Women's Status in Agricultural Societies

Text extracted from

Our Kind

By Marvin Harris

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/512HK3QSD3L._SL160_OU01_SS160_.jpg

Women’s Status

• Women have less status than men in agricultural societies– Social– Political– Economic– Educational– Religious

• Two main causes– Men dominate weapons and war– Men dominate plow-based

agriculturehttp://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2007/11_02/muslimDM1511_468x310.jpg

Men are larger, stronger than women

• Women 4.6 inches shorter than men– on average

• Women have lighter bones – and more fat

• Women 2/3 to 3/4 as strong as men

http://www.geocities.com/MotorCity/Factory/1940/wood2.jpg

Men specialized in hunting large game

• Men were the big game hunters in 95% of band-and-village societies

• Male advantage in height, weight, brawn in use of hand-held hunting weapons

• Women less mobile when pregnant, lactating– hunt smaller game, gather

food (majority of diet)

http://www.alaskool.org/LANGUAGE/manytongues/Images/Hunter.jpg

Men usually specialists in weapons

• Men monopolized lethal weapons since Paleolithic times: – spears

– bow and arrows

– harpoons

– clubs

– boomerangs

• Men thus more dangerous– and more coercive in conflict

• "I'm a man.  I've got my arrows.  I'm not afraid to die“– !Kung hunter http://www.museum.state.il.us/muslink/nat_amer/pre/images/dmm_p02_200.jpg

Men trained to be warriors

• Warriors aggressive and fearless • More capable of hunting and

killing other human beings– without pity or remorse

• Women warriors only significant in recent times– with firearms, not muscle powered

• In Band and village societies, the more warfare there was– the more women suffered from

male oppression. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/06/Assyrian_spearman_%C2%B7_HHWI469.svg/300px-Assyrian_spearman_%C2%B7_HHWI469.svg.png

Oppression of Women

• Amount of war correlates to the oppression of women

http://www.rrtraders.com/Shields/kikuyu-tribe.jpg

Bands of hunters and gatherers:

•  !Kung– Kalahari desert, Africa

– Low population density hunters and gatherers

• Little warfare• Women have almost equal

status as men

http://www.der.org/films/images/kung-instrument.jpeg

Aborigines (Australia): 

• More warfare between bands • Fairly low population density hunters

and gatherers • Captives from war cooked, eaten

– Mostly women and children

• Males get best food • Men beat or kill wives for adultery • Wives cannot do the same to men for

adultery – Double standard

http://theology1.tripod.com/images/aborigines.jpg

Aborigine Women• Aboriginal women do all the

hard work– Gather fruits, dig roots

• chop larvae out of tree-stems

– Carry child on shoulders whole day – Prepare food

• beating, roasting, soaking fruits and roots

– Makes hut, gathers materials – Provide water and fuel – Women carry all baggage when travel

• including children

• Men only carry light weapons– out in front when travel

                                                                     

Village Societies of Agriculturalists

• Boys train for war at early age– learn cruelty by practicing on animals

• Raids between villages common:– 33% males die from armed combat

– competition for resources due to population pressure

• Polygynous:– men can have many wives

• Wives beat or maimed for disobedience or adultery – burned , ears chopped off

Yanomami (Rainforest of Brazil, Venezuela)

Village Societies of Agriculturalists

• Male initiation cult trains men as warriors – and to dominate

women

• Warfare between villages rampant: – competition for

resources due to population

Nama  (Papua New Guinea)

New Guinea warriors http://www.infobrasil.org/fotos/fotos/Corel/images/1218.jpg

Nama (Papua New Guinea)

• Males given bride at initiation – – shoot her in the thigh with

arrow

– to demonstrate "unyielding power over her"

• Women work in gardens, raise pigs, do all dirty work

• Men stand around gossiping

http://www.world-traveler.eu/travels-papua-new-guinea-Dateien/papua-new-guinea-highlands-warrior.jpg

New Guinea Warrior

Nama  (Papua New Guinea)• "Women were severely punished for adultery by having

burning sticks thrust into their vagina, or they were killed by their husbands; they were whipped with a cane if they spoke out of turn or presumed to offer their opinions at public gatherings; and were physically abused in marital arguments. 

• Men could never be seen to be weak or soft in dealings with women.  Men do not require specific incidents or reasons to abuse or mistreat women: it is part of the normal course of events; indeed, in ritual and myth, it is portrayed as the essential order of things." 

--Daryl Feil, University of Sydney

Why Intense Warfare in Agricultural Village Societies?

