1
The Fossil Fuels:Natural Gas and Coal
Lecture #5HNRT 228 Spring 2013Energy and the Environment
2
iClicker Question
• What is a typical drill depth for an oil well?– A Several hundred feet– B 1000 feet– C Several thousand feet– D All of the above– E Only A and B above
3
iClicker Question
• Which of the following is (are) used to confirm the presence of oil in a well?– A Core samples– B Well logging– C Drill stem testing– D All of the above– E Only A and B above
4
iClicker Question
• What is the name of the suspension used to keep fractures in rock open and allow oil to flow?– A crackant– B fracture suspension– C flowant– D fracturant– E proppant
5
iClicker Question
• The process by which components in a chemical mixture are separated according to their different boiling points, is called– A Distillationism– B Fractionation– C Fractioning– D Fractional distillation– E Fractional fractionating
6
iClicker Question
• Which of the following are not petroleum derived products?– A gasoline– B kerosene– C jet fuel – D plastics– E None of the above
7
•Oil is trapped in rare geological structures•Most of the oil in the world comes from a few large wells•About one in ten exploratory drillings strike oil
8
Overview of Natural Gas
• Supply of recoverable natural gas available at affordable costs has greatly increased over past 10 years
• Industry’s ability to produce natural gas from shales has gone from almost 0 to > 20% of U.S. needs in just 10 years
• Natural gas demand is at 22-23 Tcf/year in the U.S. (historic highs). Increased availability of gas will allow demand to continue to grow over next several years
9
1999 View of Natural Gas Supply
• N. American natural gas reserves found each year were replacing produced gas, but…– Industry needed to drill more and more
wells just to hold reserves constant while demand for production was increasing
– Production from the Gulf of Mexico had peaked and was in decline
• The petroleum industry was starting to have success in producing gas from shale
10
U.S. Reserve Base – Trends Before and After Shale Gas Production
Significant increase in gas reserves and production from shales starts in 1999
Source: EIA
11
U.S. Natural Gas Production
U.S. natural gas production is at its highest level ever in 2008
+1.1%/yr -1.9%/yr +3.7%/yr
Source: EIA
12
Offshore Gulf of Mexico in Steep Decline
Production is down by almost 50% from 2001-07
Source: EIA
13
Enter Barnett Shale
• Barnett Shale– Geological formation located in the
Bend Arch-Fort Worth Basin of Texas– Consists of sedimentary rocks of
Mississippian age (354–323 million years ago)
– Formation underlies the city of Fort Worth and underlies 5,000 square miles (13,000 km2) and at least 17 counties of Texas
14
Barnett Shale– Daily Production
While supply from offshore GoM has fallen by >6 bcf / day, Barnett Shale production has grown by > 4 bcf/d
Source: TX RR Commission
(TX RR Commission Areas 5 + 9 only)
- 4%
- 8%
- 0%
Percentage of U.S. natural gas demand supplied by Barnett Shale only
15
What Has Changed to Allow us to Produce This Gas?
• Techniques to allow horizontal wells to be drilled efficiently have greatly improved– In 4Q ’06, Barnett wells drilled in 25
days for $161/ft;– In 2Q ‘08, Barnett wells drilled in 19
days for $131/ft – This is 24% faster and 19% cheaper
Source: Simmons
16
Frac’d (Fracturing) Wells
Barnett shale is very hard, and it was virtually impossible to produce gas in commercial quantities from this formation until recent improvements were made in hydraulic fracturing technology and horizontal drilling, and there was an upturn in the natural gas price.
17
What Has Changed to Allow us to Produce this Gas
• Ability to drill longer laterals• Experimentation on Completion
Methods:– Cemented/Uncemented liners– Staged Frac’ing– Simulfracs– Frac fluids and proppants
18
What Has Changed to Allow us to Produce This Gas?
Ability to fracture shales and significantly increase production per well has dramatically improved– In 2005, the median initial production rate
Barnett Shale wells in Johnson County, TX was 2.2 Bcf /day
– In 2008, the median initial production rate for the Barnett wells in the same county was 7.0 Bcf/day
Source: IHS
19
What Has Changed to Allow us to Produce This Gas?
Combining drilling + production efficiencies: – One rig in 2005 could drill 9 wells at 2
bcf/well Versus
– One rig in 2008 can drill 12 wells at 4.5 bcf/well
In 2005, the rig added 18 bcf of reservesIn 2008, the rig adds 54 bcf of reserves
20
Conventional Well vs. Shale Gas Well Production Curves
21
BarnettHaynesville
Marcellus
Woodford
Basins Where Additional Gas Will Be Produced From Shales
Estimated Gas In-Place in these Shales is ~ 2000 Tcf
22
Today’s Relative Share of Energy Market by Fuel
Source: EIA – Annual Energy Outlook 2009
23
iClicker Question
• Which shale basin stretches from West Virginia to New York?– A Haynesville– B Woodford– C Barnett– D Marcellus– E None of the above
24
U.S. Energy Demand by Fuel
120 -
100 -
80 -
60 -
40 -
20 -
0 - 1980
1995
2005
2015
2030
History Projections
Quadri
llion B
tu’s
Renewable
s
Liquids
Natural
GasNuclear
Coal
Biofuels
Source: EIA – Annual Energy Outlook 2009
25
Natural Gas Use by Sector in 2008
21% Residential
29% Electricity Generation
14% Commercial
33% Industrial
3% Transportation
Source: EIA – Annual Energy Outlook 2009
Electricity generation from natural gas has grown at rate of 4%/year since 1990
Industrial usage of natural gas has fallen at rate of 2%/year since 1998
26
Today’s Relative Share of Electricity Generation by Fuel
Natural Gas 21%
Nuclear20% Coal
49%
Oil 1%
Hydro 6%
Other Renewables 3%
Source: EIA – Electric Power Monthly, April 2009
27
Natural Gas Supply thru 2030
Source: EIA – Annual Energy Outlook 2009
Alaska
25
-20
-15
-10
-5 -
0 -
199
5
200
5
201
5
202
5
History Projections
Unconventional
Conventional
Net Imports
28
History: U.S. Natural Gas – Production & Consumption
Source: EIA
29
Supply vs. Demand thru 2015
Available supply: Assume 1.8% growth / year in production capacity (starting in 2010) and net imports at 3 Tcf/yr vs. 3.3-4.0 Tcf/yr seen since ‘01
Demand (dashed curve): Assume 4% growth in use of gas for electricity generation after 1 year, 3% reduction in overall demand for 2009
30
Natural Gas is Cleaner120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Natural Gas
Diesel Ethanol Blends
Low Sulfur Diesel
Bio Diesel
Gasoline
Relative Level of NOx Emissions
Relative Level of Particulate Emissions 120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Source: South Coast Air Quality Management District2007 Air Quality Management Plan Summit Panel
31
Natural Gas is a Low Carbon Fuel
Natural Gas
Oil 28% more
Coal 43% more
0 50000 100000 200000150000
Pounds of Carbon per Billion BTU
Source: EIA, Natural Gas: Issues & Trends, 1998
32
iClicker Question
• Which has lowest amount of nitrous oxide emissions?– A Diesel Fuel– B Gasoline Fuel– C Bio-diesel Fuel– D Ethanol-blend Gasoline– E Natural Gas
33
iClicker Question
• Which has lowest amount of particulate emissions?– A Diesel Fuel– B Gasoline Fuel– C Bio-diesel Fuel– D Ethanol-blend Gasoline– E Natural Gas
34
iClicker Question
• Which puts the lowest amount of carbon into the environment?– A Oil– B Coal– C Natural Gas
35
Overall Economics of fuels before any carbon tax
$/KWh
Source: SDI research + team analysis
36
Distribution of natural gas• Impractical to ship: must route by pipe• 1.3 million miles of pipe (250,000 miles of
mains)
37
Natural Gas
• Extracted as oil-drilling byproduct– was once burned off at well head as means of
disposal• Mostly methane, some ethane, and a little
propane, butane• 2 times cheaper than electricity per energy
content, comparable gasoline per joule– this is recent: in 2004, it was 3.5 times cheaper
than electricity, 3 times cheaper than gas• Well-suited to on-the-spot heat generation: water
heaters, furnaces, stoves/ovens, clothes dryers– more efficient than using fossil-fuel-generated
electricity
38
Summary of Natural Gas
• U.S. has a very large natural gas resource base remaining to be produced, and
• The petroleum industry has greatly improved its ability to produce gas from shales, so
• We believe supply capacity will be able to meet growing demand w/o significant cost increases unless government imposes onerous taxes and additional regulation.
39
How much do we use, and where do we get it?
• In 2003, we used 21.8 Tcf (Tera-cubic feet, or 1012ft3); about 23 QBtu (23% of total)
• Out of the 21.8 Tcf used, 88% was domestic– 11.8% from Canada– 0.08% from Algeria (shipped in liquefied
form)– 0.03% from Mexico
• Have used about 1,100 Tcf to date
Q
40
How much do we have left?
• Estimated recoverable amount: 871 Tcf• 40 years at current rate• Estimates like this do account for future discoveries
– present proven reserves provide only 8 years’ worth
41
Recollecting Chemistry
• All fossil fuels are essentially hydrocarbons, except coal, which is mostly just carbon
• Natural Gas is composed of the lighter hydrocarbons (methane through pentane)
• Gasoline is hexane (C6) through C12
• Lubricants are C16 and up
kJ per gram
55
51
50
46
48
48
48
48
48
48
42
Hydrocarbon Reactions
• Methane reaction:CH4 + 2O2 CO2 + 2H2O + energy1 g 4 g 2.75 g 2.25 g 55 kJ
• Octane reaction:2C8H18 + 25O2 16CO2 + 18H2O + energy1 g 3.51 g 3.09 g 1.42 g 48 kJ
• For every pound of fuel you burn, you get about three times that in CO2
– one gallon of gasoline ~22 pounds of CO2
– occupies about 5 cubic meters (1300 gallons) of space
43
iClicker Question
• Which natural gas has the highest potential energy content per gram?– A Octane– B Heptane– C Butane– D Methane– E Hexane
44
Aside: Carbohydrate Reactions
• Typical carbohydrate (sugar) has molecular structure like: [CH2O]N, where N is some integer
– refer to this as “unit block”: C6H12O6 has N=6• Carbohydrate reaction:
[CH2O]N + NO2 NCO2 + NH2O + energy
1 g 1.07 g 1.47 g 0.6 g 17 kJ• Less energy than hydrocarbons because one
oxygen already on board (half-reacted already)• For every pound of food you eat you exhale 1.5
lbs CO2
45
Coal• Coal is a nasty fuel that we seem to have a lot
of • Primarily carbon, but some volatiles (CO, CH4)
• Reaction is essentially C + O2 CO2 + energy• Energy content varies depending on quality of
coal, ranging from 4–7 Cal/g• Highly undesirable because of large amounts
of ash, sulphur dioxide, arsenic, and other pollutants
• Also ugly to remove from the ground
46
Coal types and composition
NaturalGraphite
Anthracite
Bituminous
Bituminous
sub-bituminous
Lignite
Peat
Wood
fixed carbon
ash
volatile matter
moisture content
kJ/g
34
29
35
31
27
25
21
20
47
Use of Coal• 88% of the coal used in the U.S. makes
steam for electricity generation• 7.7% is used for industry and
transportation• 3.5% used in steel production• 0.6% used for residential and
commercial purposes• 0.1% used on Halloween for trick-or-
treaters <chuckle>
48
Estimated Worldwide Coal Reserves
Country Amount(109 tonne)
Percentageof Total
United States 250* 25
Russia 230† 23
Europe 138 14
China 115 12
Australia 82 8.3
Africa 55 5.6
South America 22 2.2
North America 7.7 0.8
Total 984 100
*1st edition of book had U.S. at 1500 billion tons. What happened to all that coal?†1st edition of book had Russian coal at 4300 billion tons. Gross overestimates?
49
U.S. Coal Production History
50
iClicker Question
• Which country has the most coal reserves?– A Russia– B China– C United States– D Australia– E Canada
51
When will coal run out?
• We use 109 tons of coal per year, so the U.S. supply alone could last as long as 250 (1500) years at current rate
• Using variable rate model, more like 75–100 (400–600) years– especially relevant if oil, gas are gone
• This assumes global warming politics doesn’t end up banning the use of coal
• Environmental concerns over extraction also relevant
52
Shale Oil
• Possibly 600–2000 billion barrels of oil in U.S. shale deposits– compare to total U.S. oil supply of 230
billion bbl• Economically viable portion may only be 80
billion bbl• 8 times less energy density than coal
– lots of waste rock: large-scale disposal problem
• Maximum rate of extraction may be only 5% of our current rate of oil consumption– limited by water availability
53
Tar Sands
• Sand impregnated with viscous tar-like sludge• Huge deposit in Alberta, Canada
– 300 billion bbl possibly economically recoverable
• It takes two tons of sands to create one barrel of oil
– energy density similar to that of shale oil• In 2003, 1 million bbl/day produced
– grand hopes for 5 Mbbl/day; or 6% of world oil production
• 2002 production cost was $20 per barrel, so economically competitive
54
In Class Question for Group Discussion
• In 2009, we had “snowmageddon”. There was a political pundit talk show on television where the moderator of the show asked the panel about the weather storms (snow storms in USA and cyclones in Australia) and if they may be a result of global warming. The moderator quoted Al Gore about the reason that these weather patterns may be indicators of global warming. One of the pundit’s stated that Al Gore would link anything bad to global warming. Discuss in your groups these matters. Address two questions in your responses:
– How is the moderator question itself flawed?– How may global warming and low pressure storm
intensity be causally linked?
Top Related