70103358 Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service

7/17/2019 70103358 Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/70103358-revised-uniform-rules-on-administrative-cases-in-the-civil-service 1/23

REVISED UNIFORM RULES ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASES IN THE

CIVIL SERVICE

The Civil Service Commission, through Resolution No. 99-1936 dated August 31,1999. adopted the ne

!"ni#orm Rules in Administrative Cases in the Civil Service$ hich ill govern the conduct o# disciplinar% and

non-disciplinar% proceedings in administrative cases &rought &e#ore this Commission and'or other government

agencies, e(cept here special la provides otherise,

The said resolution as pu&lished in the )anila Standard on Septem&er 11. 1999 and thus it ill ta*e e##ect on

Septem&er +, 1999. n this regard, all concerned are enoined to #ollo strictl% the said ne Rules.

/Sgd.0 CRA2N A)A 4. 5 N

Chairman17 Septem&er 1999

Resolution No. 99-1936 was published Sept. 11, 1999 on pages 9-10 of the Manila Standard.

Resolution No. 991936

Whereas, Section 1+ /+0, Chapter 3. Title , Su&title /A0, 8oo* o# Administrative Code o# 19: /(ecutive

rder No. +9+0 empoers the Civil Service Commission to prescri&e, amend and en#orce rules and regulations to

e##ectivel% carr% out its mandate;

Whereas, Section 1+ /110, Chapter 3, Title , Su&title /A0, 8oo* o# the same Code provides, in part, that the

Commission shall hear and decide administrative cases instituted &% or &rought &e#ore it directl% or on appeal,including contested appointments, and revie decisions and actions o# its o##ices and o# the agencies attached to it;

Whereas, the e(isting rules and regulations in administrative cases need to &e updated and revised to ma*e them

more responsive to the demands #or speed%, #air and udicious disposition o# cases;

N<, T=R>R, the Commission here&% adopts and promulgates the #olloing rules that shall govern

disciplinar% and non-disciplinar% proceedings in administrative cases.

RULE I

GENERAL ROVISIONS

Section 1. Title. - These Rules shall &e *non as the "ni#orm Rules on Administrative Cases in

the Civil Service.

Section +. Coverage and Definition of Terms. - These Rules shall &e applica&le to all cases

&rought &e#ore the Civil Service Commission and other government agencies, e(cept here aspecial la provides otherise.

The terms hereunder shall &e construed as #ollos?

a. CIVIL SERVICE is the generic term hich re#ers to all men and omen in all &ranches,

su&divisions, instrumentalities and agencies o# the 4overnment, including government-oned orcontrolled corporations ith original charters.

&. COMMISSION re#ers to the Civil Service Commission /Central ##ice and Regional ##ices0.

c. COMMISSION ROER re#ers to the Civil Service Commission-Central ##ice.

d. CIVIL SERVICE REGIONAL OFFICES re#er to the si(teen /160 Civil Service Regional##ices and those hich ma% &e su&se@uentl% created, each headed &% a Regional 5irector.

e. DEARTMENT re#ers to an% o# the e(ecutive departments or entities having the categor% o# a

department, including the udiciar% and the other constitutional commissions, and o##ices.

#. AGENC! re#ers to an% &ureau, o##ice, commission, administration, &oard, committee, institute,

corporation ith original charter, state universities and colleges, or an% other unit o# the national

government as ell as provincial, cit% or municipal government.

g. DISCILINING AUTHORIT! re#ers to the person, tri&unal or &od% dul% authoried to

suspend, dismiss or discipline o##icials and emplo%ees in the Civil Service.

h. AOINTING AUTHORIT! re#ers to the person or &od% dul% authoried to issue

appointments in the civil service.

i. ERSONNEL ACTION re#ers to an% action denoting the movement or progress o# personnel

in the Civil Service hich shall include appointment through certi#ication, promotion, trans#er,reinstatement, reemplo%ment, -detail, reassignment, secondment, demotion and separation #rom

the service.

. RESONDENT re#ers to the person ho is #ormall% charged &% the disciplining authorit%.

*. ERSON COMLAINED OF re#ers to the person ho is the su&ect o# a complaint &ut ho

is not as %et #ormall% charged &% the disciplining authorit%

l. ART! ADVERSEL! AFFECTED re#ers to the respondent against hom a decision in a

disciplinar% case has &een rendered.

m. FORUM"SHOING re#ers to the #iling o# an administrative action or complaint &e#ore

another agenc% or an% tri&unal against the same part% involving the same acts or causes o# action

and relie#.

m. #UALIFIED NE$T"IN"RAN% re#ers to the emplo%ee ho is appointed under a permanent

status to a position previousl% determined to &e a ne(t-in-ran* to the vacanc% and ho meets the

re@uirements #or appointment thereto.

o. THIRD LEVEL re#ers to positions in the Career (ecutive Service /CS0 hich include"ndersecretar%, Assistant Secretar%, 8ureau 5irector, Regional 5irector, Assistant Regional

5irector and other o##icers o# e@uivalent ran*.

p. RO&ATIONAR! EMLO!EE re#ers to the emplo%ee ho is issued an original

appointment and ho is re@uired to undergo the #irst si( /60 months o# service on a pro&ationar%

status.

Section 3. Technical Rules in Administrative Investigations. - Administrative investigations shall

&e conducted ithout necessaril% adhering strictl% to the technical rules o# procedure and evidence

applica&le to udicial proceedings.

Section 7. Jurisdiction of the Civil Service Commission. - The Civil Service Commission shall

hear and decide administrative cases instituted &%, or &rought &e#ore it, directl% or on appeal,

including contested appointments, and shall revie decisions and actions o# its o##ices and o# the

agencies attached to it.

(cept as otherise provided &% the Constitution or &% la, the Civil Service Commission shall

have the #inal authorit% to pass upon the removal, separation and suspension o# all o##icers andemplo%ees in the civil service and upon all matters relating to the conduct, discipline and

e##icienc% o# such o##icers and emplo%ees.

Section B. Jurisdiction of the Civil Service Commission Proper. - The Civil Service Commission

roper shall have urisdiction over the #olloing cases?

A. Dis'i(lin)*+

1. 5ecisions o# Civil Service Regional ##ices &rought &e#ore it on petition #or revie;

+. 5ecisions o# heads o# departments, agencies, provinces, cities, municipalities and other

instrumentalities, imposing penalties e(ceeding thirt% da%s suspension or #ine in an

amount e(ceeding thirt% da%s salar% &rought &e#ore it on appeal;

3. Complaints &rought against Civil Service Commission roper personnel;

7. Complaints against third level o##icials ho are not presidential appointees;

B. Complaints against Civil Service o##icials and emplo%ees hich are not acted upon &%the agencies and such other complaints re@uiring direct or immediate action, in the

interest o# ustice;

6. Re@uests #or trans#er o# venue o# hearing on cases &eing heard &% Civil Service

Regional ##ices;

. Appeals #rom the rder o# reventive Suspension; and

:. Such other actions or re@uests involving issues arising out o# or in connection ith the

#oregoing enumerations.

&. Non"Dis'i(lin)*+

1. 5ecisions o# Civil Service Regional ##ices &rought &e#ore it;

+. Re@uests #or #avora&le recommendation on petition #or e(ecutive clemenc%;

3. rotests against the appointment, or other personnel actions, involving third level

o##icials; and

7. Such other analogous actions or petitions arising out o# or in relation ith the

#oregoing enumerations.

Section 6. Jurisdiction of Civil Service Regional Offices. - The Civil Service Regional ##ices

shall have urisdiction over the #olloing cases?

A. Dis'i(lin)*+

1. Complaints initiated &%, or &rought &e#ore, the Civil Service Regional ##ices providedthat the alleged acts or omissions ere committed ithin the urisdiction o# the Regional

##ice, including Civil Service e(amination anomalies or irregularities and the persons

complained o# are emplo%ees o# agencies, local or national, ithin said geographical

areas;

+. Complaints involving Civil Service Regional ##ice personnel ho are appointees o#

said o##ice; and

3. etitions to place respondent under reventive Suspension.

&. Non"Dis'i(lin)*+

1. 5isapproval o# appointments &rought &e#ore it on appeal;

+. rotests against the appointments o# #irst and second level emplo%ees &rought &e#ore itdirectl% or on appeal;

3. 5ecisions o# national agencies and local government units ithin their geographical

&oundaries relative to personnel actions and non-disciplinar% cases &rought &e#ore it on

appeal; and

7. Re@uests #or accreditation o# services and corrections o# personal in#ormation in therecords o# the Commission.

Section . Jurisdiction of Heads of Agencies. - =eads o# 5epartments, agencies, provinces, cities,

municipalities and other instrumentalities shall have original concurrent urisdiction, ith the

Commission, over their respective o##icers and emplo%ees.

A. Dis'i(lin)*+

1. Complaints involving their respective personnel. Their decisions shall &e #inal in case

the penalt% imposed is suspension #or not more than thirt% da%s or #ine in an amount note(ceeding thirt% /3D0 da%s salar%.

5ecisions o# =eads o# Agencies imposing a penalt% o# removal shall &e e(ecutor% onl%a#ter con#irmation &% the 5epartment Secretar% concerned.

&. Non",is'i(lin)*+

1. rotests against the appointments o# their respective personnel. The% shall have

original concurrent urisdiction ith the Civil Service Regional ##ice concerned; and

+. Complaints on personnel actions and other non-disciplinar% actions o# their respective

personnel.

RULE II

DISCILINAR! CASES

Section :. Complaint. - A complaint against a civil service o##icial or emplo%ee shall not &e given

due course unless it is in riting and su&scri&ed and sorn to &% the complainant. =oever, in

cases initiated &% the proper disciplining authorit%, the complaint need not &e under oath.

No anon%mous complaint shall &e entertained unless there is o&vious truth or merit to the

allegations therein or supported &% documentar% or direct evidence, in hich case the person

complained o# ma% &e re@uired to comment.

The complaint should &e ritten in a clear, simple and concise language and in a s%stematic

manner as to apprise the civil servant concerned o# the nature and cause o# the accusation against

him and to ena&le him to intelligentl% prepare his de#ense or anser.

The complaint shall contain the #olloing?

a.. #ull name and address o# the complainant;

&. #ull name and address o# the person complained o# as ell as his position and o##ice o#

emplo%ment;

c. a narration o# the relevant and material #acts hich shos the acts or omissions allegedl%

committed &% the civil servant;

d. certi#ied true copies o# documentar% evidence and a##idavits o# his itnesses, i# an%; and

e. certi#ication or statement o# non-#orum shopping.

n the a&sence o# an% one o# the a#orementioned re@uirements, the complaint shall &e dismissed.

Section 9. hen and here to !ile a Complaint. - (cept hen otherise provided #or &% la,

an administrative complaint ma% &e #iled at an%time ith the Commission, proper heads o#departments, agencies, provinces, cities, municipalities and other instrumentalities.

Section 1D. ithdra"al of the Complaint. - The ithdraal o# the complaint does not result in its

outright dismissal nor discharge the person complained o# #rom an% administrative lia&ilit%. <here

there is o&vious truth or merit to the allegation in the complaint or here there is documentar%

evidence that ould tend to prove the guilt o# the person complained o#, the same should &e given

due course.

Section 11. Action on the Complaint. - "pon receipt o# a complaint hich is su##icient in #orm

and su&stance, the disciplining authorit% shall re@uire the person complained o# to su&mit a

Counter-A##idavit'Comment under oath ithin three /30 da%s #rom receipt.

Section 1+. Preliminar# Investigation. - A reliminar% nvestigation involves the e parte

e(amination o# records and documents su&mitted &% the complainant and the person complained

o#, as ell as documents readil% availa&le #rom other government o##ices. 5uring said

investigation, the parties are given the opportunit% to su&mit a##idavits and counter-a##idavits.

>ailure o# the person complained o# to su&mit his counter a##idavit shall &e considered as a aiver

thereo#.

Therea#ter, i# necessar%, the parties ma% &e summoned to a con#erence here the investigator ma%

propound clari#icator% and other relevant @uestions.

"pon receipt o# the counter-a##idavit or comment under oath, the disciplining authorit% ma% nodetermine hether a prima #acie case e(ist to arrant the issuance o# a #ormal charge.

A #act-#inding investigation ma% &e conducted #urther or prior to the preliminar% investigation #or

the purpose o# ascertaining the truth. A preliminar% investigation necessaril% includes a #act-

#inding investigation.

>or this purpose, preliminar% investigation ma% &e entrusted &% the Commission to la%ers o#

other agencies pursuant to Section 9.

Section 13. Duration of the Investigation. - A preliminar% investigation shall commence not later

than #ive /B0 da%s #rom receipt o# the complaint &% the disciplining authorit% and shall &e

terminated ithin thirt% /3D0 da%s therea#ter.

Section 17. Investigation Report. - <ithin #ive /B0 da%s #rom the termination o# the preliminar%

investigation, the investigating o##icer shall su&mit the nvestigation Report and the complete

records o# the case to the disciplining authorit%.

Section 1B. Decision or Resolution After Preliminar# Investigation. - # a prima #acie case is

esta&lished during the investigation, a #ormal charge shall &e issued &% the disciplining authorit% A

#ormal investigation shall #ollo.

n the a&sence o# a prima #acie case, the complaint shall &e dismissed.

Section 16. !ormal Charge. - A#ter a #inding o# a prima #acie case, the disciplining authorit% shall

#ormall% charge the person complained o#. The #ormal charge shall contain a speci#ication o#

charge/s0, a &rie# statement o# material or relevant #acts, accompanied &% certi#ied true copies o#

the documentar% evidence, i# an%, sorn statements covering the testimon% o# itnesses, a

directive to anser the charge/s0 in riting under oath in not less than sevent%-to /+0 hours

#rom receipt thereo#, an advice #or the respondent to indicate in his anser hether or not he

elects a #ormal investigation o# the charge/s0, and a notice that he is entitled to &e assisted &% a

counsel o# his choice.

# the respondent has su&mitted his comment and counter-a##idavits during the preliminar%investigation, he shall &e given the opportunit% to su&mit additional evidence.

The disciplining authorit% shall not entertain re@uests #or clari#ication, &ills o# particulars or

motions to dismiss hich are o&viousl% designed to dela% the administrative proceedings. # an% o#

these pleadings are interposed &% the respondent, the same shall &e considered as an anser and

shall &e evaluated as such.

Section 1. Ans"er. - The anser, hich is in riting and under oath, shall &e speci#ic and shall

contain material #acts and applica&le las, i# an%, including documentar% evidence, sorn

statements covering testimonies o# itnesses, i# there &e an%, in support o# his case. t shall also

include a statement indicating hether or not he elects a #ormal investigation.

Section 1:. !ailure to !ile an Ans"er. - # the respondent #ails or re#uses to #ile his anser to the

#ormal charge ithin #ive /B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#, he shall &e considered to have aived hisright thereto and #ormal investigation ma% commence.

