Jim Fournier February 27, 2006 An Optimistic Scenario About Global Warming, Peak Oil and Other...

Post on 15-Dec-2015

214 views 0 download

Tags:

Transcript of Jim Fournier February 27, 2006 An Optimistic Scenario About Global Warming, Peak Oil and Other...

Jim FournierFebruary 27, 2006

An Optimistic Scenario About Global Warming, Peak Oil

and Other Global Crises

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 2

Good News!

…Later

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 3

What Are We to Make of the Global Situation?

http://www.maa.org/devlin/GordianKnot.jpg

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 4

The Human Time Scale

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 5

Four Planetary Crises, orEvolutionary Drivers:

1. Global Warming

2. Peak Oil

3. Peak Population

4. Resource Depletion (Mass Extinction)

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 6

Global Warming: Climate Change

http://www.brighton73.freeserve.co.uk/gw/paleo/millenniumCO2.htm

Atmospheric CO2 & Temperature, 1000 Years

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 7

CO2, Methane, & Temperature Over the Last 160,000 Years

http://www.iitap.iastate.edu/gccourse/chem/gases/images/meth_temp.gif

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 8

Peak Oil

http://www.peakoil.org

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 9

The Green Party View

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 10

Peak OilWill Increase Energy Prices

• Drive Efficiency • Reduce Demand• Enable Renewables• Increase Demand for

Coal & Oil Sand

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 11

Global Energy Use Per Person Has Actually Stopped Growing

http://www.esru.strath.ac.uk/EandE/Web_sites/03-04/biomass/ background%20info.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 12

But the Population has Not, so CO2 is Still Growing Under Kyoto

http://www.climatechange.gc.ca/english/publications/ap2000/Action_Plan_2000.htm

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 13

Long-Term Population Growth

Global Population: Milestones, Hopes, and Concerns Vaclav Smil, PhD http://www.ippnw.org/MGS/V5N2Smil.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 14

Population S-Curve

http://www.gcrio.org/CONSEQUENCES/summer95/fig1.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 15

Peak Population?

http://hydro.iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp/GW/data/global/ciesin-sres/

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 16

Some Plausible Good News On Population

U.N. Population Figures May be Correct, Because Over 50% of the Global Population Now Lives in Cities and a Large Family is a Liability in a City, Even Among the Poor

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 17

Overall Consumption Is Still Growing

http://www.oilcrash.com/articles/kerr_02.htm

Natural Resource Use

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 18

Measured by Weight,95% of All Output from Industrial Activity is Waste

Grasberg Gold Mine, West Papua

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 19

Ecological Footprints Attempt to Combine Many Factors and Fail to Focus on Key Biological Resources:

• Forests• Fisheries• Farmland• Fresh Water

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 20

Destruction of Forests

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 21

Collapse of Fisheries

http://www.fao.org/NEWS/FACTFILE/FF9803-E.HTM

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 22

Exhaustion of Farmland

http://arch.rivm.nl/ieweb/ieweb/databases/images/NH3-fertilizer_sm.jpg

40% of allAgricultural Soils are Seriously Depleted

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 23

Limited Fresh Water Supply

http://www.waterandnature.org/eatlas/html/gm15.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 24

All Put Biodiversity At Risk

http://www.biodiversityhotspots.org/xp/Hotspots

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 25

If We Do Not Change Course, We Will Lose Half the Species on Earth in the Next 100 Years

Tree of Life Web Project http://tolweb.org/tree

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 26

For all of human evolution Nature was something with teeth and claws that could jump out of the dark and eat you. Now, in a single generation that situation has been inverted.Nature is suddenly something fragile that we must protect lest we perish.

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 27

What Are We to Make of the Global Situation?

http://www.maa.org/devlin/GordianKnot.jpg

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 28

One Biological Metaphor Is Cancer

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 29

Will Humanity Turn Out to Be Like a Colony of Mold in a Petri Dish?

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 30

Or Like An Embryo

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 31

Using The White of the Egg to Grow

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 32

A New Form of Complexity?

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 33

Teilhard de Chardin’s Noosphere…

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 34

Nature has repeatedly done just that before.

Life has always invented its way out of the box.

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 35

Here’s the Box

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 36

Periodic Spiral of the Elements

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 37

Eight Fold Spiral Elements

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 38

Inner Spiral of the Elements

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 39

Reframing the Evolution of Technology In the Context of Biological Evolution

Roger Dean

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 40

Life First Derived Energy from Chemicals in the Primordial Soup

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 41

Until Photosynthesis

http://fig.cox.miami.edu/~tkoop/spring00/blnphotosyn.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 42

Only After the Oxygen Released Rusted All of the Iron in the Earth’s Crust

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 43

The Oxygen Level Finally Spiked

Causing Spontaneous Combustion

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 44

Respiration Took Advantage of New High-Energy Oxygen

http://bioweb.wku.edu/courses/BIOL115/Wyatt/Metabolism/Glycolysis2.htm

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 45

Resulting in the Carbon Cycle

http://www.energex.com.au/switched_on/energy_environment/energy_s_html_carboncycle.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 47

The Carbon Cycle Has Remained in Balance Until Deforestation and Fossil Fuels Increased CO2 Levels

http://www.bom.gov.au/info/climate/change/gallery/images/9.jpg

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 48

Peak Oil Is Analogous to Previous Energy Crises on Earth When Our Ancestors, the Microbes, Used Up All of the Most Easily Available Energy

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 49

As Humanity Has Discovered How to Take Advantage of the Immense Fossil Energy Reserves of the Planet, We Have, Like Other Life Forms Before Us, Unbalanced the Atmosphere

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 50

Since the year 2000 even our president has started saying that we are going toward a hydrogen economy. Everyone seems to agree that we need renewable energy.

