7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
1/20
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
2/20
There is no better, more easily understood, and more fun
explanation of the complexity of markets than Leonard
Reads I, Pencil. It ought to give considerable pause when
we listen to the arrogance of politicians who tell us they
can manage an economy better than millions, perhaps
billions, of independent decision makers in pursuit of their
own goals. Its message to would-be planners is to bug out!
WALTER E. WILLIAMS
PROFESSOR OF ECONOMICS GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY
I, Pencil is a superb case study of free markets in action.
Half of the worlds economic problems would vanish if
everyone would read I, Pencil.
BURTON W. FOLSOM
PROFESSOR OF HISTORY HILLSDALE COLLEGE
What have economists contributed to human knowledge?
Plenty, but the magical, beautiful idea of the division of
labor might rank as the most important insight. I, Pencil
explains we create so much more wealth as a community
than we ever could alone- in fact, even the simplest item
cannot be made without a complex division of labor.
JEFFREY A. TUCKER
DIRECTOR OF DIGITAL DEVELOPMENT FEE
I, Pencil provides remarkable insights into the complexitygenerated by market mechanisms. Textbook economics
almost never incorporates these insights.
MICHAEL STRONG
CO-FOUNDER CONSCIOUS CAPITALISM
CEO RADICAL SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURS
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
3/20
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
4/20
FEEs mission is to inspire, educate, and
connect future leaders with the economic,
ethical, and legal principles of a free society.
Find us online at:FEE.org
Facebook.com/FEEonlineTwitter.com/FEEonline (@feeonline)
Contact us directly at: 1-800-960-4FEE (4333)
Foundation for Economic Education
1718 Peachtree St. NW, Suite 1048Atlanta, GA 30309
Print ISBN: 978-1-57246-043-0Ebook ISBN: 978-1-57246-042-3
Published under the Creative CommonsAttribution 4.0 International License.
Cover design by CrowdskoutPrint layout design by Lauren Hicks
Foundation forEconomic Education
We invite you to advance liberty with us.
VISITFEE.org
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
5/20
My Family Tree as Told to
Leonard E. Read
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
6/20
IntroductionBY LAWRENCE W. REED
Eloquen. Exraordinary. Timeless. Paradigm-shifing. Classic.Six decades afer i firs appeared, Leonard Reads I, Pencil sillevokes such adjecives o praise. Righully so, or his litle essay
opens eyes and minds among people o all ages. Many firs-ime
readers never see he world quie he same again.
Ideas are mos powerul when heyre wrapped in a
compelling sory. Leonards main poineconomies can hardly
be planned when no one soul possesses all he know-how andskills o produce a simple pencilunolds in he enchaning
words o a pencil isel. Leonard could have writen I, Car or I,
Airplane, bu choosing hose more complex iems would have
mued he message. No one personrepea, no one, no mater
how smar or how many degrees ollow his namecould creae
rom scrach a small, everyday pencil, le alone a car or an airplane.
This is a message ha humbles he high and mighy. Ipricks he inflaed egos o hose who hink hey know how o
mind everybody elses business. I explains in plain language why
cenral planning is an exercise in arrogance and uiliy, or wha
Nobel laureae and Ausrian economis F. A. Hayek aply ermed
he preence o knowledge.
Indeed, a major influence on Reads hinking in his regard
was Hayeks amous 1945 aricle, The Use o Knowledge in
Sociey. In demolishing he spurious claims o he socialiss o he
day, Hayek wroe, This is no a dispue abou wheher planning
is o be done or no. I is a dispue as o wheher planning is o be
done cenrally, by one auhoriy or he whole economic sysem,
or is o be divided among many individuals.
Maximilien Robespierre is said o have blessed he horrificFrench Revoluion wih his chilling declaraion: On ne saurai
pas aire une omelete sans casser des oeus. Translaion:
One can expec o make an omele wihou breaking eggs.
A consummae sais who worked irelessly o plan he lives
o ohers, he would become he archiec o he Revoluions
1
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
7/20
bloodies phasehe Reign o Terror o 179394.
