YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al.,...

21
RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Enhancing and implementing Knowledge based ICT solutions within high Risk and Uncertain Conditions for Agriculture Production Systems (RUC-APS) WP Leader Prof. Hervé Panetto Université de Lorraine, CRAN, CNRS, France [email protected] WP 11 Enterprise systems interoperability assessment in Agriculture domains YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Skype for Business: https://meet.lync.com/univ-lorraine.fr/panetto5/XAXC6HFI The session is recorded!

Transcript of YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al.,...

Page 1: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Enhancing and implementing Knowledge based ICT solutions within high Risk and Uncertain Conditions for Agriculture Production Systems

(RUC-APS)

WP Leader

Prof. Hervé Panetto

Université de Lorraine, CRAN, CNRS, France

[email protected]

WP 11

Enterprise systems interoperability assessment

in Agriculture domains

YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Skype for Business: https://meet.lync.com/univ-lorraine.fr/panetto5/XAXC6HFI

The session is recorded!

https://meet.lync.com/univ-lorraine.fr/panetto5/XAXC6HFI
Page 2: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

THE WP11 TEAM at ULName Institution/Group Expertise

Prof. Hervé Panetto (WP Leader) UL/CRAN Interoperability of systems, cyber-physical systems

Dr. Mario Lezoche UL/CRAN Knowledge management and ontology

Dr. William Dérigent UL/CRAN Data management and BIM

Prof. Hind EL-Haouzi UL/CRAN Simulation-based decision making

Dr. Concetta Semeraro UL/CRAN & POLIBA Data mining and digital twin

Dr. Wided Guédria LIST/CRAN Interoperability assessment

Dr. Gabriel Leal UL/CRAN & LIST Ontology-based interoperability requirements

Page 3: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Final product

Assessment

info

info

info

info

info

info

info informationcompetencies

products

Problems

Page 4: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Towards an Interoperabilty Agri-food 4.0Assessment tool

• Generaly interoperable by design

• Human centred

• Technology oriented (CPS, Sensors, AI, …)

• Data, Information and Knowledge –based

• Along the global value chain

Page 5: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Interoperability Assessment

(Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015)

Potent ia l i ty

The potential of an enterprise to

be interoperable towards its

environment

Compat ibi l i ty

The compatibility

Between two

Enterprises

Performance

The performance of

interoperation between

two enterprises

T rans format ion

Identifying impacts that

changes may cause

Creat ion o f a network

Selecting new

partners

Page 6: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The Conceptual Model: Assessment MetaModel

Systemic coreAssessment core

Page 7: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The Conceptual Model: Interoperability Assessment MetaModel

Page 8: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The Conceptual Model: Instantiation

Page 9: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The Ontology of Interoperability Assessment (OIA)

Protégé 5.2 (Musen, 2015)Extract of the ontology

pointsOutProblem

recommends

removesProblem

satisfies

isSatisfiedBy

mayCause

requires

impactsisRequiredB

y

Page 10: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Prototyping the computer-mediated tool for Interoperability Assessment in Agriculture

It provides user interfaces

It automatically identifies barriers based

on the requirement rating

It recommends solutions based on:

- the identified barriers

- the knowledge that has been

stored in the OIA

The prototype architecture

Page 11: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Prototyping the computer-mediated tool forInteroperability Assessment

Page 12: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Prototyping the computer-mediated tool forInteroperability AssessmentInserting logic rules for automatic reasoning

Language Description (Formula)

Natural

Language:

If a specific requirement that is verified by the assessment has a lower rate than the one

stipulated as “minimum”, the assessment points out the interoperability barrier(s) and

recommends the best practice(s) that are related to the concerned requirement.

