7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
1/19
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
2/19
91
The Folly of Unity
The fact is so widely known that few make the effort
bu : C (3.7 qu ),
bu ppu u , ug bu 20 p ppu. I
g up C ppu ju pg
pb, bu I xp ,
C, Bz, Ru, g Ig S
gb . C ug bu-
p gp b. Bu
b u, b pvg b - p v, xp, -
g.
Chapter 6
Can China Be Governed?
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
3/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E92
u u b W
C v - ug v
u bv. I, gu upp C
xp u qub. :
upp u . Bu bgju b C , u p u
u , up b g p-
v. B, p u
b. Ag p, 1916 1927
1937 1949, C v v . -
gu gu. gug v p-
u , bu xp gup g gug. Mv, C-
, Bjg, p b ppu, p
u u.
uu gu g g, bu C
uu p qu -v z
50 pup b
v b bu v. u C -p v C . F ug u
C u pg v Bjg
gv g g j b, u
uu u b b .
W u g, xp, L b, Gu,
u, u b
u p p b H gup, b , u
z Mu b p
Sz. H C up , ,
uu g u p p bu uu
upb.
N ub, p, , p -
u vb p v gv C u . I , p p-
u g v b v u v
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
4/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 93
pb v Mu, Mg, b-
. I p u x u p,
, p . I , g, b-
u u v p u.
Bu , p, p b g u, p bv .
pv j x u , xp g
p, ug p.
pv j up uu
z, , pg vv,
u u p
. , u pv b pu gbg pv.
Fu, pv, gu v
b p , b
p C, v uu p,
x vgu CCP v
. I pv H, p v u-
, v g uu p p, u-pb u
C p b gb-
g .
, u u, bu p
bg x p pu
ug p pp bu u
b b pv g. Dpg u , p , ,
g u ub vg. N , gu-
, u p vp v pg -
p. W gv g
, u pv ppu. Bu
p pp b p, b
u.Ov, C p u b upp v CCP
, b pj p puu,
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
5/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E94
b p bu u: , b
p , g u, Jp. I u
bu u u, bu p b
ub u u
p u qu .Uu, ubj bu pub u p-
b, bu u z p g. I
b p b u C -
u uu u. g
p u b b b Ugu , Bjg
xp pg u qu, b b :
p Gug u p, p u b u ug -
. u u p u
g. g p , bu b
g .
Will the Provinces Obey?
u b p
p, v b ug
g v u p, ,
, v p pp p -
. gu pv-
up, p u z p b Dg Xpg u p
g. pgv
pv u b qug uz
b g ug Bjg. I , g
pp p u p x
p u, bu
ugg u upp v . W g p, ppu p-
v up v
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
6/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 95
u g . I
g u v b ub pb
u pg bu; b b
j Pbu CCP up
v v v pv.Sv u u g pub
u p v pv b
g , ggg p vg
, bu z. Bu u pp-
p ug u g xp,
p v ppu bu p b u-
pu ub , u g bu . u
v v g u qu jg
WO, bu vv .
Bu u pb , bu g
pv p g, g u p,
p v g v u.
p pb gv, p g pp. I Cg
CCP 2007, v, p g p,
Db 2007 g C C
u u gg v . W b
u bz? W b pb v b-
b ? H p z
pp C uvv uz g p v? A p
, pb qu.
An All-Powerful but Aging Party
u u u b g CCP g
p-C bu v p pp
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
7/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E96
. gv p,
, bu vg p g b-
b b up.
pb
u vp p ug b ju b pub b g g, v -
u . u b vu,
u gg v v. Cg
p . Sub p v b g v
v. u g ug
g-v x, u p -
v pp. x pub p. Ep u-
v gu ub
b, p qu v v -
pvg.
A pv g , bu
g, pz v b pg
p. p v gg u- v , bu g b
b p. M p
v p b b p.
ju, xp, u jug, jug u
, b g pp p:
ub v b Sup Cu
g v jug. Pu p vg u ug upp
g x u v.
g z b M p.
Y p g g pubz u-
v u pu
v g CCP u-
v . p p , ug M Ju Fg M. g
g p p g p
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
8/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 97
v b p b
g v: u W ub
p gu v v .
I , g p gu v v p
u vu p. I p up ug v pu .
u up g b : xp, p-
p uv up, ug v
I v b b v u -
. ub g g up b
vgu v pubz Hu J
p. I , v bug pu g, :
v v up u . Bu
ub. I g p
b pubuu vg bg
, u p p
v v px p.
