccormick11.Clorox12.Hershey13.Triabeauty14.Hello15.Harrys16.Nike17.3m18.Mondelez19.Generalmills20.L'oreal21.Mattel22.RalphLauren23.Avon24.ElectricArts25.Snapple26.Method27.WalkerandCompany28.unrealsnacks29.HamptonCreek30.Navitasorganics

Page 53: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

53

Figure5

SMIRANKING:

1.COCA-COLAà8.88E+13

2.NIKEà3.55E+13

3.ELECTRONICARTSà1.68E+13

4.RALPHLAURENà3.77+12

5.3Mà1.17E+12

6.PEPSIà9.06E+11

7.HONESTCOMPANYà4.98E+11

8.HERSHEYSà4.09E+11

9.AVONà2.94E+11

10.CHUBBIESà2.90E+11

11.SNAPPLEà2.53E+11

12.NESTLEà2.19E+11

13.LOREALà1.92E+11

14.UNILEVERà1.84E+11

15.P&Gà1.47E+11

16.GENERALMILLSà1.44E+11

17.HARRYSà8.37E+10

18.CLOROXà8.17E+10

19.HAMPTONCREEKà7.15E+10

20.MATTELà5.90E+10

21.METHODHOMEà3.21E+10

Page 54: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

54

22.UNREALSNACKSà1.98E+10

23.MCCORMICKSPICESà1.83E+10

24.NAVITASORGANICSà1.63E+10

25.MONDELEZà1.27E+10

26.HANESà1.19E+10

27.SMUCKERSà1.04E+10

28.HELLOPRODUCTSà4.33E+09

29.TRIABEAUTYà3.35E+09

30.WALKER&COMPANYà1.21E+09

LARGEMEDIUMSMALL

****ingeneral:largercompanieshaveahighersocialmediapresence&smallerhavealower

socialmediapresence(astobepredicted,newercompaniesmaynothavetheknowhow/

followingyet),BUTtherearequiteafewoutliers

Figure6

LARGECOMPANIES

Coefficients

StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 13.63 0.56 24.23 <.0001SMI 0.01 0.02 0.23 0.82FAM 1.22 0.10 11.60 <.0001

Page 55: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

55

Figure7

MEDIUMCOMPANIES

Coefficients

StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 6.89 3.60 1.92 0.09SMI -0.34 0.19 -1.77 0.12FAM 2.38 0.59 4.03 0.01

Figure8

SMALLCOMPANIES

Coefficients

StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 13.94 0.97 14.38 <.0001SMI 0.95 8.57 0.11 0.91FAM 0.99 0.45 2.22 0.04

Figure9

LARGECOMPANIES

Coefficients

StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 19.96 0.58 34.40 <.0001SMI 0.12 0.10 1.23 0.25

Page 56: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

56

Figure10

MEDIUMCOMPANIES

Coefficients

StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 21.38 0.27 79.46 <.0001SMI -0.84 0.25 -3.39 0.01

Figure11

SMALLCOMPANIES

Coefficients StandardError

T-Stat P-value

Intercept 16.01 0.32 50.20 <.0001SMI 11.85 8.56 1.38 0.20

Figure12

*SMIvaluesloggedtoappearonthesamescalingastrust

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

24

8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

TRUS

T

SMI

Observations

LARGE

MEDIUM

SMALL

Page 57: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

57

IX.REFERENCES

Calefato,F.,Lanubile,F.,&Novielli,N.(2015).Theroleofsocialmediainaffectivetrust

buildingincustomer-supplierrelationships.ElectronicCommerceResearch,15(4),453-

482.

DeMers,J.(2015).TheTop10BenefitsOfSocialMediaMarketing.ForbesMagazine.

Hajli,M.N.(2014).Astudyoftheimpactofsocialmediaonconsumers.International

JournalofMarketResearch,56(3),387-404.

Kaul,A.,Chaudhri,V.,Cherian,D.,Freberg,K.,Mishra,S.,Kumar,R.,etal.(2015).Social

media:Thenewmantraformanagingreputation.Vikalpa:TheJournalforDecision

Makers,40(4),455-491.

Laroche,M.,Habibi,M.R.,&Richard,M.(2013).Tobeornottobeinsocialmedia:How

brandloyaltyisaffectedbysocialmedia?InternationalJournalofInformation

Management,33(1),76-82.

Lee,K.,Lee,B.,&Oh,W.(2015).Thumbsup,salesup?thecontingenteffectoffacebook

likesonsalesperformanceinsocialcommerce.JournalofManagementInformation

Systems,32(4),109-143.

Mayer,R.C.,Davis,J.H.,&Schoorman,F.D.(1995).Anintegrativemodeloforganizational

trust.TheAcademyofManagementReview,20(3),709-734.

McKnight,D.H.,Cummings,L.L.,&Chervany,N.L.(1998).Initialtrustformationinnew

organizationalrelationships.TheAcademyofManagementReview,23(3),473-490.

Niederhoffer,K.,Mooth,R.,Wiesenfeld,D.,&Gordon,J.(2007).Theoriginandimpactof

CPGnew-productbuzz:Emergingtrendsandimplications.JournalofAdvertising

Research,47(4),420-426.

Page 58: © 2018 Alexandria Marie Ross · 2018-05-03 · information (such as number of likes and followers) from the firms’ Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube pages. This data was

SocialMediaPresenceandConsumerTrust

58

Smith,S.(2013).ConceptualizingandevaluatingexperienceswithbrandsonFacebook.

InternationalJournalofMarketResearch,55(3),357-374.

Tiago,MariaTeresaPinheiroMeloBorges,&Veríssimo,J.M.C.(2014).Digitalmarketing

andsocialmedia:Whybother?BusinessHorizons,57(6),703-708.

Wilcox,G.B.,&Kim,K.(2013).Measurementofsocialmediaeffects:Socialmedia

performancemodel.AmericanAcademyofAdvertisingConferenceProceedings,,65-65.