8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
1/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 1
Introduction to Paper Industry
The use of paper by a society is often taken as a yardstick of its development. The need for
documentation of knowledge and record keeping has long been perceived to be linked to the
intellectual prowess of a nation. The tradition of use of bhoj patra or the bark of the
Bhoj Tree for documentation of our scriptures is acknowledged the world over Such
recording pre-dates most of the earliest known documentation on paper like substances. As
time progressed, the need for cheaper means of documentation of records was felt by
civilizations. It was here that the Chinese made their first attempt to manufacture paper from
plant resources. Historians believe that it was the Moghals, who introduced the traditional
paper makers - the kagzis- in the country as they expanded their empire in India. It was in
1832 that the first modern paper mill was set up in Sreerampur, West Bengal, using themechanized process for paper making developed in the western world. Thus the journey of
machine made paper in India has seen over a century and a half pass by.
Unlike the West, however, India had very little soft wood for the manufacture of paper. Since
machines were designed to process soft wood, there was a problem in using them for harder
indigenous raw materials. In the year 1914, a process was developed to use bamboo for paper
making. This provided the required impetus to the paper making operations in the country.
Figure 1 shows some of the major events that shaped the fortunes of the paper industry in its
journey from a single unit in 1832, to the present day scenario.
After independence the country faced a major challenge of marshalling all the available
resources to lay down the foundations of an industrialized India. Consequently, most
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
2/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 2
manufacturing was placed under government control through an elaborately administered
license regimen. Under this regimen the paper industry grew rather slowly over the next three
decades. However, the paper "famine" of 1970 changed the working environment of the
paper sector, and a number of licenses were given to smaller units for manufacture of paper.These units used agricultural residues and waste paper as the raw material base, and eased the
paper scarcity in the country. However, this also created a fractured structure in the industry,
where small, medium as well as large mills came in to co-existence.
India began its program of economic reform in 1991. One by one, the industrial sectors were
freed from an administered license regimen. In July, 1991, the government decided to deli
censes the paper industry. This acted as an incentive for the growth of the industry (Fig. 2).
Today, there are 759 Pulp & Paper mills with an installed capacity of 12.7 million tons
producing around 10.11 million tons/annum of paper/paper board and newsprint out of an
annual consumption of around 11.15 million tons.
The steady growth rate shown in the figure above tells a satisfying growth story for the Indian
paper industry.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
3/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 3
Porter's Five Forces analysis of Indian Paper Industry
Michael Porters model identifies the most powerful driving forces within industriesand the
interactions between them to determine the competitive position and profit potential. The five
driving forces are;
Threat of new entrants
Bargaining power of suppliers
Bargaining power of buyers
Threat of substitute products or services
Rivalry among existing competitors
Porters five forces indicating the competitive intensity and attractiveness of the market for
the Indian Paper Industry are shown in Fig. The analyses of these forces indicate that industry
is operating under various positive and negative forces which have a mixed effect on its
competitiveness. Competition among the mills is low due to large number of grades being
manufactured. High switching cost among the products also makes the industry rivalry less
intense; however the difficulties to exit from the business due to high capital cost increases
the chances of the rivalry among the producers of similar grades. The threat from new
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
4/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 4
entrants is low on account of high capital cost, low return on investment and scarcity of raw
materials for paper making.
Bargaining power of suppliers of raw materials i.e. wood, straws, biogases, waste paper,
energy (coal etc.) and modern technology is high which a deterrent for growth of the industry
is. A positive factor for growth & competition among the industry is the forecasted increase
in consumption of paper with growing per capita income, literacy rate and living standards.
However increase in imports of duty free newsprint and diversified customer requirement are
the negative factors for the industry. Apart from these, Industry is also facing tough
competition from electronic media, wide spread use of internet, computerization, ebooks and
imported printed books. The industry is thus operating under various constraints and high
risks, as mentioned above. Therefore it requires support from Government, in terms of policy
interventions for its sustenance.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
5/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 5
JK Paper Limited
Headquarter:New Delhi
Works: JK Paper Mills (Rayagada, Orissa); Central Pulp Mills (Songadh, Gujarat)
Branch Location:NewDelhi, Kolkata, Mumbai, Chennai
No. of Employees: Close to 3000 employees
Management
Name Designation
Arun Bharat Ram Director
Dhirendra Kumar Director
Hari Shankar Singhania Chairman & Managing Director
Harsh Pati Singhania CEO
Harsh Pati Singhania Managing Director
M H Dalmia Director
Om Prakash Goyal Whole Time Director
R V Kanoria Director
S K Pathak Director
Shailesh Haribhakti Director
Suresh Chander Gupta Company Secretary & Compliance Officer
Suresh Chander Gupta Secretary
Udayan Bose Director
Vinita Singhania Director
Wim Wienk Director
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
6/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 6
New Technologies Adopted since 2008
Trials for usage of WGCC / PCC as fillers in JK Branded products were undertaken, for
improving the printing properties of paper and also the aesthetic look.
