“Measuring” Team Work in Captsone Projects
Using Rubrics Developed by Minha Ha
Context
• Chem Eng 4W04: Three projects, different areas, groups of 4-5 students.
• Report writing, group presentation and peer evaluation.
• How to “measure” team work for accreditation purposes. Need rubrics for indicators/attributes
Attributes/Indicators
Use Minha Ha's Teamwork Assessment Strategy as Rubrics
Rubric Developed by Minha (old version)
Rubric Developed by Minha (contd.)
How Measurement Was Done
• The quality of team work is reflected in three fronts:– Quality of the Final Report (but what %)– Observations by the professor– The opinions of the students in the groups.
• Created a googledocs survey where the rubric was given to students. They had to pick which level to be closest to their experience
Example of Survey
• Screen Capture from Google Docs
Results
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Fails to Meet Expectations
Marginally Meets Expectations
Meets Expectations
Exceeds Expectations
Main Results
• Lots of Room for Improvement• Time management is most common problem• Accountability is widely achieved • A high number of people are in the
“marginally achieve” expectation category
Most Recent Rubrics for Team Work (V3)
Most Recent Rubrics for Team Work (V3-contd.)
Most Recent Rubrics for Team Work (V3-contd.)
Top Related