8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
1/33
CONCEPTS RELATEDCONCEPTS RELATED
TO PATENTABILITYTO PATENTABILITY
By
Somashekar Ramakrishna
Brain League IP Services
Brain League IP Services Pvt. Ltd
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
2/33
Industrial applicability/Utility
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
3/33
Industrial Applicability/Utility
Industrial Application The invention is capable of being made or used in an industry Sec 2(1)(ac)
No Industrial applicability
If vague and speculative possible objectives are indicated (MPPP Sec 3.25.3)
For processes or articles alleged to operate in a manner contrary to well-establishedphysical laws (MPPP 3.25.5)
For method of treatment of the human or animal body by surgery or therapy or ofdiagnosis practiced on the human or animal body (MPPP 3.25.6)
For parts/pieces of the human or animal body to be used in transplants (MPPP 3.25.6)
e.g. Scheme for exchanging all or part of a prison sentence for corporal punishmentLacks Industrial Applicability Melias Applicaton (BL O/153/92)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
4/33
Anticipation
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
5/33
Anticipation
(l) new invention means anyinvention or technology which hasnot been anticipated by publication
in any document or used in thecountry or elsewhere in the worldbefore the date of filing of patentapplication with complete
specification, i.e. the subject matterhas not fallen in public domain orthat it does not form part of the stateof the art;
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
6/33
Anticipation
Paten
table
Subject
Matte
r
Invention Prior Art
Utility
Filte
r
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
7/33
Anticipation
Prior ArtPrior Publication
Public Knowledge and Public Use
Public displayOn sale
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
8/33
Anticipation
Prior Publication
Date offiling ofCSIndian Patent application
Publication( )Section 13 1 a
Indian Patent applicationPublication
( )Section 13 1 b
Publication in India orelsewhere in any document
( )Section 13 2
No limit on the age of thedisclosure
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
9/33
Anticipation
Prior Publication
if X files a patent application on 25thSeptember, 2009 relating to an invention andif Ys application relating to the sameinvention, which was filed on 25thSeptember, 2007, is published on 25thOctober, 2009, the invention of X will not benovel.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
10/33
Anticipation
Exceptions/No Anticipation by Prior Publicationif 1) the patentee proves:
a) Wrongful Obtainment; and
b) Application for patent was filed as soon asreasonably practical after learning about the publication (Sec 29(2) (a) and (b))
e.g. if X takes information relating to an invention from Ys laband publishes it without Ys knowledge, such publication willnot anticipate the invention provided Y files a patent applicationafter learning about the publication within a reasonable period oftime.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
11/33
Anticipation
2) a complete specification was filed by a personand thereafter the invention is published or used
by contravening the rights of the true and first
inventor or any person deriving rights from him.(Sec 29(3))
e.g. if X is the true and first inventor of an
invention and if Y his colleague files for a
patent over the invention without informing Xand permits A to use it, Ys application whenpublished or use of the invention by A will notanticipate the patent application filed by X
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
12/33
Anticipation
3) the invention is communicated to theGovernment or to any person authorized bythe Government to Investigate the invention
or its merits (Sec 30)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
13/33
Anticipation
4) If the invention in a paper is read by the trueand first inventor before a learned society or
published with the inventors consent in thetransactions of such a society IF
if an application for a patent relating to theinvention is filed within twelve months (12) ofthe date of publication (Sec 31 (d))
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
14/33
Anticipation
Public Knowledge and Public UseKnowledge already in the public domain or
knowledge easily accessible to the public.
Exception
If the use of the invention was by way of imposingsecrecy then it is not a public use .
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
15/33
Anticipation
Public DisplayPublic Display of an invention before the filing
date of the patent application will anticipate theinvention.
Exception However, if an invention is displayed by the inventor
at an exhibition notified by the CentralGovernment in the official gazette, such a publicdisplay or use of the invention at the exhibition or
publication of details of the invention as aconsequence of the exhibition will not anticipatethe invention
provided a patent application is filed withintwelve (12) months from the date of such public
display
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
16/33
Anticipation
On Sale If an invention is on sale or is commercially
worked in India by the applicant. beforethe date of the patent application, it will not
be considered to be novel.
