Yeh 2008 the Social Constructionist Viewpoint on Gays and Lesbians and Their Information Behaviour

8/15/2019 Yeh 2008 the Social Constructionist Viewpoint on Gays and Lesbians and Their Information Behaviour

1/17

VOL. 13 NO. 4, DECEMBER, 2008

Contents | Author index | Subject index | Search | Home

The social constructionist viewpoint on gays

and lesbians, and their information behaviour

Nei-Ching Yeh

Department of Information and Communications, Shih-Hsin University, Taipei, Taiwan

Abstract

Introduction. Explores the social construction processes of gay and lesbian

worlds and the characteristics and meanings of their information behaviour

during the construction processes.

Method. Semi-structured qualitative interviews were utilized to explorehomosexuals' information behaviour from January to March 2006. In total,

there were fourteen participants: ten gays and four lesbians living in Taipei.

Analysis. The study adopted an inductive method for data analysis, which is

based on the constant comparison approach of Glaser and Strauss.

Results. Gays and lesbians used information to find others of the same sexual

preference to construct their homosexual worlds and become members of the

homosexual community. The two major information channels of the

respondents are the Internet and their personal mentors. Their information

behaviour had four purposes: self awareness, construction of their homosexual

world, accumulation of social capital, and confronting the structure of the

heterosexual-dominated society.

Conclusions. The model for the characteristics of gays' and lesbians'

information behaviour is explored. This study suggests a new perspective on

the role of information behaviour, which may not help people face certain

situations but which facilitates their construction of meaning amidst daily

living. This can help them become agents who are able to successfully

confront the structure of a heterosexual-dominated society.

CHANGE FONT

The social constructionist viewpoint on gays and lesbians, and... http://www.informationr.net/ir/13-4/paper364.html

1 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


2/17

Introduction

In Taiwanese society, homosexuality is still considered an abnormality. Members of this sexual

minority group are often subject discrimination (Yang 2000, Yen et al. 2007) and feel that they are

restrained by the heterosexual-dominated society. Living in a culture that places great emphasis on

family values and conformity to social norms, most homosexuals are forced to hide their

orientation ( Shaw 1997). Conditions like these lead them to hiding, fearing, and hating, hencehindering them from revealing their sexual orientation to others. In fact, it is difficult for them to

share their homosexuality with others. Such a phenomenon spurred the need for a study on how

homosexuals construct another world that is different from the one in which they grew up.

Consideration is also given to whether homosexuals' information behaviour reflects inhibitions or

any other characteristics. Previous research suggests that the Internet, as an information channel,

creates a space for homosexual groups where homosexuality is the norm rather than an exception

(Dishman 1997). In a separate study by Yang (2000), it was revealed that movements to advocate

equal human rights for homosexuals push greater visibility for the gay and lesbian community.

Despite this research the information behaviour of sexual minorities has received relatively little

research attention. This is what this study seeks to probe.

In the library and information science domain, the majority of previous research available on the

subject of gays or lesbians primarily concerned library usage, such as understanding what kinds of

services which libraries could offer to them. It was found that libraries played an important role in

offering these homosexuals space and collections, even though results revealed that the

interviewees remained unsatisfied with library service. The factors behind this dissatisfaction are

collection deficiencies, misunderstanding of their information needs, and librarians' homophobia

(Alyson 1984, Monroe 1988, Wyatt 1978, Parkinson 1987, Ashby 1987, Whitt 1993, Stenback and

Schrader 1999). Later research investigating the information needs and seeking behaviour of the

homosexual community emerged (Creelman and Harris 1990, Whitt 1993, Stenback and Schrader

1999, Hamer 2003).

Creelman and Harris (1990) investigated the information needs of lesbians when they were in the

process of recognizing, understanding and accepting their homosexual identity. Their study aimed

to provide empirical support for library collections. Whitt (1993) on the other hand, described the

information needs of lesbians as they use library functions and their level of satisfaction. Stenback

and Schrader (1999) explored the information needs of lesbians during the process of coming-out,

to reflect the effectiveness of information. An inquiry into the information-seeking behaviour of

gay males about coming-out was conducted by Hamer in 2003. The studies of Creelman and

Harris (1990), Whitt (1993) and Stenback and Schrader (1999) focused on the experience of

lesbians, while Hamer's (2003) centred on gays. Most studies used the qualitative approach to seekthe answers to the research questions, but only Whitt's (1993) study used surveys to collect data.

Collectively, these studies contributed to the body of knowledge on homosexuals' information

needs and information seeking behaviour, as well as on the subject of coming out. Specifically,

studies revealed the information needs that gays and lesbians encounter in relation to coming out.

It was found that this group of people cited libraries as a major information source. Factors

influencing gays' and lesbians' information seeking decisions were also determined.

Unfortunately, the sample populations used in studies usually focus either on gays or on lesbians.

Bodies of research which focus on both gays and lesbians and the attempt to understand their

information behaviour are rare. Besides, these studies assumed that the process of recognition of


2 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


3/17

one's homosexual identity is lineal and has different stages, from questioning one's sexual identity

to accepting it. It must be noted that because homosexuals need discrete reading space, libraries

often provide services for them. But the prevalence of Internet challenges these assumptions.

