8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
1/114
"#$%#$& '()*+,)) -./0012#+#3,4,+5 60+)(15*+3 61(7
6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
2/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
3/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
4/114
I JD6C86F 6 D-F KN LHGJ2QED I JGTQ6FJ M=======================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F KO LI"DJ2D6FQC86DE 6 G2ID>\ M ===============================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F KV L-6GC6" 2 D>QHD6CQJFJ M =====================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F KR LJ F:8G>DE SFC 6 GJIGJDC8G> M ===============================================================================================================
I JD6C86F 6 D-F KY L'J8C8-" C82F- M ======================================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F KZ L6"8ETJF> 6 EGC"F- F]J FCD8EFJ M =========================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F KU L6G>-Q2FJ I JGTQ6C- M==========================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F P[ LC"F W8TFG - CGJF M=================================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F PK LC"F F >:E8-" 6 "QJ6" M==========================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F PP L"'- D- D ' Q-8>F-- M==============================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F PN LHD-C HGGT J F-CDQJD>C M =====================================================================================================================I JD6C86F 6 D-F PO LDQCG2G'8EF I JGTQ6FJ M ======================================================================================================================
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
5/114
!GHIJKLMHNJG) %OPIONPQ JR HSP (TUP
C/, @*$)5 ^(,)5*0+ 5/#5 4*3/5
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
6/114
C/, .#), #1)0 3*%,) # )5$0+3 *+&*.#5*0+ 0@ ;0($
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
7/114
%OPIONPQ JR (TUP .ITXPQJIVU
D .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
8/114
7JIHPI8U .NOP .JIMPU-0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B !"#$%&'('()& +',-'&./0 1&234(56&7 8#, 94-:/;(4.
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
9/114
7JIHPI8U .NOP .JIMPU -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B "#$%&'('()& +',-'&./0 1&234(56&7 8#, 94-:/;(4.
7(;,$g)
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
10/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = %OPIONPQ
C/, 2#$`,5*+3c-5$#5,3; 60+.,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
11/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
5 !. h+09*+3 5/, O6) @$#4,90$` #+& 5/, &,5#*1) (
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
12/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
!67/89:;
5 !.\0($ #+#1;)*) 0@5,+ 5*4,) +,,&) 50 7,3*+ 9*5/ *&,+5*@;*+3 5/, .0+)(4,$c.()504,$= 8+ &0*+3 )0B #+ *4
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
13/114
4TIVPHNGW ; 1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, U
C/,$, #$, 590 4#*+ #+#1;5*.#1 ,%#1(#5*0+) 5/#5 4()5 7, (),& 9/,+ 100`*+3 #5 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
14/114
4TIVPHNGW ; 1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
E3-/(BB3..A+B$"%.
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
15/114
4TIVPHNGW ; 1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, KK
C"F WDEQF 6"D8>
E00`*+3 #5 # .048#1.23'#G F("J1"#/
$1./8&"( 7-.$81#/H
6>3%+$&"#.D3'>8( I $'2-/'31/-3-C'/-8#G $4$3"/-&"G J1'3-/4H
;+M 9+$3%&+,.D-L"LM ("3'/-8#.%-2 K-/%.1223-"(.G N?; 7"3-A"(4G $8././(1$/1(" 8F ('K &'/"(-'3H
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
16/114
4TIVPHNGW ; 1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
A+#B&+, *#+,-.&.
D>68DE D>DE\-8-
Q+&,$)5#+&*+3 5/, @*+#+.*#1 /,#15/ 0@ 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
17/114
4TIVPHNGW ; 1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
T,%,10
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
18/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
:=$3%#+,
*#+,-.&.
!69H*7I
5 !.,d#,$"0B 0"0B
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
19/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U
,d#,$"0B 0"0B
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
20/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B "#$%&'('()& +',-'&./0 1&234(56&7 8#, 94-:/;(4.
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
21/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B "#$%&'('()& +',-'&./0 1&234(56&7 8#, 94-:/;(4.