Robespierre and his guilloine broke eggs by he housands
in a vain effor o impose a uopian sociey wih governmen
planners a he op and everybody else a he botom. Tha French
experience is bu one example in a disurbingly amiliar patern.
Call hem wha you willsocialiss, inervenioniss, colleciviss,
saisshisory is litered wih heir presumpuous plans or
rearranging sociey o fi heir vision o he common good, plans
ha always ail as hey kill or impoverish oher people in he
process. I socialism ever earns a final epiaph, i will be his: Here
lies a conrivance engineered by know-i-alls who broke eggs wih
abandon bu never, ever creaed an omele.
None o he Robespierres o he world knew how o make a
pencil, ye hey waned o remake enire socieies. How uterly
preposerous, and mournully ragic! Bu we will miss a large
implicaion o Leonard Reads message i we assume i aims only
a he yrans whose names we all know. The lesson o I, Pencil
is no ha error begins when he planners plan big. I begins
he momen one osses humiliy aside, assumes he knows heunknowable, and employs he orce o he Sae agains peaceul
individuals. Thas no jus a naional disease. I can be very local
indeed.
In our mids are people who hink ha i only hey had
governmen power on heir side, hey could pick omorrows
winners and losers in he markeplace, se prices or rens where
hey ough o be, decide which orms o energy should power our
homes and cars, and choose which indusries should survive and
which should die. They should sop or a ew momens and learn
a litle humiliy rom a lowly wriing implemen.
While I, Pencil shoos down he baseless expecaions or
cenral planning, i provides a supremely uplifing perspecive o
he individual. Guided by Adam Smihs invisible hand o prices,propery, profis, and incenives, ree people accomplish economic
miracles o which socialis heoreicians can only dream. As he
ineress o counless individuals rom around he world converge
o produce pencils wihou a single maser mind, so do hey also
come ogeher in ree markes o eed, clohe, house, educae, and
2
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
8/20
enerain hundreds o millions o people a ever higher levels.
Wih grea pride, FEE publishes his new ediion o I,
Pencil o mark he essays imeless message or a new generaion.
Someday here will be a cenennial ediion, maybe even a
millennial one. This essay is ruly one or he ages.
-Lawrence W. ReedPresident FEE
Atlanta, Georgia
May 2015
3
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
9/20
I, PencilMy Family Tree as Told to Leonard E. Read
I am a lead pencilhe ordinary wooden pencil amiliar oall boys and girls and aduls who can read and wrie. Wriing is boh my vocaion and my avocaion; has all I do.
You may wonder why I should wrie a genealogy. Well, o
begin wih, my sory is ineresing. And, nex, I am a mysery
more so han a ree or a sunse or even a flash o lighning.
Bu, sadly, I am aken or graned by hose who use me, as i I
were a mere inciden and wihou background. This superciliousatiude relegaes me o he level o he commonplace. This is a
species o he grievous error in which mankind canno oo long
persis wihou peril. For, he wise G. K. Cheseron observed,
We are perishing or wan o wonder, no or wan o wonders.
I, Pencil, simple hough I appear o be, meri your wonder
and awe, a claim I shall atemp o prove. In ac, i you can
undersand meno, has oo much o ask o anyonei you canbecome aware o he miraculousness which I symbolize, you can
help save he reedom mankind is so unhappily losing. I have a
proound lesson o each. And I
can each his lesson beter han
can an auomobile or an airplane
or a mechanical dishwasher
becausewell, because I am
seemingly so simple.
Simple? Ye, no a single
person on he ace o his earh
knows how o make me. This
sounds anasic, doesn i?
Especially when i is realizedha here are abou one and
one-hal billion o my kind produced in he U.S.A. each year.
Pick me up and look me over. Wha do you see? No much
mees he eyeheres some wood, lacquer, he prined labeling,
graphie lead, a bi o meal, and an eraser.
4
If you canbecome aware ofthe miraculousness
which I symbolize,
you can help
save the freedome
mankind is so
unhappily losing.
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
10/20
INNUMERABLE ANTECEDENTS
Jus as you canno race your amily ree back very ar, so is
i impossible or me o name and explain all my anecedens. Bu
I would like o sugges enough o hem o impress upon you he
richness and complexiy o my background.