The above-mentioned research does not explain the information behaviour of gays and lesbians

completely. Findings revealed that libraries were heavily used by homosexuals as an information

resource because majority of them do not tend to publicly reveal themseves as homosexual at theinitial stage of establishing their sexual identity. In contrast, the virtual world of the Internet

provides them with a private and safe space to seek information or to make friends. The functions

of library space and collections have been replaced by the Internet. Again, other research assumes

that the processes of accepting one's homosexual identity is lineal and information needs appear

when gays or lesbians decide to come out and end when they do come out. However, this

assumption is questionable. Hamer (2003) proposes that the essentialist view of gay identity

generally regards coming out as a stage-based progression that links same-sex romantic or sexual

feelings with gayness, presuming a gay self as a pre-existing identity. In addition, the process

suggests a progression toward a particular result, which is the acceptance and disclosure of a gay

or lesbian identity.

Aside from these studies, along with the author's observations, there is no direct causality between

homosexual identity and coming out. Homosexual identity is socially derived through interaction

in specific contexts with other people. Homosexuals seek information in an effort to understand

something they do not understand. Still, it is a fact that some people find it difficult to accept the

identity of a gay or a lesbian, even though they have come out. In other words, not all gays and

lesbians come to terms with their own identities fully. This, however, does not hinder their

information seeking activities, in the same manner that people fall in love even before they really

understand what love means.

In addition, it can be said that librarians' homophobia is not actually the reason why they do notseem to satisfy homosexuals' information needs. An alternative explanation can be forwarded. It

may be that librarians ignore homosexuals' information needs. Librarians perceive them as

belonging to a minority and spend government's money on the majority.

As has been pointed out, existing bodies of research do not accord with the present times. There is

a need to question the above-mentioned assumption and to impose restrictions on the use of this

information. Of course, besides assumptions, research approaches also influence results. The use

of the social constructionist viewpoint in place of the linear process approach was considered in

this particular study.

In recent years, the constructionist viewpoint of exploring people's information behaviour hasbecome popular. Tuominen et al. (2005) provided a general introduction on this research

approach. Some researchers have already applied the social constructionist approach in their

studies. For instance, Tuominen and Savolainen (1996) offered a social constructionist theory to

study information use behaviour as discursive actions. On the other hand, Leong and

Al-Hawamdeh (1999) used a constructivist approach to understand the differences between sex

and learning attitudes in Web-based lessons. Chelton (2001) analysed two examples of the

processes of user categorization in professional communication to show how marginalization

occurs as a direct product of communicative activity. Olsson (2005) explored the information

behaviour researchers' social construction processes of meaning and significance. The Library

Quarterly published a special issue (volume 77, number 2) that focused on discursive approachesto information seeking in context gathering articles that applied the constructionist, discourse and


3 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


4/17

conversation analytic methods to studies (Talja and McKenzie 2007). Rarely is information

behaviour viewed as constitutive. Only one of these articles (Hamer 2003), directly examined

gays' information seeking about coming out, taking a social constructionist perspective on gay

identity. However, the discussion is limited to self-labelling, self-identifying as gay and its

consequences.

This study attempts to address social constructionist viewpoints on the constitutive processes of homosexuals' world and interprets their experience of information behaviour because of several

considerations. One is the existence of inappropriate assumptions, the results of which are

inconsistent with the conditions set by the information society. Limitations of the linear research

approach as used in previous research on gays' and lesbians' information behaviour also served as

a factor. This research sought to answer the following questions: How do gays and lesbians

construct their homosexual worlds? What are the characteristics of their information behaviour

during the processes of construction? and What are the purposes of their information behaviour

during the processes of construction?

Conceptual frameworkThe core idea that guides this research is social constructionist theory, particularly in that it

advocates the interaction between the individual and the social-cultural milieu and the ways in

which these interactions are used by people to construct meanings of their behaviour.

In the past, especially in the late 1970s and 1980s, the main aim of many information studies

researchers was to build general and universal information behaviour models. These models

suggest that individual users' information behaviour is influenced by group memberships and a

number of cultural, personal, situational, organizational and social factors (especially social norms,

values and customs) (Talja et al. 1999).

In order to resolve these limitations, Talja et al. (2005) provided some new research approaches to

information behaviour studies in their article "'Isms' in information science: Constructivism,

collectivism and constructionism." For example, collectivism assumes that individuals construct

their knowledge when interacting with the environment and that during the process, both the

individual and the environment are changed. Thus, the subject of study is the dialectical

relationship between the individual and the socio-cultural milieu. The core assumption of

collectivism is that applying psychological issues such as "relevance" concepts to study human

information behaviour are mistakes because individuals are social and cultural beings (see

Hjorland 1999).

This socio-cultural perspective is based on the idea that social practice develops on a collective

level through communicating with others and ends when the limited abilities of people's physical

and linguistic tools for dealing with the community that they work in are exhausted. From the

socio-cultural perspective, the nature of information seeking is symbolic and it will influence the

development of identities (Sundin and Johannisson 2005). As such, an understanding of people's

information seeking behaviour should start with an understanding of the communities of

justification which they participate in. Just as Jenkins (1996) stated, people's communicative

participation in social practices contribute to the creation of identities. Identities are seen here as

being created, maintained and socially changed through individuals' and groups' identification of

themselves in relation to how they are categorized by others.


