AHM 250 - MANAGED HEALTHCARE: AN INTRODUCTION
Summary Document
Table of Contents
1. The Evolution of Healthcare Delivery and Financing..................................12. Basic Concepts of Managed Healthcare........................................................83. Managed Care Organizations, Plans, and Products...................................154. Managed Healthcare for Specialty Services...............................................275. Provider Organizations..................................................................................326. Health Systems Management.......................................................................367. Medical Management I...................................................................................438. Medical Management II..................................................................................519. Managed Healthcare Operations I................................................................6210. Managed Healthcare Operations II...........................................................7211. Legislative and Regulatory Issues in Managed Healthcare..................8612. Ethical Issues in Managed Healthcare...................................................106
1. The Evolution of Healthcare Delivery and Financing
Reading 1A: The Evolution of Healthcare Delivery and Financing in the United States
Define managed care Identify the major factors that influenced the evolution of healthcare delivery and
financing in the United States Describe the role of the government in the development of healthcare delivery and
financing List and describe some factors that limit accessibility to healthcare Discuss how the meaning of quality (as it relates to healthcare) has changed
Reading 1B: Basic Concepts of Benefits, Coverage, and Insurance Explain how traditional indemnity health insurance works List some characteristics of the fee-for-service payment system Define anti selection Explain how deductibles and coinsurance are used in traditional indemnity plans Describe some efforts commonly used to combat the rising costs of healthcare
1
Reading 1A: The Evolution of Healthcare Delivery and Financing in the United States
Managed Care System of healthcare financing and delivery or Various techniques of managing the financing and delivery of healthcare or Different Kind of organizations that practice managed care techniques Accepted Definition Integration of both the financing and delivery of
healthcare within a system that seeks to manage the accessibility ,cost and quality of that care
Historical FactorsVariations of Managed care have been around from the 1900’sEarliest example of Managed Care Org 1910 – Prepaid Physicians Group Practices
These offered a range of medical services thru exclusive physicians in return for a monthly premium.
Blue Cross Plans – 1929 for hospital reimbursementBlue shield Plans – 1939 for physicians reimbursementIndividual Practice Associations (IPA’s) which contracted with physicians in independent fee- for-service practices were established in 1954 as a competitive response to group practice based HMO’s
Statistic – 1999 – 81 million people enrolled in HMO’s – nearly as many as those in PPO’’s and other non HMO plans
Federal HMO Act of 1973This was designed to reduce healthcare costs by increasing competition in the healthcare market and to increase access to healthcare coverage for individuals without insurance or with only limited insurance benefits
4 Key Features Federal qualification requirement
o This act established a process by which HMO’s could obtain federal qualification.
o This was optional licensing – (the state licensing was mandatory for all HMO’s).
o Plans who elected for this option were required to meet a series of standards related to
Minimum benefit packages Enrollment and premiums Financial stability and Quality Assurance
Dual Choice Provisionso This required that the employers with more than 25 employees offer a choice
of traditional indemnity coverage or managed care coverage under either a closed Panel HMO or an open panel HMO.
o Federally qualified HMO’s that wanted to be part of this needed to submit a formal request to the employer
Federal Development Grants and Loanso This offered funding to support planning and start of new HMO’s and service
area expansion for existing HMO’so Available only to federally qualified HMO’s
Exemption from State Laws
2
o Some state laws restricted the development of HMO’so This act exempted federally qualified HMO’s from these State Laws
Positives The act did accomplish its goals of reducing costs and expanding access to
healthcare services. Federal Qualification did offer competitive advantage to HMO’s entering the
healthcare market. They sort of gave them a ‘stamp of approval’ Allowed the HMO to participate in Medicare without providing additional
documentation The dual choice provision gave the HMO access to the Employer Segment of the
market The Federal grants and loans allowed effective competition to the indemnity based
insurance plans
Negatives
Partly hampered their competitive positiono Needed to satisfy a lot of requirements on Quality and Financial Stability
These did NOT apply to Indemnity based programs or Non-Qualified MCO”s Slow implementation of the laws Amendments between 1976 to 1996
o These eliminated and reduced the strict requirements imposed on Federally Qualified HMO’s
o Dual Choice Mandate repealed in 1995o Allowed greater flexibility in designing and marketing these products and
strengthened their emphasis on Quality
Introduction of New Products and Programs
Preferred Provider Organizations o Services by a network of providers o Limited services provided by a non-network of providerso Visit without a specialist referral
Point of Service Productso Combination of traditional indemnity insurance and managed careo Can take both In or Out of network providerso Non Network providers involve more limited benefits and higher out of pocket
expenseso Visits to network specialists require PCP approval
Physician-Hospital Organizationso Coalitions of hospitals and physicianso Vehicles for contracting with MCO’s
Carve-Outso Organizations that contract with MCO’s to provide specific types of services
Mental Health Chiropractors Dental Vision Pharmacy services thru specialty networks
3
Government Influence
Financing Medicare, Medicaid, Federal Employee Health Benefits Program (FEHBP) and State Children’s health Insurance Program (SCHIP)
The government is increasingly turning to managed care as an alternative to traditional fee for indemnity programs.
Statistic – Medicare 6.8 million people enrolled in 1999. Also 17.1 Million Medicaid recipients enroll in some form of MCO. Economic Factors
1. Increased in Healthcare Costsa. Inflationb. Increased cost of service for providers and insurersc. Rapidly Expanding Technology – expensive proceduresd. Increases in Malpractise Lawsuits
i. Award amounts increasedii. Practice Defensive Medicine – unneeded /expensive tests
e. Consumer Expectationsi. Increased health consciousnessii. Cover at whatever cost and Freedom to visit who they likeiii. Unnecessary Treatment –Medically unnecessary procedures – Common
coldf. Lack of Incentive to Control Costs
i. Traditional fee for service – more services more pay!ii. Payment occurred after service rendered
2. Cost Shiftinga. Some coverage to people who can’t pay /can pay at reduced ratesb. Physicians and hospitals receive lower payments for these servicesc. Emergency room treatmentd. Spread these unreimbursed costs to other paying patients – This
Practice of shifting costs from non paying to regular customers is Cost Shifting
3. Frauda. 100 Billion market annuallyb. 10% of national Healthcare billc. $966.14 per family excess cost because of Fraud
Technological Factors
Information management has improved significantly Statistical analysis has helped improve cost and quality Pharmacists can - Determine eligibility/Adverse reaction to a drug/Formulary
compliance/ Preauthorization requirements/Co-payment, deductible and coinsurance requirements
Claims Automationo Reduced Staff/ Increased Accuracy/ Shortened Turnaround times/Turning
health plan data into actual information Paper to Electronic – Costs down by 25% Future Applications of technology
o Administrative – Employee Recruitment/Online formulary/Consulting via email
4
o Customer Service – Physician profiles/Customer feedback/Referral automationo Clinical Applications – health and drug info/ disease mgmt/ Medical Call Center
Social FactorsHigher emphasis on Quality and access to healthcare has happened
Maturing Population- Increase in median ageo Higher increases foreseen in the 55 – 64 categoryo Higher illnesses – and better mechanisms to handle these illnesses
Access to Services – 44 Million did not have access in 1998o Most coverage is thru an employer sponsored group plan – as employee or
dependento BUT employment status does not guarantee health coverageo Higher proportion of self employed and private sector firms with < 25
employees are uninsured High Cost Inverse relationship between employer size and premiums
o Poor Health Risks Don’t qualify Could have preexisting conditions
o Uneven Distribution of Medical Services Very low coverage in rural areas Hospitals have closed in these areas and in inner city localities these
are disproportionately higher than the rest of the country Demographically – coverage is lower in South Central and South
Western parts with large rural populations Also lower income/employment/racial and ethnic groups percentage
o Quest for Quality Employers have become more discriminatory on cost Consumers want higher quality as the most important factor How is quality measured
Safety/Preventive Care/ Access to primary and specialty care/care for chronic illness
National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA)o Health Plan Employer Data Information Set (HEDIS)
American Accreditation Healthcare Commission (URAC) Joint Commission of Accreditation of healthcare organizations
(JCAHO)
Reading 1B: Basic Concepts of Benefits, Coverage, and Insurance
Statistic – 1988 Traditional indemnity 71% of the market share of Employer Sponsored group Health Plans1996 – 74% were managed care and 26% were indemnity plans
Traditional Indemnity Coverage or Fee-for-service- Payment system
Indemnify means to protect from /provide compensation for loss or damage. This reimburses the insured for amounts paid to cover medical expenses
Employer is Policy Holder Pays premiums can collect part/full from employees
Insured visits doctor receives treatment submits a claim to insurer insurer pays benefit to insured or healthcare provider
5
Basic Concepts 1. Risk2. Loss rate – number of times a loss occurs in a group3. Underwriting / Selection of risks – Process of identifying and classifying the potential
degree or risk represented by an insurance applicant4. Anti-selection – Tendency of higher than average risk people to apply for insurance
than below average or average risk people5. Individual insurance evaluation is VERY different from group evaluation
a. Need to provide evidence of insurability in individual insurancei. Activities, health history etc
b. Group – check if the group meets the underwriting requirements6. Group
a. Key question – Can you predict the Loss rate to a great extent?b. Can you avoid Anti selectionc. Prove ‘evidence of Insurability’ if he is a late entrantd. Prove evidence of insurability in case of small groups
7. Characteristics of a group checked includea. Group Sizeb. Groups Composition
i. Steady flow in and out of membersii. Age level of the groupiii. Gender – females are more susceptible than men
c. Level of participationi. Need a 75% or higher to allow otherwise anti-selection danger
d. Level of Benefitsi. Not usually allowed to select benefitsii. But now Cafeteria plans are allowed
e. Occupational Hazardf. Geographic Location
Features of traditional indemnity Plans Deductibles and Coinsurance
o The Coinsurance is calculated on the balance amount after deductible Preexisting Conditions
o Condition for which insured received medical care 3 months prior to coverageo Groups policies say that a condition is NO longer preexisting if
The insured has not received treatment within the last three months for that condition
The insured has been covered under that plan for the last 12 months HIPAA limits this significantly
Initial Efforts to Control and Manage Care
Cost Sharingo Coinsurance, Deductibles and Co-paymentso Higher risk for insured if he increased these 3– but lower premiums
Changing Plan Design/Coverage Optionso Use of Coordination of Benefits
Consider one plan as primary, other as secondary Primary Pays the full benefit amount up to the limit Secondary pays the difference between the amount of expenses and
amount paid by the primary Normally Insured can get COMPLETE REIMBURSEMENT of all expenses
– including out of Pocket expenses
6
Now a new Non Duplication of benefits Provision in the secondary payers plan will limit the amount paid by the secondary payer to the difference between the Primary payer paid amount and the amount the secondary payer would have paid if it was the Primary Plan
Implementing Cost Containment Programso Outpatient careo Preadmission testingo Outpatient Surgeryo Utilization review and case managemento 2nd Surgical Opinion
But carries a high cost of second opinion Redundant if you have a good utilization review program
Preventive Care and Wellness Programso Higher coverage on preventive care – checkups, immunizations ,hypertension
screenings , mammograms etco Wellness programs – nutritional counseling , fitness and exercise programs
Managed Care still emerged despite the best efforts of the indemnity insurers
There had to be a logical link created between the financing and delivery! – Managed provided this link
7
2. Basic Concepts of Managed Healthcare
Reading 2A: Managed Care - Benefits and Networks Define primary care and describe its role in a managed care plan Define copayment Define network and explain its importance in a managed care plan Describe how managed care plans influence and affect availability of healthcareReading 2B: Financing Managed Care Discuss how managed care plans combine the financing and delivery aspects of
healthcare Define capitation Explain how capitation differs from fee-for-service compensation Identify and describe various financing arrangements between managed care plans and
physicians and hospitals
8
Reading 2A: Managed Care - Benefits and Networks
Managed Care and MCOs
Managed Care encompasses more than just cost containment techniques.MCO – Entity that utilizes certain concepts or techniques to manage the accessibility, cost and quality of healthcare.
Difficult to define it very clearly – The following can be described as MCO’s
1. Indemnity Plans with Managed care COmponetns2. PPOs3. HMOs4. POS5. Physician Hospital Organizations6. Physicians Groups7. Physician Practice Management Companies8. Utilization review organizations
Please note that increasing changes in laws and regulations, Mergers and Acquisitions has resulted in the differences between these plans to come down rapidly.
Key Players
1. Providers – Physicians, Nurses, Hospitals, Labs2. Payers – Employers, Federal Agencies, Insurance Firms3. Purchasers – Pay the premium for the healthcare plan4. Members – Enrollees or Customers
Benefits Provide a comprehensive set of Benefits – More than Indemnity These include Physician Services, Hospitalization, Well Child Care, Prenatal Care,
Periodic Health examinations, Eye and Ear Exams, Immunizations, Home Nursing, Emergency Care, Diagnostic services, Outpatient Services, Inpatient and Short Term Rehab services, Physical, occupational and Speech Therapy
A lot of these things were not covered by indemnity – but managed care has found them to be cost effective in the long term.
Some of these services are offered using a small Co-payment. Other Services Provided by MCO’s
i. Ancillary Services – Lab, pharmacy, radiology, physical therapy, medical supplies
ii. Primary care – Care without referral from another iii. Specialty care – secondary care – care delivered by specialists –
outpatient / in patient services provided by acute hospitals
Managed Care have LOWER out of pocket spending than the Traditional Indemnity Plans
They place GREATER emphasis on Preventive Medicine to improve efficiency There are nearly a 1000 MANDATED benefits required by law Legislation is now done by both State and Federal Law
Organized System of Care
‘Network’
9
Groups of Physicians, Hospitals and other medical care providers that a specific manage care plan has contracted to deliver medical services to members
Better benefits from choosing in-network providers Contract also provider the utilization and quality assurance There is a SHARED financial Risk now! Location and availability of network providers
o Number of Physicians/hospitals neededo Geographical location of memberso Combination Services – Ancillary and Secondary Care in the same area
Primary Care This is general medical care that is provided without referral from another physician Primarily focused on preventive care and the treatment of routine injuries/illness Contact Point Primary Care Physician - Gatekeeper
o First contact with the healthcare system o Could be GP, Internist, Pediatrician, OB/GYN, Nurse, Physicians Assistanto Also called Personal Care Physician, Personal Care Provider o Manages authorization of all non emergency medical procedures and referrals
to specialists o Follow up on caseso Tries to refer people to specialists in the network itselfo Some Plans allow two PCP’s – women can select an OB/GYN and a normal
practitionero Shift from a Gatekeeper role to ‘Coordinator of Care’ role
Provider Choice Consumers are feeling that their freedom is restricted New products which offer lesser restrictions are being introduced Lots of consumers resisted change initially because of restricted provider choice But the cost differential started pulling consumers towards Managed Care Can control costs by
o Giving Member the Incentive to select doctors in their networko Negotiating favorable rates with these providers
Enhancing Accessibility via the network
There are many ways in which the MCOs can enhance the access to healthcare1. Premium and Cost Sharing Arrangements
a. There are lower out of pockets as compared to Indemnity plans – making the access easier
2. Emphasis on Primary Care, Prevention and Wellnessa. These are little or no out of pocket expensesb. Premium discounts to employees with Wellness Programsc. Greatest incentives to the customers are given if they visit the PCPd. Till now people who did not have access to the PCP tried to go to emergency
rooms to get treated for things which could more cost effectively be done in a primary care setting
Utilization and Quality Management
Utilization Management is a mechanism that involves managing the use of medical services such that the patient receives necessary, appropriate, high quality care in a cost effective manner UM consists of the following basic techniques
10
Demand Managemento Strategies designed to reduce the overall demand for services by providing
information to the users Utilization Review
o Evaluation of the medical necessity, efficiency and appropriateness of healthcare services
Case Managemento System of identifying members with specific healthcare needs and
developing a strategy to meet these needs and coordinating and monitoring the delivery of these services
Disease Managemento This is a coordinated method of preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic
measures that focuses on management of specific Chronic illnesses or medical conditions
Quality ManagementOrganization wide process of measuring and improving the quality of healthcare provided. The features of this process include
Quality Assurance program oversight and integrity - Senior Executive Credentialing Members rights and complaints resolution process Monitoring Physician practice
11
Reading 2B: Financing Managed Care
Old System – The provider would be rewarded for excessive usage of his service. How does managed care address this issue?
Sharing of RiskFinancial risk – The actual cost of a plan member’s care is diff from projected costThis no longer only rests with the healthcare plan alone – shared by employers/members/payers also
In Fee for Service the cost of medical care is shared by1. Employer – Pays premium
Employee – pays premium/deductibles and coinsurance2. Healthcare Payer 3. Provider – Assumes little or no risk
The two ends of the spectrum – Fee for Service <----------------- CapitationCapitationMethod of paying healthcare services based on the number of patients who are covered for the specific services over a specified period of time – Simple terms – Per Person Per Capita.
How does it work? Critical Metric – The Per person per Month payment Same amount paid irrespective of amount of service The Provider has assumed a lot of the financial risk Highly used in the reimbursement of PCP’s
Capitation increases1. Focus on prevent2. Treatment of illnesses promptly3. Improve the status of health
a. Health screeningsb. Immunizationsc. Follow up care
Making Capitation PaymentsPayments made to
Individual PCP’s Specialty Physicians Group of PCPs Multi Specialty groups of physicians Hospitals and other Providers
Larger the population, more stable is the utilization rates of that population – more reliable estimation of the revenues to cover the costs.
Typical arrangements include1. Global Capitation – Total Capitation. This is a payment that covers virtually all of
the members inpatient and outpatient expenses including physicians, hospitals, specialists and some ancillary services
2. Partial Capitation – A system that may include primary care only (and maybe secondary care ) but no ancillary services
3. Carve out – A medical service that is removed from the scope of service covered by capitation payment and is reimbursed as a separate payment
PMPM payments are influenced by 1. Age
12
2. Sex3. Number of members4. Usage
Capitation for physicians Need to identify the services to be included in the capitation payment Typically Preventive Services, Outpatient care and hospital visits. Other services may be immunizations, diagnostics testing and some surgical
procedures. There is a written contract on what is included between provider and MCO 1999 – 76% of all HMO plans used capitation as payment for physicians
Capitation for Hospitals Clearly define the scope Enforce the utilization standards – through financial benefits More difficult to manage if the out of network option exists
o Need a DUAL compensation mechanismo Reduces the ‘in-network’ Capitation amount to pay for the out of network
usage. Solution – Recalculate the capitation based on % of member hospital admissions
that month Hospitals which purchase global capitation makes a provision for stop-loss
insurance to transfer risk to a third party
Other Financing ArrangementsThese form part of the spectrum between Fee-For-Service and Capitation
Discounted Fee-For-Serviceo MCO’s seek a discount from the physician’s normal feeso Pay amt BELOW the usual, customary and reasonable Fee (UCR)o UCR Fee was the fee charged by the old indemnity insurance firmso UCR fees are determined bu collecting data on charges for specific conditions
based on the Current Procedural Terminology Codeo CPT was started by the American Medical Association
It’s a 5 digit code which identifies the procedures performed by providers
Fee Scheduleo Also called Fee Allowance , fee maximum or capped feeo MCO determines what it thinks is an acceptable fee for a serviceo Similar to discounted fee-for-serviceo This transfers financial risk from the MCO to the providero The MCO is NOT allowed to bill the “balance bill” - ie the amount above
the max limit to the member Resource-based Relative Value Scales
o Relative Value Scales (RVS) or relative value of serviceso Assigns a weighted average value to each medical procedure or service as
defined by the CPT codeo To determine the amount the MCO must pay to the physician, this is
multiplied by a money multipliero These multipliers are negotiated between the plan and providerso BIG PROBLEM with straight RVS system – Incentive mechanism
Surgery is given more weightage than cognitive services Disincentive to restrict services provided
13
o Resource Based Relative Value Scale – This attempts to take into account all the resources that physicians use in providing care to the patients, including physical, procedural, educational, mental and financial
Diagnosis Related Groupso Medicare tried to control costs by implementing a Prospective Payment
System (PPS) for medicare reimbursement hospitalso In the context of medicare, a PPS refers to a system of reimbursement based
on Diagnosis Related Groups (DRG’s)o DRG classifies hundreds of hospital services based on number of criteria like
Primary and secondary diagnosis , Surgical procedures, Age, Gender and Presence of Complications
o The provider is paid a fixed amount based for each DRGo Payment is made on the average expected usage of hospital resources in a
given geographical areao Medicare PPS – saved costs Providers receive a fixed compensation PER
HOSPITALIZATION, regardless of cost/length of stay.o MCO’s have started using this route for reimbursing hospitals
Salaryo Pay salaries to physicianso Based on average earnings and also have performance bonuses and incentive
paymentso Some level of risk sharing
Per Diemso Pay a specific negotiated rate per inpatient Dayo Differs based on serviceo Variation includes a higher per diem charge for the first inpatient dayo There is a ‘Sliding scale’ of reimbursement with the discount increasing
with patient volumeo Works best in hospitals where the utilization patterns are predictable
Other Provisionso Use of Withhold
This is a percentage of the provider’s payment that is held back during a plan year. This is used to offset or pay for any cost overruns for referral or hospital services. The rest of the money is then returned
These are most commonly used for capitation and Fee-Schedule reimbursements
These values range between 5% and 20%o Risk pools for specific services
These could include referral (specialty care), hospital and institutional care and ancillary services
MCO pays Capitation amount to each PCP Additional PMPM into a referral pool PMPM into a hospital pool and PMPM into an ancillary pool
Once these expenses are made, any excess funds are paid to physicians who participate in the pool
14
3. Managed Care Organizations, Plans, and Products
Reading 3A: The Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) Identify and describe the general characteristics of HMOsReading 3B: Types of HMO Models Differentiate between a closed-panel HMO and an open-panel HMO Distinguish among the various HMO models in terms of provider relationships and
compensation arrangementsReading 3C: PPOs, POSs, and Managed Indemnity Describe a preferred provider organization and explain how it differs from other types of
managed care plans List and describe two characteristics common to most POS products Describe one major difference between an EPO and a PPO
15
Reading 3A: The Health Maintenance Organization (HMO)
Health Maintenance Organization is a healthcare system that assumes or shares both the financial risks and the delivery risks associated with providing the medical services to a voluntarily enrolled population in a certain area in return for a fixed fee
These are also referred to as Prepaid Group Practices Most states require them to be classified as a corporation. Need to comply with regulations in ALL the states they operate. May be for-profit or not-for-profit type of corporations
BackgroundPopular in the 1970’s because of federal legislations the HMO act of 1973 removed some barriersThis act allowed them to be Federally Certified and pre-empt state laws in some cases
To be federally qualified the HMO could noto Exclude preexisting conditions o Offer the following services
Healthcare delivery in a certain geographic area Basic and Supplemental healthcare services Voluntary membership for the enrolled population
Needed to offer mandatory Dual Choice Provisions (both indemnity and Managed Care options)
This federal route provided market access to national employers 1995 – federal law Eliminated the dual choice option The grants have now died out and dual choice has been eliminated – lesser
incentives to form a federally qualified HMO This is still important for Medicare and large employer contracts HMO’s are heavily regulated to ensure solvency and member access to quality
medical care The License they get in each state is called ‘Certificate of Authority’ Try and assure quality by accrediting to national agencies
Benefits
Membership Member = Subscriber + dependent Most of the enrollment is through group plans
o Contracting relationship is with the HMO and Employer HMO offers an employer an OPEN ENROLLMENT PERIOD (usually 30 days) during
which all the employees are to be given automatic admission Federally qualified HMO’s and some state qualified HMO’s must accept the risk for
pre-existing Conditions Individuals are directly contacting the HMO and picking up insurance also Financing could be national but the delivery of healthcare primarily local. Important criteria used for selecting and evaluating HMO’s
o Access , Current cost/premium, Satisfaction, Financial strength, Reputation, Ease of doing business, Outcome of care, Wellness/Prevention Focus, NCQA accreditation, physician turnover
Their market reach stretches right across employees ,dependents ,individuals ,small groups ,large groups, medicare / Medicaid.
