8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
1/40
An enemy
within
Page 06
Tough at
the top
Page 14
Tax and
the City
Page 22
The search for
all-rounders
Page 32
HOURGLASSHR
Issue 10 May 2008 Enhancing value through peopl
How does HR remain relevant in a changing world?
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
2/40
Human Resource Services international conference, Boca Raton 2008Changing course: redefining the people frontier
Save the dateOctober 2124, 2008Boca Raton Resort and Country Club
Boca Raton, Florida
The world around us is changing at an unrelenting pacein everything from the economy to the environment. Perhapsbecause of this changeor in spite of it, organizations arecontinually being held to higher standards and held accountableto the public.
Do businesses today have the leaders they need to executeon the strategies of tomorrow? Are the skill-sets needed
to pilot the worlds leading organizations through changereadily available where and when they are needed?How will your organization arm itself for the changes thatare happening?
It is clear that in order to go from vision to execution we mustlook past our own borders for the leaders with the skills to helour businesses connect and succeed. We are changing coursstretching the boundaries, challenging past practices and thusredefining the people frontier.
In this light, PricewaterhouseCoopers will be hosting its annuaUS international human resources conference in Boca Raton
in October 2008. The conference will feature a diverse rangeof plenary speakers and will be supported by a comprehensivworkshop program.
We look forward to seeing you in Boca Raton!
To register your interest, please send an email to:
NY-08-0727 2008 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. All rights reserved. PricewaterhouseCoopers refers to PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP or, as the context requires, the PricewaterhouseCoopers glwork or other member firms of the network, each of which is a separate and independent legal entity.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
3/40
Editors Welcome Douglas Broom 0
Thought leadership without the padding
Hourglass cuts through the clutter to reach the key issues.
As reverberations from the credit crunch continue
to be felt across the business world, with every
development we realise that few of us are immunefrom its effects. The consequences present particular
challenges for HR. As Alex Blyth outlines on page
26, money worries are becoming a major cause of
stress-related absences from work.
The question is how far businesses should become
involved in making sure that their employees are in
a fit state, emotionally and physically, for work. The
sudden interest in wellness at work programmes
suggests that the HR function is at the forefront of the
fight against stress.
This is just one area that amply illustrates the new demands placed on the HR function
in a fast-changing world. The role that HR will play in the future is an issue that is
preoccupying many a HR professional at the moment, as our regular columnist, PwC
global leader for HR services Michael Rendell, addresses on page 4.
HR undoubtedly has much to contribute in these turbulent times and should be one of
the first in line providing advice on future strategy. But as Michael Rendell points out, HR
is facing a perception problem. HR professionals have the skills and experience to help
in times such as these and should be an integral part of the business. The challenge for
HR is how it can communicate that it deserves its place at the strategic centre of the
company and has much to contribute.
We hope you find this issue of Hourglass a stimulating read. We are always delighted to
hear feedback from our readers details of how to contact us are on page 37.
Douglas Broom
Chief Editor
Editorial OfficesHourglassCroner145 London RoadKingston-upon-ThamesSurrey KT2 6SR
Chief EditorDouglas [email protected]
Editorial CommitteeMichael Rendell, Sandy Pepper, Faye Graham,
Andrew Smith and Janet Davies(Human Resource Services, PricewaterhouseCoopersDouglas Broom, Liz Fisher(Croner, Wolters Kluwer)
Commissioning EditorLiz Fisher
Sales
Mark Cleeve
DistributionBarry [email protected]
Design and ProductionPhil George
Published byWolters Kluwer (UK) Ltd145 London RoadKingston-upon-ThamesSurrey KT2 6SR
Tel. 44 (0) 20 8247 1372Fax. 44 (0) 20 8247 1388
Publication SponsorPricewaterhouseCoopers Human Resource ServicesPlumtree CourtLondon EC4A 4HT
Tel. 44 (0) 20 7583 5000Fax. 44 (0) 20 7212 2040
To comment on this issue of [email protected]
To request additional copies of [email protected]
Wolters Kluwer 2008
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
4/40
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
5/40
Contents 0
18
26
29
Looking forward
How can the HR function stay relevant in a changing world?
Michael Rendell
HR risk
The Socit Gnrale affair has once again highlighted the risks companies face from their
own employees. How is the HR function responding?
Philip Smith
Called to the bar Karen Caddick The hospitality and beverage industry demands a steady flow of quality talent. The HR director oPunch Taverns explains how the group meets the challenges of supply.
Hamish Champ
Succession planning
The best succession-planning strategy encourages the steady identification of talent at all levels
throughout the organisation.
Mick James
Leadership
Businesses are increasingly turning to other disciplines to learn what makes a good leader.
Liz Fisher
Tax and reward
Recent changes to the UK tax regime for non-domiciles have shown how politics can affect
long-term HR strategy.
George Yeandle
Stress at work
Money problems are the most significant cause of problems at work. Should employers do
more to improve their workers financial education?
Alex Blyth
Employee wellbeing
Illness and stress-related absence costs business billions of pounds a year, which is why more
companies are turning to wellness programmes.Beth Holmes
Governance
The responsibilities and demands placed on non-executive directors has increased dramatically
over recent years. Is the result a shortage of suitable candidates?
Clare Gascoigne
End notes
The latest HR publications and research
Liz Fisher
Keeping in touch
Description Pa
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
6/40
opic author
Looking forward Michael Rendell
Reality checkWhat can HR do to bridge the gap between its perceived profile, reputation and relevance and the function it actually fulfils? How doeHR remain relevant in a changing world?
04
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
7/40
0
At the end of March, PricewaterhouseCoopers hosted its second HR
conference in Rome for people managers from all over the world. Our
theme was Keeping HR relevant in a changing world, and we explored
the important challenges and opportunities for our industry over the next
few years.
The pace of business change is unrelenting and the challenge of leading
and managing people in a global environment has never been tougher.
Yet some commentators are question ing the role of HR and its abi lity to
influence and shape the people challenges facing businesses now and
in the future. How does HR become more relevant to the business it
serves? Can HR truly take the lead in driving the people agenda?
We have come to expect people issues to be high on the CEOs agenda.
Our 11th Annual Global CEOsurvey showed that it was the number onepriority for nine out of 10 CEOs. 65% of CEOs said that an inability
to access the right skills was the biggest barrier to their business
achieving success, but we were surprised that only 43% had confidence
in their HR function to compete effectively for this talent. The questionfor us is, how can HR become more relevant?
Before the conference, we asked the delegates some searching
questions to kick off the debate. For example, what more could HR do
to attract new talent to the profession? More than three quarters of
respondees thought that raising the professions reputation and profile
would address this. What is the single most important challenge for HR
leaders over the next five years? Attracting and retaining talent was the
overwhelming response.
So, what does the future hold and how can we position ourselves to
take advantage of the changing environment? At the end of last year,
we looked at the future of work and what it might be like in 2020.
In one scenario, traditional HR departments become more and moremarginalised. Nearly a fifth of the delegates at our conference believed
the HR function would be defunct by 2015, yet nearly half believed there
would be a chief of Human Resources, or a similar role, by this date.
What can HR do now to bridge these potential gaps and remain
relevant? Where some people see gaps, others see opportunities. HR
needs to become more focused on the external market, particularly in
the current economic climate. HR teams should be discussing with the
board how they might be affected by the downturn. How will they retain
their talent if things get tough?
Beyond the current economic turbulence, in some markets there is also
the changing nature of global economic dynamics. Traditional routes
for capital flows are being diverted or even reversed. China is now
a major investor in the West, not a low-cost production solution. Al
this irrevocably changes the way organisations manage their peoplfrom where they get their people from, to the terms on which they
engaged.
In an article on succession in this issue, Laurence Barrett of Prude
plc makes the point that HR will be invited to the board table when
HR is recognised and valued for its role. When the HR function wor
effectively in its entirety, the questions around its value disappear.
The challenge is for HR to believe in itself as an integral part of the
business and advise the board in the areas it understands better th
anyone else.