Section 19. Preventive Suspension. - "pon petition o# the complainant or !otu proprio, the

proper disciplining authorit% ma% issue an order o# preventive suspension upon service o# the

>ormal Charge, or immediatel% therea#ter to an% su&ordinate o##icer or emplo%ee under his

authorit% pending an investigation, i# the charge involves?

a. dishonest%;

&. oppression;

c. grave misconduct;

d. neglect in the per#ormance o# dut%; or

e. i# there are reasons to &elieve that the respondent is guilt% o# charges hich ould arrant hisremoval #rom the service.

An order o# preventive suspension ma% &e issued to temporaril% remove the respondent #rom the

scene o# his mis#easance or mal#easance and to preclude the possi&ilit% o# e(erting undue

in#luence or pressure on the itnesses against him or tampering o# documentar% evidence on #ile

ith his ##ice.

n lieu o# preventive suspension, #or the same purpose, the proper disciplining authorit% or head o#o##ice, ma% reassign respondent to another unit o# the agenc% during the #ormal hearings.

Section +D. Duration of Preventive Suspension. - <hen the administrative case against an o##icer

or emplo%ee under preventive suspension is not #inall% decided &% the disciplining authorit%

ithin the period o# ninet% /9D0 da%s a#ter the date o# his preventive suspension, unless otherise

provided &% special la, he shall &e automaticall% reinstated in the service; provided that, hen

the dela% in the disposition o# the case is due to the #ault, negligence or petition o# the respondent,the period o# dela% should not &e included in the counting o# the 9D calendar da%s period o#

preventive suspension. rovided #urther that should the respondent &e on )aternit%'aternit%

leave, said preventive suspension shall &e de#erred or interrupted until such time that said leave

has &een #ull% eno%ed.

Section +1. Remedies from the Order of Preventive Suspension. - The respondent ma% #ile a

motion #or reconsideration ith the disciplining authorit% or ma% elevate the same to the Civil

Service Commission &% a% o# an appeal ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#.

Section ++. Conduct of !ormal Investigation. - Although the respondent does not re@uest a

#ormal investigation, one shall nevertheless &e conducted &% the disciplining authorit% here #rom

the allegations o# the complaint and the anser o# the respondent, including the supporting

documents o# &oth parties, the merits o# the case cannot &e decided udiciousl% ithout conducting

such investigation. The investigation shall &e held not earlier than #ive /B0 da%s nor later than ten

/1D0 da%s #rom receipt o# the respondentEs anser. Said investigation shall &e #inished ithin thirt%

/3D0 da%s #rom the issuance o# the #ormal charge or the receipt o# the anser unless the period ise(tended &% the disciplining authorit% in meritorious cases.

>or this purpose, the Commission ma% entrust the #ormal investigation to la%ers o# other

agencies pursuant to Section 9.

Section +3. Pro$Hearing Conference. - At the commencement o# the #ormal investigation, the

=earing ##icer ma% conduct a pre-hearing con#erence #or the parties to appear, consider and

agree on an% o# the #olloing?

a. Stipulation o# #acts;

&. Simpli#ication o# issues;

c. denti#ication and mar*ing o# evidence o# the parties;

d. <aiver o# o&ections to admissi&ilit% o# evidence;

e. imiting the num&er o# itnesses, and their names;

#. 5ates o# su&se@uent hearings; and

g. Such other matters as ma% aid in the prompt and ust resolution o# the case.

The parties ma% su&mit position paper'memoranda and su&mit the case #or resolution &ased on theresult o# the pre-hearing con#erence ithout an% need #or #urther hearings.

Section +7. Continuous Hearing %ntil Terminated& Postponement. - =earings shall &e conducted

on the hearing dates set &% the =earing ##icer or as agreed upon during the pre-hearing

con#erence.

<here no pre-hearing con#erence is conducted, the parties, their counsel and itnesses, i# an%,

shall &e given a notice o# at least #ive /B0 da%s &e#ore the #irst scheduled hearing speci#%ing the

time, date and place o# the said hearing and su&se@uent hearings. Therea#ter, the schedule o#

hearings previousl% set shall &e strictl% #olloed ithout #urther notice. A part% shall &e granted

onl% three /30 postponements upon oral or ritten re@uests. A #ourth postponement ma% &e

granted onl% upon ritten re@uest and su&ect to the discretion o# the disciplining authorit%.

# the respondent #ails or re#uses to appear during the scheduled hearings despite due notice, the

investigation shall proceed e( parte and the respondent is deemed to have aived his right to &e present and to su&mit evidence in his #avor during those hearings.

Section +B. Preliminar# 'atters. - At the start o# the hearing, the hearing o##icer shall note the

appearances o# the parties and shall proceed ith the reception o# evidence #or the complainant.

# the respondent appears ithout the aid o# a counsel, he shall &e deemed to have aived his right

thereto.

8e#ore ta*ing the testimon% o# a itness, the hearing o##icer shall place him under oath and then

ta*e his name, address, civil status, age, and place o# emplo%ment.

A sorn statement o# a itness/es0 properl% identi#ied and a##irmed shall constitute his directtestimon%, cop% #urnished the other part%.

Clari#icator% @uestions ma% also &e as*ed.

Section +6. Appearance of Counsel. - An% counsel appearing &e#ore an% hearing or investigation

shall mani#est orall% or in riting, his appearance #or either the respondent or complainant, stating

his #ull name, 8 receipt and e(act address here he can &e served ith notices and other

pleadings. An% pleading or appearance o# a counsel ithout compl%ing ith the a&ove stated

re@uirements shall not &e recognied.

Section +. Order of Hearing. - "nless the =earing ##icer directs otherise, the order o# hearingma% &e as #ollos?

a. The prosecution shall present its evidence su&ect to the pre-hearing agreement;

&. Cross-e(amination &% the part%;

c. There ma% &e redirect and re-cross e(amination;

d. The respondent shall then o##er evidence in support o# his de#ense #olloing the same order;

e. Re&uttal and sur-re&uttal, i# an%.

<hen the presentation o# evidence has &een concluded, the parties shall #ormall% o##er their

evidence either orall% or in riting and therea#ter o&ections thereto ma% also &e made eitherorall% or in riting. A#ter hich, &oth parties ma% &e given time to su&mit their respective

memorandum hich in no case shall &e &e%ond #ive /B0 da%s a#ter the termination o# the

investigation.

>ailure to .su&mit the same ithin the given period shall &e considered a aiver thereo#.

Section +:. O()ections. - All o&ections raised during the hearing shall &e resolved &% the hearing

o##icer. =oever, o&ections that cannot &e ruled upon &% the hearing o##icer shall &e noted ith

the in#ormation that the same shall &e included in the memorandum o# the concerned part% to &e

ruled upon &% the proper disciplining authorit% The =earing ##icer shall accept all evidence

deemed material and relevant to the case. n case o# dou&t, he shall allo the admission o#evidence su&ect to the o&ection interposed against its admission.

Section +9. 'ar*ings. - All documentar% evidence or e(hi&its shall &e propert% mar*ed &% letters

/A,8,C, etc.0 i# presented &% the complainant and &% num&ers /1,+,3, etc.0 i# presented &% the

respondent. These shall #orm part o# the complete records o# the case.

Section 3D. Re+uest for Su(poena. - # a part% desires the attendance o# a itness or the

production o# documents, he shall ma*e a re@uest #or the issuance o# the necessar% su&poena adtestifi"andu! and'or su&poena du"es te"u!, at least three /30 da%s &e#ore the scheduled hearing.

Section 31. Issuance of Su(poena. - The =earing ##icer ma% issue su&poena ad testifi"andu! to

compel the attendance o# itnesses and su&poena du"es te"u! #or the production o# documents or

things.

