Download - Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

Transcript
Page 1: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link

state information

Miklos Molnar, Janos Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron, Csaba Vegso

To cite this version:

Miklos Molnar, Janos Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron, Csaba Vegso. Multicast routing withQoS based on incomplete link state information. [Research Report] RR-5428, INRIA. 2004,pp.21. <inria-00070579>

HAL Id: inria-00070579

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070579

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--54

28--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Multicast routing with QoS based on incompletelink state information

Csaba Végsö, Miklós Molnár, János Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron

N˚5428

Décembre 2004

Systèmes communicants

Page 3: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice
Page 4: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������! #"$�� �%'&(���)�������*,+$�%���%-����. /���0��%1����23�4�5*��0�������

687:9<;59>=�?A@B7DC/EAFHGJILKNMLOB7PGJQBMLR5SUTWVWFHXBSURYQB7PZ'[]\U[ARY^�Q_\N7D`AK/a�bAFdce9<fWTWILgA[hZ'[A@BiY[]7W^YTDQBRdjkmlonqpsr�t!uDn'v�wxt!t�y_z|{}vD~�zApsn

�d� w��qup��������e���~��_�Uw � p��ou � uDv��_u � v��_u�z��]�3�m���������Dv�u�t�� � u��x�x�������o�0�|~x�xuWn

�P���D�� 3¡_¢x�x£¥¤ �_{¦nH�|~x�<u � {¦nHv�wxz|v�u � z_uD�8§'{¨p©�P�ouDªxuD«¨w]�_{¨z|�4z_w3ªxuD«<~�«}�xw � {¨p©�|t!n5¬­w � t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p � wxyops{¨z|�{}z¯�|~]v�°xup�n©§'{¨psv��_uW�¯vwxt!t�y_z_{¦v�~3ps{¨w]z¯z_upq§�w � °on0§'�_u�z±ps�_u � u�{¦n�z_w�~:ª:~x{¨«¦~��|«¨u²u�³o~]v´p�{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]z~x�<w]yop5p©�|u'«¨{}z_°�n®ps~�p©uWnY{¨z8p©�|u'z_upq§�w � °BµN¶·z8p©�_uWn®u�vD~xn©uDnY� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¦n®p©{¦v¸t!wo�ouD«}n5vD~�z!�<u'y<n®uW�8~xz|��p©�_u�]w]~x«Awx¬|ps�_u � w]yop©u'n©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz8� � wov�uD�oy � u�{}nYpswe¹|z|�!~�z!~x�ot!{¦n©n©{}�_«¨u � wxyopsuº§'{»ps�8t²~�³m{}t²~�«o� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pqlxµ¤ �|u¼t�y|«»ps{}vD~xn®p�� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¦n®p©{¦v � w]yop©{}z_��t8wo�ouD«B§'{»ps���|~�z<�o§'{}�op©��~xz|�Pv�w]n®p � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApH{}z�p©�|uevD~xn©uwx¬�{¨z<vwxt!�_«}upsu¼{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]z�{}n � uD�oy|v�uD�8psw�~��_up©u � t!{}z_{¦nqps{}vekAp©uD{¨z_u � p � u�u�� � wx�|«¨uDt�µ ¤ �_u�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp� wxy_p©{}z_��v�wxz|v�u � z_{}z_��ps�_u!u�z|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|�h�_u�«¦~:l � uW½]y|{ � u�t!u�zAp0v�~�z��<u8p � ~xz|nq¬­w � t!uW�À{}zÁn©wxt!u!v�~xn©uDn¼p©w¹<z|�o{}z_�Ân®�_w � psuDn®p4�|~3ps�|n4�Uupq§�u�u�z�p©�|u²t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp4z_wo�ouWn4�|~xn©uD��wxzÁuD½Ay_{}ª3~�«}u�zAp��oupsu � t!{¨z_{¦n®p©{¦v!«¨{}z_°t!uW~xn©y � uWn�µÃÂÄAÅBÆsÇ�È  3É��x£ËÊ upq§�w � °BÌot�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp � wxyops{¨z_�<Ì<Í�y|~�«}{¨pql�w�¬5kmu � ªm{}v�uxÌ|kApsu�{}z_u � � � w]�_«¨uDt

ΦÏ/ЩÑÓÒDÔºÐ'Õ�Ö}ÑÓ׿ØÙ

Ú�Û:ÜÞÝmß/à´áãâ�ß�ä�ÝoÝLå:æ:æ�à´áãçLèqé�êëYçLÛ:èBÝ¿ìqÜÞèqíç¿Ü î3ì<ìqà�ïðà´æ�è®áLäsçLÜÞà´í�æ:áãà�ñãè®ì·ç�òqó/ä�ôõäsçLà´ímòBê�è·çðß/èqèqí¸ö­÷�öãøDùP÷Nèqí:íWè®Ý®ú�û3áLä�í:ìqèä�í:é�çLÛ:èdü�èqæ3ä�á­ç¿ý'èqíç�à�þ|ÚoèqôÞèqìqà´ý'ý�å:í:ÜÞì®äsçLÜÞà´íAú3óBåWé3ä�æ�è®ÝãçYÿNí:Ü �èqáLÝLÜ çðë¼à�þ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞà���ë4ä�íWé��<ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®ú���åWí��ä�áãë� óBå:é3ä�æ�èqÝLç�ÿ�í:Ü �èqáãÝ¿Ü çðë�à�þ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞà���ëeä�í:é�<ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®ú���� 5ø�����ø���Û:Ü ç�� Û:Ü ç�� ê:ý'è�� ÛDå� ö��YøDùÀïUö­÷�öãøDùHú��0ÜÞâDôÞà´Ý�� �0à´ôÞí3ä�á���ÜÞáLÜÞÝ¿ä�� þ}á� óBå:é3ä�æ�èqÝLç�ÿ�í:Ü �èqáãÝ¿Ü çðë�à�þ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞà���ëeä�í:é�<ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®úWôÞè��èqí:é:à�����Û:Ü ç�� ê:ý'è�� Û�å� ö��YøDùNïðö­÷��0ù�÷dú� _äsç¿áãÜÞìqè!� "Aè��´åWè®ÝLé:áãà´í���ÜÞí:ÝÓäsï¦áLèqí:í:èqÝ�� þ}á

Unité de recherche INRIA RennesIRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France)

Téléphone : 02 99 84 71 00 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 00Télécopie : 02 99 84 71 71 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 71

Page 5: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

� ���P������% * ���������� �� ����%' ���! "$�� ��1 N��� &�%' ����23�4�5*��0������� ������*,+$������%' �&�%' ��%'��

�� �� � � £ ��~xz|n4vu�p4~ � ps{}v�«¨u]Ì/z_wxy<n4�o��ª]u�«}wx�_�Uwxz|n0�ou!z_w]y_ªxuW~�yo³À~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t!uDne�<w]y � «}u � wxy_ps~��]ut�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p4�_~�z|n0«}uDn � �Dn©uD~xyo³À�ou²vw]t8t�y_z_{¦v�~�p©{}wxz�µ � «¨y<n0� � �Wv{¦n®uDt!t8uDzApDÌ/z_w]y|n0� � wx�Uw]n©wxz|ne�ouDn4~x«»¾�]w � {»ps�_t!uDn��<w]y � «}uDn4v�~]new��h«}uDn0{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]z|nen®y � «�� �ps~�p��ouDne«}{¨uDz|n0z_u²n®w]zApe�|~]ne¹<~��|«¨uWn�µ � w]y � «¨u� � w]�_«¨rDt!u��oy � w]yops~x�xu�t�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®pe~:ª]uDv�v�wxzAp � ~�{}zAp©u��_u��|~xz|�ou��|~xnsn©~xzAp©u�w]yh��� y_z�v�w��op0�x�Dz_� � ~�«}{¦n®�]Ìz|wxy|n0� � wx�Uw]n©wxz<n¼«¦~�p � ~�z|n®¬­w � t²~3p©{}wxzÁ�oyÁ� � w]�_«}r�t!u!«¨w � ns½Ay_u�«�� {¨zo¬­w � t²~�p©{}wxzÁuDn®p0{}z|v�wxt!�_«}rp©u!uDzÁy|z� � w]�_«¨rDt!u!�_uPkAp©uD{¨z_u � �o�psu � t!{¨z_{¦n®p©u²�D½Ay_{}ª3~�«}u�zApDµ��Nw � n©½Ay_u8«¦~hÍ�wAk��ou²«}~$v�wxt!t�y_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxzÁt�y|«»ps{»¾vD~xn®p�uWnqp��ow]z_z_�Duen©wxy|n�«¦~�¬­w � t8u0��� y_z_u0«}{¨t!{¨ps~3ps{¨w]z��_y��o�D«}~x{��ou0�<w]yop'u�z��<w]yopDÌoz|wxy|nº� � wx�Uw]n©wxz<n¸�oup � ~xz|n®¬­w � t8u � «}u4� � wx�_«}r�t!ueu�z$y_z�� � wx�_«}r�t!u4n®{}t!{¨«¦~�{ � u�yops{¨«}{¦n©~xz]p¼�_uDnºª3~�«}u�y � nº�o�psu � t!{¨z_{¦n®p©uDn'n©y � «}uDn«}{}u�z|nDµ Ê w]y|nºu�zÂ�ow]z_z_wxz<n¸y|zA§ n©wx«}yop©{}wxz$~��_� � wov��_�Du��Uwxy � «}u � wxyop�~��xu]µ� È �W� Æ ¢�� � £ ���Dn©uD~�y_³BÌ � wxy_ps~��]u�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®pDÌ_½Ay|~x«¨{¨p©���_u0n©u � ªm{}v�uxÌo� � wx�|«¨rDt8u4�ou�kApsu�{}z_u �

Page 6: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� :

; < ���N�Y�²&���H������¶·z � w]yop©{}z_��t!up©�|wm�|n�Ì/§'�_uDzÁ~�vw]z_z_uWv´p©{}wxz�~�«}«¨wov�~�p©{}wxz � uD½Ay_uWnqp0{¦n�� � uWn®uDz]psuD�/Ì�~��|~�p©��n©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz�{}nu�³ouDvy_p©uD�Pp©w8¹|z<��~xz�~]�ot!{}nsn®{}�_«}u>=ãw � ps�_u0�<u�p®p©u ��? �<~3p©��w � p � uDu¼¬ � wxt�~xt!wxz_��p©�_u4~:ª3~�{}«¦~��_«}u � wxy_p©uDnps�|~3pPns~3ps{}n®¹|uWn�ps�_u � uD½Ay_uDn®pDµ ��{A@Bu � u�zAp � wxyops{¨z|�±n®p � ~3psu��]{¨uWn8vD~�z �<uÀ~x�_�_«}{¨uW�>{}z w � �ou � psw±ns~3ps{}n®¬­lps�_u � uD½Ay_uDn®p©uW� v�wxz|�_{»ps{¨w]z|n8w�¬ep©�_u�Í�wmk>~:§º~ � u�v�wxt!t�y_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxz<n�µ Í�wAk �xwA~�«¦n8vD~�z �<uÀ~]v��_{}u�ªxuW�§'{¨p©� p©�_u��|u�«}� w�¬º¹_³ouD�±w � �olmz|~xt!{}v � wxy_p©{}z_�Ànqp � ~�p©uD�x{}uDnDµ�¶·z¯ps�_u�vD~xn©u²w�¬��olmz|~xt8{¦v � wxyops{¨z|�Âp©�_u� wxy_p©{}z_�$� � wov�uD�oy � u�=­t²~�{}z_«}lÀps�_u � w]yop©{}z_��ps~x�_«}u ? {¦n � uDªm{}n©uD�/µ���wxyops{¨z_��p�~��_«}uDn�vD~�z±�Uu�~�«¨p©u � uD�Á~3p~�¹_³ouD�Â�Uwx{}zAp�{}zÀps{¨t!u�w � ~]v�v�w � �o{¨z|�!p©w�ps�_u!nqp�~3p©u�w�¬5ps�_u�z|upq§�w � °Uµ¼¶·zhvu � p�~�{}zh�olmz|~�t!{¦v � wxyops{¨z|�n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|nNn©wxt!u5u�ª]u�zApsnN{¨t!�_«}{¦v�~3psudps�_uHt!wo�o{¨¹<v�~�p©{}wxz4w�¬ � wxy_p©{}z_�ºps~x�_«¨uWnN~xz|��n©w'p©�_u � w]yop©{}z_�'�UuDv�wxt!uDnuDªxuDz]p4�ouD�<uDz|�ou�zApWµ ¤ �_u!y|n®uW� � wxy_p©{}z_�Pp�~��_«}uDn4vD~�zÁ�<u!� � u¾Ó�_«¦~�z_z|uD��§'{»ps�hps�_u²�_u�«}�Áw�¬�~xz�wB@<¾Ó«}{¨z_uv�wxt!�_yop�~3ps{¨w]zÁw � � � u��|~ � uW��w]z¯�ou�t²~�z<��§'�|u�z v��|~xz_�xuWn4~ � u8z|u�uD�_uD�/µ ¤ �_u�vw]t!�_yops~�p©{}wxz¯v�~xz¯�<uv�u�zAp � ~�«}{DC�uD��w � �o{¦n®p � {¨�_y_p©uD�"E}���'F¿µ5¶·zÂ~�zmlPvD~xn©uep©�_u � wxyopsu4vwxt!�_y_ps~3ps{¨w]z�=ðp©�|u4�|~3ps�HGWp � uDu0n©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz ?� uD½Ay_{ � uDn�u7I�v{}u�zAp��|~�p©��w � p � uDu0v�wxt!�_yop�~3ps{¨w]z�~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n�µ

¤ w¯�<u � ¬­w � t � w]yop©{}z_�¯§'�_{¦v�� v�~xz � uW~�«}«¨l �UuhvD~�«}«¨uW� Í�wmk � w]yop©{}z_�|̸p©�|uÀu³_~xvp�ª3~�«}y_uDn²wx¬4«¨{}z_°�_uDnsv � {¨�opsw � nJ=L~:ª3~�{}«}~x�_«¨u��|~�z<�o§'{}�op©��ÌN�_u�«¦~:lxÌA�q{»p©p©u � Ì�u�psvxµ ? n©�_w]y_«}�h�<u8°mz_w3§'z�~�p�ps�_u!� � wx�Uu � z_wo�ouDn§'�|u � u5p©�_u � wxyopsuHn®uD«¨uWv´ps{¨w]z�n®�|wxy_«¦�4�Uud¬­y_«¨¹|«}«¨uW��{}z�p©�|uHz_u�pq§¸w � °e§'�_{}«¨u�v�~�«¦vy|«}~�p©{}z_� � wxyopsuDnDµLK�z_¬­w � p©yo¾z<~3p©uD«¨l]Ìxps�_{¦n¸{¦n¸z_w�p'~��Uw]nsn®{}�_«}u¼§º~:l�w � {}�x{}z|~�p©uD�8¬ � wxt ps�_u � uD½Ay_{ � uD�²~�t!w]y_zAp¸w�¬NvD~��|~]v{¨pql8n©�_w]y_«}�P�<uy<n®uW��psw!�_{}n®p � {¨�|yop©uep©�|uDn©u4u³_~xvp�ª3~�«}y_uWnº{¨z�p©�|uez|upq§�w � °Uµ ¤ w!~:ª]wx{¦��y|n©{}z_�8p©�_u4n©{¨�]z_{»¹Uv�~�zApº¬ � ~xv´ps{¨w]zwx¬'z_upq§�w � °hv�~x�|~xv�{»pqlh¬­w � p � ~�z|n©t!{»p©p©{}z_�À«}{¨z_°±n®ps~3psu�{}zo¬­w � t²~3p©{}wxzNÌNps�_uPª3~�«}y_uWn4w�¬'«}{¨z_°¯�ouWn©v � {}�opsw � nvD~�zÀ�Uu!~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uW�$�<u � {}wo�o{}vD~�«}«¨l$w � w]z_«¨lÂ~�p¼p©�|u�ps{¨t!u8{¨z|n®ps~xzApsn�§'�_u�z�� � uW�ou¹<z_uD�$ps� � uDn©�_wx«¦�_ne~ � uu�³_vu�uW�ouD��µ5¶·z�ps�_{¦n'§�~:l!ps�_u � wxyops{¨z|�!~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²nºv�~�z$n©u�«}uDv´p � wxy_p©uDnº�<~xn©uD��wxz�p©�_u4«¦~xn®p�~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uW�ª3~x«¨y_uWn�w�¬N«}{¨z|°��ouDnsv � {¨�_p©w � n�~�z|��v�~�z�wx�op�~�{}z�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz<n¸§'�|{}v���v�~�z��<u0½Ay_{¨p©u4�o{.@Uu � uDz]p�¬ � wxt p©�|u0n©w�¾«}yops{¨w]z|n¸v�wxy_«¦�²�Uu¼¬­w]y_z|�²°mz_w3§'{}z_�4ps�_ueu³_~xvpHª3~�«}y_uDnDµdkmw|Ì]p©�_u � wxyops{¨z_��t8u�p©�_wo�_nºvD~�z�w]z_«¨l8§�w � °�w]zM{¨z<vwxt!�_«}upsu'{¨z_¬­w � t!~�p©{}wxzNMº~xz|�!v�~xz!¹|z|�!wxz|«¨l8n®y_�_¾¿w]�op©{}t²~�« � wxyopsuDnY¬­w �PO w3§�n � uD½Ay_{ � {¨z_��Í�wmkBµ ¤ �_un©{}t8�|«¨uWnqp0§�~:l�psw�vD~�«¦vy_«¦~3psu�n©y_�o¾Ówx�ops{¨t²~�« � wxyopsuDn�{}n0n©{¨t!�_«}lÂu³ouWvyops{¨z_��p � ~x�_{»ps{¨w]z|~�«�t!up©�|wm�|n>=ãuxµ �|µ��{ �q°mn®p � ~�w �RQ u�«}«}t!~xz_zo¾3S_w � ��~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n5psw�¹|z|��n®�|w � p©uDn®pH�|~�p©�|nDÌ�T¼w]y�w � ¤ ~x°3~��|~]n®�_{¨¾·�À~3p�n®y_lA~�t²~~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n0EÞ�oÌVU'F5p©w�¹|z|���|~ � p©{¦~�«5n©�|~�z_z|{¨z_��p � u�uWn ? w]zÀp©�|u8«¦~xn®p4~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uW�À«}{¨z_°hª:~x«¨y|uDnDµ ¤ �_{¦n0{}nps�_u4t²~�z_z|u � �_w3§ p©�_u�v�y �©� u�zAps«¨l²y|n©uD� � wxyops{¨z|��� � w�pswovwx«¦nºv�~xz�§�w � °�E : Ì_��FÓµ

