When Did Life Begin? It is Older than 3.8 Ga:
Evidence from Greenland
Yuichiro UENO*
Abstract The oldest record of life is a carbonaceous material preserved in 3.9–3.8 Ga metamorphosed sedimentary rocks in western Greenland. The carbonaceous material is now graphitized due to extensive metamorphism, although it exhibits a low 13C/12C ratio. The 13C-depleted isotopic composition is comparable to organics produced through biological carbon fixation, so it could support the biological origins of the graphite. This interpretation has been debated for 15 years. Here, the on-going controversy is briefly reviewed. In summary, geologists have good reason to believe that life emerged on Earth at least in 3.8 billion years ago.
Key words:graphite, carbon isotopes, Akilia island, Isua Greenstone Belt
I.Introduction
The oldest fossil records of life date back to ca.
3.5 Ga microfossils from Pilbara craton, Western
Australia (Ueno et al., 2001, 2006). The age is 1.1
Ga younger than the birth date of the Earth. We
do not yet know when life first appeared on this
planet. Older, but more metamorphosed rocks, oc-
cur in the Acasta gneiss complex, which dates
back to 3.96 Ga (Bowring et al., 1989) or even old-
er to 4.2 Ga (Iizuka et al., 2007). However, none
of these rocks include the signature of life because
the protoliths for their gneisses are derived from
igneous rocks of TTG and related rocks.
The Isua supracrustal belt (ISB hereafter) in
western Greenland (Fig. 1) includes the oldest
known sedimentary rocks (3.9–3.8 Ga), which
contain graphite of a possible biological origin.
For this reason, a number of researchers have in-
vestigated the origins of graphites in the ISB since
the pioneering work of Schidlowski et al. (1979). The problem that makes matters difficult is the
high-grade regional metamorphism in the ISB
belt. Moreover, the geology is not yet detailed
enough to identify the tectonic setting for the ori-
gins of the carbonaceous matter. A Japanese team
* Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, 152-8551, Japan
877— —
地学雑誌(Chigaku Zasshi)Journal of Geography120(5)877–885 2011
The 100s: Significant Exposures of the World (No. 3)
Fig. 1 Locality index of the Isua Belt, Greenland.
GMT
878— —
visited the area to map it in great detail, introduc-
ing accretionary complex geology established in
Japan prior to 1990 to identify the origins of rocks
and graphite-bearing rocks (Maruyama, 1997). The results have been published in a series of pa-
pers, geology as a Pacific-type orogeny (Komiya et
al., 1999), regional metamorphism (Hayashi et
al., 2000), igneous petrology and source mantle
composition and temperature in the Eoarchean
(Komiya et al., 2002). The author has completed carbon isotope stud-
ies on the ISB using SIMS (Ueno et al., 2002).
Since then, further studies have been completed
on the ISB and western equivalent region (Akilia) on the origins of graphites (e.g., Mojzsis et al.,
2003; Papineau et al., 2010b), I summarize the
oldest chemical record of life in this region togeth-
er with a representative outcrop.
II.Interpretation of Outcrop
The graphite-bearing meta-sediments are ex-
posed on the eastern side of the ISB (Fig. 2), as
top-sitting meta-sedimentary rocks in an accre-
tionary complex (Fig. 2). A general outline of the
Fig. 2 Locality map of the 3.8 Ga Isua metasediments (after Ueno et al., 2002). Metamorphic zonations from Zone A (greenschist facies) through B, C (amphibolite facies) to D (upper amphibolite facies) is Hayashi et al. (2000). Outcrop location of Fig. 3 is close to K244 sample locality of metasediments.
879— —
accretionary complex is given in this issue by
Maruyama and Komiya (2011). The location of
the representative outcrop is the site of K244 at
the center of the map, and it belongs to Zone D of
the upper amphibolite facies of regional metamor-
phism (Ueno et al., 2002). Fig. 3 photo looks south of the accreted frag-
ments of the Early Archean oceanic crust (right) overlain by white-colored bedded cherts (on which
a man stands), which in turn are overlain by
graphite-bearing meta-sediments (left), presum-
ably derived from trench-turbidites in an intra-
oceanic environment (Komiya et al., 1999). Con-
glomerate layers of a few meters thick appear on
top of the meta-sediments (Komiya et al., 1999). Fig. 4 photo shows an area further to the south
of this zone with isoclinal folds (center) of carbon-
ate-layers interlayered with graphite-bearing
metasediments (cm- to a few tens of cm scale). The hill at the back is overlain with white-colored
bedded cherts and meta-sediments. Graphites are
derived from these meta-sediments resting on top
of the accreted oceanic crust.
