HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL ORDINARY MEETING OF
COUNCIL DRAFT MINUTES
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010
CRESWICK SENIOR CITIZENS ROOM WATER STREET, CRESWICK
CRESWICK 7PM
This Document is printed on 50% Australian recycled paper
i
Hepburn Shire CouncilOrdinary Meeting of
Council
DRAFT MINUTES TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 CRESWICK SENIOR CITIZENS
Water Street, Creswick Commencing 7PM
CONTENTS PAGE
1. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF TRADITIONAL OWNERS ................................... 1
2. OPENING OF MEETING .................................................................................... 1
3. APOLOGIES ...................................................................................................... 1
4. DECLARATION OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST .............................................. 2
5. CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES ......................................................................... 3
6. NOTICES OF MOTION ...................................................................................... 4
6.1 UTILIY METERS ........................................................................................ 4
7. PRESENTATIONS ............................................................................................. 6
8. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION TIME ...................................................................... 14
8.1 PETITIONS .......................................................................................... 14
8.2 QUESTIONS ........................................................................................ 14
9. EXECUTIVE SERVICES ................................................................................. 19
9.1 COUNCILLOR NOMINATION – HIGHLANDS REGIONAL WASTE MANAGEMENT GROUP ..................................................................... 19
10. CORPORATE SERVICES ................................................................................ 23
10.1 OCTOBER FINANCE REPORT .......................................................... 23
10.2 SALE OF LAND – 6 HEPBURN STREET, SMEATON ....................... 47
10.3 JUBILEE LAKE CARAVAN PARK REPORT .................................... 52
ii
Hepburn Shire CouncilOrdinary Meeting of
Council
11. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................... 55
11.1 COMMUNITY GRANTS 2010-2011 ROUND 1 ................................... 55
Attachment 1 – GRANT RECOMMENDATIONS ............................... 58
11.2 BUSHFIRE MEMORIAL RECOMMENDATIONS ................................ 68
Attachment 2 – BUSHFIRE MEMORIAL SITE RECOMMENDATION74
Attachment 3 – COMMUNITY RESPONSES .................................... 85
12. SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT .................................................................... 93
12.1 PROPOSED LEASE AGREEMENT – FORMER CRESWICK RAILWAY AND CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOPS ASSOCIATION MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING ............................................ 93
Attachment 4 - LEASE ..................................................................... 100
Attachment 5 – MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING (MOU) ... 160
Attachment 6 – WORK PLAN .......................................................... 193
12.2 HEATWAVE STRATEGY .................................................................. 198
12.3 CODE RED DAY ARRANGEMENTS ................................................ 198
13. INFRASTRUCTURE ....................................................................................... 205
13.1 APPOINTMENT OF HEPBURN SHIRE FREIGHT STRATEGY STEERING COMMITTEE .................................................................. 205
13.2 WASTE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY ............................................... 209
Attachment 7 – CONSULTANT’S BRIEF ........................................ 215
13.3 B-DOUBLE PERMIT – SPRINGHILL ROAD .................................... 229
iii
Hepburn Shire CouncilOrdinary Meeting of
Council
14. COUNCIL SECTION 86 AND ADVISORY COMMITTEES AND STATUTORY REPORTING ........................................................................................ 233
14.1 COMMON SEAL APPLIED TO DOCUMENTS ................................. 233
14.2 ASSEMBLIES OF COUNICLLORS OCTOBER 2010 ....................... 235
Attachment 8 – ASSEMBLIES OF COCUNCILLORS OCT. 2010 ... 237
15. CLOSURE OF MEETING TO THE PUBLIC .................................................. 246
16. CONFIDENTIAL ITEM .................................................................................. 248
17. RE-OPENING OF MEETING TO THE PUBLIC ............................................. 248
18. CLOSE OF MEETING .................................................................................... 248
KAYLENE CONRICK CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
11 NOVEMBER 2010
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
1. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF TRADITIONAL OWNERS: We would like to acknowledge we are meeting on Jaara people country, of which members and elders of the Dja Dja Wurrung community and their forebears have been custodians for many centuries. On this land the Jaara people have performed age old ceremonies of celebration, initiation and renewal. We acknowledge their living culture and their unique role in the life of this region.
2. OPENING OF MEETING: The Meeting opened at 7.05pm PRESENT: Mayor Councillor Janine Booth, Deputy Mayor Councillor Rod May, Birch Ward Councillor Jon Barrell, Cameron Ward Councillor Tim Hayes, Coliban Ward Councillor Sebastian Klein, Creswick Ward Councillor Don Henderson, Holcombe Ward Councillor Bill McClenaghan.
IN ATTENDANCE: Chief Executive Officer Kaylene Conrick, General Manager Corporate Services Evan King, General Manager Community Development Martin Walmsley, General Manager Infrastructure Peter Reeve, General Manager Sustainable Development Robert Jennings. Chief Executive Officer Kaylene Conrick; General Manager Infrastructure Andrew Bourke; General
STATEMENT OF COMMITMENT
“WE THE COUNCILLORS OF HEPBURN SHIRE
DECLARE THAT WE WILL UNDERTAKE ON EVERY OCCASION TO CARRY OUT OUR DUTIES IN THE BEST INTERESTS
OF THE COMMUNITY AND THAT OUR CONDUCT SHALL MAINTAIN THE STANDARDS
OF THE CODE OF GOOD GOVERNANCE SO THAT WE MAY FAITHFULLY REPRESENT
AND UPHOLD THE TRUST PLACED IN THIS COUNCIL BY THE PEOPLE OF HEPBURN SHIRE”
3. APOLOGIES: Nil.
Page 1
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
4. DECLARATION OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST:
Councillor Bill McClenaghan declared a conflict of interest in Item 9.1 Councillor Nomination – Highlands Regional Waste Management Group, and in Item 13.2 Waste Management Strategy, due to his waste removal business.
Councillor Don Henderson declared a conflict of interest in Item 12.1 Proposed Lease Agreement – Former Creswick Railway and Creswick Railway Workshops Association Memorandum of Understanding, due to his membership of the Creswick Railway Workshop Association.
Page 2
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
5. CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES:
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
5.1.1 That the Minutes of the Ordinary Meeting held 19 October 2010 (as previously circulated to Councillors) be confirmed as required under Section 93 (2) of the Local Government Act 1989.
MOTION 5.1.1 That the Minutes of the Ordinary Meeting held 19 October 2010 (as previously circulated to Councillors) be confirmed as required under Section 93 (2) of the Local Government Act 1989.
Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 3
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
6. NOTICES OF MOTION
6.1 UTILITY METERS
MOTION
Hepburn Shire Council believes that the installation of smart meters by utility companies should be a cost to the supplier, and not a cost to the consumer. Hepburn Shire Council instructs its representatives to present this view in relevant forums such as the Victorian Local Government Association. BACKGROUND
In April 2009 the Victorian Government launched the roll-out of the installation of compulsory smart meters to all households and small businesses. The electricity monitoring devices provide feedback to households about patterns of electricity use, with the aim of consumers using the meter data to reduce electricity use during peak times. Victoria is the only state where the installation of smart meters is compulsory. The cost of the installation is paid by the consumer as an added charge to electricity accounts. The installation program is currently temporarily suspended, due to concerns about the cost of installation and increased electricity costs.
Councillor name: Cr Sebastian Klein
Councillor signature:
Councillor name: Cr Jon Barrell
Councillor signature:
CEO signature:
Page 4
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION
6.1.1 That Council write to the relevant Minister regarding this matter.
Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 5
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
7. PRESENTATIONS 7.1 PRESENTATION OF REPORTS Mayor’s Report Councillor Janine Booth, Creswick Ward presented the following report: During the past month I have represented Council at the MAV Annual conference held in Melbourne. A full day conference – the focus was on - transforming our future and embracing and understanding change.
The Honorable John Brumby Premier of Victoria officially opened the conference and spoke at length on his Party’s commitment to rural and regional Victoria. Whilst acknowledging the presence of the large Metropolitan Councils, he said he was really there to speak to the Rural Councils, particularly the small rural Councils. He thanked rural Councils for the partnership work that is being done in preparation for the upcoming fire season, he acknowledged that many small Councils were working with their local communities to address the effects of Climate change and acknowledged Rural Councils hard work and commitment to our Regional Plans as the strategic planning that strengthens and reinforces the partnership between local and state government.
Leader of the Victoria Nationals Mr. Peter Ryan also spoke later in the day. Mr. Ryan is also the shadow Minister for Rural and Regional Development so issues such as bushfire preparedness, the pressures on our Agriculture sector, water management and water and food security were high on his list of discussion points.
The MAV had also arranged for a number of visiting experts from the UK who spoke on the challenges of change, what makes reform so difficult, sustainable population growth and the changing political landscape.
The next day I attended the Rural Councils of Victoria breakfast meeting where a new President in Mr. Ken Gale from Moyne Council was elected. Rural Councils Victoria is the Network within the MAV that represents the 38 rural Councils and provides updates on rural issues and contributes to the advocacy goals of its member Councils.
The Minister for Regional and Rural Development Jacinta Allen attended the meeting and again acknowledged the partnership and co-operation of Rural Councils in the Regional Plans, as well as the links between Regional plans and funding priorities through programs like Small Towns funding and
I have attended the Creswick new residents welcome session hosted by the Creswick Neighbourhood Centre and earlier this month welcomed the Maree McPherson CEO of the VLGA at her visit to Hepburn Shire.
Page 6
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
As the Mayor of Hepburn Shire, a member of ALGWA and a local small business owner, I had the pleasure of being asked to attend a Ballararat Business Forum to speak to regional business woman of my experiences in local government and as a small business owner.
Councillors Samantha McIntosh and Cheryl Bromfield were also speakers on the night which was well attended by other business women from across the region. I hope that our personal insights and interest in Local Government will inspire other women in this region to consider a career or consider nomination for Council elections at the next election
I attended a fundraiser for flood victims of Creswick and Clunes at Novotel – this week I have been advised that the fundraiser raised over $32,000.
Work Rural Women’s Day- was held at Smeaton House support by CWA – A number of guest speakers on Rural Women’s involvement across the agriculture and business sector.
I attended the South Central MAV forum along with Cr McClenaghan and our CEO.
This is the opportunity to meet to with MAV representatives and Council colleagues from surrounding Shires to report on and raise matters of concern, and discuss and learn about the advocacy work being undertaken by the MAV on behalf of Rural Councils in the South West Central area.
Remembrance Day in Creswick was well attend and was again conducted not by our aging RSL Members but by the youth of the Creswick Primary School. This year grades 3 and 4 conducted the service at the Cenotaph telling those gathered of the significance of the Remembrance Service acknowledging Armistice Day-the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month when the guns of World War I fell silent.
It was an incredibly moving service as the young people of Creswick talked about their wish for a peace filled world.
As Mayor I welcomed Minster Gavin Jennings and Geoff Howard MP to Creswick recently to make an announcement of funding for a new playground at St Georges Lake.
Whilst not a Council project it is an important infrastructure project for this increasingly popular swimming area in Creswick.
I was also pleased to welcome Minister Jo Helper Minister for Small Business and Agriculture and Small Business and member for Ripon to Clunes yesterday where he made an election promise that if re-elected to government his government would
Page 7
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
commit $2.7 million towards Councils priority capital works project the Clunes Museum, Interpretive centre with the co-location of and Visitor Information Centre services. This six year dream of the Clunes community supported by Hepburn Shire Council will now be a priority for a re-elected Labor Government and along with recent funding announcements in support of our Streetscape project and the Small Towns adaptation program funding there have been a number of opportunities to encourage and support Community, Local government and State government partnership projects across our Shire.
Councillor Reports Councillor Sebastian Klein, Coliban Ward presented the following report: In the past month I attended:
The Central Highlands Agribusiness Forum AGM and annual dinner. Michael Buxton was the guest speaker at the dinner and spoke convincingly about the need for an overarching strategy for planning that would incorporate the long term preservation of farmland and accommodate projected population increases.
I also attended the Victorian Local Governance Association AGM where Noelene Duff, the CEO at the City of Whitehorse spoke on increasing women’s participation in LG in this the year of Women in Local Government.
I also attended the TRATA AGM where the committee opted to cease their role as whole-community representatives and focus mainly on the restoration and preservation of the station.
Councillor Rod May, Birch Ward presented the following report: On 28 October I attended the event wombat forest, conservation, connectivity, catchments, carbon and climate change.
On 3 November I attended the sustainability committee
Councillor Bill McClenaghan, Holcombe Ward presented the following report: It has been a busy month with much of interest again to report. The MAV State Council was held on 22 October in Melbourne but ended suddenly when just before the morning break the auditorium filled with smoke as a clothes dryer had caught fire in the Sofitel hotel. We were all evacuated out and I became separated in the confusion from the others who went to the nearby MAV office to resume the forum. I was told that everyone had gone home, so I did so too.
Page 8
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
At least I was back in time that day to attend celebrations of “150 Years of Local Government” at Glenlyon because this year marks 150 years after the creation of the Glenlyon Roads Board that became the local municipality. At first it was the Borough of Glenlyon and later the Shire of Glenlyon before amalgamation with the Shire of Daylesford in 1966 produced the Shire of Daylesford and Glenlyon. Another amalgamation in 1995 created the current Shire of Hepburn. At the celebration this day, a new booklet was launched called “Snapshots of Glenlyon” containing many colourful stories of the town and district. One account of the building of the Glenlyon Shire Hall in 1890 shows how things were done differently then. The Shire President owned a sawmill that provided timber for the hall and he also directed the workmen doing the building. Claims were made that the timber was substandard and the work poorly done, especially the roofing frame and the windows. There certainly appears to be issues with the windows even today when such behaviour from a Councillor is considered quite improper. I have pleasure in presenting a copy of “Snapshots of Glenlyon”, edited by Wendy McKillop, to Hepburn Shire Council to mark 150 years of local government in our Shire. On 25 October I again attended a meeting of the Highlands Waste Management Group as we prepare for amalgamation with Grampians and Desert Fringe. Also that day, I attended a Glenlyon Progress Association meeting. This group has been the local community planning group in Glenlyon for many years and has a community plan with priority projects. Council has recently created a second community planning group in the greater Glenlyon area called the “Glenlyon Action Group” that has its own community plan and a list of priorities which are almost identical to those of the GPA. I believe that work must be done to achieve harmony between these two groups, both having committed enthusiastic members but which are working independently and duplicating the work that each is doing. Again in Glenlyon on 30 October was the opening of the Glenlyon Annual Sculpture Show that runs for a week. Numerous interesting and somewhat unusual exhibits were on display demonstrating the huge artistic talent in the area. Congratulations to the category winners. The Municipal Emergency Management Planning Committee met again on 3 November to finalize amendments to the Municipal Emergency Management Plan that is to be re-issued electronically as a controlled document. We now have our Neighbourhood Safer Places designated for a summer fire season and are awaiting audit of the MEMP by the SES. The committee recommended to Council that its operations not be suspended on Code Red days as Council need to maintain an operational presence and as the
Page 9
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
accessibility of swimming pools was seen as important especially for young people who won’t be at school on Code Red days. I have inspected the racetrack at the Glenlyon Recreation Reserve with members of our Special S. 86 Committee to find ways of repairing damage done by recent heavy rains and flooding and the collapse of large trees. Without urgent repairs the track will be too dangerous to be used at the nest New Years Day Sports where money is raised for many worthwhile community projects and the CFA. I hope that we can assist here. On 8 November, I attended the MAV South Central Forum at the Borough of Queenscliffe with the Mayor and CEO where we discussed some of the problems of small rural shires like planning issues pertaining to wind farms, road funding and bushfire preparation. The Jim Crow Planning Group met again on 10 November at Yandoit. The big priority project now is the restoration of the Yandoit tennis courts so that the school and the local tennis club can use them again. Finally, I attended the Remembrance Day service in Daylesford on 11 November and laid the wreath representing Hepburn Shire. Councillor Don Henderson, Creswick Ward presented the following report: During the last month the flurry of activity around elections has meant major funding announcements for some areas of the shire. Creswick has had benefits over a period of time such as Doug Lindsay and some smaller grants for the museum, magic pudding playground and numerous other events. I commend the officers who have put together applications for such things as the Clunes museum project. In this round there has been an election pledge to fund an adventure playground at St Georges Lake. This is something dear to my heart as it translates into something for the people who live here to enjoy. I do know that visitors enjoy these things as an added bonus. Another announcement was $35k for an extension to the Creswick mens Shed. I attended as Geoff Howard announced the grant to a very happy crew. I took the opportunity as our mayor will attest to make sure that the foot/cycle bridge over the creek on the Dean road is right at the forefront of Geoff Howard and Minister Jennings mind.
I also applaud the opposition candidate making a pledge to fund some restoration of the bowling club during last week.
Page 10
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Work is progressing well on the DLRR and although some bad weather and mines have set things back the project should now get into full swing. I have noted the progress at the new Childcare Centre with the frame up and exterior cladding coming along this will be a welcome boost to the working families in our area and I commend the owners for their foresight and confidence in Creswick.
I have been speaking with many of those affected by floods and there is still much work to be done in assisting those in our community who are suffering from the financial loss but also the psychological impact of the events. On a brighter note Cr McClenaghan and I had the pleasure of being able to purchase our evening meal from the newly reopened Krackerjacks who were impacted terribly by the flooding. I am sure that Creswick folk are pleased to see this and other businesses reopen. Welcome news was the response from our Engineer Mr. Reeve that we have applied to do work on the creek form the Catchment Management Authority. I hope that they respond speedily as it is in the minds of Creswick people that this work is vital.
The Creswick Summit was a great opportunity for the community to come together to share their visions for our town and area. Taking this event and the New Residents welcome held in Creswick for the first time, things are looking bright for better relations and communication between our various community groups. I commend the community organisations involved in organising these events and the participation of all of those who attended and supported them. It is intended that as a result that a proposal will come for community groups to meet on a quarterly basis to catch up and share with others the activities they are involved with.
Councillor Tim Hayes, Cameron Ward presented the following report: Council Report Nov 2010
Cr Hayes provided a verbal report in relation to the following matters:
• The announcement by the Honourable Joe Helper, Member for Ripon in relation to the funding of the Clunes Community & Interpretative Centre. An amount of $2.4 million should the Labor Government be re-elected.
• The announcement by the Honourable Lily D’Ambrosio – Small Towns Adaptation Program
• The announcement by the Honourable Joe Helper of a $40,000 grant to the Clunes Free Lending Library and of a $20,000 grant for the establishment of a Men’s Shed in Clunes.
Cr Hayes also spoke of the news that the Club Hotel has been finally sold and will provide a much needed economic boost to the town of Clunes.
Cr Hayes advised that since the last Council meeting he had attended
Page 11
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• A Dinner for Flood Relief at Forest Resort, Creswick • A Dinner to mark the 150th Anniversary of Clunes Show & Launch of ‘The Best
Show Ever’ held at the Clunes Town Hall • The Hepburn Tourism Awards at the Convent Gallery
Cr Hayes also encouraged councillors to attend the 150th Clunes Show on Saturday 20 November 2010 to be officially opened by the Governor of Victoria
Councillor Jon Barrell, Birch Ward presented the following report:
1. Wombat Hill Botanical Gardens Advisory Committee met this morning and a. We were joined by Mr Peter Casley, Acting Parks & Gardens Works
Officer for HSC who reported he had recently attended the Botanic Gardens of Australia & New Zealand (Vic) Plant Forum on 10-11 November 2011 in Sale behalf of HSC
b. We reviewed Council’s “Removal and Disposal of Dead Trees from Council Land” policy & procedure
c. We agreed to a meeting schedule for 2011 including reviewing of the action plan for the WHBG & meeting with stakeholders
2. Daylesford Macedon Ranges Regional Tourism Board has now appointed its
new CEO Mr Jonathan Marshall who will commence in November. The board is currently conducting a Strategic Planning exercise.
3. ARC Advisory Committee will meet next week
4. I have been delighted to attend a wide range of community events over the past month including
a. 24/10/2010 Swiss & Italian Festa Red Lantern Closing Ceremony with Mr Geoff Howard MLA for Ballarat East, fireworks & no PA
b. 28/10/2010 The launch of the Winery Touring Guide of Daylesford & Spa Country brochure with Mr Geoff Howard MLA for Ballarat East at Captains Creek Winery – a splendid self funded effort by 25 odd passionate entrepreneurs – vignerons & related businesses
c. 29/10/2010 Daylesford Rotary Art Show with Ms Catherine King, MHR for Ballarat and the Daylesford Swing Band
d. 08/11/2010 WHBG with Mr Geoff Howard MLA and all of Councils’ GMs for the announcement of $105000 funding from Regional Development Victoria for a Sustainable Water & Power Project. Not election dependent.
e. 11/11/2010 Tourism Hepburn Excellence Awards @ Convent Gallery Mayor Booth, Cr Hayes & CEO Ms Conrick, & Liberal candidate for
Page 12
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Ballarat East Mr Ben Taylor & hosted by Mr Bruce Roberts, Newsreader, WIN TV.
f. 12/11/2010 Hepburn Kindergarten Trivia Night g. 14/11/2010 New Musk CFA Shed community opening h. 15/11/2010 RACV Victorian Tourism Awards with CEO Ms Conrick
Hepburn Shire was well represented by nominees i. Creswick Woollen Mills, ii. Daylesford Day Spa
1. Finalist Health & Wellness Tourism, iii. Hepburn Bathhouse, iv. Shizuka Ryokan Japanese country spa & wellness retreat.
1. Finalist Unique Accommodation, 2. Merit Health & Wellness Tourism
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
7.1.1 That Council receive and note the reports of the Councillors.
MOTION
7.1.1 That Council receive and note the reports of the Councillors.
Moved: Councillor Rod May Seconded: Councillor Tim Hayes Carried.
Page 13
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
8. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION TIME:
This part of the Ordinary Meeting of Council allows for the tabling of petitions by Councillors and Officers and 30 minutes for the purpose of:
Responding to questions that have been submitted by members of the community
Allowing members of the community to address Council. Community members are invited to submit written questions to the CEO by 12 noon on the day of the Council meeting. If you wish to address Council you must provide a brief synopsis of your address in writing to the CEO by 12 noon on the day of the Council meeting. Questions may be taken on notice and responded to later. Likewise, some questions of an operational nature may be responded to through usual administrative procedure. Separate forums and Council processes are provided for deputations or for making submissions to Council. 8.1. PETITIONS:
Nil Questions received at time of collating Agenda. 8.2 QUESTIONS: All questions are transcribed exactly as submitted.
Note that all questions concern Jubilee Lake Holiday Park, Daylesford.
1. Submitted by Vincent and Esther Gilmore, Grovedale: (a) Many annuals have invested a considerable amount of money into their on-site
vans. How safe are our vans? With uncertainty with ATPM and closure, can Council guarantee us that our vans will not become worthless?
(b) Why will council allow ATPM to manipulate them so as to get their own way to
stay in park after we received letter stating they were resigning. They have already done a lot of damageing (sic) and bullying the annuals. Move one forget mediating with them PLEASE.
Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King:
(a) What has been invested in is the moveable dwelling and structures themselves at the risk of the occupier. There is NO ownership of sites. There is only a licence to occupy a site for up to a max of 1 year. ‘How safe are our vans’? Is a good question in the sense of compliance with Regulations, especially on siting, fire access and protection?
Page 14
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
(b) It is not a matter of manipulation it is a matter of compliance with lease obligations and regulations. Day to day arrangement and operations of the Park is an ATPM responsibility not Councils.
2. Submitted by Elizabeth Cox I have had my caravan at Jubilee Lake Holiday Park up for sale since early this year. I have recently been advised by letter from ATPM that I cannot now sell my van unless the buyer removes it from the park. ATPM by not maintaining our upark have substantially devalued my asset. On-site fees have ben drastically raised without any flow-on benefits to anuals. As I am on a disability pension I am struggling to pay these fees. Additionally I have been told my fees must be paid until the end of January, despite the Park Manager's verbal statement that the park will be closed on 31st December this year. An unsigned note attached to my fee statement threatens me with legal consequences if I do not comply. I have not reeived any official communication from Council as to the situation at our park. My question to Council is this: "Have Council approached the people who tendered for our park in 2007/2008 to see if they are still interested in taking over the lease?" I sincerely hope Council will take issue with ATPM re their poor performance, unsatisfactory management style and threats.
Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: 1. The ATPM/Shire holder licence agreement has never guaranteed occupancy
beyond a 1 year term 2. The only ‘value’ involved is that of the ‘moveable dwelling’ itself. Site holders
never had any claim to a site or a right to sell a site, therefore no value can be attributed to it.
3. No, to do so nearly 3 years later would not be appropriate.
Page 15
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
3. Submitted by Brian Roberts, Corio Re JLHP (Jubilee Lake Holiday Park) Agenda -: Community & Stake holder engagement statement about site occupancy and fee structure being entirely a matter for ATPM. Would Council please be prepared to consider the following main points during their mediation with ATPM? 1. Sixty one annuals and two permanents are the prime users of JLHP and need a voice please. 2. Since tacking over in 2008 ATPM have doubled our site fees, this was indeed excessive as there was little given in return for our money. 3. Relocation of annual sites at ATPM’s behest is at annual’s expense and entirely without any compensation which is very unfair. 4. Based on past performance a continued contractual lease under ATPM would still likely as not lack facility improvement and progress. ATPM are poor communicators. I fear ATPM may be deliberately forcing our attrition to implement replacement cabins on our sites? Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: The above points could be noted, and considered during any mediation.
4.Submitted by Marita Pierce, Brown Hill As an annual site holder at Jubilee Lake Holiday Park, I have received a letter from ATPM informing me that this company, for various reasons, is not continuing with the lease of this Park. I have reason to believe that this is not necessarily the case, and the matter is now going to mediation. If this is in fact what is happening, it is considered that if Richard Pekin is the council representative in the mediation process, then the park may as well be handed over to ATPM, as Richard is pro ATPM. This would be biased and an unfair representation. Could I have some clarification on this matter please?
Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: Mediation would be before a totally independent person specifically agreed to by the parties. As there is a legally binding contract between Council and APTM which provides for mediation, this path will be followed accordingly.
Page 16
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
5.Submitted by Judy Macleod, Carnegie It is extremely disappointing that ATPM will be going to medication with council. They may be experienced in running upmarket holiday parks, however they have proven insensitive and incompetent in their running the unique bushland jewel of Jubilee Lake Holiday Park over the past 2 ½ yrs. We have had enough of their manipulation, disregard and bullying of annual site holders, disregard for the uniqueness of Jubilee Lake, lack of maintenance, excessive rate rises with no return and not keeping of their lease agreement. Another 20 yrs under their management will totally alter and ruin a unique park. What cant Council fine them to recoup some of the excessive rates they have ripped off us, let them break the lease and withdraw? Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: Mediation is a part of the lease or contract arrangements between Council and ATPM. There is no provision in the lease to fine ATPM, although Council may seek damages through a legal process where ATPM has not performed its obligations under the lease. However, before taking this expensive option, which cannot be guaranteed as being successful, mediation is the first step to be used. The ‘unique’ nature of this Park is a very important issue to ATPM that requires addressing. The balance between Regulations and in particular the safety of all users is of utmost importance to all involved. 6.Submitted by Kevin Macleod, Carnegie Most annual site holders at Jubilee Lake have invested thousands of dollars into their onsite van. As stakeholders and lovers of the park, we would welcome the chance to share with Council our positive thoughts and ideas. We can see a great future with ATPM, but we have been ignored. Why is that? Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: Ignored by whom? ATPM presumably! Any occupancy is on the basis of a 12 month licence with no right of renewal. Any “investment” on a site is at the risk of the occupant. In terms of any redevelopment of the Park, ATPM’s proposal was always to seek Council approval first, and then consult with Park occupiers. As Councils approval for the proposal was not given there was nothing to consult owners about. One of ATPM’s failings has certainly been not to have directly informed long term holiday site occupiers of its plans and proposals.
Page 17
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Any future for the Park depends on compliance with new Regulations and its registration under these Regulations. 7.Submitted by Bruce Whitton, Daylesford At the July 16th council meeting I asked Council to take action to make ATPM undertake basic roads and drainage works, now 4 months later NOTHING HAS BEEN DONE. I also requested Council to appoint the “Ward Councillors” Cr Ron (sic) May & Cr John Barrell to act as mediators on behalf of all Site-Holders, as the site holders as a group are very dissatisfied with all aspects of the parks upkeep and management since ATPM has taken over. My understanding from the CEO, Kaylene Conrick that Council would discuss this with ATPM. Please be advise communication from ATPM have not improved and the situation now appears to be deplorable. In the report before you, section “COUNCIL PLAN / LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE” “Residential Tenancies (Caravan Parks and Moveable Dwellings Registration and Standards) Regulations 2010 – from 1 July 2010 are applicable These Laws were made on order on 28th September 2010. These Regulations etc (as did the previous Regulations) clearly states in park – The Lessee is responsible for maintaining Roads and Drainage etc Site-Holders receive a letter dated 6th October quote “ATPM will be resigning as managers of the Jubilee Lake Holiday Park” The report before you “ATPM has applied for a renewal of registration of JLHP for the 3 year period commencing on 1 January 2011” MY QUESTION TO COUNCIL “In the discussions you have had with ATPM, what has Council offered ATPM for them to change from “Resigning as Managers at JLHP to applying for a New 3 year Registration” and What has / is Council doing to enforce the Victorian Legislative Compliance” Response by General Manager Corporate Services, Evan King: Nothing has been offered to ATPM they have as a matter of course and as required by the regulations applied for registration of the caravan park. The Council has proposed that ATPM should comply with its lease obligations. In respect of compliance with the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010 this is a matter for ATPM and Caravan Park users/occupiers in respect of ATPM obligations to manage and operate the Caravan park.
Page 18
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
9 EXECUTIVE SERVICES:
Councillor McClenaghan left the Meeting at 8.18pm due to a conflict of interest and returned at 8.22pm.
9.1 NOMINATION OF COUNCILLOR TO SERVE AS DIRECTOR WITH THE HIGHLANDS REGIONAL WASTE MANAGEMENT GROUP.
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
PURPOSE
The purpose of this report is for Council to nominate a Councillor to serve as Director on the Highlands Regional Waste Management Group (HRWMG).
BACKGROUND
The HRWMG recently wrote to Hepburn Shire Council reminding Council of its requirement to appoint a councillor as a Director to the HRWMG Board. The HRWMG is an independent Statutory Authority and is one of Victoria's 12 Regional Waste Management Groups (RWMGs) outside the Melbourne metropolitan area. Regional Waste Management Groups are responsible for planning the management of municipal solid waste in Victoria. Each Regional Waste Management Group produces a regional plan to coordinate and direct the waste management activities of its member councils.
The HRWMG is made up of six member councils, Hepburn Shire Council and the following local government authorities:
• Ballarat • Central Goldfields • Golden Plains • Moorabool • Pyrenees
The HRWMG has a Board of Management whose Directors are nominated by its Member Councils. HRWMG Directors act independently of their Member Council and are directly accountable and subject to direction from the Minister for the Environment and Climate Change.
Page 19
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Under the HRWMG constitution the appointment made by each member Council must be a Councillor. Hepburn Shire Council’s current nominated Director is Cr Bill McClenaghan.
Also, in accordance with the Constitution, by 30 December each year member Councils are required to appoint their Director.
ISSUE/DISCUSSION
Council is required to notify HRWMG or confirm its appointed Councillor as Director on the HRWMG Board by 30 December 2010. The appointment term will only be to 31 June 2011 as the HRWMG has been advised that the long anticipated merger with the Grampians and Desert Fringe RWMGs is to occur on the 1 July 2011, subject to satisfactory passage of the enabling legislation. Cr Bill McClenaghan has been this Council’s nominated Director on the HRWMG since December 2008. Cr McClenaghan also served as Hepburn Shire Council’s nominated Director during the term of the previous Council.
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE The operations of the HRWMG are governed by a Constitution. The Constitution provides: 2.2 Each Member is entitled to appoint a councillor(s) as a Director, as defined in Schedule 1 of this Constitution. 2.6 Such appointment shall be made: (a) by 30 December each year; or (b) within 21 days of the expiry of an existing Director’s tenure of office pursuant to clause 2.7, whichever is the earlier. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Appointing a Councillor as a Director has no financial implications for Hepburn Shire Council. The Victorian State Government provides funding to support the payment of Sitting Fees to Directors. The HRWMG current rate for a full day (greater than
Page 20
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
three hours) is $150. For meetings less than 3 hours a half day allowance applies. Travel reimbursement is paid at current ATO rates as well as reimbursement of any other expenses that a nominated Director may incur as a result of their duties.
RISK IMPLICATIONS No risks identified in association with the appointment of a Councillor as Director to the HRWMG. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS There are no environmental, social or economic implications with Council nominating a Councillor as Director on the HRWMG Board.
COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT The nomination of a Councillor to the HRWMG Board does not require any community engagement. CONCLUSION
Cr McClenaghan has served as Council’s nominated Director on the HRWMG Board for a number of years. His experience and continuity will be important over the coming six months as the HRWMG transitions into an amalgamated entity.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION 9.1.1 That Council appoints Cr Bill McClenaghan as Hepburn Shire Council’s
nominated Councillor to serve as a Director with the Highlands Regional Waste Management Group.
Page 21
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION 9.1.1 That Council appoints Cr Bill McClenaghan as Hepburn Shire Council’s
nominated Councillor to serve as a Director with the Highlands Regional Waste Management Group.
Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Don Henderson Carried.
Page 22
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
10 CORPORATE SERVICES: MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT GENERAL MANAGER CORPORATE SERVICES
PURPOSE The purpose is to report on the Council’s financial performance for the 2010/11 financial year up to the 31 October 2010.
BACKGROUND This report provides information on Council’s operating performance for four months to the 31 October 2010. Further, it provides a forecast to 30 June 2011.
ISSUE/DISCUSSION OPERATING SUMMARY: The year to date operating result is a surplus of $10.2 million, almost entirely due to bringing the full year’s rates and charges to account. For accounting purposes all revenue is raised in August, however, collection occurs throughout the year. The first instalment of the remaining Grants Commission income had been further delayed and was only received in early October. The second instalment was due in November, but pre-paid also in October. This amount has been invested. It should be noted that voting on the proposed Enterprise Bargaining Agreement has taken place and is currently with Fair Work Australia to be ratified. Currently all salary and wages to 31/10/10 do not include the annual salary increase per this agreement. Once the agreement is in place the salary and wages percentage (proposed 3.5%-4%) increase will be backdated to 1/7/10 and reflected in the expense accounts. CAPITAL WORKS AND MAJOR PROJECTS: $887,000 has been spent in capital works and $71,000 in major projects for the period ended 31 October 2010. Construction of Doug Lindsay is on schedule at the moment, despite ongoing wet weather conditions, $311,000 has been spent to date.
Page 23
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
See tables for details of status of capital and non capital project later in this report. SEPTEMBER 2010 FLOODS: Following the floods of Saturday 4 September 2010 Hepburn Shire Council is facing a flood damage bill of an estimated $4-4.5 million for roads, bridges and public assets according to initial engineering surveys. The total cost will become known once all damage is fully assessed by insurers and engineering staff. Council will continue to work on recovering these costs through insurance and through the $10.4 million flood package recently announced by the State Government. $224,000 of additional expenses incurred during the flood relief effort have been captured in the actual and forecasts at end of October. No other costs have been included in the forecast at this stage until more accurate information is available.
BALANCE SHEET CURRENT ASSETS: Cash and investments at 31 October 2010 total $7.2 million, which is consistent with the balance at 30 June 2010, because of the prepayment of the second instalment of the Grants Commission payment of $717,000. Refer to the Investment schedule (attached) for detail of investments and cash held and the graph of cash and cash equivalents for the 12 months to 30 June 2010 with comparison to the first 4 months of this year. With the exception of the early Grant Commission payment, cash is tracking fairly consistent with prior year. TRADE & OTHER RECEIVABLES: Rate debtors at the end of October 2010 are $9.7 million. This compares to rate debtors at the same time last year ($8.8 million.) Approximately $1.3 million in debtors remain from 2009-10 and prior. Sundry debtors total $564,000 at the end of October which is very similar to the same time last year ($558,000).
Page 24
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The two graphs attached show the level of Rate Debtors for 2010/11 in comparison to the same time last year and Sundry Debtors in comparison to the same time last year. CURRENT LIABILITIES: The major items are trade and other payables which include accrued contractor payments, current loan liability, employee provisions such as annual leave and long service leave and provisions for landfill rehabilitation. Deposits and trusts are reviewed quarterly with refunds or transfers made where applicable. Council still holds $90k in trust following a Section 181 property sale that to date is unclaimed. Total current liabilities are fairly similar to the same time last year. NON-CURRENT ASSETS: These include all infrastructure assets including current capital costs that have been classified as work in progress. It should be noted that property, plant and equipment, infrastructure was re-valued by $7.5 million as part of the 30 June 2010 year end process, hence the major difference between the same time last year. All Long Service Leave, Annual Leave and RDO calculations have been completed for 30 June 2010. Long service leave investments consist of financial instruments that vary in market value during the course of their holding, as reflected in the balance sheet ($962k), but will on maturity be able to be redeemed for their face value ($1m). An investment in associates of $443,000 is Councils share of Central Highlands Regional Library Service which shows a $4,000 decrease on the prior year. NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES: Major items are Councils loan liability of $3.1 million and provisions for long service leave and landfill rehabilitation totalling $838,000. CASH FLOW: Cash flow for October 2010 is attached. Due to the early payment of the Grant Commission second instalment, cash inflows are in line with cash outflows at end of October.
Page 25
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Under Section 138 of the Local Government Act 1989 a report comparing expenses and revenue to budget must be presented at least quarterly to the Council in a meeting which is open to the public.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS The reports attached provide the opportunity for constant review of Council’s financial position.
RISK IMPLICATIONS The internal financial report is required to assist in decision making and ensure departments do not exceed their budget.
ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS None noted. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Open reporting to the public on a monthly basis. CONCLUSION The report on the financial performance of Council for the four months to 31 October 2010 has been reported.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
10.1.1 That Council receives the Monthly Financial Report for the four months from 1
July 2010 to 31 October 2010.
Page 26
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION 10.1.1 That Council receives the Monthly Financial Report for the four months from 1
July 2010 to 31 October 2010. Moved: Councillor Sebastian Klein Seconded: Councillor Don Henderson Carried.
Page 27
$1,437
Annual Budget
YTD Budget YTD Actual YTD Variance ForecastVariance
forecast to budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's
INCOMECorporate Services 14,006 12,275 12,826 551 14,051 45Community Services 1,865 659 697 38 1,955 90Regional Development 548 206 240 34 594 46Public Safety 319 43 51 8 544 226Recreation 633 221 287 66 653 20Infrastructure 1,967 576 791 215 1,967 0Waste Management 1,930 1,856 1,886 30 1,937 7Capital Grants 3,182 0 212 212 3,182 0
Total Income 24,449 15,835 16,990 1,154 24,883 434
EXPENDITURECorporate Services 4,858 1,733 1,586 147 4,869 -11Community Services 3,587 1,055 868 187 3,586 1Regional Development 2,735 874 765 110 2,763 -28Public Safety 974 270 434 -164 1,198 -223Recreation 1,586 423 383 40 1,577 8Infrastructure 2,373 780 828 -48 2,373 0Waste Management 1,882 581 568 13 1,888 -6
Total Expenditure 17,994 5,716 5,433 283 18,254 -260
NET 6,454 10,119 11,556 1,437 6,629 175
Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000's
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010
OVERALL
Page 28
Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s $697
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance forecast
to budget
Variance forecast
to budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %CORPORATE SERVICESINCOMERevenue Services (Rates & M/C) 11,725 11,641 11,669 28 11,726 2 0%Grants Commission 1,912 478 965 486 1,912 0 0%Other Income 369 156 192 36 412 44 12% 1
Total Income 14,006 12,275 12,826 551 14,051 45 0%EXPENDITURECouncil & Executive Services 755 272 251 21 755 0 0%Financial Services 819 270 224 46 819 0 0%Technical Services 672 211 219 -8 672 0 0%Governance & IT 505 179 151 28 506 -1 0%
Organisational Development & Risk 560 181 140 41 560 0 0%Other Administration 1,528 621 602 18 1,539 -11 -1%Administrating Projects 18 0 0 0 18 0 0%
Total Expenditure 4,858 1,733 1,586 147 4,869 -11 0%NET 9,148 10,542 11,239 697 9,182 34 0%
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010
Note
NOTES1. Interest is ahead of $30,000 of budget.
Page 29
$225
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance
forecast to budget
Variance forecast to
budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %COMMUNITY SERVICESINCOMECommunity Development 142 99 95 -4 192 50 35% 1
Family & Children's Services 105 35 41 6 105 0 0%Aged & Disability Services 1,123 363 401 38 1,164 40 4% 2
Housing 52 17 23 6 52 0 0%Contract Services 443 145 136 -9 443 0 0%
Total Income 1,865 659 697 38 1,955 90 5%
EXPENDITURECommunity Development 1,072 311 237 75 1,033 39 4% 4
Family & Childrens Services 294 94 62 32 294 0 0%Aged & Disability Services 1,471 461 389 72 1,510 -39 -3% 2
Housing 26 7 10 -3 26 0 0%Contract Services 421 141 118 22 420 1 0%Other 133 41 33 8 133 0 0%Community Services Projects 170 0 19 -19 170 0 0%
Total Expenditure 3,587 1,055 868 187 3,586 1 0%
NET -1,722 -396 -171 225 -1,630 91 -5%
4. Currently there is a vacancy in the Arts & Cultural Officer position, once the position is filled, will be a part time position,hence the decreased forecast cost.
L2p program grant budgeted of $67,000 is now forecasted to be $80,000.$80,000 in non-budgeted for Bushfire money has been received.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010
2. $40,000 training grant received in August not budgeted for.
Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
1. The Arts & Cultural Officer will not be a shared position with Moorabool going forward. Therefore budgetedreimbursement of $43,000 will not be received (this will be offset by decreased expenditure, see comment below).
Page 30
$143
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance
forecast to budget
Variance forecast to
budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %REGIONAL DEVELOPMENTINCOMEPlanning & Heritage Services 168 64 76 12 168 0 0%Building Services 132 44 49 5 131 -1 -1%Tourism & Economic Development 230 96 113 17 276 47 20% 1
Public Halls 5 2 1 -1 5 0 3%Projects 14 0 0 0 14 0 0%
Total Income 548 206 240 34 594 46 8%EXPENDITUREPlanning & Heritage Services 1,124 326 225 101 1,124 0 0%Building Services 166 56 57 0 166 0 0%Tourism & Economic Development 618 185 167 18 645 -27 -4% 1
Community Amenities 177 59 54 5 177 0 0%Library Services 451 214 216 -2 451 0 0%Other Cultural Activities 88 9 20 -11 88 0 0%Public Halls 75 25 25 1 76 -1 -1%Regional Development Projects 36 0 2 -2 36 0 0%
Total Expenditure 2,735 874 765 110 2,763 -28 -1%NET -2,187 -669 -525 143 -2,170 18 -1%
1. $30,000 Provincial Partnership Program grant received and $12,000 contribution that was not budgeted for.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
Page 31
-$156
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance forecast
to budget
Variance forecast to
budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %PUBLIC SAFETYINCOMEFire Prevention 18 0 -8 -8 18 0 0%Animal Control 90 14 7 -7 90 1 1%Compliance 28 9 24 14 29 1 2%Health 164 16 16 0 164 0 0%School Crossings 8 0 0 0 8 0 0%Emergency Management 12 4 12 8 236 224 1919% 1
Total Income 319 43 51 8 544 226 71%EXPENDITURE
Fire Prevention 50 6 0 6 50 0 0%Animal Control 32 7 11 -5 31 1 3%Compliance 262 90 70 20 262 0 0%Health 317 93 80 13 317 0 0%Environmental Initiatives 205 37 18 19 205 0 0%School Crossings 35 12 9 3 35 0 0%Emergency Management 74 25 245 -220 298 -224 -305% 1
Total Expenditure 974 270 434 -164 1,198 -223 -23%NET -656 -227 -383 -156 -653 2 0%
1. $224k has been incurred YTD on additional work in relation to floods. This is anticipated to be recouped via insuranceor State Government funding.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
Page 32
$106
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance forecast
to budget
Variance forecast to
budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %RECREATIONINCOMEParks & Gardens 1 0 0 0 1 0 -1%Reserves 8 3 3 1 8 0 0%Mineral Springs Reserves 527 217 247 30 547 20 4% 1Projects 96 0 36 36 96 0 0%
Total Income 633 221 287 66 653 20 3%EXPENDITUREParks & Gardens 191 69 46 23 191 0 0%Reserves 749 250 242 8 749 0 0%Mineral Springs Reserves 242 81 76 5 243 -1 0%Swimming Areas 251 15 8 7 241 9 4%Cemeteries 1 0 0 0 1 0 0%Indoor Recreation 25 8 8 1 25 0 0%Recreation Projects 127 0 4 -4 127 0 0%
Total Expenditure 1,586 423 383 40 1,577 8 1%NET -953 -203 -97 106 -925 28 -3%
1. Bathhouse and kiosk rental income $20,000 ahead of budget.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
Page 33
$167
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance forecast
to budget
Variance forecast to
budget000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %
INFRASTRUCTURE
INCOMERoad Maintenance 958 240 479 240 958 0 0%Other Transport 1,009 336 312 -24 1,009 0 0%
Total Income 1,967 576 791 215 1,967 0 0%
EXPENDITURE
Road Maintenance 1,883 628 640 -12 1,883 0 0%Depots 47 16 17 -1 47 0 0%Other Transport 409 136 159 -23 409 0 0%Local Road Projects 33 0 13 -13 33 0 0%
Total Expenditure 2,373 780 828 -48 2,373 0 0%
NET -406 -204 -37 167 -406 0 0%
Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010
Page 34
$43
Annual Budget
YTD Budget
YTD Actual
YTD Variance
ForecastVariance forecast
to budget
Variance forecast
to budget
000's 000's 000's 000's 000's 000's %WASTE MANAGEMENTINCOMEWaste Revenue 1,920 1,856 1,852 -4 1,927 7 0%Land Management 10 0 34 34 10 0 0%
Total Income 1,930 1,856 1,886 30 1,937 7 0%EXPENDITURE
Street Cleaning 113 38 26 12 113 0 0%Waste Management 1,729 538 543 -5 1,735 -6 0%Land Management 40 5 0 5 40 0 0%
Total Expenditure 1,882 581 568 13 1,888 -6 0%NET 48 1,275 1,318 43 49 1 2%
DEPARTMENTAL REPORT FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 OCTOBE R 2010Variance - Surplus/(Deficit) 000’s
Note
NOTES
Page 35
31-Oct-09 31-Oct-10000's 000's
AssetsCurrent assetsCash and cash equivalents 5,702 7,161 Trade and other receivables 9,759 10,511 Inventories 40 36 Other assets - 11
Total current assets 15,501 17,718 Non-current assetsTrade and other receivables 1 55 Financial assets 899 962 Investments in associates accounted for using the equity method
447 443
Property, plant and equipment, infrastructure
161,579 171,883
Total non-current assets 162,926 173,343 Total assets 178,427 191,061
LiabilitiesCurrent liabilitiesTrade and other payables (111) (418)Trust funds and deposits (939) (903)Provisions (1,537) (1,417)Interest-bearing loans and borrowings (296) (277)
Total current liabilities (2,883) (3,014)Non-current liabilitiesProvisions (736) (838)Interest-bearing loans and borrowings (3,193) (3,078)
Total non-current liabilities (3, 929) (3,916)Total liabilities (6,812) (6,930)
Net Assets 171,615 184,131 EquityAccumulated surplus (95,956) (100,814)Operating result for period (10,127) (10,139)Reserves (65,532) (73,178)
Total Equity (171,615) (184,131)
BALANCE SHEET AS AT 31 OCTOBER 2010
Page 36
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
1. New works
ROADS & BRIDGESAsset renewalReseals GMI 1,500,000 11,844 1,500,000 Main expenditure will occur February - March 2011 Reseal Preparation GMI 78,000 8,716 78,000 Main expenditure will occur December - February Shoulder Resheets GMI 100,000 - 100,000 Scheduled for November through to April Gravel Resheets GMI 600,000 596 600,000 Scheduled for November through to April Stabilisation Project GMI 790,000 117 790,000 Scheduled for December through to February Bridge Replacement Design GMI 30,000 - 30,000 Scheduled for November through to April Bridge Maintenance (including $82k of c/f) GMI 371,733 93,348 371,733 Ongoing works
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
Bridge Maintenance (including $82k of c/f) GMI 371,733 93,348 371,733 Ongoing works
Mullers Lane Bridge Construction (including $18k c/f) GMI 167,500 - 167,500 Permit being sought from DSE, therefore work has not
commenced to date Footpath Improvement GMI 40,000 - 40,000 Scheduled for November through to April Total asset renewal 3,677,233 114,620 3,677,233
- Asset expansion/upgrade - Shoulder Sealing GMI 363,000 - 363,000 Scheduled for November through to April Swords Road Road Works GMI 15,000 - 15,000 Scheduled for November through to April Total asset expansion/upgrade 378,000 - 378,000 TOTAL ROADS 4,055,233 114,620 4,055,233
- RECREATION - Asset renewal -
Newlyn Football & Netball Club Upgrade GMCD 60,000 - - The associated grant was not successful. The $15,000 Council
contribution will be reallocated at the mid-year budget review. Skatepark improvement program GMCD 20,000 - 20,000 Works to commence in January/February 2011. Playground Equipment Replacement Program GMCD 20,000 - 20,000 Program to be completed by May 2011 Total asset renewal 100,000 - 40,000
Page 37
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
New assetsAmenities block at Daylesford Community Park (including GMCD 88,900 14 88,900 Work to commence in December/January Calembeen Park Walking Track GMCD 100,000 - 100,000 Ideally work to be completed in conjunction with the Dive Total new assets 188,900 14 188,900 TOTAL RECREATION 288,900 14 228,900
- BUILDINGS - Asset renewal - Buildings Renewal GMI 180,000 57,616 180,000 Ongoing.