Product Launches since 2008
Branded Copier Cedar
Packaging BoardJK Endura, JK IV Board, JK Pristine Cote
Stationery Note Pal (notebook), JK Printblank (plotter roll)
Steps taken towards better Environment & Society
The savings envisaged equal the average annual water consumption of 75,000 Indian
households and energy use of 9,100 families.
Installed lime sludge recycling plants at both factories.
25 Women Self-Help Groups have been formed in 12 adopted villages with a membership of
294 rural Women, mostly belonging to Tribal Community. As a part of Health Education, 29
Balika Mandals with 466 adolescent girls were formed for sensitizing the target audience on
basics of health care.
To intensify the efforts on the Community Development front and thereby to create a better
quality of life to the people of the society in the vicinity, the company has formed a new
NGO named SPARSH.
Financials (2009-10)
Turnovers 1300 crores Net Profit: Rs91crores Growth Rate: 10%
Future Plans
Planning the installation of a new paper machine of 150,000 TPAand pulp mill of 200,000
TPAalong with utilities
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
7/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 7
Classification of Ratio
Classificationof Ratio
Solvency
Short term
1.Current ratio
2. Liquidity ratio
3. Cash position ratio
4. Stock ratio
5.Debtors velocity
6. Creditors velocity
Long term1. Proprietary ratio
2. Debt equity ratio
3. Leverage ratio
4. Security ratio
5. Interest coverage ratio
Profitability
1. Gross profit ratio
2. Net profit ratio
3. Expenses ratio
4. Operating profit ratio
5. Return on capital
employed ratio
Activity
1. Capital turnover
2. Creditor turnover
3. Debtors turnover
4. Cash turnover
5. Stock turnover
Earnings
1. Dividend ratio
2. Earning per share
3. Price earning ratio
4. Pay out ratio
5. Earning power ratio
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
8/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 8
1. RETURN ON INVESTMENT RATIO:
1. Return on net worth:
Return on net worth (RONW) = PATpreference dividend 100
Share holder Equity (Net worth)
Year PAT Preference dividend Share holder equity RONW (%)
2008 34.71 0.06 392.58 8.80
2009 40.8 0.05 408.86 9.97
2010 94.16 0.03 475.74 19.78
2011 108.21 0.01 588.89 18.37
2012 49.32 0.01 851.46 5.79
Interpretation:
The return on net worth ratio indicates that in the last two years, the net worth increases. The
firm has earned a factory return for its equity holders. The rate of return on net worth is of
crucial significance for the company.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
9/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 9
2. Earnings per share:
Earnings per share (EPS) = PATpreference dividend
No. of share out standing
Year PAT Preference dividend No. of share outstanding EPS
2008 34.71 0.06 78.15 0.44
2009 40.8 0.05 78.15 0.52
2010 94.16 0.03 78.15 1.20
2011 108.21 0.01 78.15 1.38
2012 49.32 0.01 136.62 0.36
Interpretation:
EPS indicates that, EPS increases from the last four years. This means that, the firms
profitability has increase. Here, the no. of share outstanding remains constant for all the
years. This shows that, it does not necessarily follow that the firms profitability has
improved for all the years.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
10/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 10
3. Cash earnings per share:
Cash earnings per share (CEPS) = PAT - preference dividend + non cash expenses
Total no. of equity share
(In cr.)
Year PAT Preference dividend Non cash
expenses
Total no. of
equity share
CEPS
2008 34.71 0.06 47.14 78.15 1.05
2009 40.8 0.05 70.11 78.15 1.42
2010 94.16 0.03 71.51 78.15 2.12
2011 108.21 0.01 71.71 78.15 2.30
2012 49.32 0.01 136.62
Interpretation:
The CEPS ratio indicates that, it increases from year to year. which shows that the cash
generating ability of the firm increases. In 2008, as PAT decreases, the cash generating
ability of the firm also decreases. And after that in 2009, as PAT increases the cash
generating ability of the firm also increases.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
11/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 11
4. Return on capital employed:
Return on capital employed (ROCE) = NP (before interest & tax) 100
Capital employed
(In cr.)
Year NP Capital Employed ROCE
2008 71.11 1111.22 6.40
2009 117.79 1103.26 10.68
2010 182.54 1023.68 17.83
2011 200 1126.31 17.76
2012 101.5
Interpretation:
The ratio indicates that, the higher the ratio the more efficient is the use of capital employed.
Here, in the last three years it increases. which means that company is using long term fund
of owners and lenders efficiently. In 2008, the ratio decreases because the NP decreases.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
12/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 12
5. EFFICIENCY RATIO:
1. Fixed assets turnover ratio:
Fixed assets turnover ratio = Net sales
Total Fixed Assets (Net block)
(In cr.)
