INFERTILITY
ABOVE 40
Aboubakr Elnashar Benha University Hospital,
Egypt
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTIOM Magnitude of problem
Ovarian aging
Age associated infertility
2. EVALUATION When
What
3. TREATMENT Pre conception counseling
Methods
CONCLUSION
3 ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
1. INTRODUCTION
Magnitude of problem 15 %
(voluntarily or involuntarily) postponed their desire for
pregnancy requesting reproductive tt after 40 (CDC, 2011)
Number of women ≥43 y seeking IVF is increasing
25%
ICSI cycles in Europe: ≥ 40 y
10% in Egypt (Mansour R & Abousetta 2006).
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Risk Poor response to ovarian stimulation
Obstetric risks:
Miscarriage
PET
IUGR
Chromosomal defects in the offspring
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Ovarian aging
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
At birth: 1–2 million oocytes in her ovaries
As a woman ages: absolute number of developing follicles declines at a rate that is bi-
exponential to her age.
At 37.5 y: The rate of follicle loss (atresia) more than doubles when
reserves fall below the critical level of 25,000
As the ovarian follicular pool decreases: Infertility
cycle shortening
cycle irregularity and finally
menopause
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Number of primordial follicles and
Poor quality of oocytes in relation to
Female age and
Reproductive events.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Aneuploidy of oocytes Age (years)
20% 30
30% 35
60% 40
85% 42
≥90% 45
Effect of age on aneuploidy of oocytes
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Age associated infertility What?
increasing age: lowered fertility.
Particularly noticeable: above 30 Y
Accelerating: between 35 and 40 Y
Reducing to almost zero: 45 Y
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Causes
1. Decrease quality of oocytes
{Increase in the rate of oocyte aneuploidy}
Most important
2. Decrease numbers of oocytes:
Decrease ovarian reserve
3. Increase in the miscarriage rate
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Ovarian:
Primarily related to ovarian aging and the
diminishing ovarian follicle count.
Endometrium
has the capacity to maintain a pregnancy
throughout reproductive years, even beyond (egg
donation)
Age does not affect the endometrium’s response
to hormonal stimulation.
PR from donor egg cycles confirm that the age of
the recipient does not affect PR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
SOGC Clinical Practice Guideline, 2011
Reproductive-age women should be aware that
natural fertility and ART success (except with egg
donation) is significantly lower for women in their
late 30s and 40s. (II-2A) SOGC, 2011
Above 40y:
1. Decreased oocyte quality
2. Decreased oocyte number
3. Poor endometrium
4. Medical Risk: DM, Hypertension, hypothyroidism
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
2. EVALUATION When?
After 40 y
Immediate evaluation in women.
35-40 Y
After 6 months of unprotected intercourse without
conception
Because of the decline in fertility and the
increased time to conception that occurs after the
age of 35, women > 35 ys of age should be
referred for infertility work-up after 6 months of
trying to conceive. (III-B) SOGC, 2011
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
What?
I. Infertility investigation:
Semen analysis
Mid luteal P
HSG
No specific findings: unexplained infertility
Age related factors:
Endometriosis
Fibroids
Polyps
:Assessment of uterus
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
II. Ovarian reserve tests:
A.F.C
AMH
FSH, E2
>39 y 34–38 y 24–33y Parameter
1.1
(0.5–2.3)
1.6
(0.8–2.9)
2.1
(1.1–3.4)
AMH level
(ng/mL) Median (interquartile range)
7.9
(6.2–10.6)
7.4
(6–9.4)
6.9
(5.5–8.3)
FSH level (IU/L) Median (interquartile range)
7
(4–11)
10
(6–13)
11
(8–16)
AFC Median (interquartile range)
(Imog et al ,2011) ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
NICE, 2013
High response Low response
16 or more 4 or less Total AFC
3.5 or more
25
0.8 or less
5.5
AMH
ng/ml
pmol/l
Conversion ratio:7
4 or less 8.9 or more FSH IU/L
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Indications:
≥ 35 ys or
< 35 ys
Endometriosis
Unexplained infertility
Single ovary
Previous ovarian surgery,
Poor response to FSH,
Previous exposure to chemotherapy or
radiation (Iii-b) SOGC, 2011
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Significance:
Particularly important ≥40y
1. All detect the quantity rather than the quality of the
follicular pool (Broekmans et al. 2006)
2. Poor predictive value for non pregnancy and should
be used to exclude women from tt only if levels are
significantly abnormal. (II-2a) SOGC, 2011
3. Predict response to ovarian stimulation and
potentially, successful outcome with ART.
