7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
1/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry 1- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ; no ;4?
Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Fistrubtfnikm Smki kil Skp`r Srntntyp`
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
2/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 4 no ;4?
\kdm` no Bnit`its
;)BNI\@Z\L@RBTFS\FNIKILM@KTIFIANDE@B\F_@R)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
3/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry 1- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 2 no ;4?
KB\F_K\FNI)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))6
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
4/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` < no ;4?
NS@TK FR IN\ K ONPT'M@\\@T QNTL
;) BNI\@Z\ L@RBTFS\FNI KIL M@KTIFIA NDE@B\F_@R
BNI\@Z\ L@RBTFS\FNIFitrnlubtfni kil Tktfnikm`\jfs fs ki nimfi` bnurs` fi np`rk kppr`bfktfni tjkt wfmm d` noo`r`l ks k bnitfiufia `lubktfni
`xt`isfni `'M`krifia bmkss dy tj` l`pkrtg`it no gusfb kt Lf_k Bngguifty Bnmm`a`) \jfsbnurs` fs fgpnrtkit fi tjkt ft fit`ils tn gkh` tj` a`ir` gnr` kbb`ssfdm` tn tj` a`i`rkm pudmfb-
`xpkil tj` bumturkm jnrfznis no tj` m`kri`rs kil nv`rbng` kiy dkrrf`rs tjkt gfajt lkgp`i tj``ienyg`it tj` krt onrg)
Rtul`its wfmm m`kri kdnut tj` bngpni`its tjkt bngprfs` ki np`rk- fibmulfia5 stnryt`mmfia- kbtfia-
gusfb- mkiauka`- s`ts kil bnstug`s) M`kri`rs wfmm kmsn gkh` bnii`btfnis d`tw``i tj` krt onrg
kil burr`it snbfkm- `bningfb- pnmftfbkm bumtur` kil d`mf`os) Ofikmmy- tj` fit`it no tjfs bnurs` fs tndufml kulf`ib`s fi nrl`r tn `isur` tj` survfvkm no tj` p`ronrgfia krts dy akfifia suppnrt fi tj`onrg no kppr`bfktfni kil pkrtfbfpktfni)
Bnit`xt\j` bnurs` fs l`sfai`l fi gnlum`s dks`l ni filfvflukm np`rks) \j` bnit`it no tjfs bnurs` wfmm d`
dks`l ni `xfstfia fionrgktfni sp`bfofbkmmy r`mktfia tn np`rk) D`bkus` no fts gnlumkr onrgkt kil`v`r'arnwfia lktkdks` no fionrgktfni- tjfs nimfi` bnurs` gky d` p`rsnikmfz`l dy k okbfmftktnr
tn fibmul` mnbkm bnit`it fo sn l`sfr`l) Burrfbumug bki d` nrakifz`l kil l`mfv`r`l fi vkrf`l wkys)\j` bnurs` bki d` l`mfv`r`l fi k wky tjkt dufmls fi bngpm`xfty tjrnuajnut tj` lurktfni no tj`
`itfr` bnurs`- dy usfia gnlum`s tjkt bnrr`mkt` tn np`rks d`fia p`ronrg`l dy mnbkm p`ronrgkib`
bngpkif`s- syibjrnifz`l wftj mfv`.pr`'r`bnrl`l drnklbksts- pr`s`it`l bjrninmnafbkmmy dybngpnsftfni- nr us`l ks k stkil'kmni`- s`mo'pkb`l `'M`krifia bnurs`) \j` fit`it no tjfs bnurs fstn br`kt` ki `ivfrnig`it wj`r` tj` nv`rkrbjfia ankms no np`rk kppr`bfktfni kr` bkptur`l dy
okbfmftktfia bnii`btfnis kil r`mktfnisjfps d`tw``i kiy no tj` gnlum`s)
\wn np`rk m`ssnis *gnlum`s& wfmm d` r`pr`s`it`l fi tjfs prne`bt5 \nsbk kil Bkrg`i) Fi tj`outur`- tj`r` wfmm d` ki v`r'`xpkilfia lktkdks` no r`snurb`s kil np`rks) \j`r` fs kmsn k A`i`rkm
gnlum` tjkt wfmm bnitkfi eust'fi'tfg` r`snurb`s subj ks amnsskrf`s- kulf`ib` fionrgktfni-fistrubtnr fionrgktfni- suppnrt tutnrfkms- r`o`r`ib` gkt`rfkms- ki`blnt`s- k bnggni g``tfia kr`k-
symmkdus- kil arklfia rudrfbs)
\kra`t M`kri`rsK m`kri`r kikmysfs wks bnilubt`l dks`l ni tj` hinwm`la` no m`kri`rs `irnmm`l fi tj` Mfo`mniaM`krifia `xt`isfni bmkss kt Lf_k bngguifty bnmm`a`) Dks`l ni tjfs r`s`krbj- tj` onmmnwfia
l`sbrfd`s tj` tkra`t m`kri`rs onr tjfs bnurs`)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
5/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 0 no ;4?
M`kri`r Kikmysfs
A`i`rkm Ka` Arnup5 Gnstmy 00 y`krs kil nml`rTkbfkm.`tjifb dkbharnuil5 Gfx`lRnbfn`bningfb dkbharnuil5 T`tfr``s wftj p`isfni fibng`Okgfmfkm Rftuktfni5 Arnwi bjfmlr`i kil arkilbjfmlr`i) Mfgft`l
r`spnisfdfmftf`s)
Kbb`ssfdfmfty Fssu`s *fo kiy&5 Snssfdm` *prndkdm`& j`krfia- `y`sfajt kilgndfmfty fssu`s)
M`v`m no bngput`r.Fit`ri`t `xp`rf`ib`5 _`ry mfttm`)Sr`vfnus nimfi` bnurs` `xp`rf`ib`5 Mfttm` tn ini`)Kbb`ss tn t`bjinmnay- jfaj sp``l Fit`ri`t5 Jng` nr pudmfb mfdrkry
*r`qufr`g`it onr tj` bnurs`&)
Bnaiftfv` A`i`rkm kptftul`s5 Jfajmy gntfvkt`l- wfmmfiai`ss tn m`kri- pnsftfv` kttftul`-`xb`mm`it onbus- fit`mm`btukm)
Rp`bfofb kptftul`s5 Jfajmy l`v`mnp`l mfst`ifia shfmms- kdfmfty tn onbus onr mniap`rfnls no tfg`- wfmmfia kil kdm` tn sjkr` npfifnis)
L`v`mnpg`itkm m`v`m5 Gnr` kl`pt kt kdstrkbt bnib`pts ks nppns`l tn bnibr`t`tkshs *wjfbj fs ki fgpnrtkit bnisfl`rktfni tn tkh` fitn kbbnuit onr tjfs bnurs`&)
Mkiauka` l`v`mnpg`it m`v`m5 Srnofbf`it fi r`klfia- wrftfia kil sp`khfia@iamfsj)
T`klfia m`v`m5 Kt m`kst jfaj sbjnnm m`v`m)M`v`m no vfsukm mft`rkby5 A`i`rkmmy `xb`mm`it- dut l`p`ils ni pjysfbkm kulfn
kil vfsukm bjkmm`ia`s)
Bnaiftfv` prnb`ssfia stym`s5 L`p`ilfia ni ka` okbtnr- bnaiftfv` kdfmftf`s gkyrkia` ar`ktmy- wjfbj wfmm d` ki fgpnrtkit okbtnr tn bnisfl`r) Mnia't`rg kilsjnrt't`rg g`gnry gky d` l`ofbf`it dks`l ni ka` kil gust d` tkh`i fitnkbbnuit)
M`krifia strkt`af`s5 Bksukm- int` tkhfia- lfsbussfni dks`l)A`i`rkm wnrml hinwm`la`5 _kst hinwm`la` kil pr`vfnus `xp`rf`ib` tn lrkw
orng) \jfs arnup no m`kri`rs jks ki kduilkib` no mfo` `xp`rf`ib` tn r`o`r tn
kil bnitrfdut`)
Rp`bfofb prfnr hinwm`la`5 _krf`l prfnr hinwm`la` dks`l ni wnrml trkv`m-pr`vfnus bumturkm `xp`rf`ib`s wftj gusfb- lkib` kil ntj`r p`ronrgfia krts- ki
jfstnrfb vf`w no pnmftfbs kil snbfkm bumtur`)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
6/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ? no ;4?
M`kri`r Kikmysfs
Koo`btfv` Fit`r`sts5 Gusfb- Krt- Lkib`- \rkv`m)Gntfvktfnis tn m`kri5 Kbtfv` m`kri`rs tjkt wkit tn h``p tj`fr gfils kbtfv` kildrnkl`i tj`fr `xp`rf`ib`s)
Kttftul` tnwkrl m`krifia5 @itjusfkstfb- pnsftfv` kttftul`- gntfvkt`l kil wfmmfiatn m`kri)
Kttftul` tnwkrl sude`bt gktt`r5 Sr`vfnusmy fitfgflkt`l- uisur` no sude`btgktt`r)
Kttrfdutfni no subb`ss5 Kdm` tn lfsbuss kil kikmyz` burr`it np`rks wftj ntj`rsfi snbfkm kil kbkl`gfb sftuktfnis)
Rnbfkm T`mktfnisjfps tn p``rs5 Skrtfbfpkits gfajt kmr`kly hinw `kbj ntj`r orng tj`bngguifty) \j` gkenrfty no pkrtfbfpkits kr` wng`i)
O``mfias tnwkrl kutjnrfty5 T`sp`btoum kil qu`stfnifia)\`il`ibf`s tnwkrl bnnp`rktfni nr bngp`tftfni5 _`ry bn'np`rktfv` kil rkr`my
bngp`tftfv`)
Sr`'
r`qufsft`sJkv` kbb`ss tn k bngput`r wftj k wnrhfia kil r`mfkdm` fit`ri`t bnii`btfni)Jkv` tj` kdfmfty tn typ`- sp`kh- r`kl kil wrft` fi @iamfsj)Jkv` kbb`ss tn r`s`krbj gkt`rfkms)Jkv` kbb`ss kil kdfmfty tn ikvfakt` tjrnuaj k m`krifia gkika`g`it syst`g)Snss`ss tj` kdfmfty tn br`kt` kil sudgft k lnbug`it ni tj` bngput`r)D` kdm` tn j`kr kulfn- s`` vfsukm gkt`rfkm kil.nr r`kl prfit`l lnbug`its)Kdfmfty tn r`b`fv` kil noo`r bnistrubtfv` o``ldkbh)Kdfmfty tn onbus onr k p`rfnl no kt m`kst ;)0 jnurs)Jkv` kbb`ss tn k bkm`ilkr no mfv` nr r`bnrl`l p`ronrgkib`s)D` kdm` tn mfst`i nr s`` tj` p`ronrgkib` kil r`g`gd`r ft)
\kdm` ;)3 'M`kri`r Kikmysfs
Bnilftfnis\j` Fistrubtfnikm @ivfrnig`it5 D`bkus` no tj`fr ka`- tj` gkenrfty no stul`its kr` gnr`bngonrtkdm` m`krifia orng jng` rktj`r tjki ni tj` sbjnnm bkgpus onr k vkrf`ty no r`ksnis) Ifajt
lrfvfia- mkra` lfstkib`s kil kbb`ssfdfmfty fssu`s kr` tj`fr gkfi bnib`ris) \j` bnurs` fs noo`r`lnimfi` kil bki d` r`'bniofaur`l tn bnrr`mkt` wftj burr`it kil mnbkm p`ronrgkib`s) G`lfk wfmm
fibmul` fgka`s- vfl`ns kil kulfn) \j`r` wfmm d` k bjkt rnng bkmm`l \j` Ony`r wj`r`pkrtfbfpkits bki lfsbuss kiy p`ronrgkib`s tj`y jkv` s``i mnbkmmy) \j`r` wfmm kmsn d` k lfsbussfni
arnup fi tj` onrg no k bjkt rnng bkmm`l \nsbks Bko` onr stul`its tn pkrtfbfpkt` fi) \nsbksBko` fs onr snbfkm fit`rkbtfni nimy kil wfmm int d` arkl`l)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
7/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 1 no ;4?