4 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


5/17

During the processes of interacting with others, individual constructs and revises their ideas and

knowledge about the reality and the meanings of his/her activities. Hence, it can be said that

information or knowledge is neither objective nor subjective, but inter-subjective, produced within

a shared community of meaning (Talja 1996). As Dervin (1994) stated, reality is captured by

information. Information is also constructed as something that instructs person as to the nature of

reality, reduces people's uncertainty about the world and helps people resolve problems and

complete tasks. Wilson (1999) espoused the same idea. Information seekers are active in socialand cultural situations and steered by the norms, values and expectations present in these

situations.

Jacob and Shaw's (1998) study also shaped this research. They proposed the application of the

activity theory in exploring people's information behaviour. An individual, immediately after birth,

lives at once as a physically, socially and subjectively constructed being and he/she compiles

his/her knowledge through interacting with others. Personal knowledge is constructed through

acting. It influences people's determinant for subsequent actions; at the same time, it modifies the

individual's knowledge. In this way, the individual, as an actor, constructs internal knowledge of

facts, values and procedures through ongoing interaction between his/her internalized knowledge

and his/her participation in the external world. Knowledge is both explicit and implicit. It can be

communicated through language and it can be embedded in individual's particular activities

without being perceived.

Also, Dervin's invention of sense-making theory (Tidline 2005) suggested that people's activities

or behaviour implies some meaning, which may or may not be explicit. This idea of sense-making

corresponds to the philosophy of social constructionist which states that people construct the

meanings of their behaviour through interacting with the socio-cultural environment. This theory

consists of a set of conceptual and theoretical premises and related methodologies for assessing

how people make sense of their worlds and how they use information and other resources in the

process. It applies 'situation-gap-use' concepts to describe people's information behaviour (Dervinand Nilan 1986). These concepts provided guidance to this research. However, this study did not

apply the three concepts mentioned above to describe homosexuals' information behaviour.

Solomon's (2002) term information discovery proved relevant to this study's purpose. Solomon

labelled the behaviour that people use to discover, shape, or create information as part of their

lives and work as discovering involvement in context. The discovery of information characterizes

it as constructed through involvement of an individual in various activities, problems, tasks and

social and technological structures. Guided by this approach, Solomon (1997) used the

ethnography research method of communication to explore individuals' information behaviour in

annual work planning of a unit of a public agency.

Moreover, McKenzin's (2003) model of information practices, which focuses on the social concept

of information behaviour, can be related to this study. The model consists of four modes, namely:

active seeking, active scanning, non-directed monitoring and by proxy, along with two phases:

connecting and interacting. McKenzie's concepts correspond to Wilson's (1997) passive search,

Choo et al's (2000) conditioned viewing and Erdelez's (1996) browsing. They have revealed that

practice can reflect the dynamic states of people's activities or behaviour in daily life. These ideas

ultimately led to the conceptualization of this research.

Methodology


5 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


6/17

This study took the social constructionist viewpoint as its research approach. Within this

perspective, data were gathered premised on the idea that individuals construct their meanings

through interaction with the social-cultural milieu.

Homosexuals were chosen as respondents of this study for the reason that most people regard

them lowly, especially in early Taiwanese society. Without the efforts of homosexuals to initiate

social movements to claim their rights, they will not have a chance to speak publicly. Eventually,more and more people, including homosexuals themselves, became open to homosexuality (Yang

2000). Before exploring their sexual orientation, a majority of homosexuals lack homosexual-

related knowledge and need to construct a new world view. This fact shapes the motivation of this

research to explore homosexual information behaviour, focusing on the construction processes of

the homosexual world.

From January to March 2006, face to face interviews were conducted to explore the characteristic

of information behaviour as gays and lesbians constructed their homosexual worlds. Contact was

made initially through the referral of the author's student, although the student is not a lesbian.

Then a snowball sampling approach was used to locate participants. A total of fourteen

interviewees, including ten gays and four lesbians, served as the respondents. All of them lived inTaipei and their ages ranged from 15 to 35. The range of their age during coming out was four to

twenty years old and the majority were well educated. Data collection was made until the indices

of saturation were reached, such as repetition of the information already obtained.

First, the participants were asked to think back on their experiences upon discovering their sexual

orientations. They were requested to relate any thoughts or feelings they had about their lives

before the interview. By asking open-ended questions, the researcher tried to determine the

processes of participants' construction of their homosexual world. In other words, the respondents

reviewed their past and these stories were jointly constructed by them, along with the researcher.

The following questions were asked to solicit responses on specific incidents:

What was the first situation that caused you to think that you might be a gay or lesbian?1.

Which information resources have you accessed in order to help you understand the

homosexual's world?

2.

Why did you choose these resources? What were the meanings of these resources for you?3.

During the processes of understanding the homosexuals' world, what was the greatest

challenge that you encountered when seeking or using information?

4.