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
22/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B 6040 #&%#+5#3, *+ )*d, *+ &,#1*+3 9*5/
.011#70$#50$)! T*%,$), 4#$`,5 +,,&)! "*3/
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
23/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
24/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B 604
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
25/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B 604
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
26/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B 604
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
27/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 (U -0($.,? 2*./#,1 F= I0$5,$B "#$%&'('()& +',-'&./0 1&234(56&7 8#, 94-:/;(4.
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
28/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = #SP 9 7U5 H. 7$%&'(#
8+ ,b#4*+*+3 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
29/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ
5 H. 7$!(,
:,55*+3 5/, $*3/5
/%" 0"33"(
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
30/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
31/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ5 H. 7$%4%#!%";A$0"&!":
I$0405*+3 #+& &,%,10
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
32/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = (JGHIN_LHNJG 0GTYZUNU!"#$%&'($&"#
*#+,-.&. C/, @01109*+3 *) # @$#4,90$` 5/#5 ;0( .#+ (), 50 /,1< ;0( (+&,$)5#+& 5/, ,.0+04*.) 0@ 5/, .0+5$*7(5*0+ 0@ # 1/-8# /8 VO I :(8F-/ : "+$)$&'
73$ H%"N&$ ;8/'3 E8#/(->1/-8# /8 VO I :(8F-/ Y Wa_M_`Z9 ;8/'3 VA"(%"'7 E8./. 9 W^XMXXX] b"/ :(8F-/ : "($)$&'
E'3$13'/" /%" $8#/(->1/-8#/%'/ "'$% 1#-/ 2(8A-7". /8$8A"( F-T"758A"(%"'7 $8./.
6"/"(&-#" /%" #1&>"( 8F1#-/. /%'/ #""7 /8 >" .837 /8>("')9"A"#
+..".. /%" 2"($"#/'," 8F /%"&'()"/ .%'(" /%'/ #""7. /8 >"$'2/1("7
@./-&'/" /%" $8#/(->1/-8# 8F'33 1#-/. .837 D#"/ ("A"#1" d
A'(-'>3" $8./H
E'3$13'/" /%" #"/ 2(8F-/ F8(/%" 4"'(
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, PZ
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
33/114
4TIVPHNGW;1HITHPWZ (JGMP[HU $PONPQ = 4TIVPH 1NaNGW 0GK 1PWXPGHTHNJG/&0 P
/3143#$+$&"# 8+ &,5,$4*+*+3 5/,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
34/114
%[PITHNJGU (JGMP[HU $PONPQ
:(871$/6".-,#
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
35/114
7IJRNHT_NYNHZ .ITXPQJIV
2#+; 0@ 5/, .#),)
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
36/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, NP
/PY[RLY /NGHU
K= h,,< *+ 4*+& 5/#5 5/, .#), *+5,$%*,9 *) #1)0 #+ *+5,$%*,9 0@ *+5,$
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
37/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, NN
7ITMHNMP (TUPU
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
38/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, NO
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3 b$PHTNYPIc
iLPUHNJG
D 4#a0$ $,5#*1,$ 0@ .105/*+3 #+& /0(),/01&
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
