Download - Presentation from May 14, 2002

ASN (RDA)CHIEF ENGINEER

Dr. Harry E. CrispDirector, RDA CHENG Naval CEE

Naval CEE Presented to WMA INCOSE

Naval CEE Presented to WMA INCOSE

14 May 200214 May 2002

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 2 04/08/23

TopicsTopicsTopicsTopics

Naval CEE Purpose

RDA CHENG Website

Collaborative Engineering Data Resource

Integrated Engineering Environment

Summary


Naval CEE PurposeNaval CEE PurposeNaval CEE PurposeNaval CEE Purpose

To provide an integrated digital environment that:– Enhances the cooperation and exchange of

data, information, and knowledge among Naval stakeholders engaged in ------ activities directed toward assuring integrated and interoperable Naval force systems.

– Enables the integration and interoperability of Naval force systems across the spectrum of the Naval acquisition process.

Naval CEE Terms of Reference,

4 January 2001

Based on Both E-Business and E-Systems Engineering Capabilities


Collaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration Capabilities

Formal Reviews Markups

Formal Comment Documents

Interactive Electronic Comments

Discussions and Interactions Telephone

Meetings

Video Teleconferences

Threaded E-Discussions

Data Transfer Mail (Documents, Briefings, Reports)

E-Mail

Centralized Repository

Technical Manual

Standalone Tools

Enterprise Environment

Security Enforcement Physical

Electronic

Access Control

Activities Alternatives


IntegratedEngineeringEnvironment

LiveLinkDRIVERS

Concept Exploration & Definition

Demonstration / ValidationEngineering Manufacturing & Development

Production & Deployment

Upgrade and

Replacent

PHASE

100010010

MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

OutlookServer

DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition

Demonstration / Validation

Engineering Manufacturing & Development


Upgrade and Replacent

PHASE

100010010

MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

DSC

DecisionSupportEnvironment

Interoperability Data Management and Analysis

Distributed InformationRepository

REQSPEC Logical Structural / HME

CONCEPTUAL

RequirementsRepository

REQSPEC

Logical Structural / HMECONCEPTUAL

ExistingDatabase

REQ

SPECLogical

Structural / HME

CONCEPTUAL

OtherRepository

NAVAL CEE

Joint Services

ASN RDA CHENG

OPNAV

SYSCOMS

PEOs/PMs

CINCs

Fleet

• Leverage Existing Infrastructure• NMCI Reliance

• Classified/Unclassified Connectivity• Information Assurance

Naval Collaborative Engineering Naval Collaborative Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment

Naval Collaborative Engineering Naval Collaborative Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment

Classified and Unclassified Connectivity to Enable Stakeholder Collaboration

CoalitionPartners


Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”User Workspaces

Netmeeting

Livelink

Interchange

CEDAR Database B

Database A

Database C

Tool A

Tool BTool C

Mix of Web-Based and Client/Server Technologies


RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website

Keep team members informed Share information

Collaborate

Keep track of upcoming events

Monitor status of team action items

Access data and tools


Collaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data Resource

Graphical User Environment

Toolbox• “plug-ins”• Interchange• MS Office

CHENG DB

Work Space• Per user, project• Provides export• Includes local DB• Share Data

Web Interface : Web Pages with Content on Resources

User Access Support

DA

TAIN

FOR

MA

TION

Web Interface

NAVSEA (AMPS)

Web pages•Navigation•Structure•Access

Excel Spreadsheets

MARCOR (MSTAR)

Web Interface

•Navigation•Structure•Access

Application Server pages

DB (Oracle)Dat

a R

esou

rce

Spac

eU

ser

Spac

e N

CEE

Fun

ctio

nal S

pace

On-Line Help

Cross Reference Index

Meta Data

Exploration Layer

User• Answer a Question• Browse Repositories

Graphical Navigation Aid

SPAWAR (VPO)Web Interface

•Navigation•Structure•Access

Server pages

DB

NAVAIR (IDR)

Web Interface

Word (.DOC) Files

Web pages•Navigation•Structure•Access•Content


IDR OverviewIDR OverviewIDR OverviewIDR Overview

Authorita-tive Data

Program Links


IDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative Data


IDR - Authoritative Data (cont.)IDR - Authoritative Data (cont.)


