west asia synopsis.pdf

Post on 13-Sep-2015

212 views 0 download

Transcript of west asia synopsis.pdf

  • 1FatahUSDiplomaticrelationshipinWestBank

    Background

    Thehistory of theIsraeliPalestinian conflicthas its roots in the late 19th century and

    beginningof20thcenturyalongwiththehistoryofregionandcontinuestothepresentday.

    Theendofthe19thcenturyandthebeginningofthe20thcenturyaremarkedbythebirth

    of two major nationalist groupsas the Jews and the Arabs. In the 7th century, a new

    influencewasgrowingintheWestAsiathatwasknownasIslam.TheIslamasapractice

    startedwiththeprophetMuhammad.

    ThePalestineIsrael conflict is theongoing strugglebetweenIsraelisandPalestiniansthat

    began in the early 20th century. It is also important to look at the history of early 20th

    century.Howtheseproblemswereshaped.MajorturningpointinthehistoryoftheWest

    Asia came whenoilwas discovered, first in Persia in 1908 and later inSaudi Arabiain

    1938and theotherPersianGulf states,andalso inLibyaandAlgeria. It isalsovery fact

    thatcrudeoilwas themost importantcommodity in the20thcenturyof industrialworld.

    However,theOttomanEmpirewasdefeatedbyBritishEmpireforcesin1918.Atthesame

    time,theBritishpromisedtotheJewsthroughtheBalfourDeclaration(1917)increating

    aJewishhomeland in Palestine. The rise to power of German dictatorAdolf Hitler

    inGermanyhadcreatedanewurgencyintheZionistquest toimmigratetoPalestineand

    createaJewishstatethere.TheimmigrationofJewishhasincreasedtotheLandofIsrael.

    However, it is also important to see the key issues of conflict between PalestineIsrael.

    Thesearethemutualrecognition,settlementofrefugees,borders,security,waterdisputes,

    controloverJerusalem,Israelisettlements.Atfirst issue, theJerusalemismost important

    forbothparties, social,politically, theologically, andchronologically. It is alsoholycity

    forJudaism,IslamandChristianity.ForChristians,Jerusalemhasbeenaholycitysince,

    even according to theNew Testament,Jesus was crucifiedthere. As well as, in Islam,

    Jerusalemisthethirdholiestcity.InIslamictraditionin610CEitbecamethefirstQibla,

    the focal point for Muslim prayer. Prophet Muhammadmade hisNight Journey over

    there.Whereas,theWesternWallistheancientwallthatsurroundedtheJewishTemples

    courtyardandisoneofthemostandlastsacredsitesinJudaism.Insumup,theOldCityis

  • 2hometomanysitesoftremendousreligiousimportance,theTempleMountanditsWestern

    Wall, theChurchof theHolyTomb, theDomeof theRockandAlAqsaMosque.These

    religiousholysitescannotbeseparatedorcansayinseparablebecausetheirlocation.They

    areattachedwithonetoothersbytheirwalls.

    InApril,PalestinianPresidentMahmoudAbbasannouncedthatthePalestinianLiberation

    Organization's (PLO) leading faction, Fatah, has agreed to a unity pact with its main

    political rival,Hamas, endinga sevenyear riftbetween theparties.This led to thenews

    immediatenegativereactionsfrombothIsraelandtheU.S.,whoconsiderHamasaterrorist

    group. It is also a fact that Hamas and Fatah have long held fundamentally opposing

    viewpointsonseveral issues,mostnotably, that statusof Israel,whichFatahhas tried to

    workwith,butHamashasofficiallyvowedtodestroy.

    US provide humanitarian assistance in West Bank. Although it is also a fact that

    UNRWAs services encompass education, health care, relief, camp infrastructure and

    improvement,communitysupport,microfinanceandemergencyresponsewiththesupport

    ofUS.Hamas and Fatah have fundamentally different approaches to the state of Israel.

    Hamas believes the state does not have the right to exist, and Fatah believes it does,

    choosing to attemptpolitical solutions instead.Fatahhas anofficial stanceof nonviolent

    resistance,whileHamashasconsistentlyusesterroristtacticsagainstIsrael.These(major)

    disparities have kept the two from joining forces since 2006, whenHamas swept

    PalestinianelectionsandunseatedFatahastherulingpartyinthePalestinianAuthorityfor

    adecade.Abbashadjusttakenhisseataspresidentinanelectionthatfollowedthedeathof

    longtimeleaderYasserArafat,andwasslatedtofinishouttheterm.

