Download - Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Transcript
Page 1: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

RevisedJune12,2011 [email protected] [email protected]

INTHESHADOWOFDEBT

AnIntroductiontotheUSBudgetImbalance

OurFederaldeficitandnationaldebtareoneveryone’smind.Itdoesn’ttakemanysurfsthroughtheTVchannelstofinddramaticallydifferentopinionsofthecostsimposedonusbythedebt,thelikelihoodofafinancialcrisis,andtheappropriatestepstodealwiththeproblem.Economists,likepoliticiansandthegeneralpublic,coverthefullspectrumofopinionontheseissues;butthereisamiddlegroundoccupiedbymosteconomists.Speakingfromthismiddleground,wehopetoplaceinperspectivethecausesofourbudgetimbalance,itsseriousness,andtheavailableremedies.

Thisprimerwilladdressfourtopics.Inthefirstchapter,welaythegroundworkbydefiningtermsandcollectingdata:whatarethedebtandthedeficit;howaretheymeasured;andhowdoesthecurrentsituationcomparetothepastandtothatofothercountries?Asecondtopiciswhetherournationfacesbankruptcyandfinancialcrisiswithoutcorrectiveactionandwhatneedstobedone,inthenextdecadeandbeyond,tomakethebudgetsustainable.Wecanactabruptly,andsharplylimitthesizeofthedebt,orgradually,andacceptalargerobligation.Suchchoicesmotivateourthirdtopic:whatarethebenefitstousandtheburdensonfuturegenerationsofourdeficitsandthedebttheyimply?Thegreatertheburden,themorequicklyanddecisivelyweshouldact.Finally,wetakeamoredetailedlookatthecomponentsoftheUSbudgettodiscoverhowthedeficithasemerged,howitislikelytoevolvewithoutcorrectivepolicies,andsomeproposedoptionsforreachingasustainablelevelofdeficitsattheendofthedecade.Thebottomlineisthatalthoughwedonotfaceanimmediatedebtcrisis,thedebtproblemislargeandrealsolutionswillrequiresignificantchangesintaxesandspendingonpopularprograms.Wecannotgrowoutoftheproblem.Comprehensivereformsarenecessaryandshouldbegintobeimplementedinthenextfewyears.

ONE:THEMESSWE’REIN

ThedeficitofourFederalgovernmentistheexcessofitsexpendituresoverrevenuesinagivenyear.Expendituresincludethecostsofourmilitaryandgovernmentemployees;paymentstotheretired,sick,andunemployed;andinterestchargesontheaccumulatedborrowings.Revenueismainlyintheformoftaxcollections.For2010,estimatedexpenditureswereapproximately3.5trilliondollarsand

Page 2: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

2

estimatedrevenueswereapproximately2.2trilliondollars;thedifferenceistheFederaldeficitofapproximately1.3trilliondollars.For2011,thedeficitisexpectedtobeevenlarger,approximately$1.5trillion.

Thegrossnationaldebtisthetotal,accumulatedamountborrowedbytheUSTreasurysincethebirthofourcountry.Nowadays,thesefundsareobtainedprimarilythroughthesaleofgovernmentbonds.SomeofthisdebtisowedtoandownedbyUShouseholds,businesses,andgovernmentsnotapartoftheFederalsystemandbyforeignindividuals,businesses,andgovernments.Thisportionofthedebtissaidtobe“ownedbythepublic.”TherestofthegrossdebtisheldbydepartmentsoftheFederalgovernmentdifferentfromtheTreasury,notablybytheSocialSecurityAdministration.Thisportionofthedebtexistsaspaperentriesonthebooksofthegovernmentanddoesnotinvolvetheliteralpaymentofinterestto,oracquisitionoffundsfrom,apartyoutsideofthegovernment.Consequently,itisirrelevanttothewaygovernmentactionsaffecttheeconomy.Themeaningfulportionofthedebt,ownedbythepublic,isthedefinitionusedthroughoutourdiscussion.Attheendof2010,thenationaldebtheldbythepublicwasapproximately9.0trilliondollars.Incontrast,thegrossdebtwasapproximately$13.5trillion.

Thedebtanddeficitareintimatelyrelated.SincetheUSFederalgovernmentmustborroweverydollarofspendingthatisnotcoveredbyrevenues,thedeficitrepresentstheincreaseinthenationaldebtfromoneyeartothenext.(Actually,becauseourgovernmentsometimesmakesloansatthesametimeitborrows,thisassertionisnotexact;butthediscrepancyisminorandwillbeignoredhere.)Inanalogytotheuseofacreditcard:thedeficitissimilartothemonthlychargesthatarenotpaidoff,andthedebtistheoutstandingbalanceagainsttheaccount.Failingtocoveratleastthemonthlychargesisdangerous,becausetheoutstandingbalancegrows,andinterestexpensesgrow,andtheoutstandingbalancecanspiraloutofcontrol.Suchisthefearthatdeficitswillleadtomoredebt,moreexpendituresoninterest,andinturnevergrowingdeficits.

TheCongresslegislatesadebtceiling.Aspresentlyset,theceilingputsanupperlimitofroughly$14.3trilliononthedollarvalueofthegrossdebt‐‐thatis,theuninformativemeasureofthedebtthatincludesallofwhattheTreasuryhasborrowedfromthepublicandfromotherdepartmentsoftheFederalgovernment.Atthemomenttheceilingisreached,additionalborrowingbytheTreasurybecomesillegal;so,everydollarofnewexpendituremustawaitadollarofnewtaxrevenue.Thebudgetwillbeforcedintobalanceasaresult.Eliminationofa$1.3trilliondeficitinthetickofaclock,inunplannedfashion,isalmostinconceivableandnooneknowshowitcouldbedone.Certainly,theimmediateconsequencewouldbethenon‐satisfactionofmanyobligations,likefederalworkerpay,interesttocreditors,andpaymentstotheretiredandunemployedForthisreason,failuretoincreasethedebtceilingdoesnotinitselfsolveourfiscalproblemsinasatisfactoryway,wouldseverelyjoltanalreadyfragileeconomy,andmightevenbringaboutthecrisisinfinancialmarketsthatfiscalconservativesfearfromdeficits.Becausetheconsequenceswouldbedire,somebelievethatthethreatofmaintainingtheceilingcanspurotheractionstocorrectthedeficitinthelongterm.

Page 3: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

3

Forcomparisonovertimeandwithothercountries,deficitsandthedebtshouldbegaugedinrelationtotheeconomyasa“whole,”oftenmeasuredasthegrossdomesticproduct(GDP),thedollarvalueofgoodsandservicesproducedwithinacountryduringagivenyear.TheratioofthedeficitordebttoGDPcanbelegitimatelycomparedovertimebecausetheyarenotdistortedbyinflationoreconomicgrowth.Figures1(deficits)and2(debt)andTable1showtheseratiosoverthelast40years.Here,wecanseethatrelativetoGDPdeficitsandthedebtin2009and2010havereachedlevelsunprecedentedduringpeacetime.(USdebtexceededtheGDPshortlyafterWWIIbutfellquicklytolessthanhalfofGDPastheeconomygrewrapidlyafterthewar.)Duringthe38yearsbefore2009,only8timeshadthedeficitbeenlargerthan4percentoftheGDP,andonlyonceaslargeas6percent.Debthadneverreached50percentoftheGDPand,exceptforyears87‐98hadbeenlessthan40percent,andsometimeslessthan30percent,ofGDP.Duringthelasttwoyears,deficitshavebeen9‐10percentofGDPandthenationaldebthasgrowntoover60percentofGDP.Deficitsprojectedfor2011and2012,atleast,willbesimilarlylarge,andthedebtisexpectedtogrowasaproportionoftheGDP.Withoutquestion,theseareredflags.

Hasthedeficitbeencausedbyadeficiencyoftaxrevenues,oranexcessofexpenditures,relativetohistoricalstandards?Chart3,whichshowstheratioofrevenuetoGDPandexpenditurestoGDP,indicatesthatbothpartsofthedeficithavebrokennewground.Revenueshaveaveragedapproximately18.0percentofGDPoverthelastfortyyears,butin2009and2010taxcollectionswereonly14.9percentoftheGDP.Theseratiosarethelowestintheentire40yearhistory.Expendituresinthelasttwoyearswere25.0and23.8percentofGDP,incomparisontotheaverageof20.8percent,andarealsothelargestduringtheentireperiod.

Diggingdeeper,wemustaskwhatpoliciesandcircumstanceshavecausedthishemorrhageinthebudget.Thereisnosinglesource(moreonthisinchapterstofollow),butatleastsomeofthehemorrhageisnotcausedbychanginggovernmentpoliciesatall.Rather,partofthedeficitisapassiveresponsetothedepressedstateofoureconomy.Wehavenotedthatthedeficitisunprecedentedinmodernhistory,butsotooistheextentoftherecenteconomicdownturn,asmeasuredbytheunemploymentrate–thehighestithasbeeninthelastfortyyears–andasmeasuredbythepercentagegapbetweenwhatweinfactproduceandwhatwewouldproduceiftheworkforcewerefullyemployed.Thelatteriscalled“potentialGDP.”Thesizeoftheserecentoutputgaps,showninTable1,revealthatwereallyareexperiencingtheGreatRecession.Itisnoaccidentthattheothersevereeconomicdownturninmodernhistory,theeightyears1980‐1987whentheUSwassignificantlyunderemployed,werealsotheyearsofextremedeficitsinrelationtoGDP.

