8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
1/45
;
[tf Wnir ci| Zdwz @fjw?
K wztjv ic znd dccdgzw ic k giextzd|
lkwdj bked |dsfdr ziia im znd
dmbkbdedmz kmj |dzdmzfim ic efjjad
wgniia nfwzi|v wztjdmzw-
Lv
Oiwntk Nk||fw
Ekv 7;!
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
2/45
zn b|kjd TW Nfwzi|v zd~z twfmb k
giixd|kzfsd)giaakli|kzfsd giexdzfzfsd giextzd|%lkwdj bked .GLB&! zndv rfaa kgnfdsd nfbnd|
wgi|dw! fm bdmd|ka! znkm zndf| xdd|w rniwd fmwz|tgzfim rkw fjdmzfgka fm dkgn ckgdz d~gdxz ci| znd
GLB |dsfdr- Znfw rfaa ld kgnfdsdj miz imav zn|itbn |dfmci|gdedmz ic znd zd~z zn|itbn |dsfdr!
ltz kawi zn|itbn k aird|fmb ic znd kccdgzfsd cfazd| kmj km fex|isdedmz fm kzzfztjd klitz znd
wtlodgz kmj zdwzfmb jtd zi znd ctm kwwigfkzdj rfzn xakvfmb k giexdzfzfsd zdke%lkwdj bked kw
x|dxk|kzfim ci| kwwdwwedmzw fm znfw wtlodgz-
Zndi|dzfgka Lkwfw?
Fm znd cfdaj wztjfdw gimgd|mfmb twd ic giextzd|%lkwdj bkedw)bkefmb .GLB& kmj |dg|dkzfimka
fmwz|tgzfim fm kgztka x|kgzfgd! eiwzav rnkz |dwdk|gnd|w wztjv k|d znd dmbkbdedmz ckgzi|! kmj
znd wztjdmzw i| xakvd|w kzzfztjdw zirk|j znd wtlodgz ekzd|! i| kccdgzfsd cfazd| fm |dbk|jw zi znkz
wtlodgz! |kznd| znkm znd dccdgzfsdmdww ic znd bked fm zd|ew ic adk|mfmb i| |dzdmzfim- Znitbn znd
afzd|kzt|d mdsd| kjj|dwwdw znfw |dwdk|gn bkx! adk|mfmb i| |dzdmzfim! znd|d wdde zi ld wied
tmjd|avfmb fjdkw klitz zndwd zri k|dkw-
Imd ic zndwd tmjd|xfmmfmbw wddew zi ld znkz fc znd adsda ic dmbkbdedmz fw nfbn kmj znd
kccdgzfsd cfazd| fw air! edkmfmb znd adk|md| nkw k xiwfzfsd kzzfztjd zirk|jw znd wtlodgz ekzzd|!
wzkmjfmb kmj kggdxzdj xdjkbibfgka zndi|v kmj |dwdk|gn ilsfkzdw znkz adk|mfmb! tmjd|wzkmjfmb
kmj |dzdmzfim rfaa zk`d xakgd kz k gi||dakzfsd adsda- Znd lkwfw ci| rnkz fw dwwdmzfkaav k |dwdk|gn%
lkwdj kwwtexzfim fw kgztkaav wz|imb- Znd |dwdk|gn wztjfdw jimd im znd gi||dakzfimw ic
dmbkbdedmz i| kccdgzfsd cfazd| kmj adk|mfmb! kmj zniwd jimd im dmbkbdedmz i| kccdgzfsd cfazd|
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
3/45
7
kmj |dzdmzfim k|d wz|imb dmitbn zi xiwfz rfznitz |dwztjvfmb twfmb znfw misda ziia! GLB kmj
giextzd| lkwdj adk|mfmb- Lkwfgkaav! fz fw kggdxzdj lv ekmv znkz fc k wztjdmz fw nfbnav dmbkbdj fm
k wtlodgz! kmj nkw k biij cddafmb klitz fz! lk||fmb k adk|mfmb jfwklfafzv ic wied wi|z! znkz wztjdmz
rfaa adk|m kmj |dzkfm znkz wtlodgz ldzzd| znkm fc zndv k|d li|dj lv znd wtlodgz kmj cdda af`d k
ckfat|d fm znkz kgkjdefg k|dk- Ct|znd|! kmiznd| |dkwim ci| miz sdmzt|fmb fmzi kzzdexzfmb zi
edkwt|d adk|mfmb kmj |dzdmzfim fw znkz fz gkm ldgied sd|v jfccfgtaz zi jfwkbb|dbkzd rnkz rkw
adk|mdj wiadav fm znd GLB dmsf|imedmz kmj miz znd wigfka adk|mfmb znkz zk`dw xakgd fm ekmv GLB
ltz rnfgn ekv miz ld znd jf|dgz |dwtaz ic znd GLB fzwdac! ltz lv znd eijkafzv ic znd GLB-
Znd gieeim wtggdwwcta ckgdz fm cfdaj wztjfdw ic GLB fm djtgkzfim rkw znkz mdk|av
tmfsd|wkaav! zndv dmbkbdj wztjdmzw fm miz imav znd bked! ltz znd wtlodgz ekzzd| kw rdaa! kmj
zndv x|ijtgdj k xiwfzfsd kzzfztjd im znd xk|z ic znd wztjdmz zirk|jw znd wtlodgz ekzzd|- Znfw
dccdgz rkw ak|bdav kgnfdsdj fm wtggdwwcta GLB zn|itbn znd twd ic ctm! wigfkaav fmzd|kgzfsd bkedw
znkz twdj k `fmj ic ded|bdmz x|ilade wiasfmb-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
4/45
:
\dsfwdj! Ekv
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
5/45
4
Znfw cdk| rkw wiednir gimcf|edj rndm djtgkzfimka |dwdk|gnd|w ldbkm zi giexfad
jdeib|kxnfg fmci|ekzfim im znd irmd|wnfx kmj twkbd ic giextzd|w kmj fmzd|mdz kmj
gi||dakzdj fz zi wigfi%dgimiefgw kmj wgniia kgnfdsdedmzznd wi%gkaadj jfbfzka jfsfjd- Rndm
znfw rkw |dxi|zdj fm znd xixtak| edjfk! fz zii` im k wxdgfitw gktwka |dakzfimwnfx rnfgn
giexadzdav ckfadj zi zk`d fmzi kggitmz znd wfefak|fzv fm znd kgnfdsdedmz jfwxk|fzv ic zniwd wked
wigfi%dgimiefg adsdaw ldci|d znd rfjdwx|dkj twd ic jfbfzka kmj mdzri|` zdgnmiaibv- Ciaairfmb
znfw! wgniia jfwz|fgzw kg|iww znd mkzfim! rfzn kaa znd d~xdmwd! wxddj kmj gii|jfmkzfim ic k gkzzad
wzkexdjd xtz giextzd| zdgnmiaibv fmzi wgniiaw! rndznd| znd ntekm i| xnvwfgka fmc|kwz|tgzt|d
d~fwzdj zi wtxxi|z fz i| miz- Znd |dwtazw rd|d znd wked kw k jdgkjd ldci|d! mi rfjdwx|dkj