Michael Rendell is global leader of HR Services at PricewaterhouseCoo
HR needs to becom
more focused the external markparticularly
the current economclimate. HR team
should be discussiwith the boa
how they migbe affected by t
downtu
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
8/40
opic author
HR risk Philip Smith
An enemy withinA rogue trader at a French bank has sent human resource managers running to make sure their own systems and policies are in
place in the battle against fraud. But will they ever win the fight?
06
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
9/40
0
History has a habit of repeating itself. When news broke about a 4.5bn
(3.8bn) rogue trader scandal at Socit Gnrale, commentatorsimmediately compared it to the collapse of Barings back in 1995. In that
case, Nick Leeson famously broke the bank betting on a recovery in the
Japanese stock market, losing a cool 827m.
Amid all the comparisons made between the two cases, one fact stands
out both Leeson and Jrme Kerviel (pictured, left), the alleged culprit at
SocGen, had detailed knowledge of the so-called middle and back offices.
In Leesons case he was in charge of both the front office, where the tradesare made, and the back office, where they are checked. Although this was
not the case at SocGen, Kerviel had had considerable experience in the
back office before moving into a trading position.
Following the collapse of Barings, and other financial scandals, moves were
made to ensure the separation of front and back office, alongside numerous
other controls, but with the passing of time, memories fade, and fraudstersspot their opportunities. In the immediate aftermath of this latest scandal,
HR functions in the financial services industry are working alongside theirinternal audit and control departments to ensure the opportunities are
closed down.
One immediate action for HR departments in many financial services
companies was to ensure traders were taking time off at SocGen itemerged that the man at the centre of the scandal had only taken four days
off in the previous eight months. Many organisations, if not all, will have
a policy stipulating that traders should have a two-week break from the
trading floor. The immediate response in the weeks after Soc Gen was toask whether this policy was being properly enforced. A key reason behind
this is that, with a fraudster out of the office, colleagues would be in a
position to value and check their outstanding positions.
It might seem obvious, but such a simple precaution can pay real dividends.Systems can be put in place to monitor not only the amount of holiday
taken, but also when it is taken. A red flag will wave when a trader, or anyother person in a high-risk position, takes their holiday but never fails to be
at their desk on a Monday morning.
This, of course, is just one simple step out of many steps human resources
professionals can, and are, taking to tighten procedures. Which employees
can gain access to which systems is also on the HR agenda, with many
HR departments going through a reconciliation process to understand whoshould have access, and who has.
Sharing passwords is a classic risk, as is the risk posed by temporary staff,
something that has been heightened during the current skills shortage when
staff might not be vetted as thoroughly as they should be. A recent surby Websense, an internet security company, found that nearly nine out
temporary staff had the same access to documents on the company sy
as permanent staff, 62% had used someone elses log-in details and 4
were able to connect a personal USB device such as an MP3 player ormemory stick to their work computer.
The risk of sensitive material being stolen should always be high on thlist of worries, and there are numerous cases where carelessness in th
way data is handled has placed millions of records at risk. This might
seem some distance from the financial scandal at SocGen, but the risk
are just as strong both financial and reputational and made more sby increasingly imaginative uses of technology employed by determine
fraudsters.
This is a two-way street, though, and technology can also be used mo
effectively in the way employees in high-risk areas are monitored. Hi-t
fraudsters demand a hi-tech response.
Phil Beckett, a director at Navigant Consulting, an international forensi
accounting and business advisory consultancy, says there are a numb
of areas where technology can assist in preventing and detecting fraud
First is data analysis, where one looks at the outcome of a fraud and tlooks for traces of it within the data held by the company duplicate
payments, ghost employees and suppliers for instance and how muc
they statistically vary from the average. Clusters and patterns can alsoidentified alongside neural networks, which pinpoint relationships bet
sets of data. Patterns identified from known cases of fraud can then b
applied to future data to give an early warning of problems. The patte
may be good, or they may be bad, but for every cluster there are two tyou need to think about, says Beckett. Why is there a cluster there a
why are there outliers to that cluster?
Technology allows this method to be applied to communications as wetransactions, according to Becketts colleague Andrew Durrant, manag
director at Navigant. You can now mix voice with emails and transact
to look at clusters and outliers. This forms part of the traffic analysiswhere you not only look at content but also at communication patterns
between people and organisations. This will also cover instant messag
and mobile phones, often the fraudsters favourite tools, as content
monitoring in the past was more difficult.
Moving on from this, it is now possible to have live monitoring of netw
which are then subsequently analysed with alerts put in place, says
Beckett. As soon as something unexpected happens, then it triggers investigation. Beckett adds that some of the most sophisticated softw
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
10/40
will combine all of the above with external information sources news
websites, for instance and again look for correlations. But, says
Beckett, the tools allow you to do this, but it doesnt solve anything. As
Durrent says: Before you do this, you need to identify where your high-risk
areas are.
There is of course a danger that over-reliance on technology can create a
Big Brother atmosphere and there has been talk of patent applications
or software that will monitor, among other things, an employees every
heartbeat. Such innovations might seem over the top, but could be
employed if an organisation can see a commercial benefit in doing so.
A less contentious option is to look at some of the softer areas to help
identify potential problem areas. Staff satisfaction surveys, for instance, are
coming under closer scrutiny.
Organisations are now looking into predictive analytics, looking into areas
such as employee survey results to see whether they can be a precursor to
risk occurring, says Christopher Box, a director in PricewaterhouseCoopers
financial services human resources department. Are there correlations
between lapses in security and employee survey results? And once these
correlations have been identified, HR needs to act on them. You need to
equip your managers with the skills so they can understand their staff, so
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
11/40
0
There has been talk of patentapplications for software that will
monitor, among other things, anemployees every heartbeat. Suchinnovations might seem over thetop, but could be employed if anorganisation can see a commercialbenefit in doing so.
that they have a certain level of emotional intelligence. It is about giving
people the skills so they can sense and understand certain situations, Box
says.
Managers and their organisations need, however, to be able strike a balance
when monitoring their employees. As PwC partner Richard Phelps says:
Most organisations at the moment are striving for staff to be engaged
but it is a fine balance with the risk scenario, where you do not want a
huge financial loss because you gave someone too much freedom. Phelps
stresses the importance of the quality, rather than the quantity, of controlsthat are put in place. SocGens own internal investigation into its losses
revealed that some 75 warnings had been issued over the conduct of its
trader, but that these were either ignored or not considered important
enough to warrant action.
Although much of the attent ion has focused on the role of internal controls
and systems, Box believes HR has an important role to play: I would argue
that if there was more effective management of an individual, then the
manager of that individual is going to have a greater opportunity to stop
that person from doing something they shouldnt be doing. Box says that
doing this will not guarantee success against a fraudster, but you will have
a better chance of succeeding if you do and a better chance of preventing
history repeating itself.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
12/40
opic author
Profile Hamish Champ
Called to theAfter a varied HR career that has ranged from banking to broadcasting, Karen Caddick, HR director of Punch Taverns, explains theunusual challenges of the hospitality industry.10
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
13/40
These are challenging not to mention trying times for the UK pub
industry and its customers. Alistair Darlings debut Budget, which
introduced bigger-than-expected rises in alcohol duty, came at a time when
confidence across the hospitality industry was already at a critical low. Bad
weather effectively wrecked many a pubs summer last year, while the
effects of the now UK-wide smoking ban throughout the cold, dark winter
months are being felt in many establishments throughout the country.
Pubs that have previously relied on smoking customers are reporting
declining sales as people stay home and drink beer, wines and spirits
they have bought cheaply from their local supermarket. Meanwhile, those
who do visit pubs must now pay more for the drinks they buy. Economic
uncertainty is denting consumer confidence, and subsequently discretionary
spending on leisure pursuits is under greater pressure than ever. Pubs, to
put it mildly, are finding the going tough.
In such an environment it becomes even more crucial to ensure that a
company has the best talent at its disposal. Recruiting the best people to
run its pub estate, to manage the link between head office and its pubs, andoversee the whole company generally requires considerable effort.