Chart3illustrateshowthedeficitissensitivetothestateoftheeconomy.Periodsofslowdownineconomicgrowth(whichcorrespondapproximatelytoperiodsofrisingunemployment)areshadedinthechart.Duringtheseperiods,revenuessystematicallydeclineasapercentageofGDP,andexpendituressystematicallyincrease.Eveniftaxlawsandpoliciesareunchanged,revenuesfallwhengrowthslowsorisnegative,becausetaxescollectedonpersonalincomeandbusinessincomefallasincomesfall.Infact,revenuesdeclineseverelyinrelationtoGDP,becausepeoplearepushedintolowertaxbracketsandsomeofthetaxbaseunrelatedtoGDP(eg,capitalgains)evaporates.Evenifthe

Page 4: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

4

lawswhichunderlieFederalexpendituresareunchanged,expendituresrelativetoGDPincreaseduringeconomicdownturns,inpartbecausemanyexpenditures(suchasnationaldefense)arenotautomaticallyreducedinlinewithGDPandinpartbecauseotherexpenditures,suchasunemploymentcompensationandaidtothepoor,actuallyincreasewhentheeconomyworsens.

Thesepassivemovementsofthebudgetinresponsetoeconomicfluctuationsarenotofmajorconcern,becausetheyarenotapermanentfeatureofthebudget:theywillgoaway,andevenbereversed,whentheeconomyreturnstofullemploymentandtoboomperiods.(Indeed,mosteconomistsregardthispassiveresponseasagoodthing,becausetheautomatictendencyfortaxcollectionstofallandexpendituretoincreaseduringdownturnsstimulatesdemandwhentimesarebadand,hence,dampensthesizeofeconomicfluctuations.Forthisreason,thepassivebudgetresponseisknownas“automaticstabilization.”)Weseekameasureofthebudgetwhichmeasuresexpenditures,revenues,andthedeficitpurgedoftheseautomaticreactionstothestateoftheeconomy.Suchameasure(carefullyconstructedbutnecessarilyspeculative)iscompiledbytheCongressionalBudgetOffice(CBO),amongothers.Knownasthestructuralbudgetdeficit,itcomputesthedeficitthatwouldhappenunderexistingtaxlawsandexpenditurerulesIFtheeconomywereatfullemployment.

Table1andchart1showtheUSstructuralbudgetdeficitasapercentageofthepotentialGDP.Thetableandchartalsoshowperiodsofexcessiveunemployment,duringwhichactualGDPfallsbelowpotentialGDP.Asisevident,whentheGDPisbelowitsfullemploymentlevel,theactualdeficitrelativetoGDPislargerthanthestructuraldeficitrelativetofullemploymentGDP.Forexample,iftheeconomyhadbeenfullyemployedin2010,thedeficitwouldhavebeenreducedby360billion.Accordingtothislattermeasure,structuraldeficitsinmoderntimeshaverarelyexceeded4percentofGDPunderfullemployment–themid‐80scontinuetocatchoureye–butdeficitsinthelasttwoyearsremainatunprecedentedlevels,of7.3and6.1percentofpotentialGDP.Thisrefinedviewofthedeficitremindsusthatrelativetotheeconomythecoreoverspendingisnotaslargeaswefirstsupposed,butitdoesnotchangeourconclusionthatthebudgetimbalancesofrecentyearsareuniqueandominous.Fancycalculationscannothidethistruth.

Comparativeinformationfromaroundtheworldprovidesanotherusefulperspectiveonourbudgetsituation.InTable2welookatbudgetdataforthesevenlargestindustrialcountries(the“G7”)andthreesmallerEuropeaneconomiesinfinancialturmoil.Thesedata,compiledbytheInternationalMonetaryFund,averageresultsfrom2009and2010anddifferslightlyindefinitionfromthedatainTable1.AmongtheG7,asashareofGDP,USdebtisinthemiddlerangeandquitetypical.However,theUSdeficit,alongwiththoseofJapanandtheUK,arethelargestintheindustrializedworld,evenafteraccountingfortheautomaticresponsetotherecession.AnotherinterestingfeatureisthattheUShasrelativelylowtaxesamongindustrializedcountries.OnlyJapanhaslowergovernmentrevenuesasshareofGDP.

FromtheTable,wecansensewhyGreece,withatypicallylargedebtanddeficits,andIreland,withmassivedeficitsandasevererecession,havecomeunderpressure.ButPortugal,mentionedoftenas

Page 5: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

5

anotherpossibletargetforinternationalspeculators,hasdebtanddeficitsnotdissimilarfromtheUS.Areweindanger?Thatisthetopicwetakeupnext.

TWO:AREWEBROKE?

Lettherebenomisunderstanding:governments,likehouseholds,mustlivewithintheirmeans.Households(neglectinginheritedandbequeathedwealth)mustmatchspendingovertheirlifetimetoearningsovertheirlifetime.Inanyparticularyear,itoftenmakessensetolend,ortoborrow;buthouseholdscannotborrowtoomuch.Iftheirdebt(netofacquiredassets)exceedstheirlikelyfutureearnings,minusnecessaryexpenditures,theyarebroke.Similarly,ifagovernment’sdebthasgrownsolargethatitcannotberepaid(inasensetobeexploredbelow),thatgovernmentisbroke.

MostAmericanswouldbesurprisedtolearnofthefrequencyofnationalbankruptciesaroundtheworldandoverhistory.Forexample,inacomprehensivestudyoffinancialcrises,RinehartandRogoff(2009),chapter5,estimatethatafterWorldWarII,almost40percentofthecountriesoftheworldwereindefault;andduringthe1980s,almost10percent.Thetrainofeventstriggeredbyunsupportabledebthaveplayedoutmanytimes.Investorsloseconfidenceandtrytosellthedebt,loweringitsvalue,orinsistonhigherinterestincompensationfortheheightenedrisk.Thesereactions,whichdepresstheeconomyandincreasetheinterestowedbythegovernment,inflamethesituationintoacrisis,whichendsindefault–thegovernment’sadmissionthatitwon’tkeepitspromisetorepay.Theeconomyisthrownintoturmoil;andhavinglostitsreputationforsounddecisions,thegovernment’sabilitytoborrowinthefuturedeteriorates.RecentexamplesareArgentina2001/2002,andIrelandandGreecein2009/2010.(SeeCBOJuly2010foranicesummary.)

Principlesofsoundfinanceapplytogovernmentsandhouseholdsalike.Butgovernmentsdifferfromhouseholdsinseveralcrucialregards.Thesedifferencesmakeusre‐thinkwhatitmeansforagovernmenttobebrokeandhelptoputintocontextthesolvencyoftheUS.

1)Householdshavelimitedlifespansandmustsettletheirfinancialaffairsattheend.Ourgovernment,wehope,livesonindefinitely.Therenevercomesatimewhenitsdebtmustbeeliminated;instead,itcan“rollover”itsdebt,issuingnewtofundtheold,foraslongaspeoplearewillingtoloanitthemoney.Allgovernmentsusethistechnique.Thekeyistomakesurethatthegovernmentcanalwayscovertheinterestowedonthedebt.Theinterestispaidoutoftheexcessoftaxrevenuesoverexpendituresongovernmentprograms.SincetaxesarecollectedmainlyfromournationaltaxbasetheGDP,andgovernmentexpendituresotherthanoninterestgrowinroughproportionwiththesizeoftheeconomy,thisrollovertechniqueworksaslongasthedebtgrowsnofasterthandoestheGDP.Inthissituation,thebudgetissaidtobesustainable.Acountryisbrokewhenitcannot,orwillnot,achieveasustainablebudget.

2)Householdsandbusinessesarebrokewhenthesacrificeofpayingbacktheirdebtsisextremeandunreasonable.Legalstandardsgovernwhenthesacrificeisunbearableandhowmuchcreditorscanrecover.Incontrast,governmentsfacenoenforceablelegalstandardwhichdictateswhenrepaymentisunbearableandwhatcreditorsareentitledto.Agovernment’srevenues—itstaxcollections—and

Page 6: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

6

expendituresarenotsetinstone:theyaredeterminedinthepoliticalprocess.Governmentscan,anddo,defaultontheirdebt.Countrieswhichgobrokealmostalwayshavetheabilitytocollectsufficienttaxes,orreduceprograms,tosustaintheirdebts.Afterall,inprinciple,theentireGDP,minusexpendituresnecessarytomaintainlife,isavailabletofinancetheinterest.Countriesgobrokebecausetheyareunwillingtomakesuchdiresacrificesfromtheircitizens.Insteadofbearingtheburdenofhightaxesorreducedprogramstosustainthedebt,theychoosetosufferthecostsofdefault.Inconsequence,thereisnosimple,judgment‐freedeterminationofwhenacountryislikelytogobroke:sustainabilityisasubtlebalanceofpoliticalwillandthepenaltyofbreakingyourpromise.Thisbalanceisdifferentfordifferentcountriesandtimes.

Withtheseideasinmind,wecangrapplewithseveralkeyquestions.

