Okay.I will think about it.

ERNST" YCUNB TCWER. lil3Z BAY IiITREET. BUITE 91;10.TaRaNTO, ONTARIO, M5K 1He-w.VICTDIIYVI!!:IUIAT'M.COM 141 at aBC".l 17 INFO@VIQ"TCRYVEIU!lATIM.COM

Or who requested it bye-mail?I distributed it to people I know,

ERNST'" YOUNG TOWER, aza IIAY STREET, SUITE 900, TaRaNTO, ONTARIO. M5K 1HeWWW.VICTORYVERBATIM.CDM 1418) 36a-&117 INFC@VICTORYVEIlIBATIM.COM

many. And he told me he was distributing to otherIsmailis.

What was the printing price?Are you talking of cost?

ERNST. YCUNG TOWER, :aza BAY STREET. 8UITE liI'O'O,TORDNTC, CNTARICI. MSK 1He.WWW.VICT'ORYVERBATIM.C'OM 141.) 36e-51 t 7 INF"a@V1cTDRYVERBATIM.CDM

That, I will not tell you for now.Okay. And who recorded the

A. who recorded? I don't know. Theyare circulating in the Ismaili community. There aresome of 1957, when I was just born. There are some

A. These recordings circulate all thetime with all the Ismailis. There is nothing

ERNST" YOUNG TDWER. :Bza I!IAY STREET, SUITE 900. TaRaNTO. CNTAFltO, MSK 1HeWWW.VICTQRYVl!"RElATIM.CCM (41 el ::Iea·el1"1 INr:'C@VICTDAYVERI!IATIM.CCM

This is why I told you in the beginning: Unless youunderstand the relation between the Imam and the

pUblisher? You agree with me the book doesn'tidentify a publisher?

about the editor. I am talking about the publisher.It doesn't identify who published the book, does it?

ERNS" •• yeUNG TeWER. :aza .A.Y STREET. SUITE: 90C. TORDNTD. DNTARIC, MSK 1H6WWW.vlCTDRYVElllBA.TIM.CDM (41 IS) a8C-1Ii 1 1'7 INFa@VICTORYVEReATIM.CC,",

connected with the printer. I have made sure thisis the way the book ...

And you distributed copies?And I have distributed copies.And normally, books identify the

the books that you have done?A. No, I disagree. There are other

Farmans books in circulation. There have alwaysbeen, in many languages ...

Q. You are talking about the ones from

ERNST. YOUNG TDWER, aaa SAY BTFlEET, .UITE vea, TORONTO, ONTARIO, M5K 1Hl5W'ww.vICTORYVERElATIM.CCM 141en 3l5e·e t 1"1 INVC@VICTCRYVEFU'ATIM.CCM

A. Okay.

Q. What about the money that youreceived; what did you do with it? How much moneydid you receive?

Q. And what happened to the money?A. I will not tell you anything about

this aspect. It is not part of the motion.Q. I see. You have pleaded that you

gave the money away. You are not going to tell mewhat you did with it?

A. No. It is not relevant to the

Q. You are not going to produce, Iguess, an accounting of any money you received?

A. Not at this point. It is not

Q. And how about the receipt of anyfunds from the distributionj you are not going totell me that, either?

ERNST'" VoUNII TOWER, zaz BAY BTRI!:I:T, BUITE 9ao, ToRONTD, DNTARIO, Mlil< 1H6WWW.VICTCRYVEABATIM,CDM 14' IIliI 360'6117 INF'C@VICTDRYVERBATIM.CDM

recognize that?A. Yes, that is a website I have

EAN5IT •• YOUNG TOWER, aaz BAY IlTREET. SUITE gOO, TaRONTa. ONTARIO, MSl< 1HeWWWoVICTCRYVEfl8ATIM.CCM (41.1 ~.C·"I1., INFC@VICTCRYVERBATIM.CDM

has been going on, and rarelYt it happens thatpeople put their things which are unwanted, which I

ERNST" ,,"DUN. TOWER, 3Z2 SAY STREET, SUITE 9CO, ToRDNTO. ONTARIO, M!51<1HeWWW,vICTCRYVERBATIM.CDM (4.81 380·8' 17 INFD@VICTDRYVERBATIM.CDM

see if they were all written by the same person?A. No, I don't know if they are written

all by the same person. I would believe so, but Idon't have any proof for now.

Can you produce those?I have an e-mail with Pettinati,

which I can bring you. I have in a letter here, inToronto. So, I will print it for you.

I will forward you the e-mail.Okay. And did you give her other

ERN8T & YOUNG TOWER. 222 BAY STREET. SUtTE !ileOt TORONTD, ONTARIO, MlilC. 1H6WWW.VIDTDRYVEFUIATIM.CCM (4161 :160'6117 INFD@VIC-rDRYVERSATIM.COM

think, something like that, "of the relativemeasurement of the height of the letter", orsomething like that. That is an e-mail I...I willsend you the e-mail, and it will be clear for you.

e-mails that you sent to her concerning yourinstructions to prepare the report. Okay?