III.Akilia Controversy
The oldest evidence of life on Earth comes from 13C-depleted graphite preserved in the Isua-Akilia
Eoarchean supracrustal sequence (3.9–3.6 Ga) in
western Greenland, 100 km west of the ISB, as an
isolated enclave (Mojzsis et al., 1996). In the 3.9
Ga Akilia section, high-grade quartz-pyroxene
rock hosts graphite with a 13C-depleted isotopic
composition as low as -44‰ (Mojzsis et al.,
1996). The quartz-pyroxene rock may have origi-
nally been deposited as a banded iron formation
(BIF) and subsequently suffered from upper am-
phibolite to granulite facies metamorphism (Mojz-
sis and Nutman, 1994; Nutman et al., 1997). Since the first discovery, many questions concern-
ing the original interpretation have arisen.
The sedimentary origin of the Akilia quartz-
pyroxene rock was once questioned by trace ele-
ment geochemistry, suggesting that the putative
meta-BIF is metasomatized komatiite and not
sedimentary rock (Fedo and Whitehouse, 2002a, b;
Whitehouse et al., 2009). However, a subsequent
reanalysis revealed that all isotopic, trace element
geochemical, and textual characters are not in-
compatible with the BIF-origin of the quartz-
pyroxene rock (Friend et al., 2002; Nutman et al.,
2002; Mojzsis and Harrison, 2002a, b; Manning et
al., 2003, 2006; Dauphas et al., 2004, 2007). In
particular, the S-MIF signature of sulfides in the
quartz-pyroxene rock (Mojzsis et al., 2003) clearly
indicates the sedimentary origin of this graphite-
bearing BIF.
Independent reanalysis by Lepland et al. (2005) and Nutman and Friend (2006) failed to recog-
nize graphite within the Akilia BIF, casting doubt
on the presence of graphite in this rock. However,
these reports do not address the same hand speci-
men originally studied by Mojzsis et al. (1996). Recent studies of this sample by Papineau et al.
(2010a, b) and McKeegan et al. (2007) clearly re-
located the graphite within the Akilia BIF. A thor-
ough petrographic study by Papineau et al. (2010a,
b), however, showed that most of the graphites are
attached to the surface of apatite grains and do
not occur as inclusions within apatite crystals,
suggesting the possibility that the graphite was
deposited from hydrothermal fluid with co-occur-
ring base-metal sulfides. This fluid deposited sce-
nario does not discard biological origins, because
carbon-bearing fluid is often derived from sedi-
mentary organic matter during metamorphism of
C- and S-bearing sedimentary rock.
Papineau et al. (2010b) also revealed that the
δ13C values of Akilia graphites range from
-24‰ to -4‰, which are more 13C-enriched than
those reported originally by Mojzsis et al. (1996:
-44 ~-28‰). The large 13C-depletion under
-30‰ has never been reproduced (McKeegan et
880— —
Fig. 3 The accreted Eoarchean oceanic crust (pillow lava and hyaloclastite on the right) and overlying pelagic sediments (a man is standing at the middle, 2–3 m thick) and trench turbidite to the left.
Fig. 4 The highly folded trench turbidite interlayered with dolostones. The location is ca. 500 m south of Fig. 3. The same stratigraphical horizon as that shown in Fig. 3 appears again to the south. The outcrop shows a stratigraphically higher succession of ocean plate stratigraphy (OPS).