39/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, NV
T*3 T,,
! D$, 5/,$, &*@@,$,+.,) *+ ! 8) 5/,$, 40$, .04
! T0 5/, )50$,) ),11 5/, )#4,
! q:*%,+ 5/#5 #11 )50$,) ),11 5/, )#4,
! X0(1& ;0( )#; 5/#5 5/, .($$,+5 < .6&77 (' (7>
h,; H*+&*+3)
! C/, .0+)(4,$ *+ 5/, .*5; /#) &*@@,$,+5 +,,&) #+&
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
40/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP @ bALHMSPI 1SJ[c
iLPUHNJG
D @#)5 @00& ./#*+ $,.,+51; 70(3/5 # 70%*+, 4,#5]
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
41/114
T*3 T,,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
42/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, NZ
h,; H*+&*+3)cJ,.044,+*0+)
! F%,+ 5/0(3/ *5k) ./,#
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
43/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
44/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, O[
! E,5g) 5$; 50 (+&,$)5#+& 5/, 5$,+& *+ )#1,)= X/#5 97 '3& #)&,-:: )#:6$& (7 (42,&-7(4.R %:-7'(2 .-::#47 3-)& 2#$%,(7&= _[` #8 '3& 7-:&7> 13& #S4&, 3-7 K&&4 )&,/ %:&-7&= -K#6' '3-'>
! 85 ),,4) 50 4, 5/#5 *5 .0)5) 40$, 50
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
45/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OK
7ITMHNMP (TUP 9 b(SPXNMTY 4TGLRTMHLIPIc
iLPUHNJG
D 4#a0$ ./,4*.#1 4#+(@#.5($,$ 9 46$K&, #8 %:-/&,7 3-)&&X('&= '3& (4=67',/>
! X/; /#) 5/#5 7,,+ 5/, .#),_ 13&/ S&,& :#7(4. $#4&/> 13&/ 8&:' '3-' '3& (4=67',/ 3-= .#''&4 7-'6,-'&=R 7# '3&/ :&8'>
! "#) )#1,) &,.$,#),& @0$ 5/, *+&()5$; 0%,$#11_ U&7R '3&,& 3-7 K&&4 - .&4&,-: 4&.-'()& ',&4= (4 '3& :-7' 8&S /&-,7> 13&,& 2&,'-(4:/ 3-7 K&&4 :&77=&$-4= 8#, '3& %,#=62'>
! D$, )(7)5*5(5, G,&73 8##= (7 4#S '3& %,&8&,,&= 23#(2& 8#,$-4/ 2#476$&,7>
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
46/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OP
! X/#5 #70(5 5/, 4#`,$) 0@ @00&_ D$, 5/,; ,b 9==('(#4-::/R '# :#S&, 2#7'7R '3&/ -,& 67(4. '3&(, :&)&,-.& '# ,&4&.#'(-'& %,(2& 7',62'6,&7 #8 ,-S $-'&,(-:7>
!
-0 *) 5/, .04! '(5 .0)5) /#%, )5#;,& 5/, )#4,_ U&7>
h,; H*+&*+3)
! C/, *+&()5$; 0%,$#11 *) )/$*+`*+3= C0 )($%*%,B 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
47/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, ON
7ITMHNMP (TUP g b+NP#NIPc
iLPUHNJG
D 5*$, 4#+(@#.5($,$ *+ W*,5+#4B W*,C*$,B /#) 7,,+ 5/, 0+1;
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
48/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OO
! D))(4*+3 )/*
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
49/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OV
7ITMHNMP (TUP > b-JIYK +NPQc
iLPUHNJG
D .#71, CW .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
50/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OR
! X/#5 #70(5 )(7)5*5(5,) #+& %*,9*+3 7,/#%*0$_ "09 *) 5/, .0+)(4,$ *+ 5/, +0$5/,#)5 Q- &*@@,$,+5 @$04 5/, 0+, *+ 6#+#_ V&::R '3& "-4-=(-42#476$&, =#&7 4#' ,&:/ $623 #4 :#2-: 7'-'(#47 8#, S-'23(4. 1Z> "-K:& (7 - $-Y#, 7#6,2& #8 &4'&,'-(4$&4' -4= 4&S7 2#)&,-.&>
! T0,) 5/, +,9 4#$`,5 1#%, # 109,$ *+.04, 1,%,1_ U&7R '3&/ =#R K/ -K#6' H[` #4 -)&,-.&>