Trentham Pool Filter GMI 90,000 2,399
90,000 Project anticipated to cost 125,000 due to additional works required and increased cost of filter. Reallocation of funds to occur during mid-year budget review. Trentham Pool Filter GMI 90,000 2,399 occur during mid-year budget review.
Painting Daylesford Pool GMI 40,000 - 40,000 Quotes in progress, to be completed by start of season Replacement of Seals at Daylesford Pool GMI 5,000 - 5,000 Quotes in progress, to be completed by start of season Pool Entrance Steps Rails GMI 4,800 - 4,800 Quotes in progress, to be completed by start of season Repairs to Pound GMSD 3,500 - 3,500 Repairs to be undertaken prior to Christmas Street Litter & Recycling Bins GMI 50,000 - 50,000 To be carried out November through to January 2011 Duke St Drainage Works GMI 30,000 - 30,000 Works to be carried out April - June 2011 Total asset renewal 403,300 60,015 403,300
- Asset expansion/upgrade - Wombat Hill Gardens Kiosk GMI 250,000 - 250,000 Not expected to be required until early 2011 Pool Entrance Steps Rails GMI 4,800 - 4,800 Quotes in progress Landing Providing Access to Medlyn Bottle Museum GMI 15,000 - 15,000 Works to be carried out in 2011 Transfer Station Facility Upgrade GMI 60,000 - 60,000 Works to be carried out Nov - March 2011 Duke St Drainage Works GMI 30,000 - 30,000 Works to be carried out April - June 2011 Total asset expansion/upgrade 359,800 - 359,800
-
Page 38
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
New assets -
Cameron Court Units (Including $241k carried forward) GMI 591,220 - 591,220
Site assessments being made. Some delay due to floods. Total new assets 591,220 - 591,220 TOTAL BUILDINGS 1,354,320 60,015 1,354,320
- PLANT, EQUIPMENT and OTHER - Asset renewal - Corporate System (including c/f $74k) GMCS 173,249 11,050 173,249 Tender closed 14 October 2010. Computer Equipment $90k (including c/f $22k) GMCS 111,825 16,736 111,825 Purchases made according to resources Survey Total Station GMI 18,500 15,863 18,500 Completed Mineral Spring Reserves projects GMI 81,500 886 81,500 Works to be carried out in first half of 2011 Mineral Spring Reserves projects GMI 81,500 886 81,500 Works to be carried out in first half of 2011 Passenger & Commercial Fleet (including c/f $110k ) GMI 328,195 74,535 328,195 On track, working through 2010/11 purchase schedule Works Plant & Equipment (including c/f $244k) GMI 994,325 100,467 994,325 On track, working through 2010/11 purchase schedule Total asset renewal 1,707,594 219,537 1,707,594
- New assets - Creswick Office Refit GMCD 20,000 - 20,000 Quotes being obtained, to be completed by end of December Auto Startup Generator GMCS 5,000 - 5,000 Purchase outstanding Mineral Spring Reserves projects GMI 35,000 849 35,000 Works to be carried out in first half of 2011 Air Conditioning - Economic Development & Tourism Office GMI
6,000 - 6,000 Quotes currently being sought
Total new assets 66,000 849 66,000
TOTAL PLANT, EQUIPMENT and OTHER 1,773,594 220,386 1,773,594 -
TOTAL CAPITAL WORKS 2010/11 7,472,047 395,034 7,412,047 Asset renewal 5,888,127 394,172 5,828,127 New assets 846,120 862 846,120 Asset expansion/upgrade 737,800 - 737,800
Page 39
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
2. Works carried forward from the 2009/10 year
RECREATIONAsset renewalVictoria Park Daylesford Project GMCD 82,410 4,438 82,410 Quotes to be finalised before works commence Clunes Bottle Museum GMI 2,389 - 2,389 Seeking Consultant Drummond Hall Tennis Court GMCD 28,000 - 28,000 Delayed due to wet weather. Clunes Football/Netball Club redevelopment GMCD 5,000 - 5,000 To be completed over summer period. Calambeen Park - Dive Tower GMI 121,244 6,953 121,244 Delay due to awaiting application approval from Heritage Leitches Creek and Woolnoughs Crossing Mineral Springs Works
GMI 12,500 - 12,500
Scheduled for November through to April Works Scheduled for November through to April Total asset renewal 251,543 11,391 251,543
- New assets -
CDDA Magic Pudding Playground GMCD 63,863 16,721
63,863 Quotes currently being obtained, work anticipated to commence in December 2010.
Calambeen Park shade area GMCD 6,000 330
6,000 To be completed in conjunction with walking track and dive tower works
Carbon Negative Initiatives GMSD 104,500 - 104,500 Clunes & Newlyn solar/hot water projects - Quotes being Wombat Hill Gardens recycling plan GMSD 7,336 - 7,336 Wombat Hill Gardens tree replacement plan GMSD 12,000 - 12,000 Tree planting to take place during dormant growth period Victoria Park Daylesford Project GMSD 82,410 4,438 82,410 Quotes to be finalised before works commence Total new assets 276,109 21,490 276,109
TOTAL RECREATION 527,652 32,881 527,652
Page 40
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
ROADS & BRIDGESAsset renewalBlackspot program - Clunes GMI 9,427 7,160 9,427 Final guard rail being installed Gooch's Bridge design & construction GMI 47,521 36,663 47,521 Completed final invoices to be received Footpath & Kerbing High St Trentham GMI 6,000 7,293 6,000 Completed slightly over budget due to Telstra costs Zig Zag Road re-establishment GMI 8,000 - 8,000 WIP completion May/June 2011 Mossops Road re-establishment GMI 25,341 - 25,341 WIP completion May/June 2011
Mobile Skate Park modifications GMCD 2,935 - 2,935 Money to be utilised as part of skate park upgrade works
scheduled for commencement in January 2011 Total asset renewal 99,224 51,116 99,224
TOTAL ROADS & BRIDGES 99,224 51,116 99,224 TOTAL ROADS & BRIDGES 99,224 51,116 99,224
BUILDINGSAsset renewalGlenlyon Hall restoration GMI 91,341 2,153 91,341 WIP Demolition of back area completed Creswick Town Hall works GMI 91,131 94,453 94,453 Nearing completion some works to finish
Doug Lindsay Recreation Reserve Multi Purpose Facility GMSD 1,433,975 155,748 1,433,975 Delays as a result of weather. SJWeir are constructing
foundation, building slab and continuing earth works to oval. Sealing of access way to Municipal; Recycle Facility GMI 29,179 97 29,179 Ongoing Total asset renewal 1,645,626 252,451 1,648,948
New assets
Doug Lindsay Recreation Reserve Multi Purpose Facility GMSD 1,433,975 155,748 1,433,975 Delays as a result of weather. SJWeir are constructing
foundation, building slab and continuing earth works to oval. Sealing of access way to Municipal Recycle Facility GMI 29,179 97 29,179 Ongoing Total new assets 1,463,154 155,845 1,463,154
TOTAL BUILDINGS 3,108,779 408,297 3,112,101
Page 41
Project YTD Forecast Comments Capital Works Area Cost Actual
Res
po
nsi
bl
e G
M
PLANT, EQUIPMENT AND OTHERAsset renewalUpgrade of generator & electrical service GMI 7,000 - 7,000 To be purchased Total asset renewal 7,000 - 7,000
- New assets -
Music equipment for Schools GMCD 10,000 - 10,000 To be purchased once flood damage assessed for existing
equipment stored in Creswick. Total new assets 10,000 - 10,000
TOTAL PLANT, EQUIPMENT AND OTHER 17,000 - 17,000
TOTAL CARRIED FORWARD WORKS 2009/10 3,752,655 492,294 3,755,977 Asset renewal 2,003,393 314,958 2,006,715 New assets 1,749,263 177,336 1,749,263 Asset expansion/upgrade - - -
3. Summary
Asset renewal 7,891,520 709,130 7,834,842 New assets 2,595,383 178,198 2,595,383 Asset expansion/upgrade 737,800 - 737,800 TOTAL CAPITAL WORKS 11,224,702 887,327 11,224,702
Page 42
Maturing Rate Balance
CBA Investment Account Variable 1,143,370$
FIIG Securities 30/08/2014 Variable 250,000$
Laiki Bank ( Australia ) Ltd 23/11/2010 5.85% 1,000,000$
Bankwest 26/11/2010 5.50% 300,000$
Community CPS Credit Union 29/11/2010 5.85% 1,000,000$
Qantas Staff Credit Union 8/11/2010 5.50% 1,000,000$
Ing Bank Australia Limited 4/01/2011 5.58% 1,000,000$
Doug Lindsay Reserve Variable 992,024$
Litherland Bequest Variable 92,188$
Medlyn Bequest Variable 21,773$
F Shaw Bequest Variable 10,000$
Bendigo Bank Variable 989$
General CBA Bank Account Variable 349,836$
Cash Floats and Petty Cash 6,000$
7,166,180$
LSL Reserve Funds
Bendigo Bank Floating Rate 12/12/2011 Floating 484,850$
CBA Investec 27/02/2014 Floating 489,300$
974,150$
8,140,330$
Hepburn Shire Council
Cash and Investments
As at 31 October 2010
Total Investments
Page 43
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Actual 2009/10 Vs 2010/11
2010/11 2009/10
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
B/Fwd July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
$0
00
's
Months
Page 44
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
Rate Debtors
Actual 2009/10 Vs 2010/11
2010/11 2009/10
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
B/Fwd July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
$0
00
's
Months
Page 45
800
1,000
1,200
Sundry Debtors
Actual 2009/10 Vs Actual 2010/11
Actual 2009/10
Actual 2010/11
0
200
400
600
B/Fwd July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
$0
00
's
Months
Page 46
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
10.2 SALE OF LAND – SMEATON GENERAL MANAGER CORPORATE SERVICES
PURPOSE The Council property at 6 Hepburn Street, Smeaton, a former depot site, was identified as surplus to needs and therefore may be sold. This Report recommends proceeding to give public notice of intention to sell the site.
BACKGROUND As part of the vacant land holdings review, land known as CA 1A Sec 1 Smeaton Township - 6 Hepburn Street, Smeaton was identified as surplus to needs and therefore could be sold.
Page 47
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
ISSUE/DISCUSSION The property was acquired in 1948, is approx 1080sqm in area and contains a concrete block shed of about 100sqm. An underground fuel storage tank also remains on the site. The depot has not been used in any extensive way for around 30 years.
B & D Gervasoni who own and live on adjoining land over many years have expressed an interest in purchasing the property. They appear to have had a quasi occupancy of part of the site for several years. They state they have maintained the land. In fact around 1997/98 the Council advertised an intention to sell the property and again in 2000 a sale to the Gervasoni’s was agreed but for some unknown reason did not proceed. The giving of public notice of intention to sell the land - a major part of the statutory process prior to actually resolving to sell the land. COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE The Council Plan 2009 – 2013 refers to “Disposing of poorly utilised, inefficient or surplus assets in consultation with the community where appropriate.”
For the Council to sell the land, it should pursuant to Section 192 of the Local Government Act 1989 (Act) formally declare the land as surplus to needs and must as required by S189 of the Act, give 4 weeks public notice of intention to sell. In either case any interested person is entitled to make a submission about the proposal. The Council may determine to sell by private treaty, public auction or as has sometimes been used, tender. In this instance it would be appropriate that public notice provide for a sale by private treaty to B & D Gervasoni. If public notice advertising commences late November, the Council will be able to initially deal with any submissions at its first 2011 Briefing meeting and then resolve on the sale or otherwise of the land on 16 February 2011. Any submitter may express a desire to put oral submissions before the Council. Under the Hepburn Shire Council Planning Scheme the land is Township Zone (TZ). The land is also subject to the Planning Scheme ESO 1 meaning certain requirements must be met for use or development. A contamination issue
Page 48
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
referred to below in Part 7 may also affect any proposal for future use or development of the land.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS A separate statutory valuation is required prior to any sale and normally the Council would not proceed with a sale at any amount less than the valuation obtained for the purposes of the Act. The current CIV is $26,000.
The statutory valuation will be obtained during the notice of intention period. The land will become rateable. Selling and legal costs for the land are estimated to be no more than $2,500.
RISK IMPLICATIONS There are risk implications associated with contamination on the site The Contract of Sale will contain appropriate hold harmless conditions in favour of Council. See Part 7 below.
ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS Environmentally the property does, according to a November 2000 site investigation report, contain “some low level contamination on the eastern side”.
Contamination analysis confirmed the presence of arsenic, lead and zinc in 3 soil samples which were beyond EPA classification for clean fill. 9 samples in all were taken at depths of approximately 200-250mm with the remaining samples reporting “the condition of the soil on site is generally good conforming to EPA guidelines for clean fill classification”. It was recommended that more detailed investigation be undertaken if removal of the contaminated soil was to be undertaken. While it is not necessary, a further report could be sought, although this would presumably only confirm what was found in the 2000 Report. The matter of contamination was discussed with BJT Legal. The advice was that the land may be sold in its existing state provided it is drawn to the purchaser’s attention that the land may be contaminated and that the purchaser should make their own appropriate enquiries and with indemnity and hold harmless clauses
Page 49
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
included in the Contract of Sale. As for seeking a further site report, this was considered as unnecessary. Whether the presence of contamination was a reason for the previous sale not proceeding is not clear. The Contract of Sale at the time contained appropriate indemnity and hold harmless clauses recommended by Council’s solicitors. The Gervasoni’s are aware of the contamination.
COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Public notice of intention to sell this land must be given and allow for the receipt of submissions and the hearing of submitters if any so request. CONCLUSION If the Council is to proceed with the sale of this site it should resolve as per the following recommendation.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 10.2.1 is satisfied Crown allotment 1A Section 1 Township of Smeaton more
particularly described in Certificate of Title Vol 1942 Folio 311 is no longer required nor is it necessary or desirable to use the land for a municipal purpose, therefore declares it is surplus to needs and may be sold; and
10.2.2 proceed to advertise its intention to sell the land by private treaty to B & D
Gervasoni and seek public submissions on this proposal in accordance with S189 and S223 of the Local Government Act 1989.
Page 50
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION That Council: 10.2.1 is satisfied Crown allotment 1A Section 1 Township of Smeaton more
particularly described in Certificate of Title Vol 1942 Folio 311 is no longer required nor is it necessary or desirable to use the land for a municipal purpose, therefore declares it is surplus to needs and may be sold; and
10.2.2 proceed to advertise its intention to sell the land by private treaty to B & D
Gervasoni and seek public submissions on this proposal in accordance with S189 and S223 of the Local Government Act 1989.
Moved: Councillor Rod May Seconded: Councillor Tim Hayes Carried.
Page 51
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
10.3 LEASE – JUBILEE LAKE HOLIDAY PARK GENERAL MANAGER CORPORATE SERVICES
PURPOSE This Report will update Council on matters concerning the Lease of Jubilee Lake Holiday Park (JLHP) held by Australian Tourist Park Management (ATPM) as a mediation process is being sought.
BACKGROUND ATPM advised Council on 30 September 2010 that it regretfully was not in a position to continue with the lease of JLHP. ATPM continues to manage JHLP day to day. In response Council discussed the obligations of ATPM under the Lease and sought legal advice (privileged) regarding its position. As ATPM pointed to a number of deficiencies with infrastructure at JLHP, Council also sought an independent review (part commercial in confidence) of the Park from a caravan park consultant. Based on subsequent advice from ATPM stating “mediation in our lease is binding so this will be the best way forward for us” and other advices and reports to Council, according to Lease requirements on this matter, mediation is being arranged.
ISSUE/DISCUSSION The principle issue is the obligation of a tenant to undertake its contractual obligations to meet essential terms under a properly entered and executed Lease and the failure to so do meaning there is a likely breach of Lease which may result in damages. Where there is ‘any dispute’ between the parties the Lease provides for mediation and prescribes the procedures to be followed to undertake the mediation.
Page 52
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE
For the purposes of the Lease and appropriate legislation, ATPM is the “caravan park owner” – defined as being the person or body “who is (either or partly) the owner of a business which operates a caravan park.” Apart from Lease obligations, the Residential Tenancies (Caravan Parks and Moveable Dwellings Registration and Standards) Regulations 2010 – operative from 1 July 2010 are applicable. The Regulations are specific about registration for caravan parks and include requirements for fire protection and emergency management, structure standards, water supply, drainage and waste water, facilities/amenities, lighting and access measures. ATPM has applied for a renewal of registration of JLHP for the 3 year period commencing on 1 January 2011.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Mediation costs are to be shared equally between landlord and tenant. It might be expected mediation would take a day with total cost in the order of $2,500.
RISK IMPLICATIONS There is no significant risk implication associated with the mediation process. It is possible mediation will not provide an acceptable or any outcome, resulting in consideration of further legal process. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
JLHP is an existing operation. The unique environment of this park has been referred to in the past and especially by users. The new Regulations will affect operational aspects of the Park, certainly in relation to layout (includes caravan siting and location) to meet fire protection requirements. It has been estimated to meet standards costs could be as much as $10,000 or more per site. Park turnover could also be affected by these changes.
Page 53
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT JLHP users particularly those with ‘annual sites’ are known to be uncertain regarding their site occupancy at JLHP. It is entirely a matter for ATPM as the ‘caravan park owner’ to deal with such matters including fee structures. CONCLUSION
Mediation is being arranged as an appropriate step in the process of determining a dispute concerning contractual lease obligations between Council and ATPM. A further report will be provided.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
10.3.1 That Council note this report and that there will be a further report at the
conclusion of the mediation process.
MOTION
10.3.1 That Council note this report and that there will be a further report at the
conclusion of the mediation process.
Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Bill McClenaghan Carried.
Page 54
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
11. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 11.1 COMMUNITY GRANTS ROUND 1 2010 - 2011 GENERAL MANAGER COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to present to Council Round 1 2010/11 Community Grants recommendations.
BACKGROUND Twice each year Council has the opportunity through its Community Grants Program to directly support the work of community groups and organisations as well as provide the chance for new innovations. Round 1 Community Grants opened on 16 August 2010 and closed 17 September 2010. The availability of Community Grants was advertised in the Advocate, on the Council webpage and in community newsletters. The Community Grants Program was also promoted through e-mail distribution lists. Grant writing workshops were held in Trentham (25 August), Clunes (26 August), Daylesford (1 September) and Creswick (2 September). Attendance at the workshops was down on previous rounds with no participants attending the Clunes workshop and only one person in Trentham although attendance was good in Creswick and Daylesford.
The funding pool available for Round 1 (2010/11) is $22,500. 31 applications were received (although two applications were received for the same project) compared with 35 applications in Round 2 and 26 in Round One 2009/10. ISSUES/DISCUSSION No applications were received from community groups in Clunes and the majority of applications (14) were from Daylesford. A good number of applications were received from small towns (Smeaton, Clydesdale,Glenlyon, Kingston, Lyonville and Newlyn). Grant applications were assessed against the following criteria: 1. Description of project - 10% 2. What will this project address? – 25% 3. What will the project achieve? – 25% 4. How will the project be implemented and who will be doing it? – 20% 5. How will risk and safety issues associated with the project be assessed? –
10% 6. Financial details – income and expenditure budget – 10%
Page 55
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Representatives from the Arts and Culture and Recreation Advisory Committees along with the Recreation Officer and Community Strengthening Manager assessed all grants. The recommended Community Grant allocation for Round 1 (2010-11) is $20,033. A summary of projects and recommendations is attached (Attachment 1). COUNCIL PLAN/LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE The Hepburn Shire Council Plan states: “ We will create healthier, safer, more vibrant communities”. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Council has allocated $45,000 in the 2010/11 budget for Community Grants. RISK IMPLICATIONS N/A ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS N/A COMMUNITY/STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Round 1 2010/11 Community Grants were advertised in the Advocate, on Council’s webpage and through community newsletters and email distribution lists. Grant writing workshops were conducted in Daylesford, Creswick, Clunes and Trentham. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION 11.1.1 That Council award the Community Grants 2010-2011 Round 1 as
recommended in Attachment 1
Page 56
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION
11.1.1 That Council award the Community Grants 2010-2011 Round 1 as
recommended in Attachment 1 Moved: Councillor Tim Hayes Seconded: Councillor Don Henderson Carried.
Page 57
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 1 Item 11.1
COMMUNITY GRANTS 2010/2011 ROUND 1 RECOMMENDATIONS
Page 58
Recommended Projects: Arts & Culture
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Arts & Culture Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
ClaySpace (Daylesford
Region Ceramics Co-
operative Ltd.)
Further development of Clayspace as a hub of ceramics
practice & community arts by the collective building &
inaugural firing of a wood fired kiln, followed by showing of
works created. Project to emphasise the inclusion of people
with no previous ceramics experience working with
experienced ceramic artists.
Arts & Culture 2,000.00 $2,000.00 82.25
U3A Hepburn Shire Inc U3A Hepburn Shire plan to conduct a community concert
that will feature the Zelman Memorial Symphony Orchestra.
The Orchestra is Melbourne's longest running community
symphony orchestra composed of both professional and
amateur musicians. The professed aim of the orchestra is to
spread the spirit and joy of fine music amongst friends and
the wider community. U3A Hepburn Shire will be covering a
portion of the costs involved in bringing the orchestra to
Daylesford.
Arts & Culture 1,525.00 $1,525.00 74.25
Words in Winter This grant application is to fund a series of haiku and drama
workshops for children culminating in an exhibition of their
work during the 2011 words in winter celebration.
Arts & Culture 750.00 $750.00 69.00
Murmur Collective Murmur Collective plans to mount a theatre production of
Sam Shepard's Play When the World was green (A Chef's
Fable) April 8,9,& 10 2011 at DWA 3 East St Daylesford. A
hauntingly lyrical play, Sam Shepard's When the World was
Green (A Chef's Fable) sketches a tender narrative of regret
and loss through which we can transcend our memories and
reach forgiveness and love. This play premiered at the 1996
Atlanta Olympic Arts Festival.
