Download - 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

Transcript
Page 1: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

5t ii " �� .::.. � � .::.. Jtrj

�1�liL+-1f-+'::"}j

JI 151 � JI 168

Journal of Traffic Science

Central Police University

Vol. 2 No. 2

Dec. 2002, pp. 151-168

A Study on Ameliorating Strategies for the Enforcement of

Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance

Chih-Chiang SUI

Chung-Jen Chao'

Benny Chen'

••••••Ma��.��aka&4.MA.**.�*(�TM.

*.�W••��.M•••�-,�••*a**.�.M�•••��

.M.'�0.�M••••••Mm��a*�*.��.*�.����

.��.�.�*����#'����m�a*�.����M���.'

��.����.MM�&4�*���.�*����#••••••M�

���M�.'RM4.*••a*��.����.M&4M*'�•••

M.i.*.M��*4t.

M_�:���****�'��.�

l�*••*"5tii"��&�5tii�.i.*'�*(ii�ft�:�OO�_w�*�#�A

� 56 � ; 't"ii< ; 03-3281991 ; E-mail: [email protected]).

2 � i iI;l,\' *".i. *.I.{l"� �F!i'jf*Jjl.� �1.(ii�1HJ1: : 106 iI:lt 'if **ljU'lUif#'� 4

$lt 1 � ; 't"ii< : 02-23625920 #- 112 ; E-mail: d90521 [email protected]) •

, f'\JjI!r.�.jIt"'1** •• �7dMl�-'f¥I'jt#Jli'l(ii�ft;J1:: III iI:lt'if**g �*#t

36 � ; 't"ii< : 02-28820449 ; E-mail: Is671lll@ sun4.cpu.edu.lw).

151

Page 2: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

M�#.�«.'t*���.�•••••A•••••M.#A*M�

A�R*�����'��'*�A���������'��M����

iid�*4'tAi!����J!-kpT :

•••M4*.�.���!������.&.A••••�••t

*(A*•••*��*'�+�.'-.'-.)E.��*.��'�k•

••M.#�_�.�.��A••�••tt,�.»��*��•. �

M����t:*4'tAij,iA1.iJtaJl-kpT :

- , ���"f�iH"*.

**.�*T.�M.+�••�:r*.��.��••*•••

�'#•••••M��•••��•••M���.&.*'A*.

�A�M�A�.E••����;*••�*' ••�A� ••••

��.M•• 'J��*.4'tA*•••*.�*'�.'�••�:

'i�.MJ!.�.1*��.M(MI5t,*)1f#��.' k.�."f�A{Jt1lJf•

• Ma1*MI5t�. M 1f#(;t�k{�A 1f#,*{)})J!.{jiji!-iI,f,*4't(#.-tnlll

••�A1f#{*1li!-'A."Ji'- ••�) .

� , �*�l:iI.iU

•••M#���.&.�•••t*'*.���A*M�A�

••A*.*���'*�••*��k��***.�ft.*.�.

'M8����1f##r*��R••�.�••#.�.J.��.

�a�����4�#���••�•••���'�.Ma,*�.�

••���••�a�.,�••••�•• r�R.�A*.*��

.{4-ii�. J ii:!ipj\*l'if1fA •

1 ••••••M4*��.�������.*.�*I�+K••

-••�*��*.�a�.*'����••••••MM���r�•

•�.����JAr���a�JZ�R.����,*�A���.M

153

Page 3: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-=-)11.�*tf 1:�*4t

������.*�R*��*.*�*�*4t*���.#

��*��+A*��:'��������������¥���

�������*'#�**����*���'4T.*'J

(.=.):jl( � tf1:�*4t

��:jl(�tft:*AA*��*��+�*��:' ••��A**

**����*��'4*��_�.�.*�����'�.�

1i<.T 7� .&.$UJl� :

.�������4��������.*�'ro��iT��.

