Download - Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Transcript
Page 1: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Airport DART LinkThe Council’s View

• Sean McGrath• Senior Executive Engineer• Fingal County Council

Page 2: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Introduction

• What is the Airport DART Link?• 7km link from Clongriffin to Airport• Trains to City Centre and

Bray/Greystones• Cost €300M or €200M or €150M• Generate 9 MPPA in 2030

Page 3: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Indicative Route

Page 4: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

History

• 1994 - Dublin Transportation Initiative• Not included – open for future

evaluation• 1997 - A Platform for Change• Not included - low passenger numbers • 2011 – 2030 Vision• Not included – rejected at initial stage

Page 5: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Reasons for Rejection

• Very low flows• No development potential (green

belt,airport)• No additional capacity in city centre

– Displaces Howth / Malahide or Maynooth services

• Does not serve Swords, MetroPark, Ballymun, Drumcondra, Parnell Square, O’Connell Street, St Stephen’s Green

Page 6: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Metro North• Integrated with land use planning (joined up thinking)• 27,000 jobs or 16,000 jobs and 11,000 residential

units• Already approved• Serves: Airport, Swords, MetroPark, Ballymun, DCU,

Drumcondra, Mater Hospital, Parnell Square, O’Connell Street, Trinity College, St Stephen’s Green (14 stops)

• Serves airport employee catchment• Straight from city centre• Critically - new capacity in city centre

Page 7: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

NTA Passenger Numbers

• NTA model peak hour two-way flows:• DART:• 1,400 without Metro North• 500 with Metro North• Metro North:• 22,000• Metro North needs to be built anyway, so

DART is needless and wasteful duplication.

Page 8: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Questions

• How are IE’s flows so much higher than NTA’s?

• There are currently 31 DART stations. How does adding one more station lead to a “50% increase in passenger numbers”?

• Are there any other suburban rail lines without any stations for a length of 7Km?

• Are there any airports within 10Km of their city centre?

Page 9: Airport DART Link The Council’s View

Conclusions

• Not integrated with land use

• Serves only one new station

• Does not serve current employment catchment

• NTA flow forecast are extremely low