SWRL

Language:

Assessment_Process(?iap) ^ Evaluation_Criterion(?ir) ^

verifiesCriterion(?iap, ?ir)^ Existence_Condition(?ib) ^

relatedToCondition (?ir, ?ib) ^ Solution(?bp) ^ satisfiesRequirement(?bp,

?ir) ^ hasRate(?ir, ?ra) ^ hasMin(FA, ?miv) ^ swrlb:lessThan(?ra, ?miv)

-> pointsOutCondition (?iap, ?ib) ^ hasCause(?ib, ?ir) ^ recommends(?iap,

?bp)

Language Description (Formula)

Natural

Language:

If a considered requirement has a rate greater than the stipulated minimum, the

concerned requirement satisfies the related maturity level.

SWRL

Language:

hasMin(FA, ?miv) ^ Quality(?il) ^ dependsOnRequirement(?il, ?ir) ^

Evaluation_Criterion(?ir) ^ hasRate(?ir, ?ra) ^ swrlb:greaterThan(?ra,

?miv) -> satisfiesLevel(?ir, ?il)

Page 13: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Ontology before reasoning

Page 14: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Ontology after reasoning

Page 15: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Page 16: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The case study

The Factory Group

Agrifood productor & supplier

Exxus

Farm

Agro-Interact

Transport

RIDL

Distributor

Sustain

Quality control service

Page 17: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

The Factory Group Case Study20

Page 18: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

DEMONSTRATION

Interoperabilty Agri-food 4.0 Assessment tool

Developed by Gabriel Leal SerapiãoDecision Support for Interoperability readiness analysis in Networked Enterprises. Phdthesis of Université de Lorraine, 2019

Gabriel Leal, Wided Guedria, Hervé Panetto. A semi-automated system for interoperability assessment: an ontology-based approach. Enterprise Information Systems, Taylor & Francis, 2020, 14 (3), pp.308-333. ⟨10.1080/17517575.2019.1678767⟩

The names of the enterprises used in this demo are purely fiction

http://docnum.univ-lorraine.fr/public/DDOC_T_2019_0001_DA_SILVA_SERAPIAO_LEAL.pdf
Page 19: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Learning Outcomes• Analysis of data sharing and exchange in the food supply chain

• Starting point analysis of applications used in agribusiness

• Information flows between Agrifood stakeholders

• Some idea about the definition of an Agri-Ontology

• The Agri-Food Experiment Ontology (AFEO)

• Interoperability map between enterprise systems in agriculture domain

• Adaptation of the PLATINE prototype for an Ontology-based Interoperability assessment in Agriculture (Demo)

Page 20: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

THANKYOU !Q&A

Page 21: YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS€¦ · RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS Interoperability Assessment (Ford et al., 2007a), (Panetto. 2007), (Yahia et al. 2012), (Guédria et al. 2015) Potentiality The

RUC-APS YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Enhancing and implementing Knowledge based ICT solutions within high Risk and Uncertain Conditions for Agriculture Production Systems

(RUC-APS)

YEAR 4 HIGHLIGHTS

Skype for Business: https://meet.lync.com/univ-lorraine.fr/panetto5/XAXC6HFI

Presenter

Ass. Prof. Mario Lezoche

Université de Lorraine, CRAN, CNRS, France

[email protected]

Next presentation: Wednesday 27th, 2020 – 15:30 CET

Agriculture Ontology


USA, Et Al v. Kaplan, Et Al

USA, Et Al v. Kaplan, Et Al

Shire Et. Al. v. Apotex Et. Al.

Shire Et. Al. v. Apotex Et. Al.

Oceana et al vs.BOEM et al

Oceana et al vs.BOEM et al

Stragent et. al. v. Audi et. al.

Stragent et. al. v. Audi et. al.