! X/#5 #70(5 5/, 10.#1 )5#5*0+)_ "09 4#+; #$, 5/,;_ T0 5/,; 4,,5 40)5 0@ 5/, +,,&) 0@ 5/, .0+)(4,$_ 13&,& -K#6' F_ :#2-: 7'-'(#47 '3-' 3-)&2#)&,-.& #)&, '3& &4'(,& 4#,'3&-7'> < .6&77 '3&/ -,& =#(4. %,&''/ S&:: K/ %,#)(=(4. %,#.,-$$(4. '3-' '3& 2#476$&, S-4'7> U#6 '&4= '# 7&& '3&-)&,-.& 2#476$&, (4 '3& 4#,'3&-7' S-'23 ,&.6:-, 1Z $#,& '3-4 "-K:& S3&4 2#$%-,&= S('3 '3& "-4-=(-4 2#476$&,>
! T0 5/,), )5#5*0+) /#%, 300& $,.,
! 8) X0$1& W*,9
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
51/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OY
7ITMHNMP (TUP ? bBP 1PNGPc
iLPUHNJG
D H$,+./ )0@5 &$*+` .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
52/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OZ
! "#) 5/, .04 b6' S3-' =# /#6 '3(4ER -' - 3(.3 :&)&:R S3(23 7&.$&4' 73#6:= '3&/ &4'&,c
! qs(*.`1; $(+ 5/$0(3/ 5/,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
53/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, OU
7ITMHNMP (TUP C bAPPI AIPQc
iLPUHNJG
D 4#a0$ Q- 7,,$ .04
! "09 /#%, 5/, )#1,) 0@ 705/ 7,,+ &0*+3_ 13& 7',#4. '-7'(4. K&&, (7 7&::(4. 7:(.3':/ K&:#S -)&,-.& -4= '3& :(.3' K&&, (7 4#' 7&::(4. -' -::>
! X/#5 #70(5 4#$`,5*+3_ 13& 2#$%-4/ 3-7 7%&4' $#,& #4 $-,E&'(4. '3-4 '3& (4=67',/ -)&,-.& 8#, '3-' ,&.(#4>
! 8) *5 # /*3/1; .04 13&,& -,& 4# =#$(4-4' %:-/&,7>
! D+;
! X/#5 #70(5
! X/#5 *+& .0440+ ./#$#.5,$*)5*.) &0 5/,; /#%,_ 13&/ -,& -:: $#=&,-'& (4 -:2#3#: :&)&:R =-,ER -4= 7',#4. '-7'(4.>
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
54/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, V[
! "09 &0,) 5/#5 .04 b&&, b,&S 7-S '3(7 -7 -4 #%%#,'64('/ '# 2-73 (4 #4 '3& :(.3' K&&,(4=67',/ '3-' 3-7 '-E&4 '3& a+ $-,E&' K/ 7'#,$>
! X/#5 #70(5 .010$_ D$, ',,$ '$,9g) 590
! -*+., 40)5 0@ 5/, 7,,$ .0+)(4,& *+ 5/, Qh *) $`B #+& $` )*3+*@*,) )5$0+3 7,,$B &0,) 5/, 1*3/5 .010$ 0@ 5/, 7,,$ )*3+#1 50 5/, .0+)(4,$ 5/#5)04,/09 5/, 7,,$ *) 9,#`_ M&,3-%7R K6' '3& 2#$%-4/ 8(.6,&= '3-' #42& '3& 2#476$&, ',(&= ('R '3& 2#:#, S#6:=4W' $-E& -4/ =(88&,&42&>
h,; H*+&*+3)
! 85 ),,4) 5/#5 5/, .0+)(4,$ *+ 5/, Qh /#) (+*^(, &$*+`*+3 /#7*5)= D@5,$ @($5/,$ *+^(*$;B 9, @*+& 5/#5 5/, #%,$#3, '$*5*)/ &$*+`,$ %#1(,) $` 7,,$0%,$ #+; 05/,$ @#.50$= 85 ),,4) 5/#5 5/, $` .010$ /#) #
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
55/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VK
7ITMHNMP (TUP E b-SPPYPI &PTYPIc
iLPUHNJG
D 4#a0$ #(50 ),$%*., ./#*+B X/,,1,$ T,#1,$B /#) ,+a0;,& /,#15/; $,5($+) 0+ *5) N[])50$, 0
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
56/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VP
! X/#5 #70(5
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
57/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VN
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3F b#ITOPY 0WPGMZc
iLPUHNJG
D 5$#%,1 #3,+.; 4#`,) # K[o .044*))*0+ 0+ #11 0@ *5) 5$#%,1 700`*+3)= C/,*$ .($$,+5
! "09 4#+; 505#1 5$#+)#.5*0+) &0,) 5/, #3,+.; P4 -)&,-.&R -K#6' I[[d .# '# '3& K67(4&77 7&.$&4'R -4= e[[d '# '3& :&(76,&>
