8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
1/77
Dgtf Lvhcfst5 77(60;2= gli 77(60709
.Djltjomigyfi @fcsvgs} 4/ 3;73-
VLMYFI TYGYFT DJVSY J@ G[[FGOT
@JS YNF LMLYN DMSDVMYZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
OMTG OMCFSM/ fy go/
[ogmlym``t*G{{foofft
pt,
JSO] YGMYU/ IF@FLI JVS
@SFFIJHT @JVLIGYMJLT/ MLD,/ fy go/
If`fliglyt*G{{fooglyt
5555555555
55555
Jl G{{fgo `sjh ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft Imtysmdy Djvsy/Dflysgo Imtysmdy j` Dgom`jslmg/ Tjvynfsl Impmtmjl
Dgtf Lj, >577(dp(;;9>6Njljsgcof Glisfr Bvmo`jsi
G[[FOOFFT DJLTJOMIGYFI
GLTRFSMLB CSMF@
[nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf .[G Cgs Lj, ;=>02-Ogr J``mdft j` [nmom{ E, Cfsb
666 Glijssg Bofl Djvsy/ Tvmyf 73Og`g}fyyf Nmoo/ [G 7=999(3647
[n5 .07;- >36(4749
Gyyjslf} `js G{{foofft Omtg Omcfsm/ OmtgJtyfoog/ Bj F~dfo Bojcgo/ [nmom{ E, Cfsb/
Ftwvmsf gli ynf Ogr J``mdft j` [nmom{ E,Cfsb
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 7 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
2/77
DJS[JSGYF IMTDOJTVSF
[vstvgly yj Svof 30,7 j` ynf @fifsgo Svoft j` G{{foogyf [sjdfivsf/
G{{foofft/ Omtg Omcfsm/ Omtg Jtyfoog/ [nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf/ Bj F~dfo Bojcgo gli
Ogr J``mdft j` [nmom{ E, Cfsb QG{{foofftX hgaft ynf `joojrmlb djs{jsgyf
imtdojtvsf tygyfhfly5 Lj {vcomdgoo} nfoi djh{gl} jrlt 7;& js hjsf j` Bj F~dfo
Bojcgo js ynf Ogr J``mdft j` [nmom{ E, Cfsbt tyjda/ gli Bj F~dfo Bojcgo gli ynf
Ogr J``mdft j` [nmom{ E, Cfsb ngpf lj {gsfly djh{glmft,
Sft{fdy`voo} tvchmyyfi/
Igyfi5 Hgsdn 7=/ 3;73 *t* [nmom{ E, Cfsb[nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf
Gyyjslf} `js G{{foofft/ Omtg Omcfsm/
Omtg Jtyfoog/ [nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf/Bj F~dfo Bojcgo gli ynf Ogr J``mdft
j` [nmom{ E, Cfsb
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 3 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
3/77
m
YGCOF J@ DJLYFLYT
[gbft
YGCOF J@ DJLYFLYT,,,m(mmm
G, YNF VLMYFI TYGYFT IMTYSMDY DJVSYNGI TVCEFDY HGYYFS EVSMTIMDYMJL
gt IMPFSTMY] EVSMTIMDYMJL F^MTYFI
C, YNF IMTYSMDY DJVSYT JSIFS IFL]MLB
YGMYU gli IJ@@T HJYMJL yj TYSMAF
D, YGMYU gli IJ@@T GJCT gsf [SFHMTFIjl LFR GSBVHFLYT/ LFR
TYGYFHFLYT/ gli LFR IF@FLTFT/ LJY[SFTFLYFI yj ynf IMTYSMDY DJVSY1
gli DJLYGML MH[SJ[FS DMYGYMJLT yj
7, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t G{{fooglyt J{flmlb
3, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Dmygymjlt yj ynfSfdjsi gsf mh{sj{fs dmygymjlt gli ynf
Dmygymjlt yj ynf sfdjsi ij ljy tygyf
js sf`ofdy ynf tygyfhflyt dogmhfi c}
Ygmyu gli IJ@@30(3=
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT,,,,,,,mmm(~mm
Csmf`,,,,,,,37(30
ynf SFDJSI,,37(3=
mt LJY g @MLGO G[[FGOGCOF JSIFS,,,*,76(37
GY GOO YMHFT**77(79
MMM, GSBVHFLY,,,,,,77(6>
M, MLYSJIVDYMJL,,,,,,,,,,7(4
MM, TYGYFHFLY J@ @GDYT,,,4(77
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 4 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
4/77
mm
YGCOF J@ DJLYFLYT ( Djlymlvfi
[gbft
I, YNF GLYM(TOG[[ TYGYVYF ijft LJYG[[O] yj G[[FOOFFT DJH[OGMLY
js ynf VLIFSO]MLB GDYMJL,,,3=(42
F, YNF GLYM(TOG[[ TYGYVYF DGO, DMP,DJIF
@, G[[FOOFFT([OGMLYM@@T JSMBMLGO
m, Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd} Rmoo`vo gli
Mlyflymjlgo Mlysvtmjl v{jl [ogmlym``t
mm, Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd} [vcomdgymjl j`
mmm, Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd} @gotf Ombny[vcomdgymjl,,,92(9>
mp, Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd} G{{sj{smgymjl
j` Lghf/ [njyj gli Omaf,9=(6;
3, Pmjogymjl j` Dgom`jslmg Ml`jshgymjl[sgdymdft Gdy QM[GX/ Dgo, Dmp, Djif
72=>,64 gli72=>,>6,6;(67
4, If`ghgymjl {fs tf/ Toglifs/ gliOmcfo {fs tf,,,67(64
6, Mlyflymjlgo Ml`omdymjl j` Fhjymjlgo
7, [ogmlym``t Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd} Dogmht,,,93(6;
[smpgyf @gdyt,,,,,90(92
936,70,,42(97
DJH[OGMLY97(6>
Tfdovtmjl gli Tjomyvif,,,,,,,,,99(96
9, D}cfs(Tygoamlb gli Ngsgtthfly,,,,,,,,,64(66
gli Hflygo Imtysftt,66(6>
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 9 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
5/77
mmm
YGCOF J@ DJLYFLYT ( Djlymlvfi
[gbft
MP, DJLDOVTMJL/6=
SFOGYFI DGTF TYGYFHFLY,,,0;
DFSYM@MDGYF J@ DJH[OMGLDF,,,07
DFSYM@MDGYF J@ TFSPMDF,,,03(04
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 6 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
6/77
mp
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT
Dgtft [gbf.t-
Gbvmogs p, Gpmt Sfly G Dgs T}tyfh/ Mld,/ .7===- 37 Dgo,9yn
737Q>2 Dgo,S{ys,3i 7431 =>; [,3i >90X,,,40/ 42/ 96/ 92
Ghfsmdgl Fdjljh} Mltvsgldf Dj, p, Sfcjglt/ Mld,/
>63@, Tv{{, >26/ >2=(>>; .L,I, Dgo,7==9-6;
Gllfyyf @, p, Tngsjl T,/ 77= Dgo, G{{, 9yn 7790/ 7702/76 Dgo, S{ys, 4i 7;; .Dgo, Dy, G{{, 3;;9-,,,64
Glym(If`ghgymjl Ofgbvf j` C"lgm C"smyn p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/
.7==>- 02 Dgo,G{{,9yn 7;23/ 7;2>(7;2=/ 2= Dgo, S{ys,3i 6=2,,,6;
Cfgvngslgmt p, Moomljmt/ 494 V,T, 36;
23 T, Dy, 236/ =0 O, Fi, =7= .7=63-,7/ 3/ 46/ 96/ 92
Cfnsflt p, [foofymfs/ 670 V,T, 3==/ 4;6/
770 T, Dy, >49/ 744 O, Fi, 3i 224 .7==0-7>
Cfsb p, Jcghg/ 6>0 @,4i 349 .4i Dms, 3;;=-,,30
Csmbbt p, Fifl Djvldmo `js Nj{f & J{{jsyvlmy}/ .7===-
7= Dgo,9yn 77;0/ 7734,,9;
Csjrl p, Afoo} Csjgidgtymlb Dj,/ .7=>=-9> Dgo,4i 277/ 290 QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 734(736X,42/ 96/ 92
Dglysfoo p, @jsfty Dmy} [vcomtnmlb Dj,/
97= V,T, 396/ =6 T,Dy, 906/ 93 O,Fi,3i 97= .7=29-46/ 96/ 92
Dgshfl p, Tgl @sgldmtdj Vlm`mfi Tdn, Imty,/342 @,4i 7;30/ 7;4; .=yn Dms, 3;;7-,,,3>
Dgttmsfs p, Amlbijh j` T{gml/
070 @,4i 7;7=/ 7;39 .=yn Dms, 3;7;-,,,7>
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 0 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
7/77
p
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
Dngdjlgt p, E[ Hjsbgl Dngtf Cgla/
274 @, Tv{{, 3i 77>;/ 77>2(>> .T,I, Dgo, 3;7;-60
Dnsmtymgl Ofbgo Tjd"} Dng{yfs j` Vlmp, j` Dgo, p, Rv/030 @,4i 9>4/ 9>2(>> .=yn Dms, 3;7;-,,3>
Dhy}, Djhhfsdf Cgla p, J"Csmfl/
473 @,4i 7746/ 7742 .=yn Dms, 3;;3-,,,3=
Djdnsgl p, Djdnsgl/ 06 Dgo, G{{, 9yn
9>>/ 9=9 .7==>-,,60
Djhfi} MMM [sjivdymjlt/ Mld, p, Bgs} Tgifsv{/ Mld,
36 Dgo, 9yn 4>2 .3;;7-,9=
Dys, `js Cmj(Fynmdgo Sf`jsh/ Mld, p, Dmy} & Djvly} j` Njljovov/
3;;0 V,T, G{{, OF^MT 70>421 966 @,4i =7; .=yn Dms, Evo} 0/ 3;;0-,,36
Imbmygo Fwvm{hfly Djs{, p, Iftayj{ Imsfdy Mld,/
677 V,T, >04/ >0> .7==9-7=
Ivll & Csgitysffy/ Mld, p, Bsfflhjtt Cvmoifst/ .7=>6-923 V,T, 29=/ 20340
Iv[jly Hfsda [ngshgdfvymdgo Dj, p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy .3;;3-/
2> Dgo,G{{,9yn 603,,9;
Fpglt p, Vlajr/ .7==6- 4> Dgo, G{{, 9yn 79=;Q96 Dgo,S{ys,3i 039X,,40/ 9>
@gnmugn Gomh p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy j` Tgdsghflyj Djvly}/
7>6 Dgo, G{{, 4i 799 .7=>0-,,,6;
@mtnfs p, Ogstfl/ .7=>3-74> Dgo, G{{, 4i 032/ 09; Q7>> Dgo, S{ys, 370X,,,40/ 9>
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 2 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
8/77
pm
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
@ogyof} p, Hgvsj/ .3;;0- 4= Dgo, 9yn 3==/ 47440/ 96/ 92
@jstnfs p, Cvbomjtm/ .7=>;-
30 Dgo, 4i 2=3 Q704 Dgo, S{ys, 03>X,,,,93
Bgssmtjl p, Ojvmtmglg/ 42= V,T, 09/ 29/>6 T, Dy, 3;=/ 74 O, Fi, 3i 736 .7=09-64
Bfsyu p, Sjcfsy Rfodn/ Mld,/ 97> V,T, 434 .7=29-,,,63
Bsfflt{smlbt Cg{ymty Dnsmtymgl @foojrtnm{ Ysvty p, Dmoof}/
3;7; V,T, G{{, OF^MT 30372/ 03= @,4i 7;09 .=yn Dms, 3;7;-,,,72/ 3;/ 93
Bvmoojs} p, Bji`sf}/749 Dgo, G{{, 3i 03> Q3>0 [,3i 979X .3i Imty, 7=66-,6>
Ngl p, Tygl`jsi Vlmp,/ 37; @,4i 7;4>/ 7;9; .=yn Dms, 3;;;-,,3=
Nmoo p, Lgymjlgo Djoofbmgyf Gynofymd Gttl,/ .7==9-2 Dgo, 9yn 7X/ Q30 Dgo, S{ys, 3i >49X,,,93/ 99
Nmoyjl p, Ngoohgsa Dgsit/ 6>; @,9i >29/ >>= .=yn
Dms, 3;;=-,9=
Nmoyjl p, Ngoohgsa Dgsit/ 6== @,4i >=9 .=yn
Dms, 3;7;-,9=
Ml sf CmjOgtf Yfdn, Tfd, Omymb,/
Lj, ;9(=92 IJD .D,I, Dgo, Egl, 32/ 3;;4-3>
Eglft p, Rgo(Hgsy Tyjsft/ Mld,/32= @,4i >>4/ >>2 .=yn Dms, 3;;3-,,,36
Efllm`fs H, p, Sfirjji Rjhfl"t Nfgoyn Dys,/
>> Dgo, G{{, 9yn >7/ >= .Dgo,Dy,G{{,3;;7-,6;
ALC Flyfst p, Hgyynfrt/ 2> Dgo, G{{, 9yn
403 .3;;;-9=
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 > j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
9/77
pmm
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
AJPS(YP, Mld, p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ 4o Dgo, G{{, 9yn 7;34 .7==6-,,,60
Aglyfs p, Rgslfs(Oghcfsy Dj,/
306 @,4i >64/ >62 .=yn Dms, 3;;7-,73/ 79
Amstdnlfs p, Vlmifl Djs{, j` Gh,/
>93 @,3i 7;29 gy 7;2> .=yn Dms, 7=>>-,,30/ 3>
Ofmcfsy p, Ysgltrjsoi T}tyfht/43 Dgo, G{{, 9
yn70=4 Q4= Dgo, S{ys, 3i 06X .7
tyImty, 7==6-,,,99
Ofr p, Hjtt/ 2=2 @,3i 292/ 26; .=yn Dms, 7=>0-,,,74/ 79
HgdIjlgoi p, Bsgdf Dnvsdn Tfgyyof/
962 @,4i 7;2=/ 7;>0 .=yn Dms, 3;;0-,,,36
HdFohvss} p, V,T, Cgla Lgy"o Gtt"l/
9=6 @,4i 7740/ 779; .=yn Dms, 3;;2-,,7=
Hfygcjom`f Mlyo/ Mld, p, Rjslmda/309 @,4i >43/ >4= .=yn Dms, 3;;7-,3=/ 4=
Hmdngfot p, Mlyfslfy Flyfsygmlhfly Bsjv{/
6 @,Tv{{,3i >34/ >4> .D,I, Dgo, 7==>-,,,6;
Hjoaj p, Njo} T{msmy Gttl, .7=>>- 90 Dgo,4i 7;=3/ 7733Q363 Dgo, S{ys, 733/ 203 [,3i 90X62
Hjssjr p, Ojt Glbfoft Vlm`mfi Tdnjjo Imty,/
79= Dgo, G{{, 9yn
7939 Q62 Dgo, S{ys, 4i >>6 .3i Imty, 3;;2-90
L*T Djs{, p, Omcfsy} Hvyvgo Mlt, Dj,/732 @, 4i 7796/ 7790 .=yn Dms, 7==2-3>/ 3=
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 = j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
10/77
pmmm
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
Lgpfoomfs p, Tofyyfl/ .3;;3- 3= Dgo,9yn >3,,,9;
Lfgs} p, Sfbflyt j` Vlmpfstmy} j` Dgom`jslmg/
7>6 Dgo, G{{, 4i 7740 Q34; Dgo, S{ys, 3>7X .7ty Imtys, 7=>0-,,67/ 63
Lfr ]jsa Ymhft p, Tvoompgl/420 V,T, 369/ >9 T, Dy, 27;/ 77 O, Fi, 3i 0>0 .7=09-,40
Lmdnjotjl p, HdDogydn} Lfrt{g{fst/ .7=>0-
722 Dgo,G{{,4i 6;=/ 679/ l, 3/ 334 Dgo,S{ys, 6>,,,6;
Jdnjl p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .7=>6- 4= Dgo, 4i 76= Q370 Dgo, S{ys, 007X,,,6>
J{fsgymlb Flbmlffst Ojdgo 4 p, Ejnltjl/77; Dgo, G{{, 9
yn7>; Q7 Dg, S{ys, 4i 663X .7
tyImty, 3;;4-,92
[gibfyy p, Rsmbny/ 6>2 @,4i =>4/ =>6 l,3 .=yn
Dms, 3;;=-36
[fyfstjl p, Nmbnogli Hvtmd/ Mld,/79; @,4i, 7474/ 7437 .=yn Dms, 7==>-,,3>
[vfsyj Smdj Gwvfivdy & Tfrfs Gvyn, p, Hfydgo` & Fii}/ Mld,/
6;0 V,T, 74=/ 799/ 774 T, Dy, 0>9/ 737 O, Fi, 3i 0;6 .7==4-,7=
Sgldnj Og Djtyg/ Mld, p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .7=>;-7;0 Dgo, G{{, 4i 090/ 002 Q706 Dgo, S{ys, 492X,40
Sfgifs"t Imbfty Gttl, p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .7=>9-
42 Dgo,4i 399/ 36>/ Q3;> Dgo, S{ys, 742/ 0=; [,3i 07;X,40
Snjift p, HgdIjlgoi/ 02; @, Tv{{, 3i 7404 .H,I, Bg, 3;;=-,30
Snjift p, HgdIjlgoi/3;7; V,T, G{{, OF^MT 649; .77yn Dms, Hgs, 76/ 3;7;-,30
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 7; j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
11/77
m~
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
Smdngsitjl(Hfssfoo p, Ajoofs/ 923 V,T, 939/ 940 .7=>6-,7=/ 3;
Tdnrgsyu p, Ynmfof/
393 Dgo, G{{, 3i 2== Q67 Dgo, S{ys, 202X .3i Imty, 7=00-,,96