Year Net sales Total Fixed Assets Fixed asset turnover ratio
2008 686.65 949.46 0.72
2009 1,206.36 928.71 1.30
2010 1,258.82 879.58 1.43
2011 1,387.78 844.45 1.64
2012 1,494.85 807.06 1.85
Interpretation:
The fixed asset turnover ratio is continuously increasing. It means the company has more
efficient managing and utilization of assets. And the company expands the sale without
additional capital investment or purchase of fixed assets.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
13/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 13
2. Net worth Turnover:
Net worth Turnover = Net sales
Net Worth
(In cr.)
Year Net sales Net worth Net worth Turnover
2008 686.65 392.58 1.75
2009 1,206.36 408.86 2.95
2010 1,258.82 475.74 2.65
2011 1,387.78 588.89 2.36
2012 1,494.85 851.46 1.75
Interpretation:
The net worth turnover ratio is continuously increasing. This means that the company has
more efficient managing and utilization of share capital and reserves. And the company
expands the net worth; it means the company can operate higher level of activity.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
14/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 14
3. Working capital turnover:
Working capital turnover = Net sales
Working capital
(In cr.)
Year Net sales Working capital (CACL) Working capital turnover
2008 686.65 142.78 4.88
2009 1,206.36 157.83 7.64
2010 1,258.82 81.37 15.47
2011 1,387.78 105.19 13.19
2012 1494.85 157.48 9.49
Interpretation:
The working capital turnover ratio is continuously increasing. It means the company has
more efficient managing and utilization of liquidity.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
15/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 15
4. SOLVENCY RATIO:
1. Net asset value:
Net asset value = Shareholder fund
No. of equity share outstanding
(In cr.)
Year Shareholder fund No. of equity share
outstanding
Net asset value
2008 392.58 78.15 5.022009 408.86 78.15 5.23
2010 475.74 78.15 6.09
2011 588.89 78.15 7.54
2012 851.46 136.62 6.23
Interpretation:
Here, the ratio increase for all the years and higher the ratio higher the capacity of company
to raise further capitalborrowed as well as equity.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
16/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 16
2. Debt Equity Ratio:
DER = Long Term Debt
Equity shareholder fund + preference capitalmisc.exp.
(In cr.)
Particulars Secured loan Unsecured Loan Shareholder
Funds
DER (in times)
2008 583.54 137.78 389.9 1.86
2009 563.42 132.45 407.39 1.71
2010 392.15 156.06 475.47 1.15
2011 412.40 125.96 587.95 0.92
2012 701.84 274.45 819.86 1.19
Interpretation:
DER of 1.5:1 is satisfactory. In 2007 to 2009, the ratio is very high and higher the ratio, more
the financial risk of default in interest and debt service. It also adversely affects capacity of
company to raise cheaper funds. In 2010 and 2011, the ratio is decreasing which shows that
the company had less financial risk of default in interest and debt service.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
17/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 17
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
18/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 18
3. Capital Gearing Ratio:
Capital gearing ratio= Fixed interest Gearing Funds 100
Equity capital
(In cr.)
Year Fixed interest Gearing
Funds
Equity capital CGR
2008 0.81 78.15 1.04
2009 0.41 78.15 0.52
2010 0.20 78.15 0.26
2011 0.09 78.15 0.12
2012 0.03 136.62 0.02
Interpretation:
Capital gearing ratio indicates the proportion between owners funds and non owners funds.
JK paper has lower gearing which means company goes slowly towards corporate goal and
company is over capitalize.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
19/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 19
4. Interest coverage ratio:
ICR = PAT+ interest on long term debt + non-cash charges
Interest on long term debt
(In cr.)
YearPAT & non-cash charge Interest on long term debt ICR
2008 119.87 38.01 3.15
2009 176.06 65.15 2.70
2010 218.64 52.97 4.13
2011 230.16 50.24 4.58
2012 171.29 48.98 3.50
Interpretation:
An idle ratio is 2:1 times. The ratio measuring the capacity of company to pay the interest
liability it has incurred on its long term borrowing. Over the last 2 year ratio is increasing and
higher the ratio, greater the ability of a company to service interest, lesser the financial risk of
default and higher the comfort level of the lenders.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
20/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 20
5. Debt service coverage ratio:
DSCR (times) = PAT+ interest on long term debt +non-cash charge
Interest on long term debt + installment of principle due
(In cr.)
Year PAT & non-cash
charge
Interest on long term debt Installment o
principle due
DSCR
2008 119.87 38.01 0.00 3.15
2009 176.06 65.15 0.00 2.70
2010 218.64 52.97 0.00 4.13
2011 230.16 50.24 0.00 4.58
2012 171.29 48.98 .00 3.50
Interpretation:
An idle ratio is 1.6:1 times. The ratio measuring the capacity of company to pay the
interest liability it has incurred on its long term borrowing. Over the last 2 year ratio is
increasing and higher the ratio greater the ability of a company to service interest, lesser
the financial risk of default and higher the comfort level of the lenders.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
21/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 21
6. Proprietary Ratio:
PR = Shareholder Fund
Total assets
(In cr.)
