8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
1/81
IMPERFECTCOMPETITION
Dr.R.JAYARAJ, M.A., Ph.D.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
2/81
MONOPOLY
Definition
The term monopoly is from Greek monos , alone or single +polein , to
sell.
In Economics, a monopoly(or "Pure oligopoly") exists when a specificindividual or enterprise has sufficient control over a particular productor service to determine significantly the terms on which other
individuals shall have access to it.Monopolies are thus characterizedby a lack of economic competition for the good or service that theyprovide and a lack of viable substitute goods.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
3/81
A monopoly should be distinguished from monopsony, inwhich there is only one buyerof a product or service; a
monopoly may also have monopsony control of a sectorof a market. Likewise, a monopoly should bedistinguished from a cartel (a form ofoligopoly), in whichseveral providers act together to coordinate services,prices or sale of goods.
A government-granted monopoly or legal monopoly issanctioned by the state, often to provide an incentive toinvest in a risky venture or enrich a domesticconstituency. The government may also reserve theventure for itself, thus forming a
government monopoly.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
4/81
No close substitutes: A monopoly is not merelythe state of having control over a product; it alsomeans that there is no real alternative to the
monopolised product. A price maker: Because a single firm controlsthe total supply in a pure monopoly, it is able toexert a significant degree of control over the
price by changing the quantity supplied.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
5/81
Why Monopolies Arise
The main cause of monopolies is barriersto entry other firms cannot enter the market.Three sources of barriers to entry:
1. A single firm owns a key resource. E.g., DeBeers owns most of the worlds
diamond mines
2. The govt gives a single firm the exclusiveright to produce the good.
E.g., patents, copyright laws
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
6/81
Why Monopolies Arise
Natural monopoly: a single firm can produce the entire market Qat lowerATCthan could several firms.
Q
Cost
ATC
1000
$50
Example: 1000 homes
need electricity.Electricity
Economies ofscale due to
huge FC
ATCis lower ifone firm servicesall 1000 homesthan if two firms
each service500 homes.
500
$80
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
7/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
8/81
Monopoly vs. Competition: Demand Curves
A monopolist is the onlyseller, so it faces themarket demand curve.
To sell a largerQ,the firm must reduce P.
Thus, MR P.
D
P
Q
A monopolistsdemand curve
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
9/81
A monopolys revenueA monopolys revenue
We consider, BSNListhe only seller of 3Gconnection in town.
The table shows themarket demand for3G.
Fill in the missing
spaces of the table.What is the relationbetween PandAR?Between Pand MR?
9
Q P TR AR MR
0 $4.50
1 4.00
2 3.50
3 3.00
4 2.50
5 2.00
6 1.50
n.a.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
10/81
AnswersAnswers
Here, P=AR,same as for acompetitive firm.
Here, MR< P,whereas MR= Pfor a competitivefirm.
10
1.506
2.005
2.504
3.003
3.502
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
$4.004.001
n.a.
9
10
10
9
7
4
$ 0$4.500
MRARTRPQ
1
0
1
2
3
$4
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
11/81
BSNLs D and MR Curves
-3
-2
-1
0
12
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Q
P, MR
Demand curve(P)
MR
$
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
12/81
Understanding the Monopolists MR
Increasing Qhas two effects on revenue:
The output effect:More output is sold, which raises revenue
Theprice effect:The price falls, which lowers revenue
To sell a largerQ, the monopolist must reduce theprice on allthe units it sells.
Hence, MR< P
MRcould even be negative if the price effect
exceeds the output effect(e.g., when BSNL increases Qfrom 5 to 6).
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
13/81
Profit-Maximization
Like a competitive firm, a monopolist maximizes profit byproducing the quantity where MR= MC.
Once the monopolist identifies this quantity,it sets the highest price consumers are willing to pay for
that quantity. It finds this price from the Dcurve.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
14/81
Profit-Maximization
1. The profit-maximizing Qis where
MR= MC.2. Find P from
the demandcurve at this Q.