Comprehensive Care
There is a base standard set of benefits given by law
16
Offer extensive preventive care programso Prenatal Care, well baby care, routine examinations, 24 helplines, childhood
immunizations are exampleso Wellness programs and health programs
Comprehensive benefits – Comprehensive care and cost effective and timely
Networks
Negotiated Contracts with providers Form its network of facilities and physicians Need to consider
o Accesso Credentialing – what to verify, when to consider recredentialing and peer
reviewso Contract relationships
Employ or buy services? Compensation mechanisms
Physicians
This could be through direct contract or through independent contract Need to contract with sufficient NUMBER and TYPE of physicians Based on
o Size, location, network adequacy, medical needs of members, employer or purchaser requirements, provider education, board certification and work history
Need to verify his credentials This is required to – maintain clinical competence, professional Conduct and
practice management Need to select a PCP from the network
o Usually a internal medicine/family practitioner for adults and pediatrician for children
o Some HMO allow specific conditions like obstetricians to go out of the network
o Also using nurses for PCP function
HospitalsSame issues of access/credentialing/contract engagements are consideredAccreditation by the joint committee on healthcare organizations
Ancillary ServicesThese are auxiliary or supplemental services usually used to support diagnosis and treatment of a patient’s condition and include stuff like
Labs Radiology Other diagnostic services Home health services /nursing home centers Physical Therapy Occupational Therapy Pharmacies Surgery Centers
Financing
Prepaid Care Fixed monthly premium paid in advance of delivery of managed care This generally covers most healthcare services
17
HMO’s USUALLY don’t impose coinsurance or deductible requirements They will require some level of copayment
Negotiated Provider Compensation1. Fees or discounted Fee schedules2. Relative Value Scales3. Capitation4. Salary5. Per Diem6. Diagnosis Related Groups
Physicians Typical arrangements include salary, capitation, and FFS compensation Capitation is used for PCP’s The type of fee arrangements that an HMO uses distinguishes the various HMO
models Many HMO’s use the risk pool mechanism to facilitate risk sharing and utilization
mgmt
HospitalsHMO’s reimburse fees in many waysDepends on factors like
State laws Market Competition Hospital Ownership of HMO Level of Predictability of data Incentives like
o Service Bonuseso Quality bonuseso Risk Pools
Disincentiveso Exceeding utilization goals
Those providers under DRG’s of capitation may negotiate a stop-loss-provision in their HMO contracts
Costs beyond this point will be reimbursed by a different payment system like Discounted FFS
Ancillary Service Providers Range from discounted Fee for service to capitation Capitation helps share risk with the provider and manage costs In Return By accepting capitation, the ancillary provider gets a stable and large
income flow Capitation is good for discrete services like diagnostic testing But Capitation and discounted fees arrangements are used home healthcare or
hospice care
Utilization ManagementPhysicians
Managed through risk pools, capitation and physician Practice guideline Referral management, copayments for office visits and options like nurse advice lines
and subacute clinic for emergency careHospitals
In-patient utilization review, convurrent and retrospective review of admissions, precertification for inpatient hospitalization, discharge planning and case management
18
COMPLIANCEo All medicare/mediclaim beneficiaries should comply with utilization
management requirements set forth by HCFAo Other requirements may come from accreditation agencies and state laws
Quality Management Credentialing / recredentialing and peer review for PCP /Specialists/ Accreditation
standards for hospitals and ancillary services providers nad overall plan accreditation standards
Compliance with HCFA is essential for medicare and Medicaid Employers review a HMO’s accreditation status in its health plan employer data and
information set (HEDIS) measures to evaluate plan quality
19
Reading 3B: Types of HMO Models
Closes Panel and Open Panel HMO’sClosed Panel HMO – Physicians are either HMO employees or belong to a group of physicians that contract with the HMO. This panel is ‘closed’ to other physicians
Closed Access – Plan members are not allowed to obtain medical services from out of the network but only thru PCP.
Open Panel HMO – Any physician who meets the HMO’s standards of care may be eligible to contract with the HMO as a provider. These guys operate from their own offices and see others patients are well as HMO members. This panel is ‘open’ to any physician who is selected by the HMO.
Open Access – Plan members may self refer themselves to a specialist either in or out of the network at full/reduced benefit.
Key differencesClosed Panel HMO’s Open Panel HMO’sProviders are HMO employees/ contracted to the HMO
Providers are independent and may be selected to join the HMO if they meet the criteria
Providers operate out of HMO facilities or group practice facilities
Providers operate out of their own offices
Providers generally see only HMO members
See both HMO and non HMO members
Select PCP from HMO n/w Select a PCP from HMO n/wNeed PCP referral because the services are only covered if the specialists are in the network
Members in a few cases may self refer to specialists inside or outside the n/w without going thru PCP
HMO Models IPA Model Staff Model Group Model Network Model
Distinguished by Contractual relationship, provider reimbursement
Early HMO’s were Staff or group model HMO’sCurrent trend is towards a mixed model HMO – combination of characteristics of > 1 HMO.For e.g. to provider geographic coverage to a multi state employer, an IPA model HMO in one state may contract with a network model HMO in another state.Or a staff model HMO may have separate contracts with specialty group
Independent Practice Association Most comment HMO model today Contract is with one or more physicians in independent practice who agree to provide
medical services to plan members IPA is a separate legal entity established to give member physicians a negotiating
vehicle for contracting purposes Physicians who meet IPA criteria for participating providers may be selected to
contract with the IPA which in turn contracts with the HMO
20
They offer contracts with several parties – Individual PCP’s, Specialists, Multi-Specialty Groups ( group of physicians with two or more different specialties)
Variation is the IPA model is a direct contract model HMO – this is also called direct model HMO
o The HMO contracts directly with the individual physicians who provider the medical services to the HMO members
o There is no IPA or legal entity representing the doctorsStructure
This may be a closed panel or Open panel plan Closed Panel IPA model HMO
o A HMO and Community physicians establish an IPA and recruit other physicians
o Because the HMO helped establish the IPA, the contract between the IPA and the HMO is usually an exclusive contract
o Sometimes a hospital helps establish the IPA, which contracts with the HMO to provider clinical services
o Community based Hospital based IPA is usually a closed panel IPA as members must be affiliated with a specific HMO/Hospital to be members
Contract o Nature of physician-patient relationshipo Duties and responsibilities to be assumed by physicians, the IPA and HMOo Open-panel IPA – physicians in the service area independently establish the
IPA They are free to contract on a non exclusive basis An Open-Panel HMO may close its provider panel when it finds that
adequate people are on boardo Direct Contract model HMO – recruits a wide range of skillsets
Physicians may contract with other MCO’s if they wish This is an open panel HMO because all physicians who are qualify the
criteria can joinCompensation
Usually based on fee-for-service (FFS) or through capitation IPA then compensates the member physicians Many IPAs use capitation with PCP’s and discounted FFS basis / resource based
relative value scale for specialists Capitation forms a SIGNIFICANT component of the funds inflow to a IPA Use withholds and risk pools to share incentives Direct Contract Model – Compensate PCP’s through Capitation and specialists
through discounted FFS HMO assumes MOST of the risk associated with providing medical services to plan
members
Features and Comparisons They appeals to both HMO’s and their members by providing a wide range of
physician services Have access to medical care at individual physicians offices located throughout the
HMO’s provider network The combination of choice and private physician practice has given the open panel
IPA HMO models a competitive edge over staff and group model HMO’s An IPA’s participating physicians operate out of their own offices so that the HMO
does not have to incur the expenses associated with buying or building offices Capitation payments & withholds for PCPs and discounted FFS payment for
specialists offer the IPA model HMO and the IPA cost control opportunity Open panel – can have multi HMO contacts increasing access
21
However cost control might be an issue – difficult to achieve economies of scale with independent offices
Difficult to achieve consistency in quality and utilization management Under the direct control model – HMO’s have to recruitment physicians directly
Utilization management and quality management are other administrative responsibilities of a direct contract model HMO
Staff Model HMO This is a closed panel Plan – Physicians are employees of the HMO Contractual arrangements are exclusive and they need to become employees HMO needs to employ enough specialists and PCP’s to meet its members needs
Structure Most physicians practice in ambulatory care facilities Definition: An Ambulatory care facility/medical clinic / medical center is a care center
that provides a wide range of healthcare services including1. Preventive care2. Acute Care3. Surgery4. Outpatient care in a centralized facility
A one stop shop – Access to physicians and non physician services Contract with hospitals and pharmacies to provide non physician services
Compensation Distinguishing factor is Reimbursement – Compensation is primarily Salary Now begin to offer financial incentives like withholds and bonuses These are usually tied to medical expenses and other controllable costs The risk here PRIMARILY is with the HMO There are very few FFS patients seen in this model
Features and Comparisons The HMO can achieve economies of scale, manage utilization better and provide
consistent quality and evaluation of performance Convenience and local access to all facilities in one place is a big draw More time Consuming to establish and maintain – huge capital costs Not very fast moving owing to capital costs required to make changes Limited provider choice (for members) and limited access (for providers)
Group Model HMO (Group practice HMO) Contracts with a multi specialty group of physicians - Employees of a group practice Group Practice – Corporation/Partnership/professional association/ legal entity Share office space / Support staff/medical records and medical equipment Consists of both PCP’s and specialists Sub contract non supported services to other doctorsStructurePhysicians are employees of the group practice in which they (may) have an equity interest
Captive group model Physicians sign management services agreement with the HMO and the practice
primarily focuses on the HMOs members This is usually exclusive making it a closed Panel HMO takes care of the management services/admin part HMO may also own the facilities or equipment used by group practice
Independent Group Model Established group practice – usually a multi specialty group – contracts with the
HMO
22
The physicians may own or sponsor an HMO but may also contract with other HMOs
Open Panel Plans
Compensation Negotiated Capitation Rate to the group practice Group practice determines the physician salaries and incentives Could include financial incentives for utilization management Group practice bears the risk of providing medical care
Features and Comparisons This has lower startup costs vis-à-vis a staff model No need to provider a facility/ No fixed expenses on physician’s salary Limited by geographic location of the group practice Differing quality between facilities unlike staff models with the ACFs Access may be limited by the closed-panel nature of captive group model
Network Model HMOs Contract with one or more group practice of physicians / specialty groups Extension of a group model Wide range of services Can be either an Open or Closed Panel
Compensation Capitation Basis Physician groups bear most of the risk Group practice compensates specialists who the PCP’s refer the members to Share profits when utilization is lower and can see non-HMO members
23
Features and ComparisonsMembers have access to a broad range of services (particularly open panel ones)
HMO ModelPhysician Location
OpenClosed Panel
Physician Relationship
Physician Reimbursement
Advantages to HMOs
Disadvantages
IPA ModelSeparate physician offices
BothPCPs and specialists are both independent
PCPs: Capitation and Discounted FFSSpecialists: Discounted FFS
Provider Choice and lower startup costs
Limited Utilization and quality control No economies of scale
Staff ACFs Closed
PCP’s : Employees and Specialists: employees or independent
PCPs: salariesSpecialists: discounted FFS
Utilization, Quality control, Economies of scale
Provider restrictionsCapital Intensive
GroupSeparate Group Practice
Both
PCPs and specialists are both independent
Group Practice: CapitationPCPs: Salaries and Incentives Specialists: varied
Lower startup costs, utilization and Quality Control
Provider restrictionsPotentially limited geographic access
NetworkSeparate Group Practice
BothPCPs and specialists are both independent
Group Practice: CapitationPCPs: Salaries and incentives Specialists: varied
Broader range of services and multiple locations
Varied utilization and quality control
24
Reading 3C: PPOs, POSs, and Managed Indemnity
Preferred Provider OrganizationsHealthcare benefit arrangement designed to support services at a discounted cost by providing incentives for members to use designated healthcare providers (who contract with the PPO at a discount), but which also allows the member to avail of services out of the network.Financial incentives for in-network usage include lower copayments/coinsurance and maximum limit on out-of-pocket cost for in-network usage
Most PPOs Arrangement between a panel of providers and purchasers Preferred providers agree to specified fee schedules in return for preferred status and
have to comply with Quality and Utilization Management targets PPO sponsors vary Physician Groups/ Hospitals/BCBS plans/ TPA’s/
employers/HMO/Independent investors/Joint Ventures However 50% plus of all PPO plans are owned by insurance firms MOST don’t bear any financial risk PPO may be a decentralized n/w of preferred providers which are established by
employers or it could be leased from some other organization Or it could be administratively centralized, with not only a PP n/w but also the
capability to manage administrative functions and assume some financial risk
Benefits Wide range of services including specialty services
o Managed Pharmacy, Psychiatric Mental Health, Chiropractic Care, Podiatry, Case Management , wellness, vision care, dental care, workers compensation, dental care, long term care
Networks Contract with PCPs, specialists/diagnostic facilities/hospitals/ancillary services On average the 1079 PPO’s contracted with 8421 physicians Less restrictive on the out of network usage Can Visit specialist without a referral
Financing Most PPO arrangements did not have providers sharing financial risk They were paid on a FFS basis and passed on risk similar to a traditional indemnity
plan Some have started including this into their contracts PRIMARY FUNCTION: Negotiate contracts between the providers and the
organizations that buy the coverage Most Common compensation:
o Physicians: Fee Schedule or Capped Fee method 82% of all physicians were paid this way
o Hospitals 52% were paid on Per Diem 31% on discounted Charges
Incentive to join PPO? Increased Patient Volume
Utilization Management In house review of utilization BLEND HAPPENING WITH HMOS
o Utilization Management being adopted by PPOo Selection of PCP in PPO too
Quality Management High percentage routinely recredentialed their network physicians
25
Also Physician Peer Review
Other Types of Managed Care
Specialty PPOsThese work only in defined areas – physical therapy, dental care, pharma, lab services, chiropractor service, behavioral healthcare
Exclusive Provider Organizations Similar in structure and administration to a PPO Out-of-network care is not generally covered making it like a HMO These are developed by PPO corporations to compete with HMOs LEGAL ISSUE They are regulated by state laws and NOT by state and federal laws
as is true for HMOs Some states have begun to treat EPOs like HMOs
Point of Service ProductsFastest growing productThis is a hybrid product which combines the traditional group insurance with HMOs and PPOs
Point of Service product allows the members to chose at the point of service on whether to go within the plans network or to seek medical care out of the network. This offers a greater amount of coverage within the network and requires members to pay deductibles and coinsurance for coverage out of the network
This combines HMO features and out of network coverage with economic incentives ( like copayment instead of coinsurance)
HMO’s generally offer POS options Out-of-network usage is generally a per person cap and the usage is insured as a fee-
for-service-coverage Most common characteristics
o Freedom of choice – customize healthcareo Cost cutting effort and structure of coverageo PCP is used for medical services and for referrals within the n/w
Capitation is used to compensate the physician These are very popular with employers as they act like a bridge between traditional
indemnity plans and the MCO’s DRAWBACK
o Costlier to administer as compared to traditional group health plan
Managed Indemnity Plans These include managed care overlays like precertification and utilization review Managed care devices are primarily to control costs
26
4. Managed Healthcare for Specialty Services
Reading 4A: Managed Healthcare for Specialty Services Explain how an MCO might carve out the delivery of specialty services Define specialty HMOs Describe three types of managed dental plan Describe the four basic strategies that managed behavioral health organizations
(MBHOs) use to manage the delivery of behavioral healthcare services List four activities that a typical pharmacy benefit management (PBM) plan uses to
manage pharmaceutical utilization
27
Reading 4A: Managed Healthcare for Specialty ServicesThese are services that are generally considered outside the standard medical-surgical services. They involve different types of providers and delivery systems than do standard medical servicesExamples include
Prescription Drugs , Mental health/substance abuse , Dental, Vision ,Long term Care, Workers Compensation , Chiropractic care, rehab services, home healthcare, cardiac surgery, Oncology, Care for Patient with Chronic diseases, diagnostic services like radiology
Two options for employers and health plans wrt Specialty Services Develop and Maintain their own programs Carve out the delivery and management of these services
Carve out refers to the separation of a medical service(or group of services) from the basic set of benefits in some way
These may be through a different compensation mechanism OR Use of a separate network or delivery system E.g. AIDS services may be carved Freq used services: Dental , Behavioral healthcare and Pharma
Carve Outs EmergeEconomies of scale for certain specialtiesKey Characteristics
1. An easily defined benefit2. Defined Patient Population3. High or rising costs4. Inappropriate utilization Comprehensive Carve-out - Manages all the details including network management /
quality / utilization / case management / claims administration Partial Carve-Out – MCO retains the management of the selected activities Comprehensive Carve-out: Compensation is usually on a CAPITATION BASIS Partial Carve-out: On a FFS or Fee-plus percentage of savings basis Legal Challenges – Some state require HMO’s to retain these services
Some States have provisions for Specialty HMO’s
Dental Care Increasing willingness of Dentists to negotiate with HMOs Increased admin/overhead costs/oversupply of dentists have moved dentists to this
plan Managed care products are cheaper than indemnity products Three types of plans are
o Dental HMOs, Dental PPO’s and Dental POS
Dental HMOs Started in 1950s with the preventive care benefits realized This is an organization which provides dental benefits to its members in exchange for
some form of prepayment No benefits for out of network services This is regulated at state level Has around 18% of the dental insurance market share
Dental PPOs 31% market share in 1999 Provide through network of dentists who offer discounted feeds Visited out of network you get less benefits
28
Most compensated on a Discounted FFS basis
Dental POS Option This is generally offered in conjunction with a DHMO The consumer chooses at the time of appointment where they want to go
Behavioral Healthcare
Deals with mental health and chemical dependencyThis has grown in prominence in the last few decades, the cost of delivery has sharply increased. Management strategies to tackle this failed.
Initially they looked to cost sharing as a mechanism to manage costs and also had benefit limits.