Year Shareholder Fund Total asset PR
2008 389.9 1113.90 0.35
2009 407.39 1104.72 0.37
2010 475.47 1023.96 0.46
2011 587.95 1127.24 0.52
2012 819.86 1827.65 0.45
Interpretation:
Proprietary ratio shows the long term solvency and general strength of the business. Total
assets are greater than share holders fund is good for the company. Over the last 2 years, the
ratio increasing, the position of the firm is good.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
22/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 22
7. Total assets to debt Ratio:
TADR = Total asset
Long term debt
(In cr.)
Year Total asset Long term debt TADR
2008 1,113.90 721.32 1.54
2009 1,104.72 695.87 1.59
2010 1,023.96 548.21 1.87
2011 1,127.24 538.36 2.09
2012 1,827.65 976.19 1.87
Interpretation:
The ratio measuring the capacity of the company for more investment compare with its long
term debt. The acceptable ratio was 4:1 for the company to raise assets. Here, the total assets
are high but long term debts are high, with respect to total asset which shows that the position
of company is not good.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
23/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 23
8. Liability to equity ratio:
LER = Total liability
Equity Shareholder fund
(In cr.)
Year Total liability Equity Shareholder
fund
LER
2008 1,113.90 389.09 2.86
2009 1,104.73 406.98 2.71
2010 1,023.95 475.27 2.15
2011 1,127.25 587.86 1.92
2012 1,827.65 819.86 2.23
Interpretation:
The ratio measuring the total liability of the company & also increases the capital capacity.
Here, the LER decreasing from year to year which shows that it is good for the company
because the total liabilities are decreasing from year to year and share holder fund s are
increasing.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
24/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 24
9. LIQUIDITY RATIOS:
1. Current ratio:CR = Current asset + loans & advances + short term investment
Current liability + provisions + short term debt
(In cr.)
Year Current assets Current liability Current ratio
2008 408.15 265.37 1.54
2009 420.72 262.89 1.60
2010 400.24 318.87 1.26
2011 438.07 332.88 1.32
2012 712.76 555.28 1.28
Interpretation:
As a standard norm, this ratio should be 1.33:1. Here, current ratio for all the years is higher
which shows that the firms ability meet current obligation is more. And the safety of fund ofshort term creditors is also more.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
25/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 25
2. Quick ratio:
QR = Current assetInventoryPrepaid Exp.
Current liabilitiesB.O.D + short term debt
(In cr.)
Year Quick assets Quick liability Quick ratio
2008 287.81 265.37 1.08
2009 107.9 262.89 0.41
2010 273.34 318.87 0.86
2011 310.54 332.88 0.93
2012 548.57 555.28 0.99
Interpretation:
The quick ratio of the company in past years is more than the standard of 1:1. This ratio has
decreases in last 2 years. which shows that the availability of the current asset to pay current
liabilities goes down. In 2009, the ratio is below the 0.5, which indicates that in that year thefirm had difficulty to pay its current liability. The liquidity position is marginally satisfactory.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
26/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 26
3. Stock Turnover Ratio:
STOR = COGS
Avg. Inventory
(In cr.)
Year COGS Avg. inventory STOR (In times)
2008 321.99 108.38 2.97
2009 635.96 118.73 5.36
2010 555.45 122.0 4.55
2011 644.36 127.22 5.06
2012 145.86
Interpretation:
In 2008, the ratio decreases from 4.42 to 2.97 which show that, the inventory does not selling
fast and stays in the warehouse for the long time. From 2009, the ratio increases continuously
which shows that inventory is sold fast.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
27/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 27
4. Stock Turnover Period:
STOP = Avg. Inventory 365
COGS
(In cr.)
Year Avg. inventory COGS STOP (In days)
2008 108.38 321.99 123
2009 118.73 635.96 68
2010 122.0 555.45 80
2011 127.22 644.36 72
2012 145.86
Interpretation:
The stock turn over period is continuously decreases, it means the company can fast selling
the inventory and the companys liquidity position is good or improved in over the years. In
2008, STOR is very high which shows that company cant sell the inventory fast.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
28/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 28
5. Debtors Turnover Ratio:
DTOR = Net Credit Sales
Avg. debtors
(In cr.)