¤ �_u�u7@BuDvp©{}ªxu�z|uDnsn¼v�~xzÂ�<u�{¨z|v � uW~xn©uD���ml$y|n®{}z_�²ps�_u�°mz_w3§'«}uD�o�]u�~��Uwxyop�p©�_u�t8uWv��|~�z|{}n©t wx¬5p©�_u~]�oªxu � ps{}n©u�t!uDz]p!w�¬0«}{¨z_° �ouDnsv � {}�op©w � nW=­u]µ �<µ §'�_{¦v�� ps� � uDn©�_wx«¦�_n²~ � u$y|n©uD� �oy � {¨z_�±ps�_uÂwx�Uu � ~3ps{¨w]z ? µQ ~]n®uW�hw]z�ps�_{¦n�~�z<�Án©wxt!u�~$� � {}w � {d{¨z_¬­w � t!~�p©{}wxz±~��Uwxyop�p©�_u²�Uu��|~:ªm{}w � wx¬�ps�_u�ª3~�«}y_uWn4w�¬�p©�_uP«¨{}z_°�_uDnsv � {¨�opsw � n�Ìo� � w]�|~��_{}«}{}n®p©{¦v0t!wm�_u�«¦n�v�~xz��Uu�n©up�y_�$psw�� � w3ªm{}�ou0t!w � u4~��_� � w]� � {¦~3psu � w]yop©uWnº¬­w � Í�wmkO w3§�nXE �_ÌZY�FÓµ ���mªm{¨w]y|n©«¨l]̺p©�_uÁwx�o�quWv´ps{¨ª]uhw�¬4ps�_u � w]yop©uÁn®uD«¨uWv´p©{}wxz �<~xn©uD� w]z �o{.@Uu � uDz]p�pqlm�<uWnPwx¬� � w]�|~��_{}«}{}n®p©{¦vPt!u�p©�_wo�_n�v�w �s� uWn®�Uwxz<�_n�p©w¯�oupsu � t!{¨z_u$ps�_uÂwx�_p©{}t!~x« � w]yop©uWn�̸§'�_{¦v�� vD~�z ¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«¼p©�_uÍ�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApº§'{»ps��t²~�³m{}t�y|t�� � wx�|~x�_{}«¨{¨pqlxµ

¤ �_u � ue~ � u¼wxp©�_u �H� uD~xn©wxz<nd§'�ml8p©�_u � w]yop©{}z_��t8u�p©�_wo�_n�v�~xz�wxz|«¨l!§�w � °�w]z�{¨z<vwxt!�_«}upsu�{}zo¬­w � t²~3¾ps{¨w]z�µdkmy|v���~ � uD~xn©wxz�v�wxt!uDnd¬ � w]t p©�_u��0k � S¯~xz|� � Ê�Ê ¶d� � wxp©wovw]«}nDÌ]§'�|{}v���§�w � °ond{}zP�_{}u � ~ � v��_{¦v�~x«t²~xz_z_u � Ìm§'�_u � uep©�_u0ª3~�«}y_uWnºw�¬Nps�_u0«¨{}z_°P�_uDnsv � {¨�opsw � n�wxzP�|{¨�]�_u � �_{}u � ~ � v��_{¦v�~x«|«}u�ªxuD«}n'~ � u0v�~x«}v�y_«¦~3p©uW�~]n¼~:ª]u � ~��xu4ª3~x«¨y_uWn¼w3ª]u � ps�_u8«¨w3§�u � w]z_uDnDµ4kmw|Ì � w]yop©{}z_��{¨zÂps�_uDn©u8«¨uDªxu�«¦n¼~ � u8~�«¦n®wP�|~xn©uD�$w]zÀ{¨z<vwxt8¾�|«¨u�p©u�«}{¨z|°8ª3~x«¨y_uWn-=ðps�_u¼u�³_~xv´p¸ª:~x«¨y|uDn5¬ � wxt p©�_u�«¨w3§�u � «}u�ª]u�«¦nH~ � u'z_wxpH°mz_w3§'z ? E ��FÓµ5�¼u�p©u � t!{¨z|{¨z_��p©�_ups� � uDn©�_wx«¦�_nDÌ]§'�_{¦v��P~ � u�y<n®uW�!p©w��<u0~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uW�/Ìx{¦n�~�z�{}zAp©u � uDn®p©{}z_��ps~xn©°8�<uWv�~�y<n®u�{»pºt!uD~�z<nH� � ~:§'{¨z|�~��|~�«¦~�z<vu��Uupq§�u�uDz²p©�_u�z_upq§�w � °!v�~��<~xv{¨pql8y|n®uW�!¬­w � �o{¦nqp � {}�_yops{¨z|��p©�|u�«}{¨z|°!n®ps~�p©u�{¨zo¬­w � t²~�p©{}wxz�~�z<�

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 7: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

ps�_u�{}z|vw]t!�_«¨u�p©uDz_uDnsn�wx¬�ps�_u�{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]zÂnqpsw � uD��{¨zÀp©�_u � wxy_p©{}z_�²ps~x�_«}uDnDµ�¶·z<v � uD~xn©{}z_�!p©�_u��o{}n®ps~xz|vu�Uupq§�u�uDzhps�_u!p©� � uWn®�_w]«}�|n4�ouDv � uW~xn©uDn�p©�_u²z|uDvuWn©ns~ � lÀv�~x�|~xv�{»pql$¬­w � ~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uDt!u�zAp4§'�_{¨«}u²{}z|v � uD~]n®uWnps�_ue{¨z|v�wxt!�_«}upsu�z_uWn©n¸w�¬N{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]zP~��Uwxy_p¸«}{¨z_°²ª3~x«¨y_uWn�µH��zPp©�_uew�ps�_u � �|~�z<��§'�_uDz²p©�_u4�o{¦n®ps~�z<vuDn~ � u0�ouWv � uD~xn©uD��~x�_ªxu � p©{¦n©u�t!u�zApºu�ªxuDzApsnº§'{}«¨«/wov�v�y � t!w � ue¬ � uW½]y|u�zAp©«}l(=­t�y|v��$t!w � ue�<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps��t²~:l�Uuez_u�uW�ouD��¬­w � «¨{}z_°�n®ps~�p©uet8uWn©ns~��]uDn ? ÌA�_yop't!w � u¼� � uDv�{}n©u¼«}{}z_°�nqp�~3psu�{}zo¬­w � t²~3ps{¨w]zP§'{}«¨«B�Uuen®p©w � uW��{}zps�_u � w]yop©u � n8=­p©�_u²� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pqlÂw�¬¸¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«}{}z_��p©�_u�Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp0~x«¨w]z_�Pps�_u²n®uD«¨uWv´psuD� � w]yop©u!§'{}«¨«�Uu4{}z|v � uD~]n®uW� ? µ

¤ �_u�t²~�{}z¯¬­wovy|n8wx¬'p©�_{¦n8�|~��Uu � {}n�pswh{}z]p � wo�oy<vuPz|u�§�t�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®p � wxyops{¨z|��~�«}�xw � {¨p©�|t!n�§'�_{¦v��~ � u8~��_«}u�p©w��<u � ¬­w � t � wxyopsu8n©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz��|~xn©uD�hwxzh� � w]�|~��_{}«}{}n®p©{¦v�«}{¨z|°Ât8uW~xn©y � uDn�{¨z�p©�_u²vD~xn©u�w�¬¸p©�_ut!wAnqp�pqlm�_{¦v�~x«Hpqlm�UuDn�w�¬eÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsn =­w3ª]u � ~�«}«dvw]n®pDÌ5uDz|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|�¯�ou�«¦~:lÁw � �q{¨p®psu � Ì5t!{¨z_{}t²~�«�<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� ? ~�z|�$~xz|~�«}l2C�uep©�_uD{ � n'�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�uDnº~��A~�{}z|nqpºps�_u�vy �©� u�zAp©«}lPn®ps~xz|�_~ � �o{DC�uW�P~�«}�xw � {¨p©�|t!n=ã§'�_{¦v���§�w � °�w]z M´{}t!� � uDv{¦n©u�M5�ou�p©u � t!{}z_{}n®p©{¦v¸«¨{}z_°4t!uD~]n®y � uDn ? µ ¤ �_u � uWn®y_«¨psn�~ � udpsuDn®p©uW���ml4u³mp©uDz|n©{¨ª]un©{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]z|n�µ

¤ �_uWn®u0pswx�_{¦v�nº§'{}«}«��<u0p � uW~3psuD��{¨z�p©�|u�¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_�²nqp � y|vp©y � u��� {¨z V#*$�������� ps�_u4t!wo�ou�«�~xz|��p©�_u4z_wxps~�p©{}wxz�{}nº{}zAp � wm�_y|vuW�Ppsw8ps~xv�°m«}uep©�_u4� � wx�|«¨uDt! � {¨z V#*$������#" §�u$� � w]�<wAn®u$n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n�¬­w � p©�_uÂt�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®p � w]yop©{}z_�±� � wx�_«}u�t {}z p©�_uÂvD~xn©u�wx¬{¨z<vwxt!�_«}upsu0{¨zo¬­w � t²~�p©{}wxz�y|n®{}z_��p©�_uepqlm�_{¦v�~x«�Í�wAk²w]�o�quDvp©{}ªxuWn�~xz|�Pp©�_u4~��|� � w]� � {}~�p©u¼t!u�p � {}vDn�

� {¨z V#�7������%$ u³mpsu�z|n©{¨ª]u4zmy_t!u � {}vD~�«�~�z<~�«}lmn©{¦n'w�¬�p©�_u�t8u�p©�_wo�_n�~ � u4�x{}ªxuDz��Uu¬­w � u4ps�_u�v�wxz|v�«¨yo¾n®{}wxz<n�µ

& ' %��U� �4��.(*��²&�%'�±����& ��%'Y������������(�Nup*),+.-0/21�354��<u�p©�|uP� � ~��|� � uD� � uWn®uDzAp©{}z_�$p©�_u�z_u�pq§¸w � °hp©wx�Uwx«}wx�]lÁ~xz|�¯«}up8y|n�n©y_�_�Uw]n©u�ps�|~3pps�_u²z_u�pq§¸w � °Â{¦n4~��_«}u!p©w$�Uu � ¬­w � t1Í�wAk � wxyops{¨z_�$t!uDv��<~�z_{¦n®t²nDµ S_w � ps�_{¦n � uW~xn©wxzhp©�_u�n®ps~�p©u!w�¬�p©�_uz|upq§�w � °h{¦n�t!wxz_{¨p©w � uW�¯~�z|�±«}{}z_°±ª:~x«¨y|uDn�v�w �s� uWn®�Uwxz<�o{¨z|��pswÂp©�|u�n©u�«}uDv´psuD� Í�wmk��xw]~x«}n�~ � u�°mz_w3§'z§'{¨p©�Á~²�x{}ªxuDzh�ow]y_�op®¬­y|«¨z_uWn©nDµ ¤ �_u�«}{¨z|°�ª3~x«¨y_u8t!uD~]n®y � u�t!uDz]pe~�z|�$ps�_u8� � w]�|~��A~3ps{¨w]z�wx¬5p©�_u�ª3~�«}y_uDn~ � ue{}z|n®y � uW��§'{¨p©��ps�_u4�_u�«}��w�¬5~²Í4�0k � «}{¨°]u4t!uDv��|~xz_{}n©t E : Ì_��FÓµ

�Nup¸y<nHn©y_�_�Uw]n©u�p©�<~3p � wxyopsu � nH~]�oªxu � ps{}n©uºp©�_u�ª3~�«}y_uDnHw�¬Bp©�_u�«¨{}z_°²�ouWn©v � {}�op©w � ndw3ªxu � ps�_u¼z|upq§�w � °UÌ{}z�p©�_u0¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_��¬ã~]n®�|{¨w]z6�

� ¤ �_ue�|~ � ~�t!upsu � ~3³o{}n =ðps�_u0n®u�p�wx¬��<wAn©n©{¨�|«¨ueª3~�«}y_uDn¸w�¬�ps�_ue«¨{}z_°²�ouDnsv � {}�op©w ��? {}nºvw3ª]u � uD�8§'{¨p©��~� � {}�!78+:9<;>=?1�@�+:AB1�CDCCD1�EGFxµ� ��p¼uD~]v��Pps{¨t!u�{}z|n®ps~xz]p'ps�_u�ª3~�«}y_u�;>=5{¦n�~]�oªxu � ps{}n©uD�P¬ � w]t�ps�_u�«}{¨z_°H-JIK1?L�4´Ì<{»¬Yp©�|u4ª:~x«¨y|u4w�¬Yp©�_u«¨{}z_°��ouDnsv � {¨�_p©w � w]z�«}{}z_°�-JIK1?L�4ºn®p©u��<n'{¨zApsw�ps�_u4{}z]psu � ª3~�«M-J;>=�1?;>=DNPO�4´µ

¶·z p©�_{¦n!§º~:l¯uD~xv�� «¨{}z_°#-QIP1�LR4TS:3 �|~]n8~¯Í�wAk>�ouDnsv � {}�op©w �*U�VWBX Y[Z §'�_{¦v�� {}n²~]n©n©y_t!uD� p©w±�<u� ~�z<�owxt ª3~ � {¦~��_«}u4n®y_�_�quDv´pºpsw!p©�_u�v�wxz|�o{¨p©{}wxz<~�«/� � wx�|~x�_{}«¨{¨pql��o{¦nqp � {}�_yops{¨w]z�¬­y|z|v´ps{¨w]z

\ V = Z]?^`_ba c?d -Qe�42+#fg- U�VWBX Y[Z2h eKi ;>= hjU�VWBX Y[Z�h ;>=DNPO�4

ö���÷�öðù

Page 8: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �

¶·z$vu � p�~�{}zPv�~]n®uWndps�_u � ~�z<�owxt ª3~ � {}~x�_«}uDn�vw �s� uDn©�<w]z|�o{}z_�4p©w�p©�|u0�_{A@Bu � u�zApº«¨{}z_°onºv�~�zP�<u4vw]z|n©{}�m¾u � uW��~]nº{¨z<�ou��Uu�z|�_u�zAp � ~xz|�ow]t�ª3~ � {}~x�_«¨uWn =ãv´¬qµHkouDv´ps{¨w]z : ? µ

¤ �_u�n©up'wx¬�t�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®p'� � wxy_��t!u�t��Uu � nº{¦nº�x{}ªxu�z$~�z<���_u�z_wxp©uD���ml / ��� /²µ¤ �_ue�xwA~�«Uw�¬�ps�_u0t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp � wxyops{¨z_��{}n¸psw�¹|z<�P~��|~ � p©{¦~�«Bn®�<~�z_z_{}z_��p � u�u�� §'�_{¦v���n©�|~�z|n¸¬­w � ~x«¨«

I�{}z / � ~xz|�²§'�_{¦v���v�w �s� uWn®�Uwxz|�|nYp©w�p©�_u � uW½Ay_{ � uD�PÍ�wmk²v � {¨p©u � {}wxz²§'{¨p©��ps�_u¼t²~�³m{}t²~�«U� � wx�|~x�_{¨«}{¨pql������� ������������������ fg-HÍ�wAk¥v � {¨p©u � {}wxz {¦n p � y_u�4 =q� ?

§'�|u � u�� {¦n�p©�_u�n©up�wx¬Np � uDuDn'n©�|~�z_z|{¨z_� / � µ¤ �_u4t!wAnqpº¬ � uD½Ay_u�zAps«¨l�y<n®uW�ÂÍ�wmk�v � {¨p©u � {}wxz|n�¬­w � t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqpºp � uDu0n©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz$~ � u4~�z|~x«¨lon©uD��{}z�p©�_uz|u³mp¼n®uWv´ps{¨w]z�wx¬Np©�|{}n'�<~��Uu � µ

� � �������������������)���¸��*,+��%���% ���23���Y*��0������¤ �|u²Í�wmkÀ~:§º~ � u � w]yop©{}z_��� � w]�_«}u�t²neª:~ � l${}zhps�_u!y|n©uD�Àw]�o�quDvp©{}ªxu�¬­y_z|v´ps{¨w]zÁ~xz|�À{}z�p©�_u!y|n©uD�h«¨{}z_°t!u�p � {}vDn�µ¼� ¬­u�§��|~x�<u � n�~�z|~x«¨l2CDu4p©�_u²Í�wAk � wxyops{¨z|��� � wx�_«}u�t §'{»ps�h�ou�p©u � t!{¨z|uD�«}{¨z|°�t!u�p � {}vDn¼~�z<�§'{¨p©�8~��_� � w]� � {¦~3psuHw]�o�quDvp©{}ªxud¬­y|z|v´ps{¨w]z|n�µY� «}~ � �]uHw3ªxu � ªm{}u�§¯~�z<��v«¦~xnsn©{»¹<vD~3ps{¨w]z4w�¬ � wxy_p©{}z_�¼� � wx�|«¨uDt!n~xz|�!n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|n5vD~�z!�<u�¬­wxy_z|�!{}zWE ��F¿µ ¤ �_uWn®u�~xz|~�«}l2C�uDn5~ � uºw]yopHw�¬/nsvwx�Uu'w�¬Bwxy � �|~��Uu � µd��y � ~�z|~x«¨l2CDu~x{¨t²nºps�_u � wxy_p©{}z_�²� � wx�_«}u�t §'�_u�zÂps�_u�«}{¨z|°�ª3~�«}y_uWn¼~ � u4t!uD~]n®y � uD��§'{¨p©�Ây_z<vu � ps~x{¨zApql]µ¸¶·zÀw]y � vD~xn©ups�_u�Í�wAk � wxyops{¨z_�8t!wo�ou�«¦n'�|~]n®uW�Pw]z��ou�p©u � t!{}z_uD��ª3~�«}y_uDn'vD~�z�z_w�p��Uu�~��|�_«¨{}uD��µ�euDz_u � ~�«}«¨l]ÌUp©�_u�Í�wAkhv � {»psu � {¨w]z$¬­w � t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]zh�ou��Uu�z<�_newxzÀps�_u�pqlA�Uu8w�¬dps�_u�y<n®uW�À«}{¨z_°Ât!u�p � {}vDn�µ¶Ó¬ep©�|uÀ«¨{}z_° ª:~x«¨y|uDn�~ � u°mz_w3§'z §'{»ps� y_z|v�u � ps~�{}zApqlx̸p©�_uhwx�o�quWv´p©{}ªxu�¬­y_z<v´p©{}wxz<n!¬­w � t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p²p � u�un©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz$v�~xz��Uu0¬­w � t�y_«¦~3psuDnº~xn�¬­w]«¨«}w3§�nDµ�xµ'�¼nsn®y|t8{}z_� !*�'�9���.#$�H#��1>�0�*, # w�¬�«}{¨z|°8t!u�p � {}vDn =ãuxµ �|µY�|~�z<�o§'{}�op©� ? p©�_u0v � {¨p©u � {}wxz�v�~xz��Uu�§ � {»p©p©uDz~xn �! #"VDW�X Y[Z ��� U�VDW�X Y[Z $&%§'�_u � u % vw �©� uDn©�Uwxz|�_n¸psw�ps�_u�~xn©°xuW�Pª3~x«¨y_u =ãuxµ �|µYp©�|u4z_u�uW�ouD���|~xz|�o§'{¦�mp©� ?