881— —
al., 2007; Papineau et al., 2010b), despite using
the same analytical technique (secondary ion
mass spectrometry). Hence, the Akilia graphite is
not so 13C-depleted that the δ13C value may have
also been explicable if the graphite had been
formed by an abiological reaction during meta-
morphism. An alternative abiotic scenario pro-
posed so far is that the graphite may have been
formed through a disproportionation reaction of
siderite (van Zuilen et al., 2002; Lepland et al.,
2005). During prograde metamorphism, siderite
may decompose into magnetite and graphite at
about 450℃ (French, 1971):
6FeCO3→2Fe3O4+5CO2+C (1)
In this case, the δ13C value of the deposited
graphite can be depleted in 13C by about 15‰
compared to the original carbonate phase. Hence,
a large part of the Akilia graphites are isotopically
indistinguishable from those produced abiotically
through reaction (1), although some Akilia graph-
ites are slightly more 13C-depleted up to -24‰,
compared to co-occurring carbonate (-3~-6‰;
Papineau et al., 2010b). Sano et al. (1999) measured the age of the apa-
tite including graphites in the same samples as
described by Mojzsis et al. (1996), and obtained a
U-Pb age of 1.5 Ga, casting doubts on the interpre-
tation of the oldest signs of life. The 13C-depleted
Akilia graphite has no guarantees of the oldest
known record of life ca. 3.9–3.8 Ga, but still re-
mains a possibility (see also Eiler, 2007).
IV.Isua Greenstone Belt
In contrast to the Akilia controversy, growing
evidence supports the existence of life at 3.8 Ga,
based on investigations of lower grade metasedi-
ments in the 3.8 Ga ISB. The ISB hosts green-
schist to amphibolite facies metamorphosed chem-
ical and clastic sedimentary rocks deposited on
the 3.8 Ga seafloor (Nutman et al., 1984; Baads-
gaard et al., 1984; Appel et al., 1998, 2001; Komiya
et al., 1999, 2002; Hayashi et al., 2000; Myers,
2001; Friend et al., 2002; Nutman and Firend,
2009). Some of the ISB metasediments contain
graphite, which show whole rock δ13C values of
-5 to -29‰ (Oehler and Smith, 1977; Perry and
Ahmad, 1977; Schidlowski et al., 1979; Hayes et
al., 1983; Shimoyama and Matsubaya, 1992; Na-
raoka et al., 1996; Rosing, 1999; Ueno et al., 2002). In addition to metamorphism, some parts of the
ISB are severely metasomatized (Rose et al., 1996;
Fedo et al., 2001). Due to metasomatism, some
mafic to ultramafic volcanics were severely car-
bonatized, which sometimes made identification of
the protolith difficult. Nonetheless, less carbon-
atized unambiguous sedimentary rocks also host
graphite with 13C-depleted carbon isotopic compo-
sitions (Rosing, 1999). Also, the carbonate-metasomatism could possi-
bly have deposited graphite abiologically, although
the mechanism forming graphite from carbonate
fluid is largely unknown. Van Zuilen et al. (2002) reported some of the ISB graphite co-occurring
with siderite and magnetite, thus they interpreted
that the graphite may have been deposited by a
siderite decomposition mechanism through reac-
tion (1). However, the presence of abundant sid-
erite is by itself problematic for a fluid-deposited
scenario, because siderite should not have sur-
vived if reaction (1) proceeded at an elevated tem-
perature over 450℃. This abiotic mechanism can-
not be applicable to sub-amphibolite grade ISB
metasediments, which occur sporadically in West
ISB (Rosing, 1999) and especially in the eastern
margin of the ISB (Hayashi et al., 2000; Ueno et
al., 2002). Hayashi et al. (2000) and Komiya et
al. (2001) mapped the eastern part of ISB and
separated the region into three mineral zones,
from greenschist, through epidote-amphibolote, to
amphibolite facies zones (Fig. 2). The graphite-
882— —
bearing sedimentary rocks were systematically
collected covering these three zones and carbon
isotopes were measured at different localities
(Ueno et al., 2002). The results showed a system-
atic decrease of graphite δ13C values from -5‰
to -17‰, along the low- to high-grade metamor-
phic profile. Note that carbonate rocks of putative
metasomatized origin also host graphite, but the
graphite within the carbonate rocks exceptionally
shows heavier δ13C values compared to metasedi-
ment of the same mineral zone (Ueno et al.,
2002). Moreover, graphites enclosed within pre-
metamorphic minerals show a more 13C-depleted
isotopic composition than those outside these min-
erals (Ueno et al., 2002). Thus, apart from the ef-
fects of sporadic carbonatization, the original sedi-
mentary organic matter and carbonate would
have been re-equilibrated isotopically, as is com-
monly observed in younger regional and contact
metamorphic profiles (Hoefs and Frey, 1976; Val-
Fig. 5 Carbon isotopic composition of minute graphite globules. A to D show the metamorphic grade, based on the mineral assemblage of metabasites (Hayashi et al., 2000). Note that the well-buffered graphites through progressive metamorphism changed the carbon isotope from low to high with increasing metamorphism (above). Extraporating the temperature effect to surface temperature below 100℃, the original δ13C must be -25 to -30‰ which is similar to the value by Nishizawa et al. (2005) (below).