My amily ree begins wih wha in ac is a ree, a cedar o
sraigh grain ha grows in Norhern Caliornia and Oregon. Now
conemplae all he saws and rucks and rope and he counless
oher gear used in harvesing and caring he cedar logs o he
railroad siding. Think o all he persons and he numberless skills
ha wen ino heir abricaion: he mining o ore, he making oseel and is refinemen ino saws, axes, moors; he growing o
hemp and bringing i hrough all he sages o heavy and srong
rope; he logging camps wih heir beds and mess halls, he
cookery and he raising o all he oods. Why, unold housands o
persons had a hand in every cup o coffee he loggers drink!
The logs are shipped o a mill in San Leandro, Caliornia.
Can you imagine he individuals who make fla cars andrails and railroad engines and who consruc and insall he
communicaion sysems incidenal hereo? These legions are
among my anecedens.
Consider he millwork in San Leandro. The cedar logs are
cu ino small, pencil-lengh slas less han one-ourh o an
inch in hickness. These are kiln dried and hen ined or hesame reason women pu rouge on heir aces. People preer ha
I look prety, no a pallid whie. The slas are waxed and kiln
dried again. How many skills wen ino he making o he in
and he kilns, ino supplying he hea, he ligh and power, he
bels, moors, and all he oher hings a mill requires? Sweepers
in he mill among my ancesors? Yes, and included are he men
who poured he concree or he dam o a Pacific Gas & ElecricCompany hydroplan which supplies he mills power!
Don overlook he ancesors presen and disan who have a
hand in ransporing sixy carloads o slas across he naion.
Once in he pencil acory$4,000,000 in machinery and
building, all capial accumulaed by hrify and saving parens
5
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
11/20
o mineeach sla is given eigh grooves by a complex machine,
afer which anoher machine lays leads in every oher sla, applies
glue, and places anoher sla aopa lead sandwich, so o speak.
Seven brohers and I are mechanically carved rom his wood-
clinched sandwich.
My lead iseli conains no lead a allis complex. The
graphie is mined in Ceylon [Sri Lanka]. Consider hese miners
and hose who make heir many ools and he makers o he paper
sacks in which he graphie is shipped and hose who make he
sring ha ies he sacks and hose who pu hem aboard ships
and hose who make he ships. Even he lighhouse keepers along
he way assised in my birhand he harbor pilos. The graphie is mixed wih clay rom Mississippi in which
ammonium hydroxide is used in he refining process. Then
weting agens are added such as sulonaed allowanimal as
chemically reaced wih suluric acid. Afer passing hrough
numerous machines, he mixure finally appears as endless
exrusionsas rom a sausage
grindercu o size, dried, andbaked or several hours a 1,850
degrees Fahrenhei. To increase
heir srengh and smoohness
he leads are hen reaed wih
a ho mixure which includes
candelilla wax rom Mexico,
paraffin wax, and hydrogenaed
naural as.
My cedar receives six coas
o lacquer. Do you know all he
ingrediens o lacquer? Who
would hink ha he growers o casor beans and he refiners o
casor oil are a par o i? They are.Observe he labeling. Thas a film ormed by applying hea
o carbon black mixed wih resins. How do you make resins and
wha, pray, is carbon black? Why, even he processes by which
he lacquer is made a beauiul yellow involve he skills o
more persons han one can enumerae!
6
Why, even the
processes by which
the lacquer is made
a beautiful yellow
involve the skills of
more personsthan one can
enumerate.
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
12/20
My bi o mealhe erruleis brass. Think o all he
persons who mine zinc and copper and hose who have he skills
o make shiny shee brass rom hese producs o naure. Those
black rings on my errule are black nickel. Wha is black nickel
and how is i applied? The complee sory o why he cener o my
errule has no black nickel on i would ake pages o explain.
Then heres my crowning glory, ineleganly reerred o in he
rade as he plug, he par man uses o erase he errors he makes
wih me. An ingredien called acice is wha does he erasing.