Arts & Culture 1,500.00 $1,500.00 61.13
Arts &Culture $5,775.00
Page 59
Arts & Culture Not recommended
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Arts & Culture Score
Historic Commercial
Vehicle Club - Ballarat
Branch
To utilise the historic township of Clunes to demonstrate to
the public the historical significance and give to them the
opportunity to view, the vehicles of yesteryear. Restore and
displayed in their former glory by enthusiasts from
likeminded district clubs.
Arts & Culture Project failed to address
Arts & Culture Grant
objectives or how Clunes
community would benefit.
53.00
Spa Country Events A Boutique community owned cinema for Daylesford,
located upstairs at the Rex, Vincent street Daylesford.
Arts & Culture Assessor's considered that
the project needed further
development, in particular
financial analysis and that
the proposed site privately
owned.
54.75
Creswick Museum To Celebrate the re-opening of the Creswick Museum, the
official museum accreditation and a collection of milestones
in the community of or about 150 years, we will stage an
exhibition of life in Creswick.
Arts & Culture The application was
underdeveloped and did not
address all assessment
criteria, the project is
eligible for support through
the Museums, Boroughs
and Shires project.
53.50
Page 60
Recommended Projects : Community Events
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Community
Events
Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
Great Trentham
Spudfest May 2011
Council funding, should this application be successful, will be
put towards Arts & Culture performances and activities
targeted mainly at teenagers and children, e.g. band and
individual music performances, creative artists (clown face
painters, puppet performances, town criers and poets etc),
unique creative artistic inventions made out of cardboard,
animal farm etc. This will create a highly visible, celebratory,
fun and festive atmosphere around the event, engaging all.
Community
Events
2,000.00 $2,000.00 80.50
Creswick and District
Development
Association Inc.
The design, production and installation of street decorations
that identify the festive nature of the town during the Legacy
of the Lindsays Festival, April 15-25 2011
Community
Events
2,000.00 $2,000
(Subject to
Powercorp
approval)
78.25
Andersons Mill Festival Funding to ensure the continuing high standard of
performances at the 2011 festival.
Community
Events
2,000.00 $1,500.00 74.25
$3,500.00
Community Events Not Recommended
Friends of Trentham
Station
This year celebrates 10 years of this annual festival, a
significant milestone and is a major source of income for the
railway station and the Visitor information centre, so that
they can remain a major attraction for the visitors to
Trentham.
Community
Events
Assessors felt event already
viable and was a fundraising
event.
60.13
Daylesford Music
Technologists
Intimate autumn/harvest festival celebration featuring local
musicians & artists from Melb. 2 day affair - focus on
community involvement. Gypsy themes chai tent
Community
Events
The funding request was to
support a festival at the Old
Hepburn Hotel
Not
eligible
Page 61
Recommended Projects : Community Strengthening Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Community
Strengthening
Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
Clydesdale Hall
Committee
To further enhance Clydesdale Hall by building a Rotunda
adjacent to War Memorial. Used for social community
gatherings esp. Anzac & Remembrance day. Facility to have
disabled person access.
Community
Strengthening
1,500.00 $1,500.00 83.00
Daylesford Girl Guides 2011 Breakfast (and Future Mentor Breakfasts) 11 March
2011. An International Women's Day celebration. Aims to
encourage & inspire young women to reach for the best in
themselves as they consider future career paths. Brings
together female Yr 11 students & woman achievers from a
variety of fields. Mentors sponsor students.
Community
Strengthening
700.00 $700.00 85.75
Kingston Pony Club We are currently seeking assistance in obtaining funds to
create the opportunity for our riders to learn and practice;
how to approach, manage and execute some cross country
jumps. Without this addition to the club we may begin to
lose riders to other clubs, with the majority of these clubs
being outside the Hepburn Shire boundary.
Community
Strengthening
2000 $2,000.00 70.25
Daylesford Community
Swing Band
The group would like to present themselves in a visually
unifying fashion. They require Music Stands and Banners and
be able to buy their own music scores and not rely on
borrowing.
Community
Strengthening
1,720.00 $1,720.00 73.88
$5,920.00
Page 62
Community
Strengthening
Not Recommended
Country Women's
Association - Creswick
Branch
We Pride ourselves in reaching out to women in rural and
isolated settings that are keen to develop new skills and
confidence. We aim at being a worthwhile group with
stimulating activities that reach out and strengthen our
community
Community
Strengthening
Project not clearly specified,
request for general support
44.50
St Michael's Primary
School Parents
Association
St Michael's School spring fete is held every two years and is
a major social event and fundraising event for the school.
The Fete will take place on Sunday 31st October and is an
important celebration for not only our school community but
also our local community.
Community
Strengthening
Proejct ineligible as event
occurs prior to Council
decision.
ineligible
Page 63
Recommended Projects: Small Equipment
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Small Equipment Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
Friends of Creswick Park
Lake Botanical Reserve
Due to poor soil in Park plants require being fed & weeds
need to be sprayed to make path safe. New plants are
needed.
Small
Equipment
372.00 $372.00 68.50
Pony Club Association of
Victoria - Trentham
This project will engage TPC Volunteers in the removal of one
cross-Country fence and a professional Equestrian Fence
Builder will be engaged to design, build and install a
replacement fence, for the enjoyment of all riders at NRR
(Newbury Recreation Reserve)
Small
Equipment
500.00 $500.00 83.00
St Vincent de Paul,
Daylesford
The Daylesford Food Share Project is manned completely by
volunteers. It is envisaged this project will remain in place for
the coming years, and we ask Council to consider purchase of
a safe trolley for food transport, with step access/belt, and
also a step that is safe to enable volunteers to access stored
food on top of shelving.
Small
Equipment
486.00 $486.00 72.25
Daylesford Makers
Market
The Daylesford Markers Market - monthly event. It provides
opportunity for local musicians to play and promote their
music. Music is played in two 1hr sets which leaves three
hours of silence. Use of a designated iPod or MP3 player
linked into a portable Sound System would address the issue.
Small
Equipment
500.00 $500.00 73.00
Page 64
Recommended Projects: Small Equipment
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Small Equipment Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
The Lyonville Hall
Committee
This grant is in the content of the Lyonville Woodchip, as well
as private hiring of the hall. A new Refrigerator will promote
social benefit to our community and will ensure health and
safety aspects are properly addressed.
Small
Equipment
485.00 $485.00 78.25
Hepburn Shire State
Emergency Service Unit
The Hepburn Shire SES unit seeks funding to purchase a
Vehicle Recovery Kit. This Equipment will enable our crews to
rescue stranded or disabled vehicles as part of our search
and rescue responsibilities.
Small
Equipment
495.00 $495.00 70.75
Seeding Victoria The Cutting garden is a historic garden area at the Creswick
nursery that was previously utilised to propagate plants for
the nursery as well as being an asset to the grounds which is
intriguing and lovely to walk through. In recent times both
the structure and garden are in a state of disrepair and
neglect. Restoration of this garden is viewed as important
and is priority for the Nursery through the engagement
associated community groups and volunteers. Small tools
and equipment are being sort to assist this project and will
be an ongoing asset for future restoration projects on site.
Small
Equipment
500.00 $500.00 68.13
Page 65
Recommended Projects: Small Equipment
Name of Organisation or
Group
Project Description Small Equipment Requested
Amount
Recommended
Amount
Score
Newlyn Football Netball
Club Inc.
The Newlyn Football Club is requesting funding through the
community grants program for purchase of a portable public
address system. The system would be multipurpose having
facility for microphone as well as amplified music. The
system will be housed at the Newlyn Community and
Sporting Complex and will be available to the many
community complex user groups. The Newlyn Community
complex is a designated emergency relief centre and this
equipment be of great benefit in emergency situations.
Small
Equipment
$500.00 68.63
Creswick Band The Creswick Brass band is made up of members from
Creswick and other surrounding areas. The band is quite a
large size for a small community - 30+ members. The band is
in need of a new photocopier.
Small
Equipment
500.00 $500.00 71.00
Glenlyon Progress
Association
The proposal is to purchase 4 sets of event display signs for
annual Glenlyon Progress Association events in Glenlyon - Art
show, Food & Wine Fayre and sculpture show and the
monthly Glenlyon Market to place on the recently installed
signage frames at either end of Glenlyon.
Small
Equipment
1,260.00 $500.00 69.00
$4,838.00
Page 66
Small Equipment Not Recommended
Grounded Dance
Company
To construct transportable ballet bars that can be used for
technique training and warm up for newly formed local
dance company. By having ballet bars the company dancers
can improve a technique and thus improve quality of their
performance. The bars can also be used by other members of
the community in movement workshops held by Grounded
Dance Company.
Small
Equipment
There was no evidence that
this was a community group
and the application did not
demonstrate community
need and involvement
Not
eligible
Spiritual Unity of the
Tribes Australia Inc.
Assoc.
We would like to purchase a 4 burner BBQ/ Gas bottle/ Fire
extinguisher/ blanket/ first aid kit for our non-profit
organisation. We need all the safety equipment for safe
operation and so we can be prepared for any incidents that
may occur.
Small
Equipment
The application did not
adequately demonstrate
how the project met the
selection criteria but was
focused on fundraising.
Council, has community
BBQ. Previous grant not
acquitted despite follow up.
48.75
Lyonville Planning group Our request for a small equipment grant is to fund a fridge
for our community hall. It is basic necessity that will benefit
our small but thriving community to function better and
therefore operate more effectively. At this point we have no
working fridge at all which makes it difficult as our
community grows and more events are being held in the hall.
Small
Equipment
The application was a
duplicate of that submitted
by Lyonville Hall Committee
and has been withdrawn.
Page 67
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
11.2 COMMUNITY BUSHFIRE MEMORIAL SITE SELECTION GENERAL MANAGER COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
PURPOSE The purpose of this report is for Council to consider the recommendation of the Community Recovery Committee on the proposed Bushfire Memorial at the road reserve at Sailors Falls and to consider further community feedback.
BACKGROUND At the Ordinary Council Meeting on September 21 2010, Council considered a report seeking Council’s endorsement of the Community Recovery Committee’s recommendation that a Bushfire Memorial located at Sailors Falls be constructed (Attachment 2). The Officer Recommendations in the report was: That Council:
Endorse the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee’s recommendation to develop a bushfire memorial at the road reserve at Sailors Falls;
Note that an expression of interest for an artist to develop the memorial will be advertised and that the project will be managed by a Project Reference Group.
At the Council Meeting, Council resolved to: That Council:
Recognise and thank the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee for their recommendation to develop a bushfire memorial at the road reserve at Sailors Falls;
Allow the recommendation to remain on the table for a further period of one or two months before coming back to Council for consideration at either the October or November Ordinary Meeting. Following the 2009 bushfires Council was allocated $79,647 from the Department of Planning and Community Development (DPCD) for a bushfire memorial to symbolise the 2009 Daylesford/Musk Vale and Black Saturday fires.
Council officers and the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee have facilitated a public consultation process to select a location for a bushfire
Page 68
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
memorial in accordance with the DPCD funding guidelines, which require an inclusive and supportive community consultation process
Consultation has included a series of public meetings hosted by consultant artist Sally Goldstraw and Council officers to generate ideas for the memorial including its location. A subsequent report was produced by the consultant identifying the symbols and themes that were important in developing the memorial. The Report also identified sites for the memorial as recommended by the community: • Burke Square • Daylesford Community Park • Lost Children’s Memorial Park • Next to Daylesford Museum • Defiance Tunnel site • Roadside reserve (in the fire affected area) • Walking trails between Sailors Falls and Bullarto • A community garden (site uncertain). These sites were evaluated by Council officers including engineers and town planning staff to assess site ownership, zoning and relevant planning overlays. The following sites were found to be preferential: • Roadside reserve (recommended as being at Sailors Falls) • Lost Children’s Memorial Park • Daylesford Community Park • Burke Square The CRC considered these sites at its July meeting and selected the Sailor’s Falls roadside reserve as the preferred option. The CRC Memorial Working Group unanimously endorsed the decision following a site visit, identifying the exact location as the road reserve on the Daylesford Ballan Road, opposite Sailors Falls. The reserve begins at Shanahans Lane and stretches towards Daylesford along the road frontage of a farming property at the exact location where the fire started. ISSUE/DISCUSSION Advertisements were placed in the Advocate on 29 November and 18 October 2010 seeking public consultation on the preferred site at Sailors Falls. Written submission addressed to the Chief Executive Officer closed on 22 October 2010.
Page 69
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Five submissions (Attachment 3) were received from: • Russ Jenkins • Winsome Menadue • Don Henderson and Ken Rea (Daylesford Urban Fire Brigade) • Judy Macleod • Ian Marshall (Daylesford & District Historical Society Inc.)
The Sailors Falls site is highly visible and could provide a ‘gateway affect’. The site assessment report prepared by Council found there was plenty of potential for a tree row/avenue of remembrance/appreciation and public art to commemorate the efforts of CFA etc. This stretch of roadside is also where locals displayed banners after the fire to thank CFA volunteers. There is plenty of room for people to pull over and park their vehicles to view and enjoy the memorial along with good visual prominence for people just passing by.
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Council Plan 2009-2013 – Good Governance: 17. Embracing community knowledge and expertise to help guide its decision making and implementation. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS The Hepburn Shire has been allocated $79,647 for the project. Ongoing maintenance will become the responsibility of the Council. A community program could be incorporated to maintain the reserve, such as Adopt a Roadside. RISK IMPLICATIONS The site has been assessed by VicRoads and they have given written approval for a memorial to be established at the site. Council would need to enter into an agreement with VicRoads to maintain the site. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS The communities of Sailors Falls, Musk Vale and Leonard’s Hill claim there is little to visually ‘define’ their area for people driving through. This project would provide something for these communities to identify with and be proud of. Council officers are about to embark on working with these communities to develop Community Plans.
Page 70
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The site is adjacent to the Sailors Falls Reserve and has the potential to value add to this tourist location. At present the Sailors Falls site that is selected is overgrown with grass and weeds and this project would provide a method to beautify and manage this section of road reserve. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Extensive consultation has taken place in determining themes and location of the bushfire memorial. Following endorsement of the site:
• An expression of interest for an artist to develop the memorial will be advertised;
• A Community Advisory Group, will be involved in selection of the artist; and,
• A Project Reference Group comprising Council officers, Vic Roads and Parks Victoria will be appointed to oversee project implementation.
CONCLUSION Following extensive community consultation the Sailors Falls roadside reserve adjacent to the Sailors Falls Reserve has been determined as the most suitable location for the Hepburn Bushfire Memorial. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 11.2.1 Endorse the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee’s recommendation
to develop a bushfire memorial at the road reserve at Sailors Falls; 11.2.2 Note that an expression of interest for an artist to develop the memorial
will be advertised and that the project will be managed by a Project Reference Group.
Page 71
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION That Council: 11.2.1 again recognizes and thanks the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee for their great work on this and other matters, and the wide range of community members who have made written and verbal submissions on the topic. 11.2.2 Accepts the written advice of the Daylesford Urban Fire Brigade and others against the Sailors Falls site, and the request of the Bushfire Memorial that will property acknowledge and represent the views of our community on this matter, benefit our community and provide a functional asset for our community and visitors to our area. 11.2.3 Favours a memorial being community infrastructure works, with a very significant public art component, at one of the following sites: Vincent Street Daylesford between the roundabouts and /or Burke Square Daylesford Daylesford Community Park (Daylesford Youth and Skate Park) cnr Stanbridge and Duke Streets Defiance Tunnel Site, cnr Bleakley and King Streets. Council is currently engaged in a Vincent Street Revitalisation Project and the staged development of the Daylesford Community Park, and has received submissions regarding the development of a Daylesford Historical Precinct. Council will make its final decision on the site and nature of its Bushfire Memorial as the above proposals progress. Moved: Councillor Rod May Seconded: Councillor Don Henderson Not carried.
Page 72
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
AMENDED MOTION That Council: 11.2.1 again recognizes and thanks the Hepburn Community Recovery Committee for their great work on this and other matters, and the wide range of community members who have made written and verbal submissions on the topic. 11.2.2 Accepts the written advice of the Daylesford Urban Fire Brigade and others against the Sailors Falls site, and the request of the Bushfire Memorial that will property acknowledge and represent the views of our community on this matter, benefit our community and provide a functional asset for our community and visitors to our area. 11.2.3 Favours a memorial being community infrastructure works, with a very significant public art component, at one of the following sites: Vincent Street Daylesford between the roundabouts and /or Burke Square Daylesford Daylesford Community Park (Daylesford Youth and Skate Park) cnr Stanbridge and Duke Streets Defiance Tunnel Site, cnr Bleakley and King Streets. Sailors Falls Reserve, cnr Telegraph Road and Ballan-Daylesford Road Council is currently engaged in a Vincent Street Revitalisation Project and the staged development of the Daylesford Community Park, and has received submissions regarding the development of a Daylesford Historical Precinct. Council will make its final decision on the site and nature of its Bushfire Memorial as the above proposals progress. Moved: Councillor Sebastian Klein Seconded: Councillor Bill McClenaghan Carried.
Page 73
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 2 Item 11.2
BUSHFIRE MEMORIAL SITE RECOMMENDATION
Page 74
Bushfire memorial consultation SITE ASSESSMENT July 2010
Page 75
Bushfire Memorial Consultation Site assessment July 2010 Background The Hepburn Shire received $80,000 from the Department of Planning and Community Develop-ment for a memorial to symbolise the 2009 Daylesford, and Black Saturday fires. A series of public consultation sessions were held during March 2010 to gather ideas about what types of things could be created to embody a symbol to the 2009 fires and the type of memorial that could be created (such as a playground, park, gates, a path or trail, reflective space, sculp-ture or garden). The consultation revealed ideas around what the memorial would look like and a number of site locations were suggested. Some of these ideas were linked to specific sites and locations around the shire. This document provides: • evaluation of the sites including the status of the land eg: privately or publicly owned 2) The
controlling body eg: Council as the committee of management 3) The zone the site is lo-cated within 4) Any heritage overlay which may apply to the site.
• Site assessment criteria. The next steps • The Community Recovery Committee Memorial Working Group will make a recommenda-
tion regarding the preferred memorial site and/or options, based on the site assessment to Council.
• A designer/artist brief will then be developed which will include the approved project site, consultation feedback, historical information, project budget and timeline.
• It is proposed that a Project Control/Reference Group will be appointed to oversee the pro-ject implementation. Membership and residents will be consulted regarding the final design/concept. A community engagement strategy will be devised to support the implementation of the project.
General location ideas/general ideas Daylesford - most residents saw Daylesford as the most appropriate place for a memorial. Sailors Falls beside the road - one resident would like to see a memorial on the road verge at Sailors Falls close to where the fire started. Linking Sailors Falls and Bullarto - this was seen as a symbolic linking of communities as well as where the fire started and stopped. Walking trails and tree plantings were suggested in rela-tion to these towns. NOT Bullarto - the community definitely did not want a memorial located at Bullarto. During the meeting two residents were keen to see something for the children and the involvement of the local school if appropriate. Community Gardens These were seen as memorials to the community spirit where people could continue to connect and contribute in many different ways. The gardens would be a symbol of growth, healing and hope. It was suggested they could be located in the communities that were affected. Locations ideas have not yet been determined.
Page 76
Burke Square, Vincent Street, Daylesford Owned/Managed: Hepburn Shire Council. Burke Square Daylesford - shows as a Road Zone 1. Maintained by Council with guidance from VicRoads. Description: Road Reserve. Small village green in town centre where the town’s war memorial is located. Overlays: Overlays applicable to this main street area include Design and Development, Heri-tage and Environmental Significance. A village square that is designed to be a place where residents can go if they have lost someone or need to be found in an emergency. It was suggested that a village square could be developed which could also be utilised by people on code red days if they are unable to leave. A public space with gates in Albert St Lancefield was mentioned as a model. It was envisaged that this location would provide shade, shelter for animals, water to drink, inspiring art and some activities such as a chess set. This would be a place where people could go so they were not alone. Other residents would know that this was a place they could go to offer help to those who may be alone or in need of support with transport and animals. It was specifically mentioned that a village square could be used to find one another on code red days and that public art could be incorporated into the design. Maybe it could have an open art gallery for local artists to display work. Notes: this site is located nearby the area declared by the Council/CFA and State Govern-ment as the Neighbourhood Safer Place. However, it must be noted the Neighbourhood Safer Places are ‘Places of Last Resort’ were there will be no services or provisions are residents are encouraged to use these sites as just that: A place of last resort when all their other fire plans have failed, where their survival would not be guaranteed. A village square may attract people to gather at this location or stay in the area during a fire, rather than the preferred option of them leaving early.
Page 77
Daylesford Community Park. 33 Duke Street, Daylesford Owned/Managed: Owned by DSE, Managed by Hepburn Shire Council is Committee of Manage-ment. Description: Public Park and Recreation Zone, and Public Use Zone—Local Government. Large open space. A skate park exists at this site. No facilities other than skate ramps. Overlays: Environment Significance Schedule 1 Environment Significance Schedule 2, Heritage Overlay HO898. A space for children and adolescents Upgrade a space for young people so they can connect and support one another. A number of residents mentioned a playground for children and another the existing skate park as a space to be improved for local young people. Location: Current Daylesford Community Skate park or Creswick Road Lost Children’s Site Public Art Residents liked the public art installation in Kyneton – particularly the symbolism of the black to white for those who were greatly affected to those who were least affected by the fires; the inclu-sion of found objects into the tiles and the placement at a level where people were able to touch the artwork. Another resident was interested in a memorial on a road verge close to where the fire started at Sailors Falls that incorporated the symbols of rocks, steel and something spiritual. One resident mentioned a sculpture. Location: Burke Square, Roadside verge at Sailors Falls, Skate (Community) park, Lost Children’s site NOTES: Long history of residents wanting more facilities including toilets and shade sails. Bushfire memorial funding may provide an opportunity to further develop this site.
Page 78
Lost Children’s Walk memorial park site. 4360 Midland Hwy, Daylesford Owned/Managed: Crown Land, Committee of Management—Hepburn Shire Council. Description: Zoned residential. Park with monument and interpretive signage for Lost Children’s Walk. Open space and picnic tables. Overlays: Design and Development Overlay Schedule 3 Environmental significance schedule 1, Environmental significance schedule 2 Heritage overlay H0731 Wildfire Management Overlay A space for children and adolescents Upgrade a space for young people so they can connect and support one another. A number of residents mentioned a playground for children and another the existing skate park as a space to be improved for local young people. Location: Current Daylesford Skate park or Creswick Road Lost Children’s Site Public Art Residents liked the public art installation in Kyneton – particularly the symbolism of the black to white for those who were greatly affected to those who were least affected by the fires; the inclu-sion of found objects into the tiles and the placement at a level where people were able to touch the artwork. Another resident was interested in a memorial on a road verge close to where the fire started at Sailors Falls that incorporated the symbols of rocks, steel and something spiritual. One resident mentioned a sculpture. Location: Burke Square, Roadside verge at Sailors Falls, Skate park, Lost Children’s site NOTES: Located near the new SES and ambulance buildings. Visual from main road to Creswick from Daylesford, and the Mill Market.
Page 79
100 Vincent Street (Between Daylesford Museum and Old Fire Station, Daylesford (to locate historic Stanbridge Jinker) Owned/Managed: DSE, Managed by Museum Reserve Committee of Management. Description: Block beside museum building, used to exhibit museum items. Located next door to old fire station which is now the Visitor Information Centre. Overlays: Environment schedule 1 Environment schedule 2 Heritage overlay H0285 and Heritage overlay H0286 Historical Jinker in Daylesford One community member suggested that the Jinker that has been donated to the Shire could be housed next to the fire station as a memorial. The relationship between the Jinker and fires was not ascertained. Location: Next to the fire station in Daylesford. NOTES: There appears to be no particular link to the jinker and the fires but a number of residents recognised it was a prime location for a memorial of some kind.