AfirstsetofquestionsrelatestosustainabilityoftheUSbudget.Isitnowsustainable?Ifnot,howfardoweneedtogotomakeitsustainable?TheanswerstothesequestionsdependonthelongtermgrowthrateoftheUSeconomy:thefasterGDPgrows,themoredebtcangrowwithoutgainingasapercentageofGDP.Formanyyears,therateofgrowthofUSproductionunderconditionsoffullemploymenthasaveragedaround2.5percentperyear.OurFederalReservetargetsabout2percentinflationundernormalconditions.Thus,manyeconomistswouldballparkaverageGDPgrowthatapproximately4.5percentperyearintothefuture.Debtlevelsinrecentyearsandintheneartermforecastareontheorderof60to70percentofGDP.Underthesecircumstances,thedeficitcouldbeonaverage2.7to3.2percentoftheGDPwithoutgeneratinganincreaseindebtrelativetothesizeoftheeconomy.Consequently,manyeconomistsbelievethatastructuralbudgetdeficitrelativetofullemploymentGDPontheorderof3percentwouldbesustainablefortheUS.

RelativetofullemploymentGDP,ourstructuraldeficitin2010(andlikelyfor2011)isontheorderof6percent.Thisbudgetisnotsustainable.Toachieveasustainablebudget,weneedtoincreasetaxrevenues,orreducegovernmentprograms,ontheorderof3‐4percentoffullemploymentoutput–incurrentdollarsabout$500billionperyear.Thisgoalisnoteasy.Forexample,$500bisconsiderablylargerthantheentirenon‐militarypayrollofourFederalgovernment.Thegoalwillbecomefarmoredifficulttoachieveasourpopulationages,orifourdebt/GDPratioisallowedtoincreasesubstantially.But,aswediscussinsubsequentchapters,sustainabilityisachievable.

Asecond,relatedquestioniswhetherourdebtlevelisnow,orintheforeseeablefuture,sohighthatwearevulnerabletoalossofconfidencebyinternationalinvestors‐‐thatis,shouldthemarketplacebelieveourbudgetmaynotreachsustainability?Toanswerthisquestion,wemustaskhowlargeasacrifice,intheformofhighertaxesorsmallergovernmentprograms,theUSpublicwouldacceptinlightofthecosttoourcountryofdefault.Intruth,nooneknowstheanswertothisquestionwithprecision.Butaswelookaroundtheworld,theUS–withadebttoGDPratiotypicalofindustrializedcountries‐‐iswellpositionedtoshoulderitsdebt.Itsrateofeconomicgrowthoverthelongtermhasbeenhealthy,andsteady,bythestandardsoftheindustrializedworld,anditborrowsatfavorableinterestrates.UStaxesarelowbythestandardsoftheindustrializedworld,andoursystemsoftaxcollectionandexpenditureareefficientandfreeofcorruption.Thus,atthesameratioofdebttoGDP,

Page 7: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

7

theexcessoftaxesoverexpenditures(relativetoGDP)necessaryforsustainabilityissmallerintheUSthaninmostothercountries;andthebudgetpoliciesneededtobringthesechangesaboutinvolvelesspain.Inthebroader,globalpicture,ourgovernmentisstableandourcohesionasanationisstrong:weacceptthepromisesofourgovernmentinthepastasourownandtakesomeresponsibilityforthewelfareofourfuturecitizens.Also,thecosttotheUSofadefaultonitsdebtandconsequentlossofinternationalreputationisveryhigh.Weareoneofthefewcountriesthathasneverdefaulted;weobtainlargebenefitsofhavingourassetsheldthroughouttheworldandthedollarastheworld’scurrency;andtheconsequencesfortheworldeconomyofadebasementofUSobligationswouldbecataclysmic.Nooneknowsthe“triggerpoint”atwhichUSdebt/GDPgetssolargethatrationalinvestorsshouldpanic.Butincomparisontoalmostallcountries,includingthoseintheindustrializedworld,therelativelysmallsizeifitssacrificetostaysolvent,andtherelativelylargecostofarepudiationofitspromises,makeaUSdefaultnoworintheforeseeablefuturealmostinconceivable.

Themarketplaceagrees.TheinterestratesonlongtermUSTreasuryobligationswereathistoricallowsattheendoflastyearandremainlowbyhistoricalstandardsandincomparisontotheinterestratesoncomparableobligationsofmanyotherindustrializedcountries,includingCanada,France,andtheUK.RatesonGermanbonds,whileslightlylowerthanUSratesatthetimeofwriting,aresurprisinglysimilarinlightofthelikelyfallinthevalueofthedollarinthefuture.Whilesuggestive,thisevidenceisnotdecisive,becauseinterestratesaredrivenbymanyforcesinadditiontodefaultrisk(especially,theactionsoftheFederalReservenowandexpectedinthefuture)andinternationalcomparisonsaredistortedbyexpectedchangesincurrencyvalues.Moredirectevidenceonconfidenceisprovidedbythepriceofinsuranceongovernmentobligations(knownascreditdefaultswapsonsovereigndebt)andtheassessmentsoftheseveralagencieswhospecializeinratingnationalandcorporatedebt.InsuranceagainstdefaultonUSdebtisamongthecheapestintheworld,becausethemarketplaceviewsUSdebtasamongthesafest.Forexample,attheendof2010,outofthe56nationswhosenationaldebtcanbecoveredbyinsurance,only4‐6nations(dependingonwhethertheinsuranceisfor5yearor10yearbonds)haddebtwithcheaperinsurancethanthatonUSdebt.Notably,insuranceonFrance,Germany,andtheUKwasmorecostly.StandardandPoor’s,amongotherratingsagencies,assignstheUSdebtitshighestAAAratingforquality,aratingearnedbylessthanonesixthof126countries.Bythesemeasures,USdebtisamongthesafestintheworld.

Recenteventsdonotnegatethisconclusionbutsurelygiveuspause.ThepriceofinsuranceagainstUSdefaultroseduringthefirstquarterof2011,andattheendofthatperiodthedebtsof6‐9countriescouldbeinsuredmorecheaplythancouldUSdebt.Partly,marketsreactedtoatemporaryworryaboutdebtserviceifthedebtceilingisnotraised;butalsomarketsreactedtotheheateddebateandpossiblegridlockinWashingtononlongtermdeficitreduction.StandardandPoor’s(April18,2011)tooktheUStotaskforitslackofconsensusonadeficitreductionplanandhasindicatedthatfailuretoactcouldresultinadowngradeofUSdebtfromAAAtoAAquality.ThesedevelopmentsarehealthyearlywarningsthateventheUSisnotimmunetotheseriousconsequencesofexcessivedebt:weshouldnotdelayactionmuchlonger.Butthesedevelopmentsalsoputoursituationincontext.Tododgethedowngrade,StandardandPoor’sdoesnotlookforimmediate,sizabledeficitreductionbutrathera

Page 8: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

8

credibleandenforceableplanforthelongtermtobeagreeduponoverthenexttwoyears.DespitetherecentincreaseinthepriceofinsuranceonUSdebt,weremaininelitecompany(cheapest1/6);andUSdebtisstillcheaper,orvirtuallythesame,toinsurethanthoseofthelargeindustrialcountriesontheContinent.ComparisonstoGreece(priceofinsuranceis25timesaslarge)andIrelandandIceland(insurancepriceabout12timesaslarge),orevenItalyorJapan,areoutrageous:theyareinadifferentleague.Similarly,eveniftheUSratingweretofalltoAA,itsdebtqualitywouldberegardedasahairwidthinqualitybelowthatofAAA,stillimminentlysecure(onlyabout1/10ofcountriesachievetheAArating),andhardlyinthesameclassasPortugal,Ireland,Greece,andIceland(BBBcountries).Inthisworstcase,theUSwillfacehigherborrowingrates;andthefailuretoactwilladdimportantlytoourfutureburden,asdiscussedinournextinstallment.Butwewillstillbealongwayfromnationalbankruptcy.

Insummary:theUSisnotonthedoorstepofafinancialcrisistriggeredbyexcessivenationaldebt.Evenatthedebtlevelsprojectedfortheendofthisdecadeifnocorrectiveactionsaretaken(about90percentofGDP),itisalmostinconceivablethattheUSwouldchoosetodefault.Theimportantproblemsofthefiscalimbalancelieelsewhere.Letuslookatthem.

THREE:THEBURDENOFTHEDEBT

Aswehavediscussed,ournationaldebtisnotlikelytobankruptus.But,itcausesotherseriousproblems.Ittakesawayourflexibilitytorunlargedeficitsintheeventoffuturewarsornationalemergencies,whenotherwiseitwouldmakegoodsensetospreadthecostofsecuringourcountryoverseveralgenerations.Alargedebtlimitsourgovernment’sabilitytosoftenrecessionsthroughtemporarytaxreductionsandincreasesinexpenditures.Somebelievethatwhenweborrowfromothercountries,webecomebeholdentothemandloseadegreeofsovereignty.Thesecostsoflargedebtaredifficulttomeasurebutsurelyimportant.However,oneconsequenceoflargedebteclipsesalloftheothers:whenourgovernmentborrowstoday,itnecessarilylowersthestandardoflivingofcitizensinthefuture.Thisharmtothefutureisknownastheburdenofthedebt.Themostcompellingargumenttocorrectourfiscalimbalanceisthatourdeficitsaretakingresourcesawayfromourchildrenandgrandchildren.

Whatisthesourceofthisburden?Howlargeisit,ifwefailtogetourimbalanceundercontrol?Letusbeginwiththebasics,andthenturntosomeimportantrefinementsthatshedlightonthetimingandpoliciesneededtodealwithourcurrentproblems.