(Exception) However, if the invention was onreasonable trial, it will not be anticipated. Section29(2)(b), Section 31(1)(a) and (b),
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
17/33
Anticipation
On Sale
e.g. if the inventor sellshis novel road roller to thegovernment, he cannot get a patent over it as the salenegates novelty of the invention.
However, if the inventor tests the functioning of a RoadRoller in public under a government contract, such a
test will not anticipate the invention.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
18/33
Anticipation
Subject Matter in the Prior Art
Thumb Rule: A Prior publication will
anticipate.ONLY if it contains..ALL the features of the invention FarbewerkeHoechst Aktiengesellschaft vormals meister Lucius &Bruning a Corporation etc. Vs. Unichem Laboratories and Ors
MANU/MH/0064/1969
The anticipatory disclosure must beentirely contained within a singledocument. (MPPP 3.3.4)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
19/33
Anticipation
ExampleA chair
4 legs
Each leg is provided with a wheelPrior Art 1 chair with 4 legsPrior Art 2 wheels in toy chair.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
20/33
Anticipation
Invention
Prior Art
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
21/33
Inventive step/non-obviousnessInventive step/non-obviousness
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
22/33
Inventive Step
Inventive step 1) Technically advanced in the light of the
prior art or should have economicsignificance ; and
2) The invention should be non-obvious to
a person skilled in the art
inventive step means a feature of an invention thatinvolves technical advance as compared to theexisting knowledge or having economic significanceor both and that makes the invention not obvious to aperson skilled in the art; Sec 2(ja)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
23/33
Inventive Step
Person skilled in the artPresumed to be an ordinary practitioner
aware of what was common generalknowledge in the art at the relevant date(MPPP 3.51.2)
A notional skilled person who would
perform a transfer of technology from aneighboring field to his specific filed of
interest, if this transfer involved routineexperimental work comprising onlyroutine trails (MPPP 3.51.3)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
24/33
Inventive Step
Some Issues Involved in determiningInventive step What was the problem which the patented
development addressed?
How long had that problem existed?
How significant was the problem seen to be?
How widely known was the problem and howmany were likely to seeking a
solution?.........
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
25/33
Inventive Step
Indicators of inventive stepDistance- b/n the Subject matter and the
prior art
Unexpected effectLong felt need
Failure of others
Commercial success
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
26/33
Inventive Step
Lack of Inventive stepInvention provides equivalent
Prior art is incomplete and the inventionlies in filling the gap which would readilyoccur to a person skilled in the art
New use of a known material
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
27/33
Inventive Step
In determining Inventive StepMosaicing multiple documents is permitted
All information in any set of documents
can be combined provided they are all inthe same art (analogous)
No hindsight should be employed (takingthe solution and working backwards)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
28/33
Inventive Step Biswanath Prasad Radhey Shyam Vs. Hindustan Metal
industries, AIR 1982 SC 1444 Patent: Means for holding utensils for turning purposes Prior Art: Lathe (tailstock)
To be patentable the improvement or the combination mustproduce a new result, or a new article or a better orcheaper article than what was already existing
Improvement or combination should be somethingmore than the mere workshop improvement
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
29/33
Inventive Step Haberman and another v. Jackel International Ltd
(1999) FSR 683
Patent:ANWY CUP, a trainer cup for toddlersHad a valve fitted to the lidWould open when baby sucked and closed when it
stopped
Immediate commercial success. Defendant: launched rival product: super-seal Suit for infringement: claim of obviousness.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
30/33
Justice Laddie: though involved a very small and simple
step, it is sufficiently inventive. It hadsolved a problem (that is the long-feltneed for a spill-proof cup)
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
31/33
Inventive Step
Garewall ropes Ltd. Vs. Mr. Anant KanoiMANU/GJ/8265/2006
Patent:Prefabricated collapsible gabion product made
from synthetic ropes
Gabions are well known (since 7000 years)Rope gabions and polymer gabions were
being used in Maharashtra since 1991 andin Bihar since 1987
Held: Substituting elements of commonknowledge in a product would not give rise toinventive step
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
32/33
Inventive Step
Example:Device for manually collecting the
agricultural produce has container (Plastic) open at the top
and closed at the bottom wall of the container has a contour
adapted to proximate the back of a humanbody
Straps and buckles for securing the
container to the individual Traditional product made out of
bamboo.
8/14/2019 Concepts Related to Patentability
33/33
THANK YOU!
Top Related