\j` FistrubtfnikmL`sbrfptfni5 Bnurs`sft`s wfmm d` us`l onr dufmlfia tj` bnurs` onr us` fi tj`Dmkbhdnkrl m`krifia gkika`g`it syst`g) Ps`rs wfmm br kt` k stul`it us`rikg` kil pksswnrl tn
akfi kbb`ss tn tj` bnurs` kil fts gnlum`s) @m`g`its wfmm d` dufmt usfia fGnvf`- Akrka`dkilorng Kppm`s fMfo` snotwkr` kil Ska`s- Iugd`rs kil H`yint` orng Kppm`s fQnrhsuft` no onr
Gkb) Ntj`r pnssfdm` t`bjinmnay tn d` us`l fi br`ktfni gky fibmul` Vnu\ud`- Klnd` Bkptfvkt`-
Sr`zf- Ztrkinrgkm kil ntj`r snotwkr` fo l``g`l kpprnprfkt` kil.nr i`b`sskry)
\j` Ruppnrt @ivfrnig`it5 \j` bnurs` wfmm d`afi wftj k mkra` lktkdks` no np`rks dut jks tj`
pnt`itfkm tn d` gnlfof`l dks`l ni tj` s`ksni p`ronrgkib`s no tj` mnbkm np`rk bngpkiy*s&) \jus-k lktkdks` wfmm bnitfiu` tn arnw ks r`p`rtnfr` fs br`kt`l tjkt bki d` r`us`l ni ki ks'i``l`l
dksfs) \j` stkoo kil okbumty kt Lf_k Bngguifty Bnmm`a` wfmm prnvfl` gkika`g`it-gkfit`ikib` kil t`bjifbkm suppnrt no tj` lktkdks` kil l`mfv`ry syst`g) Okbumty wfmm l`mfv`r kil
bnitrfdut` tn bnit`it)
Nimfi` T`snurb`s5 Fi kllftfni tn tj` np`rk gnlum`s- a`i`rkm fionrgktfni wfmm d` kvkfmkdm` kt kmmtfg`s fibmulfia5 Fistrubtnr fionrgktfni- Kiinuib`g`its- A`i`rkm Nrf`itktfni onr tj` Rft`- Bmkss
Tnst`r- Amnsskry- Ony`r- Ki`blnt`s- Rymmkdus- Bnurs` Ruppnrt- Sr`'p`ronrgkib` T`s`krbj Mfihs-kil Ikvfaktfni Ruppnrt)
Sr`'r`qufsft`s onr tj` M`krifia @ivfrnig`it5 Rtul`its wfmm i``l k bngput`r wftj kbb`ss tn tj`
Fit`ri`t) \j` bngput`r wfmm pnssfdmy d` kt jng`- kt k pudmfb mfdrkry nr s ifnr b`it`r) In ntj`rgkt`rfkms wfmm d` r qufr`l) Bngput`r suppnrt onr tj` stul`its wfmm d` prnvfl`l usfia tj`
bjkii`ms kmr`kly fi pmkb` fi tj`fr jng`s nr r`gnt` mnbktfnis tjkt bnuml fibmul` orf`ils- okgfmy-stkoo nr t`m`pjni` suppnrt) \j` fistrubtnr- tjrnuaj nimfi` lfsbussfnis nr ni'bkgpus t`bjifbkm
suppnrt- gky prnvfl` sng` mfgft`l fistrubtfnikm suppnrt)
M@KTIFIA NDE@B\F_@R
\`rgfikm Ankm\j` nv`rkrbjfia ankm no tjfs bnurs` fs tn l`v`mnp ki kppr`bfktfni onr np`rk dy akfifia k l``p`r
uil`rstkilfia no tjfs bngpm`x krt onrg) \j` jnp` fs tjkt m`kri`rs wfmm bnitfiu` tn ktt`il tj`p`ronrgfia krts- wjfbj wfmm dufml kulf`ib`s kil `isur` tj` survfvkm kil suppnrt no tj` krts)
M`krifia Nde`btfv`sDks`l ni k bngdfiktfni Jnrtnis m`krifia nde`bts *Jnrtni- 43;4- p) 4:0& kil Gka`rs
Fistrubtfnikm Nde`btfv`s *Gka`r- ;661- p) 2&- tj`s` m`krifia nde`btfv`s jkv` d``i l`v`mnp`l tnr`mkt` tn sp`bfofb tkshs kil m`krifia nde`bts- tj` fit`il`l nutbng` no subj tkshs- kr` sp`bfofb kil
g`ksurkdm` kil wrftt`i orng tj` pnfit no vf`w no tj` m`kri`r)
*Gnlum` ; ' \nsbk&
M`krifia Nde`btfv` "; *\j` @m`g`its&5 M`kri`rs wfmm fl`itfoy `kbj no tj` bngpni`its *stnry-
gusfb- kbtfia- mkiauka`- bnstug`s- s`ts& no \nsbk fi nrl`r tn akfi k l``p`r uil`rstkilfia no tj`krt onrg ks k wjnm`)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
8/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` : no ;4?
Rud'Nde`btfv` ;); *Rtnry&5 Kot`r r`klfia tj` syinpsfs kil mfdr`ttn no \nsbk- m`kri`rs wfmm d`kdm` tn lfsbuss nrfafis no kil tj` lfoo`r`ib` d`tw``i tj` twn onrgs no stnrymfi`)
Rud'Nde`btfv` ;)4 *Gusfb&5 Afv`i tj` kulfn no ki krfk- m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn fl`itfoygnnls kil tj`gktfb `m`g`its no tj` gusfb wftj :3% kbburkby)
Rud'Nde`btfv` ;)2 *Kbtfia&5 Afv`i k tj` stnrymfi`- m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn l`sbrfd` tj`
r`mktfnisjfps d`tw``i tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs no \nsbk)Rud'Nde`btfv` ;)< *R`ts&5 Afv`i vfsukm `xkgpm`s kil gkps no mnbktfnis- m`kri`rs wfmm d`kdm` tn fl`itfoy wj`r` sb`i`s orng \nsbk kr` mnbkt`l wftj :3% kbburkby)
Rud'Nde`btfv` ;)0 *Bnstug`s&5 Afv`i vfsukm `xkgpm`s no bnstug`s- m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tngktbj bjkrkbt`rs tn tj`fr kpprnprfkt` kttfr` fi tj` np`rk \nsbk wftj :3% kbburkby)
M`krifia Nde`btfv` "4 *\j` S`npm`&5 Afv`i hinwm`la` no tj` stnrymfi` no \nsbk- m`kri`rs wfmm d`
kdm` tn l`gnistrkt` p`rsnikm vf`wpnfits no \nsbk dy lfsbussfia tj` r`mktfnisjfps d`tw``i burr`it`v`its kil snbfkm.`bningfb- pnw`r kil bmkss syst`gs- pnmftfbkm bmfgkt` kil rngkitfb `m`g`its no
\nsbk)
Rud'Nde`btfv` 4); *Snmftfbkm&5 Afv`i okgfmfkrfty no tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs- m`kri`rs wfmmd` kdm` tn lfsbuss tj` pnmftfbkm gntfv`s no ni` no tj` bjkrkbt`rs orng \nsbk kil r`mkt`
ft tn burr`it `v`its fi tnlkys snbf`ty)Rud'Nde`btfv` 4)4 *Tngkitfb&5 Afv`i okgfmfkrfty no tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs- m`kri`rs wfmm
d` kdm` tn lfsbuss tj` rngkitfb r`mktfnisjfps fi tj` stnrymfi` kil wrft` ofbtfnikmnutbng`s)
Rud'Nde`btfv` 4)2 *Rnbfn'`bningfb&5 Afv`i hinwm`la` no tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs-m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn fl`itfoy tj` snbfkm stktus no ni` no tj` bjkrkbt`rs kil lfsbuss
fts `oo`bt ni r`mktfnisjfps wftj ntj`rs)
M`krifia Nde`btfv` "2 *\j` Rjnw&5 Dy ktt`ilfia k mfv` nr pr`'r`bnrl`l p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk-m`kri`rs wfmm pr`s`it tj`fr p`rsnikm npfifni tn tj`fr p``rs)
Rud'Nde`btfv` 2); *Kulf`ib` @tfqu`tt`&5 Dks`l ni k lnbug`it nutmfifia kulf`ib` `tfqu`tt`-
m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn l`gnistrkt` kpprnprfkt` kulf`ib` d`jkvfnr onr k mfv` np`rkp`ronrgkib` no \nsbk)
Rud'Nde`btfv` 2)4 *Ofilfia k S`ronrgkib`&5 Dy bjnnsfia orng k mfst no mfv` kil pr`'r`bnrl`l prnlubtfnis- m`kri`rs wfmm ktt`il k p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk wftjfi k afv`i
tfg`orkg`)Rud'Nde`btfv` 2)2 *Brftfqu`&5 Afv`i ktt`ilkib` no k p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk- m`kri`rs wfmm
wrft` kil sjkr` k p`rsnikm brftfqu` no tj` sp`bfofb prnlubtfni ktt`il`l)
*Gnlum` 4 ' Bkrg`i&
M`krifia Nde`btfv` "< *\j` @m`g`its&5 M`kri`rs wfmm fl`itfoy `kbj no tj` bngpni`its *stnry-
gusfb-kbtfia-lkib`-kilbnstug`s& no Bkrg`i fi nrl`r tn akfi k l``p`r uil`rstkilfia no tj`
krt onrg ks k wjnm`)
Rud'Nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
9/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 6 no ;4?
Rud'Nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
10/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;3 no ;4?
Rud'Nde`btfv` 1)2 *Sr`s`it&5 M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn pr`s`it tj` lfoo`r`ib`s fi br`ktfv`l`bfsfnis gkl` dy tj` prnlub`rs kil krtfstfb lfr`btnrs no twn lfoo`r`it np`rk
prnlubtfnis *skg` nr lfoo`r`it np`rks&)
4)RF\@ GKSRN_@T_F@Q
Onmmnwfia fs k tnp'm`v`m sft` gkp tn vfsukmfz` tj` fistrubtfnikm omnw no tj` `itfr` bnurs`5
Ofaur` 4)3 ' \np Rft` Gkp *s`` kpp`ilfx onr oumm'sfz`l gkp&
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
11/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;; no ;4?
GNLPM@R
\nsbk Gnlum`\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no tj` ofrst gnlum`- \nsbk- wftj fts kssnbfkt`l sud'nde`btfv`s5
Ofaur` 4); 'Gnlum` ; *\nsbk& Gkp *s`` kpp`ilfx onr oumm'sfz`l gkp&
Bkrg`i Gnlum`\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no tj` s`bnil gnlum`- Bkrg`i- wftj fts kssnbfkt`l sud'nde`btfv`s5
Ofaur` 4)4 'Gnlum` 4 *Bkrg`i& Gkp *s`` kpp`ilfx onr oumm'sfz`l gkp&
Nv`rkmm Bngpkrfsni Gnlum`\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no tj` a`i`rkm nv`rvf`w gnlum` wftj fts kssnbfkt`l sud'nde`btfv`s5
Ofaur` 4)2 ' Nv`rkmm Bngpkrfsni Gkp *s`` kpp`ilfx onr oumm'sfz`l gkp&
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
12/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;4 no ;4?
A`ttfia Rtkrt`l\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no tj` a`ttfia stkrt`l gnlum` wftj fts kssnbfkt`l sud'nde`btfv`s5
Ofaur` 4)< ' A`ttfia Rtkrt`l Gkp
Ntj`r T`snurb`s\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no tj` r`snurb`s kvkfmkdm` tn tj` m`kri`rs kt kmm tfg`s5
Ofaur` 4)0 'T`snurb`s Gkp
Snssfdm` Outur` Gnlum`s\jfs gkp sjnws tj` omnw no pnssfdm` outur` gnlum`s wftj kssnbfkt`l sud'nde`btfv`s5
Ofaur` 4)?'Snssfdm` Outur` Gnlum`s Gkp *s`` kpp`ilfx onr oumm'sfz`l gkp&
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
13/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;2 no ;4?
2)R\NTVDNKTLRA`i`rkm\j` np`ifia pka` onr tj` bnurs` fs tj` Kiinuib`g`it pka`) \jfs pka` jks k dkii`r- sfl`dkr kilbnit`it zni`s) \j` ofrst tjfia tn d` s `i fs tj` np`ifia w`mbng` vfl`n) I`xt fs tj` fistrubtfni
tn us` Ofr`onx ks tj` drnws`r fo tj` vfl`n ln`sit pmky) \j`r` fs k mfih tn tj` gnzfmmk w`dsft`wj`r` m`kri`rs bki lnwimnkl Ofr`onx onr or``) I`xt fs k w`mbng` stkt`g`it tjkt ura`s tj` us`r tn
prnb``l fgg`lfkt`my tn tj` Bnurs` Nrf`itktfni pka`) Ofikmmy- ki `xpmkiktfni kil mfih tn tj`bmkss rnst`r fs prnvfl`l)
Ofaur` 2)3 ' Np`ifia Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
14/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;< no ;4?
\j`sfl`dkrbnitkfis k bngpm`t` mfst no kmm tnp'm`v`m `m`g`its onr tj` `itfr` bnurs`) \j` sfl`dkrr`gkfis tj` skg` in gktt`r wj`r` tj` m`kri`r ikvfakt`s) \jfs prnvfl`s onr annl znifia *Jnrtni-
nimfi` Bj) ;
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
15/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;0 no ;4?
\j` Bnurs` Nrf`itktfni pka` prnvfl`s tj` m`kri`r wftj k gkp no Dmkbhdnkrls us`r'fit`rokb` kiljnw ft r`mkt`s tn tj` bnit`xt no tjfs bnurs`) \jfs pka` kmmnws us`rs tn s`` tj` `itfr` bnit`it no tj`
nrf`itktfni aufl` dy sbrnmmfia ni tj` sbr``i) M`kri`rs gky kmsn lnwimnkl tj` )plo ofm` tn skv` onrmkt`r us`)
Ofaur` 2)4 ' Bnurs` Nrf`itktfni Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
16/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;? no ;4?