Punch Taverns is the UKs largest owner and operator of public houses, and
knows only too well the stresses and strains that affect the industry.
Formed through the purchase of a portfolio of nearly 1,400 pubs from the
Bass Lease Company in 1997, the group has since grown to become a
publicly-listed business of some 8,500-odd pubs, around 7,500 of which
are operated by lessees effectively independent businessmen and women
who pay rent to and buy beer from Punch in return for operating the pub as
their own enterprise while the remaining pubs are managed operations,
whose staff are directly employed by the company.
Karen Caddick has been Punch Taverns HR director for 18 months and ispart of a team determined to create the best environment for all staff across
the company, whether it be a new member of bar staff at one of the groups
managed pubs found via an employment agency, or a new finance director
sourced by one of the countrys leading head-hunters.
The challenge of finding the right person to run a Punch Tavern pub should
not be underestimated, says Karen. The right candidate has to be good at
running a customer-facing business, a task that requires a whole range of
skills and responsibilities.
On the leased side of the business, new operators are found through a
number of methods, from advertising through to word of mouth. Being the
size we are we get a lot of interest from people. A lot of people come to us,
wanting to run one of our pubs, she says. Punch operates a Recomm
A Friend system, whereby those putting forward someone who succes
becomes one of the groups lessees receives a 500 reward. It helps
reduce agency fees, says Karen. Recruitment agencies are very good
put forward good quality people, but it can be costly.
Finding the right person to become a lessee is only the first step.
Then comes training in all aspects of running a hospitality business,
encompassing the serving of food and drink, health and safety
requirements, law, accounting and financial well-being and so on. We
offer training packages that are designed to bring out the best in a les
entrepreneurial side, such as Profit Through Beer or Profit Through F
says Karen. Beyond the tie, whereby lessees are required or tied
buying certain products from the group, these operations are independ
of much of the groups head office control. Lessees have recently beco
rebranded within Punch itself from retailers to customers. Designed
bar
CV Karen CaddickPrevious career
Karen began her career with Royal & Sun Alliance in 1993. She perfom
several roles while with the insurer, including head of HR for its divisio
More Th>n. She moved to Barclays, where she was head of Employee
Relations and HR Policy, before joining Channel Five Broadcasting as h
of HR. Before joining Punch Taverns in October 2006, Karen was Globa
Director at The Financial Times Group.
Qualifications
Karen is a graduate of the Chartered Insurance Institute and a Fellow o
Chartered Institute of Personnel & Development.
She says:
Our employer brand is really important in attracting key people, and it
important that we focus on building our profile as an employer. We are
doing a lot internally to ensure that we build our employer brand throu
external PR activity, and we also make sure that all of our employment
literature is clear about what we stand for. That is a key part of our HR
strategy. Awards are also very important to us, since again they enhan
the perception of the company with public.
The smoking ban and increasing food agenda has help to improve the
perception of the industry. That, and the fact that Punch has a Leased
a Managed arm means that the career opportunities we can offer to pe
are very broad. We need to sell all of this to increase our attractiveness
talented people.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
14/40
remove the tenant/landlord tag, with all its connotations, the move, Karen
says, aims to give lessees the feeling that they are just that: customers of
the group.
Away from the relative freedom of the leased business, the managed side
of the Punch the Spirit estate has tighter structures in place for its 700-
plus pubs.
Recruits to run the managed pubs are sourced through a core of
employment agencies and, intriguingly, are sometimes poached from rivals
We keep our ears to the ground, and if we hear of someone who is running
a rival companys pub really well we will sometimes approach them to see
if they would like to come and work for us, says Karen. Inevitably, the
company also sources employees from overseas. For our Managed estate,
she adds, we recruit a large number of people from outside of the UK. In
fact, in key areas such as London they are an incredibly valuable source of
labour. We now provide language training to help people to improve their
English.
Punch also monitors other sectors in the industry, for example hotels and
restaurants, to unearth good quality staff. The group applies benchmark
criteria against rival companies to ascertain the right level of pay, bonuses
and benefits for its employed staff.
As with the leased estate, training is a vi tal part of driving the standards
of the business higher all the time. Our Spirit Academy, based in
Northampton, raises the profile of our training across the managed estate,
says Karen, and is all about launching career paths, where possible, acros
the business. We look at the optimum structure for each managed pub
salaries, career progression and so on.
Further up the chain of command are the Business Relationship Managers,
or BRMs. Charged with overseeing the business needs of a number ofleased pubs each, these individuals are often found through traditional
networking opportunities, while the groups regional operations directors
can be found this way or via head-hunters.
But its a small world, relatively speaking, and finding the right person from
within the industry can be tricky. Were all fishing from the same pool
for these people, says Karen. We often try to get a fresh perspective by
looking outside the pub trade when were trying to find a suitable applicant
to fit a role. That said, Punch rarely takes chances: In both the Managed
and Leased business we use the Gallup SRI tool as a way of screening
potential managers to ensure we get the right talent in. We have profiled
what great looks like in these roles, and so we use the SRI assessment
tools to narrow down the talent pipeline to make sure we hire great people
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
15/40
As with any organisation, sometimes the things that seem the most obvious
to maintain are the hardest to keep tabs on. A lot of training is easy to
evaluate, its quantifiable through results, says Karen. More difficult
are things like leadership issues. We evaluate our senior leaders with
twice-yearly personal assessments, and we have dedicated leadership
programmes in place to support and assess these individuals.
Part of this has been driven by the changes Punch has experienced as
a company in recent times. Weve gone from acquiring, acquiring,
acquiring, to being a business focusing on organic growth while getting
a grip on our cost base. We need leaders to shift up a gear and see the
market differently. More accountability is essential, she says.
But what of the top of the companys tree? Some of Punch Taverns senior
management are, after all, among the best paid in the sector. When it
comes to executive packages we benchmark against FTSE100 companies to
attract the right calibre of person, says Karen.
When it comes to hiring in the executive area, Punch looks for people
who can plug gaps, as Karen puts it. It seems that the process can be
exhaustive. With Phil Dutton [Punchs recently-appointed finance director]
we did head-hunter interviews, and Giles [Thorley, Punchs chief executive]
and I interviewed him. Then we got an occupational psychologist to profilehim. We wanted to ensure he would fit the role. Our culture is special; it
emanates from the senior team, and whoever joins us at a senior level
needs to be in tune with that.
Dutton hadnt worked in the pub trade before. He had previously been
finance director at budget clothier Matalan and before that had worked at
supermarket chain Asda. Karen herself had had no experience of the pub
sector, having worked in newspapers and television industries before
joining Punch.
Were looking for people who have the ability to work in the industry and in
our company, she says. It doesnt matter if theyve not worked in the pub
sector before, so long as we believe they are the right person for the role.
Reward packages and bonuses at senior level are linked to financial
performance, while discretionary long-term incentive plans are assess
by benchmarking against a number of listed companies, namely 20 lar
and 20 smaller than Punch in terms of market capitalisation. The long-
term incentive plan, says Karen, is an important retention tool: Like m
businesses, the rewards are high for exceptional performance and they
focus the mind on delivering outstanding results. On top of that, they a
built to deliver over a three-year period and people dont retain them if
leave. That increases the reasons to stay with the company.
While retaining many of its executives for lengthy periods, the group
saw two senior departures last year that demanded a dip into the
senior management pool as well as a rejig of the corporate structure to
accommodate new people and new talents.
But stability is key, says Karen. As we hire people we ask ourselves Ho
long will they hang around? When we see candidate for senior roles it
becomes apparent. We can sense their drive, their ambition.
People can also move sideways at senior level, and far from being a pot
negative, this can add value to the business, suggests Karen. When Ad
Fawcett [Punchs former chief operating officer] left the business last ye
Deborah Kemp moved across to run the operational side of our leased pbusiness. Deborah started her life at Punch on the property side, doing d
and now shes overseeing the leased estate.
So what of the challenges facing Punch Taverns? Crucially its the shift in
culture, from an acquisitive group to one focusing on growing from within.
Karen again points to the slowdown in dealmaking. We could do other de
she says, alluding to a proposed merger with rival managed pub operator
Mitchells & Butlers, which at the time of writing Punch had walked away f
But for now, like I said, we are focusing on driving organic growth.
Were looking for people who have the ability to work in the industry and in ocompany. It doesnt matter if theyve not worked in the pub sector before, so
long as we believe they are the right person for the role
Hamish Champ is business editor of The Publican.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
16/40
opic author
Succession Mick James
Tough at theGood succession is about much more than filling the top job; the best systems encourage a steady identification of talent at all levels.14
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
17/40
Poor succession planning costs money lots of it. A 2005 survey carried
out by the Centre for Economics and Business Research suggested that
poor succession planning had wiped 2bn a year from the stock market
value of FTSE 350 companies between 2002 and 2005. Companies
with clear succession plans outperformed their rivals, not only in the
immediate aftermath of a senior departure, but in the longer term as
well.
Yet many companies s till find themselves unprepared for the unplanned
departure of a senior figure. A lot of things have come through that
work against succession planning, says Jonathan Krogdahl, managing
consultant heading the consulting sector team with Futurestep, a
division of executive search firm Korn/Ferry International. Many UK
companies work on a very short-term and immediate basis compared
to, say, Japanese firms that think about succession planning in terms of
the lifecycle of the firm, says Krogdahl. Theres a perceived need for
flexibility, and an expectation among Generation Y that they will need to
change jobs to get to the next step.
Against this background, the costs o f poor success ion planning are often
overlooked. Theres a loss of intellectual property, damage to client
relationships and to the bonds that hold teams together, says Krogdahl.
Firms need to find a way to make people stay longer, but they put off
having those conversations until theres a sense of urgency, someone
says theyre leaving and they have three months to fix it. But most
people who accept a counter offer leave within three months anyway.
Good succession planning not only saves on recruitment costs but
protects companies against the vagaries of the war for talent. In China
the organisations that are doing better are those that have developed
people internally rather than just stuck expats in, says Laurence
Barrett, director of group resourcing and development at Prudential plc.
In Asia salaries are becoming highly inflated, but you can pay peoplereasonable salaries and they will stay if they can trade off career growth
and development for cash.
The more senior the position, the greater the risk of external
vulnerability. A vacancy at the top is a classic sign a company may get
taken over, says Paul Harper, chairman of the Association of Executive
Recruiters and head of Paul Harper Search. Thats when youre
exposed, when you can seem like a natural target.
Even if an immediate successor is not appointed at once, having a
strong bench and a good acting CEO can be enough to manage the
transition if it has been planned in advance. The problem with
appointing a headhunter once someone has left is the time it takes,
says Harper. People underestimate the time it takes to get the righ
person for any of their key roles. Youve effectively got to pluck out
someone who is at the top of their game; getting the best versus th
second best can make a lot of difference at this level.
This doesnt necessarily mean that an external search is in itself a
of weakness. Often people will use it as a benchmarking exercise
against the internal candidate to demonstrate to the world that it is
the right one, says Harper. Often when theres change at the top
intention is to change direction to get different thinking or new blo
but if you dont have anyone in mind you are massively exposed.
Many companies simply dont have the information to support prop
succession planning. We look at succession planning as the starti
point for talent management, says Grant Crow, UK managing direc
of talent management software provider Stepstone Solutions. A ty
client will be an international player, which might run the SAP HR s
in Europe, and PeopleSoft or Oracle in the US. How do they start to
an overview of that talent and the aspirations of that talent base?
Crow says that UK organisations need to be a bit bolder in their
attitude to talent management: Many management teams have no
even defined what they mean by talent. Or theyve gone down the t
in-the-water route but people dont know they are in the talent p
Crow is strongly in favour of moving towards a self-service appro
to succession planning, in which people can nominate themselves
the talent pool to be assessed against explicit criteria. Its a view t
endorsed by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development:
Succession planning should not necessarily be restricted to the to
roles, but should be extended more widely to look at the career jou
of more junior people, says Vanessa Robinson, adviser on organis
and resourcing at the CIPD. You dont always have to have a verysophisticated system, but you have to be active both to nurture peo
and to see it matches their own aspirations.
Transparent processes and self-nomination make it easy for manag
to have open conversations with their staff and for individuals to se
where they might need to change or think differently about their ca
path. People can waste a lot of effort second-guessing the criteria
needed to progress, says Robinson. However, intervention may als
be necessary, for example where firms are looking to build a more
diverse management team. Certain groups of individuals may self
select themselves out, Robinson adds, so it needs to be done wit
management support, so you can say to people, why dont you put
yourself forward.
top
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
18/40
Succession planning also needs to be considered in a more flexible manner
han simply lining up individuals for roles. More and more people are
not looking for someone for a specific job but for a broader role, for types
of behaviour and competences, says Robinson. You need a number of
people you could possibly put in different roles if the external business
environment moves on. If you start to plan five years ahead, by the time you
get there the organisation will be looking very different.
According to Robinson, one of the problems with succession planning, and
development work generally, is a lack of consistency through the employee
ifecycle.
You get a lot of development at the graduate level, and then it comes back
at a senior level, she says. Its the people in the middle who get less
attention.
Now that the job-for-life culture has been all but eradicated, this coincides
with the period when people are developing their careers by moving jobs.
But even leavers can be included in succession planning. Korn/FerrysKrogdahl points out that many professional services firms such as lawyers
and consultants have become adept at placing and tracking their alumni: If
he career path is away from what we do and towards the client, then why
ry to delay the inevitable? If you let them go in the right way you can have
hem back at some time later on.
While HR can advertise the benefits of succession planning, it is not
necessarily something that can be forced on an organisation. You cant
mpose it on people organisations are complex, says the Prudentials
Barrett. I see this as a line manager responsibility to develop a succession
plan. If as a manager I dont know the market well enough to recruit talent,
f I cant create opportunities for my people, then I havent done my job very
well.
The role of HR is much more about having the expertise to support and
educate line management. Its not a question of saying to your top people
you must go through this process, but of getting to the situation where the
CEO says to you I need your advice, says Barrett. HR doesnt need to
ight to get a seat at the top table we do good work and we get invited.
The important thing is to avoid overprocessing succession management.
Most of our talent processes are very light, says Barrett. To devise a
succession plan is a no-brainer. The trick is to turn that into real outcomes,
he real issue is the quality of the conversations you have with people.
Nor should people see succession planning, or even achieving a particular
atio of internal to external appointments, as a goal in itself. Succession
planning is not a silver bullet, says Barrett. If you choose to go internally,
thats not a problem, but equally if you choose to go externally to refresh
the organisation, thats equally not a problem. The point is whether you are
actively thinking about and caring for a pipeline of talent: if you do that you
need to have a conscious strategy on how to approach talent.
A family problem
A recent PwC survey highlighted the problems of succession planning in
family firms. Well over a quarter of family firms expected to change hands
over the next five years, and nearly half (44%) of those are expected
to remain in the family. But of those firms only 47% have drawn up
succession plans, and only 30% of those with a plan have nominated a
specific successor. While family firms are more than twice as likely as
global firms to appointed a management team composed entirely of
non-family members, six out of 10 will appoint at least one family memberto a key role.
Paul George, a PwC partner who specialises in family businesses,
commented: Many owners are not facing up to the tough choices
involved. There is, sadly, a long tradition of great family businesses that
have failed as a result of sleepwalking into a succession process.
A vacancy at the top is a classic signa company may get taken over. Thatswhen youre exposed, when you canseem like a natural target
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
19/40
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
20/40
opic author
Leadership Liz Fisher
Lessons from theSporting stars and military leaders have become a popular feature of the leadership lecture circuit. But this is more than a novelty
business has invaluable lessons to learn.
18
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
21/40
If you are looking for a practical induction to the essentials of leadership,
you could do worse than start with this years RBS Six Nations rugby
championship. To the surprise of just about everyone, Wales won not only the
title but beat every other team in the contest to win a grand slam, just months
after the same collection of players were unexpectedly bundled out of the
Rugby World Cup by Fiji.
For the past two years, the Welsh team has been a collection of individually
talented players who, infuriatingly, consistently failed to add up to the sum
of their parts. If the rumours are to be believed, too many strong characters
among the players and coaching team contributed to their lack of overall
focus.
It took a new coach, the New Zealander Warren Gatland, to pull them into
shape but not, he stresses, by placing a proverbial bomb in the changing
room. There is a public impression that I am ruling with an iron fist, but
there are only three things I insist on, Warren Gatland told journalists the day
before Wales secured the championship title with a win over France. They
are intensity and quality in training, working hard in the gym and the type ofgame I want us to play. Everything else is up for grabs. Its not a dictatorship.
Provided with a leadership structure that has made it clear who is in charge
but respects the players skills and contributions, and is never despotic, the
team have thrived. In Ryan Jones the team has a captain who commands
respect and affection among the players, but who completely trusts the
guidance of the coaching team. In the space of a few months, the new
approach turned a team embroiled in a crisis of confidence into an unbeatable
force (in the northern Hemisphere, at least).
The contrast with Englands performance over the same period has been
salutary. At the time of their World Cup win in 2003, England arguably had a
similar leadership set-up to the Gatland regime at Wales. Sir Clive Woodward
was seen as an excellent manager of the team, and while the coachingleadership was strong, there was a solid emphasis on collaboration and
mutual respect between coach and players. And in Martin Johnson the team
had a captain who commanded respect and inspired commitment. The end of
the Woodward/Johnson tenure, though, saw England lose their way.
Over recent months, England showed many of the same characteristics and
shortcomings that plagued Wales in the run-up to last years World Cup. The
players seemed to lack a clear understanding of what their strategy on the
pitch should be, and they wanted for ambition and focus at times. It was not
until the young scrum-half Danny Cipriani made his full-match debut at the
final game of the Six Nations against Ireland that England played like the team
of old. That Cipriani runs the game with an authority bordering on arrogance
cannot be a coincidence. He may not be the best type of leader, but at least
the team had one. It remains to be seen whether Martin Johnsons rece
appointment as the England team manager will ensure that the squad re
its focus.
Even if you are not a rugby fan, the respective fortunes of the two teams
raise some fascinating insights into leadership styles and skills that work
and the effect they can have on an organisation as a whole. It is no acci
that some of the key members of the England World Cup team, as well a
many other successful sporting stars, are now sought-after speakers on
leadership lecture circuit. Business and sport may be different discipline
that does not mean that they cannot learn from each other.
Business is different, but its not that different, says Jeff Grout, former
business adviser to Woodward, now an international leadership speaker
consultant and co-author of a number of books that draw on lessons in
leadership from other disciplines. Ive learned some incredibly valuable
from listening to sportsmen, and people from the military, talking about
they approach leadership and their chosen discipline in general.
Grout uses as an example the psychological approach that many Olympi
athletes take to their long-term goals. Many of these sportsmen and
women set a number of interconnected goals, he says. They would ha
an outcome goal, a series of performance goals and process goals. The
swimmer Adrian Moorhouse, who won a gold medal at the Seoul Olymp
and now runs a performance development consultancy, told Grout that h
set his outcome goal to win an Olympic gold at the age of 12.
Winning required a time of 63 seconds, which was his performance go
says Grout. So the next few years were taken up with process goals, w
meant training, working on style, technique and mental performance. It
the process goals that were going to get him closer to the performance
The outcome goal was pushed to the back of his mind and he focused o
the process. That is true of many athletes they only take that outcomeout occasionally and dust it off to get them out of bed on a cold, dark m
when they need to be training. There are lessons to be learned here I
convinced that business concentrates far too much on the outcome goa
the detriment of the process goals.
It is this ability to break down winning strategy and processes, which ha
become more common in the sporting world as it becomes more profes
and competitive, that brings valuable lessons for business. Martin Johns
for instance, talks during his leadership sessions of his view of successf
communication. He divides the communication strategy that went on du
his time with the England team into Big Talk and Little Talk. The big t
was the strategic-level discussions, on and off the pitch, of how the gam
would be played and the tactics that would be used. These were genera
field
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
22/40
set beforehand but could often change during the course of a game because
of the weather, for example, or because the opposition were employing
unexpected tactics.
The little talk was what Johnson calls the everyday stuff that gets
hings done. When on the pitch, he says, he was rarely quiet, constantly
encouraging players, supporting or correcting split-second decisions,
eminding the team of tactics and communicating (along with other players)
he second-by-second judgments that drive a game. Johnson makes the point
hat both forms of communication are essential, but its easy to concentrate
on the big picture alone. Its the little talk that makes the big talk happen, is
how he puts it.
The analogy with business is not difficult to see. The best business leaders
set a successful strategy, but they then concentrate the greatest part of
heir effort in making sure that the strategy is properly communicated and
understood at all levels, that it is being followed and that, crucially, they listen
o and act on any events that may influence their strategic decisions. Johnson
says that if things were going well on the pitch, his role was akin to thatof the conductor of an orchestra the preparation had already been done,
everyone knew what they should be doing and had the confidence and ability
o do it. His role was to inspire them to do their best and guide them should
he tempo change.
nterestingly, Johnson and the World Cup squad also learned valuable
essons from other disciplines over the years. The team spent what Sir
Clive Woodward says was a valuable session with the Royal Marines, which
emphasised the importance of reacting to what does happen rather than
ust merely rehearsing what you think will happen. The Marines made the
point that war is a series of cock-ups, and that is what they train for when
hey jump out of a helicopter in a combat zone, they have no idea what will
happen. Woodward transferred a similar approach to the rugby field, stressing
hat a team may have the best players and coaching team, but the oppositioncould still outsmart them on the pitch. The secret was to react to what was
happening in the game.
Perhaps this is why military leaders are also in demand as leadership
ecturers. The thing about the military is that they practice scenarios they
might face for real and explore everything that could go wrong, says Grout.
They make enormous efforts to replicate real conditions, so there are as few
surprises as possible. The sporting world also makes great use of visualisation
and scenario planning. A lot of business training, by contrast, is classroom-
based, and generally there is only ever a plan A.
Major General Patrick Cordingley, who commended the Desert Rats during the
irst Gulf war, is one of the military speakers in popular demand on the lecture
circuit. Along with other military commanders, he emphasises that no-one
will follow their leader into a life-threatening situation unless they have their
absolute trust, and believe in what they are being asked to do.
Military leaders know better than most the importance of maintaining morale
and mutual trust between leader and followers. Major General Cordingley
says that when he was in charge of troops he would be sure to eat with them
whenever possible, particularly when in a combat zone. The commander
needs to know what the men are thinking, he says, and it is relatively easy
to gauge mood when you talk to someone over breakfast, for instance, and
he has been on guard during the night. I could sit next to him and say, what
were you doing last night? And he would say he had been on guard and did
I think it was going to be alright. And that was very useful because I had the
opportunity to say directly to him that yes, of course it was.
Cordingley and his 5,000 men spent five months in the Saudi Arabian desert,
waiting for orders to advance on Kuwait. During that time he made huge
efforts to stave off boredom among the troops and made sure that they knew
they were as well-prepared as possible, but he also took great pains to makehimself visible and accessible. If I went into an area where I didnt know the
men particularly well and I saw someone playing chess, I would go over and
play with them, he says. It was a bit of a waste of time, strictly speaking,
because it might take half an hour, but if they beat me and they often woul
they would love being able to tell everyone that they had beaten the brigade
commander. Those sorts of things really helped, and I think it is an important
thing to do, although it wasnt studied on my part.
Military leaders are generally (there are always exceptions) more adept than
most at engaging with their men, and work hard to inspire trust and keep
motivation high. Some are naturally empathetic, but those that are not will
have learned through structured leadership training and experience that these
skills are invaluable. They are also skills that transfer successfully to business
some of the greatest business leaders are those that inspire their staff to dotheir best.