Page 80
Defiance Tunnel site, Daylesford. 1 Bleakley Street, Daylesford Owned/Managed: Hepburn Shire Council Description: Vacant land opposite BP, on main entrance to town from Ballan Road. Overlay: Design and Development overlay Environment schedule 1 overlay, Environment schedule 2 overlay, Neighbourhood Character Schedule 1 overlay Defiance Tunnel Daylesford One community member proposed that the tunnel be re-opened with a diorama showing local his-tory. It could contain local history about fires in the region. It was seen as a welcoming entrance way to the township and improved pedestrian access from the town centre to the lake. It could include an amphitheatre for CFA & schools to use for educational purposes. Location: Opposite the BP service station NOTES: The site hade been suggested as a park previously by some members of the com-munity, and other suggested uses have been development for housing and council has previously recommended its sale to raise revenue. * An exact location/s has not been suggested for the Community Garden idea.
Page 81
Roadside reserves between Sailors Falls and Daylesford, and Dayles-ford and Bullarto and Bullarto or Muskvale and Bullarto. Owned/managed: VicRoads Description: Main arterials between Ballan and Daylesford; and Daylesford and Trentham Overlays: Design and Environment Environment significance schedule 1 Environment significance schedule 2 Heritage overlay HO694 Avenue of Remembrance Tree planting for the 173 people who were killed on Black Saturday to form an avenue of remem-brance. This could also take the form of an “Avenue of Appreciation” for CFA volunteers and fire fighters. Location: Between Sailors Falls and Bullarto or any location that was appropriate. Walking Trail This could be a symbolic connection between communities and a way to remember where the fire travelled. This could enhance other trails. This could be a contemplative trail incorporating art and education. Location: Between Sailors Falls and Bullarto or Muskvale and Bullarto Sailors Falls beside the road - one resident would like to see a memorial on the road verge at Sailors Falls close to where the fire started..
Page 82
Walking trail on tracks and roads between Sailors Falls and Bullarto. Owned/Managed: Combination of Parks Victoria (Hepburn Regional Park), DSE (Wombat For-est), local Council Roads and Vic Roads. Description: Other known trails already exist through this bushland including Lost Children’s Walk and Great Dividing Range Trail. Overlays: A number of overlays exist throughout this forest and area including environmental significance and wildfire management Walking Trail This could be a symbolic connection between communities and a way to remember where the fire travelled. This could enhance other trails. This could be a contemplative trail incorporating art and education. Location: Between Sailors Falls and Bullarto or Muskvale and Bullarto Daylesford - most residents saw Daylesford as the most appropriate place for a memorial. Sailors Falls beside the road - one resident would like to see a memorial on the road verge at Sailors Falls close to where the fire started. Linking Sailors Falls and Bullarto - this was seen as a symbolic linking of communities as well as where the fire started and stopped. Walking trails and tree plantings were suggested in rela-tion to these towns. NOT Bullarto - the community definitely did not want a memorial located at Bullarto. During the meeting two residents were keen to see something for the children and the involvement of the local school if appropriate.
Page 83
Community Gardens These were seen as memorials to the community spirit where people could continue to connect and contribute in many different ways. The gardens would be a symbol of growth, healing and hope. It was suggested they could be located in the communities that were affected. Locations ideas have not yet been determined. Would require parcels of land which provide public access and accessibility to water. Sites recommended for memorials that may also be suitable for a community garden include: Daylesford Skate Park Defiance Tunnel site Lost children’s walk memorial park Notes: other public/private locations may be available. These locations could be identified in a number of ways including calling for ideas/expressions of interest from the community. A community garden is currently being de-veloped in Trentham.
Page 84
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 3 Item 11.2
COMMUNITY FEEDBACK RE BUSHFIRE MEMORIAL SITE RECOMMENDATION
Page 85
Patron: Professor Davkj de Krester. AC. Govemor of Mctoria
DAYLESFORD URBAN FIRE BRTGADE26 Btidport StrcetP.O. Box 2ElDAYLESFORD 3460
Ca$aln: Don Andepon Phone 53481291(BH)Secretary: KenRea Phone53482970(AH)
0/.nor20rc
lGyleen CondrickChief Executive OfficerHepbum ShireCuncilMnert StrcetDAYLESFORD. 3460
PEttRN co,{"$nrcil"
Fito [,ts: ..... -r-^<r.c\lo[:St"A
Rocu Dah: | 3 oCT 2010
ae' is Vu\or) ,
L Cc, n c:.URe: Hefiened Sitefor Bushfire Memorial
Dear Ms Conddck.
At the last meeting of the Drybsford Fire Brigade the su$ect of the Bushfire Menprialrvas dlscussed.
The B{tade is oorpemed that fte allocatbn of funds b thb prciect will be nrasbd on a pointlessmemorialan fte slde of the road at Saibrs Falfs.
The memberc of the BIigEde bd that tfe allocdtirn of tpse furds should be direcbd to a wortlnrvtrileproidd that will benefit the cornrnunily ard abo prorUe a ftrrrctinnal 6s6t for the ornmunity andvisitors to $is area.
The Bdgde is awate of frre Defiance Tunnel propcal and we believe Orat this proposd has anenoFnous amount of merit to benefit the ommunity and ppvirJe a prominent pcitton fur UE Mernorbl,in whatever form it takes.
The Br[ade underctands that the coats associded wih the cornpleb proposal would prob$ly be ine)<oesst of the amount albcated fut vrould enoourage Councrl to take a brod view of thb s.Egpstionand eryen take on the prtjai in silages.
Abo of gret onoern to ilte tsrigpde is iltat thb area b a se*rus fire hazad. lts retrabillitEtinn vloulden$lre that tte area uouH be made safe and r€dJe the pobntFil ftrks faced by the refrbres in thisatea.
Yoursfaihtully
wM&Ken Rea
Seoetary
DonAndeson
Captain
CcCrJ BanellCr Bill McClerng€nCrRod Mry
creating safer communities
Page 86
Usqc*..b
-
Zoc,'5go
:,,. ,, .",",1
rP."- 1L ?.Vr,.l
c-'- K 61r.-;1..k
30 Rosstown RdCarnegie 3163
0407 534 925 [email protected]
166 October .2010
Ms Kaylene Connick CEOHepburn councilPO Box 21,Daylesford 3460
Dear Kaylene,
There is much Jubilation at Jubilee Lake regarding the withdrawal of ATPM.
I am concerned however, the current manager is saying the park is closing on the 31"1 December. I
spoke with him last week and told him it was not his place to say that. He should only be sayingATPM withdrawing as he willturn many prospective c€rmpers away for Christmas, New Year andJanuary which is the busiest holiday time. This will cause loss of revenue at a time when the parkparticularly needs it.
The Park Manager Stewart has also been telling annuals that ATPM are negotiating with council. I
had wondered if ATPM were trying to manipulate council into accepting their terms because ofsome things Stewart said to me last week. lt appears their resignation was a bluff tactic to get theirown way. Are you able to reassure us that ATPM are definitely withdrawing or whether it is truecouncil are willing to renegotiate with them. This is a verv scary thought!
I do understand there are a lot of hurdles to work through regarding the caravan park section. Theannuals are feeling a great sense of relief (those who are yet unaware about the possibility ofrenegotiations) and are very willing and happy to work with council to enable the park to remainopen. Many have come up with suggestions with ways to keep park open and necessary financeswe would love to share if you feelthat is appropriate.
One resident has been to consumer affairs and he has been told although the new regulations havebeen passed by parliament there is no date for when these are to be implemented.
ATPM accuses Council of running an illegal park, however, during the 2% yrs they have beenmanaging they have not fulfilled their obligations regarding maintenance of the drains, amenities,roads and many other aspects. They have no right to accuse council when they have done that verything themselves. Finance hasn't been a reason because they have ripped us off with increasedfees and have given nothing in return.
They acted in presumption that the new lease boundaries would be approved by selling off the oldcabins to make way for powered sites. They have left the park in a dreadful state. Removing thecabins will lose a large amount of holiday revenue for that area.
lf at all possible it would be well worth council taking over the park earlier than 31" Decemberbecause of the fact of holiday season and ATPM are sending out very negative reports about thepark.
I would like to run a suggestion by you. I read in the Advocate a couple of weeks ago that councilhad received $80,000 for a memorial of the fires of 2 years ago. I noted a suggestion was made forSailors falls.
Page 87
This is a lot of money to spend on something that doesn't provide ongoing use. A plaque at Sailorsfalls I would like to suggest would be adequate.
Jubilee Lake came under a realthreat and was closed for 5 days. Fire surrounded about 50 % ofthe park and actually burnt along one edge of the reserve boundary.I am NOT suggesting this money be used for the caravan park area, however I feel it would bemoney used in a very practical way if the fire water main was brought into the reserve and a hydrantbe placed in the reserve area. This would protect the house and sunounding reserve. Perhapsthere is a pump system that could be put in place to use the lake water in case of another fire.Of course this would also benefit the caravan park section because then less money is needed tobe found to complete the hydrants in the caravan section. I feelthis would enable the money to beused to help in a long term and practical way the very thing the money was given in memory of.
I spoke with a local last Sunday who I had never met before and we were talking about Jubilee lakeand I made mention of the money needed to put in the fire protection in the caravan park. I madethe comment it wasn't fair for the rate payers to put in to assist the caravan park and her responsewas 'why not? | think most people would rather do that than have it wasted on other things lessimportant to the towns' people." I thought that was a very interesting sentiment.
lf I am able to assist in anyway or be a link between council and the annuals at Jubilee Lake thendon't hesitate to contact me. I would like to thank the Councilors and yourself for the support youhave given to Jubilee Lake. We appreciate that you have listened to us and realized ATPM wouldhave ruined a precious jewel in Daylesford. lt is certainly a much loved park.
With thanks and regards
\*a\ \4."-(*:.1.-\,
Mrs Judy Macleod
Page 88
22 Daly Street
Daylesford
t3/L0/20L0
Hepburn Shire Chief Executive Officer
Kayleen Condrick
75 Vincent Street
Daylesford 3450
Ps',li i'i,:'
Flec'd L1y:
Action By:
Fleg No:
e-c V- 4e t:r<-i c/'
Re Bushfire Memorial
Dear Ms Condrick,
I wish to again put forward the proposal sent to the Recovery Committee on 15th October 2009 in regard
to my suggestion re the Bushfire memorial.
Not having heard anything official from this committee and noting the further public consultation
required I again put forward the proposal for the area of the Defiance Tunnel.
This project has the support of the local CFA and the Historical Society and should be considered as a
worthwhile project.
I will assume you still have my original proposal.
I realize that it will need a lot of work to complete the project but it could be handled in stages.
Please give this project the support that it deserves and not waste the money provided on some useless
stone obelisk or such
Yours faithfully
-, n) D 'go
.o":;\czo'io
s
Page 89
Daylesford & District
VINCENT STREET DAYLESFORD, 346Q*'= ,^ rl*t; " sr tr*Fri; #{3{J
Dear KayleneRe: Defiance Tunnel site Proposed Park and addition
With regard to the recent press item indicating that Council were desirous of commentregarding the proposal for a bushfire memorial we offer the following comments.
This Society is not in favour of spending public money on a memorial on the side of the roadnear Sailors Falls. We note that the MuskVale fire was some order of magnitude less thanthe Kinglake and Gippsland fires and does not justify this level of memorialisation. IfCouncil wished to have our Shire's declaration of sympathy included on other memorials inseriously affected districts that would be appropriate.
If public funds are to be expended in this district then it should be on projects deliveringsome tangible community benefit and, ideally, serving multiple uses.
Alternatively, this Society supports the concept of developing the unused land, owned by theShire on the corner of Bleakley Street and Vincent Street North, into a park with appropriatehistoric interpretation. The area should also be included in the Lake Daylesford Reserve.
The land is a major component of Daylesford's history and deserves to have suitablerecognition and interpretation. This can also include some acknowledgement of the 2009fires.
The advantages of creating a new park and adjunct to Lake Daylesford are:-
o Provide an opportunity for improved information for pedestrian visitors to the LakeReserve and an imporlant opportunity to present information on the town and theLake to all other stop-off visitors.
o Recognition of a significant heritage siteo Enable suitable recognition of the 2009 fireso Enhance the visual amenity of a key mid-entry point to Daylesfordo Provide a major opportunity to significantly upgrade pedestrian access to Lake
Daylesfordo Provide the opportunity in the future, by way of a splay on the corner of the block, to
provide for an effective traffic roundabout. This would solve the traffic problems atone of the worst intersections in town.
Historical SocietyIncorp orated " ?.
Inc. No. 135868 ABN. 94 876 895 453 e-r trle6J.e^gL^
(03) 53 481453 email.N*:
Ftr:cij sab: | 5 ocT ?010
A
to Lake Dayles
100Tel
Kaylene ConrickCEOHepbum Shirer0ll0l20r0
Page 90
(-..
A failure to adopt the proposal would:-o Negate the above pointso Raise the likelihood of development unsympathetic to the Precinct that would fuither
damage the heritage fabric of the town.
We note that the concept has strategic support in the just lauched Mineral SpringsMasterplan Review. The basis of this support is the relationship with and the enhancement ofthe Lake Daylesford Reserve.
We note that the site is an archaeological site under the meaning of the ArchaeologicalRelics Act. The sensitive use as public open space permits protects this. Other privatedevelopments almost certainly would not. We attached an historic photograph below foryour information.
Yours faithfullyt l ir'l\ \,AT-C 1.
Ian Marshall (Secretarv)
Crs Barrell, McClenaghan,Henderson, Klein; Russ Jenkin; Trevor Westmore; LandPartners.
'.'''.''..''''''jt.'*,.l..l:."'',"tl.'.a.;''''.,.l':o',,j.|:.:
lt';,i'i.lt, J.t,t a t )r.* n:it):o ii 1; ".' ). ")
:. :,:"'..,.. '.".'"t'. ' ) ,i .iltz. iqi'"l.Ail}" t';;'|WL,q
i,, .,,+,, u" ,t.,il,tt.ri.t t' t t "'i , .- .;.ri)-\ \,.;,,iri '-: j 1.,,, !-,i.-,..t-,. ..!, 't, 1,)."
j "::,,1, Z)r;; ,111t,,,!* '8"r. i*i'rliji lalit'i i t::.";t ,; ..r.: '. .t: ,<;. . z 1,t.,1 l;." .;"".i;;:t *i:t,i-,l";t,iLct. ,.> 't"ti.l(t":i"n.L"f t., \ .'r '--t, t;T 1." ....: i ' ', . "'-' ," ,t',"it-" i'tt:; "". !\-t.->': '',:tl ;2.' ,";ti$r;iz-: ii".rii. *i";.,,i:; Vt"!:;ttt.-'.;".. ..
"";,.'.-'! .Li"t'."'. \')', "v..',;'t'," ':'' :r'"'tr|1'
\t,it:t+l::11i i:.i:i'ii11,;;:t't:(.'ta,i;;,..".:|i*:;'f l-r'.':i::.,i. 1 I' ,t:: ;:.'11',"lt,i:.1
{i {iii"3;i.ir. !:. 1:,i:,1:l .::"/'-,1':t'. l,,ilij7 1.1 i.,tr1i!\ltt, -./ .1,;11:l t,,tt.,:l ;
Page 91
90 OIC Main RC
EGANSIOI{N 346I4th Octobor 2010
Hepburn Shire100 Vincent StDAYLESFORD 3460
ro Hepburn Conrmunity Recovery Conmitleo
It is dishoartaning that Hepburn Shir:e (Advocate 29/09/LOLO)has extenCeC anothor month asking tha Conrrunity for noroidoas as how th spond tho $80,000., Iheso ideas then to boaccessed anC reviewed.
The Recovory Committeo havo givon constan& attendance at meetingsoxanining suUmissions to ensure the outcome to remembor this firaof febuary 2009 a succoss anC Iong timo memorial
IamYcurs sinceroly
H W MenadRed Crossnombor of
Daylosfordthe Conmitteo }8GP&JRN Sffin€ cfr,ftcf;_
File tS: ...*.oc.\t.p.\
Recd Dare: - 5 ()cT 2010
Page 92
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
12 SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: Councillor Don Henderson left the Meeting at 9.30pm due to a Conflict of Interest and returned at 10.03pm.
12.1 PROPOSED LEASE AGREEMENT FOR THE FORMER CRESWICK RAILWAY STATION, GOODS SHED AND LANDS, AND PROPOSED MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH THE CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOPS ASSOCIATION
PURPOSE This report presents for Councils consideration:
• A lease agreement between Hepburn Shire Council and VicTrack for the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands
• A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Hepburn Shire Council and the Creswick Railway Workshops Association (CRWA) for the use of the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands for community and tourism activities.
BACKGROUND With the re-use of the existing railway line to Creswick and the construction of the new Creswick railway platform in 2010, the former Railway Station, Goods Shed and Land became the focus for possible alternate uses by community groups.
Page 93
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
View from South of the former Creswick Railway Station (prior to restoration works)
View from South of the brick Goods Shed located behind new platform and shelter As endorsed at the March 2010 Ordinary Meeting, Council has been in discussion with VicTrack regarding opportunities to lease the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands to develop the community and tourism hub. Council have also been in discussions with the CRWA to produce a MOU for the buildings and land.
After a number of meetings with both VicTrack and CRWA representatives, two proposed agreements have been produced, as detailed later in the report. The buildings and land for lease by VicTrack are composed of the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and the lands identified in the VicTrack lease. (Refer plan below) A Councillor briefing was previously held for the CRWA to address Council on the merits of the proposal. ISSUE/ DISCUSSION
Page 94
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The use of the former Creswick Railway buildings and land for a community use should provide community and economic benefits for the Creswick community. Some of the anticipated uses of the facility include workshops and short courses, tea rooms, trades training programs, community market, arts and crafts, exhibitions and other like activities.
Page 95
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and the lands as identified in the VicTrack lease To enable this use to occur, two documents have been produced for consideration:
• A lease agreement between Hepburn Shire Council and VicTrack for the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands
• A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Hepburn Shire Council and the Creswick Railway Workshops Association (CRWA) for the use of the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands for community and tourism activities.
The proposed lease (Refer Attachment 4) provides details on the terms and conditions of the lease of the building and lands from VicTrack (the landlord) to Hepburn Shire Council (the tenant). The lease between VicTrack and HSC is an extensive document that is derived from a VicTrack standard format and adapted to suit this particular situation. The document deals with all aspects of the buildings lease and specifically deals with:
• Rent • Lease Duration • Payment Requirements • Repairs/ Refurbishment and Alterations • Insurance • Permitted Uses • Obligations from all parties
The key features of the lease include:
• Starting rent of $1,000 per annum plus GST payable annually in advance • 5% increase in rent every two years before a rent review in the fifth year • Community purposes are the identified permitted use • Outgoings to be paid by the tenant • Public Liability Insurance to be at $20M • Community Conditions as set out in Annexure C • Special Conditions as set out in Annexure E
In turn, it is proposed that Council should enter into an MOU for the use of the identified building and lands by the CRWA as an incorporated body. The MOU
Page 96
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
(Refer Attachment 5) essentially links the CRWA to the relevant conditions of the main lease as well as providing an agreed understanding of the use and occupancy of the former Railway buildings and lands. The key points from the MOU are:
• The grant of occupancy to CRWA will be subject to a Licence or sub-lease with Hepburn Shire Council (HSC). The sub-lease will identify all relevant obligations and be guided by the MOU.
• The Licence or sub-lease for occupancy of the Premises by CRWA will
require CRWA to meet the same obligations as HSC – but only those applicable and adapted for the purpose of any Licence or sub-lease - in the Lease between VicTrack and HSC.
• CRWA will be required to meet the same obligations as HSC that are
applicable in meeting the repair and maintenance Lease obligations and through the annual work plan.
• CRWA will pay a Licence or sub-lease fee/rent equal to the amount
payable by HSC to VicTrack.
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Council Plan 2009-2013: 54. Facilitating the restoration of important heritage buildings. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS The outgoings, rental, insurance and maintenance will be paid for by the CRWA through the sub-lease document. Councils ongoing cost implications will be the legal and administrative cost of creating and maintaining the sub-lease document (inspections and letters etc). The legal cost of creating the sub-lease is expected to be around $1,900. RISK IMPLICATIONS With the creation of the lease, MOU, Annual Work Plan and the business plan (Refer Attachment X), the key risk implications have been addressed.
Page 97
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS There will be positive social and economic implications for the Creswick community as a result of this project, based on the business plan the CRWA has produced. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT The project is a community initiative and has been delivered after numerous meetings with both the CRWA and VicTrack. CONCLUSION The re-use of the former Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Lands will provide community and the economic benefit as a result of the community markets, tea rooms, trade and arts workshops as well as preserve an element of the heritage fabric of Creswick. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 11.1.1 Sign and seal the lease between Hepburn Shire Council and VicTrack for
Creswick Railway Lots 18, 23, 24 and 29 together with access rights over Creswick Railway Lots 19, 20, 21 and 22.
11.1.2 Sign the Memorandum of Understanding for Occupancy and Use of
Premises of the Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Associated Lands between Hepburn Shire Council and the Creswick Railway Workshops Association.
Page 98
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION That Council: 11.1.1 Sign and seal the lease between Hepburn Shire Council and VicTrack for
Creswick Railway Lots 18, 23, 24 and 29 together with access rights over Creswick Railway Lots 19, 20, 21 and 22.
11.1.2 Sign the Memorandum of Understanding for Occupancy and Use of
Premises of the Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Associated Lands between Hepburn Shire Council and the Creswick Railway Workshops Association.
11.1.3 Request that the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) include a clause that
a properly prepared business plan be submitted to Council within three (3) months of signing the MOU.
Moved: Councillor Tim Hayes Seconded: Councillor Rod May Not carried. MOTION
That Council: 11.1.1 Sign and seal the lease between Hepburn Shire Council and VicTrack for
Creswick Railway Lots 18, 23, 24 and 29 together with access rights over Creswick Railway Lots 19, 20, 21 and 22.
11.1.2 Sign the Memorandum of Understanding for Occupancy and Use of
Premises of the Creswick Railway Station, Goods Shed and Associated Lands between Hepburn Shire Council and the Creswick Railway Workshops Association.
Moved: Councillor Bill McClenaghan Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 99
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 4 Item 11.1
CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOP LEASE
Page 100
Page 101
Page 102
Page 103
Page 104
Page 105
Page 106
Page 107
Page 108
Page 109
Page 110
Page 111
Page 112
Page 113
Page 114
Page 115
Page 116
Page 117
Page 118
Page 119
Page 120
Page 121
Page 122
Page 123
Page 124
Page 125
Page 126
Page 127
Page 128
Page 129
Page 130
Page 131
Page 132
Page 133
Page 134
Page 135
Page 136
Page 137
Page 138
Page 139
Page 140
Page 141
Page 142
Page 143
Page 144
Page 145
Page 146
Page 147
Page 148
Page 149
Page 150
Page 151
Page 152
Page 153
Page 154
Page 155
Page 156
Page 157
Page 158
Page 159
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 5 Item 11.1
CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOP MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING (MOU)
Page 160
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL Ref 12711R
AND
CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOPS ASSOCIATION
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
CRESWICK RAILWAY STATION, GOODS SHED AND ASSOCIATED LANDS
OCCUPANCY AND USE OF PREMISES
Hepburn Shire Council ABN 76 845 763 535
76 Vincent Street Daylesford, PO Box 21 Daylesford Vic 3460
Tel 03 5348 2306 Fax 03 5348 2911 email [email protected]
Page 161
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
This Memorandum of Understanding (Memorandum) is made on and operates from the day written below
BETWEEN
Hepburn Shire Council ABN 76 845 763 535 (HSC)
76 Vincent Street Daylesford Vic 3460
AND
Creswick Railway Workshops Association (CRWA)
PO Box 119, Creswick Vic 3463
INTRODUCTION
This Memorandum records an agreement between HSC and CRWA for the use and occupancy of the Creswick Railway Lots 18, 23, 24 and 29 (Premises) being all that land shaded red on the attached Plan including the improvements comprising the former station buildings and goods shed, together with access rights over Creswick Railway Lots 19, 20, 21 and 22 the land shaded brown.
RECITALS
1. HSC will lease from VicTrack Level 8, 1010 Latrobe Street, Docklands, Vic 3008 the Premises.
2. The Lease Term will be 5 years with an initial annual rent of $1,000 + GST, although the annual rent may by further negotiation with VicTrack be reduced.