TheBasics:CrowdingOutandDistortions

Onesourceoftheburdenisthepropensityforgovernmentborrowingto“crowdout”privateinvestmentexpenditures.

Recallthatwhenourgovernmentrunsadeficititmustborrowthefundstocoverthegapbetweenexpendituresandrevenues.Wherewillthesefundscomefrom?Onepossibilityistoobtainthefundsfromothercountries.Forexample,theBankofChinamightpurchasesomeofthegovernmentbonds

Page 9: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

9

soldtofinancethedeficit.Thisborrowingfromabroadbyourgovernmentcreatesaburdenbecauseinthefuturewewillpayinteresttoourforeigncreditors,andthisinterestmusteventuallycomeoutoftaxesonusorareductioninexpendituresongovernmentprograms.Indeed,presently52percentoftheUSnationaldebtisheldbyforeigncitizensorforeigngovernments,upfrom36percentadecadeago.Theinterestwepayonthisforeigndebtispurchasingpowerthatwecouldotherwisespendongoodsandservicesbut,instead,wearesendingabroad.That’saburdenonourchildren.Here,thegovernment’sborrowingissaidtocrowdoutforeigninvestmentbecausetheseborrowedfundsareanetreductionintheamountourcountryislendingabroad.

AnotherpossibilityisthatthegovernmentobtainsfundsfromUSbusinessesorfinancialinstitutions.Atfirstglance,becauseweareinthiscaseborrowingfromourselves,thispossibilitymayappearbenign:afterall,thetaxesraisedinthefuturetocovertheinterestarejustbeingreturnedtodomesticbanksandbusinesses.Emphatically,suchlogicisflawed.Infact,thefundsborrowedbythegovernmentfromdomesticbusinessesandbankswouldotherwisehavebeenusedtopurchasenewmachines,newstructures,andotherprojectsthatmakeusmoreproductive.Economistscalltheseproductiveresourcesthecapitalstock,andtheincreaseinthecapitalstockiscalleddomesticinvestment.Inthiscase,thegovernment’sborrowingcrowdsoutfundsthatwouldotherwisebeusedfordomesticinvestment,andindoingsowillcausethefuturetohaveasmallercapitalstock.Downtheroad,wewillproducelessthanweotherwisewould.Thislostproduction,relatedtotherateofreturnontheprojectsnotundertaken,isaburden.(Belowwereturntothepossibilityofgovernmentinvestment.)

“Crowdingout”is,forthemostpart,familiartoallofus:ifwecarrydebt,eventuallywemustreduceourdesiredexpenditurestorepaythedebt,oratleastcovertheinterest.Thatreductioninfutureconsumptionisour“burden.”However,thisanalogydoesnotworkperfectly;andestimatingtheburdenofournationaldebtisconsiderablymoresubtlethansimplymeasuringtheinterestpaidonournationaldebt.Foronething,therelevantinterestrateisnottheinterestrateatwhichourgovernmentborrowsbut,instead,thatrateadjustedforinflationandeconomicgrowth.Remember:soundpublicfinanceallowsdebttogrowinagrowingeconomy(keepingtheratioofdebt/gdpconstant),anddebtislessburdensomeifitisrepaidindollarsshrunkbyinflation.Inaddition,thegovernmentdebtisnotidenticaltotheaccumulatedinvestmentthathasbeencrowdedout.Possibly,aportionofthegovernment’sdemandforfundsismetbyincreasedsavingsonthepartofhouseholds,ratherthanbyattractingfundsthatotherwisewouldhavebeenusedfordomesticorforeigninvestment.Ifdeficitsencourageprivatesaving,theburdenonthefutureislessened.Thesizeofsavingsoffsetiscontroversial,becausesomeforcesunleashedbydeficitsandtheeventualpoliciestocorrecttheimbalanceencouragesaving(eg,higherinterestratesandtheanticipationofgreatertaxesinthefuture)whileotherforcesdiscouragesaving(eg,taxesoninterest).Butalmostallbelievethataheftyshareofthegovernment’sborrowingresultsinreducedprivateinvestment.

TheCBO(Dec2010)givesoneestimateofthecostsofourfiscalimbalance.Itsmodelcontainsassumptionsthatareplausibletomanyeconomistsand,hence,providesausefulballparkestimateofourdebtburden,inthefollowingsense.IftheUSfollowsitspresentpolicies,deficitswillgrowasashareofGDPandthedebtwillgrowinrelationtoGDP.(Moreonthis“statusquo”pathinournext

Page 10: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

10

chapter.)TheUScouldachievesustainabilityin2015(ie,byadjustingtaxesandexpenditurestolimitdeficitstonomorethan3percentofGDPinthatyearandbeyond),oritcouldwaituntil2025toachievesustainability.Ofcourse,ifwewaittenyears,thedebt/GDPratiothatissustainedwillbelarger;andthetaxincreaseand/orexpenditurereductionrelativetothestatusquoneededtoachievethatsustainabilitywillbelarger.Inparticular,ifwewait,wewillhaveallowedthedebttoincreasetoabout115percentofGDPinsteadof75percentofGDP,andthetaxincreaseand/orexpenditurereductionneededtobalancetheannualbudgetisconsequentlyabout3.5percentagepointsofGDPlarger.TheCBOasks:ifwestabilizein2025ratherthanin2015,byhowmuchwillourannualconsumptioninthelongrun(ie,after2025,whentheeconomyhasre‐equilibrated)bereduced?Theansweris(dependingonthepoliciesundertakentoachievesustainability)anywherefrom1.5centsto5centsofconsumptionoutofeachdollarwemake.Thatis,becauseofcrowdingout,foreverypermanentincreaseinthedebt/GDPratioof.1,weharmourdescendentstothetuneof$.40to$1.25onevery$100theyearn,eachyear,forever.Thesearefairlytypicalestimatesoftheburdenofthedebt.

Asecondsourceofburdenistheinevitabledistortionsassociatedwithtaxesorinsufficientprovisionoflegitimatepublicgoods.Aswehavediscussed,whenthegovernmentcreatesdebtitmusteventuallyraisetaxes,orcutexpenditures,sufficientlytokeepthedebtgrowingnofasterthantheeconomyasawhole.Ifwecouldcollectthosetaxesinawaythatdoesnotdistortpeople’sincentivestosave,invest,andwork,thenthecumulativelostinvestmentwouldbetheonlysourceofaburden.However,theactofcollectingtaxes(orcuttingprograms,forreasonsthatwouldtakeusonanunproductivedetour)typicallydistortsincentivesandcreatesinefficienciesinouruseofresourcesinthefuture.Asaconsequence,theverypoliciesrequiredtocorrecttheimbalancetakeatollontheeconomy.

Likecrowdingout,attachinganumbertothedistortionscausedbycorrectivepoliciesisasubtlequestionthathasoccupiedeconomistssinceAdamSmith.Allagreethatwhenyoutaxoneperson,andtransferthatmoneytoanother,somethingislostintheprocess,duetothedistortionsinincentivescreatedbythetax.Allagreethatthisleakinthebucketbecomesmoreserious1)themoresensitiveweareinourdecisionstowork,save,andinvesttothepriceswefaceand2)thegreateristherateoftaximposedontheseactivities.However,thereisarangeofreasonableestimatesofoursensitivity,andthecomplexityofourtaxandexpendituresystemmakestracingincentiveshighlycomplex.Asaballparkestimate,manyeconomistsbelievethateverydollarofnewtaxrevenue,derivedfromanincreaseinincometaxrates,generates$.15to$.5ofhiddencoststotheeconomy.Thus,intheCBOmodelcitedabove,those3.5percentagepointsofGDPoftaxrevenuesthatneedtoberaisedasaresultofwaitinguntil2025haveahiddencostontheorderof0.5to1.75percentagepointsofGDP.Theselossesareinadditiontothe1.5to5percentagepointsofGDPoflostdirectconsumptionresultingfromthecrowdingoutdescribedabove.

Refinements

Uptothispoint,wehavetreatedallgovernmentexpendituresasequallyburdensome,andalltaxesasequallyinefficient.Infact,thereareimportantdifferences.Theproblemswithgovernmentborrowing

Page 11: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

11

arecrowdingoutandtheinefficienciescreatedbythefuturepoliciesthatclosethegap.Theobviouscorollarytothisobservationisthat,inattackingourimbalance,weshouldtargetforreductionthoseexpenditureswhichgeneratethemostcrowdingoutandfindthosetaxincreaseswhosedistortionsarethesmallest.

Consider,first,theissueofminimizingtaxdistortions.Efficienttaxsystemsexploittheentiretaxbase,havesimilartaxratesatthemarginfordifferentindividualsandactivities,andmakecomplianceeasyandinexpensive.Ourtaxsystemisflawedinmanyways.Thus,manydeficitreductionplans(seenextchapter)proposetaxreformthatwouldsimplifyourtaxsystemandreducemarginaltaxratesbyexpandingthetaxbase,reducingthelevelofemployerbenefitsthancanbeshelteredaspre‐taxdollars,andlimitingdeductionswhicharepoorlytargeted.Thesereformscanbeaccomplishedinawaythatpreservestheprogressivityofourtaxstructure.Inaddition,weoughttoidentifytaxesthatmakeoureconomyoperatemoreefficiently,becausetheycorrectproblemsthatarisewhenourmarketeconomyfailsus.Examplesareagastax(foreigndependency),acarbontax(environmentaldegradation),andataxonsweetenedbeverages(publichealth).Suchreformsarealwaysgoodbutareespeciallytimelytomoderatethedebtburden.