During the processes of determining to come out or not, did you use any information to help

you make the decision? What were the reasons for using the information?

5.

What were the thoughts and feelings which you experienced during these processes?6.Please describe the resources that helped you most and the experiences that strongly

impressed you.

7.

After the collected data had been studied, clues related to information behaviour were analysed.

The next step entailed posing information behaviour-related queries. Essentially, the use of

follow-up questions helped in obtaining more in-depth answers, thus giving further insight into the

topic. Interviews took place in a locale chosen by the participants. Each individual interview lasted

from one to two hours and these were transcribed for analysis. The research adopted an inductive

approach to analyse data. The constant comparison approach by Glaser and Strauss served as basis

for the analysis in order to detect themes and patterns in relation to participants' constructionprocesses of their homosexual world and information behaviour.


6 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


7/17

Findings

Results reported here are retrospective and reflective in identifying important issues which

emerged in the study. The majority of the experiences described by the respondents suggested the

following sections: the construction of homosexual worlds; the characteristics; and the purposes of

information behaviour during the construction processes. What follows are the findings from the

interviews.

The construction of homosexual world

This section is categorized into three parts: exploring another himself or herself, the mentor and

joining a homosexual group and entering a new world.

Exploring another himself or herself

When subjects found themselves attracted to people of the same sex rather than of the opposite

sex, they sensed that they were different from their same-sex friends and they found themselves ina suspicious confusion. The feelings of uncertainty made them eager to confirm their real sexual

orientation. At this moment, they may ask themselves the question: 'What is happening to me?'

Initial experiences of preferring same-sex romance and enjoying sex with people of the same

gender could be big surprises for the respondents. At times, these experiences mixed with the

feeling of fear. For example, interviewee J said,

I always felt that my classmates, who made boy and girl friends, were strange. I tried

to do so like them, but I just liked people of the same sex.

At this point, the respondents were not disturbed by this thought: 'whether or not they needed to

accept and admit that they are gays or lesbians'. The word identity was still strange to them. They

simply knew that they liked members of the same sex and there was the possibility that they could

become good friends quickly and naturally. The respondents' same-sex romance led them to live a

homosexual life. At this point, information was important to help them open the door to the

homosexual world. In the following exploration processes, their information behaviour was rich.

However, the exploration processes were obscure and subjects dared not let others (including

family members) know their sexual orientation. This is because in a heterosexual hegemony

society, subjects felt that heterosexuals had negative views on their sexual orientation, stigmatized

them and even insinuated that they were spreading AIDS. Heterosexuals also thought that

homosexuals do not have a promising future because they were without descendants to take careof them when they reach old age. These kinds of ideas originated from Taiwanese traditional filial

culture which emphasises the importance of getting married and having children and sees this as

corresponding to social norms. Even more, there is one popularly accepted saying in Chinese

society: 'Of the three sins of lack of filial piety, the greatest is to have no sons.' It means if people

do not have any children, they are not dutiful sons. Parents, who have homosexual children even

feel inferior and blame themselves for giving birth to an 'abnormal child'. As interviewee A

pointed out,

When I was young, I was educated that homosexuals were abnormal. Homosexuals

put their families to shame. My parents always told me that if you were a homosexual,

then you do not have a bright future.


7 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


8/17

Social morals constitute people's ideology that inappropriate sexual behaviour makes sexually

active people prone to acquiring AIDS and homosexuals are those whose sexual behaviour borders

on excessive. Moreover, in a heterosexual hegemony society, the media often communicate

inaccurate messages, which tend to produce negative impressions of homosexuals.

After the respondents confirmed their sexual orientation, regardless of the pressures posed by the

Taiwanese society or even their family members and whether or not they indicated a strong orlimited homosexual identity, most of them hoped to find another gay or lesbian to satisfy their

emotional needs. The subjects did not clearly distinguish between acts and identity. There is not a

cause and effect relation between coming-out and identity. The respondents took part in

homosexual life, but did not think that they need to see themselves as homosexuals. It was

possible that gays'/lesbians' homosexual identities were not enough, but still, they came out of the

closet and became open about their lifestyle.

Identity is a key factor when people construct their subjective reality while keeping a dialectical

relationship with physical reality. During the socialization processes, an individual's identity will

be shaped, revised and reshaped. Socialization is determined by the social structure. To illustrate,

legalization and institutionalization can strengthen identity. However, the identity itself isconstructed by the interweaving of the human organism, consciousness and the existing structure

of the society. Different historical and social structures evoke different kinds of identities. People's

behaviour is based on these principles of identities in daily life (Berger and Luckmann 1991).

Homosexuals have the need for both love and sex within the context of a same-sex relationship.

They apply social and cultural resources and personal experiences to construct the meaning of

being a homosexual. Their homosexual identity makes them experience stability and a sense of

belonging to one community. Legalization (being accepted by the society) and institutionalization

(being shaped by the environment) strengthen identity. From this viewpoint, information seeking

becomes the key point during construction processes. Interviewee K described this occurrence.

Actually, there was no such word as 'homosexual' sixteen years ago in Taiwan. I never

questioned that I was different from my same-sex friends. It was a very complicated

state, so I did not admit to it. Perhaps, I just felt a little curious when reading the

newspaper or watching the TV about homosexual news. In fact, I was confused with

my identity at that time, especially my sexual orientation!

