8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
1/29
Center for Thin Film DevicesCenter for Thin Film DevicesMaterial Research InstituteMaterial Research Institute
DOE Photovoltaics SubprogramPeer Review August 13-15, 2003
SiSi:H Materials and Solar Cells:H Materials and Solar Cells
Research at Penn StateResearch at Penn State
C. R. Wronski and R.W. Collins
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
2/29
Progress in Research on Si:HProgress in Research on Si:HMaterials and Solar CellsMaterials and Solar Cells
DevelopedReal-Time Spectroscopic Ellipsometry forin-situcharacterization of growth and evolution of microstructurein both films and solar cells. (Now being applied by others)
Developed new approaches for characterizing carrierrecombination and the multiple defect states in a-Si:H filmsand solar cells. (Past focus on just one defect state D0)
Developed deposition phase diagrams identifying themicrostructural transitions during growth from amorphousto mixed phase to a single microcrystalline phase. (Powerful
guide in material optimization)
A comprehensive understanding is being developed of Si:Hmaterial growth, microstructure, properties; mechanismslimiting p-i-n, n-i-p solar cell performance and stability.
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
3/29
Identified protocrystalline a-Si:H from its growth andmicrostructural evolution with thickness and substrate dependence.(Novel concept of a-Si:H deposited with hydrogen dilutionrepresenting the growth of such materials with outstanding properties)
Applied concept ofprotocrystallinity in optimizing intrinsic anddoped materials as well as solar cell structures. (Systematic approach)
Identified, separated and quantified carrier recombination in both p/iregions and bulk intrinsic layers of solar cells. (Not carried out in past)
Characterized carrier recombination in amorphous and mixed phase(a+c) materials with their effect on solar cell characteristics.(Importance not recognized in past)
Obtained the elusive direct correlations between light inducedchanges in a-Si:H films and corresponding solar cells.(Not establishedin past)
Addressed issues regarding nature, origins of different light induced
defects in a-Si:H and their dependence on microstructure. (Despiteextensive studies in past generally ignored)
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
4/29
Real Time Optics of Silicon Film PECVDReal Time Optics of Silicon Film PECVD
Developed at PSUrecently being appliedin other laboratories
Allows in situ
characterization ofgrowth (surfaceroughness)
microstructure, opticalproperties 1.5 to 4.5eV Acquisition time
~50ms allowsmonolayer growth to
be characterized
Suitable for analysis of inhomogeneous films with
micro/macro/geometric scale structure
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
5/29
Evolution of Surface Roughness duringEvolution of Surface Roughness during SiSi:H Film:H Film
Film Growth at Various R on R=0 SubstrateFilm Growth at Various R on R=0 Substrate
Dilution ratio in PECVD R=[H2]/[SiH4]H2 dilution extensively used in fabricationof Si:H materials and solar cells
Two microstructural/phasetransitions vs. thickness:
Roughening Transitiona(a+c)mixed phase
db = 3000 for R=15
db = 700 for R=20db = 200 for R=40
Smoothening Transition(a+c)mixed phase c :db > 7000 for R=15db = 3500 for R=20
db = 650 for R=40
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
6/29
Characterization of Recombination in Solar Cells FromCharacterization of Recombination in Solar Cells FromDark CurrentDark Current--Voltage CharacteristicsVoltage Characteristics
Voltage (V)
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2
C
urrentDensity(A/cm
2)
1e-10
1e-91e-8
1e-7
1e-6
1e-5
1e-4
1e-3
1e-2
1e-1
1.65eV
1.72eV1.86eV
Clear separation of p/iinterface recombination fromthat in the bulk of a-Si:H solar
cells has not allowed JD-V tobe used in characterizing gapstates.
Bulk recombination has beenidentified and quantified bysystematic reduction of p/i
contributions in cell structures Cell structures are studied in
which the two components ofcarrier recombination areclearly separated.
p(a-SiC:H)-i-n4000 R=10i-layers
Cody Gapof 200 p/iinterface layer
Information about the gapstates in the intrinsic layers can
be obtained directly from thebulk recombination.
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
7/29
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
8/29
Extended Phase Diagram:Extended Phase Diagram:SiSi:H Growth on:H Growth oncc--Si/oxide SubstratesSi/oxide Substrates
(1) a asurface roughening transition
(2) a (a+c)surface roughening transition
(3) (a+c) csurface smoothening transition
These transitions provide insights intomaterials and device optimization
Narrow window for protocrystalline
Si:H growth in a thick layer is
centered at R=10;
here the film surface is stablethroughout deposition.