�*��+��L.=.���T��'���••�AA'��*�

�.fJt 1,JU!*� ,

.*��••�.�'ro��iT��.�*�-�-=-+��L;,

���T���'���••�AA'��*�����*�'J

���A.��Afi ••��•• 'M*••R��A••#�

�.*�-:jl(ft•••���'�.I��'

155

Page 4: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(�.n�••.�.: .•��.n.�••ff.*'*••�*��

*�••*,���•• t••n•••n���••�.��MI

������'����*�.���'*T���o

(-=-)"tf1f-amJ�1t.�.iii:.. : 1; .�á1tlfl �1f-a��{;lt•.��$.-11!!.�

.*'t••n•••n���••••W#.*••�MI���

���'����*�.���'�T���o

��M����_M�ff**�*��M�.�.����.'�.

w.�HH-�. ' ��"*pIl2 �-if< 0

fJ"! JoiJl:;jlUUtA "''''1i ... IRi:tI:{;f<Httl:

• '" "'.t1ttt"1f-1};i}Jt-jIH'"

Jt-ll!

A'" .'1j,tJ.l. M1��"

'" '" '1 i' .p.t1t••1}�"l#- {;f. <jo ,.:..'

(.f<.4t1of,,j'-)

Jt-IHJl(1Nl.,,4£-;iJ)

• '"

<tll1J"j� -.,..

<t

lI1JII

..

"fl...

.. .q

• fl '""-

fl

•"-

-=-' .��*,/>.��.�.:;tj(,

ia��.M��.'�.w..��.�.#.�'���8MI

�$J�mt1})-�I'l��(YATAAf4Il1JI����)I'JfJtIl� r *�#1*t'�J �

157

Page 5: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI
Page 6: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

�'�rr��'.�N������OC��

*.t••n••����M�.#��,a90.1�I6��,

,�£liJ.f.#'t JIII�� ��,*t *- ' ;f;.{t1i'< .•lUAtJlJJ '*AHrdt J ��1'1'� it 159,134

1+ ' ,1ij#£:$!1f!.*ft'jlj�it*it 142,0201+ ' jIJ�4"i! 89,25%' A9t1i.1�

��o�ffi�rr�JIII��t'*�.#���JIIIW�����I��'

liJ.f.#'tJIII�M ••••����rr•• '_#�ä�.��'��.�

T-1� , #£ �f;t!£ T 91 r.,"! :

(-)'i##£�l!�*���Aif"t* ' 'fftliJ.f.1f!.{;I. � -,� 11 0 1t�Åj:j �

tUI-( 1f !£ i>-� , Ii Jl'.Å j:j � ;'!-� .iE� if 9HIJ �� (sUHA1t) 0

(�)1i'<�'i#jJU�1i'<��it, JIII W��' ••����liJ.f.#'tJIII"*1f!.{;I.:f,

Mf�i!••• ,.�.#.���aä�.iE�äo

.=. ' r,'��J.f.N��

(- )*ft'�� �r.,,,!

l,�*.�.**�*t'.*;f;..*���ff�'�;f;.�#�.'

�ft*fl�Å�••�,�a*.�••;f;..*��',1ij;f;..�

••**��k�ifa'ft�liJ.f.#'tJIII���J.f.���!£�f��

-t�o

2,�*.��-t�M.�k�a*4"••M"!���'ffi,1ijS4TA

��liJ.f.�rr��M"!'M�A��liJ.f.0/.-t�1IoM!£�T-Y

M"!'��:.���••*��,*��.���, ••••a

*aJlJJ'*�.#T-�*'T-��AliJ.f.�o/�-t����a�

1Hdt� 1II4t 0

(�)'i#� ;f;.lip � � 4Jf�r.'-iI!

