ApAche junction (480) 984-2700
cAsA GrAnde (520) 876-5470
Globe (928) 425-6200PO Box 12141 • Casa Grande, AZ 85130
Nutritional Comparison of Drink Supplements vs. Food
The chart below was devised to compare three nutritional drink supplements as well as showcase a convenient “real food” counterpart—low-fat yogurt and an orange.
Soups
Boost® Ensure®
Carnation® Instant Breakfast
Essentials™ Ready-to-Drink
Low-fat Yogurt +
Orange
Serving Size 8 ounces 8 ounces 11 ounces8 ounce yogurt + medium orange
Calories 240 220 250 206
Carbohydrate 33g 41g 34g 31g
Protein 15g 9g 14g 12g
Fat 6g 6g 5g 3.5g
Calcium 300g 300g 500g 467g
Fiber 0g 3g 0g 3g
Vitamin C 60mg 30mg 30mg 71mg
1st two Ingredientswater, corn syrup
solidswater, corn syrup non-fat milk, water
low-fat milk, milk solids (from the yogurt)
Cost $2.05* $1.16* $1.12* $1.00*
TASTE Best = 1 to Worst = 5
3 4 2 1
*Prices based on an Illinois grocery store in 2009. Prices in your area may differ. All samples tested were vanilla flavored.
The products are not hugely different in their calorie, carbohydrate or fat content. Of the supplements, Carnation® Instant Breakfast Essentials™ has the lowest fat and the most calcium.
All of the products but Ensure® are sorely deficient in fiber. Carnation® Instant Breakfast Essentials™ is the cheapest supplement per serving and according to the chart, the best tasting.
At Home Solutions • Apache junction (480) 984-2700 • Casa Grande (520) 876-5470 • Globe (928) 425-6200 Page 2
Nutritional Comparison of Drink Supplements vs. Food
The gold medal though, definitely goes to the low-fat yogurt and orange for more nutrient-dense ingredients, fiber, vitamin C and photochemicals, as well as low-fat and high-calcium content, cheapest price and best taste.
Healthy guidelines for supplement users
For those who struggle to meet caloric intake, supplements can be helpful. Below are guidelines to be certain the body is receiving the nutrients it needs:
• At least 5 fruit and vegetable servings daily.
• 6–11 servings of grain products daily, preferably from whole-grain and high fiber sources.
• 2–3 low-fat or non-fat servings of dairy products daily.
• 2–3 low-fat protein servings daily.
Those who are drinking lots of supplement drinks, but not following the above guidelines, are not being provided with optimal nutrition.
Source: The Diet Channel
Top Related