Bu ug CCP v p, -v p g v pg , -
, v v, v u v ubj u-
b pg, p u, g:
v u, v pvu ub
p, p. Ev qu g
pJp, N K, Ip -g b
v b v p g. A -, vg p
v b pp Fg M.
L , p xp p pv
p g bz bu-
u u. I ppg v pp ,
, , v u ug Bjg S-
A C 2006, ugg -b A gu v b x
u p p,
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
9/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E98
p, u v up b: hutongs, -
b g. Exp
b , p g . I
Bjg, ug b p u p-
b.A j vp, u u p b
pp uv gu pb p,
u gg ppu pu v g
x . gg xp p-
u uu . I xp p -
ppu u xp, p-
p Fu Gg Ap 1999 SARS p pg 2003. I u , v v, p
up g gup
p up v, bu b g p .
I g u p, -
b, g p, g. O -
u, u qu v p,
gu g p g. p buu pu u
gv .
A Bureaucratic Elite, a Cumbersome Apparatus
CCP p p vu u.I u u pp b b-
. N u p b v -
v. O b b CCP
g bg ,
pu g. F xp, p uu -
b g b u20 p u
u Qgu Uv, xp g p vg g . Bg u b p g-
g g, , .
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
10/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 99
Bu g pp. g ,
- , p g
xg g , u p ju
gb Su, up
u pub b v g g. O u x b
p v b v p p. A ug
pp C v xub v -
: xp, uv p g-
u u j p g g pv C
uvp .
G pg, p zv- b C Cu P p . O 32.5 p
b p 11.5 p , 30 p v
b uv. I p pp
b. Bu g ub p : -
g 2003 uv, quv pg u Bjg62
60 p pv j
p.
Cp g M, g u v
g uqub pv
. Egg u p ug -
g. I g g v ,
p qu: -
Pbu v g, ug X Jpg L
Kqg, b u Hu J b .
Hv, ,
vg p. Ev uv, uu p
buu u: u g p
gz . Sub-
qu, u b p pp, ug
v u, pg ,
, , pv, u vp v g qu bp
pg. I Pbu,
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
11/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E100
g buu g uub
gv. I , g j v b xp-
g qu u
g . b
pp pup pv pub u u p.
B u p, buu ju
ub: p u p up b
g - v, bu uv -
p p g v . ub
v v u g, 2005
pp u v -x u-. p p u g
ppg , bu ju ,
pv pp : u ug
, p b v -
, ppg, g . A
, uu vg ub -
gz g , v Bjg -gz uu v , .
Ov, C Cu P v p p-
v g v, p
g u gg u u b
u: ub-
ppu. u : upp -
g p p .
A Dangerous Aristocracy
u g p, u u g-
z p g p g v
p-M CCP j j p.I p g . I , v, , -
v g u .
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
12/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 101
Sv g v u b v
p , p p ,
v pvg p p . F xp, Hu
J , Hu Hg, u p 2006, b ,
upp u C p.C Jg Z, L Pg, W Jb, g C
Yu , bg v M g, u p -
p. I pv pvg
v b b
p.
p p, g,
g p g p p. p u, Eg-pg pb,
v p xp, , p,
g p . Bu p
v. F xp, Zjg
Eup, p F G B,
v U S.
p p v v v . b u
g ug 1990 up u
qu ; , j up
.
A pvg , j pb ppu
vg. I C g, u p: p u-
, uu pu. S 1980, j pv
p j g C . F xp, C
Yu, C Yu, p bg
: B C
Dvp B.
F , b bv p
v ug L Pg, p pg 1989, p Zu E. g g, v,
p v pp g
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
13/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E102
v p. M g pv p,
C C b Sv
Cg, v g b P-
bug ub M Jg
Qg. A g v, ug Zg Qgg, p M, , b-p u Hu
J, X Jpg, X Zgxu, pug b
M Zg p b Dg Xpg
p pg. S pu pu,
Dg Xpg: ug b C
C. A Z Zg, u Hu Y-
bg 1989, 2005, b g u. b pu p
Dg Xpg , gp v
up g upb L Hu Bjg.
b u, b v g
u u C pub p. I v ,
g uv, I v ppu
b B X, B Yb, , -b , b g Cgq-
g. S u, p pbb
g uv b pv -
, u p bg u.
I , pp v , bu
g Sg , g
Hu J. Bu x u p p g gu-
g xv .
M p, b p
u b ubj ub. I,
ug, , L Kqg bv
b u. I b-
v C g v . Ag u Hg Kg, 8,371 b CCP , g
Jp u, u u up v v v
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
14/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 103
C , g $50 b: v
v v, ,
u v g pp -
. u ug A
19971998 xp , ug SARS - 2003,
ppu. I , pbb b
u pu v p gb b
p bu p u-
p b U S.