\nsbk\j`Tkfs` tj` Burtkfi ni \nsbk+ jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` np`rk \nsbk) Ft s`rv`s
tn mur` tj` m`kri`r fitn tj` g`mnlrkgktfb np`rk dy `ibnurkafia tj`g tn r`kl tj` stnry- mnnh kt tj`vfl`n no tj` ofikm kbt *wj`r` \nsbk eugps tn j`r l`ktj&- kil mfst`i tn tj` lrkgktfb ofikm krfk) Kmm
ofm`s onr tj`s` kbtfvftf`s gky d` lnwimnkl`l orng tj` mfihs prnvfl`l ni tjfs pka`) \j`r` fs kmsn k
r`qu`st tn m`kri`rs tn prnvfl` p`rsnikm dkbharnuil fionrgktfni dy `gkfmfia tj` fistrubtnr usfiatj` prnvfl`l lfr`bt `gkfm mfih)
Ofaur` 2)2 'Tkfs` tj` Burtkfi ni \nsbk+ pka`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
17/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;1 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` @m`g`its jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` np`rk kil spkrhs tj` fit`r`st rfajtkwky wftj k vfl`n no tj` np`ifia sb`i`) \j` fitrnlubtfni t`xt afv`s fistrubtfnis onr jnw tn
prnb``l wftj tj` `m`g`its s`btfni kil stkt`s tj` m`krifia nde`btfv`) Kmm no tj` bngpni`its*Rtnry- Gusfb- Kbtfia- R`ts- kil Bnstug`s& kr` kbb`ss`l orng tjfs pka`) \jfs pka` kmfais wftj
M`krifia Nde`btfv` ;)3)
Ofaur` 2)< ' \nsbk ' \j` @m`g`its Jng` Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
18/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;: no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Rtnry gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr lnwimnklfia tj` syinpsfs kil mfdr`ttnlnbug`its- wjkt tn r`kl kil wjkt tn lfsbuss) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` ;);)
Ruds`qu`it pka`s kr` sjnwi j`r` ' tj` Ryinpsfs / Mfdr`ttn Ofm`s pka` kil tj` lfsbussfnionrug tjkt wfmm d` us`l onr kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` ;);)
Ofaur` 2)0 ' \nsbk ' \j` Rtnry Gkfi pka`- Ryinpsfs / Mfdr`ttn pka`- kil Lfsbussfni \jr`kl pka`)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
19/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ;6 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Gusfb gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr lnwimnklfia tj` mfdr`ttn tn r`kl- mfst`ifia tntj` kulfn- lnwimnklfia tj` trkisbrfpt no tj` kulfn- kil onr tkhfia tj` gusfb qufz) \j`r` fs kmsn k
mfih tn tj` dfnarkpjy no tj` burr`it au`st sp`kh`r) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`;)4) Ruds`qu`it pka`s kr` sjnwi j`r` ' tj` Kulfn \rkisbrfpt lnbug`it- Au`st Rp`kh`r
Dfnarkpjy kil fistrubtfnis kil t`st onr tj` Gusfb no \nsbk qufz wjfbj wfmm d` us`l onr
kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` ;)4)
Ofaur` 2)? ' \nsbk ' \j` Gusfb Gkfi pka`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
20/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 43 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Kbtfiagkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` kbtfia smfl`sjnw- r`s`krbjfiaokgnus kbtnrs kil pkrtfbfpktfia fi tj` lfsbussfni onrug onr tjfs nde`btfv`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis
kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` ;)2) Ruds`qu`it pka`s kr` sjnwi j`r` ' tj` pka` wftj tj` kbtfiasmfl`sjnw kil tj` lfsbussfni tjr`kl Qjkt gkh`s ki kbtnr ar`kt>- wjfbj wfmm d` us`l onr
kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` ;)2)
Ofaur` 2)1 ' \nsbk ' \j` Kbtfia Gkfi pka`- Kbtfia Rmfl`sjnw pka` kil Lfsbussfni \jr`kl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
21/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 4; no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` R`ts gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` s`ts smfl`sjnw- r`s`krbjfiamnbktfnis fi Tng` orng tj` np`rk kil tkhfia tj` s`ts t`st onr tjfs nde`btfv`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis
kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` ;)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
22/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 44 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Bnstug`s gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` bnstug`s smfl`sjnw-r`s`krbjfia bnstug`s orng lfoo`r`it prnlubtfnis no \nsbk kil tkhfia tj` bnstug`s t`st onr tjfs
nde`btfv`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` ;)0) Ruds`qu`it pka`s kr` sjnwi j`r` 'tj` pka` wftj tj` bnstug`s smfl`sjnw- fistrubtfnis onr tj` t`st kil tj` kbtukm t`st- wjfbj wfmm d`
us`l onr kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` ;)0)
Ofaur` 2)6 ' \nsbk ' \j` Bnstug`s Gkfi pka`- Bnstug`s Rmfl`sjnw- Fistrubtfnis onr t`st- Bnstug`s \`st
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
23/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 42 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` S`npm` jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` bjkrkbt`r- Rbkrpfk fi tj` np`rk kilspkrhs tj` fit`r`st rfajt kwky wftj k vfl`n no Rbkrpfks `vfm sb`i` wj`r` j` pmnts tn gkh` \nsbk
jfs) \j` fitrnlubtfni t`xt afv`s fistrubtfnis onr jnw tn prnb``l wftj tj` p`npm` s`btfni kilstkt`s tj` m`krifia nde`btfv`) Kmm no tj` bngpni`its *Snmftfbs- Tngkitfb- kil Rnbfn'@bningfb&
kr` kbb`ss`l orng tjfs pka`) \jfs pka` kmfais wftj M`krifia Nde`btfv` 4)3)
Ofaur` 2);3 ' \nsbk ' \j` S`npm` Jng` Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
24/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 4< no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Snmftfbs gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr bnisfl`rfia k pnmftfbkm mnnh kt tj`bjkrkbt`rs fi \nsbk) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 4);) K suds`qu`it pka` onr tj`
lfsbussfni onrug fs sjnwi j`r`- wjfbj mkys nut fistrubtfnis onr r`pmf`s) \jfs lfsbussfni tjr`klwfmm d` us`l onr tj` kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` 4);)
Ofaur` 2);; ' \nsbk ' \j` Snmftfbs Jng` Ska`
Ofaur` 2);4 ' \nsbk ' \j` Snmftfbs Lfsbussfni \jr`kl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
25/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 40 no ;4?
\j` \nsbk ' Tngkitfb gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr bnisfl`rfia k rngkitfb mnnh kt tj` tjr``gkfi bjkrkbt`rs fi \nsbk) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 4)4) K suds`qu`it pka`
onr tj` lfsbussfni onrug fs sjnwi j`r`- wjfbj mkys nut fistrubtfnis onr r`pmf`s wjfbj fivnmv`rnm`pmkyfia ni` no tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs) \jfs lfsbussfni tjr`kl wfmm d` us`l onr tj`
kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` 4)4)
Ofaur` 2);2 ' \nsbk ' Tngkitfb Jng` Ska`
Ofaur` 2);< ' \nsbk ' Tngkitfb Lfsbussfni \jr`kl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
26/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 4? no ;4?
\j` \nsbk ' Rnbfn'`bningfb gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr bnisfl`rfia k snbfn'`bningfb mnnhkt tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs fi \nsbk) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 4)2) K
suds`qu`it pka` onr tj` lfsbussfni onrug fs sjnwi j`r`- wjfbj mkys nut fistrubtfnis onr r`pmf`swjfbj fivnmv` rnm`pmkyfia ni` no tj` tjr`` gkfi bjkrkbt`rs) \jfs lfsbussfni tjr`kl wfmm d` us`l
onr tj` kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` 4)2)
Ofaur` 2);0 ' \nsbk ' Rnbfn'`bningfb Jng` Ska`
Ofaur` 2);? ' \nsbk ' Rnbfn'`bningfb Lfsbussfni \jr`kl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
27/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 41 no ;4?
\nsbk ' \j` Rjnw jng`pka` prnvfl`s fitrnlubtfni t`xt afvfia fistrubtfnis onr jnw tn prnb``lwftj tj` sjnw s`btfni kil stkt`s tj` m`krifia nde`btfv`) Kmm no tj` bngpni`its *Kulf`ib`
@tfqu`tt`- Ofilfia k S`ronrgkib`- kil Brftfqu`& kr` kbb`ss`l orng tjfs pka`) \jfs pka` kmfaiswftj M`krifia Nde`btfv` 2)3)
Ofaur` 2);1 ' \nsbk ' \j` Rjnw Jng` Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
28/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 4: no ;4?
\j` \nsbk ' Kulf`ib` @tfqu`tt` pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis kpprnprfkt` d`jkvfnr tjkt fs `xp`bt`lwj`i ktt`ilfia k mfv` p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2);)
\j` kss`ssg`it onr tjfs bngpni`it fs dks`l upni tj` klj`r`ib` tn tj`s` rum`s no `tfqu`tt` fo tj`ykr` kppmfbkdm` tn tj` m`kri`rs ktt`ilkib` `xp`rf`ib`- wjfbj kmfais wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2);)
Ofaur` 2);: ' \nsbk ' Kulf`ib` @tfqu`tt`
\j` \nsbk ' Ofilfia k S`ronrgkib` pka` prnvfl`s k mfst no mfihs tn okgnus np`rk bngpkif`s
wj`r` m`kri`rs bki ofil fionrgktfni kdnut mfv` p`ronrgkib`s- vfl`n ni l`gkil- kil np`rksbr``ifias no \nsbk) \j`s` mfihs wfmm prnvfl` fionrgktfni kdnut ktt`ilfia tj`s` p`ronrgkib`s-
wjfbj fs k r`qufr`g`it no tj` bnurs`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2)4) \j`kss`ssg`it onr tjfs bngpni`it fs dks`l upni tj` ktt`ilkib` no k p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk- wjfbj
kmfais wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2)4)
Ofaur` 2);6 ' \nsbk ' Ofilfia k S`ronrgkib`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
29/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 46 no ;4?
\j` \nsbk ' Brftfqu` pka` prnvfl`s fistrubtfnis onr tj` kssfaig`it Qrft` k Brftfqu` no \nsbk)\j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2)2) \j` kss`ssg`it onr tjfs bngpni`it fs dks`l
upni tj` pr`s`itktfni no tjfs brftfqu` no \nsbk tn p``rs- wjfbj kmfais wftj sud'nde`btfv` 2)2)
Ofaur` 2)43 ' \nsbk ' Brftfqu` pka`
Fi kllftfni tn tj` kdnv` pka`s- tj`r` wfmm d` pka`s wj`r` tj` m`kri`r bki b`itrkmmy kbb`ss kmm notj` lfsbussfnis kil qufzz`s onr tj` \nsbk Gnlum`5
Ofaur` 2)4; ' \nsbk ' B`itrkm Lfsbussfni Dnkrl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
30/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 23 no ;4?
Ofaur` 2)44 ' \nsbk ' \nsbk [ufzz`s pka`
Mkstmy- tj`r` wfmm d` k \nsbkQfhf pka`) Dks`l ni tj` hinwm`la` tj`y jkv` bnistrubt`ltjrnuajnut tj` bnurs`- tj` stul`its wfmm bnistrubt tjfs pka`) \jfs \nsbkQfhf wfmm s`rv` ks ki ni'
anfia r`snurb` onr tj` bnurs` kil wfmm int d` arkl`l)
Ofaur` 2)42 ' \nsbk ' \nsbkQfhf
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
31/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 2; no ;4?