Then looked to limitation on services covered – for certain illnesses, certain services or certain patient groups
Tried to limit the ACCESS to services – through triage systems and waiting lists based on priority
Managed Behavioral healthcare organizations emerged in the 1980s 1997 – 149million people were enrolled
o Specialized knowledgeo Better outcomes and proper diagnosis and treatmento Techniques used to manage care include
Alternative treatment levels Offered benefit packages that included full coverage Developed clinically reasonable care
o Acute care – continuous intensive monitoringo Post acute care – continuous monitoring in a structured
environ but < Acute Careo Partial Hospitalization o Intensive outpatient care – extensive therapyo Outpatient Care
Alternative treatment settings Acute is in psychiatric hospitals etc , for high risk patient Post Acute – in Skilled Nursing homes Partial Hospitalization in rehab centers or halfway homes
Alternative treatment methods Drug therapy, psychotherapy and counseling Licenses Clinical Social workers (LSCWs) and Marriage, family or
child counselors (MFCCs) Crisis intervention
Directing Patients to appropriate Care Mechanisms to direct individuals to the most appropriate care PPOs and Open access plans – Directly access healthcare services Most other plans – PCP’s or other gatekeepers Need authorization of payment of services before seeing a specialist (278) Assessment could be through a PCP, centralized referral or employee assistance
programs PCPs as gatekeepers
o Focal point for all healthcare needo But PCP’s lack the experience necessary to diagnose and treat these
problems.o Provide educational programs – Clinical Practice Guidelines
Centralized Referral Systems
29
o Telephone or in-person referralo This can provide faster access to behavioral healthcare than a PCPo More accurate diagnosis and effective treatmento Not grassroot linked like PCP – disruption in care
Employee Assistance Programso This the first point of contact for this kind of careo Can help trap the problem earlyo Lack of expertise is a problem
Next Generation Started significantly using outpatient treatment Clinical practice guidelines New ideas development of an alternative treatment options, incorporation of
community based resources into healthcare and increased reliance on case management
LAW – Mental Health Parity Act 1996 – Treat the Mental or behavioral health benefits ON PAR with Physical Health services
Pharmacy Benefits Fastest growing market in the US Inappropriate usage of drugs is the reason for 25% of all Medicare admissions A Pharmacy/ Prescription Benefit Management Program
o 88.4% of all HMO’s contracted with PBMso These screen drug interactions by using integrated databases between the
MCO, provider and pharmacy networkServices Offered
Physician Profilingo Data on physician subscribing patterns and comparing these actual
prescribing patterns to expected patterns within a select drug categoryo Peer Comparison is
Drug utilization Reviewo Are the drugs being used safely/effectively/appropriatelyo Quality management – identify problems related to drug ordering ,
dispensing , administration and use of drugs Inappropriate dosage, overuse , underuse, length of time , duplication,
side effects and drug interactionso Monitor patient specific drug problems through prospective, concurrent and
retrospective review. Factors identified include Drug/disease conflict, Drug Control Interactions, Chronic over-
utilization , underutilization, drug/sex drug/age conflicts and drug/pregnancy contraindications
Formulary Managemento Formulary is a listing of drugs classified by therapeutic category or disease
class that are considered preferred therapy for a given managed care population and that are used in prescribed medications
o This is developed by an independent panel of physicians, pharmacistso They can be classified as open or closed
Open formulary – both preferred and other drugs are covered Closed Formulary – only drugs on the preferred list are covered
o These are key tools to get Rebates from the drug manufacturerso Key features of a good Formulary include
Cover all outpatient diseased / Promote Generics/ include all medically necessary drugs/ include the cheapest single source drugs/minimize
30
expensive prescribing/ minimize medically unnecessary prescribing / improve overall cost effectiveness of therapy
Need good communication of the Formulary to physicians and to the pharmacists on the relative benefits of drugs etc
Two types of substitution Generic Substitution
o Dispensing of a generic equivalent Therapeutic Substitution
o Dispensing of a different chemical entity within the same drug class
Prior Authorization
o Medical necessity review – certification of medical necessity prior to the drug dispensing
Additional ServicesMail order pharmacy programs – lower cost deliveryNegotiate discounted rates for the same
Pharmaceutical cards – Issued to plan members. These cards must be presented to the pharmacist before receiving benefitsElectronic processing of claimsCard identifies to which plan the patient belongs
New copayment structure1. Two tier copayment structure
a. Lower copay for a generic and higher copay for branded drug2. Three tier Copayment structure
a. Pay one copay for a generic b. Higher for branded drug included in the planc. Highest for branded drug not included in the plan
PBM contractual arrangement Fee for service
a. Create a retail chain / offer discount on prescribed drugs / perform online claim adjudication.
b. Receives a claim administration fee Risk Sharing
a. Agree on a target cost per person per monthb. In case of exceeded/underun of cost PBM shares the losses /savings
Capitation Contractsa. Provide all the care for a fixed dollar amount per monthb. These are gaining popularityc. Not that popular as can’t project what the pharma requirement will be
Move towards mergers and integration with Pharma firms
31
5. Provider OrganizationsReading 5A: Provider Organizations Explain what it means for providers to integrate Describe some of the advantages of provider integration Discuss some of the types and levels of provider integration Describe the general characteristics of several types of provider organizations
32
Reading 5A: Provider OrganizationsWhy integration
Achieve economies of scale Strengthen their negotiating position wrt MCO’s and payers
Provider Integration
Two or more previously separate providers combine under common control/ownership/business operations
1. Structural integration – Coming under common ownership or control2. Operational Integration Consolidate previous separate operations
Structural IntegrationComplete Integration – Common Ownership AND control e.g Merger/Acquisition
Merger – two or more separate entities are legally joined. This could be to create a new corporation, in which case it’s called Consolidation
Acquisition – One organization buys the otherPartial Integration
Joint Venture / Not a separate legal entity Execute contracts and agree to act as one body in business transaction
Operational IntegrationBusiness Integration – Combine one or more separate business functionClinical Integration – Making a variety of services available from one entity Physician Only Model
1. IPA (least integrated)2. Group Practices without Walls GPWW/ Management Services Org (MSO)3. Physician Practice Management (PPM) company4. Consolidate Medical Group (MOST integrated)
Physician and Hospital Model1. PHO (least integrated)2. Integrated Delivery Systems (IDS) /Medical Foundation (Most integrated)
A high level of structural integration need not mean a high level of operational integration. But in reality usually both go together
Advantages1. Greater Operational efficiency and effectiveness2. Expertise Building – Helps in better planning/marketing3. Improve contracting position with MCOs4. Good for MCO’s as it improves quality and efficiency for their members
Disadvantages1. Loss of autonomy
Provider Integration Models
Independent Practice AssociationsMessenger Model - Simply just negotiate the agreement with MCO and then make its members directly contract. This model is used with FFS or discounted FFS
MCO Contracts with IPAThe IPA then separately contracts with the member physicians
33
IPA can limit its risk when it uses Capitation as payment by buying a stop loss insurance protection. If they IPA pays claims more than a defined Maximum for the year, the insurance firm reimburses it
In case the IPA is seen to assume too much risk, then the regulators may classify it as an insurance company
Group Practice without Walls (Clinic without Walls) Legal entity that combines multiple independent physician practices under 1
umbrella and performs a certain business operation for them Can be owned by member physicians/hospital/ by a PPM
Physician Practice Management Organization/ Managed Services Org Owned by hospital / Investors that provides management and admin support to
physicians Relieve physicians of non medical business functions Either provide the functions for a fee or they make the Physicians lease the assets Specific MSO is the Physician Practice Management Company which
purchases the physicians practice assets. All assets – not only tangible ones Physicians could get some equity in this firm too Develop a network of either PCP’s or specialists
Consolidated Medical GroupsFull structural and operational integrationOperates in one or a few facilities and consolidates the operationsAdvantages
1. Lower costs2. Access to a large group of physicians3. Creates an ability to monitor and manage quality/utilization
Integration of Physicians and HospitalsPhysician Hospital Organizations – JV between hospital and physiciansPrimary purpose is contract negotiation with MCOsDo not merge operations apart from contracting and marketingReasonsBetter relations / Increased Collaboration / Shared Financial Risk / Contracting with MCOs / Employer Direct Contracting / Enhancing Quality
Community Contracts with this – Physician Hospital Community OrgTwo types
1. Open PHO Available to all the hospitals eligible medical staff2. Closed PHO Limits the number of specialists by type of specialty
a. Specialist PHO Only one type of specialtyCompensation – Discounted Fees and Capitation (PCPs) and DFSS (Specialists)
Integrated Delivery SystemOperationally integrated – maybe not structurallyEmployment model IDS – the IDS controls the different providersMedical Foundation
Not-for-profit Entity that purchases and manages physicians practices Need to provide significant benefit to the community Used to create an IDS in states where IDSs cannot be business corporations
34
Provider Organizations that Bear Insurance Risk IDSs / IPA / PHO / CMGs/ choose to bear financial risk – called AT RISK They need to be able to have expertise in the core insurance functions like actuarial /
underwriting / claims / quality etc May need a HMO or insurance company license These entities can contract directly with employers or Medicare The BALANCED BUDGET ACT (1997) gives rights to organizations who meet basic
standards to contract directly with healthcareo These organizations are known as Provider Sponsored Organizations
35
6. Health Systems Management
Reading 6A: Health Plan Structure and Management Describe the most important functions of a managed care organization’s board of
directors Identify a managed care organization’s key management positions and their functions Identify the common medical management committees and describe the committees’
general functionsReading 6B: Network Structure and Management Describe some of the factors commonly evaluated in a market analysis for network
management List the types of providers typically included in a MCO’s network List and explain some of the factors that influence the number of providers included in
an MCO’s network Define credentialing and explain why it is important List some common clauses and provisions in provider contracts
36
Reading 6A: Health Plan Structure and Management
Structure of MCOsMost of them are Corporations - Can be party to a legal actionMCO’s may be under a taxable not-for-profit form, tax exempt not for profit and a for profit form
This will affect on taxes, effects on regulation, capital raising considerations
Traditionally – HMOs and BCBS – Not-for-profitBCBS – do not qualify for tax exemption
Adv and Disadv – Not for Profit Plus Tax exemption from federal / state property / state income taxes Minus
a. Adhere to numerous restrictions like Operate only for tax exempt purposes Provide only incidental benefits to private individuals Not engage in lobbying and political activities
b. Careful in transactions with taxable entities Not for profit have Limited ability to raise capital
Advantages and Diadv – For Profit MCOs Minus Pay taxes Plus Can raise capital
Components of organization and organizational structure Board of Directors
Review the activities and finances of the firm Minimum number of directors is specified by the organization charter and the
insurance regulations Inside and outside directors exist Not-for-profit firms have a restriction on number of inside directors Key Responsibilities
o Authorization of major financial transactions – M&A and capitalo Appointment, evaluation of senior management including CEOo Participating in Corporate Strategic Planningo Approval of Organizational operational policies/procedureso Oversight of the Quality Plano Fiduciary responsibility – Act in the best interests of organization
Key Management Positions CEO , Marketing Directors, Finance Director , Director of Operations ,CIO , Medical
Director (Utilization, Quality issues and Operational issues) ,Network Management Director
Corporate Compliance Director – a. Mandated by HIPAA to have a Chief Privacy Officer and Chief Security Officerb. Roles
i. Implement written standards and proceduresii. Assigning upper level personnel to oversee complianceiii. Communicate Standards to all employeesiv. Enforce standards through disciplinary measuresv. Establish and enforce confidentiality and security rules
CommitteesStanding Committee – Long term advisory on financial, compliance, quality management, Utilization Management, strategic planning and Compensation
37
Ad Hoc Committee – Convened to address a specific issue
Some Common Committees include 1. Executive Committee – Organizational policy/ LOB / Employment Policy2. Strategic Planning Committee- Direct the MCO strategic direction/goals3. Compensation Committee4. Finance Committee5. Nominating Committee – nominations of company offices
Other Committees include1. Executive Quality Improvement Committee – Quality / Accreditation etc2. Quality management Committee – quality assessment/improvement activities
a. Identifies issues to be monitoredb. Evaluates the results of quality studies to identify opportunitiesc. Develop / Oversee / Monitor quality improvement action plansd. Oversee Accreditation efforts
3. Medical Advisory Committee – policies in clinical mgmt / contracts / compensation4. Credentialing Committee – policies /review /recredentialing5. Utilization Mgmt - review the UM program6. Pharmacy and Therapeutics Committee – Formulary and Regulatory reviews7. Peer Review Committee- review questionable /problematic healthcare services
delivery8. Appeals Review Committee – Medical management or coverage determination9. Corporate Compliance Committee
38
Reading 6B: Network Structure and Management
Managing of provider networks is one of the Critical Tasks in the MCO process
Designing a Provider Network
Market Analysis1. Market Maturity – determine the level of managed care activity in a market
a. How receptive are consumers – less receptive would prefer PPO while more receptive would prefer HMOs
b. How much competition exists in the areac. How receptive are providers
2. Provider Communitya. Number of physicians and locationsb. Details on hospital beds/ pharmacies / other ancillary servicesc. Accessibility of providersd. Utilization patterns and average costs for specified services e. PCP’s and their linkages with other specialists – difficult to breakf. Associations within the existing community
3. Competitive Analysisa. Provider Panel Sizes / Premium Levels / cost Containment Strategiesb. Physicians to members ratio in existing network of competitorsc. Levels of provider satisfaction or dissatisfaction with other plans
4. Economic Conditionsa. Size of the employers in the market – large adopt MCO easierb. Growing economy Trigger growth in Young population and medical
community will come in / Vice Versa for declining economy5. Characteristic of the Service Area
a. Is this an urban/rural/suburban area? Rural areas have fewer hospitalsb. Urban areas have higher proportion of specialists and facilities – More choice
but also more cost/quality/satisfaction levels6. Population Characteristics
a. Age/Income/Ethnic background7. Health Plan Characteristics
a. Number & Types of products offered by MCO / geographic scope/market focus / particular population it serves
b. Use diff providers for diff plans (nested/customized/sub networks) 8. Current and Proposed Regulatory requirements
a. Laws address Network adequacy / Patient Access to medical services /Quality of care/ mandated benefits/ Providers right to contract
b. Adequacy – Extent to which a network offers the appropriate types and numbers of providers in the appropriate geographic distribution according to the needs of the plans members
9. Guidelines from Accrediting Agenciesa. These include NCQA / American Accreditation Healthcare Commissionb. Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations JCAHO
HMO Act 1973Federally qualified HMO’s should 1. Provide geographic accessibility to primary care and most specialty providers with
‘reasonable promptness’ and ‘within generally accepted norms for meeting projected enrollment needs’
2. 24/7 access to emergency services3. Detailed description of service areas/provider locations
Federal Employee Health Benefits Program (FEHBP)
39
Requires health plans offering services to federal employees and their dependents to provide1. Immediate access to emergency services2. Urgent Appointments within 24 hours3. Routine appointments once a month4. Average office waiting time of < 30 minutes
NAIC Managed Care Plan Network Adequacy Model ActAdopted in 1996, this act offers guidelines for states to use in measuring network adequacy. Includes Standards for
1. Provider Enrollee Ratios2. Geographic Accessibility3. Appointment Waiting Times4. Hours of Operation5. Volume of Technology/Specialty services available
Any Willing Provider Laws1. This requires health plans to allow provider who is willing to accept the terms and
conditions of the plan to contract with the plans network2. Can include economic criteria. This is regulated by state law and sometime applies
to only PPO’s and not to HMO’sMandated Benefits LawsRequire MCO’s to
1. Include specific benefits in the plans design – Hospice/ maternity/chiropractic2. Include Specified providers or provider classes (Behavioral)3. Access to specified provider classes w/o PCP approval (OB/GYN/Pediatric)
Determining the structure Composition and Size of network Network StructureCan operate as a closed panel (MCO facilities) / Open Panel (Own facilities)
Network Composition1. PCPs – General practitioners / family practitioners / internists / pediatricians /nurse
practitioners/physician assistants (last 2 under physician guidance)2. Specialists3. Hospitalists – PCPs don’t have time to follow up inpatient care / These physicians
coordinate diagnostic/ treatment services @ hospitals4. Healthcare Facilities5. Ancillary Service Providers – Diagnostic/therapeutic care/labs/radiology/ physical
therapy/pharma / home healthcare Network Size
1. Appropriate number of practitioners – This is based ona. Plan characteristics – more closely managed fewer providers
i. MCO requires less than PPO or POSii. Large plans have fewer providers per 1000 membersiii. Based also on geographical spread
b. Provider Accessi. Staffing ratio – number of providers to the number of enrolleesii. Drive time – Time to drive to PCP- 15 min urban / 30 min ruraliii. Geographical Availability – number of PCPs within a radiusiv. Population Characteristics – Demographic characteristicsv. Purchaser and Consumer preferences – Quality , Access and Cost
(check which is most imp) / Large PCP panelvi. Plan Goals – Cost – Quality Tradeoff / Subdivide the panels based on
quality/utilization and cost effectiveness and incentivise consumers
40
2. Appropriate Number of Hospitals and Other Facilitiesa. Accessibility, Cost and use of resources, service capacity and types.
Reputation within service area, accreditation status , level of participation
Adding Providers to the Network
Recruiting ProvidersInformation sources include Hospitals already in the network / Provider Directories of Competitors / Local medical societies / Plan purchasers and members
Selecting ProvidersFirst stage is application form with standard questions – education / workex /affiliations etc
CredentialingInformation presented is reviewed and verified in order to determine
1. The current clinical competence of the provider and2. Fit into the pre-established criteria for participation
This Credentialing process is important1. Employers want to offer their members high quality providers2. Ensures certain aspect of their quality program3. Minimize the liability and other legal risks – have good historic record4. Accrediting bodies require it before the accredit the MCO
Who Performs Credentialing?1. Varies from plan to plan2. Some have Credentialing committees / departments3. Others assign to specific person4. External Entities called Credentialing Verification Organization5. Practitioners on committee for review/technical inputs/ peer’s perspective
How does the Process Work?1. When the provider submits the application + supporting documentation2. Review and verification of the documentation3. Check to see if additional documentation is required4. Onsite inspection of providers offices
What standards must be met?1. Have their own guidelines for credentialing2. Written guidelines which access the ability to deliver care
a. Licensure / Training / experience /Disclosure of any Health issues / Appropriate Documentation to be verified
3. Need a primary source verification – Process of validating the credentialing from the organization that originally conferred it
4. Selection is based on needs / qualifications / fair and equitable5. P-PC-7 Standard -American Accreditation Healthcare Commission/ URAC6. Review any adverse claims / malpractice suits / sanctions7. National Practitioner Data Bank - This is a database maintained by the federal
government that lists info on malpractice claims / disciplinary actiona. Maintained by the DHHS – Started in 1990b. Scrutiny of areas of practitioner licensure / membership / malpractice history/
record of clinical privilegesc. Meant to provide a support to the existing state credentialing/licensing boardsd. Types of Queries
i. Mandatory – need to query every two years on practitioner privilegesii. Voluntary – any other general queries
Recredentialing1. This is done every 2-3 years – for changes in licensure / sanctions / certifications/
competence / health status
41
2. Incorporates quality management and utilization results3. NCQA data for recredentialing includes
a. CR 9.1 Member complaints , CR 9.2 Information from quality improvement activities , CR 9.3 Member satisfaction
Contracting
Common Provisions1. Use the provider manual as a reference in the contract
a. This document contains the providers rights and responsibilities2. Provisions for Provider Responsibilities
a. Provider Servicesb. Administrative Policies – Follow the MCOs policiesc. Credentialing and Re-Credentialingd. Participation in Utilization and Quality management programse. Maintenance and submission of medical records for all membersf. No Balance billing and Hold Harmless Provisions
i. Requires Provider to accept the amount the plan pays as payment in full and not bill plan members apart from (copy/coinsu/deductibles)
ii. Hold harmless – Forbids providers from seeking compensation from patients if payer fails to compensate providers cos of insolvency etc
3. Provisions for Payer Responsibilitiesa. Payment – how will he compensateb. Risk sharing and Incentive Programsc. Timely Payment – Max time period is specifiedd. Eligibility information – will provide 270 and 271 information to the provider
4. Termination Provisiona. Termination without cause – like 90 day periodb. Termination with cause – if one of the users did follow contract provisionsc. Cure provision (60-90 days) during which the breach an be rectifiedd. Extreme situations may require immediate termination of contracte. Due Process clause – contest/appeal the termination
5. Tone of Contracta. Influences the nature of the business relationship
Network Maintenance and Provider Services Orientation
1. Parameters of the MCO plan2. Training in UR / quality /authorization systems3. Written manual of policies and procedures4. Communication between MCO & network – updates/ bulletins / guidelines / claims
informationPeer ReviewEvaluation of performance by other providers
Provider ServicesPayer staff responsible for maintaining communications with providers
42
7. Medical Management I
Reading 7A: Basics of Utilization Management Define medical management and identify its component parts Describe the strategies MCO’s can use to manage member demand for healthcare
services Identify the kinds of cases for which case management is typically used Define disease managementReading 7B: Utilization Review and Authorization Systems Explain the purpose of utilization review Define authorization and explain the criteria MCO’s use to determine whether benefits
are payable Describe the types of services that require utilization review and authorization Identify the three types of utilization review Describe the utilization review process Discuss some of the techniques MCOs use to manage utilization review and authorization
processes
43
Reading 7A: Basics of Utilization ManagementSystem that MCOs and their providers use to achieve and maintain both high quality and cost effectiveness is defined as Medical Management
Three Key Areas exist Utilization Management – use of medical services / regulation / planning Clinical Practice Management – development/implementation of delivery techniques Quality Management – process of measuring and improving QOS
Utilization Management FunctionAffects all components of healthcare delivery – primary/specialty/inpatient/pharma/ancillaryApplication depends on nature of patient population
Preventive Care 70% of healthcare costs come from preventive diseases / injuries Center for Disease Control & Prevention – 12% of all hospitalizations were avoidable Reduce need for diagnostic / therapeutic / inpatient care Need to assess individual health risks and ensure targeted care Health Risk Assessment (HRA)
o Process by which an MCO uses information about a plan members health status / personal and family health history / health related behaviors / to predict the likelihood of a specific illness or disease
o Sources – Providers / health plan records / HRA surveyso Use data analysis software to segment the different categories
Preventive Care Initiativeso Mostly received from PCPso Include stuff like Immunization programso Health Promotion Programs (wellness programs – which educate on lifestyle
choices / maternity management / pre natal care)o Screening Programs – check if a health condition is present – blood
pressure/cholesterol checks etc
Self Care Programs Complement physician services Teach how do educate members on distinguishing between major and minor illnesses
and how to effectively treat minor problems Use techniques like members newsletters / how to perform screenings
Decision Support Programs Need to know what is relevant – Decision support programs provide educational
material and advice from physicians Telephone Triage programs
o Usually give inputs for cough / ear pain / skin problems / chest pain / fever /headache / sore throat
o Urgent case - Notify the emergency services / Other cases schedule physician appointments
o Staffed by nurses or nurse practitionerso Clinical staff in triage use decision support tools
Shared decision making programs o Provide patients with in-depth info about diseases/procedures/treatment and
encourage them to participate in healthcare decisionso Sources – Physicians / printed materials / personal or group counseling /
internet/ support groups / interactive computer programsUtilization Review
44
UR refers to the evaluation of the medical necessity/ appropriateness/ cost effectiveness of the healthcare services given to a patientCan do it in-house or contract with Utilization Review Organizations
Case ManagementProcess of identifying plan members with special healthcare needs and developing a coordinated effort for monitoring care / needs Improve / stabilize a plan members overall health status by preventing complications Optimize use of healthcare resources Improve member compliance with provider recommendations for care Improve coordination and continuity of care Employed with high risk / high cost cases
o High Risk case is one that involves complex / catastrophic illness or injury that requires extensive medical intervention or treatment plans
o High Cost Case – one that requires a large financial expenditure or human/technology resource commitment
o Chronic Case – persists for long periods of time or patients life Possible Conditions for Case Mgmt include AIDS, Stroke, Burns, Cancer , Neonatal
Complications , brain injuries, congenital defects Identified by UR process, referrals from providers/ employers / payers 5 Basic steps are Case Identification / Assessment / Planning / Implementation and
monitoring / Evaluation Factors to determine health status
o Medical condition or diagnosiso Treatment being receivedo Use of prescription drugso Level of resource utilization o Cost of careo Length and frequency of hospital visitso Financial / social / psychosocial factors
If selected the candidate is assigned a Case Manager (nurse . physicians / social worker or any other healthcare professional) These people should be familiar with
o Benefit plans and how benefits are paid to providerso Legal / regulatory / ethical issues related to case managemento Utilization review processes and techniqueso Availability of community resources and supporto Role of coordinating care and in educating patients and family memberso Evaluation of the overall effectiveness of the case management
Final approval of decisions RESTS WITH THE PHYSICIAN
Disease ManagementDisease state management is a coordinated system of preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic measures intended to provide cost effective quality healthcare for patients who have risk of chronic illnesses or medical condition. Focuses on comprehensive care over a extended period of time rather than individual episodes or medical care
Driving force High level of spending on chronic diseases Proactive engagement helps Pharma firms have proved this – This was in sharp
contrast to the more traditional practice of addressing acute episodes as and when they occurred
Conditions which make a disease management appropriateo High rate of variability in patterns of treatmento High rate of preventable complications – that results in use of costly services
45
o Show low rates of patient compliance with recommended treatmento Can be managed on an outpatient basis using non surgical approacheso Are Chronic in natureo Likely to result in high costs over time
Differences from Traditionalo Focuses on managing a population of patients and not individual patientso Highly coordinated and integrate delivery across providers/siteso Apply TQM and continuous quality improvement methods
Tools – 4 specific tools are usedo Disease Modeling – life cycle / interventionso Customized clinical guidelineso Clinical practice processeso Measurement and improvement systems
Pharma Industryo Treatment Guidelineso Provider Education and Complianceo Patient education and complianceo Pharmacotherapeutic outcomes research
Disease Management and Managed Careo Integration into managed care with the help of Pharma firmso STILL a NEW approach and its effects on outcomes and cost
effectiveness has not been yet establishedo This is usually set up as a voluntary outreach and support program plan
Clinical Practice GuidelinesThis is a UM and quality management mechanism designed to aid providers in making the most appropriate course of treatment for a specific clinical caseThe ultimate goal of clinical practice guidelines is to achieve the best clinical result in the most cost effective manner
46
Reading 7B: Utilization Review and Authorization SystemsUtilization Review
Manage the overall cost effectiveness of healthcare services Managing the costs of paying healthcare benefits Information collected includes
o Patient Information – Demographic / eligibility / Plan typeo Provider Information – PCP / referring Provider/ In-Patient facilityo Service Information – Referral service/ date of service / diagnosis
codes/treatment codes / hospital admission and discharge date etcReasons for conducting UR
Reduce Unnecessary Practice Variationso Caused due to reimbursement methods / population morbidity / lack of
scientific evidence and current medical practice informationo Variance will remain – Need to however reduce Unnecessary variance
Make appropriate authorization decisionso Authorization is a health plans system of approving payment of benefits for
services that satisfy the plans requirement for coverageo Usually Payers pay only if
Service is covered under the benefit plan Considered medically necessary and appropriate – These are
services or supplies as provided by physician or other healthcare provider to identify and treat a members illness or injury which are
Consistent with the symptoms/diagnosis/treatment In Accordance with the standards of good medical practice Not soles for convenience reasons Furnished in the least intensive type of care required
Authorization could begin from the PCP Improve the quality of Patient Care
o Use of physician based decision making systems Physicians have training / experience to determine appropriateness They are familiar with a wide range of treatment options
Improve the Cost effectiveness of patient careo Good metrics include Hospitalizations / member/year , hospital bed days/
admission , hospital bed days/ admission , specialists encounter per member, referrals per PCP per 100 encounters
Number of bed days per 1000 members (normalized for the year) [A / (B / 365) ] / (C/ 1000)
o A – Gross bed days per time unito B – Days per time unito C – Number of Plan members
Services that Require Utilization Review for AuthorizationFramework to evaluate UR
Access requirements Frequency of Utilization Cost per procedure Total Cost Level of Inappropriate utilization Cost of Review
Access requirementso PCP / direct access for OB/GYN or pediatric / dermatology/ DVo Serious Chronic conditions allowed direct accesso Complimentary and alternative medicine (CAM)
47
Frequency of Utilizationo Don’t target very routine serviceso Need authorization for complex procedures
Cost per procedureo High cost or high risk procedures and treatment
Total Costo Cost of service * Frequency of use
Level of Inappropriate utilizationo Higher the denial rate– more likely is the service will require UR/authorization
Cost of Review o Balance Cost of review vis-à-vis benefit received
Types of UR1. Prospective Review
Review and possible authorization of proposed treatment plans for a patient before the treatment is implemented
This is a preferred option Accomplished through precertification or prior authorization requires plan
members to notify the plan in advance for a particular treatment Helps evaluate reasons for request / determine most appropriate course of
treatment / intervene to alter the care Tools include
o Utilization Guidelines – accepted approach to care for common problemso Site Appropriateness listings – most appropriate settings for procedures o Experience Based Criteria – based on medical directors / provider
experience ; for procedures which are not performed /documented wello Length of Stay Guidelines – Average length of stay based on a patients
diagnosis, severity of patients condition and types of services Length of stay – number of days (From admission to day of
discharge that a plan member spends in hospital / other facility Mechanisms to limit LOS include
o Preadmission testing – tests before inpatient admissiono Discharge Planning – determine what activities must occur before patient
is ready for discharge and conduct them efficiently. 5 key activities What treatment and procedures have been prescribed Determine other services required prior to admission Establish length of stay Determine where patient goes after hospitalization Determine what equipment/ services will be needed after discharge
2. Concurrent Review Treatment is in progress ; Applies to services that continue over a period of time Used to evaluate outpatient courses of care – chemotherapy / radiotherapy/
physical therapy / home healthcare and counseling or In Patient care Coordinated by the UR nurse who services as a liaison between physicians /
hospital staff / health plans medical management and UR staff o Gathering information about a members progresso Tracking the total length and Cost of Careo Continuing Discharge Planning
Plan can intervene in the middle to help direct course of care Alternative Care Settings and Levels of Care
Primary purpose is to determine the proper setting for patient care. Some areo Emergency Departments
These are essential to the immediate diagnosis and treatment of critical illness/ severe injuries
48
To avoid liability for payments , some plans require the authorization of payers within 24 hours of admittance
Plans conduct retrospective review of claims for emergency services to determine the necessity /appropriateness of care
Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labour Act 1986 says hospitals that receive Medicare/Medicaid grants are required to screen / stabilize all patients who come to their emergency depts.