Literature Review Messent et al (1998,1999) Robertson et al (2000) Beart et al (2001) Heller et al (2002)

Literature Review Messent et al (1998,1999) Robertson et al (2000) Beart et al (2001) Heller et al (2002)

Fluorescent biological aerosol particle concentrations … Mortazavi et al., 2008; Rosenfeld et al., 2008; Ariya et al., 2009; Bowers et al., 2009; Pratt et al., 2009; Prenni et al.,

Fluorescent biological aerosol particle concentrations … Mortazavi et al., 2008; Rosenfeld et al., 2008; Ariya et al., 2009; Bowers et al., 2009; Pratt et al., 2009; Prenni et al.,

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US … · Liamos et al. Mann et al. Heller et al. Gotoh et al. Rush et al. Mao et al. Liamos et al. Desai ..... A61B 5,14532 204,403.01

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US … · Liamos et al. Mann et al. Heller et al. Gotoh et al. Rush et al. Mao et al. Liamos et al. Desai ..... A61B 5,14532 204,403.01

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US 9,120,245 B1 ...Polikarpus et al. Pham et al. Bawendi et al. Bagger et al. Masuzawa et al. Conley et al. Mardilovich Higuchi et al. Kobayashi

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US 9,120,245 B1 ...Polikarpus et al. Pham et al. Bawendi et al. Bagger et al. Masuzawa et al. Conley et al. Mardilovich Higuchi et al. Kobayashi

., et al. Petitioners, et al. Respondents.

., et al. Petitioners, et al. Respondents.

Pfizer et. al. v. Alembic et. al.

Pfizer et. al. v. Alembic et. al.

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US 7895.275 B1 ... Gutta et al. Signes et al. Hashimoto et al. Ghashghai et al. Ting et al. Vaidyanathan et al. Obradovich Larsson et al.

(12) United States Patent (10) Patent No.: US 7895.275 B1 ... Gutta et al. Signes et al. Hashimoto et al. Ghashghai et al. Ting et al. Vaidyanathan et al. Obradovich Larsson et al.

et al. et al

et al. et al

Wisconsin et al v. Fitzgerald et al

Wisconsin et al v. Fitzgerald et al

Silver et al. v. Pueblo et al.

Silver et al. v. Pueblo et al.

Mutanwad et al., 2019 · signaling (Swain et al. 2001; Tseng et al. 2001; Silverstone et al. 2007; Zentella et al. 2016; Zentella et al. 2017). One of the most prominent features

Mutanwad et al., 2019 · signaling (Swain et al. 2001; Tseng et al. 2001; Silverstone et al. 2007; Zentella et al. 2016; Zentella et al. 2017). One of the most prominent features

The KMOS Redshift One Spectroscopic Survey (KROSS) · Kassin et al. 2007, 2012; Buitrago et al. 2008; Dunne et al. 2009; Peng et al. 2010; Geach et al. 2011; van Dokkum et al. 2011;

The KMOS Redshift One Spectroscopic Survey (KROSS) · Kassin et al. 2007, 2012; Buitrago et al. 2008; Dunne et al. 2009; Peng et al. 2010; Geach et al. 2011; van Dokkum et al. 2011;

Integrative analysis of multi-platform RPPA data · 2011, Hayashi et al. 2014, Bernhardt et al. 2017, Hutter et al. 2017, Lièvre et al. 2017, Aslan et al. 2018, Faham et al. 2018,

Integrative analysis of multi-platform RPPA data · 2011, Hayashi et al. 2014, Bernhardt et al. 2017, Hutter et al. 2017, Lièvre et al. 2017, Aslan et al. 2018, Faham et al. 2018,

Smartflash Et. Al. v. Google Et. Al.

Smartflash Et. Al. v. Google Et. Al.

Garber et al v. MLB et al

Garber et al v. MLB et al

Multi-scale assessment of human-induced changes to ... · (Neill et al. 2001; Davidson et al. 2004; Neill et al. 2006; Figueiredo et al. 2010; Neill et al. 2011; Macedo et al. 2013;

Multi-scale assessment of human-induced changes to ... · (Neill et al. 2001; Davidson et al. 2004; Neill et al. 2006; Figueiredo et al. 2010; Neill et al. 2011; Macedo et al. 2013;