Is There a Pilot on the Plane?
u p ubg, bu
g g. I p-
b, ,
p . v Zg,
pp g pv: ug SARS p, Hu J upp
b C Yu u
b . I xp, Hu Dpg,
G S CCP Hu Ybg, gu v Hu
J, 1980.
Hu J v u , v
p ug. Bu vu gu CCP. Hu qu qu. H
g u b b qu xp
u pg pbb b pb p
C . H uvg uqub: -
bg b p Dg Xpg gu, u
pg u Jg Z 1992, b-
g b u Jg p, b g, 20022004. Dug p u u Sg-
b bg p Zg Qgg,
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
15/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E104
upp Jg C-
C, bu bup v u
Sv Cg g Zg.
W qu Hu J b b b
gu p ppu. I , Sv C-g v v Sg
p v p p
u. I u ,
b , L Kqg, bu p u b
Sg, X Jpg, ub uu pp
Hu p.
Hu J p pu v pp
Pp Rpub C, Jg Z. B Sg,
b p gvg p xp,
bg g, bu p p vv
bv vg b p
bu C, , Ygz C . I ,
j , -g pv . pp p-
g j . O v , xp,
pv u Gugg v j g
u vg. O , px v
b pu v g pu pv: pp,
xp, u p, Dg
Xpg, v gup gu g pupv Su, b b
Cgqg, b up
b gv v g u. -
g b p bu gu p
b pv pu
v. A g g, Sg .
I p qu Hu J upp b b p . A
g Sg ,
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
16/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 105
uu p, v u
v g, pu pv . A
pp b Sx Cg, Hu bg up
, ug v Jg upp g
pv gv, , b, b b upp
. A p , p
gu pv Cu
Yu Lgu, gu Qgu Uv, u C-
P S, p bu
v g.
H u u . F g, b gg p b-
p uvv. Hu J
qu Sv Cg g
g pp ub
v up p. Hu g ub
, b b g Pbu Sg
C xu C C. uu vu -
uv u uz u -
, , p, qu u
, b p.
F , Hu J u p p u-
: up p (bu p -
p), p pub p (bu v ), u p b (bu u v
b ), p (b-
u p ).
I , pbu pu
v p pp, p ,
gu u, pu bu
b Dg Xpg . gv v u g p -
. Bu g , b
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
17/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E106
p u u b u ppu
g p , , pubuu
u ppu g
v, pu g u u -
b .
The Military Unknown
I v g p u
qu ubg, pu bu
. pp v xp-
u b g vg ub -
: C bug, p pub,
bv b g , ug b
U S. pp p
v v: 2007 up 2.2 p -
bp CCP bu 18 p b C C-. Bu , p g
p M p. I, 2002,
pv -b Pbu Sg C,
2007 pv S CCP,
g p pu
C M C C C,
.
A , , R A, b
ubj p pz -
z. Pg b pu
v, u p p:
g p, p, .
C - pb g ub-
.
G pg, vg p, Sv, -b g v bg
.
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
18/19
C A N C H I N A B E G O V E R N E D ? 107
Exp b g g x .
I u gu qu bug . I
, pb u
v pp jug bu v p
g qu pp bu u. F x-p, up U S u
. H pub pu,
p .
A pu Ju 4, 1989, v
b gv u, C xp -
g p p . I gg pz
p ub p g u. Mv, g ub -
( u b ), u
b u u g,
p u bug g.
Bu Hu J p p g
. Dg Xpg bu
v . Jg Z g xp, ug 19951996 x-
g . Hu J pu v
. A v ub -
M 2003, bup v
v up . A , ,
p . F xp,
bug b 17.8 p bgg 2007, pb 150 p bu .
F p, pp v. I p-
g Sv Cg, v -
b p u u . M p,
v b
p: Ob 2006, C ub
gu A ; Ju2007, g C , g
v v g uz v
Copyrighted Material
7/31/2019 Domenach China Excerpt
19/19
T H E G R E A T R I D D L E S O F T H E F U T U R E108
u ; b pvg
pu p, v W gv-
Ju Ju 2007.
Evg v pv g
Hu J. b g -v - b C C b
Sv Cg, b g C M
C C C, b p
v . g p v
v j g pp
.
Bu vg vg b b v u. Ag vu u, C
ub v A Kitty Hawk
S Nvb 2007. Dug ,
g gg v u C b x-
u b C u -
v u, Op G.
L b : g b pb g v p g b .
Copyrighted Material