dccdgz! xiwfzfsd i| mdbkzfsd! gitaj ld jdzdgzdj-
Znd akg` ic wtlwzkmzfsd dccdgz fm xtlafg djtgkzfim lv twd ic giextzd|w wnitaj miz nksd
zk`dm kmvimd lv wt|x|fwd- Znd |dkwimw afd fm znd rkv znd fexadedmzkzfim rkw jimd- Fm kmv
fmjtwz|v! fc mdr ziiaw k|d l|itbnz fm ltz zniwd dexaivdj fm znd cfdaj k|d miz zni|itbnav z|kfmdj
zndm znd mdr ziiaw k|d ic afzzad twd zi kmvimd fmsiasdj- Mted|itw wztjfdw kmj k ak|bd siated
ic kmdgjizka dsfjdmgd xifmz zi znd |dkafzv ic djtgkzi|w nksfmb giextzd| d{tfxedmz mdk|av catmb
fmzi zndf| ri|` afsdw rfzn afzzad i| mi x|d%z|kfmfmb i| fm%wd|sfgd djtgkzfim kmj wtxxi|z-
Znfw rkw |dakzdj fm ak|bd xk|z zi cfmkmgdw- Wgniia jfwz|fgzw nkj afzzad ctmjw! ltz cdaz znd
x|dwwt|d zi ld jifmb wiedznfmb zi d{tfx zndf| wztjdmzw ci| znd jfbfzka ctzt|d kmj wi j|flladj
znd nk|jrk|d fmzi wgniiaw! rfzn rnkz wxk|d ctmjfmb zndv nkj! adksfmb sf|ztkaav miznfmb ci|
z|kfmfmb! fmwzdkj |davfmb im fmjfsfjtka d~xd|zfwd- Fm iznd| gkwdw! wgniiaw |dgdfsdj imd%zfed
eimfdw rnfgn k|d kz znd ndk|z ic nir kmvimd etwz z|v zi fexadedmz kmv wi|z ic fmmiskzfim fm
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
6/45
3
xtlafg djtgkzfim kmj znd ctmjw rd|d wxdmz kg{tf|fmb nk|jrk|d rnfgn ritaj ld ilwiadzd fm 7
vdk|w! i| dawd znd z|kfmfmb gitaj imav ld iccd|dj kz k adsda rnfgn rkw miz d~nktwzfsd adksfmb
ak|bd bkxw fm znd zdkgnd| w`faa lkwd kg|iww k jfwz|fgz! wzkzd! kmj mkzfim- Kczd| k rnfad! rndm
nk|jrk|d kmj mdzri|`fmb rd|d ei|d tlf{tfzitw fm wgniiaw! znd imd%zfed ctmjfmb |dekfmdj k
x|ilade- Znd gnifgd gt||dmzav fw ldzrddm? z|kfmfmb zniwd rfzn znd sk|fdzv ic w`faa adsdaw keimb
zdkgnd|w zi k gieeim efmfete! x|isfjfmb dmitbn nk|jrk|d kmj wiczrk|d kz k wztjdmz adsda zi
ek`d gieeim twd xiwwflad! |dbtak| ekfmzdmkmgd! |dxakgdedmz kmj txb|kjd giwzw! i| znd
gielfmkzi|v gnifgd ic txb|kjfmb nk|jrk|d! wiczrk|d! kmj zdkgnd| z|kfmfmb zi ld klad zi |dkaav
fexadedmz z|tav fmmiskzfsd djtgkzfimka x|kgzfgdw-
Fz fw znfw akwz gkzdbi|v! zdkgnd| z|kfmfmb zirk|jw z|td fmmiskzfim! znkz xk|kji~fgkaav fw
adkwz ctmjdj i| tmjd|wziij! vdz fw eiwz af`dav zi x|ijtgd znd nfbndwz |dzt|m im fmsdwzedmz
rndm fz giedw zi wztjdmz dmbkbdedmz kmj kgnfdsdedmz- Fm kjjfzfim zi cfmkmgfka ilwzkgadw!
rnfgn gkm adkj zi k akg` ic znd |dwtazw x|iefwdj lv znd jfbfzfkzfim ic djtgkzfim! fw znd akg` ic
rfjdwx|dkj twd ic |dka i|fbfmkafzv fm jfbfzka djtgkzfimka x|kgzfgdw- Fm znd ltwfmdww eijda! znd
giextzd| wxdj tx zkw`w znkz nkj lddm jimd ekmtkaav i| edgnkmfgkaav! .zndi|dzfgkaav&
fmg|dkwfmb dccfgfdmgv! gieetmfgkzfim! itzxtz kmj x|ijtgzfimznfw iggt||dj lv fzw ed|d
kxxafgkzfim zi ekmv ri|`xakgdw- Znd wiczrk|d fmjtwz|v gimzfmtdw zi fex|isd txim zndwd fmfzfka
jfbfzka x|ijtgzw? ri|j x|igdwwfmb! jfbfzka wx|dkjwnddzw kmj fmsdmzi|v gimz|ia! dekfa kmj
gieetmfgkzfimw! edjfk jdwfbm! sf|ztka eddzfmbw! kmj x|dwdmzkzfimw- Znd wfexad jfbfzfkzfim ic
zkw`w fm ltwfmdww ekjd k xiwfzfsd fexkgz-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
7/45
2
Rndm znd wked kxxafgkzfim ic jfbfzfkzfim nkxxdmdj fm djtgkzfim! znd |dwtazw rd|d miz
gimb|titw- Znd ekoi| dccdgz rkw znkz zdkgnd|%i|fdmzdj zkw wkjefmfwz|kzfsd |dgi|j `ddxfmb!
zdkgnd| g|dkzdj gt||fgtak| gimzdmz! xk|wfmb kmj jfwz|fltzfmb xtlafwnd| g|dkzdj gimzdmz! kmj
kjefmfwz|kzfsd kmj giaakli|kzfsd gieetmfgkzfim ldgked dkwfd| ci| zniwd rfzn znd w`faaw zi twd
znd mdr zdgnmiaibv- Nirdsd|! znd|d rkw afzzad fexkgz im fmwz|tgzfim i| adk|mfmb- Znfw fw ci|
wdsd|ka |dkwimw- Zi ldbfm rfzn! wztjdmzw rd|dmz z|twzdj zi nkmjad d~xdmwfsd d{tfxedmz rfzn
gk|d .km d~xdgzkzfim znkz zndv gimwfwzdmzav afsd tx Pi| jirmU zi fm znd ktzni|w d~xd|fdmgd&! kmj
zndm rndm znd giwzw ic znd d{tfxedmz gked jirm! znd zdkgnfmb ic znd lkwfg w`faaw zi wztjdmzw
ci| twd ic zndwd mdr ziiaw rkw miz kw iemfx|dwdmz kw mddjdj- Kw rfzn zdkgnd| d~xd|zfwd znfw
rkw! im wied adsda kwwtedjzndv rd|d li|m fm znd 68w! zndv etwz `mir nir zi twd znfw wztcc-
Fm kjjfzfim! eiwz ic znd kxxafgkzfimw l|itbnz fmzi znd djtgkzfim ri|aj fmfzfkaav rd|d zk`dm
rniad%gaizn c|ie zndf| ltwfmdww i|fbfmw- Zndv rd|d miz jdwfbmdj kw zdkgnfmb ziiaw ltz kw
x|ijtgzfim ziiaw- Ci| d~kexad! Efg|iwiczw nfbnav jdsdaixdj ri|j x|igdwwfmb wiczrk|d! Ri|j!