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 51

The Ratio of Hydrogen to Carbon Has Been Steadily Evolving

• Wood• Peat• Coal• Oil• Natural Gas• Hydrogen

Each has more Hydrogen and less Carbon

Until one arrives at pure Hydrogen

Hydrogen is the smallest element

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 52

Energy In Matter Inevitably Converges on Hydrogen

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 53

Transformation of Energy Media from Wood to Hydrogen

http://people.hofstra.edu/geotrans/eng/ch8en/conc8en/energytransition.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 54

We Can See Other Parallels With Nature As Well?

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 55

Photovoltaics Capture Photons in SiliconJust as Photosynthesis Does with Carbon

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 56

Silicon is Like the Next Octave of Carbon

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 57

Solar Is the Long-term Solution

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 58

Wind Is Cost Effective Now

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 59

Neither can reverse the climate change already set In motion.

http://cires.colorado.edu/science/groups/steffen/greenland/melt2002/melt1992-2002.jpg

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 60

Current Biomass Technology

• Depletes The Soil

• Is Only Carbon Neutral

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 61

We Need a Bridge, Something to Close the Gap Between:

• 6 Quads Renewables Provide Now• .06 Quads Each For Solar & Wind• 100 Quads/Year U.S. Consumes

A Quad Is: 1 Quadrillion BTU1,000,000,000,000 BTU = 580,000 barrels of oil

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 62

If the bridge were not just Carbon Neutral, like current renewables, but Carbon Negative, i.e. could remove net CO2 from the atmosphere, it would be a miracle.

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 63

Terra Preta Agricultural Soil Carbon Breakthrough

• Made in the Amazon 500 Years Ago

• Removes Net CO2 From the Atmosphere

• Restores & Improves Soil Fertility

• Replenished By Soil Organisms

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 64

Biomass Energy Breakthrough The Best Charcoal For The Soil

Also Makes Hydrogen Energy

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 65

Carbon Sequestration Breakthrough

http://www.eprida.com

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 66

Fully Integrated Small Scale Biomass Technology Will:

• Remove CO2 From the Atmosphere

• Return CO2 to the Soil As Fertilizer

• Restore Soil While Adding Nitrogen

• Create Green Diesel Infrastructure

• Create Hydrogen Infrastructure

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 67

Mimics the Carbon Cycle

http://www.energex.com.au/switched_on/energy_environment/energy_s_html_carboncycle.html

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 68

An Octave of the Carbon Cycle

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 69

“Back of the Envelop” Global Calculations

• These are NOT fully proven results• The following are a first pass approximation

of what MIGHT potentially be possible based on what we have seen from initial science, preliminary field trials and first working prototypes of the this technology

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 70

Potential Global Context• We Release 26,700,000,000 Tons of CO2

• One Unit Can Remove 4,000 Tons of CO2

• Soil Organisms Increase This Around 200%

• 3.5M Units To Remove 26.7B Tons of CO2

• Would Also Produce 25B Barrels of Diesel

• Global Oil Production = 26B Barrels (2004)

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 71

How Much Land Would That Take?

• 1 Unit Needs 10 Tons of Biomass per Day

• 1 Unit Needs 3,000 Tons Biomass per Year

• 1 to 10 Tons of Biomass per Acre per Year

• For Each Unit: 300 to 3,000 Acres

• For 3.5 Million Units: 1 to 10 Billion Acres

• Total Global Agricultural Land: 12B Acres

• Does Not Include Forestry Land

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 72

There Is No Guarantee; Stabilizing Climate Change Will Be a Race

• Increase Energy Efficiency• Increase Material Efficiency• Ethanol, Methanol & Other Biofuels• Capture Methane From Compost• Reduce Beef Production (Methane)• Capture & Sequester CO2 From Coal• Solar, Wind, Tidal, Geothermal Heat Pumps

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 73

It Is Plausible That We Could• Reverse Global Warming

• Transition From Fossil Fuels to Renewables

• Transition From Biodiesel to Hydrogen

• Restore Soil Fertility

• Eliminate Nitrogen Runoff

• Eliminate Acid Rain

• Decentralize Wealth Creation

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 74

We Could Transform the Global Situation

http://www.maa.org/devlin/GordianKnot.jpg

Into Something That Feels More Like a Winning Hand of Solitaire

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 75

Plausible Solutions For:

Global Warming Peak Oil Peak Population? Mass Extinction

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 76

An S-Curve Goes from Concave Up to Concave Down at the Point of Inflection

Point of Inflection

If Global Trends Decelerate,What Looked Like Log Curves May Turn Out to be S-Curves

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 77

An S-Curve Implies a Future Plateau Characterized by Climax Technology

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 78

We are undergoing a point of inversion in matter and culture. From this point on our technological evolution in matter may be guided by the recognition of the potential for a climax technology, a state of Meta-Nature. A state as harmonious as nature in the coherence of its design, which, like nature, is the realization of a potential already inherent in the puzzle that is matter.

Meta-Nature

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 79

GEOMAN

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 80

At the Point of Inflection Near the Millennium the System Is:• Changing So Fast That Nothing is Retained

• So Inefficient Nothing Should Be Retained

• First Glimpsing the Potential Future State

• Passing Through the Neck of the Hourglass

• Itself the Global Birth Canal

• Chaotic, Highly Unstable

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 81

The Shift must reframe the perception of society, to at once validate everything that has happened to bring us to this point, while at the same time making it self-evident to everyone that we must each now radically change course in the light of this new found perspective.

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 82

The Shift Point in Time

© James L. Fournier

February 27, 2006 The Planetary Situation 83

As We Pass Through the Neck of the Hourglass There Will BeTwo Key Measures of Success:

• Preservation of Biodiversity

• Achieving Climax Technology