X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they...

42
X factor in LEAN implementation 28 Nov 2017

Transcript of X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they...

Page 1: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

X factor in LEAN implementation

28 Nov 2017

Page 2: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight
Page 3: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight
Page 4: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

X factor in LEAN implementation

28 Nov 2017

Page 5: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

History on LEAN implementations

Unfortunately not all change interventions are successful:

• Book Good to Great, Jim Collins 11 out ofthe1435 organizations sustainable

performance improvements.

• Survey conducted by Industry Week in 2007 only 2% lean program achieved their

anticipate results

• Other studies 67% of TQM interventions fade away after two years,

• 30% of IT projects are cancelled

• 50% of IT projects exceed their budget by 200%

Clearly, the global change track record does not look too promising!

It is easy to blame unwilling employees, but it is a fact that human beings resist

change when it is imposed.

Page 6: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Tools as deliberately practicing a routine for continuous improvement:

• How to develop solutions

• Coaching (questioning)

Selecting people for the business:

• Western business - with good innate work/management characteristics (habits)

• Toyota – focus on openness to learning then the later

“When we look at lean in this way it is not only a set techniques for eliminating waste,

but a process by which managers as leaders develop people so that desired results

can be achieved, again and again – Coaching people in practicing an improvement tool

or methodology – Jeffrey Liker, Ph. D, Mike Rother”

Some differences on LEAN implementations

Page 7: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

What makes the difference

Organization

Capability

Senior Leadership

Capability

Leadership is leading and running the business

Page 8: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

What makes the difference

Organization

Capability

Good business - healthy – creates growth - Expand the organization

Senior Leadership

Capability

Page 9: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

What makes the difference

Senior Leadership

Capability

Organization

Capability

Frustration

Limited

People leave

WCM Fail

Page 10: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Key Motivations Behind Work

Pay check Driven

Passion Driven

Philanthropy Driven

Purpose Driven

Page 11: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Active and visible senior leadership is critical to success

• Supporting change by giving consistent attention to the change and the need for change management

• Championing the change by leading and motivating others in the organization; being the face of the change

• Making effective and influential decisions regarding the change, including the ability to align priorities among other leaders in the organisation

• Maintaining direct communication with the project management and change management teams and being accessible during the change

1

1

Page 12: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

AS IS and TO BE management actions

Page 13: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

1. Leading 2009

2. Cultivating leaders 2011

3. All Leaders – Self driven 2013

0. Realization - 2007

My/Company journey

Personal Growth

Co

mp

an

y G

row

th

Laissez-Faire Direct Coaching Democratic Charismatic

Direction?

Und

ers

tand

Results

Susta

inable

Results

Page 14: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Different TOOLS

Page 15: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structures: Laissez-Faire

Purpose

Page 16: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

0. Meetings: Direction?/Laisses-Fair

Are we

nearly there

yet?

I thought we following

you?

Ask the guy

at the back

Where are

we going?

Page 17: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structures: Laissez-Faire

Page 18: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

1. Meeting: Direct Coaching

Page 19: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structured….

Operator to Operator (Shift Handover)

Operators meet when they hand over shift

Discuss problems in area of work

Discuss KPI’s of equipment

Highlight areas of concern

Page 20: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structured….

Operator to Operator (Shift Handover)

Operators meet when they hand over shift

Discuss problems in area of work

Discuss KPI’s of equipment

Highlight areas of concern

Shift meeting

Issues from previous shift

Problem areas and set priorities for shift

Review performance & set targets for the

shift

Assign actions

Page 21: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structured….

Operator to Operator (Shift Handover)

Operators meet when they

hand over shift

Discuss problems in area of

work

Discuss KPI’s of equipment

Highlight areas of concern

Shift meeting

Issues from previous shift

Problem areas and set

priorities for shift

Review performance & set

targets for the shift

Assign actions

Daily operation review (DOR)

Review of KPI’s for

department UV, Availability,

Run-rates

Review previous day losses

Verify problem solving

actions

Highlight areas of concerns

Set priorities for the day

Page 22: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structured….

Operator to Operator (Shift Handover)

Operators meet when they

hand over shift

Discuss problems in area of

work

Discuss KPI’s of equipment

Highlight areas of concern

Shift meeting

Issues from previous shift

Problem areas and set

priorities for shift

Review performance & set

targets for the shift

Assign actions

Daily operation review (DOR)

Review of KPI’s for

department UV, Availability,

Run-rates

Review previous day losses

Verify problem solving

actions

Highlight areas of concerns

Set priorities for the day

WOR/MOR• Overall

performance

• Feedback from

all teams

• Review losses

• Actions

assigned to

teams to

correct losses

• All meetings

can delegate

up or down

Page 23: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structure: Disciplined

Page 24: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structure: Disciplined

Page 25: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Structure: Disciplined

Page 26: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

2. Cultivating leaders

Page 27: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Formal Process - Approach