Section 3+. Records of Proceedings. - Records o# the proceedings during the #ormal investigationma% &e ta*en in shorthand or stenot%pe or an% other means o# recording .

Section 33. !iling of 'otions, Petitions, Appeals and Other Pleadings. - An% motion, petition,

appeal and other pleadings sent &% mail shall &e deemed #iled on the date shon &% the postmar*

on the envelope hich shall &e attached to the records o# the case and in case o# personal deliver%,

the date stamped thereon &% the disciplining o##ice.

Section 37. -ffect of the Pendenc# of an Administrative Case. - endenc% o# an administrative

case shall not dis@uali#% respondent #or promotion or #rom claiming maternit%'paternit% &ene#its.

>or this purpose, a pending administrative case shall &e construed as #ollos?

a. <hen the disciplining authorit% has issued a #ormal charge; or

&. n case o# a complaint #iled &% a private person, a prima #acie case is #ound to e(ist &% the

disciplining authorit%.

Section 3B. !ormal Investigation Report. - <ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s a#ter the conclusion o# the

#ormal investigation, a report containing a narration o# the material #acts esta&lished during the

investigation, the #indings and the evidence supporting said #indings, as ell as the

recommendations, shall &e su&mitted &% the =earing ##icer ith the disciplining authorit%. The

complete records o# the case shall &e attached to the Report o# nvestigation.

The complete records shall &e s%stematicall% and chronologicall% arranged, paged and securel%

&ound to prevent loss. A ta&le o# contents shall &e prepared. <hoever is in-charge o# thetransmittal o# the complete records shall &e held responsi&le #or an% loss or suppression o# pages

thereo#.

Section 36. hen Case is Decided. - The disciplining authorit% shall render his decision on the

case ithin thirt% /3D0 da%s #rom receipt o# the Report o# nvestigation.

Section 3. !inalit# of Decisions. - A decision rendered &% heads o# agencies here&% a penalt%o# suspension #or not more than thirt% /3D0 da%s or a #ine in an amount not e(ceeding thirt% /3D0

da%sE salar% is imposed, shall &e #inal and e(ecutor% =oever, i# the penalt% imposed is

suspension e(ceeding thirt% /3D0 da%s, or #ine in an amount e(ceeding thirt% /3D0 da%s salar% the

same shall &e #inal and e(ecutor% a#ter the lapse o# the reglementar% period #or #iling a motion #or

reconsideration or an appeal and no such pleading has &een #iled.

RULE III

REMEDIES

Section 3:. !iling of 'otion for Reconsideration. - The part% adversel% a##ected &% the decisionma% #ile a motion #or reconsideration ith the disciplining authorit% ho rendered the same ithin

#i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#.

Section 39. hen deemed filed. - A motion #or reconsideration sent &% mail shall &e deemed #iled

on the date shon &% the postmar* on the envelope hich shall &e attached to the records o# the

case and in case o# personal deliver%, the date stamped thereon &% the proper o##ice.

Section 7D. rounds for 'otion for Reconsideration. - The motion #or reconsideration shall &e &ased on an% o# the #olloing?

a. Ne evidence has &een discovered hich materiall% a##ects the decision rendered, or

&. The decision is not supported &% the evidence on record, or

c. rrors o# la or irregularities have &een committed preudicial to the interest o# the movant.

Section 71. /imitation. - nl% one motion #or reconsideration shall &e entertained.

Section 7+. -ffect of !iling. - The #iling o# a motion #or reconsideration ithin the reglementar%

period o# #i#teen /1B0 da%s shall sta% the e(ecution o# the decision sought to &e reconsidered.

Section 73. !iling of Appeals. - 5ecisions o# heads o# departments, agencies, provinces, cities,municipalities and other instrumentalities imposing a penalt% e(ceeding thirt% /3D0 da%s

suspension or #ine in an amount e(ceeding thirt% da%s salar%, ma% &e appealed to the Commission

roper ithin a period o# #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#.

n case the decision rendered &% a &ureau or o##ice head is appeala&le to the Commission, the

same ma% &e initiall% appealed to the department head and #inall% to the Commission roper.ending appeal, the same shall &e e(ecutor% e(cept here the penalt% is removal, in hich case

the same shall &e e(ecutor% onl% a#ter con#irmation &% the Secretar% concerned.

A notice o# appeal including the appeal memorandum shall &e #iled ith the appellate authorit%,

cop% #urnished the disciplining o##ice. The latter shall su&mit the records o# the case, hich shall

&e s%stematicall% and chronologicall% arranged, paged and securel% &ound to prevent loss, ith its

comment, ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s, to the appellate authorit%.

Section 77. hen deemed filed. - An appeal sent &% mail shall &e deemed #iled on the date shon

&% the postmar* on the envelope hich shall &e attached to the records o# the case and in case o#

personal deliver%, the date stamped thereon &% the proper o##ice.

Section 7B. Appeal !ee. - The appellant shall pa% an appeal #ee o# Three =undred esos /3DD.DD0

and a cop% o# the receipt thereo# shall &e attached to the appeal. Section 76. er#ection o# an

Appeal. - To per#ect an appeal, the appellant shall ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt o# the

decision su&mit the #olloing?

a. Notice o# appeal hich shall speci#icall% state the date o# the decision appealed #rom and the

date o# receipt thereo#;

&. Three /30 copies o# appeal memorandum containing the grounds relied upon #or the appeal,

together ith the certi#ied true cop% o# the decision, resolution or order appealed #rom, and

certi#ied copies o# the documents or evidence;

c. roo# o# service o# a cop% o# the appeal memorandum to the disciplining o##ice;

d. roo# o# pa%ment o# the appeal #ee; and

a. A statement or certi#icate o# non-#orum shopping.$

>ailure to compl% ith an% o# the a&ove re@uirements ithin the reglementar% period shall &e

construed as #ailure to per#ect an appeal and shall cause its dismissal.

Section 7. -ffect of !iling. - An appeal shall not stop the decision #rom &eing e(ecutor%, and incase the penalt% is suspension or removal, the respondent shall &e considered as having &een under

preventive suspension during the pendenc% o# the appeal, in the event he ins the appeal.

Section 7:. hen Case is Remanded for 0iolation of Respondent1s Right to Due Process. - # the

case on appeal ith the Commission roper is remanded to the proper disciplining authorit% #or

#urther investigation, the said disciplining authorit% shall #inish the investigation ithin three /30

calendar months #rom the date o# receipt o# the records #rom the Commission, unless the

investigation is dela%ed due to the #ault, negligence or petition o# the respondent, or an e(tension

is granted &% the Commission roper in meritorious cases. The period o# dela% shall not &eincluded in the computation o# the prescri&ed period.

<ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom the termination o# the investigation, the disciplining authorit% shall

render its decision. # at the end o# said period, the disciplining authorit% #ails to decide the case,

the Commission roper shall vacate and set aside the appealed decision and declare respondent

e(onerated o# the charge. # the respondent is under preventive suspension, he shall &e

immediatel% reinstated and shall &e entitled to &ac* salaries and other &ene#its.

The Civil Service Regional ##ice and the ##ice #or egal A##airs o# the Commission roper

shall evaluate re@uests #or the e(tension o# #ormal investigations and grant the same on

meritorious grounds. n disposing the re@uests, these o##ices shall &e guided &% the principles o#

ustice and #air pla%, provided, that the e(tension shall not &e #or more than tent% /+D0 da%s.

>or this purpose, the 5irector shall monitor the implementation o# the CSC Resolution remanding

the case to the proper disciplining authorit% #or #urther investigation and to su&mit a report to theCommission roper.