Next,letusreconsidertheissueofthecrowdingoutofcapitalinvestments.Whenwe,ashouseholds,takeoutamortgagetopurchaseahome,orastudentloan,wedosotoacquireanassetthatwillbearfruitinthefuture.Suchborrowingmakesperfectsenseif,inthefuture,thebenefitofourinvestment–forexample,theincreaseinearningsattributabletooureducation–cancoverthedebtservice.Thecalculusissimilarforgovernmentexpendituresthatarethemselvesinvestments,definedasprojectsthatyieldbenefitsinthefuture.Yes,borrowingforsuchexpenditurescrowdsoutformsofprivateinvestment,butthegovernmentinvestmentinitsplaceactstoincreaseourfutureproduction.Ifthegovernmentprojectswouldnototherwisebeundertakenbyprivateinvestorsandyieldarateofreturnatleastaslargeasprivateprojects,thengovernmentborrowingtofinancethoseinvestmentexpendituresmakesperfectsense.Unfortunately,ourgovernmentdoesnotaccountsatisfactorilyfortheportionofexpendituresthatshouldcountasinvestment;so,wecannotjudgehowmuchofitsapparentcrowdingoutisactuallyhelping,ratherthanharming,thefuture.Manyexpendituresyieldfuturebenefitsthatarehardtoquantify.Forexample,howquantifythefuturebenefitstoourcountryofdefensespending,orthefuturesavingstohealthcostsofpreventativemedicinetoday?Despitetheseconceptualdifficulties,thereisevidencethatcarefulspendingoneducation(especiallypreschool),basicscienceresearch,theenvironment,andonprojectstosustainourtransportationandcommunicationsinfrastructurecanyieldatleastacompetitiverateofreturn.Wehavecost‐benefitframeworksthatcanguideus.Reducingsuchexpenditurestocureourcurrentfiscalimbalancemightbepennywisebutsurelywouldbepoundfoolish.Onemajorchallengeintrimmingexpenditureswillbetoidentifyandprotectthoseinvestmentexpenditureswhoseratesofreturncomparefavorablytoprivateopportunities.

Theotherimportantcaseofdeficitswithmodestcrowdingoutiswhendeficitspendingissuccessfulinstimulatingtheeconomyinarecession.Ifgovernmentspending,ortaxreductions,canincreaseourincome,thenthisincreasewillencouragemoreprivatesaving.Asnotedabove,thisnewsavingwillhelp

Page 12: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

12

tofundthedeficitandoffset,inpart,thereductioninfundsavailabletoprivateinvestors.Anotherroutetothissameconclusionistorecallthatinvestmentexpendituresarepurchasesofnewcapitalgoods.Assuch,theyareacomponentofourdemandforgoodsintheaggregate.Thegovernmentcanstimulatetheeconomybyincreasingthedemandforgoodsintheaggregate,directlythroughitsownpurchasesorindirectlythroughtheprivatespendinginducedbytaxreductions.Thegovernment’sstimulationispowerfulonlyifitisnotoffsetbyreductionsintheothercomponentsofaggregatedemand,suchasinvestmentexpenditures.Fromthisangle,thegreateriscrowdingout,thesmalleristhenetimpactofgovernmentactionsonaggregatedemand,andthesmalleristhenetstimulus.Insum,deficitswhichsuccessfullystimulatetheeconomyarebenign,orevenbeneficial.Thefutureburdenfromcrowdingoutislessenedbythestimulation,andtheemploymentofresourcesthatwouldotherwiselieidleisitselfabenefittosetagainstthisfuturecost.

Howpowerful,inpractice,aregovernmenttaxandspendingpoliciestoinfluenceemploymentandproduction?Economistsdivideonthisissue,butallagreethatthepreconditionsforsuccessfulstimulusare1)unemployedresourcesand2)supportivepoliciesbythecentralbanktopreventtheincreaseininterestrates(andvalueofthecurrency)thatwouldotherwiseaccompanytheactionandchokeoffinvestment.WithunemploymentintheUSnear9percentandaFederalReserveintentonkeepinginterestratesandvalueofthedollarlow,theUSisnowinpreciselythecircumstanceswhenstimulusthroughfiscalactionscanwork.Asaconsequence,manyeconomistsrecommendthatthesignificantreductionsinspendingorincreaseintaxesrequiredtoeliminateourimbalancebedelayedwhiletheeconomyisweak,i.e.untilthesepreconditionsforstimulusarenolongerwithus.Actingearlierdelaystherecoveryandhasminorimpactsonthecrowdingoutofconcern.

TogaugethestimulationandburdenofUSfiscalpolicies,weturnagaintotheanalysisoftheCBO(Nov2010).AsizeableportionofthepresentUSbudgetdeficitisattributabletothetaxcutsandexpenditureincreasesthathappenautomaticallywhenoureconomydeclinesandhappenasaresultofactivegovernmentstimulus.ThebestknownofthelatterwastheAmericanRecoveryandReinvestmentAct(ARRA)of2009,whichincreaseddeficits2009‐2011(mainly)ontheorderof$800billion(accordingtoCBOestimates).(OtheractivestimulusmeasureswereapartoftheDecember2010taxextension,whichwilladdroughly$200billionofdeficits(inadditiontothedelayoftaxincreases),andtheTroubledAssetReliefProgram(TARP)whichaddedanestimated$15billiontogovernmentexpenditures.)BecausethesemeasureswereundertakenwhentheeconomywasslackandwiththeassistanceoflowinterestratesmaintainedbytheFederalReserve,theyincreasedproductionand(throughtheadditionalprivatesavingsthatincomespawned)didnotcrowdoutinvestmentdollarfordollar.Howmuchwascrowdedoutand,theflipside,howmuchtheeconomywasstimulated,areuncertain,buttheCBOprovidesarangeofestimatesthatspantheopinionsofmosteconomistsandtheirmodels.The$800billionofARRAdeficitsaddedsomewherebetween$480to$1200billiontoGDP;$800billionisaconvenientconsensusestimate.Theseestimatesofstimulusdonot,inthemselves,indicatethedegreeofcrowdingout.Tocompletethepicture,wemustpositapropensityofUShouseholdstosaveanadditionaldollarofincome.Forthesakeofdiscussion,weselect30centsofeachdollarsaved,anumberwithinarangeplausibletomosteconomists.

Page 13: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

13

Withthesenumbersinhand,wecanestimate1(anupperbound)onthecrowdingoutassociatedwithARRA.Forthosewhobelieveinastrongstimulusof$1200b,thecrowdingoutisonly$280b:averyfavorabletradeoff.Attheotherextreme,thosewhobelieveinasmallstimulusof$480bwouldpredictacrowdingoutof(atmost)$500b.Conservativepoliticiansarepronetoassertthatrecentstimulusmeasureshavebeenineffectiveandshouldbeabandoned.Conservativeeconomists,atthelowerendofthebeliefinstimulus,wouldgiveamorenuancedassessment:fiscalpolicycanwork,buteachdollarofcurrentGDPcreatedoutofidleresourcesdrawsapproximatelyonedollarfromfutureincome.Forthoseinthemiddle,undertheconsensusestimateofastimulusof$800b,thecrowdingoutisonly$400b.Yes,thereisaburden,butforeverydollaroflossinthefuture,twodollarsaregainedinthepresent.

Thesearethedimensionsofthetrade‐offrelevantfordeficitreductionsduringperiodsofhighunemploymentandsupportivemonetarypolicies.Aswelooktothefuture,theeconomywilleventuallyrecover.Andthenwemusttacklethedifficultproblemofhowtoachieveasustainabledeficit,towhichwenowturn.

FOUR:THEHARDCHOICES

In2001,whentheUSwasalmostfullyemployed,itranabudgetsurplusof1.3percentofGDP.In2008,whentheUSeconomywasjustbeginningtoexperiencetheslumpwhichprevailstothisday,thebudgetwasindeficitequalto3.2percentofGDP.Nowmiredinthatdownturn,theUSin2011islikelytoexperienceabudgetdeficitontheorderof9.8percentofGDP.Howdidwegethere?Whatdoesthefutureholdifwefailtoact,andwhatarethedimensionsofthesacrificesrequiredtoachieveasustainablebudget?InthischapterweexplorekeycomponentsoftheUSbudgettoshowhowthedeficithasemerged,andplanstobringitbackintosustainability.