• New Guinea: – high population leads to

depletion of resources • Forests depleted, burned

– replaced by fields • Yams and pork

– replace wild animals and plants

• Selection for warfare: – take over neighboring

resources http://www.theage.com.au/ffximage/2006/09/17/18W_PNG_narrowweb__300x334,0.jpg

Male Domination in Agricultural Village Societies

• Male domination leads to female infanticide: – Females can't become

warriors

• sex ratios skewed toward males

• Female infanticide ultimately lowers population growth rate

http://www.infobrasil.org/fotos/fotos/Corel/images/1208.jpg

Male Domination of Food

• New Guinea: male hunters, warriors – monopolize meat (pork)

• Malnutrition: – especially women,

children and older men

• Women and children – Eat more insects, frogs,

mice, placenta, maggots

http://www.ebible.org/mpj/gallery/MamaNaPikininiLongBulal.jpg

Patrilocality

• Patrilocality: – women leave their family,

village – move in with man's family

• Allows male raiding parties to be made up of blood relatives:  – trust in combat teams

• But who will look after land when men away?  – Women

• especially sisters: loyalhttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b8/Orma_Village_Kenya.jpg/800px-Orma_Village_Kenya.jpg

Matrilocality• Matrilocality: men leave their family,

village– move in with woman's family

• Occurs in some chiefdoms where men gone on long raiding parties – up to a year

• Example: Iroquois • Women were in charge of home and

fields: – harvesting and storing crops

• Women in longhouse could withhold food for men's raids – if didn't approve

Iroquois longhouse

http://www.historyforkids.org/learn/northamerica/before1500/history/pictures/tiogapointmuseum.jpg

Matrilocality• Women's power not the

opposite of mens: – not equally cruel or

humiliating.  Why?

• Not because women less vicious: – women often participate in

torture

• Women cannot boss and degrade men – when men have the weapons

of war and warrior training.

Mohawk Warriorhttp://dsccrafts.com/ProductImages/_american_indians/51872_Mohawk_Warrior_Pg3_WEB.jpg

Large Stratified Societies

• Effect of warfare less direct: – most men not trained

to be warriors

• Most men unarmed peasants – also terrified of

professional warriors

Type of Agriculture affects women's status

• West Africa– Agriculture not dependent

on men– Women empowered

• North India– Men’s strength required

for plowing– Women unempowered

• South India– Women control agriculture– Women empowered

http://www.thp.org/activist/105/hoe500.jpg

West Africa

• People:– Yoruba, Igbo, and Dahomey

• Women's status strong: – can own fields and crops – Dominate local market – Acquire wealth from trade

• No animal-plowed fields– due to tse-tse fly – Short-handled hoe used in farming – Therefore women not dependent

on men for agriculture http://www.hobotraveler.com/blogphotos01/207-266-hoe-farming-africa-girl.jpg

West Africa

• Men must pay bride-price to get married– Women valuable

• Male polygyny– only with permission of senior wife

• Women participate in village councils – and high state office

• Women mobilize as group– to seek redress against mistreatment by men

North India

• Men have monopoly on ox-drawn plows

• Greater body strength: – 15-20% more efficient than women

• Advantage may mean difference between survival – and starvation

• Even young men not strong enough to plow all day: – short window of weather

opportunity for plowing http://www.gonomad.com/tours/0512/images/india-plowing.jpg

North India

• Female infanticide common • Dowries from women

required for marriage • Widows powerless:

– sometimes throw themselves on husbands funeral pyre

• Increasing incidence of intentional acid sprayingAcid Burn Victim,

Bangladesh

http://news.bbc.co.uk/media/images/36204000/jpg/_36204440_acidvictimbbc300.jpg

South India

• Rice paddy agriculture:– doesn't need men's strength

• Women in charge of much agriculture

• Women have more freedom, – status, social power

• True in other rice producing areas– Southeast Asia, Indonesia

  http://frank.itlab.us/India_2002/dec_25_planting_rice.jpg

How did male dominance evolve in large agriculture societies?

• Men in charge of large plow animals – From ancient times

• Men thus drive animal-drawn carts when wheel invented– In charge of trade

                                   

                                      

http://www.greathall.com/photoalbum/photos/itl_plow.jpg

How did male dominance evolve in large agriculture societies?

• Men thus in charge of bookkeeping, records

• Men thus became the scribes, accountants, literate

• Men thus became the philosophers, theologians, and mathematicians

How did male dominance evolve in large agriculture societies?

• Men also controlled warfare

• Men thus gained control over governments– and state religions

"At the dawn of modern times men dominated politics, religion, art, science, law, industry, commerce, and the armed forces wherever people depended on animal-drawn plows for their basic food supply"

http://www.visitingdc.com/images/george-washington-picture.jpg http://thescroogereport.files.wordpress.com/2007/07/pope.jpg

http://www.smh.com.au/ffximage/2004/05/25/michelangelodavid,0.jpghttp://www.fourmilab.ch/documents/figures/einstein.png http://richmondthenandnow.com/Images/Famous-Visitors/Thomas-Jefferson-big.jpg

http://a.abcnews.com/images/WNT/ap_bill_gates_060921_ssh.jpg http://img.slate.com/media/1/123125/2158911/2159086/2159087/070221_CL_HitlerEX.jpg