LJ.tJ.f.1f!.{;I.��1t.Th"1t�� , 'fit.'i#T-� , 'fft�i!-JtlMIJi1!1t '

51�)'V��ä�.f!0/��rt�*ft'�� 0

2,��M#�*�f*�JlJJ�.'f�AJIIIW����M.ä�*�

JlJJ�T-�'�AliJ.f.Åj:j����i>-�o

(-=-) 0/ � 1t 1+� r., "!

ifJlllm�liJ.f.#'tJIII�ff**�ffä�-t'M.o/�M-iI!�A�

� ffi ' jf#l�lJf,*uT :

1,•• ffi.:��••;f;..a,�alt,�.;f;.•• o

161

Page 7: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-)1lt�A;/] j-� ,�{��;ji1�ittl>1' �l>1;ji1Jt

.��••��R��A+�.-�-a�.�� .•a�•

••ft�.A;/].t���M�'�*�.�.A*•••�.#

.t•• J'A�*�.�t.��*A�'��.�M4.��

.�.jf.i#]�1lt�a:tJt{�j-#���',*)JLr . f"latA��l}M,lHf\i&l.*'R .

���#j-Mr' •••ft*�••���at�MA�t�*�*

�•••�t.�••t.*A��.ftat��� ••aA;/].

t���.�.�a.�.�•• ' •• '.fit.�*��.n .

• Ji:. • ;j;.. 0Jf ��� ft;J- ,lHfI � X. i@.��#< i\IJ -fi..... M;. -f m ��'fl ( 44' }J'Hill

{1t £. k�{�J'ld\'4'-)' �;fj(:f� nM#£ 't:jillM:fJti!-#l�("�a*4 .Il'-.

ft). :jiIJJt.�tA;/] 'f.liHU�alJ�� . iIÉ;fi1��l>1�itl:l>1;,MJt("*p#*

.�k�••�l>1)'�•••��••�*�i&l.���:fJtn�3

�.

(�).��IM4*�j-#.�••••�.�ta4'-�j-#�at�

1.�.�IM4.�.#.��at�.��.a4'-'�.�.Il'-#l�

••• �j-#at'�*��IM4��••�.��.M.A�a

*j-#�� .•a.����*.n�.�M*�.���'&*

.Il'-�t •• '*A�������A;j;..��.

2.'9:'iJ]if-�A4h1��/.};>J 1tit�1I:iE.�1��'i'H•.•�*A��

M#�.��.�.��.�I*�M.��.�*��-a'A

��.��.œ.;��•••#��*�M.��.�'iIÉ.�

*#l���.at.Il'-�••. ���t.*�#�.�.(�.�

•• ,�.���;j;...��.�.a�.�.M.A�:fJtnœ••)

3 .•*4•• IM�j-'H•••. ��.�a••��••�.��

j-#.ft'iIÉ.�IM4*��.��j-#.�a.�.�at��

£*4.Il'-j-#.'��*4.Il'-.ft*�••����••�m

.�at .••��j-#.�M.��a.aoc.

4.� ••�RtA�-ft*4'�••�a*j-'Haat*•. �.�

.�A�4•• �•••#at'.�.��A�.j-#�4.'iIÉ

163

Page 8: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

.� ••���a'.��.aa••��'K�.��.���

�a�.400.' •••�•• ' ••*.�M�*.*'.'�

••#.�a���•• '�4�a.�.a�••�.�'AA�

�{*'+� , fA.��a.'

*���••MA••êa���ff���.��.ff.#AM��#'

��AUM.A•• '4.��.T:

(-) f'l m.�Ji!t.*ê{*,�JJiJR�'f#'t�1bMJJi� , 'i*HIl.�1b4l-.�•

• '.#••• �I�.�� •••• '�.M���ff••A.fi

�.1b••#'t�'.�J.�.�.����••••�M-'a*

••.•••#�.�*a�.£.�Aa.�•• 't��*.ff

#'t���••••A���.�,��••#�£.�'�.*�ff

.f.j�.��a'

(-=-).�� 'f#'t�(MJJi�)'Jl.jjj ...e{*,�••�.�»t•• ;I] , �it�r *

�••• 'a�*�.*.M�•• '*��a�••�A*it��

•• 'Ma••#f'lm�.K*�.�k���'

(..=.)�.a��{*,.#.��A.'i#*.' Jib;1Pll f'l A.�i' fA.a.#

.�#Y�;�••����a�••��La��»tfi.�'�.

a.�J���U1#•.