Further some states prohibit precertification requirements for emergency services
“Prudent Layperson Standard” of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 also limits precertification and retrospective review in making coverage decisions. According to this standard
A condition is considered to be an emergency if a prudent layperson (person who has average knowledge of health and medicine) could reasonably expect the absence of medical attention to put the individual’s health in jeopardy
26 states have adopted this standardo Urgent Care Centers
Problems that are not life threatening but that require immediate attention. The cost of care is higher than that in a PCP’s office but lower than hospital ED
o Observation Care Units Designed to address the immediate care needs of patients who
require continuous monitoring but not emergency/acute careo Sub Acute Care Facilities
Addresses continuing care needs of patients who don’t need hospitals but can’t be treated from home
o Step down Units Ward or section of ward in a hospital that is devoted to delivering
sub acute care to patients following acute care Alternative to sub acute care facilities Intermediate – Critical Care units and Regular Nursing Units
o Home Healthcare Need intermittent rather than 24 hour care Usually used by Medicare patients Also seen younger people recovering from acute episodes Services Include
Basic nursing care , Wound care , Pharma care , respiratory care, rehab services, nutrition care , social work assistance, provision for durable medical equipment
o Hospice Care Set of specialized healthcare services that provide support to
terminally ill patients and their families Services address medical / nutritional / social /psychological and
spiritual needs Medicare Specifies that these benefits come to patients
who have a life expectancy of 6 months or less
3. Retrospective Review This occurs after the treatment is completed Evaluation of medical necessity is based on claims data and medical records Find Coding Errors – procedures don’t match diagnosis Upcoding – Involved using a procedure code more complex than actual code
49
Unbundling – Separating a procedure into parts
Utilization Review Process Data Collection
o Prospective review – does he satisfy criteriao Concurrent review – Document patients progresso Retrospective review – address utilization of services/ patient outcomes/ costs
Data Transmittalo Manual transmittal - Manual / Paper Based
Advantage – High degree of physician acceptance; can be completed at their own convenience
o Telephone Transmittal Requires providers to call a central number and relay authorization via
IVR over the fone Faster / less cumbersome / less labor intensive Plans like fone transmittal as its more accurate/complete/error free
o Electronic Transmittal Faster / less labor / less Error/ > Scrutiny and stringent regulations
Data Evaluationo Evaluation of Non Clinical Aspects of Coverageo Evaluation of medical necessity and appropriateness of proposed careo Administrative Review
Compare the proposed medical care with applicable provisions in the purchaser contract to determine coverage
If its not satisfied – the claim is deniedo Medical Review
In case the above is satisfied – there is an evaluation of the medical necessity and appropriateness
Nurses can approve authorization requests Physicians can approve and authorization of payments In case there is a dispute on any issue – the authorization is delayed.
This then becomes a PENDED Authorization
Managing the Utilization Review ProcessSome more tools to manage the utilization process
Single Visit Authorization - PCPs submit separate requests for each visit to the specialist
Limited Visit Authorization – Plan members make a specified number of visits before approval is required again
Prohibition of Secondary Referrals - Specialists cannot make a referral without plan authorization.
Exceptions to these rules could be made for chemotherapy and radiation therapy, mental health and substance abuse therapy
Authorization can be extended to manage complex cases
50
8. Medical Management II
Reading 8A: Quality Assessment and Improvement Identify the two types of quality delivered by MCOs Describe the methods MCOs use to assess the quality of administrative and healthcare
services Describe the advantages and disadvantages of using structure measures, process
measures, and outcomes measures to evaluate healthcare quality Discuss three tools MCO’s commonly use to improve performance and qualityReading 8B: Quality Standards, Accreditation, and Performance Measures Identify the major agencies that provide accreditation for healthcare organizations Explain the role of quality standards in the accreditation process Describe the most important sources and types of performance measures
51
Reading 8A: Quality Assessment and Improvement
Two Key areas – Quality assessment activities and quality improvements activities
What is Quality?Quality in a managed care context refers to an MCO’s success in providing healthcare and other services in such a way that plan members needs and expectations are met.Quality delivered by an MCO can be divided into two key areas
Service Quality – MCO’s success in meeting non clinical customer needs and expectations. Will include details like
o how long a member had to wait to see a doctoro how friendly office staff areo how well the MCO’s members explain the details of coverage
Healthcare quality is “the degree to which health services for individuals and populations in crease the likelihood of desired health outcomes and are consistent with current professional knowledge”
If a plan member goes to a provider the healthcare quality refers to the manner in which the physicians treats the members condition
Importance of QualityConsumers consider it to be an important factor in deciding which health plans to offerSource of competitive advantage that helps organizations compete successfully
Importance of Quality for Patient Safety –o This enhances patient safety and decreases medical errorso Medical error occurs when a planned treatment or procedure is delivered
incorrectly or when a wrong treatment or procedure is deliveredo Medical errors are caused MORE by breakdown in the Healthcare
system rather than provider errorso Adverse Event – Harm a patient suffers that is caused by factors other than
the patients underlying condition – Need to see if the adverse event was random or if it was caused by medical errors or deficiencies
What are the factors that contribute to medical Errorso Faulty or Inadequate Communication
Physician’s handwriting is acknowledged as the leading cause of medical error
Illegible prescription can lead to improper dispensing of medications Illegible orders can lead to inappropriate procedures and course of
treatmento Inconsistent Quality Oversight
Every state has different licensing requirements for healthcare professionals. Accreditation programs are also widespread
Very little overlap exists to promote uniform quality oversighto Lack of Compliance with internal and external reporting
requirements Most healthcare organizations have internal systems for reporting
adverse drug interactions and minor medical errors Any disciplinary action that limits physicians clinical privileges for > 30
days MUST be reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank 95% of the adverse drug reactions go unreported
o Lack of Verification Procedures Treatments based on individual’s analysis of results, without secondary
verification. Very high error rates are caused by this
52
IOM report to Bill Clinton – Now they required a nationwide mandatory system of collecting/ analyzing and reporting information on Medical Errors
Other Mechanisms to Combat this includeo Medical Error Reporting Systems that allow healthcare providers and
facilities to analyze common errors and identify error causing processes in healthcare delivery
o Medical Alert systems that apply preprogrammed online criteria to identify test results that fall outside acceptable ranges
o Drug Checking systems that link physician and pharmacy order entry information systems and automatically alert physicians and pharmacists of possible drug interactions or allergic reactions to prescribed drugs
o Electronic Medical Record systems that allow providers and health plans to track and analyze clinical data and provide reminders for needed services
Assessing Quality in an MCO Difficult to define what quality is and based on that definition determine whether an
MCO is delivering that quality Performance Management can help an MCO determine how well it is doing in meeting
member’s needs Quality is in the eyes of the customer – It’s the patients opinion which matters more
than the physicians or MCO’s opinion Quality Measures
o Structure Measures – Relate to the nature, quantity and quality of resources that an MCO has available for member service and patient care
o Process Measures – Methods and Procedures an MCO and its providers use to furnish services and care
o Outcome Measures – Gauge the extent to which services succeed in improving or maintaining satisfaction and patient health
o Most measures till now have been structure and process measureso All three measures are interdependent – structure and process are important
because the lead or are believed to lead to better outcomes – but outcome is the end result
o The Most useful outcome measures are those that can be related to specific processes or structures
Assessing Service Qualityo Provider Service quality issues include
Ease which members can get through to a clinicians office by fone Length of time patients must wait for an appointment Length of time patients must wait in office to be seen by a provider Attitude, Competence and efficiency of office staff Clinicians Bedside Manner – friendly/ listener / explanations
o Administrative Service Quality Phone wait times when calling MCO Attitude, Competence and efficiency of member services staff Accuracy and timeliness of claims payment and provider
reimbursements Speed with which member services representatives can retrieve
needed information from the MCO’s IS Availability of educational material for members
o Use structural – (no: of service reps, processing capabilities , number of PCP’s) , process linked (length of stay, accuracy , efficiency) or outcome measures (Member satisfaction, compliant resolution)
Assessing Healthcare Qualityo This can be evaluated using structural ,process and outcome measures
53
o Structural Measures Number of PCP’s in the network , % of providers who are board certified Education, training and experience of Plan providers Number of providers accepting new patients Number and distribution of specialists in the plans service area Geographic dispersal of providers Physicians turnover in the plan Hospitals included in the plans network Number of hospital beds available Physical conditions of hospitals and other facilities Emergency room access Availability of member education programs Credentialing Main advantage – Easy to identify and report / intuitively
linked to quality of careo Process Measures
Some look at illness prevention measures and others look at how the Providers treat sick patients
Preventive care statistics are the MOST popular measures used during quality assessment – statistics are easy to measure and understand and they fit well with the emphasis on prevention
% of children receiving immunization percentage of adults receiving regular checkups percentage of members receiving screening exams like
mammograms, pap smears or cholesterol screening % of members receiving advice on smoking cessation
Important factor – appropriateness of the care delivered Inappropriate care can be divided into
Overuse of care – antibiotics to treat viral infections etc Underuse of care – provider fails to provide care that would
improve the patients health e.g. Beta blockers not administered to patients following a heart attack
Misuse of Care – wrong treatment is provided for patients illness or correct treatment is delivered incorrectly
Standards of Care are diagnostic and treatment processes that a clinician should follow for a certain type of patient/illness/clinical circumstance
Published by American Medical Association (AMA) , American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) etc
Advantages Easy to identify , measure and report Lead to improved health outcomes in some cases But … no link between process and improved outcome has been
defined for many processo Outcome Measures
3 key activities – Clinical Status, Functional Status, Patient Perception Clinical Status – Relates to biological health outcomes e.g. cancer
treatments are judged using 5 year survival rates / change in tumor rates. Other examples could include
No: of hospital admissions for certain condition Average length of hospital stay by type of injury/illness No: of patients contracting infection in hospital Survival rate of people who received angioplasty Incidence of certain conditions that commonly afflict long term
diabetes patients – foot ulcers , blindness
54
Occurrence of low birth weight infants or premature births Functional Status – Functional status relates to patients ability to
perform activities of daily living Patient Perception – How the patient feels
o Advantage of outcome Ability to demonstrate improved clinical and functional status over time
o Outcomes are effective measures of MCO or provider performance only if they can be linked to structures or processes and only if they are sensitive to modifications in those structures or processes by the MCO or provider
o Disadvantages Not feasible in all situations like long treatment plans Other disadvantages Inconsistency of source data , need to provider
risk adjustment, difficulty & cost of obtaining outcomes data, problems with incentives
Need to adjust outcomes to account for risk – The response to treatment depends on factors that independent of the quality of care provided - Risk adjustment or Case –Mix Adjustment is the statistical adjustment of outcome measures to account for these factors
Evaluation of performance of providers is very difficult – in case outcomes are made public and used to judge providers – some might be reluctant to treat the sickest patients
Collecting and Analyzing Quality Assessment Datao Financial Data
Describe the costs of physical , technological and human resources needed to provide administrative and healthcare services to plan members.
o Clinical Data This includes both disease specific data and data related to general
health and functional status. Provide in depth overview of outcomes associated with a particular
healthcare process and structure Patient records / claims and encounter forms / are primary sources Tools used include – SF-36 and HSQ-39 (health status questionnaire)
o Customer Satisfaction Data How do members / providers / purchasers view the delivered services? Telephone or email surveys Widely used Consumer Assessment of Health Plans (CAHPS) developed
by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Reporting Quality Assessment Information
o Performance reports serve two primary purposes – internally , they help MCO’s improve the quality of the healthcare and service plan members receive by identifying the plans strengths and weaknesses
o Externally performance reports address accountability to the health plans customers and to outside agencies
Quality Improvements Haphazard Change/ Random Change – unplanned/ uncontrolled & produces
unpredictable results e.g. Explosion of healthcare costs resulting from unlimited utilization
Reactive Change – Controlled – but leads to positive/negative/unintended results Planned Change – Deliberate, controlled, collaborative and proactive Need to do the following to make changes effective
55
Planned – Identify where improvement / define desired outcomes/ define barriers or roots causes for problems / decide what actions are most likely to achieve the desired outcomes
Communicated – Process of Transmitting information and results upward/downward /horizontally through the organization and outward to its external customers
Implemented – Implementation of quality improvement initiatives turns intention into action by providing a method for responsible parties to complete assigned tasks in a specific timeframe
Documented – Accrediting organizations and regulatory bodies require MCO’s to provide documentation of three major components of quality improvement – performance assessment , program planning and program evaluation
Evaluated – Provides a measure of how well the MCO’s improvement plans achieved stated goals by comparing performance before and after changes
Strategies and Tools for Improving Quality
Benchmarking Most effective mechanism – Key Tasks include Identifying best practices and best outcomes for a specific process Emulating the best practices to equal or surpass the best outcome Best practices – are the latest treatment modalities and accepted by providers
are the most effective and efficacious approach to medical care Clinical Practice Guidelines
Provide consistent delivered services that will improve plan members health Jointly developed inhouse plus plan/provider committees or from outside
sources such as National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC) , a Joint Venture of AMA, AHRQ and the American Association of Health Plans (AAHP)
Provider Profiling Involves collecting and analyzing information about the practice patterns of
individual providers Uses credentialing and recredentialing to determine how well a provider
meets MCO standards Identifies those providers who practices vary from the norm either because of
Usage of medical resources higher /lower than normal Use of resources in a manner noticeably different from other providers
Peer Review System in which the appropriateness of healthcare services delivered by a
member are evaluated by a panel of medical professionals This can focus on a single episode of care or on the entire program of care Results are used to
Provide Measures of overall quality Identify opportunities for improvement in provider performance Serve as a general learning tool for members of the panel
Peer review is REQUIRED for services provided by Medicare and Medicaid Recipients
Peer review participation is voluntary for services provided to commercial plan members
Reading 8B: Quality Standards, Accreditation, and Performance Measures
Standards are defined by the Institute of Medicine as “Authoritative Statements of Minimum levels of acceptable performance or results excellent levels of performance or results and the range of acceptable performance or results”
56
For them to represent valid measures of quality and performance – They have to satisfy three requirements –
They must relate to the conditions that are important to the plan/ members Standards must focus on structures, processes or outcomes that can be influenced
through quality improvement initiatives Standards should address situations that are controllable by the organization
Internal standards are developed by the MCO and based on their historic performance levelsExternal Standards are based on outside information such as publishing industry wide averages or best practices. MCO’s use internal standards to measure the quality of administrative services and External Standards to evaluate healthcare services.
AccreditationThis is an evaluative process in which a healthcare organization undergoes an examination of its operating procedures to determine if they meet designated criteria as defined by the accrediting body and to ensure that they meet a specified level of quality
Use a combination of document review, onsite review, interviews, medical record review and evaluation of member services systems.
External accreditation is becoming more and more important as states and purchasers are requiring firms to undergo some kind of review process.