�oµº¶·zhps�_u!v�~xn©u�wx¬ � %B%������ ��#�� �*, # wx¬Hy_z_{¦v�~]nqp0«¨{}z_°Àt!u�p � {}vDn�pq§�wPpqlm�_{¦v�~x«�vD~xn©uDn�w�¬�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp0wx�o¾�quDvp©{}ªxuDn¼n®�_w]y_«¦�P�Uu��o{¦nqps{¨z_�]y_{¦n®�_uW�/µ=ã~ ? S|w � Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp�vw]z|vu � z_{}z_� � � # #7�)%�'3�3��' #$�H%)($� ������� � =­u]µ �<µ��ouD«}~:l]Ì©�q{¨p®psu � Ì3z_u��A~3ps{¨ª]u

«}wx�A~ � {»ps�_t w�¬�p©�|u4�|~xv�°]upº«¨wAn©n ? p©�_u�v � {¨p©u � {}wxz$v�~xz��Uu4§ � {¨p®psu�zÂ~xn�����* ^,+>a -/.Qd ��021 3VWBX Y[Z ��* ^,+>a -4. d U�VWBX Y[Z�h65

7 u � u 5 vw �©� uDn©�Uwxz|�_n�psw4p©�|u¼ª3~�«}y_u'pswx«}u � ~3p©uW�8�Al�p©�|ueÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp =­uxµ �|µ�pswx«}u � ~3p©uW�uDz|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|� �ouD«}~:l ? ~xz|�&8 � �ou�z|w�p©uWn�ps�_u±n®u�p�w�¬��|~3ps�|nP�Uupq§�u�uDz p©�|uÁn©u�z|�_u � =49 S/ � ? ~xz|��p©�_u � uWvuD{¨ª]u � =;: = SH/ �)< 9=9�F 1?@2+ A�1<CCDCD1�> ? z_wo�ouWn0=¿km{¨z|�x«}u8kmw]y � v�u��Ây_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqpt!wo�ouD« ? w � ps�_uH�<~3p©�<nN�Uupq§�u�uDz4u�ªxu � lez_wo�ou¸�|~�{ � wx¬ / � =ã�¼zAl�kmw]y � vuH�Ây|«»ps{}vD~xn®pNt!wm�_u�« ? µ� � {}�x{}z|~3psuD��¬ � w]t ps�_ud¬ � uD½Ay_uDzAp©«}l�y|n©uD��n®w]y � v�u5�|~xn©uD�4~x�_�_«}{}vD~3ps{¨w]z|n�~�z<�ep©�_u�~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t!{¦vv�wxt!�_«}u³o{¨pql²p©�_u4�<~��Uu � {¦n'vwxz<vu�zAp � ~�p©uD�Pp©w8ps�_u�km{}z_�x«}u�kmwxy � v�ue�Ây|«»ps{}vD~xn®p�t8wo�ouD«Lµ

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 9: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

U � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

=­� ? S|w ��� uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsnNvwxz<vu � z_{}z_�ºp©�|u ����#$������� ��� �� wx¬mp©�_u�n®�|~xz_z_{}z_�ºp � u�udp©�_u'Í�wAkev � {»psu � {¨w]zv�w �s� uWn®�Uwxz<�_n¸p©w

3VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z�h��§'�|u � u � {¦nºps�_u�vwAnqpºp©w]«¨u � ~�p©uW���ml�ps�_u��ou�t²~xz|�/µ

¤ �_u²w]�o�quDvp©{}ªxu!w�¬�p©�|u²t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp � wxyops{¨z|��{¦n0psw$¹|z|�±~�z±wx�_p©{}t!~x«Yp � u�u�� � � §'�_{¦v��Án©�|~�z<n0p©�_ut�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p'z_wo�ouDn¼~�z|��t!w]n®pº«}{}°xu�«}l²¬­y_«¨¹|«}«}n'p©�_u�Í�wmkPv � {¨p©u � {}wxz�Ìoz<~�t!u�«}l ��xµ'vw]z|n®{¦�ou � {}z_�8�<wxp®p©«}u�z|uDv�°�pqlm�Uu4w�¬�«¨{}z_°Pt!u�p � {}vDn

��� ��0O ������� ���������� fg- �! #"VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4 =L� ?

�oµ'vw]z|n®{¦�ou � {}z_�!~x�_�o{¨p©{}ªxu0pqlm�Uu0w�¬Y«¨{}z_°Pt!u�p � {}vDn=ã~ ? {}z�p©�_u�vD~xn©u�wx¬�uDz|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|��½Ay|~x«¨{¨pql � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zAp

� � ���� �������������� ��� fg- �����* ^ + a - . d ��0 1 3VDW�X Y[Z ��* ^,+>a - . d U�VWBX Y[Z h 5 4 = : ?

=­� ? {}z�p©�_u�vD~xn©u�wx¬Y~xz�w3ª]u � ~�«}«/vw]n®pº¬­y_z|vp©{}wxz� � � �� � ����� ���������� fg- 3VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z h�� 4 =­� ?

¤ �_u0¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_�8�_{}nsvy|nsn©{¨w]z�~xz|~�«}l2C�uDn¸ps�_u4wx�ops{¨t!{DCD~�p©{}wxz�ps~xn©°on4=L� ? ¾�=­� ? µ

��� � ��������������������������! "�#$���&%'�(�*)�#$�(+¤ �|uº¬­wx«}«¨w3§'{}z_�0«¨uDt!t!~4n®ps~�p©uWnYp©�|~�p =L� ? v�~xz8uW~xn©{¨«}l��Uu'p � ~�z<nq¬­w � t!uD��p©w�~�kmp©u�{}z_u � p � u�u'� � wx�|«¨uDt ~�z<�n©w²v�~xz�w]z_«¨lP�<u�~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psuD��{}z$�<w]«¨lmz_w]t!{}~x«Bp©{}t8u]µ,¸Ä � � ¡ -/. � ���+J���2�8������1 ���)%B#3, #$�H% #7�)*# ��� # $���A���9��'� � 510 �328� 4# ($��� ���'�.#$� � �3�> $��� �6���2� � , ����������+>��� ��+ ���Z �, ��� � �������9��#�# 0Q�R�W �4*2 ,H�*�B!$�.#7+ ������� ��� #(%B#$�3#7��+>��� � �����+ #*�� �����#� ��� � ��A�'�)#�%"�/� �A���21-QIP1�LR4 !�#7���2�656VWBX Y[Z +87:9<; �gf>= U�VDW�X Y[Z $&%@?�A�Z���6� 53B�C u�n©u�u�°�p©�_u4t�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®pºp � u�u

� � � 0O � �������!���� ��� fg- �! "VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4§'�|{}v���{}n�uD½Ay_{}ª:~x«¨uDzAp�psw � � � 0O � �������!���� ��� fg-ED

VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4

ö���÷�öðù

Page 10: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �

��n©n©y_t!{}z_�!{¨z|�_u��Uu�z|�ouDzAp � ~xz|�owxt�ª:~ � {¦~��|«¨uWn = � A�# A «}{¨z|°P{}z|�ou��Uu�z<�ou�z|v�l ?fg-EDVWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4�+ �

VWBX Y[Z ��� fg- U�VWBX Y[Z $&% 4~xz|�Pp©�_u4w]�op©{}t�y_t v�~xz��Uu��ou¹<z_uD���ml

�����0O ����� � �! #"����� 3VDW�X Y[Z ��� 7:9<; �2fg- U�VWBX Y[Z $&% 4 =L� ?

¤ �|u � u¬­w � u0~xnsn®{}�xz_{}z_�8t!uD~xn©y � u 5 VWBX Y[Z p©w²«}{¨z_° -JIK1?L�4º~xn 56VWBX Y[Z � + 7:9 ;��2fg- U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4´µ¸Í�µ ��µ ��µ7 u�y � {}n®p©{¦v4t!ups�_wo�_n0=9T¼w]y�Ì ¤ ~�°3~x�|~xn©�_{¨¾Ó�À~�psn©y_l]~xt²~_Ìmup�v�µ ? vD~�zÀ~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psu�ps�_u�w]�op©{}t²~�«�n©w�¾

«}yops{¨w]z E � FÓµ����� ����� # ��#!� �������>�! �#$���&%'�(�*)�#�(+��n¸vD~�z��Uu0n®uDu�z²¬ � wxt = :�? ~xz|�X=ã� ? ÌAps�_uen©u�«}uDvp©{}wxz²wx¬�p©�_u�wx�ops{¨t²~x« � k ¤ �|~]n®uW�!wxzP~]�_�o{¨p©{}ªxu�pqlm�Uu�wx¬«}{}z_°�t!up � {¦v�n��_u��Uu�z|�_n�wxz�p©�_u�½Ay|~x«¨{¨pqlPv � {¨p©u � {}wxz�µ

� ����� - ����É Æ � È|ÆsÄ ��É�� È��   Ä�� ��­  Ä � Ä �B��euDz_u � ~�«}«}lxÌ<p©�_u��|~3ps�|n¼�Uupq§�u�uDzÂp©�|u8n©u�z|�_u � z|wm�_u8~xz|�$p©�|u � uDvuD{¨ª]u � wxz_uWn¼vw]zAps~�{}zÀvw]t!t8w]zÀ«}{¨z_°on{}zÂ~!t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp¼p � u�uxµ�kmw|Ì|p©�_u � ~�z<�owxt�t!uW~xn©y � uWnºw3ªxu � ps�_uDn©u��|~�p©�|n¼nqp�~3p©{¦n®p©{¦v�~�«}«}l��ouD�<uDz|�$wxz$uD~]v��wxp©�_u � µ ¤ ~�°m{¨z|��{¨zApsw�~xvDvwxy|z]p5ps�_u¼uDªxuDz]p�ndwx¬B{}z|v�«¨y|�_{¨z_��p©�_u�n©~xt8u¼«¨{}z_°V=ãn ? {}zP�o{.@Uu � uDzApH�|~3ps�|n � uWn®y_«¨psn~xz!wx�ops{¨t!{DCD~3ps{¨w]z8ps~xn©°��<~:ªA{}z_�0�_{}�x��v�wxt!�_«}u³o{»pql]Ìxn©{¨z|v�u'p©�|u5�qwx{}zApH�o{}n®p � {}�_yop©{}wxz²wx¬<ps�_u��|~�p©�|nHn®�_w]y_«¦��Uu4°mz_w3§'z�µ ������������� � �!���� ��� fg- D* ^,+>a - . d ��021 9 3VWBX Y[Z ��* ^,+>a -4.Qd U�VWBX Y[Z h 5 F�4 =U ?

� � {}�x{}z|~3psuD�4¬ � wxt p©�_uº¬ã~]v´pdps�|~3p5ps�_u � u'{¦nYz_w�~:ª3~�{}«}~x�_«¨uºt!ups�_wo��p©w�n©wx«}ªxu4=U ? �o{ � uDvp©«}lxÌxp©�_uº¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{¨z|��_{}nsvy|nsn©{¨w]z�{¦ndvw]z|vuDzAp � ~3p©uW��w]z²~4n®�UuDv�{}~x«|v�~]n®uº§'�_uDz!p©�_uY�qw]{¨zApH�o{¦nqp � {}�_yops{¨w]z²w�¬Up©�_u'�<~3p©�<nd{}z|v«}y|�ouW�{}z�p©�_u � k ¤ nep�~�°xuWn0~ � u�«¦~3ps{¨ª]u�«}lÀn®{}t!�_«}l¬­w � tË~�z|��{¨p�{}n4�ou�p©u � t!{}z_uD���mlÂp©�_u8¹ � n®pepq§�w�t8w]t!u�zApsn=ã�ml²p©�_u4u�³o�<uWv´p©uW��ª:~x«¨y|u�~�z|�Pp©�_u4ª3~ � {¦~�z|v�u ? µ

�Nup�y|n'{}zAp � wo�oy|vu � ~�z|�_wxt ª3~ � {}~x�_«}uDn���=d~]n�<=P+ 3VDW�X Y[Z ��* ^,+>a -/.Qd U�VWBX Y[Z

~xz|� � uD§ � {¨p©u =U ? ~xn������������� � ������ ��� fg-��D=! PO 9"�<= h65 F�4

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 11: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

�¼�_�_«}lA{}z_�!ps�_u�vuDz]p � ~x«/«¨{}t!{»p'ps�_u�w � uDt � ����� v�~xz��Uu0¬­w � t�y|«}~�p©uD��~xn��� ���� � ����� � #"���������� CDCC ���� � e�� 9 7 O� -�e 7�� 4 � � ��� O -��e 7��� 4[F� -���� 4 ��� � ; � �� � e 1 = �'?

§'�|u � u � = + 3*9 � = F�{¦nºps�_u�u³o�UuDvp©uD�$ª3~x«¨y_u4wx¬�� = Ì � =�� + 3*9 - � = 7 � = 4�- � � 7 � � 4[F]Ì @ 1�� + A�1<CCDCD1�>~xz|�&> v�w �s� uWn®�Uwxz|�|n�psw±p©�_uÀvD~ � �o{¨z<~�«}{»pql¯wx¬�ps�_uÀn®u�p�w�¬e�|~3ps�|n�µ ¤ �|uÂt!~�p � {»³ � �� vD~�z uD~]n®{}«}l �<uvD~�«¦vy_«¦~3psuD��§'�_u�z ~]n©n©y_t!{}z_��p©�_u�«}{}z_°h{}z|�ouD�<uDz|�ou�z<vl =­w�¬'vw]y � n®u8p©�|u��|~3ps�±{¨z|�_u��Uu�z|�ouDz|vlÁ{¦n4z_w�pp � y|u ? � =�� + 3VWBX Y[Z ��* ^,+>a -4.0d�� * ^ + a -���d� � VWBX Y[Z C =ã� ?

kow|Ì<p©�_u8½]y<~�«}{»pql�w�¬ � � � "! {}n��oupsu � t8{}z_uW�Â�mlPps�_u�t!uW~�zª3~�«}y_uDn�~�z|�Àª:~ � {¦~�z<vuDn�w�¬d«}{¨z_°Â�ouWn©v � {}�opsw � n~x«¨w]z_�8p©�_u4�<~3p©�<n�~�z|��ps�_u�n®y|t wx¬�ps�_u4ª3~ � {}~xz|vuWnºw�¬�p©�_u�v�wxt!t!wxz$«¨{}z_°on'{}z|v«}y|�ouW��{¨z�p©�|u4p � u�u]µH�¼nvD~�z��<u²n©u�u�zh¹|z|�o{}z_��p©�_u!w]�op©{}t²~�«5n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxzht!uW~�z|n0~�vwxt!�_«}u³h�_{}nsv � upsu�w]�op©{}t!{.CW~3p©{}wxzhps~]n®°BÌ�n®p©{}«¨«§'�|u�z�p©�_uº�qw]{¨zAp¼�o{¦nqp � {}�_yops{¨w]z�ps~�°]uDnº~!n®{}t!�_«}l�¬­w � t�«}{¨°]u = �'? µ

¶·z8p©�|uº¬­wx«}«¨w3§'{}z_�|Ì�~e�_uDy � {}n®p©{¦v�� � u�uD�_l�~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t�{¦nY� � wx�Uw]n©uD��p©we¹|z|�!~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psuD��n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n�µ��u�z|w�p©uT/$#Pps�_u$n®u�p!wx¬�p©�|u$�_uDn®p©{}z|~3ps{¨w]z|n�§'�|{}v�� ~ � u�n®p©{}«¨«ºz_wxp�vwxz|z_uDvp©uD� p©w�p©�_uÂn©�|~�z|z_{¨z|�Àp � u�u� + -0/ 1 3 ?4Y�Uu�{}z_��y_z<�ou � v�wxz|n®p � y|vp©{}wxz�µ�¶·z²w � �ou � psw � uD�x{¦nqpsu � ps�_u�u�z<�m¾Lpsw�¾Óu�z|�!�ouD«}~:l]Ì]~0§�u�{}�x�ApML&%{¦n¼~]n©n©wov{¦~3psuD�Pp©w�uW~xv��Âz_wo�ou(' S / ´µ ¤ �|{}n¼§¸uD{¨�]�]p�{}n�v�~�«¦vy|«}~�p©uD�$~]nºp©�_u8n®y|t wx¬�ps�_u�t!uW~�z$ª3~�«}y_uDn~xz|��ª:~ � {¦~�z<vuDnº~x«¨w]z_�8p©�_u4�|~�p©�$vw]z_z_uDvp©{}z_�8p©�_u4z|wm�_u)'8p©w8p©�_u�n©wxy � v�u�z_wo�ou 9�{¨z � + - / [1 3 >4[�

L % + 3VWBX Y[Z ��* ^,+>a *>d � VDW�X Y[Z,+ �VWBX Y[Z¤ �_u�~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t §�w � °mnº~]n�¬­wx«}«¨w3§�n<��xµ.-�~�«¦vy_«¦~3psuep©�_u4«}{¨z|°Pt!uD~]n®y � uDnº~]n 5 VWBX Y[Z + � VWBX Y[Z + 3*9 U�VWBX Y[Z FAÌ0/�-JIK1?L�4�ST3g �oµ�kmup�/$#�+:9 :<=�1?@�+ AB1�CDCCD1�> F4~�z|�T/ �+ 9=9�F]Ìo§'�|u � u)94{}nºps�_u�n©u�z|�ou � z_wo�ou4~�z|�!L�1 +32 : µ�S�{¨z|� n©�_w � p©uWnqp8�|~3ps�|n�¬ � w]t uD~xv��>t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp!z_wo�ou :<=*S /4#Pp©wÁuD~]v��>z_wo�ou�5 S:/ 4w�¬�p©�_uvy �s� u�zAp©«}lPvw]z|n®p � y|v´psuD�Pp � u�u76

V # . X 8 Z ����� ���! #"* 3VWBX Y[Z ��* 56VWBX Y[Z:9 =Y ?

