EPE Bidders ConferenceJune 11, 2010
Ocean Observatories Initiative
OOI Organization, Management, and Control
Susan Banahan
EPE Bidders Conference 2
Consortium for Ocean Leadership & OOI
Member InstitutionsMember Institutions
Board of TrusteesBoard of Trustees
President and CEO
President and CEO
OOI Project Office
OOI Project Office
OOI Program Advisory Committee
OOI Program Advisory Committee
Implementing Organization
Implementing OrganizationNSF/OCENSF/OCE
EPE Bidders Conference 3
Project ManagementNSF
Program Director Jean McGovern
EPE Bidders Conference 4
Project Controls for a Large Facility Project*• Defined Requirements and Scope• Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)• Budget by WBS element• Integrated Schedule • Technical & Financial Status Reporting • Systems Engineering Management• Configuration (Change) Control• Quality Control and Assurance• Systems Integration, Testing, Acceptance, Commissioning• Transition to Operations and Cost Estimates* Support by the Major Research Equipment and Facility Construction (MREFC) Account
EPE Bidders Conference 5
*Requirements flow to design and are traceable among levels.
• L1 Science Themes– L1-ST-6
Climate Variability, Ocean Circulation, & Ecosystems
• L2 Science Question linked L1 Science Theme– L2-SQ-RQ-640
What are the dominant physical and biological processes that control the exchange of carbon and other dissolved and particulate material across the air-sea interface, through the water column, and to the seafloor?
Scope as High Level Requirements
EPE Bidders Conference 6
• L2 Science Requirements – Specific requirements detailing the types of measurements, their
locations, their accuracies, etc. necessary to answer the science questions.
• L2-SR-RQ-3032 - The OOI shall calculate the flux of carbon dioxide based on the measurements taken of the partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2 ) in air and in surface water...
• L3 System Requirements– Detailed for the infrastructure by system.
• L3-CG-RQ-573 - Pioneer Array surface moorings shall measure the partial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO2 ) of surface water
• L4 Subsystem Requirements– Detailed for sub-systems and instruments.
• L4-CG-IP-RQ-198 - pCO2 instruments shall have an accuracy of +/- 2 µatm in air and in water.
Detailed Requirements
EPE Bidders Conference 7
• Interface types: – Physical or logical– programmatic (cost and schedule)
• Statements of roles, responsibilities, and authorities
• Interface Requirements:– CI to CG, to RSN– CGSN to RSN– EPE to CI, to RSN, to CGSN
Interface Requirements
EPE Bidders Conference 8
L3 EPE System
Requirements
TBD
EPE to CI
EPE Bidders Conference 9
• Level 1 Science Themes 51• Level 2 Science + other 1,138• Level 3 System 1,003
– CI 183, CG 536, RSN 284, EPE TBD– Interface Requirements
• Level 4 Subsystem 2,756– CI 846, CG 911, RSN 999, EPE TBD
Total 4,948 +
Number of Requirements
EPE Bidders Conference 10
DOORS (Dynamic Object Oriented Requirements System)
EPE Bidders Conference 11
Summary WBS Level 3
OOI ProgramIntegrated Master Schedule
WBS 1
Cyberinfrastructure (CI)
WBS 1.2
Coastal / Global Scale Nodes (CG)
WBS 1.3
System Integration /Program Management Office
WBS 1.1
Regional Scale Nodes (RSN)
WBS 1.4
Education andPublic Engagement (EPE)
WBS 1.7
Program Management
WBS 1.1.1
System Engineering
WBS 1.1.2
Operations andMaintenance Planning
WBS 1.1.3
Communications andPublic Outreach
WBS 1.1.4
Environmental Management
WBS 1.1.5
Project Management
WBS 1.2.1
System Engineering
WBS 1.2.2
System Development
WBS 1.2.3
Deprecated
Implementation
WBS 1.2.5
Project Management
WBS 1.3.1
System Engineering
WBS 1.3.2
Subsystem Development
WBS 1.3.3
Implementation
WBS 1.3.4
Project Management
WBS 1.4.1
System Engineering
WBS 1.4.2
Subsystem Development
WBS 1.4.3
Site Implementation
WBS 1.4.4
Project Management
WBS 1.7.1
System Engineering
WBS 1.7.2
Subsystem Development
WBS 1.7.3
Implementation
WBS 1.7.4
Notes: WBS Elements 1.5 and 1.6 were active during the planning phases and have been deprecated. WBS Element 1.2.4 CI Hardware was absorbed into implementation and deprecated.