Bkrg`i\j`Tkfs` tj` Burtkfi ni Bkrg`i+ jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` np`rk Bkrg`i) Ft
s`rv`s tn mur` tj` m`kri`r fitn tj` lrkgktfb np`rk dy `ibnurkafia tj`g tn r`kl tj` stnry- mnnh kt kvfl`n no tj` `itfbfia Bkrg`i- kil mfst`i tn j`r bjkrgfia ofrst krfk) Kmm ofm`s onr tj`s` kbtfvftf`s
gky d` lnwimnkl`l orng tj` mfihs prnvfl`l ni tjfs pka`) \j`r` fs kmsn k r`qu`st tn m`kri`rs tn
prnvfl` p`rsnikm dkbharnuil fionrgktfni dy `gkfmfia tj` fistrubtnr usfia tj` prnvfl`l lfr`bt`gkfm mfih)
Ofaur` 2)4< 'Tkfs` tj` Burtkfi ni Bkrg`i+ pka`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
32/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 24 no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` @m`g`its jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` np`rk kil spkrhs tj` fit`r`strfajt kwky wftj k vfl`n no tj` np`ifia sb`i` wj`r` tj` bjkrkbt`r no Bkrg`i fs fitrnlub`l fi tj`
np`rk) \j` fitrnlubtfni t`xt afv`s fistrubtfnis onr jnw tn prnb``l wftj tj` `m`g`its s`btfni kilstkt`s tj` m`krifia nde`btfv`) Kmm no tj` bngpni`its *Rtnry- Gusfb- Kbtfia- Lkib`- kil
Bnstug`s& kr` kbb`ss`l orng tjfs pka`) \jfs pka` kmfais wftj M`krifia Nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
33/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 22 no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Rtnry gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr lnwimnklfia tj` syinpsfs kil mfdr`ttn
lnbug`its- wjkt tn r`kl kil wjkt tn lfsbuss) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
34/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 2< no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Gusfb gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr lnwimnklfia tj` mfdr`ttn tn r`kl- mfst`ifiatn tj` kulfn- lnwimnklfia tj` trkisbrfpt no tj` kulfn- kil onr tkhfia tj` gusfb qufz) \j`r` fs
kmsn k mfih tn tj` dfnarkpjy no tj` burr`it au`st sp`kh`r) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
35/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 20 no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Kbtfiagkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` kbtfia smfl`sjnw- r`s`krbjfiaokgnus kbtnrs kil pkrtfbfpktfia fi tj` lfsbussfni onrug onr tjfs nde`btfv`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis
kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
36/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 2? no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Lkib` gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` lkib` gnvf`s- r`s`krbjfialfoo`r`it hfils no lkib` us`l fi tj` np`rk kil tkhfia tj` lkib` t`st onr tjfs nde`btfv`) \j`s`
fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
37/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 21 no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Bnstug`s gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr wktbjfia tj` bnstug`s smfl`sjnw-r`s`krbjfia bnstug`s orng lfoo`r`it prnlubtfnis no Bkrg`i kil tkhfia tj` bnstug`s t`st onr tjfs
nde`btfv`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
38/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 2: no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` S`npm` jng`pka` afv`s ki fitrnlubtfni tn tj` gkfi bjkrkbt`r- Bkrg`i- kil spkrhsfit`r`st dy sjnwfia tj` krfk tjkt jks j`r l`sbrfdfia j`r nwi p`rsnikm d`mf`os) \j` fitrnlubtfni
t`xt afv`s fistrubtfnis onr jnw tn prnb``l wftj tj` p`npm` s`btfni kil stkt`s tj` m`krifiande`btfv`) Kmm no tj` bngpni`its *Snmftfbs- Tngkitfb- kil Rnbfn'@bningfb& kr` kbb`ss`l orng
tjfs pka`) \jfs pka` kmfais wftj M`krifia Nde`btfv` 0)3)
Ofaur` 2)2; ' Bkrg`i ' \j` S`npm` Jng` Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
39/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 26 no ;4?
Bkrg`i ' \j` Snmftfbs gkfi pka` afv`s fistrubtfnis onr bnisfl`rfia tj` gnrkm d`mf`os no dntjBkrg`i kil Lni Ens`) \j`s` fistrubtfnis kmfai wftj sud'nde`btfv` 0);) K suds`qu`it pka` onr
tj` lfsbussfni onrug fs sjnwi j`r`- wjfbj mkys nut fistrubtfnis onr r`pmf`s) \jfs lfsbussfnitjr`kl wfmm d` us`l onr tj` kss`ssg`it no tjfs sud'nde`btfv` 0);)
Ofaur` 2)24 ' Bkrg`i ' \j` Snmftfbs Jng` Ska`
Ofaur` 2)22 ' Bkrg`i ' \j` Snmftfbs Lfsbussfni \jr`kl
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
40/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
41/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
42/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
43/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
44/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
45/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
46/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
47/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
48/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
49/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
50/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 03 no ;4?
\j`Fistrubtnr Fionrgktfni pka` afv`s bnitkbt fionrgktfni- dfnarkpjfbkm int`s- pjntns kil noofb`jnurs onr tj` fistrubtnr- ks w`mm ks kiy au`st m`btur`rs.krtfsts kil ntj`r sp`bfkm au`sts)
Ofaur` 2)0< ' Ntj`r ' Fistrubtnr Fion
\j` Ryst`g J`mp pka` fs k mfih tn tj` Dmkbhdnkrl j`mp syst`g wjfbj `xfsts nutsfl` no tj` bnurs`bnit`it) Ft kmsn prnvfl`s i`ws kil uplkt`s onr tj` m`krifia gkika`g`it syst`g)
Ofaur` 2)00 ' Ntj`r ' Ryst`g J`mp
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
51/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 0; no ;4?
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
52/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 04 no ;4?
Onmmnwfia fs tj` \ksh Bjkrt nutmfifia pr`'r`qufsft` shfmms onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "2)3 *\nsbk '
\j` Rjnw&5
Ofaur`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
53/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 02 no ;4?
Onmmnwfia fs tj` \ksh Bjkrt nutmfifia pr`'r`qufsft` shfmms onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "0)3 *Bkrg`i '\j` S`npm`&5
Ofaur`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
54/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 0< no ;4?
Onmmnwfia fs tj` \ksh Bjkrt nutmfifia pr`'r`qufsft` shfmms onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "1)3 *Nv`rkmm
Bngpkrfsni&5
Ofaur`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
55/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 00 no ;4?
BNI\@I\ RS@BFOFBK\FNIRBnit`it Rp`bfofbktfnis onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` ";5
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ktt`itfni
Lrkgktfb vfl`n no tj` ofikm krfk
kt tj` `il no tj` lrkgktfb
stnrymfi` wfmm d` pr`s`it`l ofrst
tn spkrh tj` m`kri`rs fit`r`st)
@gd`ll`l *>& Vnu\ud`
vfl`n no ofikm sb`i` no
\nsbk wftj Kia`mk
Aj`nrajfu / Kmkaik5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7i?h\gQVFKbw/o
`ktur`7ynutud`^alktk^pmky
`r
KIL
@gd`ll`l *>& Vnu\ud`
vfl`n no ofikm sb`i` no
\nsbk wftj Lngfian /
Hkdkfvkishk5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7:ZDA`Z_ioIK
Fts nimy < gfiut`smnia tn kvnfl bnaiftfv`nv`rmnkl
Lrkgktfb- rngkitfb kilw`mm prnlub`l- sn `ksy
tn fl`itfoy p`rsnikmftf`s
no bjkrkbt`r
Bmkssfb prnlubtfni- s`tskil bnstug`s onr `ksy
fl`itfofbktfni no
`m`g`its
D`kutfoum p`npm`-sup`rfnr kbtfia kil
sfiafia onr fitrfau` /lrkgk- sn ft sjnuml
gntfvkt` tj` m`kri`r tn
wktbj *kil int sbkr`
tj`g&
Lngfian v`rsfni jkstj` sudtftm`s onr tjns`
int okgfmfkr wftj tj`
np`rk
\j` Lngfian v`rsfnis`ttfia fs kutj`itfb
ofmg`l kt tj` kbtukm
Bkst`m Rkit!Kia`mn
Lngfian v`rsfni fskmsn kvkfmkdm` onr
purbjks` ks k L_L onr
noomfi` vf`wfia
Surpns` no
ktt`itfni a`tt`r
\n mur` tj` m`kri`r fitn tj`
fitrfau` no tj` stnry kil
gntfvkt` tj`fr burfnsfty tn ofil
nut wjng tj` bjkrkbt`rs kr` kil
jnw tj` stnry l`v`mnps)
R`` kdnv` R`` kdnv`
Fit`r`st.gntfvktf
ni
Sr`s`itfia tj` lrkgktfb `il no
tj` stnrymfi` ofrst wfmm kll
fitrfau` kil j`fajt`i burfnsfty)
R`` kdnv` R`` kdnv`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
56/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 0? no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Sr`vf`w
T`kl- suggkrfz` / r`bkmm tj`stnrymfi`
Fl`itfoy gnnls fi tj` gusfb /tj`g`s
Bngpkr` bnstug`s tn gnl`rilr`ss fi Tng` fi tj` ;:33s
K lnwimnklkdm` )plo kilk arkpjfb fgka` fi
MKTA@ STFI\ wftj tj`
stnrymfi` kil kbtukm wnrls
orng tj` mfdr`ttn *tn
onmmnw kmnia wftj tj`
vfl`n&
Mfih tnjttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stn
rf`s.syinpsfs)kspx>fl740
onr tj` G`ts np`rk
syinpsfs
BL nr L_L mfi`r int`s
)plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l
kil fgka`s no
lnbug`its bki d`
gkl` mkra` onr m`kri`rs
tjkt gfajt jkv` vfsfni
mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmmd` k suppm`g`it tn kiy
kurkm fssu`s wftj tj`
vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmmsjnw bjkrkbt`rs /
r`mkt`l lfkmnau` fi
gumtfpm` mkiauka`s kil
nrakifz`l ks tj` gusfbRyinpsfs afv`s k
a`i`rkm nv`rvf`w no tj`
stnry mfi` usukmmy
nimy r`kl nib`
Srfnr Hinwm`la`
In pr`vfnus hinwm`la` nonp`rk r`qufr`l
M`kri`rs jkv` dksfb bngput`rshfmms- bki typ` kil ikvfakt`
tj` fit`ri`tBnggkil no tj` @iamfsj
mkiauka` *wrftfia- r`klfia-
sp`khfia- mfst`ifia /uil`rstkilfia&
A`ttfia stkrt`l ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kri> S`rjkps
mfihs tn tj` Dmkbhdnkrl
j`mp- dut jnp`oummy gnr`
nrakifz`l kil tkfmnr`l tn
tj` m`kri`rs i``ls) Fbnis
gust gkh` s`is` kil d`
uifv`rskm)
J`mp ouibtfnis i``l tn
d` kbb`ssfdm` orng kmm
m`v`ms no tj` MGR) Ft
wfmm d` fgpnrtkit tjkt tj`
lfoo`r`it HFILR no j`mp
bki d` lfoo`r`itfkt`l
dks`l ni r`pr`s`itktfv`
fbnis
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
57/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 01 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Fionrgktfni /
@xkgpm`s
T`kl- suggkrfz` / r`bkmm tj`stnrymfi`
Fl`itfoy gnnls fi tj` gusfb /tj`g`s
Bngpkr` bnstug`s tn gnl`rilr`ss fi Tng` fi tj` ;:33s
Mfihs tn nimfi` /lnwimnklkdm` v`rsfnis no
mfdr`ttn / syinpsfs
jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stn
rf`s.syinpsfs)kspx>fl740
Mfihs tn r`snurb`s *f)`)jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.fil`x)ksp
x&
Ruaa`st`l r`klfia mfst not`xtdnnhs *mfst&5
;) Np`rk onr Luggf`sdy Lkvfl Snau`
4) ;33 Ar`kt Np`rksKil \j`fr Rtnrf`s5 Kbt'
Dy'Kbt Ryinps`s dy
J`iry Q) Rfgni
2) NS@TK5Bngpns`rs) Qnrhs)
S`ronrg`rs dy Pmmgki
)plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l
kil fgka`s no
lnbug`its bki d`
gkl` mkra` onr m`kri`rs
tjkt gfajt jkv` vfsfni
mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmmd` k suppm`g`it tn kiy
kurkm fssu`s wftj tj`
vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmmsjnw bjkrkbt`rs kil
tj`fr r`mkt`l lfkmnau`
fi gumtfpm` mkiauka`s
kil nrakifz`l ks tj`gusfb fs
Ryinpsfs afv`s ka`i`rkm nv`rvf`w no
tj` stnry mfi` usukmmy
nimy r`kl nib`
Dnnhs- t`xtdnnhs kil`t`xtdnnhs bki d` us`l
ksyibjrninusmy- h`pt
onr r`o`r`ib` kil
kiintkt`l)
Ktt`itfni
Ktt`itfni wfmm d` akfi`l kil
gkfitkfi`l dy fibnrpnrktfia
vfsukm kil gusfbkm `xkgpm`s
tjkt r`mkt` tn tj` stnrymfi`)
)gp2 snuil dft`s tjkt kr`r`mkt`l tn tj` bjkrkbt`rstj`g`s
Fgka`s no bnstug`s kilgkps fi ;:33s Tng`
)gp2 skgpm`s no gnnls jnrrnr- mnv`- pnw`r-
r`mfafni- l`ktj
Au`st krtfst gusfbfki dyvfl`n bnio`r`ib` *mfv` kilr`bnrl`l onr mkt`r
r`o`r`ib`& Rt`v` Sfkzzk-
dkss bmkrfi`t Mns Kia`m`s
Np`rk
Ni` no tj` gnstprngfi`it `m`g`its nonp`rk fs tj` gusfb)
Rnuil dft`s orng
)gp2 ofm`s kr` gnst
kbb`ssfdm` kil kr` tj`
d`st wky tn r`kmfz` ki
kurkm `xp`rf`ib`
Bjuihfia tj` kulfnskgpm`s fitn sp`bfofb
dft`s kvnfls
bnaiftfv` kil kurkm
nv`rmnkl
Ki fit`rvf`w wftj kau`st krtfst wfmm kll
tj` r`kmfty kil
mnbkmfzktfni tn
fit`rkbtfni onr
gntfvktfnikm `oo`bt)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
58/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 0: no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
M`krifiaRtrkt`af`s
Dy usfia fiqufry'dks`l
bnmmkdnrktfv` hinwm`la`
bnistrubtfni- m`kri`rs wfmm
fl`itfoy kil bnitrfdut` wrftt`i
kil.nr vfsukm l`sbrfptfnis notj`fr ofilfias tn ki Np`rkQfhf-
dufmlfia ki nimfi` lktkdks` no
bngpni`its kbb`ssfdm` tn tj`
`itfr` bmkss onr tj` lurktfni no
tj` bnurs`)
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris Qfhfpka`s
Dds wfhf pka`s kr`kmr`kly wftjfi tj`
`stkdmfsj`l m`krifia
`ivfrnig`it eustkintj`r bngpni`it
Kmm jkv` kbb`ssBnmmkdnrktfni fs
fgpmfbft
Ruggkrfz` /
T`vf`w
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
l`bnistrubt- lfsbuss kil fl`itfoy
tj` bngpni`its tjkt an fi tn
gkhfia tj` wjnm` krt onrg no
np`rk fi a`i`rkm)
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rsNianfia o``ldkbh
orng p``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfninppnrtuiftf`s
\rkiso`r
Afv`i tj` fl`itfofbktfni no kmm
tj` bngpni`its no ki np`rk-
m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
lfstfiaufsj tj` uifqu` qukmftf`s
no `kbj bngpni`it ks ft r`mkt`s
sp`bfofbkmmy tn tj` np`rk \nsbk)
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rsNianfia o``ldkbh
orng p``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfni
nppnrtuiftf`s
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
59/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 06 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
T`gntfvkt`.
