Layoffs, downsizing and restructuring
by Toronto Training and HR
January 2011
Page 2
Contents3-4 Introduction to Toronto
Training and HR5-6 Definitions7-8 Implications of poor termination
practices9-20 Meeting details21-23 After the meeting24-25 Termination letters26-30 Downsizing31-36 Outplacement37-39 Separation and severance policies40-42 Career motivation43-44 Tackling survivor syndrome45-46 Layoffs in the US47-48 Avoiding pitfalls49-52 Case studies53-54 Conclusion and questions
Page 3
Introduction
Page 4
Introduction to Toronto Training and HR
• Toronto Training and HR is a specialist training and human resources consultancy headed by Timothy Holden
• 10 years in banking• 10 years in training and human resources• Freelance practitioner since 2006• The core services provided by Toronto Training and HR
are:- Training course design- Training course delivery- Reducing costs- Saving time- Improving employee engagement &
morale- Services for job seekers
Page 5
Definitions
Page 6
DefinitionsLAYOFFSDOWNSIZING
Page 7
Implications of poor termination practices
Page 8
Implications of poor termination practices
INCREASEDlegal compliance issues and litigation (time and $ saved)likelihood of sign-off on termination package (time and $ saved)NEGATIVE IMPACT ONcorporate brand (maintain $ revenue and $ saved)remaining employees (maintain $ productivity/employee)
Page 9
Meeting details
Page 10
Meeting details 1 of 11
LOCATIONConfidential room on-siteAway from employee’s work areaAway from manager’s officeAdditional or dual exit access
Page 11
Meeting details 2 of 11
TIMEEarlier in the week is ideal (Tues/Wed)Earlier in the day is idealAvoid employee birthday or anniversary dateAvoid significant holidays
Page 12
Meeting details 3 of 11
ATTENDEESDirect manager should deliver the messageHR or another manager to support the process is idealLeverage skills and experience of outplacement specialistsDefine roles and scripts ahead of time
Page 13
Meeting details 4 of 11
OTHER CONSIDERATIONSWill security be an issue?Will medical conditions create a risk?Create a termination checklist for network and software access, laptops, cell phones, pass codes, voicemail, etc.
Page 14
Meeting details 5 of 11
POSITIONING STATEMENTBe honest – don’t set up the meeting under false pretences“George, I’d like to have a conversation with you about your performance. Can you come see me in the ABC room?”Do not schedule meeting too far in advance
Page 15
Meeting details 6 of 11
DELIVERING THE MESSAGEGet right to the pointReinforce decision is final – do not negotiateBe brief, but respectful – 2 to 3 minutesKeep the discussion in business termsMove the conversation along to a discussion of next steps –this will take longer
Page 16
Meeting details 7 of 11
REACTIONS TO PREPARE FOR-SHOCK AND DENIALAllow them time to reactRepeat the message if necessaryProbe gently to ensure they understand the message
Page 17
Meeting details 8 of 11REACTIONS TO PREPARE FOR-ANGER AND HOSTILITYRemain calm, keep it businessDo not argue, debate or take sidesAcknowledge their anger but bring discussion back to next steps“You can schedule a time to discuss it at a later date withxxx/me. However, my purpose today is simply tocommunicate the decision, provide the package and introduce your career transition expert”
Page 18
Meeting details 9 of 11
REACTIONS TO PREPARE FOR-NEGOTIATIONAcknowledge their suggestionReinforce alternatives were considered but decision is final
Page 19
Meeting details 10 of 11
REACTIONS TO PREPARE FOR-RELIEF AND ACCEPTANCEProbe gently to ensure they understand the messageReinforce next stepsInform outplacement expert and HR of “controlled” reaction
Page 20
Meeting details 11 of 11
BEST PRACTICENever mention names of others affected or remainingEscort the employee out of the building – they can connect with co-workers and clean up desk at a later date (if applicable)Ensure the employee is capable of returning home – assess and offer alternatives if necessary – leverage outplacement expert
Page 21
After the meeting
Page 22
After the meeting 1 of 2
DELIVER THE MESSAGE TO THE SURVIVORSThey may go through similar emotionsReinforce decision and support employee(s) is receivingOutline how work will be allocated/replacedOutline how calls/emails/clients will be managedReinforce the importance of their jobs
Page 23
After the meeting 2 of 2
BEST PRACTICE-BE VISIBLE AND ACCESSIBLEDemonstrate objectivity and empathyUtilize change management resources – HR, Employee Assistance Programs, team meetingsHave more senior or other managers “check-in” with remaining employees
Page 24
Termination letters
Page 25
Termination letters
Should be clear, concise, direct and cover the important detailsRecognition of service and contributions can be added if applicableNot required to include details/evidence of performance issues or steps taken unless for causeCreate a separate financial package
Page 26
Downsizing
Page 27
Downsizing 1 of 4
EFFECTS OF DOWNSIZING Job securityJob satisfactionOrganizational justiceOrganizational commitmentUnion commitment
Page 28
Downsizing 2 of 4REDUCING THE IMPACT OF DOWNSIZING Do it once – identify a group if necessary and get it over with.Handle the situation with sensitivity. Have a package ready - provide employees with information regarding their benefits, eligibility for unemployment insurance, any severance payments or other information you think they will need - before they leave the meeting.Communicate – communicate – communicate.