3. CRWA has approached HSC and requested that it be allowed to occupy the
Premises for the purposes of trades training programs, arts and crafts workshops, exhibitions and all ancillary or like activities, but in any case will be in accordance with its Statement of Purposes when finalised and approved.
Page 162
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
4. HSC has agreed to the request from CRWA subject to the terms and condition of this Memorandum.
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
1. CRWA is an incorporated association – viz: Certificate of Incorporation A0054961L.
2. HSC will use its best endeavours to execute a Lease of the Premises with VicTrack within a reasonable time.
3. The grant of occupancy to CRWA will be subject to a Licence or sub-lease with
HSC, the Licence or sub-lease being subject to consent of VicTrack prior to occupying the Premises. The sub-lease will identify all relevant obligations, and be guided by this MOU.
4. The Licence or sub-lease for occupancy of the Premises by CRWA will require
CRWA to meet the same obligations as HSC – but only those applicable and adapted for the purpose of any Licence or sub-lease - in the Lease between VicTrack and HSC and in particular Annexure C – Community Conditions and Annexure E – Special Conditions, copies of which are attached hereto.
5. CRWA will during its occupancy and in carrying out its purposes do nothing to
prejudice the Lease between HSC and VicTrack.
6. CRWA will indemnify through the Licence or sub-Lease HSC and VicTrack.
7. CRWA will arrange for and hold public liability insurance to a minimum value of $20m prior to occupying the Premises.
8. HSC will insure the Premises, but CRWA must insure its own contents and works.
9. CRWA will pay for the use of waste management services where required from the
HSC.
10. CRWA will be required to meet the same obligations as HSC that are applicable in meeting the repair and maintenance Lease obligations and through the attached annual work plan.
11. CRWA will pay a Licence or sub-lease fee/rent equal to the amount payable by HSC
to VicTrack but HSC will agree that the amount may be payable in installments commencing 3 months after commencement of the HSC VicTrack lease and quarterly thereafter.
Page 163
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
12. CRWA may apply for HSC funds to establish its programs and other ongoing Licence or sub-lease commitments.
13. HSC will support CRWA applications for funding to external agencies.
The parties accept and agree to this Memorandum on ____________________ (Date) For and on behalf of HSC For and on behalf of CRWA
………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………. Kaylene Conrick - CEO Ken Davis - President
……………………………………………………… Judy A Henderson - Secretary
Page 164
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
PLAN
Page 165
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
ANNEXURE C – COMMUNITY CONDITIONS
Page 166
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 167
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 168
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 169
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 170
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
ANNEXURE E – SPECIAL CONDITIONS
Page 171
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Right of Way Access
Definition
In this clause: Common Area means those parts of Railway Lot’s 19, 20, 21 and 22 at Creswick
which is delineated and coloured brown on the plan in Annexure F.
The Tenant is granted the right to use the Common Area in common with the Landlord and those persons authorised by the Landlord, for the purpose of access to and from the Premises.
The Tenant must not and must ensure that its employees and invitees do not: obstruct any part of the Common Area; store or permit the accumulation of any property or rubbish in the Common Area; or interfere with any services in or about the Common Area.
The Tenant must:
1.1.1 use reasonable endeavours to keep the Common Area clean and tidy; contribute to the cost of maintaining the Common Area as reasonably determined by
the Landlord; and comply with any reasonable request made by VicTrack regarding the Common Area.
Asbestos (report to be provided by VicTrack)
The Tenant acknowledges that it has read and understands the asbestos survey report from Noel Arnold and Associates Pty Ltd dated 26/07/2010 (Asbestos Report).
The Tenant acknowledges and accepts the findings contained in the Asbestos Report. The Tenant will provide VicTrack with an asbestos management plan (Asbestos Management
Plan), on or before the date 14 days after the Commencement Date of this Lease. The Tenant authorises the Landlord or its agents to insert the Asbestos Management Plan into
Schedule H. Once inserted the Asbestos Management Plan is incorporated into the Lease If the Tenant becomes aware of the existence of any asbestos at the Premises which is not
identified in the Asbestos Management Plan, the Tenant must immediately cease any works being undertaken at the Premises and notify VicTrack, in writing of the existence of such asbestos.
The Tenant must provide VicTrack with an updated Asbestos management Plan) within 14 days of serving the notice referred to in special condition 2.6.
The updated Asbestos management Plan will be inserted into Schedule H. Once inserted the updated Asbestos Management Plan is incorporated into this Lease.
Condition Report 3.1 The Tenant acknowledges that it must within 28 days of the date of the Lease complete and return to VicTrack the Condition Report
Page 172
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
3.2 Once approved by VicTrack, the Tenant authorises VicTrack to insert the Condition Report into Annexure H of this Lease.
Water Infiltration 4.1 Clause 14.3.1 is deleted, and replaced with the following:
"any damage to the Premises or the Tenant's chattels located in the Premises;" 4.2 A new clause 15.2.3 is inserted into the Lease as follows: "15.2.3 The tenant acknowledges that the Premises are not watertight and water, including drain water, storm water, and rain water, may overflow, enter or leak into or from the Premises from time to time whether because of external sources or otherwise." Maintenance
In Clause 11.2.2 of the Lease General Conditions, the words ’fair wear and tear excepted’ are deleted. For the avoidance of doubt, it is agreed that the Lessee shall be responsible at its sole cost, for the future maintenance of the premises and appurtenant facilities (including fair wear and tear).
Fire Protection The Lessee shall at its sole cost conform with the fire protection requirements of all Statutory Authorities
The tenant must ensure that the improvements (buildings) comply fully with all relevant O.H.& S, ESM and other legislation prior to allowing the buildings and or associated land to be occupied. Further, Council is to provide annual Emergency Services Management (ESM) compliance certificates. If Council fails to provide this, it will be undertaken by VRT at Council’s cost, together with any compliance measures and associated costs.
Page 173
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
ANNUAL WORK PLAN
Page 174
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 175
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 176
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 177
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 6 Item 11.1
Attachment 6 Item 11.1
BUSINESS PLAN – CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOPS
Page 178
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
CRESWICK RAILWAY WORKSHOPS
Business Plan
Vision : A welcoming and sustainable creative community hub that
encourages discovery and participation by locals and visitors.
Mission : • To create a series of working and leisure areas to meet the needs of
our community, now and into the future. • To create a community place that encourages young people and the general
community to become skilled and involved in the arts, trades, ecology and history of the area.
• To develop partnerships with the local community, business, State and Federal government agencies and local government.
• To develop surrounds that will further tourism by providing products and information tourists seek, contributing to the local economy.
• To encourage greater interaction between the local community and the indigenous community.
Page 179
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• To build upon existing attractions and activities to encourage visitors and tourists to enjoy their time in our region.
Prepared By: CRWA Inc Committee
Table of Contents
1. BUSINESS OVERVIEW 77
2. PRODUCTS/SERVICES 78
3. BUSINESS STRUCTURE AND MANAGEMENT 80
4. MARKET ANALYSIS 82
5. COMPETITION 84
6. MARKETING STRATEGY 85
7. FINANCES 86
8. ACTION PLAN 87
Page 180
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
1. Business Overview
Outline of services The Creswick Railway Workshops (CRW) is a community not-for-profit enterprise that will offer a range of creative learning opportunities for residents of the district and for visitors, friends and tourists.
The services offered will be determined by the needs of the whole community, including young people and our ageing population. The intention is to develop a community hub that positively engages with people and supports artistic and cultural pursuits to build resilience and wellbeing.
In addition, the intention is to provide a place of interest that engages with visitors and tourists and enhances their experience of Creswick. A significant ambition is to highlight local venues, products and services of interest and value to the Tourist market.
History
The Creswick Railway Workshops Association Incorporated (CRWA Inc) will occupy the Railway Precinct and begin operating as soon as Hepburn Shire Council signs a lease with VicTrack. There are many CRWA members and Friends with considerable expertise willing to assist with programs commensurate with their interests and experience.
In addition, the CRWA will enter into partnerships with other local groups to value add the interactions and activities offered within the district.
Point of difference
The enterprise will stand out from other businesses because:
• being a community based not-for-profit model, it has a different focus to other traditional businesses
• being managed by the community for the community, it will promote ownership and engagement of the Railway Workshops
• facilitating a skills-based learning program based on ‘learning by doing’, will appeal to young people and promote good outcomes
• embracing the vision of cross-generational exchange will assist to broaden experience and understanding within the community
• maintaining affordable services will assist emerging artisans to showcase their talents and give opportunity
Page 181
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• revitalisation of the heritage precinct into a vibrant community asset will build pride in the community
• the precinct will deliver new exciting options for local events and festivals • promote other local products, services and places of interest to enhance
visitor experience • advance knowledge of the multicultural nature of the goldfields with an
initial focus on Chinese and Indigenous communities • create a special place, reflective of Creswick A Living History that builds its
own identity and positive future.
Service benefits
The Railway Workshops aims to give ‘opportunity with outcomes’ so that people can learn new skills, whether they are young people learning life skills or Barista training or older people learning home carpentry or pottery.
The enterprise will be accessible to a wide range of people by being affordable, responsive to community needs and inclusive of all.
2. Products/Services
Service: now and ongoing
The overall program will be developed in synergy with community needs and available expertise, interests and resources. This will be determined in consultation with all local groups and business and via expressions of interest. In addition, the program will be flexible and responsive to enable emergent topical issues to be capitalised upon, such as the recent Illuminated by Fire Arts Program fully funded by Arts Victoria.
Gatherings such as the Council sponsored Community Summit (3/11/2010) give voice to the desires of the community and inform priority setting. The Creswick Ward Community Plan and other Council documentation also provide an appropriate and legitimate foundation for the CRWA Project
• Tourism enhancement via tours and links to tourist enterprises in the area. • Space for artists, performers, musicians and fee-for-service workshops.
Page 182
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• Provision of a market outlet and Tea Rooms. • Provision of a dedicated display area for local business to promote their
products. • Information board to promote local events. • Special events to add momentum and interest – links with other festivals.
Initially, the range of available programs will be measured and conservative.
The initial focus will be on the Workshop Space, Writers (Literary Arts) Room and Art Gallery, as well as the establishment of the Tea Rooms.
The need for revenue to support the venture is also an important factor in the activity program. It is envisaged that the proposed Media Marketing & Event Management Sub-Committee will vigorously explore opportunities to advance sustainability of the precinct and to be innovative in formulating event programs.
Whilst the range of possible programs is large, there is a need to initially focus on achievable goals in order to establish the credentials and reputation of the venture. The success of this venture will be in its capacity to sustain innovative low cost services for the community by the productive cost efficient fee-for-service activities and other fund raising efforts and product sales. This is coupled with a marketing approach that targets affordability
Branding
A logo with the Railway Workshops name will be designed and implemented on all marketing material to enable brand recognition and to ensure a consistent image is maintained. This includes business cards, flyers, posters, articles, online business listings and the business website. The logo will represent the idea of community place making mindful of the existing Creswick branding ‘A Living History’. The logo will be devised from input of CRWA members and the community. The visible promotion of the Creswick identity will promote unique place making and ownership so that the people of Creswick identify with the precinct as being their own, a place run by the community for the community.
The 4 themes of the logo are the basis for all CRW activity programs, so that there is a consistency in reinforcing the Creswick identity and product. This will enable the Railway Workshops to strongly support the Creswick branding campaign along with other business. These 4 themes are:
History & Heritage
Page 183
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Environment
Forestry
Arts & Culture
In addition, the CRWA is keen to vigorously support environmental sustainability by adopting a model that promotes good practice with a desire to embrace like-minded sponsors, advocates and alliances.
E.g. particular encouragement will be given to local producers of fresh local organic produce when establishing the CRWA Market Days.
Suppliers
In terms of suppliers, the not-for-profit enterprise will seek to be as cost efficient as possible, in all financial dealings. Suppliers for equipment and stock will be sourced from local community and associated business and service club sponsorship. The CRWA Committee will retain control over all suppliers to ensure quality and product suitability.
3. Business Structure and Management
Structure
The structure of the enterprise is that the CRWA Inc Committee will be the Committee of Management. The CRWA is an incorporated body under the Associations Incorporation Act (1981) with Consumer Affairs Victoria and has adopted the standard Model Rules. There are 4 office bearers; President, Vice President, Treasurer and Secretary, with 2 ordinary members to form a Committee of 6 persons.
The annual membership fee is $5.00 that will be reviewed yearly. Members vote at the AGM to elect the Committee. The accounts and books are available for inspection by any member of the Association at any time in accordance with the Rules. The CRWA Committee will engage the assistance of the local Bendigo Bank, at which the CRWA Inc account is held, in auditing the accounts prior to the Annual General Meeting.
The benefit that CRWA members get is an opportunity to participate in a rewarding community activity with a chance to preserve and revitalise an important heritage
Page 184
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
icon. In addition, they are recognised for making a contribution to an exciting community project.
Many CRWA members are also involved in other community groups such the Neighbourhood Centre, U3A, CADRA, the Men’s Friendship Shed and others. This assists in sharing information and relationship building for the benefit of the whole community.
It is envisaged that for each planned and agreed programmed activity, a convenor from that specific sub-committee will retain overall responsibility and accountability. Regular reporting to and oversight by the Management Committee will be a shared expectation and operating principle. This will be clearly spelt out and endorsed by the Management Committee.
The CRWA will enter into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Hepburn Shire Council (HSC) based upon the VicTrack Lease signed by HSC as the lessee. The CRWA has prepared an Annual Work Plan and a Special Conditions Paper that addresses the Special Conditions and Annexures that form part of the Lease Agreement and MOU.
The need for paid employees within the Precinct may arise at a future time. The CRWA will seek to fund such a position via community operations grants or sponsorships. The assistance of volunteers will underpin this project. The contribution of in-kind support in exchange for display time or other co-operative arrangements will be of benefit in financial offsets and building collective engagement and ownership.
CRWA available expertise covers a broad range of industry groups and life experience, including youth work, all facets of building and construction, heritage restoration, hospitality, graphic design, tourism and marketing, business ownership, accounting skills, artists and artisans, safety professionals, metal fabrication, mechanical and electrical, music and performance, literary, vocational employment skills, teachers, project managers, landscape design, engineers, professional photographers, horticulture and community development and political lobbyists.
E.g. qualified chefs with training certification able to teach food preparation and hospitality skills.
Page 185
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
E.g. special class tradesmen with skills capable of conducting classes in heritage building repair and maintenance, including timber restoration, masonry and brickwork.
E.g. vehicle restoration and welding using qualified metal shapers and fabricators.
4. Market Analysis
Target audience
The target audience is two fold, local Creswick and district residents and visitors and tourists. Local district can extend to Maryborough, Daylesford, and Ballarat.
The holistic view taken by the CRWA is that the Railway Precinct is there for everybody, young and old, able-bodied and disabled. The positive benefits of providing a place where retired folk can still utilise their considerable skills is attractive in terms of the wellbeing and satisfaction that people obtain by such activities. Volunteerism is alive and well in Creswick with a large number of Clubs and Groups in place. The Australian Bureau of Statistics advises that within Hepburn Shire in 2008, some 30% of the population are involved in unpaid voluntary activities.
The need for young people to find their place within a community is also important and the CRWA is committed to working with the Hepburn Shire Council Youth Team to develop activity programs that are diversionary in a positive sense, and productive in a skills development sense.
The importance of family connectedness means that families and children are also a consideration that the CRWA will factor into program planning. There are few places for families to get together and engage in fun activities in Creswick.
The vision of the CRWA is that in 5 years the Railway Workshops will be a vital part of the Creswick community, integrated in the regular activities of locals, visitors, friends and relatives as well as a place known within the tourist market.
Page 186
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Location
The location of the enterprise is the heritage Creswick Railway Station and Goods Shed, which sit in an elevated position above the central town area within easy walking distance of the local Post Office.
Market trends
The region has an ageing population, which is a general trend within the Shire. Many new residents relocate to the region from Melbourne when they reach retirement age. Creswick will experience continued growth due to its reasonable real estate prices and good community structure and friendliness.
There are 2 primary schools nearby and one pre-School Centre with a Child Care Centre under construction. A major recreational facility is under construction in a nearby area.
Ballarat is located some 15-20 minutes from Creswick and there is a regular bus service. Many residents commute to Ballarat for medical, employment and retail needs and some folk, who obtain work in Ballarat, chose to live in this rural village environment of Creswick.
There is also a proposal to create a community market in conjunction with other local organizations. Overall, this will be a diverse market including fresh local produce, arts & crafts, books and a recycled quality goods market. It will be held on a regular basis and will raise funds to assist with the sustainability of the enterprise.
People are becoming more attuned to the notion of recycling and sustainability with renewed interest in farmers markets where local fresh produce can be purchased.
The Railway Workshops aims to create unique experiences for tourists so that Creswick has a ‘product’ that differentiates it from other tourist areas.
The CRWA market will focus on quality fresh produce and art/craft items and complement other local markets, such as the current monthly Neighbourhood Centre Market. Into the future it is hoped that some more permanent outlets may be established between markets so that there is always a market or event happening in the town each weekend.
Page 187
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The CRWA aims to value add the experience of visitors and tourists in the sense of making their time in the area memorable and satisfying so that they will return. This will support this project and also contribute to economic prosperity within the town.
Price range
The Hepburn Shire region is a mix of high and low-income earners. Many residents are older people and receive government support or are self funded retirees. The program will be mindful of the need to cater to all community members and therefore price will be carefully assessed.
The Tourist market may not have the same constraints as lower income residents, however it is envisaged that there will be a range of prices for various products with the mindfulness of having ‘something for everyone’ as a general principle. It is important that no one sector feels excluded from being a part of this precinct.
Those who exhibit will set their own prices for their own work, however there will be some innovative thinking to support the philosophy of having ‘something for everyone’.
5. Competition
Competitor’s profile
The CRWA does not see any other enterprises or service organizations as true competitors. It sees that there is value in diversity and choice. There may be some overlap and some duplication however the CRWA will endeavour to minimise such factors by working closely with other community groups and business to the benefit of the whole community in terms of choice. The CRWA understands the need to engage with other local business and their representatives to ensure clear understanding and communication about retail matters.
Decision-making will be undertaken mindful of the effect upon the whole community. The CRWA Committee will encourage business to use the Precinct as an extension to their marketing plan on a fee or commission basis.
E.g. Seeding Victoria will be encouraged to have a presence at the Railway Workshops to invite and draw visitor’s friends and tourists to their enterprise. This will enable them to have a more visible presence closer to the centre of the town.
Page 188
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
E.g. local collectable stores will be invited to have a presence at the Precinct and Market, which will effectively expand their market exposure and build variety and momentum. Such a business would be encouraged to place quality items within the Precinct.
Service edge
The CRWA aims to provide a unique experience for all who walk through the gates of the precinct. It will do this by utilising the skills, attributes and human energy of those involved with the project. The service edge will come via a dynamic and friendly atmosphere in a precinct infused with positive momentum. Leadership, planning and co-operation will be critical to the development of such a place as is the engagement and goodwill of the local community.
Price and promotion comparison
The price for goods and services will be kept within an affordable range. The innovative concept of ‘pay what you feel it is worth’ is being explored for the Tea Rooms in order to give social equity to lower income persons and families. However, irrespective of what model is adopted, the costs will be kept as low as reasonably practicable to be sustainable.
Price setting that is appropriate and a marketing approach that targets affordability will make these facilities as accessible as possible.
6. Marketing Strategy
Promotion
The CRWA plans to be active in the area of promotion by using available networks and media outlets via a specific Media Marketing and Event management Sub-Committee. A budget will be set for these activities but innovation in managing the budget will be critical.
Word of mouth and the Visitor Friends and Relatives tourist market will be most important to the building up of interest and return visits. In addition, target groups will be invited to participate and become Friends and sponsors of various events. A
Page 189
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
local marketing mentor is being considered to support the initial stages of CRW operations.
The intention to have several high profile and marketable exhibitions and events in the first 6 months will be explored vigorously.
The CRW Logo and branding will be established and actively promoted via the assistance of artistic graphic designers who are also CRWA members. A dedicated web site will be established to support links with local and regional Tourist websites and beyond.
Printed materials will include information cards, badges, bookmarks, postcards, posters, brochures, banners and other information of interest.
Measuring success
The evaluation of the success of this venture will be measured in terms of the numbers of people who attend and participate, the sustainability of the financials and the outcomes for individuals in terms of the quality of life and social interaction. The progress to further skills development of young people involved in CRW activities will also be a positive sign of the success of the enterprise. The culture of acceptance and inclusiveness together with an awareness of the need to enhance social equity will also be a positive indicator. The development of solid, co-operative linkages with other local networks, community groups, governmental agencies and business will also be a sign that the CRW is meeting its mission. 7. Finances
Finance Initial funding will be via CRWA fund raising, donations and sponsorship. One local business has offered to support the project by donating funds towards the HSC lease payments.
CRWA membership raises a small amount of funds, however the Fund Raising sub committee will be active in planning fund raising activities for a 12-month period. A local endeavour aims to set up a volunteer manned recycled shop to raise funds for the CRWA. Other local business groups will also be approached with requests for financial assistance.
The proposed market will generate funds as will the use of the display areas for tourism product display. There is also a capacity to gather funds via exhibitions, events and hiring out of space. There will be opportunity to permit special event photography to be conducted within the precinct, which can also
Page 190
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
raise revenue. Early activities such as those conducted in the Workshops will generate income for the CRWA project.
The enterprise has no employees and all work is voluntary in nature. Initially the precinct will be open only at certain days and hours until the activities and human resources gain greater momentum to permit greater accessibility. 8. Action Plan
Key Objectives Task By Whom By When
Establishment
Secure CRWA incorporation Done Sept2010
Research initial activities and management plans
Committee Mar2011
Finalise premises - MOU agreement
- VT Redecorate review
- Finalise set up
Committee Mar 2011
Legal
Contracts
Finalise contracts CRWA & HSC Dec2010
Sign MOU Committee Dec 2010
Finance
Determine fixed overheads
Estimate overheads
($3000 - $3500 pa)
Committee 15 Dec
Determine financial objectives
To be sustainable
To meet obligations
Committee
Finalise budget Committee Mar2011
Explore grants Committee Jan2011
Marketing
Page 191
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Determine marketing objectives
Committee Jan 2011
Determine launch plan
Outline plan Committee Jan 2011
Agreement and decision on implementation
Committee Feb 2011
Create a brochure Agree concept Committee Mar 2011
Approval of copy “” “” Mar 2011
Print “” “” April 2011
Distribute brochure “” “” April2011
Page 192
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
12.2 HEATWAVE PLAN GENERAL MANAGER SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT PURPOSE This report presents the Hepburn Shire Council Heatwave Plan 2010 for Council’s consideration and adoption. A copy of the Heatwave Plan is available under separate cover. BACKGROUND As a result of the bushfires in the early part of 2009 the State Government has declared that all Councils should have a heatwave strategy in place to compliment the emergency response to any future bushfires. This decision is based on the death of 347 people last summer as a direct result of extended hot periods of weather which were over and above the comparable figure of the past 5 years. At the Ordinary Council Meeting on 20 October 2009, Council adopted the Interim Heatwave Strategy for the 2009-2010 period. A further update report was provided to Council in April 2010 and the interim document has been included in the revised Municipal Emergency Management Plan. In the October 2009 report, it was also noted that the consultation period for the Municipal Public Health Plan and the Heatwave Plan would be performed at the same time. As the production of the Municipal Public Health Plan has not yet commenced, it was decided to implement the Heatwave Plan separately to ensure that the Hepburn Shire was ready for the upcoming 2010 summer season. ISSUE/DISCUSSION The Heatwave Plan aims to minimise the harmful effects of extreme heat on the health and wellbeing of the most vulnerable people in our community. The Bureau of Meteorology defines a heatwave as a period of excessively hot and uncomfortable weather that adversely affects human health. The threshold conditions for a heatwave vary around the world based on the demographic structure and acclimatisation of the population, and consequently there is no universally accepted definition.