! 8) 5/,$, # .0)5 #))0.*#5,& 9*5/ ,#./ 5$#+)#.5*0+_ U&7R &-23 ',-47-2'(#4R ,&.-,=:&77 #8 S3(23 7&.$&4'R 2#7'7 ]f>
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
58/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VO
! q>09 ;0( /#%, #11 5/, +,.,))#$; *+@0$4#5*0+ 50 .#1.(1#5, 5/, ,305*#5, 9*5/ 5/, #*$1*+,) 0+ 5/,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
59/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VV
7ITMHNMP (TUP 33 b/JU[NHTYc
iLPUHNJG
G($ .1*,+5 *) # NV[]7,& /0)
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
60/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
61/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VY
:PGPITY 1LXXTIZ (JXXPGHU
C/, .#+&*, )/0(1& @(11; #&&$,)) 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
62/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VZ
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3@ b,e:IJMPIZc
iLPUHNJGC/, .1*,+5 *) # 3$0.,$; )50$, ./#*+ 5/#5 *) .0+)*&,$*+3 9/,5/,$ 0$ +05 5/,; )/0(1& ,+5,$ 5/, ,4,$3*+3 8+5,$+,5]7#),& 3$0.,$; )/0
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
63/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, VU
8+5,$%*,9,$? \0($ 3(,)) *) .0$$,.5= Q),$) 0@ 5/, 8+5,$+,5 &,1*%,$; );)5,4 #$, 5;
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
64/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, R[
6#+&*,? C/0), #$, )04, *4
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
65/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, RK
7ITMHNMP (TUP 36 b.JIXLYT 7IJKLMPIc
iLPUHNJG
C/, .1*,+5 *) # 4#+(@#.5($,$ #+& &*)5$*7(50$ 0@ *+@#+5 @0$4(1#= C/,; ),11 5/,*$
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
66/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, RP
8+5,$%*,9,$? -($,= G7%*0()1; 5/, 5;
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
67/114
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, RN
6#+&*,? G`B )0 +09*+3 5/#5 # .0+5$#.5 *) ),%,$#1 ;,#$)B )#; VB 9, .#+ 7,3*+ 50 3,5 # 505#1 &011#$ %#1(, @0$ 5/, .0+5$#.5= 8@ 9, `+09 /09 4#+; X86$,.*
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
68/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
69/114
"#$$&4'-'#,0 C&,& '3& "-4=(=-'& 3-7 =#4& 7&)&,-: '3(4.7> G(,7'R '3& "-4=(=-'& 3-7 7'-'&= '3& #)&,-:: #KY&2'()&R )-:6& 2,&-'(#4> B&X'R '3&2-4=(=-'& 7'-'&= '3& $&'3#= #8 S-:E(4. '3,#6.3 '3(7 %,#K:&$R :##E(4. -' ,&)&46& K/ 67(4. - $-,E&' &2#4#$(27 -4= 2#$%&'('()&
%#7('(#4 8,-$&S#,ER '3&4 :##E(4. -' 2#7'7>
13& "-4=(=-'& %,#)(=&= - ,#-=$-%> B#S '3& (4'&,)(&S&, 64=&,7'-4=7 '3& -%%,#-23 -4= &X%&2'&= =(,&2'(#4 #8 56&7'(#4(4.> 13(7
3&:%7 '3& (4'&,)(&S&, 64=&,7'-4= '3& 7'6=&4'W7 '3#6.3' %,#2&77 ! 3#S 3& #, 73& '3(4E7 '3,#6.3 K67(4&77 %,#K:&$7>
8+5,$%*,9,$? C/, 0%,$#11 #+5*&,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
70/114
8+5,$%*,9,$? 60$$,.5=
6#+&*,? X/#5
9:7#R 4#'& '3-' '3& "-4=(=-'& (7 =#(4. $#7' #8 '3& '-:E(4.> a7& '3& (4'&,)(&S&, '# 2:-,(8/ 56&7'(#47 #, %,#)(=& (48#,$-'(#4R K6' '3&"-4=(=-'& $67' :&-= '3& =(72677(#4>
6#+&*,? h+09*+3 5/#5 0($ $,%,+(,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