883— —
ley and O’Neil, 1981; Wada and Suzuki, 1982). This reconfirms the earlier suggestion from pio-
neering work of Schidlowski et al. (1979) and
Hayes et al. (1983) pointing out that the observed
wide range of graphite δ13C values and smaller
isotopic fractionation between graphite and car-
bonate resulted from metamorphic re-equilibra-
tion, thus the original isotopic compositions of or-
ganic and carbonate carbon may have been
similar to those of younger Archean sequences. If
established, not only 13C-depletion of organic car-
bon, but also 13C-enrichment of carbonate carbon
relative to mantle carbon suggests the biological
primary productivity should have controlled the
global carbon cycle. Considering the effects of
metamorphic temperature of above 300℃ (Fig. 5
above), the original 13C of organic carbon could be
below -20 and around -25 to -30‰ (Fig. 5 be-
low). Nishizawa et al. (2005) extract carbon by
stepwise heating from the lowest grade BIF at the
northeastern margin of the ISB, and demonstrat-
ed that 13C-depleted carbon (-30‰) is released
at 1200℃, which may represent graphite enclosed
within magnetite of the greenschist facies BIF.
This value is sufficient to regard it to be of biotic
origin (Fig. 5 below). Now, we have reason to believe that life had al-
ready appeared on the Earth at least about 3.8
Ga. The presence of 13C-depleted carbon suggests
the onset of biological carbon fixation. Moreover,
the Eoarchean ecosystem may not have been local
but global. It is still not known if the Eoarchean
primary producers were phototrophic or chemotro-
phic. Physiological and taxonomic aspects of Eo-
archean ecosytems await further detailed studies.
References
References referred in the text are not all listed below to minimize the total length of paper. Those are included in Ueno et al. (2002) and Website of the author.
Appel, P.W.U., Fedo, C.M., Moorbath, S. and Myers, J.S. (1998): Recognizable primary volcanic and sedimen-
tary features in a low-strain domain of the highly de-formed, oldest known (~3.7-3.8 Gyr) Greenstone Belt, Isua, West Greenland. Terra Nova, 10, 57-62.
Appel, P.W.U., Rollinson, H.R. and Touret JLR (2001): Remnants of an Early Archaean (>3.75 Ga) sea-floor, hydrothermal system in the Isua Greenstone Belt. Precambrian Research, 112, 27-49.
Baadsgaard, H., Nutman, A.P., Bridgwater, D., Rosing, M., McGregor, V.R. and Allaart, J.H. (1984): The zircon geochronology of the Akilia association and Isua su-pracrustal belt, West Greenland. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 68, 221-228.
Dauphas, N., van Zuilen, M.A., Wadhwa, M., Davis, A.M., Marty, B. and Janney, P.E. (2004): Clues from Fe iso-tope variations on the origin of Early Archean BIFs from Greenland. Science, 306, 2077-2080.
Dauphas, N., van Zuilen, M.A., Busigny, V., Lepland, A., Wadhwa, M. and Janney, P.E. (2007): Iron isotope, major and trace element characterization of early Ar-chean supracrustal rocks from SW Greenland: Proto-lith identification and metamorphic overprint. Geochi-mica et Cosmochimica Acta, 71, 4745-4770.
Eiler, J.M. (2007): The oldest fossil or just another rock?. Science, 317, 1046-1047.
Fedo, C.M. and Whitehouse, M.J. (2002a): Metasomatic origin of quartz-pyroxene rock, Akilia, Greenland, and implication for Earth’s earliest life. Science, 296, 1448-1452.