�|µ�kmu�«}uDvp'p©�_u�n©�_w � psuDn®pºw]z_u6V # .<; X 8 ; Z � ����� �! "4# . �0= - X 8 �0=?> 9bL 8 +A@ VWBX Y[Z ��* ^,- . a B d 56VWBX Y[Z FB

�oµ'�'�_��uD~xv���z_wo�ouC'e{}z|v«}y|�ouW��{}z 6 V # .D; X 8 ; Z p©w�/ = / �+ / FE 9�' F ? §'{»ps��ps�_uºv�~�«¦vy|«}~�p©uD��§¸uD{¨�]�ApL&% +:L 8 ;G+H@ VWBX Y[Z ��* ^�* a B ; d - � VWBX Y[ZI+ �VDW�X Y[Z 4Ì/§'�_u � u

6V # .D; X 8 ; Z + 6

V # .<; X % Z E 6V % X 8 ; Z µe�'�|�

p©�_u4uW�o�xuWnºw�¬�p©�_u4�<~3p©�6V # . ; X 8 ; Z p©wg3

U_µ�kmup�/$#)� + /$# < 9 :<= ; FB ö���÷�öðù

Page 12: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� Y

� µº¶Ó¬ i / # i��+328p©�_uDz$�xw�p©w�n®p©u�� : ��n'v�~�z��Uu0n©u�uDz�Ìmp©�|ue�|u�y � {}n®p©{¦v�p � {¨uWn¸p©w²~:ªxw]{}��n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n��|~:ªm{¨z_�8«¦~ � �xu¼uDz|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|�P�ouD«}~:lonº~�z<�

v�wxt!t!wxz�«¨{}z_°onº§'{»ps��«¦~ � �xueª3~ � {}~xz|vuWn�µY���|�_«¨lm{}z_�8p©�_u Q u�«}«}t!~xzo¾3S_w � �P~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t p©�|ue�|u�y � {}n®p©{¦ve�|~xn- > � + > 4�i 3 i-�i / i 7 A�4��&�8v�wxt!�_«}u³o{»pql]µ� ������� ��� Ä  3¡ � � � È��   Ä�� �ã  Ä � Ä �B�K¼zo¬­w � p©y|z|~3psu�«}lxÌN{¨p�{¦n4~�ª]u � lÀ�|~ � �hps~]n®°Âpsw�¹|z|��p©�_u²w]�op©{}t²~�«Hn©wx«}yops{¨w]z�wx¬ =­� ? Ì��<uWv�~�y<n®u!ps�_u!ps~]n®°wx¬�¹<z|�o{}z_� � �hk ¤ n�{¦n�~ Ê � �|~ � ��� � w]�_«}u�t ~x« � uD~]�ol�{}z�p©�_u�vD~xn©u0w�¬5�oupsu � t8{}z_{¦nqps{}v�«¨{}z_°Pt!uW~xn©y � uWn�µ¤ �|u�t!w]n®p�~3p©p � ~xv´ps{¨ª]u²§�~:lhp©wÀt²~x°xu!p©�|uPw � {}�x{}z|~�« Ê � �|~ � �Á� � wx�_«}u�t =­� ? p©wh�<uPp � ~xv´p�~��_«}u²{¦n4p©w� uD�_y|vu0{¨p'p©w8p©�_u0p�~xn©°�w�¬�¹|z|�o{}z_� � ��k ¤ �<~xn©uD��wxz$�oupsu � t8{}z_{¦nqps{}v0«}{}z_°Pt!uD~]n®y � uWn�~xz|�Pp � l²p©w!¹|z<�n©y_�Uwx�ops{¨t²~x«�n®w]«¨yops{¨w]zP¬­w � p©�_u4w � {}�x{}z|~x«U� � w]�_«¨uDt$µ,¸Ä � � ¡ � . � ���+J���2���A���21&���H% #/, #7�)%B#$�H�# ��� � # $�������������� 5 0 $�2&*�'�"!�#8�*, ,H��� �B�� #�%�!�� $��� � �����W���� �4�,H��� !7�.#$+ ����������� #J% #7�3#$��+J��� � ����J+8#��� ����*#� �� � ��A�'�)#�%��3�8������1 -QIP1�LR4 !�#7���2�

56VWBX Y[Z +�� VWBX Y[Z -/9b4M+��63g9 � 1 ]?^`_ba c?d F�Z���6� 53B ¤ �_udw � {}�x{}z|~�« � wxy_p©{}z_�ºps~]n®°0v�~xz4�<u5p � ~xz|n®¬­w � t8uW��p©w¼~ºp�~�{}«xuWnqps{¨t²~3ps{¨w]z4� � wx�_«}u�t �ml � u�§ � {»ps{¨z|�{}zAp©w ��� ���� � �������! "� fg- 3VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $�� 4§'�|{}v��²~�«}«}w3§�n5y|nYpsw�y|n©u�§¸uD«¨«|°Az|w3§'z!n®ps~�p©{¦nqps{}vD~�«_{}z_uW½]y<~�«}{»ps{¨uWn�µ Q l�~x�_�_«}lA{}z_�0ps�_u -¸�_u � z_wB@�{}z_uD½Ay|~x«»¾{¨pql²ps�_u4«}~�p®psu � � � wx�|~x�_{}«¨{¨pqlPv�~xz��Uu4y_�_�Uu � ¾Ó�<w]y_z|�ouW�

fg- 3VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $�� 4� � � 1 V 1 Z 1�� =®�D� ?

§'�|u � u�� � -49�4 =D/�9 $ 2 ? {}n�ps�_u4«¨w]��¾Ót!wxt!u�zAp¸�]u�z_u � ~�p©{}z_��¬­y_z|v´ps{¨w]z$w�¬Nps�_u4n®y|t�w�¬�p©�_u4� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨p©{}uDn�]{¨ª]u�z��Al

� � -/9b4�+ 3VWBX Y[Z ��� � VWBX Y[Z -49�4¤ �|u � u¬­w � uxÌmt!{}z_{¨t!{DC�{}z_�!p©�|u4�<w]y_z|�$~xn

� � ���� ���! "� � e��K- 3VWBX Y[Z ��� � VWBX Y[Z -49�4 7 9 � 4 =®�x� ?

ps�_u�w � {¨�]{¨z|~x«H� � wx�|«¨uDt {}n � uW�oy|v�uD�¯pswh¹<z|�¯ps�_u � �hk ¤ §'{¨p©� «¨{}z_°¯t!uD~]n®y � uWn 56VWBX Y[Z +�� VDW�X Y[Z -/9�4´µÍ�µ ��µ ��µ

km{}z|v�u�ps�_u�y|�_�<u � �<w]y_z|�À{}z =®�D� ? �ouD�<uDz|�_n�wxzÀps�_u8ª:~x«¨y|u�w�¬ 9xÌBw]�op©{}t!{.CD{¨z_�Pp©�_{¦neª3~�«}y_u�~��xwmwo�y|�_�<u � �Uwxy_z<�²~�z|�²n©wx«}yop©{}wxz<ndv«}w]n©u � psw4p©�|u�wx�ops{¨t�y_t v�~�z²�Uu�w]�ops~x{¨z_uW�/µ C u�vwxz<n®{¦�ou � p©�_u�w]�op©{}t²~�«ª3~x«¨y_u0wx¬�94~]n�¬­wx«}«¨w3§�n<�

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 13: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

�W� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

9=��� � 3VWBX Y[Z ��� � � VWBX Y[Z -49�4� 9 + �

� !�D* �����0������ �Y%' N������ ¤ w�~xz|~�«}l2C�u4ps�_u�½Ay|~x«¨{¨p©{}uDn�w�¬5ps�_u!n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z|nev�~�zÂ�Uu!~xv��_{}u�ª]uD�$�ml$y|n®{}z_�Pp � ~x�o{¨p©{}wxz|~x«�~xz|�$p©�|u�z_uD§t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p � w]yop©{}z_�!t!ups�_wo�_n'{¨p�{}nºz_uWvuWn©ns~ � l!p©w!t²~�°]u0n©wxt!u0z_wxps~3ps{¨w]z�µ

� � ��� �$��� ��� �*� � ��� )*��#�� � +���� � � #��'� )�� ��+¤ w!�xuDz_u � ~3psue�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u0t8uW~xn©y � uDn�p©� � uDu4°A{}z|�_n�w�¬Yt�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp'p � uDuDn'~ � u0{¨zAp � wo�oy|v�uD�$~�z<��vD~�«¦vyo¾«¦~3psuD�P¬­w � v�wxt!�|~ � {¦n®w]z�µ�xµ� ������������������� ��� � !#"�$¤ �_u$n®uD«¨uWv´p©{}wxz w�¬�ps�_u�t8u�p©�_wo�_n8y|n©uD� p©w�¹|z|� p©�_uÀÍ4�0k � S�v�wxzo¬­w � t n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n8§�u � uPt!w�¾p©{}ª3~3p©uW�h�mlÀ~xz|~�«}l2C�{}z_��ps�_u��Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u�v�wxy_«¦�À�Uu!wx�op�~�{}z_uD�h{¨zÁ~�v�y �©� u�zAps«¨lÂ~:ª3~�{}«}~x�_«}u � uD~�«Í4�0k � S�u�zmªm{ � wxz|t8uDzApDµ ¤ w�wx�_ps~�{}z0p©�|{}n��<u � ¬­w � t²~xz|vuYps�_ud«}{¨z_°0n®ps~3psuH~x�_ªxu � p©{¦n©u�t!u�zApNn®p � ~3p©uD�xl�ouDnsv � {}�<uW�Â{¨zÀp©�_u8� � u�ªm{¨w]y|n¼n©uDvp©{}wxzÀn©�_wxy|«}�Â�Uu8{¨t!�_«}u�t!u�zApsuD�À~xz|�À~��|� � w]� � {}~�p©u�~�«}�xw � {¨p©�|t!n§'{»ps� «¨w3§�v�wxt!�_«}u³o{¨p©{}uDn²~�z<�>�|~]n®uW� w]z �ou�p©u � t!{}z_{}n®p©{¦v�«¨{}z_° ª3~x«¨y_uWn²n®�|wxy_«¦� �_up©u � t!{}z_u�p©�_u�|~ � p©{¦~�«5n©�|~�z|z_{¨z|�Pp � uDuDnDµ�¶·zÁwxy � n©{¨t�y_«}~�p©{}wxzhp©�_{¦n0°m{¨z|��w�¬�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp0p � uDuDn0~ � u��|y_{¨«¨p4y|n©{¨z_�wxz_u�w�¬Yp©�_u � uD�xy_«¦~ �'� k ¤ v�wxt!�_yop�~3ps{¨w]zÀ~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t²nº�|~]n®uW�$wxz�p©�_u�«}~]nqp�~]�oªxu � ps{}n©uD�!; VWBX Y[Z= w �; VWBX Y[Z=NKO «¨{}z_°Át!uD~xn©y � uDnDµ ¤ �_u�vwxt!�_y_ps~3ps{¨w]z¯w�¬�p©�_u � k ¤ �ouD�<uDz|�_n�wxzÁp©�_u�pqlA�UuPwx¬¸ps�_u$Í�wmk� uW½Ay_{ � u�t!uDz]p�~xz|��ps�_u0¬­wx«}«}w3§'{¨z_�²v�wxt!�_yop�~3p©{}wxz<~�«/vw]z|n®{¦�ou � ~�p©{}wxz|nº~ � u0� � wx�Uw]n©uD�/µ� Q wxp®p©«}u�z|uDv�°²pqlm�Uu4w�¬5Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsn�§'{¨p©�hÍ4�0k � S vw �©� uDn©�<w]z|�²psw8¹|z|�

���%� !#"�$'& ���! "VWBX Y[Z ��� ;VWBX Y[Z= $&%

¶Ó¬ºps�_u � u�~ � u�n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|n0¬­y|«»¹|«}«}{¨z_�Àp©�_{¦n�v�wxz|�o{¨p©{}wxzNÌNps�_u�z±ps�_u�wx�_p©{}t�y_t =ðps�_u²p � u�u²§'{¨p©�t²~�³m{}t²~�«Av�~��<~xv{¨pql ? vw �©� uDn©�<w]z|�_nBpsw�wxz|uHw�¬mps�_u�t$µ ¤ �_udwx�_p©{}t!~x«xp � uDuHv�~xz4�<u�vw]t8�|yop©uW��ml�y<n®{}z_� Q u�«}«¨t²~xzo¾/S|w � ��w � �¼{ �q°onqp � ~!~�«}�xw � {¨p©�|t!n�§'{¨p©�Ât²~3³m¾Ót!{¨z$~�«}�xuD� � ~8~�z<��vD~�z$�<u� � w]�<wAn®uW�P~xn � � � !#"�$ &

���%��!#"�$#& ����� � �!���� ��� �! #"VWBX Y[Z ��� ;VWBX Y[Z=

� �'�|�o{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlm�<u0w�¬Yu�z<�m¾Lpsw�¾Óu�z|�ÂÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzApsnºvw �©� uDn©�<w]z|�²psw8¹|z|�$~8p � u�u��� � !#"�$ ! � �����* ^,+>a -4. d ��021 3VWBX Y[Z ��* ^ + a -/.Qd ;

VWBX Y[Z=DNPO h65

ö���÷�öðù

Page 14: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �]�

§'�|u � u�8 � {¨z<�o{}vD~3psuDnºps�_u�n©up�w�¬5�|~�p©�|n'¬ � w]t�p©�|u�n®w]y � vuep©w²ps�_u��ouWnqps{¨z|~�p©{}wxz|n�{¨z ��µ¸¶Ó¬ps�_u � ud~ � udn©wx«}yop©{}wxz|nDÌDp©�_uDz0p©�_uHn©�_w � psuDn®p��|~3ps�|nBp � u�u5{¦nN~'n©wx«}yops{¨w]z�¬­y|«»¹|«}«}{¨z_��p©�_uHv�wxz|�_{»ps{¨w]z~xz|��vD~�z4uD~]n®{}«}l��Uu¸�ou�p©u � t!{}z_uD�4�mlep©�|u¸n©y_�<u � �Uw]n©{¨p©{}wxz4w�¬|n©�_w � psuDn®pN�|~3ps�|nDµ ¤ �_{¦n�n©�_w � psuDn®p�<~3p©��p � uDu0vD~�z��<u4� � w]�<wAn®uW�P~xn�ps�_u�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz�w�¬5~�Í4�0k � S «}{}°xu4vw]t8�|yops~�p©{}wxz6�

���%� !#"�$ ! � �# . �0=���� 1 ��� � �! #"* . ��0 ^,+>a -4.0d 3VWBX Y[Z ��0 . ;VWBX Y[Z=DNPO

§'�|u � u 8 V 1 X # . Z {¦n5ps�_u�n®u�pHw�¬/�Uw]nsn®{}�_«}u'�|~3ps�|nY¬ � wxt 9'psw): = µZ= C u�n®y_�|�<wAn®uºps�|~3p � � � !#"�$�!{¦n�p©�|u4y_z_{}wxz$w�¬Yn®�_w � psuDn®p'�|~3ps�|n'�Uupq§�u�u�z 9�~xz|�Pp©�_u��o{.@Bu � u�zAp¼�ouDn®p©{}z|~�p©{}wxz|n : = µ ?