Year Credit sale Avg. debtors DTOR (In times)
2008 686.65 110.87 6.28
2009 1,206.36 107.15 11.26
2010 1,258.82 104.49 12.05
2011 1,387.78 107.87 12.87
2012 1,437.35 144.19 9.97
Interpretation:
The debtors turnover ratio shows that over the last 3 years, it increases. which shows that
there is a shorter time lag between credit sale and cash collection. And thus receivables are
collected rapidly. In 2008, it is 6.28 times which shows that debts are not being collected
rapidly.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
29/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 29
6. Debtors Turnover Period:
DTOP = Debtors 365
Credit sales
(In cr.)
Year Debtors Credit sale DTOR (In days)
2008 110.87 686.65 58
2009 107.15 1,206.36 32
2010 104.49 1,258.82 30
2011 107.87 1,387.78 28
2012 144.49 1,494.85 35
Interpretation:
In 2008, DTOP is 58 days which is very high which shows that receivables are not collected
rapidly. And from 2009, it decreases continuously which shows that the receivables are
collected rapidly.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
30/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 30
7. Profitability Ratio:
1.
Gross Profit Ratio:Gross Profit Ratio = Gross profit 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year Gross profit Net sales GP Ratio
2008 375.66 686.65 54.71
2009 570.40 1206.36 47.28
2010 703.37 1258.82 55.88
2011 743.42 1387.78 53.57
2012 1494.85
Interpretation:
In 2011, the ratio is decreasing which shows that cost of production of firm is relatively
high and selling price is low because there may be lack of demand, competition from
rival firm, and inferior quality of the product.
In 2010, the ratio is increasing which shows a good sign of good management because the
cost of production is low and selling price is high.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
31/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 31
2. Profit before depreciation, interest and tax margin
Profit before depreciation, interest and tax margin = PBDIT 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year PBDIT Net sales PBDIT Ratio
2008 118.25 686.65 17.22
2009 187.90 1206.36 15.58
2010 254.05 1258.82 20.18
2011 271.71 1387.78 19.58
2012 174.44 1494.85 11.67
Interpretation:
In 2011, the ratio is decreases which show that the firms ability to pay expenses is declining.
There is a less increase in profit as compared to increase in sale.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
32/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 32
3. PBIT Margin or Operating profit margin:
PBIT Margin or Operating profit margin = PBIT 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Interpretation:
The PBIT ratio is continuously fluctuated but in last years it is increases. that describes that
the adequate return to the owners as well as a company withstand adverse economic
condition when selling price is declining, cost of production is rising and demand for the
product is falling.
Year PBIT Net sales PBIT
Ratio
2008 71.11 686.65 10.36
2009 117.79 1206.36 9.76
2010 182.54 1258.82 14.50
2011 200 1387.78 14.41
2012 101.5 1437.35 7.06
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
33/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 33
4. PBT and Extra-ordinary items Ratio (PBTEOT):
PBT and Extra-ordinary items Ratio (PBTEOT) = PBTEOT 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year PBTEOT Net sales PBTEOT
Ratio
2008 34.92 686.65 5.09
2009 56.87 1206.36 4.71
2010 130.06 1258.82 10.33
2011 150.24 1387.78 10.83
2012 52.55 1494.8 3.52
Interpretation:
The ratio is continuously fluctuated but in last years it is increases that describes that the
ability of the firm to pay income tax is satisfactory.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
34/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 34
5. PBT margin:
PBT margin = PBT 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year PBT Net sales PBT Ratio
2008 33.10 686.65 4.82
2009 52.64 1206.36 4.36
2010 129.57 1258.82 10.29
2011 149.76 1387.78 10.79
2012 52.47 1494.85 3.51
Interpretation:
The ratio is continuously fluctuated but in last year, it is increases. The PBT ratio is
continuously increases over the period of that describes that the taxes paid by the company iscontinuously increases because the increase in income or profit.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
35/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 35
6. Net profit After tax Margin or PAT margin:
Net profit after tax Margin or PAT margin = NPAT 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year NPAT Net sales NPAT Ratio
2008 34.71 686.65 5.05
2009 38.01 1206.36 3.15
2010 91.03 1258.82 7.23
2011 106.42 1387.78 7.67
2012 49.32 1494.85 3.30
Interpretation:
The NPT ratio is continuously increases over the period of time that describes the adequate
return to the owners as well as to the company.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
36/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 36
7. Effective tax rate:
Effective tax rate = Current income tax 100
Profit before tax
(In cr.)
Year Current income tax PBT Effective Tax
rate
2008 0.21 33.10 0.63
2009 16.07 52.64 30.53
2010 35.90 129.57 27.71
2011 42.03 149.76 28.06
2012 2.8 52.47 5.34
Interpretation:
The ratio is continuously fluctuated. In the last year, ratio is increasing which shows that
company has to pay more income tax. So there is less profit.
In 2008, income tax rate is so less, but it is not good as there is PBT is very less.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
37/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 37
8. Operating ratio:
Operating ratio = COGS+ Operating expenses 100
Net sales
(In cr.)