Quantity
Costs andRevenue
MR
D
MC
Profit-maximizing output
P
Q
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
15/81
The Monopolists Profit
As with a
competitive firm,the monopolistsprofit equals
(PATC) x Q
Quantity
Costs andRevenue
ATC
D
MR
MC
Q
P
ATC
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
16/81
The Welfare Cost of Monopoly
Recall: In a competitive market equilibrium,P= MCand total surplus is maximized.
In the monopoly eqm, P> MR= MC The value to buyers of an additional unit (P)
exceeds the cost of the resources needed to produce that unit(MC).
The monopoly Qis too low could increase total surplus with a largerQ.
Thus, monopoly results in a deadweight loss.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
17/81
The Welfare Cost of Monopoly
Competitive eqm: quantity = QE P= MC total surplus is
maximizedMonopoly eqm:
quantity = QM
P> MC deadweight loss
P= MC
Deadweight
loss
P
MC
Quantity
Price
D
MR
MC
QM QE
Socially efficientquantity is foundwhere MC and Dcurve intersect
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
18/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
19/81
Public Policy Toward Monopolies
Public ownership Example: U.S. Postal Service
Problem: Public ownership is usually less efficient since noprofit motive to minimize costs
Doing nothing The foregoing policies all have drawbacks,
so the best policy may be no policy.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
20/81
Price Discrimination
Discrimination is the practice of treating people differentlybased on some characteristic, such as race or gender.
Price discriminationis the business practice of sellingthe same good at different prices to different buyers.
The characteristic used in price discriminationis willingness to pay (WTP):
A firm can increase profit by charging a higher price to buyerswith higher WTP.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
21/81
Single Price Monopoly
Here, the monopolistcharges the sameprice (PM) to all
buyers.
A deadweight lossresults.
Consumersurplus
Deadweight
loss
Monopolyprofit
MC
Quantity
Price
D
MR
P
M
QM
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
22/81
Perfect Price Discrimination
Here, the monopolist
produces thecompetitive quantity,but charges eachbuyer his or her WTP.
This is called perfectprice discrimination.
The monopolistcaptures all CS
as profit.But theres no DWL.
Monopolyprofit
MC
Quantity
Price
D
MR
Q
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
23/81
Price Discrimination in the Real World
In the real world, perfect price discrimination is notpossible:
no firm knows every buyers WTP
buyers do not announce it to sellers
So, firms divide customers into groupsbased on some observable traitthat is likely related to WTP, such as age.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
24/81
Examples of Price Discrimination
Movie tickets
Discounts for seniors, students, and people who canattend during weekday afternoons. They are all morelikely to have lower WTP than people who pay full price
on Friday night.
Airline prices
Discounts for Saturday-night stayovers help distinguish
business travelers, who usually have higher WTP, frommore price-sensitive leisure travelers.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
25/81
Examples of Price Discrimination
Discount coupons
People who have time to clip and organize coupons aremore likely to have lower income and lower WTP than
others.Need-based financial aid
Low income families have lower WTP for their childrens
college education. Schools price-discriminate by offeringneed-based aid to low income families.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
26/81
Examples of Price Discrimination
Quantity discounts
A buyers WTP often declines with additional units, sofirms charge less per unit for large quantities than smallones. Example: A movie theater charges $4 for
a small popcorn and $5 for a large one thats twice asbig.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
27/81
CONCLUSION: The Prevalence of Monopoly
In the real world, pure monopoly is rare. Yet, many firms have market power, due to
selling a unique variety of a product
having a large market share and few significant competitors
In many such cases, most of the results from this chapterapply, including
markup of price over marginal cost
deadweight loss
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
28/81
SUMMARY
A monopoly firm is the sole seller in its market.Monopolies arise due to barriers to entry,including: government-granted monopolies, thecontrol of a key resource, or economies of scaleover the entire range of output.
