DIAGNOSTICTEST OFWORD
READING PROCESSES
Teeeacchheer’ss Guide
Forum for Research in Literacy and Language, Institute of Education
Evaluation Pack
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
Contents Introduction to the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes 03
Example reading cards 04
An essential tutorial 06
Examples 13
Order form 16
2
DIAGNOSTIC
TEST OFWORD
READING
PROCESSES
Teeeacchheer’ss Guide
Forum for Research in Literacy and Language, Institute of Education
Welcome to the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
Evaluation Pack
3
Introduction to the
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
The Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes is a test of word and non-word reading for children
aged 6 to 12.
The test comprises 90 items divided as follows:
• 30 exception words which provide a measure of lexical-semantic processes;
• 30 non-words which provide a measure of phonological recoding processes;
• 30 regular words which can be read by either process.
It is the first test to:
• match words in the regular word and non-word sets by compiling non-words from segments of
regular words;
• match the regular and exception word sets according to their frequency of occurrence in books
read by school children in the UK;
• provide normative data obtained from a large and representative sample of children from
Reception/P1 to Y7/S1 in schools in England.
Quick and easy to administer, score and interpret, the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
makes available to teachers a diagnostic tool that has long been used in research studies, and that
enables precise specification of the areas of difficulty experienced by individual children in developing
fluent and automatic word reading.
Developed by the Forum for Research in Literacy and Language and used as a research tool over
several years, the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes standardisation was carried out in
2009 and 2011 and the test yields an overall standard age score, age equivalent scores and an
individual stanine score for each of its three component parts.
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
yol
hap
cug
vus
rit
NW
1
kem
jid
wex
bof
naz
vip
tek
Pra
ctice ite
ms
4
Examplereadingcards
Ple
ase
note
: The
se a
re n
ot a
ctua
l wor
ds fr
om th
e te
st, b
ut a
re c
lose
app
roxi
mat
ions
to th
e te
st c
onte
nt.
Sam
ple
non-
wor
ds
Evaluation Pack
froll
mong
merfar
hister
nostchen
hunril
pringy
kitcess
bungentine
turpalow
NW2
EXC
do
bear
what
people
wolf
eye
country
wealth
rheumatism
beautiful
REG
frog
hill
monster
farmer
kitchen
nostril
hungry
princess
bungalow
turpentine
5
Ple
ase
note
: The
se a
re n
ot a
ctua
l wor
ds fr
om th
e te
st, b
ut a
re c
lose
app
roxi
mat
ions
to th
e te
st c
onte
nt.
Sam
ple
non-
wor
ds II
Sam
ple
exce
ptio
n w
ords
Sam
ple
regu
lar
wor
ds
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
An essential tutorial
Introduction to the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
What is involved in learning to read?There are two essential dimensions to learning to read: children must learn to recognise and understand written words, and they must learn to recover and interpret the literal and inferential meanings of texts. These two dimensions are encapsulated in the Simple View of Reading (Hoover and Gough, 1990).3
Figure 1.1: The Simple View of Reading
Language Comprehension
Processes
Language Comprehension
Processes
Word Recognition Processes
Word Recognition Processes
Poor
Poor
Good
Good
Each dimension within this simple framework is far from ‘simple’, and involves the development and use of complex cognitive processes – processes operating within the mind and brain.
3 Useful sources of information about the Simple View of Reading include: Adlof et al. (2006); Hoover and Gough (1990); Kendeou et al. (2009); Kirby and Savage (2008); Stuart et al. (2008). 6
Evaluation Pack
What does the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes assess?The test focuses on the cognitive processes that underlie the recognition and understanding of written words: the ‘word recognition’ dimension of the Simple View of Reading.
It does this by assessing pupils’ performance on three types of word: • Regular words, for example ‘meet’, ‘shampoo’, ‘catapult’, which conform to the
grapheme-phoneme correspondence (GPC) rules of the language• Exception words, for example, ‘was’, ‘yacht’, ‘meringue’, which do not conform to
these GPC rules• Non-words, for example ‘brafe’, ‘meckton’, ‘shelibowt’, which are pronounceable
sequences of letters that do not exist as real words in the language.
What are these word reading processes?Over the past 50 years, there has been a huge amount of research devoted to understanding how people are able to recognise the individual sequences of letters that constitute each written word, and thereby gain access to the meaning and pronunciation of each word. Some areas of difference in detail remain between different theories. However, there is now a large measure of agreement that skilled readers have developed two interacting sets of processes that operate together on each written word. Therefore, pupils learning to read need to develop both sets of processes if they are to become skilled readers.
In order to remain impartial with respect to the remaining differences between competing theories, the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes uses the neutral terms ‘lexical-semantic” and ‘phonological’ to describe these two sets of interacting processes. To make best use of the test, you need to understand what each set of processes involves. A brief account is provided below.
