Download - Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Transcript
Page 1: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Acoustic tagging studies – beyond presence/absence

Kevin Kumagai, Sam Johnston, and Colleen SullivanHydroacoustic Technology, Inc.

47th Annual Conference of the California-Nevada Chapter AFSApril 4th - April 6th, 2013

Davis Veterans Memorial Center

Page 2: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Overview

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations. For example, presence/absence.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Example behaviors include:• Moving towards and away• Holding• Defecation• Downstream migration• Fish passage• Searching• Predator avoidance

Page 3: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Acoustic tags = information

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations. For example, presence/absence.

Page 4: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single hydrophone deployments

• Can provide presence/absence

Hydrophone 1

Upstream

Barrier

Downstream

Hydrophone 12

Page 5: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Detection histories

• Are chronology of time-stamped tag detections

Page 6: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Fish survival and fish passage

• Can measured from the these detection histories

Page 7: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Uniform spacing, high precision: fish behavior

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

Tag ID encoded in unique period

(adapted from Ehrenberg and Steig, 2009)

Page 8: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Acoustically tagged fish movement animation

Page 9: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 1

Page 10: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 2

Page 11: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 3

Page 12: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 4

Page 13: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 5

Page 14: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 6

Page 15: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Display 7

Page 16: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single hydrophone example behaviors

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Behaviors in this example include:• Moving toward and away• Holding• Defecation

Page 17: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single upstream hydrophone example moving toward and away

Page 18: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single downstream hydrophone example moving toward and away

Page 19: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Moving toward and away

Page 20: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single hydrophone example behaviors

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Behaviors in this example include:• Moving toward and away• Holding• Defecation

Page 21: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Single hydrophone example holding behavior

Time duration 1 hour

Page 22: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Defecation

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Behaviors in this example include:• Moving toward and away• Holding• Defecation

Page 23: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Defecation

Time duration 1 hour

Page 24: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Hydrophone

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

Basic Tracking

Flow

Page 25: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Green Hydrophone

Page 26: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Maroon Hydrophone

Page 27: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Orange Hydrophone

Page 28: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Turquoise Hydrophone

Page 29: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Yellow Hydrophone

Page 30: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Nearest Blue Hydrophone

Page 31: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Hydrophone Detections: Summary

Page 32: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

2D tracks example behaviors

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Behaviors in this example include:• Holding• Downstream migration• Searching• Fish passage• Predator avoidance

Page 33: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Multiple hydrophone deployment

Downstream

Upstream

Barrier

Time Slider

Steelhead 2D positions(green)

Striped bass 2D positions(red)

Sun and moon gadget

Page 34: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Holding, 23:03-23:04

Tagged striped bass (red spheres) holding between blue and yellow hydrophones. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 35: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Holding, 23:04-23:05

Tagged striped bass continues holding. Steelhead tag (light green spheres) approaching array below pink and green hydrophones. Data

courtesy of CDWR.

Page 36: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Downstream migration, 23:05-23:06

Steelhead tag continues moving downstream through upstream array. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 37: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Downstream migration, 23:06-23:07

Steelhead tag approaching barrier while striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 38: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Searching, 23:07-23:08

Steelhead tag begins searching along barrier. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 39: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Searching, 23:08-23:09

Steelhead tag continues searching along barrier. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 40: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Searching, 23:09-23:10

Steelhead tag continues searching along barrier. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 41: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Searching, 23:10-23:11

Steelhead tag continues searching along barrier. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 42: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Fish passage, 23:11-23:12

Steelhead tag passes barrier via culvert. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 43: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Fish passage, 23:12-23:13

Steelhead tag continues past barrier. Striped bass continues to hold. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 44: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Fish passage, 23:13-23:14

Steelhead tag continues past barrier. Striped bass begins to move. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 45: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:14-23:15

As steelhead tag passes over striped bass, steelhead tag appears to avoid bass moving counter-clockiwse. Striped bass also moves

downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 46: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:15-23:16

Steelhead tag continues circling counter-clockwise as striped bass moves slightly downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 47: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:16-23:17

Steelhead tag continues circling counter-clockwise as striped bass moves slightly downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 48: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:17-23:18

Steelhead tag continues circling counter-clockwise as striped bass moves slightly downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 49: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:18-23:19

Steelhead tag continues circling counter-clockwise as striped bass moves slightly downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 50: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:19-23:20

Steelhead tag appears to avoid striped bass again as passes by. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 51: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:20-23:21

Both tags moving downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 52: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Predator avoidance, 23:21-23:22

Steelhead tag leaves downstream. Striped bass holding further downstream. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 53: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Summary 2D tracks

Page 54: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

2010 Animation

Eonfusion screen capture showing concurrent tag tracks, hydrophone positions, tidal, velocity, flow, flap gate operation, sun and moon phase within a geo-referenced image of the ORT area. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 55: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

2011 Animation

Eonfusion screen capture showing concurrent tag tracks, hydrophone positions, river stage height, sun and moon phase within a geo-

referenced image of the ORT area. Data courtesy of CDWR.

Page 56: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Summary

• Acoustic tags can provide information about fish populations. For example, presence/absence.

• If detections are uniformly spaced to a high level of precision, these detections can assess fish behavior.

• Example behaviors include:• Moving towards and away• Holding• Defecation• Downstream migration• Fish passage• Searching• Predator avoidance

Page 57: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

References

• Ehrenberg, J. E., and Steig, T. W. 2009. A study of the relationship between tag-signal characteristics and achievable performances in acoustic fish-tag studies. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 66: 1278–1283.

• Kumagai, K.K., S.V. Johnston, C. Sullivan, and P.A. Nealson. 2010. Two-dimensional fish tracking study in the Old River at Tracy barrier in 2010. Report to California Department of Water Resources, Sacramento, Calif., by Hydroacoustic Technology, Inc., Seattle, Wash.

• Tunnicliffe, C., K.K. Kumagai, and S.V. Johnston. 2011. Two-dimensional fish tracking study in the Old River at Tracy barrier in 2011. Report to California Department of Water Resources, Sacramento, Calif., by Hydroacoustic Technology, Inc., Seattle, Wash.

Page 58: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Acknowledgments

• California Department of Water Resources (CDWR)

Page 59: Acoustic Tagging Studies – Beyond Presence/Absence

Questions?

Kevin Kumagai, Sam Johnston, and Colleen SullivanHydroacoustic Technology, Inc.

For more information: www.htisonar.com