A monopoly firm faces a downward-sloping demandcurve for its product. As a result, it must reduceprice to sell a larger quantity, which causes
marginal revenue to fall below price.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
29/81
SUMMARY
Monopoly firms maximize profits by producing thequantity where marginal revenue equals marginalcost. But since marginal revenue is less thanprice, the monopoly price will be greater thanmarginal cost, leading to a deadweight loss.
Policymakers may respond by regulatingmonopolies, using antitrust laws to promotecompetition, or by taking over the monopoly and
running it. Due to problems with each of theseoptions, the best option may be to take no action.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
30/81
SUMMARY
Monopoly firms (and others with market power) tryto raise their profits by charging higher prices toconsumers with higher willingness to pay. Thispractice is called price discrimination.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
31/81
Monopolistic competition
A market structure in which many firms sell products thatare similar but not identical.
Assumptions:
Many Sellers, Product Differentiation, Free Entry-Exit.
Examples: apartments books bottled water clothing fast food night clubs
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
32/81
Another important dimension of product differentiation, is location. Petrol seems likean undifferentiated product, assume different petrol stations charge differentprices.
How can some Petrol stations get away with charging 50 or even 62.50 Rsmore per litter? The answer isproduct differentiation by location.
Imagine youre driving in rush-hour traffic from home. The Petrol indicator shows yourvehicle needs petrol. After uttering a few choice expletives, you notice on the rightside, there is a petrol station near by the place where you are driving and there isa mechanic shop owner at an upcoming intersection, who sells petrol. But, hecharges 12.50 Rs more than the one near by road. One near by road would require aheavy traffic and go via a U turn to go into the station. It makes you to spend 5 Rsworth of petrol.
And how much would you save? If you buy 2 litters, youd save only 5 Rs.
Alternatively, imagine you run a petrol station located in a highly residential area, inwhich there are few other businesses including gas stations. If people want gas,they can buy it from you, or they can drive 10 minutes to a more commercial areawith lots of gas stations. Your location allows you to charge a higher price.
Business people have long understood that location is a critical dimension of product
differentiation. Hence the saying location, location, location.
Role of Location
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
33/81
A Monopolistically Competitive Firm Earning Profits in theShort Run
The firm faces adownward-slopingD curve.
At each Q, MR< P.
To maximize profit,firm produces Qwhere MR= MC.
The firm uses theD curve to set P.
profit
ATC
P
Quantity
Price
ATC
D
MR
MC
Q
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
34/81
A Monopolistically Competitive FirmWith Losses in the Short Run
For this firm,P
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
35/81
Monopolistic Competition and Monopoly
Short run: Under monopolistic competition,
firm behavior is very similar to monopoly. Long run: In monopolistic competition,
entry and exit drive economic profit to zero. If profits in the short run:
New firms enter market, taking some demand away from existing
firms, prices and profits fall. If losses in the short run:
Some firms exit the market, remaining firms enjoy higher demandand prices.
0
The level of output that minimizes ATC is greater than the output that maximizes th
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
36/81
A Monopolistic Competitor in the Long Run
Entry and exit
occurs untilP=ATCand profit= zero.
Notice that thefirm charges amarkup of priceover marginalcost, and does
not produce atminimumATC.
Quantity
Price
ATC
DMR
Q
MC
MC
P = ATC
markup
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
37/81
Why Monopolistic Competition IsLess Efficient than Perfect Competition1. Excess capacity
The monopolistic competitor operates on the downward-sloping part of itsATCcurve, produces less than the cost-minimizing output.
Under perfect competition, firms produce the quantity thatminimizesATC.
2. Markup over marginal cost Under monopolistic competition, P> MC.
Under perfect competition, P= MC.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
38/81
Monopolistic Competition and Welfare
Monopolistically competitive markets do nothave all the desirable welfare properties ofperfectly competitive markets.
Because P> MC, the market quantity is belowthe socially efficient quantity.