I is a rubber-like produc made by reacing rapeseed oil rom
he Duch Eas Indies [Indonesia] wih sulur chloride. Rubber,
conrary o he common noion, is only or binding purposes.Then, oo, here are numerous vulcanizing and acceleraing
agens. The pumice comes rom Ialy; and he pigmen which
gives he plug is color is cadmium sulfide.
NO ONE KNOWS
Does anyone wish o challenge my earlier asserion ha nosingle person on he ace o his earh knows how o make me?
Acually, millions o human beings have had a hand in my
creaion, no one o whom even knows more han a very ew o he
ohers. Now, you may say ha I go
oo ar in relaing he picker o a
coffee berry in ar-off Brazil and
ood growers elsewhere o my
creaion; ha his is an exreme
posiion. I shall sand by my
claim. There isn a single person
in all hese millions, including
he presiden o he pencil
company, who conribues morehan a iny, infiniesimal bi o
know-how. From he sandpoin
o know-how he only difference beween he miner o graphie
in Ceylon and he logger in Oregon is in he ype o know-how.
Neiher he miner nor he logger can be dispensed wih, any
7
Actually,millions of humanbeings have had a
hand in my creation,
no one of whom
even knows more
than a very few ofthe others.
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
13/20
more han can he chemis a he acory or he worker in he oil
fieldparaffin being a by-produc o peroleum.
Here is an asounding ac: Neiher he worker in he oil field
nor he chemis nor he digger o graphie or clay nor any who
mans or makes he ships or rains or rucks nor he one who runs
he machine ha does he knurling on my bi o meal nor he
presiden o he company perorms his singular ask because he
wans me. Each one wans me less, perhaps, han does a child in
he firs grade. Indeed, here are some among his vas muliude
who never saw a pencil nor would hey know how o use one.
Their moivaion is oher han me. Perhaps i is somehing like
his: Each o hese millions sees ha he can hus exchange hisiny know-how or he goods and services he needs or wans. I
may or may no be among hese iems.
NO MASTER MIND
There is a ac sill more asounding: The absence o a maser
mind, o anyone dicaing or orcibly direcing hese counlessacions which bring me ino being. No race o such a person can
be ound. Insead, we find he Invisible Hand a work. This is he
mysery o which I earlier reerred.
I has been said ha only God can make a ree. Why do we
agree wih his? Isn i because we realize ha we ourselves could
no make one? Indeed, can we even describe a ree? We canno,
excep in superficial erms. We can say, or insance, ha a cerain
molecular configuraion maniess isel as a ree. Bu wha mind
is here among men ha could even record, le alone direc, he
consan changes in molecules ha ranspire in he lie span o a
ree? Such a ea is uterly unhinkable!
I, Pencil, am a complex combinaion o miracles: a ree,
zinc, copper, graphie, and so on. Bu o hese miracles whichmanies hemselves in Naure an even more exraordinary
miracle has been added: he configuraion o creaive human
energiesmillions o iny know-hows configuraing naurally
and sponaneously in response o human necessiy and desire
and in he absence o any human maserminding! Since only
8
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
14/20
God can make a ree, I insis ha only God could make me. Man
can no more direc hese millions o know-hows o bring me ino
being han he can pu molecules ogeher o creae a ree.
The above is wha I mean when wriing, I you can become
aware o he miraculousness which I symbolize, you can help save
he reedom mankind is so unhappily losing. For, i one is aware
ha hese know-hows will naurally, yes, auomaically, arrange
hemselves ino creaive and producive paterns in response
o human necessiy and demand ha is, in he absence o
governmenal or any oher coercive maser-mindinghen one
will possess an absoluely essenial ingredien or reedom: a
aih in ree people. Freedom is impossible wihou his aih. Once governmen has had a monopoly o a creaive aciviy
such, or insance, as he delivery o he mails, mos individuals
will believe ha he mails could no be efficienly delivered by men
acing reely. And here is he reason: Each one acknowledges ha
he himsel doesn know how o do all he hings inciden o mail
delivery. He also recognizes ha no oher individual could do i.
These assumpions are correc. No individual possesses enoughknow-how o perorm a naions mail delivery any more han any
individual possesses enough know-how o make a pencil. Now,
in he absence o aih in ree peoplein he unawareness ha
millions o iny know-hows would naurally and miraculously
orm and cooperae o saisy his necessiyhe individual
canno help bu reach he erroneous conclusion ha mail can be
delivered only by governmenal maserminding.