(11!l)• .ft. r {*,�.#�r*�.J ;MJt' �;.({t.K�I\!*��l;Ja.*�.�Jlt

;Iit.

(�)�.�••••8.f.j.MA.*êa�.#a*�.��, ••�

.�**t•••���&.�....#.'��••aa.MA

••êa��.#�8'�.�I�.���.M�.#.�aa�

••*••I�••••#.'���••••84•••••••

k»t•••••�.*,�� ••4�•••�.#.t�_••�

aa�oc'�•••M�aaaoc� ••a•.

165

Page 9: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

J/t .... �AM:.o

(�)itl'à"�-tH:;Îf)�i:. r �tf;��J&,*J �Nr•• li#îf!ll�.tU�*J/tjIJz

il'-/; o [4]

*rA.ffl#A4�.MA••*.I'à".#.�fi••�••�M�

'f . �J;t f!tiH� lIIJ(fi.� ¥-� J¥-{i)f!t1t 4'-1* l'à" i!-# �JJ zJ¥-{i�A Jl tr;t

�1IIJ.��••M�;�*A.��#îMf!t*J¥-{i�tAIA••zM

�.#tr;t ••I'à".�t'f'�•••+IIIJI��''f•••���'

.l'à"t;Îf�IIIJ�t••z�À .••-;tz��••+¥-�afi.J¥-{i(

�•••I'à" •••��'�E+f!t1t••.••.••�tA._�t

J¥-{i)�At�lIIJt�:itaAJl <ftWiJll�' .�zm . �A*�f!ti!-AJl-f-* .

JE "f ti .... 5U1 ;t••*1* l'à" jfi *- o

mm��xJ&.��rz*#��ì�k¥��Am���*# .

•��*#.��r;tAA*#J/t.£.JE�-a'A*.�x�A�

.'.k.�m9��Am���xJ&.��r*#.I�z�.A#î

�'&�¥��Am���xJ&.��r*#£I'.l'à"t;Îf��#�

��I'à"*�#-�.A������*#"f���o

(-*.�••••��i:..I'à"' ••Axì&����W#.'��Aa

�•• ' •• ' ••A.��t�xJ&���#z£•. ��*tr;t

t� IIIJ M. it *#•� i:. #U1 A;lJI. jii, o

(�)��•••• '.�.IIIJA.I'à"�� •••A$•• 'xì&.�'.

�xì&!VJl..tc.�'i#.f-'£�'tìi. o

(�)mm••fi.A.I'à"*#� •• i:.'.*#."f�I��ì&'MA�

.�.�M��'A.�J¥-{i��1txJ&.�&.*'�"f�.��

*���*#.�.��.A.ffl#AzW#'�.MA••*.1'à"

167

Page 10: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

It i! "" -fIi.�-4�-Jtil

�Wlft.+-�+'::'}j

Ji 85- Ji 98

Journal of Traffic Science

Central Police University

Vol. 2 No. 2

Dec. 2002, pp. 85-98

An Improving Policy for Traffic Enforcement and Road Safety

.I. �1lI. Ginn-Wang Wang'

.•�.�._,lti!����.�.���-.�'.�.K.�B.'

W�,r�*J�rlti!J���¥��k*�o��'��U¥��M��

.h�T'lti!.a��A.��T.,�.a.�.o.lt.M�#.*#

�' ••�IM�#.�oa.�.�••lti!_*a.�lti!*�M�' •

•••••�••lti!*��•• ,lt••a•••�alti!_*•••��

•• '#�'.8-'����••�A .•��••a�£�_*�.,�

*.N/j�a4;�-tlti!JJ.Jt 0

Abstract

Going along with the progress of society, traffic has become a part of daily life

of people and brought the huge and profound effect. Consequently, public security

and traffic have already been the two major missions for the police. Till now, the

number of deaths due to traffic accidents has decreased year by year, and it's very

effective. But, traffic problems are not only restricted to this. There're a lot of

issues to be solved. We hope that a series of new and planned actions can be made

and carried out by the review of history of traffic safety and the inspection of

present conditions of the traffic accident investigation and statistics of the

achievement of traffic enforcement to forecast policies of traffic enforcement and

j

1

85

Page 11: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

��x����rA�����+A'A�;,���-a�4x�*�

.�.�.k.B'�t..X••�'.MW••*�.��M'*

��4�.���z.���'��*����-��4x���$�

;��X�'¥�.��nT'A����4x����rA��;,'