Year COGS Operating
expenses
Net sales Operating
ratio
2008 310.99 218.84 686.65 77.16
2009 635.96 370.36 1206.36 83.42
2010 555.45 432.63 1258.82 78.49
2011 644.36 467.92 1387.78 80.15
2012 823.1 527.81 1494.85 90.37
Interpretation:
Operating ratio shows an operational efficiency of firm. Here, in the 2011 the ratio is 80.15%,
which shows that net sale is higher than the expenses which are good for the company. So we
can say that company is managing its operating expenses well.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
38/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 38
9. DU PONT ANALYSIS:
1. Return on net worth
Return on net worth = Net profitpreference dividend 100
Net worth
(In cr.)
Year Net profitpreference
dividend
Net worth Return on net worth
2008 34.65 392.58 8.83
2009 40.75 408.86 9.97
2010 94.13 475.74 19.79
2011 108.2 588.89 18.37
2012 851.46
Interpretation:
In the year 2008 to 2009, there is decrease in RONW contributed by decrease in net profit
margin and increase in net worth.
In the year 2009 to 2011, there is increase in net profit margin and in net worth so there isincrease in RONW.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
39/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 39
2. Return on total assets:
Return on total assets = Net profitpreference dividend 100
Total assets
(In cr.)
YearNet profitpreference dividend Total assets Return on total assets
2008 34.65 1256.68 2.76
2009 40.75 1367.61 2.98
2010 94.13 1342.83 7.00
2011 108.2 1460.12 7.41
2012
Interpretation:
The return on total asset ratio is continuously increases that the net earnings available to
companys owner and to lenders as assets are financed by owners as well as creditors of the
company.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
40/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 40
1. CO
MM
ONSIZE
STA
TEM
ENT
OF
PRO
FIT
AN
D
LOS
S
ACO
UNT
:
Particular 2008 2009 2010 2011
Income :
Sales Turnover 109.55 105.38 103.47 103.57
Excise Duty 9.55 5.38 3.47 3.57
Net Sales 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
Other Income 1.28 0.30 0.16 0.53
Stock Adjustments 0.60 0.58 -0.71 -0.75
Total Income 101.87 100.88 99.45 99.78
Expenditure :
Raw Materials 50.38 52.45 44.90 46.48
Power & Fuel Cost 9.20 10.19 9.41 9.81
Employee Cost 10.36 8.29 9.55 9.41
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
41/53
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
42/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 42
4. COMMON SIZE STATEMENT OF BALANCESHEET:
Particular 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Sources Of Funds:
Equity Share Capital 7.02 7.07 7.63 6.93 7.48
Share Application Money 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Preference Share Capital 0.07 0.04 0.02 0.01 0.00
Total Share Capital 7.09 7.11 7.65 6.94 7.48
Reserves 27.57 29.39 38.28 44.97 38.91
Revaluation Reserves 0.58 0.51 0.53 0.33 0.20
Net worth 35.24 37.01 46.46 52.24 46.59
Secured Loans 52.39 51.00 38.30 36.58 38.40
Unsecured Loans 12.37 11.99 15.24 11.17 15.02
Total Debt 64.76 62.99 53.54 47.76 53.41
Total Liabilities 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
Application Of Funds:
Gross Block 122.77 127.95 139.54 129.11 81.13
Less: Accum. Depreciation 37.53 43.88 53.64 54.20 36.97
Net Block 85.24 84.07 85.90 74.91 44.16
Capital Work in Progress 1.46 1.26 2.03 8.33 41.51
Investments 0.25 0.25 4.10 7.34 3.99
Inventories 10.80 10.60 12.39 11.31 8.98
Sundry Debtors 9.95 9.70 10.20 9.57 7.89
Cash and Bank Balance 0.11 0.07 0.10 0.70 0.47
Total Current Assets 20.87 20.37 22.70 21.58 17.34
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
43/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 43
Loans and Advances 15.57 14.69 15.72 15.24 14.05
Fixed Deposits 0.20 3.03 0.67 2.04 7.61
Total CA, Loans & Advances 36.64 38.08 39.09 38.86 39.00
Deferred Credit 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Current Liabilities 21.37 21.37 28.62 28.94 28.80
Provisions 2.45 2.43 2.52 0.59 1.58
Total CL & Provisions 23.82 23.80 31.14 29.53 30.38
Net Current Assets 12.82 14.29 7.95 9.33 8.62
Miscellaneous Expenses 0.24 0.13 0.03 0.08 1.73
Total Assets 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
Interpretation:
1. The common-size balance sheet shows that, in the year 2011, total current assets as a
percentage of total assets have decreased by 1.12% over previous year. The current
liabilities of the firm also have been increased by 0.32%.over previous year. Thiscondition indicates that liquidity position of the firm is not very well.