fw miz jdwfbmdj zi zdkgnfmb r|fzfmb w`faaw! mi| dsdm zvxfmb w`faaw! ltz zi ckgfafzkzd zniwd znkz
ka|dkjv d~fwz0 wfefak|av! imd gkmmiz adk|m kggitmzkmgv mi| jkzk kmkavwfw c|ie D~gda- Fm ckgz fm
znd gkwd ic znd twd ic ri|j x|igdwwfmb kxxafgkzfimw! wztjdmz adk|mfmb k|btklav zii` k wzdx lkg`
fm djfzfmbfc F ek`d k efwzk`d! wxdaa%gndg` rfaa bdz fz-
Wi! rnfad zdkgnd| zkw`w rd|d jfbfzfdj kmj ekjd dkwfd|! mi |dka fmmiskzfim nkj gied fm
kz znd gt||fgtak| i| wztjdmz kgzfsfzv dmj- Znd|d k|d ekmv gkwdw fm rnfgn znd ed|d kjjfzfim ic
giextzd|w kmj fmzd|mdz zi k xdjkbibfgka wdzzfmb jfj x|ijtgd km fmfzfka fmg|dkwd fm dmbkbdedmz
ltz miz karkvw gi||dakzfsdav fm kgnfdsdedmz0 iczdm kw wiim kw znd misdazv ic znd zdgnmiaibv
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
8/45
>
rdk|w icc ic znd wztjdmzw znd dmbkbdedmz |dzt|mw zi x|dsfitw adsdaw- Twfmb giextzd|w zi ji
jfbfzkaav rnkz rkw jimd fm k xdm%kmj%xkxd| rkv x|dsfitwav fw miz dsd| bifmb zi ld km dccdgzfsd
wiatzfim fm kmj ic fzwdac- Giextzd|w mddj zi ld dexaivdj fm k rkv znkz gkmmiz ld jimd rfznitz
zndf| twd- Z|td jfbfzka xdjkbibfgka fmmiskzfim rfaa miz ld dkwfav |dx|ijtgflad rfznitz znd twd ic
giextzd|w-
Twfmb giextzd| bkedw kmj giextzd| wfetakzfim kw k xdjkbibfgka ziia xiwwflav
|dx|dwdmzw k misda edznijiaibv rnfgn gkmmiz ld jtxafgkzdj fm k xdm%kmj%xkxd| wdzzfmb-
Dexf|fgka |dwdk|gn gkm wnir fc znfw mdr edznijiaibv fw |dkaav kw dccdgzfsd kw fw zndi|fdj lv
dmzntwfkwzw ic bkefmb zdgnmiaibv kmj fzw twd fm djtgkzfim- Znd {tdwzfimw zndm ldgied! fc znd|d
fw x|iefwd fm znd twd ic bkedw kmj wfetakzfim! rfzn rnie rfaa znfw kxx|ikgn ri|`! rnkz
jdwfbmw ri|`wrnkz fmg|dkwdw dmbkbdedmz! tmjd|wzkmjfmb! kmj |dzdmzfim! rnkz k|d znd
xd|fxnd|ka fwwtdw ci| kaa fmsiasdj9
Fm km dcci|z zi kjj|dww zndwd {tdwzfimw! znd |dwdk|gn im giextzd| bkedw nkw lddm
gimjtgzdj fm 7 ekfm k|dkw?
Jdeib|kxnv? Rni! fm |dkafzv! xakvw giextzd| .sfjdi& bkedw9 Rnkz `fmj ji zndv xakv!ci| nir aimb! kmj rnv9
Jdwfbm? Rnkz k|d znd nkaaek|`w ic biij bked jdwfbm sfw%%sfw djtgkzfimka kmjxdjkbibfgka zndi|v9
Jdeimwz|kzfim? Rnkz nkxxdmw rndm bked twd fw wztjfdj fm znd cfdaj fm zd|ew icdmbkbdedmz! dccfgkgv! kmj kgztka adk|mfmbjidw fz ri|`! i| otwz g|dkzd mdr
x|iladewi| lizn9
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
9/45
6
Jdeib|kxnv
Wdsd|ka |dgdmz mizklad wztjfdw nksd! fm km dcci|z zi dwzklafwn k cdr wzk|zfmb xakgdw ci|
jdwfbm kmj jdzd|efmd wied kgztkafzfdw klitz sfjdi bked twkbd! wztjfdj znd jdeib|kxnfgw ic
xdixad rni xakv giextzd|%lkwdj bkedw .GLB& ic kaa wi|zw- Bkfmfmb tmjd|wzkmjfmb fmzi znd
xdixad rni xakv giextzd|%lkwdj bkedw .bked|w&! ci| nir aimb kmj ci| rnkz |dkwimw! gkm ld
fmskatklad rndm fz giedw zi znd jdwfbm ic znd eiwz dccdgzfsd kmj dmbkbfmb zvxdw ic bkedw kmj
nir zi tzfafd zniwd jdwfbm zndi|fdw ci| znd g|dkzfim ic Djtgkzfimka bkedw-
@k|k`tw .K jdwg|fxzfsd wztjv ic Zt|`fwn nfbn wgniia wztjdmzw bked%xakvfmb
gnk|kgzd|fwzfgw kmj zndf| gimwfjd|kzfimw! & kmj Gnit .Bdmjd| jfccd|dmgdw fm Zkfrkm nfbn
wgniia wztjdmzw" giextzd| bked xakvfmb!
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
10/45
;8
znkz keimb znd kjtaz xakvd|w ic znfw bked! isd| 28$ nkjd k giaadbd zi xiwzb|kjtkzd djtgkzfim!
kmj kw nfbn kw
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
11/45
;;
Wzk|g|kcz&! |kgfmb .Mddj ci| Wxddj! Ek|fi @k|z&! kmj wxi|zw |dakzdj bkedw .CFCK Wiggd| wd|fdw!
Ekjjdm MCA wd|fdw&- Cdekadw fm lizn wztjfdw wnir k wz|imb x|djfadgzfim ci| xtad)lik|j bked
.Ldodrdadj! Zdz|fw! eknoimb! Eimixiav! dzg-&! Kgzfim%kjsdmzt|d .Wimfg znd Ndjbdnib! Wtxd|
Ek|fi L|iw-&! |iad%xakvfmb! kmj |kgfmb bkedw-
Dsdm rndm zndv xakvdj znd wked bkedw! ekadw kmj cdekadw wdde zi xakv znde ci|
jfccd|dmz |dkwimw kmj d~xdgz jfccd|dmz znfmbw itz ic znde- Gd|zkfmav lizn bdmjd|w xakv GLB ci|
dmzd|zkfmedmz kmj |dak~kzfim kw zndf| xk|keitmz eizfskzi|znd wigfka kwxdgz ic EEI\XB
zvxd bkedw .Ri|aj ic Rk|g|kczRiR! Dsd|{tdwz! dzg-& kawi wddew zi ld ic b|irfmb
fexi|zkmgd kw SIFX .Sifgd Isd| Fmzd|mdz X|izigiazka`fmb rfzn bked%ekzdw isd| znd fmzd|mdz
rnfad xakvfmb& fw ei|d kskfaklad zi znd xakvd|w- Cdekadw xakv ei|d iczdm znkm ekadw ci| znd
wigfka kwxdgz ic bkedw! zndv gk|d ei|d klitz znd mk||kzfsd kwxdgz ic bkedw ei|d! kmj zndv
wdde zi xfg` xtad kmj lik|j bkedw ci| znd fjdk ic wnk|xdmfmb edmzka w`faaw- Ekadw im znd
iznd| nkmj xakv ei|d iczdm znkm cdekadw ci| znd giexad~fzv kmj x|ilade%wiasfmb gnkaadmbd znkz
GLB gkm x|dwdmz-
Zndwd wztjfdw ji ndax djtgkzi|w zi tmjd|wzkmj rnkz fw |dkaav bifmb im rfzn it| wztjdmzw
kmj zndf| GLB |dakzdj nklfzw! eizfskzfimw! dzg-! nirdsd|! znd wdbedmz zi rnie znfw wi|z ic
jdeib|kxnfg fmci|ekzfim fw eiwz twdcta fw znd djtgkzfimka GLB jdwfbmd|- Imd ic znd lkwdw ci|
wiafj GLB jdwfbm fm znd djtgkzfimka k|dmk! etgn af`d znkz fm znd gieed|gfka k|dmk! fw jdwfbmfmb
k bked znkz wztjdmzw rfaa kgztkaav rkmz zi xakv! ldgktwd kz znd gdmzd| ic kmv biij bked!