Yet, not easy for policymakers to fix this problem:Firms earn zero profits, so cannot require themto reduce prices.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
39/81
Monopolistic Competition and Welfare
Number of firms in the market may not be optimal,due to external effects from the entry of new firms:
the product-variety externality:surplus consumers get from the introduction of new products
the business-stealing externality:losses incurred by existing firms when new firms enter market
The inefficiencies of monopolistic competition aresubtle and hard to measure. No easy way forpolicymakers to improve the market outcome.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
40/81
Advertising
In monopolistically competitive industries, productdifferentiation and markup pricing lead naturally to theuse of advertising.
In general, the more differentiated the products,
the more advertising firms buy. Economists disagree about the social value of advertising.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
41/81
The Critique of Advertising
Critics of advertising believe: Society is wasting the resources it devotes to advertising.
Firms advertise to manipulate peoples tastes.
Advertising impedes competition
It creates the perception that products are more differentiatedthan they really are, allowing higher markups.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
42/81
The Defense of Advertising
Defenders of advertising believe: It provides useful information to buyers.
Informed buyers can more easily find and exploit pricedifferences.
Thus, advertising promotes competition and reduces marketpower.
Results of a prominent study:Eyeglasses were more expensive in states
that prohibited advertising by eyeglass makers
than in states that did not restrict suchadvertising.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
43/81
Advertising as a Signal of Quality
A firms willingness to spend huge amountson advertising may signal the quality of its productto consumers, regardless of the content of ads.
Ads may convince buyers to try a product once, but the product
must be of high quality for people to become repeat buyers. The most expensive ads are not worthwhile unless they lead to
repeat buyers.
When consumers see expensive ads, they think the productmust be good if the company is willing to spend so much on
advertising.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
44/81
Brand Names
In many markets, brand name products coexist withgeneric ones.
Firms with brand names usually spend more onadvertising, charge higher prices for the products.
As with advertising, there is disagreement aboutthe economics of brand names
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
45/81
The Critique of Brand Names
Critics of brand names believe: Brand names cause consumers to perceive differences that
do not really exist.
Consumers willingness to pay more for brand names isirrational, fostered by advertising.
Eliminating govt protection of trademarks would reduceinfluence of brand names, result in lower prices.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
46/81
The Defense of Brand Names
Defenders of brand names believe: Brand names provide information about quality to consumers.
Companies with brand names have incentive to maintainquality, to protect the reputation of their brand names.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
47/81
Comparing Perfect & Monop. Competition
yesnone, price-takerfirm has market power?
downward-sloping
horizontalD curve facing firm
differentiatedidenticalthe products firms sell
zerozerolong-run econ. profitsyesyesfree entry/exit
manymanynumber of sellers
monopolisticcompetitionperfectcompetition
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
48/81
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
49/81
Comparing Oligopoly & Monop. Competition
highlowlikelihood of fiercecompetition
lowhighimportance of strategicinteractions betweenfirms
manyfewnumber of sellers
monopolisticcompetition
oligopoly
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
50/81
CONCLUSION
Differentiated products are everywhere; examples ofmonopolistic competition abound.
The theory of monopolistic competition describes manymarkets in the economy,
yet offers little guidance to policymakers looking toimprove the markets allocation of resources.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
51/81
SUMMARY
A monopolistically competitive market hasmany firms, differentiated products, and free entry.
Each firm in a monopolistically competitive market
has excess capacity produces less than thequantity that minimizesATC. Each firm charges aprice above marginal cost.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
52/81
SUMMARY
Monopolistic competition does not have all of thedesirable welfare properties of perfectcompetition. There is a deadweight loss causedby the markup of price over marginal cost. Also,the number of firms (and thus varieties) can be toolarge or too small. There is no clear way forpolicymakers to improve the market outcome.
0
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
53/81
SUMMARY
Product differentiation and markup pricing lead tothe use of advertising and brand names. Critics ofadvertising and brand names argue that firms usethem to reduce competition and take advantage ofconsumer irrationality. Defenders argue that firmsuse them to inform consumers and to competemore vigorously on price and product quality.