TESTIMONY GALORE
I I, Pencil, were he only iem ha could offer esimony
on wha men and women can accomplish when ree o ry, hen
hose wih litle aih would have a air case. However, here isesimony galore; is all abou us and on every hand. Mail delivery
is exceedingly simple when compared, or insance, o he makingo an auomobile or a calculaing machine or a grain combine or amilling machine or o ens o housands o oher hings. Delivery?Why, in his area where men have been lef ree o ry, hey deliver
9
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
15/20
he human voice around he world in less han one second; heydeliver an even visually and in moion o any persons homewhen i is happening; hey deliver 150 passengers rom Seatle oBalimore in less han our hours; hey deliver gas rom Texas oones range or urnace in New York a unbelievably low raes and
wihou subsidy; hey deliver eachour pounds o oil rom he PersianGul o our Easern Seaboardhalway around he worldor lessmoney han he governmen chargesor delivering a one-ounce leteracross he sree!
The lesson I have o eachis his: Leave all creaive energiesuninhibied. Merely organize socieyo ac in harmony wih his lesson.
Le socieys legal apparaus remove all obsacles he bes i can.Permi hese creaive know-hows reely o flow. Have aih haree men and women will respond o he Invisible Hand. This
aih will be confirmed. I, Pencil, seemingly simple hough Iam, offer he miracle o my creaion as esimony ha his is apracical aih, as pracical as he sun, he rain, a cedar ree, hegood earh.
10
The lesson I have
to teach is this:
Leave all creative
energies
uninhibited.
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
16/20
Leonard E. Read
Leonard E. Read (1898-1983) esablished he Foundaion orEconomic Educaion in 1946. For he nex 37 years he served as
FEEs presiden and labored irelessly o promoe and advancelibery. He was a naural leader who, a a crucial momen inAmerican hisory, roused he orces deending individual reedomand privae propery. His lie is a esamen o he power o ideas. As PresidenRonald Reagan wroe: Our naion and her people have beenvasly enriched by his devoion o he cause o reedom, and
generaions o come will look o Leonard Read or inspiraion. Read was he auhor o 29 books and hundreds o essays.I, Pencil, his mos amous essay, was firs published in 1958.Alhough a ew o he manuacuring deails and place nameshave changed, he principles endure.
11
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
17/20
CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION
ONLINE & ON-CAMPUS
FEEonline
@FEEonline
FEEonline
FEEseminars
FEE.org/magazine
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
18/20
Now available for
FREEdownload at
FEE.org/eBookseBooks
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
19/20
WE INVITE YOU TO
ADVANCE LIBERTY
WITH US
FEE.ORG |
The Foundation for Economic
Education is the premier source for
understanding the humane values
of a free society, and the economic,
legal, and ethical principles that
make it possible. At FEE, students
and their mentors explore
freedoms limitless possibilities
through seminars, classroom
resources, social media, and daily
content, all available at FEE.org.
7/23/2019 [Read] I, Pencil
20/20
The Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) is the premier
source for understanding the humane values of a free society,
and the economic, legal, and ethical principles that make it
possible. At FEE, youll be connected with people worldwide
who share those values and are inspired by the dynamic ideas
of free association, free markets, and a diverse civil society.
Explore freedoms limitless possibilities through seminars,
classroom resources, social media, and daily content at FEE.
org. Learn how your creativity and initiative can result in a
prosperous and flourishing life for yourself and the global
community. Whether you are just beginning to explore
entrepreneurship, economics, or creating value for others or
are mentoring others on their journeys, FEE has everything
you need.
FEE is supported by voluntary, tax-deductible contributions
from individuals, foundations, and businesses who believe that
it is vital to cultivate a deep appreciation in every generation
for individual liberty, personal character, and a free economy.
Supporters receive a subscription to our flagship magazine,
the Freeman, also available at FEE.org.
WE INVITE YOU TO ADVANCE LIBERTY WITH US. | VISIT FEE.ORG
Top Related