Post on 02-Apr-2015
ERM In Logistics and supply chain
Carl LeemanChief Risk OfficerKatoen Natie 1
Risk Management
can only be efficient if it is
Enterprise wide
2
ERM what’s in the nameERM what’s in the name
• A methodology to ,as good as possible, realize the goals set by a company, and to continue doing so.
• A culture of which the company, and thus all its employees have to be committed to .
• A strategy is easy to copy, a culture is very difficult to copy .
3
Business Unit structureBusiness Unit structure
Katoen Natie HQ
Corporate ServicesCorporate ServicesIT Engineering Finance Risk
Specialty Chemicals
General Cargo & Commodities
Petrochemicals
Projects & Engineering
Consumer Goods & Industry
Liquids
Process Technology
Port Operations
Budget
KTNKTN Risk Management VisionRisk Management Vision
Corporate Objectives
BU Objectives Strategy & operational planning
Action plan
(Internal) Reporting & Communication
Risk identification
Risk evaluation
Identification ofexisting controls
Risk response
Avoid
Share
Reduce
Accept
degree of risk
5
Business ApproachBusiness Approach
Risks Resources
Return
6
THE RISKS OF DOING BUSINESSTHE RISKS OF DOING BUSINESS
1. COUNTRY RISKS
2. CLIENT RISKS
3. PRODUCT RISKS
4. CONTRACT NEGOTIATION RISKS
5. SUPPLIER RISKS
6. RISKS OF PERFORMANCE DIFFICULTIES
7. BRANDNAME / REPUTATION RISKS
8. RISKS OF DAMAGES
9. ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS
7
EU laws on RMEU laws on RM
-In most EU countries we see a lot of rules and regulations on RM for Banks and other financial institutions (Insurers).
-We see very few- to none, for non-financial institutions.
8
ERM, how to proceed ERM, how to proceed ::
1.Identification
2.Evaluation
3.Handling
-It will be impossible to handle all risks detected.
-One will have to make (difficult) choices and/or set priorities.
-It is always better to make the wrong choice than no choice !
9
RISK RISK MAPPINGMAPPING
• Financial impacts (quantitative) & non financial impacts– Financial metric : EBITDA, Result, assets, …– Non financial metrics : victims, reputation, legal disputes, …
• Period of assessment : choose a significant period according to risks
likelihood
Imp
act
Risk MATRIX
Quantitative scale
Qualitative Scale
Likelihood scale
Severity =
Level of Impact + Level of likelihood
Level of impact x Level of likelihood
10
The (new) Bermuda TriangleThe (new) Bermuda Triangle
ComplexityTime Pressure
Risk Averse Society
11
Why expanding outside of Europe ?Why expanding outside of Europe ?
By 2030, 93 per cent of the world’s middle class will live in what is currently termed emerging markets.
For big expansion we have no choice than to look for new business outside Europe
12
Headline Risks (International Headline Risks (International expansion) expansion)
Currency and pricing
Supplier/Customer insolvency (1)
Pandemics
Cyber risk / IT failure (3)
Forecasting / demand risk
Political Instability
Climate change
Single sourcing
Strikes / Disputes (2)
Natural catastrophes
Brand Reputation damage
Intellectual property
All can impact the supply chain in different ways
13
Do not forget to, amongst others :Do not forget to, amongst others :
• Identify key points in your supply chain that control flows of information, physical goods or money so that risk & audit attention can be focused on these areas
• Try to identify what can be controlled, what can be influenced and what can only be monitored.
• Allow scenario planning and stress testing by taking out elements and disrupting flows.
14
Supply Chain Risks, the challengesSupply Chain Risks, the challenges
• understanding your supply chain
• Assessing the risk
• Mapping the interdependencies
• Developing solutions
• The increase in outsourcing to suppliers in more remote / exotic locations, combined with an increasing time and rate pressure is probably the main change in supply chain over the last 10 year
15
Analysis of supplier locations
Analysis of supplier locations
Earthquake
Analysis of supplier locations
Earthquakealysis of supplier locationsFlood
Analysis of supplier locations
Analysis of supplier locations
Earthquake
Flood
Storm
Problem is often elswhereProblem is often elswhere
20
Out of 327 Incidents that disrupted the supply chain
60 % happened at a tier 1 supplier
30 % at tier 2 supplier
10 % at tier 3 or further
(Survey from the Business continuity Institute (USA)
Some importants elements in your Risk Some importants elements in your Risk Management Management
• Contracts / General conditions
• Compliance
• Crisis communicatie
21
Essence of contract’sEssence of contract’s
• Client gives an order
• We execute the order
• The client has to pay for what we did.
23
Important elements in our contracts Important elements in our contracts
• Scoop of the contract
• Term of the contract
• Rate & Payment Terms
• Limitations & Exclusions of liability
• (KPI’s)
24
But sometimes things go wrongBut sometimes things go wrong
• Instructions from client are vague.
• Parties may have different understandings about the same item.
• No traces of verbal agreements
• Sometime, in order to please the client, we put ourselves in trouble.
26
Typical issues with Supply chain contractsTypical issues with Supply chain contracts
• We often start to work without written instructions or clear agreements
Client changes his mind …….!