IDR - Program LinksIDR - Program Links


Integrated EngineeringIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentEnvironmentIntegrated EngineeringIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment

SharepointServer






PHASE

1000100

10MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

LiveLinkServer



Production & DeploymentUpgrade and Replacent

PHASE

100010010

MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

ObjectServerREQ

SPECLogical Structural / HME

CONCEPTUAL

ExistingDatabase

PhysicalDesign

ENVISION/ERGO

HumanSystems

IntegrationIPME

Cost AnalysisVAMOSCCOMET

ObjectAnalysis

ROSE

FunctionalAnalysisCORE

Risk AnalysisTRIMS

RequirementsAnalysisDOORSModeling

& SimulationNSS

Provides for a Seamless Flow of Information Between Tools


Interchange OverviewInterchange OverviewInterchange OverviewInterchange Overview

Cost Tools

Project Management

Engineering Tools

ViewerAgent Builder Query Builder Schema

EditorRepository

Administration

To

ol P

lug

-in

Interchange

Server

The Power To Integrate, Coordinate and Collaborate

An Object Oriented Information Infrastructure

Integrates tools and processes into a central engineering repository

Provides access to a common system design representation

Facilitates data sharing and design configuration management

Interrelate data between applications in different domains


TechnicalTechnical

C4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture Framework

Framework

Identifies Standardsand Conventions

Identifies Standardsand Conventions

Guidelines and Process for Developing Architectures That Are Consistent, Comparable, and Integrable

OperationalOperational

Identifies WarfighterInformation Needs

Identifies WarfighterInformation Needs

SystemsSystems

Overlays Capabilities andCharacteristics on Requirements

Overlays Capabilities andCharacteristics on Requirements

High Level Op ConceptHigh Level Op Concept

Command RelationshipsCommand Relationships

Activity ModelActivity Model

Information ExchangeMatrix

Information ExchangeMatrix

Required CapabilitiesMatrix

Required CapabilitiesMatrix

Node ConnectivityDiagram (NCD)

Node ConnectivityDiagram (NCD)

Overlays to NCDOverlays to NCD

System ElementInterface DiagramSystem Element

Interface Diagram

System PerformanceParameters

System PerformanceParameters

Standards andCriteria

Standards andCriteria

Technical ForecastsTechnical Forecasts

System EvolutionDiagram

System EvolutionDiagram

Decision Makers and Operators are Critical Elementsof the Overall Architecture

Decision Makers and Operators are Critical Elementsof the Overall Architecture


Using Architectures in SystemsUsing Architectures in SystemsEngineeringEngineering

Using Architectures in SystemsUsing Architectures in SystemsEngineeringEngineering

Operational Concept

System Functional Mapping

System Interface Mapping

OV-1OV-4

OV-5

SV-3SV-4

SV-5

OV-2

OV-3

SV-1 TV-1

SV-2 SV-6

Architecture Performanceand Behavior

OV-6CSV-7

ExecutableModel

OV-1OV-1 High-level Operational Concept GraphicHigh-level Operational Concept GraphicOV-2OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity DescriptionOperational Node Connectivity DescriptionOV-3OV-3 Operational Information Exchange MatrixOperational Information Exchange MatrixOV-4OV-4 Command Relationships ChartCommand Relationships ChartOV-5OV-5 Activity ModelActivity ModelOV-6COV-6C Operational Event/Trace DescriptionOperational Event/Trace DescriptionSV-1SV-1 System Interface DescriptionSystem Interface DescriptionSV-2SV-2 Systems Communication DescriptionSystems Communication DescriptionSV-3SV-3 Systems MatrixSystems MatrixSV-4SV-4 System Functionality DescriptionSystem Functionality DescriptionSV-5SV-5 Operational Activity to System Function Operational Activity to System Function

Traceability MatrixTraceability MatrixSV-6SV-6 System Information Exchange MatrixSystem Information Exchange MatrixSV-7SV-7 System Performance Parameters MatrixSystem Performance Parameters MatrixSV-8SV-8 System Evolution DescriptionSystem Evolution DescriptionSV-9SV-9 System Technology ForecastSystem Technology ForecastSV-10SV-10 System Activity Sequence & TimingSystem Activity Sequence & TimingTV-1TV-1 Technical Architecture ProfileTechnical Architecture ProfileTV-2 TV-2 Standards Technology ForecastStandards Technology Forecast

The Role of Engineering and TechnologyThe Role of Engineering and Technology

Lesser

Greater

1st Order Analysis:Functionality--

2nd Order Analysis:Static Interoperability

3rd Order Analysis:Dynamic Interoperability

OV-3

Note: There are dependencies between the Architecture products that are not shown in the System Engineering flow. Many of the products are developed concurrently.