Page 193
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
A heatwave is generally defined as when ‘temperatures remain abnormally high over more than a couple of days’. Preliminary research has indicated that a mean daily temperature of 30oC or a minimum overnight temperature in Hepburn Shire of 26oC can result in an increase in mortality in people aged 65 years and over. Heatwave thresholds are calculated by dividing the forecast daily maximum temperature and the forecast minimum temperature for the following day by two. For example, if the forecast maximum is 38 degrees and the forecast minimum is 25, the resulting temperature calculation of 31.5 degrees would be above the 30 degree threshold and the plan would be activated. The aims and objectives of the Heatwave Plan (Refer Attachment X) are to:
• Provide a co-ordinated plan to guide agency responses • Minimise heat related mortality and morbidity in the population by
increasing the public’s awareness of the hazards of heat • Raise community awareness of extreme heat event risks to vulnerable
members of the population • Identify effective strategies, agency co-ordination and response planning
to address such risks • Implement and activate the plan successfully • Conduct a review process prior to each summer period • Ensure health information and support is readily available to the
community • Ensure support to vulnerable population groups and their carers • Increase understanding of heatwave planning in the community.
By the time a heatwave starts, the window of opportunity for effective actions is very short. A robust heatwave warning and intervention system, combined with good community education programs for preparedness, can prevent most heatwave deaths and provide a high level of care to the community. Prior preparedness is critical. The Heatwave Plan also documents the monitoring and alert process, emergency contacts for heatwave incidents, an advice sheet as well as the staged response to heatwave hazards. The proposed heatwave alert stages are:
Page 194
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• STAGE 1: Awareness Awareness will commence at the end of November each year. The Department of Health will provide heatwave health information to Councils across the State. This information will be disseminated to the community where applicable via the Communications Officer, Manager Aged and Disability Services, Senior Environmental Health Officer and through other stakeholders such as Hepburn Health Services.
• STAGE 2: Alert Alert will commence upon Hepburn Shire Council receiving a heatwave warning from either the Dept. of Health or the Bureau of Meteorology. This alert will trigger the relevant officers to disseminate the warning to the community and vulnerable groups.
• STAGE 3: Heatwave Response
Heatwave Response occurs during the heatwave event. The dissemination of information continues as outlined in the Alert Stage of the response.
Information as to what symptoms to watch out for should be disseminated to these at risk community members or made aware of where they can obtain this information.
• STAGE 4: Heatwave Recovery
Heatwave Recovery is triggered when a heatwave is exacerbated by severity, length, blackout or another emergency. Upon this occurring, either the Municipal Emergency Response Coordinator (MERC) or the Municipal Emergency Response Officer (MERO) will declare the Municipal Emergency Control Centre (MECC) open.
The Municipal Emergency Resources Officer (MERO) has overall responsibility for the management of the plan, and is supported by the Manager Aged and Disability Services and the Environmental Health Department. COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE From the Council Plan 2009-2013: 44. Continuing to provide high quality, comprehensive aged and disability services to the frail aged, disabled and their carers across the Hepburn Shire.
Page 195
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
49. Involving communities in emergency response preparedness. Legislative framework is provided by Victorian Government Acts of Parliament. These Include:
• The Emergency Management Act 1986 – requiring the development and maintenance of a Municipal Emergency Management Plan;
• The Local Government Act 1989 – requiring Councils to service the needs of the public including local emergency and safety services;
• The Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 – requiring Councils to develop and maintain a Municipal Public Health Plan.
The Department of Human Services has strongly encouraged all local governments to develop Heatwave Plans and sees them as forming part of the public health and emergency management roles of Council.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS A $25,000 grant was approved to assist in the development of the heatwave plan. This grant has covered all costs surrounding the production of the interim and full document in terms of staff costs and production of the plan. It will also cover the education component of the plan. RISK IMPLICATIONS The purpose of the Heatwave Plan is to mitigate the potential risk of heatwave incidents on the community. There is a consequent automatic accountability on Council to follow the processes identified in the Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS There are natural social implications should the full effects of a heatwave take effect and an appropriate Heatwave Plan not be in place. There will be economic implications should the plan need to be activated on Council. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Consultation was undertaken with a range of health, disability and aged care services and facilities.
Page 196
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
There was community engagement to Level 1 of the Community Engagement Framework to date, with further education at Level 2 if adopted by Council. CONCLUSION The Heatwave Plan will increase the capacity of Hepburn Shire Council to respond to the prospect of heatwaves in the Shire. It will enable Council to further identify and support the needs of the frail aged population in our community during times of extreme heat. In adopting this Heatwave Plan Council will have clear directional options in the event of a prolonged heatwave incident.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 12.2.1 Adopt the Heatwave Plan for the 2010-2014 period 12.2.2 Link the Heatwave Plan to the Municipal Public Health Plan 12.2.3 Link the Heatwave Plan to the Municipal Emergency Management Plan.
MOTION
That Council: 12.2.1 Adopt the Heatwave Plan for the 2010-2014 period 12.2.2 Link the Heatwave Plan to the Municipal Public Health Plan 12.2.3 Link the Heatwave Plan to the Municipal Emergency Management Plan. Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Bill McClenaghan Carried.
Page 197
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
13.3 CODE RED DAY ARRANGEMENTS GENERAL MANAGER SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT PURPOSE To review Council’s Code Red Day closure procedure and to present the recommendation for Council’s consideration. BACKGROUND On 15 December 2009 the Council adopted a Code Red Policy consistent with Victorian State Government Policy. The Code Red Policy outlines the organisational response to days declared Code Red Fire Danger Rating Days by Bureau of Meteorology (BoM). The Policy suspends services and closes facilities in towns and surrounding districts of Trentham, Daylesford, Hepburn Springs, Creswick on Code Red Fire Danger Rating Days for reasons of staff, contractor and community safety. All aged and disability services will be suspended beyond these towns to all clients across the Shire. In adopting this Policy in December 2009 Council also resolve to revisit the policy post the 2009/10 bushfire season. The policy review also awaited the final Bushfire Royal Commission Report handed down on 31 July 2010.
ISSUE/DISCUSSION Generally The 2009/2010 Bushfire season did not result in a Code Red day declared for the Central Fireband District. Therefore Council has not to date “tested” this Policy. However, the obligation of Council as an employer to provide a safe work place to employees on declared Code Red Fire Danger rating days remains. Victoria has adopted the nationally agreed Fire Danger Rating scale to help communities understand information about fire danger. This scale recognises the significant increase in severe bushfire conditions over the past decade and the subsequent greater level of danger to the community, as experienced on Black Saturday, 7 February 2009. A Fire Danger Rating is a prediction of fire behaviour, including how hard it would be to put out a fire once it starts.
Page 198
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Due to increasing risk and impact of bush fires it is essential Council has clear plans to protect both its staff and our community. Every day during the fire season the BoM forecasts an outlook of the fire danger index (FDI) by considering elements of the predicted weather including temperature, relative humidity, wind speed, and dryness of vegetation. When determining the Fire Danger Rating, fire agencies, in consultation with the BoM, consider a range of other factors relating to that area and day. These factors include:
• The length of time the fire danger index has been elevated • Extent of fire already in the landscape • Fuel and dryness • Likelihood of weather events such as lightning and grass fuel
conditions. Of particular concern are the four designated high fire risk towns in the shire. To ensure the safety of staff and the community and in keeping with State Government policy and Council’s obligation to provide a safe working environment for staff, it is recommended that on all Code Red Fire Danger Rating days from 12 midnight to 12 midnight all services and facilities not operate in the high fire risk towns; Daylesford, Trentham, Hepburn Springs and Creswick. Staff involved in Emergency Management will undertake their roles and responsibilities in accordance with Emergency Management procedures. State Government Policy The Council Policy is in line with State Government policy from the Department of Education and the Central Highlands Library Corporation. For the 2010 bushfire season, schools, kindergartens and child care facilities determined by the Department of Education to be at high-risk of fire danger were placed on a Bushfire At-Risk Register. Inclusion on this register was a trigger for the school, kindergarten or child care facility to close on days declared by fire authorities as being Code Red. The process of determining which schools, kindergartens and child care facilities are included on the register involves the facilities themselves, the Department’s Regional Offices, the Catholic Education Commission of Victoria, the
Page 199
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Independent Schools Association of Victoria, the Municipal Association of Victoria and information from fire and emergency services. The following Department of Education facilities (identified on their website at http://www.education.vic.gov.au/about/bushfires/register.htm) will be closed within Hepburn Shire on Code Red days as of 8 October 2010:
BULLARTO Bullarto Primary School 131 South Bullarto Road
CRESWICK Creswick & District Preschool 24 Victoria Street
CRESWICK Creswick Learning Centre 7 Victoria Street
CRESWICK Creswick North Primary School Mac Street
CRESWICK Creswick Primary School Napier Street
CRESWICK St Augustine's School (Creswick) Napier Street
DAYLESFORD Daylesford Dharma School 11 Perrins Street
DAYLESFORD Daylesford Kindergarten 81 West Street
DAYLESFORD Daylesford Preschool 20 Central Springs Road
DAYLESFORD Daylesford Primary School (including Drummond and Yandoit annexes)
102-128 Vincent Street
DAYLESFORD Daylesford Secondary College 39 Smith Street
DAYLESFORD St Michael's School (Daylesford) Smith Street
HEPBURN Hepburn Primary School Main Road
HEPBURN SPRINGS Hepburn Kindergarten 2 Golf Links Road
TRENTHAM Trentham District Primary School Bridge Street
TRENTHAM Trentham Kindergarten 23 Bridge Street The Central Highlands Library Corporation has similarly determined to close the libraries in the four high risk fire townships on days declared Code Red Fire Danger Rating as part of their extreme weather policy. Specifically, libraries in
Page 200
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Daylesford, Creswick, Clunes and Trentham under a Code Red rating will not open until the risk is lowered. Other Municipalities The current arrangements (refer to Procedure issued under separate cover) are generally in line with that of other surrounding municipalities regarding services and staffing arrangements in areas located in the 52 high risk towns. Moorabool Shire Council The Council has a policy where on Code Red days, staff, contractors, councillors and volunteers will not be permitted to either work in or travel to or through declared Fire Prone areas and all Council owned facilities in the declared Fire Prone areas will be closed to the public. Council offices remain open in Ballan and Bacchus Marsh (neither town is declared among the 52 high fire risk towns.) Macedon Ranges Closes all facilities and work places in areas included in the 52 high fire risk towns, which include Macedon and Woodend. Offices remain open in Kyneton and Gisborne. These towns are not among the 52 high risk towns. Mt Alexander The township of Castlemaine is declared among the 52 high fire risk towns. The Council does not close its offices (both of the Council’s Offices are located in Castlemaine) on Code Red Days. The Council is planning to review its Code Red Day arrangements before the fire season. MEMPC Motion In addition, Council’s Code Red Day procedure was raised at the Municipal Emergency Management Planning Committee meeting on 3 November 2010. In response MEMP Chair Cr Bill McClenaghan proposed the following motion which was subsequently carried. Motion: That Council review its Code Red Day arrangements with a view to
Council conducting business as normal on Code Red Days. Moved: Andrew Guiney (Vic PoI)
Page 201
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Seconded: Alfred Mason (CFA) Discussion at the Meeting highlighted community concern regarding the perception of “deserting” the community if the Council Offices close for Code Red days. This perception appears to exist despite all Hepburn Shire Council Emergency Management Staff being on standby on Code Red days ready to respond should an incident occur and the Municipal Emergency Coordination Centre (MECC) being on standby. COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Council Plan 2009-2013: 4. Ensuring that the Hepburn Shire Council is an employer of choice, offering a
safe and equitable workplace, also ensuring that employees are offered opportunities for professional growth.
49. Involving communities in emergency response preparedness and ensuring our response plans are sufficiently robust to deal with not only the familiar emergencies like bushfire but possible emergency crises like fuel shortages or widespread financial distress.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS There are financial implications when staff members are instructed not to attend the workplace, business ceases to operate and services are disrupted. The cost is variable depending on the number of Code Red Days declared each year. Whilst it is acknowledged that business continuity arrangements may be able to be put in place for some staff, such as operating from home via laptops and mobile broadband, there will be other staff where this is not possible. As an organisation all staff will be paid if they work at Council facilities or normally operate in one of the four high fire risk townships and due to the declaration of a Code Red day and Council’s closure policy are unable to attend work.
Page 202
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
RISK IMPLICATIONS Risks to be considered include:
• Withdrawal of services to the community. • Requiring staff to attend the workplace on a Code Red during a fire
incident. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS There may be social and economic implications through the disruption of Council business and impacts on the local community and businesses. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Council’s Communications Plan – Code Red Days will be communicated to the general public as part of media releases and advertisements (print media and website).
CONCLUSION Council continues to have a responsibility as an employer to provide a safe working place to employees on declared Code Red Fire Danger rating days. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 13.3.1 For reasons of staff and community safety not operate any services or open
any facilities in Trentham, Daylesford, Hepburn Springs and Creswick on Code Red Fire Danger Rating days
13.3.2 Formally notify Section 86 Committees of Management and Contractors of
Council’s policy direction for Code Red Days. 13.3.3 Strongly recommend to lessees of Council facilities in these towns that they
develop procedures in line with CFA recommended action on Code Red Fire Danger Rating days
Page 203
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION
That Council: 13.3.1 For reasons of staff and community safety not operate any services or open
any facilities in Trentham, Daylesford, Hepburn Springs and Creswick on Code Red Fire Danger Rating days
13.3.2 Formally notify Section 86 Committees of Management and Contractors of
Council’s policy direction for Code Red Days. 13.3.3 Strongly recommend to lessees of Council facilities in these towns that they
develop procedures in line with CFA recommended action on Code Red Fire Danger Rating days
13.3.4 Council will operate on Code Red days Moved: Councillor Sebastian Klein Seconded: Councillor Tim Hayes Not carried.
PROCEDURAL MOTION That consideration of the Code Red Day Procedure be deferred. Moved: Councillor Bill McClenaghan
Page 204
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
13 INFRASTRUCTURE: 13.1 APPOINTMENT OF HEPBURN SHIRE FREIGHT STRATEGY STEERING
COMMITTEE GENERAL MANAGER INFRASTRUCTURE PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to consider the appointment of members to the Hepburn Shire Freight Strategy Steering Committee. BACKGROUND Council at its meeting on 17 August 2010 approved the formation of a Steering Committee to oversee the development of a Freight Strategy for the Shire. The Steering Committee is to consist of the following: 2 Councillors 2 Representatives of the Transport Industry 1 VicRoads Representative 1 Tourism Representative 2 Members of the general public (community) General Manager Infrastructure Manager Engineering Services Manager Planning ISSUE/DISCUSSION An advertisement seeking Expressions of Interest for the Steering Committee was placed in the The Courier, Ballarat, The Advocate newspapers and on Council’s website. Council received the following three nominations:
1. David Preston – Creswick – operator of GDP Transport, 2. David Marshall – resident – Stanbridge Street, Daylesford, 3. Brian Rowe – resident – Smeaton.
VicRoads have yet to respond to Council’s request for a nominee and Council’s Manager Economic Development and Tourism is pursuing a Tourism representative.
Page 205
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
In order to progress this project, it is suggested that the Committee be formed with those who have nominated as we may be able to get more interest once the project commences. COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Council Plan 2009-2013: We will deliver Good Governance to the Hepburn Shire 22. Requiring Council Management to prepare policies and protocols which
support transparent decision making. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS The cost of the appointment of a consultant to prepare this strategy will be provided by the Infrastructure Services budget. RISK IMPLICATIONS The preparation of a strategy will reduce the risk of unauthorised use of Council roads by freight vehicles by defining clear routes. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS The strategy will provide clear direction on freight routes, provide greater funding opportunities and greater certainty for the community on the use of their roads. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Nominations to the Committee were publicly advertised in September 2010 in local newspapers and on Council’s website. Community consultation will be required in the development of the strategy. CONCLUSION That Council adopt the Officer’s recommendations.
Page 206
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 13.1.1 proceed with the formation of Hepburn Shire Freight Strategy Steering
Committee to oversee the development of a freight strategy. 13.1.2 Appoint David Marshall to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
general public (community). 13.3.3 Appoint Brian Rowe to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
general public (community). 13.1.4 Appoint David Preston to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
Transport industry. 13.1.5 Nominate two Councillors to the Hepburn Shire Freight Strategy Steering
Committee.
Page 207
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION That Council: 13.1.1 proceed with the formation of Hepburn Shire Freight Strategy Steering
Committee to oversee the development of a freight strategy. 13.1.2 Appoint David Marshall to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
general public (community). 13.3.3 Appoint Brian Rowe to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
general public (community). 13.1.4 Appoint David Preston to the Steering Committee as a representative of the
Transport industry. 13.1.5 Nominate two Councillors to the Hepburn Shire Freight Strategy Steering
Committee at the December Statutory Meeting. Moved: Councillor Bill McClenaghan Seconded: Councillor Don Henderson Carried.
Page 208
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Councillor Bill McClenaghan left the Meeting at 10.34pm due a Conflict of Interest and returned at 10.40pm. 13.2 WASTE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT
GENERAL MANAGER INFRASTRUCTURE PURPOSE The purpose of this report is for Council to consider the process for the review of waste services and preparation of a Waste Management Strategy for Hepburn Shire. BACKGROUND Council plays a key role in protecting the environment and meeting the needs and expectations of the community in regard to waste management services. This project is to undertake a comprehensive review of Council’s waste management services and prepare a Waste Management Strategy for the next five to ten years. Currently, Council provides a weekly kerbside garbage and fortnightly recycling collection service to the waste collection districts of Daylesford, Hepburn Springs, Creswick, Clunes and Trentham. Council also provides a fortnightly kerbside recycling only collection service to the township of Glenlyon.
Rationale for proposed review
• Review of existing services provided. • Opportunities for recovery of resources within the waste services provided
by Council and other potential opportunities, • With a significant number of residents living in rural areas, Council
receives requests from residents to provide kerbside collection to rural communities. The potential for an extension of a rural kerbside collection will be considered in the strategy and Council has expressed that green house gas emissions be considered in any extension of a rural kerbside garbage service.
• Undertake a strategy considering the effects of National, State Government and Regional waste management policies.
• A comprehensive and integrated waste management strategy is expected to improve waste management services and improve cost effectiveness.
Page 209
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
• The strategy will provide direction to Council to determine long term service contracts required for waste services.
ISSUE/DISCUSSION The Strategy is to provide the direction for Council to implement a waste management strategy that meets the needs of the community. The strategy will provide guidance for efficient service delivery, taking into account future demand, emerging new technologies and existing best practices applicable to municipal waste management. The proposed strategy will cover, as a minimum, the following current waste services:
• Opportunities for recovery of resources within the waste services and linking this to regional and state initiatives
• Kerbside domestic and commercial garbage collection service • Kerbside domestic recycling collection service • Operations of Municipal Recycling and Sorting Facility (MRF) • Operation and Management of Transfer Stations • Supply and cartage of waste from transfer stations • Litter and public recycling collection service • Special events and recycling • ChemClear, DrumMuster, tyre and oil recycling, Detox your home service • Supply of waste disposal vouchers • Green waste disposal and processing • Hard waste collection in Clunes • Unit cost comparisons.
The Waste Management Strategy will also consider community waste education requirements based on an assessment of the community waste disposal behaviour. Simply, the strategy will consider various service delivery options and make recommendations for Council consideration. In reviewing the current waste service contracts and in formulating the Waste Management Strategy, the consultant is required to consult with stakeholders including Government agencies such as Council’s Environmental and
Page 210
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Sustainable Advisory Committee (ESAC), Environment Protection Authority (EPA), Department of Sustainability and Environment (DSE), Sustainability Victoria(SV), waste contractors and resource recovery businesses, local schools, Central Highlands Regional Waste Management Group and neighbouring Councils. The consultant must undertake a community consultation process in reviewing/formulating the strategy. The community consultation process and communication plan to the public must be included in the tender/quotation submission for Council approval.
It is proposed that the preparation of the Waste Management Strategy be overseen by a Steering Committee comprised of:
2 Councillors 3 Member of the general public (community) General Manager Infrastructure Manager Assets and Engineering Services Waste Officer Sustainability Co-ordinator.
The Committee would finalise the brief and make a recommendation to Council on the appointment of the consultant to undertake the review of waste services and preparation of the Waste Management Strategy to ensure a quality outcome. The consultant will be required to meet with the Steering Committee on a regular basis, at least five times during the preparation of the Strategy. It is anticipated that new contracts based on the Waste Management Strategy will be awarded in early 2012 for commencement in July 2012. Therefore, the consultant would be required to present the final draft of the Waste Management Strategy in mid 2011. A draft consultant’s brief for the review of Council’s waste services and preparation of a Waste Management Strategy for Hepburn Shire has been prepared for Council consideration and is attached (Attachment 7). COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE
Page 211
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Council Plan 2009-2013: 74. Reducing the waste taken to landfill by encouraging waste minimisation
practices and investigating options for the extension of the kerbside collection service and community recycling drop-offs.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS The estimated cost to prepare the Waste Management Strategy is in the order of $55,000. This cost has been provided for in the Infrastructure Waste Management budget. RISK IMPLICATIONS A comprehensive community supported waste strategy reduces the likelihood of dissatisfaction with the services provided, increases the sustainability of the service and the likelihood of more efficient services. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS • An opportunity to fully utilise the resources generated within the municipality. • Possible creation of more employment and attraction/strengthening of
industry. • Provide a sustainable and efficient service for residents COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Consultation with stakeholders including Government agencies such as such as Council’s Environmental and Sustainability Advisory Committee, Environment Protection Authority (EPA), Department of Sustainability and Environment (DSE), Sustainability Victoria(SV), waste contractors, local schools, Central Highlands Regional Waste Management Group and neighbouring Councils. The Consultant in preparing the Waste Strategy will undertake a community consultation process and public communication plan will be provided to the Steering Committee CONCLUSION That Council adopt the Officer’s recommendation.
Page 212
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
That Council: 13.2.1 Approve the formation of a steering committee to oversee the review of
waste services and preparation of a Waste Management Strategy generally in accordance with the consultant’s brief attached.
13.2.2 That the Steering Committee be comprised of: 2 Councillors 3 Members of the general public (community) General Manager Infrastructure Manager Assets and Engineering Services Waste Officer Sustainability Co-ordinator. 13.2.3 Advertise for expressions of interest from members of the general public
(community) to participate on the Hepburn Shire Waste Management Strategy Steering Committee.
Page 213
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION That Council: 13.2.1 Approve the formation of a steering committee to oversee the review of
waste services and preparation of a Waste Management Strategy generally in accordance with the consultant’s brief attached.
13.2.2 That the Steering Committee be comprised of: 2 Councillors 3 Members of the general public (community) General Manager Infrastructure Manager Assets and Engineering Services Waste Officer Sustainability Co-ordinator. 13.2.3 Advertise for expressions of interest from members of the general public
(community) to participate on the Hepburn Shire Waste Management Strategy Steering Committee.
Moved: Councillor Don Henderson Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 214
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 7 Item 13.3
CONSULTANT’S BRIEF – WASTE MANAGEMENT
Page 215
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Strategic Review of Waste Services and Preparation of a Waste Management Strategy for Hepburn Shire Council
Consultant’s Brief
Page 216
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
DRAFT DOCUMENT AS AT 10/11/2010
Table of Contents
1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................... 114
2 SHIRE PROFILE ................................................................................................................................... 115
3 CURRENT WASTE MANAGEMENT SERVICES ............................................................................... 115
4 COUNCIL’S SPECIFICATIONS ........................................................................................................... 116
4.1 PROJECT OBJECTIVES .............................................................................................................................. 116 4.2 SCOPE OF WORK ....................................................................................................................................... 117
4.2.1 Current waste services review Component ................................................................................. 117 4.2.2 Community Waste Education Component .................................................................................. 119 4.2.3 Waste Management Strategy ........................................................................................................ 119
4.3 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT ................................................................................................................... 119 4.4 COMMUNITY CONSULTATION AND COMMUNICATION ................................................................................. 120 4.5 PROJECT STUDY MANAGEMENT ............................................................................................................... 120 4.6 PROJECT BUDGET ..................................................................................................................................... 120 4.7 PROJECT TIMETABLE ................................................................................................................................. 120 4.8 OUTCOMES ................................................................................................................................................ 121
5 CONTRACT RESPONSIBILITIES ....................................................................................................... 122
5.1 EFFECTIVE CONTRACT RELATIONSHIP ..................................................................................................... 122 5.2 CONFIDENTIALITY & POLITICAL SENSITIVITY ............................................................................................ 122 5.3 MEDIA & PUBLIC STATEMENTS ................................................................................................................. 122 5.4 COUNCIL’S RESPONSIBILITIES ................................................................................................................... 122
6 OWNERSHIP AND DISTRIBUTION .................................................................................................... 122
7 PROJECT MANAGEMENT .................................................................................................................. 123
8 ATTENDANCE AT MEETINGS ............................................................................................................ 123
9 ENQUIRIES ........................................................................................................................................... 123
10 CONSULTANTS’ SUBMISSIONS .................................................................................................... 123
11 OUTPUT FORMAT ............................................................................................................................ 124
Page 217
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
INTRODUCTION
Tenders are invited from suitably qualified and experienced consultants to undertake a strategic review of current waste services and prepare a comprehensive Waste Management Strategy (The Strategy) for Hepburn Shire Council for the next 5 to 10 years.