djtgkzfimka i| iznd| rfwd! fw znd gimgdxz ic ctm- Tzfaffmb znd jdeib|kxnfg jkzk GLB jdwfbmd|w
mddj zi fmgatjd znd kwxdgzw jfwgisd|dj fm zndwd wt|sdvw zi ld eiwz dccdgzfsd- Znd cf|wz kmj ldwz
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
12/45
;
Fm znd |dsfdrdj wztjfdw! sk|fdj kxx|ikgndw kmj bked wzvadw k|d x|dwdmzdj- Znd
gieeim zn|dkj zn|itbn znd cfdaj wztjfdw |dsfdrdj nd|d fw znkz znd|d fw k giextzd|%lkwdj
zdgnmiaibv kw k x|fmgfxka gieximdmz fm znd fmwz|tgzfim kmj wztjdmz d~xd|fdmgd- Fm imd wztjv! k
mk||kzfsd feed|wfsd 7J kjsdmzt|d zvxd bked rkw twdj kw k ziia ci| zdkgnfmb dadedmzk|v
wztjdmzw xnvwfgka kmj xiafzfgka bdib|kxnv .Zm!
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
19/45
;6
xiwfzfsd kzzfztjd im znd xk|z ic znd wztjdmz zirk|jw znd wtlodgz ekzzd| dsdm fc znd wztjdmz
jfwaf`dj znd wtlodgz x|fi| zi twfmb znd bked- Ci| d~kexad! imd wztjv citmj znkz?
Znfw wztjv fmci|edj znkz giextzd| ekzn j|faa bkedw! dsdm zn|itbn ldfmbei|d wfexafwzfg znkm gieed|gfka |iad%xakvfmb bkedw fm zd|ew ic sfwtka!
kgzfsfzv! kmj fmzd|kgzfim jdwfbm! wzfaa wfbmfcfgkmzav dmnkmgd wztjdmzw xiwfzfsd
kzzfztjdw zirk|j ekzn adk|mfmb- Fm kjjfzfim! xk|zfgfxkmzw nksd xd|ci|edj
gieefzzdj kmj dcci|zcta im%zkw` adk|mfmb rndm xakvfmb gd|zkfm bkedw rnd|d
ekzn j|faaw rd|d fmzdb|ka zi znd bkedxakv kmj kxx|ix|fkzdav gnkaadmbfmb
.@d! ! x- ;3;6&-
Gimgatwfim
Znd|d fw x|iefwd fm znd twd ic giextzd| zdgnmiaibv fm djtgkzfim- Znkz x|iefwd nkj akfm
tmctacfaadj wfmgd znd g|dkzfim ic giextzd|w kmj wfmgd djtgkzi|w witbnz zi twd rnkz fw! dsdm zi
znfw jkv! wzfaa giexk|kzfsdav mdr zdgnmiaibv- Znd |dkwim znkz x|iefwd nkw bimd tmctacfaadj fw
ldgktwd znd|d nkw lddm mi |dka fmmiskzfim fm znd cfdaj ic djtgkzfimka giextzfmb-
Znd twd ic giextzd| lkwdj bkedw fm djtgkzfim |dx|dwdmzw znd cf|wz wkaav fm rnkz fw cfmkaav
k |dka fmmiskzfim fm znd jfbfzfdj gakww|iie- Wfmgd! rfzn bkedw! giextzd|w k|d cfmkaav xtz zi k
zkw` znkz fw miz wfexav k ckwzd| sd|wfim im km iaj xdm%kmj%xkxd| zkw`! fz fw imd ic znd fmwzkmgdw fm
rnfgn znd tmf{td klfafzfdw ic znd giextzd| k|d cfmkaav nk|mdwwdj- Fz fw zn|itbn bkedxakv znkz
giextzd|w gkm x|ijtgd znd nfbn adsdaw ic dmbkbdedmzw kmj znd air adsdaw ic kccdgzfsd cfazd|
rnfgn g|dkzd k cair wzkzd kmj ciaair fm znd ciizwzdxw ic x|fi| xdjkbibfgka zndi|v zi x|ijtgd
ldzzd| adk|mfmb- Fz wddew znkz it| zdgnmiaibv nkw cfmkaav dmkladj tw zi adk|m znd rkv kaa iznd|
ekeekaw ji! zn|itbn xakv! ilwd|skzfim! wfetakzfim kmj detakzfim- Ltz wfexav zn|irfmb bkedw
fmzi znd gakww|iie ritaj ld giexadzdav fmkmd kmj x|ilklav x|ijtgd mdbkzfsd dccdgzw-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
20/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
21/45
zn
b|kjd nfwzi|v zdkgnd| ritaj zk`d kmj gimwzkmzav eijfcv Bked
Dmbfmd .BD&! rnfgn ritaj ld k w`dadzka 7J ri|aj%g|dkzi|)bisd|mi| zi rnkzdsd| zndv rd|d
zdkgnfmb kz znd zfed- Ci| znd cf|wz xk|z ic znd vdk|! nd gitaj zn|ir im znd Ked|fgkm \dsiatzfim
fm Liwzim w`fmjdcfmdj nd|d kw km isd|akv rnfgn nkw kaa znd |d{tf|dj fmci|ekzfim klitz znd
wfetakzfim ic k gd|zkfm zdkgnfmb gimzd~z rnfgn gitaj ld aikjdj fmzi BD isd| znd c|kedri|` ic
znd ri|aj-
Rndm znfw nkxxdmw! znd wztjdmz gitaj zndm xakv k giaimfwz i| \djgikz fm znd
Ekwwkgntwdzzw k|dk kz znd zfed ic znd ldbfmmfmb ic znd \dsiatzfimk|v Rk|- BD ritaj `mir!
wfmgd znd fmci|ekzfim gked rfzn znd w`fm .znfw fw znd xk|z ic znd gimzdmz xtlafwnd|w ritaj ld
|dwximwflad ci|&! znkz rndm znd bked gkadmjk| nfzw znd wxdgfcfg jkzd kmj zfed! Xkta \dsd|d kmj
Fw|kda Lfwwdaa ritaj delk|` ci| zndf| ckeitw |fjdwci| rnfgn imav \dsd|d bdzw g|djfz znitbn nfw
|fjd rkw ck| wni|zd| kmj nd biz k||dwzdjznd wztjdmz gitaj ld kz znd mi|zn gnt|gn kmj ciaair
\dsd|d kaimb nfw git|wd! i| bi zi rnd|d L|fzfwn z|iixw k|d jfwdelk|`fmb ci| zndf| ek|gn zi
Gimgi|j! ltz nd ritajmz nksd zi ld znd|d zi rfzmdww znde! nd i| wnd gitaj ld kmvrnd|d zndv
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
22/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
23/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
24/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
25/45
8%>6$ fz
ritaj ld wfasd|! 68%;88$ i| isd| ritaj ld biaj! dzg- Fc znd kskzk| kwxdgz ic BD rd|d kskfaklad
ci| nied kggdww zi wztjdmzw kmj xk|dmzw! znd lkjbd wvwzde gitaj kawi ndax xk|dmzw zi wdd rnkz
zndf| gnfaj fw kmj fwmz kggiexafwnfmb fm wgniia- Fc znd BD wvwzde rd|d kskfaklad ci| nied%twd! k
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
26/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
27/45
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
28/45
Lflafib|kxnv
K``d|ekm! W- k- .