Tnvnlgl p, Bsjv{ R [sjit,/ Mld,/7> Dgo, 9
yn3;;/343 .7==>-,,,96
Tnvohgl p, Bsjv{ R, [sjivdymjlt/ Mld,/ .7==>-
7> Dgo, 9yn
3;; Q29 Dgo, S{ys, 3i >94X,90
Thmyn p, Ojt Glbfoft Cjjanmlifst Vlmjl Lj, 04/
744 Dgo, G{{, 3i 9>0 Q3>0 [,3i 7=9X .3i Imty, 7=66-,,,67/ 63
Thmyn p, Hgstn/ 7=9 @,49i 7;96/ 7;63 .=yn
Dms, 7===-,,,,36
Thmyn p, Lgymjlgo Csjgidgtymlb Dj,/ 74> Dgo, G{{, 3i,99/ 96
T{gdahgl p, Bjji/ .7=00- 396 Dgo, G{{, 3i 67> Q69 Dgo, S{ys, 2>X,,6>
Tygyf Svccmtn Djoofdyjst Gttl p, Tmomulj``/ .7=63-4> Dgo, 3i 44; Q39; [, 3i 3>3X6>
Tysmlb`foojr p, Djldfslfi Lfmbncjst ml Gdymjl/
9>; V,T, 42;/ 426/ 7;2 T, Dy, 7722/ =9 O, Fi, 3i 4>= .7=>2-,7=
Ygvt p, Oj`yvt/ .3;;2- 9; Dgo, 9yn
0>4 Q69 Dgo, S{ys, 4i 226X,90
Vlmyfi Tygyft p, Fomgt/ =37 @,3i >2;/ >29 .=yn Dms, 7==;-36
Vlmyfi Tygyft f~ sfo, Lfrtngh p, Ojdanffi Hmttmoft & T{gdf Dj,/
7=; @,4i =04/ =27 .=yn Dms, 7===-,4>/ 4=
Pfsmujl Ifogrgsf/ Mld, p, Djpgi Djhht, Dj,/
422 @,4i 7;>7/ 7;=;(=7 .=yn Dms, 3;;9-70/ 7>
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 77 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
12/77
~
YGCOF J@ GVYNJSMYMFT ( Djlymlvfi
Dgtft [gbf.t-
Pgsmgl Hfimdgo T}tyfht/ Mld, p, Ifo`mlj .3;;6-
46 Dgo,9yn 7>;/ 7=3,,42
Pftt p, Dmcg(Bfmb} Djs{, VTG/472 @,4i 7;=2/ 77;= .=yn Dms, 3;;4-,,,70/ 72/ 93
Rgmyt p, @smyj( Og}/ Mld,/ =2> @,3i 7;=4/ 77;; .=yn
Dms, 7==3-,,9=/ 6;
Rfmlcfsb p, @fmtfo/ 3 Dgo, S{ys, 4i 4>6/ 4=3 .Dy, G{{, 3;;4-9;
Rmodj~ p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/
44 Dgo, S{ys, 3i 990/ 969- .Dy, G{{, 7==9-,4=
Rmoo p, Ngoojda/ 690 V,T, 496/ 49=/730 T, Dy, =63/ 704 O, Fi, 3i >40 .3;;0-,,7>/ 7=
Rmysmjo p, Of~mtLf~mt Bsjv{/3;;0 RO 773>;40 .L,I, Dgo,/ G{s 32/ 3;;0-,6;
Rjotyjl p, Sfgifs"t Imbfty Gttl/ Mld,/ .7=2=-
994 V,T, 762/ 702/ == T,Dy, 32;7/ 32;2/ 07 O,Fi,3i 96;,,,42/ 96/ 90
VLMYFI TYGYFT DJLTMYVYMJL
[gbf.t-
@msty Ghflihfly,7/ 3=/ 46/ 40
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 73 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
13/77
~m
@FIFSGO SVOFT J@ G[[FOOGYF [SJDFIVSF
[gbf.t-
Svof 7;.g-3>
Svof 3>.g-.2-,,3>/ 3=
LMLYN DMSDVMY OJDGO SVOFT
[gbf.t-
Svof 3>(3,>,,3>
@FIFSGO SVOFT J@ DMPMO [SJDFIVSF
[gbf.t-
Svof 73.c-.7-,,,=/ 77/ 79/ 72
Svof 73.c-.0-,,,,,=
Svof 76.g-70/ 72/ 7>
DGOM@JSLMG DJLTYMYVYMJL
[gbf.t-
Gsymdof M/ Tfdymjl 3/ Tvci, .g-42/ 92
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 74 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
14/77
~mm
DGOM@JSLMG TYGYF TYGYVYFT
[gbf.t-
Dgom`jslmg Dmpmo Djif5
72=>/ fy, Tfw,,7/ 4
72=>,646;
72=>,>66;
72=>,>6.g-.7-,,,67
Dgom`jslmg Djif j` Dmpmo [sjdfivsf5
936,70.c-.7-,9;
936,70.f-,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,3/ 70/ 4>
HMTD,
[gbf.t-
0G Dgo, Evs, 4i/
Gttgvoyt gli Jynfs Rmoo`vo Yjsyt 764 .3;;4-,,67/ 63
72;>,2.g-,,,,64/ 66
Glym(TOG[[ Tygyvyf/ 936,70,,7/ 3/ 70/ 42/ 4=/ 9;
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 79 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
15/77
7
M, MLYSJIVDYMJL
Ynf ysvf wvftymjl {sftflyfi rmyn ynmt G{{fgo mt rnfynfs mlimpmivgot gli ynfms
cvtmlfttft rnj sf{fgyfio} gddvtf {fj{of/ G{{foofft nfsfml/ j` `gotf dsmhmlgo
djlivdy1 sf{fgyfio} pmjogyf ynf {smpgd} j` ynf mlimpmivgot1 sf{fgyfio} {vcomtn ynf
Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfs gli jynfs {smpgyf miflym`}mlb ml`jshgymjl j` gl mlimpmivgo1
sf{fgyfio} `mof sf{jsyt rmyn im``fsfly ogr fl`jsdfhfly gbfldmft gyyfh{ymlb yj ngpf
gl mlimpmivgo gssftyfi gli egmofi cgtfi jl `gotf goofbgymjlt1 sf{fgyfio} ngsgttmlb
ynf mlimpmivgot1 sf{fgyfio} if`ghmlb gli omcfomlb ynf mlimpmivgot1 gli jynfs moofbgo
djlivdy dgl ftdg{f omgcmomy} vlifs Dgom`jslmg Djif j` Dmpmo [sjdfivsf 936,70/ ynf
tysgyfbmd ogrtvmy gbgmlty {vcomd {gsymdm{gymjl QGlym(TOG[[X tygyvyf, Gt ynf
Imtysmdy Djvsy djssfdyo} ifdmifi/ ynf gltrfs mt LJ,
G Hjymjl `mofi yj Imthmtt g Dgtf vlifs ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf rmoo ljy
{sfpgmo ml gdymjlt `mofi gt g sftvoy j` Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd}/ If`ghgymjl/ pmjogymjlt j`
ynf Ml`jshgymjl [sgdymdft Gdy/ Dgom jslmg Dmpmo Djif QDgo, Dmp, DjifX 72=>/ fy
tfw,/ Ngsgtthfly/ Tygoamlb/ gli tmhmogs dgvtft/ ljs tnjvoi ynf}, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, >(
=X,
Omafrmtf/ `gotf goofbgymjlt/ gddvtgymjlt/ mlpgtmjl j` {smpgd}/ pmjogymjlt j`
ynf {smpgd} ogrt gsf ljy @sff T{ffdn {sjyfdyfi c} ynf @msty Ghflihfly j` ynf
Vlmyfi Tygyft Djltymyvymjl, Gt f~{ogmlfi mlCfgvngslgmt p, Moomljmt/ 494 V,T, 36;/
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 76 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
16/77
3
23 T, Dy, 236/ =0 O, Fi, =7= .7=63-/ omcfojvt t{ffdn mt ljy{sjyfdyfi c} ynf Vlmyfi
Tygyft Djltymyvymjl, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, >(=X,
Ynmt G{{fgo gsmtft `sjh ynf Iflmgo j` If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt Hjymjl yj
Tysmaf gli Imthmtt [ogmlym``t(G{{foofft Djh{ogmly `js If`ghgymjl/ Mlpgtmjl j`
[smpgd}/ Omcfo/ pmjogymjlt j` ynf Ml`jshgymjl [sgdymdft Gdy/ Ngsgtthfly gli jynfs
moofbgo cfngpmjst gli gdymjlt vlifs ynf Glym(TOG[[ Tygyvyf/ Dgom`jslmg Djif j`
Dmpmo [sjdfivsf QDD[X 936,70,
Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy {sj{fso} `jvli yngy If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt `gmofi yj hgaf
g {smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb yngy ynf gdyt [ogmlym``t(G{{foofft djh{ogmlfi j` `goo mlyj
gl} j` ynf `jvs Q9X dgyfbjsmft jvyomlfi ml DD[ 936,70.f-, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy gotj
{sj{fso} `jvli yngy fpfl m` ynf If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt djvoi tgymt`} ynf `msty {sjlb
j` ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf/ ynf [ogmlym``t(G{{foofft ngi tv``mdmflyo} hgif g {smhg
`gdmf tnjrmlb j` `gdyt/ yj tvctyglymgyf g evibhfly ml ynfms `gpjs QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, >X,
Aljrmlb ynfms gdympmymft rfsf ljy {sjyfdyfi c} ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf/
G{{fooglyt ngpf ljr {sfhmtfi ynfms G{{fgot jl lfr gsbvhflyt/ if`fltft/ tyjsmft/
goofbgymjlt/ gli ijdvhflyt yngy gsf ljy {gsy j` ynf Sfdjsi jl G{{fgo/ gli yngy
rfsf ljy sgmtfi cf`jsf ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy,
If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt ngpf ljy hfy ynfms cvsifl yngy ynf [ogmlym``t(
G{{foofft dogmht gsmtf `sjh ynf If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt {sjyfdyfi gdympmy}/ ljs dgl
ynf}, [ogmlym``t(G{{foofft ngpf tnjrl yngy ynf} dgl {sfpgmo jl ynf hfsmyt j` ynfms
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 70 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
17/77
4
dogmht, Gddjsimlbo}/ ynmt Djvsy tnjvoi g``msh ynf ifdmtmjl j` ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy/
ifl}mlb If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl,
MM, TYGYFHFLY J@ @GDYT5
[ogmlym``t(G{{foofft Omtg Omcfsm QOmcfsmX/ Omtg Jtyfoog QJtyfoogX/ Bj
F~dfo Bojcgo QBFBX/ [nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf QCfsbX gli ynf Ogr J``mdft j`
[nmom{ E, Cfsb QOJ[CX js djoofdympfo} QG{{foofftX `mofi tvmy gt g sftvoy j` gli
`js ighgbft dgvtfi c} If`fliglyt(G{{fooglyt Jso} Ygmyu QYgmyuX c} gli ynsjvbn
If`fli jvs @sffijht @jvligymjlt/ Mld, QIJ@@X js djoofdympfo} QG{{fooglytX
Omcfo/ If`ghgymjl/ Ngsgtthfly/ Mlpgtmjl j` [smpgd}/ Pmjogymjlt j` Dgom`jslmg Dmpmo
Djif QDgo, Dmp, DjifX 72=>/ fy tfw,/ gli jynfs moofbgo gdyt gbgmlty ynf G{{foofft,7
QTFS Pjo, 7/ {{, =(7;/ 70(=71 TFS/ Pjo, 6/ {{, 7342(734>X1 gli QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/
{{, 7;2(769 gli 363(4;;1 FS/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 4;7(440X,
Ml js gcjvy Ljpfhcfs 3;;> Ygmyu cfbgl dgoomlb Cfsbt J``mdf, Cfsb gtafi
Omcfsm/ nmt mlyfsl [gsgofbgo gli Ofbgo Gttmtygly/ yj sfyvsl Ygmyut dgoo, Ygmyu rglyfi
gttmtygldf rmyn g V,T, Tv{sfhf Djvsy Csmf`/ jl g dgtf sfbgsimlb jvs ljr tmyymlb
[sftmifly/ Cgsgda Jcghg/ yngy tnf ngi ljy{sj{fso} `mofi ml g Ysmgo Djvsy, Omcfsm
ifdomlfi gl} gttmtygldf yj Ygmyu, Ygmyu gtafi m` Cfsb rjvoi t{jltjs nfs ml ynf
Vlmyfi Tygyft Tv{sfhf Djvsy, Omcfsm yjoi Ygmyu tnf imi ljycfomfpf nf rjvoi/ gt nf
7 @js fgtf j` sf`fsfldf/ goo `gdyvgo dmygymjlt ml ynmt csmf` gsf hgif yj Ygmyu F~dfs{yj` Sfdjsi QYgmyu FSX1 IJ@@t F~dfs{y j` Sfdjsi QIJ@@ FSX `joojrfi c}pjovhf gli {gbf lvhcfs1 gli yj ynf Tv{{ofhflygo F~dfs{yt j` Sfdjsi QTFSX`joojrfi c} pjovhf gli {gbf lvhcfs,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 72 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
18/77
9
ngi ljy aljrl nfs .Ygmyu- `js ynf {sfsfwvmtmyf }fgs, Ygmyu tygyfi Gyyjslf}t omf
gcjvy ynf oflbyn j` ymhf ynf} ngpf aljrl fgdn jynfs goo ynf ymhf, Omcfsm yjoi Ygmyu
yngy Cfsb rjvoi ljy omf jl nfs cfngo`, Gt g sftvoy/ Ygmyu ynsfgyflfi yj ygaf Cfsb
ijrl gli yj ij tj tnf rgt bjmlb yj iftysj} nmt [gsgofbgo/ Omtg Omcfsm/ gli bfy
smi j` nfs, Ygmyu gihmyyfi hgamlb ynmt ynsfgy ml {sfpmjvt Djvsy `momlbt ml ynmt dgtf,
QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 703X gli QYgmyu gli IJ@@ FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 790/ 763X,
Jtyfoog ijlgyfi nfs tfspmdft yj Ygmyu `js g tnjsy {fsmji j` ymhf, Jtyfoog mt g
Rfchgtyfs c} ysgif, Ygmyu rglyfi Jtyfoog yj omf yj ynf @fifsgo Bjpfslhfly gli
Ogr Fl`jsdfhfly gli tvctyglymgyf Ygmyut `gotf dogmht j` ngdamlb mlyj Ygmyut
rfctmyf/ cojb gli [g}[go gddjvly c} Jcghg ynvbt, Jtyfoog sf`vtfi yj omf `js
Ygmyu gli f~{ogmlfi yj Ygmyu yngy nfs rfctmyf gli cojb ngi lfpfs cffl ngdafi,
QTFS Pjo, 7/ {{, 7>(3>1 TFS Pjo, 6/ {{, 7342(734>X1 gli QIJ@@ gli Ygmyu FS/
Pjo, 7/ {{, 307(304X,
Gt g sftvoy ynfsfj`/ Ygmyu ngi jynfs If`fliglyt djlivdy moofbgo cgdabsjvli
dnfdat gli moofbgoo} {voo dsfimy sf{jsyt jl ynf G{{foofft, QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 3=(=7X
gli QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 772(77>/ 793/ 76;/ 32>(32=X,
Ygmyu cfbgl dgss}mlb jvy nfs ynsfgyt yjrgsit ynf G{{foofft gt ifhjltysgyfi
c} goo ynf F~nmcmyt `mofi rmyn ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@
{vcomtnfi jl ynfms rfctmyft Omcfsmt giisftt/ `voo Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfs/ igyf j`
cmsyn/ {ogdf j` cmsyn/ hjynfst hgmifl lghf/ `gynfst lghf/ Omcfsmt nvtcglit
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 7> j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
19/77
6
lghf/ Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfs/ igyf j` cmsyn gli jynfs {smpgyf miflym`}mlb
ml`jshgymjl Q{smpgyf igygX, Goo j` ynf `jsfbjmlb ml`jshgymjl Ygmyu ynsjvbn IJ@@
sf{fgyfio} {vcomtnfi jl nfs rfctmyf/ jl ynf Mlyfslfy/ sf{fgyfio} hgtt Fhgmofi yj
hmoomjlt j` mlimpmivgot gli cvtmlfttft/ {jtyfi jl Tjdmgo Lfyrjsa tmyft/ Yrffyfi my/
{jtyfi my gt g sf{jsyfs jlCf`jsf myt Lfrt/ sf{fgyfio} {jtygo hgmofi ynf ml`jshgymjl/
gli tfly my Mlyfslgymjlgoo} sf{fgyfio}, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;2(769/ 733(732/ 73=/ 747(
742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/
430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo, 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(