Employers use this to determine if the plan meets standards for quality care – serves as a stamp of approval
Accrediting Organizations Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations
o Developed in 1951o Evaluates and accredits nearly 12000 hospitals and home care agencies and
7000 behavioral ,long term care , ambulatory care and clinical lab facilities o Hospitals receiving Medicare / Medicaid Funds MUST be JCAHO accreditedo JCAHO also accredits MCOs and healthcare Networkso Accreditation Process
Complete Onsite Surveys conducted every three years Organizations central office and any non JCAHO accredited network All high risk services provided by the organization and a sample of the
low risk services A sample of practitioners offices and records
o Quality Standards JCAHO focuses its review of health plan delivery system and proc on
Rights / Responsibilities and ethics Continuum of care Education and Communication Health Promotion and Disease prevention Leadership Management of Human Resources Management of Information Improving network performance
o On Jan 2001 JCAH) introduced new standards on Pain Management and Patient Safety
o Accreditation decisions – There are six types of decisions reached Accreditation without Type I recommendation- Demonstrate
satisfactory performance in all JCAHO performance areas
57
Accreditation with Type I recommendation – Awarded to organizations that fail to satisfy JCAHO standards in one or more performance areas. Need to resolve it in a defined timeframe
Provisional Accreditation – Comply with a subset of JCAHO standards based on a preliminary onsite evaluation. This remains effective till the whole survey is done. That must be done within 6 months of this provisional decision
Conditional Accreditation – Awarded to organizations that Fail to demonstrate compliance in multiple performance areas,
but are considered capable of achieving compliance within a specified period of time
Persistently unable or unwilling to comply with JCAHO stds Fail to comply with one or more accreditation requirements
Preliminary Denial of Accreditation – Awarded when the JCAHO determines that denial or accreditation is justified but decision is subject to review
Accreditation Denial - Awarded when JCAHO determines that denial of accreditation is justified and all appeal processes are exhausted
o Can also place organizations on an accreditation watch when an important event occurs and the root cause analysis and corrective action have not been done correctly. This holds till JCAHO deems that it be removed
National Committee for Quality Assuranceo This accredits MCOs, Managed care Behavioral Organizations, Credentials
verification organizations (CVOs) , PPOs , disease management organizations and physicians organizations
o More than half of the nations MCOs are accredited by themo Accreditation Process – Two parts
Onsite survey of administrative and healthcare services Offsite evaluation of audited results of selected effectiveness of care
and consumer satisfaction measures included in NCQA Health Plan Employer Data and Information Set (HEDIS)
Consumer satisfaction - NCQA uses a CAHPS – 2.0H survey – this is a combination of the original HEDIS member satisfaction survey & CAHPS survey developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
The Core CAHPS survey questionnaire are administered separately to Medicare / Medicaid and Commercial populations
ONSITE review is at least one every three years HEDIS results are evaluated annually
o Quality Standards – During onsite review , the following stds are measured Program structure Program Operations Physician Contract Requirements Availability of Practitioners Accessibility of Services Member Satisfaction Assistance for people with Chronic health conditions Clinical practice Guidelines Continuity and Coordination of Care Clinical Measurement activities Intervention and follow up of Clinical Issues Effectiveness of the Quality improvement program Delegation of QI activity
58
o Reviews processes for reviewing and authorizing medical care, quality of provider networks, members rights and responsibilities, preventive health activities and medical records.
o Also address Consumer protection issues related to internal and external systems for reviewing and evaluating medical appeals
o Also coordination of access to behavioral healthcare.o Accreditation Decisions
Results are organized into 5 categories Access and service Qualified Providers Staying Healthy Getting better Living with illness
The scores are tallied and used to arrive at a accreditation decision 8 Categories exist
Excellent – exceed or meet requirements/ HEDIS top results Commendable – meet or exceed requirements Accredited – meet most basic requirements Provisional – meets some requirements but not all Denied – does not meet requirements Suspended – NCQA has withdrawn accreditation till it conducts
review and corrective action taken Under Review – initial decision made – but this is being
reviewed under request of the plan NCQA discretionary review – NCQA reviews in order to assess
the appropriateness of its decision 75% weightage Compliance with NCQA 25% - HEDIS results National Health Plan Report Card – Health accreditation status
American Accreditation Healthcare Commission (URAC)o The following organizational and component accreditation program
Health Plans, Health Networks , Health Call Centers , Case Management Organizations, Credentials verification organization, health provider organization, health utilization management, Workers Compensation network, utilization management for workers compensation and external review
o Accreditation Process Desktop review of documentation of plan policies and procedures Onsite visit to verify the accuracy of documentation and plans
compliance with accreditation o Quality Standards
QM Structure, Organization and Staffing Nature and Scope of the QM program Systems for addressing Complaints, corrective action and disciplinary
actiono Two types of standards – SHALL and SHOULD
Shall address essential issues and define minimum levels of acceptable quality
Should standards identify desirable levels of quality Should gets changed to Shall over a period of time URAC Does NOT include performance data as part of the accreditation
process. However they do require health plans to engage in quality improvement initiatives
o Accreditation Decisions Need to 100% satisfy Shall standards and 60% Should
59
Remains effective for 3 years
Performance MeasuresThis is a qualitative measure of quality of care provided by a health plan or provider that consumers, payers, regulators and others can use to compare plans or providers
Foundation of Accountability (FACCT) This is created and governed by a coalition of consumer organizations, corporate and
government healthcare purchasers Supports a number of initiatives intended to improve healthcare quality and help
consumers make healthcare decisions based on Quality The information collected is classified into the following areas
o The Basics – delivery of good care including access/skills /Communication /coordination /follow up
o Staying Healthy – avoid illness etco Getting better – sick ppl getting bettero Living with illness – people with chronic / ongoing illnesses reduce symptoms,
avoid complications and maximize quality of lifeo Changing Needs – caring for people when their need changes dramaticallyo They Don’t collect / measure performance – just guidelines
HEDIS Administered by NCQA – Performance Measurement Tool designed to help healthcare
purchasers and consumers compare the quality offered by different MCOs Specified HEDIS effectiveness of care measures are used as part of NCQA’s
accreditation program for MCOs There are 7 key domains for HEDIS
o Effectiveness of Care – 16 reporting measures like Immunization status/ screening programs etc
o Access/Availability of Care – 5 reporting measures – prenatal and postpartum care / pediatrics / dental visits
o Satisfaction Experienced with Care – member satisfactiono Health Plan Stability – practitioner turnover / total membershipo Use of Services – well child visits/ cesarean section rateo Informed Health Care Choices – management of menopauseo Health Plan Descriptive information – physician board certification
Updated annually to enhance quality evaluation HEDIS 2000 added measures for chronic conditions / ongoing treatment programs
for menopause / cholesterol management and BP monitoring
ORYX JCAHO initiative – incorporates the outcome and other performance measures into
the accreditation process. This focuses on OUTCOME – the actual results of care Participating healthcare organizations collect from at least 6 measures JCAHO plans to identify standard core performance measures for ORYX
Additional Sources of Quality Standards, Performance Measures and Data
Quality Compass NCQA offers this - A national database of performance and accreditation information
submitted voluntarily by manage care organizations nationwide This draws performance measures from HEDIS Although its voluntary – companies are finding it useful to compete effectively
60
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (Agency for Healthcare Policy and Research)Primary Research arm of the US Department of Health and Human ServicesOne imitative is CAHPSAHRQs Computerized Needs Oriented Quality Measurement Evaluation System (CONQUEST)
Quality Improvement System for Managed CarePart of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 – Healthcare Financing Administration Service Quality Improvement System for Managed Care QISMC to monitor quality improvement efforts of Medicare / MediclaimThese standards are to be met to be Medicare Contractors
61
9. Managed Healthcare Operations I
Reading 9A: Healthcare Marketing for MCOs List the elements of the marketing mix and describe their role in the marketing process List several forms of marketing research that MCOs use to obtain information about their
customers Explain the major objectives of benefit design Describe the market segments that comprise the non-group market Explain the impact of state regulations on marketing to the Medicaid population Explain the differences between small groups and large groups that affect marketing
efforts directed to each of those segments Explain which promotion tools and forms of distribution are used most frequently in the
non-group and group markets
Reading 9B: Underwriting, Rating, and Financing Define underwriting and explain the differences between new business underwriting and
renewal underwriting Identify and describe the characteristics of typical rating methods used by MCOs in
setting premiums Identify and define key accounting and financial reporting terms for MCOs Explain the differences between fully funded and self-funded health plans
62
Reading 9A: Healthcare Marketing for MCOs
Marketing TermsMarketing – “Process of Planning & executing the conception, pricing, promotion and distribution of ideas, goods, and services to create exchanges that satisfy individual and organization objectives”Other key terms to know A market, Marketing Research, Market Segmentation , Positioning, Product , branding , product line, promotion , advertising, personal selling , telemarketing, sales promotion, publicity, press release
An exchange occurs when one party gives something of value to the other party for something of value in return.
4 P’s of marketing – Product, Price, Promotion and Place (Distribution)Product - Benefits that MCO designs (through research etc)Price – Premium you chargePromotion – Communicate this to the usersPlace – Sales reps / employers
Key questionsHow should the product be positioned relative to the other products in market?What promotional tools will be the most effective for communicating?How will MCO respond to competitor’s products and service offerings?Which distribution channel members will be most effective for selling this product?
Customers Role in Marketing DecisionsCustomers could be individuals / employers / government / association / broker / employee benefits consultant / in network or out of network provider
What do employers and employees want in a health plan? Are members needs being satisfied by their MCO’s? Do physicians and hospitals need additional support or continuing education to help
them provide better quality services? Are our products being offered at a competitive price? How can we satisfy our customers demands for quality care and service in a cost
controlled Environment?
Marketing Research for MCOs Critical issue – Markets are local and not national Different areas have different needs for different healthcare facilities Techniques used include written /fone surveys , one-on-one interviews , focused
group discussions Focused group Interview - unstructured informal session in which six to ten people
participate led by a moderator who guides the group Examples of adv establishment of PPO’s / toll free lines
ProductUse branding to distinguish productsNeed to develop high quality products that meet consumer’s needs
Development and Benefit Design
Benefit Design and Pricing are two important processes.
63
Benefit Design is used to determine which level of benefits will be offered to its members, the degree to which members will be expected to share the costs of such benefits and how the members can access medical care through the health plan
Definitions will include Healthcare services covered by the plan and the UR for those services Any exclusion or limitations that will apply Requirements on deductibles or copayments Decide on prescription benefit, level of benefit, form of benefit Decide on Vision / Dental and other ancillary benefits Decide on the network providers who will support you / credentialing Determine which services may be obtained by members to be covered by the plan Determine the roles and responsibilities of a coordinator of care or PCP in the plan Decide which benefits will be carved out and delivered to specialty services Satisfy applicable regulatory requirements
Need to decide the level of benefits to include in the Plan. HMO’s typically will have more benefits included while PPOs are more flexibleSecondly, can exclude experimental procedures and cosmetic procedures from this setLastly determine which cost sharing features to include
Copayments – differential rates for different levels Coordination of care – PCP appointment / nature of self referral Deductibles and coinsurance Coordination of Benefits Out of Pocket Maximums – dollar limits set by MCO’s on what you might have to pay
out of pocket for the services Annual and Lifetime Maximum benefits Penalty provisions – decreased benefits for not complying with the plan e.g.
admission to hospital without notifying the plan
Innovations in benefit design PCP / POS were innovations PCP now is a ‘coordinator of care’ – enlarged role and responsibility Diversification of product offering out of Initial scope – Customer want one stop shop Challenge to provide marketing support for a diverse product line
PriceDiscussed in section 9B
PromotionInform the consumers about the product and pricePersuade them to buy it and remind them the benefits of choosing our organizationDifferentiate on basis of Quality / Customer Service / Cost / Convenience / Accessibility of healthcare services / Preventive medicine or health promotion services
4 tools used Advertising, personal selling, sales promotion and publicity
Distribution5 key categories for selling – Internal Sales force, agents, brokers, employee benefit consultants and direct marketing
Internal Sales Force Sales manager directs the roles of brokers and agents. Sales person and sales
support staff are employees of the firm. Organization of Sales force
64
o Lines of products like HMOs, PPOs, POS etc o Market segments – sales to groups or non group marketso Group Size – Large , smallo Population Served – Medicare / Medicaid / workers compensationo Geography – metropolitan area / rural area
AgentsThis is a person who is authorized by the MCO to act on behalf of the insurer to negotiate, sell and service managed care contracts.Captive agents represent only the MCO while Independent agents can represent anyone. They are compensated in the form of Commission.
BrokersSalesman who has obtained a license to sell and service contracts of multiple health plans or insurers and who is ordinarily considered to be an agent of the buyer, not the health plan or insurerThese broker services groups comprise of 2 to 1000 agents and are compensated mostly on commission basis. Employee Benefit ConsultantsThis is a specialist who is hired by a group buyer to provide advice on which plan to purchase This guy evaluates the proposed benefits plans and recommends the best choice to his clients. Factors including accreditation etc are also considered.The consultant is paid a fee by the client. He offers in some sense a more objective judgment on the various plans
Direct MarketingUse one or more media to elicit an immediate and measurable action from a client or prospect. Use tools like direct mail, newspaper, television.Database Marketing – Creation of a DB record of information about each customer or customer prospect that is used to narrow the focus of the organizations direct marketing effort.
Segmentation and Positioning for Healthcare MarketsMarket segmentation is the process of dividing the market into smaller more manageable segments. Top level segmentation is generally group vis-à-vis non group. Others include Geographic, Product, Demographic and Distribution Channel.
Non Group Market
Three key classifications – Individual market, senior market and the Medicaid Market
Individual Marketo Composed of customers not eligible for Medicare or Medicaid who are covered
under an individual contract for health coverage. These are sub divided into Former Customers group – Guys who retained individual coverage
after changing jobs. This contract is called a non group contract Regular Individual Market Customers –Students / self employed
o Channels used for this market are direct mail /telemarketing / advertisingo Sales personnel – Agents and Internal Sales forceo MCOs health screen members to prevent anti-selectiono Individual market consumers not meeting eligibility requirements alone are
often eligible to enroll through their affiliation with a professional association such as the Chamber of Commerce
The Senior Market
65
o The segmentation is generally based on age.o The HCFA protects the consumers interests by enforcing regulations that
affect the marketing of managed healthcare products to seniors. o HCFA must approve ALL marketing materials including membership and
enrollment materials used by MCOs to market managed care products to the medicare population.
o Other regulations include prohibition of Door-to-door selling, misrepresentation, discriminatory marketing methods, and use of misleading marketing material or practice.
o Medicare Managed Care National Marketing Guideline – Ensure uniform interpretation and to provide beneficiaries with accurate & clearer information
o Basically the senior market can choose from Traditional Indemnity Coverage under Medicare –
Medicare Part A - provides hospital insurance and Medicare Part B -Covers cost of physicians professional services Can purchase a Medicare Supplement to cover the Gaps in this MEDIGAP Policies – cover out of pocket expenses / routine
services like physical examination / prescription drugs / glasses Managed Care Coverage under Medicare+ Choice
Chose from a variety of plans HMOs / POS /PPOs / Competitive Medical Plans and private FFS plans.
Cover AT LEAST Medicare A & B - But can offer other packages Significant benefit is elimination of paperwork, Coverage
of services not covered by Medicare, generally accept all applicants (irrespective of preexisting conditions)
o Distribution: Informal discussions, direct mail, television, newspaper, telemarketing
o Sales team: Internal sales force
Medicaid Marketo JV between Federal and States which targets hospital/medical expense
coverage for the low income aged and disabled citizens. Some states require these people to join a managed care plan.
o Opportunity that is tempered with strict regulationso Requiring preapproval of all forms of written and verbal communication
between MCO and Medicaid recipiento Preauthorization of marketing materials , programs, brochures, flyers etco Prohibiting giveaways or sales promotion itemso Prohibiting door to door or telephonic solicitationo Distribution: Informal discussions / direct mail / TV advertisingo Sales Team: Some states require Independent enrollment broker / Benefits
counselor should manage enrollment. Other states MCOs can engage independent brokers / agents / internal sales force
Group MarketThe Key groups include
Employer Employee Groups – private / public / federal govt Multi-employer groups – trade associations / labor unions / Affinity Groups – Professional associations / business associations / fraternal orgs Debtor-Creditor Groups – people who have borrowed funds from a bank etc
Small Group Market Classified as 2-99 members
66
Generally seek basic healthcare products with cost mgmt features Price is the most critical decision for small businesses – lowest price/longest period
with a 2 to 3 year rate lock guarantee This segment tends to switch frequently Heavy reliance on the sales representative – agent/ broker Started joining employee purchasing alliances / Health insurance purchasing
Coops / Purchasing Pools / Employer Purchasing Coalitions / Purchasing Coalitions Offered through the local chamber of commerce or small business dev association Distribution:
o Personal Selling is the most effective method – specifically telemarketing has proved to be the most effective
o Direct Mail is also another tool Sales Team
o Agent is most importanto Local Chamber of Commerce – discounted rates for all members
Large Group Market Size > 250 (or 500 or 1000) Members These plans may be self funded – employer bears the financial risk Two key markets
o Large Local groups – manufacturing / municipal / state govtso National Accounts – Large group accounts that have employees in more than
one geographic area Usually use employee benefit consultant Want uniformity in price/ product / service
Seek cost management strategies Important factors: Quality /Diverse product range / access / service / high quality
provider networks/ employee satisfaction / accreditation / self funding capability Expectations – Customized products / high levels of service / continued
enhancements / proof of value / Ability to report utilization data Distribution:
o Personal selling is the most effective tool o Dual or multi level – need to communicate to employees and
employers Employer – target CFO / CEO / Employee benefit consultant Sometimes ask for RFPs to multiple firms
o Employees – Group meetings / Health fairs / promotional info / internet Sales team
o Internal sales force / Employee benefit consultants
Intermediate Group Market Not too large not too small Cost and price sensitive but may fully fund their coverage and offer employees only
one type of plan Negotiate lower premiums as relatively stable claims experience Limited influence on Benefit design
Reading 9B: Underwriting, Rating, and FinancingUnderwritingThe process of identifying and classifying the risk represented by an individual or group is called underwriting.Those individuals who have a greater than likely risk of loss are likely to take up insurance – this tendency is known as Anti-Selection or Adverse SelectionUnderwriters Key Task – Analyze each individual or group applying for insurance in order to identify the characteristics that contribute to risk, measure the amount of risk and determine if this is acceptable.
67
Key tasks Assessment of typical incidence of illness / injury among individuals of same age/sex Consider the effect of risks specific to the individual such as occupation/health status Underwriting Manual – document that provides background information about
various underwriting impairments and suggests the appropriate action to take if such impairments exist
o Underwriting impairments increase an individuals risk above normal levelo Average risk of loss is typically called standard risko Lower than average risk is called Preferred Risko Higher than average risk is called substandard or unacceptable risks
Group evaluation – Focus on the group as a wholeo Reason for groups existenceo Size of Groupo Flow on new members in and out of the groupo Stability of the groupo Number of eligible members who will participate in the plano Way in which benefit levels will be determinedo Activities of the group
Does the group represent a good risk as a whole ? Some states MCOs conduct medical underwriting for small groups – give out health
questionnaires submitted by all proposed plan members. Based on the results the MCO may recommend the following
o Waiting Periods – period of time during which the insured groups medical expenses are not covered
o Preexisting conditions – limit or exclude coverage for conditions that arose before coverage date
o Benefit exclusions – coverage for specific health conditions not allowed Critical balance between very strict and very lenient underwriting Common underwriting requirement include
o Min participation requirements – min % of total emp who should take parto Benefit limitations - a lifetime max of bed days / dollar amt for a conditiono Benefit deductibleo Coinsuranceo Enrollment restrictions – allow members only in certain time windowso Health statements – submitted by members when they join
New Business UnderwritingFirst issues coverage to a group – the rating structure is used as a basis for negotiation. Charges these exact premium rates only if the group satisfies the risk assumptionsThe rate is adjusted based on the following information
Age and gender distribution Level of participation in the health plan Benefits offered Occupational hazards common to the group Group Size History of persistency with the carrier Previous claims experience where permitted by state law
Renewal Underwriting Review all the selection factors that were considered when the contract was issued Compare the group’s utilization rates to those the MCO predicted Reevaluation of two factors – Groups Experience and level of participation in plan Group experience – Cost of providing care to the group during the period
68
Degree of employee participation to avoid antiselection Need to track utilization , demographic factors, cost per member
Legal Requirements Some states prohibit MCO from charging more than base rate listed for specified
products/plans like HMOs. o First ploy – decline coverage to any group with more than average risko Some states deny the above right to the firmo Then need to price the increased risk into the base rates of HMO
Federally qualified HMO’s cant medically underwrite any group – incl small groups Non federally qualified HMOs are subject to state laws and can do this
o However they also are restricted in underwriting Medicare risk
RatingThis is the process of calculating the appropriate premium to charge purchasers, given the degree of risk represented by the individual or group, the expected cost of services, and the expected marketability and competitiveness of the plan.The professionals who perform the mathematical analysis for setting up insurance premium rates are called actuaries
Rating MethodsManaged care uses a variety of rating methods to develop premiums
Community Ratingo This is a rating method which sets the premiums for financing medical care
according to the health plans expected costs of providing medical benefits to the community as a whole and not any sub group
o Both low risk and high risk are factored and the risk is spreado Not used for large groups (except when specified by state law)o This rate is generally used to calculate a reference rateo Some state and federal initiatives have mandated this for small groupso Standard Community rating/ Pure Community Rating
Consider ONLY community wide data and establishes same financial performance goals for all risk classes
No adjustment for age / gender / industry / experience Can vary rates within a plan by dividing members into tiers based on
number of individuals covered. Can have upto four or five tiers. E.g. Tier 1 – employee only tier 2 – employee + one dependent
o Community rating by class (CRC) - NIAC in 1991 adopted a Small Group Model Act that allowed health plans to use a modified form of community rating to underwrite small groups
Divided into 9 rating classes based on demographic factors / industry characteristics / experience
The average premium in any class could NOT be more than 120% of the average premium in any other class
o A 1995 amendment eliminated the class rating rules and required plans to use the Adjusted Community rating (ACR) / Modified Community Rating.
The health plan divided the members into classes /groups based on geography / family / age etc and charges all members of the same class or group the same premium
The Plan cannot consider experience in developing these rates This law did not repeal the state laws – they can still allow
rating based on experience factors Manual Rating / Book rates
69
o This is a rating method in which the health plan uses the plans average experience with all groups to calculate the premium for the group
Experience Ratingo This is a method under which the past record is analyzed and used to
calculate premium partly /completely based on the groups experienceo Lower premium for lower utilization and vice versao Use at least two years of experience to calculate these rateso Most experience rated firms have 1000 plus memberso Two types
Prospective Experience Rating – Past experience to estimate the groups expected experience. Premiums calculated on this expected experience. Health plan absorbs gains/ losses for variance from this
12 months is a typical prospective experience rating period for primary care / shorter rating periods happen for specialty services
Retrospective Experience Rating - looks back at end of the rating period and evaluate gains/losses and pass this onto the group.
Federally qualified HMOs cannot use this rating methodo Pooling – Combining a number of small groups and evaluating the
experience of the large group. Lower premiums achieved Blended Rating
o Not very extensive claims experience. o Partly on manual rates and partly on experienceo Credibility Factor measures the statistical predictability of groups experienceo Large groups have more credible experiences than small groupso Blended rate = experience group rate * credibility factor + manual rate * (1-
credibility factor)
Legal RequirementsAmendments to the HMO act 1973 permitted federally qualified HMO’s to use the community rating, CRC or ACR but not retrospective experience rating. Federally qualified HMO’s need approval for ACR can’t charge > 110% of the rate with pure community rating.
Other states force community rating for individuals and small groups. HFCA requires all health plans to assume Medicare risk using ACR.
To obtain federal contracts for the Federal Employee Health benefit program – an MCO can’t charge the government more than it charges other groups of similar size.
NIAC Small Group Act - Rate Spread – The difference between the highest and lowest rates that a health plan charges is to a ratio of 2: 1
FinancingFile an annual statement with NAIC for each state they do business in.Some critical finance terms
1. Income statement2. Revenues 3. Expenses – admin + stop loss premiums + reimbursement costs + utilization costs 4. Assets – value of all items company owns5. Liabilities – all debts and obligations of a company. Most significant are the
reserves (estimates of money that an insurer needs to pay future business obligations). These include Incurred but not Reported (IBNR) Claims.