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
29/45
zn b|kjd TW Nfwzi|v- Zri ic Zndwd wdgzfimw rd|d znd gimz|ia
b|itxw- Znd znf|j wdgzfim rkw znd zdwz b|itx rnfgn |dgdfsdj znd sk|fklad- Znd xixtakzfim ic
lizn znd gimz|ia kmj znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itxw k|d kaa k |kgfkaav ef~dj! ckf|av bdmjd|%lkakmgdj
wkexad ic znd xixtakzfim ic eiwz t|lkm)wtl%t|lkm wgniiaw- Mi dznmfg b|itx ekjd tx k lakg`
ic ei|d znkm 7>$0 znd ekoi|fzv ic znd dznmib|kxnv rkw! lv ak|bdwz zi wekaadwz b|itxw? Kc|fgkm
Ked|fgkm! Gktgkwfkm! Akzfmi kmj Kwfkm)Xkgfcfgk Fwakmjd| .Xnfafxfmi&-
Znd sk|fklad gimwfwzdj ic lfrdd`av |dsfdr bked wdwwfimw isd| k zdm rdd` xd|fij
.nirdsd| znd jkzk xifmzw twdj ci| |dwtazw kmkavwfw rd|d imav giaadgzdj c|ie km dfbnz rdd`
xd|fij rfznfm znkz zfed& twfmb znd [tf Wnir bked wiczrk|d znkz gked rfzn znd zd~zlii`
kjixzfim- Znd zd~zlii` rkw znd Gkafci|mfk Djfzfim ic Tmfzdj Wzkzdw Nfwzi|v Fmjdxdmjdmgd zi
;6;: .Niaz! zn b|kjd TW Nfwzi|v-
Znd wiczrk|d fw [tf Wnir wiczrk|d znkz kaairw ci| tx zi 7 xk|zfgfxkmzw- Zndwd
xk|zfgfxkmzw rd|d ekjd ic zdkew- F i|bkmfdj znd gakww fmzi zn|dd zdkew- Znd zdkew rd|d
catfjgkxzkfmw kmj zdke edeld|w sk|fdj c|ie wdwwfim zi wdwwfim zi kgnfdsd gd|zkfm
nieibdmdfzv ic dccdgz- Znd rkv znd bked rkw fexadedmzdj zii` kjskmzkbd ic giexdzfzfim!
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
30/45
78
giaakli|kzfim kmj giixd|kzfim! ded|bdmz bked xakv! kmj nixdctaav rkw ctm ci| wztjdmzwzndv
wddedj zi dmoiv fz-
Znd fmwz|tgzfim rkw sf|ztkaav znd wked ci| kaa ic znd gakwwdw- Znd fmwz|tgzfim gitaj miz ld
d~kgzav fjdmzfgka ldzrddm gakwwdw wfmgd znd gnfaj|dm! zndf| klfafzfdw kmj {tdwzfimw sk|fdj c|ie
gakww zi gakww- Iznd| sk|fkladw fmgatjdj znfmbw ldvimj zdkgnd| gimz|ia! wtgn kw! ltz miz afefzdj
zi! dmsf|imedmzka jfwz|kgzfimw! kjefmfwz|kzfsd fmzd||txzfimw ic fmwz|tgzfim! wztjdmz klwdmgdw!
kmj iznd| ntekm sk|fkzfimw- Znd sk|fklad rkw fmz|ijtgdj zi znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx imav fm znd
ci|e lfrdd`av |dsfdr wdwwfimw twfmb znd [tf Wnir bked- Znd gimz|ia b|itxw |dgdfsdj k
|dbtak| mizdw%lkwdj |dsfdr-
Znd d~xd|fedmz zii` xakgd ci| znd fmwz|tgzfim ic zn|dd gnkxzd|w- Znd|d rd|d zri
{tfdw kmj k giex|dndmwfsd gnkxzd| zdwz znkz rd|d |dgi|jdj kmj giexk|dj- Znd wked
{tfdw kmj zdwzw rd|d kjefmfwzd|dj zi kaa wdgzfimw im znd wked jkv ic dkgn iznd| zi gi||dgz ci|
fmci|ekzfim adk`kbd ldzrddm wdgzfimw- Kw znd d~xd|fedmz rdmz im! dsd|v kzzdexz rfaa rkw
ekjd zi fwiakzd znd sk|fklad! wi znkz k xiwfzfsd gkwtka |dakzfimwnfx gitaj ld gadk|av jdafmdkzdj-
Kz znd dmj ic znd d~xd|fedmzka xd|fij! znd jkzk rkw zkltakzdj kmj d~kefmdj- Znd
|dwtazw rd|d l|i`dm jirm lv zdwz){tf kw rdaa kw isd|kaa |dwtazw znd! {tkafzkzfsd mizdw kmj
|dwtazw rd|d fmzd|adksdj fmzi znd jkzk kmkavwfw-
Znd ldmdcfzw ic znfw wztjv rfaa ld ei|d znkm znd bdmd|ka fmg|dkwd fm znd |dzdmzfim kmj
adk|mfmb ic >zn b|kjd wztjdmzw- Fc wtggdwwcta kmj bdmd|kaav kxxafdj! znfw gkm ndax zi fmg|dkwd
wzkmjk|jfdj zdwz wgi|dw fm znd wi%gkaadj gimzdmz k|dkw .wgfdmgd kmj nfwzi|v& rnfgn! ei|ka kmj
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
31/45
7;
xdjkbibfgka k|btedmzw mizrfznwzkmjfmb! k|d nir wgniiaw! zdkgnd|w! kmj wztjdmzw k|d otjbdj
kmj wkmgzfimdj fm znd xiwz MGAL d|k-
Wztjv Edznij?
Kw jfwgtwwdj fm znd jdwfbm xnkwd! znfw wztjv fmz|ijtgdj k giextzd|%lkwdj bked .GLB&
kw k |dsfdr ziia fmzi znd fmwz|tgzfim ic >zn b|kjd TW Nfwzi|v- Znfw GLB rkw znd sk|fklad- Znd|d
rkw imd zdwz b|itx kmj zri gimz|ia b|itxw-
\dbtak| Fmwz|tgzfim?
Znd lkwfg wz|tgzt|d ic |dbtak| fmwz|tgzfim jt|fmb znd git|wd ic znfw wztjv ritaj bi kw ciaairw?