Tounderstandthesourcesofandpotentialsolutionstoourimbalance,letusreviewthestructureoftheFederalbudget,assummarizedinTable3.Inthistable,webreakdowntheFederalbudgetintoitsmajorrevenueandexpenditurecategories,fortheyears2001,2008,and2010.TheTableshowsthevariouscategoriesintermsofdollarsandassharesoftheGDP,anditrecordsthepercentagerateofchangeoftheseveralcomponentsbetweenthedifferentyears.Asisevident,revenuesoftheFederalgovernmentaremainlytaxes,andthebulkofthosetaxesarecollectedonhouseholdincomesinthe1Theseestimatesareillustrativeandtheauthors’calculations.TheARRAinvolvedmanykindsofexpenditureincreasesandtaxreductions,eachwithitsownmultipliedimpactontheGDP.Herewesimplifythepackageandsupposethatitinvolved$267bofanincreaseinspendingongovernmentpurchasesofgoodsandservicesand$533ofareductionintaxesand/orincreaseintransferpayments.Weassumeamultiplierof1(minimum)to2.5(maximum)fortheformerexpendituresandamultiplierof0.4to1forthelatterreductionsinnettaxes.(ThesemultipliersareinlinewiththeCBOranges.)Toobtainanupperboundonthesizeofcrowdingout,weassumethatprivatesavingisnotincreasedbytheincreaseininterestratesortheexpectationsoffuturetaxincreasesthatarelikelytoaccompanythefiscalstimulusandisaffectedonlybychangesindisposableincome.

Page 14: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

14

formofindividuals’incometaxesandthepayrolltaxforsocialinsurance.In2010,forexample,almost80percentofgovernmentrevenuecamefromthesetwosources,withtheindividuals’incometaxcomprisingthelargestshare.Federalgovernmentexpenditureisdividedintothreecategories:so‐calledmandatory,discretionary,andinterestexpenses.MandatoryexpendituresarisefromprogramswhoserulesforeligibilityandlevelofbenefitaresetbytheLegislatureandwhoseoutlayinanyparticularyearisdeterminedbythoserulesratherthananexplicitdollarallocation.Theseprograms,alsoknownasthe“entitlements,”includesocialsecuritypayments,paymentsforhealthinsurancefortheelderly(Medicare)andpoor(eg,Medicaid),andvariousincomesupportprograms,suchasunemploymentcompensationandfoodstamps.Inrecentyears,mandatoryexpenditureshavecomprisedabout60percentofallnon‐interestexpendituresandaredominatedbysocialsecurityandMedicare.DiscretionaryexpendituresareexplicitdollarallocationsvotedbytheLegislatureeachyear.Theyincludenationaldefenseandthemanycorefunctionsofgovernment(salariesofgovernmentofficialsandemployees,education,environment,transportation,andsoon).Foreignaidspendingisalsodiscretionary;atroughly0.3percentofGDP,itisatinycomponentofthebudget,toosmalltoshowonitsown.Thediscretionaryexpenditurescompriseabout40percentofnon‐interestexpenseandareaboutequallydividedbetweennationaldefenseandotheruses.TheseotheruseshavebeenthebattlegroundinCongressinrecentmonths.Asyoucanseefromthetable,theseskirmishesovernon‐defensediscretionaryexpenditureshavebeenfoughtonasmallbattlefield,comprisingonly4.5percentoftheGDPandlessthan18percentofallnon‐interestspending.Thefinalspendingcategoryisinterestonthenationaldebtheldbythepublic,whichin2010wassmallinrelationtotheGDP(1.4percent)andtotalFederalexpenditures(5.7percent).InapparentoppositiontotheincreaseovertimeinthenationaldebtinrelationtoGDP,theFederalinterestexpenseasashareofGDP(andasashareoftotalgovernmentspending)fellduringthedecade.Thisremarkabledeclineisaresultofexceptionallylowinterestrates,byhistoricalstandards,paidbytheUSTreasury;andisatrendthatsurelywillnotcontinue.

Table3showsthegrowthratesfrom2001to2008inrevenues,expenditures,andtheGDPmeasuredincurrentdollars.Weseereadilywhyadeficitemergedduringthisperiod,andthatitssourceswerebroadbased:duringthisperiod,everyimportantcomponentofexpendituregrewfasterthandidGDP,andeverykeycomponentofrevenuegrewmoreslowly.However,afewofthebudgetlinesstandout:defenseandMedicarewerethefastestgrowingexpenditurecategories,andtheindividualincometax(whichnormallywouldgrowfasterthanGDPaspeoplearepushedintohighertaxbrackets)grewlessthanhalfasrapidlyasdidGDP.Thereasonsforthesetrendsareapparent:warsinIraqandAfghanistan,anexpensivenewbenefitforprescriptiondrugsinMedicare(PartD),andsignificantreductionsintaxratesin2001and2003.Thesefactorsrevealastructuralimbalanceofroughly$400billion(ie,thedeteriorationinthefullemploymentbudgetbalance)thathappenedjustastheeconomybeganitsdownwardslidein2008.

Thechangesfrom2008to2010shownintheTable(2008comparedtotheestimated2011showsasimilarstory)revealstheimpactoftherecession:despitestagnantGDP,taxrevenuesdeclinedsharply,and(althoughallexpenditurescontinuedtogrow)incomesupportsuchasunemployment

Page 15: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

15

compensationandnon‐defensediscretionaryexpendituresbecamethefastestgrowers.ThesechangesevidencetheautomaticresponseoftaxcollectionsandincomecushionstotherecessionandtheexplicitstimulusmeasuresenactedbyCongress.Aswediscussedinourfirstchapter,theCBOestimatestheautomaticcushionatroughly$350billion,thedifferencebetweentheactualdeficitandthestructuraldeficit.Thestimulusmeasures(mainlyARRAplusthenegativeTARPadjustment)addedabout$300billiontothedeficitin2010,someindiscretionaryspendingbutalsointaxreductionsandincomesupport.

Thesethreecomponents–thestructuralimbalancethatemergedsince2001,theautomaticresponsetothedownturn,andthepoliciesenactedtodealwithit–accountformuchofthedeficitweexperiencetoday.Butthislogicalsohasaharshmessage:arollbackofthestimulusmeasuresandtheeventualre‐achievementoffullemployment(hopedforin2015)cannotalonebringusbacktosustainability.Thatstructuralimbalanceisnotgoingaway.Inaddition,powerfulforcesarebeginningtofuelgrowthinthemandatoryexpendituresinexcessofGDPgrowth.Thebabyboomersarestartingtoretireandtolivelonger,andthisagingofthepopulationcausessocialsecurityandMedicarepaymentsundercurrentbenefitrulestogrowmorerapidlythanGDP.Also,largelyasaresultofnewlyavailabletreatmentsandtechnologies,andasystemwhichoffersfewincentivesforpatientsorproviderstoeconomizeoncosts,healthcarespendingperindividualhasincreasedalmost2percentperyearfasterthanthegrowthofincomeperperson,formanyyears.Ifthistrendcontinues,thenthehealth‐relatedmandatoryexpenditureswillexplode.

InMarch2010theCBOprojectedtheFederalbudgetintothefutureunderdifferentscenarios.(Developmentssincethattimemakethesituationevenmoredaunting;seeCBOMarch2011.)Theseprojectionsarehighlyspeculative,formanyreasons,butarenon‐partisanandthebestavailable.Inonescenario,whichwewillcallthestatusquo(andtheCBOlabels“thealternativefiscalscenario”),theCBOtriedtocapturehowthebudgetwouldevolveifwecontinuewhatwe’redoing,inthefollowingsenses:i)benefitrulesformandatoryprogramsstayas‐is,andhealthcosttrendscontinuetheirhistoricalpatternofincrease;ii)ourtaxcoderesemblesthesystemthatwasextendedinDecember2010,exceptthattaxratesforthewealthy(+$250Kformarried)revertbackto2001levelsandestatetaxesrevertbackto2009features;andiii)thestimulusmeasuresarephasedoutanddiscretionaryspendingafterwardsgrowsinlockstepwithGDP.Inaddition,after2020,theprojectionsassumethatthetaxcodewillbeadjustedtokeeprevenuesaconstantshareofGDP.InTable4,weshowthestatusquoprojectedrevenuesandexpenditures,assharesofGDP,inyears2020and2035.Aswell,weincludetheactualsharesinthebenchmarkyearscoveredinTable3.

Themessageoftheprojectionissobering:

*overthenextdecade,debtwillcontinuetoriseinrelationtoGDPandreachroughly87percentin2020.Thedeficitatthattime,approximately6.6percentofGDP,willnotstabilizethedebt/GDPratiointosubsequentyears.Evenabrakeondiscretionaryspendingthatholdsexpendituresotherthanthoseoninterest,socialsecurity,andhealthto2001levelsrelativetoGDP(savingabout1.3percentofGDPofdeficit)isnotnearlyenoughtoachievesustainabilitybythatdate.

Page 16: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

16

*after2020,socialsecurityandhealthobligationsreallykickin:incomparisonto2020,underthestatusquo,in2035theseentitlementscomprise4.7percentmoreofthenationalproduct.Suchdevelopments,andinterestontheaccumulatedborrowing,generateadeficitofalmost16percentoftheGDPin2035andadebt/GDPratioof1.85.Ifweshouldreachthatstage,achievingsustainabilitywouldrequireanincreaseintaxes,orcutinnon‐interestspending,ontheorderof10percentofGDP.Thatisaverytallorder.

What’smore:theseprojectionsareanoverlyoptimisticvisionofthestatusquo,becausegovernmentborrowingofthismagnitudewouldleadtoslowerGDPgrowth,andbiggerinterestrates,thanusedintheexercise.