0
http://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.htmlhttp://../Program%20Files/TurningPoint/2003/Questions.html8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
54/81
OLIGOPOLY
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
55/81
BETWEEN MONOPOLY AND PERFECT COMPETITION
Oligopoly
Only a few sellers, each offering asimilar or identical product to theothers.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
56/81
MARKETS WITH ONLY A FEW SELLERS Characteristics of an Oligopoly Market
Few sellers offering similar or identical products Interdependent firms Best off cooperating and acting like a monopolist by producing a
small quantity of output and charging a price above marginal cost
MARKETS WITH ONLY A FEW SELLERSBecause of the few sellers, the key feature of oligopoly is the tension betweencooperation and self-interest.
A Duopoly ExampleA duopoly is an oligopoly with only two members.
It is the simplest type of oligopoly.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
57/81
Competition, Monopolies, and Cartels
The duopolists may agree on a monopoly outcome. Collusion
An agreement among firms in a market about quantities to produceor prices to charge.
Cartel
A group of firms acting in unison.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
58/81
Competition, Monopolies, and Cartels
Although oligopolists would like to form cartels and earnmonopoly profits, often that is not possible.
Antitrust laws prohibit explicit agreements amongoligopolists.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
59/81
The Equilibrium for an Oligopoly
When each firm in an oligopoly chooses its ownproduction to maximize its own profit, taking the otherfirms outputs as given, they collectively produce
more than the level produced by a monopolyand
less than the level produced in perfect competition.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
60/81
The Equilibrium for an Oligopoly
Therefore, the oligopoly price is less than the monopoly price but
greater than the competitive price (which equals marginal cost).
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
61/81
Equilibrium for an Oligopoly:
Joint output is greater than the monopoly quantity but lessthan the competitive industry quantity.
Market prices are lower than monopoly price but greaterthan competitive price.
Total profits are less than the monopoly profit.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
62/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
63/81
How the Size of an Oligopoly Affects the MarketOutcome
As the number of firms in the oligopoly increases, theprice effect becomes weaker.
As a result, the output effect determines firms behavior:firms feel encouraged to boost production as long as P>
MC.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
64/81
How the Size of an Oligopoly Affects the MarketOutcome
As the number of sellers in an oligopoly grows larger, anoligopolistic market looks more and more like acompetitive market.
The price approaches marginal cost, and the quantity
produced approaches the socially efficient level.
T bl 1 Th D d S h d l f W t
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
65/81
Table 1 The Demand Schedule for Water
Perfect Competition
Monopoly
Duopoly/Oligopoly
Assumption: Marginal
Cost of producingwater is zero: MC= 0.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
66/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
67/81
Defining a game
Formally, a game is a set of 4 elements: a set of players (can even be infinite)
a set of rules (allowable actions and sequencing ofactions by each player)
a payoff function (which assigns payoffs for eachplayer as a function of strategies chosen)
informational structure (what players know at eachpoint in the game)
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
68/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
69/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
70/81
More on Common Knowledge
As we know, there are known knowns. Theseare things we know we know.
We also know, there are known unknowns.That is to say we know there are some things
we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns, the
ones we don't know we don't know. D.H. Rumsfeld, Feb. 12, 2002, Department of
Defense news briefing Common knowledge means that there are no
unknown unknowns.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
71/81
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
72/81
History of Game Theory
Cournot (1838) - quantity-setting duopoly model Bertrand (1883) price-setting duopoly model Zermelo (1913) the game of chessvon Neumann & Morgenstern (1944) definedgames, min-max solution for 0-sum games
Nash (1950) defined a the equilibrium and thesolution to a cooperative bargaining problem
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
73/81
Nobel prize winners for Game
Theory (Economics) 1994 John Nash, John Harsanyi, Reinhard Selten
1996 James Mirrlees, William Vickrey
2005 Robert Aumann, Thomas Shelling
Prisoners Dilemma
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
74/81
Prisoners Dilemma
Two criminals-Bonnie and Clyde-minor crime of carryingunregistered gun- police suspect that two criminals havecommitted a Bank robbery together-but due to the lack ofevidence police convict them of their major crimes-Police question them-deal-choices
1.Lock up for 1 yr.2.If u confess to the bank robbery and implicate your partner,
you will be free. Your partner will be in jail for 20 yrs.3.But if u both confess to the crime, you will get an immediate
sentence up to 8 yrs.
