ACI  Journal  Submission    and  Evalua4on  Process  

   By  

Dr.  Nongyao  Premkamolnetr  ACI  Steering  Commi@ee  

   

27/10/2014

1

ACI  Journal  Submission  and  Evalua4on  Process

• Ac+on  by  Editor  of  journalSubmission

• Ac+on  by  ACI  Secretariat  Pre-­‐

selec4on

• Ac+on  by  NCI  Admin  /  ACI  Steering  CommiAee  /  ACI  SecretariatEvalua4on

2

3  

ACI  journal  submission  work  flow  

Fill  in  the  ACI  +tle  sugges+on  form  by    editor  

Do  not  review  this  +tle

No Yes

No Yes

Review  this  +tle  via  ACI  online  evalua+on  form

Reviewers  selected  by  TCI,  MCC,  IDCI

Reviewers  selected  by  ACI  secretariat

pre-­‐selec+on  by  ACI  secretariat  

Final  decision  by  ACI  Steering  CommiAee

Reject  this  +tleAccept  this  +tle  

for  ACI

Online  Journal  submission

4

Required  informa.on  in  the  submission  form

Title  (Na+ve)

Title  (English)

ISSN

Journal  Owner

Editor

Affilia+on  of  Journal

Phone

Email

Subject  Catagory

Website

Online  Submission?

Indexed  in  any  database?

Level  of  peer  review

Star+ng  Year

Number  of  issue  per  year

Country

5

Required  informa.on  in  the  submission  form  (cont.)

•  Ar+cle•  Reviewer’s  name•  Reviewer’s  address

Peer  review  Informa+on

•  Names•  Academic  posi+on•  Posi+on  in  the  Editorial  Board

•  Affilia+on

Editorial  board  

informa+on

• Vol./No./Year• Total  number  of  ar+cles

• Number  of  ar+cles  authored  by  outsiders

Outsider  authors

• of  the  3  latest  issuesElectronic  File

6

Journal  Submission  Form  (p.1)

7

Journal  Submission  Form  (p.2)

8

Journal  Submission  Form  (p.3)

9

10  

ACI  journal  submission  work  flow  

Fill  in  the  ACI  +tle  sugges+on  form  by    editor  

Do  not  review  this  +tle

No Yes

No Yes

Review  this  +tle  via  ACI  online  evalua+on  form

Reviewers  selected  by  TCI,  MCC,  IDCI

Reviewers  selected  by  ACI  secretariat

pre-­‐selec+on  by  ACI  secretariat  

Final  decision  by  ACI  Steering  CommiAee

Reject  this  +tleAccept  this  +tle  

for  ACI

Example  of  the  filled  in  submission  form

11

12  

ACI  journal  submission  work  flow  

Fill  in  the  ACI  +tle  sugges+on  form  by    editor  

Do  not  review  this  +tle

No Yes

No Yes

Review  this  +tle  via  ACI  online  evalua+on  form

Reviewers  selected  by  TCI,  MCC,  IDCI

Reviewers  selected  by  ACI  secretariat

pre-­‐selec+on  by  ACI  secretariat  

Final  decision  by  ACI  Steering  CommiAee

Reject  this  +tleAccept  this  +tle  

for  ACI

Evalua+on  Process  by  NCI/ACI  secretariat

Select Reviewer

13

14  

ACI  journal  submission  work  flow  

Fill  in  the  ACI  +tle  sugges+on  form  by    editor  

Do  not  review  this  +tle

No Yes

No Yes

Review  this  +tle  via  ACI  online  evalua+on  form

Reviewers  selected  by  TCI,  MCC,  IDCI

Reviewers  selected  by  ACI  secretariat

pre-­‐selec+on  by  ACI  secretariat  

Final  decision  by  ACI  Steering  CommiAee

Reject  this  +tleAccept  this  +tle  

for  ACI

Evalua+on  Form  by  Assigned  Reviewer  (p.1)

15

Evalua+on  Form  by  Assigned  Reviewer  (p.2)

16

Evalua+on  Result  (p.1)

17

Evalua+on  Result  (p.2)

18

Key  in  data  and  send  to  ACI  secretariat  by  

editors

Send  back  to  editors  for  data  

edi+ng

No Yes

Import  data  to  ACI  database  by    ACI  secretariat  

Recheck  completeness  of  the  data  by  ACI  secretariat  

ACI  data  input  work  flow  

Download  data  template  from  ACI  website  by  editors

19

Q&A  and  

Thank  You

20