The consultant is to review existing waste management services, practices and facilities, and recommend future waste management requirements for Council and its community. The review must include current waste services such as:
• Kerbside domestic and commercial garbage collection service
• Kerbside domestic recycling collection service
• Operations of Municipal Recycling and Sorting Facility (MRF)
• Operation and management of Creswick, Daylesford and Trentham Resource Recovery Centres and Transfer Stations
• Supply and cartage of hook lift bins
• Litter and public recycling collection service
• Special events and recycling
• ChemClear, DrumMuster, tyre and oil recycling, Detox your home service
• Supply of waste disposal vouchers
• Greenwaste recycling and composting
• Hard waste collection in Clunes
• Reuse and recycling of electronic waste
The Strategy must include a prioritized implementation strategy to ensure existing waste management “best practices” and emerging new technologies are considered in the medium to long term. Council requires the Consultant to canvass innovative ideas and “think outside the square”, in the development of Waste Management Strategy. The focus must be on encouraging the recovery and reuse of different materials and improving efficiency in resource use.
Council has strategically positioned most of its current major waste management contracts to be completed by June 2012. This will facilitate the Council to enter into new waste management contracts based on the recommendations expected from this study.
Page 218
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
SHIRE PROFILE Hepburn Shire is located in central Victoria, just over an hour from Melbourne. The City of Ballarat joins the Shire to the west and Bendigo is nearby to the north.
The Shire's population is approximately 15,000 (June 2006). The population is projected to reach 17,000 by 2021. The Shire's main townships are Daylesford/Hepburn Springs with 3,500 residents; Creswick with 2,480 residents; Clunes with 920 residents and Trentham with 710 residents. The remaining 6,710 residents live in more than 30 towns, villages and rural locations, scattered throughout the Shire.
Hepburn Shire's geography is varied and the region is renowned for its natural beauty and mineral springs reserves. The eastern part of the Shire is hilly with high rainfall levels and significant native forest areas. The western part is characterised by rolling hills, medium to lower rainfall and broad acre farming land. The total area of the Shire is 1,470 square kilometres.
The Council is committed to working with and empowering the community by taking a strategic and forward thinking approach to our future. One that is mindful of our heritage, enhances our environment, creates economic growth and fosters a strong community spirit.
CURRENT WASTE MANAGEMENT SERVICES Council plays a key role in protecting the environment and meeting the needs and expectations of the community in regard to waste management services.
Council provides a weekly kerbside garbage and fortnightly recycling collection service to the waste collection districts of Daylesford, Hepburn Springs, Creswick, Clunes, Trentham and a fortnightly recyclables only kerbside collection to the township of Glenlyon.
Garbage is collected from 120 litre mobile garbage bins (MGBs) only and it is the property owners/occupiers responsibility to purchase a bin. Council has a supply of 120 litre MGBs for purchase by residents within the collection boundaries.
Recycling is collected from 240 litre MGBs which are green with a yellow lid. These bins are supplied by Council, belong to the property and are to remain at the property.
Page 219
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Residential properties which are outside the waste collection districts and do not receive a garbage collection service receive 12 vouchers each year. Each voucher allows for the disposal of up to 0.5 cubic meters of approved waste at Council's tip/transfer station sites. Recyclables are free of charge. These tip/transfer stations are serviced by the Council at Daylesford, Creswick and Trentham.
COUNCIL’S SPECIFICATIONS Project Objectives The objectives of the Waste Management Strategy are;
a) To provide the framework for the planning of waste services and facilities that meet community needs and expectations for the next 5 to 10 years.
b) To ensure integration of services and facilities to meet Council and Government policies, strategies and community expectations
c) To provide a strategy for Council to influence waste minimization from all sources in the community
d) To provide a strategy for the disposal and resource recovery for all solid wastes generated in the community for the next 10 years.
The waste management strategy is to address the following services and components. If the consultant, while developing the strategy considers there are other services and components,
Page 220
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
which should be included in the Strategy, the consultant should raise those components with the Steering Committee.
Scope of Work The scope of this project is to develop a comprehensive Waste Management Strategy for the Council for the next 5 to 10 years. The Strategy will provide the direction for Council to implement an integrated, cost effective, innovative and environmentally responsible waste management strategy that meets the needs of the community. The Strategy is to be in harmony with National Waste Policy: Less Waste, More Resources, national initiatives such as National Packaging Covenant and the Victorian Government’s Towards Zero Waste Strategy (TZW). The strategy will assist the Council to achieve its share of the targets set in the TZW Strategy and contribute towards regional objectives and sustainability policies of Highland Regional Waste Management Group.
The project is expected to undertake a review of the current waste management services provided by the Council to the community. The Strategy will consider efficient service delivery, taking into account the needs of the community, environmental impact, service cost, future demand, emerging new technologies and existing best practices followed in municipal waste management.
Simply, the Strategy will consider various service delivery options and make recommendations to Council.
Detailed Scope of Work to be Undertaken and Delivered
The following outlines the scope of work expected by Council of the consultants selected to undertake the study.
Current waste services review Component Review of current waste services undertaken by the Council is a pre-requisite for preparing a waste management strategy for the proposed period. In addition to other matters and issues that may emerge during the study which will need to be addressed, the minimum outputs expected of the consultants in relation to this component of the study are as follows:
• Review the current kerbside domestic and commercial garbage collection services and examine the feasibility of extending the service beyond the waste collection districts to the regional areas. This must include but not limited to the assessment of the following against the current garbage collection services including the provision for waste disposal vouchers provided to rural households.
o Greenhouse gas emissions resulting from extended garbage collection service
o Efficiency in logistics and maximizing truck utilization for collection and disposal at the landfill site in Smythesdale
o Most efficient areas of expansion
Page 221
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
o Expected additional revenue from extended service and cost involved in collecting and disposing of garbage
o Effect of potential extension on future waste service contract
o Garbage bin size for ease of use and encouragement of waste reduction
o Unit cost comparisons
• Review the current kerbside domestic recycling collection services and examine the feasibility of extending the service beyond the waste collection districts to the rural areas. This must include but not limited to the assessment of the following against the current recycling collection services including the provision for waste disposal vouchers provided to rural households.
o Greenhouse gas emissions resulting from extended garbage collection service
o Efficiency in logistics and maximizing truck utilization for collection and delivery at MRF Daylesford and Ace Recycling
o Most efficient areas of expansion
o Expected additional revenue from extended service and cost involved in collecting and recycling
o Effect of potential extension on future waste service contract
o Impact on Resource Recovery Centres and Transfer Stations and MRF Daylesford
o Unit cost comparisons
• Review the viability of the Resource Recovery Centres and Transfer Stations in term of its ability to serve as:
o A hub to maximise resource recovery and waste management o Cost-centre, generating revenue and reduced dependency on ratepayers
• Examine the MRF Daylesford in terms of:
o Its ability to meet future recycling needs and improve resource recovery o Current infrastructure and requirements to meet future needs o Financial viability o Alternate options/facilities available for resource recovery including bulk transport
of recyclables to Melbourne or Ballarat.
• Assess the current services of litter and public recycling services for its efficiency and compliance
o Litter strategies Page 222
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
o Placement of litter and public recycling bin o Provision and servicing of litter and recycling bins at sporting clubs o Cigarette butt bin
• Assessment and options possible for green and organic waste collection and recycling and composting across the Shire including potential for biomass based energy production
• Hard waste collection in Clunes
• Private and commercial garbage and recycling collection within the Shire
• Recycling and reuse of Electronic waste
Community Waste Education Component The Waste Management Strategy will advise the Council on community waste education requirements and provide a consistent approach that will contribute in avoiding generation of waste, reducing the waste for disposal, managing waste as a resource and ensuring that waste treatment, disposal, recovery and re-use is undertaken in a safe, scientific and environmentally sound manner. In order to do this, the consultant will assess the community waste disposal behaviour particularly in the disposal of kerbside garbage, recyclables, littering and disposal at transfer stations.
Waste Management Strategy Based on the review of current waste management services and assessment of the waste disposal behaviour of the community, the consultant shall prepare a comprehensive Waste Management Strategy for the next 5 to 10 years. The outcomes expected from the Strategy are listed in Outcome section of Council’s specifications.
Stakeholder Engagement In reviewing the current waste service contracts and in formulating the Waste Management Strategy, the consultant is required to consult with the following Government agencies and interest groups. Detailed of how the consultant will engage the parties are to be included in the consultant’s proposal. The list is only indicative.
• Commercial and industrial groups within the municipality
• The Highlands Regional Waste Management Group and neighbouring Councils
• Government Agencies: Environment Protection Authority (EPA), Sustainability Victoria (SV), Department of Sustainability and Environment (DSE), WorkCover
• Schools, Current Waste Contractors and Associations
• Community environmental groups and associations
Page 223
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Community Consultation and communication An important aspect in the development of the Waste Management Strategy is public consultation. Consultation with the community must be undertaken in reviewing/formulating the Strategy. Community Consultation is also required to assess community’s waste disposal behaviour. The consultation process is expected to set the strategic direction and framework of waste management for the next 5 to 10 years.
The consultant is to provide an outline of the proposed public consultation process and communication strategy in their tender submission for Council approval. Indicative costings for the various options need to be provided.
Project Study Management The day-to-day Contract Manager for this study is Hepburn Shire Council’s Waste Management Officer.
Council intends to set up a steering committee consisting of Councillors, Council officers and the community to oversee the development of the Waste Management Strategy. The Consultant will be required to meet with the Steering Committee on a regular basis, as per the timetable, to canvas ideas, views and to obtain direction.
The Consultant will be required to attend at least a total of five (5) meetings with the Steering Committee. The cost of attending these five meetings must be included in the lump sum tender price.
All meetings with the Steering Committee will be conducted at Hepburn Shire Council Offices.
The Consultant will be required to attend a meeting of the Council to present the final Waste Management Strategy. The cost of attending this meeting must be included in the lump sum tender price.
Project Budget Council’s budget for the development of the Waste Management Strategy will be up to $ 60,000. This amount must include the consultants fees and other costs Council will incur as part of the consultation and development of the Strategy.
Tenderers are to submit a lump sum price excluding GST, for the completion/part of the project inclusive of all fees and expenses. The lump sum tender price is to be itemized for each individual project objectives detailed in Council’s specifications.
Project Timetable It is anticipated that new contracts based on the Waste Management Strategy will be awarded in early 2012 for commencement in July 2012. Therefore, Council seeks to adopt a new comprehensive Waste Management Strategy by September 2011. The Consultant is required to present the final draft of the Waste Management Strategy in July 2011.
Page 224
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The indicative timetable for the appointment of a consultant, completion of this project and payment schedule is as follows.
Proposed Timetable
S.No Key Action Stage Month/Date
1 Formation of Steering Committee November 2010
2 Appointment of Steering Committee December 2010
3 Initial meeting of Steering Committee January/February 2011
4 Advertising for Consultants February 2011
5 Appointment of Consultants March 2011
Outcomes The Waste Management Strategy must:
a) Provide one preferred model for all waste services as detailed in Council’s specifications
b) Provide a framework and model detailing individual components for the delivery of waste services and disposal facilities for the next 10 years
c) Provide a strategy for the resource recovery and disposal of waste generated within the
community
d) Provide evaluation of future innovative waste services and disposal options and opportunities
e) Provide costing and prioritisation of the key issues and recommendations, including both
capital and operating costs, together with any other associated infrastructure costs and financial implications for Council
f) Provide transitional linkages between the services – for example if the preferred option is
to include rural collection, then how this is achieved and the impact on the various collection services and the disposal facilities
g) Provide actions to integrate services and facilities to reflect the requirements of, and be
consistent with relevant Government Policies and Regional strategies
h) Provide strategies which Council can implement to influence the reduction of waste generation in the community, domestic, commercial and industrial sectors
i) Meet Occupational Health and Safety requirements
Page 225
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
j) Meet the Best Value requirements for Local Government
k) Recommend an integrated waste management model for Hepburn Shire Council
detailing individual components with supportive information
CONTRACT RESPONSIBILITIES
Effective Contract Relationship Consultants are required to ensure quality, clarity and timeliness of communication with council staff / project manager. The general conditions of contract for the undertaking and completion of the services for this brief are attached.
Confidentiality & Political Sensitivity Consultants are required to ensure that confidentiality of information is respected and political sensitivities are responded to in a timely and effective manner.
Media & Public Statements The consultants will not make any statement to the media on behalf of the Hepburn Shire Council. Any requests for a comment or statement from the media must be referred to council’s Project Manager. Any statement made by the consultants to a member of the public during the preparation of this study must be made within the context of the requirements of this brief and must only refer to factual or procedural matters.
Council’s Responsibilities Council will: • Provide advice and direction to the consultants; • Provide access to relevant Council records, publications, maps and other information
required for the study; and • Provide use of Council facilities for meetings, etc.
OWNERSHIP AND DISTRIBUTION
Ownership and the right to use any material from the project shall remain with Hepburn Shire Council. Council material supplied to the consultants shall remain the property of Council. On completion of the study, the consultants shall return all Council material and copies thereof. Council material may not be used or reproduced for any other purpose without the prior written consent of Council.
Page 226
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The consultants must ensure that no process, procedure or system whatsoever will involve payment of any royalties or fees, and does not infringe any intellectual property rights. The consultants shall indemnify Hepburn Shire Council against any claim or suit, whether arising directly or indirectly, for any infringement of intellectual property by the consultant in completing the study.
PROJECT MANAGEMENT Council’s Waste Management Officer will be the Project Manager. For the purpose of day-to-day contract management and on-going liaison with the appointed consultants an external project manager may be appointed.
A Steering Committee comprising the Project Manager and up to four other council and public representatives (to be determined) will oversee the project more broadly. Specifically, the steering committee will advise the consultants on questions of process, emerging issues and general policy parameters.
ATTENDANCE AT MEETINGS
The consultants will be required to attend meetings with the Project Manager on a monthly basis over the duration of the project. The consultants will also be required to attend meetings of the Steering Committee at key times during the project and as set out in a study strategy approved at the commencement of the project by the Steering Committee.
ENQUIRIES
Questions about to this brief should be directed to Hepburn Shire Council’s, Waste Management Officer, on (03) 5321 6461.
CONSULTANTS’ SUBMISSIONS Submissions should provide the following information:
Details regarding background, qualifications and/or expertise relevant to the project and examples of comparable study undertaken. This includes details about any sub-consultants proposed to be engaged in the preparation and consultation process.
How value for money will be achieved, including time allocation and rates for each member of the consultant team and costs associated with particular study components.
Preliminary / high level project methodology and timelines (to be refined and approved after appointment of the consultants).
Page 227
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Tender submissions must include
The rate for attendance at additional meetings with the Steering Committee not specified in the above timetable.
The cost structure that would apply to additional work that may be agreed to by the Project Manager.
Costs per each consultant and expected time required for the study.
The closing date for submissions is .xxxx
Written submissions should be addressed to: xxxx
OUTPUT FORMAT
The report must be provided in MS Word and pdf formats. Hard copies (5) of the complete report also must be provided after presentation of the final Waste Management Strategy to Council.
Page 228
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Councillor Tim Hayes left the Meeting at 10.43pm and returned at 10.47pm. 13.4 B-DOUBLE PERMIT – SPRINGHILL ROAD
GENERAL MANAGER INFRASTRUCTURE PURPOSE To consider an application for a temporary permit for the use of B-doubles on Springhill Road for Clearwater Logging and Transport. Before VicRoads can issue a permit for the Daylesford-Malmsbury Road, Council is required to consider issuing a permit for the Spring Hill Road. BACKGROUND The use of B-doubles on local roads is prohibited unless an exemption is gazetted or a permit is issued by the Local Government Authority. Timber plantations are common throughout the Shire which generate no traffic for most of their lives and then a short period of intensive use during harvesting. It is common procedure for the timber transport to be done by B-doubles where the plantations are in rural areas. ISSUE/DISCUSSION
Page 229
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Clearwater Logging and Transport have applied for permission to use B-doubles along the a 3km section of the Springhill Road from the plantation to the Daylesford-Malmsbury Road The permit is for a 12 month period from December 2010 to December 2011. It is not a continuous ongoing use; once the harvesting is complete the use of B-doubles will no longer be required on this road. COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE National Road Rules FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Springhill Road is one of Councils better performing roads requiring minimal maintenance. Traffic counts indicate that the road is already carrying a high percentage of commercial vehicles (6-12%). So the additional traffic from the plantation should have minimal impact on the road. RISK IMPLICATIONS
Page 230
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
The section of Springhill Road that is to be subject to the permit is sealed to 5.8-6.1m wide and has meandering curves and steep grades. Due to the current high use of commercial vehicles it is anticipated that the there will be minimal risk due to the plantation operations. ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS There is already a high percentage of commercial vehicles using the section of road, so the impact of noise from the additional vehicles will be minimal. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT The use is only temporary so no community consultation has been undertaken. CONCLUSION The permit is for temporary use in a rural area and will not have ongoing implications for the community. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
13.4.1 That Council issue a permit valid for 12 months to Clearwater Logging and
Transport for the use of B-doubles along Springhill Road.
MOTION 13.4.1 That Council issue a permit valid for 12 months to Clearwater Logging and
Transport for the use of B-doubles along Springhill Road. Moved: Councillor Don Henderson Seconded: Councillor Rod May Carried.
Page 231
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Page 232
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
14 COUNCIL SECTION 86 AND ADVISORY COMMITTEES AND STATUTORY REPORTING
14.1 COMMON SEAL APPLIED TO DOCUMENTS
PURPOSE This report presents to Council a summary of agreements signed and sealed between Hepburn Shire and the Victorian Mineral Water Committee. BACKGROUND Hepburn Shire Council works in partnership with the Victorian Mineral Water Committee to manage and protect Mineral Springs Reserves and mineral water resources. The Victorian Mineral Water Committee is an advisory body appointed by the Victorian Minister for the Environment. ISSUE/DISCUSSION The following grants have been signed and sealed by the Hepburn Shire Council CEO and Mayor.
1. Central Springs Reserve Upgrade – Master Plan
$12,500.00 ex GST
2. Lake Daylesford / Central Springs Reserve – “Mineral Springs Walk”
$46,500.00 ex GST
3. Lake Daylesford / Central Springs Reserve – Sutton Spring Upgrade
$15,000.00 ex GST
4. Hepburn Mineral Springs Reserve – Parking / Traffic Movement Strategy
$10,000.00 ex GST
5. Hepburn Mineral Springs Reserve – Remove concrete channel between Wyuna and Sulphur Springs
$20,000.00 ex GST
6. Hepburn Mineral Springs Reserve – Upgrade pedestrian connection into reserve
$10.000.00 ex GST
$114,000.00 ex GST
Page 233
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Nil FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Hepburn Shire Budget 2010/2011 allocates $116,000 contribution to these projects. RISK IMPLICATIONS Nil ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
Nil
COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Nil CONCLUSION
Information provided for noting.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
14.1.1 That Council note the above information re signed and sealed grant
agreements between Hepburn Shire Council and the Victorian Mineral Water Committee.
MOTION
14.1.1 That Council note the above information re signed and sealed grant
agreements between Hepburn Shire Council and the Victorian Mineral Water Committee.
Moved: Councillor Jon Barrell Seconded: Councillor Tim Hayes Carried.
Page 234
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
14.2 ASSEMBLIES OF COUNCILLORS OCTOBER 2010 PURPOSE This report summarises Assemblies of Councillors which occurred during October 2010.
BACKGROUND The Local Government Act 1989 defines Assembly of Councillors as …a meeting of an advisory committee of the Council, if at least one Councillor is present, or a planned or scheduled meeting of at least half of the Councillors and one member of Council staff which considers matters that are intended or likely to be - (a) the subject of a decision of the Council; or (b) subject to the exercise of a function, duty of power of the Council that has
been delegated to a person or committee – but does not include a meeting of the Council, a special committee of the Council, as audit committee established under Section 139, a club, association, peak body, political party of other organisation;
ISSUE/DISCUSSION In accordance with The Local Government Act 1989, Section 80A (2) the following summary of Assemblies of Councillors during October 2010 is provided. Note that details of the Assemblies are provided in Attachment 8.
Date Location 5 October 2010 Council Chamber, Daylesford Town
Hall 12 October 2010 Council Chamber, Daylesford Town
Hall 12 October 2010 Senior Citizens, Daylesford Town Hall
26 October 2010 Council Chamber, Daylesford Town
Hall
COUNCIL PLAN /LEGISLATIVE COMPLIANCE Local Government Act 1989, Section 80A FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Nil.
Page 235
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
RISK IMPLICATIONS Nil ENVIRONMENTAL/SOCIAL/ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
Nil
COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT Nil CONCLUSION
Information provided for noting.
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
14.2.1 That Council note the above information re Assemblies of Councillors during
October 2010
MOTION 14.2.1 That Council note the above information re Assemblies of Councillors during
October 2010
Moved: Councillor Tim Hayes Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 236
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
Attachment 8 Item 14.2
ASSEMBLIES OF COUNCILLORS OCTOBER 2010
Page 237
Page 238
Page 239
Page 240
Page 241
Page 242
Page 243
Page 244
Page 245
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
15. CLOSURE OF MEETING TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC 15.1 CLOSURE OR MEETING TO CONSIDER CONTRACTUAL MATTER The Local Government Act 1989, Section 89 (2), states that: (2) A Council or special committee may resolve that the meeting be closed to members of the public if the meeting is discussing any of the following— (a) personnel matters; (b) the personal hardship of any resident or ratepayer; (c) industrial matters; (d) contractual matters; (e) proposed developments; (f) legal advice; (g) matters affecting the security of Council property; (h) any other matter which the Council or special committee considers would prejudice the Council or any person; (i) a resolution to close the meeting to members of the public. OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION The Council resolve that the meeting be closed to members of the public to discuss contractual matters; Tender H234 - 2011/2013 - Road Reseals, in accordance with s 89 (2) (d) of the Local Government Act 1989.
Page 246
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
MOTION The Council resolve that the meeting be closed to members of the public to discuss contractual matters; Tender H234 - 2011/2013 - Road Reseals, in accordance with s 89 (2) (d) of the Local Government Act 1989. Moved: Councillor Rod May Seconded: Councillor Sebastian Klein Carried.
Page 247
TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2010 – HEPBURN SHIRE COUNCIL – ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
16. CONFIDENTIAL ITEM 16.1 TENDER H234-2011 – BITUMINOUS SURFACING OF VARIOUS SECTIONS
OF LOCAL ROADS WITHIN THE HEPBURN SHIRE GENERAL MANAGER INFRASTRUCTURE
17. RE-OPENING OF MEETING TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
OFFICER’S RECOMMENDATION
17.1.1 That Council having considered the confidential item re-open the meeting to
members of the public.
MOTION
17.1.1 That Council having considered the confidential item re-open the meeting to
members of the public.
Moved: Councillor Don Henderson Seconded: Councillor Rod May Carried.
18. CLOSE OF MEETING. The Meeting closed at 11.07pm.
Page 248
Top Related