71/114
9#+5 50 ),, 9/#5 #$,# 9*5/*+ 5/, .0)5 )5$(.5($, *4
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
72/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
73/114
8+5,$%*,9,$? GhB #+& 9/#5 #70(5 5/, 5/*$& 0
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
74/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3g b1MJHMS 4TGLRTMHLIPIc
ATMVWIJLGK
X, /#%, 7,,+ .0+5#.5,& 7; # 1#$3, &*)5*11,& )
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
75/114
-STH QJLYK _P ZJLI [IJMPUU HJ KPOPYJ[ T GPQ UHITHPWZk
! I0)*5*0+ D)),))4,+5 L*=,= (+&,$)5#+& )0($.,) #+& &$*%,$) 0@
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
76/114
-STH XNWSH _P UJXP JR HSP IPTUJGU HSTH ZJL QJLYK "%# QTGH HJ TMMP[H HSNU [IJlPMHk
! I01*5*.)
! >05 .044*55,& 50 %#1(,
! E00`*+3 @0$ ).#
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
77/114
-STH VNGK JR TGTYZUNU QJLYK ZJL MJX[YPHP HJ fLTGHNRZ HSP IPKLMHNJG NG GLX_PI JR UMJHMS KINGVPIUk
! J,%*,9 .,+)() 90$`
! 604
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
78/114
! P[o *+ 109],+&B R[o *+
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
79/114
! "09 /#%, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
80/114
-SZ STU JLI TKOPIHNUNGW PRRPMHNOPGPUU _PPG [JJIk
! X, &0+g5 )
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
81/114
!R JLI WJTY QTU HJ XTVP XJGPZ\ TGK GJH GPMPUUTINYZ HJ WTNG;XTNGHTNG XTIVPH USTIP\ QSTH XNWSH _P UJXP TYHPIGTHNOPUk
! J,@0$4(1#5, 5/,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
82/114
-SNMS JR HSPUP QNYY _P PTUNPUH RJI HSP MJX[TGZ HJ NX[YPXPGH TGK QSZk
! 8) 5/*) 5/, 1#$3,)5 7$#+& @0$ 5/, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
83/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3> b$PWNJGTY jPH (JI[JITHNJGc
!GNHNTY /TGKJLH RJI !GHPIONPQPP)
J,3*0+#1 S,5 60$
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
84/114
8+*5*#1 "#+&0(5 @0$ 8+5,$%*,9,, L.0+5=M
N&.(#4-: k&' "#,%#,-'(#4 M,#8('-K(:('/ K/ b67(4&77 ?Ffff@
jPH ,GWNGP 0NIMITRHALUNGPUU
7IJ[PYYPI 0NIMITRHALUNGPUU
0XJLGHbmXXc
n JR#JHTY
0XJLGHbmXXc
n JR#JHTY
J,%,+(,) pYN[ K[[o pPPV K[[o6G:- pLVZZM LZ1Mo pLZRM LNZMo-:mD pLZOM L1PMo pL1RM LYMo
T,1*%,$; m G5/,$ pLOPM LRMo pLZM LOMoC#b,) LO[oM pLKVM LPMo pLORM LP[Mo >,5 8+.04, pK [o pRU NKo6#> 6Fn
B#'&0 9776$& =&K'!'#!'#'-: 2-%('-: #8 e[`
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, Z[
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
85/114
!GHPIONPQPI8U &NUMLUUNJG :LNKP
(TUP 1LXXTIZ bRJI !GHPIONPQPIU JGYZc
J,3*0+#1 S,5 60$
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
86/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
87/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
88/114
!+2 %OPITYY (JX[PHNHNOP 7JUNHNJG
D6&7'(#4 8#, '3& 7'6=&4'0 O#&7 3&l73& '3(4E '3-' '3& 2#$%-4/W7 #)&,-:: 2#$%&'('()& %#7('(#4 (7 -=)-4'-.&=R =(7-=)-4'-.&= #, -' %-,('/c
D+)9,$? J,3*0+#1 S,5 *) .04
! M#'&4'(-: -:'&,4-'()& oI0 N&.(#4-: k&' '# (42,&-7& ('7 4&.#'(-'(4. :&)&,-.& )(7!-!)(7 -(,2,-8' :&77#,7 K/ &4'&,(4. '3& -(,2,-8' :&-7(4. $-,E&'>
!