76=/ 36;(3=2X/ QTFS/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;X/ QTFS/ Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>6X/ QPjo, 9/ {{,
>>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(7763X/ QTFS/ Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Ygmyu `gotfo} gddvtfi Omcfsm j` hvsifsmlb nfs tmtyfs1 tyfgomlb `sjh Ygmyu
gli IJ@@1 ygh{fsmlb rmyn Ygmyu gli nfs nvtcglit dgst1 `jsbmlb G``migpmyt `mofi
c} Cfsb ml jlf j` nmt dgtft1 {vcomtnmlb {mdyvsft j` Omcfsm/ jlf j` rnmdn rgt g
`ghmo} {mdyvsf j` Omcfsm gli nfs `ghmo} jcygmlfi c} Ygmyu c} `sgvivofly hfglt1
Ygmyu sf{fgyfio} {vcomtnfi `gotf tygyfhflyt gcjvy ynf [ogmlym``t/ mldovimlb cvy ljy
omhmyfi yj Omcfsm mt g dgsffs ijdvhfly `jsbfs1 Jtyfoog gli Omcfsm tyjof hjlmft `sjh
Ygmyu ljl({sj`my `jvligymjl/ IJ@@1 Omcfsm rgt djlpmdyfi j` Miflymy} Ynf y/
@jsbfs} j` Ijdvhflyt/ @gotm`}mlb [jomdf gli Dsfimy Sf{jsyt/ sfgo ftygyf `sgvi1
Jtyfoog `jsbfi Ygmyut lghf*tmblgyvsf1 yngy Jtyfoog ngi g dsmhmlgo sfdjsi1 Omcfsm
ngliofi Cfsbt `vlisgmtmlb1 Omcfsm ngi gddftt yj Cfsbt ijlgyjst dsfimy dgsit1
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 7= j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
20/77
0
Omcfsmt nvtcgli rgt jl {gsjof1 Omcfsm gli nfs nvtcgli ngi yrj Q3X dsfimy dgsi
gddjvlyt tfy v{ jl Cfsbt rfctmyf1 yngy Jtyfoogt nvtcgli rgt cflf`mymlb `sjh ynf
hjlmft tyjofl c} Jtyfoog1 Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb rfsf ngsgttmlb/ toglifsmlb gli
if`ghmlb Ygmyu/ fyd,/ goo ynf ymhf aljrmlb ynf ml`jshgymjl rgt `gotf Q`gotf
goofbgymjltX,
Ygmyu {vcomdmufi goo ynftf `gotf goofbgymjlt gli G{{foofft {smpgyf igyg
sf{fgyfio} jl ynf mlyfslfy/ ynsjvbn hgtt Fhgmomlb yj hmoomjlt j` mlimpmivgot gli
cvtmlfttft/ ynsjvbn STT `ffit/ {jtymlb my jl Tjdmgo Lfyrjsa tmyft/ imtdvttmlb my jl
sgimj/ YP mlyfspmfrt/ ]jvYvcf pmifjt/ ml gsymdoft/ fyd, rmyn hgomdf/ mldovimlb
tflimlb G{{foofft {smpgyf miflym`}mlb ml`jshgymjl mlyfslgymjlgoo}, QTFS Pjo, 7 {{,
70(=7/ 330(3=2/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;/ Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>6/ Pjo, 9/ {{, >>0(7700/
Pjo, 6/ {{, 7342(734>/ 740;(7404/ 74=7(74=3X gli QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 772(
77>/ 733(734/ 736(732/ 73=(743/ 749(74>/ 793(79>/ 76;(764/ gli 36>(32>X,
Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ gli nfs jynfs cvtmlfttft gli Djs{jsgymjlt `mofi
lvhfsjvt `gotf dsmhmlgo sf{jsyt gbgmlty Jtyfoog gli Omcfsm gyyfh{ymlb yj ngpf ynfh
gssftyfi gli egmofi jl `gotf goofbgymjlt, Ygmyu tvhhjltfi nfs tv{{jsyfst gli
`joojrfst yj `mof `gotf djh{ogmlyt gli ngsgtt ynf Tygyf gli Bjpfslhfly gbfldmft
ojdgyfi ml Lfr Efstf} gli Tglyg @f/ Lfr Hf~mdj, Ygmyu cfbgl ngsgttmlb ynf Tgl
Cfslgsimlj Bsgli Evs}/ Tgl Cfslgsimlj Djvly} Imtysmdy Gyyjslf}/ Tgl Cfslgsimlj
gli ynf Tglyg @f [sjcgymjl If{gsyhflyt/ Dgom`jslmg gli Lfr Hf~mdj Gyyjslf}
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 3; j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
21/77
2
Bflfsgo/ @fifsgo Cvsfgv j` Mlpftymbgymjlt/ If{gsyhfly j` Evtymdf gli jynfs ogr
fl`jsdfhfly gbfldmft gyyfh{ymlb yj ngpf Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog gssftyfi gli egmofi
cgtfi jl nfs `gotf goofbgymjlt gli `gotf goofbgymjlt yngy Omcfsm ngi pmjogyfi nfs
{sjcgymjl, Rnfl Ygmyu imi ljy sfdfmpf ynf sftvoyt tnf rgt tffamlb/ tnf cfbgl
gyygdamlb ynf fh{oj}fft gli j``mdmgot ml ynf Tygyf gli Bjpfslhfly flymymft gli
`mofi gl Fhfsbfld} Sfpjdgymjl j` [sjcgymjl gbgmlty Omcfsm rmyn ynf Tgl
Cfslgsimlj Djvly} Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ Sgldnj Dvdghjlbg Impmtmjl, Omcfsm rgt
sf{fgyfio} dofgsfi j` goo Ygmyu gli IJ@@t `gotf goofbgymjlt, QTFS Pjo, 7 {{, 70(
=7/ 330(3=2/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;/ Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>6/ Pjo, 9/ {{, >>0(7700/ Pjo,
6/ {{, 7342(734>/ 740;(7404/ 74=7(74=3X gli QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 772(77>/ 733(
734/ 736(732/ 73=(743/ 749(74>/ 793(79>/ 76;(764/ gli 36>(32>X,
Ygmyu `mofi g `gotf {jomdf sf{jsy rmyn ynf Jsglbf Djvly} Tnfsm``t
If{gsyhfly gbgmlty Jtyfoog gli Omcfsm dogmhmlb Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog rfsf ynf tghf
{fstjl/ gli ngi tyjofl hjlmft `sjh nfs, Tff TFS/ {{, 34/ 796(79>, Ygmyu gotj {vy
yrj Q3X [g}[go sfdfm{yt jvy jl ynf Mlyfslfy/ jlf `sjh [n}oomt Tl}ifs ml ynf ghjvly
j` @m`y} Q)6;,;;X Ijoogst gli ynf jynfs `sjh Ejtf{n Oglijsg ml ynf ghjvly j`
Yrfly}(@mpf Q)36,;;X Ijoogst/ TFS Pjo, 6/ {{, 734>/ 7406(740>/ dogmhmlb ynftf
hjlmft ngi cffl tyjofl, Gt tnjrl ml Ygmyut [g}[go sfdjsit/ Ygmyu sfdfmpfi ynftf
ijlgymjlt1 TFS Pjo, 6/ {{, 7426(74>2/ TFS Pjo, 9/ {, 740> tnjrt cjyn ynftf
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 37 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
22/77
>
ijlgymjlt bjmlb mlyj Ygmyut [g}[go gddjvly gli Ygmyu ysglt`fssmlb ynf hjlmft jvy
j` nfs [g}[go gddjvly mlyj nfs gdyvgo cgla gddjvly,
Ygmyu djlymlvfi/ ft{fdmgoo} g`yfs tvmy rgt `mofi ml [fllt}opglmg jl Hg} 9/
3;;=/ {vcomtnmlb Omcfsmt Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfs/ hjynfst hgmifl lghf/ `gynfst
lghf gli G{{foofft {smpgyf igyg/ djlymlvfi `gotfo} gddvtmlb ynf G{{foofft j`
dsmhft gli cfbgl dgoomlb `js mlimpmivgot ml ynf gsfgt rnfsf Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog
sftmifi, Tysglbf {fj{of tnjrfi v{ gy Omcfsmt njhf/ mldovimlb g hgl rnj rgt
ojjamlb ml Omcfsmt njvtf rmlijrt cf`jsf >5;; g,h, ml ynf hjslmlb gli Ygmyu isjpf
gsjvli Lfr Efstf} rnfsf Jtyfoog sftmifi gli Jtyfoogt dnmoisfl gyyflifi tdnjjo,
QTFS Pjo, 7 {{, 70(=7/ 330(3=2/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;/ Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>6/ Pjo, 9/
{{, >>0(7700/ Pjo, 6/ {{, 7342(734>/ 740;(7404/ 74=7(74=3X gli QYgmyu FS/ Pjo,
7/ {{, 772(77>/ 733(734/ 736(732/ 73=(743/ 749(74>/ 793(79>/ 76;(764/ gli 36>(
32>X,
Gt ynmt dgtf rgt cfmlb omymbgyfi/ Ygmyu cfbgl `momlb `jsbfi gli goyfsfi
ijdvhflyt ml Omcfsm gli Jtyfoogt lghf/ mldovimlb `jsbfi gli goyfsfi rfctmyf
{gbft QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 62(>2/ 743/ 749/ 74=(79;/ 3;0(33; . jsbfi Fhgmot
rnfsf Bfj`` Tyg{oft Fhgmo Giisftt rgt sfhjpfi gli Omcfsmt Fhgmo Giisftt rgt
`sgvivoflyo} ml{vy gt tnjrl ml ynf Fhgmo nfgifs ojdgyfi cfojr ynf Fhgmo-1 gli
QTFS Pjo, 6/ {{, 733;(733>/ 7347(7490 .goyfsfi gli `jsbfi Fhgmot rnfsf
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 33 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
23/77
=
Jtyfoogt Fhgmot ngi cffl dnglbfi/ gli lfr Fhgmot rfsf dsfgyfi yngy Jtyfoog
lfpfs tfly/ rnfsf Jtyfoogt Fhgmo giisftt rgt `sgvivoflyo} mltfsyfi,
Jl G{smo 76/ 3;77/ g`yfs ynmt Dgtf rgt Ysglt`fssfi yj ynf V,T, Imtysmdy Djvsy/
Dflysgo Imtysmdy j` Dgom`jslmg/ Tjvynfsl Impmtmjl `sjh [fllt}opglmg/ Ygmyu `mofi g
Hjymjl yj Imtwvgom`} Cfsb `sjh cfmlb ynf Gyyjslf} `js [ogmlym``t(G{{foofft, Cfsb
ngi ljy fpfl ngi ymhf yj `mof `js nmt [sj Ngd Pmdf gihmttmjl, G{{foofft ml ynfms
J{{jtmymjl `mofi G{smo 7;/ 3;77/ yj Ygmyut Hjymjl/ ml`jshfi ynf Djvsy yngy
G{{foofft Djh{ogmly/ rnmdn ngi lfpfs cffl ghflifi/ rgt cgtfi jl [fllt}opglmg
ogr tmldf my rgt `mofi ml [fllt}opglmg gli G{{foofft rjvoi cf tffamlb Ofgpf yj
Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly,
Jl G{smo 36/ 3;77/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ `mofi ynfms Glym(TOG[[ gli Hjymjl yj
Imthmtt Qynf HjymjlX {vstvgly yj @fifsgo Svoft j` Dmpmo [sjdfivsf Q@fi, S, Dmp,
[,X 73.c-.7- gli 73.c-.0-3, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Glym(TOG[[ rgt {sfhmtfi jl ynfms
`gotf gli mlgddvsgyf dogmht yngy ynmt dgtf mt cgtfi jl Ygmyu imtysmcvymjl j` Omcfsmt
tv{{jtfi djlpmdymjl1 yngy G{{foofft djhhmyyfi lvhfsjvt dsmhft1 Cfsb
fh{oj}t Omcfsm gt nmt [gsgofbgo1 yngy Jtyfoog ojdafi Ygmyu jvy j` nfs rfctmyf1 yngy
hjlmft rjvoi ljy bj yj IJ@@ cvy mltyfgi Jtyfoog1 yngy Omcfsm dogmhfi yj cf g
im``fsfly {fstjl sftmimlb ml [fllt}opglmg1 fyd,/ gli G{{foofft ogrtvmy tyfhhfi
3 Ygmyu mt jlo} G{{fgomlb ynf Djvsyt Jsifs ifl}mlb nfs Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl1 gliIJ@@ mt G{{fgomlb ynf Glym(TOG[[ Svomlb gli ynf Svomlb jl IJ@@t 73.c-.7-dogmh,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 34 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
24/77
7;
`sjh gdyt hgif ml djllfdymjl rmyn g {vcomd mttvf js gl mttvf j` {vcomd mlyfsfty,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@ dogmhfi ynfsf rfsf jlo} g omhmyfi tygyfhflyt*{vcomdgymjlt/ yngy
djvoi cf gyysmcvyfi yj ynf If`fliglyt/ QYgmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 766(340X,
G{{foofft `mofi ynfms Hjymjl `js Ofgpf yj Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly jl G{smo
3=/ 3;77 gli ynfms [sj{jtfi @msty Ghflifi Djh{ogmly Q[@GDX jl Hg} 3;/ 3;77
QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 0(3=2/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;/ Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>6/ Pjo, 9/ {{, >>0(
772> gli Pjo, 6/ {{, 772=(7376X,
G{{foofft sft{jlifi ml J{{jtmymjl yj Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl/ gli
{jmlyfi yj ynf Djvsyt Ijdafy yj ynjvtglit j` {gbft j` Ygmyu ynsjvbn IJ@@t/
{jtymlbt gli sf{fgyfi {vcomdgymjl j` G{{foofft {smpgyf igyg/ `gotf goofbgymjlt/
Ygmyut tvhhjltmlb j` nfs tv{{jsyfst ml gsfgt G{{foofft sftmifi/ ynf `momlb j` `gotf
ogr fl`jsdfhfly sf{jsyt/ Ygmyu ngsgtthfly j` Tygyf gli Bjpfslhflygo Gbfldmft/
Ygmyu tvhhjltmlb j` nfs tv{{jsyfst yj djlygdy gli ngsgtt ynf Tygyf gli
Bjpfslhflygo Gbfldmft/ fyd,/ gt jvyomlfi gcjpf, Goo j` rnmdn rgt djlysgs} yj
Ygmyu `gotf tygyfhflyt ml nfs gli IJ@@t Hjymjl, QIJ@@ gli Ygmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{,
7;2(769X,
Jl Hg} 32/ 3;77/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ `mofi ynfms Sf{o} yj G{{foofft Sft{jltf
ml J{{jtmymjl yj Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl, Gojlb rmyn ynfms Sf{o}/ ynf} `mofi ynf
Ifdogsgymjl j` Jso} Ygmyu/ rnmdn djlygmlfi `jsbfi gli goyfsfi ijdvhflyt QYgmyu
gli IJ@@t FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 62(>2X1 g Sfwvfty `js Evimdmgo Ljymdf QYgmyu gli
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 39 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
25/77
77
IJ@@ FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 43(90X gli Fpmiflymgs} Jcefdymjlt yj ynf Ifdogsgymjlt j`
Omcfsm gli Cfsb QIJ@@ gli Ygmyu FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 92(60X,
G{{foofft `mofi Jcefdymjlt yj ynf Ifdogsgymjl j` Ygmyu/ gojlb rmyn g Ljymdf yj
ynf Djvsy yngy Ygmyu ngi `mofi goyfsfi gli `jsbfi ijdvhflyt gt F~nmcmyt yj nfs
Ifdogsgymjl/ Jcefdymjlt yj Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Sfwvfty `js Evimdmgo Ljymdf/ gli ynf
Ifdogsgymjlt j` Jtyfoog gli Cfsb ml tv{{jsy j` ynfms Jcefdymjlt4, QTFS Pjo, 6/ {{,
7370(7974X,
Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy Bsglyfi Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsbt Hjymjl `js Ofgpf yj
Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly1 Iflmfi Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl1 Iflmfi
Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl yj Imthmtt {vstvgly yj @fi, S, Dmp, [, 73.c-.7- gli
73.c-.0-1 gli Mh{jtfi @momlb Sftysmdymjlt, QYgmyu gli IJ@@ FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 9(=
gli 36(47X,
IJ@@ G{{fgofi ynf Imtysmdy Djvsyt Jsifs jl Evlf 32/ 3;77 gli Ygmyu `mofi
nfs Ljymdf j` G{{fgo jl Evo} 74/ 3;77, QYgmyu gli IJ@@ FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7(4X,
IJ@@t G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf` QIJ@@ GJCX rgt ivf jl js cf`jsf
Ifdfhcfs 7=/ 3;77 .Dgtf Lj, 77(60;2=- gli Ygmyu G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf`
QYgmyu GJCX rgt ivf jl js cf`jsf Ifdfhcfs 3;/ 3;77 .Dgtf Lj, 77(60709,
4 G{{fooglyt `gmofi yj mldovif G{{foofft Hjymjl `js Ofgpf yj Ghfli1 [@GD1Jcefdymjlt yj Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Sfwvfty `js Evimdmgo Ljymdf1 Jcefdymjlt yj YgmyuIfdogsgymjl gli Ljymdf j` @jsbfi gli Goyfsfi Ijdvhflyt1 ml sft{jltf yj Ygmyu gliIJ@@t Hjymjl/ ml ynfms F~dfs{yt j` Sfdjsi/ gli ynfsf`jsf/ G{{foofft gsf `momlb gTv{{ofhflygo F~dfs{y j` Sfdjsi yj mldovif ynftf ijdvhflyt {vstvgly yj ynf LmlynDmsdvmy Svof Q=yn Dms, S,X 4;(7,2,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 36 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
26/77
73
Cjyn G{{fooglyt {sfhmtfi ynfms g{{fgo jl lfr gsbvhflyt/ tyjsmft/ if`fltft gli
tygyfhflyt, Ynf dmygymjlt yj ynf Sfdjsi hgif ml G{{fooglyt GJCt gsf ljy{sj{fs
dmygymjlt gli ynf Sfdjsi ijft ljy tygyf js sf`ofdy rngy G{{fooglyt dogmh ynf} ij,
IJ@@ `gmofi yj ymhfo} `mof ynfms GJC gli `mofi f~dfttmpf {gbft,
G{{foofft `mofi Hjymjlt yj Tysmaf cjyn G{{fooglyt GJCt gli FSt gli
Imthmtt ynfms G{{fgot, Ynmt Djvsy iflmfi G{{foofft Hjymjl rmynjvy {sfevimdf gli
tygyfi G{{foofft djvoi sgmtf ynf mttvft ml ynfms J{flmlb Csmf`, Ynmt Djvsy gotj
djltjomigyfi Dgtf Ljt, 77(60;2= gli 77(60709,
MMM, GSBVHFLY5
G, YNF VLMYFI TYGYFT IMTYSMDY DJVSY NGI TVCEFDY
HGYYFS EVSMTIMDYMJL gt IMPFSTMY] EVSMTIMDYMJL
F^MTYFI GY GOO YMHFT5
IJ@@ dogmht ynf V,T, Imtysmdy Djvsy ogdafi evsmtimdymjl cfdgvtf Omcfsm rgt
jl {sjcgymjl ml Lfr Hf~mdj/ cvy rgt tflyfldfi c} g Dgom`jslmg Djvsy gli sf`vtfi
yj {sjpmif nfs ismpfst omdfltf, IJ@@ dogmht `js ynmt sfgtjl/ Impfstmy} j`
Evsmtimdymjl rgt ogdamlb, QIJ@@ GJC/ MP/ {{, 92(64X, IJ@@ `gmofi yj dmyf yj gl}
ofbgo gvynjsmy} gli gotj `gmofi yj dmyf yj ynf Sfdjsi,
Ynf dmymufltnm{ j` g lgyvsgo {fstjl mt ifyfshmlfi cgtfi jl nmt tygyf j`
ijhmdmof/ ljy nmt tygyf j` sftmifldf, Aglyfs p, Rgslfs(Oghcfsy Dj ,/ 306 @,4i
>64/ >62 .=yn Dms, 3;;7-, G {fstjlt ijhmdmof mt nmt {fshglfly njhf/ rnfsf
nf sftmift rmyn ynf mlyflymjl yj sfhgml mlif`mlmyfo} js rnfsf nf ngt sftmifi ml
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 30 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
27/77
74
ynf {gty gli mlyflit yj sfyvsl, Mi, Ijhmdmof mt ifyfshmlfi cgtfi jl g lvhcfs
j` `gdyjst/ mldovimlb5 dvssfly sftmifldf/ pjymlb/ ojdgymjl j` {fstjlgo gli sfgo
{sj{fsy}/ ojdgymjl j` csjafsgbf gli cgla gddjvlyt/ ojdgymjl j` t{jvtf gli
`ghmo}/ {ogdf j` fh{oj}hfly/ ismpfs"t omdfltf gli gvyjhjcmof sfbmtysgymjl gli
{g}hfly j` yg~ft,Ofr p, Hjtt/ 2=2 @,3i 292/ 26; .=yn Dms, 7=>0-,
IJ@@ djlyflit yngy Omcfsm {ogdfi nfs cvtmlftt giisftt ml [fllt}opglmg
ml ynf jsmbmlgo djh{ogmly `mofi rmyn ynf V,T, Imtysmdy Djvsy/ Fgtyfsl Imtysmdy j`
[fllt}opglmg gli `gmofi yj {sjpmif nfs ismpfst omdfltf yj {sjpf nfs sftmifld},
QIJ@@ GJC/ MP/ {{, 92(64X, IJ@@t djlyflymjlt rfsf*gsf mldjssfdy,
Omcfsm mt g sftmifly j` Tglyg @f/ Lfr Hf~mdj/ rnmdn IJ@@ mt rfoo grgsf j`,
Ml `gdy/ Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ {vcomtnfi Omcfsmt njhf giisftt goo jpfs ynf
Mlyfslfy sf{fgyfio}/ dgoofi `js {fj{of ml ynf gsfg rnfsf Omcfsm sftmift/ `mofi `gotf
ogr fl`jsdfhfly sf{jsyt gbgmlty Omcfsm rmyn ynf Tglyg @f [jomdf If{gsyhfly/ Lfr
Hf~mdj Gyyjslf} Bflfsgot J``mdf gli ynf Tglyg @f [sjcgymjl If{gsyhfly, QFS/
Pjo, 7/ {{, 73>(744/ 794(79>X gli QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;/ 4=/ 9;/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 4;0(
479/ 43;/ 9;7(9;3/ 976(970/ 939/ 996/ 902/ 9>4(9>9/ 6;7/ 643/ 694/ 62=/ Pjo, MMM/
{{, 0;7/ 0;=/ 07;/ 076/ 070/ 06=/ gli 240X,
Omcfsm ngt sftmifi ml Tglyg @f/ Lfr Hf~mdj tmldf Ljpfhcfs 3;;31 Omcfsmt
nvtcgli mt fh{oj}fi ml Lfr Hf~mdj gli ngt cffl tmldf Ljpfhcfs 3;;31 Omcfsmt
`gynfs gli tyf{ hjynfs gsf ojdgyfi ml Lfr Hf~mdj1 goo j` Omcfsmt hfimdgo
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 32 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
28/77
79
{sj`fttmjlgot gsf ojdgyfi ml Lfr Hf~mdj1 Omcfsmt tjl gyyflit djoofbf ml Lfr
Hf~mdj1 Omcfsm mt sfbmtyfsfi yj pjyf ml Lfr Hf~mdj1 Omcfsmt pfnmdoft gsf
sfbmtyfsfi ml Lfr Hf~mdj1 Omcfsmt cgla gddjvlyt gsf ml Lfr Hf~mdj1 Omcfsm ngt g
Lfr Hf~mdj Ismpfst omdfltf gli ngt tmldf 3;;31 gli Omcfsm gli nfs t{jvtf ngpf
{gmi Lfr Hf~mdj Tygyf Yg~ft tmldf ynf }fgs 3;;4, Omcfsm mt ijhmdmofi ml ynf Tygyf
j` Lfr Hf~mdj, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 73>(744/ 794(79>X,
Omcfsm mlyfslt `js [nmom{ E, Cfsb/ Ftwvmsf rnj mt ojdgyfi ml Og`g}fyyf Nmoo/
[fllt}opglmg, Sfbgsioftt j` rnfynfs Omcfsm sftmifi ml [fllt}opglmg js Lfr
Hf~mdj/ Impfstmy} tymoo f~mtyfi, Ynf If`fliglyt ml ynmt Dgtf rfsf ojdgyfi ml
Dgom`jslmg gli Yf~gt, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 360(362X1 gli QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;(73X,
Ml j{fl Djvsy jl Gvbvty 2/ 3;;=/ Omcfsm {sjpmifi Evibf Sjcsflj ml ynf V,T,
Imtysmdy Djvsy/ Fgtyfsl Imtysmdy j` [fllt}opglmg ml ynmt dgtf nfs Lfr Hf~mdj
Ismpfst Omdfltf/ Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} dgsit/ gli cmsyn dfsym mdgyf, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 74;X,
Evibf Sjcsflj `jvli/ evty omaf ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy ml ynmt G{{fgo/ yngy evsmtimdymjl
rgt impfstm`mfi,
G{{foofft hfy ynfms cvsifl, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy {sj{fso} iflmfi IJ@@ gli
Ygmyut Hjymjl yj Imthmtt {vstvgly yj @fi, S, Dmp, [, 73.c-.7-, Aglyfs p,
Rgslfs(Oghcfsy Dj,/ 306 @,4i >64/ >62 .=yn Dms, 3;;7-1 Ofr p, Hjtt/ 2=2
@,3i 292/ 26; .=yn Dms, 7=>0-,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 3> j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
29/77
76
C, YNF IMTYSMDY DJVSYT JSIFS IFL]MLB YGMYU gli
IJ@@T HJYMJL yj TYSMAF mt LJY g @MLGO G[[FGOGCOF
JSIFS5
Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb jsmbmlgoo} `mofi tvmy ml ynf V,T, Imtysmdy Djvsy/
Fgtyfsl Imtysmdy j` [fllt}opglmg jl Hg} 9/ 3;;=, Ynf dgtf rgt tfpfsfi gli
ysglt`fssfi c} ynf [fllt}opglmg Imtysmdy Djvsy/ yj Dgom`jslmg gli Yf~gt, G{{foofft
ngi lfpfs ghflifi ynfms jsmbmlgo djh{ogmly, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 9/ 772/ 333/ 363X,
Jldf ynmt dgtf rgt ysglt`fssfi yj Dgom`jslmg Ygmyu gli IJ@@ `mofi ynfms Glym(
TOG[[ Hjymjl yj Tysmaf G{{foofft jsmbmlgo djh{ogmly, G{{foofft `mofi g Hjymjl
`js Ofgpf yj Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly gli `mofi ynfms [@GD rmyn jlf nvlisfi jsy}(
`mpf Q796X F~nmcmyt QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 9(6/ >(7;/ 36(30/ 32(3=X, TFS/ Pjo,t 7(6/ {{,
0(7376X,
Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy mttvfi myt yflygympf svomlb bsglymlb G{{foofft Ofgpf yj
Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly1 Ifl}mlb G{{fooglyt Hjymjl yj Tysmaf gli Hjymjl yj
Imthmtt1 gli {ogdfi `momlb sftysmdymjlt jl ynf {gsymft, Ynf Djvsy `jvli yngy
G{{fooglyt Hjymjlt rfsf {sfhgyvsf ml ombny j` G{{foofft `momlb ynfms [@GD QFS/
Pjo, 7/ {{, 36(47X, Ynf Djvsy gotj `jvli yngy Ygmyu gli IJ@@ imi ljy hffy ynfms
cvsifl QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {,>X,
G`yfs Jsgo Gsbvhfly jl Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl/ rnmdn G{{foofft
djvltfo rgt ljy{sftfly `js ivf yj gl fhfsbfld} hfimdgo tmyvgymjl jl nmt `ombny yj
Dgom`jslmg/ ynf Djvsy mttvfi myt @mlgo Jsifs QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 6(=X, Ynf Imtysmdy
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 3= j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
30/77
70
Djvsy iflmfi ynf Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl `mlimlb Ygmyu gli IJ@@ imi ljy hffy ynfms
cvsifl vlifsDgo, Dmp, Djif 936,70/ `gmomlb yj hgaf g {smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb yngy
ynf gdyt djh{ogmlfi j` `goo mlyj gl} j` ynf `jvs dgyfbjsmft j` 936,70.f-, Gli/
fpfl m` ynf If`fliglyt imi hffy ynf `msty {sjlb/ [ogmlym``t ngpf tv``mdmflyo} hgif g
{smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb j` `gdyt yngy rjvoi/ m` {sjpfi/ tv{{jsy g evibhfly ml ynfms
`gpjs, QFS Pjo, 7/ {, >X,
G{{foofft ngi ynf smbny yj Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly/ fpfl ynjvbn gl Glym(
TOG[[ hjymjl rgt {flimlb, @fi, S, Dmp, [, 76.g-1 Pfsmujl Ifogrgsf/ Mld, p,
Djpgi Djhht, Dj,/ 422 @,4i 7;>7/ 7;=;(=7 .=yn Dms, 3;;9- .#bsglymlb g
if`fligly"t glym(TOG[[ hjymjl yj tysmaf g {ogmlym``"t mlmymgo djh{ogmly rmynjvy
bsglymlb ynf {ogmlym`` ofgpf yj ghfli rjvoi imsfdyo} djoomif rmyn @fi, S, Dmp, [,
76.g-"t {jomd} `gpjsmlb omcfsgo ghflihfly#-,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@ djh{ogml yngy ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy fssfi ml ljy bsglymlb ynfms
Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl gli goojrmlb G{{foofft yj Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly, QFS/ Pjo,
7/ {{, 73(7>X, Ynmt tmh{o} mt ljy ynf dgtf, Pftt p, Dmcg(Bfmb} Djs{, VTG/ 472
@,4i 7;=2/ 77;= .=yn Dms, 3;;4-,
Goynjvbn ynf Pftt djvsy rgt ljy t{fdm`mdgoo} djltmifsmlb ynf {sj{smfy} j`
goojrmlb g [ogmlym`` yj ghfli myt djh{ogmly cf`jsf svomlb jl gl Glym(TOG[[
hjymjl/ ynf {jtyvsf j` yngy dgtf mt tmhmogs yj ynf {sftfly dgtf5 #Goo ynsff if`fliglyt
`mofi hjymjlt yj tysmaf {vstvgly yj Dgom`jslmg"t glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf gli `js
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 4; j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
31/77
72
gyyjslf}t" `fft vlifs yngy tygyvyf, Rmynjvy svomlb jl ynf hjymjlt/ ynf imtysmdy djvsy
bsglyfi Pftt ofgpf yj `mof g `msty ghflifi djh{ogmly,# Pftt/ 472 @,4i gy 77;3,
Ynf Pftt Djvsy djlivdyfi myt glgo}tmt j` ynf If`fliglyt" Glym(TOG[[
hjymjlt rmyn sft{fdy yj Pftt"t @GD gt j{{jtfi yj Pftt"t jsmbmlgo djh{ogmly,
Gt Pftt mh{omdmyo} tvbbftyt/ bsglymlb g If`fligly"t Glym(TOG[[ hjymjl yj
tysmaf g [ogmlym``"t mlmymgo djh{ogmly rmynjvy bsglymlb ynf [ogmlym`` ofgpf yj ghfli
rjvoi imsfdyo} djoomif rmyn @fi, S, Dmp, [, 76.g-"t {jomd} `gpjsmlb omcfsgo
ghflihfly,
G{{foofft `mofi ynfms [@GD rmyn 796 tv{{jsymlb F~nmcmyt/ QTFS/ Pjo,t 7(6/
{{, 0(7376X cf`jsf ynf} rfsf sfwvmsfi yj `mof ynfms J{{jtmymjl yj G{{fooglyt Glym(
TOG[[ Hjymjl, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy `jvli Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ngi ljy hfy ynfms
cvsifl vlifsDgo, Dmp, Djif 936,70, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy Iflmfi G{{fooglyt