Theseprojectionsarearealitycheck.Wecan’tgrowoutofourdebtproblem:theprojectionsalreadyaccountfortheeffectoftheeconomy’sgrowthontaxcollectionsandtheeliminationoftemporarystimuluswhenfullemploymentisachieved.Highertaxesontherichwillnotinthemselvessolvetheproblem:these,too,arealreadyinthemodel.Abrakeonnon‐defensediscretionaryspending(ofwhichthemuchdiscussed“earmarks”andforeignaidareatinyfraction)isnotenough:atlevelsofnon‐defensediscretionaryspendingtypicaloffullemployment(forexamplethe3.6percentofGDPin2008),eliminationofeverydollaroftheseprogramswouldnotbeenoughin2020tobringaboutasustainabledeficitoflessthan3percentofGDP.Rather,theprojectionsmakeevidentthattheactionsnecessaryforasustainablebudgetpatharepreciselytheoptionsthatnoonewantstotalkabout:weMUSTeitheri)reducediscretionaryspending,includingdefense,asashareofGDP;and/orii)collectmoretaxes,asashareofGDP,thanwehaveinrecenthistory;and/oriii)reformentitlements,especiallythenationalhealthinsuranceprograms.

Indeed,anysensibleandsuccessfuldeficitreductionplanthatwecanimaginewillinvolveadoseofallthreeoftheseoptions.Ideally,wewouldcutspendingonprogramswiththelowestfuturepayoffsandraisetaxesinawaythatinducestheleastharm.Benefitcostanalysiscanhelpguideushere,butpeoplewilllikelydisagreeontherelativevalueofprogramsandrelativeharmcausedbyvarioustaxes.Thepoliticalcompromisesneededtobringaboutanagreementrequirethatallsidesgiveupsomething.Aplancannotbesuccessfulunlessitisregardedasfair.Thissimplyreflectspoliticalreality:amajorityofAmericanswillsupportnecessarilypainfuldeficitreductiononlyifitbelievesthesacrificeisshared.Butalso,mosteconomistswouldviewabroad‐basedapproachassensible.Ineverydaylife,whenwereduceourspending,wetypicallycutbackonallexpenditures.Ifwe,asindividuals,werefacedwiththechoiceofreducingsomegovernmentprograms(likenationaldefenseoraidtofarmersoraccesstoournationalparksoraidtotheunemployedorhungry)orreducingourownconsumptionbyhighertaxes,likelywewouldchooseabitofboth.Ifwe,asindividuals,werefacedwiththechoiceofgivingupspendingwhenweareyoung(socialsecuritytaxes)and/orwhenweareold(socialsecuritybenefits,Medicare),likelywewoulddoabitofboth.Writlargeinthebudget,thesearethewaysdeficitreductionaffectsus,asindividuals.Mostofus,uponreflection,wouldoptforthesamebroad‐basedreductioninallformsofourconsumptionaswedoineverydaylife.

Page 17: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

17

Theneedforsharedsacrificeisevidentintherecommendationsoftwoprestigiousandmuch‐publicizedbipartisanbudgetplans,oneproposedbytheNationalCommitteeonFiscalResponsibilityandReform,chairedbyErskineBowlesandSenatorAlanSimpson(B&S,Dec2010),andtheotherproposedbytheDebtReductionTaskForce,chairedbySenatorPeteDominiciandDr.AliceRivlin(D&R,Nov2010).Thesegroupshadtomakedecisionsonmanydimensions,includingwhen,andatwhatlevelofindebtedness,theUSshouldreachsustainability;whatareasofthebudgetshouldbeartheburdenofgettingthere;andhowthenecessarypoliciesshouldbephasedinovertime.Itisthereforestrikingthat,inbroadoutline,therecommendationshavemuchincommon.Inparticular:

*eachrecommendsatargetdebt/GDPratioofapproximately60percent,andadeficit(ofroughly3‐2percentofGDP)thatatleastsustainsthatratio,by2020;

*tosupportthefragilerecovery,eachrecommendsnosignificantdeficitreduction(indeed,noreductionsindollardiscretionaryexpenditures)until2013.Underbothplans,debtrelativetoGDPwouldpeakatapproximately70percentinthatyear,andinthatyeardeficitsforthefirsttimewouldbesmallenoughtoeatawayatthatratio;

*bothplanswouldemploythefullrangeofbudgetaryremedies.Bothwouldrollbackdiscretionaryspending,onbothdefenseanddomesticprograms,asashareofGDP,toatmost2001standards.BothwouldincreasetotaltaxcollectionsasashareofGDPrelativetothestatusquowhilesimultaneouslyreducingmarginaltaxratesandsimplifyingthetaxcodebyeliminating,orbytargetingbetter,manyofthedeductionsandcreditscurrentlyallowed.Eachwouldfindsavingsinsocialsecuritybenefitsbyincreasedmeans‐testing,bycalibratingpaymentsandretirementagetoincreasedlifeexpectancy,andbyindexingtoacostoflivingmeasurethatismoreaccuratethatusedcurrently.Eachwouldattempttocontrolthegrowthofhealthcarecostsbyintroducingincentivesforprovidersanduserstoeconomizeandbyloweringexpenses,suchasthoseofprescriptiondrugsandmalpractice.Bothplansacknowledgethatexpenditure/gdpmustriseoverhistoricalaveragesinresponsetoouragingpopulation,risinghealthcosts,increasedhomelandsecurityneeds,andhigherinterestexpenses;

*bothplansenvisionmodestdeficitreductionfromentitlementreform2012‐2020(becauseofthecomplexityofreformandtheneedtofulfillcommitmentstotoday’sretired)butregardpromptreformsasessentialtolongrunsustainability.

Tobesure:theplansdifferinthedetailsoftheirhundredsofrecommendedpolicychanges.Thetaxandentitlementreformsarecontroversialandcomplexandwillbedebatedatlength.Butthecommonmessageofthesetwoeminentandbi‐partisangroupscapturesamiddlegroundaboutthesizeofnecessaryadjustmentsthatmanyeconomistswouldendorse.

Theseplansalsoillustrateakeydifferenceinperspectives:theextenttowhichsustainabilityshouldbeachievedthroughtaxincreasesorexpenditurereductions.TheB&Sproposalwouldachieveroughly2/3ofitsdeficitreductionthroughreductionsingovernmentprogramsand1/3throughincreasesintaxrevenues(relativetothestatusquo).TheR&Dproposalwouldachieveasimilardeficitreductionwithalesserrelianceonprogramcuts:expenditurereductionsandtaxrevenueincreaseswouldeach

Page 18: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

18

contributetoroughlyhalfofthegoal.Inbothplans,taxesandspendingwouldreachhistoricallyhighproportionsofGDPin2020(andbeyond).B&Srecommendataxshareof20.6percentin2020,wouldreducediscretionaryexpendituressharply(to5.3percentofGDPin2020,andashareof“other”of7.3percent),andwouldholdoverallspendingto21.6percentofGDPattheendofthedecade.Incontrast,D&Rrecommendthelargertaxrevenues(21.3percentofGDPin2020,inpartachievedthroughanationalsalestax)and,correspondingly,asmallerreductionindiscretionaryexpendituresrelativetothestatusquo,andalargeroverallspendingshareof23percentin2020.

Doesthebalanceofspendingandtaxesmatter?TheR&Dplanwouldprovidemorestimulustoaneconomywhichisexpectedtohaveexcessiveunemploymentuntil2015,becauseexpenditurereductionsdiminishaggregatedemandmorethandotaxincreases.TheB&Splancutsdomesticdiscretionaryexpendituressodeeplythatgovernmentinvestmentsarelikelytobereduced.However,theB&Stemplatewillbefavoredbythosewhoemphasizetheinefficienciescreatedbytaxesandwhojudgesomegovernmentprogramsaslessessentialthantheprivateconsumptiontheyreplace.

Theseissues,andthegiantcomplexitiesofreformingourtaxcodeandmodeofhealthcareprovision,arethelegitimatefocusofthedebateoverourdeficitthatmusttakeplaceoverthenexttwoyears.Thesoonerdebatecanoccupythismiddleground(ratherthantheextremesofnochangeinentitlementsortotaxrevenues)thebetter.

BOOKS,ARTICLES,ANDDATABASESCITED

ErskineBowlesandSenatorAlanSimpson,co‐chairsoftheNationalCommissiononFiscalResponsibilityandReform,TheMomentofTruth,December,2010

CongressionalBudgetOffice(CBO),“LongTermBudgetProjections,”June,2010

CBO,“FederalDebtandtheRiskofaFiscalCrisis,”July,2010

CBO,“EstimatedImpactoftheAmericanRecoveryandReinvestmentActonEmploymentandEconomicOutputfromJuly2010throughSeptember2010,”November,2010

CBO,“EconomicImpactsofWaitingtoResolvetheLong‐TermBudgetImbalance,”December,2010

CBO,“TheBudgetandEconomicOutlook:FiscalYears2011to2021,”January,2011

CBO,“ReducingtheDeficit:SpendingandRevenueOptions,”March,2011

SenatorPeteDominiciandDr.AliceRivlin,co‐chairsoftheDebtReductionTaskForce,RestoringAmerica’sFuture:RevivingtheEconomy,CuttingSpendingandDebt,andCreatingaSimple,Pro‐GrowthTaxSystem,”November,2010

InternationalMonetaryFund,WorldEconomicOutlookDatabase,October,2010

Page 19: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

19

CarmenM.ReinhartandKennethS.Rogoff,ThisTimeisDifferent:EightCenturiesofFinancialFolly,PrincetonUniversityPress,Princeton,NJ,2009