He continued,

But I wanted to know the places where homosexual communities gather and interact. I

thought there was a process involved. My homosexual identity surfaced slowly.

In order to know people like themselves and to construct homosexual identity, a homosexual

shows successive information seeking behaviour. When homosexuals explore another world, they

exercise curiosity and demand for a sense of ownership. They search and interact with

information, grasp this world's conditions through interaction, construct their worldviews of

another world and learn to become a member of the homosexual community.

Mentor

This study followed the perspective of social constructionism. It attempted to understand thecommunities where the respondents participated in and found that in a homosexual community,


8 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


9/17

there exists a so called master and apprentice phenomenon. For example, a mentor helped one of

the respondents recognize his same-sex romantic inclinations. A mentor is important because

when one finds that s/he is a gay or lesbian, s/he needs to look for others like themselves.

Associations like this help a person to engage in friendship so s/he can grasp the overall picture of

the homosexual world quickly. When the respondents had their first encounter with fellow gay

community members, most of the time, they did not have companions of the same sex. Mentors

play the role leading them to assimilate into the homosexual community and they exercise greatinfluence upon them. Hamer (2003) indicated that homosexuals needed mentors and it was even

asserted that gay mentors can be compared to role models.

Here is one analogy to describe the importance of mentors. When people go hiking in a strange

forest, while exploring the wilderness, there is a great probability of getting lost. By chance, they

may encounter other hikers and decide to go on an adventure together. Along the way, they

influence each other's cognition of the forest and decision making on what trail to tread. The

following is interviewee K's example:

In my first work, I have one homosexual friend [according to interviewee K's

statement, he is his mentor], and I draw homosexual information from him. Forexample, through his instruction, I began to widen my knowledge about

homosexuality and knew where the other homosexuals like to get together.

In addition, interviewee H pointed out that other people were important to gays and lesbians,

because mentors serve as bridges who help them make the transition from heterosexual world into

homosexual world. Mentors are knowledgeable about homosexuality and their wide homosexual

experience guided newcomers in entering the homosexual community. This is further attested by

interviewee H:

I always went with my roommate (also a homosexual) because I seldom participatedactively in the activities of homosexual communities. He lived a homosexual lifestyle

and I also lived that way too, under his guidance. Having a role model is really

important for many gays and lesbians.

Mentors also served as a source of emotional support for the respondents, except in being

information gatekeepers. The respondents secured powerful backers during their sexual orientation

exploration, particularly when their identities were not so clear and self-understandings were not

enough. Interviewee H related,

A mentor is important so I can face the pressure and bias of the heterosexual society.

Therefore, I, my mentor and a high school classmate often ate out and played togethera lot when I learned about my being a homosexual. We could be regarded as 'three

sisters.'

While a mentor's importance is well established, it is also possible that respondents acquired

inappropriate cognitions about the homosexual world because mentors provided them inaccurate

information.

Joining homosexual communities and walking into new worlds

After the guidance given by mentors to homosexuals in their initial contact with homosexualcommunities, newly integrated gays and lesbians now found the need to follow social norms


9 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


10/17

within these communities. They should dress like other members do, mingle with them and try to

be accepted by them. Their only hope is to become a member of the group as soon as possible.

The community members' lifestyle shaped the subjects' behaviour and ideas gradually, until they

eventually learn homosexual culture. For example, interviewee A noted:

The rules of homosexual communities were 'invisible,' but powerful. If we disobeyed

the rules, we would be excluded from membership in the groups.

The respondents construct their values by following homosexual communities' standards and hope

that they belong to the groups. Therefore, the homosexuals are ruled by these norms with

information serving as their aid during the processes of construction. As interviewee H said:

Sex is important to gays and lesbians, but homosexual-related knowledge is more

vital. You need to follow the norms of homosexual communities; for example, you

must exercise, be 'delicious' and beautiful and wash your face with milk twice a day

so you would have the chance to meet a boy or girlfriend in the homosexual world

and thus satisfy your sexual needs.

Information helped the subjects to create the ideas that strengthen their abilities to endure the

pressures and biases springing from the heterosexual world. Interviewee K withstood the outside

pressure as can be inferred from his following statement:

Homosexual-related books helped me survive in the heterosexual-dominant society.

Many questions surfaced after I 'came out,' and these books helped me know the

answers and decide on what I should do. Now, when someone challenges my sexual

orientation, information helps me defend myself.

Many gays and lesbians joined homosexual groups not so much for emotional support, but for sex.

This kind of sex that is not based on love made them feel empty. In addition, there is theprobability of being infected with a sexual disease, especially if they lack sufficient information on

safe sex. This scenario is very contradictory. However, joining the community allows the

respondents not to feel alone, thereby, satisfying their emotional needs.

Characteristics of the information behaviour of gays and lesbians

Heavy use of the Internet

The Internet is the most heavily used resource because it protects one's identity through

anonymity. In other words, it is able to conceal a homosexual's information seeking behaviour.Through searching, scanning, or monitoring, subjects found valuable information on seeking

others with the same homosexual identity and they shared thoughts and feelings with them.