Hjymjl yj Tysmaf1 gli bsglyfi G{{foofft Ofgpf yj Ghfli ynfms Djh{ogmly `mlimlb
yngy ynf dgtf ngi evty ysglt`fssfi gli G{{foofft ngi ljy {sfpmjvto} ghflifi, Ynf
Djvsy iflmfi Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjlt yj Imthmtt vlifs@fi, S, Dmp, [, 73.c-.7-
gli 73.c-.0- rmynjvy {sfevimdf, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 9(=X,
Ml Bsfflt{smlbt Cg{ymty Dnsmtymgl @foojrtnm{ Ysvty p, Dmoof}/ 3;7; V,T,
G{{, OF^MT 30372/ 03= @,4i 7;09 .=yn Dms, 3;7;-/ [ogmlym``t mofi gl gdymjl `js
Hgomdmjvt [sjtfdvymjl ml @fifsgo Imtysmdy Djvsy, If`fliglyt `mofi gl Glym(TOG[[
Hjymjl gbgmlty Bsfflt{smlbt Djh{ogmly, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy `jvli yngy [ogmlym``
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 47 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
32/77
7>
ngi ljy{sftflyfi tv``mdmfly fpmifldf j` ynf hfsmy j` myt dogmht, Ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy
dmyfi ynf @fifsgo {jomd} `gpjsmlb omcfsgo ghflihfly j` dogmht gli bsglyfi [ogmlym``
Ofgpf yj Ghfli myt Djh{ogmly, If`fligly G{{fgofi ynf Imtysmdy Djvsyt svomlb
dogmhmlb ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy tnjvoi ngpf `joojrfi Dgom`jslmg ogr yngy {sjnmcmyt ynf
Djvsy `sjh bsglymlb ofgpf yj ghfli ynf djh{ogmly g`yfs ynf bsgly j` gl Glym(
TOG[[ Hjymjl, Ml Pfsmujl Ifo, Mld, p, Djpgi Djhhd"lt Dj,/ 422 @,4i 7;>7/ 7;=7
.=yn Dms, 3;;9- ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy nfoi yngy #bsglymlb g if`fligly"t glym(TOG[[
hjymjl yj tysmaf g {ogmlym``"t mlmymgo djh{ogmly rmynjvy bsglymlb ynf {ogmlym`` ofgpf yj
ghfli rjvoi imsfdyo} djoomif rmyn @fi, S, Dmp, [, 76.g-"t {jomd} `gpjsmlb omcfsgo
ghflihfly,#
Jl g{{fgo/ ynf msty mlwvms} c} ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy rgt rnfynfs my ngi
evsmtimdymjl jpfs ynf g{{fgo, Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy f~{ogmlfi yngy @fifsgo G{{foogyf
Djvsyt dgl sfpmfr yrj Q3X amlit j` Svomlbt1 `mlgo ifdmtmjlt jl ynf hfsmyt wvjymlb
3> V,T,D, 73=71 Dgttmsfs p, Amlbijh j` T{gml/ 070 @,4i 7;7=/ 7;39 .=yn Dms,
3;7;-1 gli g thgoo dogtt j` djoogyfsgo jsifst wvjymlb Rmoo p, Ngoojda/ 690 V,T, 496/
49=/ 730 T, Dy, =63/ 704 O, Fi, 3i >40 .3;;0- .wvjymlbCfnsflt p, [foofymfs/ 670
V,T, 3==/ 4;6/ 770 T, Dy, >49/ 744 O, Fi, 3i 224 .7==0--, Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy nfoi
yngy gl Jsifs bsglymlb gl Glym(TOG[[ hjymjl rmyn ofgpf yj ghfli mt ljy g `mlgo
ifdmtmjl jl ynf hfsmyt cfdgvtf my {fshmyt `vsynfs omymbgymjl, Ynf tghf njoit ysvf ml
ynmt dgtf/ gl Jsifs bsglymlb ofgpf yj ghfli gli ifl}mlb ynf Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 43 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
33/77
7=
{fshmyt `vsynfs omymbgymjl gli ynfsf`jsf mt ljy g `mlgo g{{fgogcof jsifs, Ynf Lmlyn
Dmsdvmy nfoi yngy ynf jlo} jynfs {jttmcof cgtmt `js evsmtimdymjl/ ynfl/ mt ynf Djoogyfsgo
Jsifs Ijdysmlf,
Jvs Djvsyt ngpf nfoi `js g Djoogyfsgo Jsifs yj cf G{{fgogcof/ g Djoogyfsgo
Jsifs hvty hffy ynsff Q4X sfwvmsfhflyt5 7- My hvty djldovtmpfo} ifyfshmlf ynf
imt{vyfi wvftymjl, 3- My hvty sftjopf gl mh{jsygly mttvf djh{ofyfo} tf{gsgyf `sjh
ynf hfsmyt j` ynf gdymjl, 4- Gli my hvty cf f``fdympfo} vlsfpmfrgcof jl g{{fgo
`sjh ynf `mlgo evibhfly, Ynf V,T, Tv{sfhf Djvsy ngt mltysvdyfi djvsyt yj g{{o}
ynmt yfty tysmlbflyo},Imbmygo Fwvm{hfly Djs{, p, Iftayj{ Imsfdy Mld,/ 677 V,T, >04/
>0> .7==9-, Tff gotj Rmoo p, Ngoojda/ 690 V,T, 496/ 49=/ 730 T, Dy, =63/ 704 O, Fi,
3i >40 .3;;0-/ .wvjymlb[vfsyj Smdj Gwvfivdy & Tfrfs Gvyn, p, Hfydgo` & Fii}/
Mld,/ 6;0 V,T, 74=/ 799/ 774 T, Dy, 0>9/ 737 O, Fi, 3i 0;6 .7==4--, Goo ynsff Q4X
sfwvmsfhflyt hvty cf hfy `js g Djvsy yj f~fsdmtf Evsmtimdymjl vlifs ynf Djoogyfsgo
Jsifs Ijdysmlf,HdFohvss} p, V,T, Cgla Lgy"o Gtt"l/ 9=6 @,4i 7740/ 779; .=yn Dms,
3;;2- .dmymlb Tysmlb`foojr p, Djldfslfi Lfmbncjst ml Gdymjl/ 9>; V,T, 42;/ 426/
7;2 T, Dy, 7722/ =9 O, Fi, 3i 4>= .7=>2--, Ynftf djlimymjlt gsf #tysmlbfly/# gli
ynf Tv{sfhf Djvsy ngt #sf{fgyfio} tysfttfi yngy ynf "lgssjr" f~df{ymjl tnjvoi tyg}
yngy rg} gli lfpfs cf goojrfi yj trgoojr ynf bflfsgo svof , , , yngy g {gsy} mt
flymyofi yj g tmlbof g{{fgo/ yj cf if`fssfi vlymo `mlgo evibhfly ngt cffl flyfsfi,#
Imbmygo Fwvm{,/ 677 V,T, gy >0> .wvjymlb Smdngsitjl(Hfssfoo p, Ajoofs/ 923 V,T,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 44 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
34/77
3;
939/ 940 .7=>6--1 Tff gotj Rmoo/ 690 V,T, gy 46; .#QRXf ngpf ljy hflymjlfi
g{{o}mlb ynf djoogyfsgo jsifs ijdysmlf sfdflyo} rmynjvy fh{ngtmumlb myt hjifty
tdj{f,#-,
Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy ml Bsfflt{smlbt `jdvtfi jl rnfynfs ynf svomlb
djldovtmpfo} ifyfshmlfi g imt{vyfi wvftymjl/ rnmdn `goot ml ynf `msty djoogyfsgo jsifs
sfwvmsfhfly, Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy nfoi yngy ynf Jsifs bsglymlb ofgpf yj ghfli/
goojrmlb ynf [ogmlym`` yj {ofgi giimymjlgo `gdyt/ rgt ml fttfldf ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy
mlimdgymlb yngy my rjvoi sfpmtmy ynf mh{gdy j` ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf ml ombny j` ynf
ghflihfly, Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy `jvli my imi ljy ngpf evsmtimdymjl yj sfpmfr ynf
Imtysmdy Djvsyt jsifs vlifs ynf djoogyfsgo jsifs ijdysmlf gt my rgt ljy g `mlgo jsifs
gli imthmttfi If`fliglyt g{{fgo gt vlsfpmfrgcof,
Ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy `vsynfs nfoi C} djlysgty/ ynf bsgly j` gl glym(TOG[[
hjymjl rmyn ofgpf yj ghfli mt ljy #hgif rmyn ynf f~{fdygymjl yngy QmyX rmoo cf ynf
`mlgo rjsi# jl ynf g{{omdgcmomy} j` ynf tygyvyf,Mi, Evty omaf ml Bsfflt{smlbt/ ml ynmt
dgtf/ ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy ml bsglymlb G{{foofft ofgpf yj ghfli/ mlpmyfi G{{foofft(
[ogmlym``t yj tvchmy giimymjlgo fpmifldf ( fpmifldf rnmdn rjvoi/ ml yvsl/ {fshmy ynf
djvsy yj sfgttftt ynf {sj{smfy} j` bsglymlb ynf glym(TOG[[ hjymjl,
Ynmt mt ljy ynf `msty G{{fgo Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ngpf ygafl jl g ljl(g{{fgogcof
jsifs, Ynf} g{{fgofi ynf Fgtyfsl Imtysmdy j` [fllt}opglmgt Ysglt`fs Jsifs/
ifog}mlb ynmt dgtf v{ `js gohjty g }fgs, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t g{{fgo rgt imthmttfi gt
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 49 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
35/77
37
ynf Ynmsi Dmsdvmy Djvsy j` G{{fgot ogdafi evsmtimdymjl yj flyfsygml my gt ysglt`fs
jsifst gsf mlyfsojdvyjs} gli ij ljy `my rmynml ynf f~df{ymjl/ omaf ynmt g{{fgo nfsf,
@js ynf sfgtjlt jvyomlfi nfsfml/ G{{fooglyt G{{fgot hvty cf Imthmttfi gli
G{{foofft grgsifi Gyyjslf} `fft gli djtyt,
D, YGMYU gli IJ@@T GJCT gsf [SFHMTFI jl LFR
GSBVHFLYT/ LFR TYGYFHFLYT/ gli LFR IF@FLTFT/
LJY [SFTFLYFI yj ynf IMTYSMDY DJVSY1 gli DJLYGML
MH[SJ[FS DMYGYMJLT yj ynf SFDJSI5
7, YGMYU gli IJ@@t G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf`5
Ml Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl cf`jsf ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy rnmdn mt ynf tvcefdy j`
ynmt G{{fgo/ IJ@@ dogmhfi [ogmlym``t*G{{foofft ogrtvmy rgt `mofi yj omhmy {vcomd
{gsymdm{gymjl gli t{fdm`mdgoo} yj tmofldf ynf if`fliglyt/ rnj gsf rnmtyof cojrfst
Njrfpfs/ IJ@@ lfpfs tygyfi rngy ynf {vcomd {gsymdm{gymjl rgt js rngy my rgt
dogmhmlb ynf {vcomd {gsymdm{gymjl rgt js rngy ynf} rfsf cojrmlb ynf tv{{jtfi
rnmtyof jl, Tff Ygmyu gli IJ@@t FS/ Pjo, 7 gy {gbft >>(7;4 gli 766(340,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@ goo ynsjvbn ynfms GJC ngpf sgmtfi lfr if`fltft gli
gsbvhflyt mldovimlb cvy ljy omhmyfi yj ynmt tvmy mt g sftvoy j` [jomymdgo omymbgymjl/ ynf
Cmsynfs hjpfhfly/ Ygmyu mt g {jomymdgo imttmifly/ Cfsb rgt gotj mlpjopfi ml ynf
{jomymdgo omymbgymjl/ yngy Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog {gsymdm{gyf ml Cfsbt {jomymdgo gdympmymft/
`gotf gttfsymjlt gcjvy g 4si Dmsdvmy G{{fgo/ Dgtf Lj, 7;(4;;;/ `gotf gttfsymjlt
gcjvy Ijllg Glifst/ Djvsy Ysgltdsmcfs/ yngy Glym(TOG[[ g{{omft cfdgvtf Ygmyut
gdymjlt gli t{ffdn gsf {sjyfdyfi gt [jomymdgo t{ffdn ml nfs sjof gt ynf tfo`(
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 46 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
36/77
33
{sjdogmhfi ofgifs j` ynf Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly gli [ogmlym``t ngpf mlyfs`fsfi rmyn
G{{fooglyt {jomymdgo `vli sgmtmlb gdympmymft/ dsvdmgo yj `vli omymbgymjl gli jynfs
gdympmymft ml tv{{jsy j` ynmt hjpfhfly gli Ygmyu jlo} f~{jtfi [ogmlym``t
djssv{ymjl gli hgl} jynfs lfr if`fltft/ gsbvhflyt gli tyjsmft, Tff IJ@@t
GJC/ Mlysjivdymjl/ fli j` myt Ygcof j` Djlyflyt ynsjvbn {, 9/ {{, 2(=1 =(771 77(741
76(701 7=(3>1 4;(421 gli 9;(96,
G{{fooglyt flymsf GJCt gsf {sfhmtfi jl ynftf lfr if`fltft/ lfr tyjsmft
gli lfr gsbvhflyt/ vltv{{jsyfi c} ynf sfdjsi gli ljy {sftflyfi js cf`jsf ynf
Imtysmdy Djvsy, G{{fooglyt djldjdyfi ynfms lfr if`fltft/ tyjsmft gli gsbvhfly ml
ynfms GJC `js ynmt G{{foogyf Djvsy ml gl gyyfh{y yj trg} ynmt Djvsy yj jpfs(yvsl
ynf Imtysmdy Djvsyt @mlimlbt gli Jsifs cgtfi jl tyjsmft/ gsbvhflyt gli if`fltft
lfpfs{sftflyfi yj js cf`jsf ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy, Ygmyu gli IJ@@ rfsf grgsf ynf}
imi ljy ngpf g ofbgo cgtmt gli ynfms if`fltft/ tyjsmft gli gsbvhflyt/ rnmdn rfsf
im``fsfly yngl rngy mt ml ynfms GJC/ {sftflyfi yj ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy `gmofi yj
tvctyglymgyf imthmttgo j` G{{foofft ogrtvmy {vstvgly yj ynf Glym(TOG[[,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@t lfr if`fltft/ tyjsmft gli gsbvhflyt ml ynfms GJC/
vltv{{jsyfi c} ynf sfdjsi/ gsf rgmpfi cfdgvtf Ygmyu gli IJ@@ imi ljy {sftfly
ynfh yj ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t lfr gsbvhflyt gli if`fltft mldovif
cvy gsf ljy omhmyfi yj ynf `joojrmlb5
Ynmt dgtf gsmtft jvy j` gl jlbjmlb imt{vyf mlpjopmlb ynf {jomymdgoimttmifly hjpfhfly/ mldovimlb g djh{jlfly aljrl gt ynf Cmsynfs
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 40 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
37/77
34
Hjpfhfly/ c} ynjtf dngooflbmlb ynf wvgom`mdgymjlt j` Cgsgda Jcghgyj njoi ynf j``mdf j` [sftmifly j` ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft j` Ghfsmdg,If`fligly gli G{{foogly/ JSO] YGMYU .Ygmyu-/ mt g {jomymdgoimttfly ofgifs rnj/ mlimpmivgoo} gli ynsjvbn If`fligly gliG{{foogly/ IF@FLI JVS @SFFIJHT @JVLIGYMJLT/ MLD,.IJ@@- .djoofdympfo} G{{fooglyt-/ ngt cffl gli sfhgmlt ynfofgifs j` ynmt hjpfhfly, QYgmyu gli IJ@@t GJC/ gy {gbf 7X,
Omymbgymjl mt jlf j` ynmt hjpfhflyt yjjot yj gipgldf myt bjgot/
mldovimlb tfpfsgo dgtft mlpjopmlb Cmsynfs dgvtftTvdn omymbgymjl mt
g `jsh j` {fymymjl `js sfisftt j` bsmfpgldft vlifs ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft
Djltymyvymjl/ Gsymdof M, [ogmlym``t gdaljrofibf G{{fooglyt f~fsdmtf j`
ynfms smbny j` {fymymjl sfbgsimlb Ygmyu `momlb djh{ogmlytjl cfngo` j`
Gogl Af}ft gli jynfs [ogmlym``t gbgmlty ynf Dgom`jslmg Tfdsfygs} j`Tygyf gli jynfs If`fliglyt sfbgsimlb ynf Cgss} Tjfyjsj g**a*g* Cgsgda