Page 20: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Table1FederalRevenue,Expenditure,andDeficitsasPercentofGDP

GDP

PotentialGDP GDPgap

Revenue/GDP

Expenditure/GDP

Deficit/GDP

StructuralDeficit/potentialGDP

PubicDebt/GDP

1971 1,080 1,094 ‐1.32 17.3 19.5 ‐2.13 ‐1.7 28.1 1972 1,177 1,181 ‐0.39 17.6 19.6 ‐1.99 ‐1.9 27.4 1973 1,311 1,272 3.04 17.6 18.7 ‐1.14 ‐2.2 26.0 1974 1,438 1,411 1.92 18.3 18.7 ‐1.49 ‐1.2 23.9 1975 1,560 1,617 ‐3.50 17.9 21.3 ‐3.41 ‐2.2 25.3 1976 1,738 1,791 ‐2.93 17.1 21.4 ‐4.24 ‐2.9 27.5 1977 1,974 2,000 ‐1.35 18.0 20.7 ‐2.72 ‐2.1 27.8 1978 2,217 2,209 0.39 18.0 20.7 ‐2.67 ‐2.8 27.4 1979 2,501 2,473 1.14 18.5 20.2 ‐1.63 ‐2.1 25.6 1980 2,724 2,771 ‐1.69 19.0 21.7 ‐2.71 ‐2.1 26.1 1981 3,057 3,113 ‐1.81 19.6 22.2 ‐2.58 ‐1.7 25.8 1982 3,224 3,419 ‐5.71 19.2 23.1 ‐3.97 ‐1.8 28.7 1983 3,441 3,677 ‐6.43 17.5 23.5 ‐6.04 ‐3.3 33.1 1984 3,844 3,926 ‐2.09 17.3 22.2 ‐4.82 ‐3.9 34.0 1985 4,146 4,187 ‐0.97 17.7 22.8 ‐5.12 ‐4.7 36.4 1986 4,404 4,428 ‐0.54 17.5 22.5 ‐5.02 ‐4.7 39.5 1987 4,651 4,690 ‐0.83 18.4 21.6 ‐3.22 ‐2.9 40.6 1988 5,008 4,990 0.37 18.2 21.3 ‐3.10 ‐3.2 41.0 1989 5,399 5,342 1.07 18.4 21.2 ‐2.83 ‐3.3 40.6 1990 5,734 5,706 0.49 18.0 21.9 ‐3.85 ‐4.1 42.1 1991 5,930 6,091 ‐2.64 17.8 22.3 ‐4.54 ‐3.5 45.3 1992 6,242 6,414 ‐2.68 17.5 22.1 ‐4.65 ‐3.4 48.1 1993 6,587 6,729 ‐2.10 17.5 21.4 ‐3.87 ‐2.9 49.3 1994 6,977 7,062 ‐1.21 18.0 21.0 ‐2.91 ‐2.3 49.2 1995 7,341 7,423 ‐1.10 18.4 20.6 ‐2.23 ‐1.8 49.1 1996 7,718 7,796 ‐1.00 18.8 20.2 ‐1.39 ‐0.9 48.4 1997 8,212 8,192 0.24 19.2 19.5 ‐0.27 ‐0.3 45.9 1998 8,663 8,575 1.03 19.9 19.1 0.80 0.4 43.0 1999 9,208 8,994 2.39 19.8 18.5 1.36 0.4 39.4 2000 9,821 9,503 3.35 20.6 18.2 2.41 1.0 34.7 2001 10,225 10,086 1.39 19.5 18.2 1.25 0.5 32.5 2002 10,544 10,602 ‐0.55 17.6 19.1 ‐1.50 ‐1.3 33.6 2003 10,980 11,149 ‐1.52 16.2 19.7 ‐3.44 ‐2.8 35.6 2004 11,686 11,733 ‐0.40 16.1 19.6 ‐3.53 ‐3.3 36.8 2005 12,446 12,398 0.39 17.3 19.9 ‐2.56 ‐2.7 36.9 2006 13,225 13,123 0.78 18.2 20.1 ‐1.88 ‐2.2 36.5 2007 13,892 13,851 0.29 18.5 19.6 ‐1.16 ‐1.3 36.2 2008 14,394 14,513 ‐0.82 17.5 20.7 ‐3.19 ‐2.9 40.3 2009 14,098 15,020 ‐6.14 14.9 25.0 ‐10.02 ‐7.3 53.5 2010 14,513 15,397 ‐5.74 14.9 23.8 ‐8.92 ‐6.1 62.1

Source: "Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal Years 2011‐2021," CBO, January 2011. GDP and Potential GDP in current dollars; the GDP gap is the percentage difference between actual output and potential output; and the other columns are percentages of GDP.

Page 21: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Table2:InternationalComparisons

Debt/GDP

Deficit/GDP

StructuralDeficit/potentialGDP GDPgap

Revenues/GDP

Canada 30.6 ‐5.2 ‐3.3 ‐3.1 38.0France 71.4 ‐7.8 ‐5.0 ‐3.7 48.4Germany 57.3 ‐3.8 ‐2.0 ‐3.3 43.2Greece 103.2 ‐10.7 ‐11.5 1.5 38.2Italy 97.9 ‐5.2 ‐3.7 ‐3.3 46.3Ireland 45.8 ‐16.1 ‐9.0 ‐6.4 34.9Japan 116.2 ‐9.9 ‐7.4 ‐6.0 29.8Portugal 75.5 ‐8.3 ‐7.1 ‐1.5 39.6UK 64.9 ‐10.2 ‐8.1 ‐3.4 36.7US 62.3 ‐12.0 ‐7.6 ‐5.5 30.3Source: IMF "World Economic Outlook Database," October, 2010; all numbers are percentages of GDP; the GDP gap is the percentage difference between actual output and potential output; revenues are government tax revenues. Government refers to all levels of government, not just Federal.

Page 22: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Table3:ComponentsofSpendingandRevenues

2001 2008 2010

Percentchange01‐08

Percentchange08‐10 2001/GDP 2008/GDP 2010/GDP

Revenues IndividualIncomeTax 994.3 1145.7 898.5 13.2 ‐27.5 9.7 8.0 6.2

SocialSecurity+MedicareTaxes 694 890.9 864.8 22.1 ‐3.0 6.8 6.2 6.0

Total 1991.1 2524 2161.7 21.1 ‐16.8 19.4 17.5 14.9 MandatorySpending

SocialSecurity 429.4 612.1 700.7 29.8 12.6 4.2 4.3 4.8Medicare 237.9 456 520.4 47.8 12.4 2.3 3.2 3.6Medicaid 129.4 201.4 272.8 35.7 26.2 1.3 1.4 1.9

UnemploymentInsurance 143.1 260.7 437.7 45.1 40.4 1.4 1.8 3.0

Total 1007.6 1594.8 1909.6 36.8 16.5 9.8 11.1 13.2 Non‐Mandatory

Defense 306.1 612.4 689.1 50.0 11.1 3.0 4.3 4.7Non‐defense 342.9 522.5 660.1 34.4 20.8 3.3 3.6 4.5

Total 649 1134.9 1349.2 42.8 15.9 6.3 7.9 9.3 Interest 206.2 252.8 196.9 18.4 ‐28.4 2.0 1.8 1.4 Deficit 128.2 ‐458.6 ‐1294.1 1.3 ‐3.2 ‐8.9StructuralDeficit 49 ‐425 ‐935 0.5 ‐3.0 ‐6.4GDP 10255 14394 14513 28.8 0.8 Inflation 22.0 1.0 Source: historical data in CBO "The Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal Years 2011 to 2021," January, 2011. The first three columns are in current dollars; the last three are percentages of GDP.

Page 23: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

TABLE4:ActualandProjectedSpending,RevenuesandDeficitsasPercentofGDP 2001 2008 2010 2020 2035FederalRevenues 19.4 17.5 14.9 19.3 19.3 TotalNon‐InterestSpending 16.1 18.9 22.4 22.1 26.5SocialSecurity 4.2 4.3 4.8 5.2 6.2Medicare 2.3 3.2 3.6 4.3 7Medicaid/otherhealth 1.3 1.4 1.9 2.9 3.9Other 8.4 10.1 12.1 9.7 9.3 InterestSpending 2 1.8 1.4 3.8 8.7 Deficit(positiveissurplus) 1.3 ‐3.2 ‐8.9 ‐6.6 ‐15.9 Debt 32.5 40.3 62.1 87 185Source:CBO, "The Long Term Budget Outlook," June, 2010;andCBO "The Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal Years 2011 to 2021," January, 2011. Figures for 2001, 2008, and 2010 are actuals but 2020 and 2035 are the CBO's "Alternative Fiscal Scenario" -- our version of an expected status quo path.

Page 24: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Figure1

Figure2

Source:authorsgraphfromCBOdatain"BudgetandEconomicOutlook:FiscalYears2011‐2021,"CBO,January2011.

Page 25: Shadow of Debt with tables - Bowdoin CollegeThe Congress legislates a debt ceiling. As presently set, the ceiling puts an upper limit of roughly $14.3 trillion on the dollar value

Figure3 FederalRevenuesandSpendingasProportionofGDP

Note:bluelineisfederalexpenditureasproportionofGDP;redlineisfederalrevenuesasproportionofGDP.Source:FederalReserveofStLouisFREDdata.http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/