There are three advantages for using the Internet as an information source. First, homosexuals can

participate in gay communities and establish friendships easily and quickly. Usually, they meet

their mentors through the Internet. They may become an imaginational community (as do many

others). An imaginational community means that a group of people feel they belong to the same

community, even though they do not know one another. Visiting the same homosexual Web sites

lets makes them feel that 'there is someone like me in the world '. Second, the information on the

Internet facilitates self-understanding and representation for the respondents. Information is usedto clarify and affirm their homosexual identity, enabling them to face social pressures. Their


10 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


11/17

self-understanding is strengthened through interaction with other people. Hence, the Internet has

become the most commonly used channel to search for information. Third, the Internet provids the

respondents with an avenue to encounter ideas about homosexuality. They obtain information

about new events, or exchange information with other members of the community. The Internet

provides respondents with many kinds of information, including common sense and practical

knowledge that can be applied in daily living. Pre-understanding is the key point for obtaining rich

information from the Internet. This is because if one is knowledgeable, or in other words, if one'spre-understanding of the homosexual world is enough, one has the ability to make links between

the different information being located. One's pre-understanding helps one to make this easily and

quickly.

For the respondents, establishing friendship on the Internet resulted in two contradictory feelings.

On one hand, without the limitation of time and space on the Internet respondents could make

friends easily. Giddens' (1984) concept of time-space compression can be applied to describe the

respondents' characteristic eager desires to making friends on the Internet. On the other hand, the

scope of a typical homosexual community is limited and homosexuals still act within a distinct

and small world. Therefore, the chance of making friends is limited. Furthermore, there is a

popular belief in the homosexual community that youth passes away quickly. If a gay or a lesbian

is not able to find a close companion before they are 30 years old, the chances of doing so past that

age would be slim. Therefore, respondents cared about their appearance and paid close attention to

dressing well and maintaining good health.

Homosexuals frequent some places, such as parks, gay bars and bookstores in order to meet

friends face to face. However, the invisibility of a homosexual group makes them prefer to seek

out friends using the Internet. In this study, the strongest motivations behind Internet use are social

interaction and information. As many people seek information one the Internet, it is hard for

participants to judge whether information is true or not, this them anxiety. As interviewee A said:

I know of some gays/lesbians who hope to improve their sexual abilities and they seek

medical information from the Internet. They follow the information they obtain from

the Internet and try out some medicines. However, those medicines are used actually

to treat heart disease. In the other words, they took incorrect medicines.

Inability to seek homosexual information from library collections

Results show that the library was not consulted for information resources by the respondents. They

thought that libraries' collections for the homosexuals were limited and outdated. One participant

said perhaps the homophobic condition is still prevalent in Taiwanese libraries. He suggested thatthis condition influences the library's selection policy which results in poor collections on

homosexuality. To put it bluntly, the homosexual-related collections are considered as

heterodoxies and are excluded from the collection selection policy.

Purposes of gays' and lesbians' information behaviour

Basically, individuals use information to help them act in society and create meanings from the

experience. This section therefore discusses the purposes of the information behaviour of gays and

lesbians , which falls into four dimensions:

self awareness;1.


11 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


12/17

constructing the homosexual world;2.

broaden the mental horizon; and3.

confronting the processes from a heterosexual society.4.

Self-awareness

Information helps gays and lesbians find out about themselves. For instance, when the subjectsfirst found that they liked people of the same sex, they might have asked themselves 'Am I

abnormal?', 'What is happening to me?' By virtue of accessing the right information, the answer

gradually becomes obvious. During the course of becoming members of homosexual

communities, members realized that information is a big help in understanding themselves.

Information also helped them accept their sexual orientation and stimulated them to explore

another world and eventually join homosexual communities. The following is interviewee K's

testimonial:

When I was a senior high school student, I read one magazine for gay men and there

were some tests for the readers to examine their sexual orientation. The results of mytest showed that I may be a gay man. This caused me much anxiety and encouraged

me to seek information about homosexuality.

Constructing the homosexual world

After recognizing their sexual orientation, the respondents needed to construct the homosexual

world which they were unfamiliar with. For example, they needed to learn how homosexuals

dressed and acted. By seeking and assimilating information from the Internet and from

homosexual communities, they learned how to behave appropriately in these communities and to

defend against queries posed by the society.

During the process of construction, two important issues that emerged are: coming-out and

identity. The respondents were not disturbed by the two issues. Jenkins's (1996) study was in

accordance with Stenback and Schrader's (1999) suggestion that to come out meant the

acknowledgement of an individual's homosexuality either to oneself or to others. This particular

event could be a very confusing and traumatic period in the life of homosexuals. Information

helped homosexuals affirm their confidence in their sexual orientation. They could share their

homosexual experience with anyone who could accept their sexual orientation, may that person be

a homosexual or a heterosexual. As interviewee H suggested:

Until we follow the social norms of homosexual communities, we are accepted bymainstream society. Therefore, we seek information to understand these rules until we

ultimately become members of the community.