    ReviewofLiterature

    ElizabethMatthewa(2011),arguedthatEducationforpeaceisthebestwaytoensurethat

    the next generations of Israelis and Palestinians have the skills, the knowledge, and the

    motivation tocreatea trulypeacefulWestAsia.Hestressedalso that througheducation,

    IsraelisandPalestinianchildrenmustbeprovidedwiththeskillsandknowledgetolivein

    peaceandtocreatemutualrespectandunderstandingwhichwilltransformtheirlivesand

    this region into cooperation, prosperity, and freedom.Asher Susser (2012) explores that

  • 3withthefailureofthepeaceprocessunderthesigningoftheOsloAccords,thetwostate

    solution lost much of its appeal, legitimacy, and practicality in the region. The Israeli

    settlements and the successive Israeli governments is somewhere in contendingwith the

    challenge of the settler movement across the region. In this literature, the author also

    focusesthepoliticalconfusiononthenatureofPalestinewiththePAandHamas.

    ResearchQuestion

    xWhatwerethecoreissuesofPalestineIsraelConflict?xWhatexplainstheRelationofFatahandUSinWestAsianPolitics?xWhatdifferentformatsofassociationwithHamasFatahapplytoPalestineIsraelConflict?xWhatarechallengesandrestrictionsFatahUShumanitarianAid?

    ResearchMethodology

    This research will use both primary (official records and document of the states) and

    secondary (books, journals and researchpapers etc.) sourcesofdata and adopt inductive

    methods to analyze the subject of the research. This research will also use historical,

    descriptive,andanalyticaltoolsofmethods.

    TentativeChapters

    Chapter1:Introduction

    Chapter2:RootcausesofConflictbetweenPalestineIsrael

    ThischapterwillexaminetherootcausesofPalestineIsraelconflict,howithaschanged

    time to timeasmanifested in the regionandeffect regionalpolitics.Thediscussionwill

    payalsoattentiontothecoreissuesofconflicts.

    Chapter3:UnderstandingnatureofFatahUSDiplomacy

    ThischapterwillexaminetheunderstandingnatureofPalestinianRefugee.Furtherwithit

    willfollowthepoliticsoftheirRightsandintheregion.

    Chapter5:Conclusion

  • 4Thischapterwillhighlightthefindingsandtestthehypothesisofthestudy.

  • 5Bibliography

    Ahron Bregman Jihan ElTahri (1998), The fifty years war: Israel and the Arabs, .

    London:PenguinBooks.

    Akram,SusanM. (2002), PalestinianRefugeesandTheirLegalStatus:Rights,Politics,

    andImplicationsforaJustSolution,JournalofPalestineStudies,31(3):3651.

    Arthur Koestler, Koestler, Arthur (2007),Promise and Fulfilment:Palestine 19171949,

    RamagePress.

    Bregman,Ahron(2002),Israel'sWars:AHistorySince1947.London:RoutledgePress.

    Gilbert,Martin(1998),Israel:AHistory,Doubleday:London.

    Gordon,NeveandYinonCohen(2012),WesternInterests,IsraeliUnilateralism,andthe

    TwoStateSolution,JournalofPalestineStudies,41(3):618.

    Khalaf, Issa (1991),Politics in Palestine: Arab Factionalism and Social Disintegration,

    StateuniversityPressofNewYork:NewYork.

    Lenczowski, George(1990), American Presidents and the West Asia, Duke University

    Press:Durham.

    Louis, Wm. Roger (1986),the British Empire in the West Asia: Arab Nationalism, the

    UnitedStates,andPostwarImperialism,OxfordUniversityPress:London.

    Matthewa, Elizabeth (edts.) (2011), the IsraelPalestine Conflict, Parallel discourses,

    RoutledgePress:London.

    Susser, Asher (2012), Israel, Jordan and Palestine, the twostate imperative, Brandeis

    UniversityPress:NewEngland.

    THEDECLARATIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHESTATEOFISRAEL

    May 14, 1948, [online: web] Accessed 5 Feb. 2013 URL:

  • 6http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Guide+to+the+Peace+Process/Declaration+of+Esta

    blishment+of+State+of+Israel.htm.