Obtained from the three
transitions detected
during Si:H film growth:
Microstructure and its evolution isstrongly dependent on substrate
TEM f Si H d i d i h R 20 Si O/SiO
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
9/29
TEM ofTEM ofSiSi:H deposited with R=20 on c:H deposited with R=20 on c--SiSi/SiO/SiO22
TEM fTEM f SiSi H d i d i h R 10 C (H d it d ith R 10 C ( ))
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
10/29
TEM ofTEM ofSiSi:H deposited with R=10 on Cr (:H deposited with R=10 on Cr (evapevap))
S i f f Si fi
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
11/29
Schematic of the structure of Si:H filmsSchematic of the structure of Si:H filmson aon a--Si:H (R=0)Si:H (R=0)
R
Despite evolutionary nature, protocrystalline a-Si:Hhas uniform properties over extended regions ofthickness
Great attention must be given to the transition a(a+c) and its thicknessdependence on R- films and cells
Phase diagrams are a powerful guide in optimizing deposition conditions forfast growth
T T iti Ph Di Eff t f f Pl P
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
12/29
Two-Transition Phase Diagram:Effect of rf Plasma Power
Phase diagrams depend on
deposition conditions otherthan R.
Identify effect of depositionparameters on a a anda (a+c) transitions;regimes of protocrystalline
Si:H growth. Large shifts in transitions
when the plasma power is
increased.
Phase diagrams are a powerful guide inoptimizing deposition conditions for fast growth.
O ti i ti P i i l f TO ti i ti P i i l f T St iSt i LL
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
13/29
Optimization Principle for TwoOptimization Principle for Two--Step iStep i--LayerLayerof aof a--SiSi:H p:H p--ii--n Solar Celln Solar Cell
Optimization principle Prepare interface and bulk
i-layers with the maximumR=[H2]/[SiH4] values possible
without crossing the a(a+c)transition for the desiredthickness concept ofprotocrystallinity is useful
Difficulties If the a(a+c) transition is
crossed accidentally in this
process, one must decrease Rbelow 10 (below protocrystallineregime) to suppress continuedgrowth of the microcrystallites
real time monitoring andcontrol are needed
Two step optimization of R=10 bulk i-layerswith R=40 p/i 200 layerImprovement:
Voc 0.86 to 0.92VAnnealed FF same 0.72DSS FF 0.60 to 0.66
P f f (P f f ( SiCSiC H)H) ii S l C llS l C ll
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
14/29
Performance of p(aPerformance of p(a--SiCSiC:H):H)--ii--n Solar Cellsn Solar Cellswith Onewith One--Step and TwoStep and Two--Step iStep i--LayersLayers
Summary of a detailedstudy based on phasediagrams on theoptimization of cellperformanceImprovement:
Voc 0.86 to 0.92Annealed FF same 0.72DSS FF 0.60 to 0.66
Note: Optimumperformance withR=40 adjacent to p-a-
SiC:H limited to 200thickness.
Nature of (a+Nature of (a+ c) phase and its effectc) phase and its effect
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
15/29
Nature of (a+Nature of (a+c) phase and its effectc) phase and its effecton solar cell performanceon solar cell performance
From RTSE and AFM for R=40 on R=0film onset ofc nucleation occurs atthickness of 200, with completecoalescence ofc nuclei within d=400.
Increase in recombination due to reductionin the mobility gaps in R=40 layer to1.62eV at 300 and 1.22eV at 400.
Presence of such an a(a+c) transitiongreatly increases carrier recombinationand has profound effect on cellcharacteristics.
Voltage (V)0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
CurrentDensity(mA/cm
2)
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
R=40 p/i interface
layer thickness
200300400
Increase in d
4000 p(a-SiC:H)-i-nR=10 i-layer
Such phase transitions are evenmore critical in n-i-p structures
where the (a+c) phase is in directcontact with the p-layer.
P t t lli it C t li d tProtocrystallinity Concept applied to
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
16/29
Protocrystallinity Concept applied toProtocrystallinity Concept applied topp--Si:HSi:HContacts in nContacts in n--ii--p Cellsp Cells
Phase diagrams of p-Si:H layers onR=10 a-Si:H were used inoptimizing VOC in n-i-p cells.
The maximum VOC occurs with
R=150 and corresponds to aprotocrystalline layerterminated at200 or close to the (a+c) phase.
The lowest VOC is obtained with
R=200 where the layer has evolvedinto apurely c-Si:H phase because i/p recombination increasessignificantly.
The erroneous conclusions thathighest VOCs are obtained withc p-Si:H held for a long timeis due to characterizing
microstructure on layers>>200.