� �'�|�o{»ps{¨ª]u¼pqlm�Uu�wx¬Nw3ªxu � ~x«¨«/Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsn¸y|n©{¨z|��~ � uW~�«�Í4�0k � SÁu�zmªm{ � wxz|t8uDzAp�vw � ¾� uDn©�Uwxz|�Pp©w8p©�|u4wx�o�quWv´p©{}ªxu� � � !#"�$�� � 3VWBX Y[Z ��� ;

VWBX Y[Z=DNPO h��

¤ �|u�vw]t!�_yops~�p©{}wxz wx¬'p©�_u��UuDn®p8n©wx«}yop©{}wxz =­p©�_u�t!{¨z|{¨t²~�«ºvwAnqp�p � u�u ? {¦n Ê � ¾¿�<~ � �/Ì5�_yop�|u�y � {}n®p©{¦v�n5vD~�z8�<u'y<n®uW��pswe¹|z|�!~��_� � w:³o{}t!~�p©uW��n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|nDµY� �xwmwo��~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3ps{¨w]z�v�~xz�Uu'¬­w]y_z|��¬­w � u�³_~�t!�_«}u��ml�y|n®{}z_�0ps�_u T�wxy!~�z|� ¤ ~�°3~��|~]n®�|{»¾·�À~3p�n®y|l]~�t²~¼�_u�y � {¦nqps{}vDn�µ S�{»¾z<~�«}«¨l!{}z�wxy � n®{}t�y|«}~�p©{}wxz � �%��!#"�$�� {}n�~�zP~x�_� � w:³o{¨t²~3psu�n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz�wx¬/p©�_uevw �s� uDn©�<w]z|�o{}z_�kmp©u�{}z_u � � � w]�_«}u�t%� ��! �� =�� # ������� �! "� ��� 3VWBX Y[Z ��� ;

VDW�X Y[Z=DNPO

¤ �_u!� � wx�Uw]n©uD�h~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n¼�<~:ªA{}z_��«¨w3§ v�wxt!�_«}u³o{¨p©{}uDn4vw]t!�_yop©u�p©�|u!n©�|~xz_z_{}z_�Pp � uDuDn0�|~]n®uW�wxz�p©�|u�~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®uW��«}{¨z_°�t!uD~xn©y � uDn ; VWBX Y[Z= =­�Uw�p®ps«¨uDz_uDv�°�pqlA�Uu ? w � ; VWBX Y[Z=NKO =L~x�_�_{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlA�Uu ? µ

�oµ� ����� ��� ����� ����� � ���%� �� ������� � ��������������� ���� �����op©{}t²~�«Nn©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n�~3p'ps�_u0p©{}t!u�{}z|nqp�~�zAp�w�¬�p©�|u � w]yop©{}z_� � uW½Ay_uDn®p¼v�~xz��Uu��ou�p©u � t!{¨z|uD��y|n©{¨z_�p©�_u!u�³o~]v´p��U�VDW�X Y[Z «¨{}z_°Àª3~x«¨y_uWn�µ ¤ �_uDn©u8ª:~x«¨y|uDn0~ � u�°mz_w3§'z�wxz_«}lÀªm{¦~�n©{¨t�y_«¦~3p©{}wxzÁ~�z|��v�~xz_z_w�p�<u4~:ª3~�{}«¦~��_«}u¼{}z�~ � uW~�«Bz_u�pq§¸w � °m{}z_��u�zmªm{ � w]z_t!u�zApDµ�K¼n©{}z_��ps�_u0n®{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]zPt!ups�_wo�P§�u�~:ª]wx{¦�p©�_uez_uWvuDnsn©{»pql8w�¬�y|n©{}z_��u³o�|~xy|n®p©{}ªxu¼n©uD~ � v��!psw��ou�p©u � t!{¨z|u�p©�|u¼wx�_p©{}t!~x«Un©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n�Ì]§'�_{¦v��Pv�~xz¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«�p©�|u�vw]z|�o{¨p©{}wxz|nJ=L� ? ÌN= : ? ~xz|��=­� ? µº¶Ó¬Yp©�_u � u�~ � u�n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n�~3p'ps�_u�ps{¨t!u�{}z|n®ps~xz]p�w�¬Yp©�_u� uW½Ay_uDn®pDÌ]p©�_uDz�ps�_u�w]�op©{}t²~�«Bn®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|n¸~ � u�v�~xz|�o{¦�_~3psuDndp©w�¬­y|«»¹|«}«Bp©�|u0Í�wAk�vwxz<�o{»ps{¨w]z|nDµ ¤ �_uWn®uwx�ops{¨t²~x«<n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|nH~ � u�y<n®uW�!{¨z²w]y � ~�z<~�«}l�CDu�p©w�v�wxt!�|~ � uº§'{»ps�!p©�_u0Í4�0k � S��|~xn©uD�!n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n~�z|��§'{¨p©��p©�_u4n©wx«}yop©{}wxz<n¸� � w]�<wAn®uW��{}zPps�_{}nº�<~��Uu � µ ¤ �|u0v�wxt!�_yop�~3ps{¨w]z�wx¬Np©�|ue{}z|n®ps~xz]p�~�z_uDwxy|nwx�ops{¨t²~x«Nn®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|nº�ouD�<uDz|�_n'w]z�ps�_u�Í�wAk � uW½Ay_{ � u�t!uDz]pWµ� Q wxp®p©«}u�z|uDv�°²pqlm�Uu4w�¬5Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zAp<�

� �� �� & ������� ���������� � #"VWBX Y[Z ��� �U�VWBX Y[Z

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 15: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

�:� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

� �'�|�o{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlm�<u0w�¬Yu�z<�m¾Lpsw�¾Óu�z|�ÂÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp<�� �� � ! � �# . �0=�� � 1 ��� � � #"* . ��0 ^ + a -/.Qd 3VWBX Y[Z ��0 . �U�VWBX Y[Z

� �'�|�o{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlm�<u0w�¬Yw3ªxu � ~x«¨«�Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp<�� �� �� � � ����� � #"����� 3VWBX Y[Z ��� �U�VWBX Y[Z

¤ �|{}n¼wx�ops{¨t²~�«�n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz${}n�p � {¨uW��p©w��Uu4¬­w]y_z|�Â�mlPy<n®{}z_��u�³m�<~�y|n®p©{}ªxu�n©uD~ � v��"=­�ml�wxz_u�wx¬ps�_u�kApsu�{}z_u � ¤ � uDu �dzmy_t!u � ~3p©{}wxzÂ�¼«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n ? µ

: µ� ����� � � �� ����� � � ��� ��� ����� � � 1 W�� ���S_w � ps�_u�p©� � u�u�Í�wAkhv � {»psu � {¨w]z|n�~xz|~�«}l2C�uW�Â�_u � u!�o{A@Bu � u�zAp4~��_� � w:³o{}t!~�p©uW�Ân®w]«¨yops{¨w]z|n0~ � u�� � w�¾�<wAn®uW�${¨zhkouDv´ps{¨w]z : ps~�°m{}z_�²{}z]pswP~xvDvw]y_zAp�ps�_u�y_z<vu � ps~x{¨zApql�w�¬Yp©�_u�«¨{}z_°Pª3~x«¨y_uWn�µZS�{¨z<~�«}«¨l�p©�_un®uD«¨uWv´ps{¨w]z�wx¬|p©�|u'� � w]�<wAn®uW��~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²nN§�u � uºt8wxp©{}ª3~3p©uW���ml�~xz|~�«}l2C�{}z_��p©�_uº�Uu � ¬­w � t!~xz|vuº~�z<�p©�_u4v�wxt!�_«}u³o{»pql²wx¬�p©�|u0~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n�µ�¶·z � uD~x« � w]yop©{}z_��uDzmªA{ � wxz_t!u�zAp�wxz_«}l�~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t²n¸�|~:ªm{¨z|�«¨w3§ vw]t8�|«¨u�³m{¨pqlPvD~�z��<u4y|n©uD��µ� S|w � �Uw�p©p©«}u�z_uWv�°Àpqlm�<u²wx¬�Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsn�ps�_u!p � u�u�~x«¨«}w3§'{¨z|�Pps�_u²t²~3³o{¨t²~x«5� � w]�|~3¾�|{¨«}{»pql�w�¬�p©�|u�~xn©°xuW�ÂÍ�wmk�ª:~x«¨y|u�vw �s� uDn©�<w]z|�_n�p©w!ps�_u�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz$wx¬�ps�_u�kApsu�{}z_u � � � wx�_«}u�t§'{¨p©�Â�ou�p©u � t!{}z_{}n®p©{¦v0«}{¨z_°Pt8uW~xn©y � uDn 56VWBX Y[Z + 7 9 ;���fg- U�VDW�X Y[Z $&% 4µ¶·z � uW~�«¸vD~xn©uDn�~�z ~��|� � w:³o{}t²~3p©uW�±n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z � 1 W�� ��� &²vD~�z¯�Uu�v�wxt!�_yopsuD� �mlÁy|n©{¨z_�hp©�_uT�wxy"=ãv¬qµ�E ��F ? ~xz|�Pp©�_u ¤ ~�°3~��<~xn©�_{»¾·�À~�psn©y_l]~xt!~&=ãv´¬qµ E U�F ? �_uDy � {¦n®p©{¦v4~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t²nDµ

� S|w � ~x�_�o{¨p©{}ªxu pqlA�Uu wx¬�u�z|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|� Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApsn�~�z ~��|� � w:³o{}t²~3p©uW� n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z�,1 W�� � � ! {}n��_y_{}«»p8§'{»ps�¯p©�|u��_u�«}� wx¬�ps�_uP� � uDuD�ol�t!up©�|wm�>�ouDnsv � {¨�UuD�±{}z kmuWv´ps{¨w]z : µÞ�oµ}�y<n®{}z_�!«¨{}z_°�ª:~x«¨y|uDn 56VWBX Y[Z + � VDW�X Y[Z,+ �VWBX Y[Z µ� S|w � ~]�_�o{¨p©{}ªxu'pqlm�Uu¼wx¬Bw3ª]u � ~�«}«<Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzApH~�z²y_�_�Uu � ¾Ó�<w]y_z|�²v�~xz²�<u¼wx�op�~�{}z_uD�!�ml¹<z|�o{}z_�8p©�_u�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz�w�¬�p©�_u�kApsu�{}z_u � � � w]�_«}u�t §'{¨p©�$«¨{}z_°�t!uW~xn©y � uWn 5 VWBX Y[Z + � VDW�X Y[Z -/9�4´µ¶·z � uD~x« � w]yop©{}z_�!u�zmªm{ � wxz|t8uDzAp'~xz�~x�_� � w:³o{¨t²~3psuD��n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz � 1 W�� � �� � v�~�z��Uu�vw]t8�|yop©uW��ml�y<n®{}z_�8p©�_u T�wxy$~�z<��ps�_u ¤ ~x°3~��|~]n®�_{¨¾·�À~3p�n®y_lA~�t²~�~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n�µ

Ê wxp©u%�0ko{¨z|v�u8p©�_u � w]yop©{}z_��� � wx�_«}u�t²ne{¨zÁ{}z|vw]t8�|«¨u�p©u8«¨{}z_°hn®ps~�p©u8u�zmªm{ � wxz_t!uDz]p4~ � u � uD�_y|vuW�p©w wx�ops{¨t!{DCD~3ps{¨w]z ps~]n®°onP�|~xn©uD� w]z 5 VDW�X Y[Z �_up©u � t!{}z_{¦nqps{}vh«¨{}z_° ª3~�«}y_uDnPy|n®{}z_�>p©�_u�� � w]�<wAn®uW�n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|nD̺p©�_uh� � w]�|~��|{¨«}{}n®p©{¦v$«}{¨z_° t!uD~]n®y � u U�VDW�X Y[Z vD~�z �Uuh�|~xz|�o«}uD� «}wmvD~�«}«¨l =­w]z_«¨l {}z p©�_u� w]yop©u � ~x�oª]u � p©{¦n®{}z_� 5 VDW�X Y[Z {¨¬�{¨p�{}nº�Uw]nsn©{¨�_«}u ? µ

� ��� �:� )� �!)�% � � � �>%'��� +'��)���+¤ �|u'�<u � ¬­w � t²~�z<vu�~�z<~�«}lmn©{¦nY{}nd¬­wmv�y|n©uD�!wxz8ps�_u¼vw]t!�|~ � {}n©wxz8w�¬Bps�_u¼½Ay|~�«}{¨p©{}uDn5wx¬<ps�_u�n©�|~�z|z_{¨z|�0p � u�uDn� � � !#"�$ . ~xz|� � 1 W�� � �� . §'{¨p©�$ps�_u�½Ay|~�«}{¨p©{}uDn'wx¬�ps�_u�wx�_p©{}t!~x«Nn©�|~�z_z|{¨z_�8p � uDuDn � � � . ~3p'ps�_u�t!wxt!uDz]pwx¬�p©�|u � wxy_p©{}z_� � uD½Ay_uWnqpWµ ¤ w8uD~xv��Pp � u�u��J~WMv�w]n®p¸ª3~�«}y_u�M L - ��4H�|~xn��Uu�uDz�~]n©n©{¨�]z_uD�Pvw �s� uDn©�<w]z|�o{}z_�

ö���÷�öðù

Page 16: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� � :

pswep©�_u�v � {¨p©{¦v�~x«oª:~x«¨y|u¸¬ � wxt p©�_u'�Uwx{}zApdw�¬<ªm{}u�§ w�¬Up©�_u�Í�wmk�v � {¨p©u � {}wxz�µ ¤ w4vw]t!�|~ � uxÌ3ps�_{¦n5vw]n®p5ª3~�«}y_uDn~ � u²�<~xn©uD�±wxz � uD~x«H«}{¨z|°Áª3~x«¨y_uWn�~�p�p©�_u�t!wxt!u�zAp�wx¬'p©�_u � w]yop©{}z_� � uD½Ay_uDn®p�~xz|�¯~ � uPvw]t!�_yop©uW� ~xn¬­w]«¨«}w3§�nDµ�¶·z�p©�|u�v�~xn©u0w�¬

� �<wxp®ps«¨uDz_uDv�°PpqlA�Uu4w�¬�t!up � {¦v�n<�L - ��4M+ �! "VWBX Y[Z ��� �U�VWBX Y[Z

� ~x�_�_{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlA�Uu0w�¬Yt!up � {¦v�nº{}z�uDz|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|�$Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zAp<�L�-;��4M+ �����# . �0=�� � 1 ��� � � #"* . ��0 ^ + a - . d 3VWBX Y[Z ��0 . �U�VWBX Y[Z

� ~x�_�_{»ps{¨ª]u0pqlA�Uu0w�¬Yt!up � {¦v�nº{}z�w3ª]u � ~�«}«/Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zAp<�L - ��4M+ 3VWBX Y[Z ��� �U�VWBX Y[Z

¤ §¸w±t!uD~]n®y � uWn���p©�_uÂt!uW~xn©y � uWn�� �%��! "%$ . ~�z|��� 1 W�� � � . ~ � u�{¨zAp � wo�oy|v�uD� �ml>v�~x«}v�y_«}~�p©{}z_�Áp©�_u� ~3ps{¨wAn�wx¬�L - � �%��!#"�$ . 4�~xz|� L�-;� � �� . 4�w � L - � 1 W�� ��� . 48~�z<� L - � � � . 4W=L�o{}ªA{¦�o{}z_�Áp©�_uÂn©t²~�«}«¨u � ª3~x«¨y_u§'{¨p©�hp©�_u8«¦~ � �xu � wxz_u ? µ ¤ �_uWn®u8�Uu � ¬­w � t!~xz|vu�t8uW~xn©y � uDnen®�_w3§ ps�_u � uW~�«Y½]y<~�«}{»ps{¨uWn�wx¬5p©�_u²n©�|~�z|z_{¨z|�p � uDuDn2���%��! "%$ . ~�z|� �,1 W�� � �� . Ì|n©{¨z<vuep©�_uD{ � n'vwAnqp�nº~ � ue~x«}n©w8vD~�«¦vy_«¦~3psuD���|~xn©uD�Pwxz�p©�_u �U�VWBX Y[Z ª3~�«}y_uWn�µ¤ �|u¼�Uup®psu � p©�|u�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n ���%��! "%$ . ~xz|���,1 W�� ��� . ~ � u]Ìxps�_uev�«¨wAn®u � ps�_u¼�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u�t!uD~xn©y � uDnH�xuppsw±�xµ S�{¨z|~x«¨«}lxÌNp©�_u�~:ª]u � ~��]u�ª3~�«}y_uDn �� �%� !#"�$ . ~�z|� �� 1 W�� ��� . ~ � u²v�~x«}v�y_«}~�p©uW�hw3ª]u � ~�zÁu�z|n©u�t��_«}u8wx¬� ~�z<�owxt!«}l²�xu�z|u � ~3p©uW��n©up�nºw�¬Yt�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp'z_wo�ouWn�~�z<�$Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApsnº~xn'�_uDnsv � {¨�UuD��{}z�ps�_u4z_u�³Apn©y_�|n©uDvp©{}wxz�µ

¤ �_u²�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u�t!uD~]n®y � uWne~ � u!v�~x«}v�y_«¦~3p©uW�hy|z|�ou � ps�_u²~xnsn®y|t8�_p©{}wxz�p©�|~�peps�_u�Í�wAk � uW½Ay_{ � u¾t!uDz]p0{¦n�ns~3ps{}n®¹|uD�À�Al�ps�_u8n©�|~xz_z_{}z_��p � uDu�� � uDn©u�zAp©uW�Â{}zÀp©�|u�zmy_t!u � ~3psw � ~�z|�$ps�_u!�ou�z_w]t!{¨z|~�p©w � ~3pps�_u�ns~�t!uep©{}t8u]µ ¤ �_u � u¬­w � u]ÌApq§¸w8pqlm�<uWn'w�¬�u �s� w � n�n©�_wxy_«¦���<u��_{}n®p©{}z_�xy|{}n©�_uD��µ�xµ�� ���� ���� ��% #7��� ������� ��p©�|uen©wx«}yop©{}wxz ���%� !#"�$ . =ã�|~xn©uD�Pwxz ; VDW�X Y[Z= t8uW~xn©y � uDn ? ~�z<� G�w � � 1 W�� � �� .