Architectures Provide the Framework for Architectures Provide the Framework for FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & AcquisitionFoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition

Architectures Provide the Framework for Architectures Provide the Framework for FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & AcquisitionFoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition

SV-8TV-2

FoS/SoS Evolution

SV-9

SV-10 Rev 4 * 22 Apr 02

DRMOpSits

TTP

DRM: Design Reference MissionOpSit: Operational SituationTTP: Tactics, Techniques, ProceduresFoS: Family of SystemsSoS: System of Systems


Integrated Engineering EnvironmentIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentSE Process & ProductsSE Process & Products

Integrated Engineering EnvironmentIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentSE Process & ProductsSE Process & Products

Requirement Documents

• Life Cycle Traceability• Change Agent Notification• System Representation• Configuration Management• Tools Integration

Requirement Analysis Tool

SPGMNSORD

SPD

DOORS

Structured Requirements

Function Analysis Tool

CORE

Activity Model

Functional Model

Function Information

Functional Baselines

Interchange (Server)

Project Repository

Systems Spec

Physical Implementation

Information

Resource Constraint

Interchange Client

Architecture Representation

Rational RoseDIAD

JMAAT

Operational View

System View

Technical View

Architecture Information

Experimental Data

System Data

Interface Data

LSSE Analysis

COPATRAB

RCA

TRIMSM&S

COST MODELSHSI

CAD/CAM

AuthoritativeData Bases

CEDAR

NSS

Mission Analysis

Simulation Model

Design

Synthesis


OV-1

OV-4

OV-5OV-3

OV-2

• Requirement Documents• Activity Timing, Inputs & Outputs• Activity Resource Utilization• Execution Logic• OV-6a, OV-6b, OV-6c, OV-7

Operational Model

SV-1 TV-1

SV-2 SV-6

SV-3

SV-4 SV-5

SV-7

• Control Logic• Functional Resource Utilization• Functional Timing & Data Flows• Conditional Logic (Failure

Conditions, Fault Detection)• SV-10a, SV-10b, SV-10c

Functional Model

RequirementsAnalysis

(DOORS, CORE,

CEDAR)

FunctionalAnalysis

(CORE)

Physical (Design) Model

• Interface Design/Control (SV-11)• Effectiveness Models• FMECA/RAM Analysis• Dynamic Reconfiguration• Ownership Cost Analysis

Design Synthesis(CORE)

Application of Architecture Views & Application of Architecture Views & Tools to Systems EngineeringTools to Systems Engineering

Application of Architecture Views & Application of Architecture Views & Tools to Systems EngineeringTools to Systems Engineering

Interchange


Executable Operational

Model

Executable Operational

Model

Data Calls

System ORDs

Systems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering Flow

OperationalAnalysis

Capstone Requirements

Document

Operational Concept

Current Operational Architecture

RequirementsAnalysis

System Functional Mapping

Establish Activity Time-line (Budget)

FunctionalAnalysis

Logical Interface Mapping

Allocate Activities to

Sys. Functions (Budget)

Design Synthesis Assess

Technology Roadmap

Develop System Alternatives

(Perf. Budgets)

Navy Standard Functional Hierarchy

System Specifications,

ICDs

OV-1, OV-2, OV-3, OV-4, OV-5, OV-6

Systems Architecting Systems Engineering

Functional Models

Physical (Design) Models

Establish Activity Time-line (Budget)

Allocate Activities to

Sys. Functions (Budget)

Develop System Alternatives

(Perf. Budgets)

SV-4, SV-5

SV-1, SV-7

SV-9, TV-2

Systems Interfaces Mapping

SV-1, SV-2, SV-3, SV-6, SV-11, TV-1


Executable SOS ModelExecutable SOS Model

Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow (Continued)(Continued)

Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow (Continued)(Continued)

Systems Analysis

CapabilityStrategic Planning

Establish Capability Evolution Roadmap

Finalize Design

Solution(s)

Program Plans, Budgets,

Milestones

Assess Alternative Cost/Effectiveness

Update Capstone Requirements

Document

Systems Architecting Systems Engineering

Recommended Acquisition

Strategy (CV-6)