• Make sure to have clear instructions and to explain them to operational or administrative people.
• Follow up if you are paid in time for everything you did
in some cases 20% of what was done was not invoiced On average clients exceed payment terms by 30%
27
Corruption & Bribery Rules & Corruption & Bribery Rules & RegulationsRegulations
1 ) US Foreign Corruption Practices Act (FCPA)
•Exists more than 30years but increased dramatically the last 6 years•Only a minor US connection is sufficient for US authorities to enforce FCPA rules•The FCPA prohibits US companies & individuals from bribing non US officials.•Wide variety of industries investigated (oil & gas, Healthcare, pharmaceuticals, transportation, etc. .)
•8 out of 10 largest FCPA enforcements involved non US companies & citizens
•Reality : - Siemens paid 800 million USD to settle US anti corruption charges
(on top of same amount to German authorities)
- FCPA : 2009 : 641 Million USD penalties
2010 : 1,8 Billion USD in fines
• •
29
Corruption & Bribery Corruption & Bribery Rules & Regulations Rules & Regulations IIII
2) UK Bribery Act
• Effective since July 1st 2011
• Regarded as gold standard in anti-corruption laws
Due to Extra –territotial application & aggressive enforcement
• Includes strict criminal liabilities for corporate offence of failing to prevent bribery
30
Corruption & Bribery Corruption & Bribery Rules & Rules & Regulations IIIRegulations III
3) International Anti Bribery Conventions
•- UN convention against corruption (2005)
•- OECD convention on combating Bribery
(34 members including Brazil, Argentina, South Africa)
•- ………..
31
Anti Corruption & Bribery To DoAnti Corruption & Bribery To Do’’ss
• Educate employees & management
• Basic rules & standards (Compliance Program / code of conduct)
• Companies fundamental values and principles
• Policy & Procedure (e.g. (financial) reporting, authority & accountability, Hotline (?))
• In M&A’s asset deal instead of share deals can avoid a lot of (liability) problems
To leak (info) or not to leak ?
• Clause in contract with suppliers on bribery : No involvement & Hold harmless
• Remember the “non, or controlled, subcontracting clause” in suppliers contract
32
Perception Perception ≠ Fact≠ Fact’’ss
33
CONTINGENCY PLAN
BeforeBefore DuringDuring AfterAfter
Putting in Place & Testing
Talk to local authoritiescfr. Crisis center
Up to date on a yearly basis
Alarm
Start up contingency plan
Evacuation
Fire fighting
Inform : Clients
Authorities
Fire fighters
Neighbors
Social media
1)Repair/ Rebuild
warehouse & equipment
2) Support to clients
3) Handle third party
claimsInform People
Check if things are in place as it should be
Crisis communicationCrisis communicationFacingFacing the media Radio / TV I the media Radio / TV I
• All declarations, and or external communications should be coordinated
internally in order to have one message towards clients,authorities, employees,
and other third parties.
(What about : subsidiaries versus HQ in different time zones?)
• Do not forget:
- to have one spokesman
- to provide all your own employees with the same information.
35
FacingFacing the media : Radio / TV 2 the media : Radio / TV 2
• 1) NEVER TELL A LIE.
Do not try to hide info, everything does surface sooner or later.
• 2) HAVE ONLY ONE SPOKESMAN.
Journalists just love to hear contradictory statements; be aware. It is also very
important to provide your own employees with identical information, so that only
one identical version is communicated ‘to the outside world’. (Use also your
WEBSITE / INTRANET to provide that same info to anyone wishing to know it).
• 3) IF THERE ARE CASUALTIES, ALWAYS SHOW COMPASSION.
• 4) BE PREPARED FOR THE 3 CLASSIC QUESTIONS:
36
FacingFacing the media : Radio / TV 3 the media : Radio / TV 3
• -WHAT HAPPENED?• -WHY DID IT HAPPEN? • -WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO TO PREVENT THIS FROM HAPPENING AGAIN?
It is highly likely that you will not know the answers at that particular moment, and that is no problem as long as you show that you were prepared for the situation, say that these issues are still under investigation, will inform them as soon as you have any news, show them
that you are open and that there are no secrets to hide.
• 5) NEVER EVER MAKE ANY SPECULATIONS IN FRONT OF THE MEDIA.
If you are not sure about something, then do not say so! “We think that it must have been this or that” = SUICIDE.
37
FacingFacing the media : Radio / TV 4 the media : Radio / TV 4
• 6) ALWAYS SHOW THEM THAT YOU ARE IN CONTROL OF THE SITUATION.
“We are going to do this, this and that”.
This will show them that you are well prepared and that you know exactly what to do.
• 7) TELL THEM WHEN YOU WILL MEET OR INFORM THEM AGAIN.
38
But, The Most important But, The Most important is to : is to :
Make sure all you calculations are Make sure all you calculations are correctcorrect
40
Otherwise this Can Happen!Otherwise this Can Happen!
41
J.I.M J.I.M PrinciplePrinciple
• Avoid Jail
• Be aware of your Image
• Continue to make Money
42
Thank you for your attention
43