6. Capital
70
7. Surplus = assets – liabilities8. Forecasting – Predicting an MCO’s incoming and outgoing cash flows – Primarily
revenues and expenses and predicting the value of its assets, liabilities and capital.9. Budgeting – process that includes creating a financial plan of action that an
organization believes will help it achieve its goals given the forecast
Concerned with statutory solvency ability to maintain at least its minimum amount of capital and surplus specified by state insurance regulators
NIAC requires at least $1 million. HMO Model act requires – specified % of annual premiums and expected expenses Variance Analysis – difference between budgeted and actual income and expenses
Plan Funding Method that an employer or plan purchaser uses to pay medical benefit costs. Health plan may be financed or funded in a variety of ways – Fully funded plans and
self funded plans Fully funded Plans MCO bears full financial responsibility of guaranteeing claim payments paying for all
incurred covered benefits and administering the health plan – this is the traditional way
Self Funded Planso Employer or group Sponsor is financially responsibleo May be partially or fully fundedo ERISA – these plans are exempt from specific state insurance regulationso Mechanism – the money is deposited in a Funding Vehicle. Company only
pays for incurred healthcare costs. o In case of catastrophic medical claims – the employer will not have funds.
Then he utilizes Stop Loss Insurance to cover the risk.o Individual Stop Loss Coverage/Specified stop loss coverage – provides
benefits for claims on an individual that exceed a stated amount in a periodo Aggregate Stop Loss coverage – provides benefits when total claims
exceed certain amount in a specified periodo Administrative functions
Do it themselves Self pay – employer administers the plan by hiring staff/ systems TPA – no financial risk
Administrative Services Only – fixed fee per employee
71
10. Managed Healthcare Operations II
Reading 10A: Information Management Describe the kinds of information and information systems capabilities needed by
managed care organizations Discuss some of the primary challenges for managing data and information Discuss the use of the following information technologies in managed care
environments:- Electronic commerce- Electronic data interchange- Decision support systems- Data warehouses- Electronic medical records- Health information networks
Reading 10B: Claims Administration for Managed Care Define encounter Describe some of the key positions in a claims administration department Explain the steps followed to process a managed care claim Describe some types of information an automated claims database needs to contain Reading 10C: Member Services Describe four types of member services activities commonly conducted by MCOs Describe several ways in which MCO’s use technology to facilitate the delivery of
member services Explain how MCO arrangements for providing member services vary from company to
company Describe the considerations for managing accessibility, people, processes, technology,
and performance for member services
72
Reading 10A: Information Management
Information Technology NeedsInformation Management is a combination of systems, processes and technology that an MCO uses to provider the Company’s Information users with the Information they need to carry out their job responsibilitiesTypical information used will include
Description of benefits structures for the products Member eligibility rosters Current information about provider networks Reimbursement arrangements with participating providers Information to support authorization processes Reports on Utilization and Quality Management Programs Member satisfaction surveys Claims processing / billing and payment information Performance measures of various departments Financial information for accounting and reporting purposes
Needs for Information System CapabilitiesAn information system is an interactive combination of people, computer hardware and software, communication devices, and procedures designed to provide a continuous flow of information to the people who need itNeed to assist people in the day to day operations and need to support analysis and accumulated data and information and report the results of this analysisOther specialized systems include
1. Credentialing System – Plan Managers need to review documentation of the healthcare professionals and institutional providers
a. Licensure, Certifications, evidence of malpractice insurance, history etcb. Need to track the credentialing information and regularly update it
2. Contract Managementa. Can be very complex (esp with Capitation)b. If costs are not calculated properly, the are likely to lose money in bidding for
future contractsc. Need to have access to accurate lists of covered individualsd. MCOs need to reconcile capitation payments and manage risk poolse. Need to check the eligibility status very carefullyf. Contract Management System – incorporates membership data and provider
reimbursement data and analyzes transaction according to contract rulesg. Systems have support of decision making, modeling and forecasting, cost
reporting an contract Compliance Tracking3. Utilization Management Software
a. Need to manage authorization transactions and utilizationb. Pre-established Guidelines determine authorization and paymentc. Can automate this process and monitor the actual costs of cared. Need systems to manage access, utilization and quality of care under care
management or disease Management programs4. Quality Management
a. Positive outcomes of treatment or lower incidence of illness are valued by members
b. Need to store, analyze and report large amounts of clinically significant data over time to support development of quality indicators, outcome measures and clinical protocols and guidelines
5. Provider Profilinga. This helps detect under/over utilization and inappropriate utilization of
medical resources
73
6. Enterprise Schedulinga. Need to control usage of resources like MRI and surgeryb. Enterprise Scheduling System permits users within an enterprise to function
as a single organization in arranging access to facilities / resources7. Claims Processing
a. Need a vast amount of data accumulatedb. Used by all segments of the company
8. Marketinga. Need to communicate information to purchasers and members
9. Member Services – Fast/Convenient access to information, transaction processing and other types of services for members
Challenges1. MCO needs to manage large volumes of internal and external data2. Need to manage different types of data – clinical/regulators/legal /quality/ 3. Need to acquire complete, accurate and consistent data – different codesets etc4. Data that is readily available and easy to collect may not be the most relevant –
may need to modify the data through additional analytic tools5. Need to manage different data formats – from providers and plans / diff databases /
paper transactions / 6. Need to produce many different reports at different frequencies – format/ length /
type of information / level of detail all can vary7. Laws which are stringent on the usage of e-PHI and protecting it
Information TechnologyThis refers to the wide range of electronic devices and tools used to acquire, record, store, transfer or transform data or information. Devices and tools used include
1. Electronic Commerce2. Electronic Data Interchange3. Decision Support Systems DSSs4. Data Warehouses5. Electronic Medical Records (EMRs)6. Health Information Networks (HINs)
Electronic Commerce MCOs use of Computer Networks as a means to perform Business Transactions and to
facilitate the delivery of healthcare and Non Clinical Services to MCO members Use it to communicate within the Health plan and with plan members/purchasers /
providers / regulators / accrediting bodies / and potential members and purchasers E-Commerce helps expand document access Long term cost savings – Increased speed / access to information Most of the traffic is via the internet Use of websites – Informational Purposes and Transactional Purposes Informational – Marketing / Explaining Plan benefits / Lifestyle / Reporting info/
Eligibility information , Clinical Practice Management and Formularies Transactional – Changing members information / changing PCP / Prescriptions/
Status of Claims / Processing authorization requests / update eligibility / payment E-Health – Used to refer to concept of and strategies for providing health related
information, products and services online Advantages of the Internet
o Worldwide useo Growing usage among the general populationo Cooperative oversight and ready availability – no one dominates the neto Interoperable Communicationo Low Cost
74
o Direct access to current and potential consumers Potential Disadvantages of Internet Usage
o Concerns about Security – need to have secure enterpriseso Use secure internet and intranetso Extranets are used to connect providers / members / regulatory bodieso Types of securities employed include
Firewalls – unauthorized access to internal network Anti virus programs Encryption Digital Signature
Electronic Data InterchangeComputer to Computer transfer of data between organizations using a data format agreed upon by sending and receiving parties. Information is routed through network systems and follows standards and procedures that allow output from one system to be processed directly as input to other systemsOrganization who do business using EDI are called Trading PartnersEDI is used for
1. Transmission of claims and encounter reports from providers to health plan2. Transmission of data from Claims database Medical management departments3. Transmission of data among different MCO departments or geographic locations4. Exchange of data between MCO and regulatory body or accrediting agency5. Transmission of member eligibility data from an MCO to its providers6. Exchange of information between an MCO and its providers regarding requests for
authorizations of services and referrals
Advantages of EDIo Speed of data Transfer and Improved Data Integrityo Elimination of unnecessary paperwork – Cost saving in administrative costs
Largest cost of claims processing is labor Data entry and examination functions
o Reduction in processing time – increased productivityo Improved Business Methods – Focus on improving the details of repetitive
transactions and to upgrade the internal procedures Technology requirements for EDI
o Internet serves as the communication link o Standardized Data format is essentialo Set of syntax / Grammar that forms part of the basis of standard usageo Need an industry agreement on standards – examples include
ANSI – Voluntary national standards organization – creates a consensus based process by which fair and equitable standards can be developed. This serves as a legitmizer of standards
ASC X12 – ANSI’s Accredited Standards Committee X12 was created in 1979 to develop the EDI standards. X12 operates with committees and subgroups. Insurance Subcommittee came in 1989
American Health Information Management Association – Focuses on EDI standards for exchange of clinical data
American College of Radiology and National Electronic Manufacturers Association – ACR-NEMA Xray imaging standards DICOM 3
HL7 – Health Level 7 - Scope is information exchanges among computer application systems. HL7 developers are working with X12 standard developers and with the American Society for Testing and Materials to coordinate interchange of Clinical Health Data
75
American Dental Association – Reporting standards/Guidelines / for the dental system
Computer Based Patient Records Institute – CPRI – These standards are related to the Computerization of Medical Records
Decision Support Systems This uses databases and decision models to enhance the decision making process for
MCO executives / managers/ clinical staff and providers Use – Identify the most effective medical intervention, provider profiling and tracking
of provider reimbursement Expert System – knowledge based computer system – Purpose: Provide expert
consultation to information users for solving specialized and complex problems – Primarily used in Claims Administration but also used in medical management decisions
In case of providers, the focus is on supplying the providers with information they need at the time clinical decisions are made – one e.g. is embedding clinical decision support criteria into decision support software
This helps develop treatment guidelines based on specific diagnosis of problems, warnings of drug interactions.
Facilitators – not replacement!
Data Warehouses Legacy systems – need for function / high cost of replacing Searching from multiple unlinked DBs is time consuming A data warehouse is a specific database – containing data from a variety of sources
that are linked by a common subject This data is integrated and presented in a non repetitive standard format Data can be from both internal and external sources – and can be queried from a
single interface A consistent format for data helps them compare data across different types of MCO
products and against other MCOs Advantages and disadvantages
o Pros Simplify the process of extracting useful information Relieves the individual DBs from having to store large amounts of
redundant data not needed for daily operations Help detect trends or relationships between data that is not
immediately obviouso But
Very Costly and Complex to implement Time consuming and requires technological expertise and cash The ROI might not be realized very quickly
Electronic Medical Records / Computer Based Patient Record Computerized record of a patient’s clinical, demographic and administrative data Include Medical History, Current and past medications, diagnoses of illness, test
results and current treatment status Could also include Digital Images, MRI images, X Rays etc Organized along Individual Patients and not providers EMR software can be designed to Alert a provider to possible drug interactions in
case of patient receiving multiple medications
Health Information Networks This would be more efficient if it is transferred across the entire network of providers
76
Health Information Network is a computer network that provides access to a database of medical information – Proprietary to the Organization
Community Health Information – CHIN – it’s used by several organizations Health Data Network HDN – links to the data warehouse that stores very large
amounts of data that reside in the medical records of an entire provider network Access to this using a secured extranet / distributed database Most HINs are internet based rather than built on proprietary computer networks Advantages and Disadvantages of HINs
o These have the potential to increase the quality of Medical Careo MCO reviews claims, can match diagnosis treatment codes/ verify
authorization, and record utilization informationo Allows Multiple professionals at different locations to access a
member chart simultaneously Key Benefits
o Improved Care and Service to Members – Timely cost effective o Lower Costs of Information administration - o Improved outcomes measurement – Extract trends/ develop guidelineso Better Measurement of provider performance o Increased efficiency and accuracy of information about healthcare services
rendered to memberso Reduced Exposure to liability for poor careo Improved ability to meet reporting requirements
Disadvantageo Significant costs and risks including
Cost of equipment Cost of planning , installing and maintaining network and software Extreme technical complexity of achieving the reliability and speed Labour costs for training providers and their staff Lack of standardization of the EMRs Resistance to change among the providers Security issues concerning privacy , protection of the MCO’s
proprietary information and external interference with MCOs systems
Outsourcing Information ManagementHiring external vendors to perform specified functions like data and information management activities
77
Reading 10B: Claims Administration for Managed Care
Claim is an itemized statement of healthcare services and their costs provided by physician’s organizations and other providers.Claims are submitted to the insurer or managed care plan by the member / provider.
Claims in Managed Care Claim form is the application for payment of benefits to the health plan The nature of claim function varies with the type of plan and compensation
arrangements that the plan has made with its providers. PPO would be like a traditional billing approach, while HMO Capitation would simply
require the HMO to state the services provided An Encounter is a healthcare visit of any type by an enrollee to a provider of
healthcare services. HMO’s receive an encounter report supplies management information about the services provided each time the patient visits a provider – and these could be considered as surrogates for insurance claims.
These can be used to track utilization of services
Claims AdministrationThis is the process of receiving, reviewing, adjudicating and processing claimsThis is the Primary information source for the MCO for compensation, utilization, financial, provider, marketing, information management, medical management, provider relations, contracting etc
Claims Administration Department Generally a Director / VP as a head Oversees entire claims function from planning and management perspective Claims Manager - Oversees the day to day running of the claims department,
including staffing functions and managing the people and systems Claims Supervisors – Oversee the work of several claims examiners – support their
staff and establish efficient claims handling procedures. Further, they may handle difficult and large amount claims and make work assignments for claims examiners
Claims Examiners / Analysts consider all the information pertinent to a claim and make a decision about the MCOs payment of the claim. Key responsibilities include
o Analyzing claims to determine the type of coverage heldo Assessing medical informationo Requesting additional information needed to determine benefitso Determining the person or entity to payo Calculating payable benefitso Explaining claims denials, payments and contract provisions
Other posts include Claim reviewers, quality control reviewers, claims adjudicators, nurse or utilization reviewers, clerks and admin support function
Functions might be organized on o Lines of Business – PPO, HMO, POS , EPOo Claim function – COB etco Type of Claim – Hospital , physician, outpatient surgeryo Client Grouping – MCO’s with large clientso Origination of the claim – in network or out of network
Claim Decision Process Key steps
1. Was the member eligible to receive coverage under the plan at the time of service?2. Was the provider in the network of the plan?3. Was treatment provided medically appropriate and necessary?4. Was a preauthorization or referral given for the service or treatment?
78
5. Is the service covered under the plan?6. What benefits are payable?7. Does the member have other health insurance coverage?
Verifying Members StatusRoutine step – happens automatically as it is electronically maintained
Verify Provider StatusMost plans give higher level benefits in the network than outside
Determining Appropriateness of treatment provided They determine this by developing edits into the claims decision processing system.
Edits are criteria that if unmet will prompt further investigation of a claim – These in effect KICK OUT claims for further review.
This may be triggered if o Missing or conflicting informationo Illogical responses or codes contained on the claim formo Treatments or procedures not covered by the health plan. o Verification of member eligibilityo Prior authorization requestso Appropriateness of medical care.
These are programmed into the claims processing system
Verifying AuthorizationCould be issues like pre-admission testing before surgery or referral to specialist by PCP
Verifying that the Service is covered by the Plan
Verifying that the Service was actually provided The Claimant supplies on the claim form much of the info to verify this The standard terms used for this are Diagnostic and Treatment Codes. These are
brief, specific description of each diagnosis or treatment and a number used to identify each diagnosis and treatment.
These include ICD 9-CM (diagnostic codes) and CPT (Treatment Codes) Can explain conflicts between diagnostic codes and treatment codes The standardized claims forms are
o UB -92 requires hospitals to follow specific billing and itemization procedureso HCFA 1500 – Providers to bill professional feeds to HMOs, insurers etco Superbill – this lists the specific procedures or medical services provided by a
physician. It has check boxes
Determining the Amount of benefits to PayThe factors considered include compensation arrangements, authorization requirements, any copayment or coinsurance requirements, Coordination of Benefits
Automation of Claims ProcessUsed to verify member eligibility and provider statusMore sophisticated plans get claims through EDIData that is potentially required includes
1. Member data – age / sex/ PCP / dependents2. Predetermined Fee Schedules for service types3. Provider Information profiles that contain information on the provider who
participate in the plan, type of compensation arrangement , presence of any risk pooling arrangements, any special discount that applies to provider fees, and restrictions on the type of service provided
79
4. Authorization requirements and utilization information5. Use of coordinator of care function (Use of a provider such as PCP)
Still collect information about he medical condition that prompted an encounter to analyze utilization and provider practice patterns. This data is used as a basis for next years capitation payment
Nowadays we use a combination of discounted FFS and capitation
Investigation of Claims This is the process of obtaining information necessary to determine the appropriate
amount to pay on a given claim. The majority of claims do not require investigation Extent of investigation depends on – exact type of claim, information needed to make
an appropriate decision and the difficulty encountered in obtaining information Sources of info – attending physicians, labs, Medical directors and members NIAC Unfair Claims Settlement Practice Act – Specifies standards for the
investigation and handling of claims. A practice is considered improper if o Committed Flagrantly and in conscious disregard of the Acto Committed so frequently that a general business practice to engage in that
type of conduct is indicated Need to obtain a valid authorization from the member to obtain the claims
investigation data from various sources and certain investigation techniques may be prohibited by federal or state statutes and regulations. Violations of such laws and regulations subject the MCO to liability for payment of legal damages
Claims Administration as a Customer Service Function Information resource for the rest of the firm and is vital customer service role First contact point apart from enrollment Prompt processing makes a lasting impression on a customer
80
Reading 10C: Member Services
Member services is a broad range of activities that an MCO and its employees undertake to support the delivery of the promised benefits to members and to keep members satisfied with the company.
There are two key segments Inbound member contacts – member initiated requests for information, transactions,
service and assistance with problems Outbound member contacts initiated by the MCO
Type of Member Service Activities
Member Education
Need to understand their roles and responsibilities Need information that would help manage & improve their health Education is in the areas of benefits, cost sharing responsibilities, health plan
authorization systems BEFORE they need the services is a good way to reduce member confusion about access and payment
Reduce the incidence of disputes and claims Preventive care measures are proactively pitched – Member OUTREACH programs
o Focus on the administrative information about the plano Health related information or both
Typically the following information is provided to all plan memberso Description of services covered and excluded for diff types of careo Responsibilities in the care delivery process – copay/ deductible / referrals /
authorizationo Differences between in network and out of network benefitso Services requiring authorization of payment and guidelines for the same o Preventive care / screenings / disease management / triage services detailso Health related information of interest to the general populationo Options for resolving complaints and appealing to health plan decisions
Another mechanism is identification of groups of members with common characteristics (sex / age / ethic background) and sending them health related info
Communication channel o Mass mailing of letters and Health plan newsletterso Internet email o Websites – FAQs , directions , general wellness and prevention information
Need to customize the educational information based on target audience
Assistance with Questions, Transactions and other Service RequestsFour key areas Administrative Issues – some e.g.
o Identity card out of dateo Please send me new provider directoryo PCP moved out of an areao Mailing address for claim?
Coverage Issueso What type of benefit do I have for so and so?o Does the plan pay for prescriptions from out-of-network providers?
Health Plan Programso Who do I call if I am not sure abt the care I need?o What are the preventive care and wellness programs?
81
Access Issueso How do you get authorization for so-and-so?o Do you need a referral for so and so?
Telephone is the preferred communication channel – need a toll free line Use Computer / Telephony Integration – CTI – a technology that unites a
computer system with the telephone. Two common applications includeo Automatic Call distributor ACD –
Device that answers calls with recorded messages and routes to the appropriate department
User keys in the info for identification etc This prevents receiving a busy signal – and expedite the connection
o Interactive voice response (IVR) – Is an automated system that answers calls with recorded or synthesized
Self service for a certain set of transactions Can switch to an operator in case not satisfied
Paper mail is a substantial part of MCOs inbound and outbound contacts MCOs use letters to send updates to its members Also used to deliver important notifications, and handle payment updates, address
changes, claims processing and EOB Fax is another common communication tool Combine IVR + FAX to create a fax-on-demand system e.g.
o Description of health plan, benefits and how it workso Forms for filing for claims or filling prescriptionso Descriptions of common injuries and their treatment options
Websites are used to enable changes to profile etc Email – Some transactions are restricted for security and privacy
Complaint Management Complaints about the Plan
o Rudeness, payment authorization, PCP selection Complaints about Providers
o Late appointments, non returning of calls, waiting times, staff, service levels Unresolved complaints move to appeals – kill it early Need a Complaint Resolution Process (CRP) Need to address informal complaints as well as formal appeals Employer Sponsored health plans must provide avenues for appeal
o Otherwise they breach the ERISA – Employee retirement income security act State laws for CRP requirements include
o Inform all members about the CRPo Track and report complaintso Comply with specific timeframes when responding to complaintso Provide an option for independent external review of complaints when internal
reviews are exhausted The Appeal Process
o A dispute is reviewed and resolved by a party other than the person who made the initial decision or performed the service that lead to the complaint
o There are at least two levels of appeals Level One Appeal to the Medical Director or other officer of the MCO
to review the original decision and any additional supporting information submitted by the complaining member. Decision communicated to all members
Level Two Appeal – Level Two appeals are handled by an appeals committee which consists of people from various areas including utilization review, member services, health plan operations and legal
82
affairs and physicians (in case a medical opinion is required) and from plan members
o Have a maximum time frame for conducting the inquiryo Arbitration appeals to government agencies or independent external review
are often available to the member This is the process of parties to a dispute submit their dispute to an
impartial third party for final binding decisiono Commercial health plan members appeal – insurance dept for a stateo Federal Employees may appeal to the Office of Personnel Management o HCFA hears appeals regarding Medicare Plans and State Departments
handle Medicaid appeals Independent External Review – Conducted by a third party that is not affiliated to the
health plan or provider – These are called independent review organizations (IROs) Considers all info abt the dispute and may seek additional info from the plan/
member/ provider Either mediate the process of appeal OR provide a decision which is binding
Member Satisfaction Measurement and Reporting On Details like
o Satisfaction with the Plan as a wholeo Their access to healthcare serviceso Quality of the medical care received from providerso Quality of non clinical services received from the plan and its providerso Plans administration
The results are benchmarked with the company / industry / external stdsTwo Primary Way of measuring it
Member Satisfaction Surveys Parameters like
o Satisfaction with the authorization processes for hospital admissiono Satisfaction with care from hospital staffo Aspects of experience that can be improved
3 imp purposeso Assessment of members satisfaction with various aspects of a health plano Method for collecting data to assess quality and identify opportunitieso Facilitates relationship building with plan and member
Survey the general member population also – low utilizers cross subsidize the higher ones – so need to take care of them so they don’t leave!