Program Alignment

Interoperability Analysis

Architecture Performance and

Behavior

SV-8

SV-10

Systems Interfaces Mapping

Assess Technology Roadmap

SV-8

OV-1


Information Naval CEE Function Outputs/ Integrated Database

Force Systems Operational Objectives

Force Systems Operational Objectives

SE Data and ProductsSE Data and ProductsSE Data and ProductsSE Data and Products

• Life Cycle Traceability• Change Agent Notification• System Representation• Configuration Management• Tools Integration

Interchange (Server)

Capture Force Systems Information in Data Base

Management SystemForce Systems CharacteristicsForce Systems Characteristics

Force Systems Performance Profile

Force Systems Performance Profile

Platform/System O&M Cost

Profile

Platform/System O&M Cost

Profile

Platform/SystemManningProfile

Platform/SystemManningProfile

Platform/SystemC4ISR Info.

Views

Platform/SystemC4ISR Info.

Views

Integrated Force Systems Requirements

Integrated Force Systems Requirements

Integrated Force Systems Performance

Specifications

Integrated Force Systems Performance

Specifications

Force Systems Operational Functions

Force Systems Operational Functions

Platform/System Interfaces/ICDs

Platform/System Interfaces/ICDs

Platform/System Manning & Task

Profiles

Platform/System Manning & Task

Profiles

Platform/System Ownership Costs Over

Time

Platform/System Ownership Costs Over

Time

Force Systems Effectiveness & MOEs/MOPs

Force Systems Effectiveness & MOEs/MOPs

Force Systems C4ISR Arch. Framework

Views

Force Systems C4ISR Arch. Framework

Views

CRD

CRD/SRD

SPD

SPD

SPD

SPD

CED

TEMP


Data Integration FlowData Integration FlowData Integration FlowData Integration FlowDOORS

CORE

InterchangeSE Repository

Requirements Model

Operational Model (OVs)

Functional Model (SVs)

Behavior Model

Word,

PowerPoint,

Excel, DIAD, ..

Physical Model


Naval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure Overview

OutlookServer






PHASE

1000100

10MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

LiveLinkServer



Production & DeploymentUpgrade and Replacent

PHASE

100010010

MGMT

Jan Apr Jul Oct

REQSPEC

Logical Structural / HMECONCEPTUAL

ExistingDatabase Object

Server

CHENG

NSWCDDJHUAPL

NUWCNAVSEA

SPAWAR

Conferencing Tools

Document & Object Server Remote Access

Engineering Tools Management Tools

NAVAIR

MARCORP


SummarySummarySummarySummary

Modern Information Technology Provides Capabilities to Deal with Force Systems Complexity.– Configuration Management and Control of Force

Systems Architectures and Their Evolution Over Time.– Support for Geographically Distributed Teams Involved

in Acquisition Management and Engineering Analysis.

Processes, Methods and Tools are Available to Move Network Centric Warfare Off the View Foils and Into Acquisition!


DiscussionDiscussionDiscussionDiscussion


• Requirements management tool• Capture text requirements• Track requirement changes• Documents-to-document linking• Inter-project linking

• Easy to use and access• Web-access utilizing DOORSnetTM • Drag-and-drop linking that create relationships• Built-in graphics for display of statistics and metrics • Filters on all data for faster access to specific information • Color-coded change bars

• Imports/Exports• Microsoft Word• RTF• Interleaf• Framemaker(R)

• Text • Spreadsheets • HTML

DOORS OverviewDOORS OverviewDOORS OverviewDOORS Overview


CORE OverviewCORE OverviewCORE OverviewCORE Overview

Allows system engineers to capture, analyze

and verify design integrity before problems

embed themselves in the system Support C4ISR architecture framework Extensive behavior modeling notations

representing control flow, function flow, data

flow, resource utilization and interface-link

capacity System simulations automatically synchronized

with behavior models Comprehensive traceability System documentation generated directly from

the database as a by-product of the engineering

effort

OPERATIONAL MODELOPERATIONAL MODEL

FUNCTION HIERARCHYFUNCTION HIERARCHY

BEHAVIOR MODELBEHAVIOR MODEL

IMPLEMENTATIONIMPLEMENTATION(PHYSICAL) MODEL(PHYSICAL) MODEL

SIMULATION RESULT SIMULATION RESULT