D)` 5/, )5(&,+5 9/#5 ,; ^(,)5*0+) /,c)/, 90(1& ),,` 50 #+)9,$ *+ 5/, ,%#1(#5*0+ 0@ 5/*) #15,$+#5*%,= q-,, &*).())*0+ 7,109r! P'3&,7c
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, ZO
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
89/114
M#'&4'(-: 9:'&,4-'()& oI0 h4'&, '3& 9(,2,-8' A&-7(4. L-,E&'
+#$& 8-2'7 '# 73-,& S('3 '3& 7'6=&4'0
! 13& Y&' &4.(4&R ,&.(#4-: -(,2,-8' :&-7(4. $-,E&' (7 :-,.& -4= .,#S(4.
!
! 13& -(,2,-8' :&-7(4. $-,E&' (7 %,#8('-K:& S('3 '3& -)&,-.& 2#$%&'('#, .&4&,-'(4. NPh7 #8 pF\` ?2#7' #8 &56('/ pF[`@>
! 13,&& -(,2,-8' :&77#,7 ?-:7# N&.(#4-: k&'W7 267'#$&,7@ =#$(4-'& '3& $-,E&' S(73 - 2#$K(4&= 73-,& #8 _\`>
! 13& E&/ =,()&, #8 %,#8('-K(:('/ (7 2#7' #8 864=7>
! N&.(#4-: k&' 26,,&4':/ %,#)(=&7 )&4=#,! #, $-468-2'6,&,!8(4-42(4. #4 - )&,/ :($('&= K-7(7 (4 '3& 8#,$ #8 :&-7&7>
! N&.(#4-: k&' S#6:= K& -' %-,('/ (4 '&,$7 #8 2#7' #8 864=7>
!
N&.(#4-: k&' 3-7 $-,E&'(4. ,&:-'(#473(%7 S('3 -:: -(,2,-8' &4=!67&,7 S3# -,& :&-7(4. '3&(, -(,2,-8' 8,#$ '3& 2#$%-4/T7 -(,2,-8' :&77#,267'#$&,7> N&.(#4-: k&' S#,E7 S('3 '3&7& &4=!67&,7 '# 3&:% '3&$ 2#48(.6,& '3& %:-4& =6,(4. '3& 8,#4' &4= #8 '3& 7-:&7 %,#2&77>
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, ZV
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
90/114
9==('(#4-: C-4=#6' 8#,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
91/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3? bAINHNUS #NXPUc
(TUP ATMVWIJLGK)
\0(g$, # +,9 ),+*0$ )5$#5,3; #))0.*#5, #+& /#%, a()5 @*+*)/,& ;0($ 0$*,+5#5*0+ 5$#*+*+3= \0( #$, *44,&*#5,1; #))*3+,& 50 0($ '$*5*)/ C*4,) 5,#4=
C/, '$*5*)/ C*4,) *) #+ (
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
92/114
! '$*5*)/C*4,)=.04 *) # ) r
"'- 6#), 8+5,$%*,9 :(*&,B I#3, ZZ
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
93/114
!GHPIONPQPI):00&= C/,; &0 )04, 0@ 5/#5 #1$,#&; 7(5
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
94/114
C/,$, #$, #
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
95/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3C b(SNYKIPG (YJHSPU ,e$PHTNYPIc
7TIH 3)
(TUP 1NHLTHNJG)
85g) # H$* #@5,$+00+= \0(g%, a()5 #..,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
96/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
97/114
6()504,$)?