;- K mdr wdgzfim ic k gnkxzd| fw fmz|ijtgdj twfmb dfznd| k mk||kzfsd |dkjfmb x|iexzrfzn {tdwzfimw znkz kw`w znd wztjdmz nir zndv ritaj |dkgz fm wfefak| wfztkzfimw
i| twd ic k @RA gnk|z kw k x|d%|dkjfmb kgzfsfzv- Lizn ic zndwd ritaj ld ciaairdj
lv l|fdc gakww jfwgtwwfim-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
32/45
7zn b|kjd TW Nfwzi|v lii`! Tmfzdj
Wzkzdw Nfwzi|v Fmjdxdmjdmgd zi ;6;: GK Djfzfim .Niaz!
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
34/45
7:
gnkmgdw zi rfm&- Rndm km fmgi||dgz kmwrd| fw |dbfwzd|dj! imd ic zri wafbnzav wk|gkwzfg
kmfekzfimw fw xakvdj kmj
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
35/45
74
Fc zndv ckfadj zi! zndv ritaj ld ltdj%fm lv znd zdkgnd| ktziekzfgkaav- Znfw
dmwt|dj mdk| d{tka kggdww zi znd fmci|ekzfim kmj `dxz bked xakv cairfmb-
Dkgn zdke rkw kaairdj cf|wz gnkmgd zi kmwrd| im zndf| zt|m- Imav kczd| znkz
zdke ekjd k efwzk`d rd|d znd iznd| zdkew kaairdj zi lt%fm kmj wzdka-
Kw aimb kw dkgn zdke wzkvdj fm zndf| jdwfbmkzdj xk|z ic znd gakww|iie!dksdwj|ixxfmb rkw kaairdj- Znd |dkwim ci| znfw fw wfexad- ;7 kmj ;: vdk| iaj
gnfaj|dm bdz d~gfzklad! kmj aitj- Z|vfmb zi `ddx znde c|ie wnitzfmb isd| dkgn
iznd| kmj ek`fmb kggtwkzfimw rkw mdk|av fexiwwflad- Kczd| znd |tad kaairfmb
dksdwj|ixxfmb rkw fexadedmzdj! wdsd|ka ldmdcfzw rd|d |dkafdj- Cf|wz! zdkew
wdac%eimfzi|dj znd siated adsda ic zndf| jfwgtwwfimw- Wdgimj! kggtwkzfimw ic
gndkzfmb gdkwdj- Znf|j! kz adkwz imd edeld| ic ixxiwfmb zdkew ekjd wt|d zi
xkv kzzdmzfim zi rnkz zndf| ixximdmzw kmwrd|dj! zi ek`d wt|d r|imb kmwrd|w
rd|dmz jtxafgkzdj-
Zdkew rd|d giexiwdj ic Gkxzkfmw! Wxdk`d|w! kmj xakvd|w- Zdke gkxzkfmw rd|dmiz x|inflfzdj c|ie ldfmb wxdk`d|w kw rdaa- Znd cf|wz zfed znd bked rkw xakvdj!
znd zdkgnd| gniwd znd gkxzkfmw kmj xakvd|w- Dkgn zfed znd|dkczd| znd zdkgnd|
gniwd gkxzkfmw! nirdsd|! kczd| znd cf|wz zfed! gkxzkfmw rd|d wiedzfedw
xd|efzzdj zi gniiwd xakvd|w- Fc znd wdadgzfim x|igdww rkw zii wair! i| iznd|rfwd
tmjtav jfw|txzfsd! znd zdkgnd| karkvw |dwd|sdj znd |fbnz zi wdz zdkew- \dgi|jw ic
zdkew rd|d `dxz kmj iggkwfimkaav |dcd|dmgdj zi |d%ci|e zdkew kaimb x|fi| afmdw-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
36/45
73
Fm znd cf|wz xk|z ic znd wztjv! k wz|imb keitmz ic wigfka dmbfmdd|fmb im znd xk|z ic
znd zdkgnd| iggt||dj zi jfwz|fltzd kgkjdefg kmj wigfka klfafzfdw dsdmav-
iZdke Gkxzkfm znd |iad ic znd gkxzkfm rkw zi adkj kmj ekmkbd nfw i| nd|
zdke- Wnd i| nd nkj cfmka wkv im rni rkw bifmb zi ld Zdke Wxdk`d| kmj
gitaj gnkmbd Wxdk`d|w fm znd efjjad ic k bked rfzn zdkgnd| kxx|iska-
Znd gkxzkfm nkj zi kjotjfgkzd kmwrd| jfwxtzdw im zndf| irm zdkew- Znd
gkxzkfm gitaj kawi kwwfbm wxdgfcfg zkw`w zi fmjfsfjtka xakvd|w! f-d- ek`d
znde |dwximwflad ci| |dwdk|gn i| dsdm wxdgfcfg k|dkw ic |dwdk|gn! i| zi kgz
kw wxfdw- Znd ldwz zdke gkxzkfmw nkj k xakm ci| dkgn xd|wim im zndf|
zdke! wied zfedw zndwd rd|d tmgimsdmzfimka-
Znd xk|zfgtak| zdke gkxzkfm rni fmsdmzdj znd oil ic wxv .znd wztjdmz
gkaadj fz dk|%ntwzad|& rkw fmfzfkaav g|fzfgfdj lv nfw ixximdmzw- Znfw jfj
miz! nirdsd|! wzix znde c|ie akzd| detakzfmb nfw x|kgzfgd- Zfbnz
rnfwxd|%cfaadj ntjjadw ldgked znd jdcdmwd zi znfw wz|kzdbv-
i Zdke Wxdk`d| Znd Wxdk`d| rkw dwwdmzfkaav znd ntekm ltd| ci| zndzdke- Wfmgd znd zdkgnd| nkj gimz|ia ic znd ltd|! znd Wxdk`d| nkj zi
wkv! i| wiedzfedw wnitz! znd zdkew ekwgiz zi lt fm! ct|znd|! zi
dafefmkzd gimctwfim! znd imav kggdxzklad wxi`dm kmwrd| c|ie k zdke nkj
zi gied c|ie znd Wxdk`d|- Fz jfjmz zk`d aimb ci| znd wztjdmzw zi cfbt|d
itz znkz znd Wxdk`d| wnitaj karkvw ld znd aitjdwz edeld| ic znd zdke!
miz mdgdwwk|fav znd eiwz wztjfitw-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
37/45
72
i Xakvd|w rd|d kwwfbmdj sk|fitw zkw`w lv znd gkxzkfmw! kmj ci| znd eiwzxk|z gimz|fltzdj k ci|e ic d~xd|zfwd- Wied rd|d ntekm jkzklkwdw0
iznd|w |d|dkj znd |dadskmz xk|zw ic znd zd~z- Fm imav imd fmgfjdmz jfj k
xakvd| kgz jdcfkmzav zirk|j k gkxzkfm- Znd gkxzkfm kw`dj fc znkz xd|wim
gitaj ld xtz im zfed%itz .af`d xdmkazv efmtzdw fm nig`dv&- Kczd| znd
zdkgnd| kxx|isdj! kmj znd wztjdmz wkz itz ci| < |itmjw! znd |dgkagfz|kmz
wztjdmz |doifmdj nfw zdke rfznitz fmgfjdmz- Zi ld wt|d! wied ic zndwd
|iadw i| zkw`w rd|d wtbbdwzdj lv znd zdkgnd|0 nirdsd|! znd wztjdmzw
adk|mdj zi wxdgfkafd zndf| zkw`w fm i|jd| zi ek`d zndf| zdkew kw
ctmgzfimka kw xiwwflad-
Znd rfmmd|w ic dkgn bked rd|d miz |drk|jdj rfzn kmvznfmb d~z|fmwfg- Znd l|kbbfmb
|fbnzw kaimd wddedj zi ld ri|zn fz zi znde- Znd wfexad kgz ic giexdzfzfim wddedj zi eizfskzd
znd wztjdmzw wfexav zi miz aiwd zi zndf| c|fdmjw kmj gakwwekzdw wi kw zi ksifj znd z|kwn%
zka`fmb- Kjjfzfimkaav mizdri|znv! fw znkz wied ic znd ei|d fmz|isd|zdj wztjdmzw rni rd|d
mi|ekaav nfbn%xd|ci|efmb ldgked skatklad gieeijfzfdw ldvimj zvxfgka fmzd|kgzfimw-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
38/45
7>
Wztjv \dwtazw?