N, Jcghg dmymufltnm{ mttvft, QYgmyu gli IJ@@t GJC/ gy {gbf 3X,
[ogmlym`` gli G{{fooff/ [NMOM[ E, CFSB .Cfsb-/ mt gotj mlpjopfi mlynf {jomymdgo imttmifly hjpfhfly, @js f~gh{of, Cfsb ngt `mofi g dgtfdngooflbmlb [sftmifly Jcghgt wvgom`mdgymjlt yj cf [sftmifly glidogmht yj dgss} ynf hglyof j` ynf Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly ynsjvbnrrr,jcghgdsmhft,djh,,,Cfsb gttmtyfi c} [ogmlym``t gli G{{foofft/OMTG OMCFSM .Omcfsm- gli OMTG H, JTYFOOG .Jtyfoog-/ ngpfmlyfs`fsfi rmyn G{{fooglyt rfctmyft gli mlyfslfy cojbt/ dsfgyfihmtofgimlb gli djh{fymlb rfctmyft tvdn gt if`flijvs`sffijht,lfygli impfsyfi `vlit `sjh IJ@@ yj flymymft djlysjoofi c} [ogmlym``t,[ogmlym``t ngpf mlyfs`fsfi rmyn G{{fooglyt {jomymdgo `vlisgmtmlbgdympmymft/ dsvdmgo yj `vli omymbgymjl gli jynfs gdympmymft ml tv{{jsy j`ynmt hjpfhfly, QYgmyu gli IJ@@t GJC/ gy {gbf 4X
Ygmyu gli IJ@@t lfr tygyfhflyt/ gsbvhflyt gli tyjsmft gsf goo ynsjvbn
ynfms GJC/ ynfsf mt ljy fljvbn sjjh yj giisftt fgdn gli fpfs} tygyfhfly ml ynmt
Csmf`, Ljrnfsf ml IJ@@ gli Ygmyut Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl/ Sf{o} ynfsfyj/ js
gsbvhfly cf`jsf ynf ojrfs Djvsy QSfdjsiX/ rnmdn mt ynf tvcefdy j` ynmt G{{fgo/
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 42 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
38/77
39
gsf gl} j` ynf gcjpf tygyfhflyt/ goofbgymjlt js gl}ynmlb sfhjyfo} dojtf yj my, Ynfsf
mt ljynmlb sfogymlb yj/ sf`fssmlb yj/ js fpfl hflymjlmlb g Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly js
Cmsynfs ojdgyfi ml ynf Sfdjsi, Cvy/ IJ@@ gli Ygmyu sgmtf ynfms Cmsynfs gli
Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly gsbvhflyt ml ynfms GJC gy {gbft 7/ 3/ 0/ 7;/ 77>/ 7=/ 36 gli
30, Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ml ynfms GJC gy {gbft 7(4/ 2/ >/ 77/ 7>/ 7=/ 39(30 ygoat gcjvy
gli gsbvft yngy ynf} gsf g {jomymdgo imttmifly/ gli ynf dgtf gsmtft jvy j` g
{jomymdgo hjpfhfly1 {jomymdgo ijlgymjlt/ {jomymdgo `vlisgmtmlb/ {jomymdgo
imttmifly hjpfhfly/ gli {jomymdgo pmfrt/ cvy ynftf tygyfhflyt gli gsbvhflyt ij
ljy g{{fgs gl}rnfsf ml ynf Sfdjsi, Ml `gdy/ ynf rjsi {jomymdgo jlo} g{{fgst ml
jlf {ogdf/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 7>=X rnfsf Ygmyu
tygyft/ Omlig Cfodnfs/ `jshfs pjovlyffs {jomymdgo sftfgsdnfs Tff gotj Ygmyu
gli IJ@@t GJCt/ Mlysjivdymjl gy {, 7 ynsjvbn {, 9/ {{, 2(=1 =(771 77(741 76(701
7=(3>1 4;(421 gli 9;(96 `js ynfms lfr tygyfhflyt/ gsbvhflyt/ if`fltft gli tyjsmft,
G{{foofft lfpfs ngi ynf j{{jsyvlmy} yj giisftt Ygmyu gli IJ@@t lfr
gsbvhflyt/ tyjsmft/ if`fltft js tygyfhflyt/ ljs rgt ynf Imtysmdy Djvsyt Jsifs
cgtfi v{jl ynftf lfr ynfjsmft, Ynfsf`jsf/ fpfs} sf`fsfldf ml Ygmyu gli IJ@@t
GJC yj ynftf lfr gsbvhflyt/ if`fltft gli tygyfhflyt/ hvty cf tysmdafl,
Gl G{{fgo mt g {sjdffimlb ml rnmdn g nmbnfs Djvsy sfpmfrt ynf gdymjlt ygafl
c} g ysmgo Djvsy/ js ml ynmt dgtf/ ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy, G{{fgot gsf bflfsgoo} omhmyfi yj
g sfpmfr j` ynf sfdjsi `sjh ynf ojrfs Djvsy, [gsymft dglljy mlysjivdf lfr
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 4> j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
39/77
36
fpmifldf gli gsf omhmyfi yj rngy rgt tgmi gli mlysjivdfi gy ynf jsmbmlgo
{sjdffimlb, Mttvft/ if`fltft gli gsbvhflyt ljy sgmtfi gy ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy dglljy
cf sgmtfi ml ynf G{{fgo, Ynmt Djvsy sfpmfrt ynf ojrfs Djvsy"t g{{omdgymjl j` ynf
ogr yj ynf `gdyt gt {sftflyfi,Eglft p, Rgo(Hgsy Tyjsft/ Mld,/ 32= @,4i >>4/ >>2 .=yn
Dms, 3;;3- .Rf bflfsgoo} ij ljy djltmifs mttvft sgmtfi `js ynf `msty ymhf jl
G{{fgo-1 HgdIjlgoi p, Bsgdf Dnvsdn Tfgyyof/ 962 @,4i 7;2=/ 7;>0 .=yn Dms,
3;;0- .Rf ifdomlf yj djltmifs gsbvhflyt sgmtfi `js ynf `msty ymhf jl g{{fgo,-1
Thmyn p, Hgstn/ 7=9 @,49i 7;96/ 7;63 .=yn
Dms, 7===- .Rf ij ljy djltmifs
djlyflymjlt/ `gdyt js gsbvhflyt sgmtfi `js ynf `msty ymhf jl g{{fgo-1 [gibfyy p,
Rsmbny/ 6>2 @,4i =>4/ =>6 l,3 .=yn Dms, 3;;=- .{fs dvsmgh- .Rf ij ljy djltmifs
gsbvhflyt gli goofbgymjlt sgmtfi `js ynf `msty ymhf jl g{{fgo,-1 Vlmyfi Tygyft p,
Fomgt/ =37 @,3i >2;/ >29 .=yn Dms, 7==;- .Rf ifdomlf yj djltmifs fpmifldf js
gsbvhflyt {sftflyfi `js ynf `msty ymhf jl g{{fgo,-,
Gt tygyfi c} Evibf HdAfjrl ml Dys, `js Cmj(Fynmdgo Sf`jsh/ Mld, p, Dmy} &
Djvly} j` Njljovov/ 3;;0 V,T, G{{, OF^MT 70>421 966 @,4i =7; .=yn Dms, Evo} 0/
3;;0- ml nfs Ghflifi J{mlmjl gy `l, 4/ #Ynfsf mt bjji sfgtjl rn} rf bflfsgoo}
ij ljy djltmifs mttvft `js ynf `msty ymhf jl g{{fgo((ynf sfdjsi ngt ljy cffl
ifpfoj{fi/ ynf imtysmdy djvsy ngt ljy ngi gl j{{jsyvlmy} yj djltmifs ynf mttvf/ gli
ynf {gsymft" gsbvhflyt gsf ljy ifpfoj{fi gbgmlty ynf imtysmdy djvsy ifdmtmjl,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 4= j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
40/77
30
Gddjsimlbo}/ ynmt Djvsy tnjvoi Tysmaf goo if`fltft/ gsbvhflyt/ tyjsmft gli
fpmifldf yngy QrgtX ljy {sftflyfi yj ynf imtysmdy djvsy gt rfoo gt ynf gttfsymjlt ml
Ygmyu gli IJ@@t GJCt cgtfi jl ynfms lfr if`fltft/ tyjsmft gli gsbvhflyt,
3, Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Dmygymjlt yj ynf Sfdjsi gsf mh{sj{fs
dmygymjlt gli ynf Dmygymjlt yj ynf sfdjsi ij ljy tygyf js
sf`ofdy ynf tygyfhflyt dogmhfi c} Ygmyu gli IJ@@5
Goo ynsjvbn Ygmyu gli IJ@@t GJC ynf} hmttygyf gli hmtwvjyft rngy ynf
FS tygyf ml gyyfh{yt yj hmtofgi ynmt Djvsy gli {sfevimdf ynmt Djvsy gbgmlty ynf
[ogmlym``t*G{{foofft,
Ml jlf f~gh{of/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ml ynfms GJC gy {gbf 0/ tygyft Evibf
Sjcsflj djssfdyo} ljyfi5 Tjhf j` ynftf {gsymft ngpf g ojlb gli djh{omdgyfi
omymbgymjl nmtyjs}, Tff f,b,/ Cfsb p, Jcghg/ 6>0 @,4i 349 .4i Dms, 3;;=-,,,Ynmt
omymbgymjl g{{fgst yj cf {gsy j` ynmt jpfsgoo imt{vyf ghjlb ynf {gsymft, Q7 FS/ 34>/
`l, 7,X Rngy ynmt {jsymjl gdyvgoo} tygyft mt/
Tjhf j` ynftf {gsymft ngpf g ojlb gli djh{omdgyfi omymbgymjl nmtyjs},
Tff f,b,/ Cfsb p, Jcghg/ 6>0 @,4i 349 .4i Dms, 3;;=-1 Snjift p,
HgdIjlgoi/ 02; @, Tv{{, 3i 7404 .H,I, Bg, 3;;=- .mh{jtmlb
)3;/;;; tgldymjlt jl djvltfo Jso} Ygmyu `js vtf j` ynf ofbgo {sjdftt
`js gl mh{sj{fs {vs{jtf-/ g``i Snjift p, HgdIjlgoi/ 3;7; V,T,
G{{, OF^MT 649; .77yn Dms, Hgs, 76/ 3;7;-, Ynmt omymbgymjl g{{fgst yj
cf {gsy j` ynmt jpfsgoo imt{vyf ghjlb ynf {gsymft,
Amstdnlfs p, Vlmifl Djs{, j` Gh,/ tv{sg/ >93 @,3i 7;29 gy 7;2> .=yn Dms, 7=>>-,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 9; j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
41/77
32
Ynmt gsbvhfly rgt lfpfs hgif c} Ygmyu/ {sftflyfi yj js cf`jsf ynf Imtysmdy
Djvsy, Ljrnfsf ml IJ@@ js Ygmyut Hjymjl/ Sf{o} js Gsbvhfly ml tv{{jsy
ynfsfj` {sftflyfi yj ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy mt ynmt tygyfhfly hgif,
Ygmyut mldjssfdy dmymlb yj ynf sfdjsi gotj mldovift/ cvy mt ljy omhmyfi yj5
[ogmlym`` gli G{{fooff/ [NMOM[ E, CFSB .Cfsb-/ mt gotj mlpjopfi ml
ynf {jomymdgo imttmifly hjpfhfly, @js f~gh{of/ Cfsb ngt `mofi g dgtf
dngooflbmlb [sftmifly Jcghgt wvgom`mdgymjlt yj cf [sftmifly/ gli
dogmht yj dgss} ynf hglyof j` ynf Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly ynsjvbn
rrr,jcghgdsmhft,djh, Q7 FS/ 3=2X QIJ@@ gli Ygmyut GJC/ gy
{gbf 7X
FS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 3=2 {fsygmlt yj Fibgs Ngof/ If`fligly ml ynf Yf~gt {jsymjl j`
ynmt dgtf/ gli tg}t ljynmlb gcjvy g {jomymdgo imttmifly hjpfhfly/ js Hs, Cfsb
dgss}mlb ynf hglyof j` Cmsynfs Hjpfhfly ynsjvbn rrr,jcghgdsmhft,djh,
Ynf dmygymjl yj ynf sfdjsi ijft ljy tv{{jsy ynf gcjpf tygyfhfly yngy IJ@@ gli
Ygmyut dogmht my tv{{jsyt gli my mt ljy g {sj{fs dmygymjl yj ynf sfdjsi,
Ynfsf gsf lvhfsjvt mldjssfdy dmyft gli ynfsf mt ljy fljvbn sjjh ml ynmt
Csmf` yj giisftt goo ynf mldjssfdy dmygymjlt yj ynf Sfdjsi, Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ngpf
mh{sj{fs dmygymjlt yj ynf Sfdjsi ml ynfms GJCt gy {gbft 7/ 0/ 2/ >/ =/ 7;/ 77/ 3;/ 33
gli 34, IJ@@ ml myt GJC/ cfbmllmlb jl {gbf 9;/ jlo} dmyft yj ynf FS gt Pjovhf
lvhcfst gli lj sf`fsfldft yj {gbf lvhcfst/ IJ@@t FS {gbf lvhcfst ij ljy
hgydn myt FS Ygcof j` Djlyflyt1 gli ijft ljy djlygml ynf lvhcfs j` {gbft gt
dogmhfi ml IJ@@t Ygcof j` Djlyflyt, IJ@@t FS Pjovhft 3 gli 4/ {gbft 4>0(
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 97 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
42/77
3>
>70 rfsf ljy{sftflyfi yj js `mofi rmyn ynf Imtysmdy Djvsy gli gsf ljy{gsy j` ynf
sfdjsi,
Rnfl tygyfhflyt ml jlft J{flmlb Csmf` gsf ljy {sj{fso} dmyfi gli
vltv{{jsyfi c} ynf sfdjsi/ ynf} hvty cf tysmdafl gli ljy djltmifsfi c} ynf Djvsy,
Tff [fyfstjl p, Nmbnogli Hvtmd/ Mld,/ 79; @,4i, 7474/ 7437 .=yn Dms, 7==>- gli
Dgshfl p, Tgl @sgldmtdj Vlm`mfi Tdn, Imty,/ 342 @,4i 7;30/ 7;4; .=yn Dms, 3;;7-,
Tff gotjMl sf CmjOgtf Yfdn, Tfd, Omymb,/Lj, ;9(=92 IJD .D,I, Dgo, Egl, 32/ 3;;4-
l71 @fi, S, G{{, [, 7;.g-1 gli Amstnlfs p, Vlmifl Djs{, j` Gh,/ >93 @,3i 7;29/
7;22 .=yn Dms, 7=>>-,
@fi, S, G{{, [, 3>.g-.2- sfwvmsfi G{{fooglyt yj tvchmy g tygyfhfly j` `gdyt
sfofpgly yj ynf mttvft tvchmyyfi `js sfpmfr rmyn g{{sj{smgyf sf`fsfldft yj ynf
sfdjsi, Mi, .fh{ngtmt giifi,- Ml giimymjl/ QfXpfs} gttfsymjl ml csmf`t sfbgsimlb
hgyyfst ml ynf sfdjsi tngoo cf tv{{jsyfi c} g sf`fsfldf yj ynf ojdgymjl ml ynf
f~dfs{yt j` sfdjsi rnfsf ynf hgyyfs mt yj cf `jvli, Lmlyn Dmsdvmy Svof 3>(3,>, Mi,
.fh{ngtmt giifi,- G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf`t pmjogyf cjyn @fi, S, G[[, [,
3>.g-.2- gli Lmlyn Dmsdvmy Svof 3>(3,> c} hgamlb lvhfsjvt gttfsymjlt yngy gsf ljy
tv{{jsyfi c} ynf dmyfi FS tfdymjlt, Ynftf pmjogymjlt gsf bsjvlit `js tysmamlb
G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf`t ml ynfms flymsfy} gli imthmttmlb ynfms g{{fgo.t-, L*T
Djs{, p, Omcfsy} Hvyvgo Mlt, Dj,/ 732 @, 4i 7796/ 7790 .=yn Dms, 7==2-1 Dnsmtymgl
Ofbgo Tjd"} Dng{yfs j` Vlmp, j` Dgo, p, Rv/ 030 @,4i 9>4/ 9>2(>> .=yn Dms, 3;7;-
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 93 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
43/77
3=
.Ynmt Djvsy ifdomlft yj giisftt gsbvhflyt {sftflyfi gt cgsf gttfsymjlt gli ljy
tv{{jsyfi c} ynf sfdjsi-1 Ygmyu gli IJ@@t GJC sf`fsfldft yj ynf sfdjsi sf`fs yj
gsbvhflyt js `gdyt ljy mldovifi ml ynf FS gt dogmhfi c} Ygmyu/ ml pmjogymjl j`@fi,
S, G{{, [,3>.g-.2- gli Lmlyn Dmsdvmy Svof 3>(3,> gli tnjvoi cf Tysmdafl, Ynmt
Djvsy ngt imthmttfi G{{fgot cgtfi jl tmhmogs/ m` ljy ynf tghf pmjogymjlt/ L*T
Djs{, p, Omcfsy} Hvyvgo Mlt, Dj,/ 732 @, 4i 7796/ 7790 .=yn Dms, 7==2-1 Ngl p,
Tygl`jsi Vlmp,/ 37; @,4i 7;4>/ 7;9; .=yn Dms, 3;;;-1 Dhy}, Djhhfsdf Cgla p,
J"Csmfl/ 473 @,4i 7746/ 7742 .=yn Dms, 3;;3-, Gy g hmlmhvh/ ynmt Djvsy tnjvoi
Tysmaf ynjtf {jsymjlt j` G{{fooglyt J{flmlb Csmf` yngy gsf ljy tv{{jsyfi {sj{fso}
c} dmygymjlt yj ynf FS/ gli*js ynf FS mt hmttygyfi gli hmtwvjyfi gli ynf {jsymjlt
yngy sf`fs yj ynfms Sfwvfty `js Evimdmgo Ljymdf,
I, YNF GLYM(TOG[[ TYGYVYF ijft LJY G[[O] yj
G[[FOOFFT DJH[OGMLY js ynf VLIFSO]MLB GDYMJL5
Ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf rgt flgdyfi yj goojr `js fgso} imthmttgo j`