Bmns`
Afv`i tj` hinwm`la` no tj`
bngpni`its no ki np`rk-
m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn bngpkr`
uifqu` kil sfgfmkr qukmftf`s
d`tw``i twn nr gnr` lfoo`r`itprnlubtfnis no tj` skg` np`rk)
Kiy twn no tj` onmmnwfia
vfl`ns- nr wjkt`v`r
r`snurb`s tj` m`kri`r
kmr`kly jks ni jkil *L_L-
drnklbkst- `tb)&- jkskbb`ssfdfmfty tn *ki kbtukm
oumm p`ronrgkib`& nr bki
ofil5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7te^RLNKG2^K
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7i?h\gQVFKbw/o
`ktur`7ynutud`^alktk^pmky`r
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7:ZDA`Z_ioIK
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7`So'nkKmUwF *kt
2503&
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7FjLAmIA^Onw
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7lFwlFMTeRaG
Onuil r`snurb`s bkid` sjkr`l
Lfoo`r`it vfl`ns novkrfnus prnlubtfnis
wfmm pr`s`it uifqu`
krtfstfb stym`s-
lfr`btfni- kbtfia-
sfiafia- bnstug`s-s`ts- kil `v`i
mkiauka`s *ni` no tj`
vfl`ns fs fi @iamfsj
kil ni` jks Ekpki`s`
sud'tftm`s&
Kss`ss
S`ronrgkib`
Q``hmy arkl`s wfmm d` afv`ionr pkrtfbfpktfni kil qukmfty no
r`spnis`s fi lfsbussfni
onrugs)[ufzz`s wfmm d` us`l
tjrnuajnut tj` bnurs` tn
fl`itfoy bnrr`bt vs) fibnrr`bt
skgpm`s onr `kbj bngpni`it
tn kss`ss m`kri`r kbburkby kil
hinwm`la`)
Ki nv`rkmm arkl` wfmm d` afv`ionr tjfs nde`btfv` dks`l ni tj`
m`kri`rs hinwm`la` kil
kdfmfty tn fl`itfoy kil lfsbuss
bngpni`its) \j` t`st wfmm
nbbur kt tj` `il no tj` tnpfb)
Nimfi` qufz tjrnuajDmkbhdnkrl m`kri
Lfsbussfni onrugs\`st nimfi`
\j` qufzz`s kil t`stsni Dmkbhdnkrl M`kri
kr` kmr`kly wftjfi tj`
`stkdmfsj`l m`krifia
`ivfrnig`it eust
kintj`r bngpni`it
Kmr`kly fibnrpnrkt`lfitn tj` `xfstfia
arklfia syst`g
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
60/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?3 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
O``ldkbh.
T`g`lfktfni
O``ldkbh wfmm d` afv`i orng tj`
fistrubtnr kt tj` `il no `kbj
w``h no r`m`vkit fistrubtfni)
O``ldkbh orng tj`
fistrubtnr wfmm d` prnvfl`l
tjrnuaj tj` arklfia b`it`r
fi Dmkbhdnkrl- vfl`n bjkts
nr `gkfm- l`p`ilfia niwjkt tj` m`kri`r pr`o`rs kil
fs gnst bngonrtkdm` wftj)
Afvfia tj` m`kri`r
nptfnis ks tn tj` g`tjnl
no o``ldkbh klls tn tj`
nwi`rsjfp `xp`rf`ib` notj` m`kri`r kil puts tj`g
gnr` kt `ks`)
\kdm` & Vnu\ud` vfl`n
no sb`i` fi wjfbj Rbkrpfk musts
nv`r \nsbk wjfm` fi tj`
bjurbj) \j` lfbjntngy no jfs`vfm wjfm` tj` gusfb no tj`
bktjnmfb gkss fs tkhfia pmkb` fs
k wnil`roum kil fitrfaufia
bnitrkst fi `gntfnis)
Lngfian / Hkdkfvkishk
v`rsfni5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.wktb
j>v7e`@d_isVv7eg34KhHhBbs/o`ktur`7r
`sumts^vfl`n/pmkyi`xt7;/mfst
7SM340O;D
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
61/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?; no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Surpns`
\j` sjnbh okbtnr no tj` krfk
wfmm br`kt` fitrfau`- sjnw
uisbrupumnusi`ss no bjkrkbt`rs
kil spkrh burfnsfty ks tn wjktkbtfnis tj` bjkrkbt`rs
*sp`bfofbkmmy Rbkrpfk& gfajt
tkh` tn a`t wjkt j` wkits)
R`` kdnv` R`` kdnv`
Fit`r`st.gntfvktfni
Lfsbnv`r tj` fit`rikmpkssfnis kil gntfvktfni no
`kbj no tj` bjkrkbt`rs- tj`fr
vkmu`s- pkssfni onr pnw`r kil
rngkitfb fl`kms)
M`kri tj` fit`rpmky d`tw``itj`s` vkmu`s kil r`mktfnisjfps
wjkt koo`bt tj`y jkv` ni `kbj
ntj`r
K lnwimnklkdm` )plo kil karkpjfb fgka` fi MKTA@
STFI\ wftj tj` stnrymfi` kil
kbtukm wnrls orng tj` mfdr`ttn
*tn onmmnw kmnia wftj tj`
vfl`n kil gusfb&
)plo kil mfih tn5jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)nra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stnrf`s.s
yinpsfs)kspx>fl740 onr tj`
G`ts np`rk syinpsfs
Ryinpsfs bki kmsn d`ndtkfi`l orng kiy ntj`r
snurb` kvkfmkdm` tn tj`
m`kri`r
Mfi`r int`s orng BL nr L_L
plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l kil
fgka`s no lnbug`its bki
d` gkl` mkra` onr
m`kri`rs tjkt gfajt jkv`
vfsfni mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmm d`k suppm`g`it tn kiy kurkm
fssu`s wftj tj` vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmm sjnwbjkrkbt`rs kil tj`fr
r`mkt`l lfkmnau` fi
gumtfpm` mkiauka`s kil
nrakifz`l ks tj` gusfb fs
Ryinpsfs afv`s k a`i`rkmnv`rvf`w no tj` stnry mfi`
usukmmy nimy r`kl nib`
Sr`vf`w
Lfsbuss tj` bjkrkbt`rs fi tj`np`rk kil pr`lfbt tj`fr okt`
kt tj` `il no tj` stnry
T`bkmm kil suggkrfz` tj`pnmftfbkm jfstnry kil
`bningfb bmfgkt` no Tng`
fi tj` `krmy ;:33s
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n `xp`rf`ib` gkiylfoo`r`it p`rsp`btfv`s /
fl`ks
Nianfia o``ldkbh orngp``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninus fit`rkbtfninppnrtuiftf`s
Srfnr
Hinwm`la`
Srfnr hinwm`la` no tj`stnrymfi` kil mfdr`ttn no
\nsbk
Kdm` tn fl`itfoy tj`bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` stnryHinwm`la` no burr`it kookfrs
T`o`r`ib` dkbh tn pr`vfnuslfsbussfnis kil bnurs`
bnit`it tjrnuaj MGR
Burr`it kookfrs tn d` ndtkfi`ltjrnuaj wjkt`v`r g`lfk kr`
gnst bngonrtkdm` kilkbb`ssfdm` tn tj` m`kri`r)
\rklftfnikm i`wspkp`r-
lfaftkm i`ws- Fit`ri`t- rklfn-
t`m`vfsfni nr bniv`rsktfni)
Nwi`rsjfp no pr`vfnus
hinwm`la` kil
bnmmkdnrktfv` bnistrubtfni
dks`l ni fionrgktfni
lktkdks` dufmt dy bmkssorng pr`vfnus w``h*s& no
lfsbussfnis kil Np`rkQfhf
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
62/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?4 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Fionrgktfni
/ @xkgpm`s
Lfsbuss tj` gntfvktfnis notj` bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk
T`bnaifz` kil lfsbuss tj`fit`rpmky d`tw``i bjkrkbt`rs
dks`l ni tj`fr p`rsnikm
gntfv`s kil snbfn'`bningfb
stktus
Bngpkr` sfgfmkrftf`s killfoo`r`ib`s fi tnlkys
pnmftfbkm bmfgkt` fi tj` P)R)
wftj tjkt no @urnp` fi tj`
;:33s
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
Fit`rkbtfvfty wftj kilm`krifia orng p``rs
Kiy pmkb`- kiy tfg`ksyibjrninus m`krifia
Aufl`l lfsbussfniqu`stfnis
O``ldkbh orng fistrubtnrO``ldkbh- qu`stfnis kil
ourtj`r lfsbussfni tnpfbs
orng p``rs
Ktt`itfni
Sr`lfbt tj` okt` no `kbj no tj`bjkrkbt`rs
Kppmyfia tj`fr vkrf`l mfo``xp`rf`ib` fi gktt`rs no mnv`-
pnw`r kil d`mf`os wfmm kmmnw
m`kri`rs tn bngpkr` tj`fr nwi
vkmu`s tn tj` sb`ikrfns no
bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk
F lnit hinw fo tj`r` fs kwky- dut F wnuml mfh` tn jkv`
efaskw'mfh` pf`b`s no k
puzzm`- ki fit`rkbtfv` omnw
bjkrt- `'dnnh nr gnvf` tjkt
wnuml kmmnw tj` m`kri`r tn
pfbh pf`b`s no k stnry kil r`'
krrkia` tj`g fitn k bngpm`t`
stnrymfi` onr `kbj bjkrkbt`r
Aufl`l lfsbussfni wftj afv`iqu`stfnis fi tj` MGRlfsbussfni onrug
\jfs wnuml d` kbngpm`t`my fit`rkbtfv`-
dut stfmm aufl`l fi tjkt tj`
pf`b`s wnuml d`
prnvfl`l- dut tj` ofikm
krrkia`g`it wnuml d` k
br`ktfni no tj` m`kri`r) Ft
wnuml np`i pnssfdfmftf`s
onr tj`fr br`ktfvfty
Lfsbussfni onrugs wnumlprnvfl` ksyibjrninus
fit`rkbtfvfty wftj orng
p``rs
Nppnrtuifty tn m`kriorng kil d` fispfr`l dy
p``rs
O``ldkbh fi lfsbussfni
M`krifia
Rtrkt`af`s
Dy usfia fiqufry'dks`lm`krifia tn br`kt`
lfsbussfnis- tj` m`kri`rs wfmm
lfsbuss jnw tj`y gfajt
p`rsnikmmy l`km wftj sfgfmkr
sftuktfnis ks tj` bjkrkbt`rs
*rnm`'pmky&
Psfia tj` Bnistrubtfv` kilBFS m`krifia tj`nrf`s- tj`
fistrubtnr wfmm dufml sb`ikrfns
onr m`kri`rs tn syitj`sfz`
tj`fr hinwm`la` no bjkrkbt`r
gntfvktfni wftj p`rsnikmftf`s
fi tnlkys burr`it `v`its
Rp`bfofb lfsbussfni qu`stfnisonr t`kgs lfvfl`l dy
bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk tn
jkv` ki nimfi` l`dkt` fi tj`
MGR lfsbussfni onrug
r`akrlfia tj`fr p`rsnikm
eulag`its kil npfifnis
Lfsbussfni onrug fiDmkbhdnkrl MGR tn kppmybjkrkbt`r gntfvktfni wftj
tnlkys pudmfb p`rsnikmftf`s
Bnmmkdnrktfni d`tw``ip``rs tn br`kt` k dnly no
`xp`rf`ib`s *lktkdks`&
dks`l ni p`rsnikm
npfifni kil mfo`'
`xp`rf`ib`
Lfsbussfni onrug wfmmkmmnw m`kri`rs tn prnvfl`
r`km'wnrml `xkgpm`s tn
`kbj ntj`r- wjfbj wfmmbr`kt` bnii`btfnis wftj
bjkrkbt`rs kil stnry mfi`s
fi tj` np`rk
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
63/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?2 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ruggkrfz` /T`vf`w
Lfoo`r`itfkt` tj` gntfvktfnisno `kbj no tj` bjkrkbt`rs fi
lfsbussfni
Kppmy hinwm`la` nobjkrkbt`r gntfvktfni tn
bngpkr` wftj `xkgpm`s fi
tnlkys burr`it `v`its kil
pudmfb ofaur`s
Lfsbussfni onrug niDmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rs Nianfia o``ldkbh orng
p``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfni nppnrtuiftf`s
\rkiso`r
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
subb`ssoummy bngpkr` kil
bnitrkst `xkgpm`s no p`npm` fi
tnlkys snbf`ty wftj bjkrkbt`rs
fi tj` np`rk)
Lfsbussfni onrug fi
Dmkbhdnkrl MGR
Lfsbussfni onrug wfmmkmmnw m`kri`rs tn prnvfl`
r`km'wnrml `xkgpm`s tn
`kbj ntj`r- wjfbj wfmm
br`kt` bnii`btfnis wftj
bjkrkbt`rs kil stnrymfi`s
fi tj` np`rk
T`gntfvkt`.