Znd jkzk rkw giaadgzdj c|ie znd |dwtazw ic 7 jfccd|dmz ilodgzfsd kwwdwwedmzw rnfgn rd|d
kaa r|fzzdm kmj x|isfjdj lv znd zd~zlii` xtlafwnd|- Fm znd zkladw ldair zndwd k|d |dcd||dj zi kw
Zdwz K! Zdwz L! kmj Zdwz G- Zri ic zndwd kwwdwwedmzw rd|d wdgzfim {tfdw ic kxx|i~fekzdav zdm
{tdwzfimw .Zdwz K kmj G&- Znd |dekfmfmb rkw k giex|dndmwfsd gnkxzd| zdwz giex|fwdj ic klitz
ci|zv {tdwzfimw- Znd wdgzfim {tfdw rd|d cfaa%fm%znd%lakm ! ekzgnfmb! etazfxad%gnifgd i| k
ef~zt|d znd|dic- Znd gnkxzd| zd~z rkw etazfxad%gnifgd d~gatwfsdav-
Fc wztjdmzw fm k gimz|ia gakww rd|d klwdmz im znd jkv ic km kwwdwwedmz! zndv rd|d bfsdm
znd kwwdwwedmz kw wiim kw zndv |dzt|mdj! fc zndv jfjmz cdda klad zi zk`d fz im znd jkv ic zndf|
|dzt|m! zndf| wgi|d rkw miz gitmzdj fm znd gimz|ia b|itx wgi|d- Znfw rkw jimd ldgktwd ic znd
zdmjdmgv ic wztjdmzw zi wnk|d zdwz fzdew rfzn zndf| xdd|w rni efwwdj fz- Fc k wztjdmz fm znd
d~xd|fedmzka b|itx rkw klwdmz ci| znd kaa ic znd |dsfdr bked! zndf| wgi|d rkw miz gitmzdj fm
znd wztjv |dwtaz0 fc k wztjdmz rkw klwdmz ci| xk|z ic k |dsfdr bked .f-d- k imd%jkv klwdmgd fm znd
gkwd ic zri jkvw ri|zn ic bkedxakv& zndf| wgi|d rkw fmgatjdj fm znd wztjv |dwtazw-
K mizd im zfefmb? Zdwz K rkw znd wdgimj kwwdwwedmz bfsdm kczd| znd fmz|ijtgzfim ic znd
sk|fklad- Zdwz L rkw bfsdm klitz kz znd efjxifmz ic znd wztjv- Zdwz G rkw znd akwz kwwdwwedmz
bfsdm tmjd| znd wztjv kmj rkw kawi jimd wni|zav kczd| znd dmj ic wzkzd zdwzfmb- Fz rkw imd ic
znd wni|zd| kwwdwwedmzw- Kawi fm znd k|dk ic zfefmb! fz ekvld mizdri|znv! znkz znd
D~xd|fedmzka Gakww rkw kz znd efjjad ic znd jkv! znd gakww |fbnz ldci|d atmgn0 Gimz|ia Gakww ;
rkw |fbnz kczd| atmgn k zfed znkz gkm ld k lfz ei|d gnkizfg0 kmj Gimz|ia Gakww < rkw znd akwz
xd|fij ic znd jkv-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
39/45
76
Znd ilodgzfsfzv ic znd kwwdwwedmzw! f-d- zndf| akg` ic k r|fzzdm |dwximwd xi|zfim rkw zi
kaair ci| jkzk kmkavwfw zi ld kw gadk| kmj ilodgzfsd im znd xk|z ic znd fmwz|tgzi| kw xiwwflad- Kaa
kwwdwwedmzw rd|d wgi|dj lv znd zdkgnd| kmj zndm jitlad gndg` lv k ZK ci| kggt|kgv-
.Wdd |dwtazw zkladw md~z xkbd&
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
40/45
:8
Zkladw?
Zklad ;
D~xd|fedmzka Gakww .DG& Zdwz K Zdwz L Zdwz G
Ksd|kbd Wgi|d .$& 36-: 3;-: 6
Nfbndwz Wgi|d .$& 68 68-: ;88
Airdwz Wgi|d .$& ;4-7
Nfbndwz Wgi|d .$& >4 ;88 28
Airdwz Wgi|d .$& 8
Zklad 7
Gimz|ia Gakww < .G-6 :8-:
Wzj- Jds- ;3-< ;7-: 8 3< 28
Airdwz Wgi|d .$& 78 ;:-7 8
Zklad :
Kaa wgi|dw k|d $ Zdwz K Zdwz L Zdwz G
DG Ksd|kbd Wgi|d 36-: 3;-: 6-6 :8-:
G;! G< Ksb 3;-: : +;>-64 +44-4
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
41/45
:;
Gimgatwfimw kmj Jfwgtwwfim?
Znd jkzk ci| Zdwz K wnir znkz fm znd gkwd ic znd dk|av xk|z ic znd wztjv! znd|d rkw km
ksd|kbd >$ fmg|dkwd fm kgnfdsdedmz ic znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx isd| znd gimz|ia b|itxw- Kz znkz
xifmz fm znd wztjv! znd DG rkw wzfaa cfbt|fmb itz znd x|igdjt|dw ic znd bked kmj rkw miz vdz
|dkaav dexaivfmb bkefmb wz|kzdbfdw af`d zniwd jfwgtwwdj fm znd edznij wdgzfim- Zndv rd|d
ckefafk| rfzn znd bdmd|ka x|fmgfxadw ic rfmmfmb znd bked kmj znd fjdk ic ckefafk|fzv rfzn znd
ekzd|fka fm i|jd| zi wtggddj ltz mimd ic znd edzk%bked wz|kzdbfdw rd|d fm xakgd- Kjjfzfimkaav!
znd|d rkw k gd|zkfm akg` ic jfwgfxafmd k|itmj kjnd|dmgd zi znd |iad ic znd Zdke Wxdk`d|- Znfw
iggkwfimkaav gktwdj gimctwfim kmj kmwrd|%fmxtz d||i|w- Imd zdke fm xk|zfgtak| nkj jfccfgtazv fm
ekwzd|fmb znfw jfwgfxafmd kmj fz adj zi wfbmfcfgkmz lfg`d|fmb- Kczd| znd Zdwz K kwwdwwedmz! znd|d
rkw k gakww jfwgtwwfim zi |defmj wztjdmzw ic x|igdjt|dw ltz kawi zi kf| kmj f|im itz c|twz|kzfimw
ldzrddm wztjdmzw-
Znd jkzk ci| Zd~z L wnir k b|dkzd| jfccd|dmgd fm znd adsda ic kgnfdsdedmz fm znd DG kmj
G; kmj G
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
42/45
:$! G; j|ixxdj km ksd|kbd ic ;6-2$!
