FoME Symposium 2015 | Workshop 9: Story-telling and other New Methods of Evaluation | Han Rakels &...

Post on 08-Feb-2017

591 views 0 download

Transcript of FoME Symposium 2015 | Workshop 9: Story-telling and other New Methods of Evaluation | Han Rakels &...

HAN RAKELS & BERNADETTE VAN DIJCK

www.perspectivity.orginfo@perspectivity.org

Cynefin Framework (Snowden et.al,HBR, 2007)

How to make sense of

many perspectives?

Facilitating Multistakeholder DialogueSystemic Change

Large Group Interventions leading to Emerging Practice

The limits of Face-to-face meetings

“COULD WE HAVE A MINUTE OF YOUR TIME

?”

“WE ARE INTERESTED IN

YOUR OPINION !”

SURVEYS

ASSUMPTIVE SURVEYSLimited applicability in complex settings

Modern technogies

Embracing complexity

Adaptive learning

So what now…?

Sprockler is...A tool and philosophy for adaptive learning

…from stories

to statistics…To generate quantitative (meta) data,

backed-up by qualitative information

- Explanatory power of stories

- Objectivity of numbers

How does it work?

what’s your

STORY?

Can you tell me a story about a moment in the past month that you decided – because of transport security - to cancel a (personal or professional) appointment or decided to take a different route?

Incidents in Kabul

Self-significationMeaning mapping framework

Intuitive and instinctive responses

Fill in the grey areas between multiple choice options

Ownership with respondents

Authentic and more accurate data

The reason for cancelling or rerouting was:Reported security incident

Fear of insecurity

Bipole

The situation in my story happens

Bipole

Rarely Daily

The moment of travel you avoided was: Morning

Afternoon

Evening

Tripole

Tripole

Which area did you avoid in the event of the story?

Picture Pointer

App & Web CollectorOnline &App collector

Collector in action

Avicres &Kindermissionswerk

YouthLEADUNICEF

Univ GhentFuture

Women in conflict (oPt)

VisualizationQUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE

Semi-automated analyses and overviews for ownership, swiftness and users friendliness

Advanced statistical analysis possible

The moment of travel you avoided was:

At night I do not feel safe, and I never go to any invitation, my neighbourhood is too insecure. In the morning I bring my children to school and I'm going to work.

EveningMorning

Afternoon

EveningMorning

Afternoon

The moment of travel you avoided was:

Reported security incident

Fear of insecurity

The reason for cancelling or rerouting was:

Reported security incident

Fear of insecurity

The reason for cancelling or rerouting was:

Which area did you avoid in the event of the story:

Which area did you avoid in the event of the story:

EveningMorning

Afternoon

Reported security incident

Fear of insecurity

Pregnant woman

Others

SCIENTIFIC

INNOVATIVE

ONERSHIP OF DATA

TECHNICALLY ADVANCED

EASY OF USE

ON AND OFFLINE MULTILINGUALSECURE

ANONYMOUS

FLEXIBLE

Some features

UNDER DEVELOPMENT

CLOSING THE LOOP

ApplicationsMonitoring and evaluation

Strategic assessments

Lobby and advocacy

Needs assessments

Organisational DiagnosisCohort studies

Customer satisfaction Trend analysis

Impact asessment

SourcesDavid Cooperrider ‘The Art of Questioning’ on Appreciative Inquiry

Brenda Dervin and Karl Weick on ‘Sensemaking’

Cynthia Kurz and Dave Snowden on ‘Cynefin Framework’ and ‘Sensemaker”

Marvin Weisbord and Sandra Janoff on ‘Future Search’

Robert Keidel on Seeing Organizational Patterns

Charles Osgood on The Measurement of Meaning

COMPLEXITYWhat is emerging?

Does it make any

sense?

National GovernmentCommunity Radio Station ManagersRadio Program MakersJournalists Civil SocietyForeign Radio Development ExpertsUN Organisations

The “whole system” in the room

Future Search – Community Radio Liberia

In what part of the house is fuel poverty most felt?

Picture Pointer

Most of the time you can find me in the streets in the..

TripoleMorning

Afternoon

Evening

Voice of the peopleOf Groningen

MINHA HISTORIA E PRINCIPALMENTE SOBRE...

Um GrupeUm Individuo

“Como minha tarefa de supervisionar, tive receio de não ser bem aceita. Pois ambas as partes não se conheciam. Mas como pessoa observadora que sou fui aos poucos me aproximando e interagindo com”

“Toda sua família com exceção do pai, viveu na casa Esperança, hoje vive ela e uma tia. Seu nascimento foi na casa de abrigo da sede da Avicres, depois foi para a casa Esperança.”

“Conhecer a Avicres e seu trabalho com crianças e adolescente em vuneralida-de social, foi um desafio pais não tinha conhecimento de como via trabalhar com esse pelilico.”