Page 29
Downsizing 3 of 4REDUCING THE IMPACT OF DOWNSIZING Prepare managers with information and a communication strategy for their role with their teams.If at all possible, offer an outplacement service to the employees being let go…this will buy you tremendous good will with them and the employees who stay. In the end you are left with those upon whom you will rely to work harder and smarter. Make sure they are your key contributors and that you work hard to keep their trust. Let them know you appreciate their hard work and communicate, communicate, communicate!
Page 30
Downsizing 4 of 4NEGATIVE IMPACTS Decreased morale Reduced loyalty Productivity/Quality Loss Damage to brand Turnover Absenteeism Lawsuits Negative image Stock price decrease Loss of customers
Page 31
Outplacement
Page 32
Outplacement 1 of 5FACE TO FACEOne-on-one sessionsGroup sessionsPersonality and career assessments Specialized webinars, workshops and networking sessions Personal finance consultation Personal image guidanceInterview coachingGuidance on approaching organizations speculativelySmall business optionsEducation, retraining and retirement options
Page 33
Outplacement 2 of 5
NON FACE TO FACEDiscounts on a number of training & development courses Business cards
Page 34
Outplacement 3 of 5
ONLINECreation of a customized resumeCreation of a customized cover letterCreation or revision of social media profilesGuidance on contributing to blogs and forumsDatabase of contactsAccess to a computerized career transition tool
Page 35
Outplacement 4 of 5
RECENT TRENDSKey decision criteria for choosing an outplacement providerWhich employees receive outplacement support, including global differences Factors considered when determining outplacement support Which employees get what level of support, including global differences
Page 36
Outplacement 5 of 5RECENT TRENDSThe most important components of an outplacement program, including opinions of those in transition Circumstances in which outplacement support is increasedThe most important indicator of a successful outplacement partner The most important indicator of a successful downsizing Perceived differences of opinion from those inside and outside of HR
Page 37
Separation and severance policies
Page 38
Separation and severance policies 1 of 2
THINGS TO BEAR IN MINDConsideration of employees Compliance Protecting morale and commitment Corporate values Avoiding lawsuits Protecting brand Budget Return on investment
Page 39
Separation and severance policies 2 of 2
TRENDS IN SEVERANCE POLICIESWhich employees receive severance payHow severance formulae are determinedWhich employees get what level of severance, including global differencesMinimum and maximum caps for severance pay-outs, including global differencesPay-out methods, including global differencesCircumstances in which severance amounts are increased, including global differencesOther benefits provided after separation
Page 40
Career motivation
Page 41
Career motivation 1 of 2
COMPONENTSCareer resilienceCareer insightCareer identity
Page 42
Career motivation 2 of 2
SURVIVORS OF LAYOFFSIdentification with layoff victimsPerceived justice of the layoffPerceived planningContinuance commitmentTrust in managementJob insecurityAffective commitmentNegative mood
Page 43
Tackling survivor syndrome
Page 44
Tackling survivor syndrome
MASS LAYOFF STATISTICS PROGRAM1421 mass lay-off actions in the last month (50 or more employees) involving 130000 workersNational unemployment rate 8.9%Industries with the largest number of mass layoff initial claims
Page 45
Lay-offs in the US
Page 46
Lay-offs in the US
MASS LAYOFF STATISTICS PROGRAM1421 mass lay-off actions in the last month (50 or more employees) involving 130000 workersNational unemployment rate 8.9%Industries with the largest number of mass layoff initial claims
Page 47
Avoiding pitfalls
Page 48
Avoiding pitfallsDefining the pool for lay-offs incorrectlyNot offering suitable alternative employmentAbsence of a genuine lay-off situationFailure to carry out a fair selection procedureFailure to consult properly on collective lay-offsFailure to inform and consult on an individual basisFailing to consider alternatives to lay-offsNot training managers on how to carry out the exerciseNot accounting for the extra costs and resources involvedFailing to account for the wider effects of the lay-offs exercise
Page 49
Case study A
Page 50
Case study A
Page 51
Case study B
Page 52
Case study B
Page 53
Conclusion & Questions
Page 54
Conclusion
SummaryQuestions
Top Related