hfsmyoftt `msty ghflihfly dgtft gmhfi gy dnmoomlb f~{sfttmjl ynsjvbn djtyo}/ ymhf(
djltvhmlb omymbgymjl, Hfygcjom`f Mlyo/ Mld, p, Rjslmda/ 309 @,4i >43/ >4= .=yn
Dms, 3;;7-,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ml ynfms Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl ij ljy gsymdvogyf njr ynf
Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf {fsygmlt yj ynfms gdyt, Mltyfgi/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ gyygda Omcfsm
gli Jtyfoog rmyn `gotf goofbgymjlt tygymlb ynf {vcomd ngi g smbny yj aljr yngy Jtyfoog
ojdafi Ygmyu jvy j` nfs cojb gli yjja jpfs Ygmyut Cojb1 Omcfsm ngi gddftt yj
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 94 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
44/77
4;
Cfsbt ijljst dsfimy dgsit1 yngy Omcfsm mt g djlpmdyfi ijdvhfly `jsbfs rnj mt
{sf{gsmlb ynf ijdvhflyt `js Cfsbt dgtft/ yngy ynf {vcomd ngi g smbny yj aljr yngy
tjhf j` ynjtf ijdvhflyt rfsf ljy bflvmlf1 Omcfsm ijft lgymjlrmif `vlisgmtmlb `js
Cfsb gli ynf {vcomd ngi g smbny yj aljr tnf rgt g djlpmdyfi ijdvhfly `jsbfs gli
ynmf`1 yngy ynf} jlo} imtysmcvyfi Omcfsmt dsmhmlgo sfdjsi1 yngy ynf} ngi yj rgsl
ynf {vcomd gcjvy Jtyfoog gli Omcfsm1 yngy fpfs} {jty c} G{{fooglyt rgt ysvyn`vo
ml`jshgymjl1 yngy ml ynf Jdfgl j` toglifs gli nfgstg} c} ynf [ogmlym``t/ ynfsf gsf g
`fr t{fdm`md tygyfhflyt/ gyysmcvyfi yj ynf if`fliglyt/ goo j` rnmdn gsf ysvyn`vo
ml`jshgymjl1 gli G{{fooglyt djh{ofyfo} hmtwvjyf G{{foofft Djh{ogmly ml ynfms
Hjymjl, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 76=(700X, Gt ifhjltysgyfi c} G{{foofft J{{jtmymjl yj
Ygmyu gli IJ@@t Hjymjl/ G{{foofft [@GD1 gli ynf 796 F~nmcmyt `mofi ml tv{{jsy
ynfsfj`/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@t tygyfhflyt ml ynfms Hjymjl gsf vlysvyn`vo, QFS/ Pjo, M/
{{, 7;2(769X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(
76=/ 36;(3=2o/ Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/
77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ ynsfgyflfi yj ygaf Cfsb ijrl gli yj ij tj tnf
rgt bjmlb yj iftysj} Omcfsm gli bfy smi j` nfs, Ynmt ynsfgy rgt hgif g`yfs Omcfsm
gli Cfsb sf`vtfi yj gttmty Ygmyu rmyn nfs ofbgo flifgpjst gt g sftvoy j` nfs vlfynmdgo
cfngpmjst, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ rfly g`yfs Jtyfoog cfdgvtf Jtyfoog rjvoi
ljy omf `js Ygmyu gli tvctyglymgyf Ygmyut `gotf goofbgymjlt j` ngdamlb mlyj nfs
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 99 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
45/77
47
cojb rfctmyf gli [g}[go gddjvlyt QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 763/ 303(309/ 477X/ QTFS/ Pjo,
7/ {{, 70(72/ 36/ >>/ =6(=0/ 79;/ 703X,
Ynmt ogrtvmy gbgmlty G{{fooglyt Ygmyu gli IJ@@ mt ljy gcjvy gl} {jomymdgo
mttvf/ cvy mltyfgi gcjvy Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ {vcomtnmlb Omcfsm gli Jtyfoogt
{smpgyf igyg/ mldovimlb cvy ljy omhmyfi yj Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfst/ igyft j` cmsyn/
{ogdf j` cmsyn/ hjynfst hgmifl lghft/ njhf giisfttft/ hgmifl lghft/ t{jvtft
lghft/ igyft j` cmsyn/ Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} lvhcfst/ hfimdgo igyg/ `mlgldmgo igyg/
mldjhf/ dsfimy sf{jsyt gli dsfimy igyg/ gli jynfs {smpgyf igyg, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn
IJ@@ {vcomtnfi Omcfsm gli Jtyfoogt {smpgyf igyg sf{fgyfio} goo jpfs ynf Mlyfslfy/
sf{fgyfio} tfly my cf hgtt Fhgmo yj hmoomjlt j` mlimpmivgot gli djh{glmft/
mldovimlb mlyfslgymjlgoo}1 sf{fgyfio} imtdvttfi my jl Sgimj mlyfspmfrt/ YP tnjrt/
]jvYvcf pmifjt/ sf{fgyfio} {vcomtnfi my ynsjvbn ynfms Tjdmgo Lfyrjsat .g{{sj~,
fmbny Q>X @gdfcjja {gbft1 `smflit`ffi/ yrmyyfs/ cf`jsf myt lfrt/ gli jynfs Tjdmgo
Lfyrjsat-/ fyd, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 733(732/ 73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(
767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS
Pjot 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/
{{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631
Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Ynmt tvmy mt gotj gcjvy Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@t {vcomtnmlb `gotf
tygyfhflyt/ gddvtgymjlt gli goofbgymjlt gcjvy Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb, Ygmyu `gotf
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 96 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
46/77
43
gttfsymjlt gli goofbgymjlt mldovif cvy gsf ljy omhmyfi yj Omcfsm mt g dgsffs ijdvhfly
`jsbfs1 Omcfsm gli nfs nvtcgli impfsyfi `vlit `sjh Cfsb1 Omcfsm ngdafi gli
ygh{fsfi rmyn Ygmyu gli IJ@@t rfctmyf gli [g}[go1 Omcfsm tyjof hjlmft `sjh
IJ@@ gli Ygmyut [g}[go1 Omcfsm ngt `fojl} dngsbft {flimlb gbgmlty nfs1 Omcfsm
hvsifsfi nfs tmtyfs1 Omcfsm rgt f~yjsymlb hjlf} `sjh Ygmyu gli ynf jynfs
If`fliglyt1 Omcfsm ngi iftysj}fi {fj{oft ompft1 Omcfsm `jsbfi g``migpmyt ml Cfsbt
ogrtvmyt1 Omcfsm {fsevsfi nfs yftymhjl}1 Omcfsm tvcjslfi {fsevs}1 Omcfsm `jsbfi
tvc{jflgt ml Ygmyut lghf1 Omcfsm djhhmyyfi Tjdmgo Tfdvsmy} `sgvi1 Omcfsm
djhhmyyfi Mlyfslgo Sfpflvf @sgvi .yg~ `sgvi-1 Omcfsm ygh{fsfi rmyn Ygmyu gli nfs
nvtcglit dgs1 Omcfsm ngt gddftt yj ynmsi {gsymft dsfimy dgsit1 Omcfsm djhhmyyfi
`sgvi1 Omcfsm mt ml pmjogymjl j` nfs {sjcgymjl1 Omcfsm lffit yj cf cgda ml {smtjl1
Jtyfoog ngdafi Ygmyut rfctmyf gli [g}[go1 Jtyfoog tyjof hjlmft `sjh Ygmyu1
Jtyfoog nmegdafi Ygmyu cojb1 Jtyfoog `jsbfi Ygmyut lghf jl tvc{jflgt1 Jtyfoog mt
g ynmf`1 Jtyfoog ngt g dsmhmlgo sfdjsi1 Cfsb mt fh{oj}mlb g djlpmdyfi ijdvhfly
`jsbfs1 Cfsb mt tyfgomlb {fj{oft hjlf}1 Cfsb lffit yj cf imtcgssfi1 Cfsb/ Omcfsm
gli Jtyfoog gsf ngsgttmlb Ygmyu1 Cfsb/ Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog gsf if`ghmlb Ygmyu1 Omcfsm
`mofi djh{ogmlyt gbgmlty Ygmyu rmyn ynf Dgom`jslmg Tygyf Cgs/ fliglbfsmlb nfs
omdfltf1 Omcfs rgt djlpmdyfi j` miflymy} ynf`y/ j` `jsbmlb gli goyfsmlb {jomdf sf{jsyt
gli dsfimy sf{jsyt1 Omcfsmt nvtcgli rgt jl {gsjof1 Jtyfoogt nvtcgli rgt
cflf`mymlb `sjh ynf hjlmft Jtyfoog tyjof `sjh IJ@@/ g ljl{sj`my djs{jsgymjl1
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 90 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
47/77
44
Omcfsm tvhhjlfi jynfst yj `mof `gotf djh{ogmlyt gbgmlty Ygmyu rmyn ynf Tygyf Cgs1
gli hgl} jynfs `gotf goofbgymjlt, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ hgif ynftf
tygyfhflyt gt `gdy/ ljy j{mlmjl gli {vcomtnfi goo ynftf tygyfhflyt sf{fgyfio} goo
jpfs ynf Mlyfslfy/ tfly ynfh c} hgtt Fhgmomlb sf{fgyfio}/ mldovimlb mlyfslgymjlgo/
hgif ynf `gotf tygyfhflyt jl sgimj {sjbsght/ YP {sjbsght/ ]jvYvcf pmifjt/ tfly
ynfh yj ogr fl`jsdfhfly/ tfly ynfh yj cvtmlftt gttjdmgyft j` ynf G{{foofft(
[ogmlym``t/ tfly ynfh yj Bjpfslhfly gbfldmft/ fyd, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 733(732/ 73=/
747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(
439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(
790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(
7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ gotj jcygmlfi/ c} moofbgo hfglt/ g `ghmo} {mdyvsf
j` Omcfsm/ nfs nvtcgli gli tjl/ yngy rgt jlo} ojdgyfi jl Omcfsmt djh{vyfs, Ygmyu
c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ {vcomtnfi Omcfsmt `ghmo} {mdyvsf rmyn Omcfsmt njhf
giisftt goo jpfs nfs rfctmyf gy rrr,jso}ygmyuftw,djh/
rrr,jso}ygmyuftw,djh*cojb7/ rrr,sf{vc~,djh/ gli jl ynmsi {gsy} rfctmyft gli
cojbt1 tfly my c} hgtt Fhgmomlb yj hmoomjlt j` mlimpmivgot gli djh{glmft/ mldovimlb
gshfi hmomymg bsjv{t/ gli jynfs iglbfsjvt bsjv{t1 ynsjvbn STT `ffit/ Tjdmgo
Lfyrjsat/ goo j` rnmdn rgt ijlf sf{fgyfio} rmyn Ygmyu tygyfhflyt yngy Omcfsm/
Jtyfoog gli Cfsb rfsf jcjyt .[sftmifly Jcghg Tv{{jsyfst-/ sfi nfssmlbt gli yngy
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 92 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
48/77
49
Omcfsm/ Cfsb gli Jtyfoog lffifi yj cf {jomymdgoo} {vsbfi, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn
IJ@@ dgoofi `js ynfms tv{{jsyfst yj gttmty ynfh tygymlb G{{foofft([ogmlym``t hvty
cf bjyyfl smi j`1 Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ gsjvtfi ynf fhjymjlt j` ynfms
tv{{jsyfst/ rnmdn mlpjopfi hgl} rnj ngi cffl djlpmdyfi j` iglbfsjvt dsmhft/
flsgbmlb ynfh gbgmlty Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb `js ynfh yj ngsh Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog
gli Cfsb, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ ynsfgyflfi yj ngpf Jtyfoogt dnmoisfl
{sj`fttmjlgoo} amilg{{fi/ ynsfgyflfi yj bfy smi j` Cfsb gli Omcfsm gli tygyfi jl
sgimj g{{fgsgldft yngy tnf .Ygmyu- {sjpmifi {mdyvsft j` Omcfsm gli imsfdymjlt, Ygmyu
gotj {vcomtnfi gcjvy Omcfsmt nfgsy djlimymjlt gli jynfs tfsmjvt hfimdgo
djlimymjlt/ aljrmlb yngy djlymlvfi ngsgtthfly j` Omcfsm djvoi gli rjvoi
voymhgyfo} fli Omcfsmt om`f, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 733(732/ 73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(
792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/
QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21
Pjo, MM/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(
77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ dgoofi ml goo j` nfs tv{{jsyfst yj bj yj ynf {ogdft
Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog sftmifi/ `mof `gotf ogr fl`jsdfhfly sf{jsyt gbgmlty Omcfsm gli
Jtyfoog/ dgoo {sjcgymjl if{gsyhflyt gli hgaf `gotf sf{jsyt/ `mof `gotf sf{jsyt rmyn
ynf Gyyjslf} Bflfsgo j` Lfr Hf~mdj gbgmlty Omcfsm/ ogr fl`jsdfhfly gbfldmft
rnfsf Jtyfoog sftmifi/ yngy Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog lffifi yj cf gssftyfi gli egmofi,
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 9> j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
49/77
46
Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog rfsf sfdfmpmlb ifgyn ynsfgyt `sjh Ygmyu tv{{jsyfst/ gli g tysglbf
hgl g{{fgsfi gy Omcfsmt njhf cf`jsf >5;; g,h,/ Omcfsmt {njlft rfsf
tdsghcofi/ ynf hgl rgt ojjamlb gli {ffsmlb ml Omcfsmt njhf rmlijrt/ fyd,
Ygmyu rgt fpfl sf{jsymlb jl {ogdft Omcfsmt tjl ngi cffl/ ysm{t nf ngi ygafl/ fyd,
QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 733(732/ 73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/
300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/
32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo,
4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/
7343(734>X,
[vcomdgymjlt goofbfi yj djltymyvyf mlpgtmjlt j` {smpgd} hfsmy ynf tghf
djltymyvymjlgo {sjyfdymjlt gt ij {vcomdgymjlt goofbfi yj cf if`ghgyjs}, Ynf @msty
Ghflihfly j` ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft Djltymyvymjl ijft ljy{sjyfdy mlpgimlb g {smpgyf
mlimpmivgot {smpgd}/ js {vcomdgymjl j` ml`jshgymjl {fsygmlmlb yj g {smpgyf
mlimpmivgo rnmdn mt ljy lfrt rjsyn}, Dglysfoo p, @jsfty Dmy} [vcomtnmlb Dj,/ 97=
V,T, 396/ =6 T,Dy, 906/ 93 O,Fi,3i 97= .7=29-, @gotf goofbgymjlt/ gddvtgymjlt gli
sf{jsymlb j` ynf `gotf ml`jshgymjl gsf ljy @sff T{ffdn {sjyfdyfi c} ynf @msty
Ghflihfly yj ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft Djltymyvymjl, Tff Cfgvngslgmt p, Moomljmt/ 494