Limitations on 1 Sun VLimitations on 1 Sun V imposed byimposed by
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
17/29
Limitations on 1 Sun VLimitations on 1 Sun VOCOC imposed byimposed byp/i Interface Recombinationp/i Interface Recombination
Systematic increases in 1 sun Vocfound with decrease in p/i interfacerecombination for protocrystalline
Si:H and a-SiC:H p-contacts. Very large increase in such
recombination in n-i-p cells with p-
Si:H occur when (a+c) phase at ornear i-layer (R=200).
The p/i recombination for the R=150p-Si:H is significantly lower than
the lowest achieved with a-SiC:Htwo step processes
Voltage (V)
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1
CurrentD
ensity(A/cm
2)
1e-7
1e-6
1e-5
1e-4
1e-3
1e-2
1e-1
R=100R=150R=200
4000A n-i-p cellR=10 Bulk i-layer
This explains why the highest valuesof VOC are with p-a-Si:H cells
Defect states in the intrinsic layers of aDefect states in the intrinsic layers of a SiSi:H:H
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
18/29
Voltage (V)
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
CurrentDensity(A
/cm
2)
10-10
10-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
10-3
10-2
0.4 m0.8 m1.5 m
i-layer thickness
Thickness (m)
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6
Voc
(V)
0.85
0.86
0.87
0.88
0.89
p-i-n cell
Non-uniform distributionsof defect states across solarcells predicted by theDefect Pool Model haveoften been reported.
No evidence is found fromJD-V characteristics whose
bulk contributions areclearly identified.
Dependence on i-layerthickness, equivalence ofp-i-n and n-i-p structures.
Recombination consistentwith spatially uniform
defect states and those incorresponding films.
The ability to characterize bulk recombination
enables its limitations on different solar cellparameters to be quantified (e.g. VOC).
Defect states in the intrinsic layers of aDefect states in the intrinsic layers of a--SiSi:H:Hsolar cells with low p/i interface recombinationsolar cells with low p/i interface recombination
Light induced defects in the intrinsic layers of aLight induced defects in the intrinsic layers of a--SiSi:H cells:H cells
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
19/29
Light induced defects in the intrinsic layers of aLight induced defects in the intrinsic layers of a SiSi:H cells:H cells
Voltage (V)
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
CurrentDensity(A/cm
2)
10-11
10-10
10-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
10-3
10-2
Annealed State1 Sun 30 mins
1 Sun 9 hrs1 Sun 100 hrs (DSS)
p-i-n cell with 4000 R=10 i-layer
The kinetics of the light
induced changes in JD-Vcharacteristics are similar tothose in FF of cells and the products in correspondingfilms.
JD-V characteristics
offer an new probefor investigating thenature and densities
of defect states inintrinsic layers ofsolar cells.
Increase inrecombination withintroduction of light
induced defects
Kinetics of light induced changes in FFKinetics of light induced changes in FF
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
20/29
Kinetics of light induced changes in FFKinetics of light induced changes in FF
Extensively used in
characterizing lightinduced defects insolar cells.
Find kinetics in cellshaving i-layers withdifferent
microstructureclearly point tocreation ofmultiple
defects.1 Sun Illumination Time Hours0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000
FillFactor
0.52
0.54
0.560.58
0.60
0.62
0.64
0.66
0.68
0.700.72 R=0 25oC
R=10 25oC(Protocrystalline)
ND0 = 8-10x1016cm-3
4000p(a-SiC:H)-i-n
Multiple defects confirmed with the lack of correlation inthe FF degradation with ND0 (as measured with ESR),|(E)|, and presence of fast and slow states.
Direct correlation of recombination inDirect correlation of recombination in
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
21/29
Direct correlation of recombination inDirect correlation of recombination infilms and cellsfilms and cells
1/ cm-2V
0 4x106 8x106 12x106 16x106 20x10
FillFactor
0.52
0.54
0.56
0.580.60
0.62
0.64
0.66
0.68
0.70
0.72
R=0 25oC
R=0 75oC
R=10 25oC
R=10 75oC
Time
1/ cm-2V
1.0x106 2.0x106 3.0x106 4.0x106 5.0x106
FillF
actor
0.56
0.58
0.60
0.62
0.64
0.66
0.68
0.70
0.72
0.74
d=2000d=4000d=7000
Time
R=10 i-layer
4000 p-i-n
The elusive correlations betweenlight induced changes in thin filmsand those in solar cells have been
established. Because the nature and densities of
the different defect states in films and
cell i-layers are not yet known it is notpossible to directly correlate them.
