Participatory Problem Diagnosis in Nepal: What Matters Most—Poverty
or Climate Change? D. Layne Coppock1, Nirmala Pandey2
and Dale Davis2 1Dept. Envir. & Society, USU, Logan, UT USA
2Helen Keller Intl., Chakupat, Lalitpur, Nepal
2
Road Map
• Introduction to the issues
• Research objectives
• Study area and research methods
• Research results
• Discussion
• Development Interventions
• Conclusions
3
Introduction
• Extensive poverty in far western Nepal
• Evidence of climate change
• Challenges of adaptation by the rural poor
4
Research Objectives
• Identify local pathways to improve human welfare, mitigate poverty, and promote climate change adaptation
• Combine bottom-up with top-down perspectives to identify priority problems and solutions
• Clarify extent that poverty or climate change drives priority problems
5
Study Area: Bajura District
Intervention VDCs
u Budhiganga
Atichaur
Jugada
Dahakot
Manakot Pandusain
Baddhu
Control VDCs
6
Study Area: Sampled VDCs • Human population from 4,042 to
6,751
• Vulnerability to climate change = high
• Natural resource base = moderate
• Food insecurity = moderate
• Physical isolation = high
7
Research Methods: PRA
A bottom-up, community-driven approach that requires “delivery” on solutions to build trust
• Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) used to:
– Better understand the farming systems
– Rank community problems
– Identify problems and solutions
8
Research Methods: PRA Toolkit
• Problem-ranking matrix
• Historical timelines
• Labor calendars
• Institutional analyses
• Others
9
Research Methods: Special Modifications to PRA
Community members grouped in different ways to spur participation…
Mixed Gender Men Only
Women Only Dalits Only
10
Results: Cultivation Subsystem
--Crops grown on rain-
fed terraces include
cereal grains,
potatoes..
--Crops grown in sub-
irrigated valleys also
include cereal grains
11
Results: Animal Subsystems
Goats raised for meat and grazed on common land as well as cut and carry
A few bovines used for ploughing fields or milk production, and fed via grazing, cut-and-carry
12
Results: Household Subsystem
Typical household has husband and wife and 5 to 6 dependents Typical income levels vary: 5,000 to 36,000 Rs per year Most labor devoted to farming; off-site migration is common (18% migrate)
13
Results: PRA Priority Problems Rank Top 7 Problems and Opportunities
Jugada Pandusen Dahakot Budhiganga
1 Shortage of drinking water
Shortage of drinking
water
Shortage of drinking
water
Lack of irrigation facility
2 Health and Sanitation Lack of green
vegetables
Declining agricultural
production
Unemployment/ lack of
income sources
3 Declining agricultural
production
Unemployment/ lack of
income sources
Traditional animal
husbandry
Declining agricultural
production
4 Unemployment/ lack of income
sources
Declining agricultural
production
Unemployment/ lack of
income sources
Shortage of drinking
water
5 Education Landslides Education Traditional animal
husbandry
6 Traditional animal husbandry
Declining Apple
production
Health and sanitation Poor condition of trails
7 Lack of skills and capacity Traditional animal
husbandry
Lack of electricity /MHP Lack of trail bridge
14
Results Detail #1: Shortage of Drinking Water
Decrepit infrastructure had not been maintained nor kept pace with population growth
Negligible water storage tanks
Women haul water long distances for home use and livestock consumption
15
Results Detail #2: Declining Crop Yields on the Terraces
Perceived declines in grain yields due to erratic, low precipitation Irrigation development infeasible Crop systems founded on traditional seeds and practices
16
Results Detail #3: Need for Off-Farm Employment
Outmigration common but undesirable
Prefer local employment
Skill development options nominated by communities included apiculture, processing of plant and animal products, masonry, carpentry, horticulture…
17
Results Detail #4: Need to Generate More On-Farm Income- Commercialize Animal Production
• Main option is to increase numbers of meat goats
• Constraints include labor, feeds, market information, inadequate housing
18
Discussion: What Matters Most in Shaping Problems—Poverty or Climate Change?
Problem Poverty? Climate Change?
Shortage of Drinking Water
YES ---
Declines in Crop Yields
--- YES
Need for Off-Farm Employment
YES ---
Need to Commercialize Goat Production
YES ---
19
Discussion: Lack of Innovation
Warming and drying of the climate requires innovation in the types of crops grown and how terraces are managed Out of 320 households surveyed in a parallel study, only a few exhibit any innovative tendencies Why? Most likely due to physical isolation of VDCs from outside world
20
Discussion: Constraints for Problem Solutions
Problem Constraints
Shortage of Drinking Water High cost of infrastructure
Declines in Crop Yields Lack of management innovation; inability to irrigate
Need for Off-Farm Employment
Lack of local opportunities, including skill development
Need to Commercialize Goat Production
Can an expanded market be sustained?
21
Development Interventions: Rainwater Catchment Systems
• Roof rain water harvest solves the problem for animal and human consumption
• Farmers were happy to construct and provided a 15% cost share as well as unskilled labor and local materials
• The intervention can last more than 30 years
22
Development Interventions: Terrace Cropping Management
Need for drought-tolerant crop
varieties
Need for new methods for tillage and soil fertility and conservation management to better conserve soil moisture
23
Development Interventions: Off-Farm Employment
• Training in production of stinging nettle powder
• Training in nursery production of forage, vegetables, and tree saplings
24
Development Interventions: Livestock Commercialization
• Improved animal housing to promote health and productivity
• Training on goat marketing
• Organizing goat marketing groups
25
Development Interventions: Social Outcomes of Participation
Community mobilization following PRA sessions
Enhanced savings and credit activity
Climate change education spurs action
26
Conclusions
• High value of the PRA approach, both for research and community empowerment
• Lessons learned: Contrast of bottom-up versus project-driven philosophy
• Both poverty and climate change shape priority problems, but poverty is dominant
27
Acknowledgements
• HKI PRA team (M. Shrestha, A. Basnet, D. Duwal, and others)
• Community members of the four VDCs
• Local government authorities
• Work made possible from support of USAID BEAT, grant no. EEM-A-00-10-00001
Top Related