7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
1/30
Introduction to
Forensic Psychology2ndEditionBartol & Bartol (2008)
Chapter 3
Police PsychologyInvestigative Psychology
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
2/30
Investigative Psychology DEFINITION:The application of psychology to
criminal investigation.
Profilingone of the tasks often associated withinvestigative psychologyrequires sketching the
significant psychological and demographic features of aperson or persons.
Broadly defined, investigative psychology includesresearch and practice involving:
-Profiling -Risk Assessment-Police Line-ups -Interrogation-Polygraph Hypnosis -Other?-
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
3/30
3 Questions
What are the important behavioral features of thecrime that may help identify and successfullyprosecute the perpetrator?
What inferences can be made about thecharacteristics of the offender that may helpidentify him or her?
Are there any other crimes that are likely to havebeen committed by the same person?
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
4/30
CRIMINAL PROFILING
Background
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
5/30
What is Criminal Profiling?
Criminal profiling is the process ofidentifying personality traits, behavioraltendencies, geographical location, anddemographic or biographical descriptorsof an offender (or offenders) based oncrime scene characteristics.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
6/30
Goals of Profiling
The primary goal of profiling is to narrowthe field of possible suspects.
Profiling is also a form of prediction -- theprofiler tries to predict who the offenderor offenders might be and where and how
the next crime may occur.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
7/30
Traditional investigative techniques oftenfall short in extreme cases.
A subset of offenses/offenders areconsidered most suitable for profiling --
What subset of offenders and why moresuitable for profiling??
Why Use Criminal Profiles in
Law Enforcement?
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
8/30
Brief History of Criminal Profiling 1940s - First recorded use by psychiatrist Walter Langer
during WWII commissioned to construct a psychodynamicprofile of Hitler.
1957 - psychiatristJames Brussels worked with NYPD toconstruct a profile of the Mad Bomber.
1970s-1980s - FBI(Howard Teten, John Douglas, RobertRessler, Roy Hazelwood,and others) became involved inpsychological profiling and popularized the technique.
1990s 2003 - attempt (by David Canter, MauriceGodwin, Ron Holmes, Robert Keppel, Brent Turvey, KimRossmo and others) to scientize profiling and move thepractice beyond the purview of the FBI.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
9/30
The FBI Profilers Small/prominent group of FBI profilers helped to popularize
the term in 1970s in the Behavioral Science Unit -- calledthe National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime(NCAVC)since 1984.
Responsible for establishing the Violent CriminalApprehension Program (VICAP). Published CrimeClassification Manual, Sexual Homicide: Patterns andMotives and true crime novels.
Are known for the ORGANIZED/DISORGANIZEDtypologyand focus on M.O. and SIGNATURE.
Criticized for relying too much on intuition/faulty use of thescientific method.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
10/30
Is Profiling a Science or Profession? Profiling has not yet achieved the status of a profession. Factors
hindering professionalization:
Lack of consensus (on terms, approaches, training, appropriateexperience/educational background, etc.).
Practical issues (sensitivity and confidentiality of cases).
Ego/territorial issues.
Absence of uniform standards, practices, peer review, and ethics.
Small number (if any) of profiling positions where profiling is theprimary job description.
The notion (and acknowledgement among many profilers)thatprofiling is more art than science.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
11/30
Assumptions Made in the Profiling ProcessSee Holmes& Holmes (2001). Profiling Violent Crimes. Sage.
Crime scene reflects thepersonalityofthe offender.
M.O.remains similar.
Signaturewill remain the same.
Offenderspersonality will not change.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
12/30
The Organized-Disorganized Typology
Whether or not the crime scene is left ORGANIZEDor DISORGANIZED is said to provide informationabout the offenders criminal sophistication andpersonality.
Organized crime scene reflects offender whocommits crime out of a need for power. Motivationassociated with PSYCHOPATHY.
Disorganized crime scene reflects offender whocommits crime out of passion, compulsion,frustration, or anxiety. Motivation associated withPSYCHOSIS.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
13/30
Offense planned
Victim a targetedstranger
Victim personalized Controlled conversation
Crime scene reflectsoverall control
Demands submissive
victim
Restraints used
Aggressive acts prior todeath
Body hidden Weapon/evidence
absent
victim or bodytransported from scene
Associated withpsychopathy
The Organized Crime SceneSee Ressler, Burgess, & Douglas (1992) Sexual Homicide: Patterns and Motives. Free Press.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
14/30
The DisorganizedCrime SceneSee Ressler, Burgess, & Douglas (1992) Sexual Homicide: Patterns and Motives.
Spontaneous offense
Victim or locationknown
Depersonalizes victim Minimal conversation
Crime scene randomand sloppy
Sudden violence tovictim
Minimal use ofrestraints
Sexual acts after death
Body left in view Evidence/weapon often
present
Body left at death
scene Associated with
Psychosis
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
15/30
Interview/Interrogation StrategiesSee Holmes & Holmes (1996) Profiling Violent Crimes. Sage.
ORGANIZED Direct confrontation
Respects competency
One-person interview
Dont expect freeinformation
No use of false evidence(are too sharp for this)
Conduct when suspect hasno time to gatherthoughts
DISORGANIZED Relationship motivated
Empathy
Constant stream of
conversation Use positive personal
relationship
Conduct at night
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
16/30
Distinction Between
Psychopathy and Psychosis
PSYCHOPATHY Personality disorder made up of a particular constellation
of characteristics)
Lack of attachment, defect in affect, absence of anxiety In touch with reality
PSYCHOSIS
Clinical mental illness Schizophrenia May meet legal definition of insanity
Out of touch with reality
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
17/30
Developed/oversimplified for use by lawenforcement professionals with little academictraining in criminology, psychology, and forensicscience and encourages unsophisticated
profiling.
Is a FALSE DICHOTOMY--few offenders/crimescenes it neatly into either type.
Other problems?
Criticism of the Organized/Disorganized
TypologySee Turvey (2002) Criminal Profiling. Academic Press.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
18/30
M.O. and Signature(See Douglas, Burgess, Burgess, & Ressler (1997). Crime Classification Manual.
Jossey-Bass; Keppel, R.D. & Birnes, W.J. (1997). Signature Killers. Pocket Books.
METHOD OF OPERATION (M.O.) How the offender committed the crime. Tells about the
experience of the offender and situational/contextualfactors involved in the crime.
SIGNATURE The behavior/expression of fantasy the killer mustleave
at the scene to satisfy emotional/psychological needs.Goes beyond whats necessary to commit crime andtells about the offenders psychological needs andmotivation.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
19/30
Factors that Shape M.O.
Trade/Professional Experience
Criminal experience and confidence
Contact with the criminal justice system
Media and pop culture
Offender Mood/Mental state
X-Factors (unknown/unplanned influences)
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
20/30
Factors that Shape Signature
Personality/Psychopathology
Evolution of Fantasy
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
21/30
Distinguishing M.O. from SignatureSee Turvey (2002) Criminal Profiling. Academic Press.
Signature and M.O. needs may besatisfied by the same behavior. Important
to remember thetwo most importantaxioms of criminal profiling:
Different offenders do similar things fordifferent reasons.
Offender behaviors can be the result ofmultiple motivations and/or externalinfluences.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
22/30
Static and Dynamic RiskSee Andrews & Bonta (2003). The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Anderson.
Offender risk factors are static and dynamic. Areimportant in understanding M.O. and Signaturebehaviors.
STATIC RISK: Stay the same over time
DYNAMIC RISK: Change over time
Stable dynamic: change slowly over months or years
Acute dynamic: change rapidly over minutes or days.
What type of risk factors are M.O. and Signaturebehaviors?
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
23/30
The Psychological Autopsy The Psychological Autopsy is an attempt to reconstruct the
personality profile and cognitive features ofdeceased. Thispostmortem psychological analysis is also called reconstructivepsychological evaluation and equivocal death analysis .
Psychological autopsies are important to:
Assist certifying officials to clarify deaths that are ambiguous, uncertain, orequivocal as to the mannerof death
Aid in investigation to determine insurance payments and national security issues.
To make a reasonable determination of what may have been in the mind of thedeceased person leading up to and at the time of deathparticularly if the deathappears to be a suicide
Psychological autopsies differ from criminal profiling in twoimportant ways: (1) the profile is constructed on a dead person, and(2) the identity of the person is already known.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
24/30
Geographical Profiling and Mapping
Geographical profiling refers to the analysis of geographicallocations associated with the spatial movements of a single serialoffender,
Geographical mapping is concerned with analyzing thespatial patterns of crimes committed by numerous offenders overa period of time. Geographical mapping focuses on identifying the
hot spots of certain types of crime.
In 1995, D. Kim Rossmo wrote a doctoral dissertation at Simon
Frasier Universitys School of Criminology on geographicalprofiling. Rossmo developed a computer program called CriminalGeographic Targeting (CGT). It is designed to analyze thegeographical or spatial characteristics of an offenders crimes.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
25/30
The Polygraph
The polygraphcommonly called the lie detectordetectspsychophysiological responses that accompany emotional reactions toguilt, shame, and anxiety through heart rate, blood pressure, breathingrate, and skin conductance.
In addition to observing the physiological measures, the skillfulpolygrapher makes behavioral observations and notations to infer truth ordeception in the subject being examined.
The polygraph can accurately measure and record the physiologicalresponses but it is unclear whether it can detect actual lying and
deception.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
26/30
INVESTIGATIVE PSYCHOLOGY AND
OFFENDER PROFILINGDiscussion Questions
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
27/30
Discussion Questions:(Homant & Kennedy/B&B Supp Readings)
What are the major limitations in researching theeffectiveness of profiling?
Why Is Profiling So Inaccurate?
What direction do the authors of your readingsthis week (e.g., Homant & Kennedy) suggest weneed to go in terms of conducting research onprofiling? How do Homant & Kennedy define:
Offender Profiling Psychological Profiling Geographical Profiling Equivocal Death Analysis
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
28/30
Discussion Questions:(Muller/B&B Supp Readings)
What two main approaches to profiling arereviewed in this article? Explain the
features of each.
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
29/30
Discussion Questions:(B&B TextCh 3)
What might explain the popularity ofprofiling, despite the lack of evidence tosupport it?
What other applications of psychologicaltheory and research do the authors
suggest can be considered under theheading of investigative psychology?
7/29/2019 22186 Ol&BartolCh3 InvestigativePsychologyandOffenderProfiling
30/30
Discussion Questions ~ General:(B&B (Text)
Explain the significance of static and dynamic riskfactors in the prediction and profiling of humanbehavior.
Explain how the processes of a) unconscioustransference and b) own-race bias can affectidentification provided by eyewitnesses to anevent.
Forensic psychologists have offeredrecommendations to police in constructing line-ups. What are these recommendations? Uponwhat research findings are they based?
Top Related