A. No, Mr. Ospreay, I haven't sent himbye-mail. I met him, and I gave him ...

ERNST a: VDUNI3 TaWER, 322 BAY STREET, SUITE egg, TaRDNTO, ONTAAIO, MliK 1He.WWW.VICTCRWERBATIM.CDM(411&136C1-e.11?INF.O@VICTC ••YVEREIATIM.CClM

instructions. And you already refused to producethe things you gave them, and I am asking you again

I will give you the photocopies.I don1t want the photocopies. I

have already got the photocopies. Okay. You aregoing to give me the ...

ERNST &. YOUNG TOWER. 222 BAY STREET. SUITE 9CC, TORONTO. ONTARIO. M51< 1H6WWW.VICTCRVVERBATIM.COMI41 _. :a&C·lIill? INF'O@VU1TCRVVERSATlM.aOM

of the complete document, if that is allyou are going to give me/ but I am stillrequesting the originals. Can I take abreak? I may be finished.

because you referred to the squabble that the AgaKhan was witnessing between his children: do you

ERNST & YOUNG TOWER, :1:112 BAY STREET, 8UITE 9DO, TaRaNTo, ONTARIO, M5K 1Hl!!iWWW.vlCTr:2I11YVEASATIM.CDM (4161 a8C-l!!i II? INF'O@VlCTDRYVEASATIM.CDM

ERNST &. YOUNG TOWER, a2Z BAY .TR~£T. &urTE 80e, TORONTO, ONTARIO, MSK 1HeWWW.vICTQRYVERBATIM,cOM (41eiI3&0·&117 INFO@VICTORYVERIIATIM.COM

\

EXHIBITNUMBER PAGENUMBER

Letter dated January 4, 2010 fromNagib Tajdin to Aga Khan withattachmentLetter from Nagib Tajdin to TheAdministrator of Federal Court ofCanada, dated July 27, 2010Letter dated January 24, 2010 fromAga Khan to Nagib TajdinE-mail dated February 15, 2010 fromNagib Tajdin to Michelle ParkesLetter dated February 18, 2010 fromAga Khan to Nagib TajdinReport of G.R. Ospreay, under coverletter dated July 13, 2010

Letter from Nagib Tajdin to PrinceAmyn dated March 17, 2010 ande-mail dated April 2, 2010 fromGenevieve Charnet to Nagib TajdinAnnouncement by the IsmailiLeaders' International Forum, theCouncil for Canada and the Tarioahand Religious Education Board forCanada to be read in allJamatkhannasSecond announcement of the IsmailiLeaders' International Forum, datedApril 15, 2010Affirmation sworn by His HighnessAga Khan dated May 12, 2010E-mail from Brian Gray to NagibTajdin dated May 14, 2010

ERNST •• YDUNG TDWER, azz BAY STRe:E'f, SUITE gDe. TCllltDNTCI, DNTARID. M51( 1HeWWW.VICTOR"YVERBATIM.COMI4161 :s6e-61 17 INFO@VICTDRYVERBA"T'IM.I;lCM

EXHIBITNUMBERPAGE

NUMBER

photograph of Brian Gray, the AgaKhan, Bev Oda, Mr. Maki at theFoundation ceremony of the Aga KhanMuseumCopy of Constitution of Shia ImamiIsmaili Muslims (Current Edition)Printout from ismaili.netadvertisement for The GoldenEdition of "Kalam-e Imam-e Zaman" 102

108

ERNIIT ••.yaUNIi TOWER, aaa BAY STREET. BUITI: '00. TgAaNTC, aNTARla, M51( 1HeWWW.VICTDRYVIER.ATIM.COM (41 •• 3.0·6117 INFO@VICTOIllYVItIiBATIM.CgM

INDEX OF UNDERTAKINGS

REFERENCE PAGE QUESTIONNUMBER NUMBER NUMBER

1 110 6612 111 665

3 112 669

ERNST" YOUNG TOWER, zzz eAY IITREET, SUITE vee. TORONTO, ONTA'UO, M50K 1He.WWWoVICTORYVEIUIATIM.CDM (416) 360-el 17 INI'"C@VICTCRYVERBATlM.COM

N. Tajdin - 118

INDEX OF REFUSALS

REFERENCE PAGE QUESTIONNUMBER NUMBER NUMBER

1 41 236:2 75 4323 78 442

4 100 592

5 100 593

6 101 595

7 104 6188 104 623

9 107 638

10 107 639

11 107 642

12 114 677

ERNST" yaUNG TOWER, 2::1Z BAY .TRICIET,SUITE saa, TORONTO, ONTARIO, MSK 1 HISWWW.VICTCRYVERSATIM.caM(4161360-61171NFO@VICTDRYVIERBATIM.COM

Please be advised that any undertakings, objections, under advisementsand refusals are provided as a service to all counsel, for their guidanceonly, and do not purport to be legally binding or necessarily accurate andare not binding upon Victory Verbatim Reporting Services Inc.

] hereby certify the foregoing to be a true and accurate transcription ofthe above noted proceedings held before me on the 9TH DAY OFAliGUST, 2010 and taken to the best of my skill, ability andunderstanding.

Anthony NgVerbatim Reporter

ERNST" yeUNG TOWleR. 222 BAY STREET, SUITE 900, TORONTO, ONTARID, MaK 1H6WWWoVICTClFlYVE:RBATIM.CCM 14161 360-61 17 INFC@VICTORYVEABATIM.COM