KPI Setting Process

Problem solving

Culture of Continuous improvement

Tracking of Activities Impact

Tagging

Rewarding

Change How

People

think

act

&

learn over time

Characteristics

Page 29: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

All driven connected

Frontline

Management

Site

Management

Business

Management

Weekly MonthlyDaily

Frontline

Team

ShiftReal Time

Activity

Tracking

Process

control

charts

Quarterly

On Line /

Meeting

room

Yearly

Management routines standard work Improvement

Page 30: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

All driven connected

Management routines

Operation review - More Executional

Tracking mechanism

Frontline

Management

Site Management

Business

Management

Weekly MonthlyDaily

Frontline Team

ShiftReal Time

Production tracking

Process control

charts

Weekly

Informatio

n

NetworkingDaily

Operation

al ReviewShift

meeting

Quarterly

On Line / Team

room

Team/Are

a room

with

action

plan

Area/Factory

measures &

action planOperator

to

Operator

Operation review - More Strategic

standard work Improvement

Yearly

Page 31: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

All driven connected

Management routines

Operation review - More Executional

Tracking mechanism

Frontline

Management

Site Management

Business

Management

Weekly MonthlyDaily

Frontline Team

ShiftReal Time

Production tracking

Process control

charts

Weekly

Information

Networking

Point of View

Daily Operational

Review

Shift meeting

Quarterly

On Line / Team

room

Team/Area room

with action plan

Area/Factory

measures & action

plan

Are we on

track and

experience

teambuildin

g

Operator to

Operator

Monthly

Information

Networking

Monthly

measures

and

action

plan

Operation review - More Strategic

standard work Improvement

Yearly

Fertilizer

Objectives

(Division)

Are we on

track and

experience

teambuildin

g

Page 32: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

All driven connected

Management routines

Operation review - More Executional

Tracking mechanism

Frontline

Management

Site Management

Business

Management

Weekly MonthlyDaily

Frontline Team

ShiftReal Time

Production tracking

Process control

charts

Weekly

Information

Networking

Point of View

Daily Operational

Review

Shift meeting

Quarterly

On Line / Team

room

Team/Area room

with action plan

Area/Factory

measures & action

plan

Are we on track

and experience

teambuilding

Operator to

Operator

Monthly

Information

Networking

Monthly measures

and action plan

Operation review - More Strategic

standard work Improvement

Engineerin

g

Meeting

Planning

meeting

Complex support

Yearly

Fertilizer

Objectives(Division)

Are we on track

and experience

teambuilding

Page 33: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

All driven connected

Management routines

Operation review - More Executional

Tracking mechanism

Frontline

Management

Site Management

Business

Management

Weekly MonthlyDaily

Frontline Team

ShiftReal Time

Production tracking

Process control

charts

Weekly

Information

Networking

Point of View

Daily Operational

Review

Shift meeting

Quarterly

On Line / Team

room

Team/Area room

with action plan

Area/Factory

measures & action

plan

Are we on track

and experience

teambuilding

Operator to

Operator

Monthly

Information

Networking

Monthly measures

and action plan

Operation review - More Strategic

standard work Improvement

GEMBA

Walks

Safety Shop

floor meeting

Engineering

MeetingPlanning

meeting

Ground floor connectionComplex support

GM Yearly

Operator

Yearly

Fertilizer

Objectives(Division)

Are we on track

and experience

teambuilding

Page 34: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Engaged – All meetings include

Engaged Connected Sessions

Safety

Goal Alignment

KPI’s triggers

HR

Training

Maintenance

Finance

Fun

Values

Page 35: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Engaged

Personal

Growth

Big Picture

&

Understand

Impact

Linked

upwards

downwards

Responsibility

Engaged

Page 36: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

1. Leading 2009

2. Cultivating leaders 2011

3. All Leaders – Self driven 2013

0. Realization - 2007

My/Company journey

Personal Growth

Co

mp

an

y G

row

th

Laissez-

Faire

Direct Coaching Democratic Charismatic

Direction?

Unders

tand

Result

s

Susta

inable

Results

Autonomy

Page 37: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Achievements Testimonials

Page 38: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Key Success Factors

• Management understanding and commitment

• Buy-in and participation from all key stakeholders

• Effective deployment of strategy

• Line management accountability

• Effective facilitator support — expertise and focus

• Rigorous loss and waste analysis with aggressive targets

• Effective pilot activities

• Sharing and promoting successes

• Effective measurement of improvements

• Effective use of consultants

• Step-by-step implementation process

• Active HR involvement — 'it's a people deal'

Page 39: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

John Kotter's eight steps to lead change

Reasons why Change Initiatives Fail Steps to Manage Change

• Not establishing a great enough sense of urgency

• Not creating a powerful enough guiding coalition

• Lacking a vision

• Under-communicating the vision

• Not removing obstacles to the new vision and not empowering people to act upon it

• Not systemically planning for and creatingshort-term wins

• Declaring victory too early

• Not anchoring the change in thecorporation's culture

• Establish a sense of urgency

• Form a powerful guiding coalition

• Create a compelling vision

• Communicate the vision to everyone

• Remove the obstacles and empower others to act on the vision

• Plan for and create short-term wins

• Consolidate improvements and produce stillmore change

• Entrench the change

Page 40: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Pulse survey results – Oct 2016

Page 41: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Conceptual journey

5

Page 42: X factor in LEAN implementation...Operator to Operator (Shift Handover) Operators meet when they hand over shift Discuss problems in area of work Discuss KPI’s of equipment Highlight

Typical Implementation Structures

TR

AC

C S

pe

cia

list

Imp

lem

en

tatio

n M

an

ag

er

Executive Committee

Local Committee

Team Leader

Implementation Task Force

Chair: 24/7 Area Manager – Others: Production,

Quality, Maintenance, HR, Operator Reps

Shift-based

Team

Team Leader

Shift-based

Team

Team Leader

Shift-based

Team

Team Leader

Shift-based

Team

Master

Trainers

and Site

Trainers

Master

Facilitator

and Site

Facilitators

BestPractice Leaders