What do u expect them to do?
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
75/81
Bonnies Decision
Confess Remain Silent
Confes
s
Remain
Silent
Bonniegets 8 yrs
Clyde gets8 yrs
Bonniegets 20 yrs
Clydegoes free
Bonniegoes free
Clyde gets20 yrs
Bonniegets 1 yr
Clyde gets1 yr
Clydes
Decision
What do u expect them to do?Would they confess or remain silent?
Figure shows choices. Each prisoner has 2 strategies: confess or remain silent. The sentencedepend of their strategy he choose and strategy chosen by the partner.
1.Bonnies decision: If Clyde remains silent, I will confess, since then I will gofree rather than spending time in jail. If he confess, I too will confess, since
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
76/81
p g j , ,then I will spend 8 yrs in jail rather than 20 yrs.
Dominant strategy (for bonnie). If it is the best strategy for a
player to follow regardless of strategies pursued by other players.
2. Clydes Decision: He faces exactly same choices as Bonnie, and he reasonsin much the same way. (Dominant Strategy)
3.In the end, both Bonnie and Clyde confess, and both spend 8 yrs in jail. Ifthey had both remain silent, both of them would have been better off,
spending 1 yr in Jail on the gun charge.4. Therefore, Cooperation between the 2 prisoners is difficult to maintain
because, cooperation is individually irrational.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
77/81
The Equilibrium for an Oligopoly
A Nash equilibrium is a situation in which economic actorsinteracting with one another each choose their beststrategy given the strategies that all the others havechosen.
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
78/81
Nash EquilibriumJohn Nash equilibrium is a situation in which economic participantsinteracting with one another each choose their best strategy given thestrategies the others have chosen.
For Example, Jill is producing 40 gallons of water, the best strategy for Jackis to produce 40 gallons. Similarly, given that Jack is producing 40 gallons of
water, the best strategy for Jill is to produce 40 gallons. Once they reach thisNash equilibrium, neither Jack nor Jill has an incentive to make a differentdecision.Summery: When firm in an oligopoly individually choose production tomaximize profit, they produce a quantity of output greater than thelevel produced by monopoly and less than the level produced by
competition. The oligopoly price is less than the competitive price .
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
79/81
Normal Form Games
Simple games without timing, i.e. where players make decisionssimultaneously. Dynamic games can be reduced into a normalform.
The set of strategies is simply the set of possible choices for eachplayer.
Normal (Strategic) Form Game consists of the followingelements:
- N={1,.., n} the finite set of players
- S={S1,.., Sn} the set of strategies, including a (possibly infinite)set for each player
- U(s1,.., sn) the vector of payoff functions, where si
Si for eachplayer If the set of strategies is small and countable (typically 2-5), then
we can use a game matrix to represent a normal-form game
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
80/81
Game Matrix
Example 1: Advertising game
N={1, 2}
S={S1, S2} and S1 = S2 = {A, N}
U(s1, s2) = { u1(s1, s2); u2(s1, s2)}
u1(A, A) = 40; u1(A, N) = 60; u1(N, A) = 30; u1(N, N) = 50 u2(A, A) = 40; u2(A, N) = 30; u2(N, A) = 60; u2(N, N) = 50
Player 2
A N
Player1
A 40, 40 60, 30
N 30, 60 50, 50
8/8/2019 Imperfect Competitions
81/81
Thank You
Top Related