What are lexical-semantic processes?Lexical-semantic processes depend upon accessing previously stored knowledge about words.
Long before they start to learn to read, children have already stored the meanings and pronunciations of thousands of words that they use in their daily lives. Where a word is already stored in a pupil’s oral vocabulary, developing lexical-semantic processes involves:
• storing knowledge of the letter sequence of the written form of the word • linking the letter sequence to its meaning.
Word meanings already stored in oral vocabulary are already linked to their pronunciation. This means that accessing the meaning of the word automatically triggers access to its pronunciation.
7
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
However, reading soon becomes a major source of oral vocabulary development, and so pupils start to come across written words whose meanings and pronunciations are not already in their oral vocabulary. In these cases, developing lexical-semantic processes involves:
• storing knowledge of the letter sequence of the written word• inferring something of the word’s meaning from the context in which it occurs • working out a pronunciation for the word from its letter sequence • linking the letter sequence to the word’s meaning and pronunciation.
And, of course, unfamiliar words encountered in print may well be mispronounced: for example, ‘misled’ may become ‘mizzled’, and give rise to a new verb ‘to mizzle’ (as evidenced in the speech error ‘don’t mizzle me’).
Once the letter sequence of a previously unknown written word has been stored and linked to its meaning and pronunciation, on subsequent encounters that written word
will be recognised immediately on sight. Instant recognition leads to automatic and effortless recovery of the stored meaning and pronunciation. Lexical-semantic processing is extraordinarily fast and operates without any conscious awareness on the part of the skilled reader.
Lexical-semantic processes are involved in reading all words, both regular and exception.4 However, they are uniquely tapped by Exception Word Reading, as Exception Word Reading is only achieved through lexical-semantic processing. Therefore, Exception Word Reading is used in this test as the measure of lexical-semantic processes.
Importantly, the sequence of operations in lexical-semantic processing is from stored letter sequence to word meaning to word pronunciation. Thus, these processes allow us to distinguish between homophones like ‘sail’ and ‘sale’, even when we read them without any disambiguating context. The letter sequence ‘sail’ is linked to the meaning ‘an area of fabric used to catch the wind and propel a boat over water’, whereas the letter sequence ‘sale’ is linked to the meaning ‘the exchange of goods, property or services for an agreed sum of money or credit’.
4 The only requirement is that words should be familiar to the reader. That is, they must have been previously encountered in print sufficiently often for their letter sequences, meanings and pronunciations to have been stored. In skilled readers, one or two encounters with a written word are sufficient. For beginner readers, many more encounters are needed: some young beginner readers fail to recognise and understand written words that they have seen very many times previously (see, for example, Stuart et al., 2000). 8
Evaluation Pack
Figure 1.2: Sequence of operations in lexical-semantic processing
Writtenword
Writtenword
SAIL
/seɪl/
S-A-I-L
S-A-L-E
SALE
Access storedletter sequence
Access storedletter sequence
Access storedword meaning
Access storedword meaning
Access storedword
pronunciation
Access storedword
pronunciation
‘an area of fabricused to catch thewind and propel
a boat overwater’
‘the exchange ofgoods, property
or services for anagreed sum of
money or credit’
What are phonological processes in reading?Phonological processes depend on the use of previously stored knowledge about correspondences between printed letters and letter groups (graphemes) and speech sounds (phonemes): that is, stored knowledge of grapheme-phoneme correspondence (GPC) rules. They are involved in reading regular words, whether or not these have been previously seen and stored, and non-words. Using phonological processes to read exception words would lead to a mispronunciation, for example reading ‘yacht’ to rhyme with ‘matched’. Phonological processes are uniquely tapped by Non-word Reading, because non-words do not exist as words in the language. They have not been seen before, and so their letter sequence cannot have been stored. They can only be read accurately by phonological processing. Therefore, Non-word Reading is used in the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes as the measure of phonological processing.
Development of phonological processes for word reading involves:• developing an understanding of the alphabetic principle, that phonemes in spoken
words are represented by graphemes in written words• developing explicit awareness of the sequence of phonemes that constitute each
spoken word• learning the correspondences between graphemes and phonemes
9
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
• learning to recognise graphemes in written words• learning to blend phonemes into whole-word pronunciations.
Importantly, the sequence of operations in phonological processing is from letter sequences to grapheme-phoneme translation and phoneme blending, to word pronunciation and thence to word meaning.