�-�A'.�����••��*�+AM.'�������WA

z��T�'A����4x����rA����'��OAo

�>JIJ �rA� �>JIJ �rA�

65 3632 78 7584

66 4087 79 7333

67 4798 80 7322

68 5281 81 7216

69 5504 82 7367

70 5618 83 7245

71 5475 84 7427

72 5434 85 7077

73 5676 86 6516

74 5517 87 5903

75 6270 88 5526

76 7034 89 5420

77 7524 90 4787

-ti : I. 'I#.� : {TJRI'J\;1tf�;f

2.•�;fM�.�*.���rA.'.ft•••••�.'�••��

��#��'��A*����r�o

�'�����x�*�$.-��x�.��rA.���A

+ AJ-J. r

�����.4X�*�.�.���.k,��t••X.'�

�.�'�••���z���a���4'���*���rn+#�

87

Page 12: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

lf-1n- "1f3ti!i!��tt �1JJ.f.�tt

A+Alf- .::. ' 0 ,\ .::. ;il; 7L ' .li...li.. ,\ # - , ,\ � - ;il; -t ' -t ,', A�

A+7Llf- .::. ' - -t 7L ;il; � , .::.0 0 i'!' -,-tO.li..;iI;-'-O-t�

7L+lf- - , 7L -t � ;iI;.::. ' 7LA� {'!' - , -t�7L;iI; ,\ ' �.li...li..�

7L+-lf-- '��.::.;iI;�' --tAi'!' -,-tA.li..;iI;�'-A'::'�

(-.i.7LfJ)

(�7L+-lf--.i.7LfJ_���••��._�.3ti!i!�-'��.::.;iI;

#'f���.f.o'-t.li..#'�7L+lf-�M-'.li...li...::.;iI;#'�y,::,

.::.O;il;#(�y-�%),��3ti!#Mt.a.'���.ma* •

•*M.�"1f-t�O;il;#'��"1f#tt.li...li..%'����•• '

�.&���.�.t.i!�"1f.�.T:

i!JJI.'1i OIJftf.t*J<t

Ivt - .!f- - i Jr.. JJ Jr..+.!f--iJr..JJ �.ti<

i� I!f :Ii; -f-Jft.!f; : - 0 ;li; c::. ' -=. -l:; -=. # lf"- tt : - c::. ;li; Jr.. ' -=. Jr.. c::.# Jft f.t i.U" c::. - %

ite¥! : c::.;lI;11<I'Jr..li.-l:;# ite¥! : c::.;lI;-=,'li.Jr..--l:;# ite¥!!fht>:;'<%

Jt#l.�-b-f-Jft.!f; : -:;,<;lI; c::. • Jr.. AA# lf"- tt : c::. -=. ;li; Jr.. • -l:; Jr.. c::.# Jft f.t,... :y' -=. c::. %

,lJ!j'(::;,<.-l:;:;'<O# ,lJ!j'(:11<I;lI;Jr..':;'<li.c::.# ,lJ!j'(,...:Y. A:;'<%

-tAA-:Ii;-f--tAA-:Ii;-f-:c::.'11<I-l:;-# ite ¥! # tt.,... :Y' c::.

it 4i: • it rt - 11<1 -l:; it Jr.. % ' AtO�:y'(1iII,-f-)

ite¥! : - 11<1-=.# • c::.c::.O A ite1hf : c::.0 0 # • li.A-=.A f;..::..%

,lJ!i!Jfttt:c::.11<IO;ll;:;,<.c::.11<IJr.. lf"-tt : c::.li. -;lf; - , 0 A-

Jft tt,... :Y' 11<1 %# #

�.��, ( 4)Jfttt:-=.11<I;lI;-.-:;'<-l:;# Jft.!f; : -l:; 0 ;li; li. • Jr.. - -l:; # Jft tt i� :Y' li. c::.%