! X/0 #$, 5/, .1*,+5g) .()504,$)_
! X/#5 *) 5/, %#1(,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
98/114
7TIH @)
iLTGHNHTHNOP 0GTYZUNU)
D@5,$ )
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
99/114
7JUUN_YP $PU[JGUP
D))(4, 5/, ./*1&$,+g) #
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
100/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP 3E b(JGULXPI 7IJKLMHUc
(TUP 1NHLTHNJG
85g) 20+ 40$+*+3 #+& #) # +,9 I$*+.*
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
101/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
102/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP @F b#SP +NKPJ 1HJIPc
iLPUHNJG TGK ATMVWIJLGK !GRJIXTHNJG)
C90 7()*+,)) )./001 .1#))4#5,) 1#(& 5/,*$ ,+5$,,,&1,)) 50 )#;B ,#./ 5*4, ;0(4,,5 (< @0$ )0.*#1 0..#)*0+)B 5/,; )/#$, 9*5/ ;0( L40)51; 9*5/ 50+3(, *+ ./,,`M 5/,*$ )(..,)) #+& # e8 501& ;0( )0e #55*5(&,= \0( /#+&1, 5/,*$ a#7)9,11B #) ;0( @,,1 ;0( /#%, /#& # 5,$$*@*. ,b
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
103/114
C/,), ,; (,)5*0+) 9*11 3,5 7,/*+& 9/#5 *) /#
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
104/114
q",$, 5/, )5(&,+5 )/0(1& 7,3*+ 50 5/*+` #70(5 /;
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
105/114
1LXXTIZ (JXXPGHU
C/,$, *) +0 0+, $*3/5 9#; 50 #
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
106/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
107/114
C/,$, #$, 4#+; 9#;) 8 .0(1& 5,)5 4; /;
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
108/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP @@ b/A1 TU T ALUNGPUUc
iLPUHNJG TGK ATMVWIJLGK !GRJIXTHNJG)
\0( #$, T,#+ 61#$`= D 9,#15/; 7,+,@#.50$ /#) .04, 50 ;0( 9*5/ 5/, +,9) 5/#5 )/, 9*11 3*%, "'- pK[[ 4*11*0+= C/, 3$#+5 *) .0+5*+3,+5B /09,%,$B
(
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
109/114
T,#+ 61#$` 4()5 @0.() 0+ 4#*+5#*+*+3 5/, $,
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
110/114
7ITMHNMP (TUP @6 b.TUH .JJK $PUHTLITGHc
iLPUHNJG TGK ATMVWIJLGK !GRJIXTHNJG)
-*b 40+5/) 0(5 0@ "'-B # @$()5$#5,& .1#))4#5, .#11) ;0( 50 .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
111/114
1LWWPUHPK ],hMPYYPGH] $PU[JGUP)
X/#5 &0 ;0( 4,#+ 7; e10)*+3 40+,;e_ "#%, C#S S#6:= /#6 .&' - =&&%&, 64=&,7'-4=(4. #8 '3&(, )-:6& %,#%#7('(#4c
H*$)5B 8 90(1& %*)*5 #+& 1,#$+ ,%,$;5/*+3 5/#5 8 .#+ @$04 9/#5 8 ),, #+& ,b
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
112/114
&,5,$4*+, /09 4#+; 0@ 5/, .()504,$) #$, @0$4,$ 7($3,$ .()504,$) 7(5 +09 #$, ,b.1()*%,1; ./*. ,+ .()504,$)B %,$)() /09 4#+; %*)*5 705/B #+&/09 4#+; #$, .04
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
113/114
8/12/2019 Harvard Businness Case Book - Consulting
114/114
Top Related