kmj G< j|ixxdj km ksd|kbd ic ;>-
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
43/45
:7
Wfmgd fz rkw tmfci|eav kzvxfgka kg|iww kaa wdgzfimw! znd |dwtazw ic Zdwz L rd|d wzfaa gimwfjd|dj
skafj- Fm ckgz! znkz zndwd |dwtazw gimzfmtd zi wnir k xiwfzfsd dccdgz ic znd sk|fklad dsdm jt|fmb
kzvxfgka gimjfzfimw wz|dmbzndmw zndf| wtxxi|z ic znd nvxizndwfw-
Zdwz G gkm ld fmzd|x|dzdj kw ldfmb k jkzk xifmz znkz rkw km itzafd| ldgktwd ic znd
j|kekzfg jfccd|dmgd fm wgi|dw kmj kgnfdsdedmz- Nirdsd|! rndm k {tkafzkzfsd mizd fw kjjdj!
znfw wtxxiwfzfim fw efzfbkzdj- Kw mizdj ldci|d! Zdwz G zii` xakgd wni|zav kczd| znd gimgatwfim ic
wzkzd zdwzfmb- Gkafci|mfk wzkzd zdwzfmb ci| >zn b|kjd|w fmgatjdw zri ei|d zdwz znkm fz jidw ci|
iznd| efjjad wgniia wztjdmzwk nfwzi|v zdwz .zdwzdj imav fm 4zn! >zn! kmj ;;zn b|kjdw kmj
gisd|w znd fmzd|sdmfmb gimzdmz ic znd mim%zdwzdj vdk|w& kmj wgfdmgd- Fz fw wkcd zi wkv znkz lv
znkz zfed .rndm Zdwz G rkw kjefmfwzd|dj&! znd wztjdmzw fm znd wztjv! rndznd| gimz|ia i|
d~xd|fedmzka rnd|d kz k xifmz ic zdwz ckzfbtd-
Nirdsd|! zdkgnfmb gkmmiz gdkwd jtd zi znd iggt||dmgd ic wzkzd zdwzw- Rndm ckgdj rfzn
znd x|iwxdgz ic zk`fmb kmiznd| zdwz! dsdm imd kw wni|z kw znfw wdgzfim {tf! eiwz ic znd wztjdmzw
rd|d tmdmzntwfkwzfg- Znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx! nirdsd|! nkj k gnkmbd fm kzzfztjd rndm zndv
|dkafdj znkz imgd kbkfm ci| znfw |dsfdr zndv ritaj ld xakvfmb [tf Wnir0 znd |dsfdr ci| Nfwzi|v
WZK\ rkw ei|d z|kjfzfimka kmj zndv wddedj zi znfm` znkz ei|d ic fz rkw fm wzi|d ci| znde-
Imgd Gkxzkfmw rd|d wdadgzdj kmj wi ci|zn! znd kccdgzfsd cfazd| fm znfw gakww rdmz rkv jirm kmj
zndv imgd kbkfm ldgked |dgdxzfsd zi znd fjdk ic kwwdwwedmz kbkfm- Znd |dwtazw ic Zdwz G wnitaj
ld fmzd|x|dzdj! znd|dci|d! ei|d fm zd|ew ic rnkz znd sk|fkladw dccdgz im znd kccdgzfsd cfazd| kmj
kzzfztjd zirk|j znd zkw` rkw kw etgn kw fzw dccdgz im |dzdmzfim kmj zdwz wgi|d- Fm dwwdmgd! twd
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
44/45
::
ic znd |dsfdr bked rkw kaeiwz k bfeefg` zi bdz znd wztjdmzw zi ltv fmzi adk|mfmb znd ekzd|fka
kbkfm! miz ci| znd wk`d ic adk|mfmb! ltz zi xakv kmj giexdzd dccdgzfsdav fm znd bked kbkfm-
Znd |dwtazw gd|zkfmav wdde zi wnir k xiwfzfsd gi||dakzfsd |dwtaz ldzrddm znd twd ic znd
|dsfdr bked kmj znd |dwtazw ic wztjdmz kgnfdsdedmz im znd kwwdwwedmzw- C|ie zndwd jkzk! imd
gkm wt|efwd znkz znd |dsfdr bked nkw k gktwka |dakzfimwnfx im adk|mfmb! kmj ei|d wxdgfcfgkaav
ldgktwd ic znd mkzt|d ic znd GLB twdj fm znfw gkwd! im |dzdmzfim- Ct|znd|! fz wddew c|ie znd
jkzk znkz znd|d rkw k `fmj ic gtetakzfsd dccdgz kmj znkz znd aimbd| znd bked rkw fm twd znd
ei|d ic km fex|isdedmz znd|d rkw fm znd zdwz wgi|dw ic znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx kw giexk|dj
rfzn znd gimz|ia b|itxw- Znfw ekv ld jtd fm xk|z zi znd kzzfztjd rnfgn jdsdaixdj fm znd
d~xd|fedmzka gakww zirk|j znd kxx|ikgn ic zdwzw- Kw znd vdk| x|ib|dwwdj! zndv gimzfmtdj zi
aii` ci|rk|j zi znd x|dx bked- Znd|d rkw k air keitmz ic eimizimv fm znd bked! miz imav
ldgktwd ic znd gnkmbfmb mkzt|d ic znd bked gimzdmz! ltz kawi ldgktwd znd zdkew ek`d%txw
rd|d catfj! gnkmbfmb c|ie bked zi bked- Fz fw kawi ri|zn edmzfimfmb nd|d znkz fc znd gimz|ia
b|itxw rd|d miz bifmb zi cfmfwn zndf| xdm%kmj%xkxd| |dsfdrw fm k wfmbad gakww nit| kmj mddjdj
kmj kjjfzfimka imd! znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx biz k
8/9/2019 CBG Case Study Updated 02-14-10
45/45
Fm ctzt|d! rd|d znfw zi ld |tm kbkfm fm k wfefak| wfztkzfim! kmj rfzn wtccfgfdmz zfed rnfgn
rkw miz x|dwdmz ci| znfw wztjv! k |izkzfim ic znd d~xd|fedmzka b|itx keimb znd wdgzfimw ritaj
adkj zi ei|d gimgatwfsd jkzk- Kczd| znd cf|wz {tk|zd|! rndm znd |fztkaw kmj |itzfmdw! kmj
jfwgfxafmd nksd lddm dwzklafwndj! znd wztjv gitaj ldbfm- Fm {tk|zd| zri Wdgzfim K gitaj ld znd
d~xd|fedmzka b|itx kmj ld {tkmzfzkzfsdav giexk|dj zi L! kmj G- Zndm fm {tk|zd| zn|dd! Wdgzfim
L gitaj zk`d im znd sk|fklad kw fz adksdw Wdgzfim K! dzg- Rnfad F ke wt|d znkz wfefak| |dwtazw
ritaj ld citmj F ldafdsd zndv ritaj ld ei|d gimgatwfsd kmj kwwt|dj fm znd dwzklafwnedmz ic
znd gktwka |dakzfimwnfx-