CAHPS – Most popular – Consumer Assessment of Health Planso Questionnaires, directions for interviews and reporting results
Complaint Monitoring Member’s complaints as opportunities for improvement Encourage members to give positive and negative feedback Categorize, report and monitor or complaints by type Helps improve the quality and service delivery Identification , investigation and resolution of serious or recurring problems
Methods of Delivering Member Services Some - dedicated member services, others source personnel from diff departments Plans with defined networks, authorization systems and a variety of programs to
manage quality and utilization have separate member services department because the receive a high volume of inquiries and services requests from members
Fewer member services like PPOs generally have these handled through other departments
83
Some have specialized member services for different products or particular accounts An MCO can divide its member services into groups specialized in different
means of communication like telephone, email , fax, correspondence, websites or Groups specified in terms of Function – Claims or Authorization
Managing Member ServicesNeed to display attributes like
1. Competence2. Strong Communication Skills3. Professional Demeanor4. Empathy – understand the members emotional condition
Need to manage the following aspects of member services Accessibility – what communication channels? Hours of operation? Staffing Levels?
o Members and purchaser Expectations? Competitor Levels of accessibility?o Most Member services are available only during business hourso Some plans extend these services for phone and faxes beyond these hours
and on weekendso Off hours provide limited services through IVR or websiteso Staffing levels will determine the wait time / these are affected by the service
reps responsibilities, nature of the plan, availability of self service options, and members willingness to use these options
o A broad scope of responsibilities, a complex benefit structure and complicated authorization requirements can increase the staffing needs
o Effective use of telephones and computer technology can reduce staffing needs
o Average Staff to member ratio is 1:5000 Personnel who have contact with members
o Need to have an aptitude and attitude for providing serviceso Need months of training before they are put in streamo Need to educate them on – Company products/procedures/computer and
phone systems/ general principles of customer service / sensitivity training/ active listening / problem solving / dispute resolution / handling angry customers
o Subjected to high stress and a burn out – need to create incentives Processes for Delivery
o Need to support the member service reps with strong workflow processes – This could include
Fulfilling requests for provider directories EOB for different types of services Changing a members PCP Assisting in getting authorizations for payments Investigating claims Welcome calls to new members Handling Complaints
Supporting Technologyo CTI helps improve productivityo Technology is expensive in the short term
Performance of serviceso This addresses the quality and cost effectiveness of serviceso Satisfaction surveys and complaint reportso Key statistics include
Turnaround time
84
First contact resolution - % of transactions completed in the initial point of contact
Error rate – accuracy of information given and transaction proc Wait time – length of time on average members stay on hold Call abandonment rate – how many members hang up before receiving
assistanceo There is sometimes listening in on callso Measures of Cost Effectiveness Typically focus on productivity of the team
Time per call Amount per each customer contact Amount on admin duties – like documenting / follow up/research
o Set Service Levels – based on industry /company benchmarkso Try to use First Contact Resolution at the cost of wait time to improve service
levels and solve the problem first up
85
11. Legislative and Regulatory Issues in Managed Healthcare
Reading 11A: Federal Laws and Regulations Identify and describe federal laws and regulations that apply to MCOs Explain the role that federal laws and regulations play in protecting consumers and
maintaining a level playing field in the marketplaceReading 11B: State Laws and Regulations Compare the key components of state regulations for HMOs and other MCOs Describe the major functions that MCOs perform that are subject to state regulationReading 11C: Government-Sponsored Programs Describe the role of the federal government as purchaser of managed healthcare
benefits for the elderly (Medicare), those with low income (Medicaid), federal employees and dependents (Federal Employee Health Benefits Program [FEHBP]), and inactive and retired military personnel (TRICARE)
Discuss the application of managed care principles to workers’ compensation
86
Reading 11A: Federal Laws and Regulations
General Business LegislationThere are a lot of general laws which affect the structure and operation of MCOs – These include Federal Antitrust Laws, employee benefits legislation and financial services legislation
Legislative Act Who must Comply
Protected Class Effect of Legislation on Healthcare
Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA)
Employers with > 20 employees
Employers aged over 40
All active employees irrespective of age must be eligible for the same healthcare coverage and cannot be required to pay more than the younger guys
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
Employers > 15 employees engaged in interstate commerce
All employees
This Prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex or national origin. Need to be sure that their policies don’t impact one protected class. Pregnancy Discrimination Act (an amendment to this act) requires health plans to provide coverage during childbirth and related medical conditions on the same basis as they provide coverage for other medical conditions
Family and Medical Leave Act FMLA
Employers that have > 50 Employees
Birth/adoption or provide care to seriously ill family members / themselves
Can take upto 12 weeks of unpaid leave in a 12 month period. Employers need to maintain the coverage of group health insurance during this period
Anti Trust Legislation The federal government protects the business environment through antitrust legislation. These laws are designed to protect commerce from unlawful restraint of trade, price discrimination, price fixing, reduced competition and monopolies.
Three most important acts are Sherman Antitrust Act (1890)Establishes as the national policy the concept of a competitive marketing system – This prohibits the companies from Monopolizing any part of trade or commerce Engage in contracts, combinations and conspiracies in restraint of trade Applies to all companies engaged in interstate commerce and foreign commerce
Clayton Act (1914)This act forbids actions that lead to monopolies. These includeCharging different prices for different purchasers of same product without justificationGiving distributors rights to sell a product only if he agrees not to sell a competitor productThe act applies to insurance companies to the extent that the state laws do not regulate it
Federal Trade Commission Act (1914)Establishes the FTC and gave it power to enforce the Clayton Act. Key functions includeRegulation of unfair competition and deceptive business practices, also to pursue violators of the Sherman Antitrust Act
87
McCarran Ferguson Act 1945 placed the primary responsibility for regulating health insurance companies and HMOs on the State
The state laws apply sometimes over these national laws in some cases. But they need to comply with provisions of the Sherman Antitrust Act relating to boycott, coercion and intimidation. The following areas would warrant violation of the antitrust agreement
1. Price fixing – two or more competitors on the prices or fees to be charged- for e.g. they can’t cooperatively agree to accepting ONLY capitation payments
2. Horizontal Group Boycott – two competitors agree not to do business with another competitor or purchaser
3. Tying arrangements – Conditions on the sale of one product on the other4. Horizontal Division of Markets – two companies decide to divide areas5. Use of Exclusive Provider Contracts – In most cases it is legal for MCO to
contract only with selected providers. The regulation only restricts this if it creates a restraint on trade. The MCO can’t prohibit its provider from contracting with any other MCO. MCOs can prevent anti trust claims by establishing alternatives to exclusive contracts by dealing with IPAs or PHOs
Ethics in Patient Referrals Act 1989 – Starks Laws These guard against anti trust activities in the healthcare market This prohibits physicians from referring patients to a lab/radiology/ diagnostic/ home
health/ pharma / therapy services in which he has a financial interest Some exceptions have been bought in for rural providers, HMOs and group practices.
Healthcare Quality Improvement Act Exempts Hospitals, group practices and HMOS from antitrust provisions applying to
credentialing and peer review as long as these entitlements adhere to due process standards that are outlined by the HCQIA
An MCO who declines to retain a physician must provide due notice of the same and also inform the National Practitioner Data Bank of its decision
Other laws cover the MCO’s Medicare and Mediclaim contracts
Employee Benefit Legislation
Employee Retirement Income Security ActThis is a broad reaching law that establishes the rights of pension plan participants, standards for investment of pension plan assets, and requirements for the disclosure of plan provisions and funding. This applies to all employer sponsored pension plans and to all benefit plans that provide healthcare services.
Key facts Strict reporting rights to all employers and plan fiduciaries (persons who
have discretionary authority over other peoples money) Requirement to distribute summary plan descriptions and file reports with the
department of labor and IRS Most SIGNIFICANT feature – Preemption Provision – It takes precedence over
state laws that regulate employee welfare benefit planso The preemption provision leaves to the state the authority to regulate
insurance, banking and securities For e.g. – State laws apply to group plan if it is insured but not to self
funded group plans Self funded plans are exempt from paying premium taxes @ state level
(State income taxes leveled on insurer’s premium income)
88
This encourages large employers to create their own insurance like mechanism on a self funded basis
Employees who legally challenge authorization of payment decisions must file their case at a federal level and ERISA governs this
This is GOOD for MCO’s as ERISA limits the damages that can be awarded in lawsuits to the cost of non authorized treatment. No punitive damages are allowed to be claimed
There is a call for proposals to remove this preemption privilege
Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1986 This deals with the continuum of healthcare coverage on termination of employment The original HMO act contained these provisions – but they were only being applied
by HMOs – a need to change this caused the law to be passed in 1986 COBRA requires each group health plan to allow employees and certain dependents
to continue their group coverage for a stated period of time following a qualifying event that causes the loss of group health coverage. These could include
o Reduced working hourso Divorce or death of a covered employeeo Termination of employment
Applies to firms with > 20 employees After the qualifying event has occurred there is a specified timeframe in which the
member must apply for continuation of group benefits This must be identical to the benefits received by the members of the group plan Allowed to continue coverage for UPTO 18 MONTHS Spouse and Dependents are covered UPTO 36 Months following an employees
death or divorce Dependent child who ceases to be eligible can continue for UPTO 36 months Following the last month of eligibility under COBRA – the employees have a right to
convert to individual health plan IF they don’t have any other coverage The Plan administrator may add the admin fee of 2% to the cost of plan
Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999 – Gramm Leach Bliley Act This allowed the Convergence of the various components of the Financial Services
industry – banks, securities firms and insurance companies MCO’s are considered part of the financial services industry This act looks at
o How financial services industry will be structured in the futureo How the financial services industry will be regulated and supervisedo The rights of customers to protect the privacy of financial information and
remedies for violations of the privacy provisions Title V of the BGLB Act
o Disclose their privacy policies regarding the sharing of non public personal information with both affiliates and third parties
o Notify customers of any sharing of non public personal information with non affiliated third parties
o Provide customers with an option to ‘opt out’ of non public sharing of personal information subject to certain regulations
NIAC has come out with a Privacy of Consumer Financial and Health Information Regulation to govern the activities of healthcare organizations and insurers
Healthcare Legislation
HMO Act of 1973 Instrumental in defining the structure and operations of HMOs and paved the way for
89
HMO’s to enter the healthcare market Requirements were established to become federally qualified – they include
o Benefits – need to offer a comprehensive benefits package which includes inpatient and outpatient services, unlimited home healthcare benefits, outpatient behavioral healthcare – these services are deliverable only through Staff or Group Models, IPAs or direct practice arrangements
o Enrollment – Need to enroll individuals eligible for group coverage without regard to health status
o Financing – Need to be financially sound and protect against insolvencyo Quality Assurance – Establish ongoing quality assurance program in line wth
HCFA 300 HMOs meet these requirements even though it is optional
HIPAA 1996Outlines the requirements that employer sponsored group insurance plans, insurance companies and MCOs must satisfy in order to provide health insurance coverage in the individual and group marketsTwo main categories
Title 1 provisions are designed to increase the continuity of coverage o These are not preemptive of state laws– they only apply when the state
laws do not cover this topic or are not very comprehensive Title 2 calls for administrative simplification
Title 1 These are divided into group and individual health coverage Individual Coverage Provisions
o Guarantees the availability of coverage for individuals who meet specified qualifications
o Specifies that all qualified individuals who apply for insurance from a private insurer must be issued a policy automatically without a medical examination and without regard to preexisting conditions
o Someone qualifies for this is he has in the last 18 months group coverage but is now ineligible for either group coverage or Medicare/ Medicaid
o If he loses job and new job does not give coverage – he qualifies for individual coverage
Group Coverage Provisionso Limitations on the use of preexisting conditions
Preexisting condition treatment/diagnosis should have been received 6 months prior to enrollment date
The period for which a preexisting condition is exclude should not exceed 12 months after enrollment date (18 months for late enrollees)
Need to reduce the length of preexisting condition based on the creditable coverage received uner previous group plans, or benefit programs from the sate and federal government.
The Creditable coverage is credited only if the period was not followed by a break in coverage of 63 days or more.
Waiting period under employee sponsored plan does not constitute a break in coverage
Pregnancy cannot be treatment as a preexisting condition Can’t impose preexisting conditions on a newborn child / adopted child
< 18 if the child is covered within 30 days of birth/adoption o Guaranteed availability of coverage for small groups
Small groups are defined as 2 to 50 employees – can’t exclude employees or employee dependents based on health status
90
o Guaranteed Renewability of coverage for all groups Need to renew group policies for all big and small groups Renew individual policies also – they can be modified only if the whole
class of policies is being modified and CANNOT be on the basis of health status
o Special enrollment Need to allow employees who declined health coverage initially but
experienced a qualifying event to accept group coverage ant any time In cases like child birth – coverage obtained can be retroactive
Modifications to thiso Mental Health Parity Act – MHPA of 1996
Prohibits group health plans from applying more restrictive annual or lifetime limits on coverage for mental illness than for physical illness
DOES NOT require health plans to offer Mental health – but imposes restrictions on those who do
o Newborns and Mother Protection Act (NMHPA ) 1996 Group health plans or insurers cannot mandate that hospital stays
following child birth be less than 48 hours for normal deliveries or 96 hours for cesarean birth
Does not require group plans and insurers to offer maternity hospitalization benefits – instead it imposes requirements on those plans that do offer these benefits
o Women’s Health and Cancer Rights Act 1998 – Health plans offering medical and surgical benefits for mastectomy to provide reconstructive surgery following mastectomy
Title II –Administrative Simplification EDI Standards, Privacy and Security Regulations Clearinghouse – Public/Private Entity which converts provider data into correct
format for each health plan and coverts health plan data into provider format Billing services, repricing companies, community health MIS and value added
networks are considered to be healthcare clearinghouses Large health plans > $5 million will have 24 months to comply while small health
plans get 36 months to comply Penalties could range from $100 per violation to $250,000 and imprisonment for upto
10 years for violating privacy standards
Electronic Transmission and CodesetsThe Data covered includes
1. Health claims or encounter data2. Health Plan eligibility inquiries and responses3. Provider referrals and authorizations4. Claims status inquiries and responses5. Health plan enrollment and disenrollment requests6. Claim Payment and remittance7. Health Plan premium payment8. Coordination of Benefits Information
At the moment ICD9-CM must be used along with CPT-4Privacy and Security
Need an individual’s written consent to use e-PHI for treatment, payment or health operations
Generally prohibit transmission of identifiable e-phi for purposes other than medical treatment, payment or healthcare operations without the patients written authorization
Allow patients to access medical records and request amendments or corrections for
91
incomplete medical information Allow patients to request restrictions be placed on the accessibility and use of PHI Require entities that request, use, or disclose protected health information to limit
themselves to the minimum amount of information necessary Security Standards are meant to be scalable – irrespective of size and scope of firm
92
Reading 11B: State Laws and RegulationsKey entities are the state Department of Health, State department of insurance and the NIAC – the former looks at healthcare delivery and quality issues while the latter looks at financial issues in regulation
State Regulation of HMOsBefore the HMO act of 1973, managed care laws were designed to regulate insurance companies or hospitals
NIAC – Health Maintenance Organization Model Act – HMO Model ActThis regulates HMO operations in two critical areas – financial responsibility and healthcare delivery. These are addressed through licensing requirements and financial standards. It addresses healthcare delivery by establishing requirements related to network adequacy, quality assurance and grievance procedures. This also looks at filing and reporting requirements to HMOs
Financial Responsibility Requirements Need to obtain a Certificate of Authority (COA) from the state Provides proof that the organization has met the licensing requirements and
demonstrated that it is dependable, fiscally sound and able to meet quality standards Have financial standards on – net worth, financial reporting, liquidity, accounting and
investment practices COA requires $1.5 Million of net worth. Insolvency occurs when an organizations assets are not enough to cover its
obligations MCO is insolvent if it can’t pay its current and future obligations In case the HMO is insolvent –the NAIC commissioner will intervene and
o Monitor a corrective plan developed by the HMOo Reduce the volume of new business they accepto Take steps to reduce their Expenseso Prohibit from writing new business for a specified period of time
In case these are inadequate – they will allow the commissioner to take over the management of the HMO
o Administrative supervision involves placing the HMO operations under the direction and control of the state commissioner of insurance or a person appointed by him
o Receivership – the state commissioner (with directive from the court) takes control of and administers the assets and liabilities of the HMO
o In case these don’t work – the organization is liquidated and all the business and assets are transferred to other carriers
Healthcare Delivery Requirements Three key aspects are focused on
o Network adequacyo Quality Assurance
Statement of HMO’s goals and objectives Documentation for all QA activities System of periodically reporting program results to HMOs stakeholders
o Grievance procedures Reporting Requirements
Satisfy a variety of filing and reporting requirements - e.g. submitting copies of proposed provider/ group contract forms, evidence of coverage forms and premium methodology as part of the COA process
All these programs are examined and reviewed every 3 yearsLaws Governing Preferred Provider Arrangements
93
PPA - This is a contract between a healthcare insurer and provider or group of providers who agree to provide services to persons covered under the contract
PPOs and EPOs are examples of health plans who are using this arrangement Laws vary according to the state in which the contracting plan operates and structure
of the plan For e.g. HMOs offering a POS product and PPOs both provide enhanced network
benefits – but are subjected to different regulatory requirementso HMO is linked to State HMO lawso PPO are regulated by state insurance lawso HMO by state HMO laws and EPOs by state insurance laws
Differences between these laws could include – premiums difference, covered services, benefit levels and nature of funding
To bring some uniformity, the NAIC proposed a Preferred Provider Arrangements Model Act – PPA Model Act. This requires PPAs to
o Clearly identify any differences in benefits levels for services of preferred providers and non preferred providers
o Establish the amount and manner of payments to preferred providerso Include the mechanism for minimizing of the cost of the healthcare plano Provide plan members with reasonable access to covered serviceso Also – need to give adequate benefits to coverage outside this networko Not many states have similar to this law – but have some legislation on PPOs
Laws Regulating other Types of MCOs Increasingly HMOs are being allowed to offer POS options It can be offered directly in some states while other states it can be offered with an
Indemnity Wraparound Policy – out of plan product offered through an agreement with an insurance company
This is a regulatory challenge – POS products have features of regular HMOs and indemnity insurance and can be subject to sate HMO laws OR state insurance laws
There are also certain functions regulated by lawsUtilization review Laws
Entities that perform utilization review are called Utilization Review Organizations (UROs) – They can be in house departments of the MCOs or they can be external entities. Utilization Review is generally subjected regulation if the recommendations affect an MCO decision to cover a specific service
URO’s laws vary but most states require them to be licensed and to obtain certification, the personnel of a URO must satisfy certain criteria related to education, training and experience
Need to meet accessibility standards of medical information NAIC approved a Utilization Review Model Act in 1996 – All UROs must
o Implement a written utilization review program – sources / review criteria / and appeals process and report annually on the program
o Use and make publicly available upon request , documented clinical review criteria
o Use qualified health professionals including clinical peers where appropriate , to administer the program
o Not tie reviewer compensation to the number of adverse determinationso Establish written procedures for adverse determinations and appealso Cover emergency services necessary to screen and stabilize a covered
person, without preauthorization, if “a prudent layperson” would believe an emergency exists. Health carriers would also be required to pay non contracting providers for such services if a prudent layperson believes that using a contracting provider would result in delays that would worsen the
94
emergency or if a federal state or local law requires the use of a specific provider
Third Party Administrator Laws Provide administrative services to MCOs, employers, or other plan sponsors Some of these services include underwriting and claims and so these TPA’s are
subject to state regulation The important act here is NAIC Third Party Administrator Model Act In order to act as a TPA
o Obtain a certificate of authority form the state insurance department designating the organization as a TPA
o Maintain as a business record for each client organization, a written agreement describing the duties the TPA will perform, the compensation it will receive, and the standards that pertain to the business the TPA is in
MCO is still responsible for the premium rates, benefits, underwriting criteria and claim payment procedures for ensuring that its plan is administered properly
The TPA serves as fiduciary TPA Model Act specifies the mandatory suspension or revocation of a TPA’s COA if
o The TPA in financially unsound o Using practices that are harmful to the insured persons or the publico Failed to pay any judgment rendered against it within 60 days of judgment
The State insurance department has discretionary authority to suspend or revoke a TPA’s COA if the TPA has
o Violated State Insurance Lawso Refused to be examined or to produce its records for examinationo Refused without just cause , to pay claims or perform Services under its
agreemento Been placed under suspension or revocation in another state
Health Plan Accountability LawsNAIC models includeHealth Care Professional Credentialing Verification Model Act
Specifies requirements MCOs must satisfy in order to ensure that the network providers meet minimum standards of professional qualification. These requirements include the following
o Verification of the credentials of all contracted healthcare professionals in accordance with written procedures that must be disclosed upon written request to any applying healthcare professional
o Providers should be given an option to review and correct any information submitted for verification
o Collection of a minimum set of credentialing information by either primary or secondary verification.
o Recredentialing must be done every 3 yearso Establishment of a process for providers to use to review and correct
credentialing information
Quality Assessment and Improvement By 1998 – 27 states introduced bills to create or expand quality standards for MCOs These laws have been patterned after the NAIC’s Quality Assessment and
Improvement Model Act which requires MCO’s to establish and report their systems for assessing the quality of care and services that they provide. They are required to
o Establish an appropriate system for assessing the quality of care that they provide for each type of network
o Report to licensing authorities any problems that would offer grounds
95
for termination of a providers licenseo File a written description of quality assessment programs with state
Commission for insuranceo Describe quality programs to consumers through marketing and
education materialso Meet specified data confidentiality requirementso Closed Plans
Those MCO plans which the member is required to use the participating providers under the terms of the Managed care plan
Closed plans need to develop treatment protocols, practice guidelines and other quality improvement strategies and to report annually the impact of these strategies
NIAC Network Adequacy and Accessibility Model ActAll managed care plans would be required to
Meet specified adequacy and accessibility standards Hold covered persons harmless against provider collections and provider
continued coverage for uncompleted treatment in the event of plan insolvency Develop standards to use in selection of providers Adhere to specified disclosure requirements – including 60 day written notice
to providers before terminating a contract – ‘without clause’ and 15 day notice to patients of provider contract termination
File written access plans and sample contract forms with the State Commissioner of Insurance
Not induce provider to deliver medically necessary care, prevent provider from discussing treatment options with patient or penalize providers for whistleblower activates against the plan
Need to implement this within 18 months of the effective date of the act
NAIC Health Carrier Grievance Procedure Model Act Written procedure for handling all subscriber grievances Internal 1st level grievance review 2nd level review in which the covered persons are allowed to review the relevant
information and make a representationPrivacy of Financial Healthcare Information Nov 13th 2000
GLB act calls for state regulators to enact laws to regulate insurance activities and govern the use of e-PHI.