2. Here, net current assets have been 1.38% increased, which shows that company has
ability to pay its obligations. But, it is not that way, because here current assets are less
as compared to current liabilities.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
44/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 44
1. TREND ANALYSIS OF PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT:
Particular 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Income:
Sales Turnover 1.00 1.69 1.73 1.91 2.08
Excise Duty 1.00 0.99 0.67 0.76 1.03
Net Sales 1.00 1.76 1.83 2.02 2.18
Other Income 1.00 0.41 0.23 0.84 1.59
Stock Adjustments 1.00 1.70 -2.19 -2.56 4.06
Total Income 1.00 1.74 1.79 1.98 2.18
Expenditure:
Raw Materials 1.00 1.83 1.63 1.86 2.38
Power & Fuel Cost 1.00 1.95 1.88 2.15 2.95
Employee Cost 1.00 1.41 1.69 1.84 1.78
Other Manufacturing Expenses 1.00 2.92 2.26 2.09 2.46
Selling and Admin Expenses 1.00 1.71 2.00 2.39 2.54
Miscellaneous Expenses 1.00 1.57 1.48 0.00 0.00
Total Expenses 1.00 1.77 1.72 1.91 2.32
PBDIT 1.00 1.59 2.15 2.30 1.48
Interest 1.00 1.71 1.39 1.32 1.29
PBDT 1.00 1.53 2.51 2.76 1.56
Depreciation 1.00 1.52 1.53 1.56 1.59
Other Written Off 1.00 0.33 1.15 0.07 0.04
Profit Before Tax 1.00 1.59 3.91 4.52 1.59
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
45/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 45
Extra-ordinary items 1.00 2.32 0.27 0.26 0.04
PBT (Post Extra-ord Items) 1.00 1.63 3.72 4.30 1.50
Tax 1.00 76.52 170.95 200.14 13.33
Reported Net Profit 1.00 1.18 2.71 3.12 1.42
Interpretation:
1. The trend analysis of profit and loss account shows that, the net sales increases from year
to year, which is a good position for a firm. But a net sale is increasing at a very less rate.
2. The total income of the firm are also increasing from year to year .but total expenses are
also increasing from year to year. This is not good for company. Because expenses are
increasing more as compared to increase in sales and total income.
3. Here, NPAT for the last years is very high as compared to years 2008 and 2009, which
shows that company is making profit high over the years. Higher the profit, higher the
ability to meet with the future expenses.
4. The overall growth of the firm is satisfactory as the net sales as well as NPAT have
increased substantially.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
46/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 46
1. TREND ANANLYSIS OF BALANCESHEET:
Particular 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Sources Of Funds:
Equity Share Capital 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.75
Share Application Money 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Preference Share Capital 1.00 0.51 0.25 0.11 0.04
Total Share Capital 1.00 0.99 0.99 0.99 1.73
Reserves 1.00 1.06 1.28 1.56 2.32
Revaluation Reserves 1.00 0.87 0.83 0.58 0.55
Net worth 1.00 1.04 1.21 1.50 2.70
Secured Loans 1.00 0.97 0.67 0.71 1.20
Unsecured Loans 1.00 0.96 1.13 0.91 1.99
Total Debt 1.00 0.96 0.76 0.75 1.35
Total Liabilities 1.00 0.99 0.92 1.01 1.64
Application Of Funds:
Gross Block 1.00 1.03 1.04 1.06 1.08
Less: Accum. Depreciation 1.00 1.16 1.31 1.46 1.62
Net Block 1.00 0.98 0.93 1.89 0.85
Capital Work in Progress 1.00 0.86 1.28 5.78 46.74
Investments 1.00 1.00 15.25 30.10 26.53
Inventories 1.00 0.97 1.05 1.06 1.36
Sundry Debtors 1.00 0.97 0.94 0.97 1.30
Cash and Bank Balance 1.00 0.61 0.81 6.40 7.03
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
47/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 47
Total Current Assets 1.00 0.97 1.00 1.05 1.36
Loans and Advances 1.00 0.94 0.93 0.99 1.48
Fixed Deposits 1.00 14.74 3.03 10.14 61.25
Total CA, Loans & Advances 1.00 1.03 0.98 1.07 1.75
Deferred Credit 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Current Liabilities 1.00 0.99 1.23 1.37 2.21
Provisions 1.00 0.98 0.94 0.25 1.06
Total CL & Provisions 1.00 0.99 1.20 1.25 2.09
Net Current Assets 1.00 1.11 0.57 0.74 1.10
Miscellaneous Expenses 1.00 1.55 0.10 0.35 11.78
Total Assets 1.00 0.99 0.92 1.01 1.64
Interpretation:
1. The trend analysis of balance-sheet shows that, the net worth of the company increasing
from year to year, this shows that it has relied more on its own funds than on outsiders
funds.
2. Here, total liabilities are fluctuating from year to year. But if total liabilities are very high,
then it is not good for company.
