InterlinkingecosystemservicesandOstrom’sframeworkthrough

orienta9oninsustainabilityresearch

KlaraJ.WinkleraandStefanPartelowb,c

aUniversityofOldenburgbLeibnizCenterforTropicalMarineEcology(ZMT)

cJacobsUniversity

@kj_winklerklara.johanna.winkler@uni-oldenburg.de

Outline

•  Social-ecologicalsystems•  EScascade&diagnos9cSESFramework•  SESresearchinsustainabilityscience•  InterlinkingESandSESF

Social–ecologicalsystemthinking

SOCIALSYSTEMDEMANDSIDE

ECOSYSTEMSUPPLYSIDE

Social–ecologicalsystemthinking

SOCIALSYSTEMDEMANDSIDE

ECOSYSTEMSUPPLYSIDE

Social–ecologicalsystemthinking

SOCIALSYSTEMDEMANDSIDE

ECOSYSTEMSUPPLYSIDE

DPSIR

EarthSystemsAnalysis(ESA)

EcosystemServices(ES)

HumanEnvironmentSystemsFramework

(HES)

MaterialandEnergyFlow

Analysis(MEFA)

ManagementandTransi9onFramework

Social-EcologicalSystemsFramework(SESF)

SustainableLivelihoodApproach(SLA)

TheNaturalStep(TNS)

VulnerabilityFramework(TVUL)

Binderetal.,2013

Social–ecologicalsystemthinking

SOCIALSYSTEMDEMANDSIDE

ECOSYSTEMSUPPLYSIDE

DPSIR

EarthSystemsAnalysis(ESA)

EcosystemServices(ES)

HumanEnvironmentSystemsFramework

(HES)

MaterialandEnergyFlow

Analysis(MEFA)

ManagementandTransi9onFramework

Social-EcologicalSystemsFramework(SESF)

SustainableLivelihoodApproach(SLA)

TheNaturalStep(TNS)

VulnerabilityFramework(TVUL)

Binderetal.,2013

EScascadeSOCIALSYSTEMDEMANDSIDE

ECOSYSTEMSUPPLYSIDE

Biodiversity

FuncNons EcosystemService

Biophysicalvalue-domain

HumanWell-being

value

socio-culturalvaluedomain

monetaryvalue-domain

GOVERNANCE

Mar]n

-Lóp

ezeta

l.2014

Diagnos9cSESFramework(SESF)

ECOLOGICALSYSTEM SOCIALSYSTEM

Governance

ActorsResourceUnits

ResourceSystem

InteracNons→Outcomes

Externalecosystems

Social,economicandpoliNcalseWngs

Ostrom,2007

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SESresearchinsustainabilityscience

SystemknowledgeDiagnosNcSESFrameworkEcosystemServices

•  Understandingofecosystem/supplyside

•  Assessmentofecosystemservices(basedonESclassifica9on,e.g.CICES)

Descrip9onof:•  Resourcesystem•  Resourceunits•  Governance•  Actors

TargetknowledgeDiagnosNcSESFrameworkEcosystemServices

•  iden9fica9onofperceivedESbenefits

•  adapta9onofgovernanceprocessthroughstakeholders’perspec9ves

Actors’perspec9ves,goals&values

Transforma9veknowledgeDiagnosNcSESFrameworkEcosystemServices

policypathways,communica9onpathsbetweenactors

•  reconcilingtrade-offsbetweendifferentgoals&values

•  iden9fica9onofgovernancepathways

•  educa9on

SESknowledge

WhatEScanlearnfromSESF•  incorporatestandardized

approachtosocialsystem•  specifysocialsystem&

governancestage–  services-to-ecosystems

WhatSESFcanlearnfromES•  expandonecosystem

func9oningasfundamentalbasisforSES

•  broadenvaluedomains:notonlyeconomic,butalsobiophysical&socio-cultural

Compa9bilityofESandSESF

WhatES&SESFbothcanimproveengagemorewithtransforma9veknowledgeapplica9on

THANKYOU!

KlaraJ.WinklerandStefanPartelow

@kj_winkler

klara.johanna.winkler@uni-oldenburg.de

InterlinkingecosystemservicesandOstrom’sframeworkthrough

orienta9oninsustainabilityresearch

References

•  Binder,C.R.,Hinkel,J.,Bots,P.W.G.,Pahl-Wostl,C.,2013.Comparisonofframeworksforanalyzingsocial-ecologicalsystems.Ecol.Soc.18.doi:10.5751/ES-05551-180426

•  Mar]n-López,B.,Gómez-Baggethun,E.,García-Llorente,M.,Montes,C.,2014.Trade-offsacrossvalue-domainsinecosystemservicesassessment.Ecol.Indic.37,220–228.doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2013.03.003

•  Ostrom,E.,2007.Adiagnos9capproachforgoingbeyondpanaceas.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.U.S.A.104,15181–15187.doi:10.1073/pnas.0702288104