Section 79. Petition for Revie". - A complainant ma% elevate the decision o# the Civil Service

Regional ##ice dismissing a complaint #or lac* o# a prima #acie case &e#ore the Commission

roper through a etition #or Revie ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom the receipt o# said decision.

Section BD. Petition for Revie" "ith the Court of Appeals. - A part% ma% elevate a decision o# the

Commission &e#ore the Court o# Appeals &% a% o# a petition #or revie under Rule 73 o# the199 Revised Rules o# Court.

Section B1. Recommendation for an -2ecutive Clemenc#. - n meritorious cases and upon

recommendation o# the Commission, the resident ma% commute or remove administrative

penalties or disa&ilities imposed upon o##icers or emplo%ees in disciplinar% cases, su&ect to such

terms and conditions as he ma% impose in the interest o# the service.

>or this purpose, a petition #or a #avora&le recommendation #or the grant o# e(ecutive clemenc%

ma% &e #iled &% a dismissed or disciplined emplo%ee ith the Commission roper uponsu&mission o# the #olloing?

a. certi#ied true cop% o# the decision in the disciplinar% case ith a #avora&le recommendation &%

the disciplining authorit%;

&. certi#ication #rom reputa&le mem&ers o# the communit% here he resides to the e##ect that he

has &ecome a use#ul mem&er thereo#;

c. proo# o# non-pendenc% o# an appeal'petition #or revie relative to his disciplinar% case &e#ore

an% court'tri&unal; and

d. proo# o# pa%ment o# Three =undred /3DD.DD0 esos.

RULE IV

ENALTIES

Section B+. Classification of Offenses. - Administrative o##enses ith corresponding penalties areclassi#ied into grave, less grave or light, depending on their gravit% or depravit% and e##ects on the

government service.

A. The #olloing are grave o##enses ith their corresponding penalties?

1. 5ishonest%

1st o##ense - 5ismissal

+. 4ross Neglect o# 5ut%

3. 4rave )isconduct

7. 8eing Notoriousl% "ndesira&le

B. Conviction o# a crime involving moral turpitude

6. >alsi#ication o# o##icial document

. h%sical or mental incapacit% or disa&ilit% due to immoral or vicious ha&its

:. ngaging directl% or indirectl% in partisan political activities &% one holding non-

political o##ice

9. Receiving #or personal use o# a #ee, gi#t or other valua&le thing in the course o# o##icialduties or in connection thereith hen such #ee, gi#t or other valua&le thing is given &%

an% person in the hope or e(pectation o# receiving a #avor or &etter treatment than that

accorded to other persons, or committing acts punisha&le under the anti-gra#t las.

1D. Contracting loans o# mone% or other propert% #rom persons ith hom the o##ice o#

the emplo%ee has &usiness relations.

11. Soliciting or accepting directl% or indirectl%, an% gi#t, gratuit%, #avor, entertainment,

loan or an%thing o# monetar% value hich in the course o# his o##icial duties or inconnection ith an% operation &eing regulated &%, or an% transaction hich ma% &e

a##ected &% the #unctions o# his o##ice. The propriet% or impropriet% o# the #oregoing shall

&e determined &% its value, *inship, or relationship &eteen giver and receiver and the

motivation. A thing o# monetar% value is one hich is evidentl% or mani#estl% e(cessive

&% its ver% nature.

1+. Nepotism

13. 5islo%alt% to the Repu&lic o# the hilippines and to the >ilipino people

17. ppression

1st o##ense - Suspension /6 mos. 1 da% to 1 %ear0

+nd o##ense - 5ismissal

1B. 5isgrace#ul and immoral conduct

16. ne##icienc% and incompetence in the per#ormance o# o##icial duties

1. >re@uent unauthoried a&sences, or tardiness in reporting #or dut%, loa#ing or #re@uent

unauthoried a&sences #rom dut% during regular o##ice hours

1:. Re#usal to per#orm o##icial dut%

19. 4ross insu&ordination

+D. Conduct preudicial to the &est interest o# the service

+1. 5irectl% or indirectl% having #inancial and material interest in an% transaction

re@uiring the approval o# his o##ice. >inancial and material interest is de#ined as pecuniar% or proprietar% interest &% hich a person ill gain or lose something.

++. ning, controlling, managing or accepting emplo%ment as o##icer, emplo%ee,

consultant, counsel, &ro*er, agent, trustee, or nominee in an% private enterprise regulated,

supervised or licensed &% his o##ice, unless e(pressl% alloed &% la.

+3. 5isclosing or misusing con#idential or classi#ied in#ormation o##iciall% *non to him

&% reason o# his o##ice and not made availa&le to the pu&lic, to #urther his private interests

or give undue advantage to an%one, or to preudice the pu&lic interest.

1s1 o##ense - Suspension /6 mos. 1 da% to 1 %ear0

+7. &taining or using an% statement #iled under the Code o# Conduct and thical

Standards #or u&lic ##icials and mplo%ees #or an% purpose contrar% to morals or

pu&lic polic% or an% commercial purpose other than &% nes and communications media#or dissemination to the general pu&lic.

1- o##ense - Suspension /6 mos. 1 da% to 1 %ear0

+B. Recommending an% person to an% position in a private enterprise hich has a regularor pending o##icial transaction ith his o##ice, unless such recommendation or re#erral is

mandated &% /10 la, or /+0 international agreements, commitment and o&ligation, or as

part o# the #unction o# his o##ice.

8. The #olloing are less grave o##enses ith the corresponding penalties?

1. Simple Neglect o# 5ut%

1st ##ense - Suspension 1 mo. 1 da% to 6 mos.

+nd ##ense - 5ismissal

+. Simple )isconduct

3. 4ross 5iscourtes% in the course o# o##icial duties

7. iolation o# e(isting Civil Service a and rules o# serious nature

B. nsu&ordination

6. =a&itual 5run*enness

1s1 ##ense - Suspension 1 mo. 1 da% to 6 mos.

. "n#air discrimination in rendering pu&lic service due to part% a##iliation or pre#erence.

:. >ailure to #ile sorn statements o# assets, lia&ilities and net orth, and disclosure o#

&usiness interest and #inancial connections including those o# their spouses and

unmarried children under eighteen /1:0 %ears o# age living in their households.

9. >ailure to resign #rom his position in the private &usiness enterprise ithin thirt% /3D0

da%s #rom assumption o# pu&lic o##ice hen con#lict o# interest arises, and'or #ailure todivest himsel# o# his shareholdings or interest in private &usiness enterprise ithin si(t%

/6D0 da%s #rom assumption o# pu&lic o##ice hen con#lict o# interest arises; rovided,

hoever, that #or those ho are alread% in the service and con#lict o# interest arises, the

o##icial or emplo%ee must either resign or divest himsel# o# said interest ithin the

periods hereina&ove; provided, rec*oned #rom the date hen the con#lict o# interest had

arisen.

C. The #olloing are ight ##enses ith corresponding penalties?

1. 5iscourtes% in the course o# o##icial duties

1st ##ense - Reprimand

+nd ##ense - Suspension 1 -3D da%s

3rd ##ense - 5ismissal

+. mproper or unauthoried solicitation o# contri&utions #rom su&ordinate emplo%ees and &% teachers or school o##icials #rom school children

3. iolation o# reasona&le o##ice rules and regulations

+nd ##ense - Suspension 1-3D da%s

7. >re@uent unauthoried tardiness /=a&itual Tardiness0

B. 4am&ling prohi&ited &% la

6. Re#usal to render overtime service

. 5isgrace#ul, immoral or dishonest conduct prior to entering the service

:. 8orroing mone% &% superior o##icers #rom su&ordinates

9. ending mone% at usurious rates o# interest.