=­�|~]n®uW�hw]z 56VWBX Y[Z t!uW~xn©y � uWn ? n®uDu�t²n0z_wxpepsw�ns~3ps{}n®¬­lÂps�_uPÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApDÌ/§'�|{¨«}u8p©�_u²vw � ¾� uWn®�Uwxz<�o{¨z|��� � �� . ns~3ps{}n®¹|uWnºp©�|~�pDµ¸¶·z$p©�_{¦n¼vD~xn©u�ps�_u � u4{¦n¼~3p�«}uD~]nqp�w]z_u0p � u�u4§'�|u � u0p©�_u4p � ~'I�vO w3§Jv�wxy_«¦���<u � wxy_p©uD���_yop'ps�_u0p � ~�I�ve{¦nºz_w�p'p � ~xz|n®t!{¨p®psuD� =­«}w3§Jz_u�pq§¸w � °²y_p©{}«¨{DCD~�p©{}wxz ? µ

�oµ� #*��'�H%� �*%B#$��� ������� �/ps�_uºn®w]«¨yops{¨w]z ���%��! "%$ . =ã�|~xn©uD�4w]z ; VWBX Y[Z= t!uD~]n®y � uWn ? ~xz|�>G'w � � 1 W�� � �� .=­�|~]n®uW�4wxz 56VWBX Y[Z t!uD~]n®y � uWn ? n©u�uDt!nNp©w�n©~�p©{¦nq¬­lep©�|uºÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApDÌ:§'�_{}«}udp©�|u � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp~xvp©y|~x«¨«}lÀ{¦n4z_w�p�ns~3ps{}n®¹|uW��~x«¨w]z_��p©�_{¦n�n©�|~�z_z|{¨z_��p � uDuW=ã�|~xn©uD�Áw]z �U VWBX Y[Z t!uD~xn©y � uDn ? µ²¶·zÁp©�|{}nv�~]n®uºps�_uºp � ~�I�v O w3§ {}n � wxy_p©uD�8w3ª]u � ~4n®�<~�z_z_{}z_�ep � u�u'§'�|{}v��!ªm{¨w]«}~�p©uWn�p©�_ueÍ�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApDµ

ko{¨z|v�u�p©�_u'n©uDvw]z|��w � �_u � u �s� w � n�~ � u¸t!w � uºv � y|v{¦~�«m{}z²Í�wmk�v�wxt!t�y_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxz�{»pdn©�_wxy|«}���<uºuD«¨{}t!{¨z|~�p©uW�{¨¬Y{»p�n � ~�p©{}w8vD~�z_z|w�p'�<u�v�wxzAp � wx«}«}uD�/µ

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 17: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

�D� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

S�{}�xy � u!��� 4)� #0�H#$��� ����1��/��, �'�.����� � 5 .�� ��� 4 �'�H% ���9 4+8� %�� �����������

� � � ���(��� ��)����*����� � � !#��+ � ��� + #$% � ��� ��#�!� ��� ) � %'�(�*� )�+¤ w��<u � ¬­w � t¥ps�_u²n®{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]zhw3ª]u �¼� uD~x«Yz_upq§�w � °Â�o{¨t!uDz|n®{}wxz<n¼ps�_u²� Ê k Ê � ¤ �|~]v�°A�Uwxz|u�p©w]�<w]«¨w]�xl§º~xn�y|n®uW��E}��ÌB��F¿µ'¶Óp�n�v�wxz_z|uDv´ps{¨ªm{¨pql�§º~xn¼{¨t!� � w3ªxuW��¬­w � uDz|n©y � {}z_�!ps�_u�u�³m{¦n®p©u�z<vu�wx¬5t�y_«¨p©{}�_«}u��|~�p©�|n�Uupq§�u�uDz�uD~]v��4z_wo�ouH�<~�{ � =Ln®uDu E}�D��F ? µ ¤ w¼�xupY~ � uD~x«¨{¦nqps{}vdªA{}u�§ ~x�<w]yopNps�_u�wx�Uu � ~3p©{}wxz4wx¬op©�_u¸t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp� wxy_p©{}z_�!t8u�p©�_wo�_nDÌmp©�|u0¬­wx«}«¨w3§'{}z_�²vw]z|n®{¦�ou � ~�p©{}wxz|n¸§¸u � uep�~�°xuDz�{}zAp©w²~xvDvw]y_zApDµ

¶·zÂw � �ou � p©w²{}«¨«}y|n®p � ~3psu�ps�_u�{}t!�|~xvp�w�¬�p©�_u�� � ~xzmy_«}~ � {¨pql²w�¬HÍ4�0k � S>t!uD~xn©y � u�t!u�zApºp©uWv��_z_w]«¨w]�xlxÌps� � u�u��_{A@Bu � u�zAp¸� � {¦�_n =ðps� � uDu��o{.@Bu � u�zAp¸ª3~�«}y_uWnHwx¬6; =NPO 7 ; = ? §¸u � u�y<n®uW�!¬­w � uD~]v���u�zmªm{ � wxz|t8uDzApDµ S_w �uW~xv�� � wxy_p©{}z_��t!ups�_wo� � +�&2�2 � w]yop©{}z_� � uD½Ay_uWnqp�nN§�u � ud�]u�z_u � ~�p©uD��~�z|� � u��UuD~�p©uW�0¬­w � uD~]v��4ª3~�«}y_u¸wx¬;>=DNPO*7 ;>=©µ ¤ �|u¸t�y_«»ps{}vD~xn®p�� � w]y_��t!u�t��<u � n�§¸u � u¸n®uD«¨uWv´p©uW� � ~�z|�_wxt!«¨l8=q�W�'¾��x��t8uDt��Uu � nN�Uu � � � w]y_� ? µ¤ �|u�«}{}z_°>ª3~�«}y_uWn!§¸u � uÂ�ou�p©u � t!{¨z|uD� � ~xz|�owxt!«}l {}z pq§�w±nqpsu��|n<�À~3p�~Á¹<n®p!p©{}t8u$ps�_u� ; VWBX Y[Z= 1?; VWBX Y[Z=DNPO �{}zAp©u � ª3~�«�w�¬Hp©�_uPÍ4�0k � S � � {¦�§º~xnen®uD«¨uWv´psuD�Ày<n®{}z_��y_z_{¨¬­w � tË�o{}n®p � {}�_yop©{}wxzNÌ�~�z|��~3p4~�n©uDv�wxz|�$ps{¨t!ups�_uPª3~x«¨y_uPw�¬'p©�|uP«}{¨z_°¯�ouWn©v � {}�opsw � §º~xn��xu�z|u � ~3p©uW� � ~xz|�owxt!«}l�{}z� ; VWBX Y[Z= 1?; VWBX Y[Z=DNPO � ~xvDvw � �o{}z_�$p©whp©�_uv�wxz|�_{»ps{¨w]z|~�«|�_{}n®p � {¨�|yop©{}wxz|n \ V = ZVDW�X Y[Z -Je�4dw�¬ ¤ ~��_«}u��xµ�¶·z!p©�|u�v�~]n®u'wx¬/u�z|�m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|�PÍ�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApd§¸uv�wxz|n©{¦�ou � z_w � t²~�«��_{}n®p � {¨�|yop©{}wxz�Ìo§'{¨p©�

� = VWBX Y[Z � ; VWBX Y[Z= + ; VDW�X Y[Z=DNPO�~xz|�

=VWBX Y[Z � � ^`_ba c?d.�� & ^ _ba c?d.

A� �&� �

^���� � . ^`_ba c?d d !!�� ! � e + A�7��§'�|u � u�� +H2 C 2���{¦n � �<w]�|n®wmuW��¬­w � p©�_u�n©{¨t�y_«¦~3p©{}wxzNµ

¤ �_u�n©{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]z��|~ � ~xt!up©u � n�§�u � u��]u�z_u � ~�p©uW��~]n¸«}{¦nqpsuD��{¨z ¤ ~��_«}u!�xµ

ö���÷�öðù

Page 18: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �:�

Ê ~xt8u � ~ � ~xt8u�p©u � ¤ lm�<u �d~�«}y_uÍ�wAk % �<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� y�µd�/µ5{}z"E �|µ¨�0�Â�_{¨p�G�n�Ì�� : �Â�_{¨p�G3n F5 �ouD«}~:l y�µd�/µ5{}z"E : ��t²nDÌ��6U]��t²n F

� vwAnqp y�µd�/µ5{}z"E : �_Ì|���]��F��{}z_°�ª3~x«¨y_u U WBX Y �<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� y�µd��µ5{¨z"E �8�À�_{»p7G3nDÌ��W���Â�_{¨p�G�n F

�ouD«}~:l y�µd��µ5{¨z"E ��t²nDÌ<����t²n FvwAnqp y�µ �/µ5{¨z"E �_Ì/�W��F

�¼{¦nqp � {}�_yops{¨w]z \ V = ZVWBX Y[Z -Qe�4 �<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� y�µd�/µ5{}z ; VWBX Y[Z= 1�; VWBX Y[Z=NKO ��ouD«}~:l z|w � t!~x«/�/µ5{¨z ; VWBX Y[Z= 1?; VWBX Y[Z=DNPO �vwAnqp y�µ ��µ5{¨z ; VWBX Y[Z= 1?; VWBX Y[Z=DNPO �� � {}� ; VWBX Y[Z=DNPO 7 ; VDW�X Y[Z= �<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� �_Ì|�oÌ��W���À�_{»p7G3n�ouD«}~:l : Ì��D�|Ìo�x�8t!nvwAnqp : Ì|�oÌ �

¤ ~x�_«}u8�B� ��+>���.���������, �'����+ #7�3#$�� 0/��A�% A �*#57#$�� �/� ��� � 57����+ %�� ������!7�������� 2� � � ��#% � ���@��# �!� )���+'� � ��+¤ �|u¼¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{¨z|� � uDn©y_«¨psn�n®�_w3§ p©�_u0�Uu � ¬­w � t!~xz|vue~�z|���ouDnsv � {}�<u�p©�_ue¹ � n®pº~xz|��n©uDv�wxz|��w � �ou � u �s� w � wx¬uW~xv�� � w]yop©{}z_�8t!up©�|wm�$~�¬ðp©u � ���x� � wxyops{¨z_� � uD½Ay_uDn®psnDµ

� ��� � - � È ��� � Ä � Ä ¢��>� Å��HÄhÈ � È��   Ä�� �ã  Ä � Ä �B�W�!¢x¡_� Ķ·z S�{}�xy � u���p©�_uº¹ � n®pHvwx«}y_t!z²n®�|w3§�n�p©�_u�ª3~x«¨y_uºwx¬<ps�_u��Uu � ¬­w � t!~xz|vuºt!uD~]n®y � u��� � � !#"�$ &3Ìx§'�_{}«}u'p©�_un©uDv�wxz|�²~xz|�!ps�_{ � �²w]z_uDn¸n®�_w3§ ps�_u¼ª3~x«¨y_u�w�¬ �� 1 W�� � �� &'�ouD�<uDz|�o{}z_��w]z�§'�_u�p©�_u � p©�|u�w]�op©{}t²~�«Bn®w]«¨yops{¨w]z=¿� ? §�u � u0~x�_� � w:³o{¨t²~3psuD�Py|n®{}z_�8p©�|u T¼w]y�w � ps�_u ¤ ~�°3~��|~]n®�|{»¾·�À~3p�n®y|l]~�t²~�~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t²nDµ¶Óp�vD~�z$�Uu�n®uDu�z$ps�|~3p¼n©wx«}yop©{}wxz<n'§'{»ps�Â�_{}�x�_u � p©� � wxy|�x�_�_y_p¼v�~�z$�Uu�wx�_ps~�{}z_uW�$�Al�y|n©{¨z_�!ps�_u�z_uD§

~x�_� � w:³o{¨t²~3ps{¨w]zht!ups�_wo�/µ �H~]v��±t8uW~xn©y � u!�_uDv � uD~]n®uWne§'�_u�z ; =DNPO 7 ; = {}z|v � uD~]n®uWn�ÌN�_yop�ps�_u²�<u � ¬­w � ¾t²~xz|vu!t!uD~]n®y � uDn0wx¬ �� 1 W�� � �� &�p©uDz|�_n0psw�C�u � wÂn®«}w3§'«}l$p©�|~xz �� �%� !#"�$ &!~�z<�Àps�_u � uD«}~�p©{}ªxu²�o{.@Uu � uDz|vu�Uupq§�u�uDzPps�_u�t {}z|v � uD~]n®uWn�µ�¶Óp�{}n�w � {¨�]{¨z|~�p©uW�²¬ � wxt ps�_u0¬ã~xvp'p©�|~�p�{¨z|v � uW~xn©{¨z|� ; =DNPO 7 ; = p©�|u�Í4�0k � S«}{}z_° t!uD~]n®y � u%; VWBX Y[Z= vD~�z �<uÂt!w � u�¬ã~ � ¬ � wxt ps�_uÀ~xvp©y|~x«'ª3~�«}y_uÂw�¬�p©�_uÀ~:ª3~�{}«¦~��_«}u��<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps� wx¬ps�_u4«}{¨z_°H-JIK1?L�4´Ì|n©w8p©�_u�n©�|~xz_z_{}z_�8p � u�u4v�~x«}v�y_«}~�p©uW�P�|~]n®uW�Pw]zPps�_{¦n'{¨t!� � uDv�{}n©u0«¨{}z_°�t8uW~xn©y � u8=ã§'�_{¦v��y|z|�ou � uDn®p©{}t²~3psuDnep©�|uP~:ª3~�{}«}~x�_«¨u8�|~xz|�o§'{¦�mp©� ? t!~:l�lm{¨«¦� � uWn®y_«¨psn0�<~:ªA{}z_�$«}w3§ ½Ay|~x«¨{¨pqlxµ ¤ �_u � uW~xn©wxz§'�ml$ps�_u�«}{}z_°Ât!uD~xn©y � uDn�; VWBX Y[Z= =L~�z|�hz_w�p ; VWBX Y[Z=NKO ? ~ � u�n©u�«}uDv´psuD�Àp©w$v�~�«¦vy|«}~�p©u � � � !#"�$ &�{¦n¼psw�~:ª]wx{¦�ps�_u4n®uWvw]z|�Pw � �_u � u �s� w � nDµYko{¨z|v�u ; VWBX Y[Z= y_z|�_u � uDn®p©{}t!~�p©uWn�p©�_u4~:ª3~�{}«}~x�_«}u�«}{¨z|°��|~�z<�o§'{}�op©�$z_w²n®uWvw]z|�w � �_u � u �s� w � n¸~ � u�wov�v�y �s� uW�/Ì]�|yop'p©�_u � ~3ps{¨w�w�¬Nps�_ue¹ � nqpºw � �ou � u �s� w � nd{¦nºªxu � l!�_{}�x�"=­uxµ �|µº�W��� §'�_uDz;>=DNPO�7H;>=M+ � >� @ ;���9 � � ? µ ¤ �_u � u�¬­w � uxÌops�_u�z_u�pq§¸w � °�v�~xz_z_w�p��<u�y|n®uW�$u7@BuDvp©{}ªxu�«}l�§'�_u�zÀz|wPn®uWvw]z|�w � �_u � u �s� w � n8~ � uPpswx«}u � ~3psuD�/µ ¤ �|u��|{¨�]� � ~3ps{¨wÁw�¬�p©�_u�¹ � nqp!w � �ou � u �©� w � n�vD~�z �<u$uD«¨{}t!{¨z|~�p©uW�>�ml

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 19: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

� U � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

The performance of the multicast routing methods based on

bottleneck type of QoS requirements

0,086

0,000

0,646

0,848

0,394

0,617

0,406

0,630

0,864

0

0,1

0,2

0,3

0,4

0,5

0,6

0,7

0,8

0,9

1

Performance [%] (delta t

= 2 Mbit/sec)

Performance [%] (delta t

= 5 Mbit/sec)

Performance [%] (delta t

= 10 Mbit/sec)

Modified Dijkstra based on the QOSPF

link measures

Kou based on the negative logarithm of

probabilities

Takahashi-Matsuyama based on the

negative logarithm of probabilities

S�{}�xy � u4��� 4)� # ���'��� #0� 5 �� � � !#"�$ & � �� 1 W�� ��� & �2 ����2� � � #��>�'�X���4� � #"4 �61 �6� �� ��2� '/�(�'� ����B��+ ����� � ��'����� �2+ ���Z%�� � #$��#$� � ���'��� #7 J� 5 ;>=DNPO 7H;>=

n©wx«}ªm{¨z|� =¿� ? =ã� � §'�_uDz ; =DNPO 7H; = +��>� @ ;���9 � � ? µ> � ;���� � ��>� @ ;���9 ��>� @ ;���9 A?2 >� @ ;���9� � � !#"�$ & 2 C 2 ��� �&2 2 CA ��2 2 CA �&2� 1 W�� ��� & 7 � ��I 2 �&2 CDA�A�� 2 ��2 C��� �� 2 ��2 C �� 1 W�� � �� & 7 ����������� 9�� @(7 >�� ; 9<I���� � � 2 �&2 C 2��� 2 ��2 C��&2� 2 ��2 C �¤ ~x�_«}u������ ���� ����( V#�*�'�H%����*%B#$� � ��������� ������� � 54� � #0+ #7� � � %� 4� ����1'�����W�'�

!��������.#7�)#�*1 �0�*, #J� 5 �-�� (�*#�($������#$+8#$� �Z����%�� � #$��#$� �����'��� #� J� 5 ;>=NKO 7 ;>=Q yopWÌon®{}t!�_«¨l²n©wx«}ªm{¨z_� =L� ?d� uWn®y|«»p�nH�_{}�x� � ~�p©{}w�w�¬/ps�_u�n©uDv�wxz|�²w � �_u � u �©� w � n-=­u]µ �<µd� : µ U�� §'�_uDz�y|n©{¨z_�T�wxyNÌ/�x�_µ ����§'�_uDzhy|n©{¨z|� ¤ ~�°3~��<~xn©�_{»¾·�À~�psn©y_l]~xt!~²~xz|� ;>=DNPO�7�;>= + ��>� [@ ;���9 � � ? ÌBn®{}z|vu8{¨p4�_up©u � ¾t!{}z_uDn'p©�_u�n©�|~xz_z_{}z_�!p � u�u��<~:ªA{}z_�8p©�|u�t²~3³o{¨t�y_t � � w]�|~��|{¨«}{»pqlPw�¬Y¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«}{}z_�²p©�|u8Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzAp% µ ¤ �_{¦nHn©wx«}yop©{}wxz²t²~:l8�|~:ªxu�n©{¨�]z_{¨¹<v�~xz]pd� � w]�|~��_{}«}{»pql�p©w�ªm{}wx«¦~3psuºp©�_{¦n � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApH~�z<�²t²~:l � uDn©y_«»pn©uDv�wxz|��w � �ou � u �©� w � ne§'{»ps�Áp©�_{¦n�� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pqlxµ ¤ ~�°m{}z_�${¨zAp©wÀ~]v�v�wxy_zAp0p©�_u²� � w]�|~��_{}«}{»pqlÀwx¬H¬­y_«¨¹|«}«¨{}z_�ps�_u�Í�wmk � uW½]y|{ � u�t!u�zAp�~xz|�Áwxz_«}lÁ~]v�v�u��ops{¨z_�$ps�_u�n©wx«}yops{¨w]z � {¨¬'{»p�¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«¦n4ps�_{¦n�v � {¨p©u � {}wxz±~3p�«}uD~]nqp§'{¨p©�$� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pql � + A�7 ���

� e �69 7 3VWBX Y[Z ��� 56VWBX Y[Z F�+ �VWBX Y[Z ��� fg- U�VWBX Y[Z $ % 4"! �

K�n®{}z_��p©�_{¦n¸v�wxz|�_{»ps{¨w]zP~�z|� � u��UuD~�p©{}z_��ps�_u�n©{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]z²§'{»ps�#��+32 C��ep©�|u � ~3ps{¨w�wx¬/p©�_uen®uWvw]z|�!w � �ou �u �©� w � n¼vD~�zÁn®{}�xz_{¨¹<vD~�zAp©«}l$�<u²�ouWv � uD~xn©uD� =­uxµ �|µ�� � y|n©{¨z|� T�wxy�ÌVU � y|n®{}z_� ¤ ~x°3~��|~]n®�_{¨¾·�À~3p�n®y_lA~�t²~{}z p©�_u$§�w � nqp²v�~]n®u�§'�_u�z ; =DNPO 7j; = + A?2 >� @ ;���9 � � ? §'�_{}«}u�ps�_u � ~�p©{}w�wx¬¼ps�_u�¹ � n®p²w � �ou � u �s� w � nn©«}{¨�]�]ps«¨l�{¨z<v � uD~xn©uD� =ãuxµ �|µ�Y_µ � �Ëy|n©{¨z_� T¼w]yÁw � ¤ ~�°3~��|~]n®�|{»¾·�À~3p�n®y|l]~�t²~�{¨z±ps�_uP§�w � n®p�v�~xn©u²§'�_uDz

ö���÷�öðù

Page 20: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� � �

; =DNPO 7H; = + A?2 >� [@ ;���9 � � ? µ> � ;���� � ��>� @ ;���9 ��>� @ ;���9 A?2 >� @ ;���9��� � !#"�$'& 2 C 2 ��� �&2 2 CA ��2 2 CA �&2�,1 W�� ��� & 7 � ��I 2 C 2� �� �&2 2 C 2 ��� �&2 2 C 2���� ��2 C 2���,1 W�� � �� & 7 ��� � � ��� 9�� @ 7 >�� ; 9<I���� � � 2 C 2� � �&2 2 C 2 �� �&2 2 C 2���� ��2 C 2��¤ ~x�_«}u : ��� ���� ����( V#�*�'�H%����*%B#$� � ��������� ������� � 54� � #0+ #7� � � %� 4� ����1'�����W�'�

!��������.#7�)#�*1 �0�*, #J� 5 �-�� (�*#�($������#$+8#$� �Z����%�� � #$��#$� �����'��� #� J� 5 ; =NKO 7 ; =�N� #7�"�B��#/,)�9���2�W��� � �8 7�'����������(�N���*�05���� � ��� 4��� #��-�� �7�����3#$������ �'�R�D#*�� ��R����� ��� A��4,)���B!��B!$������� ���n�~Ân©�<uWv{¦~�«HvD~xn©uxÌ�y|n©{¨z_� � + 2�=Lv´¬qµ�p©�|uPv � {»psu � {¨w]z =L� ?�?0� uDn©y_«»p�n�n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n��|~:ªm{¨z_��CDu � wÀn®uWvw]z|�w � �_u � u �©� w � µ���uDv � uW~xn©{¨z|��ps�_uPª3~x«¨y_uPw�¬ ��ps�_u�~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t � � w3ªm{¦�ouDn�n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n0¬­y_«¨¹|«}«¨{}z_�Àps�_u$Í�wmk� uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zAp!§'{»ps� «¦~ � �xu � � � w]�|~��|{¨«}{»pql]ÌH�_w3§�u�ª]u � p©�|uÂz_upq§�w � °¯yop©{}«}{.CW~3p©{}wxz §'{}«¨«¼n©{}�xz_{¨¹<v�~xzAp©«}l �<u�_uDv � uD~]n®uW� =ã«}~ � �]u � � � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pql�wx¬�¹ � n®p�w � �ou � u �©� w � n ? µd¶·z|v � uW~xn©{¨z|��ps�_{¦n�ª3~�«}y_u�t!w � u0u7@BuDvp©{}ªxu�z_u�p®¾§�w � °Py_p©{}«¨{DCD~�p©{}wxzhvD~�zÂ�Uu�~xv��|{¨uDªxuD��Ì|�_w3§�u�ª]u � ps�_u�� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pql�w�¬Yp©�_u8n®uWvw]z|�Âw � �ou � u �s� w � §'{}«¨«��<u{}z|v � uW~xn©uD�/µ

� ��� ��� �8É�É��­�"� � Ä � Å��HÄ�È'Ä ��É Æ � È|ÆsÄ ��É�� È��   Ä�� �ã  Ä � Ä �B�W�!¢x¡_� Ķ·z S�{¨�]y � u : ps�_u�¹ � n®pev�wx«}y_t!z�n©�_w3§�n'ps�_u�ª3~x«¨y_u�w�¬dps�_u8�<u � ¬­w � t²~�z<vu�t!uD~]n®y � uWn �� � � !#"�$ ! Ì/§'�_{}«¨ups�_u$n®uWvwxz<�¯wxz_u�n®�|w3§�n�ps�_u�ª3~x«¨y_u�w�¬ �� 1 W�� � ��"! µ±¶Óp�v�~xz �Uu�n©u�uDz p©�<~3p²~��_� � w:³o{¨t²~�p©u�«}lÀps�_uÂn©~xt!u

The performance of the multicast routing methods based on

additive type of end-to-end QoS requirement

0,999

0,989

0,962

0,953

0,978

0,999

0,92

0,93

0,94

0,95

0,96

0,97

0,98

0,99

1

1,01

Performance [%] (delta t =

3 ms)

Performance [%] (delta t =

10 ms)

Performance [%] (delta t =

20 ms)

Bellmann-Ford based on the QOSPF link measures

Described heuristic based on the mean values and

variances of the probabilistic link measures

S�{¨�]y � u : � 4H� # ���'��� #J� 5 ���� � !#"�$ ! ���)% �� 1 W�� � � ! ���Z%�� � #$��#$� � ���'��� #7 � 5 ;>=DNPO 7H;>=�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u�v�~xzÀ�<u�wx�op�~�{}z_uD�$§'�|u�z ;>=DNPO�7H;>=Hps~x°xuWn�n®t²~x«¨«�ª3~�«}y_uDnDµ C �_uDzÂp©�_{¦n�ª:~x«¨y|u�{}z|v � uD~]n®uWnw]y � � � wx�Uw]n©uD���_uDy � {¦n®p©{¦v � uWn®y_«¨psn¼n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z|n'§'{¨p©�Â�_{}�x�|u � ½Ay|~x«¨{¨pqlxµ�K¼n©{¨z_�!ps�_{¦n�z_uD§ �|u�y � {}n®p©{¦v0t�y<v��«}w3§�u ��� ~�p©{}w�wx¬|¹ � nqp5w � �ou � u �©� w � n�v�~�z��<u�~]v��_{}u�ªxuW��=L�_µ � � {}z|nqpsuD~]��wx¬N�6Y � §'�_u�z ; =DNPO 75; = + �&2 � 9 ? µ÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 21: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

�W� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

ko{¨z|v�uPps�_u Q u�«}«¨t²~�z_¾/S|w � � ~�«}�xw � {¨p©�_t �<~xn©uD�¯w]z>ps�_u ; VDW�X Y[Z=DNPO w3ªxu � uWnqps{¨t²~3psuDn�p©�_uÂ�ouD«}~:lon8~�«}wxz_��p©�_u�<~3p©�<n�ÌU{»p � uDn©y_«»p�n�z_w�n®uWvw]z|�$w � �ou ��� ~�p©{}w(=ðps�_{¦n�{¦n'ps�_u � uW~xn©wxz$§'�ml ��� � !#"�$ ! {}nev�~x«}v�y_«¦~3p©uW�$y|n©{¨z_�ps�_u�«}{}z_°$t8uW~xn©y � uDn ; VDW�X Y[Z=DNPO {}z|n®p©uW~x�Âwx¬�; VDW�X Y[Z= ? ~�z<�Â�_{}�x�$¹ � nqpew � �ou ��� ~�p©{}wX=­§'�_{¦v��À{}z|v � uD~]n®uWn��|~ � �_«¨l§'�|u�zH; =NPO 7 ; = {¨z|v � uW~xn©uDn ? µ ¤ �_u²z_u�§ �_u�y � {¦nqps{}v8{¦n4~��_«}u8p©w$°xuDu���p©�_u � ~3ps{¨w�w�¬¸p©�_u�n©uDv�wxz|�hw � �ou �u �©� w � n�«¨w3§ =q�]µ U � {¨z8ps�_u�§�w � nqp5v�~]n®uº§'�_uDz ; =DNPO 7 ; = +3�&2 � 9 ? Ì�§'�_{}«¨u�~x«¨«}w3§�nYyop©{}«}{.CD{¨z_�0ps�_u'z_u�pq§¸w � °t�y|v���t8w � u0u$@UuWv´p©{}ªxu =¿�oµ � � §'�_uDz%; =NPO 7 ; = + �&2 � 9 ? µ

> � ;���� � � 9 A?2 � 9 ��2 � 9���%� !#"�$ ! 2 C 2�� �&2 2 CDA�A � �&2 2 CDA � ��2�,1 W�� ��� ! 7 � ��I 2 C 2�2�� ��2 C 2 2�� 2 C 2 A�� ��2 C 2 A 2 C 2 ��� �&2 C 2 A��¤ ~x�_«}u4� ��� ���� ����( V#�*�'�H%����*%B#$� � ��������� ������� � 54� � #0+ #7� � � %� 4� ����1'�����W�'�

� %B%'���9� ��#>�0�*, #0� 50#$�H%�'3�3��' #$�H%X�-�� (��# ($������#$+8#$� �Z����%�� � #$��#$� �2�����A� #� J� 5 ; =NPO 7 ; =� ��� �!� �8É�É��­�"� � Ä � Å��HÄ�È'È � Ä  :¡ � � � È �   Ä � ��­  Ä � Ä �B�D�8¢x¡|� Ä��n¼t!uDz]ps{¨w]z_uD�h{¨z±kmuDvp©{}wxzÀ�<µ¨��p©�_u8wx�_p©{}t!~x«Np � uDu � � � � {}n0vD~�«¦vy_«¦~3psuD�Â�ml$u³o�|~xy|nqps{¨ª]u�n©uD~ � v���Ì<�_yopps�_u�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~xn®p¼p � uDuDn � �%� !#"�$�� ~xz|� � 1 W�� ��� � ~ � u�~��_� � w:³o{¨t²~�p©uD�$n©wx«}yop©{}wxz<n¼wx¬5p©�_u8vw �s� uDn©�<w]z|�o{}z_�kmp©u�{}z_u � � � w]�_«}u�t$µN¶·z8S�{¨�]y � uº��p©�_uº¹ � n®pY~xz|�8n®uWvwxz<��v�wx«}y_t!z|nYn®�_w3§ p©�_u'ª3~�«}y_uºw�¬<p©�_uº�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�ut!uW~xn©y � u �� � � !#"�$�� Ì�§'�_{}«}u�ps�_u!p©�|{ � �±~�z|�h¬­wxy � p©�Áwxz|uDn0n®�|w3§ p©�|u8ª3~x«¨y_u!wx¬ �� 1 W�� � �� � ¾¼�ou��Uu�z|�_{¨z_�w]z±§'�_ups�_u � p©�_uPn©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n4§�u � u�~��_� � w:³o{¨t²~�p©uD��y|n©{¨z|�Âp©�_u T¼w]yÁw � p©�|u ¤ ~x°3~��|~]n®�_{¨¾·�À~3p�n®y_lA~�t²~�|u�y � {}n®p©{¦v�nDµ�¶Ópev�~xz$�<u8n®uDu�z�p©�|~�pe~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psu�«}l²p©�_u�n©~xt8u4�Uu � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u�v�~xzÂ�<u�w]�ops~x{¨z|uD�$§'�_uDz

The performance of the multicast routing methods based on

additive type of overall QoS requirements

0,970

0,917

0,873

0,936

0,968

0,870

0,938

0,930

0,972

0,973

0,9310,919

0,8

0,82

0,84

0,86

0,88

0,9

0,92

0,94

0,96

0,98

1

Performance [%]

(delta t = 3)

Performance [%]

(delta t = 5)

Performance [%]

(delta t = 7)

Kou based on the QOSPF link measures

Takahashi-Matsuyama based on the QOSPF link

measures

Kou based on the log moment generation function

Takahashi-Matsuyama based on the log moment

generation function

S�{}�xy � uÁ� � 4)� #G�����A� # � 5 ���� � !#"�$ � ���)% �� 1 W�� ��� ! % #/, #7�)%����2� ��� ��� #"�2 $# � 5 � � #��8��� ���"� � #4 �61 �6� �� ��2� '/�(�'� ����B��+ ����� � �'��������+0 J�'�Z%'� � #7�*#7� ��������� #7 0� 5 ;>=DNPO 7H;>=; =DNPO 7g; = ps~x°xuWn5n®t²~�«}«_ª3~�«}y_u]µ C �|u�z²{}z|v � uD~]n®{}z_�ep©�_{¦nd�o{¦n®ps~�z<vuºp©�|u�z_u�§ ~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3ps{¨w]z�p©uWv��_z_{¦½Ay_uDn

ö���÷�öðù

Page 22: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� � Y

n©wx«}ªm{¨z|� =q�]� ? �|~:ª]u��_{}�x�|u � �<u � ¬­w � t²~xz|vu]µ 7 {¨�]�_u � �Uu � ¬­w � t!~xz|vuew�¬ � 1 W�� � �� � vwxy|«}�P�<u4w]�ops~x{¨z_uW���ml{}t!�_«}u�t!u�zAp©{}z_�Ât!w � u�vw]t!�_«¨u�³Àp©uWv��_z_{¦½Ay_uDn4§'�|{}v�� ~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psu�ps�_u�wx�_p©{}t!~x«¸kApsu�{}z_u � p � uDu²t!w � u� � uWv{¦n®uD«¨l!ps�|~�z�p©�|u T¼w]y�w � ¤ ~�°3~x�|~xn©�_{¨¾Ó�À~�psn©y_l]~xt²~��ow�=ðps�_uDn©u4«¦~3p®psu � nºw'@Bu � ~ � ~3p©{}w²� ? µ

> � ;���� � - � ��9�; 9�4 � - � ��9<; 9�4 � - � ��9<; 9�4���%��! "%$ � 7 � ��I 2 C�� � �&2 2 C � � � �&2 2 C � A �&2� �%� !#"�$�� 7 ��� � � ��� 9�� @(7 >�� ; 9�I ��� � � 2 C �� � ��2 2 C � � � �&2 2 C � A �&2� 1 W�� ��� � 7 � ��I 2 ��2 C � � 2 ��2 C �� � 2 ��2 C ����� 1 W�� � �� � 7 ��� � � ��� 9�� @(7 >�� ; 9�I ��� � � 2 ��2 C � � 2 ��2 C �� � 2 ��2 C ����¤ ~x�_«}u������ ���� ����( V#�*�'�H%����*%B#$� � ��������� ������� � 54� � #0+ #7� � � %� 4� ����1'�����W�'��B% %������ ��#>� �*, #>� 5J����#7���'��� �-�� ��# (7������#$+ #7� ������%�� � #7��#$� � ������� #7 0� 5 ;>=DNPO 7H;>=

� �%��!#"�$�� {¦nHvD~�«¦vy_«¦~3psuD�8y|n©{¨z|�0p©�_u�«}{}z_°�t!uW~xn©y � u ; VDW�X Y[Z=DNPO {}z²w � �ou � psw�~:ªxw]{}�8n©uDvw]z|�8w � �ou � u �©� w � nDµK¼zo¬­w � p©y|z|~3psu�«}lxÌ|n©{¨�]z_{¨¹<v�~xz]pº¬ � ~xvp©{}wxz�w�¬�p©�_u4z_u�pq§¸w � °�v�~��<~xv{¨pqlPvD~�z_z_wxp'�<u�y<n®uW��{}z�p©�_{¦n�vD~xn©u8=ãuxµ �|µ�_� � §'�_uDz ; =DNPO 7�; = + � v�w]n®pey|z_{»p�n ? µ ¤ �_u!�_{¨�]� � ~3ps{¨w�w�¬¸p©�_u²n©uDvw]z|��w � �ou � u �s� w � n�w�¬¸p©�_u!z_uD§t!u�p©�_wo��{}nºz|w�p¼n©y � � � {¦n®{}z_�<Ìmn©{}z|vuep©�|u�n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z�wx¬Z=®�x� ?H� uD�_y|vuWn�p©w