Bmns`
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn br`kt`
k ofbtfnikm i`w `ilfia onr tj`
np`rk kil sjkr` ft wftj tj`fr
p``rs fi k lfsbussfni)
Fi tj` MGR lfsbussfni tjr`kl-
tj` m`kri`rs wnuml tjr`kl
tna`tj`r k i`w stnry ' dy
kmpjkd`tfbkmmy *onr `xkgpm`&
wrftfia kdnut ki `v`it- tj`i
sng`ni` tkhfia nv`r onr tj`
i`xt p`rsni tn tf` tna`tj`r tj`
i`xt `v`it)
Bnmmkdnrktfv`- fitrfau`-
surprfs`- l`p`il`iby ni
`kbj ntj`r- gntfvktfni-
p``r pr`ssur`)
Kss`ss
S`ronrgkib`
M`kri`rs wfmm bnilubt k s`mo
kss`ssg`it kt tj` `il no tj`
gnlum` dks`l ni tj`fr kdfmfty
tn fl`itfoy- kikmyz`- bngpkr`
kil syitj`sfz` tj`fr hinwm`la`
no tj` snbfkm- `bningfb-
pnmftfbkm kil rngkitfb `m`g`itsno \nsbk)
T`om`btfv` `ssky sudgftt`l tn
tj` kssfaig`its kr`k no tj`
MGR tn r`bkmm wjkt jks d``i
m`kri`l kil l`sbrfdfia tj`
jfajmfajts kil surprfs`s fi tj`
m`krifia `xp`rf`ib`
\fg` tn tjfih kdnut kil
r`om`bt noomfi` wjfm` wrftfia
k r`om`btfv` `ssky
\fg` kil intfb` wfmm d`
afv`i tn m`kri`r tn `isur`
r`spnisfdfmfty onr kbburkby
kil nwi`rsjfp nofionrgktfni
O``ldkbh.
T`g`lfktfni
O``ldkbh wfmm d` afv`i orng
tj` fistrubtnr kt tj` `il no
`kbj w``h no r`m`vkit
fistrubtfni)
O``ldkbh orng tj` fistrubtnr
wfmm d` prnvfl`l tjrnuaj tj`
arklfia b`it`r fi Dmkbhdnkrl-
vfl`n bjkts nr `gkfm-
l`p`ilfia ni wjkt tj` m`kri`r
pr`o`rs kil fs gnst
bngonrtkdm` wftj)
Afvfia tj` m`kri`r nptfnisks tn tj` g`tjnl no
o``ldkbh klls tn tj`
nwi`rsjfp `xp`rf`ib` no
tj` m`kri`r kil puts tj`g
gnr` kt `ks`)
\kdm`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
64/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?< no ;4?
Bnit`it Rp`bfofbktfnis onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "25
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ktt`itfni
Ki`blnt`s orng mfv` p`ronrgkib`s
no \nsbk tjrnuajnut tj` y`krs)
*Rp`bfofbkmmy- k okgnus p`ronrgkib`
wj`i \nsbk eugps noo tj` bkstm`
wkmm kt tj` `il no tj` np`rk kil-
d`fia rktj`r mkra`- vfsfdmy dnuib`s
dkbh up orng tj` sko`ty i`t pmkb`l
d`jfil tj` s`t gubj tn tj` sjnbh no
tj` kulf`ib`+&
Mfihs tn r`klfias ni tj`
fit`ri`t5
jttp5..www)bnb)bk.S`ronrgk
ib`sKil\fbh`ts.;;;4R`ksni
.\nsbk.@sskysKilOurtj`rT`
klfia.KbtfniSkbh`l\nsbk)ks
px
jttp5..np`rk)stkionrl)`lu.Sub
bfif.\nsbk.dkbhal)jtgm
jttp5..np`rkspnnok)wnrlpr`ss
)bng.np`rk'ki`blnt`s.
jttp5..dmna)km)bng.`it`rtkfig
`it'pr`ss'
r`afst`r.43;;.32.tnsbk^gndf
m`^np`rk^stka`s^pubb)jtgm
Rnurb`s bki kmsn bng` orng
t`xtdnnhs ni suaa`st`l
r`klfia mfst kil onuil
snurb`s
\j` d`st w` bki ln fs tn
r`kl kdnut tj`
`xp`rf`ib`s ntj`r
p`npm` jkv` r`pnrt`l onr
kbbfl`its tjkt jkv`
jkpp`i`l lurfia
prnlubtfni) In vfl`ns
pudmfbmy `xfst onrgfstkh`s fi prnlubtfni
*nut'tkh`s- dmnnp`rs&)
Surpns`
Kiytjfia bki jkpp`i lurfia k mfv`
p`ronrgkib` ' annl nr dkl) In
gktt`r wjkt p`ronrgkib` tj`ybjnns`- tj` sftuktfni wfmm d` uifqu`
tn `v`ry prnlubtfni kil `v`ry
kulf`ib`)
R`` kdnv`) R`` kdnv`)
Fit`r`st.
gntfvktfni
\jfs fs tj` bumgfiktfni no tj`
m`krifia tjkt jks ani` ni orng tj`
d`afiifia no tj` bnurs`- wj`r`
m`kri`rs bki kppmy tj`fr hinwm`la`
tn ki kbtukm p`ronrgkib`) Qjkt`v`r
jkpp`is- tj` m`kri`r wfmm nwi tjkt
`xp`rf`ib` p`rsnikmmy)
Ktt`ilkib` no k mfv`p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk
Kil.nr wktbjfia ki `itfr`p`ronrgkib` ni L_L- fi k
gnvf` tj`ktr`- ni \_ nr
mfst`ifia tn k BL nr rklfn
drnklbkst
Qfmm d` filfvflukm-
dks`l ni m`kri`rs
kdfmfty tn ktt`il k
p`ronrgkib`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
65/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?0 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Sr`vf`w
Fl`itfoy tj` qukmftf`s no kr`sp`btoum kulf`ib`
Bmkrfoy wjkt tn mfst`i onr- mnnh onrkil r`g`gd`r
Qrft` k brftfqu`Sr`s`it brftfqu` tn bmkssLfsbuss fi k onrug
Jnw tn d`jkv` kt kinp`rk5
jttp5..www)`jnw)bng.jnw
^4303346^d`jkv`'np`rk)jtgm
Qjkt tn `xp`bt5jttp5..mfstv`rs`)bng.4331.;
;.32.tnp';3'tfps'onr'ynur'
ofrst'np`rk'nr'dkmm`t.
Bmkssfbkm kulf`ib``tfqu`tt`5
jttp5..www)bkgksd)nra.yk
l.ykl'`tfqu`tt`)sjtgm
jttp5..www)np`rkpkbfofbk)n
ra.pa^nrkbm`)jtg
jttp5..dryb`'
w`st`rv`mt)suft`;3;)bng.n
p`rk'`tfqu`tt`';3;'k;44
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
66/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?? no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ktt`itfni
Mfst`i onr gusfbkm tj`g`s kilgnnls- mkiauka`s kil sfiafia)
Fl`itfoy jfajmfajts kil h`y pnfitsno kbtfia- stka` lfr`btfni-bnstug`s- s`ts kil v`iu` *fo
kppmfbkdm`&)
T`g`gd`r tj` kdnv` pmusstnrymfi` l`vfktfnis- s`ttfia kil
kulf`ib` r`kbtfnis)
Ktt`ilkib` kt k mfv`p`ronrgkib` no \nsbk
Kil.nr wktbjfia ki `itfr`p`ronrgkib` ni L_L- fi k
gnvf` tj`ktr`- ni \_ nr
mfst`ifia tn BL nr rklfn
drnklbkst
Mfv` ktt`ilkib` fs d`std`bkus` tj` `xp`rf`ib`
fs uifqu` tn tj` m`kri`r
m`kri`r nwis tj`
`xp`rf`ib`)
M`krifia
Rtrkt`af`s
\j` Bnistrubtfvfst tj`nry no
m`krifia wfmm d` us`l d`bkus` tj`
m`kri`rs wfmm d` br`ktfia tj`fr nwi
`xp`rf`ib` wjfm` ktt`ilfia k
p`ronrgkib` kil sjkrfia tj`frbrftfqu` wftj bmkssgkt`s)
Lfsbussfni kot`r pr`s`itktfni
no brftfqu`s wfmm dufml
filfr`bt `xp`rf`ib`s onr kmm
m`kri`rs
Bnmmkdnrktfv`my dufml k
bnmm`btfni no
fionrgktfni orng tj`
`xp`rf`ib` no ntj`rs
Ruggkrfz` /
T`vf`w
T`vf`w tj` prfit`l prnarkgLfsbuss p`rsnikm npfifnis wftj
bmkssgkt`s tjkt jkv` ktt`il`l tj`
skg` nr ntj`r v`rsfnis no \nsbk
Okb`'tn'okb` g``tfia nr
vfl`n bnio`r`ibfia wftj
Rhyp`5
jttp5..www)shyp`)bng.
Bnmmkdnrktfv`my dufml k
bnmm`btfni no
fionrgktfni orng tj`
`xp`rf`ib` no ntj`rs
\rkiso`r
T`bkmm tj` jfajmfajts kil h`ygng`its fi tj` p`ronrgkib` pmus
kiy ui`xp`bt`l nbburr`ib`s
Kdm` tn br`kt` p`rsnikm npfifnisdks`l ni tj` fl`itfofbktfni no
sp`bfofb `m`g`its fi tj`
p`ronrgkib`
Mfv` suggkry lfsbussfnis
Okb`'tn'okb` kil vfl`n
bnio`r`ibfia
`ivfrnig`its kr` r`km'
tfg`- jfajmy fit`rkbtfv`
kil bnilubfv` tn afvfia
kil r`b`fvfia o``ldkbh
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
67/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?1 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
T`gntfvkt`.
Bmns`
@xpmnr` kvkfmkdfmfty no ntj`rnp`rks tn ktt`il.wktbj
Br`kt` k pmki tn ktt`il.wktbjkintj`r np`rk
Mnbkm np`rk w`dsft`s onr
s`ksni bkm`ilkrs *onr
`xkgpm`&5jttp5..www)mknp`rk)bng.tfbh
`ts.plo.;4';2^bkm`ilkr)plo
jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)
nra.g`tnp`rk.s`ksni.bkm`ilk
r)kspx&
Mfv` JL Gnvf` drnklbkst
sbj`lum`s5
jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)
nra.g`tnp`rk.mfv`fijl.Mfv`f
iJL)kspx_f`wfia ni l`gkil5jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)
nra.nil`gkil.fil`x)kspx
Rkt`mmft` Tklfn5
jttp5..www)sfrfusxg)bng.g
`trnpnmftkinp`rk
Tklfn Drnklbksts5
jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)
nra.g`tnp`rk.drnklbkst.jl^`
v`its^t`gpmkt`)kspx>fl7;?6
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
68/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?: no ;4?