The NAIC – has Privacy of Consumer Health and Financial Information Regulation Rules governing the use and disclosure of health information are included in Article
V of the regulationo When authorization is required for disclosure of non public PHIo Requirements for a valid authorizationo Conditions under which authorization requests and authorization forms must
be delivered to customers This regulation would apply to all licensees of state insurance department, including
MCOs MCOs and other licensees that comply with the GLB act are exempt from the
provisions of the Article V of the regulation The regulation does not supercede any existing regulation on privacy &
health Only Nevada has adopted this yet
Reading 11C: Government-Sponsored Programs Federal Programs have encouraged innovation Government is a very big Payer too!
96
Established Standards for Medicare Providers, federally qualified HMOs and health plans for federal employees
At the moment most beneficiaries receive care through FFS – but this is changing HFCA (part of DHHS) administers Medicare and Medicaid Medicare – Federal and Medicaid – Federal and State Partnership
MedicareFederal program established under Title XVII of the Social Security Act of 1965 to provide hospital expense and medical expense insurance to elderly and disabled personsBenefits are available to
Persons > 65 and eligible for social security or railroad retirement benefits Persons with qualifying disabilities (regardless of age) Persons with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) or their dependents
HCFA has delegated the claims processing and related tasks to third parties.These 3rd parties are called ‘intermediaries’ under Medicare Part A and ‘Carriers’ under Medicare Part B and are usually insurance companies
Program components
Medicare Part AThis provides basic hospital insurance that covers
1. Cost of in patient services2. Confinement in nursing facilities / extended care facilities3. Home care services4. Hospice Care
Anyone who satisfies Medicare eligibility is automatically enrolled here Funding – Primarily comes from a Payroll tax imposed on employers and workers +
from social security taxes No premium is paid for Part A Need to pay an Annual Deductible for Inpatient Care Coinsurance for inpatient and skilled nursing care These requirements are reviewed annually
Medicare Part B Covers
o Cost of physicians professional services – in hospitals / physicians offices / extended care facilities / nursing homes / insured homes
o Ambulance serviceso Medical Supplies and equipmento Hospital outpatient serviceso Diagnostic testso Other services necessary for diagnosis or treatment of illnesses
Voluntary Program – need to enroll for the service Most eligible people do enroll Funding comes Primarily from enrollee premiums and copayments Pays monthly premium deducted from Social security benefits Also annual deductible and coinsurance Pay 20% of all incurred costs – Medicare pays other 80% Additional funding – general tax revenues
o These pay 65% of the costs not covered by premiums + copaysMedicare+ Choice
The Balanced Budget Act 1997 created a 3rd component This addresses how the covered services are delivered to enrollees and
increases the number and type of organizations allowed to participate in Medicare Successor to the Medicare Risk program
97
Initially Medicare available only on FFS – Medicare+ Changes this to o Coordinated Care Plans – CCPs – HMOs (with/without POS) , PPOs and
Provider sponsored organizationso Private FFS – plans – Coverage provided by private insurerso Medicare Medical Savings Account Plans – High deductible catastrophic
insurance policy and a tax preferred medical savings account MSA Purchase a catastrophic healthcare policy with a high deductible and
out of pocket plan not more than $6000 annually HCFA deposits the difference between the specified Medicare payment
and policy premium into the beneficiary MSA Beneficiaries can use the MSA funds to pay the catastrophic policies
required deductible and out of pocket expenses After the beneficiary has paid deductible and out of pocket expenses
out of the MSA funds – the Medicare covered services are paid 100% No new enrollees to MSA plan – Is suspended as of Jan 1st 2003
All Medicare + plans should cover part and part b benefits These plans have federal exemption from state mandated benefits & provider
requirements
Medicare Supplements Deductibles and Coinsurance costs exist FFS Medicare does not pay for prescription drugs, glasses, hearing aids, routine
physical examinations and basic dental services To cover this ‘gap’ between the FFS Medicare and actual cost Not necessary for Medicare+ Choices - they are COMPREHENSIVE benefits packages Two choices Medigap Policies – individual medical expense policies sold by state licensed
private insurance companieso These are developed by the NAIC and are 10 standard policies A – J o Benefits vary by plan, but not by state or insurero Costs can varyo Coverage - Offer balanced policies that include the following
Coverage for Medicare A and Medicare B coinsurance Coverage for 365 hospital days after Medicare benefits end Coverage for the 1st three pints of blood used every year
o Plan A – Simplest and coverage increases in complexity with alphabeto Plan J – All benefits including prescription drugs and preventive care
COBRA – Access to Medicare SELECT – Medicare Supplement that can be used in a PPO to supplement Medicare B coverage but Does not apply to Medicare A benefits
Medicare and Managed Care Introduced cos of the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act TEFRA 1982 MCOs enter into contracts with Medicare to provide Part A and/or Part B coverage at
a cost basis or risk basis Cost contracts
o Monthly payments from government for covered services – these based on reasonable cost of delivering the services, but could be adjusted to reflect actual costs
o The MCO accepted NO risk and allowed beneficiaries to use any providero Enrollees were required to pay a large part of healthcare expense through
premiums and deductibleso Could Contract for Only Part B or for both part A and Part B
Only Part B – Healthcare Prepayment Plans (HCPPs) Risk Contracts
98
o Monthly payments from HCFA PMPMo Available to federally qualified HMOs and health plans and heath plans
classified as Competitive Medical Plans The above is a federal designation which exempts MCOs from
needing federal qualification as a HMO before entering Medicare
The Balanced Budget Act replaced all TEFRA RISK contracts in 1999 by Medicare+ Choice Contracts – all contracts were phased out by 2002
Medicare+ is the most popular choice now
Service Requirements established by the BBA Enrollment and Disenrollment procedures
o Option to enroll and disenroll from Medicare+ Choice CCPs each montho This was phased out from 1st July 2002 – to an annual periodo If you fail to make a choice – default is traditional FFS Medicare
Utilization of Serviceso Higher incidence – and chronic illnesseso 2-3 times the care of a normal commercial membero Need better UM / communications / IS and personnel
Benefits Packages – BBA mandates thato Access to 24 hr emergency serviceso Coverage for unforeseen non emergency services outside plan service areao Coverage for renal dialysis treatment outside service areao Extended coverage of preventive benefits – including annual prostate cancer
screenings to males > 50 and older mammograms / pelvic exams and pap smears – with Part B deductibles waived
o Out Patient self Management training services & equip for diabetic patientso Coverage for bone density exams for high risk peopleo Vaccine outreach program for seniors
Total Care Management Approach includeso Prevention and Early detection of disease – identify potential conditions/
promote effective chronic illness care/ delay disabilityo Coordinated Patient Care – CCPs place primary care at the center of the
delivery system and focus on managing patients care at all levelso Alternatives to inpatient hospitalization for acute and chronic needs –
use case management and disease management programs – home health / step down units / community based services
o Coverage for services not available under Part A and Part B
Quality Assessment and Improvement
Quality Review – Need to do this periodically as part of the Healthcare Quality Improvement Program. This is initiated by HCFA to improve quality of care
o Agree to a quality review and improvement organization called Peer Review Organization for each Medicare Plan they operate
o Peer Review Organization PRO is a organization or physican group that iis paid by the federal govt to review the serices of other practitioners and monitor the quality of care to Medicare patients
o This review could be waived if a plan has excellent quality record and complies with Medicare+ Choice requirements
o Plans are deemed to have met these requirements if they are accredited by an organization that meets HCFA standards
Performance Management
99
o Quality assessment programs – CCPs should report results to HCFA on HEDIS measures that apply to a Medicare Population
o Includes – Flu vaccinations, mammography screenings, diabetes retinal screenings, smoking cessation programs
o Also submit CAHPS data to HCFAo HCFA - Health of Seniors Survey to measure patients functional status o HCFA has developed a Health Plan Management System – a database of
information on Medicare Part A and Part B recipients who are enrolled in CCPso Went into effect in 1998
Quality Improvemento 1996 HCFA established the Quality Improvement System for Managed Care
(QISMC) to strengthen MCO’s efforts to protect and improve the satisfaction of Medicare and Medicaid enrollees
o Requires CCPs to follow series of quality standards and guidelines Operate a quality assessment and performance improvement program
that achieves demonstrable results Collect performance data using standard measures of health quality Comply with admin structures and operational requirements for quality
of careo HMOs PPOs PSOs are expected to satisfy thiso MSA and PFFS have to meet a subset of these standardso PPOs are required to meet only those standards which apply to PFFS and non
network MSAs Came into effect in 1999
Medicaid Title XIX of the Social Security Act of 1965 – Medicaid Joint State and Federal Program that provides hospital expense and medical expense
coverage to low income population and certain aged and disabled individuals The guidelines have been established through HCFA – and partial funding for the
states is provided and minimum eligibility standards and provider participation and reimbursement
Program Funding Federal Funding is based on Per capita income in each state Payments range from a minimum of 50% of total Medicaid costs to 83% of
total costs – with poorer states receiving a higher percentage of funding Individual states contribute additional funds and determine the reimbursements for
individual providers and health plans
Eligibility Requirements Grafted into the state Welfare Program and Eligibility was based on monthly income
and financial resources Individuals who received Medicaid benefits because of their welfare status and were
classified as Categorically Needy Individuals – These includeo Children and low income adults who qualify for Aid to Families with Dependent
Children (AFDC) benefitso Low income aged / blind / disabled individuals who qualified for supplemental
security income benefits
Medically needy Individuals are those people who meet the financial requirements of categorically needy individuals but whose monthly income exceeds specified maximums
100
States could provide coverage for people whose incomes are upto 100% of the federal poverty level or who spent excess income on medical care to reach the threshold
Dual Eligibles - Those elderly people who qualify for Medicare coverage also
New plan which partially replaces AFDA - called Temporary Assistance for Needy Families – TANF
BenefitsFairly comprehensive – Federally Mandated Benefits include –
Physican Hospital services Lab services Home healthcare visits Long term custodial care Others include
o Prenatal Careo Vaccines for childreno Family Planning services and supplieso Nursing Midwifeo Pediatric and family nurseso Rural Health Clinic Serviceso Federally qualified Health center (FQHC) serviceso Ambulatory services of a FQHC that would be available in other settings
States can increase benefits to cover dental /vision / prescription drugsMedicaid is the SECONDARY payer of benefits
Medicaid and Managed Care Pre BBA contract to three types of organizations
o MCOs and health insuring organizations , Prepaid Health Plans, and Primary Care Case manager programs
o HIO is an organization that contracts with state Medicaid agency as a fiscal intermediary – does not provide services directly
o Primary Care Case Manager – PCP who contracts with the state to provide case management services – receive a case management fee plus a reimbursement for medical services on FFS basis
Post BBA – Included Provider Sponsored organizations Most used plan type – Comprehensive MCO
Some states make managed care enrollment Mandatory through waivers provided under Section 1915(b) and Section 1115 (b) Waivers – “Freedom of Choice” waivers allowed states to manage Medicaid recipients access to providers by assigning recipients to a Primary care Case Manager. The Goals was to reduce emergency department use, increase preventive care and improve overall effectiveness by fostering a close physician patient relationship between PCP and Medicaid Patients.
Section 1115 waivers allow the state to offer more comprehensive services to specified categories of Medicaid recipients through demonstration projects
BBA – no need for mandatory enrollment of Medicaid recipients in managed care programs – No need to submit formal applications for section 1915(b) and section 1115 waivers
Existing waivers and demonstration projects that started as a result of Section 1115 Waivers are still an integral part of Medicaid managed care
In place of waivers – states that wish to mandate managed care enrollment must give Medicaid recipients a choice of enrollment options.
Enrollment in non rural areas given a choice of at least 2 managed care plans.
101
Enrollment in rural areas must be given a choice of at least 1 PCCM MCOs and PCCMs that contract with Medicaid to provide healthcare services to Medicaid recipients must satisfy BBA mandated contractual and quality requirements
Contractual Requirements BBA imposes contractual requirements on organizations Eligibility
o BBA grants states the authority to provide Medicaid coverage to individuals in expansion populations
o Expansion populations include individuals who do not meet categorically needy or medically need criteria – this could include
Children eligible for medical benefits under the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP)
Individuals who do not satisfy federally eligibility criteria and do not qualify for federal funding – can provide out of state funds
Elderly individuals eligible for long term care under Programs of All Inclusive Care for Elderly – (PACE)
Initially set up for Medicare beneficiaries but now its scope is extended to Medicaid eligible enrollees
Individuals are not required to be enrolled in Medicare to receive these benefits
Access to services o Adequacy of Network / hours of operation / location / referral to providers / no
discrimination against enrollees based on health statuso Need significant outreach to connect to PCP rather than emergency rooms for
primary careo PCCM / availability of extended Primary care hours, expanded out patient
hospital facilities , transportation arrangements to PCP operations, are some methods used to reduce over-utilization
o Other things include child care, early detection of diseases Benefits
o Unique features – Provision of early and periodic screening, diagnostic and treatment services for children under 21
Early and periodic screening, diagnostic and treatment (EPSDT) services cover vision hearing , dental services
Reimbursement for Providerso Accept Medicaid payment as payment in fullo Nominal out of pocket expenseso No copay for emergency services and pregnant women, children < 18,
hospitals or nursing home patients, or categorically needy HMO enrollees Marketing Practices
o Direct and individual – community service agencieso Independent third parties enroll plan memberso Need state approval for distributing marketing informationo No Door to door or telephonic solicitation
Quality Assessment and Improvemento QISMC from Medicare Applies here alsoo This is not mandatory for Medicaid MCOs – depends on state lawso Can accept accrediting by private agencies
Programs for All inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) Grants waivers of certain Medicare and Medicaid requirements to a limited number
of public and non profit community based organizations providing integrated care to the elderly.
102
o Comprehensive long term and acute care to individuals > 55 years and nursing certifiable based on the patients care and needs
o No limits on the amount ,duration, scope of service and requires no deductibles, coinsurance, copayment or other cost sharing features
o 24x7 Accesso BBA granted this permanent program status and an optional for Medicaid
State Children’s Health Insurance Program BBA established the state children’s health insurance program
o Designed to provide health assistance to uninsured, low income children either through separate programs or through expanded eligibility under state Medicaid programs
If the state has separate program o Benchmark Coverage
Equivalent to standard BCBS PPO under the federal employee health benefits program
A health benefit plan that is offered and generally available to state employees or
HMO plan with he largest commercial enrollment in the stateo Benchmark Equivalent Coverage
Aggregate actuarial value at least equivalent to one of the benchmark packages and must include basic services like in patient and out patient services, labs , xrays, well baby and well child care, including immunizations
o Existing Comprehensive State based Coverage Range of benefits funded and administered by the state
o Secretary approved coverage Any coverage tat the secretary of the DHHS approves
No favouring of richer kids No preexisting conditions exclusions States need to file a State Child Health plan with the Secretary of HSS – Funding is based on the total number of uninsured low income children in the state
and geographic cost factors SCHIP available to children who meet
o Under 19 years oldo Not currently eligible for Medicaid or other insuranceo Resides in a family with income below the 200% of the federal poverty level or
50% points above the states established eligibility limits
Federal Employee Health Benefits Program Voluntary health insurance program for federal employees, retirees, and their
dependents Administered by the Office of Personnel Management Choice of FFS or MCO to 10 million people 15 FFS health insurance plans and 350 MCOs participating in this Largest employer sponsored group healthcare plan in the US Need to meet federal and state licensing agreements Satisfy OPM requirements on access of care, benefit design and patient safety Some provisions
o Federal requirements on maternity under Newborns and Mothers health protection act
o Pregnancy is not a preexistingo Mental health parity acto Meet Womens health and Cancer Rights Act
103
o Develop patient safety initiatives
Tricare Military Health System – Worldwide healthcare system operated by the US DoD Integrates the service delivery of healthcare services for active duty personnel,
retirees and families of the same Active personnel get treated through – Military Treatment Facilities – Army, Navy,
AirForce, Coast Guard Operate – Exist in 11 TRICARE regions in US and 3 overseas TRICARE was called CHAMPUS
o Integrates the Military and Commercial networks Managed by TRICARE Management Activity (TMA) Coverage
o Most inpatient and outpatient services, physicians and hospital charges, medical supplies and equipment and mental health services
Three Planso TRICARE Standard – FFS – use authorized providers or non network providers
Deductible and Coinsurance Out of pocket under this are higher than other options
o TRICARE Extra – Reduced FFS plan similar to the network part of PPO Deductibles and coinsurance In network costs are lower than out of network Out of pockets lower than TRICARE standard No need to enroll to participate in TRICARE extra
o TRICARE Prime - enrollment based MCO to provide care using a Primary care Manager – similar to PCP –
No out of pocket for military doctors Services from civilian providers have copayments
o Active Duty personnel are automatically in TRICARE prime – while their dependents and eligible retirees are covered under TRICARE prime only if they enroll
o Retirees and family need to pay enrollment feesManaged Care Features
Preventive Care , self care and decision support programs Utilization Management
o Reviewo Discharge planningo Disease/condition management o Demand Management
Case Management – broad spectrum case management - needs of groups along the entire healthcare continuum
BCM includeso Population based case managemento Disease Management approacho Care Coordinationo Individual Case Management:
Appeals and Grievances Quality Initiatives Accreditation and Performance measures
Worker’s Compensation State mandated program that provides healthcare benefits for costs and lost wages
to qualified employees and dependents in case the employee is injured Every state has this and 47 states require that employers offer this Employers purchase workers compensation insurance
104
It is mandated that coverage be provided for all employees including part time workers
No deductibles and Coinsurance – Do not specify a life time maximum benefit for medical costs Can’t limit provider choice for work related ailments ONLY BENEFITS for work related injuries Employers are NOT allowed to deny liability if they are not at fault In exchange for this – need employees to comply with – Exclusive Remedy
Doctrine – they can’t sue employers for additional amounts Additional Benefits – Workers Compensation Indemnity Benefits – for loss of pay
Manage Workers Compensation 24 hour Coverage – Employers group health plan, disability plan and workers
compensation program are merged and integrated (or coordinated) depending on a states regulation into a single Health benefit plan that covers employees 24 hrs/day
Advantage : This helps in coordination of claims processing Disadvantage: Administrative cost of coordinating separate plans is often handled by
different departments – need to work with employers benefits department and risk management department
105
12. Ethical Issues in Managed Healthcare
Reading 12A: Introduction to Ethics in Managed Healthcare Define ethics and explain the difference between ethics and laws Describe some ways that MCOs can foster an ethical corporate cultureReading 12B: Ethical Issues in Managed Healthcare Explain the Patient Bill of Rights Discuss some of the ethical issues MCOs are currently confronting
106
Reading 12A: Introduction to Ethics in Managed Healthcare
Ethics are not the same as laws - Both Reflect the values of the Community but laws are enforceable while ethics are not
Hippocratic Oath – Patient above all else5 Key Principles1. Autonomy – The patients should be able to make decisions on their lives2. Non-Maleficence – MCO’s can’t harm their patients3. Beneficence – Promote the good of the members as a group4. Justice/Equity – Fairly distribute the benefits and burdens among members5. Promise Keeping/Truth telling – be truthful!
Further Virtue
Creating an Ethical Corporate Culture1. Better communication between entities2. Honor codes3. Educating members on the system4. Educating employee/providers and members about the issues5. Policies or procedures which provide guidance when confronted with ethical issues6. Culture where ethical considerations are integrated into decision making7. The contracted organization must have similar systems in place8. Make a formalized method for managing ethical conflit – ethics task force or bioethics
consultant
Reading 12B: Ethical Issues in Managed Healthcare
1. Patients Bill of rightsa. Information , choice , access , participation , respect and non discrimination,
confidentiality , complaints , responsibilities2. 5 issues to take care of
a. Resource Allocation – fair/equitableb. Financial Incentives to providersc. Clinician Patient Relationshipd. Confidentialitye. Employee trust
107
Key Concepts Tested in Sample Test Case Mixed Adjustment or Risk Adjustment – Statistical adjustment of the
outcome based on factors like patient’s age and seriousness of patient condition Adverse Event Cost Shifting Receivership – state commissioner takes control of assets and liabilities – primary
goal is to rehabilitate the organization COA – Need proof that MCO has met the state licensing requirements, specified
quality standards and also financial standards on net worth, capital, liquidity and accounting standards – initial net worth of 1.5 million Dollars
HMOs needs to be licensed in each state it does business in and MOST HMOs are subject to state enabling statutes and requirements of the state department
Pooling – Grouping a large no: of small groups- Experience rate and offering lower premiums to all small groups
JCAHO – evaluate central office and non JCAH) accredited networks, all high risk services provided and a sample of the practitioners offices and records
Hospitals receiving Medicare Funds must be JCAHO accredited JCAHO places organizations on a accreditation watch when a sentinel event occurs
and root cause analysis and corrective action have not been completed in time WHCRA – does NOT require plans to have mastectomy benefits but does
require medical and surgical benefits for mastectomy to provide coverage for reconstructive surgery following mastectomy
HCQIA – exempts hospitals, group practices and HMOs from certain antitrust provisions as they apply to credentialing and peer review so long as these entities adhere to due process standards that are outlined in the HCQIA
NMHPA – 48 hrs min for child birth and 96 hours min for cesarean – Does not require group plans to have maternity benefits but regulates those which do
Therapeutic – different chemical entity and same class – needs physician approval Generic – same chemical composition - no physician approval GLB – Disclose privacy policies / notify customers if info is shared / opt out provision GLB – Financial information – NAIC amendment Health Information also HIPAA – preexisting condition cannot be excluded from coverage 12 months after
enrollment – 18 months for late enrollees The CREDITABLE coverage reduces this preexisting condition limit and can make it
zero – if he has stayed for a year HMO Act - Network adequacy / Quality Assurance / Grievance Procedures Process – Methods and Procedures that an MCO uses to Furnish Care Structure - Measures of healthcare performance that relates to the nature, quality
and quantity of resources that an MCO has Outcome - Extent to which the MCO succeeds in improving or maintaining
satisfaction and patient health Non Duplication of Benefits Provision TPA – Get COA from the state insurance department and not federal Federal Qualified HMOs cannot use Retrospective Rating 1995 – NAIC Small Group Act Amendment Eliminated class rating rules and required
plans to use ACR for small groups Pure & Std Community rating are the same thing – ONLY GEOGRAPHIC DATA Messenger Model IPA Medicaid PCCM Programs are exempt from HCFA’s Quality Improvement System
for Managed Care Standards Indemnity Wraparound Option – Out of plan product that a health plan offers
through an agreement with an insurance company – In some states HMOs can offer POS ONLY as an indemnity wraparound option
108
Top Related