Broaden the mental horizon

As McLuhan (1994) said, 'Media was men's extensions': perhaps, it can be said that 'information is

people's extension'. It extends people's vision, offers them space for imagination and provides

them pleasure and expectations. The most obvious example is the Internet. Respondents expect to

meet 'another person like them' on the Internet and hope that love would soon ensue. Homosexual-

related information helps them realize that they are not alone. This can be gleaned frominterviewee K's following statement:


12 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


13/17

Confirming my existence is very important to me. I need to know how to live on,

being a gay. Being seen by others without the feeling of fear is very important to me. I

was so unhappy until I heard something from the news and assimilated some

homosexual-related information. I felt that finally, homosexuals are recognized by the

society.

Confronting the processes from a heterosexual-dominated society

In Taiwanese society, heterosexual love is the norm and the majority of heterosexuals despise

homosexuals. For instance, gays are often regarded as 'sissies'. This is where the need for

homosexuals to confront pressures posed by a heterosexual-dominated society arises. As

interviewee A described:

When I was an elementary student and found that I liked people of the same sex, I

suspected that I was abnormal. I could not accept the fact that 'I am a gay,' and was

worried about it. Even more, I searched for ways to become a heterosexual. I typed,

'how to become a heterosexual' on the search engine of the Internet and found aninteresting Web page. It showed the following message: 'if you laugh five times a day,

you will become a heterosexual.' I really did this everyday until I learned that it was

all a hoax.

Discussion

Previous research findings contributed to the results of this study. They provided baseline

information on the information needs of homosexuals, such as where to find communities, how to

understand and affirm gay or lesbian identity, where to find other gays/lesbians, sex and health

concerns, learning the rules of the communities and coming out or not (Hamer 2003, Creelmanand Harris 1990, Whitt 1993). Over time, their information needs move from general to specific.

In Kuhlthau's (1993) words, they moved from relevant information to pertinent information. They

searched information about homosexual communities to further the degrees of self-acceptance

(Whitt 1993).

Hamer's (2003) study found that the library was the most significant resource when homosexuals

considered the idea of coming out. Gay and lesbian organizations and friends as resources were of

next importance. He also found that the conditions which are most strongly linked to information

seeking activities are the experiences of fear and concealment. The two most significant

information sources identified were the Internet and television. In this study, the Internet is

consulted as an important information resource for gays and lesbians. As Hamer (2003) said,heavy Internet use made sense intuitively because it supported the need for hidden information

seeking. Gay and lesbian organizations are likewise important. However, the study showed that the

library and television were insignificant resources.

Chatman's (1991) theory of small world can be applied to explain homosexuals' information

behaviour. The homosexual community is a small world and the members feel that their same-sex

relationship can only be understood by insiders. They also perceive that outsiders cannot

understand them and they feel frustrated when being excluded by the outsiders. Therefore, the

subjects opt not to seek information from outsiders.

Solomon's (2002, 1997) concept of discovering information was applied in data analysis. Solomon


13 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


14/17

suggested that information resembles something that is embedded in the fabric of people's lives

and work. Discovering information characterizes information as being constructed through

involvement in life's activities, problems, tasks and social and technological structures. It can be

said that respondents' information behaviour is similar to the experience of traveling in a strange

country. They need to explore homosexual worlds step by step. During the exploration processes,

they discover, accumulate and assimilate information until they have enough homosexual-related

knowledge and they can accept their sexual orientation fully. Conversely, browsing information onthe Internet to keep them updated became the most commonly used method to obtain information.

Figure 1 illustrates the changing characteristics of gays' and lesbians' information behaviour:

Figure 1: Model of characteristics of the information behaviour or gays and lesbians.

This figure is drawn based on the research findings along with Kuhlthau's (1993) model of the

information search process, particularly the idea of the interplay of thoughts, feelings and actions

when people experience information searching. Additionally, McKenzie (2002, 2003) describes

four dimensions of people's attempt to connect to information sources: active seeking, active

scanning, everyday monitoring and information seeking by proxy. Everyday monitoring is

recognized in this study. The work of Savolainen (1995), Wilson (1999) and Williamson (1998)

also addresses this type of information acquisition.

This indicates that when homosexuals find their sexual orientations to be different from same-sex

individuals, they are surprised and are eager to understand the homosexual world. This uncertainty

stimulates their curiosity to seek information in order to clarify their sexual orientation and to

make friends, especially through the Internet. The mentors whom they encounter accidentally

serve as the key persons who lead them into the homosexual world.

During the processes of discovering information, they accumulate homosexual-related knowledge

to arrive at their own construct of a homosexual world. At the same time, their sensitivities for

homosexual information increases; they can seek information easily and thus become super-

information-encounterers (addressed by Erdelez 1996). As soon as they gain enough knowledgeabout the homosexual world and can accept their sexual orientation, they become members of the


14 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


15/17

homosexual communities. At this point, they seldom seek new information actively. On the

contrary, they make up by monitoring information through the Internet every day or when they

have free time. As Bates (2002) stated, monitoring is a kind of direct but passive behaviour.

However, when monitoring, alertness for things of interest and for answers to problems is

maintained.