Bnit`it Rp`bfofbktfnis onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "v7N_'UoBQG2qn
KIL
@gd`ll`l vfl`n bmfp no tj`
np`ifia sb`i` no Bkrg`iEni`s wftj Lnrntjy
Lkfilrfla` kil Jkrry
D`mkonit`) *t`gpnrkry
Vnu\ud` vfl`n&5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7xN0ulABU2Vn
KIL
@gd`ll`l vfl`n bmfp no tj`
np`ifia sb`i` no Bkrg`i '
K Jfp Jnp`rk wftjD`ynib` kil G`hjf Sofo`r)
*t`gpnrkry Vnu\ud`
vfl`n&5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7Un'kUPeZ_:h
KIL
@gd`ll`l vfl`n bmfp no k
\ng / E`rry bkrtnni no ki
nrbj`strk p`ronrgfia tj`
nv`rtur` tn Bkrg`i5jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7\diRV[Z4Sgw
_fl`ns kr` nimy 0gfiut`s mnia tn kvnfl
bnaiftfv` nv`rmnkl
Lrkgktfb kil w`mmprnlub`l- sn `ksy tn
fl`itfoy p`rsnikmftf`s no
tj` bjkrkbt`rs
Rfgfmkr bjkrkbt`rs filfoo`r`it prnlubtfnis-
onr `ksy fl`itfofbktfni
no `m`g`its
D`kutfoum p`npm`-sup`rfnr kbtfia- kil
sfiafia onr fitrfau` /
lrkgk- sn ft sjnumlgntfvkt` tj` m`kri`r tn
wktbj
\j` bmkssfb G`t v`rsfnifs suia fi Or`ibj dut
jks sudtftm`s onr tjns`
int okgfmfkr wftj tj`
mkiauka` nr np`rk
\j` Bkrg`i Eni`sv`rsfni fs fi @iamfsj
kil jks bjkrkbt`rs tj`
m`kri`rs bki r`mkt` tn)
\j` s`ttfia fs kutj`itfbdut lkt`l) L_L fs
kvkfmkdm` onr purbjks`
onr noomfi` vf`wfia
\j` D`ynib` JfpJnp`rk v`rsfni fs v`ry
burr`it *D`ynib` fs
pnpumkr kot`r j`r r`b`it
pkrtfbfpktfni fi tj`
pr`sfl`itfkm
fikuaurktfni kil
Rup`rdnwm fi 43;2&
kil tj` gusfb fs no tj`jfp jnp a`ir`) L_L fs
kvkfmkdm` onr purbjks`
onr noomfi` vf`wfia
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
69/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` ?6 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Surpns` no
ktt`itfni a`tt`r
\n mur` tj` m`kri`r fitn tj`
fitrfau` no tj` stnry kil
gntfvkt` tj`fr burfnsfty tn ofil
nut wjng tj` bjkrkbt`rs kr` kil
jnw tj` stnry wfmm l`v`mnp)
R`` kdnv` R`` kdnv`
Fit`r`st.gntfvktf
ni
Sr`s`itfia Bkrg`is p`rsnikmfty
kil d`mf`os wfmm kll fitrfau` kil
j`fajt`i burfnsfty)
R`` kdnv` R`` kdnv`
Sr`vf`w
T`kl- suggkrfz` / r`bkmm tj`stnrymfi`
Fl`itfoy gnnls fi tj` gusfb /tj`g`s
K lnwimnklkdm` )plo kilk arkpjfb fgka` fi
MKTA@ STFI\ wftj tj`
stnrymfi` kil kbtukm wnrls
orng tj` mfdr`ttn *tn
onmmnw kmnia wftj tj`
vfl`n&
Mfih tnjttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stn
rf`s.syinpsfs)kspx>bustng
fl7466 onr tj` G`ts
np`rk syinpsfs
BL nr L_L mfi`r int`s
)plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l
kil fgka`s no
lnbug`its bki d`
gkl` mkra` onr m`kri`rs
tjkt gfajt jkv` vfsfni
mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmmd` k suppm`g`it tn kiy
kurkm fssu`s wftj tj`
vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmmsjnw bjkrkbt`rs /
r`mkt`l lfkmnau` fi
gumtfpm` mkiauka`s kil
nrakifz`l ks tj` gusfb
Ryinpsfs afv`s ka`i`rkm nv`rvf`w no tj`
stnry mfi` usukmmy
nimy r`kl nib`
Srfnr Hinwm`la`
In pr`vfnus hinwm`la` nonp`rk r`qufr`l
M`kri`rs jkv` dksfb bngput`rshfmms- bki typ` kil ikvfakt`
tj` fit`ri`t
Bnggkil no tj` @iamfsjmkiauka` *wrftfia- r`klfia-
sp`khfia- mfst`ifia /
uil`rstkilfia&
A`ttfia stkrt`l ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kri> Mfih tn
Dmkbhdnkrl syst`g j`mp)
J`mp ouibtfnis wfmm d`
kbb`ssfdm` orng kmm m`v`ms
no tj` bnurs`) Ft wfmm d`
fgpnrtkit tjkt tj`
lfoo`r`it HFILR no j`mp
bki d` lfoo`r`itfkt`l
dks`l ni tftm`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
70/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 13 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Fionrgktfni /
@xkgpm`s
T`kl- suggkrfz` / r`bkmm tj`stnrymfi`
Fl`itfoy gnnls fi tj` gusfb /tj`g`s
Bngpkr` bnstug`s tn gnl`rilr`ss fi Tng` fi tj` ;:33s
Mfihs tn nimfi` /lnwimnklkdm` v`rsfnis no
mfdr`ttn / syinpsfs
jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stn
rf`s.syinpsfs)kspx>bustng
fl7466
Mfihs tn r`snurb`s *f)`)jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfm
y)nra.g`tnp`rk.fil`x)ksp
x&
Ruaa`st`l r`klfia mfst not`xtdnnhs *mfst&5
Np`rk onr Luggf`s dyLkvfl Snau`
;33 Ar`kt Np`rks Kil\j`fr Rtnrf`s5 Kbt'Dy'Kbt Ryinps`s dy J`iry
Q) Rfgni
NS@TK5 Bngpns`rs)Qnrhs) S`ronrg`rs dy
Pmmgki
)plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l
kil fgka`s no
lnbug`its bki d`
gkl` mkra` onr m`kri`rs
tjkt gfajt jkv` vfsfni
mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmmd` k suppm`g`it tn kiy
kurkm fssu`s wftj tj`
vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmmsjnw bjkrkbt`rs kil
tj`fr r`mkt`l lfkmnau`
fi gumtfpm` mkiauka`s
kil nrakifz`l ks tj`gusfb fs
Ryinpsfs afv`s ka`i`rkm nv`rvf`w no
tj` stnry mfi` usukmmy
nimy r`kl nib`
Dnnhs- t`xtdnnhs kil`t`xtdnnhs bki d` us`l
ksyibjrninusmy- h`pt
onr r`o`r`ib` kil
kiintkt`l)
Ktt`itfni
Ktt`itfni wfmm d` akfi`l kil
gkfitkfi`l dy fibnrpnrktfia
vfsukm kil gusfbkm `xkgpm`s
tjkt r`mkt` tn tj` stnrymfi`)
)gp2 snuil dft`s tjkt kr`r`mkt`l tn tj` bjkrkbt`rs
tj`g`s
Fgka`s no bnstug`s kilkbtnrs
)gp2 skgpm`s no gnnls bjkrkbt`rs- `tjifb
dkbharnuils kil
nbbupktfnis
Au`st krtfst gusfbfki dyvfl`n bnio`r`ib` *mfv` kilr`bnrl`l onr mkt`r
r`o`r`ib`& Rt`v` Sfkzzk-
dkss bmkrfi`t Mns Kia`m`s
Np`rk
Ni` no tj` gnstprngfi`it `m`g`its nonp`rk fs tj` gusfb)
Rnuil dft`s orng
)gp2 ofm`s kr` gnst
kbb`ssfdm` kil kr` tj`
d`st wky tn r`kmfz` ki
kurkm `xp`rf`ib`
Bjuihfia tj` kulfnskgpm`s fitn sp`bfofb
dft`s kvnfls
bnaiftfv` kil kurkm
nv`rmnkl
Ki fit`rvf`w wftj kau`st krtfst wfmm kll
tj` r`kmfty kil
kutj`itfbfty tn
fit`rkbtfni onr
gntfvktfnikm `oo`bt)
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
71/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 1; no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
M`krifiaRtrkt`af`s
Dy usfia fiqufry'dks`l
bnmmkdnrktfv` hinwm`la`
bnistrubtfni- m`kri`rs wfmm
fl`itfoy kil bnitrfdut` wrftt`i
kil.nr vfsukm l`sbrfptfnis notj`fr ofilfias tn k Qfhf- dufmlfia
ki nimfi` lktkdks` no
bngpni`its kbb`ssfdm` tn tj`
`itfr` bmkss onr tj` lurktfni no
tj` bnurs`)
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris Qfhfpka`s
Dds wfhf pka`s kr`kmr`kly wftjfi tj`
`stkdmfsj`l m`krifia
`ivfrnig`it eustkintj`r bngpni`it
Kmm jkv` kbb`ssBnmmkdnrktfni fs
fgpmfbft
Ruggkrfz` /
T`vf`w
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
l`bnistrubt- lfsbuss kil fl`itfoy
tj` bngpni`its tjkt an fi tn
gkhfia tj` wjnm` krt onrg no
np`rk fi a`i`rkm)
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rsNianfia o``ldkbh
orng p``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfninppnrtuiftf`s
\rkiso`r
Afv`i tj` fl`itfofbktfni no kmm
tj` bngpni`its no ki np`rk-
m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
lfstfiaufsj tj` uifqu` qukmftf`s
no `kbj bngpni`it ks ft r`mkt`s
sp`bfofbkmmy tn tj` np`rk
Bkrg`i)
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rsNianfia o``ldkbh
orng p``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfni
nppnrtuiftf`s
T`gntfvkt`.
Bmns`
Afv`i tj` hinwm`la` no tj`
bngpni`its no ki np`rk-
m`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn bngpkr`
uifqu` kil sfgfmkr qukmftf`s
d`tw``i twn nr gnr` lfoo`r`it
prnlubtfnis no tj` skg` np`rk)
Kiy twn no tj` onmmnwfia
vfl`ns- nr wjkt`v`r
r`snurb`s tj` m`kri`rkmr`kly jks ni jkil *L_L-
drnklbkst- `tb)&- jks
kbb`ssfdfmfty tn *ki kbtukm
oumm p`ronrgkib`& nr bki
ofil5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7N_'UoBQG2qn
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7xN0ulABU2Vn
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.w
ktbj>v7Un'kUPeZ_:h
Onuil r`snurb`s bkid` sjkr`l
Lfoo`r`it vfl`ns novkrfnus prnlubtfnis
wfmm pr`s`it uifqu`
krtfstfb stym`s-
lfr`btfni- kbtfia-
sfiafia- bnstug`s-
s`ts- kil `v`i
mkiauka`s *ni` no tj`
vfl`ns fs fi Or`ibj-
twn kr` fi @iamfsj-
gusfb rkia`s orng
bmkssfb Dfz`t tn jfp'jnp&
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
72/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 14 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Kss`ss
S`ronrgkib`
Q``hmy arkl`s wfmm d` afv`ionr pkrtfbfpktfni kil qukmfty no
r`spnis`s fi lfsbussfni
onrugs)
[ufzz`s wfmm d` us`ltjrnuajnut tj` bnurs` tn
fl`itfoy bnrr`bt vs) fibnrr`bt
skgpm`s onr `kbj bngpni`it
tn kss`ss m`kri`r kbburkby kil
hinwm`la`)
Ki nv`rkmm arkl` wfmm d` afv`ionr tjfs nde`btfv` dks`l ni tj`
m`kri`rs hinwm`la` kilkdfmfty tn fl`itfoy kil lfsbuss
bngpni`its) \j` t`st wfmmnbbur kt tj` `il no tj` tnpfb)
Nimfi` qufz tjrnuajDmkbhdnkrl m`kri
Lfsbussfni onrugs\`st nimfi`
\j` qufzz`s kil t`stsni Dmkbhdnkrl M`kri
kr` kmr`kly wftjfi tj`
`stkdmfsj`l m`krifia
`ivfrnig`it eust
kintj`r bngpni`it
Kmr`kly fibnrpnrkt`lfitn tj` `xfstfia
arklfia syst`g
O``ldkbh.
T`g`lfktfni
O``ldkbh wfmm d` afv`i orng tj`
fistrubtnr kt tj` `il no `kbj
w``h no r`m`vkit fistrubtfni)
O``ldkbh orng tj`
fistrubtnr wfmm d` prnvfl`l
tjrnuaj tj` arklfia b`it`r
fi Dmkbhdnkrl- vfl`n bjkts
nr `gkfm- l`p`ilfia ni
wjkt tj` m`kri`r pr`o`rs kil
fs gnst bngonrtkdm` wftj)
S``r'tn'p``r o``ldkbh wfmm
d` prnvfl`l tjrnuajnut tj`
lfsbussfni onrugs)
Afvfia tj` m`kri`r
nptfnis ks tn tj` g`tjnl
no o``ldkbh klls tn tj`
nwi`rsjfp `xp`rf`ib` no
tj` m`kri`r kil puts tj`g
gnr` kt `ks`)
\kdm`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
73/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 12 no ;4?