Figure 1.3: Sequence of operations in phonological processing
Writtenword
SHAMPOO
sh-a-m-p-oo
Identifygraphemes
Blend phonemes
Access storedword meaning
Translategraphemes to
phonemes
Access storedword
pronunciation
‘soap to washthe hair’
sh ➔ /ʃ/ a ➔ /a/ m ➔ /m/ p ➔ /p/oo ➔ /u/
/ʃ-a-m-p-u//ʃampu/
/ʃampu/
Developing and learning the necessary components for phonological processes to operate fluently can be a difficult task for some pupils. But phonological processes offer rich rewards for the reader. Learning a relatively small5 set of GPC rules allows the pupil to work out pronunciations for the increasing numbers of unfamiliar written words they encounter. The meanings of many of these words may already be stored in the pupil’s oral vocabulary. Thus, working out the pronunciation allows the pupil to access the meaning of the word. As with lexical-semantic processes, something of the word’s meaning can be inferred from the context in which it is encountered, and stored for future use.
In skilled readers, phonological processes operate automatically and fluently, without the conscious awareness of the reader.
5 See, for example, Vousden et al., 2010.10
Evaluation Pack
How does the test assess lexical-semantic processes?
The test contains sets of matched regular words and exception words. Pupils whose reading relies on the use of lexical-semantic processes will read regular and exception words to a broadly equivalent level, because both can be accurately pronounced by lexical-semantic processing. Pupils who also have well-developed phonological processes will tend to show an advantage for regular over exception words. This is because regular words can be pronounced accurately by both sets of processes, and so do not need to be already known and stored by the reader.
As explained above, Exception Word Reading is the purest measure of lexical-semantic processes. Therefore, in the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes, stanine scores6 for Exception Word Reading are used as the measure of lexical-semantic processes.
How does the test assess phonological processes?
The test also contains a set of non-words: letter sequences that could be words in the language, but that do not link to any meaning. The non-words in this test have been made by recombining letter sequences from the words in the regular word set: thus, all their component letter sequences are as familiar or unfamiliar to the pupil as the letter sequences in the regular words. Pupils whose reading relies predominantly on the use of phonological processes will read regular words and non-words to a broadly equivalent level, because both can be pronounced accurately by phonological processing. Their reading of exception words, which can only be pronounced accurately by lexical-semantic processes, will be relatively poorer.
As explained above, Non-word Reading is the purest measure of phonological processes. Therefore, in the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes, stanine scores for Non-word Reading are used as the measure of phonological processes.
Why should I use the test?
The Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes is the only standardised test with British English norms currently available that allows you to uncover the nature of the difficulties an individual pupil is experiencing in developing fluent automatic word reading processes. The pupil profile provided by administering this test can usefully inform your ability to provide teaching that is appropriate to the needs of the individual pupil, and that will help the pupil to overcome his or her difficulties.
6 See page 22 of the Teacher’s Guide for a definition of stanine scores. 11
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
When should I use the test?
You can use the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes to assess the word reading skills of all the pupils in your class, or you might prefer to use it selectively with pupils whose reading development is causing you concern.
The Exception Word Reading/Non-word Reading comparisons reveal three different kinds of profile of reading difficulties:
• a Lexical-Semantic profile, indicating relative difficulty in developing lexical-semantic processes
• a Phonological profile, indicating a relative difficulty in developing phonological processes
• a Mixed profile, indicating difficulty in developing both sets of processes.
Procedures for obtaining and interpreting these profiles are described in Chapter 4. Suggestions for what to do once you have obtained and interpreted a profile for an individual pupil are given in Chapter 6.
It is important to remember that the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes is focused on the word reading dimension of the Simple View of Reading. It cannot (and is not intended to) identify pupils who are experiencing difficulties with reading comprehension, except in so far as those difficulties may be caused by poor or inefficient word reading skills. Pupils with age appropriate word reading skills who struggle to understand written texts appropriate to their age and interests should be given a prose reading test such as the York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension (YARC, Snowling et al., 2009).
12
Evaluation Pack
13
Examples using words supplied in the
Evaluation PackExample 1
Exception Regular Non-word
do √ frog √ froll √
bear √ hill √ mong √
what √ monster x merfar x
people √ farmer √ hister x
wolf x kitchen √ nostchen x
eye √ nostril x hunril x
country x hungry √ pringry x
wealth x princess x kitcess x
rheumatism x bungalow x bungentine x
beautiful x turpentine x turpalow x
Exception word = 5 correctRegular word = 5 correctNon-word = 2 correct
From these raw scores it looks as though this child reads exception words and regular words equally well, and that he/she reads words better than non-words. However, raw scores are misleading and you cannot draw any conclusions from them. You need to convert raw scores to stanine scores using the normative data tables.Using stanine scores, the test is designed to reveal three patterns (‘profiles’) of word reading. This can be done by simply comparing the child’s stanine score for exception words with their stanine score for non-words.
Let’s imagine that the child in the example above achieved a stanine score of 3 for exception word reading, and 1 for non-word reading.
As you can see, these stanine scores give the child a phonological profile. The child relies mostly in reading on lexical-semantic processes, which can read all words, regular as well as exception, as long as they are already familiar to the child. Unfamiliar words cannot be decoded using phonological recoding processes. Intervention for this child should concentrate on developing his/her phonological recoding processes.