Can howeverrelate them through theirrole as carrier recombination centers,
Nr, where 1/Nr, (1-FF) Nr
Linear relationships are obtainedbetween 1/ and FF for cells havingdifferent thickness, different i-layersand at different temperatures.
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
22/29
Distinctly different light induced defectDistinctly different light induced defect
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
23/29
Distinctly different light induced defectDistinctly different light induced defectstates at and below midgap in astates at and below midgap in a--Si:HSi:H
Ener eV
0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4
NDS
(E)/N
AS(E
)
0
510
15
20
25
30
35CBA
Evolution of kN(E) fromd[(h)]/dE in degraded state(DS) normalized to annealed state
(AS) Distinctly different states created
around 1.0 and 1.2eV from EC
Improved microstructure(C R=0 20/s to B R=0 1.5/s toA R=10 )
Systematic suppression of1.2eV defects
Evolutions of defects and their temperature
dependence self-consistent with changes in FF and Only in protocrystalline a-Si:H is the defect state at1.0eV dominant
Evolutions of defects selfEvolutions of defects self--consistent with changes in FF andconsistent with changes in FF and
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
24/29
gg
(a) R=10
Ener eV
0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
[d
(E)/dE]/[dAS
(E)/dE
]
0
5
10
15
20
25
25oC
75oC
Ener eV
0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
[d(E)/dE]/[dAS
(E)/dE]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
75oC
25oC
30 Hours of 1 Sun Illumination
ETL 20/s
1 sun degraded steady state
Degraded States after 1 sunillumination at 25, 75oC kN(E) SpectraNormalized to AS
In R=10, suppression of defects at
75oC, particularly at 1.2eV, consistentwith corresponding higher FF,
No change in spectrum ofR=0 20/sconsistent with virtually the same degradation kinetics at bothtemperatures.
Presence of multiple defect statesand their dependence onmicrostructure must be taken intoaccount in characterizing stability
of solar cell materials and SWE.
ConclusionsConclusions
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
25/29
ConclusionsConclusions
RTSE is a unique and powerfultechnique for development ofphase diagrams.
Deposition phase diagrams extremely usefulin optimizationof Si:H materials for solar cells.
Concept ofprotocrystallinity shown to be useful in:Improvementof n, i, and p Si:H layersSystematic improvement of cell structures
Controllingdeleterious effects of a (a+c) transition onsolar cell characteristics
Overcoming erroneous conclusions drawn from
characterizing films thicker than the layers used in solarcells.
ConclusionsConclusions
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
26/29
Co c us o sCo c us o s
New approach for characterizing (h) spectrahas:
Offered a more reliable method for evaluatingmaterials for solar cells.
Identified evolution ofdistinctly differentlight
induced defects. Points to a reason for the discrepancies between
stabilities claimed forfilms and those found in
correspondingsolar cells.
ConclusionsConclusions
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
27/29
Identifying p/i recombination in solar cells key tocharacterizing i-layers and their contributions to cellcharacteristics.
JD-V characteristics used as a new probe for characterizingrecombination and defect states in intrinsic layers of solar cells. Presence ofspatially uniform densities of defects in the i-layers
in conflict with Defect Pool Model but allows correlations withcorresponding films.
Elusive direct correlations between recombination in thinfilms and their solar cells established.
Same creation and annealing kinetics of fast and slowstates established for FF and .
For thefirst time distinctly different light induced defect states
centered around 1.0 and 1.2 eV have been clearly identified.
ConclusionsConclusions
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
28/29
The results on the two distinctly different light induced defectstates in a-Si:H are significant in that: They are consistentwith the discrepancies between changes in
dangling bond densities, ND0, and those in FF, . Their evolution is consistentwith that of fast and slow states.
They are consistentwith changes in stability of a-Si:H with
different microstructure. They show improved stability ofprotocrystalline a-Si:H is
accompanied bysuppression of the 1.2 eV defect state.
Theypoint outthe serious limitations of the commonly usedmethodologies of assessing the stability of solar cell materials.
The established presence and distinctly different evolutions of thetwo light induced states are not consistentwith a variety of
explanations proposed for the origin of the Staebler-Wronski effect.
Results?Results?
8/8/2019 A-Si Materials and Solar Cells Research at Penn State
29/29
Results?Results?
12 Peer Reviewed Publications12 Peer Reviewed PublicationsScores of Conference Papers,Scores of Conference Papers,
Posters, and PresentationsPosters, and Presentations
... and 10... and 10 InvitedInvited Talks atTalks at
International ConferencesInternational Conferencesand Workshopsand Workshops
Top Related