Science Community Workshop 1 6
WBS as an Integrator
EPE Bidders Conference 13
Policies, Process, Plans and Tools• Project Execution Plan• Systems Engineering Management Plan• Configuration Management Plan• Risk Management Plan• Earned Value Management Plan• Schedule Management Plan• Cost Book Database, Cost Estimating Plan• Property Management Plan• Collaborative Tools
EPE Bidders Conference 14
Policies, Process, Plans and Tools• Collaborative Tools
– Confluence, WebEx– Alfresco– JIRA– SAF (CCB, Risk, Sensor DB, Data Sets)
EPE Bidders Conference 15
Program Controlled Documents1000‐00000_CMP_OOI 1100‐00000_SEMP_OOI L4‐CG Autonomous Underwater Vehicle
1000‐00001_B2_Table 1101‐00000_FND_OOI L4‐CG Data Concentrator
1001‐00000_PEP_OOI 1120‐00000_Requirements_Module_Hierarchy L4‐CG Glider
1001‐00100_Annual_Work_Plan 1199‐00000_Document_Tree_OOI L4‐CG Instrument Package
1002‐00000_CEP_OOI L4‐CG Moorings
1003‐00000_QA_QC_Plan_OOI L1 Programmatic Requirements L4‐CG Multi‐Function Nodes
1004‐00000_Commissioning_Plan_OOI L1 Science Themes L4‐CG Operations and Management Center
1005‐00000_EVM_Plan_OOI L2 Common Requirements L4‐CG Platform Control
1006‐00000_EHSP_OOI L2 Cyber‐User Requirements L4‐CG Power Systems
1007‐00000_Risk_Management_Plan_OOI L2 Educational Requirements L4‐CG Profiler
1008‐00000_Acquisition_Plan_OOI L2 Operational Requirements L4‐CG Surface Buoys
1010‐00000_OM_Plan_OOI.doc L2 Reference Module L4‐CG Telemetry Systems
1011‐00000_Property_Management_Plan_OOI L2 Science Questions L4‐CI Analysis and Synthesis
1012‐00000_Security_Management_Plan_OOI L2 Science Requirements L4‐CI Common Execution Infrastructure
1020‐00000_Schedule_Management_Plan_OOI L3 CG System Requirements L4‐CI Common Operating Infrastructure
Integrated Risk Register_(all1022‐xxxxx) L3 CI System Requirements L4‐CI Data Management
IMS (all IOs‐
OOI, CI, RSN, CGSN) L3 RSN System Requirements L4‐CI Implementation
WBS_Dictionary_(all1041‐xxxxx) L4‐CI Planning and Prosecution
Cost_Book_(all1050‐xxxxx) L4‐CI Sensing and Acquisition
L4‐RSN Backhaul
L4‐RSN Primary Infrastructure L4‐RSN LV Node L4‐RSN Extension Cable
L4‐RSN Profilers L4‐RSN Observatory Mgmt System L4‐RSN Instrument Package
L4‐RSN Shore Station L4‐RSN Vertical Mooring L4‐RSN Jbox
EPE Bidders Conference 16
Testing Activities throughout System Development Life Cycle
Design Integration Deployment OperationsDevelopment
Developmental Testing - IO
Acc
epta
nce
By
OL
Integration Testing - IO
Requirements Verification - IO
Environmental Testing - IO
Unit Testing / First Article Testing - IO
Acceptance Testing - OL
Construction O&M
Regression Testing - IOCommissioning Evaluation - OL
Com
mis
sion
ing
Stability Testing - IO
EPE Bidders Conference 17
Configuration Management• Standards and Conventions
– Naming, Numbering, Drawing• Responsibilities and Authority• Controlled vs. Non-controlled• Details on Technical Documents• Document Management, Types, Stages• Collaboration Applications• Configuration Control Structure, Processes and
Applications• Change Control Boards (CCB)
EPE Bidders Conference 18
• Process to manage project baselines, requirements, guiding principles (hierarchical decision tree)
• Controlled process to estimate impact of proposed or needed changes– science, system integration, quality, schedule,
and budget• Formal communication that informs the entire
project team, ensures consideration of all known variables and authorizes changes to a baseline
CCB Benefits
EPE Bidders Conference 19
Change Board Levels• IO Level• System Level – Interfaces with other
subsystems/systems or IOs• OOI Level – Science Scope, Baseline Budget /
Schedule• NSF Program Manager Review – CA and CSA
Thresholds
• Each with specified core membership, authority and reporting structure
EPE Bidders Conference 20
Schedule Graphic
EPE Bidders Conference 21
CI Subsystems & Releases
Top Related