Fedo, C.M. and Whitehouse, M.J. (2002b): Origin and significance of Archean quartzose rocks at Akilia, Greenland: Response. Science, 298, 917a.
Fedo, C.M., Myers, J.S. and Appel, P.W.U. (2001): Deposi-tional setting and paleogeographic implications of earth’s oldest supracrustal rocks, the >3.7 Ga Isua Greenstone belt, West Greenland. Sedimentary Geolo-gy, 141/142, 61-77.
French, B.M. (1971): Stability relations of siderite (FeCO3) in the system Fe-C-O. American Journal of
Science, 271, 37-78.Friend, C.R.L., Nutman, A.P. and Bennett, V.C. (2002):
Protoliths of the 3.8-3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt-com-ment. Precambrian Research, 117, 145-149.
Iizuka, T., Komiya, T., Ueno, Y., Katayama, I., Uehara, Y., Maruyama, S., Hirata, T., Johnson, S.P. and Dunkley, D. (2007): Geology and zircon geochronology of the Acasta Gneiss Complex, northwestern Canada: new constraints on its tectonothermal history. Precambrian Research, 153, 179-208.
Komiya, T., Hayashi, M., Maruyama, S. and Yurimoto, H. (2002): Intermediate-P/T type Archean metamor-phism of the Isua supracrustal belt: Implications for secular change of geothermal gradients at subduction zones and for Archean plate tectonics. American Jour-nal of Science, 302, 806-826.
Lepland, A., van Zuilen, M.A., Arrhenius, G., Whitehouse, M.J. and Fedo, C.M. (2005): Questioning the evidence for Earth's earliest life - Akilia revisited. Geology, 33,
884— —
77-79.Manning, C.E., Mojzsis, S.J. and Harrison, T.M. (2003):
Geology, age, and origin of Akilia supracrustal rocks, Greenland. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 67, A271.
Manning, C.E., Mojzsis, S.J. and Harrison, T.M. (2006): Geology, age and origin of supracrustal rocks at Akilia, West Greenland. American Journal of Science, 306, 303-366.
Maruyama, S. (1997): Pacific-type orogeny revisited: Mi-yashiro-type orogeny proposed. The Island Arc, 6, 91-120.
Maruyama, S. and Komiya, T. (2011): The oldest pillow lavas, 3.8-3.7 Ga from the Isua Supracrustal belt, SW Greenland: Plate Tectonics had already begun by 3.8 Ga. Journal of Geography (Chigaku Zasshi), 120, 869-876.
McKeegan, K.D., Kudryavtsev, A.B. and Schopf, J.W. (2007): Raman and ion microscopic imagery of gra-phitic inclusions in apatite from older than 3830 Ma Akilia supracrustal rocks, west Greenland. Geology, 35, 591-594.
Mojzsis, S.J. and Nutman, A.P. (1994): Evidence for a marine sedimentary system at > 3.87 Ga in southern West Greenland. EOS Transactions, 75, 690.
Mojzsis, S.J. and Harrison, T.M. (2002a): Origin and sig-nificance of Archean quartzose rocks at Akilia, Green-land. Science, 298, 917a.
Mojzsis, S.J. and Harrison, T.M. (2002b): Establishment of a 3.83-Ga magmatic age for the Akilia tonalite (southern West Greenland). Earth and Planetary Sci-ence Letters, 202, 563-576.
Mojzsis, S.J., Coath, C.D., Greenwood, J.P., McKeegan, K.D. and Harrison, T.M. (2003): Mass-independent isotope effects in Archean (2.5 to 3.8 Ga) sedimentary sulfides determined by ion microprobe analysis. Geo-chimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 67, 1635-1658.
Myers, J.S. (2001): Protoliths of the 3.8-3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt, West Greenland. Precambrian Re-search, 106, 129-141.
Nishizawa, M., Takahata, N., Terada, K., Komiya, T., Ueno, Y. and Sano, Y. (2005): Rare-earth element, lead, carbon, and nitrogen isotope geochemistry of ap-atite-bearing metasediments from the ~ 3.8 Ga Isua Supracrustal Belt, West Greenland. International Ge-ology Review, 47, 952-970.