The business world is certainly not short of advice on what it takes to be a
good leader. Sometimes, though, the best advice can come from unexpected
quarters. Gatland and the Welsh rugby team have shown that with the right
leadership, a collection of talented individuals can be pulled together to creat
a phenomenal result in a matter of weeks. The ultimate aim of any business
to win so why not learn from the winners?
Military trainers make enormous efforts to replicate real conditions so thereare as few surprises as possible. The sporting world also makes great use ofvisualisation and scenario planning. A lot of business training, by contrast,s classroom-based, and generally there is only ever a plan A.
What Do Leaders Really Do?by Jeff Grout and Liz Fisher, is published by
Capstone Press, price 14.99
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
23/40
Human resourceful
To be resourceful you need access to the right resources.
This is particularly true for anyone dealing with HR issues
as new legislation is coming into force all the time.
The good news is that there is a powerful online resource
that gives you instant access to all the facts with
straightforward interpretation you can act upon.
CRONER-iHuman Resources
In-depth online coverage of HR topics Telephone advice line Step-by-step guides Model policies downloadable and ready for use Employee fact sheets for your staff Sample forms and letters Legislation tracker Latest news Hot topics
The even better news is that you can enjoy CRONER-i
Human Resources on a 3-day FREE trial with no
obligation to buy.
Register for your free trial now.
Youll be grateful for the resource. Your colleagues
will be grateful for your resourcefulness.
FREE 3 day
Croner-i trials
www.croner.co.uk/hray
020 8247 1626
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
24/40
opic author
Tax and reward George Yeandle
Tax and theGovernment policy, particularly tax changes, can have a profound effect on HR strategy. How can you plan for politics?22
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
25/40
Overseas secondments are a vital element of the talent management
programme of most multinationals, and often an administrative headac
for HR managers. The decisions of politicians, however, can have a
profound and sometimes unpredictable effect on an organisations
secondment strategy.
The taxation of overseas workers, particularly at the higher end of the
spectrum, is a contentious domestic issue in many countries. A key pla
for the new French president Nicolas Sarkozy, for example, is to use th
tax system to tempt talented French workers back from Belgium, whic
has a far more favourable regime. The reform of the tax system aroun
shipping sector in Greece has already resulted in companies and indiv
relocating back to their homeland.
In April the issue of non-domicile taxation hit the headlines in the UK, w
the government announced a significant amendment to the non-dom t
regime. The result has been a frenzy of HR activity as multinationals a
the impact of the changes and domestic companies anticipate a disrup
of the flow of talent into the capital.
In the last two years, London has overtaken New York as a financial
and commercial centre in terms of access to capital, its financial and
commercial infrastructure and its vibrant business community. Indeed
UKs attractiveness to businesses and to ex-pats has been undisputed
a long time. But changes to the UK taxation regime look likely to erode
attractiveness and to some minds call Londons pre-eminence into
question. In the aftermath to Alistair Darlings first Budget, the outlook
London as a destination for overseas businesses and business people
looks decidedly foggy.
It will perhaps come as a surprise to the HR directors of international
businesses that moves by the UKs new Chancellor will have an impac
their international assignment programmes. But as of April 2008, peopliving and working in Britain who have financial and business interests
other territories, but have until now not paid UK tax on those interests,
face a much more stringent tax regime than before (see box).
The changes will have little impact on the super-rich entrepreneurs an
business moguls for whom the new flat rate charge of 30,000 repres
small change. It will, however, give pause to the thousands of individu
who are offered secondments to the UK in the course of their work.
For many years, sending high potential employees on secondment to t
UK has been a no-brainer, particularly for financial services businesses
Now the personal financial affairs of those individuals are likely to be t
deciding factor on whether to move them to London or Sydney.
City
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
26/40
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
27/40
received as a blow to Londons competitiveness, but they also represent aloss to the wider global business community, which now faces either added
complications when formulating the pay and benefit packages for those
destined for the UK, or a reduced set of choices when it comes to finding
assignments for their talented individuals.
In and of itself, taxation is probably not a factor that will rule London out as
a destination entirely, but the changes are likely to make HR directors and
senior managers look twice at the UK for employees whose financial affairs
are more complex than the norm. Its a close decision, but the new regime
may prove one obstacle too far.
Tired of London?
The City of London Corporations Global Financial Centres Indexfor 200
rated London as the most successful of 47 financial centres around the
world, and ahead of New York by five points in an index that rates citie
by the quality of their people, business environment, market access,
infrastructure and general competitiveness.
London, the researchers conclude, is in the top quartile in over 80% of
what they consider to be instrumental factors (such as cost and quality
living, access to qualified people, infrastructure and regulatory climatewith particular strengths in people, market access and regulation. And
London benefits from strong inflows of professional and managerial
workers more than half the number attracted to the UK as a whole. T
main negative comments concerned corporate tax rates, transportation
operational costs.
Hong Kong and Singapore were third and fourth in the 2007 index
respectively, well ahead of Tokyo (in ninth place) and two major Chines
centres, Shanghai (24th) and Beijing (36th).
In Europe, Zurich is in fifth place and Frankfurt sixth. Paris is 11th in th
index, only three points behind Geneva. Canadas national financial cen
Toronto acts as major international centre and is in 12th place in the in
ahead of two US cities: San Francisco (13th) and Boston (14th).
The Corporation, which publishes the index, says that research for the
study shows a change in emphasis in the factors that make up a count
competitiveness ranking over the past few years. In 2005, for instance
people and skills issues were rated as the most important factors of
competitiveness, followed by regulatory issues.
It seems more than likely, however, that concerns about the level and
complexity of corporate and personal taxation and other regulatory issu
may eclipse the people agenda in years to come.
Source: The Global Financial Centres Index
George Yeandle is a partner with PricewaterhouseCoopers
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
28/40
opic author
Stress at work Alex Blyth
Drowning in debtMoney worries are thought to be the root cause of poor performance at work. Should employers do more to improve their workers
inancial education?
26
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
29/40
After years of out-of-control consumerism fuelled by cheap credit, the globalcredit crunch has brought the chickens home to roost. The crisis has broughtpersonal debt levels in almost every developed country into the spotlight.In Canada, for instance, personal debt has increased by 36% over the past
decade (to Can$752.1bn). The populations take-home pay increased by just15% over the same period.
Personal debt is at unprecedented levels in all OECD countries. In Australia,credit now accounts for more than 150% of GDP, compared with 25% in themid-1960s. In the UK, personal debt increases by 1m every five minutes. Atthe end of January 2008, total UK personal debt stood at 1,412bn. This wasup 113bn, or 9.1%, on the previous year. On average, every household owes56,708, and is paying an average of 3,775 each year in interest.
The evidence globally suggests that on almost every aspect of personalfinance, from debt through to savings and pensions, the majority of thepopulation in developed countries are under-educated and under-performing.While this is undoubtedly a problem for many people in their personal
lives, it is also increasingly becoming a problem for us in our working lives.According to the latest MoneyExpert.com research, 33% of adults with debtsare concerned or very concerned about their ability to keep on top of theirborrowing. 4.8m adults spend more than they earn and 9m adults just breakeven at the end of every month.
Indeed, more and more companies are beginning to consider whether ornot they have either a responsibility or an incentive to help their employeesaccess financial advice. While there are potentially many benefits to themof doing so, it is also a complex area which is fraught with danger. For theforward-looking employer of today it is an area that cannot be avoided.
The latest figures from the UKs Health & Safety Executive for 2005/06 reportthat more than 420,000 people took a month off due to stress, equating to
more than 10.5m working days lost, says John Hall, chief executive of debtsolutions provider newtomorrow.com. Debt worries play a major part instress at work. It has been estimated that 250,000 of those people takingtime off work did so because their stress was caused by money problems. Itis not only debt that is a problem. Research from Scottish Widows reveals that34% of those aged 55 and over do not believe they have enough savings tobe able to retire at state retirement age.