Bnit`it Rp`bfofbktfnis onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "05
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ktt`itfni
Lrkgktfb vfl`n no Bkrg`is
krfk tjkt pkssfnikt`my
`mubflkt`s j`r d`mf`os kdnut mfo`
kil or``lng no spfrft)
@gd`ll`l vfl`n no tj` sb`i`
fi wjfbj Bkrg`i `xpmkfis tjkt
sj` fs mfh` k dfrl kil j`rkpprnkbj tn mnv` kil g`i ' fo k
gki wkits j`r- sj` ln`sit
wkit jfg- kil fo sj` wkits k
gki- j`mm d` snrry+
\j` G`t v`rsfni *t`gpnrkry
Vnu\ud` bmfp&5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.wktb
j>v7N_'UoBQG2qn
NT5
Bkrg`i Eni`s *t`gpnrkry
Vnu\ud` bmfp&5
jttp5..www)ynutud`)bng.wktb
j>v7xN0ulABU2Vn
KIL5
)gp2 ofm` no tj` krfk tjkt wfmm
d` `gd`ll`l ni tj` w`dsft`)
\jfs kurkm nimy v`rsfni wfmm d`
m`ss lfstrkbtfia kil gnr` pur`
fi onrg tn tj` vfl`n v`rsfni)
_fl`ns kr` onur gfiut`smnia tn kvnfl bnaiftfv`
nv`rmnkl
Rkg` prnlubtfnis ks tj`ni`s orng nde`btfv` "
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
74/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 1< no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Fit`r`st.
gntfvktfni
Lfsbnv`r tj` fit`rikmpkssfnis kil gntfvktfni no
`kbj no tj` bjkrkbt`rs- tj`fr
vkmu`s- d`mf`os kil rngkitfb
fl`kms)
M`kri tj` fit`rpmky d`tw``itj`s` vkmu`s kil r`mktfnisjfps
wjkt koo`bt tj`y jkv` ni `kbj
ntj`r
K lnwimnklkdm` )plo kil karkpjfb fgka` fi MKTA@
STFI\ wftj tj` stnrymfi` kilkbtukm wnrls orng tj` mfdr`ttn
*tn onmmnw kmnia wftj tj`
vfl`n kil gusfb&
)plo kil mfih tn5jttp5..www)g`tnp`rkokgfmy)n
ra.g`tnp`rk.jfstnry.stnrf`s.s
yinpsfs)kspx>bustngfl7466
onr tj` G`ts np`rk syinpsfs
Ryinpsfs bki kmsn d`ndtkfi`l orng kiy ntj`r
snurb` kvkfmkdm` tn tj`
m`kri`rMfi`r int`s orng BL nr L_L
plo lnbug`its bki d`prfit`l- jfajmfajt`l kil
fgka`s no lnbug`its bki
d` gkl` mkra` onrm`kri`rs tjkt gfajt jkv`
vfsfni mnss
\j` prfit`l wnrl wfmm d`k suppm`g`it tn kiy kurkm
fssu`s wftj tj` vfl`n
Srfit`l mfdr`ttn wfmm sjnwbjkrkbt`rs kil tj`fr
r`mkt`l lfkmnau` fi
gumtfpm` mkiauka`s kil
nrakifz`l ks tj` gusfb fs
Ryinpsfs afv`s k a`i`rkmnv`rvf`w no tj` stnry mfi`
usukmmy nimy r`kl nib`
Sr`vf`w
Lfsbuss tj` bjkrkbt`rs fi tj`np`rk kil pr`lfbt tj`fr okt`
kt tj` `il no tj` stnry
T`bkmm kil suggkrfz` `v`itskil p`npm` fi burr`it tfg`s
tjkt s``g tn jkv` tj` skg`
d`mf`o syst`gs nr stnrf`s)
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n `xp`rf`ib` gkiylfoo`r`it p`rsp`btfv`s /
fl`ks
Nianfia o``ldkbh orngp``rs
Aufl`l fistrubtfni kilfiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninus fit`rkbtfninppnrtuiftf`s
Srfnr
Hinwm`la`
Srfnr hinwm`la` no tj`stnrymfi` kil mfdr`ttn no
Bkrg`i
Kdm` tn fl`itfoy tj`bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` stnry
Hinwm`la` no burr`it kookfrs
T`o`r`ib` dkbh tn pr`vfnuslfsbussfnis kil bnurs`
bnit`it tjrnuaj MGR
Burr`it kookfrs tn d` ndtkfi`ltjrnuaj wjkt`v`r g`lfk kr`
gnst bngonrtkdm` kil
kbb`ssfdm` tn tj` m`kri`r)\rklftfnikm i`wspkp`r-
lfaftkm i`ws- Fit`ri`t- rklfn-
t`m`vfsfni nr bniv`rsktfni)
Nwi`rsjfp no pr`vfnus
hinwm`la` kil
bnmmkdnrktfv` bnistrubtfni
dks`l ni fionrgktfni
lktkdks` dufmt dy bmkss
orng pr`vfnus w``h*s& no
lfsbussfnis kil Qfhf
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
75/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 10 no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Fionrgktfni
/ @xkgpm`s
Lfsbuss tj` vkmu`s kild`mf`os no tj` bjkrkbt`rs fi
tj` np`rk
T`bnaifz` kil lfsbuss tj`fit`rpmky d`tw``i bjkrkbt`rs
dks`l ni tj`fr d`mf`os kil
snbfn'`bningfb stktus
Bngpkr` sfgfmkrftf`s killfoo`r`ib`s wftj p`npm` fi
tnlkys i`ws fi tj` P)R) wftj
bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
Fit`rkbtfvfty wftj kilm`krifia orng p``rs
Kiy pmkb`- kiy tfg`ksyibjrninus m`krifia
Aufl`l lfsbussfniqu`stfnis
O``ldkbh orng fistrubtnrO``ldkbh- qu`stfnis kil
ourtj`r lfsbussfni tnpfbs
orng p``rs
Ktt`itfni
Sr`lfbt tj` okt` no `kbj no tj`bjkrkbt`rs fo tj` rngkitfbbjnfb`s w`r` tn bjkia`
Kppmyfia tj`fr vkrf`l mfo``xp`rf`ib` fi gktt`rs no mnv`
kil d`mf`os wfmm kmmnw
m`kri`rs tn bngpkr` tj`fr nwi
vkmu`s tn tj` sb`ikrfns no
bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk
Aufl`l lfsbussfni wftj afv`iqu`stfnis fi tj` MGR
lfsbussfni onrug
Lfsbussfni onrugs wnumlprnvfl` ksyibjrninus
fit`rkbtfvfty wftj orng
p``rs
Nppnrtuifty tn m`kriorng kil d` fispfr`l dy
p``rs
O``ldkbh fi lfsbussfni
M`krifia
Rtrkt`af`s
Dy usfia fiqufry'dks`lm`krifia tn br`kt`
lfsbussfnis- tj` m`kri`rs wfmm
lfsbuss jnw tj`y gfajt
p`rsnikmmy l`km wftj sfgfmkrsftuktfnis ks tj` bjkrkbt`rs
*rnm`'pmky&
Psfia tj` Bnistrubtfv` kilBFS m`krifia tj`nrf`s- tj`
fistrubtnr wfmm dufml sb`ikrfns
onr m`kri`rs tn syitj`sfz`
tj`fr hinwm`la` no bjkrkbt`r
gntfvktfni wftj p`rsnikmftf`s
fi tnlkys burr`it `v`its
Rp`bfofb lfsbussfni qu`stfnisonr t`kgs lfvfl`l dy
bjkrkbt`rs fi tj` np`rk tn
jkv` ki nimfi` l`dkt` fi tj`MGR lfsbussfni onrug
r`akrlfia tj`fr p`rsnikm
eulag`its kil npfifnis
Lfsbussfni onrug fiDmkbhdnkrl MGR tn kppmy
bjkrkbt`r gntfvktfni wftj
tnlkys pudmfb p`rsnikmftf`s
Bnmmkdnrktfni d`tw``ip``rs tn br`kt` k dnly no
`xp`rf`ib`s *lktkdks`&
dks`l ni p`rsnikm
npfifni kil mfo`'`xp`rf`ib`
Lfsbussfni onrug wfmmkmmnw m`kri`rs tn prnvfl`
r`km'wnrml `xkgpm`s tn
`kbj ntj`r- wjfbj wfmm
br`kt` bnii`btfnis wftj
bjkrkbt`rs kil stnry mfi`s
fi tj` np`rk
Ruggkrfz` /
T`vf`w
Lfoo`r`itfkt` tj` gntfvktfnisno `kbj no tj` bjkrkbt`rs fi
lfsbussfni
Kppmy hinwm`la` nobjkrkbt`r gntfvktfni tn
bngpkr` wftj `xkgpm`s fi
tnlkys burr`it `v`its kil
pudmfb ofaur`s
Lfsbussfni onrug ni
Dmkbhdnkrl M`kris MGR
\n m`kri orng p``rs Nianfia o``ldkbh orng
p``rs Aufl`l fistrubtfni kil
fiqufry orng okbfmftktnr
Ksyibjrninusfit`rkbtfni nppnrtuiftf`s
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
76/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 1? no ;4?
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
\rkiso`r
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn
subb`ssoummy bngpkr` kil
bnitrkst `xkgpm`s no p`npm` fitnlkys snbf`ty wftj bjkrkbt`rs
fi tj` np`rk)
Lfsbussfni onrug fi
Dmkbhdnkrl MGR
Lfsbussfni onrug wfmmkmmnw m`kri`rs tn prnvfl`
r`km'wnrml `xkgpm`s tn
`kbj ntj`r- wjfbj wfmmbr`kt` bnii`btfnis wftj
bjkrkbt`rs kil stnry'mfi`s
fi tj` np`rk
T`gntfvkt`.
Bmns`
M`kri`rs wfmm d` kdm` tn br`kt`
k ofbtfnikm i`w `ilfia onr tj`
np`rk kil sjkr` ft wftj tj`fr
p``rs fi k lfsbussfni)
Fi tj` MGR lfsbussfni tjr`kl-
tj` m`kri`rs wnuml tjr`kl
tna`tj`r k i`w stnry ' dy
kmpjkd`tfbkmmy *onr `xkgpm`&
wrftfia kdnut ki `v`it- tj`i
sng`ni` tkhfia nv`r onr tj`
i`xt p`rsni tn tf` tna`tj`r tj`
i`xt `v`it)
Bnmmkdnrktfv`- fitrfau`-
surprfs`- l`p`il`iby ni
`kbj ntj`r- gntfvktfni-
p``r pr`ssur`)
Kss`ss
S`ronrgkib`
M`kri`rs wfmm bnilubt k s`mo
kss`ssg`it kt tj` `il no tj`
gnlum` dks`l ni tj`fr kdfmfty
tn fl`itfoy- kikmyz`- bngpkr`
kil syitj`sfz` tj`fr hinwm`la`
no tj` snbfkm- `bningfb-
pnmftfbkm kil rngkitfb `m`g`its
no Bkrg`i)
T`om`btfv` `ssky sudgftt`l tn
tj` kssfaig`its kr`k no tj`
MGR tn r`bkmm wjkt jks d``i
m`kri`l kil l`sbrfdfia tj`
jfajmfajts kil surprfs`s fi tj`
m`krifia `xp`rf`ib`
\fg` tn tjfih kdnut kil
r`om`bt noomfi` wjfm` wrftfia
k r`om`btfv` `ssky
\fg` kil intfb` wfmm d`
afv`i tn m`kri`r tn `isur`
r`spnisfdfmfty onr kbburkby
kil nwi`rsjfp no
fionrgktfni
O``ldkbh.T`g`lfktfni
O``ldkbh wfmm d` afv`i orng
tj` fistrubtnr kt tj` `il no`kbj w``h no r`m`vkit
fistrubtfni)
O``ldkbh orng tj` fistrubtnr
wfmm d` prnvfl`l tjrnuaj tj`
arklfia b`it`r fi Dmkbhdnkrl-
vfl`n bjkts nr `gkfm-l`p`ilfia ni wjkt tj` m`kri`r
pr`o`rs kil fs gnst
bngonrtkdm` wftj)
Afvfia tj` m`kri`r nptfnis
ks tn tj` g`tjnl no
o``ldkbh klls tn tj`nwi`rsjfp `xp`rf`ib` no
tj` m`kri`r kil puts tj`g
gnr` kt `ks`)
\kdm`
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
77/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633- Lr) _fbtnrfk Qkmh`r Skp`r Srntntyp` ' Np`rk fs int k Onur'M`tt`r Qnrl
Ska` 11 no ;4?
Bnit`it Rp`bfofbktfnis onr M`krifia Nde`btfv` "?5
Fistrubtfnikm
@v`its
Sr`sbrfptfni.Fistrubtfnikm
Rtrkt`ayOfikm G`lfk Bjnfb`
Tktfnikm` onr G`lfk
Bjnfb`
Ktt`itfniKi`blnt`s orng mfv` p`ronrgkib`s
no Bkrg`i tjrnuajnut tj` y`krs)
Mfihs tn r`klfias ni tj`
fit`ri`t5
jttp5..np`rkspnnok)wnrlpr`ss
)bng.bkt`anry.ki`blnt`s.
jttp5..www)ouitrfvfk)bng.`i
.Gusfb.Bkrg`i'
7/29/2019 Paper Prototype Opera ROKAW
78/126
Or`llf Tnhkw- Surlu` Pifv`rsfty O`drukry ;3- 43;2
@LBF 0?633-
Top Related