:Ii;-f-

�j!U�-f-Jftf.t::;'<-;lI;A'li.c::.:;,<#

Jftf.t:-Ac::.;lI;-=,'A011<lJfttti�:Y':;'<:;'<%

,f;.�*Nii #

1�m +#.>\ Jfttt:-=.;lI;Jr...011<lO#Jft.!f; : -;lI;-'-AO#

+.Ii)�JJ#tt.!f( Jr.. i + c::. JJ )

+rfJJ -tU- -t.li)�JJ11<I'-=.-=.A#-t.li)�JJc::..-l:;Jr..li.#

ht>li.li.%

Jfttt:--;lI;-'-=.A-=.#Jftf.t: - -=. ;li; li. • -=. -=. c::.1t

-t.li)�JJ#tt.,...,f;.**�>.ll' ( Jr.. i + c::. JJ )

-t.li)�!1-;lI;c::.'11<IA-l:;# �Y f;.-=-.%-t.li)�!1-=.;lI;-=..A-=.-=.#

89

Page 13: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

-l:(�lf-#.IJ3.-t-=-Ef1t), 1'l]tE.J!:.i. A2 � (1:�) -l:#(�lf-#.IJ,\;!ri;

#), ,*-�M,}jf.JJ!:.i. A3 �-l:1t�-l:(�lf-#.IJ+ll!1;ii;1t) 0

4. ,*m�jE , i!� x.� :$tUPI i\'�%*- J . ýj}f�1r �$ft x.�:$M:-tÆ

Jl. . AA 1t.»t�*-� . fJ.1� Jl JfJ;,�'#.#dt 0 *-;f3E$t,m 'i!� x.�

:$M:»t�+.J'1rÆ••�t.�'3E••�»t�ÁJl#*-.�o

5. ��-t-*JfJ'J:$}M.»t�x.�:$M:' m 1t.+lf--}]�+-=-}]�jlfd1:$}

�Jf��-t-*ÁJl:$}�»t�x.�:$M:.���»t�£�'#*�,�

���+-���Jf��'-=-+A�:$}��'#�jlf�.'�*-;f,*

##��.A�l�,jE•••••£�æ�.o

6.jlf�-=-Mai!�x.�:$M:.�•••• '*-;f•••�.�a-t-*

ÁJl'$t,.M-.#'3E.��••M���.*jlf�•••• '

�llll.-;ii;A-t-M;Á 0

(-=-)�«A�

1. x.�:$M:.tjclt�jf-Á-�æ

1t.+lf-�����.���x.�:$M:-1t.;!ri;3.'�-=-3.#'�A3.'

3.ll!1ll!1ÁÆr'�;!ri;1t.'A�1t.Á1:�',#A+Alf-��.�A;!ri;

�'O-3.#'Ær-=-'3.1t.-=-Á'1:�3.;!ri;�'A�-Á�_�

*- 2 ' .�1HU';tfw-O;!ri; � , �-01't- (;l'tfw--=-A%)' Ær;l'tfw

1t.A-=-Á(;l'tfwll!10%)'1:�;l'tfwll!1;!ri;-=-'O-AÁ(;l'tfw--­

%)on*-;f'#m�;fx.�:$M:ÆrÁ.M�-tÆ�*���'��

�.d1+�-=-'ll!1�.�A-'ll!13..�*-3'x.�:$M:M�E.�jf

-Á-'tæo

2.x.�:$M:�:$Á��&.*3.+%

*-;f�1t.+lf-�Th�*¥�*��M:$M:.�Jl¥':$M:�*Á'

*�',*��'#��.Æ�Jl.ff-=-�».M••i\"��_:$)�

.i\'M*'�M�M£�Jl¥.�x.�:$M:£�-t��&��M.

