8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
1/27
Case
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
2/27
Mexican EconomyForeign investment can’t solve Mexican economy—non-
tradable sectors are key but don’t attract investorsMaurer, Harvard Business Scool associate !ro"essor, #(Noel, associate professor at the Harvard Business School in the Business,Government and the International Economy (BGIE) unit, Ph.. from Stanford!niversity, former assistant professor in the epartment of Economics at I"#$(university in $e%ico &ity)' as N#*"# Necessary+ "rade Policy and elativeEconomic *ailure since -/0,1 http233444.h5s.edu3faculty3Pu5lication607*iles37897:;.pdf , ps strate
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
3/27
&rctic 'urn3F causes 7ussia !rotectionism in te artic0
Pete 8as!ero(ic9 , Dune 0=, 1*:, sta 4riter for "he Hill, House votes toimplement !S9$e%ico oshore ener
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
4/27
/0S de!endence F>?
3o3 (ill al(ays ave access to "uel—& crisis in Syria (ill not
e2ect 3=3 access—3e"ense @roduction &ct makes sureBartis and Aan Bibber **—senior !olicy researcer 7&%3
Dames " and La4rence, #lternative *uels for $ilitary #pplications1 #N efense epartment
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
5/27
"or(ard "or air travel0 $ *or e%ample, te %avy used a 1>1 bio"uel blend to!o(er its reat reen Fleet, a carrier stri?e slar
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
6/27
(orld’s largest oil !roducing nation by 11 and %ort &merica may
become a net oil ex!orter in 1:10*
=il doesn’t urt leadersi! D interde!endence and connectionsto oil-de!endent allies means tat (e (ould only lose
in6uence over oil !roducers i" (e abandoned oil0Aerrastro and ?adisla( 1I (*ran? and Sarah, &SIS Ener
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
7/27
Saudis even exiled one o" teir o(n on &mericaJs beal" 2 # prominent,4ealthy, and popular humanitarian and freedom C
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
8/27
Extensions
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
9/27
3=3 (ill al(ays ave "uel %C
3o3 (ill al(ays ave access to oil—3o3 consensus in on ourside
Sclossberg **(#ndre4 Scholss5er
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
10/27
&ir Force %C
&ir "orce-using bio"uels no( and (ill s(itc by 1*#/0S &ir Force *:, (!.S. #ir *orce ener
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
11/27
%avy %C
/S %avy is investing in advanced bio"uels to reduce’s "ossil"uel de!endence e
Dames Hacker **, is an ener
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
12/27
N /S %aval @o(er Stronger tan its ever been&xe *-0 (avid, :30, p
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
13/27
/0S oil inde!endent %C
'ey ave no advantage—status 5uo oil and gas develo!menton land solve de!endence -
Moi-uddin *W$ansoor $ohi9uddin is mana
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
14/27
'e !resent system solves entirely (it on land ex!loration8arl #-:9-0. avid D. Uarl, president of the #sia Strate
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
15/27
"he political ramiCcations are eAually profound. #s alter ussell $ead sees it, s pras roilin< ideolos pivotal capacity for s4in< oil production and the continued dependence of ?ey !.S. allies(Europe, Dapan and South Uorea) and partners (India) on the res petroleum means that the !nited Statescannot 5ecome entirely indierent to the Persian Gulf>s security dynamics. But the relative decline in strate
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
16/27
Miniscule
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
17/27
& eavy vs0 ligt oil'ey don’t ave a single !iece o" evidence tat says one or te
oter is key to military inde!endence
'e only di2erence is density4ndex Mundi no date http233444.inde%mundi.com3commodities3
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
18/27
&' Entanglement
Military oil inde!endence doesn’t solve "oreign entanglement—oil is a global commodity and e2ects te global economy—
means /S (ill maintain its !resent to insulate itsel"ES?C *—Energy Security ?eadersi! CouncilThe New American Oil Boom: Implications for Energy ecurity p< ;:
7ising oil !roduction (ill not mitigate te "oreign and military callenges
o" /0S0 oil de!endence : hether the result of production disruptions due to conFict in a speciCc
country or the impediment of supply throu
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
19/27
@olitics ?inks
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
20/27
@lan /n!o!ular@o!ularity is not bi!artisan—4t is 7e!ublicans (o (on’t vote
"or =bama any(ay (o "avor it—His democratic base does notand teir turnout is keyCa!iello *ina &appiello and $atthe4 aly, #ssociated Press ` "hu, Dun -:, 07-0http233444.apnorc.or
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
21/27
3odd-Frank Exem!tion /n!o!ular
=bama (ould veto any la( including 3F &ct0Pete 8as!ero(ic9 , Dune 0=, 1*:, sta 4riter for "he Hill, House votes to
implement !S9$e%ico oshore ener
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
22/27
=nly (itout re!orting exem!tions does te 'B& stand acance o" !assage0Ian ary, $ay , 1*:, the Senior Policy $anas report Ghana>s Bi< "est2 il>s&hallenI3-;, "here>s No Such "hin< as Political &apital,444.nationalJournal.com3ma
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
23/27
mood. !nli?e Bush, 5ama did ultimately
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
24/27
@lan @o!ular
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
25/27
3odd-Frank Exem!tion @o!ular
3odd-Frank Exem!tion @o!ular (it =il ?obbieserman L>#3-; OGerman, Ben, sta 4riter for "he Hill, Senate Bill on !S9$e%icorillin< Lac?s odd9*ran? E%emption. The Hill. N.p., 08 #pr. 07-;. e5. ;- Duly07-;.'e Senate !lan does not include language in te House version tat(ould create a limited exem!tion "rom Securities and E%chan
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
26/27
they are already on the 5oo?s is foolhardy. ecall that much of odd9*ran? 5ecame la4 4ithout a 4hole lot ofthou
8/9/2019 Mexico Hydrocarbons Negative - SDI 2013
27/27
n the ne
Top Related