1D. <ill#ul #ailure to pa% ust de&ts or ill#ul #ailure to pa% ta(es due to the government

The term !ust de&ts$ shall appl% onl% to?

1. Claims adudicated &% a court o# la, or

+. Claims the e(istence and ustness o# hich are admitted &% the de&tor.

11. o&&%ing #or personal interest or gain in legislative halls and o##ices ithoutauthorit%

1+. romoting the sale o# tic*ets in &ehal# o# private enterprises that are not intended #or

charita&le or pu&lic el#are purposes and even in the latter cases, i# there is no prior

authorit%

13. >ailure to act promptl% on letters and re@uest ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt,

e(cept as otherise provided in the rules implementing the Code o# Conduct and thical

Standards #or u&lic ##icials and mplo%ees

17. >ailure to process documents and complete action on documents and papers ithin a

reasona&le time #rom preparation thereo#, e(cept as otherise provided in the rules

implementing the Code o# Conduct and thical Standards #or u&lic ##icials and

mplo%ees

1B. >ailure to attend to an%one ho ants to avail himsel# o# the services o# the o##ice, or

act promptl% and e(peditiousl% on pu&lic transactions

16. ngaging in private practice o# his pro#ession unless authoried &% the Constitution,

la or regulation, provided that such practice ill not con#lict ith his o##icial #unctions.

1. ursuit o# private &usiness, vocation or pro#ession ithout the permission re@uired &%

Civil Service rules and regulations

1s1 ##ense - Reprimand

Section B3. -2tenuating, 'itigating, Aggravating, or Alternative Circumstances. - n the

determination o# the penalties to &e imposed, mitigating, aggravating and alternativecircumstances attendant to the commission o# the o##ense shall &e considered.

The #olloing circumstances shall &e appreciated?

a. h%sical illness

&. 4ood #aith

c. Ta*ing undue advantage o# o##icial position

d. Ta*ing undue advantage o# su&ordinate

e. "ndue disclosure o# con#idential in#ormation

#. "se o# government propert% in the commission o# the o##ense

g. =a&itualit%

h. ##ense is committed during o##ice hours and ithin the premises o# the o##ice or

i. &uilding

. mplo%ment o# #raudulent means to commit or conceal the o##ense

*. ength o# service in the government

l. ducation, or

m. ther analogous circumstances

Nevertheless, in the appreciation thereo#, the same must &e invo*ed or pleaded &% the proper

part%, otherise, said circumstances shall not &e considered in the imposition o# the proper penalt%The Commission, hoever, in the interest o# su&stantial ustice ma% ta*e and consider these

circumstances.

Section B7. 'anner of Imposition. <hen applica&le, the imposition o# the penalt% ma% &e madein accordance ith the manner provided herein &elo?

a. The minimum o# the penalt% shall &e imposed here onl% mitigating and no aggravating

circumstances are present.

&. The medium o# the penalt% shall &e imposed here no mitigating and aggravating

circumstances are present.

c. The ma(imum o# the penalt% shall &e imposed here onl% aggravating and no mitigatingcircumstances are present.

d. <here aggravating and mitigating circumstances are present, paragraph FaG shall &e applied

here there are more mitigating circumstances present; paragraph F&G shall &e applied hen the

circumstances e@uall% o##set each other; and paragraph FcG shall &e applied hen there are more

aggravating circumstances.

Section BB. Penalt# for the 'ost Serious Offense. # the respondent is #ound guilt% o# to or morecharges or counts, the penalt% to &e imposed should &e that corresponding to the most serious

charge or count and the rest shall &e considered as aggravating circumstances.

Section B6. Duration and effect of administrative penalties. - The #olloing rules shall govern in

the imposition o# administrative penalties?

a. The penalt% o# dismissal shall result in the permanent separation o# the respondent #rom the

service, ith or ithout preudice to criminal or civil lia&ilit%.

&. The penalt% o# trans#er shall carr% ith it the sanction that #ailure on the part o# the respondent

to see* trans#er to another o##ice ithin a period o# not less than ninet% /9D0 da%s, he shall &e

considered resigned. The penalt% o# trans#er ma% &e imposed ith a condition that the respondent

shall &e &arred #rom holding a position involving propert% or mone% responsi&ilit%.

c. The penalt% o# demotion shall include reduction in ran*, or salar%, or &oth.

d. The penalt% o# suspension shall result in the temporar% cessation o# or* #or a period not

e(ceeding one /10 %ear.

Suspension o# one da% or more shall &e considered a gap in the continuit% o# service. 5uring the

period o# suspension, respondent shall not &e entitled to all mone% &ene#its including leave credits.

e. The penalt% o# #ine shall &e in an amount not e(ceeding si( /60 months salar% o# respondent.The computation thereo# shall &e &ased on the salar% rate o# the respondent hen the decision

&ecomes #inal and e(ecutor%.

#. The penalt% o# reprimand or censure shall not carr% ith it an% accessor% penalt% nor result in

the temporar% cessation o# or*.

Section B. Administrative Disa(ilities3Accessories to Administrative Penalties.

a. Cancellation o# eligi&ilit%

&. >or#eiture o# retirement &ene#its

c. 5is@uali#ication #or reinstatement or reemplo%ment

d. 5is@uali#ication #or promotion

e. 8ar #rom ta*ing an% Civil Service e(amination

Section B:. Administrative Disa(ilities Inherent in Certain Penalties.

a. The penalt% o# dismissal shall carr% ith it that o# cancellation o# eligi&ilit%, #or#eiture o#retirement &ene#its, and the perpetual dis@uali#ication #or reemplo%ment in the government

service, unless otherise provided in the decision.

&. The penalt% o# trans#er shall carr% ith it dis@uali#ication #or promotion #or a period o# si( /60

months #rom the date respondent reports to the ne position or station.

c. The penalt% o# demotion shall carr% ith it dis@uali#ication #or promotion at the rate o# to /+0

months #or ever% step or one /10 month #or ever% range o# salar% &% hich he as demoted to &ecomputed #rom the date respondent reports to the ne position or station.

d. The penalt% o# suspension shall carr% ith it dis@uali#ication #or promotion corresponding to the

period o# suspension.

e. The penalt% o# #ine shall carr% ith it dis@uali#ication #or promotion #or a period tice the

num&er o# da%s he as #ined.

#. The penalt% o# #ine shall &e paid to the agenc% imposing the same, computed on the &asis o#respondentEs salar% at the time the decision &ecomes #inal and e(ecutor%.

g. The #olloing are the 4uidelines #or the pa%ment o# #ine?

1. >ines shall &e paid ithin a period not e(ceeding one %ear rec*oned #rom the date the

decision'resolution &ecomes #inal and e(ecutor%.

+. >ine ma% &e paid in e@ual monthl% installments su&ect to the #olloing schedule o#

pa%ment prescri&ed &elo?

a. >ine e@uivalent to one /10 month salar% shall &e paid ithin to /+0 months;

&. >ine e@uivalent to to /+0 months salar% shall &e paid ithin #our /70 months;

c. >ine e@uivalent to three /30 months salar% shall &e paid ithin si( /60 months;

d. >ine e@uivalent to #our /70 months salar% shall &e paid ithin eight /:0 months;

e. >ine e@uivalent to #ive /B0 months salar% shall &e paid ithin ten /1D0 months;

#. >ine e@uivalent to si( /60 months salar% shall &e paid ithin telve /1+0 months;

3. Should the respondent #ail to pa% in #ull the #ine ithin the prescri&ed period, he shall

&e deemed to have #ailed to serve the penalt% imposed, hence, the dis@uali#ication #or

promotion shall remain in e##ect until such time that the #ine is #ull% paid.

h. The penalt% o# reprimand shall not carr% ith it an% o# the accessor% penalties.

i. A arning or admonition shall not &e considered a penalt%.