V,T, 36;/ 23 T, Dy, 236/ =0 O, Fi, =7= .7=63- QFS/ Pjo, M/ {, 739X, Ynfsf mt
gctjovyfo} lj wvftymjl yngy Ygmyut `gotf goofbgymjlt rfsf ijlf rmyn hgomdf, Ynf
sf{fgyfi {vcomdgymjl gli {vcomdmumlb j` Ygmyu `gotf tygyfhflyt/ gli ml`jshgymjl
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 9= j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
50/77
40
{fsygmlmlb yj Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb fpmifldft hgomdf, Tff @mtnfs p, Ogstfl/
.7=>3- 74> Dgo, G{{, 4i 032/ 09; Q7>> Dgo, S{ys, 370X1 Sgldnj Og Djtyg/ Mld, p,
Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .7=>;- 7;0 Dgo, G{{, 4i 090/ 002 Q706 Dgo, S{ys, 492X/ Fpglt p,
Vlajr/ .7==6- 4> Dgo, G{{, 9yn 79=; Q96 Dgo,S{ys,3i 039X wvjymlb @mtnfs p,
Ogstfl/ .7=>3- 74> Dgo,G{{,4i 032/ 09;/ Q7>> Dgo, S{ys, 370X1 gli Sfgifs"t
Imbfty Gttl, p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .7=>9- 42 Dgo,4i 399/ 36>/ Q3;> Dgo, S{ys, 742/
0=; [,3i 07;X QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 734X/ QTFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 2=(>;X,
Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog gsf ljy {vcomd mlimpmivgot/ ynvt ynf hgomdf tygligsi
ijft ljy g{{o} QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 733X, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@t {vcomdgymjl j`
Jtyfoog gli Omcfsmt {smpgyf igyg/ gt rfoo gt goo ynf `gotf tygyfhflyt/ goofbgymjlt/
gttfsymjlt/ `gotf sf{jsyt/ ngsgtthfly/ fyd, gsf ljy {sjyfdyfi vlifs ynf @msty
Ghflihfly j` ynf V,T, Djltymyvymjl js Dgom`jslmgt Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf, Tff Lfr
]jsa Ymhft p, Tvoompgl/ 420 V,T, 369/ >9 T, Dy, 27;/ 77 O, Fi, 3i 0>0 .7=09-, Tff
gotj Ivll & Csgitysffy/ Mld, p, Bsfflhjtt Cvmoifst/ .7=>6- 923 V,T, 29=/ 203
.{ovs, j{l, j` [jrfoo/ E,- Qtygymlb yngy rnfl t{ffdn #djldfslt lj {vcomd mttvf# gli
mt #rnjoo} `gotf gli dofgso} ighgbmlb/# my #rgssglyt lj t{fdmgo {sjyfdymjl# vlifs
ynf @msty GhflihflyX, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 734(736X,
My mt tfyyofi ml Dgom`jslmg yngy ljy goo t{ffdn js {fymymjl gdympmy} mt
djltymyvymjlgoo} {sjyfdyfi, Tff @ogyof} p, Hgvsj/ .3;;0- 4= Dgo, 9yn 3==/ 4741
Gbvmogs p, Gpmt Sfly G Dgs T}tyfh/ Mld,/ tv{sg/ .7===- 37 Dgo,9yn 737 Q>2
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 6; j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
51/77
42
Dgo,S{ys,3i 7431 =>; [,3i >90 gy {, 749X Qynf smbny yj `sff t{ffdn mt ljy
gctjovyfX, Jvs Dgom`jslmg Djvsyt ngpf tygyfi/ Goojrmlb tgldymjlt mt djltmtyfly
rmyn ynf yf~y j` ynf tygyf djltymyvymjlgo {sjpmtmjl/ rnmdn hgaft gl}jlf rnj
#gcvtfQtX# ynf smbny j` `sffijh j` t{ffdn #sft{jltmcof# `js ynf hmtdjlivdy, .Dgo,
Djlty,/ gsy, M/ 3/ tvci, .g-1 Tff Csjrl p, Afoo} Csjgidgtymlb Dj,/ .7=>=- 9>
Dgo,4i 277/ 290 QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 734(736X,
Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog gsf ljy{vcomd `mbvsft/ ynf} gsf ljy ml ynf {vcomd f}f gli
ynfms ompft gsf ljy lfrtrjsyn} gli ljynmlb ml Jtyfoog gli Omcfsmt ompft gsf g
{vcomd mttvf, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 739X, Ygmyu gli IJ@@ dogmh yngy Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog
rjsafi jl dgtft yngy rfsf j` {vcomd mh{jsygldf, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {, 704X, G {smpgyf
mlimpmivgo mt ljy gvyjhgymdgoo} ysglt`jshfi mlyj g {vcomd `mbvsf evty c} cfdjhmlb
mlpjopfi ml js gttjdmgyfi rmyn g hgyyfs yngy gyysgdyt {vcomd gyyflymjl, Rjotyjl p,
Sfgifs"t Imbfty Gttl/ Mld,/ .7=2=- 994 V,T, 762/ 702/ == T,Dy, 32;7/ 32;2/ 07
O,Fi,3i 96;,
Ynf Glym(TOG[[ tygyvyf/ Dgo, Dmp, Djif 936,70 ijft ljy g{{o} yj Omcfsm/
Jtyfoog gli Cfsbt ogrtvmy gbgmlty Ygmyu/ IJ@@ gli*js ynf jynfs If`fliglyt,
F, YNF GLYM(TOG[[ TYGYVYF DGO, DMP, DJIF 936,705
Ml ifdmimlb gl Glym(TOG[[ G{{fgo/ ynf Lmlyn Dmsdvmy fh{oj}t g yrj(tyf{
{sjdftt `js ifyfshmlmlb ynf dgtf, Pgsmgl Hfimdgo T}tyfht/ Mld, p, Ifo`mlj .3;;6-
46 Dgo,9yn 7>;/ 7=3 mt moovtysgympf5 #@msty/ ynf djvsy hvty ifyfshmlf "rnfynfs ynf
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 67 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
52/77
4>
if`fligly ngt hgif g ynsftnjoi tnjrmlb yngy ynf dngooflbfi dgvtf j` gdymjl" gsmtft
`sjh gl gdy ml `vsynfsgldf j` ynf smbny j` {fymymjl js `sff t{ffdn ml djllfdymjl rmyn
g {vcomd mttvf, QDmygymjl,X Tfdjli/ ynf djvsy hvty "ifyfshmlf rnfynfs ynf {ogmlym``
ngt ifhjltysgyfi g {sjcgcmomy} j` {sfpgmomlb jl ynf dogmh,"# QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 737(
73>X,
Ml jsifs yj {sfpgmo jl gl Glym(TOG[[ hjymjl/ ynf If`fligly mt sfwvmsfi yj
hgaf g {smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb yngy ynf [ogmlym``t tvmy gsmtft `sjh gl gdy c} ynf
If`fligly hgif ml djllfdymjl rmyn g {vcomd mttvf ml `vsynfsgldf j` ynf
If`fliglyt smbny yj `sff t{ffdn vlifs ynf Vlmyfi Tygyft js Dgom`jslmg Djltymyvymjl,
Tff Vlmyfi Tygyft f~ sfo, Lfrtngh p, Ojdanffi Hmttmoft & T{gdf Dj,/ 7=; @,4i
=04/ =27 .=yn Dms, 7===-1 Tff gotj 936,70.f- .if`mlmlb gdy ml `vsynfsgldf j` g
{fstjlt smbny j` , , , `sff t{ffdn,-, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 737(73>X,
Ygmyu gli IJ@@ ml ynfms GJCt ngpf giifi lfr tyjsmft gli if`fltft gli
ljr dogmh ynfms t{ffdn gcjvy Cfsb/ Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog rgt {jomymdgo t{ffdn/ rnmdn
my rgt ljy, Ynf t{ffdn ml wvftymjl/ gt jvyomlfi gcjpf/ rgt ynf sf{fgyfi {vcomdgymjl
j` Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsbt {smpgyf igyg1 gli `gotf gttfsymjlt/ tyjsmft/ gli
goofbgymjlt yngy rfsf {gyflyo} `gotf/ yngy ngi ljynmlb yj ij rmyn gl} y}{f j` {vcomd
js {jomymdgo mttvf, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@t {vcomdgymjlt gcjvy Cfsb/ Omcfsm
gli Jtyfoog rfsf pmdmjvt gyygdat gmhfi gy bfyymlb Omcfsm gli Jtyfoog gssftyfi cgtfi
jl ynf `gotf goofbgymjlt/ gli yj fldjvsgbf Ygmyu gli IJ@@t tv{{jsyfst yj ngsh ynf
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 63 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
53/77
4=
G{{foofft([ogmlym``t, FS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 733(732/ 73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/
76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS
Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/
{{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631
Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X, Ynvt/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ djvoi ljy jpfs(djhf ynf
`msty tyf{ ml ynf Glym(TOG[[ glgo}tmt, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;2(769X,
Ynf cvsifl ynfl tnm`yt yj ynf [ogmlym``t yj ftygcomtn g sfgtjlgcof {sjcgcmomy}
yngy ynf [ogmlym``t rmoo {sfpgmo jl ynfms dogmht, Tff Ojdanffi/ 7=; @,4i gy =27,
QYXnf {ogmlym`` hvty ifhjltysgyf yngy ynf djh{ogmly mt ofbgoo} tv``mdmfly gli
tv{{jsyfi c} g {smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb j` `gdyt yj tvtygml g `gpjsgcof evibhfly m` ynf
fpmifldf tvchmyyfi c} {ogmlym`` mt QtmdX dsfimyfi,
Yj tvspmpf g Hjymjl yj Tysmaf {vstvgly yj Dgom`jslmgt Glym(TOG[[ ogr/
G{{foofft([ogmlym``t hvty ifhjltysgyf g {sjcgcmomy} yngy ynf} rmoo {sfpgmo jl ynf
hfsmyt j` ynfms djh{ogmly, Dgo, Dmp, [sjd, Djif 936,70, Ynf Imtysmdy djvsy nfoi
yngy G{{foofft([ogmlym``t ngi hgif tvdn g tnjrmlb, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, >/ 733(732/
73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/
434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/
777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61Pjo, 9/ {{,
>>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X, Yj ftygcomtn ynf
Rmodj~ p, Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ 44 Dgo, S{ys, 3i 990/ 969- .7==9-, QFS/ Pjo, M/ {, 737X,
Hfygcjom`f/ 309 @,4i gy >9;/
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 64 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
54/77
9;
sfwvmtmyf {sjcgcmomy} j` {sfpgmomlb jl ynfms dogmht . 936,70/ tvci, .c-.7--/ Omcfsm/
Jtyfoog gli Cfsb ngi yj ifhjltysgyf ynfms Djh{ogmly rgt .7- ofbgoo} tv``mdmfly gli
.3- tv{{jsyfi c} g tv``mdmfly {smhg `gdmf tnjrmlb j` `gdyt yj tvtygml g `gpjsgcof
evibhfly m` ynf fpmifldf ynf} tvchmyyfi mt dsfimyfi, . Lgpfoomfs p, Tofyyfl/ tv{sg
.3;;3- 3= Dgo,9yn >3 gy {{, >>(>=1 Csmbbt p, Fifl Djvldmo `js Nj{f &
732/ 73=/ 747(742/ 794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(
437/ 434(439/ 430(432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(
=7/ 777(790/ 792(76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/
{{, >>2(7;>7/ 77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
Rfmlcfsb p, @fmtfo/ 3 Dgo, S{ys, 4i 4>6/ 4=3 .Dy, G{{, 3;;4-/ g dgtf `sjh ynf
Ynmsi Imtysmdy/ gsymdvogyfi g yfty/ iftmblfi yj imtymlbvmtn cfyrffl mttvft j` {vcomd/
sgynfs yngl hfsfo} {smpgyf/ mlyfsfty,, Ynf RfmlcfsbDjvsy/ 3 Dgo, S{ys, 4i gy 4=3(
4=4 nfoi5
@msty/ {vcomd mlyfsfty ijft ljy fwvgyf rmyn hfsf dvsmjtmy}, Tfdjli/ ghgyyfs j` {vcomd mlyfsfty tnjvoi cf tjhfynmlb j` djldfsl yj gtvctyglymgo lvhcfs j` {fj{of, Ynvt/ g hgyyfs j` djldfsl yj ynf t{fgafs
gli g sfogympfo} thgoo/ t{fdm`md gvimfldf mt ljy g hgyyfs j` {vcomdmlyfsfty, Ynmsi/ ynfsf tnjvoi cf tjhf ifbsff j` dojtflftt cfyrffl ynfdngooflbfi tygyfhflyt gli ynf gttfsyfi {vcomd mlyfsfty1 ynf gttfsymjl j`g csjgi gli ghjs{njvt {vcomd mlyfsfty mt ljy tv``mdmfly, @jvsyn/ ynf`jdvt j` ynf t{fgafst djlivdy tnjvoi cf ynf {vcomd mlyfsfty sgynfs ynglg hfsf f``jsy yj bgynfs ghhvlmymjl `js gljynfs sjvli j` {smpgyfdjlysjpfst}, @mlgoo} , , , QgX {fstjl dglljy yvsl jynfsrmtf {smpgyf
J{{jsyvlmy}/ .7===- 7= Dgo,9yn 77;0/ 77341 Iv[jly Hfsda [ngshgdfvymdgo Dj, p,
Tv{fsmjs Djvsy/ .3;;3-/ 2> Dgo,G{{,9yn 603/ 60>,-, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;2(769/ 733(
Dgtf5 77(60;2= ;4*7=*3;73 MI5 >7;2=>2 IayFlys}5 47 [gbf5 69 j` 22
8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al Consolidated Appellees Brief Dock 31
55/77
97
ml`jshgymjl mlyj g hgyyfs j` {vcomd mlyfsfty tmh{o} c} djhhvlmdgymlbmy yj g ogsbf lvhcfs j` {fj{of,
Mi, gy 4=3(=4 .mlyfslgo wvjygymjl hgsat/ dmygymjlt/ gli goyfsgymjl jhmyyfi-,
Ml ynmt dgtf/ Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ hgif {gyflyo} `gotf gddvtgymjlt/
tygyfhflyt gli goofbgymjlt gbgmlty Omcfsm/ Jtyfoog gli Cfsb gt jvyomlfi
nfsfmlgcjpf, Ygmyu c} gli ynsjvbn IJ@@ gotj {vcomtnfi goo ynf {smpgyf igyg j`
G{{foofft([ogmlym``t sf{fgyfio}, QFS/ Pjo, 7/ {{, 7;2(769/ 733(732/ 73=/ 747(742/
794(799/ 790(792/ 76;(767/ 764/ 309/ 300(32>/ 477(476/ 43;(437/ 434(439/ 430(
432/ 43=(44;X/ QTFS Pjo,t 7/ {{, 36/ 32(3>/ 47(43/ 49(>0/ =;(=7/ 777(790/ 792(
76=/ 36;(3=21 Pjo, 3/ {{, 3=>(6=;1 Pjo, 4/ {{, 6=7(>>61 Pjo, 9/ {{, >>2(7;>7/
77;;(77;9/ 777=(77631 Pjo, 6/ {{, 7376/ 7343(734>X,
@, G[[FOOFFT([OGMLYM@@T JSMBMLGO DJH[OGMLY
G{{foofft([ogmlym``t jsmbmlgoo} `mofi tvmy jl Hg} 9/ 3;;= ml [fllt}opglmg,
Jldf ynf dgtf rgt ysglt`fssfi yj Dgom`jslmg/ Ygmyu gli IJ@@ `mofi ynfms tfdjli
Glym(TOG[[ Hjymjl, [ogmlym``t gihmyyfi ynf} lffifi yj ghfli ynfms djh{ogmly/
rnmdn ynf Im
Top Related