Nutman, A.P. and Friend, C.R.L. (2006): Petrography and geochemistry of apatites in banded iron forma-tion, Akilia, W. Greenland: Consequences for oldest life evidence. Precambrian Research, 147, 100-106.
Nutman, A.P. and Friend, C.R.L. (2009): New 1:20,000 scale geological maps, synthesis and history of investi-
gation of the Isua supracrustal belt and adjacent or-thogneisses, southern West Greenland: a glimpse of Eoarchaean crust formation and orogeny. Precambrian Research, 172, 189-211.
Nutman, A.P., Friend, C.R.L. and Bennett, V.C. (2002): Evidence for 3650-3600 Ma assembly of the northern end of the Itsaq Gneiss Complex, Greenland: Implica-tion for early Archaean tectonics. Tectonics, 21, 1-28.
Papineau, D., De Gregorio, B.T., Cody, G.D., Fries, M.D., Mojzsis, S.J., Steele, A., Stroud, R.M. and Fogel, M.L. (2010a): Ancient graphite in the Eoarchean quartz-pyroxene rocks from Akilia in southern West Green-land I: Petrographic and spectroscopic charactgeriza-tion. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 74, 5862-5883.
Papineau, D., De Gregorio, B.T., Stroud, R.M., Steele, A., Pecoits, E., Konhauser, K., Wang, J. and Fogel, M.L. (2010b): Ancient graphite in the Eoarchean quartz-pyroxene rocks from Akilia in southern West Green-land II: Isotopic and chemical compositions and com-parison with Paleoproterozoic banded iron formations. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 74, 5884-5905.
Sano, Y., Terada, K., Takahashi, Y. and Nutman, A.P. (1999): Origin of life from apatite dating?. Nature, 400, 127.
Ueno, Y., Yurimoto, H., Yoshioka, H., Komiya, T. and Maruyama, S. (2002): Ion microprobe analysis of graphite from ca. 3.8 Ga metasediments, Isua supra-crustal belt, West Greenland: Relationship between metamorphism and carbon isotopic composition. Geo-chimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 66, 1257-1268.
Ueno, Y., Yamada, K., Yoshida, N., Maruyama, S. and Iso-zaki, Y. (2006): Evidence from fluid inclusions for mi-crobial methanogenesis in the early Archaean era. Na-ture, 440, 516-519.
Valley, J.W. and O’Neil, J.R. (1981): 13C/12C exchange be-tween calcite and graphite: a possible thermometer in Grenville marbles. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 45, 411-419.
van Zuilen, M.A., Lepland, A. and Arrhenius, G. (2002): Reassessing the evidence for the earliest traces of life. Nature, 418, 627-630.
Wada, H. and Suzuki, K. (1982): Carbon isotopic ther-mometry calibrated by dolomite-calcite solvus temper-atures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 47, 697-706.
Whitehouse, M.J., Myers, J.S. and Fedo, C.M. (2009): The Akilia controversy: Field, structural and geochro-nological evidence questions interpretations of >3.8 Ga life in SW Greenland. Journal of the Geological So-ciety, London, 166, 335-348.
885— —
地球生命はいつ誕生したのか?世界最古の生命の痕跡―西グリーンランドの高変成泥質岩中の石墨の炭素同位体組成―
上 野 雄 一 郎*
地球上にいつ生命が誕生したのだろうか? この疑問に答えるために,世界最古の地層を探し,その痕跡を突き止める努力がなされてきた。西グリーンランドイスア地域には 38–37億年前の太平洋型造山帯が見られるが,そのなかの付加体を構成する海溝堆積物中に石墨が産する。この石墨の炭素同位体組成は起源推定に有用であるのだ
が,この堆積岩はのちに 300–600℃程度の広域的な変成作用を被っているため同位体組成は改変されている。そこで変成作用による影響を考慮すると,もとの炭素同位体組成は-25から-30‰程度であったと予測される。これらの同位体的特徴は,地球誕生後 8億年時点ですでに生物は地球に出現していたことを示す。
キーワード: 石墨,炭素同位体,アキリア島,イスア緑色岩帯
* 東京工業大学大学院理工学研究科
Top Related