In this study, one surprising finding is that a relationship between homosexual identity and anincrease in homosexual-related knowledge is not obvious. Even though the subjects live as gays

and lesbians, some of them still have doubts as to their sexual orientations. But they do not engage

in seeking information for the purpose of identification. As usually, they only monitor information

on the Internet.

Conclusions

The aim of this paper is to apply the social constructionist viewpoint on gays' and lesbians'

information behaviour. The social constructionist approach in this study contributes in suggesting

that human information behaviour may be understood by focusing on the long-term interactionbetween humans and information. The author also offers a model for conceptualizing

homosexuals' information behaviour.

Theoretically, this study addresses the usefulness of the concepts of accumulation and monitoring

when investigating people's methods of obtaining information. These two concepts complement

the concept of information seeking. Also, this study reveals that information helps people in

confronting pressures from the society and in making sense of their daily life. Giddens' (1984)

emphasises the skills of a human agent and suggests that a human being can be a free agent and

confront the restricted structures within their environment.

Methodologically, this study finds that homosexual communities are important for gays andlesbians. Members of these communities provide helpful information and more so, valuable

emotional support. The social network of the communities could be an important issue for further

study. The ethnography of Internet-related behaviour could be a practical method to explore this

subject, as more and more people make friends on the Internet. We also need a study considering

the differences between hetero- and homosexual identity and related information behaviour. It may

lead to a deeper and holistic understanding of homosexuals' information behaviour.

Acknowledgements

The paper benefited from the thoughtful feedback of its anonymous reviewers.


15 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


16/17

References

Alyson, S. (1984). What librarians should know about gay and lesbian publishing.

Collection Building, 6(1), 22-23.

Ashby, R. (1987). Library Services to gay and lesbian people. Assistant Librarian,

80(10), 154.

Bates, M. (2002). Toward an integrated model of information seeking and searching.

New Review of Information Behaviour Research, 3, 1-15.

Berger, P. & Luckmann, T. (1991). The social construction of reality: a treatise in

the sociology of knowledge. London: Penguin Books.

Chatman, E. A. (1991). Life in a small world: applicability of gratification theory to

information-seeking behaviour. Journal of the American Society for Information

Science, 42(6), 438-449.

Chelton, M.K. (2001). Young adults as problems: how the social construction of a

marginalized user category occurs. Journal of Education for Library and

Information Science, 42(1), 4-11.

Choo, C.W. & Auster, E. (1993). Environmental scanning: acquisition and use of information by managers. Annual Review of Information Science and Technology,

28, 279-314.

Choo, C.W., Detlor, B. & Turnbull, D. (2000). Information seeking on the Web: an

integrated model of browsing and searching. First Monday, 5(2). Retrieved 30

September, 2008 from http://firstmonday.org/issues/issue5_2/choo/

Creelman, Janet A. E. & Harris, R.M. (1990). Coming out: the information needs of

lesbians. Collection Building, 10(3/4), 37-41.

Dervin, B. (1994). Information democracy: an examination of underlying

assumptions. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 45(6),

369-385.Dervin, B. & Nilan, M. (1986). Information needs and uses. Annual Review of

Information Science and Technology, 21, 3-33.

Dishman, J.D. (1997). Digital dissidents: the formation of gay communities on the

Internet . Unpublished MA thesis, University of Southern California, Los Angeles,

California, USA.

Erdelez, S. (1996). Information encountering: a conceptual framework for accidental

information discovery. In Vakkari, P., Savolainen, R. and Dervin, B. (eds). I.

Information seeking in context: proceedings of an international conference on

Research in Information Needs, Seeking and Use in Different Contexts, Tampere,

Finland. (pp. 412-421). London: Taylor Graham.

Giddens, A. (1984). The constitution of society: outline of the theory of

structuration. Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press.

Glaser, B.G. & Strauss, A.L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: strategies

for qualitative research. New York, NY: Aldine Publishing Corporation.

Hamer, J.S. (2003). Coming-out: gay male's information seeking. School Libraries

Worldwide, 9(2), 73-89.

Hjørland, B. (1997). Information seeking and subject representation: an activity-

theoretical approach to information science. Westport, CT.: Greenwood Press.

Hjørland, B. (1999). Theory and metatheory of information science: a new

interpretation. Journal of Documentation, 54(5), 606-621.

Jacob, E.K. & Shaw, D. (1998). Socio-cognitive perspectives on representation. Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, 33, 131-85.


16 de 17 07/05/14 23:18


17/17

How to cite this paper

Yeh, N-C. (2008). "The social constructionist viewpoint on gays and lesbians, and their

information behaviour" Information Research, 13(4) paper 364. [Available at

http://InformationR.net/ir/13-4/paper364.html]

Find other papers on this subject

Scholar Search Google Search Windows Live

Check for citations, using Google Scholar

Bookmark This Page

© the authos, 2008.Last updated: 8 December, 2008

Contents | Author index | Subject index | Search | Home


17 de 17 07/05/14 23:18

Yeh 2008 the Social Constructionist Viewpoint on Gays and Lesbians and Their Information Behaviour

Documents

Transcript of Yeh 2008 the Social Constructionist Viewpoint on Gays and Lesbians and Their Information Behaviour