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
14
Example 2
Exception Regular Non-word
do √ frog √ froll √
bear x hill √ mong √
what √ monster √ merfar √
people √ farmer √ hister √
wolf x kitchen √ nostchen √
eye x nostril √ hunril √
country x hungry x pringry x
wealth x princess √ kitcess x
rheumatism x bungalow x bungentine x
beautiful x turpentine x turpalow x
Exception word = 3 correctRegular word = 7 correctNon-word = 6 correct
From these raw scores it looks as though this child reads regular words and non-words equally well, but finds exception words difficult.However, raw scores are misleading and you cannot draw any conclusions from them.You need to convert raw scores to stanine scores using the normative data tables. Using stanine scores, the test is designed to reveal three patterns (‘profiles’) of word reading. This can be done by simply comparing the child’s stanine score for exception words with their stanine score for non-words.
Let’s imagine that the child in the example above achieved a stanine score of 2 for exception word reading, and 5 for non-word reading.
As you can see, these stanine scores give the child a lexical-semantic profile. He/she relies mostly in reading on phonological recoding processes, which can read nonwords and regular words, whether or not the latter are already familiar to the child. However, he/she has difficulty with exception words, as these can only be read accurately by lexical-semantic processes. Intervention for this child should concentrate on developing his/her lexical-semantic processes.
Evaluation Pack
15
Example 3
Exception Regular Non-word
do √ frog √ froll √
bear x hill √ mong √
what √ monster x merfar x
people √ farmer x hister x
wolf x kitchen x nostchen x
eye x nostril x hunril x
country x hungry x pringry x
wealth x princess x kitcess x
rheumatism x bungalow x bungentine x
beautiful x turpentine x turpalow x
Exception word = 3 correctRegular word = 2 correctNon-word = 2 correct
From these raw scores it looks as though this child has equal difficulty reading all three types of word.However, raw scores are misleading and you cannot draw any conclusions from them.You need to convert raw scores to stanine scores using the normative data tables.
Using stanine scores, the test is designed to reveal three patterns (‘profiles’) of word reading. This can be done by simply comparing the child’s stanine score for exception words with their stanine score for non-words.
Let’s imagine that the child in the example above achieved a stanine score of 2 for exception word reading, and 1 for non-word reading.
As you can see, these stanine scores give the child a mixed profile. He/she has not developed either set of word reading processes to an age-appropriate level, and has no relative strength or weakness in one or other set. Intervention for this child should concentrate on developing both phonological recoding and lexical-semantic processes.
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
Mr/Mrs/Miss/Ms
Job Title
Address
Post Code
Tel Fax
Official Order No.
Paying Authority/School
Please invoice me Cheque enclosed Amount: £ ___________(payable to GL Assessment)
Using the DiagnosticTest of Word ReadingProcesses andPhonologicalAssessment Batterytogether
4 easy ways to order1) Photocopy and fax this order form to 0845 601 5358
2) Post it to: GL Assessment, FREEPOST LON16517, Swindon SN2 8BR
3) Call 0845 602 1937
4) Visit www.gl-assessment.co.uk and enter DTWRP or PhAB into the Searchbox (no credit card required – we invoice your school)
GL Assessment’s Phonological
Assessment Battery (PhAB) is anideal follow-on assessment forsome children tested with theDiagnostic Test of Word Reading
Processes. The latter is designedto benchmark and test pupils’developing skills in word readingand can be used to track progressas part of a school’s assessmentregime. If persistent problems aredetected then the specialistteacher/SENCO could administerPhAB, a well-established test thatlooks at six different areas ofphonological processing.
Please contact us for moreinformation:
T: 0845 602 1937E: [email protected]
+
*+VAT**UK postage and packing: Add £4.15 if enclosing paymentwith your order (If you are not enclosing payment, you will becharged the full cost of postage based on weight anddelivery date required.)
Sub Total
P&P**
+VAT @ 20%
TOTAL
For advice on the Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes or any of our other
assessments, or to arrange a visit from your local Area Consultant to discuss your
reading assessment needs in more detail, please call 0845 602 1937 or send an email
to [email protected]. Alternatively, find your local Area Consultant online at
www.gl-assessment.co.uk/findyourrep.
Title Code Price Qty Total
Diagnostic Test of Word Reading Processes
Complete Set 978 07087 20721/GLA449 £100.00*
Record Forms (Pack of 50) 978 07087 20738/GLA449 £35.00*
Phonological Assessment Battery (PhAB)
Complete Set 978 07087 07081/GLA449 £119.99*
Record Forms (Pack of 10) 978 07087 07098/GLA449 £17.99*
Secure your copy ofthe brand new Diagnostic Test of
Word Reading Processes
GLA449GLA475