Serious as all this is, companies have no legal obligation to do anything.James Carmody, principal at employment law firm Reculver Solicitors inLondon, says: There is no legal obligation on employers to educate staffon personal finance. The only obligation is to put in place a stakeholderpension scheme if more than five people are employed. There is not even anyobligation on employers to contribute anything towards the scheme.
Yet, many people believe that it is in the interests of companies to providtheir staff with financial education. Bev Budsworth, MD at advisory firm TDebt Advisor, says: Regardless of whether they are blue or white collardebt can affect an individual physically, as well as mentally, so that theyunderperforming at work and may have higher than usual absenteeism.
Organisations that understand the effects that debt and financial worriehave on their staff can help them by providing confidential help and advishe adds. Staff who are educated in personal finance are less likely to debt and to suffer the associated stress. A happier workforce contributesthe business more efficiently.
Staff that are educated in personal finance are less likely to bedebt and to suffer the associated stress. A happier workfo
contributes to the business more efficien
Case study:
Dunfermline Building Society
Alan Mitchell, HR Director at Dunfermline Building Society, believes thacompanies do have a responsibility to educate staff about financial matMoney worries are never a good thing for anyone to have, and helpingstaff in this area can play a vital part in the morale of the business,he says. It can only improve the relationship between employee andemployer, and it gives employees a way to find information if they do hmoney issues.
Dunfermline Building Society has partnered with the Financial ServicesAuthority to provide all staff with a booklet that contains information onbasic budgeting, saving for the future, borrowing and costs of repaymeacross different types of mortgage. It also covers personal finances in staff training.
Mitchell recognises the dangers inherent in providing advice, and believthat the best way to avoid these potential problems is to partner with aindependent financial adviser. Dunfermline also helps other employerseducate their staff. For example, it provides a savings scheme foremployees at Michelin Tyres in Dundee, through which staff can savedirectly from their wages and receive a preferential rate of interest.
We are keen to ensure our staff are financially aware, and so we provsupport both internally and externally, through our employee assistanceprogramme, says Mitchell. I guess some companies assume their staare financially aware or that it is not their responsibility, but we feel it our responsibility to help in this area, and we dont see any reason whyany company wouldnt at least provide staff with information from theFinancial Services Authority.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
30/40
As well as these operational benefits, providing financial education can
enhance the employer brand. Many people appreciate their employers
advising them in this area, says Marc Hommel, partner and head of
pensions at PricewaterhouseCoopers. However, you need to consider
carefully whether or not it is suitable for your staff. Generally, financial advice
s valued by those who have money to save or invest, and who are willing to
consider different options. If your workforce fit that profile then this can be a
great way to set yourself apart from rival employers.
t is important to tread carefully in this area. Apart from anything else, if you
get it wrong you can end up facing legal action from the very employees
you are trying to help. Carmody at Reculver Solicitors explains: Liability can
arise if the employer ends up offering financial advice that turns out to be
wrong. It is a complicated area and many employers may not be sufficiently
well-informed to try to educate their staff.
Budworth outlines what she believes companies should do: They should
concentrate on educating their staff in how to take a responsible attitude to
heir finances and help them to realise how an irresponsible attitude can leado debt problems. They should also provide practical help with their finances
such as mortgages, insurance, lending and their rights as a consumer.
Companies should employ a welfare officer so staff have someone they
can talk to, in confidence, about their finances, she continues. They
could also consider having in-house courses by teaming up with charitable
organisations that offer debt advice.
Donald McNaught, director at Scotlands largest personal debt solution
provider Invocas, suggests setting up a full-time helpline. Having a debt
counselling service that is accessed through the workplace is an effective
way to tackle employees financial problems and reduce absenteeism,
he says. Such a service can be provided under the brand of the employer
and can help prevent employees taking time off work through stress. Ourexperience suggests that almost half of callers can be put back on track
hrough general budgetary advice, with the rest of callers requiring a more
specific solution such as a debt management plan, refinancing or Protected
Trust Deed.
There are many options for how to provide this advice, and many external
suppliers willing to help you provide it. Whichever route you choose, you
must always ensure that it gives you and your staff what you need. As PwCs
Hommel concludes: Many employers waste time and money providing
advice that their staff dont understand. Some make the grave error of
providing specific investment advice. The solution is to give your staff
generic information in a format that is straightforward and easily accessible.
Do that and you will soon reap the benefits.
Today in the UK
According to campaigning group Credit Action, the following will happen in
the UK today:
Consumers will borrow an additional 310m Consumers will pay 257m in interest The average household debt will increase by over 12.45 74 properties will be repossessed 292 people will be declared insolvent or bankrupt 2,750 County Court Judgements will be issued Bank and building societies will hand out 1bn in mortgages 4,000 fixed-rate mortgages will come to an end 388 mortgage possession claims will be issued 404 landlord possession claims will be issued and 306 landlord
possession orders will be made
Citizen Advice Bureaux will deal with 6,600 debt problems More than 7,716 loan repayments will go unpaid 526m will be withdrawn from cash machines 24.5m transactions worth 1.4bn will be spent on plastic cards
Debt in the USYear Consumer debt Outstanding debt as a
percentage of disposable income
1975 $736.3bn 62%
1980 $1,397.1bn 69.5%
1985 $2,272.5bn 73%
1990 $3,592.9bn 83.8%
1995 $4,858.1bn 89.8%
2000 $6,960.6bn 96.8%
2005 $11,496.6bn 127.2%
Source: Federal Reserve
Liability can arise if the employer ends up offering financialadvice that turns out to be wrong. It is a complicatedarea and many employers may not be sufficientlywell-informed to try to educate their staff
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
31/40
Ill health costsEmployees are waking up to the benefits of effective wellness management. In a climate of pressurised economic uncertainty, it hnever been more important.
29
topic author
Wellness at work Beth Holmes
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
32/40
ll health costs the UK economy over 100bn a year the same as the
cost of running the National Health Service for a year according to
an analysis by Dame Carol Black, national director for health and work.
Her report, published in March, looked at all aspects of the delivery
of workplace health, includes measures such as replacing sick notes
with well notes, stating what work someone with health problems can
actually do.
The shift from sickness to wellness, both in terms of recognition and
management, has been subtle. Indeed, wellness is a relatively recent
ntroduction to the language of business, at least as far as human
capital is concerned. It is one thing striving for a healthy bottom line,
but companies are beginning to cotton on to the fact that the physical
and emotional health of their employees is not only as important as, but
directly correlates to, the success of the business.
Broadly speaking, wellness encompasses all those reasons why staff may
not either be giving their best or actually be present in the workplace,
rom illness to stress to a Monday morning hangover. With the currenteconomic climate meaning that more is expected of employees to help
companies ride the wave of a credit crunch while their personal finances
are being stretched to the limit, the pressures of work are being felt by
most. Add to that the endless media reports of binge drinking, a time-poor
nation fuelled by unhealthy eating in a polluted environment, and its a
miracle anyone manages to function at work effectively.
According to Pr icewaterhouseCoopers partner David Baty, stress is one
element of wellness and one that is increasingly recognised as a problem,
even if it is still difficult to see it happening. It creeps up on people,
he explains. Its an insidious set of small, incremental changes. People
suddenly become aware that things arent right. It could be event-based
or a sudden perception of loss of control, and, crucially, it cuts in to the
broader topic of wellness.
Baty defines wellness at work as consisting of three things. First,
occupational health and safety, including workplace ergonomics, accident
prevention and so on; second, managing ill-health, taking into account
such things as absence through stress, how you deal with the absence,
how it is monitored and measured, and looking at the culture of the
company; and finally, promotion and prevention, which is all about
enabling employees to be healthy on all levels, and helping them with
stress, diet and exercise, plus the cognitive aspects and understanding
about what makes for feeling good at work.
When you consider that even people who are unwell but not off sick
have an impact on productivity indeed potentially a bigger impact than
absenteeism a companys success becomes inextricably linked with its
workers enlightened self interest.