Section B9. -ffect of -2oneration on Certain Penalties.

a. n case the penalt% imposed is a #ine, the same shall &e re#unded.

&. n case the penalt% imposed is demotion, the e(onerated emplo%ee shall &e restored to his

#ormer position ithout loss o# seniorit% rights ith pa%ment o# salar% di##erentials.

c. n case the penalt% imposed is trans#er, he shall immediatel% &e restored to his #ormer post

unless he decides otherise. n case there is demotion in ran*, salar% or status, he shall &e restored

to his #ormer ran*, salar% or status.

d. n case the penalt% imposed s suspension, he shall immediatel% &e reinstated to his #ormer post

ithout loss o# seniorit% rights ith pa%ment o# &ac* salaries.

e. n case the penalt% imposed is dismissal, he shall immediatel% &e reinstated ithout loss o#

seniorit% rights ith pa%ment o# &ac* salaries.

)andator% leave &ene#its shall not &e charged against the respondentEs leave credits.

The respondent ho is e(onerated &% #inal udgment shall &e entitled to the leave credits #or the

period he had &een out o# the service.

RULE V

NON"DISCILINAR! CASES

A. ROTEST

Section 6D. ho ma# !ile a Protest and here to !ile. - A @uali#ied ne(t-in-ran* emplo%ee ma%

#ile a protest ith the appointing authorit% or ith the Civil Service Regional ##ice against anappointment made in #avor o# another ho does not possess the minimum @uali#ication

re@uirements.

=oever, an% protest against appointments to third level position shall &e #iled ith the

Commission roper.

Section 61. !orm and Content of Protest. - The protest shall &e su&scri&ed and sorn to and

ritten in clear, une@uivocal and concise language. t shall contain the #olloing?

a. the position &eing contested, including its item num&er, correct position title and the salar% per

annum;

&. the #ull name, o##ice, position and salar% per annum o# &oth the protestant and the protestee;

c. the #acts and arguments constituting the grounds #or the protest; and

d. proo# o# pa%ment o# a #iling #ee o# Three =undred esos /3DD.DD0.

Section 6+. hen to !ile a Protest. - The protest ma% &e #iled ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom theissuance o# the appointment or promotion. n cases here the protest is #iled ith the Commission,

the protestant shall #urnish the appointing authorit%, a cop% o# his protest and su&mit proo# o#

service thereo#.

>or this purpose, all appointments or promotions shall &e dul% announced and'or posted in &ulletin

&oards or at conspicuous places in the 5epartment or Agenc%.

Section 63. -ffect of Protest on the Appointment. - A protest shall not render an appointmentine##ective nor stop the approval thereo#, &% the Civil Service >ield or Regional ##ice, &ut the

approval shall &e su&ect to the #inal outcome o# the protest.

Section 67. -ffect of ithdra"al of Protest. - A protest or an appeal in this case ma% &e

ithdran at an% time as a matter o# right. The ithdraal o# the protest or appeal shall terminate

the protest case.

Section 6B. hen Protest is Deemed !iled. - A protest is deemed #iled, in case the same is sent &%mail, on the postmar* date on the envelope hich shall &e attached to the records o# the case, and

in case o# personal deliver%, on the date stamped &% the agenc% or the Commission.

Section 66. Transmittal of Records. - n cases here the protest is #iled ith the Commission, the

head o# department or agenc% shall #orard his comment and the records o# the case ithin ten

/1D0 da%s #rom receipt o# the cop% o# the protest. The records shall &e s%stematicall% and

chronologicall% arranged, paged and securel% &ound to prevent loss and shall include the

#olloing?

a. Statement o# 5uties or Ho& description o# the contested position;

&. 5ul% accomplished and updated personal data sheets o# the parties ith certi#ied statement o#

service records attached;

c. Certi#ied cop% o# the protested appointment; and

d. Comparative assessment o# the @uali#ications o# the protestant and protestee.

Section 6. Dismissal of Protest. - A protest shall &e dismissed on an% o# the #olloing grounds?

a. The protestant is not a @uali#ied ne(t-in-ran*;

&. The protest is not directed against a particular protestee &ut to !an%one ho is appointed to the

position$ or directed to to or more protestees;

c. The protest is not in accordance ith the re@uired #orm as prescri&ed in these Rules;

d. No appointment has &een issued or the appointment has &een disapproved;

e. The protest is #iled outside the 1B-da% reglementar% period as provided in Section 6+ hereo#;

#. Non-pa%ment o# the #iling #ee; and

g. Non-su&mission o# a certi#icate o# non-#orum shopping.

Section 6:. !inalit# of Decision. - 5ecision on a protest case shall &ecome #inal a#ter #i#teen /1B0

da%s #rom receipt thereo#.

Section 69. Availa(le Remedies.

a. The decision o# the regional o##ice or &ureau ma% &e appealed initiall% to the 5epartment

Secretar% then to the Civil Service Regional ##ice ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s and #inall% to the

Commission roper. in cases here the protest is #iled ithin the department or agenc%, the

protestant ma% #ile a motion #or reconsideration o# the adverse decision, ruling or action ithin

#i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt ith the same agenc%.

&. n cases here the protest is #iled ith the Civil Service Regional ##ice, a motion #orreconsideration ma% &e #iled ith the same o##ice ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom the receipt o# the

adverse decision then to the Commission roper ithin the same period.

The protestant shall #urnish a cop% o# his protest to the head o# agenc% concerned ho shall su&mit

his comment to the Civil Service Regional ##ice ithin ten /1D0 da%s.

Section D. -ffect of Decision. - n case the protest is #inall% decided against the protestee, the

approval o# his appointment shall &e recalled and the appointment shall &e considereddisapproved. The protestee shall &e reverted to his #ormer position, i# applica&le.

&. OTHER ERSONNEL )n, NON"DISCILINAR! ACTIONS

Section 1. Complaint or Appeal to the Commission. - ther personnel actions, such as, &ut not

limited to, separation #rom the service due to unsatis#actor% conduct or ant o# capacit% during pro&ationar% period, dropping #rom the rolls due to A&sence <ithout ##icial eave /A<0,

ph%sicall% and mentall% un#it, and unsatis#actor% or poor per#ormance, action on appointments

/disapproval, invalidation, recall, and revocation0, reassignment, trans#er, detail, secondment,demotion, or termination o# services, ma% &e &rought to the Commission, &% a% o# an appeal.

Section +. hen and here to !ile.- A decision or ruling o# a department or agenc% ma% &e

appealed ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo# &% the part% adversel% a##ected to the Civil

Service Regional ##ice and #inall%, to the Commission roper ithin the same period.

A motion #or reconsideration ma% &e #iled ith the same o##ice hich rendered the decision or

ruling ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#.

Section 3. Re+uirement of !iling.- The appellant shall #urnish a cop% o# his appeal to the head o#

department or agenc% concerned ho shall su&mit his comment, together ith the records, to the

Commission ithin ten /1D0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#. roo# o# service o# the appeal on the head

o# department o# agenc% shall &e su&mitted ith the Commission.

Section 7. rounds for Dismissal. -An appeal involving non-disciplinar% cases shall &e

dismissed on an% o# the #olloing grounds?

a. The appeal is #iled &e%ond the reglementar% period;

&. The #iling #ee o# Three =undred /3DD.DD0 has not &een paid, or

c. The appeal does not contain a certi#ication o# non-#orum shopping.