3. The total current assets are fluctuating from year to year. Cash in hand is very high in the
year 2011, which is good. Total current liabilities are also increasing. Here net current
assets are fluctuating over the years, which show that working capital position is bad.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
48/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 48
1. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF
PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR 2011 AND 2012
Particular Increase /decrease
(Amount)
% increase/ decrease
Income:
Sales Turnover 125.01 8.70
Excise Duty 17.94 36.19
Net Sales 107.07 7.72
Other Income 6.60 89.68
Stock Adjustments 27.06 -258.45
Total Income 140.73 10.16
Expenditure:
Raw Materials 178.11 27.61
Power & Fuel Cost 50.54 37.14
Employee Cost -4.08 -3.12
Other Manufacturing
Expenses
0.89 17.84
Selling and Admin Expenses 12.54 6.39
Miscellaneous Expenses 0.00 0.00
Total Expenses 238.00 21.38
PBDIT -97.27 -35.80
Interest -1.26 -2.51
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
49/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 49
PBDT -96.01 -43.35
Depreciation 1.32 1.84
Other Written Off -0.04 -44.44
Profit Before Tax -97.29 -64.96
Extra-ordinary items -0.40 -83.33
PBT (Post Extra-ord Items) -97.69 -65.02
Tax -39.23 -93.34
Reported Net Profit -58.89 -54.42
Interpretation:
1. The net sales of the company have increased by 10.35% in the year 2011 from the
previous year 2010, which is quite good.
2. The total income has also been increases by 10.60% in the year 2011.and total expenses
increases by 11.53%.so, total expenses are increasing more than increase in total income.
This situation is not good and company should control expenses.
3. The NPAT has increase by 14.92%, which is quite satisfactory.
4. The overall profitability is somewhat satisfactory, because expenses are more than
income.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
50/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 50
1. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF
BALANCESHEET FOR THE YEAR 2011 AND 2012
Particular Increase /decrease
(Amount)
% increase/ decrease
Sources Of Funds:
Equity Share Capital 58.47 74.82
Share Application Money 0.00 0.00
Preference Share Capital -0.06 -66.67
Total Share Capital 58.41 74.65
Reserves 204.34 40.31
Revaluation Reserves -0.18 -4.77
Net worth 262.57 44.59
Secured Loans 289.34 70.16
Unsecured Loans 148.49 117.89
Total Debt 437.83 81.33
Total Liabilities 700.40 62.13
Application Of Funds:
Gross Block 27.40 1.88
Less: Accum. Depreciation 64.79 10.60
Net Block -37.39 -4.43
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
51/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 51
Capital Work in Progress 664.69 707.95
Investments -9.81 -11.85
Inventories 36.66 28.75
Sundry Debtors 36.32 33.67
Cash and Bank Balance 0.78 9.91
Total Current Assets 73.73 30.31
Loans and Advances 84.94 49.45
Fixed Deposits 116.02 504.00
Total CA, Loans & Advances 274.69 62.70
Deferred Credit 0.00 0.00
Current Liabilities 200.18 61.37
Provisions 22.22 331.64
Total CL & Provisions 222.40 66.81
Net Current Assets 52.29 49.71
Miscellaneous Expenses 30.63 3258.51
Total Assets 700.41 62.13
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
52/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
S.R. Luthra Institute of Management Page 52
Interpretation:
1. Net fixed assets in the year 2011, decreased by Rs. 35.13 and decreases by 3.99%.which
are low. But it is not good for company.
2. The total current assets increases by 4.68%, but current liabilities increases by
11.29%.thus, there is a high increase in current liabilities as compared to increase incurrent assets. Thus, working capital position of the company is not good.
8/13/2019 Jk Papers Finance Project
53/53
Financial statement analysis of JK PAPER LTD.
Bibliography
Web Sites:-
http://planningcommission.nic.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp12/wg_paper.pdf
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-
11827.cms
http://rapidbi.com/porterfiveforces/
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanyhistory/companyid-11827.cms
http://papermart.in/2010/05/31/top-paper-companies-in-india/
http://planningcommission.nic.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp12/wg_paper.pdfhttp://planningcommission.nic.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp12/wg_paper.pdfhttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-11827.cmshttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-11827.cmshttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-11827.cmshttp://rapidbi.com/porterfiveforces/http://rapidbi.com/porterfiveforces/http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanyhistory/companyid-11827.cmshttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanyhistory/companyid-11827.cmshttp://papermart.in/2010/05/31/top-paper-companies-in-india/http://papermart.in/2010/05/31/top-paper-companies-in-india/http://papermart.in/2010/05/31/top-paper-companies-in-india/http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanyhistory/companyid-11827.cmshttp://rapidbi.com/porterfiveforces/http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-11827.cmshttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/jk-paper-ltd/infocompanymanagement/companyid-11827.cmshttp://planningcommission.nic.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp12/wg_paper.pdfTop Related