4. Help in determining the dose of HMG/FSH and the
protocol of stimulation to be used but they are poor
predictors of PR (Fauser B et al 2007)
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3. TREATMENT Pre-conception counseling
Risks of pregnancy above 40,
Promotion of optimal health and weight
Screening for medical condition: hypertension, DM. (III-B) SOGC, 2011
Women should be informed that increased risk of
spontaneous pregnancy loss
chromosomal abnormalities.
Women should be counseled about and offered
appropriate prenatal screening once pregnancy is
established. (II-2A) SOGC, 2011
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Methods:
1. CC and IUI
2. GnT and IUI
3. IVF
4. Oocyte donation:
The only effective tt for age-related infertility and
declining oocyte quality
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
1. CC and IUI Simple, inexpensive Aim: 2 or 3 dominant follicles of at least 18 mm.
PR/cycle (Tsafrir et al, 2009, Dovey et al,2011)
1–4 %
38 to 40y: 7%
41 to 42 y: 4%
42: 1%
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
LBR:
40-41y: low
>42 y: No LB (Corsan et al.1996)
CC:
PR and LBR are low.
Little or no value
Swift referral for IVF after 1 or 2 failed cycles.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
2. FSH and IUI Aim:
2 or 3 dominant follicles. Ovulation induction may encourage
the recruitment of suboptimal follicles that may otherwise
have not developed.
PR/cycle (Tsafrir et al.2009)
3%
LBR/cycle: 1 %
LBR/cycle (Haebe et al, 2002)
40-42y: 9.8 %
>44: no live births
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
No significant difference in LBR between ovarian
stimulation protocols (GnRH-a and FSH, FSH,CC,
tamoxifen, CC and FSH) (Haebe et al, 2002)
All live births happened within the 1st or 2nd cycles
PR for COS, IUI are low for women > 40 y.
Women > 40 should consider IVF if they do not
conceive within 1 to 2 cycles of COS. (II-2B) SOGC, 2011
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3. ICSI Advantage:
overcoming
most male problems
female mechanical problems which are not
uncommon in older women.
significantly higher PR and LBR than COS IUI
But lower rates than oocyte donation.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Cycle cancellation and LBR women > 40
Author Initiated
cycle
Cancellation
Rate %
LBR%
Klipstein et al, 2005 2750 19.9 9.7
Tsafrir et al , 2007 1217 16.6 4.7
Serour et al, 2010 2386 16 6.7
ESHRE 2010 8.6
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Number of oocytes collected/cycle in women aged
40 years and above. (Seng et al, 2005)
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Implantation rates as a function of female age
Age Implantation rate
25-29 18.2%
30-34 16.1%
35-39 15.3%
40-44 6.1%
(Hull MG et al 1996; ASRM Practice Committee, 2006)
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
PR and LBR in
infertile women
above age 40
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
LBR/cycle
6.7% (range: 10% to 0.5%).
40 to 42: 7.4%
≥ 43: 1.1% (Sorour et al, 2014)
Miscarriage rate
40 to 42: 43.1%
≥ 43: 65.2%
Once women have attained age 43 y, alternative
methods such as oocyte donation cycles or
previously cryopreserved embryos are likely to be
more effective.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Upper age for allowing IVF attempts Old studies:
41 or 42 y
Recent studies:
43 and 44 y:
CPR: 8.3%/cycle
LBR: 5.3 %/ cycle
≥45: No pregnancy. (Mehmet et al, 2013)
Reasonable success rate up to 44 y
Most pregnancies occurred within the first 3
cycles
≥45: no benefit from ART procedures using their
own oocytes.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Very recently Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HFEA) (2014)
LBR/cycle
38–39 y: 19.2 % /cycle
40-42: 12.7 %
43-44: 5.1 %
45 and over: 1.5 %.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
4. Oocyte donation PR based on the age of the donor, not the
recipient.
Pregnancies and live births have been reported in
women into their 60s
Use of donor eggs above 50y: controversial.
Increased rates of complications:
Maternal death
Hypertension
Prematurity
Fetal and neonatal death
Operative delivery. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
CONCLUSIONS
Outcome of ART is adversely affected by
advancing maternal age
IVF is best chance for successful ongoing
pregnancy in this age group
Ovulation induction and IUI with either CC or
FSH can waste much precious time: reducing
chances of success with IVF.
Women 45 y and beyond do not benefit
from ART procedures using their own oocytes.
The only effective tt for ovarian aging is oocyte
donation. (II-2B) SOGC, 2011
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Thank You
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR