ZINC OXIDE FROM STEEL MILL DUST A WIDE RANGE OF …bestevent.management/event/2/session/21/... ·...
Transcript of ZINC OXIDE FROM STEEL MILL DUST A WIDE RANGE OF …bestevent.management/event/2/session/21/... ·...
1 Christian Doppler Laboratory for Optimization and Biomass Utilization in heavy metal recycling,
Montanuniversitaet Leoben, Austria 2 Chair of non-ferrous metallurgy, Montanuniversitaet Leoben, Austria
Caterina Benigni 1, Christoph Pichler 2, Jürgen Antrekowitsch 1
ZINC OXIDE FROM STEEL MILL DUST – A WIDE RANGE OF
OPPORTUNITIES
Abstract
Caused by an increasing amount of zinc coated steel products, zinc enters the steel
production through galvanized steel, which is used in the basic oxygen furnace (BOF) and the
electric arc furnace (EAF). Based on the process temperatures, the zinc evaporates as metallic
zinc, reoxidizes to zinc oxide in the offgas and gets collected in the bag house filter. Beside
zinc, which represents the main component, elements like lead, iron, cadmium, sodium,
potassium, fluorine and chlorine form part of the dust. In the European Union, this dust is
declared as hazardous waste, with 1.5-2.5 million tons of EAF dust produced in 2015. This
amount corresponds to a zinc amount of approximately 0.33-0.55 million tons. Due to the zinc
content, the EAF dust displays a usable by-product. This paper deals with the different
opportunities to produce products for the zinc market, using BOF dust as a raw material. A
special focus is set on the production of Waelz oxide (WOX) followed by strategies to form
different zinc products such as oxides, sulphates, carbonates as well as a metallic shape.
Furthermore, the paper deals with the different product qualities which are generated depending
on the process steps.
Keywords
Steel mill dust, zinc, zinc oxide, recycling, Waelz oxide
1. Introduction
The rising production of steel and nonferrous metals leads to an increase of residues which
contain a significant amount of valuable elements. Slags, sludges and other types of dust
represent such remaining materials. The target is represented by the recycling of these residues
in an environmentally friendly way by avoiding the production of residues for landfilling.
Steel mill dust displays a recyclable residue which contains zinc as main component due
to the input of galvanized steel scrap into the electric arc furnace (EAF) or the basic oxygen
furnace (BOF). Around 55 % of the produced electric arc furnace dust is globally sent to
landfill, although the recycling rate in Europe reaches approximately 90 %. Tab. 1 gives an
overview of the electric arc furnace steel production of 2010, 2011 and 2012 and the estimated
amount of electric arc furnace dust (EAFD). The production of 100 kg EAF-steel results in
1.8 kg EAFD and leads to 8,1 million tons in 2012. The calculation with 1.8 % is based on
surveys from several steel mills. [1]
Tab. 1: Overview of the production- and recycling amounts of EAFD [1]
Year
2010 2011 2012
Geographical Region [mmt of steel] [mmt of steel] [mmt of steel]
Asia 185.3 201.7 203.6 (3,666)*
European Union 71.0 75.8 70.1 (1,261)
North America 67.7 71.8 72.5 (1,306)
Other Europe 23.6 28.4 29.6 (532)
CIS 23.0 23.8 24.3 (437)
Middle East 17.8 20.7 22.5 (405)
South America 15.1 16.8 18.2 (291)
Africa 11.1 10.6 10.3 (186)
Oceania 1.5 1.5 1.4 (25)
Total 416.2 451.1 450.5 (8,109)
[mmt] Million metric tons * Estimated dust production in kmt
In 2015, a global crude steel production of 1,617.3 million tons [2] lead to a dust amount
of approximately 32.2 million tons. The electric steel route generates 25.1 % of the whole steel
production. This corresponds to a dust amount of 8.1 million tons which results from the
consideration that 15-20 kg dust/t of steel are generated. The amount of zinc depends on the fed
scrap during the production of steel. Normally, the zinc content in EAFD fluctuates around
22 % which represents a total zinc amount of 1.78 million tons. This corresponds to a sum of
12.8 % based on the zinc production of 13.9 million in 2015 [3].
Beside zinc, elements like iron, lead, manganese, sodium, potassium, fluorine and
chlorine also form part of the dust. Especially iron and the halides cause problems during the
production of various zinc products.
2. Currently used recycling technologies for treating steel mill dust
All of the currently applied pyrometallurgical processes utilize the low evaporation
temperature of zinc which gets concentrated in the gas stream and is separated as zinc oxide.
During the hydrometallurgical processes, a dissolution of zinc displays the main target.
Afterwards, different ways are possible to extract the zinc from the solution. Tab. 2 summarizes
the available pyro- and hydrometallurgical technologies to recycle steel mill dust.
Tab. 2: Available technologies to recycle steel mill dust
Pyrometallurgical process Hydrometallurgical process
Waelz Process H2SO4 leaching
Rotary Hearth Furnace NaOH leaching
Shaft furnace NH4Cl leaching
Multiple hearth furnace
The Waelz process represents the dominating process. 80 % of the dust recycling runs
along this route in Europe [4]. The first step is represented by the mixing and pelletizing of dust,
coke and slag additives after which the pellets enter a 40 m long rotary kiln. At approximately
1100 °C, carbon and carbon dioxide reduce the zinc oxide and the produced zinc volatilizes.
Based on the temperature also non-ferrous metal compounds like lead oxide, zinc chloride and
sodium-potassium chlorides volatilize and enter the off-gas stream. Iron and calcium form part
of the product due to carry-over. The reoxidized zinc steam can be collected in the dust chamber
as zinc oxide. [5]
The advantages of a Waelz kiln include the wide range of feeding materials which are
treatable, a simple process control, a low energy consumption and low investment costs. The
high CO2 emission, the low product quality, the minimum amount of zinc in the residues and
the high slag amount are negative aspects of this process type.
Nowadays, the Waelz oxide is sold to the primary industry to produce metallic zinc. Due
to the impurities – iron, fluorine and chlorine – a direct leaching of the Waelz oxide is not
possible. The halides are especially critical because of their damaging effect to the electrodes
in the zinc electrowinning. To remove these elements, the secondary zinc oxide is washed three
times by applying a counter-current process. Fig. 1 displays the water solubility of different
chlorides and fluorides which displays the fundamental characteristic to remove halides from
the Waelz oxide. In addition, the dissolution of some of these compounds leads to a metal loss
when considering zinc chloride among other. In order to avoid this, the addition of soda results
in an insoluble metal carbonate and a soluble sodium salt (see equation 1).
MeF2/MeCl2 + Na2CO3 MeCO3 + 2NaF/NaCl Eq. [1]
Fig. 1: Solution behaviour of different chlorides and fluorides [6]
The removal of chlorides is easily possible due to the high water solubility. Regarding
fluorides, only sodium-, potassium- and zinc fluoride are rarely soluble. Lead fluoride is slightly
soluble in comparison to calcium fluoride which is not soluble at all. An alkaline pH value
improves the solubility of fluorides, however, not for a complete removal. During the washing
process, calcium oxide shows a negative effect on the removal of fluorine. It forms part of
secondary zinc oxides due to carry over. [7]
During the washing process, a reaction between the calcium oxide and the fluorine ions
is possible and leads to a reduced fluorine yield. In general, two precipitation reactions can be
taken into account, one with calcium ions in the solution while the other reaction takes place at
the surface of the hydrated calcium oxide. [7,8,9] The reaction with calcium and fluorine ions
is explained in equation 2:
Ca2+ + 2F- CaF2 Eq. [2]
The condition for this reaction is represented by the fact, that calcium oxide dissolves and
forms calcium ions. The product - calcium fluoride - is not soluble in water which causes a
negative effect on the removal of fluorine. Therefore, calcium fluoride still remains in the Waelz
oxide and gets dissolved with sulfuric acid in the following leaching stage. [7,8,9]
Furthermore, an adsorption mechanism also leads to the formation of calcium fluoride.
This is a two-step process, where the calcium oxide hydrates to calcium hydroxide at first
(equation 3). The aqueous fluorine adsorbs on the surface of calcium hydroxide and results in
a calcium fluoride precipitate (equation 4). Based on the low solubility of calcium oxide in
water, the main mechanism for the removal of fluorine is represented by the adsorption.
CaO + H2O Ca(OH)2 Eq. [3]
Ca(OH)2 + 2F- CaF2 + 2OH- Eq. [4]
Due to the release of OH- ions, the pH value increases and with a rising OH- concentration
which results in a balance between fluorine and hydroxide ions. The higher the pH value, the
less fluorine ions can be adsorbed on the surface. [7,9]
Low halide values are required (chlorine <100 ppm, fluorine <50 ppm) to use the Waelz
oxide directly in the leaching stage of the primary zinc winning. These low values cannot be
achieved with the washing process which is why the zinc oxide runs through the whole primary
process together with the primary concentrates. The usage of Waelz oxide for other products is
critical as well due to the impurities. In the next chapter different possibilities are listed to use
secondary zinc oxide to generate different zinc products.
3. Zinc markets
In the field of steel mill dust recycling only pyrometallurgical processes are industrially
applied. Starting from secondary zinc oxides generated from steel mill dust, four different ways
are possible which are illustrated in Fig. 2. The most common one is displayed by the usage in
the primary industry to generate metallic zinc. Other routes include the production of a high
purity oxide, a sulfate or a carbonate. Zinc oxide is a basic material for products in the medicine,
cosmetics, paints, sun cream, catalysts, tyres and rubber industry. Zinc sulfate is used for
agricultural applications as well as in the dye house. Zinc carbonate is used for pigments and as
absorption medium for hydrogen sulfide. The requirements in relation to the product quality
varies depending on the market. [10]
Fig. 2: Flow Sheet of the different markets for secondary zinc oxides
Today, most of the Waelz oxides are sold to the primary industry. Based on the contained
impurities – iron, chlorine, fluorine – these secondary oxides enter the process route at the
roaster and run along the whole production route. A direct usage in the leaching stage would be
preferable due to the reason that the zinc content is high enough and the amount of zinc ferrite
is lower in comparison to the produced concentrate in the primary industry. Nevertheless,
purification steps are necessary to generate a leachable zinc oxide without disturbing elements.
The formation of high purity zinc oxide is complex because the tolerance of contained
impurities is really low. Critical elements include iron due to its colouring effect as well as
sulfur, cadmium and lead. The usage of zinc oxide in the tyre industry demands a stricter
chemical composition than the ceramic industry. Standards like the“ASTM D4315 - 94(2006)
Standard Test Methods for Rubber Compounding Material-Zinc Oxide” or the “ISO 9298:1995
Rubber compounding ingredients -- Zinc oxide -- Test methods.” describe the typical chemical
and physical requirements. Important parameters for the utilization in the tyre industry include
the surface area, heat loss, sieve residue, zinc oxide, sulphur, lead and cadmium content. Tab.
3 shows these requirements for zinc oxide which is used in the tyre industry. [10]
Tab. 3: Guideline for zinc oxide for the tyre industry [10]
Loss during drying (105 °C) max. 0.5 %
Ignition residue (950 °C) min. 99.0 %
Sieve residue (0.045 mm) max. 0.05 %
Zinc oxide content min. 99.0 %
Cadmium content max. 300 mg/kg
Copper content max. 10 mg/kg
Lead content max. 0.4 %
Manganese content max. 10 mg/kg
Sulphur content max. 0.02 %
Nitrogen surface (BET) min. 5 m2/g
In the ceramic industry there is no special quality for zinc oxide. In this sector zinc oxides
with a lower quality are saleable. The pharmaceutical industry shows the highest standards
regarding to the purity of the input materials. In this field the maximum content of impurities
are as follows:
5 ppm Arsenic
10 ppm Cadmium
200 ppm Iron
50 ppm Lead
Beside zinc oxide, zinc sulfate represents an important zinc compound. 51 % of the
produced zinc sulfate is used in agriculture. Typically, this material is produced by dissolving
zinc oxide in sulfuric acid. As alternative to the sulfate the carbonate can also be applied in this
area. Critical elements like arsenic, cadmium, chromium, lead and mercury accumulate in the
soil and possibly enter the food chain through crop plants and groundwater. The content of these
elements is limited in the ppm range but differs between several countries. [11,12]
The application of zinc oxide from the secondary industry for the production of zinc
fertilizer is difficult. Due to the contained impurities more purification steps are needed to reach
the low values of such elements.
4. Experimental
In the past, various concepts were developed to treat zinc-containing filter dust or similar
residues. As already mentioned above, the Waelz process is currently state-of-the-art for the
recycling of high zinc containing residues together with other waste materials to reach a zinc
content in the input mixture of around 23 wt.-%. At the moment it is not possible to treat
materials which show a lower zinc value although they occur in the industry. Therefore, some
integrated steel mills put an effort on getting independent from recyclers and develop their own
technology to treat the zinc-containing dust, which mainly occurs at the Basic Oxygen Furnace.
One example of such a concept is the so called “Flash Reactor”. Equal to the Waelz process a
zinc oxide is produced, which can be collected in a filter house together with a heavy metal-free
slag. The advantage of the process lies in the possible treatability of low-grade residues
regarding to the zinc value without prior agglomeration. A Flash Reactor pilot testing plant is
available at the Chair of Thermal Processing Technology, Montauniversitaet Leoben. Fig. 3
represents the 3D view of this plant.
The process starts at the mixing cyclone followed by the reaction vessel where the
separation of zinc takes place. The off-gas runs into the converter and the slag is tapped at the
bottom of the vessel. Post combustion and cooling is the main part of the converter. The last
part is the spray tower where the gas is quenched to 150 °C which is low enough for the filter
system. The crude zinc oxide gets collected in the filter and the flue gas leaves the system over
the chimney. [13]
During the cooling of the gas some amount of the solid zinc containing product settle at
the bottom of the spray tower quenching system. This collected residue is characterized through
a greater particle size, a higher iron content and a lower zinc content in comparison to the crude
zinc oxide. The iron content of the crude zinc oxide was 5.9 % and the quenching residues
shows concentrations of 14.5 % during the investigated trials. To utilize both zinc containing
products they get mixed together which results in a total average iron content of 7.4 %. The
separate treatment of the filter dust will become more attractive for the zinc industry due to the
lower iron content.
Fig. 3: 3D-view of the Flash Reactor pilot plant at the Chair of Thermal Processing
Technology, Montauniversitaet Leoben
The generated mixture consists 82.4 % of the filter dust and 17.6 % of the residue from
the quenching system. Due to the existing impurities in the mixture from the Flash Reactor
treatment, a double washing step - similar to the processing of Waelz oxide - was performed to
remove the existing halides. The target is to determine the difference in the product quality
between the mixed Flash Reactor product and the Waelz oxide after a leaching step.
The chemical analysis of both raw materials for the washing step are displayed in Tab. 4.
Only elements which are relevant for the primary zinc industry are considered.
Tab. 4: Comparison of the mixed Flash Reactor product and crude Waelz oxide
Flash Reactor dust* Mixed Flash Reactor
product
crude Waelz oxide
[wt-%] [wt-%] [wt-%]
Ca 1.40 1.59 0.60-1.20
Fe 5.93 7.43 1.20-1.40
Pb 1.09 1.04 4.00-5.20
Zn 63.7 62.3 57.20-62.80
Cl 1.078 1.049 5.20-8.50
F 0.093 0.096 0.07-0.50
*Without the settled material from the Spray Tower
By operating the Flash Reactor process with an air ratio of 0.8–0.9, the results from Tab.
4 are reproducible. In this case, the zinc content of the Flash Reactor dust is nearly equal to the
crude Waelz oxide from the Waelz kiln, by using an input material for the Flash Reactor with
12.9 % zinc. Lower halide values are recognizable in the Flash Reactor products, which is an
advantage due to the damaging effects of chlorine and fluorine in the zinc electolysis. Fig. 4
represents the process flow for the pilot washing trials, starting with the Flash Reactor and
ending with the washed zinc oxide.
Fig. 4: Flow Sheet of the treatment of steel mill dust with the Flash Reactor
The zinc-containing material from the Flash Reactor, designated as “Secondary Zinc Oxide” in
Fig. 4 and the residue of the quenching system, was supplied from the Chair of Thermal
Processing Technology. The concept for the washing procedure with soda was specified with
the knowledge from the Chair of Nonferrous Metallurgy regarding to their experience in the
product upgrade of zinc-containing materials. The used leaching tanks were provided from
“ARP Aufbereitung, Recycling und Prüftechnik GesmbH”, located in Leoben Austria and are
shown in Fig. 5. Water was added to the Flash Reactor mixed product in order to generate a
suspension, which was continuously mixed in an indirect heated leaching tank. During this
washing process, soda was added discontinuously to reach a defined pH value and to minimize
the zinc loss in the solution. Subsequently, a solid-liquid separation took place in a filter press.
The washing itself was performed twice with different solid-liquid ratios in order to reach the
most possible purification.
Fig. 5: Pilot plant of the washing unit of the Flash Reactor mixed product
5. Results
After the performed double leaching of the mixed Flash Reactor product an extensively
chemical analysis was done. To verify the results, three different labs analysed the same
samples. In Tab. 5 the standard Waelz oxide is contrasted to the treated mixed Flash Reactor
product. Once more, only relevant elements for the primary zinc industry are described.
Tab. 5: Contrast of the zinc containing products from the Flash Reactor and the Waelz kiln
after a double leaching
Mixed Flash Reactor product
(double leached)
Waelz oxide
(double leached)
[wt-%] [wt-%]
Mg 0.34 0.30-0.60
Ca 1.91 1.30-3.20
Fe 7.7 2.30-4.60
Pb 0.95 3.90-6.00
Zn 63.6 65.00-68.00
Cl 0.11 0.05-0.2
F 0.06 <0.10-0.25
Regarding to the results, the mixed Flash Reactor product shows halide values in the range
of the double leached Waelz oxide after the washing. The iron content of the Flash Reactor
shows a higher value regarding to the Waelz oxide. This results by the existing gas flow in the
Flash Reactor. Through optimizations of the burner system, this carry over problem can be
solved. The zinc content is nearly the same and by reducing the carry over, the zinc content will
increase. The advantage of the Flash Reactor lies in the possibility to recycle low-grade zinc-
containing residues. In the Waelz kiln only residues with a zinc content higher 25 % are
recyclable. The lower zinc content in the Flash Reactor material can also be explained through
the generally low zinc content of the used steel mill dust for these experiments. In general the
composition of each zinc dust depends on the feeding material of the process. In case of the
steel mill dust the amount of zinc-coated scrap is essential.
Further Flash Reactor experiments show that the best product results are reached by
running the process with an air ratio of 0.7. The improvement of the Flash Reactor dust results
in a better product quality after the washing step. Therefore, the dust of the Flash Reactor is
regarding to the zinc content comparable with the Waelz oxide although the zinc content of the
feeding material of the Flash Reactor is lower.
The treatment of zinc residues with the Flash Reactor is possible but does not lead to a
dust which can directly be used in the leaching stage of the primary industry due to the
impurities like iron, magnesium and halides. First, iron is critical due to its nobler behaviour in
comparison to zinc. In the common hydrometallurgical route the iron is precipitated as jarosite.
Through a weak acid leaching, the iron content in the solution can be held at a minimum amount
but zinc, which is combined with iron, gets lost in the leaching residue. Today, the Waelz oxides
enter the primary zinc process route at the roaster where the formation of iron-zinc-phases takes
place. Hence, it is useful to treat the secondary zinc oxides separately. Secondly, halides show
negative effects on the electrodes in the zinc electrolysis. Chlorine leads to a corrosion of the
lead anode and the production of chlorine gas proves to be problematic for the working safety.
Furthermore, the presence of fluorine causes the formation of hydrofluoric acid which dissolves
the aluminium oxide layer of the cathode. Thus, the zinc precipitates on the blank aluminium
and leads to problems at the stripping process. In order to avoid these problems, the chlorine
content has to be lower than 100 mg/L and the fluorine content has to be lower than 50 mg/L.
Additionally, magnesium is also critical for the production of zinc as it changes the
electrodeposited zinc’s morphology and causes the occurrence of a zinc reduction at a more
negative potential. At magnesium concentrations lower 10 g/L the current efficiency increases
and the energy consumption decreases, however, these positive effects get eliminated by
concentrations greater or equal of 15 g/L. Also the viscosity of the electrolyte increases.
Additional to the viscosity change the size of magnesium and zinc ions is similar and high
concentrations of magnesium complicates the transportation of zinc ions to the electrode and
their deposition. [14, 15]
Nevertheless, selling the material to the zinc winning industry is possible but only the
zinc gets paid and adding the secondary zinc oxide into the roaster pretreatment can lead to the
formation of zinc ferrite which is negative as mentioned before. Furthermore, the addition into
the roaster is limited due to cooling effects and accretion formation caused by lead and halides.
Therefore, it is useful to apply a pH controlled leaching step to minimize the iron content if this
element is not combined to zinc.
6. Summary
To sum up, the recycling of steel mill dust is a necessity due to the declaration as
hazardous waste in the EU. As valuable metals zinc plays the most important role followed by
lead and iron. In the course of the experiments steel mill dust from the Basic Oxygen Furnace
was recycled with a Flash Reactor in order to generate a zinc oxide which can be used for the
production of different zinc products. The dust was leached with soda twice to eliminate the
halides which are critical. In comparison to the Waelz oxide (80 % of the steel mill dust gets
recycled via this route) the mixed Flash Reactor dust shows slightly higher amounts of zinc and
significant more iron, by lower amounts of halides. The remaining content of chlorine and
fluorine is too high to use the dust directly in the leaching stage of the primary zinc production,
therefore a purification like a washing step is needed. The iron which is nobler and a colouring
component also shows significantly negative effects. However, the Flash Reactor is able to
recycle low-grade zinc containing residues which reduces masses for landfill and the produced
dust is comparable with the Waelz oxide. An additional advantage of the Flash Reactor concept
is the remaining slag, which is low in zinc and high in iron, therefore it can be used as input
material for the hot metal production.
References
[1] L. Southwick, Zinc Recovery from Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) dust – Worldwide
Survey, Report for the International Lead and Zinc Study Group, January 2015
[2] World Steel Association: World Steel in Figures 2016,
http://www.worldsteel.org/media-centre/press-releases/2016/World-Steel-in-Figures-
2016-is-available-online.html, excess 28.12.2015
[3] Statista, Global Zinc Production, https://www.statista.com/statistics/264878/world-
production-of-zinc-metal/, excess 28.12.2016
[4] C. Pichler and J. Antrekowitsch, Strategies for the treatment of metallurgical recycling
slags, Proceeding, Wastes, Viana do castelo (2015), p. 221-228
[5] H. Martens, Recyclingtechnik, Book, Heidelberg (2011), p.141-145
[6] GESTIS Stoffdatenbank,
http://gestis.itrust.de/nxt/gateway.dll/gestis_de/000000.xml?f=templates$fn=default.ht
m$vid=gestisdeu:sdbdeu$3.0, excess 27.01.2017
[7] B. Turner, P. Binning and S. Stipp, Fluoride removal by calcite, Environmental
Science & Technology (2005, Volume 39), p.9561-9568
[8] L. Hartinger, Handbuch der Abwasser- und Recyclingtechnik München (1991,
Volume 2)
[9] M. Islam and R. Patel, Evaluation of removal efficiency of fluoride from aqueous
solution using quick lime, Journal of hazardous materials (2007, Volume 143), p. 303-
310
[10] S. Steinlechner, Amelioration and market strategies for zinc oxide with focus on
secondary resources, PhD, May 2013
[11] S. Schlag, Global ZnO Supply/Demand, International Zind and Zinc oxide conference,
Cancun, Mexico, 23.02.2011
[12] G. Tóth, T. Hermann, M.R. Da Silva and L. Montanarella, Heavy metals in agicultural
soils of the European Union with implications for food safety, Environment
International (2016, Volume 88), p. 299-309
[13] B. Geier, H. Raupenstrauch and K. Pilz, Crude zinc oxide production from steel mill
dusts with the RecoDust process, Proceeding, Pb-Zn 2015, Düsseldorf, Germany, p.
799-806
[14] J. Antrekowitsch and D. Offenthaler, Die Halogenproblematik in der Aufarbeitung
zinkhältiger Reststoffe, Berg- und Hüttenmännische Monatshefte (2010, Volume 155),
p. 31-39
[15] V.F.C. Lins, M.M.R. Castro, C.R.Araujo and D.B. Oliveira, Effect of nickel and
magnesium on zinc electrowinning using sulfate solutions, Brazilian Journal of
Chemical Engineering (2011, Volume 28), p. 475-482