Ben Willmott, employee relations adviser at the Chartered Institute of
Personnel and Development (CIPD), says: Adopting a policy of wellness
management means taking a holistic approach to the promotion of employee
health and wellbeing in order to create enhanced business performance.
Wellness management, he claims, is about prevention of sickness and
absence, rather than rehabilitation. CIPD figures show that absence costs
business on average 659 per employee every year.
Due to the sheer size of the job of managing wellness, more and more
companies are implementing wellness programmes.
But Willmott warns: Attempts to promote wellbeing and manage absence
will be fatally undermined unless they are underpinned by good people-
management and effective work organisation. There is no point providing
healthy eating options and on-site gyms if people are dreading going to work
because of their bullying line manager or because of excessive workload.
So what can be done? In Aguascalientes in Mexico, the authorities have
plumped for fiscal incentives, with overweight police officers being offered
cash bonuses if they slim down. Elsewhere the approach is broader and
perhaps more educational.
According to the CIPD, in the UK almost half of organisations provide all
employees with access to counselling services as part of their wellbeing
initiative. This is followed by employee assistance programmes (31%) and
support to stop smoking (31%). Around a quarter of employers also provides
health screening, healthy canteen options and subsidised gym membership to
all employees.
PwC undertook a review of its entire health-related benefits in 2004 inorder to implement an integrated approach. The firm set up a working
group with members of leading individual workstreams examining sickness
and absence data, sick pay policy, health benefits, long-term sickness
absence management and wellbeing initiatives. It also ran workshops with
representatives from the business to understand how they currently managed
employee sickness.
The result was a completely revamped Health Matter Programme, which
includes Zest for life at PricewaterhouseCoopers a scheme that supports
employee health and wellbeing by raising awareness of health issues.
Activities across the UK include on-site dentists and physiotherapists,
reflexology, massage, meditation, yoga, pilates, smoking cessation clinics,
wellbeing workshops, fit-for-life and desk survival courses. The scheme also
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
33/40
3
provides an employee assistance programme to staff and families and offers
Choices a flexible benefits scheme providing a range of health-related
options.
Jackie Gittins, director in Human Resources Consulting at PwC, is also keento stress that it is not a one-size-fits-all package and that each employee,
wherever they are based, has the right to a tailored package that suits them.
PwC has 37 offices across the UK, she says, and our network of health
champions act as the eyes and ears for what kind of local health matter
activity would be successful.
Accountants Ernst & Young also has a comprehensive infrastructure to
help monitor its people, including private health insurance, annual health
screening, dedicated occupational health professionals and workplace
assessments, along with an employee assistance programme that supports
employees families as well. It also claims to lead by example, with chairman
(and marathon runner) Mark Otty being lauded as the model of a healthy and
balanced approach to life and work.
Supporting our people to achieve their potential must begin at the most
fundamental level their physical and mental wellbeing, says Richard
Jordan, head of employer brand at E&Y. It is only from strong foundations
that they can handle the complex issues and challenges that they face every
day.
All of this admirable and growing attention to employees all-round health
is commendable, but it does throw up some difficult questions. For instance,
do employees still have the right to assert their unhealthiness? It is, says
Willmott, a fine line to tread.
Theres clearly a balance to be struck between promoting health and
wellbeing and interfering in private lives and choices of employees, he says.
Most employees want to live healthier lifestyles, so in most cases empl
promotion of wellbeing will be supported. However, wellbeing can only r
be about positively engaging with employees. You cant bully people into
healthy living. That wouldnt work and would be actively counterproduct
Baty also believes that knowledge is power. It has to be about persona
choice, but an educated one. Choice has to remain the fundamental
principle of this. And he agrees that compulsion is not an option. Argu
compelling people to do something that they dont want to do could be
causing more problems.
Also crucial is the constant evolution of health programmes, claims PwC
Gittins. Using integrated reporting we are continuously identifying key
issues in the workplace. The programme also has links with our diversit
agenda, community affairs and corporate responsibility. It supports our o
business by engaging with our people, giving them opportunity and choi
So what, then, does a healthier workforce mean for the future? Will a st
and healthy workforce build the foundations for, ironically, a more stressfuture in the form of a pensions crisis?
There are bigger forces at play in the pensions crisis than wellbeing
initiatives, says Willmott. It is inevitable that more of us are going to k
working for longer in the future. Wellbeing initiatives will do more to help
employers get the most from valued and long-serving employees than th
will to contribute to the pension crisis.
With employers persistently experiencing difficulties attracting and reta
talented people, then keeping workers happy, healthy, well-motivated an
work can only become more important for employers, continues Willmo
Many employers are already working actively to improve their engagem
their workers, and are reaping the rewards.
With employers persistently experiencing difficulties attracting and retainingtalented people, keeping your workers happy, healthy, well-motivated
and at work can only become more important for employers.
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
34/40
opic author
Corporate governance Clare Gascoigne
The search forAre the increased demands placed on non-executive directors resulting in a shortage of good-quality candidates?
32
8/2/2019 Hrs Hourglass Issue 10
35/40
3
It is relatively rare for a country to claim that it has set business standards
worldwide, but it is a claim that the UK could legitimately make in the area
of corporate governance. The Cadbury report, published in 1992, was a
comprehensive review of corporate governance practice that set out a code
of best practice for company directors. In particular, its recommendation
that company boards should contain a minimum proportion of non-executive
directors was one that was quickly adopted around the world.
A year after Cadburys recommendations were published, Sweden issued its
own report on recommended corporate governance procedures. South Africa
was next, with the King report in 1994, followed by Australias Bosch Committee
report in 1995 and India in 1998. Between 1993 and 2000, more than 18
countries issued their own guidance on corporate governance and specifically,
the role of executive and non-executive directors (NEDs).
Since then, the UK has continued to review and refine the role of non-executive
directors. The Greenbury report looked at directors remuneration, Hampel
at internal controls, and guidance from Turnbull pulled everything together.
In 2002 corporate scandals such as Enron and WorldCom had the corporateworld worried; Derek Higgs, chairman of the investment bank SG Warburg,
was appointed to find out how a similar disaster could be averted in the UK. It
was Higgs that changed the role of NEDs, setting out clear requirements and
responsibilities (see box) and describing them as custodians of the governance
process. This is echoed in other countries in the US, for instance, independent
or outside directors are viewed as the key gatekeepers under the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
There is still a debate about whether non-executives are there as policemen or
to develop the business, says Malcolm Higgs (no relation), professor of Human
Resources and organisational behaviour at Southampton Universitys School of
Management. Good corporate governance can enable people to fulfil both roles.
What the Higgs Report did do was to significantly boost the importance of anddemands on NEDs. That may have helped on the corporate governance side, but
has the increased responsibility led to a shortage of people willing to take on the
role? Yes, according to Graham Durgan, chairman of the NED Association, which
trains people in NED responsibilities and acts as a clearing house for companies
looking for a non-executive.
There are a lot of people who could be NEDs partners of professional
practices, those who work in not-for-profit organisations, civil servants. These
people are all capable and the way round the shortage is through training, he
says.
Not everyone, though, agrees with the idea that there is a shortage of good NED
candidates. I dont see any evidence of it, says Sir Andrew Likierman, professor
of management practice at the London Business School and himself an NE
four organisations. If companies have very particular requirements it may
difficult to find someone, but I see plenty of good new non-execs.
Perhaps the perception of shortage stems from a slowing down of the rate
appointment of new NEDs, according to Sean OHare, partner in the HR res
service at PricewaterhouseCoopers. Boards have gone through a significan
refreshing following the Higgs Report, which said there should be a greate
diversity in boards and a focus on the calibre of non-execs, he says. Betw
12% and 15% of NEDs were appointed new each year for the first few yea
after Higgs; then in 2007 that dropped to 2%.
But, he argues, that is more a sign of the corporate world achieving its aim
of a shortage in good candidates. There isnt a drum beat of chairmen say
Top Related