Section B. -ffect of Decision. - <here the Commission, on appeal, sets aside, modi#ies orreverses the decision here&% an emplo%ee as dropped #rom the rolls, he shall &e reinstated

immediatel% to his #ormer post ith pa%ment o# &ac* salaries and other mone% &ene#its.

>or this purpose, dropping #rom the rolls, &eing non-disciplinar% in nature, shall not result in the

#or#eiture o# &ene#its. n case o# illegal termination, the emplo%ee shall &e reinstated ith pa%ment

o# &ac* salaries. n case o# disapproval, invalidation, recall and revocation o# appointments, the

appointee shall &e restored to his #ormer position ithout loss o# seniorit% rights.

n case o# reassignment, trans#er, detail, or secondment, he shall return to his #ormer position.

n case o# demotion in ran*, salar% or status, he shall &e restored to his #ormer ran*, salar%, and

status.

C. CORRECTION OF ERSONAL INFORMATION IN THE RECORDS OF THE COMMISSION

Section 6. here to file. - Re@uests #or correction o# name, date o# &irth, place o# &irth and other

personal in#ormation in the records o# the Civil Service Commission shall &e #iled ith the Civil

Service Regional ##ice concerned and ith the #olloing documents?

a. riginal Certi#icate o# ive 8irth, or in its a&sence a court order;

&. A##idavit o# 5iscrepanc%; and

c. hotocop% o# the documents sought to &e corrected.

A #iling #ee o# ne =undred esos /1DD.DD0 shall &e paid and a receipt thereo# shall &e attached

to the re@uest.

Section . Availa(le Remedies. - n case o# denial o# the re@uest #or correction o# personal

in#ormation, the re@uesting part% ma% ithin #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#, #ile a motion#or reconsideration ith the same regional o##ice. An appeal ma% therea#ter &e #iled ith the

Commission roper ithin the same period a#ter pa%ment o# the appeal #ee o# Three =undred

esos /3DD.DD0.

RULE VI

MISCELLANEOUS ROVISIONS

Section :. Schedule of !iling !ees.- The #olloing are the schedule o# #ees su&ect to the

revision #rom time to time hen the need arises?

a. Appeal 3DD.DD

&. rotest 3DD.DD

c. etition #or Revie 3DD.DD

d. Complaints'appeal on other personnel and non-disciplinar% actions 3DD.DD

e. >avora&le Recommendation #or (ecutive Clemenc% 3DD.DD

#. Correction o# ersonal n#ormation in the records o# the Civil Service Commission 1DD.DD

Section 9. Deputi4ation (# CSC of other la"#ers.- The Commission ma% deputie la%ers o#

other agencies and similar o##icials to conduct preliminar% and #ormal investigation and to ma*e

the necessar% report and recommendation ithin the period speci#ied in Sections 13 and ++.

Section :D. -2ecution of Decision. - The decisions o# the Commission roper or its Regional

##ices shall &e immediatel% e(ecutor% a#ter #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom receipt thereo#, unless a

motion #or reconsideration is seasona&l% #iled, in hich case the e(ecution o# the decision shall &e

held in a&e%ance.

Section :1. Implementation of !inal Decisions. - The Civil Service Regional ##ices /CSRs0

shall monitor the immediate implementation o# these decisions.

Section :+. -ffect of Pendenc# of Petition for Revie"3Certiorari "ith the Court. - The #iling and

pendenc% o# a petition #or revie ith the Court o# Appeals or certiorari ith the Supreme Court

shall not stop the e(ecution o# the #inal decision o# the Commission unless the Court issues a

restraining order or an inunction.

Section :3. 5on$e2ecution of Decision. - An% o##icer or emplo%ee ho ill#ull% re#uses or #ails to

implement the #inal resolution, decision, order or ruling o# the Commission to the preudice o# the

pu&lic service and the a##ected part%, ma% &e cited in contempt o# the Commission and

administrativel% charged ith conduct preudicial to the &est interest o# the service or neglect o#

Section :7. Computation of Period. - n computing an% period o# time prescri&ed &% these Rules,the #irst da% shall &e e(cluded and the last da% included unless it &e a Saturda% a Sunda% or a legalholida%, in hich case the period shall run until the end o# the ne(t or*ing da% hich is neither a

Saturda%, a Sunda% nor a legal holida%.

Copies o# decisions and other communications shall &e served on counsel &ut receipt &% either

counsel or part% shall &e deemed to &e a valid service. The period to per#ect a motion #or

reconsideration or an appeal shall &e rec*oned #rom the date o# receipt o# counsel or part%,

hichever is later.

Section :B. -ffectivit#. -These Rules shall ta*e e##ect a#ter #i#teen /1B0 da%s #rom date o#

pu&lication in a nespaper o# general circulation.

Section :6. Repealing Clause. - The "ni#orm Rules o# rocedure in the Conduct o#

Administrative nvestigation in the Civil Service Commission as prescri&ed in the CSC Resolution

No. 97-DB+1 dated Hanuar% +B, 1997, the Rules o# rocedure in the Conduct o# reliminar% I

>ormal nvestigation as prescri&ed &% the Civil Service Commission in its Resolution No. 9+-7Bdated )arch +7,199+, Resolution No. :9-9 as implemented &% )C No. 76, s. 19:9, Sections 61

and 6B o# )C 71, s. 199:, Section 9, Rule J o# the mni&us Rules mplementing 8oo* o#

Administrative Code o# 19: / +9+0, Section +, CSC )emorandum Circular No. 3+, s. 1963,

and all other o##ice memoranda, memorandum circulars, resolutions, rules or regulations

inconsistent ith these Rules are here&% repealed or modi#ied accordingl%.

Kueon Cit%, August 31, 1999.

70103358 Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service

Documents

Transcript of 70103358 Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service

Headnotes of Canadian Administrative Law Cases

PART 200—UNIFORM ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS, COST ... · 12/19/2014 · PART 200—UNIFORM ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS, COST PRINCIPLES, AND AUDIT REQUIREMENTS FOR FEDERAL AWARDS

Cases in Administrative Law

UNIFORM ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES · 2019. 2. 27. · Adopted July 2018 . OMMISSION. Uniform . Administrative . Procedures . Procedures adopted by the Commission (after consideration

Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles

Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service

UNIFORM LAW COMMISSIONERS' MODEL STATE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE … administrative... · · 2002-05-16UNIFORM LAW COMMISSIONERS' MODEL STATE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ... or prescribes

Uniform Administrative Policies and Procedures of the ...

Administrative Law Cases, 1st Batch

PART 200—UNIFORM ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS, COST PRINCIPLES… … · PART 200—UNIFORM ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS, COST PRINCIPLES, AND AUDIT REQUIREMENTS FOR FEDERAL AWARDS

Recent Uniform Commercial Code Cases Affecting ...

2011 Administrative Cases

daniel-administrative law cases 2016.docx

45 CFR 75 Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements … · 2019. 12. 18. · 45 CFR 75 - Overview 2 CFR 200 OMB Uniform Guidance: Administrative

cases - administrative law

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND PROCESS CASES AND MATERIALS

cscro6.files.wordpress.com · on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service Republic of the Philippines ... service have been embodied in the Uniform Rules in Administrative Cases

Uniform Guidance Administrative Requirements Comparison Chart · Administrative Requirements Comparison Chart – 2 CFR Part 215, Circular A-102, and Final Uniform Guidance Subchapters

Digest cases administrative law

Administrative Law Cases