� � ���� ���! "� 3VDW�X Y[Z ��� � VWBX Y[Z -49�4§'�|{}v��¯{¦n�{}z|�ouD�<uDz|�ou�zAp�¬ � w]t ps�_u�Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zAp � µ C uP~x�_� � w:³m{}t²~3psuD��p©�_u�n®w]«¨yops{¨w]z¯§'�_{¦v���<~xnHp©�_u0t²~3³o{}t!~x«B� � w]�|~��|{¨«}{»pql!wx¬�¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«}{}z_�8p©�_u�Í�wAk � uW½]y|{ � u�t!u�zApº~�z|��p©�_{¦nºwx�ops{¨t²~x«Bn©wx«}yops{¨w]zPv�~xz�<~:ªxuº�_{}�x�8� � w]�|~��|{¨«}{»pql�w�¬Bz_w�p5¬­y_«¨¹|«}«¨{}z_�4ps�_{¦n � uW½Ay_{ � u�t!uDz]pWµY� � {¨�]{¨z<~3p©uW��¬ � wxt p©�_{¦n5¬ã~]v´p5p©�|u � ~�p©{}wewx¬ps�_u�n©uDv�wxz|�$w � �ou � u �s� w � n'v�~�zÀn©{}�xz_{¨¹<v�~xzAp©«}lP�Uu��ouDv � uW~xn©uD�$~xvDvuD�op©{}z_��w]z_«¨l$n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n�§'�_{}v��$¬­y|«»¹|«}«ps�_u�Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzApº~�p�«¨uW~xn®pº§'{¨p©�$� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¨pql � + A�7 ���

fg- 3VWBX Y[Z ��� U�VWBX Y[Z $�� 4� � e�� 9 3VWBX Y[Z ��� 56VWBX Y[Z 7 9 � F �K�n®{}z_��p©�_{¦nºnqp � ~�p©u��]l�§'{¨p©�#��+ 2 C 2 A¼~xz|� � u��UuD~3ps{¨z|��~��A~�{}z!p©�_u0n©{¨t�y_«}~�p©{}wxz²z_w8n®uWvw]z|�²w � �ou � u �s� w � n§�u � u0wov�vy �©� uD��§'�_{}«¨u4ps�_u � ~3p©{}w²w�¬�¹ � nqp�w � �_u � u �s� w � n�~ � u4n©{¨�]z_{¨¹<v�~xz]ps«¨l�{¨z<v � uD~xn©uD� =­u]µ �<µHy|n©{}z_�!p©�_uT�wxy¯t!u�p©�_wo� � : Y_µ U��˧'�_u�z�; =DNPO 7 ; = + � Ì5�_yop � uDt²~�{}z_uD�¯«}w3§�u � ps�|~�z>~�p � �%��!#$�� §'�|{}v�� §º~xn�_� � ? µ

> � ;���� � - � ��9�; 9�4 � - � ��9<; 9�4 � - � ��9<; 9�4���%��! "%$ � 7 � ��I 2 C�� � �&2 2 C � � � �&2 2 C � A �&2���%� !#"�$ � 7 ��� � � ��� 9�� @(7 >�� ; 9�I ��� � � 2 C �� � ��2 2 C � � � �&2 2 C � A �&2�,1 W�� ��� � 7 � ��I 2 CDA ��2 2 C ����� �&2 2 C ��� �&2�,1 W�� � �� � 7 ��� � � ��� 9�� @(7 >�� ; 9�I ��� � � 2 CDA ��2 2 C ����� �&2 2 C ��� �&2¤ ~x�_«}u U ��� ���� ����( V#�*�'�H%����*%B#$� � ��������� ������� � 54� � #0+ #7� � � %� 4� ����1'�����W�'��B% %������ ��#>� �*, #>� 5J����#7���'��� �-�� ��# (7������#$+ #7� ������%�� � #7��#$� � ������� #7 0� 5 ; =DNPO 7H; =

�N� #$� � *�#3,H�������W��� � �8 $������������ � �N�2���05���� �P��� 4� � #&�-�� $�����/#$������������.#��� ���������� � A�� ,H��� !��B!$�������0�

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 23: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

�x� � 7� !��������' ����P���.1'�� 4�(�'�����'� �������H�� ��L#���#$�H% ���6 ��*1��������'�9����#��N#��B� #7 7%'�����

kmw<ÌBp©�_u!�|~ � ~xt!up©u � �PvD~�zh�Uu8y|n®uW��~x�]~x{¨z$psw��|~x«}~xz|vu8�Uupq§�u�u�zhp©�_u8z_u�pq§¸w � °$yops{¨«}{.CW~3ps{¨w]z�~�z<�ps�_u4� � wx�|~x�_{}«¨{¨pql²w�¬5n©~�p©{¦nq¬­lm{}z_�8p©�_u�Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApDµ5�¼n¼~�«}{}t8{¨pDÌ<§'�_u�z"=q�]� ? {¦nºy|n©uD��§'{»ps� ��+H2ps�|~�z�{¨p � uWn®y_«¨psn'n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n � 1 W�� � �� � §'�_{¦v���ns~3ps{}n®¬­l²p©�|u�Í�wAk � uW½]y|{ � u�t!u�zAp'§'{¨p©�$� � wx�|~x�_{¨«}{¨pqlÂ�xµ� � ����¸��� N������ Ê w3ªxuD«Ht�y|«»ps{}vD~xn®p � w]yop©{}z_�h~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n4§�u � u�{¨zAp � wo�oy|v�uD�¯{}z¯ps�_uP�|~x�<u � p�~�°m{¨z|�À{¨zApsw�~xvDvw]y_zAp�p©�_u� ~�z<�owxt �Uu��|~:ªm{}w � w�¬|ps�_uº«¨{}z_°��ouWn©v � {}�opsw � n�µ ¤ �|u�z|u�§ t!ups�_wo�_n5~ � uº~��_«}uHpsw�t!uDup5�|~�z<�o§'{}�op©��Ì�uDz|�m¾psw�¾Óu�z|���ou�«¦~:l4~�z|��w3ªxu � ~�«}«xv�w]n®pNpqlm�<u�w�¬/Í�wAk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt!u�zApsnN{¨z�p©�_uºv�~]n®u¸w�¬|{}z|vw]t!�_«¨u�p©u�{¨z_¬­w � t!~�p©{}wxz�µ¤ �|u�vwxt!�_y_ps~3ps{¨w]z¯w�¬�p©�_uP� � w]�<wAn®uW�Át�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp4p � uDuDn4{¦n��|~]n®uW�Áwxz ~��|� � w:³o{}t²~3p©uW��n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|n0�_yopvD~�z��<u � uD~x«¨{DC�uW��§'{¨p©�«}w3§ vw]t!�_«¨u�³o{»pqlP~x«¨�]w � {»ps�_t²n�µ¤ �|u$n©{}t�y_«¦~3ps{¨w]z � uDn©y_«»p�n!� � uDn©u�zAp©uW�¯p©�<~3p�t!w � u�~x�_� � wx� � {¦~3p©u�t�y_«¨p©{¦v�~]nqp!p � uDuDn²v�~xz>�Uu$¬­wxy_z<�>�mlp�~�°m{}z_��{}zAp©w0~xvDvwxy|z]p�p©�_uº� � wx�<~��_{}«¨{¦n®p©{¦vHz|~�p©y � u�w�¬_ps�_u � w]yop©{}z_�¼� � w]�_«¨uDt$µ�¶·z�p©�_u'v�~]n®u�w�¬<�<wxp®p©«}u�z|uDv�°~xz|� ~x�_�o{¨p©{}ªxu�pqlm�Uu�wx¬4Í�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � uDt8uDzApsn�p©�_uÂz|u�§ ~x�_� � w:³o{¨t²~3ps{¨w]z¯p©uWv��_z_{¦v�n � uDn©y_«¨psn²n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n�<~:ªA{}z_�!�_{}�x�À½Ay|~x«¨{¨pqlxµ ¤ �_u�«¦~ � �xu � ~3p©{}w²w�¬Yps�_u4¹ � nqp�w � �ou � u �©� w � n'v�~xz$n©{}�xz_{¨¹<v�~xzAp©«}lP�Uu��ouDv � uW~xn©uD�/̧'�|{¨«}uPps�_u � ~�p©{}w�wx¬�p©�|u$n©uDv�wxz|� w � �ou � u �s� w � n�{¦n8n©«}{¨�]�]ps«¨l¯{}z|v � uW~xn©uD�/µ �Âw � uDw3ªxu � ÌY{}z>ps�_u�vD~xn©u�wx¬�<~�z|�o§'{¦�mps�À~�z|��w3ªxu � ~x«¨«/v�w]n®p'pqlA�Uu�wx¬dÍ�wmk � uD½Ay_{ � u�t!u�zApsn�ps�_u�z_uD§ � wxy_p©{}z_�²t!up©�|wm�|n¼~ � u4~��_«}u0p©w�<~�«¦~�z|v�u��Uupq§�u�uDzhps�_u!z_upq§�w � °$yop©{}«¨{DCD~�p©{}wxz±~�z|�hp©�|u8� � w]�|~��_{}«}{»pqlÂwx¬Hp©�|u!n©uDv�wxz|�hw � �ou � u �©� w � n��mlv��<~�z_�]{¨z_��p©�|u4ª:~x«¨y|uewx¬Y~!v�wxt!�_yop�~3p©{}wxz<~�«/�|~ � ~xt8u�p©u � �oµ

� %'23%º�Y%'���%' E¨�$F�k/µ -¸�_uDz�Ì T!µ Ê ~�� � n®p©uW�mp<��� �Z� � ���H%'����� ��������� ' � �'� ����������)#*% ���'���2 �� Ì �d� wovu�uW�o{}z_�]nPw�¬ � ps�

¶� � �J¶·zApsu � z|~3ps{¨w]z|~�« -¸wxzo¬­u � uDz|vu�w]z -¸wxt!t�y_z_{¦v�~3ps{¨w]z|nDÌU��p�~�«¦~�zAps~|Ì �0��ÌB�_�NµB� � �x¾Ó� � Y_Ì��]y_z_u� YBY]�_µ

E ��F�k/µ,-¸�|u�z�Ì T!µ Ê ~x� � nqpsuD�mpb��� . � ����#7�[� �#7� � 5!($� ���A���0��� 50 $#7�[� ��# ���'���9���2� 57���8�H# ����#$�H#$�������������A� � '/ �, #�#�%W�H#$��� ����1� 3B ����� !7�D#7+J 8�'�H%& $������������ �� Ì/¶� � � Ê upq§�w � °��h~��]~BC�{}z_uxÌBkm�UuDv{¦~�«�¶qnsn®y_uw]z ¤ � ~�z<n®t!{¦n©n©{¨w]z�~xz|�Â��{}n®p � {¨�|yop©{}wxzÂwx¬5��{}�x{¨ps~�« �¼{¦�ou�w<ÌN�W� =U ? �RUx��¾ � Y|Ì Ê w3ªxuDt��Uu � ¾Ó��uDv�u�t��<u �� YBY]�_µ

E : F4��µ �ey_u � {}z�Ì|��µB� � �_~|Ì_��µ C {¨«}«¨{¦~�t²n<��� �-�� � ����������� �X#��� �'� � �+0 J�'�H% �� �� � � �/#$� ���'� A�� Ì�H� wovuDuD�o{}z_�Anºw�¬d�3z|� �e«¨w]�|~�«/¶·zApsu � z_up��Â{}z_{¦vwxz_¬­u � u�z|v�uxÌ � �_wmuDz_{»³/Ì|�� �Ì Ê w3ªxu�t��<u � �6YBY � µ

E �BF �8µU���Uw]n®p©w]«¨w]�<w]y_«¨wAn�Ì_��µ C {}«}«¨{¦~�t²nDÌUkBµHT4~�t²~3pWÌ|�4µ �ey_u � {}z�ÌU��µB� � �_~|Ì ¤ µ �d� C�lm�x{}u�z<�_~ ��� �-�� � ����������� �X#��� �'� � �+0 J�'�H%��R � � � �/#$� ���'� A�� Ì|�-S - �BU � U_ÌA§'§'§4µ {}up©¬qµ w � �<Ì_��y_�]y|nqp�� YBY Y_µ

E ��F �Hµ T¼w]y�Ì �8µ��À~ � °]w3§�n®°mlxÌ �dµ Q u � t²~�z6��� . � �� �� . � ��������� �2+ 57���> �3#7���)#7� 4 ��#�#�� Ì��'v´ps~�¶·zo¬­w � ¾t²~�p©{¦v�~��W�_Ìo�_��µ��D�|�¾����m�oÌU�6Y]�_�xµ

E U'F 7 µ ¤ ~�°3~��|~]n®�|{LÌm��µ|�h~3psn©y_lA~�t²~ ��� . � . , ,H����B��+ ���3# V������������J57���4� � # H�/#$���H#$� 4��*#*# ����� !7�.#$+�����Z���*, �� �� Ì<�h~3p©�|u�t²~3ps{}vD~��A~��Uwxz|{}vD~_Ì/�6Y]�x�|µ

ö���÷�öðù

Page 24: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

������������ ����������������������������� "!��� $#�%&�'�(���)*�'+-,)�.#$�/#0�����21� ��3���3#4���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �_�

E � F � µ �Nu��xy|uDns� � w]z�Ì �<µ ��u�ª]u�z|�_w3ªmn�C�°ml]Ì<�¯µ/�Âw]«¨z|~ � Ì,-�nDµ�5uD�]n©w � � ���������*�� ���������������� ����� �"!����H%�'���%'��� ��# (7�����*#7+ #7� � ��� � � # *�� $#(� 5W���)���+ ,H�.#$�/#(���657�'��+8�'�9��'� �� ��� �3#7���)#7� �9�*#*#>,H��� !7�.#$+ � ̤ uDv��|z_{}vD~�«��'uD�<w � pWÌd¬ðps�6� G G:§'§'§4µ { � {¦n©~|µ ¬ � GWpsuDv�� � u��Uw � psn�G��x�x�_��G � ¶Ó¾���� : �mµ �|n�µ �BC]Ì�¶q�'¶®ko��Ì S � ~�z<vuxÌ��uDv�u�t��<u � ���]�_�xµ

E �'F4��µ2�ey_u � {}z�Ì'��µ'� � �_~ � � �-�� ' !��� 7#�% � ����������� ��� � #7��� ����1� ������������H� �7�����'�/#���� 57����+ �������� B4)� #*�'�[� �'�H% . � � �'��������+0 �� Ì_¶� � � ¶ Ê SY� -'�e� � Y � Ì �A~��|~xz�Ìo��� � {}«d�6Y Y � µ

E Y'F4��µ 7 µ ��w � uDz CxÌo��µB� � �_~ ��� �-�� � ��������������� � #$��� ����1� ����� ��� �H�#$���/�'���%���'����+ #7�3#$�� �� Ì_¶� � �¶ Ê S�� -'�e� � Yx�|Ì �]~x�|~�z�Ì_�h~ � v��h�6Y Yx�|µ

E}�D�'F4k/µ -¸�_uDz�Ì T!µ Ê ~�� � n®p©uW�mp<� ��� � ��9���!$���3#*% �-�� � �����������X����������+ ,H��#�$� $#� H�/�'�/#��� 57����+ �������� � ̶� � � kmuDªxuDz]ps�$¶·z]psu � z|~3ps{¨w]z|~�«I-¸w]zo¬­u � u�z<vu4wxz -¸w]t!�_yop©u � Ì -¸wxt!t�y_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxz<n�~�z|� Ê upq§�w � °on=㶠- : Ê � Y]� ? Ì<�evp©w]�<u � �6YBY]�_µ

E}�x�$F��<µ �Nu�ªxuDz|�ow3ªon�C�°mlxÌ �8µ|�'u�p©ª3~ � {LÌ ¤ µ<��~:ªm{¦�/Ì_��µ S<~�z|vDn©~x«¨{¿Ì$-�nDµ �5u��An®w ��� �-�� (����������������� , �B�1B#$� ������3*� #�%4�H#$��� ����1� ' �H����#$� �'� � �'��������+0 L57�'�Z������������� ������� ���H���+ ,H�.#$�3#-��� 57����+ �������� � Ì �H� wovuDuD�m¾{}z_�An�wx¬RY3ps�À¶ S�¶ � -¸w]zo¬­u � u�z<vu�w]z � u � ¬­w � t²~�z|v�u��Âwo�ouD«¨«}{¨z|��~�z<� �dª3~�«}y|~�p©{}wxzhwx¬¸� ¤ �� ¶ �Ê upq§�w � °on�Ì Q y|�_~x�<uWnqpWÌ 7 y_z|�]~ � lxÌo�|��µ<�3��Y3¾q�'U]�_ÌA� � ¾q�'Y �xy_z|u����x�|�xµ

E}�W��F S�µVT!µ 7 §�~xz_�|ÌB��µBkBµB�'{¦v��|~ � �_nDÌ � H�/#$���H#$�:4 ��#�#������B!$�.#$+0 �� ÌI-¸w]t!�_yop©u � k_v{}u�z|v�u��'u��Uw � p Ê w|µ¤ �'¾Ó� � ¾q�o�xÌ�K¼z_{¨ª]u � n®{¨pql²w�¬ �¼{ � �x{}z_{}~|ÌB�6Yx� � µ

E}� : F � µ C {}z]psu � Ì � �3#7���)#7� ,)���B!$�.#$+ ��� �)#7��� ����1� B . ����[��#�� � Ì Ê upq§�w � °on�Ì�ªxw]«Lµ¸� � µ��_��µ��W�BY3¾��6U � Ì� Yx� � µ

E}���BF)�8µº�4µº�¼n©��Ì 4 ��� � � ���B���H#�#$������� ���)% �-�� �(#7� � � %� J57�'����� ' � . 4V� ' �&���)%>4 � � '�� �� 7#�%��������� $#7�[� ��# � #$�9� �'��1� ÌK��������Ap®ps�6� G G:§'§'§4µ {¨u�p®¬qµ w � �2G3� � wov�u�uD�_{¨z_�An�G��_�W~�y_��GW¶Ó¾Ó�4G3� � ~:¬ðp©¾¿{}up©¬ð¾Lpsu�§'�x¾Ó½Awxn®¾ � wxyops{¨z|��¾¿�|��µ p®³mpDÌ�h~ � v��$�x�x�_�

÷�÷ í�[6\�]7^�_

Page 25: Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state ... · PDF fileMulticast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information Miklos Molnar, J anos Levendovszky, Patrice

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LÈS NANCY

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES CedexUnité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY CedexUnité de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

ÉditeurINRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399