Download - Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Transcript
Page 1: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

The necessity of

investigating garbage

The menacing anachronism of

contemporary journalism studies

a Dutch perspective

Page 2: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Starting point: the NRC Handelsblad

debate

Changes in the Dutch quality newspaper

Reproach of tabloidization

The classical daily with its enlightenment program of Lux and Libertas, dedicates too much space to personal stories, emotion,

lunch-interviews, gossip and other forms of tabloid journalism

Also: loss for society

Page 3: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Tabloidization as an important aspect

of nowadays journalism. But……

Page 4: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

My paper: an odd man out

Paradigm study

Literature study

Research questions

Page 5: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Literature study

Just one theme has been exhaustively investigated:

The question of tabloidization itself.

But the results are completely contradictory

Page 6: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

‘We lack concepts, we need clear

terms’

‘It is hard to think of other concepts that are so important and popular and at the same time so

poorly defined and theorized as soft news.’

Page 7: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Lack of interest is the more strange

because…

things are changing (the buzzword of

the moment), very quickly,

a change nobody can stop

(and as far as can been seen with tabloidization as a dominant tendency)

Page 8: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Source: Colin Sparks & John Tulloch: Tabloid Tales (2000)

Page 9: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Long, international tradition of

journalism studies

Walter Lippmann

Journalists are public intellectuals who

‘provide not only the facts but also the formats, norms and rhetorics that citizens employ to develop their opinions’ (about public life, politics, economics &

sports).

Page 10: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Some important changes

Blurring of differences (as shown)

Invasion of non-professionals in the field (end of monopoly)

Growing consciousness of narrow-mindedness of journalism studies (influence of cultural & historical

studies)

Market pressure (competition, user oriented)

Weltbild of public & students

Page 11: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013
Page 12: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Research 1

Research 2

Page 13: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Subjects of future study

What are we talking about? The nature of the blurring & the truth of the lack of study of popular journalism

The history of a contempt

The effects of popular journalism in past & present

Definitions, terms, language, lay out, image use, literature

The nature of today’s change (update Sparks)

Popular journalism & modern citizenship (I-epistomology, Ratgeberjournalismus, first person media)

Ethics of journalism in a consumer society

Page 14: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

The necessity of

investigating garbage

[email protected]

University of Applied Sciences, Utrecht School of Journalism

Page 15: Necessity of investigating garbage - The future of Journalism Cardiff 2013

Subjects of future study

What are we talking about? The nature of the blurring & the truth of the lack of study of popular journalism

The history of a contempt

The effects of popular journalism in past & present

Definitions, terms, language, lay out, image use, literature

The nature of today’s change (update Sparks)

Popular journalism & modern citizenship (I-epistomology, Ratgeberjournalismus, first person media)

Ethics of journalism in a consumer society