*'��:$M:�:$Á���.*Ef:$}-t3.+'»t�£���.*,

*-;fJj1;-Mft&-f.�A E.Æ.AJii 0

91

Page 14: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI
Page 15: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-=-HMtA lik-

i. it- <}1; iJA�h ' ;f;. ft- !t y k {tj- � � 14- :

���.���Y'�ffl���������*'���R�ft-!t

{tj-�'.��.���ft-!tA.��ÅMM.��M.4.��+

K#'�;f;.�••Åft-!tYk{tj-�.#,�����.*<}1;iJA

�'R�••••*.�.'�.E����*';f;.ft-!t�R{tj-�

� 14- '

2. Y -fl ft- ff:.i! �.IUh Ii!'. ' iim � � ....i� :7' I"l AK :

�+-.-�IA�'��.�+�.��.���.-.-'�

-�#'��.��.�'�OA#,.��+�ak�M��1"l

AK'��Y-fla.'.h�*T'�ft-ff:.i!a�.,

3. iim��.ft,-ei�:7'�i;-AK ' :i!A'il}J!Mt!ft :

�+-.-�IA��.�.*.�iJa-=-��Åft,-e'+�.�

ft,-e�KÅ'��.���.*.��A�+Åft,-e'.��+�

11i.i� :7' �i; - AK '

4. i�I1*T.�4jj.4'-�i;KAK:

�+-.��.'�����•••�#��*-fl�'�I�a*

T.' �KAK(A.��A, ••�I"lA)'ffl�

••��Å.�Xg�-fl�•••�,������AA-�.,�

.�ffl�.'�����.,���Aat�k�a�'

a�+-.��-a.'������A' ••�ilik�*��'

�*,.(*)���•••��.�T.�.�a.�.�.�.. '

/}t7it{l\;�� ' ••fI::J\:.i!J" ••1f�lii J" ••ii.###lii J' �*"••

�.*m�M*'�E�1;iJ•• '.�+K.Y••• '.h�*'

tT*T'T.A.k�'*.�#4••*.,�/}t7•••*mT.'

a.�.��,�.��•••��ft-!t,

95

Page 16: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

*������������#��T�#'��k��WÀ+�

#'a*�W�#��'�����*�������a������

�.A'��.#.¥••rn4A��.��a&.4a.m��a*

��.�.�'�••#��••�•••«••• ' •• '.A��

��'�R•• ,.*,���#���•.•�,*.�•• r ••

�M•••R�4��T��#������J'��•••�«���

������'��a&a��A.'�����'�m�+����

-a.Y.'_.�£•••$'�a*A.��_.'

�.*��••��M���.h'*.�+-�4.�r.��

4���M:lt+,*- 't.J!I J ' r �4���M: 't!ID $i-ilf*- il'.J!I J ' r -f'y �-f.*

�T�aikAj)l*-il'.J!IJ' r ��iHf/,*-il'#IJ' r !f.$i-$j��#Jl.-ka�

�1't�*#Jl.-kJF.I.m4il' J' r ��!f.#%���il'.liIJ 'f4l-'J���i)ll� ,

#���-'Aoo��4I-.#_a£�M�'�.*.�.#�.��

M*-il'��'�.-.$�.*'��.*a*£w.

rk*J�r��JM�••�*��'�.�.�A'��M���

�&&�M'��a4��'��.*A.'�.� .�-k�r.*��

i€J*��lh1-rfJJ��J �••.f,ij� , *>t4l-1-rjfH�rHt�#-fJJ r i€J* J' r-0­

**�J�r��*�J.�*t.��'�#A���.��•.f,ij�'�

�����M:�rA�'m�+��.*.rm�T�J'�+����M:�

rA��MT.�.��.'B_�+-�.�.1.R'.�••4I-.-k't

.f,ij�'*.����+�����M:�rA���+-����-A'��

��m�'��.�'�k�.4���,�r��a�hJ'R*an�ft

�'�fJJ•• '.�.�4I-�M.d' ••#.�IE�' •••"_h'

�.�A�-k�#���.*••�ra����J�••�$'�fJJ'.

97